We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 1–213 of 812. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I notice that there are now in the House five ex-Ministers of the previous Government—Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Dillon, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Everett and Deputy Keyes— and also a couple of ex-Parliamentary Secretaries. Last night I was trying to get some information from minor members of the Coalition Government as to why, between March, 1948, and March, 1951, they increased the sterling holdings of Government funds and the Central Bank by £43.8 million. I think that is a reasonable question to put to these gentlemen.

Between March, 1948, and March, 1951, the period of the Coalition in office, departmental funds invested in sterling securities went up by £7.1 million and the Central Bank investments in sterling securities went up by £36.7 million. There is now another ex-Minister of the former Government, Deputy MacBride, present in the House, so we have these six gentlemen here who were members of the Governmentunder the xgis of which the sterling assets in the hands of Government funds and the Central Bank increased by £43.8 million. I want to know why. Nobody is jumping to tell me why—none of these six gentlemen.

Comment on this

I thought we were accused of wasting them. Would you turn up your own speeches, where you said we had wasted them all?

Comment on this

I said the sterling holdings of the Government funds and the Central Bank went up.

Comment on this

You are calling yourself a liar.

Comment on this

Other sterling assets decreased but not the sterling holdings of the Government funds and of the Central Bank.

Comment on this

Which you accused us of liquidating. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins is not going to talk himself out of this. I am quite prepared to sit down for five or ten minutes while one of these gentlemen answers why they did this. After all, for many years they yapped round the country about the sterling holdings that Fianna Fáil kept in the hands of the Central Bank and in the Government funds.

Comment on this

They are still yapping.

Comment on this

They were not out of office a week when they started to yap again round the country, that the reason we were holding to these sterling assets in the Central Bank and the Government funds was that we wanted to give cheap money to Jhon Bull, that we wanted to keep our people idle here and force them over to England, that instead of using these sterling assets to build up our industries we gave them to John Bull, that we sent them off so as to give employment in England to Irishmen who could have been employed here. Is there anyone can deny that that was the line taken by those gentlemen? Everyone is aware of that and I am prepared to sit down here for five or ten minutes so as to get a reasonably straightanswer from any of those gentlemen on this simple question. After all, it is not a new question, it is not something that their minds were turned to for the first time; they have made it the basis of their policy. It has been half the speech of every Fine Gael Deputy and every Labour Deputy; it has been 95 per cent. of the speeches of Deputy MacBride in this House and outside it.

Comment on this

And of the unemployed yesterday outside the gate.

Comment on this

That is right. Of course it was. The unemployed believed the story.

Comment on this

They are well tutored.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy Cowan is proud of them.

Comment on this

Deputy Keyes is perfectly right; it was the speech of 95 per cent. of the people who are unemployed. Why? Because they have been taught by Deputy Dillon, Deputy MacBride, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Keys and Deputy Everett, all Ministers of the former Government, to believe that the reason they are unemployed is that we have these sterling assets.

Comment on this

They are unemployed because you are in office, and I will prove it when you sit down. That is certain.

Comment on this

That is not answering my question.

Comment on this

I will prove it.

Comment on this

We are here now, not at a street corner——

Comment on this

No, in Dáil Eireann.

Comment on this

——where you can tell the people round about that the reason there is unemployment——

Comment on this

Because you are in office.

Comment on this

——is that we have sterling assets in England——

Comment on this

——held by Government funds and the Central Bank. That is the reason you gave.

Comment on this

The reason is that Fianna Fáil is in office and their policy is to create unemployment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dillon should allow the Minister to proceed.

Comment on this

He asked us to intervene.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister did not ask a question.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon cannot talk himself out of this.

Comment on this

No; he is going to talk you into it, putting your neck into a halter—and the people will pull it, as soon as they get a chance.

Comment on this

That is what he is trying to get.

Comment on this

Let us do it. Let the people put the halter round our necks.

Comment on this

Give them the chance.

Comment on this

And let them do it, for a good reason.

Comment on this

They did it three times and you will not let them do it now.

Comment on this

The Opposition Deputies —former Ministers—are prepared to yap about everything under the sun but sterling assets. I want that made clear. They have been talking all round the country for the last two years about sterling assets and yet there is not one of them prepared to open his mouth here at the moment and answer me a simple question: "Why, when they were in office, did they increase those sterling assets directly under their control in Government funds and in the Central Bank by £43.8 million?" Is it not a queer world? We are not doing this in secret. Every gentleman on that Press Gallery——

Comment on this

Oh, that is where this is addressed to.

Comment on this

Every gentleman on that Press Gallery——

Comment on this

Where is the Irish Pressrepresentative? Was he warned to be present?

Comment on this

——for the past two years——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is entitled to be heard and if the ex-Ministers are asked a rhetorical question there is no need for them to intervene. Deputy Dillon, Deputy O'Higgins and other Deputies concerned and mentioned will have an opportunity of speaking and will get fair play, as the Minister is getting.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is there any precedent in our procedure for the Minister, speaking from the Front Bench of the Government, to address the Press Gallery and to notify the representative of his own newspaper that he is now called on to take a verbatim note?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister, as far as I know, did not address the Press Gallery.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon, he did.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No, the Minister did not address the Press Gallery. He is entitled to address the House and should be allowed to do so.

Comment on this

Twist and twist.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister did not address the Press Gallery. He is entitled to address the House and should be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

I cannot address Deputy Dillon directly.

Comment on this

The Minister should not address members of the Press Gallery directly.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will have to take very serious notice of interruptions. The Minister is entitledto proceed and should be allowed to do so without interruption.

Comment on this

And I respectfully submit on a point of order not to address the Press Gallery.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister did not address the Press Gallery. He said: "every member of the Press Gallery". That was not an address to the Press Gallery.

Comment on this

Every member of that Press Gallery who has had the misfortune to be sent down the country after Deputy Dillon, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Everett, Deputy Keyes and Deputy MacBride in the past couple of years has had to take notes of the speeches made by these gentlemen. Their notes consisted largely of speeches by these gentlemen to the effect that Fianna Fáil wanted to ruin this country——

Comment on this

Hear! hear!

Comment on this

——that Fianna Fáil were keeping the sterling assets in Britain——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The "standing army".

Comment on this

——in order to build up British economy. The young gentleman who was sent here the other day by East Cork was so much impressed by these speeches as to the reason why we were keeping these sterling assets in Britain that he devoted half of his ten-minute speech to the subject of sterling assets and said that the reason Fianna Fáil were preaching that we should build up our sterling assets in Britain was to enable John Bull to oppress the negroes in Africa. That, if you do not mind, is alleged to be the reason why we kept these sterling assets in Britain. Was that the reason why the gentlemen opposite, when they were in Government, voted for increasing them by £43.8 million? Was it to oppress the negroes in Africa? Was it to build up British economy? Was it to build factories to employ Irishmen who were forced out of their own country? If not, what was the reason? I am prepared to sit downhere for five, ten or 15 minutes to listen to an answer to that exact question. Why did they build up our external assets by £43.8 million in the hands of the Government funds and the Central Bank during the three years they were in office?

Comment on this

Sit down and you will be answered quick enough.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Sit down——

Comment on this

They are all as meek and as mute as mice.

Comment on this

Sit down and shut up and you will be answered in a minute.

Comment on this

Not sit down. I will give way. I am prepared to give way.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister says that unless somebody answers him he will assume his argument to be a fact. To that, I wish to say to him that if he will sit down and stop talking we will wipe the floor with him—but we will not intervene in the course of his observations.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the House will agree that it would be better if the debate were conducted in the ordinary way of a speech by a Deputy or Minister rather than by question and answer.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I was prepared, with the Ceann Comhairle's permission, to give way for five, ten or 15 minutes in order that I should be told why these sterling assets in the hands of the Central Bank and Government funds increased by £43.8 million during the Coalition Government's term of office —and nobody jumped up. Deputy MacBride looked down. He looked coy. He looked shy. Deputy Dillon started to raise points of order.

Comment on this

I was looking up a few quotations from speeches by the Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is quite prepared to talk down the country where he cannot be answered, but he is afraid to take advantage of my offer to give way for five minutes.

Comment on this

Sit down and stop talking and I will answer you. The Taoiseach can follow me.

Comment on this

The Minister loves this fooling.

Comment on this

You can talk about sterling assets down the country but here you raise points of order when sterling assets are mentioned.

Comment on this

Clatter away now. When you are finished you will be answered.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking to the Vote on Account. One would not know it.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon cannot get out of it as easily as all that. Lest any of the people behind them might think that I am taking them unawares by asking this question, I want to point out that, a few months after the Coalition Government came into office, I started asking questions about the sterling assets for the benefit of all the members of the House as well as for my own benefit. As reported in columns 2452 and 2453 of Volume 111 of the Official Report, I asked the then Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, if he would state the total amount of British securities held by all the funds controlled by his Department on (a) the 18th February, 1948; and (b) the 18th June, 1948. The Coalition Government assumed office on the 18th February, 1948. Deputy McGilligan was the Minister for Finance in that Government and, before he assumed office in that Government, he used to talk about sterling assets as "waste paper." On numerous occasions he spoke in this House and elsewhere about the "waste paper" in which Fianna Fáil were investing the Irish people's savings. Deputy McGilligan's reply to that question which I asked him was as follows:—

"The figures requested are (a) £45,860,916; (b) £49,614,416."

The House will note that in the first four months of Coalition Government the figure rose from £45,860,916 to £49,614,416. I then put the followingsupplementary question to Deputy McGilligan:—

"Has the Minister, therefore, directed that £4,000,000 more should be invested in what he used to describe as waste paper?"

Deputy McGilligan corrected me and said:—

"£3,750,000. I cannot prevent what is happening."

Then I asked:—

"And that was done at the instance of the Minister for External Affairs?"

The then Minister for External Affairs was Deputy MacBride. Deputy McGilligan replied:—

"We have to follow what is, possibly, a bad precedent, but once lines have been laid it is not possible to go on to new lines in four months."

Deputy McGilligan invested another £3,750,000 in what he used to call "waste paper" and he said that it was not possible to go on to new lines in four months. He carried out an operation which Deputy MacBride and even he himself often referred to as "helping John Bull to build up his army at the expense of Irish economy." But Deputy McGilligan could not change it in four months.

Comment on this

You did not change it in 16 years.

Comment on this

I asked the question within four months of their taking office. What happened afterwards? In March, 1948, the sterling assets in the departmental funds were a mere £49.7 million. In 1949, at the end of the first year of Coalition Government, the assets had increased by nearly £4,000,000 to £53.5 million. In the first four months of Coalition Government the assets had increased by £3,750,000. The Minister could not change it in four months and he did not change it in one year because, in the remaining eight months of that first year, he added additional funds to those which he invested in Britain in the first fourmonths of the Coalition Government. He said he could not do it in four months. What did he do the second year, 1950? By March, 1950, it had gone up again by almost another £3,000,000 to £56.1 million. He could not do it in four months: he did not do it in one year; and he did not do it in two years. What happened in the third year? It went up again to £56.8 million. In fact, in Government funds, he had invested in three years an additional £7.1 million of sterling assets which he used to call waste paper.

What happened in the Central Bank? In March, 1948, when we went out of office, the external holdings of the Central Bank stood at a sum of £43.9 million. I do not know what they were four months after, but, 12 months after these miracle workers took over the reins of Government, the £43.9 million had risen to £49.1 million.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for the Minister, even though he may be a shadow Taoiseach, to repeat exactly what he said here last night for the second or third time?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Repetition is not in order. If the Minister did, he should not do it now.

Comment on this

Word for word and figure for figure.

Comment on this

I did not mention the parliamentary question last night, nor did I give any details about it. I gave no block total. I know that Deputy Davin does not like to hear this, but he supported Deputy McGilligan in investing Irish funds in —as they called it—British waste paper, and he is going yapping around the country with the rest of them at present saying that the reason we keep them there is to give John Bull cheap money with which to build up his economy and to oppress the negroes.

Comment on this

You are the biggest yapper I ever heard.

Comment on this

In March, 1949—to return to the point which Deputy Davin tried to put me off—the external holdings of the Central Bank stood at £49.1 million. By March, 1950, theyhad gone up to £68.7 million and, by 1951, they had gone up to £80.6 million.

Comment on this

And they were said to have been all frittered away.

Comment on this

Would the Minister give us the figures for 1953?

Comment on this

That is an interesting question. I want to ask Deputy MacBride, who is awfully coy to-day— I cannot get a word out of him——

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell me why his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, said it was high treason to suggest that we should repatriate external assets?

Comment on this

He is as mute as a mouse over there.

Comment on this

Would you answer the question he asked?

Comment on this

I have the floor and I am asking a question. I want to repeat that there are six members of the Coalition Government here——

Comment on this

Answer Deputy MacBride's question.

Comment on this

——who have been going around the country talking about——

Comment on this

Answer Deputy MacBride's question.

Comment on this

You invited him.

Comment on this

You asked for it. Now answer him.

Comment on this

They are going all around the country deafening the people——

Comment on this

You asked for the question. Answer it.

Comment on this

——deafening the people of this country, as I say——

Comment on this

You asked for the question. Answer it now. Do not wriggle.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not——

Comment on this

Do not wriggle—answer Deputy MacBride's question.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has very little sympathy with interruptions and very little sympathy with members of the House who seek interruptions. I ask both sides of the House to conduct the debate in the ordinary way, by speech and not interruption.

Comment on this

And not to behave like a clown.

Comment on this

There are six members of the Coalition Government in this House who have been going around the country——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order, that is at least the third time the Minister has repeated that sentence.

Comment on this

He wants it to sink into your thick skull.

Comment on this

I know that Deputies on the opposite benches do not like to be put even a rhetorical question as to why they are so voluble down the country about external assets and will not allow them to be mentioned here.

Comment on this

On a point of order. You have requested, Sir, that the practice of putting rhetorical questions be suspended in the cause of order. I do not think I trespass too far on your indulgence if I say that, so often as this man asks an idiotic rhetorical question, I shall answer it, for he seeks to deceive the people into the belief that silence——

Comment on this

This is a speech.

Comment on this

You asked for silence, Sir, and we gladly bowed to your ruling, but that is not to be used by this man as a device for the purpose of misleading our people. I will nail his ear to the post every time he puts such a question.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has asked that Deputies will conduct the proceedings in the ordinary way by means of speech. The Chair does not understand that rhetorical questions are used in order to elicit replies—they are used for effect, so far as the Chair understands—and there is, therefore,no reason why rhetorical questions should be answered.

Comment on this

The Minister, in my submission, is deliberately seeking to deceive the House by saying——

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is the Chair's function to decide whether it is or not.

Comment on this

If the Minister asks a rhetorical question, I quite submit to your ruling that no reply is required or permissible, but if, having secured that ruling from you, Sir, the Minister then goes on to say: "I am quite prepared to sit down now and give way if anyone will answer me," that is an attempt to use your ruling for the purpose of misleading the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am asking that that system should be abandoned.

Comment on this

I do not like to be raising unnecessary points of order——

Comment on this

Now the peacemaker has intervened.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister says he is raising a point of order and he is entitled to do so.

Comment on this

The Standing Orders provide that members of the House will be referred to by the term "Deputy" or "Minister," as the case may be. Is it in order, therefore, to refer to the Minister as "this man"?

Comment on this

If that affronts the Minister, I withdraw it immediately and substitute "the Minister for External Affairs."

Comment on this

And apologises to men for the mistake.

Comment on this

It is the first time I have apologised to anybody for calling him a man.

Comment on this

Even that will not draw me on to a line which could quiteeasily be taken in regard to Deputy Dillon. I am on one single question here to-day and I want it to be noted that the former Ministers made no effort—they wanted to run away, to raise points of order, to raise questions as to who was a man and who was not and who fought for the Republic and who did not——

Comment on this

It was the Minister for Finance raised the point as to who was a man.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has proceeded on that line for quite a long time. I suggest that he should pass from that and deal with the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

He does not know how.

Comment on this

This arose out of the question of the external assets and out of the fact that the newest Deputy in this House thought that he must give us a lecture—it was a very nice lecture, indeed—as to how we should be brief in speaking and that we should only speak about important issues. As a new Deputy who came into the House to represent the people and deal with the great issues in which they took an interest, he proceeded to speak about sterling assets throughout most of his speech. He accused the Government of wanting to build up our external assets in order to help John Bull oppress the negroes in Africa. Deputy Keyes and Deputy Everett asked me a very pertinent question. It was a very civil and nice question and I am prepared to give a very civil and nice answer.

Comment on this

You would not give the answer to Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

That will not draw me away from answering Deputy Everett in a very nice and civil way.

Comment on this

He asked how did these sterling assets fare under Fianna Fáil seeing that they were increased by £43.8 million under the Fine Gael Coalition. The fact of the matter is that since March, 1951, the sterlingholdings of the Government funds fell by £15.25 million and the sterling holdings of the Central Bank fell by £9.2 million. Therefore, there was a total reduction in the sterling assets of these two funds of £24.45 million.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There was an increase of £6,000,000 last year. Is not that right?

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy Everett's question, the sterling assets, under Fianna Fáil, fell by practically £24,500,000 instead of increasing by £43.8 million as they did under the Government which he kept in office

Comment on this

The sterling assets are always falling under you.

Comment on this

There is the reply and there is no answer.

Comment on this

Do you remember the speech about the rake's progress?

Comment on this

There is the rake's progress for you. For three years the gentlemen opposite were so much against holding sterling assets in the Government funds that they called them waste paper.

Comment on this

Do you remember the speech that accused us of wasting external assets?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins is beginning to pipe up again. He would not accept my invitation to interrupt my speech when I asked a very simple question about which he appears to know everything when he goes down the country.

Comment on this

I hope the Ceann Comhairle is taking note of this.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy O'Higgins will take an opportunity in his speech of explaining the matter in this House.

Comment on this

You may be sure I will—as soon as the clowning is over.

Comment on this

Might I direct attention to the Chair's ruling that when a Deputy purports to ask a rhetorical question a rhetorical reply is evoked? The Minister has returned to thatthesis in so far as he asked a rhetorical question and was not interrupted by an answer. I say that is an abuse of order. There is a ruling to stop rhetorical questions because they evoke a rhetorical reply. The Chair's ruling is being used by the Minister to mislead the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair never attempted to direct a Deputy's method of speaking or a Deputy's method of addressing the House. I simply indicated that rhetorical questions do not require replies and that they were merely used for the sake of effect. I ask Deputies to conduct the proceedings in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that the object of these long explanations on points of order by Deputy Dillon is that he does not like the subject under discussion. It is the last thing they want to talk about.

Comment on this

Do you hear that?

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick said that this was the first time ever for a second Vote on Account to be taken. There was a second Vote on Account in the year 1928-29.

Comment on this

That is a long time ago.

Comment on this

But it was once before. Deputy Blowick said there was never a second Vote on Account. There was also a second Vote on Account in 1932-33 and 1943-44 so that instead of there never being a second Vote on Account taken it was taken in this House on three occasions before. What is the reason for taking it this time? Simply because the Opposition Deputies think that by turning this House into a bear garden——

Comment on this

What are you doing?

Comment on this

Will you listen to him?

Comment on this

——they can make ordinary democratic Government in this House impossible. They will not be able to do that.

Comment on this

You want to be able to pay a quarter of a million pounds for Tulyar.

Comment on this

As long as we have the——

Comment on this

The vote of Deputy Cowan behind you.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon was very glad to have Deputy Cowan behind him for three years. As long as we have the confidence of this House we are constitutionally entitled to carry on the Government.

Comment on this

To hang on desperately by your eyebrows.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy say?

Comment on this

To hang on desperately by your eyebrows. That is what I said.

Comment on this

To hang on by Deputy Sheldon's eyebrows.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins, Junior, made exactly the same proposition yesterday, that we were trying to hang on desperately by our eyebrows.

Comment on this

Or by Deputy Sheldon's eyebrows.

Comment on this

By our eyebrows.

Comment on this

But you would not have enough eyebrows to hang on to.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy O'Higgins said, and Deputy Dillon now confirms that we should have got out when we were defeated at a by-election. That was their thesis. We should have got out when we were defeated in the first by-election. During the Cumann na nGaedheal régime the Government were defeated in a by-election but they hung on by their eyebrows as long as they could.

Comment on this

And what eyebrows!

Comment on this

And if they had not eyebrows they would have tried to hangon by any other means that they could hang by. In 1924 there was a by-election in which the Cumann na nGaedheal people were defeated by Deputy Lemass by about two to one, but they hung on until 1927.

Comment on this

Did you come in and raise a point of order?

Comment on this

In 1928 or 1929 they were defeated in Longford-Westmeath. Did they declare a general election? No, they hung on by their eyebrows. They had a by-election in 1931 in North Kildare. They were defeated. Did they declare a general election? No, they hung on by their eyebrows.

Comment on this

By their own eyebrows there is a distinction.

Comment on this

No, they borrowed them.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party had in this House somewhere between 40 and 50 seats.

Comment on this

And the Fianna Fáil Party was not there at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a mistake and he cannot cover it up by trying to talk more as he usually does. When he makes a mistake he is so voluble he tries to cover it up by continuing to talk and makes about ten more mistakes that he gets away with. The Deputy's point was that it was by Fine Gael's own eyebrows they hung on. In 1924 they hung on by their eyebrows. In 1928 they hung on and in 1929 and in 1931.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

And this is the 1953 Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is exactly what I was going to point out. These gymnastic displays with eyebrows may be very interesting but at the moment I am interested only in the Vote on Account and I suggest it is that which should be considered, and not eyebrows.

Comment on this

This Vote on Account was caused largely by the obstructionist tactics of Fine Gael and it isnecessary to do the public work so that there will not be chaos. This Vote on Account had to be taken so that the various Government services may carry on.

In the Coalition's time, they were defeated at a by-election in East Donegal in 1949, and they hung on until 1951—by their eyebrows.

Comment on this

Oh, get away from eyebrows.

Comment on this

And they were prepared to hang on by their eyebrows.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Might I ask are we discussing eyebrows or the Vote on Account?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have asked the Minister to discuss the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon started this discussion on eyebrows. I know that the Deputy from Mayo——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister should not follow a bad lead; he should discuss the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I just wanted to mark that through me and through the Chair the Deputy from Mayo has rebuked Deputy Dillon for talking about eyebrows.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Keep the gymnastic display on eyebrows for another time.

Comment on this

Fine Gael did not hang on by their own eyebrows. We have 68 Deputies in this House but after their defeat in the East Donegal election they had only 40 and they are the people who hung on by any support they could get.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister should return to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Return? He has not dealt with it yet.

Comment on this

As those were the only two points I proposed to deal with I will conclude by thanking the Opposition for their patient hearing.

Comment on this

I have listened over a long period of years to many silly, stupid and provocative speeches—from the Minister for External Affairs in particular.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very easily provoked.

Comment on this

I cannot understand why a Minister who hopes to be the next Taoiseach if Fianna Fáil survive much longer should engage in the obstructionist tactics that are alleged against his political opponents. I never heard more misrepresentations in a speech from any Minister of any Government since I came into this House, but I propose to deal only with one of the many misrepresentations that were made here last night in particular and again to-day.

Last night he said and he knew he was stating what was untrue——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Well, now, that must not be said. If a person knows what he is saying is untrue it is a lie and the Deputy is accusing the Minister of telling a lie.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is a lie, but he must not say it in this House?

Comment on this

I did not say it was a lie.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No, but the Deputy said the Minister knew what he said was untrue. The Deputy must withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

Well, in deference to your wishes. I believe the Minister has not yet——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not repeat it.

Comment on this

——lost his memory.

Comment on this

He did not repeat it. He said that the Minister had not lost his memory yet.

Comment on this

The Minister in a speech last night which he more or less repeated to-day—although he did not repeat the statements he made last night—said among a number of things that the only thing the Labour Partyhad done while in the Coalition Government was to increase the price of the National Health Insurance stamp without increasing the benefit. I believe the Minister is young, active and intelligent enough to know that that statement was not in accordance with the facts. The Minister, when he was a Deputy sitting on this side of the House in March, 1951, voted against the social security scheme which passed its Second Reading in spite of his vote and in spite of the vote of his colleagues on the 2nd March, 1951.

Now, that social security scheme which passed its Second Reading in this House by a majority made certain provisions, and on the evening of the 2nd March, after voting against the second reading of that Bill, Deputy Aiken with other colleagues of his went to 13 Lower Mount Street and there gave careful consideration to the contents of the Social Security Bill which had received its Second Reading by a majority on that date. On the following day, Fianna Fáil issued to the Press of this country an official statement from their office at 13 Lower Mount Street giving particulars on the one hand of the proposals contained in the Norton social security scheme and on the other hand of the proposals which Fianna Fáil said they would put into operation if and whenever they again became the Government, or secured a majority in order to enable them to govern in this House and in the country. I do not want to go into details. I do not want to read out what is contained in the daily Press of the 3rd March giving on the one hand the proposals contained in the Norton social security scheme and on the other hand what Fianna Fáil proposed to do if they came back to office. But in any case at the end of the Fianna Fáil statement it says the cost of the proposals—on the one hand they gave their estimate of the cost of the proposals contained in the social security scheme introduced by Deputy Norton and they gave on the other hand the estimated cost of their own proposals. Their scheme included a number of proposals and as a footnote they said there would be no increase in the contributions to provide what they promisedwould be better benefits than those contained in the Norton social security scheme. They also said they would give an increase of £4,600,000 in the benefits and that figure was to be raised by increased taxation. The Minister said last night and yesterday —in all seriousness I suppose and believing it to be true—that the Labour Party while in the Coalition Government—I want to give it exactly—"The only thing the Labour Party had done while in the Coalition Government was to increase the price of the National Health Insurance stamp without increasing benefits". Did the Minister not know that he had voted against the Norton Social Security Bill in this House on 2nd March, 1951? They promised they would provide better benefits at that particular time than what were contained in the Norton social security scheme without any increase in contributions.

What have they done? They came along and cut the death benefits out of the Norton Bill. They modified the maternity benefits and they increased the contributions by 5d. in the case of men and 2d. in the case of women. They made other alterations which were a definite reduction on the benefits provided in the Norton social security scheme. If the Minister expects to be treated seriously in this House he should not make statements which are incorrect.

Comment on this

Was that Bill passed?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

You did everything you could by your vote on that particular occasion to prevent that social security scheme from coming into operation. I am dealing with this matter only for the purpose of correcting what was a deliberate misrepresentation of the position and of the attitude of the Labour Party.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These terms are creeping into the debate. "Deliberate misrepresentation" suggests that the person against whom the accusation is made knows that it is a misrepresentation. The Deputy must withdraw that remark. "Deliberatemisrepresentation" means that a person makes it with the consent of his will and that therefore it is a lie. The Deputy must withdraw that.

Comment on this

In deference to your wishes, I withdraw, but I cannot conscientiously, from my knowledge of the Minister for External Affairs—his youth, his energy and his readiness to use quotations which suit his case— believe that he has lost his memory to the extent that he could make a misstatement of that kind on serious matters of public policy without knowing that they were misstatements.

Comment on this

These proposals never came into operation. It was a string by which you were led by the nose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Davin is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The hundreds of unemployed who congregated outside the gates of Leinster House yesterday and the tens of thousands of their brothers and sisters without work in other parts of the country have no use for the nice points which the Minister tried to make in the discussion to-day. Whether we sit on this side or on the other side of the House we ought to try to approach the consideration of the serious crisis which exists in the country from a realistic point of view. I heard a Deputy on my left say last night that the real position confronting the Taoiseach and his colleagues, so far as the people of the country are concerned, is that the Government must either change their financial and economic policy or get out and make room for people who will do so. That is a fair representation of the viewpoint of the people of the country as freely expressed in the recent byelections. I am not one of those Deputies who are extremely anxious for another early general election. I have no hesitation in confessing that and I do not care whether it is the Government of to-day or the Government of to-morrow which solves these serious and pressing problems so long as we find a solution for them. I have fought 14 general elections and one by-election in my own constituency and,both from a physical and financial point of view, I would be fit only for a lunatic asylum if I were looking for another election, but there is every justification for the demand for an immediate change of policy or the introduction of some new policy which will attempt to solve the serious problems confronting the country. If the Government are not in a position to find an earnest solution for these pressing problems, they should in all honesty make room for others who are willing and capable of doing so.

This Vote on Account is bluntly a request to provide the Government with further huge sums of money in order to enable them to implement the financial policy enshrined in the Budget of 1952. That was one of the most disastrous Budgets, in my honest opinion, ever presented to this House. Those who said that not alone in this House but in O'Connell Street and at other meetings down the country at the time the Budget was introduced have lived long enough to realise that their interpretation of the Budget at that time has unfortunately turned out to be only too true. One of the most disastrous aspects of that financial policy for which this money is now required was the decision of the Minister for Finance to increase interest charges on loans, especially public loans. Do we even yet know the effect which that disastrous decision has had and is having on every section of the community, not alone on those who were thrown out of work as a direct result and even in some cases as an indirect result of that decision, but also on those who are tenants of houses built by local authorities all over the State? In my constituency there have been a number of public protests on recent occasions by the tenants of fairly good houses built there by local authorities—protests against the prohibitive rents that are being charged by the local authorities to tenants who are not in a position to pay such rents and who should not be called upon to pay one-third, or in some cases up to 40 per cent., of their weekly earnings by way of rent. Will the Minister for Finance tell us the effect of the increase in interest charges upon rent alone apartaltogether from its disastrous effect on the cost of building houses? Does he not admit—there is no use in denying this further—that this increase in interest charges has practically held up the whole building industry, particularly that side of the building industry where houses were being built for people who were purchasing them on the hire purchase system? The increase in interest charges has practically paralysed the whole building industry. If the Minister is not satisfied on that point he should read the weekly list of building contractors advertised in Stubb's Gazette.

Apart from their effect on the building industry and the unemployment caused, the increased interest charges have had many other disastrous effects that are not yet fully appreciated even by the Taoiseach. I heard the Taoiseach state here recently in the debate on the vote of confidence that he had not heard very much, if anything at all— I cannot quote his exact words and I do not want to be unfair to him—about the restriction of credit. The Taoiseach must be living very far away from some of his constituents, if he has heard nothing in his own constituency, apart from the rest of the country, about the restriction of credit.

Does the Minister for Finance admit there is restriction of credit and, if he does, does he not know the effect of that restriction upon every aspect of business and of private enterprise through which agency a considerable amount of employment is provided as well as through the capital works carried out through the medium of loans provided by the Government? I would not venture to say what percentage, but I would say a very high percentage of the unemployment in this country since the Budget of 1952 has been brought about as a result of the restriction of credit.

As one of the oldest members of this House I want to know if this restriction of credit is taking place without the knowledge of the Government? If it is, then the Government does not know what is taking place in the country. Has the Government any power to deal with the banks and to deal with thisrestriction of credit—a restriction that is taking place to my own knowledge of documents that I have seen in the possession of business people? I am perfectly satisfied that this restriction of credit is operating to the disadvantage of my own constituents and to the disadvantage of genuine business people who want to carry on their business on proper lines and continue to provide employment for the normal number of people.

Will the Minister for Finance answer that question when he is replying to this discussion? Has this Government led by the Taoiseach, Deputy Eamon de Valera, any power over the private banking institutions of this country? Who has the first and last word in fixing the rates of interest? I want to find that out myself for myself and for the people whom I represent. I think it is about time the Minister for Finance, or the Taoiseach, told the House and the country whether or not it is the Government that has the last word in fixing interest charges on loans for private citizens or interest charges on loans for public authorities and for the Government in so far as the Government provides money for local authorities?

Comment on this

They should have the last word but they have not.

Comment on this

I am perfectly satisfied, as one of the oldest Deputies here, that we have all the freedom we want in this part of the country so far as our political economy is concerned. How can any Government led by the present Taoiseach carry out their financial and economic policy if they have not got the sympathy and support of the people who provide the money to enable them to do so? I have suspected for many years past that the private banking institutions here are not giving the help they should be giving to the Government. They did not give the help they should have given to past Governments in order to enable them to carry out their policy. If that is so, what harm is there in the Minister for Finance, or the Taoiseach, telling the country that they have discovered that to be the position and that they now requirewhatever further powers they consider necessary in order to get for the Government of the day whatever money is required to enable the Government to carry out its financial and economic policy?

We are wasting our time here if there is some hidden hand behind the scenes which does not provide the money necessary to enable the Government to carry out its declared policy, the policy upon which it was elected by the people. I want the Minister for Finance to answer a definite and specific question. If he is afraid to give the answer, perhaps the Taoiseach will give it. What is the Government's fundamental financial policy? Does the Government believe that the first charge on production should be a decent livelihood for the producer or, on the other hand, does the Government admit that the first charge on production should be 5 per cent. or 6 per cent. for the moneylender? I want an answer to that question. There is no use in the Taoiseach getting up, as he did here, and delivering in the most polite language possible a homely little lecture to the Labour Party on their policy implying that he was not such an extreme socialist as were the members of the Labour Party.

The question I ask is a fundamental one and, if I have an answer to that question, I shall know then where I stand in so far as the Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil are concerned or in so far as any other Party is concerned. If the first charge on production in this Christian State is supposed to be 5 per cent., 6 per cent. or any higher percentage for the moneylenders then I am much further removed from the Taoiseach than he thinks some of us are, if that is his outlook. The position must be settled once and for all and as soon as the Minister, or the Taoiseach, makes the position clear then we will know where we stand in relation to the Government that is now operating and we will know where we stand in relation to every other Party in this House if they declare in equally plain language their position on the same fundamental question.

I gathered from the Taoiseach in his speech on the motion of "No Confidence"that there is no shortage of money. Will he or his Minister for Finance confirm that? If that is so, will they explain why it is that so many schemes of such a useful nature and with such a high labour content are now lying idle in the pigeon-holes of the Department of Local Government while tens of thousands of able-bodied men are waiting for the work that could be provided if the money was allocated for these schemes?

Comment on this