We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 349–537 of 537. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

——a considerable fall, and I propose to give the Minister forFinance some figures. The average fall in the volume of industrial production amounts to about 12½ per cent. Amongst other things, we have vehicle production down by 19 per cent.; furniture production down by 15 per cent.; clothing production down by 12 per cent.; boots and shoes down by 14 per cent.

Comment on this

For what year is the Deputy quoting?

Comment on this

I am quoting for 1952.

Comment on this

Oh, now!

Comment on this

From what is the Deputy quoting?

Comment on this

From his memory.

Comment on this

I am quoting from my notes. I went to the trouble of getting these figures for the benefit of Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

From what, and when?

Comment on this

I know you do not want to hear them.

Comment on this

I want to hear them, but where did you get them?

Comment on this

You can find them in the Library, where he got them.

Comment on this

Do not prompt him.

Comment on this

It is probably a closer date than the date I have given. It is probably in the first six months of this year. In addition to that, internal purchases have dropped by about £50,000,000 and that explains the business slump, the trade recession, unemployment and credit restriction. All these things add up.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get the figure, £50,000,000?

Comment on this

I will produce that, also, for the Minister on another occasion. I would like to remind the Minister—maybe he will not dispute this—that a one-point rise in the cost of living means an increase of £1,000,000 against the consumer here. Is the Minister prepared to accept that?

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept anything the Deputy givesbecause he has given no authoritative source for the figures he has been quoting.

Comment on this

I can give these figures from the official statistics.

Comment on this

I do not forget the Deputy's brilliant attempt to reform the poultry industry in this country.

Comment on this

Do not worry about poultry for the moment. Every rise of one point in the cost of living means an extra £1,000,000 of a burden on the consumers. The cost of living has risen approximately 20 per cent. since 1951. That means that our people are paying out of their pockets for the ordinary things they were purchasing in 1951, and are paying to-day an extra £20,000,000. That can be regarded as extra taxation in addition to the various types of taxation applied to different commodities.

Another reason for the conditions existing at the present time, particularly in relation to trade, business and credit restriction, is the fact that the purchasing power of the £ has dropped 2/- in the last two years. The purchasing power of the £ now in relation to pre-war is about 8/10. In 1951 it was 10/10, and its value is continuing to decline. Nevertheless we have the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce telling the people that prosperity is around the corner while the purchasing power of the £ continues to decline and the value of people's earnings declines with it. I would like to remind the Minister for Finance that 500,000 people have emigrated from this country since the State was established and in spite of all the talk of the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to emigration it was greater in the last two years than it was ever before.

Comment on this

Again there is no proof of that.

Comment on this

I am going to quote now. This is a quotation.

Comment on this

This is a wild assertion.

Comment on this

The Minister will be surprised with this quotation.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely a Deputy should be permitted to make his speech without this, I will not refer to it in the manner in which it should be referred to, but without this interruption.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy himself should help to maintain order.

Comment on this

I want to quote here from the Clare Champion.This is a report of a Fianna Fáil convention which took place last September.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy give the date?

Comment on this

Well, Sir, I have the date. I do not mind whether I have the date or not, but I can tell you that here is a statement of a Fianna Fáil delegate which was published and he said: "People are emigrating by boat loads simply because they cannot find employment at home". This statement was made at a Fianna Fáil convention by a Fianna Fáil Deputy, a Fianna Fáil delegate, and it was published in the newspaper.

Comment on this

A Deputy or a delegate?

Comment on this

Who was the Deputy?

Comment on this

What was his name?

Comment on this

That is what some of the ordinary people who were foolish enough to support Fianna Fáil in the past and apparently were supporters of Fianna Fáil when this convention took place think of emigration at the present time. They say that people are emigrating by boat loads simply because they cannot find employment at home. That is the position, particularly in relation to Dublin County, and I suppose County Dublin is no different from the western counties, because if we go to Westland Row or to Rosslare, or to any of these places we will see fine young boys and girls obviously having packed up and stepping into the emigrant ship because there is no policy here and there is no prospect for them here and there is no enticement for them to remain at home and they must travel elsewhere, not alone for a living, but for an existence.We have a situation now where we must expect from the Government some positive action. The only positive action they have indicated recently is that they are going to draw up a plan of relief schemes in order to absorb the thousands of people who are unemployed. That will bring them relief of a temporary nature, but how long is that relief going to last? Would it not be better for the Government to sit down and consider a proper scheme by which these people could be engaged in productive work, such as the work they were engaged in when the inter-Party Government were in office and when the number of unemployed was reduced to 38,000 in July, 1951, compared with 63,000 at the beginning of the present month? That is the situation we have at present and it is obvious from the statements of the Ministers and of the Government that they have no solution for it.

Apparently they do not want to bother about trying to find a solution for it, because the only remedy they are going to offer is relief schemes instead of productive work. In common decency, I consider that the Government should put their policy to the people. It is not the policy which they put before the people in 1951 when they were trying to deprive the nation of the inter-Party Government. We had some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies saying: "Why did the inter-Party Government go out of office in June, 1951? Why did they do it?" I would like to remind the House that when the inter-Party Government was established it was forecast by the Fianna Fáil Party that they would not last three weeks. Then it was three months and then it went into three years, but all during that time the validity of the inter-Party Government was being challenged by Fianna Fáil. We had nothing but obstruction, sabotage and sneering from the Fianna Fáil Party, and it was being fanned, of course, by the Party organ, the Irish Press, until the people had been worked into a frenzy and we had a situation where——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have reminded the Deputy already that we are discussing a Vote on Account of the present Government.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir; I am replying to the argument put forward by Deputies who said that the inter-Party Government should not have had an election in 1951.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is proceeding to discuss certain incidents that happened during the inter-Party Government. This is not at all relevant to this Vote. What is relevant to this Vote is expenditure and administration of the present Government.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, I felt that I was entitled to reply to points which were made by Fianna Fáil Deputies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair cannot remember everything that was said by every Fianna Fáil Deputy, but I have no recollection of those things being said.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, if I am not entitled to reply, I will not attempt it, but the people know the answer. They gave their answer in East Cork, in Wicklow, in Dublin and in Limerick. They gave their answer to the present Government in those places, but the present Government are determined not to heed them. Instead of that, we are being asked now to vote this money in order that the services can be carried on until next November, and that in the meantime this Dáil will be closed down and the people will not be given an opportunity of speaking through their Deputies in this House in relation to their many problems, not the least of them being the unemployment problem. We have a situation now where we are being asked to go on holidays instead of being asked to remain here in this House in order to consider a solution of the unemployment situation, and the business slump and the stagnation in agriculture and the lack of stability that exists in the country. We are being asked to close down the Dáil in face of these very great problems, and they are very great problems when there are hungry people, people without a week's wages although they are willing to work. For that reason I think it is only fair to expect from the Government that they should give anopportunity in this House to Deputies of all the Opposition Parties, who are the voice of the people at the moment, to put before the Government the various problems and the difficulties under which the people are suffering at the present time.

Comment on this

This is the first time in the history of this House that a second Vote on Account has been asked for by any Government-the first time in the history of this House since it was established, and seeing that it is a very strange thing we must examine the causes. They are not hard to seek and not far to find. The cause is that the time of this House has been deliberately frittered away and wasted particularly this summer by the present Government's proposals.

They were principally trying to regain lost fortunes, in a frantic effort to see what has happened that turned the people against them in the way revealed in the last three by-elections.

A very short time ago the Taoiseach tabled a motion of confidence. It could have been disposed of in 15 minutes, instead of the 28 hours of the time of the House, proposed for it. Now we have a second Vote on Account. This is a new way to manage the affairs of the country. It is a strange thing that we have a Government which cannot go ahead with the business because it might deprive Deputies of a few days' summer holidays, customary in the previous years. Seeing that Deputies are here to give the people the very best management they can of the country, I do not think anyone would object, except a few on the Government side, to take the Estimates as usual one after another in accordance with the custom since the House was established. Now we are asked to rush through a lump sum of £40,000,000 to give the Minister money to run the country until November. This is just a clever parliamentary device to stifle criticism-particularly criticism of the remaining Votes. I can understand the Minister and the Government not being very anxious to discuss the Estimates for Local Government or the Board of Works, to mention only two. The Estimate forAgriculture has not been finished yet and the debate so far has not been very favourable towards the management of that particular Department by the present Minister for Agriculture.

Such things as unemployment are not pleasant things to discuss at the present time. Discussion must be stifled. This is really only the second part of the trick. A few weeks ago we had the Taoiseach's motion of confidence, wasting a week of valuable time. Now, we have a second Vote on Account, for the first time in the 30 odd years' history of this House.

Comment on this

Not at all. The Deputy does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

If the Minister will tell me when it occurred and, secondly, that the Government agree that, before the Dáil rises for the summer recess, each of the remaining Votes will be taken, I will not delay further on the subject and will withdraw what I have said as having accused the Government of doing something that it did not intend to do. No answer is forthcoming.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember 1951?

Comment on this

There are at least half a dozen Votes to be discussed yet.

Comment on this

Why did you not finish Agriculture in 1951?

Comment on this

It would not be very pleasant to have a discussion on those Votes. There is not a single one of the remaining Estimates on which the question of the 67,000 unemployed could not come up in some way or other. The people are aware that the present Government has lost completely all knowledge of what is happening in the country. The Government seems to have deteriorated into a system of bungling and bad management, which has brought distress and uncertainty into every single home in the country.

It is only now that the full impact of the Government's policy of restriction of credit is being felt by thepeople. All over the country hundreds of people whose business depended to some extent on credit are very hard hit. Small farmers anxious to purchase stock, farm machinery, fertilisers or, perhaps, an extra bit of land, are told when they go to the banks that they will not get any money. The Government has produced a situation where even the vested farmer with a good local reputation, not alone during his lifetime, but of his family for generations, will not get a pound on his land when he goes to the local bank now.

That has all been produced by the Minister for Finance, sitting across the floor, because he entered into competition with his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce shortly after they came into office in 1951, in a desperate attempt to try to discredit the inter-Party Government. They both went around the country wailing that the country was sunk, that bankruptcy was around the corner. They retracted these statements a few months later when they were made do so in the Dáil, but already the damage had been done, the freeze had set in. That freeze has not yet fully solidified. I am sure the present Minister for Finance must feel very proud of the way he has handled the particular portfolio he got in 1951, of the distress and misfortunes brought upon the people. Several speakers quoted in this debate what is only too true—the vast number of unemployed, the lowered standard of living of all the people, of practically every single one in the country. That is intersely noticeable, as is the recession in trade, hitting particularly small traders and shopkeepers all over the country.

These are things sticking out noticeably at present and since the bungling and mismanagement that the present Government started long before the inter-Party Government took office in 1948. The first effects of it were seen in the Supplementary Budget introduced in October, 1947, months before they thought there was going to be a general election so soon, imposing a tax on tobacco and drink. I challenge the present Government with taking the advice that we got while we were the inter-Party Governmentfor three and a half years from the people behind the scenes; and I am proud now that as a Government we rejected that advice. I am sorry to say that the present Government accepted it in September and October, 1947, and as soon as they came into office in June, 1951, they took up where they left off. The result is that to-day it is not Fianna Fáil policy that this country is being administered under, but the policy of people behind the scenes.

The present Government put forward, when they wanted to gain certain support for the election of Taoiseach and a Government in June, 1951, a policy of 16 points. On every single one of them they have gone back absolutely shamelessly. We can take a few of the points. The promise to maintain the food subsidies has gone overboard. Then there was the promise of the present Minister for Finance—I am not speaking in his absence now—made in the Rathmines Town Hall that if he and his Party were returned to power the taxes on tobacco and drink would not be reimposed.

Comment on this

I did not make that promise. The Deputy had better recite what I said.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance—Deputy Seán MacEntee as he was then—made that promise in the Rathmines Town Hall to his constituents two nights before polling day in the 1951 General Election.

Comment on this

I will not allow the Deputy to put that gloss on my words. He may be an adept at misrepresentation, but he had better give the exact quotation.

Comment on this

If I wanted to become an adept at misrepresentation I would need to go to school for a few years to the Minister; I might learn a little about it then. The Minister stated at Rathmines Town Hall that people in the Opposition Parties up and down the country were saying that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power the tax on tobacco and drink would be reimposed. Deputy MacEntee, replying,said: "There is not a shadow of truth in those rumours." What does the present Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, make of that? Was that intended as a cunning trick, so that the people, particularly his own supporters, would understand that Fianna Fáil, having got a kick in the pants in 1948, at the general election, could not go back and reimpose the tax on tobacco and drink? The very gentleman sitting across from me could walk in here last April 12 months and was only too glad to reimpose the tax, as much as to say to the people: "We are back again and we will show you that we will do what we like."

It is absolutely useless to be talking about that here. No impression can be made on the present Government, not even by the catastrophic fall in their votes in the two recent by-elections, a drop that ran to extraordinarw proportions in County Wicklow and was alarming for the Government in power.

The rise in the cost of living is beyound the capacity of the ordinary people to bear. The result, if we examine it, is borne out in a short statement which the Minister for Finance made in his Budget speech in this House when he boasted that £20,000,000 worth more of agricultural produce was exported this year than last year. He added, in a semi-undertone at the time, that a small amount of that increase in agricultural exports was due to increased production. I think he said £2.5 million worth. Where did the rest come from? Where did the other £17.5 million worth of agricultural produce that we exported come from?

Comment on this

From better prices.

Comment on this

The Minister should not make a joke of a fact of which he must be very well aware by now, and that is that the standard of living of the community, and particularly of the working-class people and the small farmers, has been lowered very seriously. The Minister knows as well as I do that what has produced that extra £17.5 million worth of exports from this country has been the fact that our own people have been deprived of the power to purchase our own food.

Comment on this

I know that farmers' incomes are up by nearly £11,000,000.

Comment on this

Very good. If that be the case, then the farmers of East Cork and of Wicklow must have just gone mad. They seem to be determined to vote for the inter-Party Government because that Government injured them and they seem to be determined to vote against Fianna Fáil that is acting like the father which the Minister for Finance would have us believe he is to the community. Let us give him the figures lest he should have forgotten them. Twenty thousand people odd in Wicklow voted against this benevolent Fianna Fáil Government which we have at present. If we are to take the Minister for Finance seriously, only 7,788 people in the Wicklow constituency are sane or have their heads screwed on properly, and the 20,109 who voted against Fianna Fáil must be absolutely daft. Is that what I understood the Minister for Finance to say? If it is, I do not believe it is true.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not understand the figures.

Comment on this

In the Cork by-election, 17,381 people voted against the present Government while only 11,000 people voted for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is shutting his eyes to the facts. A substantial Labour vote was transferred to the Fianna Fáil candidate in Wicklow and in Cork.

Comment on this

The Minister and his Government are shutting their eyes to the misery which they have brought on the people of this country. However, the people will not stand for it. In at least three constituencies in the past 12 months the people have told the Government in no uncertain manner that they do not agree with their policy. Despite that, the Government pig-headedly continue with their policy as if it were quite all right. The final touch was when the Minister for Local Government proposed to slash £500,000 off the agricultural grant to be paid to farmers and a few days ago the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs ranin here breathless to make a present of £800,000, derived from an extra charge on post office services, to the Minister for Finance.

This time last year we were all up to our eyes wondering what section of the community the Minister for Local Government would tax next. He hit the petrol buyers, the paraffin users, the tractor owners, the lorry owners, hackney-car owners, and so forth. Every section of the community has been pretty hard hit by the present Government. On top of all that, we now have the highest ever number of unemployed. The scenes which have been taking place for the past few weeks in O'Connell Street and outside Leinster House are unparalleled in the history of this State. A Cumann na nGaedheal Government ruled this country for ten years, then a Fianna Fáil Government for 16 years, then an inter-Party Government for three and a half years and for the past two years we have had a Fianna Fáil Government again. In all these years, this is the first time that such scenes have been witnessed in this country. Three or four thousand men have stood clamouring outside the gates of Leinster House. Some Deputy said earlier that the Government are now under siege. In the name of common sense, should all that evidence not be sufficient to make the Government realise that there is something radically wrong in the country? Should not the fact that 78,000 men between the ages of 15 and 45 have fled from the land during the past six years tell the Government that something is wrong? Should not the train loads of young men and women fleeing from this country through the port of Dublin and Dún Laoghaire Harbour tell the Government that something is radically wrong? Have the Government gone blind or stupid? I believe that they are both. Along with all that, the Government are absolutely heedless of the condition of things throughout the country. They are now asking for a Vote on Account. My guess is that the remaining Estimates will not be taken but will be bundled together next November or December.

Comment on this

They will go through before we rise.

Comment on this

I am not accepting Deputy Cowan's statement for the Government.

Comment on this

It is not the Government. It is the Dáil.

Comment on this

If the Government do not present the Estimates to the House the House can do nothing about it.

Comment on this

The House need not adjourn unless it wishes.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Blowick tell me why the inter-Party Government ran away from the division on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture?

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan is not a member of the Government.

Comment on this

I am a member of the House.

Comment on this

I have challenged the Minister for Finance to tell me whether or not the remaining Estimates will be taken before we adjourn and he has remained silent.

Comment on this

I hope that they will be taken.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance and the present Government have been feeding the people for the past two years with talk about plans— plans that have never materialised. They have been promising more employment, and other things. The trouble is that the good days ahead are always just around the corner. A lot of our people are wondering if we will ever turn that blessed corner.

Comment on this

Do you remember all the estates that you promised to divide? You never divided one of them.

Comment on this

When Deputy Cowan becomes Minister for Lands I hope he will do half as good a job as I did. I am proud of what I did.

Comment on this

Deputy O. Flanagan said he would make a better Minister for Lands than you.

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath should hold his tongue. If he feels cutup by recent happenings in Cork, I can assure him that I can quite understand it and that I sympathise with him.

Comment on this

Do you know what Deputy O. Flanagan said about you?

Comment on this

I know what he said about Deputy McGrath and it was not complimentary either.

Comment on this

Deputy O. Flanagan said that he would make a better Minister for Lands than you.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blowick is in possession and should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

This is a new line of procedure to try to dodge the discussion of very important Estimates which have yet to come before the House. The Minister for Finance expresses a pious hope—a hope not a certainty. Bear in mind that that pious hope is expressed by the second principal Minister in the Government of this country to-day—a hope that the Estimates will be taken. He expresses that pious hope although one can safely assume that at recent Government meetings they have considered every possible scheme to try and dodge the unpleasant criticism which they know is inevitable on certain Estimates.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very well aware that the introduction of this Vote on Account has been necessary because of the obstructionist tactics pursued by the Fine Gael Party for a considerable time past.

Comment on this

The people of this country know quite well that a Fianna Fáil promise is nothing but a Fianna Fáil promise, and they know that the Fianna Fáil plans do not exist even on paper. They are just like the biscuit factory that was to have been established in Ballina—the factory that the people of North Mayo were promised last year by the Tánaiste, the Deputy Prime Minister of this country. He had the unbounded cheek to go down to North Mayo and to tellthe people of Ballina, on the Saturday night before voting day, that Fianna Fáil intended to establish a biscuit factory in Ballina.

Comment on this

This is reminiscent of Greyfriars.

Comment on this

I understand that a few days prior to that, the present Minister for Finance presided, very ably no doubt, at a convention. Some of the candidates at that particular convention——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not seem to be relevant.

Comment on this

It does not arise and it is an awful pity that it does not arise because, if it did, we would have a very lively discussion here in a few minutes.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Hara gets very uncomfortable when you talk about North Mayo.

Comment on this

Does he?

Comment on this

I will give the Minister a run for his money. I will take him on next week, if he likes.

Comment on this

We will give the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce a chance to go down to North Mayo and explain away the beautiful plans for the establishment of a biscuit factory in Ballina —the plans which never materialised. That kind of talk will not cut ice any longer. I admit that it deceived a lot of decent people in North Mayo at the last election, but the famous plans the Government have up their cuff for unemployment and other problems did not deceive the people of Cork, or of Wicklow, or of Dublin.

It is time the Government took a proper view of the present condition of the country. They should try to cut down unemployment and to restore in some measure the prosperity which the people enjoyed during the inter-Party Government's term of office. Let them remember this: it is the same country,the same people, the same land, the same climate, the same towns and villages——

Comment on this

And the same speeches.

Comment on this

——and the same ability and willingness of our people to work that the present Government has to manage as we had. I said before that, with the exception of the United States, there is not a wealthier country in the world to-day than this country, if it were properly managed and given a proper chance.

Comment on this

Why did you not stay here longer?

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan put us out—so he says.

Comment on this

I want to refer now to the Irish Press,which to-day has a big heading: “£2,000,000 Drainage Plan— Western Counties Will Benefit—To Employ 500 at Peak Period.”

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will not criticise that?

Comment on this

There is nothing of the Ballina biscuit factory about this, and the reason is that this was ordered by Deputy Donnellan when he was Parliamentary Secretary in the inter-Party Government. On 3rd May, 1948, the survey was ordered, and, one month after the inter-Party Government went out of office the Corrib drainage scheme was to start. Sufficient of the survey had been completed and machinery had been ordered down. The present Government took office in June, 1951, and all these orders were cancelled. The only contribution the present Government have made towards the Corrib drainage scheme, which is now to employ 500 at peak period, was to delay it and hinder its operation for the past two years. This announcement would not appear now, were it not for the pending by-election in portion of County Galway. I notice —I mention this because I want to draw attention to the meanness of Government policy or whoever was responsible for this announcement—that they take great care not to say that the Government have done this. We will read what they say.

Comment on this

Who say?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us who passed the Arterial Drainage Act?

Comment on this

Here is the announcement:—

"A £2,000,000 drainage scheme for the Corrib-Clare catchment area designed to drain about 52,000 acres in Counties Galway, Mayo and Roscommon and which will give employment to 500 men at peak development, has been prepared by the Commissioners of Public Works."

It has not been ordered by the present Government. They could not claim that because they would be leaving themselves open to a refutation.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us who passed the Arterial Drainage Act, in the teeth of the opposition of the Deputy and his colleagues?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would hold his tongue. I am in possession. When he starts, I can assure him that he will get what he has always got from this side—empty benches. More co-operation than that he cannot get. There will be no interruptions because there will be nobody here to listen to him, as nobody ever waits to hear him. That scheme was initiated by the inter-Party Government. Deputy Cowan was a supporter of the inter-Party Government and he can claim a certain amount of credit for it, if he likes. This announcement in the Irish Pressof to-day does not say that the Government ordered it and they have omitted to say that the Government have delayed the starting of this work since they took office.

Comment on this

You do not want any work to go on—is that not it?

Comment on this

They fail to mention that Deputy Donnellan, as Parliamentary Secretary, gave the order for that work to commence, for the survey to be proceeded with on 3rd May, 1948.

Comment on this

There were a lot of things Deputy Donnellan did which were unmentionable.

Comment on this

Mention them. If the Minister knows anything about them. let him mention them. Let him not try to save Deputy Donnellan, me, or anybody else on this side. I have never know him to do it. If he has anything to mention, let him come out with it— I am here to listen to it. If there was anything to mention, I can assure the House that the Minister would not have kept it in his head until now. We would have heard about it. What is getting under his skin is the fact that he has not got more mud to sling.

Comment on this

The Deputy seems to be annoyed.

Comment on this

I am annoyed about one thing; I am annoyed because the Minister has brought poverty into practically every workingman's home, because he has deprived thousands of employment, because he has taken butter and meat off the tables of many of the working-class who were accustomed to it during our period in office. I am annoyed because he has spent the past three months in vote catching nonsense and in wasting the time of the House and because now, when the business of the House should be discussed, he has brought in this device of a second Vote on Account to stifle discussion of very important matters, a discussion which would not be too palatable for the Government.

Comment on this

You are annoyed because you started talking about it over five years ago.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions should cease. Deputy Blowick is in possession.

Comment on this

It is not easy to remain in possession when we have to listen to unintelligible grunts from Deputy McGrath.

Comment on this

Five years ago you were talking about it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The Deputy is suffering a certain amount of anxiety at present and I feel for him. Regardless of what the Irish Pressmay say,Deputy Donnellan, the inter-Party Government and Clann na Talmhan, if the Minister wants to know the truth of it, were responsible for the Corrib arterial drainage scheme. The only part the present Government have played is deliberately to delay it and to butcher it, if they could, just as they butchered the Local Authorities (Works) Act passed by the inter-Party Government, as they butchered the forestry scheme of the inter-Party Government and reduced it from 25,000 acres to 12,000 acres, as they butchered and cut down on the work of the Land Commission and have tried to cut down the relief of rates on agricultural land and have gone shamelessly back on their promises with regard to food subsidies.

When the Minister is replying, I suppose he will clap himself on the back and boast again of the £20,000,000 worth of extra agricultural produce we exported this year. He will be too careful to mention the policy of the Government in particular directions, the first inkling of which we got was the short and terse statement of the Taoiseach when he said, in a pained way, that the people are living beyond their means. By this time, the people of the country know quite well the full depth of that statement. They have felt the full impact of it in no uncertain way, and they know exactly what the Taoiseach meant. The average person wondered at the time who were these horrible bad-minded people who were living beyond their means and causing the poor Taoiseach all this trouble and anxiety because they were doing so. Now they know exactly whom he meant. They know that he meant themselves—the workingman, the small farmer, the small businessman, and the housewife. They know that it is they themselves who were living beyond their means, and they know what that very strong expression by the Taoiseach meant.

Comment on this

I wonder could we have a record made of this and have it played? It would be much easier.

Comment on this

I do not say that outof political bitterness. I want to state the hard facts which the Deputy will encounter whenever the election comes off. Whatever is happening in the towns of Connaught is happening also in the towns of Munster and Leinster and in Dublin City, too.

Comment on this

Would what the farmer gets for his beef have anything to do with it?

Comment on this

The people are not going to be deceived by that kind of side-tracking in regard to the farmers. The farmer is finding it as hard to live as anybody else and the working people are beginning to realise that. The present Government, backed by Deputy Cowan, has reduced the standard of living of the people, but what is much worse is that families and children of school going age and younger have not now the standard of living that the Irish Medical Association prescribes as being the lowest possible minimum.

Comment on this

For God's sake, leave the Irish Medical Association out of it.

Comment on this

You show signs of it.

Comment on this

We will see how Deputy McGrath gets on at the next election. Deputy McGrath may joke about the poverty of the people in his constituency. That is his affair, but I take it that the people of Cork are not the fools that Deputy McGrath would have us believe. Deputy McGrath himself may not be feeling the pinch but his constituents are. We were upbraided by the Government because we asked for a general election. We do not ask for a general election. It is the people who are asking for it. In the recent by-elections the people told the Government in no uncertain manner to get out. The biscuit factory in North Mayo is there as a monument.

Even at this late hour I want to ask the Government at least to face the most urgent problems that confront them. Unemployment and the high cost of living are two of these most urgent problems.

Comment on this

What does theDeputy suggest in regard to unemployment?

Comment on this

Another urgent problem is the flight from the land, including emigration and the flight to the towns and cities in our own country. That is a most urgent problem at the present time. I would ask the Government to face up to their responsibilities even now regardless of whether this Vote on Account goes through or not.

Comment on this

Of course, it will.

Comment on this

Give us a full discussion on the Estimates. We do not mind if three or four weeks of our summer holidays are taken from us but we know that the Government Deputies mind. They are in a panic and ostrich-like they are sticking their heads in the sand. They want to close down the House and get away from the searchlight of criticism which is being played on them by the Opposition. They want to get away and close the House until November. That is no policy and I warn the Government not to follow that particular line of country.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Rooney in repudiating Deputy Blowick's opposition to the back pay for the civil servants said that Deputy Blowick had no responsibility.

Comment on this

He was not in the Government.

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney said that Deputy Blowick had no responsibility. The Fine Gael people and the Labour people promised they were going to give this extra million to the civil servants and Deputy Rooney said that Deputy Blowick had no responsibility.

Comment on this

He was not in the Government.

Comment on this

That is typical of the whole Coalition set up. They have no responsibility. Deputy Davin supported Deputy Dillon in reducing the price of milk to 1/- a gallon and when Deputy Rooney went round to the dairyfarmers he said that Deputy Dillon had no responsibility and Deputy Davin had no responsibility.

Comment on this

What about Deputy Cowan?

Comment on this

None of them had any responsibility. Deputy Cowan is prepared, as is every member on this side of the House, to take responsibility for his own vote, but Deputy Rooney is not prepared to take responsibility for Deputy Blowick. When Deputy Blowick became a member of the Coalition, he took no responsibility for the promise he made that he would never join a Coalition. He took no responsibility for having sworn that all over the country Mayo and other parts of the West, after describing the bad smell that was in the Dáil when the other Parties joined Fine Gael. I do not believe that the voters are going to take any responsibility for those groups who will not take responsibility themselves.

Comment on this

How does the Taoiseach like his Coalition?

Comment on this

If Deputy Rooney wants to form a Coalition with Deputy Davin and Deputy Blowick——

Comment on this

And Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

——or with anybody he likes, all he has got to do is to get them together and show the people a policy in respect of which they are prepared to take responsibility.

Comment on this

This is a rum Coalition.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy indicated to-day that Fine Gael had not changed its policy. I remember 1931 when Deputy Mulcahy was Minister for Local Government. We asked him to promote a great housing campaign. Deputy Mulcahy's answer was that they could not build houses until the cost of materials and wages came down so that houses could be built to let at an economic rent. To-day he showed that, notwithstanding the fact that he rubbed shoulders with Deputy Davin for a short time, he has not lost his fundamental philosophy. He pointed out that this idea of having public works for the relief of unemploymentwas a very dear business and that really Dublin Corporation should make no effort to co-operate with the Government because it was dearer to keep a man on public works than it was on the bureau.

Comment on this

In fact, he stated that it was cheaper to give him the full wage for doing nothing.

Comment on this

Is it?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin would take no responsibility for what Deputy Mulcahy said and Deputy McGilligan took no responsibility for the Labour Party's social legislation. They let Deputy Norton talk his head off about what he was going to do in regard to social welfare for three years and they were not prepared to take the responsibility of finally putting it through the Dáil.

Comment on this

You voted against it on the 2nd March, 1951.

Comment on this

We put the social services legislation through here within a few months after we became the Government.

Comment on this

You voted against it in 1951.

Comment on this

We were the only majority Party in this House for the last 30 years that was prepared to take the line that those who are in the greatest need in the country are entitled to get help from the community——

Comment on this

You butchered our scheme.

Comment on this

——and we did that in one piece of social legislation after another. The only thing that the Labour Party got when they were members of the Coalition was the right to put an extra 9d. on the national health stamp without increasing the benefit.

Comment on this

What did you do on the 2nd March, 1951?

Comment on this

That is something that Deputy Davin cannot get away from.The only thing the Labour Party did as members of the Coalition was to increase the national health stamp—by 9d. I think—without increasing the benefit. We were not back in office more than a few months when the national health benefit was doubled.

Comment on this

You butchered our scheme.

Comment on this

The cost of living was doubled.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Minister be allowed to make his speech?

Comment on this

Tell us about the death grant.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Minister be allowed to make his speech without interruption?

Comment on this

There is a certain attitude of blueshirtism around among Deputies Davin, Rooney and Blowick.

Comment on this

On a point of order is the Minister allowed to tell a damned lie like that? To describe me as a Blueshirt?

Comment on this

He wants to do everything except deal with the problem of the cost of living at the present time.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Davin tells the Minister he was not a Blueshirt the Minister will accept it.

Comment on this

But I did not say that.

Comment on this

He is not going to get away with the barefaced lie that I was a Blueshirt.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To say a person is a Blueshirt is a political accusation.

Comment on this

But I did not make it. What I said was, that there was a certain element of blueshirtism about this whole business; that when the Government is elected here to carry on the national work a Minister replying to a debate, in which no other Minister has spoken, is not allowed to get in two consecutive sentences without interruptions.

Comment on this

On a point of order, would the Minister explain the differencebetween the hairshirt and a blueshirt?

Comment on this

He would do anything to get away from the cost of living and the unemployment problems.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy made a statement in which he said that we were endeavouring to build up external assets, so that we would give the people's money to Jhon Bull to oppress the negroes in Africa. Let us take the external assets held by Government Departments and the Central Bank since 1948. In 1948, the nominal value of departmental funds invested in British securities was £49.7 million. In 1951, under the régime of the groups who would not take responsibility for each other, it rose to £56.8 million. During their time Government funds alone showed an increase of £7.1 million worth of external assets. Nobody accused them at that time of having increased departmental funds in external assets for the purpose of enabling John Bull to oppress the rest of the world. Nobody accused them of investing £7.1 million extra in wastepaper, as Deputy McGilligan called it.

Since March, 1951, the same funds have dropped from £56.8 million down to £41.55 million, a drop of about £15,000,000. The Central Bank's holdings of external assets in March, 1948, just after we left office, were £43.9 million. What did they go up to? In the March before the Coalition left office they had gone up to £80.6 million, or an increase of £36.7 million. They had fallen last March to £71.4 million. Deputy Rooney does not like to hear about the increase in sterling assets during their time in office, and I would like to ask Deputy Rooney does he take responsibility for Deputy Blowick or for Deputy Davin? Does he take responsibility for Deputy McGilligan? Does he take responsibility for the increase in the sterling assets held by the Central Bank from £43,000,000 to £80,000,000 during his régime, and the sterling holdings of departmental funds from £49,000,000 to £56,000,000?

Comment on this

It is a week's wages the people are interested in and not in the millions.

Comment on this

I knew the Deputy was afraid to say he takes responsibility for the actions of Deputy McGilligan. That is what bedevils the whole situation. What this country wants is a Government not afraid to take responsibility. Deputy Rooney is afraid to say: "Yes, it is true that during our régime the holdings of sterling assets by the Central Bank went up from £43.9 million to £80.6 million and the sterling holdings of departmental funds went up from £49.7 million to £56.8 million. Deputy Rooney is afraid to take responsibility for it. He is afraid to take responsibility for the process that Deputy Mulcahy described here to-day as giving the people's money to John Bull in order to beat the negroes.

Comment on this

The Minister is afraid to let the people judge.

Comment on this

And that is another little bit of blueshirtism. Our Constitution, which Deputy Rooney and some of his colleagues tried to defeat, is a democratic Constitution. It provides that we have an election every five years and the Government once elected can remain in office for the five years, so long as it holds the confidence of the House. This Government have proved no later than the last week or two that they retain, on a deliberate vote announced a fortnight beforehand, the confidence of the House.

Comment on this

But not of the people.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Not even the confidence of the House.

Comment on this

If we were to have a general election every time a Government is beaten in a by-election we would never be done with by-elections.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You would not be in office.

Comment on this

Fine Gael were often beaten in by-elections.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We were beaten once and we went to the people.

Comment on this

You were beaten in 1924. Deputy Lemass beat the Fine Gael candidate by about two to one, butthere was no general election until 1927.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That was the time you said you would never go into Dáil Eireann. You said you would never swallow the Oath.

Comment on this

We did not invite the King to the Park, did we?

Comment on this

You gave us the External Relations Act.

Comment on this

The republicans of Bantry, the Bantry band. I can quite understand Deputy O'Higgins trying to blueshirt us out of office here, because the O'Higginses were always hungry. They want to grab office by fair means or foul, by honouring a foreign king or a native president— anything at all that would do them, in order to get in.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Has the Minister still his top hat?

Comment on this

He has the one your father wore at the Imperial Conference.

Comment on this

Is it the suggestion that he would not buy one of his own?

Comment on this

All that is worrying Deputy O'Higgins is that he cannot get three or four jobs for the O'Higginses.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister is disgusting as he usually is. He is sordid, disgusting.

Comment on this

If a man acts as a gentleman I am prepared to treat him as a gentleman, but if he tries to roughhouse it with me, I shall treat him as he deserves.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister would not know the meaning of the word "gentleman".

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins should cease interrupting.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Surely I am entitled to some protection from the Chair. Isthere a licence to cast reflections on me?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There certainly is not, but those reflections arose from the Deputy's interruptions.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

No matter how they arose.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins, any more than Deputy Rooney, is not prepared to take responsibility for the increase in sterling assets. They have been yapping around the country about the sterling assets we hold. They have been saying that the reason we held them was in order to give cheap money to John Bull. Yet, during their régime, as I have already pointed out, a much higher amount of the funds of the Central Bank and of Government funds were invested in sterling assets. Of course, they will not take responsibility for that, but they will go around the country yapping that we hold sterling assets although we have decreased the sterling holdings of departmental funds since we came back from £56.8 million to £41.55 million, while the Central Bank's holding of sterling assets has dropped from £80.6 million to £70.4 million. These Deputies still go around the country yapping that we keep these moneys there to provide cheap money for John Bull.

I have on many occasions before pointed out that if we want to have external reserves with which we can meet our debts, buy machinery and anything we want for capital development, we must have sterling assets of some kind unless, when we want machinery, we are prepared to go to Britain or America to borrow a few million pounds in order to buy that machinery. So long as this country as a national unit has external assets, somebody must hold them, whether it be the Central Bank, Government funds, the commercial banks or ordinary individuals. Our Central Bank has still £71,000,000 in external assets and Government funds have £41,000,000 of these assets. We could to-morrow realise that £111,000,000 of Central Bank and Government funds. We could, by law, force the Central Bank to get rid of their holding andtake it back here for investment in public work funds or development funds. What would be the first result of that? If we sold the £71,000,000 of external assets held by the Central Bank and took that amount back to the Bank of Ireland, the result would be to decrease the sterling holdings of the Central Bank but at the same time to swell the Bank of Ireland's external holdings by the same £71,000,000. All this talk that we should keep this money invested here simply means that Government funds and the Central Bank should realise their external assets to swell the sterling holdings of the commercial banks.

Deputy Mulcahy to-day also said that we were very anxious to grind down the people by taxation. We are not. Any more than other politicians in the world, we do not go seeking unpopularity or seeking to impose unpopular taxes on the people without having a basis of honesty which appeals to us. If we were dishonest enough to meet all Government expenditure by inflationary finance, there is no reason why we should go to the rounds of deceiving the people by switching external assets from Government funds to the commercial banks. We could take any of the direct inflationary measures to increase the amount of money in the country, get it into the Exchequer and dole it out to the people. The reason that we have held that it is wrong to decrease taxation, that it is wrong not to increase it in an inflationary period and restore a fairly normal balance between the production of goods and money, is because it is the correct financial procedure and it is honest treatment of our people.

The worst possible form of taxation is inflation. At the present time there is in circulation £70,000,000 or £80,000,000 in notes. We could double that to-morrow by the process of law. We could double it by getting inflationary loans from the banks or an inflationary advance from the Central Bank by one means or another. Supposing we doubled the circulation of money, doubled the level of deposits in the banks and instead of having £80,000,000 of Central Bank notes and another £300,000,000 or £400,000,000 on deposits, we raised the total to£1,000,000,000, it could be done quite simply, but is that going to make the people any better off? The only people whose position it would improve would be the owners of the lorries, who would be dragging the notes from one place to another. I say that inflation is the worst form of taxation because it takes as much off the £ of the poor man, by reducing its value, as it does off the £ of the rich man.

It decreases in value the poor man's £ just as much as it does the £ of the rich man. A man with £1,000 a year can afford to have a reduction of 5 per cent. or 10 per cent. in his standard of living if the value of money decreases owing to inflationary Government finance but the man with a few pounds a week cannot. The reason why normal Government with a sense of responsibility set their faces against an inordinate inflation of credit and money is because they know it is the worst possible form of taxation. I grant you it is a form of taxation which weak Governments, Governments comprised of groups that are not prepared to take responsibility for one another, Governments that are not prepared to accept responsibility to the people for unpopular acts, will adopt; it is the type of taxation to which they resort. They will not put so much on the beer or on cigarettes or income-tax, but they will decrease the value of money by inflation.

That would be one system of running the country's finances; instead of imposing taxation we could have a system of progressive inflation. We could dismiss all the Revenue Commissioners and everyone else engaged in the collection of taxes and substitute the other system of creating sufficient money to enable the Government to pay the Civil Service, the Army, the police and run the social services. That could be done simply by increasing the amount of money in circulation and progressively decreasing the value of each unit of money in circulation. But we do not think that is a good system. That system has been followed, not to the utmost extreme of abolishing all taxation but a good distance along that road, by Governments in France in recent years. The result is that France, potentially therichest country in Europe, with the richest land in Europe per head of the population, is in a bad way. Some of the smaller countries with not one-tenth of the resources France has but with Governments prepared, as we were, to grasp the nettle and honestly consider the right thing to do by the people and prepared to take the unpopularity attaching to that step, have done reasonably well in the post-war world.

I am glad to say that the measures which the Minister for Finance took two years ago to remove some of the inflation out of the situation here have been successful. Looking forward in June, 1951, and noticing that our balance of payment was running at a deficit of £60,000,000 a year, I did not think then that the Minister for Finance would be able to bring that balance down to reasonable proportions for at least two or three years. The extra taxation, however, that he had put on and some of the consumers money that he got in by way of loan reduced that inflationary circulation to reasonable proportions and during last year, as the Minister pointed out, the deficit in our balance of payments was down to about £9,000,000. I would not worry about £9,000,000 per year as a deficit, but I hold very strongly against deliberately reducing our external assets to the tune of £60,000,000 a year because the Government was afraid to take unpopular steps, the unpopular steps of applying the correct financial procedure.

We could not have lasted as a financially independent people if we had continued with a deficit of £60,000,000 per year for another few years. Away back in 1949, or thereabouts, we had only £222,000,000 net in external assets. Three or four years at the rate of £60,000,000 per year would have left us going on our knees to some foreign country for a loan in order to buy the machinery we required. There is no reason why the Irish people should have to do that if they live within their means. Our present means are not by any standard insignificant. We have the highest standard of food consumption in Europe outside a couple of the richest countries, such as Switzerlandand Sweden. Deputy Blowick likes to sympathise with the starvation of everybody else and he assures his constituents that they are starving, but in 1951 the average consumption of creamery butter per head per week was 8.9 oz. as against 8.63 oz. in 1950. The consumption of butter had gone up a little from 1950, the year of plenty when the inter-Party Government was in office spinning our money at the rate of £60,000,000 per annum. Beef consumption in 1952 stood at 10.74 oz. per head per week, as against 10.14 oz., so that even beef consumption in 1952 was better than it was in the year of plenty in 1950. Sugar went up from 18.55 oz. per head per week in 1950 to 21.16 oz. per week in 1951. Mutton went up from 3.09 oz. per head per week to 4.03 oz.

It would not be true to claim that our people have anything like the standard of living that we would like them to have but the only way in which we can permanently increase our standard of living as a nation is by increasing our standard of production. We could increase our standard of living temporarily for a year or two by running through all our reserves and all our savings like a farmer with £200 a year income and with £100 in the bank who decides that he will live at £300 per year for one year by spending his savings. Our country with a national income running about £400,000,000 a year and with foreign reserves of around £200,000,000 could live, say, at the rate of £600,000,000 a year for one year. We could increase our standard of living by 50 per cent. for one year but at the end of that year if we wanted to make progress and develop we would have to go looking to some other country for a loan; and that is a position into which we do not want to put our people.

Comment on this