Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 417–620 of 812. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
I think the Deputy had better wait until the particular Estimate for the Department comes before us because the provision is not itemised in this Vote.
Comment on this
That wouldenlarge the scope of the debate considerably. We are dealing with general matters on this Vote.
Comment on this
May I conclude on that matter by saying that I hope the House will get a fuller opportunity of discussing this matter? I think it should have been mentioned when the Estimate for the Department of Defence was before the House.
Comment on this
I shall not pursue it further. I hope that, apart from relaxing the restrictions on credit, the Taoiseach will consider the implementation of a policy which is likely to increase the purchasing power of the people. The Government policy of keeping wages down despite the increase in the cost of living is part and parcel of the policy of reducing the purchasing power of the people. I do not see how the unemployment position can be remedied so long as you maintain a reduced purchasing power. The immediate cause of the unemployment position was the reduction in the purchasing power of the people brought about by the restriction of credit, the removal of the food subsidies and the imposition of additional taxation. So long as we seek to keep wages down in relation to prices, so long will conditions of unemployment continue. You may relieve the situation temporarily by relief schemes of one kind or another, but if a permanent solution is to be arrived at there will have to be a more fundamental approach to it than the Government appear to have adopted so far.
There are many other matters towhich I would like to refer but I have already dealt with a number of them in other debates. Let me say this in regard to the question of sterling assets. The Minister for External Affairs made what he thought was a very clever speech to-day, pointing out that the sterling assets of the Central Bank and of certain Government Departments had increased in 1951. Of course they had increased, but the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for External Affairs know perfectly well what was the cause of that increase. They know perfectly well that the increase was of a temporary nature caused by the deposit of the Marshall Aid Funds in the Central Bank. The Minister knows that that is no real argument to use against the demand that we should utilise more of these assets for development at home. In my view, the lack of development from which this country suffers, the chronic unemployment and the emigration from which we suffer, were due to the mistakes in economic policy pursued since this State was set up. That policy was pursued by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government originally, and it was carried on by the Fianna Fáil Government.
In practice, it was not carried on to the same extent by the inter-Party Government. The fundamental approach to our economic problem in the past proceeded on the assumption that we should export our surplus moneys and invest them abroad instead of utilising them for development at home. So long as that policy is continued, we cannot hope to develop the country as it should be developed. The sooner the two major Parties in this House—I seem to be excluding the Labour Party but I thought it might be easier for the two major Parties to reach agreement on this question— face the situation and decide that our whole approach to the financial and economic problems of this nation has to be changed, the better.
Comment on this
I know that so far as the Labour Party and ourselves areconcerned we see eye to eye on that. I think that the Fine Gael Party has made considerable progress in that direction. Fianna Fáil seems to be the only Party that is dragging its feet on that question now but I think Fianna Fáil should march in that direction. I hope that a new approach will be made by the two major Parties in this House. I would prefer to see a matter of that kind considered carefully by either a national Government or if needs be—if the Taoiseach does not want to have anything to do with a national Government—by an all-Party committee of this House to see if we can approach this question purely with a desire to develop the country and with a desire to remedy the unemployment position which is weakening the country politically and nationally as well as economically.
Comment on this
It is very easy for speakers on the Opposition side to misrepresent facts to-day but the same speakers who are now so fluent in misrepresenting facts and trying to gull the people of Ireland in an endeavour to cover up their own mismanagement were not so successful in their efforts when they had the opportunity to remedy all the grievances of which they complain to-day. They tell the people of the country now: "If you put us back again everything in the garden will be lovely." They pretend that there was nothing worthwhile done in this country except during the three and a half years of the period of office of the inter-Party Government.
May I point out to the learned gentlemen on the opposite benches that if it were a fact that all this great work was carried out during their three and a half years in office, we should be living in Utopia now and that all our economic ills should have been cured long ago? Their sole desire is to misrepresent the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party. They want to get that Party out of office so that they will have another opportunity of putting the country in the same position as it occupied when they left office—a position in which our people would have to beg from some other Power instead of standing on their own feet.I will take County Dublin to show some of the results of the policy implemented by the inter-Party Government. Last night my colleague referred to the factories in County Dublin. In 1951 the factories in County Dublin were practically closed down. Why? Because of the mismanagement of the inter-Party Government with their stockpiling of the finished article instead of importing the basic raw materials. The effects of that policy are still being felt. Apparently their aim was to provide employment for the foreign worker rather than for their own people at home. Men in public positions, some of them representatives here, will grasp at any opportunity to pillory the Government, a Government that has done everything it possibly could do to develop the country and provide employment for our people. We have never left a stone unturned. We gave every encouragement to our industrialists and our agriculturists. We gave them the maximum protection. We provided them with the necessary finances.
The present Minister for Industry and Commerce is the best friend the workers of this country ever had. He has been responsible for putting thousands into productive employment. His work was retarded through the advent of the inter-Party Government and the short-sighted policy they pursued. Certain projects then on the stocks were scrapped by that Government. Why? Because they had been conceived by Fianna Fáil and for that reason the inter-Party Government were prejudiced. The machine tool factory project at Inchicore was one of the first to come under the hammer. I wonder what Deputy Hickey has to say about that.
Comment on this
I would prefer if the Deputy dealt with the matter in a proper, serious, practical way.
Comment on this
That is only one of a number of projects that were scrapped. The Fianna Fáil Government had arranged in 1947 to carry out certain mineral development. That went by the board when the inter-Party Government came into power. In orderto encourage industrial development here the Minister for Industry and Commerce, as well as providing all the protection necessary, introduced an insurance scheme to give our manufacturers the maximum coverage on the export market for their surplus products. The Minister never failed to do his job. He tried to create all the employment he could; he is doing that again to-day and he will continue to do it so long as he remains Minister for Industry and Commerce. He has played more than a man's part in developing industry and providing employment thereby.
Can the same be said of other Ministers for Industry and Commerce? Did they not try to kill the industries we established? Any country that wishes to progress must develop internally both from the industrial and the agricultural point of view. The only way in which a country can become really self-supporting is by producing enough to meet the needs of its own people and an exportable surplus. That is the economic policy of every successful nation.
When we returned to office in 1951 there was a slump. The warehouses, the factories and the shops were full because of the stockpiling that had taken place. We are still feeling the effects of that slump.
The Opposition Parties have referred to our airfields. Do responsible members of the Opposition believe we should have no airfields at all? Is that their policy? Do they think we should be by-passed by the Great Powers?
Comment on this
Do not misconstrue my statement. The Deputy is an adept at that. We must move with the other civilised nations of the world. We must keep in touch. Apparently the Opposition believe we should not have airfields or aeroplanes. If that is their mentality the country will never progress. Do they not want the country to progress? Within our own resources, we should try to do the things we think desirable in order to retain our place amongst the civilised nations of the world. I now propose to deal with thequestion of agriculture. We have on the opposite benches Deputy Dillon, who was Minister for Agriculture during the inter-Party Government. On many an occasion during the three and a half years that we were in opposition I had to speak to him on behalf of the tillage farmers of the County Dublin, the fruit growers, the tomato growers and others. Deputy Dillon, who was then Minister, said that I was only concerned with vested interests. He always trotted out statements about the people in George's Street or in Dominick Street.
Comment on this
No. I used to trot out the Balbriggan widow and ask you her name and where I could find her but you never told me.
Comment on this
He tried that on before when I mentioned about that lady having a lot of oats on her hands.
Comment on this
And when I asked you where she was and where I could find her you never told me, and I still do not know.
Comment on this
If the Deputies could get back to the Vote on Account it would be more interesting than any widow.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not going to put me off by any of his statements in that regard. During the time of the inter-Party Government I had to deal one night on the Adjournment with Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture. I had to point out to him that he had advised the farmers of the County Dublin not to grow wheat in 1948 but to grow oats. They did grow the oats, but when the crop came in they found that there was no storage for it.
Comment on this
On that occasion I read a number of letters for the House on which Deputy Dillon hung his coat afterwards. I told him that, as a result of his advice, of his wrong advice I should have said, the tillage farmers in the County Dublin had changed from the growing of wheat to the growing of oats, and that when the crop came in they, as well as the poor widows, could find no market for the oats.
Comment on this
The only point I want to make is that he tried to slander me by saying that I was concerned only in vested interests—that I was only interested in the poor widow—while the fact is that my only interest was in the tillage farmers in the County Dublin.
Comment on this
I gave the Deputy at the time the names of the bachelors and the widows and of the old men, too, who had suffered as a result of his policy.
Comment on this
I am replying to the allegations which have been made by the honourable Deputy on the other side of the House.
Comment on this
That, however, was the advice which Deputy Dillon gave to the tillage farmers in the County Dublin. In 1950 he trotted in here and, holding out his arms, said that he was going to import maize meal and various other things. We had Deputy MacBride and other Deputies on that side talking this evening about theunemployed. When you have a mentality in the Cabinet of any Government, of being more concerned about bringing in manufactured goods that we should be able to produce at home, is it any wonder that the tillage farmers in the County Dublin did not know how they stood when they saw the results of following the advice given to them by Deputy Dillon? Deputy Dillon was not long in disillusioning them as well as every other farmer throughout the country.
Comment on this
What about the quantity of meal that your Government left which had to be sold for animal feeding, with the balance of it walking out?
Comment on this
In 1950 the tillage farmers in the Twenty-Six Counties decided that they would get out of tillage as fast as they could.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy excuse me? There is a motion on the Order Paper for £30,000,000 in the Vote on Account by the present Government. I cannot relate what the Deputy is talking about to the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
May I say this with all due respect? Since I came into the House I have heard other speakers trying, by every means in their power, to point out to the House that it is our policy that was responsible for having the country as it is to-day. They have tried to misrepresent the facts. I am only trying to answer some of the points that were made, to show the mistakes that were made in the case of the agricultural industry during the period of the inter-Party Government and, as a result of which, thousands of people lost their employment then. I am only trying to cite particular cases where that situation was brought about.
Comment on this
Is it not true that Deputy Ó Briain passed a note to the Parliamentary Secretary to say thatthey wanted this talked out and to get. Deputies up to talk?
Comment on this
No, it is not. We do not mind if we have to remain here until the middle of September. The Deputy wants, of course, to go away to the Riviera.
Comment on this
I saw the note being passed. We would make a nice pair going to the Riviera, the Parliamentary Secretary and myself.
Comment on this
I want to say this, that Deputy Dillon during his time in office succeeded in putting hundreds of agricultural workers out of employment. When he was Minister, and when I spoke to him in this House about the tomato growing, the fruit growing and other things that we had started to produce here, he said that I was concerned only with vested interests. His policy destroyed all these things. It destroyed the trend of a natural development amongst our tillage farmers. Instead of giving them advice and encouragement, and all the help possible, he started to blame them for a number of our ills. Naturally, when they found that they could not have confidence in the advice which was given to them by the Minister, our farmers got completely out of tillage. As a result, we found ourselves purchasing from other countries agricultural products produced, mainly, by foreign labour. Another result of that policy was that we had a big adverse trade balance here. If that had gone on for another year under the inter-Party Government, we would not have had one milch cow in Ireland. The dairy farmers at that time had been so discouraged and so badly treated that they were getting out of milch cows as fast as they could. Now, as a result of the policy of the present Minister for Agriculture, we aregetting back into butter production again. Those who support the inter-Party policy talk about the plans they have on the shelves if ever they get into office again.
I suggest that they have no plans to take off the shelves because they have no policy. Fianna Fáil had a hard job to do in 1952 and I want the people to realise that.
Comment on this
The people of Ireland know that the decision taken by this Party in the 1952 Budget which is now accused of restricting credit and doing all these other things was taken because we had to do a very hard job. It is no harm to repeat what I have said three times before in this House, that we had to put the interests of this and future generations before the interests of our own Party in trying to restore the country's financial position to the position in which we left in it 1948. Deputy Lemass, when he spoke on the Opposition side of the House when we were defeated in 1948, said to the inter-Party Government: "We have given you over the country in a sound financial position. I hope that when you are giving it back to us you will give it back in the same way". That was not done. A dishonest Budget was introduced by the inter-Party Government. They failed to balance their Budget in 1951. They brought in a dishonest Budget and they left us a legacy that we have had to carry. In dealing with the problems created by that Budget we had to put the interests of Ireland before the interests of our Party.
Comment on this
It was a very hard thing for any political Party to take the step that Fianna Fáil had to take. They took it because they wanted the country to be economically sound and to stand on its own feet and not to have to beg crumbs from any foreign Power. When you get loans from great Powers or when you get a loan in private life you are under an obligation. It isvery little to have political freedom in the Twenty-Six Counties if we have not economic freedom. We are slowly and gradually restoring economic freedom to the country by the policy we adopted. By that policy we are bringing the country, slowly but surely, back to prosperity.
I want the people to realise the serious step we had to take at that time. When we are all gone, some future historian will pay a compliment to the Fianna Fáil Party for taking that stand and for their effort to make the country economically free again.
I deplore the despicable politics being played by ex-Ministers of the inter-Party Government and the encouragement they are trying to give to unfortunate people who have no employment at the present time. I am deeply concerned for every section of our people. I am deeply concerned for the unemployed. We are doing our best to see that they will get employment. We have made the maximum stand both in the industrial field and in the agricultural field to give employment. By public works schemes and everything else we are trying to create employment. Yet people try to mislead some of these people and use them for their own political ends.
I am interested in people in all walks of life. Fianna Fáil are deeply concerned with all sections of the people. By social welfare schemes we are trying to be fair to every section of the people. If this Party has a leaning towards any section, it is towards the weaker section. We feel that, as a result of our policy, the people have confidence in us and will back us. We feel that the people will be very delighted that we have taken the stand that we have taken and will take, honestly and sincerely.
We will not barter the economic freedom of this country for any expediency. Expediency may be adopted in the political field for some political kudos but we in Fianna Fáil will not adopt it. If we are defeated for honesty and sincerity of purpose in the economic and political field, we can never be charged with dishonesty. If we get an opportunity to carry out our economic policy we will, pleaseGod, see all our people working and happy.
Comment on this
Is it not a striking fruit of two years' Fianna Fáil administration that we have procured in Dáil Éireann unanimity on one fact and that is that never at any time were relief works more urgently needed? Is it not true that on every side of the House there is agreement on that proposition to-day? Have not we travelled a long road in two years, when you throw back your mind to the fact that in the spring of 1951 the inter-Party Government was derided by the then Opposition for having inprovidently created so much employment that the wage structure was becoming unmanageable?
I was recently discussing with a Fianna Fáil employer of labour the problems which were created by the Fianna Fáil policy with which the State is grappling now, and he stopped me to say that he did not agree that our difficulties were created by anything Fianna Fáil had done because he believed that they were due in the last analysis to the unhealthy position of overemployment that the Government of which I was a member had created before we went out of office and that it was his experience that in the circumstances obtaining in the spring of 1951 it was becoming progressively more difficult to control labour, there was such a shortage of unemployed and that, in his judgement, the situation was very much healthier to-day and it was easier to talk to the men.
I ask Dáil Éireann to cast their mind back to the genesis of the situation with which we are grappling now. Is it or is it not true that a White Paper was introduced into this House for the purpose of convincing the Oireachtas and the country of the urgent necessity for a deflationary economic policy? Is it or is it not true that that was followed by a Budget in 1952 designed to establish deflation? Is it or is it not true, as Deputy MacBride described to-day, that the Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government stated in Dáil Éireann that private and public spending are causing congestion that can be relieved only by a reduction of one or theother, that credit facilities are encouraging outlay on less essential goods? Bearing these words in mind, is it not true that Fianna Fáil then claimed that we were about to expand public spending? In that context, are not these words an express direction to the banks to restrict credit, and was not the Government an approving party to the increase in the bank rate in this country?
Taking all the impact of the Budget of 1952, taking all the impact of the steady campaign of denigration of the credit of this country that was operated by the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, and the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, in 1951 and 1952, all that was relatively insignificant compared to the impact on the economic position of this country by the increase in the bank rate. When you add to that the approach by the Minister for Finance on behalf of our Government to the money market for a national loan at 5 per cent., when Jamaica was borrowing at 4½ per cent., when commercial firms in Great Britain were having their debenture issues oversubscribed 15 times at 4½ per cent., and the consequential increase in the cost of moneys borrowed by local authorities and by everybody else who was concerned for the creation of employment in this country, are we unjust if we say that the unemployment with which we are confronted now, and which evokes in this House agreement as to the necessity for relief works, is the responsibility of Fianna Fáil?
There is no use in some well-intentioned Deputies protesting that we must not look back, but that our duty is to look forward and to come forward with co-operative suggestions for the resolution of the difficulties which at present confront us. The only way of correcting the problems which confront us at the present time, if we intend to correct them permanently, is to look back at the policy which created them and correct that policy. Relief works now, we are all agreed, are necessary in order to provide bread for hungry men. But there is no use in this country embarking on a system of floundering from one crisis of unemployment into another in the hope that freshdoses of relief works will lay each emergency as it arises. Such a policy is suicidal. We must provide relief works now because our neighbours are willing to earn their living in their own country and we have not the means to enable them to do so; but the time purchased by that device of relief works must be used so to reorient the economy of this country as to render unnecessary in future the provision of relief works for the employment of our people.
That is one of the fundamental things that divide the Fine Gael Party from the Fianna Fáil Party. In 18 years of Fianna Fáil administration they have always looked upon the employable elements of our community as a problem, a sword of Damocles hanging over their heads. The three years' administration of the inter-Party Government was founded on the proposition that every unemployed pair of hands in Ireland presented an invaluable opportunity for developing our own country, with the result that the policies we operated put these hands to work to the point, as Fianna Fáil said, of overemployment. But it was employment in our own country which, with astonishing rapidity, produced results.
Comment on this
Can you quote any member of the Fianna Fáil Party for making that statement about overemployment? I challenge you to give that quotation from anyone.
Comment on this
I think all Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party believed it. That is one of the great mistakes into which they have suffered themselves to be misled. Perhaps some of them did not understand where they were being misled. But I ask Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, who are in good faith in this matter, what did they think their own Minister for Finance was up to when he introduced the Budget of 1952, when he sanctioned the increase in the bank rate, when he increased the interest costs on all loans to local authorities, and when he increased the borrowing rate of this country from 3½ per cent. to 5 per cent.? What doDeputies on the Fianna Fáil side think was the purpose which he had in mind? Did they not know that his purpose was to reverse what he called the inflationary trend?
We told the Fianna Fáil Deputies at that time that the first consequence of deflation is the creation of a pool of unemployment. We tried to warn the Fianna Fáil Deputies that, in our peculiar circumstances, that would not manifest itself at once as obviously as it did in other countries, because a great number of our unemployed would emigrate to Great Britain and it was only when the situation became extremely grave that you got, in addition to those who fied in emigration, a considerable number left workless at home, and that at that stage it might be a matter of the greatest difficulty to correct the trend that had been inaugurated. Surely Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party remember our saying that. They did not believe it.
I give some of them credit for honestly believing we were wrong and that we were misrepresenting what their Minister hoped to do. I can sympathise with them in making that mistake but now that the consequences are here before us, now that they have asked the House to agree with them —and we have to agree—that relief works must be instantly inaugurated, surely there must dawn in the minds of some of these Deputies an inkling of the fact that what we told them was about to happen has, in fact, come to pass.
It would be a disaster at this eleventh hour if the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party are themselves unable to understand the consequences of the things they have been induced to do. Some day they will realise how dreadful a thing they have done. They have persuaded a great many young men in this city that an Irish Government considers itself justified in looking on some of its neighbours as expendable, expendable in the sense that it was economically desirable to make them unemployed. That bitter resentment is in their mind—let me say at once, a resentment that I myself would feelwere I in their position—and there have been found individuals to avail of their distress most grievously to mislead them. I believe there are communist influences which, were they able, would gladly exploit the distress which to our eternal shame an Irish Government inflicted on our own people.
I loathe and detest the very name of communism. I despise and detest their unscrupulous agents who would exploit the misfortune of decent neighbours of ours in this country to mislead them. But I am in this difficulty that I know it is true that three months ago the Government was protesting that there was no unemployment, and I am humiliated and ashamed to confess that what suddenly brought the Government of this country into this House in an atmosphere of emergency calling on us all to lend a hand was the fact that the exasperated unemployed in Dublin sat down on O'Connell Bridge and refused to get up. I think the people who gave them the advice so to sit and so to march are not their friends. I believe that some of those people—and I think it is time it was openly said—have as their ultimate objective to bring our neighbours into physical conflict with the representatives of the law. I believe the men who lead those men to-day desire nothing but to see their blood shed on the streets of Dublin to supply publicity to a cause that none of our neighbours desire to serve.
I indict Fianna Fáil for having created a situation in which the young men of this city have been reduced to a state of exasperation for which I cannot find it in my heart to blame them, which has permitted them to become instruments in the hands of men who care nothing for the welfare of our neighbours and less for the integrity of our country. These same influences have tried again and again and again to mislead our people. They have never succeeded before.
Comment on this
Driven what so far? Does the Deputy dare to challengeanything I say. I have said that Fianna Fáil have delivered these men into the hands of bad leaders and they have created a situation in which I find it extremely difficult to give the right answer. How can we escape from the facts? No argument in this House, no appeal from the benches would stop Fianna Fáil. Remember that for two years we have implored the present Government to stop a policy designed to create unemployment here. Every warning we gave, every appeal we made, was brushed aside, and we have reached the humiliating position that men under bad leadership can get results in a fortnight that the whole Opposition of Dáil Éireann have been unable to produce in two years. That is one of the worst crimes Fianna Fáil has ever perpretrated against our country and generations may yet have to pay for the obscurantism and the stubborn blindness of the Party that is responsible for the problem with which we have to deal at the present time.
The trouble is that if Fianna Fáil cannot read the record as it is to-day, I wonder will they be able to understand developments as they unfold themselves in the immediate future. It is because I doubt that capacity, not because I want to have any part in clearing up the truly desperate situation that Fianna Fáil has now created, that I would like to see a general election. I want to say with great deliberation that no sane man who understands the full implications of the present situation could conceivably desire to undertake ministerial responsibility now or at any foreseeable time in the future.
Comment on this
No, it was Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan, Deputy Browne and the rest of the busted flush. What I am asking Deputy Beegan to think of now is the situation which he himself conceives as grave enough to require the institution of immediate relief work. I want him to ask himself the question: what made reliefworks necessary? He knows they were not necessary two years ago. Surely the Deputies of the Party responsible for this country for the last two years must ask the question: why are they necessary now? What has brought that about?
Comment on this
Certainly, there are many unemployed men who have been offered employment and have not taken it.
Comment on this
I do not know why, but the labour exchanges have been asked for workers and where did they come from? They came from Birmingham and from Manchester.
Comment on this
Now is not this interesting? The tune now is at this time that there is not any unemployment.
Comment on this
They had to get men from Birmingham and Manchester and I will prove that on very good authority.
Comment on this
What is one to do? What is one to say to people who lined up under bad leadership and you say to them: "There is available in your own Parliament the means of exposing your grievances and of getting an appropriate remedy for it" if he replies to you "but the man in charge of the Board of Works says we are not there. There are not any unemployed to see."
Comment on this
He says that the only unemployed in this country are the men coming from Birmingham and Manchester.
Comment on this
I am saying that there are unemployed people in this country who have not accepted offers of work and that is well known, and that menhave come over from Birmingham and Manchester and have taken up work.
Comment on this
Now this is most helpful. These men are mad. These men are stark, staring mad. Their self-evident solution is that there are not any unemployed. The whole thing is an illusion.
Comment on this
Deputy Killilea and Deputy Beegan say now that the problem is that there are a vast number of men who will not take work, and the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Finance say that an emergency is upon us and we must provide relief works all over Ireland. Who is right? Which is the policy that Fianna Fáil proposes to follow? Do Deputy Killilea and Deputy Beegan speak for the Party or do the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Finance?
Comment on this
Well, the workers will not work on turf at £4 10s. a week. You do not expect them to work for that.
Comment on this
I thought that all Parties in the House were agreed that relief work was necessary. It now appears that Fianna Fáil believe that they are not necessary.
Comment on this
Think well of what I have said to-day and think well of the responsibility that Fianna Fáil's own obscurantism has brought upon us, for so surely as to-morrow's sun rises the Fianna Fáil Party will have to answer for what they have done to the country some day, and if they do not understand now the nature of their own act they will get a shock such as no political Party in this country ever got before.
Comment on this
I want to say a word in reference to a speech made by Deputy Colm Gallagher, and I make the reference because I believe that Deputy Gallagher spoke bona fideof things that he believed to be true, and he explained to the House that one of the reasons that he stood over what Fianna Fáil have done in the last two years was that he sympathised with the Minister for Finance, who had come in and found the whole floor littered with bills and no money to pay for them. I want to reiterate most emphatically again that when the present Government took office in the spring of 1951, there were no unpaid bills awaiting them, but there was close on £30,000,000 sterling of the Marshall Aid Loan Counterpart Fund——
Comment on this
——lying on the desk of the Minister for Finance to do with it precisely what he thought best to do.
Comment on this
I want to read to him what the Minister for Finance said and remember he is his Minister for Finance. I refer to column 1001.
Comment on this
Oh, yes. At column 1001 of Volume 140, No. 6, July 9th, 1953, we find the following:—
"Mr. MacEntee: The position when we took office in the middle of July, 1951, was that there had already disappeared out of the Loan Counterpart Fund over £18,000,000 worth——"
Mr. Dillon: And £24,000,000 remained.
Mr. MacEntee: ——and, as the Deputy has reminded me, there remained £24,000,000."
Comment on this
The report continues:—
"Mr. Dillon: Have the Deputies opposite got a note of that?
Mr. MacEntee: Yes. The point is this. Every penny of that £24,000,000 had already been hypothecated by the commitments which our predecessors entered into."
Is it now agreed that £24,000,000 was there?
Comment on this
Is it now agreed that there was £24,000,000 there? Is it?Is that agreed? The report continues:
"Mr. MacEntee: That is the point. These obligations, these debts, these commitments which we inherited——"
Mr. Dillon: There were no debts.
Mr. MacEntee: I can assure the Deputy that there were. These commitments, these obligations, these contracts which we inherited were of such magnitude that before six months were out the whole of the £24,000,000 had to be expended in meeting the obligations of our predecessors."
Now remember, observe the word "debt" is never used. It continues:—
"Here is how they were met. There was a cash deficit on the 1951 Budget on 3lst December of at least £5,000,000.
Mr. Dillon: There was none.
Mr. MacEntee: There was spent on voted capital services £6.3 million. There was advanced to the E.S.B., to enable them to carry out plans that had been projected and that were actually in the course of implementation when we took office, £6.4 million."
Comment on this
Yes, it was; but we had said to the country and to our successors: "You ought to spend this on developing electricity supply in Ireland"; and the incoming Government said: "Yes". We agreed it ought to be spent on this capital purpose ofdeveloping electricity. We both agreed upon it and £6,000,000 was spent.
Comment on this
We did—and you advanced it to the E.S.B. The quotation continues:—
"There was advanced to the Local Loans Fund £6.3 millions."
Comment on this
Did the Fianna Fáil Government advance to the Local Loans Fund £6.3 millions to enable people to borrow money to build their own houses? They did or they did not. Deputy MacEntee says they did. If they did, it must have been there. They could not have advanced it if they had not got it.
Comment on this
The quotation continues:—
"There was advanced to Bord na Móna £860,000."
The question I want to ask is: "Did Fianna Fáil advance £860,000 to Bord na Móna or did they not?" If they did, it must have been there. They could not have advanced it otherwise. Is not that so? So it seems to me. They advanced to Telephone Capital £1,600,000. Did they so do?
Comment on this
No, no, no. The money was there. We had told the Parliament and the country we were going to develop the bogs, we were going to build houses, we were going to extend rural electrification. we were going to reclaim land and to help in telephone extension. It was quite open to our successors when they came into office to say: "We will not develop bogs, or build houses, or extend telephones. "They did not say that; they came in and said: "Yes, we will do that." And all they had to do was to put their hand out and there was the money on the desk, to lend out. Deputies will remember that we said to the Minister for Finance: "Do not take that money; go for a national loan at 3½ per cent.; use what you borrow from our own people for these capital purposes and if you want a part of this £24,000,000 you can add it to what you borrow from our own people and keep the rest in reserve." The Minister for Finance refused to do that. He spent all this money that we left there. In the following year he had to go for a loan and when he had to go for a loan the moneylender produced the hot tongs and they said: "There is 5 per cent. on the brand now; it used to be only 3½, so long as you had £24,000,000 to fall back on."
Comment on this
They said: "Now that you have not got sixpence to get along with, there is 5 per cent. on the hot tongs and when you put out your nose we are going to put `5 per cent.' on both nostrils"—and they did. I would not mind if just the two sides of Deputy MacEntee's nose were decorated with the figure "5" but that meant, because his nose bore the numeral "5", that everyone who wanted to build his own house, when he went to borrow from the local authority discovered that they had a hot tongs, too, and they put 6 per cent. on it, when you translated that down to individuals. You found the man who built a house under the inter-Party Government for the occupation of himself and his family could redeemthe cost at 22/- a week; but his next door neighbour who went to build the same house in the same municipal or rural area to set up a similar family next door, discovered that under the new dispensation what his neighbour could get for 22/- was going to cost him 34/-. When they found it was 34/- a week, dozens of young men so circumstanced made up their minds that they could not afford 34/-. They went to the small builders who were building houses for them to buy, under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts, and told them they could not take them. Those small builders, to my knowledge, put their houses on the market and could not sell them—and the banks sold them up. I know two small builders who two years ago employed five men; and the two small builders and the five men who worked for them are all drawing unemployment assistance to-day at the same exchange. That is the difference between our policy and the policy of Fianna Fáil.
I dare swear that in amongst the the men misled in the streets of Dublin you will find quite a number of small contractors, linked to-day in those demonstrations with the chaps whom they employed five years ago; and I ask Fianna Fáil to-night: "Are you proud of that performance?" Was it better to have them working building houses for our neighbours than to be holding them at bay from the gates of our own Parliament with the promise of relief measures?
We all have long memories in this country, Sir, and I do not want to revive them to-night; but with present to my mind the memories that all of us have, I say deliberately that Fianna Fáil has done no greater injury to this country than to create a situation in which 2,000 of our neighbours could accept the leadership of some of the gentlemen who profess to represent organised labour in the street riots that they have sought to precipitate. Maybe it is not popular for me to say it, but I say it to my own neighbours in this city where I was born: let them not misunderstand those who profess solicitude for them to-day. So certainly as I am in this House, I am convinced that the main purpose of those who pretend to befriend them is to spilltheir blood in the streets of their own capital city. I pray to God that that foul purpose will not be encompassed and that the men will still believe that there are elements in this House and influence in this House to put right what is wrong quicker than, and better than, those who do not belong to them could ever hope to do. I pray that we can carry conviction out beyond this House to the men, that those who are their neighbours and amongst whom they were born are infinitely more interested to see them in the enjoyment of their full rights in their own country than fly-by-nights who care nothing for them and who are using them for a base, ulterior motive at the present time. God forgive Fianna Fáil for giving these people the chance to do what they appear so successfully to be doing now.
I say the Minister for Finance and his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, are mad when they return to the theme that our people are eating too much, drinking too much and smoking too much. Can you imagine, in the atmosphere in which we are living, that the Minister for Finance would rush to send a letter to the public Press to say that it is illusory to speak of anyone in this country suffering any economic pressure at present, when 3,000,000 are spending £60,000,000 a year on drink and tobacco? He conveniently wipes out of his consideration any consumption by tourists and also exports. Any member of this House who is a member for a Border constituency knows well the dimensions of the export trade in more than one of these commodities. But there is a passionate desire to prove, common sense notwithstanding, which is at the bottom of all that Fianna Fáil have done in the past two years, that our people are getting too big for their hats, that they are aspiring to live too well and that it is the duty of a realistic Irish Government to get them back down into the dust where they belong. What has happened to Fianna Fáil? What has happened to any Party of this House that arrogates to itself the traditional task of the oppressors of our people and that was to tell them to get back inthe dirt where they belong? Ought we not be proud if we can create a situation in this country whereby our people aspire to and succeed in attaining to a higher standard of life than they had before? Why is it that Fianna Fáil get into a panic at the thought that our people are enjoying amenities remotely analogous to those which are the average experience of the people of Great Britain or continental countries? The inter-Party Government's aim and object was to expand and develop exports so that the exports from the land of Ireland would amply pay for what the free desire of our people, in the enjoyment of a decent standard of life, would import.
Were we wrong in that? We saw no evil in a growing volume of imports if they were met by a growing volume of exports. On the contrary, we said that, by that barometer, the standard of our people's living is rising and that is something we glory in. We want to raise it still further. We want to see the volume of exports constantly expanding, with a corresponding expansion on the import side—for that is the sure barometer of the standard of living of any people in any country in the world. Were we wrong in that?
Comment on this
Does Deputy Beegan honestly believe that the standard of living of our people has gone up in the past two years? Does he believe that?
Comment on this
You are clean daft. Pause a moment and think. Take an ordinary working man to-day who pays 4/2 a lb. for butter which, under the inter-Party Government, he was getting for 2/8; who pays 2/- a stone more for flour, 2d. a lb. more for sugar——
Comment on this
Does Deputy Beegan believe that the standard of living of such a man has gone up? Upon my word, I am sometimes consternated by the mentality that the Fianna Fáil Party itself reveals. I think they just do not know. I think they do not know because they will not look, and I think the reason they will not look is that they are afraid to look.
Comment on this
If our living costs are so very high here, what is the explanation for the smuggling that is alleged to take place across the Border? Why is it alleged that thousands of cigarettes are being smuggled across the Border?
Comment on this
There are children in County Wicklow who, since the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952, have not been able to get enough bread to eat because their parents could not pay the high price for it.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Beegan rebut that the cost of living is rising in Ireland and that the standard of living of most of our people is going down by adducing as a proof that this-key is going across the Border? What relation has the smuggling of whiskey to Northern Ireland to the standard of living of a man, his wife and four children in Dublin City or in South Cork?
Comment on this
There are only three Fianna Fáil Deputies in the House at the moment—Deputy Beegan from Galway, Deputy Walsh from Louth and Deputy M. O'Reilly from Meath.
Comment on this
Well, I ask him to take Deputy Beegan aside and tell him whether, in Deputy Larry Walsh's judgment, the Standard of living of the ordinary working people of Drogheda has gone up in the past two years.
Comment on this
——than they were two years ago and that the increased cost of their weekly food bill has caused them no reduction in their standard of living?
Comment on this
Deputy Larry Walsh was born and reared in Drogheda. He knows the people in his own town. He goes on record here as saying that the standard of living of the working people in Drogheda has gone up in the past two years.
Comment on this
Deputy Walsh says that the people of Drogheda are better off to-day than they were two years ago. The last time Deputy Walsh and myself had an exchange in this House half the people of Drogheda used to follow him around mewing like a cat. I do not know what they will do the next time.
Comment on this
I respect a loyal old wheel horse like that who says: "Whatever it may cost me when I get home, I will stick to the chief when he wants me". I like loyalty. It is agood quality in any man, but it is a poor consolation to those who depend on Deputy Walsh's voice to defend their interests in this House.
Comment on this
Our town was never better off since it was first established than it has been since 1932.
Comment on this
I should like to say this to the Labour Party. I remember a time when the trade unions in Drogheda had not sufficient income to pay the secretary of the union. He had to be paid from headquarters in Dublin. That was pre-1932. That is not the case to-day, thanks to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Order! If Deputy Walsh cannot cease interrupting I will have to ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
With great deference, I must say that I am afraid I gave Deputy Walsh provocation, and if I caused him to be disturbed I accept full responsibility and offer my apologies.
Comment on this
I am sorry Deputy Gallagher is not here now, because I want to direct the attention of the House to a very important fact. Every week, there is published in Iris Oifigiúilthe Exchequer returns. The last item on the revenue side is described as “sundry receipts”. Deputy Sweetman had the curiosity to putdown a question asking of what these “sundry receipts” consisted. He discovered that the sundry receipts in 1953, between the 1st April and the 11th July—I would ask Fianna Fáil Deputies to listen to this—were £1,300,000 higher than they were in 1952.
Comment on this
The first interesting item is that the interest on Exchequer advances is up by £400,000; the second interesting feature is that the Central Bank payment to the Exchequer on foot of surplus income is up from £100,000 to £200,000; but the next is, I think, the most dramatic figure of all. I notice that I have a new recruit, Deputy Cunningham from Donegal. Does he remember being told that the inter-Party Government squandered the Marshall Aid funds, that they dissipated them? Deputy Walsh, the Mayor of Drogheda, remembers it. I have now actually recruited the Minisfor Finance and I should like him to enlarge on this when he comes to wind up the debate. The third item in the sundry receipts in 1952 was nil, which means nothing, Deputy, and, in 1953, the third item amounted to £568,075. I should be very grateful to Deputy Walsh if he would take the Minister for Finance aside and ask him to explain this description of that receipt from the Exchequer—"Payment from the American Loan Counterpart Fund to cover interest on dollar borrowing."
Comment on this
Where did it come from? Where did a sum of £568,075 come from, when there was nothing there? Remember that that is not the remnant of a fund. That is the first drawing on a growing accumulation of money and it is drawing of sterling which the minister has found possible to convert into dollars. Is that not true? Deputy Walsh was sent down toDrogheda to tell the people that the money was all gone and nothing but debts left all about the floor.
The decent, innocent man went down and staked the honour and the reputation of the Mayor of Drogheda on that proposition. Is it beginning to dawn on him now that that little man took him for a ride, that he made a fool of him and was guilty of the last treason to friendship of sending Deputy Walsh down to his own neighbours who trusted him and took it on his word because he gave his word that what he said was true? They are now beginning to find out that the whole thing was a dirty fraud, that Deputy Walsh had been taken in by the Minister for Finance, on whose testimony he depended, and had been used to mislead his own neighbours who gladly took his unsubstantiated word for whatever he chose to tell them.
If Deputy Walsh doubts a word of what I say, let him draw the Minister for Finance aside in some private place and ask him ihis question: in what were the Counterpart Funds of the Marshall Aid Counterpart Fund invested by him and by his predecessor? Let him ask him what income is derived from these investments and, lastly, what are the annual charges by way of interest which he has to meet and what is the annual income from interest which that Loan Counterpart Fund, upon which he now begins to draw, receives. The only thing that will astonish Deputy Walsh is this, that, when we went borrowing from ourselves, we could pay only 3½ per cent. interest, but when we went borrowing from the moneylenders, we paid 5 per cent. I want to ask Deputy Walsh this revolutionary question: how long does he think it right that our people should be required to pay through their own Government 6 1/4 per cent. for the money wherewith to finance the building of houses for themselves and their families at the same time as we have on permanent loan to the British Government over £60,000,000 sterling at 1 1/4 per cent.?
Comment on this
Will Deputy Walshanswer that question to his satisfaction or the satisfaction of anybody else? Everything I have got is invested in this country. If this country went down in the morning, I and those belonging to me, would be penniless paupers and I have been accustomed all my life to a certain modicum of comfort. I do not think anyone could conceivably believe that I was indifferent to the stability of the community on which I depend for my very existence and for the existence of my family. I want to go on deliberate record here as saying that no Minister for Finance of this country can conceivably justify to this Legislature any future borrowing on behalf of our people for essential capital services at 5 per cent. to the moneylender, while we are lending ten times as much to another Government at 1 1/4 per cent.
We were all taught to judge a tree by its fruit. We were taught as children and as men that a bad tree cannot bear good fruit, but that a good tree in all human probability will. Our policy in this country was to borrow our people's savings and invest them in our people and in the land they lived on. I will make no apology for trespassing on the time of this House to tell again the fruit of that policy, for I am proud of it, and we had only three short years in which to operate. In these three years. I ask the House to remember that we increased the exports of this country from £39,000,000 per annum to £101,000.000 per annum.
Of that, agricultural exports represented approximately £30,000,000 in 1947 and £75,000,000 in 1952. I want this House to remember that when we took office there were fewer live stock on the land of Ireland than at any time in the previous half century.
Comment on this
They did not, but listen to the record expressed not in terms of estimates but in terms of exports made, paid for and used to raise the standard of living of our people. Cattle in all forms exported in 1948 amounted to 405,000 head and to 523,000 head in 1949.
Comment on this
Granted, but they were not slaughtered when I did come in. That is the difference. There is no use in the poor cow having a calf if the Minister for Agriculture is going round with a razor. One of the fundamentals of our policy was to use razors in this country for shaving human beings and leave the calves alone except in so far as the skins of the dead ones were used to strop the razors to shave the farmers. Eighty thousand calves per annum were buried every year that Fianna Fáil was in office and in 1951 the total mortality of calves in Ireland was reduced to 12,000 from 80,000.
It is true, as Deputy Allen says, that all these cattle were not born when we came into office but by the mercy of God's Providence and the inter-Party Government they were allowed to live. Four hundred and five thousand of the survivors of the holocaust of the years before went out in 1948; 523,000 went out in 1949; 591,000 went out in 1950 and 642,000 went out in 1951.
Comment on this
When you add to this the astonishing fact that over the same period the stock of cattle on the land increased from 3,900,000 to 4,300,000 you see the initial results of a policy which did more to rehabilitate the economy of this country than was done by anything else which any Government took on. We borrowed the people's money to rehabilitate the land. In 1951 directly and indirectly the land project in Ireland employed 10,000 men and the work of every single one of those men was designed not to confer benefit on our people for a year but for a generation. Every field in Ireland where the land project worked will show the result of that work when everyone in Oireachtas Eireann to-day is dead, buried and forgotten.
Was that good work? Was that public money well spent? Will anyone say that the man whose work will leave a track on the land of Ireland three generations hence was doing relief work? He was doing the best work that any man could undertake in this country and we borrowed money to pay for it. I say that every penny we borrowed, every penny we intended to borrow and every penny we intend to borrow for that purpose will be well spent in employing our people on the only thing that matters in the last analysis in Ireland—the land.
I shall not read about—I have done so once before—the steady increase that manifested itself in every branch of production from the land. I shall not remind the House unduly that the Minister for Finance recorded that he founded his policy in 1952 on the proposition that there was no hope or prospect of agricultural exports substantially relieving the balance of payments situation. I now declare that almost alone the expansion of agricultural exports from this country has resolved in totothe whole problem of our balance of payments as we confidently foretold. Compare that fruit I have described over three short years of our policy with 18 years plus two of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Yes, 16 years, plus two. It felt like 90. I lived through it all. Look at the devastation on the land that was there when we took over. Look now at the quasi riots in the streets of Dublin. Yes, that is the word. Let us not burk at it. That is the gravest thing that has happened as far as my memory goes. Is there a single Deputy of Fianna Fáil who does not feel a sense of guilt for what he has done? They were warned but they did it in spite of all the warnings they got. I do not think I speak too strongly when I say that for what has transpired in this city in the last six weeks posterity will curse the name of Fianna Fáil.
I conclude by saying I am as sure to-day as ever I was that the resources of this country courageously exploited and prudently employed are sufficientto provide for our people in their own country not wealth or affluence but comfort, security and dignity in their own homes. I say to those who are inclined to believe that their best friends are outside the Legislature of this country that they are being Misled. There is the means, there is the will and there is the way to correct their undoubted grievances through the medium of their own sovereign Parliament, and anyone who advises them to look to other means for relief is not concerned for their interests but is concerned for some base ulterior motive which can only harm those who are now being used for it.
I say, lastly, if Fianna Fáil have grown too timid to use the resources of this country for the welfare of our people, if they have grown too tired, too frightened, or confused, there is a constitutional way to resolve that dilemma. Come to the country. The people will not do wrong. They will either send Fianna Fáil back here rehabilitated, or they will dismiss them. I will accept either verdict; but in God's name, look for that verdict before your follies have done damage to Ireland that no successor will be able to repair.
Comment on this
I propose to accept the advice of the Deputy from East Cork. I will be brief in my remarks. I want to indicate at the outset that I am not going to support the Vote on Account because in so doing I would be associating myself with the implication of— in some manner—endorsing the policy of the Government who are seeking the vote, and of the Government Departments whose Estimates are not wet dealt with. That policy has been vigorously described by previous speakers and has brought undue misery to the country. I have only to suggest that it was not, or should not have been, done by one man. The operations of the people who have framed that policy, starting with the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance and the members of the Cabinet generally—whatever about the members of the Fianna Fáil Party—I believe they definitely and deliberately sought to bring about what has happened. There may be some wonderment at theresult of their actions, because in sowing the wind they did not expect to reap the whirlwind which has swept over the country.
But they were determinedly setting themselves to reduce employment. That cannot be denied. Statements we have had from the Taoiseach himself, on a number of occasions, notably at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis two years ago, confirm that. Speaking at the Ard Fheis he said—referring to the land project, which had been started by Deputy Dillon—that that was like taking money from the banks in London where it was earning small interest and utilising it for the purpose of ploughing the rocks into the sea at Connemara. He dismissed that project with those rather sneering remarks, which I thought came very ill from the Leader of this country, particularly having regard to the part of the country to which he was referring. I believe that an effort made—particularly in Connemara—to restore even six or seven acres of ground to the people who had been scratching among the rocks for generations and to enable them to till it—would be better than transferring them to the Midlands or to the South of Ireland to the big farms. It would be doing something to preserve and concentrate the Gaeltacht which we hear so much about. The Taoiseach indicated that it was not by any means a worthy or a suitable object for which to transfer the bank balances in London—this ill-planned scheme of ploughing the rocks into the sea at Connemara.
He also mentioned later that we should tighten our belts, eat less, and restore those balances frittered away by the dissolute inter-Party Government. Bank balances seem to be the be-all and end-all, but surely those who decided that policy of the present Government must have been aware of the results that would follow from it. If we were to tighten our belts and eat less, we were going to create unemployment and put more people out of employment.
The Taoiseach also stated that wages were catching up with prices as if that was some kind of offence which should not happen at all. We, of the Labourmovement working directly for the working-class interests, have always been struggling to try to get parity between prices and wages but we always found ourselves trailing slowly up the ladder. The prices got a flying start and we never caught up with them. We have not caught up with them now. Prices seem to have the happy knack of eluding the worker who is trying to get a decent standard of life.
We have had references here to the standard of life of our people, and while I hold with previous speakers that we have not reached the standard of life to which we are entitled, I wonder if the members of the Government and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party assert with Mr. Walsh from Drogheda that we have improved our standard of life to the extent that there is no cause for the complaint. I have to disagree completely and totally with that. The facts stand out for themselves. Our people who tried to ensure that the workers would reach some measure of comfort and get a decent standard of life and keep money circulating here, were doing a good job for the nation in trying to prevent the emigration that was taking place, to prevent people going over as a bodyguard to mind those pounds we are sending out to be lodged in the banks in England. Approximately £15,000,000 has been sent over in the past 12 months and I would like to know the number of men who went with that £15,000,000, because we have no record to tell us how many are going out. We could be told rather glibly this evening that the ranks of the unemployed at our labour exchanges to-day are swelled by workers returning from England. I wonder does anybody believe that? Deputy Beegan, who was supported by Deputy Killilea, stated to-night that the men were returning from London, Birmingham and Manchester——