Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 171–348 of 537. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I have given the average price for the last two years when it was 76/- per barrel. The Fine Gael Party, which is always talking about barley prices, never succeeded in bringing the average price above 53/-per barrel. I think it is about time that this whole campaign of misrepresenting the position of agriculture, a campaign which has been indulged inby the Fine Gael Party, should be blown sky high.
Agricultural prices have certainly increased over the last two years. The agricultural price index for 1950 was 260, as compared with 100 in 1938. In 1952, it was 297. That represents a substantial increase. It means that, if a farmer got £260 for his produce in 1950, last year he was getting £297, or an increase of £37. In addition, the wages of agricultural workers have been increased by approximately £1 a week. The farmer, even though he got the increase, did not put it in his pocket. He has, in the main, passed it on to the agricultural worker. You have there an indication that there has been a general effort to improve the condition of the farming community, of not only the man who owns the land but of the farm worker as well.
Over the last two years, the price of wheat has been increased by 15/-per barrel, beet by 10/- per ton, milk by 3d. per gallon, and the price of cattle, that is good store cattle, by £5 per head, and pigs by over 10/- per cwt. It is no harm to point out that the price of oats has also been increased.
The Fine Gael Party talk a lot about the price of oats. During the three years of the Fine Gael Government, the average price of oats was £19 per ton, while the average price in the last two years was £23 per ton. There, again, you have an all round improvement of the position so far as the farmer and farm workers are concerned. These are the principal people engaged in the economic life of this nation. They are the people on whom the nation, in the main, depends.
Comment on this
And 4/2 a lb. for New Zealand butter. That is a record, but I am not aware that the farmers of Ireland are getting it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary would like to see the price of milk to the farmer reduced. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot pay the farmer a reasonable price for his produce and at the same time expect that the consumer will get his requirements at avery much reduced price. That cannot be done and the Government are right to recognise it.
It is all nonsense to say that whatever increase has taken place in the cost of living was due entirely to the reduction in the food subsidies. In the last three months of the Fine Gael Government the cost of living went up by nine points. Although that happened, nothing was done by the Fine Gael Government to offset that increase. The cost of living went up a further nine or ten points under the present Government and the net result of the reduction in food subsidies was an increase of six or seven points. Therefore, to attribute every increase that has taken place in the cost of living to the reduction in food subsidies is simply not facing facts which are easily ascertainable.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Could you swear, Sir, that this is the same Deputy Cogan who supported the inter-Party Government for three years?
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to point out that I am the same Deputy Cogan who opposed the Estimate for Agriculture in the two years that the Fine Gael Government was in power and I was not given the opportunity to oppose it the last time their Estimate came before the House.
Comment on this
I wonder if Deputy Davin is the same Deputy Davin who many years ago, used fiercely to attack the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government and the Fine Gael Party?
Comment on this
To meet the increase in the cost of living a number of improvements in social services have been introduced. When various Deputies of the Opposition—I will not mention names—speak about the higher cost of living they never refer to the fact that sickness benefit has been increased within the last two years from 22/- in a case where there are two children in the family, to 52/6.
Comment on this
That is a substantial increase and offsets to a considerable extent the increase in the cost of living.
Comment on this
Disablement benefits have been increased from 15/- to 24/-. Unemployment benefit has been increased from 35/- to 52/6 in the case of a family of the same size. Unemployment assistance has been increased from 28/- to 40/6.
Comment on this
Widows' and orphans' contributory pensions have been increased from 28/- per week to 40/6. Non-contributory pensions have been increased from 26/- to 34/6 per week and old age pensions have been increased from 17/6 to 21/6. All those reforms have been carried through in spite of the vigorous opposition of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I do not think that those people who have opposed these reforms, who have despised them and resented them, have anything to talk about in regard to the lower privileged sections of our community. Since 1951, the majority in this House have been endeavouring strenuously to improvethe position of the lower privileged section of the community.
That brings me to the question which I was endeavouring to deal with when I was interrupted, the question of how to provide increased employment for our workers. I referred to the Trade Union Congress statement which was issued recently and which I commended as being reasonable and responsible. The Trade Union Congress made a number of suggestions. They said:
"Administrative delays in regard to housing schemes should be eliminated."
That is very, very sound. Those of us who are members of local authorities have had the experience of seeing a housing scheme initiated in our counties and wondering why it was not proceeding. We call at the county council office and we are told that the scheme is in the Department in Dubline. We call to the Department and we are told it has gone back to the county council. We call again to the county council office and we are told that it has gone back again to the Department.
That kind of thing goes on for months and in some cases for years. While a housing scheme may be sent up and down from the county council to the Department and from the Department to the county council, there are people living in crowded conditions, perhaps two or three families in one worker's cottage, married sons or daughters of the tenant. They are waiting for the houses to be built. There are skilled workers in the towns waiting for employment. There are unskilled workers waiting for employment that would be provided in the development of the sites and other ancillary work.
It is a very sound suggestion that unnecessary delays should be eliminated. There is a firm in Wexford which manufactures a very good type of Irish slasher. The Government should purchase one of these slashers and cut away as much as possible of the red tape that impedes the development of housing schemes.
Comment on this
There is no one whocould cut that as soon as the Deputy. He is in a right way now to cut it.
Comment on this
The Trade Union Congress also suggest that work should go ahead on the development of various derelict sites. That would provide employment. They suggest the speedy allocation of contracts, no holdup in regard to them. They also suggest a time limit in the carryingout of these contracts so that the work would be set on foot rapidly. They suggest that, wherever possible, direct labour should be employed. There may be Deputies who have an objection to direct labour but I have seen it working successfully and I have no objection to it at all. I believe that direct labour should be used by a county council wherever possible and, in addition, there could be a certain amount of contract work done. Let the two systems compete with each other and see which is the more efficient. The competition between the two systems would probably create greater efficiency.
They also suggest a speeding up of arterial drainage. That is a point on which I feel very strongly. Newspaper reports indicate that there is a considerable amount of work being undertaken at the moment in connection with arterial drainage. I think the Office of Public Works should be asked to get more work done in regard to arterial drainage. There has been a great deal of talk in this House about providing for increased work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. Work in regard to drainage generally has got to be tackled in a comprehensive national way. You have to follow the streams from the source to the outlet and you cannot always do that with a county scheme. The widening and expansion of arterial drainage work would be very desirable. I, therefore, have no hesitation in commending the suggestions put forward by the Trade Union Congress. They are sound and reasonable. In regard also to the question of drainage, there should be a certain amount of co-operation between the Department of Agriculture and the Office of Public Works so that when a scheme of reclamationunder the land project is likely to be held up by the need for arterial drainage the work will be set on foot immediately.
Notice taken that20Deputies were not present; House counted and20Deputies being present,
Comment on this
Most of the Deputies taking part in the debate have referred to a restriction of credit and stated that sufficient credit is not being made available for agricultural and industrial purposes.
Comment on this
Would it be in order to suggest that when a quorum is called for the number of Deputies present from each Party should be recorded on the records of the House?
Comment on this
Would it be in order to ask Deputy Rooney to call back the Deputies out of their hiding place?
Comment on this
I think the figures relating to credit facilities for agriculture over the last two years should be published. There has been a very wide expansion of credit in regard to the purchasing of tractors and other agricultural machinery over the last two years. I know also that over the last two years there has been a very great expansion of credit for tillage operations, particularly for the growing of wheat. I am sure that in the present year, credit to the extent of tens of thousands of pounds has been given to farmers in connection with the provision of seeds and manures. That is a very good type of credit for agriculture. It is short-term credit, if you like, but if a farmer is in need of capital that is one of the ways in which he can get it with the least possible trouble and by which he can equip and stock his land. By growing a satisfactory and successful crop of wheat a farmer can acquire a certain amount of capital which will enable him to increase his stock and also add to the general equipment for the working of his farm. So that there is a great deal of exaggeration and of misrepresentationin regard to the question of credit for agriculture. I think we have extended it very considerably over the last two years. We all regret that the interest charges are higher but, as has been indicated, that is something over which the State has not any really effective control.
In opening yesterday's debate, Deputy McGilligan referred at considerable length to the question of finance. It is an extraordinary thing that when Deputy McGilligan is out of office he talks in a vague kind of way as if he were a monetary reformer, as if he had swallowed all the theories of Major Douglas and the other experts in finance. But when he becomes Minister for Finance he forgets all about these theories and he plods along in a crude way endeavouring to carry on under the existing system, perhaps not very effectively. He told us—and it is one of the stock arguments of Fine Gael—that his Government left £24,000,000 of Marshall Aid money behind them. He did not tell us, however, that every dollar borrowed from the United States under Marshall Aid was spent before his Government went out of office. What was left was sterling which carried a relatively high rate of interest. It has been proved in this House that 2½ per cent. on money borrowed from a country with a hard currency represents a much heavier burden upon the community than even 5 per cent. payable on money borrowed from our own people. When money has to be paid out to citizens of another nation it is dead money, so to speak. When it has to be paid in dollars to a country with which we have an adverse trade balance, it constitutes a much heavier burden upon the community.
In reply to a question some time ago it was pointed out here by the Minister for Finance that in 30 years' time we will be paying £9,000,000 annually to the United States. We will have to pay that £9,000,000 dollars in the form of goods exported to the United States from which we will get no return. It is about time that all these stupid misrepresentations of Fine Gael were abandoned. Perhaps during the recess they will consider this questionin a more constructive way rather than trying to misrepresent the position that existed when they were in office and the position as it exists to-day.
I did not intend to refer to Deputy O. Flanagan but he did make one statement that deserves comment. He said that two years ago when the Coalition Government was in office, there was no conflict between any sections of the community. I wonder does he think that our memories are so short. Does he think that we have forgotten that Deputy MacBride and himself were chasing each other around this House with long knives in their very bitter opposition to each other? Does he forget the bitter conflict that arose in regard to an appointment in Baltinglass?
Comment on this
Does he think we have forgotten these things and that our memories are so short that we are prepared to accept Deputy Flanagan's statement that everything in the garden was lovely two and a half years ago? Two and a half years ago the then Minister for Agriculture was violently attacked for pouring abuse——
Comment on this
It would be impossible to reply to any point made by Deputy Flanagan without straying from the rules of order, so I shall have to leave it.
Comment on this
You are worried about the Chair.
Comment on this
Another statement made by Deputy Flanagan and otherDeputies was that there has been a slowing down on land reclamation projects. I think it is time that was effectively dealt with. Figures available to every Deputy show that in the last year the Coalition Government were in office £569,000 was spent on land reclamation, that £2,500,000 was spent last year and that there is provision for a much higher expenditure in the present year. That represents five times the amount expended on land drainage and reclamation in the last year of the Coalition Government's term of office. I hope the expenditure will continue, as I believe it will continue. It will expand under the provision which has been made for an increased grant to the farmer who undertakes the work himself. Where a farmer undertakes the work of land reclamation he can secure as much as £30 an acre. With the aid of good tractors in each district, farmers will be able to undertake the work themselves and will do it much more efficiently and cheaply than the Department could ever hope to do it for them. It is a good thing that farmers should carry out work of this kind on their own farms and that the grants for that purpose are being substantially increased.
Land reclamation is not a Party issue. It has not been introduced into this country by any one particular Party more than another. It was first undertaken on a modest scale, let us say, by Fianna Fáil about ten years ago and it was gradually expanded year by year. When Deputy Dillon came into office, to his credit let it be said, he paid a generous tribute to the work that had been done in regard to land reclamation by his predecessors in office.
Comment on this
It is to his credit that he paid that tribute. I suppose Deputy Rooney would not like to give credit for the making of such a statement. It is proper to have it on the records of the House that he paid tribute to the work done by his predecessors, and it is also to his credit that he endeavouredto extend that work by introducing mechanisation and by increasing the grants available to the farmer for that purpose.
It would be a good thing if Deputies on both sides of the House would refrain from bandying words across the House in regard to this project. Every farmer is entitled to avail of any scheme that is designed to improve his farm and to increase his output. There is no decent farmer who does not try to get the maximum from his land and to bring it up to the highest state of fertility. I know farmers in my own constituency who are so keen on developing their land that they are now availing of this grant to remove earth fences and to replace them by wire fences, so that when the farms are small the farmers can increase the area which they can put under cultivation. As I said, one of the main inducements to increased output in agriculture is the fixed and secure guaranteed prices for certain products of the land. One of the farmers to whom I have referred is an extensive beet and wheat grower. He realises the value of every inch of his holding and he is endeavouring to extract that value from it, not wasting it with fences which are only the breeding grounds for rabbits.
In regard to ground limestone, I have heard people claiming that we owe that scheme entirely to Deputy Dillon. Again, I think there ought to be a little more broadmindedness in regard to this matter. The manufacture of ground limestone was being undertaken before Deputy Dillon took office. In this connection, I would like to pay a tribute to an ex-member of Fine Gael, and that member was the late Deputy Hughes. We remember in this House, in the years before the Fine Gael Party came into office, Deputy Hughes was constantly advocating the manufacture on a large scale of ground limestone.
That manufacture was undertaken under the administration of Deputy Smith and it was continued under the Coalition Government during the three and a half years they were in office, but it continued very slowly because Deputy Dillon opposed the granting of a subsidy on ground limestone.
It was only after long and bitter agitation by Independent Deputies and by the American E.C.A. representative that we succeeded in getting a subsidy on the transport of ground limestone. As a consequence there was very little output applied to farms in the last year of the Coalition Administration. The total output applied to farms was only £75,000. In the present year we are approaching very close to £1,000,000. That is a very substantial expansion and it is one that is very desirable. There is nothing calculated to do more to improve output generally than a scheme of this nature.
Certain Deputies are trying to contend that there is something wrong in the nature of a close-down, or something in the nature of opposition on the part of the Government to long-term works of national development. I indicated at the very outset that national development undertaken by the State forms and must form a substantial portion of the work to be done in alleviating unemployment, no matter what may be done by private enterprise and no matter how we may expand agriculture. There will always be need for large-scale works of development by the State so as to absorb the unemployed and to give an opportunity to the young people growing up, so it is significant to note that in the last year provision for housing has been substantial. Thirteen thousand houses were built in 1952 as against 12,000 in 1950. Turf production in the last year was trebled as compared with 1950.
Rural electrification has been increased and expanded by 30 per cent. Generating stations are being established and projected to the extent of 11 new stations. During the three and a half years of the Fine Gael administration only two generating stations were established and those two were established to use imported fuel. It will be seen that the whole policy of the present Government over the last two years has been directed towards expanding works of national development with a view to providing employment. The area under forestry has been doubled and the grant for the improvement of our harbours has been very largely increased.
In all those works there is the need being met for the provision of employment, but all those works, in my opinion, are not sufficient. We must advance still further and provide the necessary money. It can only be provided, as I say, by borrowing for long-term works of this kind, and it must be used and it must be provided so that increased numbers of our people will be given an opportunity of obtaining work.
Some Deputies may have been impressed by a number of workers here in the city demonstrating in order to focus attention on their claim for employment. We have heard them cry out, "We want work", but while those men are demonstrating and while they are appealing for work we have at the same time very large-sized advertisements appearing in all the newspapers seeking workers. Bord na Móna is spending enormous sums of money advertising its slogan, "We want workers. Workers wanted". They outlined the wages that they are prepared to give, and to the ordinary unskilled worker and to the young man who is prepared to face healthy outdoor work I think there is not very much wrong with the terms that they offer.
Comment on this
If they are, I would like to have that expounded. Is it not a strange thing to find men parading through the city and crying out, "We want work", while we have a huge State organisation. financed by the State, spending large sums of money advertising for workers? There must be something wrong somewhere and I think we are entitled to find out what it is and where it is.
Comment on this
The workers are getting only £4 10s. a week. Thepiece-rate is all right but they will not be allowed to do it.
Comment on this
Surely these advertisements should be drawn to the notice of these people who are demonstrating and crying out for work. I think there ought to be some solution of this problem. It is not right or desirable that we should have, on the one hand, young men crying out that they cannot find employment when we have, on the other hand, a large State body crying out that they cannot speed up their production to the extent to which they would desire because they cannot get sufficient workers.
Comment on this
I do not think there is anything ignoble about joining the National Army. It is a very fine Army which has a very fine tradition, and it is hard to see why any young man who is unable to find employment, or, indeed, any young man, would not be prepared to join the National Army for a time. I think that there should be opportunities, particularly for young men and for single men, to get employment. For the married man with a family and a home the problem is a little more difficult, but even in regard to married men I think that a real effort should be made to step up the opportunities of employment. Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy McGilligan denounced proposed measures on the part of the Government for works of national development on the ground that they were relief schemes.
Comment on this
No. The House of Parliament was projected in the mind of Deputy Dillon. What I am thinking about are works of national development scattered throughout the country. I cannot see why those works should not be undertaken and why they shouldnot be supported by Deputies on all sides. We can provide for the improvement of our country roads, for the extension of arterial drainage and for a number of schemes of that kind which will increase employment for our people, but one thing that the Fine Gael Party appear to be afraid of is that these schemes will be undertaken and that they will give considerable employment, and that they will be deprived of one of the many arguments they have used against the Government. Their whole anxiety is and they are determined on it, that the country's economic and social condition is on the up-grade, that it is improving and that it will continue to improve, and that they cannot capitalise the discontent and the grievances which they have been trying to exploit.
I said at the outset that there was a commendable difference between the speech delivered by Deputy Corish on behalf of the Labour Party and that delivered by Deputy Flanagan on behalf of the Fine Gael Party. Deputy Corish's speech was moderate, restrained, sane and constructive, Deputy Flanagan's was abusive, destructive and silly to a very large extent.
He quoted agricultural statistics designed, as he claimed, to prove that there never was and never will be such a Minister for Agriculture as Deputy Dillon. I notice that in this Deputy Flanagan was simply repeating what Deputy Dillon had said about himself in Carlow. A newspaper described Deputy Dillon on that occasion as floating majestically into the auditorium of the Carlow Town Hall like a swan. One of the outstanding features of a swan is its marvellous and substantial neck. Deputy Dillon had neck enough to go to the town where he admitted he would like to blow up the sugar factory, to tell what he had done or was going to do about agriculture. Deputy Flanagan, nevertheless, quoted a number of figures in regard to various types of live stock to show that Deputy Dillon was a wonderful benefactor to the farmers generally. Deputy Dillon himself in Carlow claimed credit for every calf born since 1948, every increase in the pig population and inthe live-stock population generally, with the exception of the rabbits. Modesty prevented him from claiming credit for that spectacular expansion in live-stock production.
Figures are things that cannot be overlooked. There are figures recorded in the Statistical Abstractwhich show the measure of success achieved by Deputy Dillon in the last year he was in office. In that last year he was in office, the number of sows—he often talked about “one more sow”—went down by 400; the total number of pigs went down by 90,000; the number of geese—Deputy Flanagan would be interested in geese—went down by 9,000. The number of ducks—Deputy Flanagan would also be interested in ducks —went down by 40,000.
In ordinary fowl, day-old chicks went down, in the last year in which Deputy Dillon was in office, by 500,000—and that occurred because he claimed that 2d. per egg was a very good price. The number of heifers in calf went down by 23,000; the number of milch cows by 10,000; the number of mules and jennets—this is something that would appeal to Deputy Flanagan, and to Deputy Rooney, too—went down by 1,000. On 13th June, 1951, Deputy Dillon himself went down and his Government went down, too. After they had gone down, there was a substantial increase in the numbers of the principal items of live stock I have mentioned—sows, pigs, ordinary fowl, heifers in calf and ducks. We know that the reduction in the number of milch cows was brought about by the effort of Deputy Dillon in 1950 to reduce the price of milk.
Comment on this
Those are the 1950 figures, compared with 1951. Those reductions took place as between 1950 and 1951.
Comment on this
Anyone who can read can go to the library convenient to the House, where they will find the Statistical Abstractfor 1952, whichcontains all those figures which I have mentioned.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy opened the debate to-day. It has been said in regard to Deputy Mulcahy that when he speaks in Irish he speaks very intelligently and very coherently, but when he breaks into English he finds it difficult himself to understand what he is saying. He made just one ccoherent statement and that was in regard to unemployment, that it is better to pay doles to workers than to establish relief works. I join issue with Deputy Mulcahy on this matter. I believe that, no matter what difficulties of organisation or planning arise, it is better to give employment to our men than to pay them the miserable and degrading dole. Even the Independent—which, by the way, is not the official organ of the Independent Deputies in the House; I think it would be more truly described as theIzvestiaof the Fine Gael Party—has denounced the provision of the dole as against giving employment.
Wherever it is possible, and no matter what difficulties have to be overcome in organising and providing the work, the work should be provided. It should be the duty of local bodies— county councils, city councils, town councils and parish councils—where they exist—to plan out schemes of employment, each in its own district, which will enable workers to keep their self-respect and to do useful work for the community. It is an ugly and sad thing to see a man cycling three or four miles along a road strewn with potholes and almost impassable, to sign for the dole. Would it not be better for that man, instead of taking a pen in hand to sign for the dole, if he were given a shovel and allowed to put into permanent repair the road that he has to travel—to sign his name, as it were, permanently, with his shovel rather than to sign with a pen on some official document?
Deputy Mulcahy, reading up, someobscure theory of economics or social teaching, probably not from any Christian source, has laid down the doctrine that it is better to pay a dole to unemployed workers than to give them employment. That is a statement that ought to be refuted by Deputies here and that ought to be refuted in a real way by the Government through the provision of the necessary work. This country is not down and out and is not likely to be down and out. Many of the economic problems that faced us last year, such as the frightening balance of payments, have been solved. In the last year, agriculture has expanded to a tremendous extent. One has only to travel through the country to see the flourishing fields of grain, of wheat and beet, to see that agriculture is on the upgrade. I know there are some crops of barley which may have been damaged by the weather. We hope and pray that the valiant efforts of the farmers over the last year to increase tillage and the production of their land will be rewarded by a bountiful harvest.
Over the last year, 140 new industries were established. I find in my own constituency and adjoining constituencies a real effort made to get into production in various manufacturing industries. Only in the last week I have come across a case in which a firm setting out to engage in manufacturing industry found that they had not the difficulty that they anticipated in securing the necessary credit from the bank for that work. Therefore, I do not think that things are really as black as the Fine Gael Party would have us believe.
I belive that with a united effort on the part of Deputies on all sides of the House and with a united effort on the part of voluntary workers who have the interest of the people at heart, we can put this country on a firm and secure foundation and we can increase the output of our land and of our fields and our factories and increase the employment for our people. Therefore, I think there is hope in the statement that was made here last evening by Deputy Corish, in the statement that was issued bythe Trade Union Congress and in the real efforts being made by men of good will and national outlook to improve the economic position of our country. I think that that is a source of hope for our people.
I see no reason why progress should not be continued. The main Opposition Party cry out again and again for a general election. I think that one of the reasons why they cry out for a general election is because they believe and know that the passage of time will show up the false nature of much of the propaganda on which they are concentrating at present. The passage of time will show that this country is developing, that the capital works being undertaken are yielding results, that agriculture is now really expanding and that industrial development is making headway.
The unemployed have the sympathy of every well-meaning citizen in this State. We should leave aside Party politics and co-operate in an effort to discover ways and means to provide more employment for our people. I speak as a farmer. I try to give as much employment on my farm as I can. I am sure that every well-meaning farmer does the same. Every farmer should avail of the increased grants for land reclamation and improvement and should employ additional men to add to the productive capacity and arable area of the farm. In that way, we shall come nearer to a solution of the unemployment problem. That problem will not be solved by statements such as those which we heard yesterday from Deputy McGilligan and Deputy O. Flanagan. Such statements are deliberately designed to create instability, insecurity and to frighten the people away from undertaking increased productive work. An effort was made last year to frighten farmers from increasing their acreage under wheat and beet. That effort failed but it indicates that all such panicky measures, designed to stampede our people into doing the wrong thing, will fail.
The legal gentlemen who control the Fine Gael Party realise that they will inevitably fail and, for that reason, they are pressing, shouting, screaming for an immediate general election.They want to get to the electorate as quickly as possible and before the electorate have an opportunity of finding out how cruelly, how viciously and how unscrupulously they have misled and deceived them.
Comment on this
In rising to take part in this debate, I must confess that since I came into this House about a month ago I have been somewhat amused, though very disappointed, at the attitude of certain Ministers and Deputies on all sides of the House.
It is strange that, while the Fine Gael Party are accused of deliberately obstructing the Government's work, we had to listen here last night and again this afternoon to a Fianna Fáil Deputy who spoke for one and three-quarter hours without saying anything of value. All that is very disappointing to a newcomer to public life.
I am not blaming anyone in particular or any Party in the House in particular but it is very disappointing to find this kind of thing going on. Whether it be on a vote of confidence, the Vote on Account, the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture or anything else, I believe that any Deputy can make his case in an intelligent way to this House and to the country in half an hour. Example is better than precept and I now propose to be very brief in my contribution to this debate.
I want to refer, first to the excessive taxation which the present Government have imposed on our people. That point is so obvious and has been stressed so much and so frequently that it is hardly necessary for me to dwell on it at length now. In addition, there are increases which are not reflected in the cost-of-living index figure—increases in the price of petrol, in the price of drink, in the rates, and so forth. Both directly and indirectly, the present Government have placed a burden of taxation on the backs of the people of this country which is unequalled in any other country in Europe, including those countries which had to go through the ravages of the recent war. Furthermore, the impositions in the 1952 Budget happened at a time when prices, generally, were steadying elsewhere and when world economicconditions were becoming more stable. One can only assume, in regard to the Budget of 1952, that the 69 Fianna Fáil Deputies looked upon the population of this country as children who were spending too many pounds and too many pennies and that they had to be saved from themselves by the prudent 69 Fianna Fáil Deputies. We all know what the result has been. The housewife in Youghal, in Midleton, in Cobh, Fermoy and Mitchelstown must now pay more for bread, tea, sugar and other essential foodstuffs. The farmer and the farm worker must pay more for the pint and for cigarettes. The prospective house-owner must pay a higher interest rate on his loan, if he is lucky enough to get it, to enable him to build a house.
Despite all the talk which we have heard here in the past three weeks, no decent attempt has been made to rectify our economic ills. The excessive taxation on the people of this country caused the people of East Cork to send me into this House to say to the Ministers and to the Government: "There is something wrong with your economic policy. For goodness' sake, put it right." On behalf of the people of East Cork, I say to the Government that if they want to remain in office, they should make a decent and immediate attempt to lower the cost of living.
Unemployment has been referred to here, ad nauseam, both yesterday and to-day. Without a doubt, the unemployment problem is becoming more acute day by day. Yesterday morning, before I left Fermoy, I took a look in at the labour exchange. I found that the number on the register had increased since last week and that it was about three times as great as the figure for the corresponding period two years ago. That is a sad state of affairs in a country town like Fermoy. In fact, one would imagine that people in a country town should not have to go to the labour exchange. At this stage I should like to say to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Government—being one of the first members from that town in this House for 27 years—that it seems rather strange that Fermoy is not as prosperousnow as it used to be. Fermoy was very much to the fore in the fight for freedom even though, at that time, it was a garrison town. Its coffers were full and business was brisk when the military were there but, in spite of all that, the people of Fermoy and district were well in the vanguard in the fight for Irish freedom. As a result of achieving that freedom, business in the town of Fermoy has dwindled away and its population has seriously fallen. I can never understand why at least one substantial factory from amongst the couple of hundred of factories that Fianna Fáil boasts so much about which were doled out in their 18 years of office was not located in the town of Fermoy, and I can never understand why some encouraging action on the part of the then Fianna Fáil Government did not put one man into gainful employment in that town.
I said I would be brief because I want to give an example, for reasons I have already explained. I want to say, finally, that I do not quite follow the policy of the Government in regard to external assets. When Fianna Fáil was a more vigorous Party than it is now, they had very much in the forefront of their programme the withdrawal of external assets and their reinvestment at home, but, of late years, it seems that they were, more or less, advised by some contacts they have made in this country, whether consultative or otherwise, and they are preaching in the best university style about how and why our money should be left with John Bull. It seems rather strange that that money, for all the owners know, may be supporting slavery or semi-slavery in some remote corner of the globe, instead of being put back here into useful industrial and agricultural development. That is a policy which Fianna Fáil, in their declining years, seem to be forgetting entirely.
I think it is a pity, coming as I do from a country town and depending upon my livelihood on the side of a street in a country town, that there is such a recession and depression in trade, as the result, no doubt, of Government policy. It is a pity that somany of our country people have to emigrate. Some few hundred years ago, Goldsmith wrote:
"A bold peasantry, their country's pride,
When once destroyed, can never be supplied."
That is as true to-day as it was then, and it is more apparent to-day than it was then, because many of our young men and women are going from the country and the country towns to seek employment in other towns. That is a sad state of affairs for one like myself who has to live on the side of a street and depend on the welfare of the country. How much more sad must it be for their parents, who cannot but feel that, when they go to another country, their morals and their health will not be the same. I say that there is something wrong with Government policy and I have been sent here by the people of East Cork to tell you that. It has been debated for the last two days and may I say, in conclusion, that if the Government are honest with themselves, they will get out and give the people of the country a chance of deciding which side is right, which side is wrong, and who has the better policy? The people, under the Constitution, are entitled to get that chance.
Comment on this
I should first like to compliment my colleague, a new-comer to this House, on his statement. I want to say that I agree with him entirely with regard to the conditions prevailing in the town of Fermoy. Every word he has uttered in connection with conditions in that town is true. That town did its part during the Black and Tan war and paid for it afterwards. From 1922 to 1932, it remained a wreck. I asked a question of the Minister for Industry and Commerce a fortnight ago in connection with an industrial project which I had put under way for that town and I was rather amused to find that the licence in respect of that industry was given on the day of the poll in East Cork— a licence which was lying in the Department for a least four months. I suggest to the Government that there should be a bit of a clean up in so far as the higher civil servants——
Comment on this
When my colleague. Deputy Barry, complains about high taxation, I should like to remind him that, while he and I were fighting things out in East Cork, his Party were here very busy on the bribe, and here is the bribe that was held out:—
"If the Government do not honour the award in full, I hope it will not be many months until another Government is in office. If the Labour Party have any responsibility in that other Government, we shall do our best to ensure that whatever balance of this award is not paid by this Government will be honoured and paid by the next Government."
That was Deputy Norton on 27th May, 1953. We had the same guarantee from the benches opposite and the amount guaranteed is £966,000 of further taxation—21 weeks' back money for the civil servants. Where was it to be got? That was a definite bribe held out, a bribe which was on par with the bribe given in the three letters sent by Deputy Norton, Deputy Keyes and Deputy J.A. Costello to the local authorities of the country from seven to 15 days after the previous Government was dissolved and which cost the taxpayers £850,000 in taxes and the ratepayers roughly £2,000,000.
If the civil servants are to be dragged into the political arena by a bribe of £1,000,000, let them come out in the open and let us not have the miserable spectacle we saw at the last general election, of everybody, from the county manager down to the office boy, with their six months' back wages in their pockets going out on the warpath. If there is to be democratic rule in this country, let it be the rule of the people and not the rule of the Civil Service. Deputy Barry was interested in taxation. Let us take that item alone. In 1951 there was an increase of £3,600,000. In 1953 there was a further increase of £2,400,000.That £6,000,000 per year had to be found in the pockets of the people and it had to be found by taxation for increases in civil servants' salaries alone.
Comment on this
It is no more dishonest than what the Deputy's Party did when the findings of the arbitration board were on the Table. They made no provision in the Budget.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin speaks of the glorious position that existed during the time of the inter-Party Government. At that time, according to Deputy Davin himself, the farmers were selling potatoes at £5 per ton.
Comment on this
At column 273 of the Official Report of the 18th November, 1948, Deputy Davin stated:—
"The constituency of the Minister for Industry and Commerce must be affected in the same way as my constituency. He knows more about this matter than I do and I hope he will see that I am not exaggerating the position. If the Minister for Agriculture encouraged different committees of agriculture to grow oats and guaranteed a market for the crop, that guarantee should have been honoured."
At that time—in November, 1948— according to Deputy Davin oats were being sold in his constituency at 22/-a barrel. At column 274, Deputy Davin says:—
"In parts of my constituency potatoes have been sold at £5 a ton..."
That was the condition of affairs under the Minister Deputy Davin brought in here.
Comment on this
Those are his own words —£5 a ton for the spuds and 22/- a barrel for the oats, while the taxpayershad to pay for the advertisements that went up on the wall exhorting the people to grow more oats and potatoes as there was a sure market for both.
Comment on this
During the same period there was a reduction of between 10,000 and 15,000 acres in beet. We had a reduction of about 300,000 acres of wheat and the acreage in respect of oats was reduced by 60,000. Deputy Davin knows well why the farmers would never grow oats if Deputy Dillon was in power.
Comment on this
I increased it well. The price for barley that was got by the grain growers' branch of the Beet Growers' Association in this country is a headline for any Minister of State. It is a headline that no Minister of State has yet reached. We got 2/6 per barrel for malting barley over the price paid to any British farmer. This year it will be 3/9 a barrel over the English price. That is the guarantee this year. I, and also Deputy Davin, have heard Deputies on the Opposition side of the House say: "Oh, yes, I grew 20 acres every year and I grew one acre this year."
Comment on this
Deputy Davin will find that out. He contributes to Guinness in a way that I do not. Deputy Davin will find out that information and he should not draw me out. The Deputy came into this House having committed the criminal act of putting Deputy James Dillon sitting on these benches as Minister for Agriculture. The result was that the Deputy's unfortunate constituents got only 22/- a barrel for oats and £5 a ton for potatoes. The Deputy came into the House openly on the 18th November, 1948, driven in by the nailed boots of the unfortunate growers who produced the stuff, to attack the Minister in regard to those prices. Deputy Davin, therefore, ought to keepquiet. When I heard him interrupting I went out and procured the speech he made.
Comment on this
I went out and found it. I can assure the House that there are even worse quotations than that.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin knows as well as I do that the acreage of beet is up by 10,500 acres. He knows there will be 200,000 tons of beet more for motor transport this year than there was last year. He knows that will improve the position of lorry owners, the C.I.E., the men working in the factory and the men working on the land.
When I hear all the wailing and moaning about the unemployed I wonder. In the Fermoy area to which Deputy Barry alluded there was a list of unemployed two months ago. There was also a list of unemployed in the town of Midleton two months ago but 150 men had to be got from the County Mayo and paid from £10 to £15 a week singling beet in the area. We had to go to Mayo for them whilst the unemployed were signing in the labour exchange.
I admit they might dirty their boots. What, then, is the trouble? I hope I will hear from some Minister before this debate ends about the activities of a board set up during the past two or three years known as the Industrial Development Authority. To what extent and for how long have they retarded industrial progress? And what did they cost? Let us get down to bedrock in this and let us get rid of the machinery brought in by the inter-Party Government for the purpose of retarding industry in this country.
Comment on this
I am getting down to bedrock. I am asking a straight question. I asked 15 questions here in connection with the Haulbowline steelindustry and the last reply I got in 1950 was that it was in the hands of the Industrial Development Authority. Last week the Minister told me that there had been some finding now referred to himself in connection with Haulbowline sheet mills. Did it take from 1950 to 1953—three years—to decide on the extension of the industry? What do they expect the men who are waiting for employment during that period to do—I admit those bucks themselves are all right with their £2,500 a year—but what about those who are depending on those industries to provide employment for them and save them from emigrating? Let us think of that. That particular industry would be giving employment to over 100 people in the town of Cobh to-day were it not for, first of all, the inactivity of the inter-Party Government during their period in office and, secondly, the activity in retarding progress, of the Industrial Development Authority. I say that without putting a tooth in it. We are importing each year the materials which that sheet mill should be producing—that sheet mill for which three-fourths of the machinery has been lying at Haulbowline since 1939, lying there rusting.
I admit that on the first opportunity he got of getting the balance of that machinery from abroad which was in November, 1947, the Minister went over there with me and examined the condition of affairs and guaranteed in my presence the money to erect that sheet mill and put it into production. I was three and a half long years sitting over there begging the Deputy Davins, the Deputy Nortons and the Deputy Morrisseys and all the rest of them for the £150,000 necessary, and during that period they borrowed and squandered £94,500,000 of the Irish people's money, and then they had the neck to come in here and talk about taxation. They had the neck—no wonder Deputy Cogan would say they were like swans, for their necks were thicker than swans, if you ask me. That is the condition of affairs there. We are importing into this country each year something over £2,000,000 worth of tinplate and tin cans while the machinery was lying at Haulbowline. Those twoitems alone and the subsidiary industries that would follow them would provide enough employment to put every unemployed man in my constituency into a job—that is those of them that want jobs. As far as those who do not are concerned, the sooner they get out the better.
That is in my opinion the first way in which we should deal with the unemployment situation—by the establishment of those industries which were foreseen many years ago. Anyone who would read the prospectus of Irish Steel Limited in 1938-39 would see that whole group of steel works envisaged there. Unfortunately, there was only the full machinery for one of those mills in this country when the war broke out. One quarter of the machinery for the sheet mill was caught in France or Belgium, and portion—I am afraid the greater portion of the tin sheet mill—was caught there also, but there is no reason that I know of why those industries should not now begone ahead with. We have, thank God, a Minister now who will do his part and get ahead with it. The whole go-ahead movement in regard to that industry was held up for three and a half long years due to the unfortunate advent of the mixum-gatherum Government of this country.
Comment on this
I challenge Deputy Davin or any one of his colleagues to tell me the number of industries established by the inter-Party Government when they were in office?
Comment on this
They even ruined the tomatoes. Deputy Dillon ruined that when he brought in the Dutch tomatoes. I would like every Deputy to go into that matter from that point of view, from the point of view of industries that could be established in his constituency. I do not want this dang thing—relief work—that will get 30 or 60 or 100 men off the dole for six months and bring them back on it again when it is over. That is not what we want in this country.
Comment on this
Tell me how much of the £94,000,000 borrowed and squandered by that mixum-gatherum Government in three and a half years—how much of that went into industry? Can they show me ten men employed in this country out of the expenditure of that money? I see that according to one figure they paid £6,000,000 extra to the civil servants. We can add to that £7,200,000 to be paid in interest and sinking fund on the money the inter-Party borrowed and which will have to be paid no matter who is here. That will have to be raised by taxation each year on the unfortunate taxpayer.
Comment on this
If they came from Cork you would not want one-third of them. If they were from Cork you could immediately relieve yourself of two-thirds of them. If one-third of them come from Cork I will make the serious suggestion that you get rid of the rest of them and let the Cork fellows carry on.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry is right —the Cork people were the best in helping us in Wicklow.
Comment on this
Sure, wherever you get a Corkman, you could not beat him. You are half a Corkman yourself.
Comment on this
At the start of the emergency here when we had to go into the condition of affairs such as rationing, compulsory tillage and all those other things, we had to recruit for that purpose something like 4,200 extra civil servants on a temporary basis. Any of us who, in the course of our duties during that period, went over to Balls-bridge saw an army of them there. There were 4,200 of them there on atemporary basis and, when the inter-Party Government came into office and the emergency was over, they made them permanent. They added to that number, during their three and a half years of office, another 5,400. You have to-day 9,600 more civil servants in this country than you had in 1939. It is no wonder that we Deputies, who are endeavouring to do work for our constituents, find that we have so many civil servants to pass the buck from one to another that we cannot get any result or decision.
Comment on this
We cannot get any result or decision. That is our trouble. These 9,800 extra unwanted men and women are costing this nation £3,800,000 a year. We have Deputy Davin and other Deputies then coming along and demanding a subsidy on this or that, but the money spent on these extra civil servants would mean a reduction of something like 2d. a lb. on butter if it were devoted to that purpose. Consider these things for yourselves. Consider how much relief could be given, for instance, if that £6,000,000 were available for subsidy purposes. Take the £7,200,000 that we have to pay for the squandermania that went on for three and a half years. If that money were available now for useful governmental expenditure, we need not have put anything on beer or "fags". We could even afford to give an increased subsidy on bread.
Let those people remember every time they are paying this £7,200,000, that they are only paying for the luxury and the pleasure of having a mixum-gatherum Government in this country for three and a half years. It is not we who are responsible for the extra taxation; it is the spree boys of the western world. That is the position. These are the definite replies I received to questions asked in this House from the Minister for Finance. Can there be any denial of it? There were on the Front Benches there ex-Ministers who would deny, if they were able to do so, the fact that there was borrowed during the three and a half years of inter-Party Government to run this country £14,000,000 more thanwas borrowed from 1922 to 1948. Let us examine that. Let us realise that when we hear the whispers going along in one place: "Oh, you have to pay 4/2 per lb. for butter"; and in another place: "The farmer is not getting half enough for his milk". These are the two eries, the two voices from the one source, the two different tunes on the one fiddle.
Let us get down to business and examine the matter from a business viewpoint. Deputies opposite should shed their irresponsibility. They know that taxation had to be imposed to pay the £7,200,000 in interest on the money with which they had a spree. They remind me of a particular type of farmer. You will find one in every parish. On Sunday he goes to Mass and when he comes out from Mass he makes for the local pub. At about half-past three he goes home and kicks up a row with the wife because his dinner is not ready. Then when the dinner is placed on the table, he will go off again because he cannot eat it. He will get up next morning and come down to the yard after his wife and the boys have the cows milked and harnessed the pony to take the milk to the creamery. He will go off for the rest of the day. About 3.30 p.m. in the evening, when the calves are bawling with the hunger, the young lad will have to go off to the pub, throw him into the cart like half a sack of meal, bring him home, and when he gets home he is no good for the rest of the day. When the rates and annuities fall due he will do what the inter-Party Government did-he will borrow to pay them.
After a few years the bank manager will refuse to give him any more money. Then the young lads will take over the farm from him, put him sitting in the corner, give him 2 ozs. of tobacco a week and half a dollar on Sunday for a few pints. Mind you, that is the nearest picture I can give of what the inter-Party Government did, with this difference, that when that poor old devil is put sitting in the corner he will stay quiet in the corner, and will not kick up a row by asking where they got the money to pay his debts. You over there are all the timeshouting. I cannot give you a better picture than that. Let them think it over for themselves and then they will not have the neck——
Comment on this
You would not believe me that the spuds grown on Deputy Dillon's orders in your constituency were sold at £5 a ton. If I had not been able to give the quotation, you would be on your hind legs to know who made that foolish statement.
Comment on this
Not one bit. The net result of the East Cork election was that our man was beaten by exactly the self-same vote as he was beaten in 1951.
Comment on this
I cannot help it. I hate being interrupted. That is the position. When I heard Deputy Barry talking about what the people in East Cork told him to do when he came in here——
Comment on this
He does, and I am glad to see him here, but I can tell you one thing—his comrade will not be there the next time. I will give you five to one on that.
Comment on this
If Deputy Corry has nothing further to say on the Vote of Account, I will ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
We will talk about that outside. I will fix it to my satisfaction, anyway, even if it is not to the satisfaction of the Deputy, for I will be drawing.
Comment on this
I cannot understand why this Vote on Account is being held up. I cannot understand what the objection is on the part of those Deputies who know that responsibility for this extra taxation rests on their shoulders, and only on their shoulders. What objecttion have they to voting the money required now for the services of the country? Apparently the only claim they make is that we should put on more taxation in order to give 21 weeks' back pay to the civil servants. That would mean another 2d. in the lb. on butter.
Comment on this
The New Zealand butter is gone, gone with the Formosan sugar. Brian Boru's butter is gone. All those are gone with the Minister who wasresponsible for bringing about a condition of affairs that compelled us, as his successors, to import butter. He was the Minister who was responsible for the disappearance of 57,000 milch cows in 12 months. That was the direct result of the policy of our Jamesy.
Comment on this
In reference to any member of this House, is that in order?
Comment on this
That is not an answer to the point of order I have raised.
Comment on this
The Chair has pointed out that the reference is not in order and the Chair understands the Deputy has withdrawn.
Comment on this
That is as may be, but I wanted the ruling of the Chair.
Comment on this
Deputy James Dillon was appointed Minister for Agriculture by the mixum-gatherum Government. Twelve months prior to his appointment he said here in reference to wheat: "It was only last week I had the exhilarating experience of eating bread made from Irish wheat; you held it out in your hands and you squeezed the water out of it and then you looked at it and you decided whether it was boot polish or bread; if it was boot polish you applied it to your shoes and, if it was bread, you masticated it, if you were able." Then Deputies wonder why in three and a half years with Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture there was a reduction of 300,000 acres in the acreage of wheat.
Comment on this
I am sorry I was not here when the shortage of milch cows was referred to. I spoke about that before and know just as well as Deputy Corry knows what brought that about.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry is in possession. Deputy Murphy will get an opportunity of making a speech later.
Comment on this
There is a change of policy now and instead of letting the foreigner produce 300,000 acres of wheat for us, we have this year increased the acreage under wheat in our own country by 100,000 acres. During the last three or four months, Deputy Dillon, ably supported by Deputy Rooney, has been endeavouring to prevent the farmers producing on their land the food required by our own people. That was the policy that operated here when Deputy Davin's oats were only 22/- per barrel and when 1,200,000 tons of foreign malting barley were thrown into the market here within a month of the delivery of our farmers' harvest. During the last three or four months Deputy Dillon has been preaching here and demanding the flooding of the market with foreign maize before the farmers have the barley harvest reaped.
I have given the House the facts. I give every Deputy credit for wanting to see the unemployment problem solved; no one wants to see men drawing the dole, men who should be working in productive employment. I appeal to Deputies in their constituencies to think out ways and means of ending unemployment.
Comment on this
Do you want us to do the Government's work? There is an easy way of doing it; get out and keep out and we will end unemployment.
Comment on this
I guarantee that the bill that Deputies opposite left after them when they ran out the last time will be remembered by the people of this country for the next 50 years because they will be paying that bill for the next 50 years. Mind you, you were not put out at all. You ran out.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but that is the fifteenth time that that Deputy has interrupted me. I know, of course, that I would be wasting my time in making appeals on that particular line to Deputy O'Higgins. I give him this guarantee that, unless something very extraordinary happens, I will be looking at him over there this time two years, and that this Government will still not have gone out of office.
Comment on this
If the Deputy looks at it from that point of view he will be all right. I do not want to delay the House. I have given the facts as I see them. I hope Deputies will approach these matters in a more serious and helpful frame of mind than we have seen some of them do in the last two days.
Comment on this
This Vote on Account is designed to gag the Opposition Deputies who have reason to be critical of the present Government. We have a situation at the moment where, with the aid of a couple of Independents, the strength of Dáil Eireann is 72 on either side. In that situation we have 72 Deputies who are supported by the vast majority of the people. They are not in Government but, instead, we have a group which is supported by a minority of the people.
Notice taken that20Deputies were not present; House counted and20Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I was pointing out that we have a situation where half the Deputies of this House, supported by the vast majority of the people, are not in Government, while the other half, supported by a minority, are the Government, aided, of course, by a couple of irresponsible Independentswho are afraid to face their constituents. Deputy Corry, who was speaking a moment ago, is one of the Deputies who does not wish to face a general election. He has as much fear in him of a general election as the three Deputies who are keeping in office at the moment a Government which the people do not want.
Comment on this
This Vote on Account is designed to gag the people, to ensure that the Deputies on this side of the House will not be given an opportunity to criticise the work of the different Departments. We will not be given the opportunity to criticise the Department of Industry and Commerce, particularly in relation to the cost of living and unemployment, to criticise the activities of the Minister for External Affairs or the policy that is being pursued by the Minister for Finance. We are faced with the situation where, instead of being able to do that in detail, we are asked to give this Vote on Account in order to keep the country going until November. This Vote on Account is designed purely and simply to put an end to the business of this Dáil in order that it will go into recess and that no question of a general election or a change of Government can arise until near Christmas.
I have listened to some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies trying to justify the policy of the present Government. One had to admire them for the manner in which they beat the air in their attempt to justify the present Government and its activities. One of the excuses they offered for asking for this Vote on Account, which prevents Deputies on this side from criticising each particular Minister and Department, was that the Fine Gael Party had opposed the Health Bill. We did, and we consider that we were justified in our opposition to it. It will be seen, I think, that our attitude to that Bill was well-founded and justified. But that was the excuse that was offered by Fianna Fáil Deputies in asking for this lump sum Vote instead of allowing Deputies an opportunity of dealing with the Estimates for each Department.I would remind those Deputies that, when the inter-Party Government were attempting to put the Local Authorities (Works) Bill through this House— a very different matter indeed from the Health Bill—they did not show the same consideration. That Bill was held up in this House for eight months by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. The Health Bill was opposed by the Fine Gael Party line by line and comma by comma during the last eight weeks for a very good reason and we are criticised for that.
We have a situation now where the people outside Dáil Eireann are clamouring at the walls, where the Government are under siege. They are besieged in this House while there is a tumult of the people outside clamouring for a change, but they are not going to be given an opportunity of bringing about a change of Government and a change of policy. It is apparent that, instead, they are going to be offered relief schemes which will not be of a productive nature. These relief schemes will have to be paid for by the taxpayers without any prospect of a return for the investment made in them.
We have a situation, too, where the policy that was announced by the Fianna Fáil Party in 1951, when they were seeking the support of a couple of Independent Deputies in order to bring about a change of Government, has been reversed. They have reversed the policy which they set out in their programme at that time when they were seeking the support of a couple of Deputies who call themselves Independents in order that the present Government could be established. They have gone back on the policy which they set out at that time. The only honest thing for them to do now is to say that they repudiate that policy, and that they are going to put to the country the policy which they are implementing at the present time.
We have noticed, in the last few days, that Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll has become very impatient. He was elected to this House because he said, in his election programme, that he intended to increase the sub-O'Carrolsidies on essential foods In order to get his support, the Fianna Fáil Party promised that they would maintain subsidies and control prices. Instead of that, as soon as they got Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll's vote to bring about a change of Government, they immediately proceeded to decontrol prices one after another and in the next Budget they abolished subsidies in respect of bread, tea, sugar and butter. There is a subsidy on bread at the moment but it is only the remainder of the subsidy, between the price of 6½d. a loaf, which was the price in 1951, when the change of Government took place, and 9½d. now.
We have seen several drastic changes of policy since the present Government came into office. We have observed in various by-elections that the people are opposed to the policy being pursued by the Government. We got a result in Cork, Wicklow, Cabra and Limerick. When Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Wicklow speak, their voice should be heeded by the Government. Instead of that, they introduce a Vote on Account which will enable them to go on holidays and ignore the demands of the people for a change of policy and a change of Government.
Some Deputies say that Fianna Fáil won the elections in Waterford and Mayo. They had a narrow victory in both places. At that time the taxpayers' money was used advertising a social welfare scheme and a new arrangement was arrived at whereby children's allowances were payable monthly in advance. A couple of days before the by-elections in Waterford and Mayo housewives queued at the post offices and got a month's payment of children's allowances in advance. That was the bribe to get their support a couple of days later at the polls. A month later, the prices of tea, sugar, butter and bread were increased, when the people had spoken in Waterford and Mayo and had no chance to change their ideas about the Government.
The change in Government in 1951 took place mainly as a result of an increase of 2d. a lb. in the price of butter. There was considerable agitation, fanned, of course, by the FiannaFáil Pravda, theIrish Press, fanned by political sabotage, obstruction and sneering on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party. Combined with the damp Fianna Fáil squib in Baltinglass, as it has proved to be in the Wicklow by-election, all those things brought about a situation where a couple of Independent Deputies found themselves in a position, because they had become cranks for one reason or another, to bring about a change of Government. None of those Deputies who are responsible for this Government can face his electorate without serious loss. Four of them cannot be re-elected have no hope of being re-elected. Deputy Noel Browne will certainly find a vary substantial loss in his support in his constituency, if he does not lose his seat.
Comment on this
This is a Vote on Account for the present Government. The Deputy is travelling over various by-elections and the results of them. Expenditure and administration are concerned in this debate.
Comment on this
We have got a decision outside the House on the policy of the present Government. I want to bring that point before the Minister for Finance in this debate. We will state in this House the reasons why we believe that an opportunity should be given to the people to bring about a change of policy and a change of Government. We will criticise on this Vote the policy of the Government. The people outside have already given their decision. We are criticising the fact that, instead of being allowed to debate each Estimate separately on its merits, we are now being asked to give £40,000,000 to the Government so that they can carry on the services until next November.
I would remind the Government that when the inter-Party Government were in office, taking the cost of living at 100 in 1947, it remained at 100 in 1948 and dropped to 97 in 1949. In 1950 it came back again to 100. In 1951 it had gone up to 105. At the moment it has gone up to 127. When the cost of living, in three years, had gone up by only 5 per cent., the incomes of our people had been increased by 20 percent., which left a margin in their favour. As a Government, we considered it was better to leave the money in the pockets of our people and to let them do the spending. Deputy Lemass said that the Government should take as much money as possible from the people and let the Government do the spending for them. That is the difference between the present Government and the last Government, a difference that is appreciated by the voters, as shown in recent times when they got an opportunity of speaking.
Let me remind the Government that on 1st July, 1951, there were 38,000 people registered as unemployed. On 1st July, 1953, there were 63,000 on the register. The increase in the number of unemployed shows the result of the Fianna Fáil policy over the last two years. Business is slumping; there is a trade recession, stagnation, a lack of stability and credit restriction and, of course, almost a complete stoppage in building development owing to the increased interest charges, owing to dear money, owing to the fact that many families cannot now afford to embark on the building of a home for themselves which they were busy doing when the change of Government took place.
It is all very well to have the present Government hitting the headlines trying to pacify our people by saying that stability has at last been reached, that progress is ahead. Let me remind the Taoiseach of his statement last February, when he said that taxation had reached its limit. I can quote his own words from Volume 136, column 502, Dáil Debates, 10th February last:
"....we are bearing a burden of taxation which is already so heavy that we are practically staggering under it."
That is a statement by the Taoiseach at that time. A few days later we had an announcement that wireless licences were to be increased. The total amount to be collected on wireless licences was to be increased by £750,000. That was followed by an announcement of an increase in post office charges which was to bring inan estimated £750,000. Then we had the Minister for Agriculture asking for £250,000 to buy Tulyar. After that there was an announcement of an increase in the price of stamps and telephone charges which was to bring in a further £1,000,000. These things all followed the Taoiseach's statement that the country was already staggering under a heavy burden of taxation.
That was not the finish of it, however, because we had an announcement recently made to the county councils that the supplementary agricultural allowance was to be withdrawn. That means an increase of £350,000 on the rates of the farmers. In County Dublin it means putting something like £30,000 extra on the rates, in addition to the extra 5/- in the £ put on the rates of every property owner in this country in the last two years. That will be followed by an extra 2/6 in the £ on the rates when the Government decide to bring the provisions of the Health Bill into operation and force the county councils to operate them. Of course, this taxation on the land came after the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance in which he said that taxation presses lightly on the land. He is following that up by an increase in the rates on land amounting to nearly £500,000, on top of the extra rates imposed on the farmers and property owners of all kinds during the last two years in consequence of the policy being pursued by the Government.
That does not represent all the taxation imposed since last February, when the Taoiseach said that the country was staggering under the burden of taxation. The tax on lorries, particularly those belonging to farmers and people carrying their own goods, went up from £25 to £70 in many cases. Interest charges on loans have gone up from 3¾ to 5¼ per cent. This increase applies, not alone to people who desire to avail of a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act but to houses built by county councils. If the families who will live in these county council houses do not bear this extra burden of interest, which will possibly amount to 10/- per week on each house, it will be necessary for the ratepayersto pay that extra charge of 10/- on each house in consequence of the increase in the interest charges on loans for house building. Similarly, the bank interest rate on overdrafts has been put up and imposes a very heavy burden on many businesses.
Comment on this
Of course you can. You want £30,000,000 now to spend which has to be raised in taxation.
Comment on this
I know the Minister for Lands does not like to hear the truth when it comes to facts and figures. These are the things which affect our people. Deputy Corry talked about money in millions of pounds, but most people are interested in a week's wages and not in millions of pounds. Deputy Corry and other Fianna Fáil speakers should come down to the week's wages instead of talking about millions of pounds when they are trying to confuse their listeners and to impress some of their supporters. Where is the stability and where is the progress that we hear so much about, not alone from the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Taoiseach but from other Fianna Fáil front benchers who are trying to make people believe that the situation is not as they find it and that they are not suffering from hardships imposed by the policy of the Government?
We know that the Minister for Finance considered that our people during the inter-Party régime were eating and spending too much and living too well. The attack on the people's pockets is due to the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party believed that to be true. They believed that to be true because in 1950 more butter was consumed than ever before in the history of this country, and every ounce of it was Irish butter.
I should like to give some comparative figures in relation to the taxation imposed under the policy of the presentGovernment and under the policy of the inter-Party Government. We have a situation now where rates have gone up by 5/- in the £ on property owners since 1951; butter from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb.; bread from 6½d. to 9½d. per two-lb. loaf; flour from 2/8 to 4/9½ per stone; sugar from 4d. to 7d. per lb.; tea from 2/8 to 5/6 per lb.; the pint of stout from 11d. to 1/3; cigarettes from 1/8 to 2/4 per packet of 20; petrol from 3/2 to 3/9½ per gallon; income-tax from 6/6 to 7/6 in the £.
Then we have the Government wondering why there is unemployment in this country, why there is a recession in trade, why business is slumping, why the bottom has fallen out of the property market and why stocks and shares have fallen considerably in value. Many people who are not physically fit to work were depending on the returns from these stocks and shares to give them a bare living. The value of these stocks and shares decreased considerably when the loan was floated last year offering 5 per cent. interest and extra facilities. The result was that many of these people were compelled to sell out at a loss of 10 or 15 per cent. when they could ill afford it. These are the people who are suffering most at present in addition to those who are unemployed.
In Balbriggan during the inter-Party régime people had a full week's work. They had overtime; they had round-the-clock work, and they had shift work. Now most of them are lucky if they can get half a week's work in the factories in Balbriggan. Many skilled workers who were engaged in the Balbriggan hosiery factories are now picking gooseberries and strawberries in Donabate. Many families are emigrating. I could give the names of families who got new cottages in Balbriggan and Skerries and who had three or four children. These families have packed up bag and baggage and gone to England or Canada as the case may be. That is because they could not eke out a living on the present unemployment allowance having regard to the increased charges, particularly on tea, sugar and butter. We know, of course, that many people have been forced to use margarine asa result of the policy of the Government in relation to butter. That has happened, particularly in the City of Dublin and probably in the City of Cork.
Comment on this
In regard to the price of milk I would like to remind the Deputy that he has a Minister for Agriculture in office at the moment who, when he was in opposition, said that creamery milk suppliers should be paid 2/- per gallon for their milk, but when he came into office, instead of giving them 2/- a gallon, he gave them 1d. a gallon increase. They have since got an increase of five farthings per gallon.
Comment on this
We have the Minister for Industry and Commerce opening some factories which were planned during the term of office of the inter-Party Government. During that time the arrangements were made, the sites were acquired, the factories were built, and now we have the Minister for Industry and Commerce turning the key in the door of those factories and receiving a certain amount of publicity for it. There is only a skeleton staff and a board of directors going into them instead of the number of persons we anticipated when those factories were being planned during the inter-Party Government régime.
Comment on this
There are many new factories, and even factories established 20 or 25 years ago, which have only skeleton staffs. It is a remarkable thing to hear in this debate some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies claiming credit in connection with the E.S.B.They followed up by claiming credit for the Dillon scheme of field drainage. I am not talking about the ditch-cleaning scheme that was in operation before Deputy Dillon became Minister for Agriculture. I am talking about the land project which involved field drainage and brought about the increase in production which is being reflected now in our statistics, including those dealing with exports.
Apparently Deputy Corry reflects the view of the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to civil servants when he referred to them as unproductive drones. Speaking here to-night he tried to justify his belief that they were not entitled to an adjustment of pay from the date of the award, but Deputy Corry refrained from stating that that award was made necessary by the policy of the Government and by reason of the fact that there is a clear understanding regarding the cost of living and Civil Service pay. They submitted their case for decision in an open court.
The decision could have gone against them but it went in their favour and should have been honoured. The result is that the conditions of the Civic Guards, the teachers, the Army and, of course, the civil servants proper, have been worsened in consequence of that policy and in consequence of the fact that there were so many persons in the Fianna Fáil Party who, like Deputy Corry, considered them to be unproductive drones.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick did not believe in giving them anything at all. He said that very clearly on the Vote.