We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 214–416 of 812. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Would the Deputy give us some particulars of these schemes?

Comment on this

I will do so with great pleasure. Will the Minister for Finance inquire from his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, what is the cost—I know it runs into some millions—of the schemes that are now lying in the pigeon-holes in the Department of Local Government, schemes approved under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, 1949?

Comment on this

Running into millions?

Comment on this

Will he say whether it is his deliberate desire or intention to scrap that Act or, as indicated by the reduction in grants, will he say whether it is their intention to go ahead and operate that Act in the way in which it can be operated, thereby providing employment for additional tens of thousands of able-bodied men in every constituency throughout the country?

Comment on this

The Deputy is avoiding my question: give me particulars of these schemes.

Comment on this

I assure the Government and the Minister for Finance, in particular, that three years ago in the Counties of Laois and Offaly 400 more men were employed by the local authority than are employed there to-day.

If the money was provided for the schemes that are lying idle in the Department of Local Government, and approved by the officials of that Department, the same 400 men who are now idle in the Counties of Laoisand Offaly could be put back into employment of a very useful nature.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell the House why it was that the inter-Party Government cut very drastically the allocations for public works and local authority schemes?

Comment on this

I want to tell the Minister for Finance that every grant and every scheme that was sent up by the county manager for the Counties of Laois and Offaly, and approved by the engineers of the Local Government Department, was not alone sanctioned by the Department but the necessary money was allocated during the lifetime of the inter-Party Government. If the Minister has any doubt as to the accuracy of that statement, let him go and make inquiries direct from the Secretary of the Department of Local Government or the county manager of the Counties of Laois and Offaly. Every penny was allocated.

I was on several deputations with the Minister's own colleagues when delay was being complained of; that cause of complaint was removed and the money was allocated. I can assure the Minister that there was no cause for any complaint by any of the Deputies representing Laois-Offaly while the inter-Party Government was in office. Let us be realistic in relation to the matter. Has any advice been tendered to the present Government that the Local Authorities (Works) Act is an Act that should be either gradually scrapped or repealed? Is it the intention of the Taoiseach and his colleagues in Government to continue to operate the schemes under that Act to the benefit not alone of those who are provided with employment under the Act but also to the benefit of the farmer whose lands are drained? Will any Deputy even now —my half-brother, Deputy Davern, can do it if he likes but he will take a considerable risk in doing so—stand up and say: "I stand for the repeal or scrapping of the Local Authorities (Works) Act, 1949"?

Comment on this

I did not stand for thereduction of the road grant by 50 per cent. as Deputy Davin did.

Comment on this

I challenge Deputy Davern to stand up here—I know he is a fearless Deputy—and say whether he is prepared to stand over the scrapping of that Act. He is not going to take that risk because he knows perfectly well that if he went back to South Tipperary and advocated the repeal or the scrapping of the 1949 Act it would have serious consequences for him.

Comment on this

Why did you reduce the road grant?

Comment on this

If no one is prepared to stand for the repeal or gradual elimination of that Act, why not make use of it? It is an Act that has provided useful employment for tens of thousands of people in every county and constituency in this country. What I am suggesting to the Government, I would be prepared to suggest in equally forcible language to any Taoiseach or Government that was sitting on the benches opposite and that had the responsibility of finding a solution for the unemployment problem. I am assured that, so far as the operation of that Act was applied in the two counties in my constituency, the schemes carried out there under it had a labour content of 85 per cent. That is very high labour content. That is a kind of work and activity that you cannot describe as relief schemes. It is the kind of work that should be carried out by a Government that pretends it is anxious to find even a temporary solution for a problem that we are all so interested in.

Comment on this

Why did you reduce the Estimate that was brought in for that Act in 1951?

Comment on this

I was a member of the House when other Deputies advocated, and I agreed with them, the carrying out of work that has a high labour content, work such as the removal of dangerous corners on main, trunk and byroads all over the country. There were many Deputies who supported that proposal at the time and, as I say, I agreed with them. That schemewas put up by officials of the Government at that particular period as being a good useful one. I do not know why it is still lying in the pigeon-holes of the Department. If money is available for the carrying out of useful work of that kind why is the work not started? Of course, if the money is not available I am simply wasting the time of the House, that is if the Minister for Finance will get up and say that there is no money for that kind of work. If he says that I will sit down and say no more, but let him shoulder the responsibility for not being able to provide the money. I am paying him the tribute of thinking that the money is available, and therefore I am making suggestions as to some of the ways and means by which it should and could be used with advantage not only for those who are looking for work but with advantage to the people of the country generally.

The members of this House know quite well that works, such as those carried out under the Works Act, bring a considerable acreage of land into production. That has been the effect of the operation of that Act in parts of the country that I am fairly well acquainted with. I hope that the Minister for Finance will tell the House, when replying, whether it is the purpose and intention of the Government to use the machinery of that Act to implement schemes that are lying probably in hundreds and maybe in thousands in pigeon-holes in the Department of Local Government. I am carrying out the wishes of the two county councils in my constituency when I urge the Taoiseach and his colleagues in the Government to investigate the possibility of making a better use of the machinery of that Act for the purpose of providing additional employment in the rural areas.

I do not want to repeat what has been much better said by a number of previous speakers. All of us, of course, are interested in the provision of more houses. More houses are needed not only by the people in the City of Dublin but by those in the rural areas. On this matter, I cannot speak with the same authority as those Deputies who are members of local authorities, but Iknow it is a fact that a considerable delay takes place between the framing of a housing scheme by a local authority and the starting of work on the building of the houses under the contract system. I have always urged—I do not say that in every case it should be done—that it is a very good thing, from the point of view of creating competition and keeping costs down, to erect houses under the direct labour system wherever, in the opinion of the authorities, the price under the contract system is regarded as excessive. I am sorry to say that the direct labour system has not been adopted to the extent that I would like to see in the two counties in my constituency.

I am prepared to give particulars, if anybody challenges me, with regard to house building schemes carried out under the direct labour system. In the constituency of Laois and Offaly houses that were built under the direct labour system were found to be better and cheaper houses than those built under the contract system. I am assured that, under the contract system in my constituency, building contractors have made profits of between £300 and £400 on houses they built for the local authorities. I suggest that a considerable portion of that profit could be saved for the taxpayers, the ratepayers and the tenants, and that the work done would be equally as good if the houses were built under the direct labour system.

I had sufficient influence about 20 years ago with other people, of course—I am not claiming the whole credit for myself—to get the Local Government Department to sanction as an experiment the carrying out of the housing scheme in a particular town in my constituency under the direct labour system. I asked them to build half the houses under the direct labour system and the other half, in another part of the town, under the contract system. If anybody is anxious to get the facts and the full particulars in regard to these schemes I will give them. The experiment proved this, that the houses built under the direct labour system were built at a much lower cost, butthe main point is that for the past 20 years there has been practically no charge on the local rates for the maintenance of the houses built under the direct labour system while the cost of maintenance of the houses built under the contract system has been excessive.

When you build houses under the direct labour system you eliminate the profit of the middle-man or the building contractor. I am not advocating, and I hope that nobody will think that I am, the elimination entirely of the building contractor. He is a useful citizen of the State and does very useful work; but I am not prepared, as a Deputy, to tolerate, and if I were a member of a local authority I would certainly do all I could to prevent it, a building contractor getting a job where he was getting a profit of £300 or £400 on a house. I would take the risk, and I think there would be very little risk in it, of having the houses built by direct labour. I suggest that the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach in particular should study the results of house building carried out in this State under different Governments over the last ten, 15 or 20 years under the direct labour system and under the contract system.

I heard Deputy Crotty who, I suppose in the ordinary way, would be regarded as a capitalist as compared to me at any rate, say in this House that the best houses built in Kilkenny by the local authority were those which had been built under the direct labour system. Does any Deputy think that Deputy Crotty, or anyone associated with the business and other circles in which he moves, would advocate the direct labour system were it not for the fact that he was convinced that better and cheaper houses were built under it than under the contract system? Was not that the only reason, and it was a very good business reason, why a man like Deputy Crotty should advocate a continuance of the direct labour system in his constituency rather than the contract system? As I have said, I am not advocating the elimination of the building contractor. If you had thedirect labour system working side by side with the contract system, then you would ensure that the contractor would have to keep an eye on his costs and keep his profits down to the minimum. If, for no other reason, the direct labour system would be useful if it did that.

There is no use in building houses at a prohibitive price in the provincial towns for workers and expect that those workers can afford to pay one-third or 40 per cent. of their weekly wages in rent. Sixty-five per cent. of the total weekly rent of the houses built by the local authorities in some parts of my constituency represents interest on money to moneylenders. These poor moneylenders, who are able to secure 65 per cent. of the rent from these tenants, are getting an additional 1 per cent. from the decent, over-generous Minister for Finance in the Budget that he brought in in 1952 and which has had these disastrous effects on every angle of business.

I know that the Taoiseach is a very busy man. I know he works very hard and very long hours. I do not share his views on every aspect of public policy. He is a hard worker and has devoted his life to the public service of the country. I would appeal to him that it is time to look into this question of using the Local Authorities (Works) Act of 1949 for relieving unemployment that is at a dangerous stage at the moment. It is not a long term policy because, if he uses that Act extensively, without any limit on the money, if he uses it as fully as it could be used with the available unemployed, it would come to an end in the course of a couple of years and you might have to repeat it in another ten years. It is a very useful scheme and if the money is available it should be used for this purpose so that men will not be idle in the rural districts with no alternative but a passport to Britain. Let these men do the job and give them employment that is badly needed.

The same applies to house building. I would ask the Taoiseach to look into that matter because it deserves attention. I have a shrewd suspicion that the engineers are opposed to thedirect labour system. I know why. Does not any common-sense Deputy know the reason? If a house building scheme is in operation in my constituency and is being carried out under the contract system, the engineer goes in once a week or once a month and shakes hands with the contractor and says: "Well done, lad. I will give you a certificate for £10,000 or £20,000." Under the direct labour system, he has to be on the job all the time and has to watch costs and supervise the work. He works harder under the direct labour system than under the contract system and has less time to be on the local golf course if he has to supervise the carrying out of a direct labour scheme as compared with a contract scheme. That is the hidden reason why engineers are opposed to it and are getting their way against direct labour schemes which, in many cases in my constituency, meant better and cheaper houses.

If I am challenged on any of these matters, either privately or publicly, by any Deputy, I will give him evidence to prove that what I am saying is true. I do not want to exaggerate. This is not the place for exaggeration. In present circumstances we are not expected to exaggerate when we put forward our views in the House.

I do not want to take up any further time of the House. I could if I wanted to engage in filibustering tactics. I could, I suppose, attempt to repeat what has been so well done last night and to-day by the Minister for External Affairs. It surprised me to hear the Minister exaggerating— that is a mild word, because I have been warned about the words I should use so far as he is concerned. It surprised me to hear an active, virile looking Minister for External Affairs who, I am sure, hopes to be the next Taoiseach if Fianna Fáil live long enough, grossly exaggerating the position and making a speech of a deliberately provocative character. These are not unparliamentary words. I hope I am not being unfair to the Minister for External Affairs by using these words.

There is a serious situation confrontingthe country at present, more serious than I remember in my 31 years' membership of the House. Personally, I do not care who finds a solution for these problems. I said in the beginning that I am not one of those who are extremely anxious for another general election. So far as a name is concerned, I am not bothering whether it is the name of the Taoiseach to-day or the name of the Taoiseach to-morrow, so long as we find a solution for the serious and pressing problems that undoubtedly confront the country.

I do not want to say anything inside the House or outside the House—I hope I have never done so—which would help to create an agitation or trouble so far as the unemployed people are concerned. It is very easy for people with eloquent tongues to play on the position of people who have been unemployed for a long period. I never like to give a letter to a person which will enable him to get out of this country. I like, if I have the power, to give a letter to a person which will get him a job in this country. I have been often asked and have refused to give a letter to a person to get a job in England which we can find at home by the use of measures of the kind I have indicated to-day. Where is a Deputy representing a rural area who will give a letter to a person to get a sailing ticket for Great Britain if he knows in his heart that a little bit more money to operate the Local Authorities (Works) Act or house building activities will enable him to get a job at useful work in his own country?

That is the position which confronts every one of us whether we sit on this side or the other side of the House. I have to admit that a general election will not bring an immediate solution to this problem. If another Government succeeded the present Government they could not find an immediate solution for the grave problem that confronts the country to-day. If we would talk less about personalities in this House and more about principles and general proposals and face the present serious position in a realistic way and co-operate as far as we possiblycan, forgetting about personalities, at least a temporary solution could be found.

With all the power I have at my command—and I cannot speak with the same vehemence or eloquence as members on the other side of the House—I urge the Taoiseach and his colleagues and every member on every side of the House to agree to find the money that must be found to carry out the schemes that are in the pigeon-holes of the Local Government Department, the Office of Public Works, the Department of Industry and Commerce and many other Departments. It is a damned shame for the whole lot of us and for the Government in particular that hundreds of proposals are lying in Government Departments and cannot be carried out not because they are not useful but because we will not allocate the money to the people who can have these schemes carried out and provide useful employment for our citizens, rather than give them passports to get out to another country.

Comment on this

In listening to the Minister for External Affairs to-day and indeed to the few brief remarks of the Minister for Finance one would scarcely believe that this House was faced with a demand for no less a sum than £30,000,000. The Minister for Finance came in here and slapped down the demand—£30,000,000. He spoke for three minutes—£10,000,000 per minute; no explanation as to the policy of the Government, as to whether there was any determination for retrenchment, whether there was any hope of economy in any direction, but merely a demand in a three minute statement for £30,000,000.

Who was called upon to open the case for the Government presenting such a demand and to defend the Government's policy and the results of the Government's policy? The Government called on Deputy Captain Cowan. There was no member of the Government who had the courage to step out of the funk-hole into which they were all driven in panic since they decided to treat with contemptthe voice and the votes of the people of this country, so they called on Deputy Captain Cowan. In a way they could not have called on a better man. He is a very good man to make a good job out of even a rotten bad case. His experience here and his professional training outside have made him quite competent in that particular direction. But even that Deputy failed completely in his task.

I do not believe there is a man living that could make a success of defending the results of the present Government's policy. They may talk vaguely, as they do, about plans. There never was in the history of the world a Government Party with more plans and less achievement than the present Government. Every time we have an election, the principal spokesman of the Government, the Tánaiste, parades the country and everywhere he goes he has magnificent plans, but the fructification of those plans is just around the corner. Of late he is getting tired of the repetition in his own mind of that particular set of words and he has altered them to the extent of saying that the results and the benefits of those plans are just over the hill. There is always a corner to be turned or a hill to be climbed. But the corner has not been rounded nor the hill reduced in height during the 20 years that Government has been in office— plans, words, plans.

Then we have a demand for money, more money demanded each year, more spending each year; the capacity for spending without any equivalent returns developing according to the ease with which the money is got in. It is very easy to get money if you dig into a sufficient number of pockets. When you go down to the bread cupboard of every person in the country extra money of course comes in, and extra money is easily spent. But what is the result of these two years, with plans just around the corner, plans just over the hill? A figure for unemployment unprecedented and unheard of at any previous time in the records of this State.

Comment on this

Except in 1948.

Comment on this

Possibly February, 1948.

Comment on this

June.

Comment on this

Therefore, you have the figure of 90,000 unemployed, never equalled except in the last year they were the Government, according to the Minister for Finance. A figure of 90,000 unemployed, never more human beings on the ships carrying our people abroad, a weight of taxation unequalled and unprecedented either in peace or war, ratepayers everywhere staggering and groaning under the demands and the increasing demands for rates. We have such a situation brought about that the Taoiseach himself, the head of that Government which is making these demands on the people, states that the load of taxation is such that the people of this country are staggering under it and that not even one extra penny can be imposed on the unfortunate people.

When the Taoiseach points out that the people are just staggering under the load of taxation, his jaunty little Minister for Finance waddles in here, throws down a demand for £30,000,000, stands in a perpendicular position for three minutes and then scoots. The next representative of the Government we have is the Minister for External Affairs. He comes in here last night and, in a fashion which has become typical and characteristic of the individual, he sprays the Dáil with insolence, venom and offensiveness for a considerable period of time.

Comment on this

The delicacy of the Deputy is well known.

Comment on this

We have that studied insolence and offensiveness that has become characteristic of the man. But there is a technique in all that. While he is doing that he is keeping away from discussing the results of the Government's policy; he is keeping away from discussing this Vote on Account, this demand for £30,000,000. He is putting in time but evading the issue. To-day he comes in here again and we have an hour of buffoonery. But during the whole of that hour not one period of fiveminutes was devoted to the Vote on Account and not one second to the state of the country, with unemployment, high taxation, and people leaving the land in sheer despair. Even when he was invited to discuss such matters or to pay some attention to them, we had the dumb, determined refusal and just an agile bit of sidestepping back again to clowning and buffooning. Are the Government proud of that? Is the Taoiseach proud of that? Does he think that that is proper behaviour for a Government Minister making a demand on the country for a further instalment of £30,000,000 out of a sum which he himself says has the people staggering under the load?

The people are entitled to some explanation as to why this is required and why no economies can be effected. We have the Minister for External Affairs putting in an hour talking about the increase in sterling assets when the previous Government was in office. Even that brought a blush to the face of the Minister for Finance, and it is very hard to make him blush, because the Minister for Finance remembers what the Minister for External Affairs forgot, that for 12 months after the change of Government the popular tune on every Fianna Fáil platform was the manner in which their predecessors had dissipated sterling assets.

Comment on this

It was Marshall dollars you dissipated.

Comment on this

Deputies who could not spell the word "sterling" were making speeches about it, so much so that in a speech in Cork I said they were all instructed on the one theme and the bulk of them did not know the difference between sterling assets and a new type of artichoke. They were all talking of the manner in which we had squandered the sterling assets. Now the charge against us is that sterling assets grew during that period. I mention that to show the inconsistency of the people opposite.

Comment on this

I suppose it would not be in order to correct the blatant misrepresentation of the Deputy.What we did allege was that they had squandered the Marshall Aid dollars.

Comment on this

And the sterling assets.

Comment on this

We will not quibble about the word "allege." I am talking about what you said, not alleged. In the Minister's own speech—if he wants his own words—what he said was that they had managed this country without reimposing the taxes on beer and tobacco. There is no allegation about that. What the Taoiseach said in his manifesto was that they would run the country better than we did and without reducing the food subsidies. There is no allegation about that. That is the printed word and the other is the spoken word.

Deputy Cowan, as I said, was put up to make the case for the Government. What was his case? He said we always had unemployment and that apparently we always will have it. There is the case for a Government that time and again has stated that they would clear off unemployment, that there was no country in the whole world in which it was easier to cure unemployment. They reached a figure never previously reached and their principal spokesman, Deputy Cowan, says:—

"You will always have unemployment; it will go up and it will go down but you will always have it."

Why should we always have unemployment? We will only have it always if we always have Fianna Fáil. Why was unemployment practically gone and why did it come back two years ago? What creates unemployment?—restricted credit, shortage of money, high taxes and high rates. If any Government in any country takes the last halfpenny out of the people's pockets so that, according to the head of the Government, they are staggering under the load of taxation, there is no money left for spending; there is no money left for house building; there is none left for employment or for reconstruction of houses. The credit of the individual is not good when hislast halfpenny has been taken from him.

All this unemployment began, remember, two and a half years ago when the present Government took office. When they knew they could not better the work of their predecessors their only hope was to slander the name of their predecessors. They toured the country saying we were living on borrowed money; we dissipated the sterling assets; we were spending too freely and borrowing too much. Now to steady the old boat we must have a régime of austerity where the people have less to spend. They withdrew the subsidies, increased taxes and restricted credit. They made money dear and employment dried up. Now that the hunger marchers are shouting at the gates we have the usual remedy, the talk about plans, plans. Hungry people cannot eat plans. Committees and plans, that is the cure but as well as talking about plans and setting up committees they stroll back here with a demand in a three-minute statement for £30,000,000. Both the Minister and the principal spokesman for the Government, Deputy Captain Cowan, explained in a rather laboured way, apparently suffering from the irritation resulting from a guilty conscience, that the Government had a legal and a constitutional right to hang on. Nobody ever disputed the legal or the constitutional right to hang on——

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

——but what we did dispute was the morality of hanging on. You can hang on as long as you have a majority of one here but is that the democratic road? When the voters in by-elections in different provinces, one in the city and two in rural areas, call on you with a thunderous and clamorous voice to get out, do you think the answer is to come in here to secure a vote of confidence from the Fianna Fáil Party and act on your legal and constitutional right to hang on?

Was that the spirit of democracy that the Taoiseach believed in in the winter of 1947? He had a bigger majority in the House then; he had a comfortable majority. There were three by-elections and there was a possibility that thepeople might turn against him. What was his theme in County Dublin, in Tipperary and in Waterford? What were the speeches he made and what was the special message that he sent on the eve of polling to the electors in each of these three constituencies? The gist of all that was that if the Government was weakened by the votes of the people in by-elections, if the votes of the people at by-elections showed a falling away and a loss of confidence in the Government, there was no honourable course open to a democratic Government but to dissolve and refer the election of a Government to the people.

Comment on this

That is a new version of it.

Comment on this

We all know the Taoiseach is a master of ambiguity and he never makes a statement but there is a backdoor emergency exit through which he can escape. Therefore, I did not come in without being armed with records of the Taoiseach's statements because I know if I did not produce the newspaper at the time I was speaking he would take it for granted I had not got it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Might I say, as a further precaution against another interruption, that the only paper I have taken them from is the Irish Pressbecause if I made the quotations from any other paper I would be told they were inaccurate?

Comment on this

I am glad you read it.

Comment on this

I want to quote his own statements.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins, Junior, gave it all to us before.

Comment on this

That is what made you so bilious.

Comment on this

The O'Higgins's are very economical.

Comment on this

You are going to get it again until you obey the people.

Comment on this

Like Kitty O'Shea.

Comment on this

I will not follow the Minister in these paths.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These personalities must cease.

Comment on this

I must ask the Chair if it can put an end to these personal references by the Minister for Finance which he uses regularly in the House. If they were followed the Minister might learn a few things about himself.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not hold himself up as a figure of public rectitude.

Comment on this

Will the Chair take action with regard to the Minister?

Comment on this

We know nothing about Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order! There should be no personalities

Comment on this

Will the Minister withdraw?

Comment on this

There is nothing to withdraw.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dr. O'Higgins.

Comment on this

However, he is simply keeping in step with the other Minister here. To return to some quotations——

Comment on this

I hope that the Deputy has references.

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach object because he does not like to hear what I am going to say?

Comment on this

I do not object at all. I only want to explain that I do not want him to come in without references for the quotations.

Comment on this

You did not think I had the quotations?

Comment on this

I did not know if you had them or not. I did not think that you had them anyway.

Comment on this

Very well; here are the quotations. In the winter of 1947, the 12th October, speaking at Waterford, the Taoiseach said:—

"If you want a change of Government then there will be sense in voting against the Government because you will indicate quite clearly that you want a change of Government."

Speaking at Tipperary, one week later, he said:—

"If a Government were weakened it was not able to do its work properly and if weakened by the by-elections the question must be settled by a general election. He thought the people would agree with him that that was right."

Further, speaking at Dún Laoghaire on the 27th October, he said:—

"If there was a want of confidence in the people, a want of confidence, it would be absolutely necessary to have a general election so that the people could say whether they wanted a change of Government or not."

Then in a message to the people of the three constituencies on the eve of the poll:—

"To weaken the Government unless it were intended to set it aside would be foolish. Were the Government to be weakened by the by-elections it would in the national interest have to be set right by reference to the people in a general election."

That was the headline in the winter of 1947. That was the headline when Fianna Fáil considered that they were still strong enough to scramble back. That headline is completely departed from when Fianna Fáil know absolutely that if they poke their noses out of the hidey-hole this time, never again will they sit on that side of the House. That is the reason why democratic principles have completely changed. That is the reason why the path of honour has got a crooked bend in the middle of it and that they are going in the same direction now by going in the opposite direction.

Comment on this

Was not 1947 the year before you became a Republican?

Comment on this

I can tell the Minister that I was a Republican the week he missed the train to join the British.

Comment on this

You were never a Republican or anybody belonging to you. You were killing Parnell. Were you Republican then?

Comment on this

Might I inquire was that a good Republican train which the Minister missed?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order! The discussion must be confined to the general results of Government policy.

Comment on this

General results of Government policy. Whether it is appreciated on all sides here it is certainly appreciated by the people outside. The general result is to be seen, as Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll said at a corporation meeting, by looking out of the window and seeing the unemployed in their thousands, by going around the homes of the people seeing the last food in the larders, seeing the worried, anxious, pinched faces of women trying to fill their baskets for the week's provisions with money inadequate to do so, when the loaf of bread and the pound of butter alone give no change out of a 5/- bit. Then it is time for the general public to say: "It is time for a change of Government." It is either a case of no change out of the £ or a change of Government up here. Clearly, emphatically and on every occasion over the last 12 months, the people have roared at you: "Get out, get out and give somebody else a chance, Get out, you are no longer wanted here." And your answer to that is to ramble in here, take three minutes to look for another £30,000,000 from the people, and then tell them in defiance that you are going to hang on because you have a constitutional and a legal right to hang on. Shame!

Comment on this

We will agree that it is rather difficult to listen with patience to a speech of the type delivered just now, but nothing from Fine Gael is out of the way. We would indeed be very surprised if we heardanything else from them. The only thing I say to Deputy Dr. O'Higgins is that his memory is very short and his love for the workers and the unemployed has very recently become a sort of canker with him. I wonder when he was Minister in the old Fine Gael Government when they told the workers they could fall dead of starvation, what did they mean by that?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Will you quote?

Comment on this

I quoted it before.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is a complete slander.

Comment on this

That was their attitude.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Quote it.

Comment on this

Quote, quote.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order! Deputy Davern must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

They stated that it was not the duty of the Government to provide work for the unemployed, and that was a very few years ago, and men died of hunger and women died of hunger and men were driven into the asylums, the mental homes of this country, because of the policy of Deputy Dr. O'Higgins and the rest of the gang who were then Ministers with him. Things have changed since and with the Fianna Fáil Government coming into power our people appreciated and fully realised what the workers went through during that ten years of the Fine Gael Government. You did not have unemployment assistance at all and when a man was starving he had to go to the home assistance officer with his hat in his hand begging for a few shillings to try to keep body and soul together. The cap-lifting age is gone. We abolished that in 1932 and 1933. It is many years since we abolished it the same way as we abolished many of the evils that we took over from the old Fine Gael Government.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You scrambled to the right side of the ditch.

Comment on this

You scrambled to theright side of the ditch when you got to be legal adviser to the Post Office.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I would like to know, Sir, if the Deputy is permitted to go back to the days of the civil war?

Comment on this

I might say something which I would not like to be tempted to say.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I ask the Chair to keep the Deputy in order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will keep the Deputy and every other Deputy in order.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I hope so.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins should not interrupt the speaker.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

On a point of order, I am asking you to rule, is the Deputy out of order when he is referring to matters now 20 years old?

Comment on this

What is 20 years old? The appointment to the G.P.O. was not 20 years old.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

1922 is more than 20 years ago.

Comment on this

The Deputy's father has been referring for years——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to compare one administration with another.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is a ruling, that it is in order for Deputies to refer to these matters, as a comparison?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has been done. Most Deputies have done it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Then that applies to other Deputies also?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must allow Deputy Davern to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

In accordance with the rules.

Comment on this

The Deputies oppositehave been trying to inject poison of a dangerous nature not alone into this House but into the people outside this House. It is all very fine for Deputy O'Higgins to have a pleasant smile——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Do not hit me, with the baby in my arms.

Comment on this

——but when he gets a little of his own medicine he does not like to take it. I have heard speeches from many of the Opposition here and, with the exception of the speech delivered by Deputy Davin in which I believe he was perfectly honest, there was not even one word uttered that would in any way help to relieve one unemployed man. Not even one suggestion was made that could in any way be interpreted as doing this country one iota of good.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Except for you to get out.

Comment on this

We have: "Get out, get out." We have come to the "get out" end of it. That is the war cry of Fine Gael, knowing as they do, when urging this "get out" business, telling the people there is to be a general election in the next month or two or that there should be a general election and that we are not democrats, that these are statements which are doing infinite harm to the country, creating instability and creating unemployment. For the past two years they have been at it, urging the people not to till their land. The former Minister for Agriculture never encouraged one acre more of tillage when he was a Minister and tillage became practically unknown in some parts of the country as a result of that unfortunate policy of Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is the Deputy serious?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon consigned agriculture to a limbo, almost a hell, and we have a difficult job to redeem it now. We have to try to persuade the people that unless the land of Ireland is cultivated and worked we are bound to have more and more unemployment. The peoplegoing off the land, as they did in those three years, flocking into the cities already overloaded—that is the cause of much of the unemployment. Worse than that, they now continue with their dual purpose voices, telling us that it is not a democratic thing to remain in this House unless you have the permission and the votes of Fine Gael. What on earth are we coming to?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We only require you to have the support of the people.

Comment on this

We are not going to go back again——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I know that.

Comment on this

——to the terrible years of destitution that prevailed prior to the advent of a Fianna Fáil Government. When I see some of the Fine Gael people shedding crocodile tears about housing, let me remind them that they never built even one house in rural Ireland during their period of ten years of office.

Comment on this

We repaired a whole lot—and well you know it.

Comment on this

Not even one house did you build in rural Ireland and the houses that were built under that régime had to be let at such an exorbitant rent that it was beyond the reach of ordinary working men to accept the tenancy.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We did not blow up any bridges.

Comment on this

My only regret about the bridges is that a few like Deputy O'Higgins were not on top of them. I offer no apologies for the bridges.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

That is a nice statement to make.

Comment on this

That is the apology I give for the bridges. Will Deputy Seán MacBride apologise for the bridges? Tell that to Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely there should be agreement not to start the civil war over again in this House.

Comment on this

Oh! Was not theDeputy trying to get a little capital out of national records yesterday?

Comment on this

What is that a reference to?

Comment on this

Look at the Order Paper and you will see.

Comment on this

The worst feature is that speech after speech is directed to create instability in the country and to try if at all possible to force the people's mind away from giving this Government the confidence that it so richly deserves. We have heard speakers opposite—Deputy O'Sullivan, I think—talking about the high cost of living. I ask the Fine Gael people do they stand for a reduction in the price of milk? Will they tell that to the dairy farmers of Cork? Are they going back to Deputy Dillon's price of 1/- a gallon? Do they stand for a reduction in the price of wheat or the price of beet?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Or barley.

Comment on this

If they do, then let them tell the people of rural Ireland that they want them to go back to the old days when people were hawking samples round the country, like mendicants from door to door trying to get a price; and when, incidentally, the farm workers had to work for 12/-or 15/- a week and had to bring up their families on that meagre sum. If they desire that we should continue to import butter from Australia or Denmark, that we should continue to import sugar from Formosa or other countries, and that we should obtain our full requirements of wheat from outside the country, then instead of criticising the price of bread, butter and sugar they should go down the country and tell the farmers and farm workers that they are going to reduce the prices of these commodities if they get in and give 1/- a gallon for milk, and so on.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We are not going to do that, but we are not going to export Irish sugar and import foreign sugar.

Comment on this

You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is what this Government is doing.

Comment on this

You criticise taxation and at the same time urge expenditure. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You can. There are many other uses for milk.

Comment on this

You can? That is a new one to me.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You can give a substantial increase in the price of milk without increasing the price to the consumer—by adjustment.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Davin say, and I want to contradict him, that the position in regard to unemployment now is the worst for 30 years. That is not so. Deputy Davin has been a member of this House for 30 years and if he puts on his considering cap as every honest Deputy ought to do, he will withdraw that statement and say that the régime of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government was the worst since the famine days.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Ask Deputy Dr. Browne to withdraw that statement. He made it here on the vote of confidence.

Comment on this

I gave Deputy O'Sullivan his job to do, not to be coming in here preaching one thing and going down to the farmers and farm workers in Cork and preaching another. If he does that, he will be doing a good day's work for the country. We want a little more honesty in Irish public life. If we got more honesty, more upright and outspoken statements and more constructive criticism, if the Opposition have such a thing, it would be welcome; but we deplore the sabotage statements that have come from the Fine Gael Benches.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What are the sabotage statements?

Comment on this

It has been stated again that there were more people employed on the roads during the three and a half years of the inter-Party Government. I wonder how can anybody explain away the reduction in the roadgrants during that period. In the South Riding of County Tipperary alone, there was a reduction of £222,000 in the very first year in respect of the grant to which they were entitled. The Coalition Government reduced the road estimate by that sum, and on that basis, Tipperary South lost almost £700,000 in the three and a half years of the Coalition régime. If the rates in my constituency are high and if the roads remained in a bad state of repair we must naturally put the blame for it on the people who are responsible— and they are the disciples of Fine Gael sitting on the opposite side of the House.

I beg of you not to make statements of a kind which are detrimental to the nation's economy. We have had a hard task in this country in the past 35 years. Does anybody seriously think that it is being made easier by making grossly false or exaggerated statements? We hear the same old parrot cry all the time but never one constructive idea. I am sure that the dreadful enmity which the Fine Gael Party have shown us is not due to any personal animosity and, therefore, we must try to find a motive for it. The motive is very obvious. We redeemed this country from the financial chaos to which three and a half years of Coalition Government had brought it. Because we have redeemed the country, we are experiencing this terrible antagonism from the Opposition. Let me tell the Deputies opposite that they will have a general election——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not before the recess.

Comment on this

——in May, 1957, so sit over there quietly, like good children, and continue to be educated by the people from these benches. If you do that then, maybe in ten or 15 years' time, you will be capable of taking over the reins of Government.

Comment on this

The new Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Certainly I would compare favourably with the Taoiseachwhom Deputy Davin put into power. I would know a bullet from a hobbyhorse and that is more than Deputy Costello would.

Comment on this

We will agree to differ on that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What has the difference between a bullet and a hobby-horse to do with the Vote on Account?

Comment on this

The Opposition are trying to blow hot and cold. They are trying to tell people, in effect, that they can have omelettes without cracking egg shells. That is not so.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You took that expression from Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

Nobody ever took Deputy Dillon seriously except, unfortunately, some of the tillage farmers who got out of tillage during his term of office as Minister for Agriculture. My advice to Deputy Dillon and to Deputy Seán Collins is to go and have Deputy Dillon's belfry examined, even by a chiropodist. She might find a corn where his brain should be.

Comment on this

I do not really blame so much Deputy Davern——

Comment on this

He speaks more in sorrow than in anger.

Comment on this

——or some other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party for using language which should not be used in this House and for seeking to play on civil war bitterness.

Comment on this

It is time Deputy MacBride stopped preaching.

Comment on this

They would not do it unless they felt they were being encouraged by more responsible men, such as the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for External Affairs. True, it is seldom that the Taoiseach himself ever indulges in direct personal invectives based on the civil war but it is equally true to say that the Taoiseach sits in this House smiling and grinning broadly when these invectives and attempts to revivepast bitternesses are made and obviously encourages them by his attitude. I do not think that that is a thing that the Taoiseach should do.

Comment on this

We want no lectures from that quarter. We want no lectures from you.

Comment on this

I am not going to be silenced by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach or by anybody else.

Comment on this

Leave off that game. We do not want that. The Deputy who is talking is one of the worst at that game and has been all his life.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach conduct himself—the watchdog of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this

I am proud to be the watchdog of that man.

Comment on this

Do not make a fool of yourself.

Comment on this

Presumably, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach would not behave in that manner unless he knew that it pleased his leader.

Comment on this

Had Deputy MacBride not better come off it? We know that he is a humbug.

Comment on this

I will say what I have to say in this House——

Comment on this

That would be very unusual.

Comment on this

——and I will not be intimidated by the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance or by the shouts of the henchman behind.

Comment on this

Pensioner! We know the pensioner all right. Listen to the man who travelled this country talking about Ministers' pensions. When the opportunity arose, he was the first to take advantage of it himself. He has it now. We know who the pensioner is. That is a contemptible remark from a contemptible person.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The word "pensioner" was not used by Deputy MacBride. He used the word "henchman".

Comment on this

The word which Deputy MacBride used was not "pensioner."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Deputy MacBride might now be allowed to continue his speech, without further interruptions.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach to state in this House that something was "a contemptible remark by a contemptible person?"

Comment on this

That is a mild observation.

Comment on this

I withdraw it, if there is any doubt about it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Now perhaps we could hear Deputy MacBride on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I have listened on numerous occasions in this House to personal attacks being made by members of the Government Party. I respectfully submit that a number of personal attacks have been made in the course of this debate—attacks to which I, as an ordinary member of this House, am entitled to take exception.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should refer to such attacks at the time they are made. He cannot debate them now.

Comment on this

The Deputy would have been unruly if he had done so.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy speaking as a Deputy or as a lay preacher?

Comment on this

On a point of order. There must be some order in the House. Surely to God, the Chair is not going to rule that a Deputy speaking in the House may not discuss contributions to the debate that have just taken place?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has not so ruled.

Comment on this

I understood the Chair to say that, unless we interrupt aspeaker when he is making an observation to which we take exception, no further reference can be made to it.

Comment on this

Can the Chair tell us whether the running fire of remarks being made by the Minister for Finance are going on the record?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot know that.

Comment on this

It should not be allowed.

Comment on this

This House is being asked to vote a sum of over £30,000,000.

Comment on this

Is it in order for Deputy MacBride to make an unprovoked attack on me and to say that I used certain unparliamentary language in this House? He did not even qualify it by saying that that statement was extracted from me through the provocation of Deputy O'Higgins. Unlike Deputy MacBride, I do not make any apologies for anything that I do.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

This House is at present discussing a Vote on Account of some £30,000,000. Part of the money which the House is being asked to vote is to defray the cost of the administration by different Ministers of the Government and I am entitled, in dealing with this Vote on Account, to deal with the conduct of these Ministers in this House as I have witnessed it. I have witnessed a number of personal attacks made by the Minister for Finance on different members of the House. I have also read—I was not present—of attacks made by the Minister for External Affairs on other members of the House. I do not think that is the way in which any responsible Minister should behave and I do not think the Taoiseach should give that type of conduct tacit approval. Having said that, let me pass to the problems with which this House has to deal at present.

The main and gravest problem the House has to deal with is the question of unemployment. There has been arising and mounting tide of unemployment in the course of the past two years. At first, the attitude of the Government was to deny the existence of such a problem, to deny that there was increasing unemployment and to throw in all kinds of reasons as to why there was the existing unemployment. Then, we were told that unemployment was going down, because seasonal unemployment goes down by reason of the operation of employment period Orders. Attempts were even made to use figures which were not really fairly representative of the position. Now, at last, the Government have been forced into a position in which they have to face up to the fact that the country is confronted by a serious crisis, as a result of their own policy.

Unemployment does not grow of itself; it is not caused by a change in the weather; and it is not caused by a change in the seasons. It is the definite result of the economic policy pursued by the Government. There are two main causes of the unemployment position and they have been repeated of ten enough from this side in the course of the past two years. The first was the restriction in the purchasing power of the people which was caused deliberately by the Government in its implementation of the Central Bank policy. The Central Bank advised a reduction in the purchasing power of the people and advised achieving that objective by the removal of the subsidies, the imposition of additional taxation and the restriction of credits. The Government, step by step, implemented that policy, while, at the same time, pretending they were not doing it, pretending they had no responsibility for the Central Bank. Step by step, every single recommendation made by the Central Bank was implemented, and implemented with the results which the Central Bank warned the Government would be achieved, namely, the creation of unemployment.

One of the most potent factors in the creation of the present situation was the restriction of credits. Again here, we were faced with denials that there was any restriction of credit. Then we were told that, if there wasrestriction of credits, it was not due to any wish on the part of the Government. I challenged the Taoiseach, time after time, on that question. He first denied that there was any such thing as restriction of credit. Then he said he did not know, that he had not seen recent figures, but did not believe there was any such thing. Other Ministers said that the Government had no responsibility for it. Now, at last, we have the facts. We know that bank credits were reduced in the course of the year by some £4,500,000 and it can no longer be denied that bank credits were reduced; but we had the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs coming to the House on last Tuesday and saying that, if there had been a restriction of credits, it was in no wise due to anything the Government had said or done and was not part of their policy. That, of course, does not bear examination. The Central Bank advised rigorous credit restrictions. The Government never disowned that policy, although it was invited to do so on numerous occasions.

Comment on this

We have several times made it quite clear that we had nothing to do with it and did not believe in it.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach says that several times he made it quite clear that the Government had nothing to do with it. With what—the Central Bank report?

Comment on this

With the restriction of credit.

Comment on this

I invited the Taoiseach specifically on a number of occasions to state that it was the Government's policy that credits should not be restricted.

Comment on this

And I did state that.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Taoiseach will not be able to refer me to any statement to that effect.

Comment on this

Not at the moment, certainly.

Comment on this

At any time—there is plenty of time. Presumably, theTaoiseach is going to speak on this Vote on Account. Let me remind the Taoiseach, however, of what his own Minister for Finance said.

Comment on this

I quoted my predecessor.

Comment on this

At column 1899 of the Dáil Debates of 18th July, 1951, the Minister for Finance said:—

"Private and public spending are causing congestion that can be relieved only by a reduction of one or the other."

What does that mean, if it does not mean credit restrictions? He went on:—

"Credit facilities are encouraging outlay on less essential goods; money incomes of all kinds are being raised irrespective of increases in output."

Either words in the English language have some meaning or they have not. What other meaning can be taken out of this statement than that it is the desire of the Government to see a restriction of credit policy pursued by the banks. No other meaning can be taken from it, and the Taoiseach knows that full well. When these statements are taken in conjunction with the declaration of the Central Bank that "rigorous restriction of bank credit for non-essential and less urgent purposes is now imperative," it is obvious that these amounted to a direction to the commercial banks to reduce credits.

We had also in the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance on 2nd April, 1952, certain declarations which were obviously also intended to indicate that it was the policy and the desire of the Government that credit should be reduced. At column 1119, the Minister in the course of his Budget statement on 2nd April, 1952, said:—

"Advances in incomes in recent years have been accompanied by disproportionate increases in consumption. This is one of the more unhealthy features of our situation and a clear appreciation of its significance is essential."

"Advance in incomes in recent years have been accompanied by disproportionate increases in consumption." Reduced income and a reduction in the amount of money available was the policy to remedy that situation. That is the advice of the Minister for Finance of the present Government to the commercial banks and other different financial interests in the country. The inevitable results of that policy have been pointed out repeatedly in this House but because it was pointed out by Deputies on this side of the House the Government did not pay any attention to it. Their ears and eyes were closed to the warnings. But they got the same warnings from their own financial advisers. They got these warnings from the Central Bank, who did not put a tooth in it; they considered that certain measures should be taken to remedy what they described as "unusually favourable conditions of employment in the country." Those steps were taken. The "unusually favourable conditions of employment" have now been remedied and the Government can congratulate itself on having achieved at least that purpose. The governor and members of the Central Bank can also congratulate themselves on having reached that objective. The Government were repeatedly asked to dissociate themselves from that policy. They did not do so.

In dealing with the economic problems of the country, one of the difficulties is to find out exactly what the Government's policy is. I had thought until very recently that the main charge the Government was making against the inter-Party Government was that the inter-Party Government had in some ways dissipated the external assets of this country. In the course of practically every by-election that has been held in the last three or four years the Taoiseach has made a standard speech about sterling assets— a standard speech which usually appears in the Irish Pressunder the banner headline: “The country is in danger”. The Taoiseach in that standard speech proceeds to say that the sterling assets “have now dwindled down to £120,000,000.” I have hadnumerous controversies with the Taoiseach about that speech. He made it again in the recent by-elections and he made it before.

I pointed out that the figure £120,000,000 was a misleading one and that the total amount of our external assets was over £500,000,000. That did not prevent the Taoiseach from repeating the same speech at the next by-election.

Comment on this

You left out a very important word which I put in—"net".

Comment on this

I know the Taoiseach's capabilities of putting in a quibbling word.

Comment on this

The word "net" is not a quibbling word, I am sure.

Comment on this

When you talk of the investments of a person, a bank, a business firm or a country, you talk of their investments.

Comment on this

When you talk of a man's assets and liabilities together you talk of net.

Comment on this

I wish the Taoiseach would look into this matter seriously. I never know whether the Taoiseach pretends not to understand a point in regard to financial matters or whether he misunderstands it. I wish the Taoiseach would investigate the methods of computation of this net figure he quotes. If the Taoiseach likes I can give him now the actual figures in regard to the external assets.

Comment on this

I got them from a more reliable source than the Deputy.

Comment on this

I wish you would use them. My sources are derived from the statistics provided by the Government. I have no sources other than those I can obtain in the House by asking questions. I find it difficult to reconcile the Taoiseach's figures with those given in replies to questions in this House.

Comment on this

If an Englishman invests £1,000,000 in this country should this country have £1,000,000 of its own invested in England to safeguard that gentleman?

Comment on this

You did not do a whole lot about it for three and a half years.

Comment on this

I should like the Taoiseach to pay some attention to this and get it looked into. I understand that one of the liabilities charged against the sterling assets of this country by the Department of Finance consists of all the property and assets held by the commercial banks whose headquarters are outside this country. Likewise, all the assets and property of the different commercial companies whose headquarters are situated outside the Twenty-Six Counties are also charged against our external assets. I think that is a misleading basis of computation. I hope that the Taoiseach's annoyance will not preclude him from having it looked into. I think it is worth getting looked into.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

On the latest figures available from Government sources, the total sterling assets of this country amounted to over £500,000,000. I did not intend discussing sterling assets in that context to-day? I mentioned it several times before. What I want to ascertain is what exactly is the charge which the Government levels against the inter-Party Government. Judging by the Taoiseach's speeches at election times, the charge used to be that we squandered the sterling assets of this country and that we reduced them to the danger point and that we had only £120,000,000 left. In the speeches made during election time, the Taoiseach referred to the assets dwindling down to £120,000,000. Could that have any other meaning but to suggest that the danger point had been reached and that the inter-Party Government had so squandered the assets that the country was now in danger?

Apart from the Taoiseach's speeches at election time we have a number of speeches like that of the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Finance, speaking on the 21st May, 1952, as recorded at column 2163 of the Official Report, said:—

"The Coalition during their threeyears of office reduced our net external assets by almost £150,000,000".

The Minister for External Affairs said we did not. You cannot have it both ways. Let us know what is the charge. Did we or did we not decrease them? Did we squander them or not? Has the Taoiseach been wasting his breath making speeches saying that we had squandered them? I was dealing with the point that was made.

Comment on this

We will deal with it, too.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

Comment on this

Dealing with this question in his speech in the Dáil on the 21st May, 1952, at column 2163, the Minister for Finance said that: "The Coalition during their three years in office reduced our sterling assets by almost £150,000,000". And then he goes on—"not only did the Coalition Government squander our net external assets but they have further impaired our economic independence by loading us with foreign debt—at the instance, let this be borne in mind, of a foreign Power".

That is the charge against us, that we squandered external assets and that we put the country in pawn to a foreign power. Indeed, these charges were made not merely by the Taoiseach and by the Minister for Finance but by many other Ministers as well. I am sure Deputies will remember the speech made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs in January, 1952, in which he said that, "the controllable part of our external assets was a standing army of occupation in England and it was treachery to the national cause to suggest that that army should be brought home"—treachery to the national cause to repatriate external assets.

The House will also remember the speeches made at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis, where the Minister said: "It was putting him to the pin of his collar"—I am quoting his words—"to maintain our currency on a parity basis with the British pound sterling", because the position was so serious because the inter-Party Governmenthad squandered so much of the sterling assets of this country. Now, to-day, I do not know whether the Minister for External Affairs was reflecting a change of policy which is a general change of policy on the part of the whole Government or whether he was speaking off the cuff on his own behalf, but it would appear that the charge against us was not that we squandered external assets but that we had unduly increased them. It was somewhat of a contradiction. It caused me rather to wonder why a change of attitude had taken place. Is it by any chance that the Government are contemplating repatriating external assets or contemplating the possibility of using external assets for capital development schemes or contemplating using them for the purpose of balancing their budget? I do not know, but there must surely be some cause for the sudden change of policy that seems to have taken place in the course of this debate. Possibly the Taoiseach will enlighten us when he is speaking on these matters.

Many indications have been given that the Government proposes to make money available for relief schemes. I welcome that, but I think it is a pity that money has to be wasted now on relief schemes when the employment position could have been maintained by not pursuing a deflationary policy. Relief schemes always involve a waste. They are wasteful in their nature, but I welcome the provision of any relief schemes that will relieve the unemployment position that exists in this country to-day. But I hope that apart from relief schemes the Government will realise that some more fundamental changes will have to be made in our approach to our economic problems and that one of the first essentials is to countermand the order for the restriction of credit which the Government virtually gave in 1951 or 1952.

Comment on this

That is not true, of course.

Comment on this

It is not untrue. I will quote again for the Taoiseach— I wish he would take it down, as Ithink the Taoiseach is able to delude himself into thinking that when he says a thing is untrue, it is untrue— a statement made by his own Minister for Finance in this House:—

"Private and public spending are causing congestion that can be relieved only by a reduction of one or the other. Credit facilities are encouraging outlay on less essential goods; money incomes of all kinds are being raised irrespective of increases in output."

"Credit facilities are encouraging outlay." If that is not an advice to the banks to restrict credit I do not know what it is. That statement of policy taken in conjunction with the much blunter declaration of the Central Bank that: "Rigorous restriction of bank credit for non-essential and less urgent purposes is now imperative." It can only have been taken by the banks or by any reasonable person as a clear indication that it was the Government's wish and desire that credit should be restricted. Indeed, too, the Taoiseach will recall that I drew his attention to a circular which was sent out by the Department of Finance quoting the O.O.E.C., "Country Studies," which had been drafted on Department of Finance material, boasting of the fact that there had been a 2 per cent. restriction of credit.

I drew the Taoiseach's attention to that circular at the time. He said he had not seen it and was not aware of credit restriction. Now he is aware of it and of the statements made by his Ministers. If he was not aware of it before, he is now. Will he now get up in this House and say it is the desire and the policy of the Government that the banks should relax credit restrictions. Unless he does so, naturally credit restrictions are going to continue. Is he prepared to make that statement? He can alter the employment situation extremely rapidly if he does. I suggest it is a far less wasteful way of dealing with unemployment than by the provision of relief schemes, though I agree relief schemes have to be provided because the situation is so bad.

Arising from the provision of relief schemes, I would like to mention one other matter. In reply to a question in the Dáil a few days ago, I extracted the information that it was proposed to build, apparently, a new military base for jet planes at Baldonnel and to spend about £600,000 on it. The Taoiseach had mentioned some works at Baldonnel but it was only in the course of a reply to a question that it emerged it was the intention to build this jet air base at Baldonnel or to build runways capable of taking jet planes. I think it is a pity that the House was not given an opportunity of discussing that when the Estimate for the Department of Defence was before the House. I want to make it quite clear that there may be a case for having jet planes. There may be a case for having a base capable of taking jet planes, but I think the House might be given an opportunity of discussing it and of discussing whether Baldonnel is the best place for such a base. It would have occurred to me that if we were to have a military airfield capable of taking jet planes that Galway might have been better, or that Cork might have been better. There may be good reason—I am not prepared to criticise or oppose the Government's policy in the matter until we have had an opportunity of discussing it—for constructing these runways at Baldonnel. But it does appear prima facieto be somewhat shortsighted to construct a military airfield of that nature so close to the existing civil airport at Collinstown.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will understand, of course, that this Vote on Account is not itemised.

Comment on this

We do know that this Vote includes a certain provision for the Department of Defence.

Comment on this