Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–170 of 537. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Last night, when I was speaking on the concluding stages of the debate, Deputy Mulcahy and myself had some words. There were so many interruptions from the other side when I was attempting to speak that I took it Deputy Mulcahy, in his remarks to me, mentioned my family. I took it that his remarks were a bit below the belt. I find now that is not the position.
Comment on this
I hasten to assure Deputy Mulcahy that I am glad that that was not so. I would be surprised indeed to find that he would adopt such tactics.
Comment on this
I certainly would not say anything that would hurt anybody's feelings and neither, I am sure, would Deputy Mulcahy. There was, however, so much cross talk from the other side during the debate—I suppose that was due to the fact that many Deputies were anxious to get home—that I gotthe impression that Deputy Mulcahy was in very bad humour and that he did not like the name of Gallagher. Apparently, that is not the position, and I hope that he will now take my assurance on that.
Comment on this
When I was about to conclude my speech, the debate was adjourned at 10.30 p.m. I intended that my final words would be on what the Dublin Corporation have in mind in regard to the committee which it is supposed to set up. I said in the course of my remarks that things were looking brighter as far as the building of private houses in Dublin is concerned. I checked up on that to-day in the housing department of the corporation. I was told that applications under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act are pouring in every day at the rate of from six to ten. That would go to show that there is bound to be, even this year, a step up on the building of private houses in Dublin. The figures relating to small dwellings applications with the Dublin Corporation for 1951 were 400. In 1952, the number was 430, and from January to July of this year the number is close on 800. As I say, they are pouring in at the rate of from six to ten per day. That is a good sign, and I am sure that Deputies on all sides of the House will be glad to know that. These figures indicate that there is going to be a step up in private house building. A supplementarty grant of £137 10s. is being given by the Dublin Corporation. I am sure that, as a result of it, we will be inundated with applications. I sincerely hope that if we want money from the Government to meet these small dwellings loans, or assistance of any kind, that we will get it without any question. There should certainly be no damper on such activity because private house building gives a good deal of employment.
On the other side of the corporation's activities at the moment, I may say, we are paying £250,000 a month to contractors. It is hoped that this sum will reach £300,000 a month. Onthat score it cannot be said that the corporation are sitting down on the job of house building. We are doing our best. As I have said, we should get any assistance we want from the Government. It is the duty of every Government to provide houses for the people, and no political Party should try to score over another on the question of house building. It is the duty of a Government to provide houses and at the greatest possible speed. I may say that I do not agree with, or like the term, "all convenient speed." It should be done without delay.
A works committee was set up by the Dublin Corporation. Other Deputies are members of it like myself. We have certain plans for the Government. I appeal to the Government to consider those plans and to meet our demands. We suggest that the Minister for Local Government should release a very efficient officer that we have in the Dublin Corporation to act with this committee. We also ask the Minister for Local Government to appoint a senior official of his Department to attend our meetings and to bring back decisions to the Department of Local Government and to see that the plans are passed without all the unnecessary delay of sending letters and awaiting replies, and so on. If we get that liaison officer it will help to speed up the plans we have in mind to solve the unemployment situation in the city which certainly requires urgent attention.
Another suggestion that we make is the expedition of the clearance of derelict sites. In my constituency alone there are schemes for blocks of flats. I agree that the Dublin Corporation are not blameless in this matter either. If any of our plans are submitted for places like Hardwicke Street, Dorset Street, Temple Street and Grenville Street, there should be no hold up in sanction. There are empty houses ready to be rebuilt, the rebuilding of which would give a great deal of employment. This district is in the heart of my constituency. Traders there have had to dismiss many of their staffs because they had no work for them when large families were removed from the area.Thousands of people were removed from the district and the traders suffered severe loss. That is only one item which caused unemployment. If builders were put into the block of streets that I have mentioned the traders would be very grateful for the custom they would get from the workers rebuilding the houses. It would also give much needed employment and provide flats for the people.
It is not a question of developing sites. The work is there and the question should be tackled. If the corporation submit plans there should be no delay on the part of the Government. The Department of Local Government should tell us to go ahead and do the work and, if we want money, that they will give it to us. That is the only way to solve to a great extent unemployment in the building industry.
Another suggestion that works committees have in mind is the postponement of revaluation of premises that have been altered. If a person decides to put in a new shop front, the valuation officer immediately adds a considerable sum to the rateable valuation. The rates go up right away. If a private householder builds a garage, it costs him, I suppose, another 30/- on his rates.
Comment on this
I suppose eventually it will. It is a suggestion that should be borne in mind. It could be done in a day with the goodwill of all Parties concerned. I take it that Deputy Sweetman has some plans for valuation and I would be glad to hear them and support them if they contain anything along the lines of that suggestion. People are afraid to improve their property because of revaluation.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not develop it because it requires legislation. He cannot continue in that strain indefinitely.
Comment on this
It is no harm to mention it when it is a question of putting people into employment.
Comment on this
As I said at the beginning, the main reason for this Vote was the tactics of the Fine Gael Party on the Health Bill. They kept us here day after day. I know it is our duty to be here. It was strange that they should delay the House and yet not vote. That is one of the main reasons why this Vote is necessary. We on this side of the House and the Government are not one bit afraid to debate the Estimates. We will not shirk our duty. As I said earlier, we had the unenviable task of imposing taxes to try to clear up the mess of three and a half years of Coalition Government.
Comment on this
You are much older than I am and you heard much older yarns during those three and a half years.
Comment on this
There was more prosperity during those three and a half years than there has been in the last two.
Comment on this
There were still 60,000 unemployed, if you like to look at the figures, during your term. You, as a member of the Labour Party——
Comment on this
Blame your own Government. You are in power now. What is the use of shouting about what happened two years ago?
Comment on this
I would refer the Labour Deputy to all the great things his Party got out of the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
You did not buy Royal Charger. Royal Charger hasmade considerable profit. I know nothing whatsoever about racing or racehorses. Maybe the Deputy does. He used to gamble. It is not my line and I shall not go into that.
Comment on this
The Labour Party got very little out of that three and a half years. I do not think the Deputy has much to crow about. He has very little to crow about and he should hide his head in shame.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary is constantly interrupting. I am just warning him that these interruptions will not be allowed.
Comment on this
The Deputy will restrain himself and allow Deputy Gallagher to proceed in an orderly fashion.
Comment on this
I have the greatest respect for Deputy O'Leary and I think we get on reasonably well together. I never interrupt him. It is not in my line to interrupt anybody. I would ask him to examine his conscience and examine what they got out of three and a half years of Coalition Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Gallagher should remember that the administration of the inter-Party Government is not up for consideration. What is under discussion is the administration of the present Government.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary mentioned the unemployed marching up here. I met these unemployed people and they told me that they did not want any Party to make capital out of them. They also told me that the Labour Party took little or no interestuntil they marched up to Kildare Street.
Comment on this
I know a lot of those who are marching better than the Deputy. Most of them are a decent type of fellow. We in Dublin are certainly doing our best for these men. He need have no worry on that score. It is a pity that they are marching, but we will not shirk our responsibility. He will not find us slow in facing up to our responsibility. This works committee set up by the Dublin Corporation will certainly do what they can and I ask the Government to see that anything put up by them will be dealt with in an expeditious manner.
Comment on this
I am very grateful, not only for the sake of Deputy Gallagher and myself from a personal point of view, but for the sake of the establishment here that any misunderstanding that arose last night has been cleared up. Deputy Gallagher started off last night to stockpile honesty. He gave figures and I was suggesting that his treatment of the figures hardly warranted his claims for the stockpile of honesty. At any rate, I appreciate that he has always been a reasonable and a courteous opponent here and that induces me to make a suggestion. The Deputy is used to ringside performances and perhaps even to getting inside the ring. The Deputy repudiates having anything to do with racing. I have had very little to do with boxing, although I did bring Tansey Lee over here to lay the foundations of boxing in the Army long ago. As Minister for Education I also went to the Stadium to see schoolboys from this city box with London school-boys.
Comment on this
It was a joy and a delight to see the demeanour of these little boys towards one another before and after their performance. I wonder would he be able to bring the Minister for Finance to see a boxingtournament between some of these boys?
Comment on this
Take him again. It may prolong his life and be a great help to him. I am grateful for the Deputy's expression and I hope he will not mind if I suggest to him that he will want to perfect his technique inside this ring, because we have very important matters to deal with and they are being completely muddled at present. The attitude of the Government he supports puts Deputies who have a sense of their responsibilities and a sense of the function of this institution in relation to the interests of our people in a very grave dilemma.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy Cowan could be remainded as to when he can talk. This Parliament has been put out of commission. It is being put into a position by the Government which orders the business here that none of the vital things which concern the financial and economic interests of the country can be discussed here, and no decisions affecting vital and urgent matters in connection with the economic interests of the country can be taken. The Government have decided that they will so order business that they can say with regard to the Parliament: "Let them come in and talk, but do not give them any matters to discuss that they can get their teeth into in a detailed way in relation to the things affecting our people; do not give them anything to discuss that will enable them to come to decisions in the Division Lobby that will show that the Parliament here disagrees with the actions of the Government and with the results of the Government's actions." The Minister for Finance yesterday moved a second Vote on Account and gave as an excuse that it was necessary to do this in order to get money to carry on until November next.
Comment on this
I object to being interrupted in making remarks which I consider serious by a person who has adopted the attitude of acting the buffoon here in order to help the Government to obscure and to befuddle certain matters.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan will allow Deputy Mulcahy to proceed without interruptions. Interruptions of all kinds are disorderly.
Comment on this
The Government have so ordered business as to prevent this House functioning not only as an institution to take decisions on things vitally affecting the people, but even to prevent it functioning in connection with the detailed discussion of various matters. The Minister for Finance said just a few words yesterday to the effect that we would not have time by the end of this month, when he implied that the Dáil recess will begin, to discuss the various Estimates and therefore it was necessary to take a second Vote on Account. We are being prevented by the way in which the Government have ordered their business from discussing Estimates dealing with the position of na gCeantar gCúng, from dealing with the Office of Public Works and its plans for implementing emergency schemes, from dealing with the Department of Industry and Commerce, from dealing with matters that come under the review of the Minister for Social Welfare and the Minister for Finance himself, who is responsible for so much of the confusion and the disorder economically here; from dealing with the supplementary agricultural grant in respect of which the striking of rates and the issue of rate noticesby the local authorities have been thrown into the most utter confusion. Not a single one of these which vitally affect the strained economic conditions from which our people are suffering can be discussed. There is not a single one of these upon which the Government's policy could not be challenged and the responsibility put on Deputies for showing where they stand in connection with the Government's handling of the general situation in relation to all these Estimates.
That is all set aside. This period of the year is set aside particularly for an examination of the Government's financial proposals affecting both the taxation of our people and the general economic well-being; our production, our employment, our financial security, the confidence with which employers and business people generally face their work. A short period of the year is set for all that. As Deputy Gallagher reminded us, we have had thrown on top of that a very contentious and very obscure measure such as the Health Bill. The Vote on Account is taken before the Easter recess and, normally, the period from the time we return after the Easter recess until the summer recess is set aside by the House to consider the general economic, the general financial position, and the detailed administration of the various Government Departments. What do we find? Up to last Friday the Dáil Debates, in terms of columns, ran to 6,132 as from the 15th April last. About 700 or so of these were devoted to questions, the ordering of parliamentary business, and one or two motions on the Adjournment. Outside of that, in relation to ordinary legislation, the Budget, Estimates, the Health Bill and the vote of confidence, 5,438 columns of the debates are the measure of the amount of time given to these. Of that parliamentary time expressed in terms of columns, the Health Bill stands first with 1,812 columns as against 1,400 for the Estimates; 1,000 for the Budget and 570 for the ordinary legislation, and 490 for the vote of confidence. The vote of confidence was one of those long drawn out general discussions andall the possible things that could be obscured and could be dove-tailed in together, were drawn into this discussion, and a vote taken at the end. In regard to the Budget there was only occasion for a few decisions on that, and it was all a long discussion. The Government can have no complaint in regard to the way legislation generally was dealt with. A small amount of time was given to that, but the Committee Stage of the Health Bill was thrown in on top of that and got more parliamentary time given to it than the Budget or such Estimates as were dealt with.
We want to know the reason why it is necessary to choke down detailed discussion, because that is what the Government handling of the situation means. We are told that we have been opposing and obstructing during the discussions on the Health Bill without taking part in any votes. We may vote time enough. But I want to say the Government has attempted to make this House here just an air bubble in the general economic machinery where the whole inefficiency, incompetence and maljudgment of the Government in their handling of both financial and economic affairs has brought the country outside nearly to a standstill so far as any confidence in the country's development and progress is concerned. It has produced a considerable amount of unemployment. Anything this House has done by way of positive action in the financial line has been to the detriment of the country. Now, while the Government are recovering from the shock of the conditions they have brought about and recovering from the shock of the effect of those conditions on the electorate as shown by some of the by-elections, they reduce the position to this: that we can take no decisions that will in any way change the situation here. They are supported by a sufficiently steady number of their own Party and a certain number of Independents to make sure that they can hold the fort here so long as there are just long drawn out discussions on general matters.
The Government were asked to takethe Health Bill and send it before a committee that would have powers to send for persons; papers and documents and get real views on the problem, and consider what were likely to be the financial and other implications of the measure. The Government refused that and we had to discuss the matter in Committee with the Minister who must have a crick in his neck and a pain in his side from leaning over the edge of the bench to get information from his officials on what the Bill is all about.
Comment on this
He had to tell us when we were discussing the position of the one person in the Bill who was being given control—the county manager—that he did not know what the reserved functions were, or whether they were reserved to the county manager or to the council.
Comment on this
We have been charged here, Sir, with bringing the proceedings of this House to the condition to which, in fact, the Government have brought it, by reason of the fact that we had lengthy discussions on the Committee Stage of the Health Bill. We had those discussions because of the attitude of the Minister for Health in dealing with the House and with matters here.
Comment on this
The Deputy can review those as far as is desirable but I want to sound this note of warning: we cannot discuss the Health Bill or any provision of it on this Vote.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, but in view of what has been said on the Government Benches I could not say less than I have said on the subject and be clear.
The House then, as I say, is just put out of commission. The work has been so organised here that we can come in and argue and the alarm clock can be set for a particular period at which all the Government supporters can be there plus all their attendants and the,vote of two or three or possibly four or five as the case may be, can be taken and the alarm clock can be turned off again, and we can go on with general discussions. But we are not allowed to discuss industry and commerce or the supplementary agricultural grant or the various works that are under the control of the Office of Public Works or unemployment or emergency schemes or western conditions or the general policy of the Minister for Finance. All these things are just put off and it seems that the Vote on Account is taken here so that the doors of this establishment can be shut at the end of this month so that the Government can go and breathe for a month or two. During that month or two they may come to their senses and they may realise that the way in which they are behaving is just that of a dog in the manger. They have got into office; they have misjudged both the financial and economic situation and they have brought a very considerable amount of dislocation to our manufacturers, to our commercial people that has shown itself in the very serious unemployment and general situation and domestic distress on those particularly who have to rear and educate their families and have the problem of seeing their older children put into some kind of employment here in their own country. Meantime, in a general way, everything that can be said or done to obscure the situation is being said and done by the Minister for Finance and by the various other agents of the Government.
The Minister for Finance, responding to criticisms made—at the Congress of Irish Unions Conference, I think it was, at any rate replying to Senator McMullen—published a series of statements which are as grotesque as anything you could expect the Government to indicate. He stated, and it was repeated here yesterday by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, that national income—I am reading from a letter published in the Irish Timesand dated 18th July and signed by the Minister for Finance himself— in real terms increased in 1952 despite all the difficulties of that year. There was by contrast a slight fall inBritain's gross domestic production in that year, 1952.
Our national income in real terms according to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Finance increased last year. I asked when we would be favoured with a statement on that matter and I was told, or it was implied, that it was in the printers' hands but it was rather clear from both the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that we are not going to see it until this House is shut down. But will the Minister or any of his colleagues or any of the back benchers of his Party connected with any aspect of the productive life of this country say what changes in technique, what changes in process or organisation have taken place in this country during the year 1952 that would increase the national production of this country without increasing the numbers of unemployed we have in industry and agriculture?
With a pretended air of responsibility and in a most detailed A, B, C, D, E, F, G kind of style, the Minister purports to reply in the most informal way to an important body dealing in a realistic way with some of the country's conditions. Is it not the fact that in that list of 32 groups of industries, with the rest generalised under the heading: "Other Industries," on which the employment in transportable goods is calculated, we find that in December, 1952, there were 3,437 persons fewer employed than there were in December the year before and that there were 7,228 fewer employed than there were in December, 1950? How does it happen that national income in real terms has gone up in 1952 with 3,437 persons fewer employed in the production of transportable goods in December of that year than in December of the previous year and with 7,228 fewer employed than in December, 1950? If we make a comparison for the whole of 1952 as compared with 1951, apart from the figures which I have given for December, there were 7,308 fewer employed in the September quarter of 1952 as compared with that quarter in 1951, 9,035 feweremployed in the June quarter as compared with the corresponding quarter in 1951 and 4,777 fewer employed in the March quarter of that year as compared with the corresponding quarter in 1951. Over the whole year, therefore, the number employed in the production of transportable goods showed a reduction in March of 4,777, in June of 9,035, in September of 7,308 and in December of 3,437.
The Minister has had repeated to him on very many occasions the number of people that were unemployed in these industries. The number of persons unemployed, classified accordig to the normal industrial analysis, which included agriculture, in mid-April, 1951, was 58,000, in mid-April, 1952, 70,275 and in mid-April, 1953, 85,167. Of the last mentioned figure, 30,000 were unemployed in the agricultural industry. Unemployment in agriculture has risen from 22,500 in mid-April, 1951, to 30,700 in mid-April, 1953. Yet we have the Minister's statement that the national income in real terms increased in 1952 despite all the difficulties of that year, despite the substantial fall in the number of persons employed in transportable goods industries and despite the substantial increase in unemployment in every one of the groups in which there is a normal industrial analysis.
As if to underline that from another direction, the Minister says that the volume index for production of transportable goods for the March quarter of 1953 was 4.4 per cent. above that for the same quarter of 1952. The March Trade Journalgives under the heading of No. 20, a statement which shows that in the year 1952 in February the index based on 100 in 1936 was 160.6, and if we add the Minister's 4.4 per cent. to that, it brings it up to 165 but the index in last December was 170.7 and the index in December, 1951, was 173.5. Again we ask what change has there been, in the case of transportable goods, in technique or organisation when the substantially smaller number of people employed are able to increase the volume of transportable goods even by 4.4 per cent. against the spring of last year? The fact is,nevertheless, that this index is still substantially below what it was in December, 1952, December, 1951, and December, 1950.
We may get some kind of line on the Minister's technique if we look at what he says in regard to community spending. The Minister winds up his letter with the remark:—
"A community of less than 3,000,000 souls which to-day is spending at the rate of £60,000,000 per annum on beer, spirts and cigarettes cannot be said to be practising austerity or enduring privation to any noticeable degree."
Is the Minister for Finance able to see the privation that the people are suffering? He makes a further statement in relation to that which I shall quote:—
"The following figures for the total consumer expenditure in each of the years 1948-49 to 1952-53 on tobacco and alcoholic beverages are equally enlightening."
The Minister for Finance thinks it enlightening for Senator McMullen to take note of the fact that tobacco, consumed as cigarettes, in the year 1951-52 cost purchasers £22,000,000 and in 1952-53 cost them £27.3 million. It would be enlightening if the Minister had added to this amount the particular part of these figures that represents taxation rather than consumption. In the year 1951-52 the price of a packet of cigarettes was 1/9; in the year 1952-53 it was 2/4. In other words, the price of a packet of cigarettes had increased by one-third. The consumer expenditure, which the Minister quotes, for 1951-52 was £22,000,000. If that expenditure had increased by one-third, then there should be an increase of £7.3 million in consumer expenditure, but there is only an increase of £5.3 million. Therefore, with the substantial reduction in the actual consumption of cigarettes, the Minister is able to take £5.3 million more out of the people's pockets. The people pay £5.3 million more for a substantially reduced consumption of cigarettes and the Minister tells us that these souls who are spending at that rate on cigarettes cannot be said to be practising austerity or enduring privation to any noticeable degree.
The Minister concludes the figures with those relating to spirits. He says that in the year 1950-1951 the consumer expenditure for Irish spirits was £9.6 million and in 1952-1953 it was £9.03 million. There was a substantial reduction. The price of the half glass was raised by the Minister's taxation from 1/6 in the former year by one-sixth last year. If the £9.6 million that was expended in the year 1951-1952 was raised by one-sixth there actually should be an expenditure of £11,200,000. Actually there was only an expenditure of £9,050,000. There was, in fact, a substantial reduction in the consumption of spirits as a result of the Minister's taxation, on the one hand, and general economic conditions on the other.
The Minister quoted the consumption of beer as showing the absence of any noticeable privation. He says that in the year 1951-1952 consumer expenditure on beer—that is porter and stout—was £17,500,000 and in 1952-1953 it was £19,800,000. But the Minister had raised the price of the pint from 1/- to 1/3 last year, that is by one-fourth. If consumption remained even what it was the year before that the increase should have been nearly £4,500,000. Actually the increase was £3,333,000. Therefore the people paid substantially more for a substantially reduced amount. The Minister sticks these figures into that long categorical kind of letter and they are supposed to be imposing by the very weight of the figures themselves and by the authority of the Minister's name at the bottom of that letter. He says: "These figures are enlightening."
The Minister starts off by saying that agricultural production has gone up by 1.6 per cent. Agricultural production ought to have been substantially higher than that as a result of the climatic conditions that existed last year. The Minister will find in the case of barley the yield per acre went up by 5 per cent. In the case of sugar beet it went up by 10 per cent. That is an indication of the favourable conditions that existed for successful farming and effective harvesting.
The reduction in the number of personsemployed in agriculture is, on the other hand, an indication of how agriculture has varied from the production point of view. If it were not for the increase in agricultural exports and the increased incomes to farmers for cattle, even the increase of 1.6 per cent. in the volume of agricultural production would not be something about which we could boast.
Every aspect of the economic situation with which the Minister has dealt here in his statement is an indication that he is trying to pull the wool over the eyes of the people outside as well as of the people here. He states, quite correctly, that the exports rose by £20,000,000 from 1952, and are still rising. He states that the balance of payments deficit had been reduced from £62,000,000 in 1951 and £30,000,000 in 1950 to the more tolerable figure of £9,000,000. We have protested for the last 12 months in various ways against a policy which is operating to the disadvantage of the general economic condition of our people here. We have protested against the disastrous policy of the Minister for Finance and the Government based upon a drastic reduction in the balance of payments.
What is the position? The deficit in our trading in January, 1952, was £6.3 million. In February of that year it was £6.5 million. In March it was £6.6 million. In April it was £7.0 million. A substantial fall has taken place in these deficits. In 1953 it was £3.27 million in January. In February it was £3.17 million. In March it was £2.67 million. Therefore, a fall of £9.1 million has taken place in our trading deficit in the first three months of this year, sufficient to wipe out completely, as a result of the change in our trading balance, the balance amounting to £9,000,000 last year. When we come to April we find that there has been a further decrease in our trading deficit of £2,000,000 and we are now, as a result of the Government's policy, beginning to build up in a rather substantial way our external assets; that is, the savings of our people are being to an increasing extent loaned to Britain for the purpose of developing British economy. We are once more in a violent way changinga very considerable part of our trading position and, therefore, a very considerable part of our employment position. We believe it is necessary to have a deficit in our balance of payments in order to deal with our undeveloped general economic situation here. The continuing weight of the Government's policy is now showing itself in the creation of a situation in which, while we want all the savings we can get, we continue to export these savings and lend our money to Britain for little or nothing and the Government through its policy tolerates the appalling situation of a rise to 5 per cent. in the basic charge for money here and that appalling policy is steadfastly maintained here.
I have indicated that the Government has shut down on consideration of serious matters in an effective way here. If we may mention the Health Bill again, it is taking more and more power to build up the grip of the State on our social as well as on our economic life.
When the Minister for Finance was introducing his Budget he gave details of the £39,290,000 which it was proposed to use as capital expenditure during the current year. He indicated, when dealing with the matter, that he was going to reduce that to £36,300,000. I notice, from discussions recently going on, that we are now going up to a proposed capital expenditure during the year of £40,000,000. I think Deputy McGilligan asked yesterday where this money was going to come from. There is another question which I would like to ask. Where does the Minister think that the capital for the maintenance and for the development of the private sector of our production economy is going to come from during a year in which the State is taxing to the extent that it is taxing the people and using that money on the general supply services while at the same time proposing, if we are to understand what has been said in recent weeks, to look for £40,000,000 for expenditure on capital projects? Is that not again strengthening the hand of the State against the individual developer of our industrial and commerciallife? Where does the Minister think that is going to lead to, particularly in view of the confusion and incompetency which have so marked the actions of the Fianna Fáil Government over so many years?
I think that we require to be told by the Minister for Finance, before he shuts down this Parliament, what is his outlook and policy with regard to the raising of capital for Government capital expenditure on the one hand, and where he thinks the commercial, industrial and agricultural communities are going to get the capital which they require for the maintenance and development of the really important and really productive part of our economy— the economy that even the incompetency, the panic and the inefficient policies of the Government over the last two years have not been able to crush at any time?
Have the Government any idea how many employers there are among the unemployed at the moment? Have they any idea how many men among the ranks of the unemployed to-day were themselves employing four, five, six, ten or 12 men a year or two ago? The fact is that they are there. I want to know if the Government have any idea as to how any of these men are going to get back into the position of being employers this year or next year.
Deputy Hickey has been asking us to try and concentrate our minds on what is likely to happen in 1954. I appreciate very much his anxiety or the anxiety of any Deputy to concentrate on these things. One of the complaints which I have against the Government's policy of putting this House out of commission is that, within the next few weeks, it is going to prevent us from having a detailed discussion on the various Estimates. Estimates such as those for the Department of Industry and Commerce, the Board of Works, Unemployment Schemes, Social Welfare, and Estimates dealing with the western districts. We are going to be prevented from getting down to details on all these things. The Minister for Finance while giving us all these great figures for the purpose of misleading us, gave us no idea, good, bad or indifferent, as to what his proposals arefor getting the capital that he requires for carrying out the capital projects that he indicated during his Budget speech with a sum of £36,300,000, or with the £40,000,000 that has been indicated to us in recent speeches by members of the Government. They have indicated in their speeches that this sum of £40,000,000 is to be provided.
On the general use of language to cover and distort a situation, I find that I would like to get the Minister for Finance to direct his attention to a statement made in the Seanad on the 15th instant by Senator Professor O'Brien when the Finance Bill was being discussed there. Speaking at column 228, Senator O'Brien said:—
"I think we can say right away that the Budget is not deflationary. The 1952 Budget was deflationary."
Speaking at column 229, he went on to say:—
"We are all agreed that it was a deflationary Budget. This Budget is not deflationary. It imposes no new taxes. It reduces no subsidies. It does nothing to raise interest rates to a higher level."
He said later:—
"It is difficult to say whether it could be described as inflationary. Perhaps, the correct description would be to say that it has a potentially inflationary effect."
The Minister for Finance, and the Minister for External Affairs in his previous contacts with the Department of Finance and since then have been very adept in discussing inflationary and deflationary effects. What does it matter what terms are applied to what is happening here, if what is really happening is that the taxation burden that was put down on top of the people last year is being maintained this year, whereas, last year, it was put down on people who were emerging from a period of substantial employment, if not full employment? Last year's heavy blow of taxation hit people who had been somewhat refreshed by three years of a period in which there had been hope, encouragement and employment. The same weight of taxation is hittingthem again this year, hitting them after they had suffered from the economic and unemployment distresses of the last 12 months. What does language mean, or what do figures mean, to those people? Is it not the people and the condition in which they are that we are concerned with?
The various statements that have been made recently indicate that we are now going to have relief works. Let us have relief works. Some people object to them being called relief works. They want them called works of development. Call them anything you like, but they are, in fact, works that are carried out by the Government in relation to matters that, at any rate, are somewhat removed from the basic development of our economy here which is the development of the production that is in the hands of private employers and private companies. At any rate, this expenditure is going to be of a type that in the past at any rate was called relief works. Anybody who has had any experience of what were called relief works in the past, must be very well acquainted with the very definite argument there has been as to whether relief works are not more costly and more wasteful than the giving of maintenance payments to keep people in a position that will enable them to carry on and pay for their subsistence. There has been a long and substantial argument that it is easier financially for a country to pay direct payments to people than to pay them in the kind of works that, in the past at any rate, were organised as relief works.
Two years of the Government's control of things and of their policy brings us from a condition in which there was hope and confidence and something near full employment to relief works. That is the position to which the country is reduced. The dilemma of those who regard this Parliament from a sense of responsibility and who have an understanding of what its function is—to safeguard, help and sustain the people and to aid them to do their work—is that we find ourselves just herded in here by the type of business that the Government is ordering, and told that we cangabble along here but will not be allowed to come near practical decisions on the details of the Government's policy that would jeopardise the Government's position in the House.
So determined have the Government been to see that nothing is done, that there is just a period of halt in which they can blow and blah about things in general, that they introduced the measure to postpone the local government elections. The country has been told that the Government have plans for changing the local government machinery. Under cover of a statement of that kind, the Government introduced a measure to prevent the local government elections from taking place. The small margin of authority and the queer margin of authority that the Government have in the House has put them in the position that they can stifle the electorate on all occasions except when a by-election takes place. They are using their position in the House just to order business that will deal with general matters and, by the generality of the way in which things are being discussed, prevent them from being put in the awkward position that would arise if members of their Party and Independent Deputies would have to use their consciences in taking decisions.
Deputy Gallagher yesterday spoke of the tragedy of unemployment. He spoke in a personal way of how much he was able to appreciate it. He, nevertheless, supports the Government that is responsible for it and, when he is driven into an argument as to why on earth he would do such a thing, he has to point to the halos that surround the heads of some of his leaders, from the Minister for Justice, Deputy Boland, to the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera. That was the final argument that Deputy Gallagher produced to us last night as to why he supports the Government that is responsible for so much of the unemployment and misery that he complains about and feels so much.
Comment on this
I should like, first of all, to compliment Deputy Mulcahyon the industry he displayed in counting the columns of talk reported in the Dáil Debates since the beginning of this session. One has heard of Nero fiddling but here we have Deputy Mulcahy counting columns when there is serious work to be done in the House. What is the purpose of this Vote? This Vote on Account is necessitated by the fact that the House has not dealt and cannot deal with the Estimates in full before the 31st July. When the House finds itself in that position the Government moves the Vote on Account to enable the services of the country to be continued until such time as the Estimates are debated fully and passed. That has been done not only in this country but in other countries where there are democratic institutions such as this. If we had an Opposition with a sense of that responsibility about which Deputy Mulcahy talks, the Vote on Account would be passed without any debate or discussion.
If the Vote on Account were not passed, the position would be that there would be no money to pay anybody as from the 1st August, no money to pay the Civil Service, the Army, the Garda, the old age pensioners, no money to provide allowances for widows and orphans, no money for the unemployed. There would be no money for any of those people if this Vote on Account were not passed. It seems to me that responsible people in the House would agree as a matter of course to provide the amount that is set out in this Vote on Account so that the services could be carried on until November next.
As Deputy Gallagher and other Deputies have pointed out, since the beginning of the present session, in fact, since the beginning of the year, Fine Gael have been engaged in a campaign of obstruction, a campaign of holding up necessary work. The Fine Gael Party is responsible for the fact that the Estimates have not been debated in full during the present session.
The House must seriously consider the whole machinery of dealing with Estimates. In the British Parliament it is agreed on all sides that certain Estimates are discussed and that certain other Estimates are passed almostautomatically. Discussions on Estimates are not discussions, as Deputy Mulcahy suggested, on matters of Government policy. It is not permitted to discuss Government policy on the Estimates. On Estimates, one may discuss the administration of a Department for the previous 12 months. That is all that may be discussed on the Estimates. If Fine Gael want to assist in the democratic constitutional Government of this State, there is no reason why they cannot arrange amongst themselves that some of their members will give the Party line in regard to the Estimates. But, unfortunately, we have developed over the years a habit that when an Estimate is introduced it is opposed as a matter of form by somebody on the Opposition Benches and the speech that he makes is repeated word for word by perhaps 20 other Deputies on his own side. Hours of Parliamentary time are wasted by this continuous repetition.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. O'Higgins refers to the Army Bill. That is a Bill which has been discussed for a small number of hours in this House.
Comment on this
It is a Bill which, as far as I am concerned, will be a good Bill when it leaves this House. The amendments which I have put down to that Bill are amendments, not for the purpose of obstruction, but for the purpose of getting a decent Bill.
Comment on this
When I spent many hours at night delving into that Bill and preparing amendments I am sorry that I did not think of the publicity value at the time.
Comment on this
I know that I can suggest easier methods of getting publicity. Perhaps some of the Deputies might be able to give me lessons in easier methods of getting publicity. However, last year we were in the position coming to the end of July that we had not passed all the Estimates. The Dáil, in the frame of mind it was in then, agreed to pass the Estimates in globo,with the right to the Opposition to discuss any of these Estimates after the Dáil reassembled in the autumn. I opposed that at the time as I thought it was wrong. I thought that the House should deal with its business and that there should be none of this postponement of business to another session. The debates we had on these Estimates in the autumn have had the effect of slowing up the business of the House.
Deputy Mulcahy referred to Government policy. Government policy has been discussed in the past few months on many occasions. It was very fully discussed on the first Vote on Account; it was discussed on the Budget; it was discussed on the various stages of the Finance Bill; it was discussed on the vote of confidence; and now it is being discussed again on this Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I am talking about the business of the House. Policy has been discussed on all these occasions and perhaps on other occasions since the beginning of the year. Every Deputy has had his opportunity of discussing Government policy. On the votes that arose on all these matters, the Government have had the decisive support of the majority of Deputies in this House.
Comment on this
Democratic Government can only be carried on when the Government have the support ofa majority of Deputies in the House. We are in the position that the Government have a small majority. The inter-Party Government, which was in office for three and a half years, had a similar small majority. A very strong effort was made by Fine Gael to become the Government of the country at the present time. If they had succeeded, they would have been governing this country by even a smaller majority than the present Government. A Labour Government in Great Britain carried on for a number of years with a very small majority. A British Conservative Government are carrying on since the last general election with a small majority.
According to the Tánaiste, speaking in this House on the vote of confidence, it is likely that for many years to come such large majorities as Governments enjoyed in the past will not exist. The House and the country will have to get used to a position in which the Government will exercise their constitutional power on behalf of the people with a small majority. The very fact that the majority is small does not entitle any person to say that the authority of that Government is not a good one. That is the new idea, the new line, that has developed in this House over the past 12 month, or two years.
Comment on this
Only then—that because the Government have only a small majority they have no right to administer the affairs of this country.
Comment on this
For the last two years we have had call after call for a general election from Deputy Mulcahy. We have certain organs of the Press who support the Deputy calling for a general election.
Comment on this
Will you quote what the Taoiseach said in 1947 with regard to the powers of this House?
Comment on this
The purpose of the whole campaign is to create a spirit of instability in the country.
Comment on this
The whole purpose has been to create a spirit of instability that would lead to unemployment.
Comment on this
That has been the whole purpose—to create a situation whereby unemployment would be caused day after day. The people are beginning to see through that. The people are beginning to see the effects of that policy which is not the policy of the Government but the policy of the Opposition, a policy of instability, of unemployment, of creating a lack of confidence in the institutions of the State.
Comment on this
If there is one thing that I would have agreed with Deputy Mulcahy about, it is this: that perhaps the Government instead of introducing this Vote on Account would have brought in a motion for consideration by the Dáil, enabling the Dáil to finish the Estimates before 31st July and the Government would have a majority in the House to see that that was done.
Now, we have had in the course of the debate a reference by Deputy Mulcahy to the Health Bill. The Health Bill is one of the Bills which the Governmenthas decided will be passed into law at the earliest opportunity. It is part of the social measures which the people of this country require. It follows and takes its place with the Social Welfare Bill which I am glad to say has been passed into law by the present Government since the general election.
Comment on this
The Army Pensions Bill, which has been before the House and has passed its Committee Stage, is another of the important measures of social legislation that the people required and which is on its way to be passed into law. The Workmen's Compensation Act is another important measure which I was hoping we would have passed into law in all its stages before 31st July. But Deputy Mulcahy has made the suggestion that the Government has decided—in fact he said that the Minister for Finance had decided—that these Estimates would not be discussed by the Dáil. The Dáil is all powerful in these matters and as far as I can see, while it may have been the tradition over a number of years to close down for recess on the 31st July, I think it is in the public interest that this session should continue until all these Estimates are passed and the work of the session is completed and if the Government take a decision to introduce a motion to that effect I am quite prepared to support it. I think it would be in the public interest.
Comment on this
I would support a proposal that the House should sit until the business of the session is completed.
Comment on this
It is an extraordinary thing how opposition to this Vote on Account has been taken. Opposition to it has been taken by the Fine Gael Party and the Fine Gael Party apparently are not too happy themselves in regard to their opposition to this necessary Vote on Account. Into the trenches last night we had thrown Deputy McGilligan who makes an appearance in the House now and again. He was thrown in to lead for the Opposition and he was followed by Deputy Flanagan. Deputy Rooney was in reserve waiting to be called last night and then Deputy Mulcahy with his record of columns of talk was thrown in to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins was not here to hear Deputy Mulcahy telling of the count—the precise count —he made of all the columns of talk that have taken place on different matters in his House since the session started.
Comment on this
I am perfectly satisfied he is much better at action than talk because he certainly counted the columns and that required some action on his part. Deputy McGilligan, whom one might have expected to advance some constructive argument in regard to the matter discussed, made one of his usual propaganda platform speeches. Generally he comes into this House armed with stacks of references. Yesterday he just picked out of the hip pocket of his trousers his standard political propaganda speech and spoke it here. There was nothing new in it, nothing that has not been said many times in the past 21 years. It interested me considerably to hear him talking yesterday again about banking, currency and credit.
Deputy McGilligan was a Deputy of this House when the Central Bank Bill was going through and he made exactly the same speech on credit, currency and banking on the CentralBank Bill as he made here yesterday. He said that the bankers would have to be tackled. I have no objection to that, but what I have objection to is that a Deputy knowing that those were his views when the Central Bank Bill was going through became subsequently Minister for Finance and was Minister for Finance for three and a half years and never did anything to put his principles or alleged principles into operation and when he is out of office and can do nothing about it he comes in and repeats the whole speech of ten years ago, or so.
Deputy McGilligan had some contemptuous references for Deputies such as myself who take a line in opposition to him. When I was supporting him, supporting the Government of which he was a member, I was all right, but when I disagreed with the line he is now taking, then he must make these contemptuous references to me and to other Independent Deputies in the House. Now, I wonder if Deputy McGilligan has any right to make contemptuous references about any Deputies in this House? As I say, Deputy McGilligan did nothing about amending the Central Bank Bill when he was Minister for Finance for three and a half years. Is it possible that Deputy McGilligan had not the time to do it? Is it possible that during those three and a half years he could not take sufficient time off from his law lectures in University College, Dublin, to look after the affairs of this State? What other Deputy of this House if he were appointed Minister would during the period when he was Minister carry on his business of professor of law in a university instead of giving his full time in the public interest?
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan came in here yesterday afternoon andmade certain contemptuous references to other Deputies and he is not going to get away with it.
Comment on this
I am not pursuing it any further because I am finished with it but I do say that when a Deputy comes in here to make contemptuous references to other Deputies, he should think twice before he does so. It was only recently I heard of that shocking affair. It has not been done by any other Minister in this State since the State was established and I do not think it has been done by a Minister in any of the States that are run under democratic institutions, such as exist in this country. It is a pity that Deputy McGilligan did not have enough time to give some effect to the observations that he made ten years ago in regard to finance and monetary reform and to which he again gives expression now when he is not in a position to do anything about it.
The general condemnation of the Government is put under four heads— unemployment, cost of living, the reduction in house building, and emigration. There have been references to marches of the unemployed. I want to say, as I have already said, that I am glad the unemployed marched in the city to draw attention to the fact that they were seeking work and wanted work. But there have been marches of the unemployed on many occasions during the last 25 years. I have seen marches of the unemployed in the last 25 years. I have addressed meetings of the unemployed on many occasions in the past 25 years and I always took the line of telling the unemployed that they would never get anything unless they were prepared to fight for it.
Comment on this
In those years the number of unemployed in this city and in the country approximated to 60,000, 70,000, 80,000 or 90,000. The numberfluctuated, but over the past 30 years there has been that level of unemployment all over the country. Why has there been that unemployment? Because the system to which Deputy Mulcahy gave expression, the system of private enterprise, has failed to provide employment for these people. I have always said that it is the duty of the Government to provide employment for people who are unemployed and able to work. That view is not held by everybody in this House. It was not held by Deputy McGilligan when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Cosgrave Government. He never accepted the principle that it was the duty of the Government to provide work for the unemployed. I have seen many cases of hardship and destitution not only in the City of Dublin but in many parts of the country. It was the sight of hardship, destitution, hunger, poverty and misery that brought me into politics at all and into public life. I want to see something done that will really put an end to this continuous misery of unemployment and hunger because I think that there should be no reason why any person, particularly why any little child in this country, should be hungry. It is a food-producing country, a wealthy country and it can provide food and the necessaries of life for everybody living in the country. Unfortunately we have not got agreement as to the means of distributing that food so that there will be no more hunger or misery in the country.
We have had this unemployment problem for 30 years. The problem to-day is as big as ever it was although the figures for several weeks show that unemployment has been decreasing at the rate of roughly 1,000 a week but we have had that unemployment and we shall continue to have that unemployment unless we have a completely new approach to the problem. When the Government prepared plans—and unemployment can only be solved by putting into operation plans of public works—we had leading Ministers of the old inter-Party Government and leading members of the Fine Gael Party, going around the country condemning every proposal that was put forwardfor giving employment to people who were unemployed.
Comment on this
This country can only get along in the way France and other countries get along—by the provision year after year of a certain percentage of the Budget moneys for the doing of public works. When I talk about public works I am not talking about the miserable relief works I used to see down the country where a number of people were taken from the labour exchanges in the middle of winter, unfortunate people who had been suffering hunger during the whole of the year up to that and were put up to their necks in water to clean up a drain here and there. That is not what I speak about. I speak about public works in the provision of public amenities that will enrich and benefit the country. We have sat down on that job for the last 30 years. Look around the City of Dublin and you can count on the fingers of your two hands the number of new public buildings that have been erected in the last 30 years.
Comment on this
On the fingers of your two hands you can count the number of public buildings that have been built over the last 30 years. That is no credit to us. We should have built many important public buildings during that time. We want, as everybody knows, new Government buildings. The erection of new Government buildings will provide work over a number of years. Yet Deputy Seán MacEoin goes down the country and condemns any scheme for the building of new Government buildings.
Comment on this
We want new Parliament buildings. That mentality is the cause of all this unemployment, and we have not yet agreed on how we are to deal with that. When we get the mentality of Deputy Giles, who holds that we should do no workat all, the question is how can we solve the unemployment problem?
Comment on this
Deputy Giles asked why should we build public buildings and says that in building five or six buildings in the last 30 years we were doing too much.
Comment on this
Blow up half Dublin and send the people down the country. Then you will solve the unemployment problem.
Comment on this
It is all very well to talk about taking the people out of Dublin and sending them down the country. Happily, we have not reached that state of regimentation here yet and, even if we were inclined towards that idea, the whole movement in the world is against it. The movement to-day is into the cities and towns and nothing can stop that. Deputy Giles may think it is a bad thing that the people are leaving the countryside, but the same story can be told of many parts of the world. It may be a bad thing to have the people flocking into the cities and towns but one cannot stop that movement by repressive measures irrespective of what Government is in power. We could say to the farmer: "Give your workers £2 per week more and they will stay with you." What would Deputy Giles' reaction be to that?
Comment on this
We will leave it at that. We must get down to the problem of public works. I am glad that the corporation in Dublin has taken a decision to establish a committee, of which I am a member, the purpose of which will be to endeavour to provide public works of the kind to which I have referred—not gazebos built for the purpose of only being built but things which will enrich and improvethe city. In giving employment to our fellow men in carrying out that work we will bring happiness and contentment into many thousands of homes. If we can put 1,000 people into employment to-morrow on a direct scheme of public works, paying them a decent trade union rate of wages, there will be employed indirectly as a result of that 4,000 people. For every 1,000 we put directly into employment 4,000 will be indirectly put into employment. That is a well-established fact known to economists all over the world.
Comment on this
That is the Fine Gael approach: what will it cost? Can we afford it? To the devil with broken men, broken women and hungry children ! Where will we get the money to do it? That is the Fine Gael mentality.
Comment on this
Whatever number of Parties I have been connected with, I never had anything to do with Fine Gael.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael mentality has always been wrong. Where will the money come from? That has been responsible in large measure for the enormous emigration we had in the period 1922 to 1932, and for the queues of unemployed during that period.
Comment on this
As far as we are concerned in the corporation, whatever money the scheme will cost will, we understand, be provided by the Government for us. This committee was only set up last Monday. It will hold its first meeting to-night, and we will have details in relation to the cost.
Comment on this
What were you doing for years back that you had not the men working? Did you only get your committee when they stopped you outside Leinster House?
Comment on this
I have special reasons for not responding to Deputy Dr. O'Higgins in the way in which I might. I want to put before the House constructive proposals in relation to the problem of unemployment. If we can abolish this Deputy General MacEoin idea of condemning public works such as Houses of Parliament, Government buildings and municipal offices, and if we can get agreement from Fine Gael that it is desirable to spend £5,000,000 or £10,000,000 every year on the provision of public works, then we will make substantial progress in solving our huge unemployment problem. Certain unemployment has been created in the last two years by Fine Gael propaganda to the effect that the Government is not stable, that it would not exist much longer, that it only had a few weeks to run. Certain people who intended to spend money were misled by that propaganda with the result that all over the country men were let go. A good deal of unemployment is the result of that damaging propaganda directed against the present Government over the last two years.
There is very little likelihood of this Government being defeated until its term of office has run its full course and if we can get that idea across to the people we will very quickly find that there will be employment for the odd ones here and there and the total will be a substantial one. We must create confidence because confidence engenders prosperity. Fine Gael, for their own purposes, want to create a feeling of instability and they want to deprive the people of that confidence necessary to the country's maintenance.
In to-day's paper I was glad to read that the Corrib drainage scheme will give employment to 500 people in the West of Ireland. That will be very valuable and the Government should be applauded for speeding up plans and operations so that that work can be put in hands straight away.
The cost of living has been referred to. It is higher than it was some years ago but it is lower than it is in England and in Northern Ireland. One can get decent food here at a reasonable price. One cannot do that in England.
There is no comparison between the cost of living here and the high cost of living in France or in the United States of America. Every one of us would wish to reduce the cost of living if we could. I do not think it does this country any good for people to be moaning and groaning on platforms all over the country that the cost of living here is the highest in the world. That is no good to the country because it is not true. The cost of living is undoubtedly higher than it was a couple of years ago, but it should be put in its proper perspective in relation to the cost of living elsewhere.
There are few countries in the world to-day where you could get as fine food as one can get it here, or get it at the price it is in this country. The unfortunate thing is that we have people who are working but they are not earning enough money to buy the food they need. That is no new story in this country. It, unfortunately, has been so for many years. It is also true that we have unemployed who cannot buy the very fine food that we have because their allowances are inadequate, although these allowances have been substantially increased by the present Government. There are some allowances which, certainly, were not there when the Fine Gael Party were the Government, such as children's allowances, widows' allowances or the allowances for the unemployed who are now on unemployment assistance.
It would be a great thing if we could reduce the cost of living and if we could reduce the price of milk in Dublin City. It would be a grand thing,but what would be the reactions of the farmers to it, or if we could reduce the price of butter. We could not do that unless we got back to the subsidy business. It had the effect, as we all know, of enabling butter to be smuggled across the Border and sold there, butter that was distributed on a rationed basis all over the country at a subsidised price. That butter went across the Border in lorry loads.
These are the practical problems which we have to face. As I say, there will be great difficulty in any Government reducing the cost of living unless it is prepared to raise millions of money in taxation for the purpose of subsidising certain foods.
House building is another matter. We have been told that there has been a reduction in house building. As far as the Dublin Corporation is concerned, there has been no reduction in house building. We are still building on the average that we have been building over the last three years. I want the House to realise this, that we in the Dublin Corporation understand that if we build 10,000 more houses we will have solved the housing problem in Dublin City. In other words, building at the rate of 2,000 houses a year for five years the housing problem as far as the Dublin Corporation is concerned will have been solved.
Now there is one big problem confronting the city council and confronting the trade unions and that is should we speed up that work now and do it in three years or should it be spread over the five years in order to maintain continuity in employment. That is the huge problem that confronts the trade unions and confronts the corporation. It is one which must confront every person in this House who feels he has any responsibility in regard to public affairs. The position is that we are building and will continue to build for the next five years 2,000 houses a year. That will be the average. In one year it may be 2,100 or 2,200 but the approximate figure is 2,000 houses a year for the next five years.
As far as money under the Small Dwellings Act is concerned we in theDublin Corporation had to make provision the other day for £3,000,000. That money is required for payments under the Small Dwellings Acts for houses that have been and are being built. Deputy Gallagher said to-day that the average number of these houses built over some years has been 400. He also mentioned that there are 800 applications in this year so far for advances under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act. Therefore so far as the public authority is concerned there has been no reduction in building in Dublin.
We know that a number of people had the idea of buying their own houses a couple of years ago. People did in fact buy them. They paid a deposit of £200 or £250 on a house. They entered into negotiations with a building society and took a mortgage on the balance. Very many of these people have found that they have not been able to meet their commitments or their obligations. This morning I met a woman who had entered into a commitment of that kind. She is the wife of a tradesman, a plasterer who has been employed and is employed. She has a large family. She told me that the sheriff is going to put her out next Monday because she has been unable to pay the instalment on the loan she got.
Comment on this
I am glad to say that the Dublin Corporation has agreed to house that family. It takes a very sympathetic view of all these cases. We do our best and I am glad to say that although the woman will be put out of the house which she has been buying for the last couple of years and will lose her deposit she will not be homeless on Monday next.
I mention that case to show that there are a number of people who, by making small deposits, were endeavouring to become the owners of their own houses, but they have found from experience that they were not able to meet the charges and so a lot of these houses are coming on the market day after day. There are many applications in with the city council and with the Dublin County Council to approve of transfers in the case of these housesThere is in the building industry quite a considerable number of people unemployed. The desire ought to be to put these men back in employment as quickly as possible. There is a suggestion which I want to make to the Government. I am glad that the Minister for External Affairs is here. The suggestion is that the Dublin Corporation and public authorities generally should help people who want to build their own houses by the provision of sites with roads and sewerage installed. I would be in favour of making the provision of sites almost free for citizens. In fact I would make them free for people who want to build their own houses and I would have these sites, roads, severage and all services made available and put in by the local authority. In that way we would be able to encourage quite a number of our citizens to take the plunge and build houses for themselves. It is only in that way coupled with the reconstruction of the Castle and work of that kind that we could solve the unemployment problem among skilled building workers. Skilled building workers are a problem. Every effort should be made to put these men back into employment. They are out of employment now, not because of any Government decision but because of a natural change in circumstances. The sooner that is appreciated, the better and the sooner we will be able to solve the problem.
The last matter raised is the question of emigration. Since the Famine of 1847 there has been a drift of people out of this country year after year. Only recently a parish priest in the West of Ireland told me that there were roughly 40,000 direct emigrants or descendants of emigrants in Boston, U.S.A., from that small area of the country. When one talks to any of the older people in Connemara one finds that every one of them has lived in the United States for a time. There is nothing that will stop the people of this country emigrating. A number of them desire to emigrate, to go abroad and see their friends and relatives. That emigration is what one might term voluntary emigration. There is a different type of emigration. There is enforced emigration that isdue to unemployment. We have had enforced emigration for many years. Emigration and unemployment go hand in hand.
We must stop enforced emigration by the provision of employment here. I have talked about workers who are engaged in building and kindred work. In my view, much more employment could be given on the land if the land were properly distributed. It is a shame that there are hundreds of acres left derelict and improperly tilled and cultivated. As I have said before, the food situation in the world is very serious. There will be grave shortages and famines, unfortunately, in many places in the near future. This country can contribute a tremendous amount to ease the danger of famine by the provision of food. We have tens of thousands of acres that are not under cultivation. Those acres should be under cultivation. I have my own views about how they can be put under cultivation but, whether one agrees with my views in regard to that or not, there is a problem arising from the fact that the land is not being used to its fullest extent. If the land were used to the fullest extent, there would be opportunities for employment for thousands of people on the land. As I look at it, this is a national problem, a social problem, a problem that will have to be faced no matter what Government happens to be in power. I want to see it faced by the united effort of this Irish Parliament.
We should try to inculcate in the people as a whole the idea that they live in one of the finest countries in the world, one of the best countries in the world, that there are better opportunities for employment here than there are in other countries if we would only stand together and pull together in the interests of the country. We should try to inculcate the idea in our young people that we have amenities and sports, fun and amusement and opportunities for marrying in this country that are not in every other country. That is the line we should follow instead of the moaning and the wailing that we have on the public platforms about this country being down and out, about its being theworst country in the world, about its having the highest cost of living.
Comment on this
We have a grand country if we would only get together and do the things that ought to be done. Deputy Hickey has referred to all this talk about our being bankrupt. We are not bankrupt. We need not be bankrupt. There is no necessity for us to be bankrupt.
Comment on this
If we all make a genuine effort we can create conditions that will lead to an increase in employment. This country is reduced now to a population of roughly 3,000,000 people. We must increase that population rapidly because we require a higher population to make the country economically sound. It is the drain of emigration that is doing damage to the country. If we can stop the drain of emigration by providing employment we will be able to increase the population and bring prosperity into every home. There is a responsibility on the Fine Gael section of the Opposition to stop moaning and wailing and running down the country.
Comment on this
I would appeal to Deputies of Fine Gael to give up that moaning and wailing and condemnation——
Comment on this
——and help us all to try to make this country what it ought to be, the very best country in the world.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan took a line which was adopted by one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies last night and which I resent, namely, that in recent months we, on this side of the House, have pursued a policy of obstruction and that for that reason the Estimates cannot be dealt with within the statutory time. May I remind Deputy Cowan that a week was wasted discussing a vote of confidence, a vote of confidence which had been denied to the Government by the people in the ballot boxes and that that week could have been well utilised in discussing Estimates?
We also had Deputy Cowan telling the Parties to detail certain Deputies to speak on certain Estimates. How can we get the Estimate for Agriculture when Dublin City Deputies will insist on speaking on agriculture which most of them know very little about? You cannot level the charge at this side of the House that we are responsible. That charge was made last night after the Minister for Defence had thanked the House for the expenditious manner in which the Military Service Pensions Bill was dealt with. My interpretation of obstruction would be that every measure coming before the House would be opposed. It is worth nothing that the Minister for External Affairs spoke for two hours on the vote of confidence. Ministers are the greatest culprits in the matter of delaying the House by making lengthy speeches. Deputies are as much entitled to speak on any measure as any Minister.
On this Vote on Account, we intend to avail of the opportunity of putting on record the opinions of the people in relation to the Government's financial policy. As a result of the wailings and groanings that went on in ministerialcircles, following the advent of this Government to office, about the condition in which the country was then we had a recession in trade, an increase in unemployment, resumed emigration, and a general depression in industry during the past two years. The Government had to meet an obstruction of their own making in their first year of office when they could not go to the country for a loan in the atmosphere they had created by decrying the achievements of their predecessors. In that atmosphere, they could not ask the people's support for a national loan because they were afraid of the consequences. Then when they did float a national loan they paid an exorbitant rate of interest. The stock exchange returns since prove that we paid too much for that money.
A city Deputy told us last night that they would have to find £3,000,000 for loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. It is worthy of note that as a result of the interest paid on the last loan—the indications are that at least the same rate will have to be paid for the coming loan—young people in the City of Dublin will have to pay £30,000 extra in interest on the loans they will receive under that Act. I am more concerned with agriculture, and it is a great impediment to progress in that sphere that the Agricultural Credit Corporation have had to raise their rate of interest on loans as a direct result of the financial policy pursued by the Government.
Deputy Cowan blamed the previous Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, for not having done something about the Central Bank. There is nothing wrong with the Central Bank giving advice to any Government. They gave it to the inter-Party Government and to this Government. The fault lay in the acceptance of that advice. We can now see the results quite clearly in the number unemployed, in the increased cost of living, and in the general condition of affairs throughout the country. For a time Government Deputies made puerile efforts to minimise the situation in regard to unemployment. But, speaking on the vote of confidence, Deputy Dr. Browne, as an IndependentDeputy supporting the Government, stated that Fine Gael had not in any way exaggerated the situation with regard to unemployment. I would point out to that Deputy and other Deputies that it was their support of all measures introduced by this Government which has brought about that situation.
As to the Government's drive to dig deeper into the people's pockets by way of increased taxation, following on the Taoiseach's statement that the country was staggering under an excessive load of taxation the Minister for Finance now finds that the law of diminishing returns is operating in a very strong way. We find that revenue has been reduced because the people were unable to consume the amount of commodities which the Minister thought they would consume so that he would have millions with which to play around. Deputy Mulcahy indicated that the revenue from cigarettes and tobacco had increased by only £5.3 million, whereas it should have been £7,000,000 if the same consumption was maintained. We have had in recent weeks very clear evidence that the tax on spirits has dealt a very heavy blow to that industry which was giving valuable employment and paying fair prices to a very large number of farmers for raw materials. The position is that that industry to-day has its back to the wall as a result of the financial policy of the Government.
Deputy Cowan stated that this Government had substantial majorities on all the votes which they sought in this House since the last election. I do not agree with that. The most important vote from the Government's point of view was when they tried to secure a majority in this House on the vote of confidence. It was our belief that as the people had recorded their disapproval of Government policy the people constituted the jury before whom the Government should go. Although it was this House which put the Government in office, when they sought a majority on the vote of confidence they failed to secure that majority. They only secured the support of 50 per cent. of the members ofthe House. One member indicated that he was opposed to giving a vote of confidence to the Government, but, for reasons best known to himself, he abstained from voting. Another Deputy elected to oppose the Government occupies the position of Ceann Comhairle and, of course, could not record his vote. Taking these things into consideration, the Government were denied a majority on that occasion.
To return to the important matter of unemployment, I would say, as representing a country constituency, that it is a matter of great concern to us that in the small towns in my constituency we have unemployment for the first time. The principal reason for that is the recession in the building industry. Many skilled workers who returned from abroad to take part in building operations here a few years ago are now registering at the employment exchanges. In the rural areas we have a ready-made scheme for absorbing these unemployed people. Deputy Cowan may sneer at the Local Authorities (Works) Act. That was introduced by a Labour Party Minister in the inter-Party Government. It is to his credit and to the credit of Deputy Corish, who was responsible for its operation after the late Minister's death, that it has given very valuable employment in the country. In particular, a very large percentage of the moneys voted for it was spent on payments to workers engaged on the scheme. Relatively little went in administrative costs. I know this, that if every the loyalty of members of Fianna Fáil who were members of local authorities was tried it was tried then because these men knew the benefits this scheme was bringing to their area and in company with other local representatives supported this at that time. They produced to the county manager and the county council officers schemes which they felt would be useful for the clearance of land or of obstructions in water courses with sure benefit to the work under the land rehabilitation scheme.
In County Cork we had at that time over £150,000 of a grant for that work.This year it was reduced to £48,000. Some weeks ago I asked the Minister for Local Government what it was likely to be next year and he said: "Half the present amount." Well, spread £24,000 over the County of Cork in schemes like that and you will see that not very much employment can be given by it. With the Government now in a state of emergency looking round for schemes to absorb the unemployed, I would ask them to take up that scheme again. Let them forget the year it was introduced, forget who introduced it and put it back into operation, safe in the knowledge that it will give useful employment to men who are not afraid of the conditions Deputy Cowan referred to. Perhaps, compared with conditions in the cities, city workers would find it very strange, but those who are used to working on the land for seven days of the week and often for 14 or 15 hours a day have to work under similar conditions and they have no court of appeal. Surely men that were formerly engaged on this work could be used for this scheme with consequent benefit to the country as a whole and it would be a definite help to increase production. I know that many acres scheduled for work under the scheme are now waterlogged and the farmers cannot get any income or profit from them. But if they were drained they would give some return to the farmers and perhaps he would be able to keep another member of his family at home working on the land, or he could put more cattle on it or obtain more crops from it. I merely suggest that, if you want a scheme that could improve the present situation in relation to unemployment in this country.
In this Vote on Account, I note with some concern a reduction of £1,738,910 for agriculture. I note a reduction in the supplementary agricultural grants of £51,000, and then I wonder how much extra employment would be given by an increase of £2,400 for the Secret Service. I wonder what field of production would be enhanced by that allowance? And that is some of the money we are asked to vote on this and asked to do it, as Deputy Cowan would have us do it, without demur.
One of the grave problems facing this country to-day is the cost of living which everybody has to meet. When Deputies speak of butter versus farmers anybody would think that the farmers and their wives and families and employees do not eat any butter and that every single penny comes back to them the moment the consumer has to pay an increased price for butter. I know this: if the Cork and Dublin consumers had been aware of the prices they would be asked to pay for that essential foodstuff before Fianna Fáil were two years in office, they would certainly think twice before they would vote for new Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party or for Independent Deputies who voted this Government into office.
The slashing of the food subsidies as they were slashed showed its result in the cost of living——
Comment on this
The Deputy refers to the guaranteed minimum price which is not guaranteed by the Government. There is no guaranteed minimum price. Many results have come from the effects of the increase in the various items of the cost of living. They have been often specified here on these benches and must surely be accepted by everyone now. When I hear Deputies talking of hunger, I would ask them what Government increased the price of the loaf from 6½d. to 9½d.; or what Minister for Finance was responsible for the price of flour going up from 2/8 to 4/9½.
Comment on this
What Minister for Finance was responsible for the price of sugar going from 4½d. to 7d. a lb.; or what Minister for Finance or what Government was responsible for raising the price of tea from 2/8 to 5/6 a lb.? And what Minister, when he was seeking more money to carry out whatever schemes he had in mind was responsible for increasing the price of cigarettes from 1/8 to 2/4 per packetof 20? Or for increasing the price of petrol as it was increased? Or for increasing taxation on all vehicles transporting goods or passengers in this country? Transport charges have a vital effect on increasing production, as they are charges which every single one has to meet, and in particular, the farmer, because in that field owing to the type of produce he is engaged in bringing to market, any increase in transport costs is a definite blow to him. Even the Taoiseach recognised that when he sought election in Clare. He stated that the Government then in office were experts in hidden taxation because everything and anything in the way of a charge on vehicles or petrol or postage stamps or any levy was, in effect, a tax and nothing but a tax.
Now the Government, as the Taoiseach said, having reached the limit of taxation are, through the activities of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Health—by passing 50 per cent. of the cost of his new Bill on to the rates— are passing on new taxes month after month. We were told when the food subsidies were slashed there would be compensatory benefits for all sections of the community. It would be impossible, even if all 147 members of this House were to speak on every occasion, for them to recount all the ill results that have accrued from the slashing of the food subsidies. Various people were given—because they were sufficiently organised—increases to meet that increase in the cost of living but what they found cost of living but they found they were not a bit better off after getting the increase because it was all absorbed in the increased cost of living.
There were many sections of the community who got no increase and many who got increases were adversely affected in other ways. I have a letter before me from a man working for a local authority and his salary was increased to meet the increase in the cost of living. He has a home to maintain, a wife and three children. Shortly before that, he had decided to acquire a home under the SmallDwellings Acquisition Act. He applied for a grant and found that having embarked on all the preparations to erect his home, because his salary had been slightly increased, it was brought above the maximum and therefore he lost a couple of hundred pounds because of this increase which was designed merely to compensate him for the effect of the 1951 Budget. He now finds that he is at the loss of a couple of hundred pounds because of the results directly accruing from Government policy.
That is merely an instance. There is not a Deputy on any side of the House who could not find dozens of other people who have been affected in a similar way. Another case that comes to my mind is that of a widow with two children. One of the children —a girl—is employed in a co-operative creamery, and the son is unfortunately physically deficient. Instead of throwing him on the mercy of the local authorities they are looking after that boy in his home and merely because the sister got a few shillings increase in her wages and because the mother got a slight increase in the widows' pension, he was struck off the list of those obtaining public assistance.
I think the case could also be made that the increase of 1/6 given to old age pensioners is not a sufficient compensation for the extra prices which they are called upon to pay for bread, tea, sugar. If an old person has the temerity to take a "hot drop" when he goes in to collect his old age pension, or if an old man drinks an odd pint or bottle of stout, will the extra 1/6 meet all these fresh commitments arising from Government policy? I think it is clear from the results of the recent by-election that the people are demanding a change of Government. They have despaired of a change of policy. They have heard of these points of view being put forward on numerous occasions while no heed whatever is taken of them. The feeling of the people, expressed in the by-elections held since the full effect of the Government's financial policy has come to bear upon them, has beenmade quite clear. We have had an election in a city constituency and in two rural constituencies and the verdict of the people in each of these constituencies has been unanimous—a message to the Government that it is the desire of the people to have a general election. Any effort to defer the general election, or to stave off what may be described as the evil day for the Government, will be of no avail. I think that in making that statement, I am expressing the views of my own constituents, as well as the views placed on record in North-West Dublin, Cork and Wicklow.
Comment on this
The Government, despite their promises that if given another term of office they would not impose additional taxation, have not alone reimposed the taxes which were abolished by the inter-Party Government but have added considerably to that taxation. The present Minister for Finance told the licensed trade in his own constituency that there was no foundation for the rumours circulated by people on this side of the House that if Fianna Fáil ever got into power again they would reimpose the taxes on beer and spirits. The Tánaiste had to be brought to Cork at the same time to reassure the people there that there was no truth in any of these allegations. However, they have been proved, unfortunately, only too true, with the result that in every town and village in Ireland, families engaged in the licensed trade, engaged perhaps as a sideline in the hackney business having perhaps a truck employed in transport for the local mill or the local shopkeeper or the local farmer, find to-day that there is such an attack on their means of livelihood that they cannot pay even the taxes that they were paying a few years ago, not to speak of the increased commitments they have been asked to meet since the present Government came into office. For these reasons, we on this side, desire to place on record on this Vote on Account our view that the Government is continuing a policy that cannot bring to our people the relief that isso badly needed in the matter of unemployment, the cost of living, production, emigration, or any of the other problems that affect us to-day.
The Tánaiste, in the course of the discussion on the vote of confidence, said that he felt that rural workers should not be given rights here in the City of Dublin in relation to housing and other matters which might result in Dublin people being deprived of such rights. I can see some reason for that point of view, but may I point out that we must add to the figures of people coming to Dublin the additional numbers that we are now taking into the Army? If a farmer gives employment to a young lad after he has left the national school, he has to train him, and perhaps for the first year or two the young lad will not be of much use but, working with the older labourers and perhaps the members of the farmer's family, he will become a skilled agriculturist in the course of a few years. I think it is inimical to the success of the production campaign if we have Government agents going into rural areas with their vans, loudspeakers and high-powered propaganda to induce such young men to join the Army. If it is the desire of these young men to serve in the Defence Forces, they have an opportunity of doing so in Fórsa Cosanta Áitiúil, and I think it is wrong that they should be drawn from their employment to become members of the Regular Army. These young men have grown up in a different atmosphere from that in which they will be trained in the Army, and if it is the desire of the Government to secure recruits for the Regular Army, I think their attention should be directed to the people who are standing at the street corners, who are unemployed, but who are physically fit and have sufficient intelligence to absorb the training which they would receive in the Army. It would be far better to augment the Defence Forces from such a source than to draw on a body of young men who spent years working as agricultural labourers or as labourers in any of the avocations by which we seek to improve the standard of living of our people. I have intervened in the debate merely to give expression tothese few remarks and not with any idea of obstructing the business which the Government wish to put through in this session.
Comment on this
The object of this Vote, as the Minister stated in introducing it, is to provide sufficient money to enable the services for the various Departments to be financed pending the passing of the various Estimates and the necessary financial legislation to provide the money. Since that is the position, we may take it that no sane or rational Deputy will think of voting against this motion. Nobody will object to any Opposition Deputy— he has a perfect right on a motion such as this—declaring his views in regard to Government policy. I listened very attentively to the debate yesterday and I think anyone who was present will bear out the statement that the most remarkable feature of it was the striking contrast, the almost startling contrast, between the speech delivered by a member of the Labour Party, Deputy Corish, and the speech delivered on behalf of the Fine Gael party by Deputy Flanagan. Deputy Corish's statement, as I think everybody who was present will agree, was a reasonable and moderate one. It was a constructive one. His whole approach to the questions involved in this debate was one of a Deputy trying to find a way out of our difficulties and trying to help the nation to surmount them. One might not agree with every point he made but he certainly was. endeavouring to put to the Government constructive suggestions for the solution of our national problems, particularly the problem of unemployment. Deputy Flanagan, however, went to the other extreme. He recited all the silly partisan slogans that we heard over the past two years. I do not intend to follow Deputy Flanagan. I will deal with this debate on the lines suggested by Deputy Corish. Bearing out what Deputy Corish said, it is no harm to point out that the Trade Union Congress, which is apparently a responsible body, has considered the question of unemployment and put forward a number of suggestions. There are very few Deputies who would findfault with those suggestions. My only point in regard to them is that in all probability they do not go far enough. In the main they deal with matters of detail rather than with the question of tackling the unemployment problem in its widest, broadest and deepest aspects.
Unemployment is the most important national problem at the moment. No one can deny that. Unemployment has always been a big problem down through the years. It is not a problem that affects only the wage-earning classes. It affects all sections of the community, but in particular those in the lower and middle income groups. The farmer is faced with the problem of finding employment for his second, third and fourth sons and for his daughters. The professional man and the businessman are preoccupied with the same problem in relation to their children. The problem affects the nation as a whole and it should be our aim to ensure that the young people, educated at considerable expense in the primary and secondary schools, will find employment at home and a decent means of livelihood rather than be forced to go abroad.
Emigration ranks second in importance to unemployment. Unemployment is our primary problem. It is a problem that the Government must face. It is a problem they must tackle. Even with full employment here it is possible that we would still have some measure of emigration. Emigration is to a large extent outside our control. It is governed by the conditions prevailing in other countries. If conditions elsewhere are better than they are here, there will be emigration. Our whole aim, however, should be to ensure that nobody will be forced to leave the country to seek employment if he or she prefers to remain at home.
There are two main sources of employment. There is employment arising out of agricultural development and employment provided in the main by private enterprise through the intensive development of both agriculture and industry. It is in relation to such employment that I now want tojoin issue with the main Opposition Party. The only alternative to the present Government is a Fine Gael Government. The last Government— some of us may not have realised it at the time—was not an inter-Party Government at all; it was a Fine Gael Government, slightly disguised or camouflaged. During the last two years members of the Fine Gael Party throughout the country have been boasting that the Government that held office for three and a half years was a Fine Gael Government pure and simple.
What is the attitude of the main Opposition Party towards providing employment for our workers in the way in which it could be provided, namely, through the development of agriculture and industry? For 20 years Fine Gael has been fiercely opposed to all measures of industrial development. Every manufacturer has been held up to ridicule. Every measure designed to increase industrial and agricultural output has been denounced. Yet, it is only through the intensive development of agriculture and industry that we can provide employment for our people. Despite all the attacks levelled against industrial development the country has marched forward. Industry has expanded and is to-day providing employment for many thousands of workers.
Notice taken that20Deputies were not present; House counted, and20Deputies being present,
Comment on this
Despite the fierce and vindictive campaign against the development of industry over the last 20 years industrial development has proceeded. The second way in which employment can be provided for our people is through the development of agriculture. Does anybody think there is anything in Fine Gael policy that makes for increased employment in agriculture? For the last 20 years the main spokesmen of the Fine Gael Party have denounced the main factors contributing to an expansion of agricultural production. The shadow Minister for Agriculture has denounced the growing of wheat and the growingof sugar beet. It is significant that at the moment the gross income from agriculture amounts to something like £12 per acre. Now, here is an account of four acres of beet which produced a gross income of £301, or approximately £75 per acre.
Not all of the £75 goes to the farmer. Close on £100, out of the £301, goes for seeds, manures and transport, so that there is approximately £50 left to the farmer. Out of that £50 the farmer pays approximately £25 in wages. That is to say, that out of one acre of sugar beet, the agricultural worker will get approximately £25. On ten acres of beet, a sum of over £200 will be paid out in labour to agricultural workers. Is it not better to grow sugar beet and pay that substantial sum to agricultural workers than follow the lines advocated by the Fine Gael Party of having a gross income of £13 or £14 an acre and employ nobody? Under that system, nobody would get any wages. The only thing that would have to be supported is a dog. According to leading Fine Gael spokesmen, the growing of sugar beet should be terminated, and the four sugar factories should be blown up with dynamite.
Comment on this
The criticism on the Vote on Account should be directed towards the present Government and not to any other Government.
Comment on this
What I am suggesting is that we should adopt a policy of intensive agriculture and in that way provide employment. We have listened to speakers from the Fine Gael Party over the last 20 years denouncing the growing of wheat. If you want to have intensive agriculture, with the land giving its maximum production, you must have a policy designed to promote tillage. The only way to do that is to have guaranteed prices for certain tillage crops.
Comment on this
Yes, and for sugar beet. Sugar beet and wheat are the two crops in regard to which it is easy and possible for a Government to guarantee prices in all circumstances. It is not so easy to control the price of feeding barley or even of malting barley or of other agricultural products. I have often advocated the extension of the principle of guaranteed prices for commodities other than wheat and sugar beet, but we are always up against certain serious difficulties in regard to supply and demand. In regard, however, to sugar beet and wheat, there is no such difficulty. We cannot but condemn the action of what claims to be the main Opposition Party for its violent attacks on the growing of these two crops which have a guaranteed price fixed for them by the State. Deputy Rooney, I think, suggested, by way of interruption, that I should talk about barley and other crops and the prices for them. The growing of these crops also provides a good volume of employment. It will be noted that in the last two years the average price of malting barley was 76/- per barrel. In the three years of the Fine Gael Government the average price was 53/-per barrel. Even in regard to malting barley, there has been a very substantial increase in the price paid to the farmer. The average price, taking the last two years, has been 76/- per barrel, while the average price for the three previous years was 53/- per barrel. Yet, in face of that situation, we have people like Deputy Rooney going around the country persistently shouting that the present Government has reduced the price of malting barley.