We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 621–812 of 812. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

He may have said they were coming back to work, but they are going also and with a vengeance. There are agents working through the country still as they were in the bad old days and sending men not alone to England but to Canada. One big agency is organising workers to bring them to Toronto.

Comment on this

Every week.

Comment on this

This, of course, was one of the solutions that must have been in mind when we were told about tightening our belts, eating less and restoring the bank balances. I think it is clear to everybody except to those too blind to see it, that the policy of the Government since they came back into office is a policy of sinking this country down to the lowest level it ever had to endure.

Deputy Burke of Dublin Was speaking here an hour or two ago and indicated clearly the abysmal gulf between Fianna Fáil front benchers and their back benchers. He talked as if he was on a beautiful green. To use his own words, everything was lovely in the garden. He said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had made a great job of work of everything to which he put his hand. I am not making any reflections on the Tánaiste—a very able and competent statesman—or making any reflection on any Minister or any individual Department, but I am making a set on the overriding policy which governed those Ministers and prevented them from doing their job in the interests of the country. The net results of their efforts have been reflected in the Local Government Department and in every Department of State. The housing question, on which money was being utilised, surely could not be shelved as not being desirable project. We had need for housing going back for 100 years. Our people had been used to cabins or mud hovels and the cities had their slums. We had the problem of 110,000 houses to be built according to a medical survey of the country. That projectwas got down to, and accelerated to the highest pitch, and building operatives were geared up to the extent that they produced 1,000 houses per month.

Comment on this

We did more than that.

Comment on this

There was no fear that we were going to have the job finished very quickly. Between the houses and the hospitals there was ten or 15 years' complete employment for all building operatives in this country staring them straight in the face—guaranteed employment. Whatever truth may be in the story about men coming back from England now they came back then. That progress has been shattered. Building has receded; a recession has taken place both in public building and in private building.

Private building is practically non estat present owing to the high cost of money as has been explained by other speakers. We do know that in every constituency private building has practically come to an end and builders cannot sell the houses they have already built. Men who hitherto were inclined to take advantage both of the Government grants and county council and corporation loans for the purpose of acquiring new houses are not availing of these facilities now because their weekly outgoings would be beyond their capacity to bear. What a contrast that all is to the condition of affairs which prevailed when everybody concerned set to work with energy and enthusiasm to promote the housing drive, until Fianna Fáil brought their blighting hand to bear on the situation in 1951?

The cost of living, following the withdrawal of the subsidies, has, of course, caused very serious reactions amongst the people, poor and semi-poor. It is not even the destitute poor who are badly hit; working class families and fairly well off families have felt the very severe effect of the withdrawal of the food subsidies. They are now called upon to pay 4/2 per lb-for butter but notwithstanding the fact that they are compelled to purchase lesser amounts and that some of them have been driven to buyingcheaper substitutes, we are told by some Fianna Fáil back benchers that the standard of living of the people in Drogheda has gone up in the last three years. That is another of the dreams of Deputy Walsh and Deputy Burke. Deputy Burke thinks that everything in the garden is lovely and that there Can be nothing wrong so long as Fianna Fáil is at the helm.

The allegation has also been made against our unemployed that they refused to take work and that they refused to go to the Bord na Móna bogs. Whilst we have had visible demonstrations from massed battalions in Dublin of the unemployment which prevails in this city, unemployment is not confined to Dublin. We have pro rataunemployment throughout the country. We do not have these demonstrations in the country, but none the less we have unemployment stalking through the land, and that has been contributed to in no small measure by Government policy. The Local Authorities (Works) Act, which was designed specifically to give employment in rural areas and to be worked in conjunction with the land drainage project, so that there would be an out-fall in the proper places to take the water off the land, has in part been suspended. A good deal of work had already been done in that direction by the construction of slips or culverts and by attention to road subsidences in various places. All that work was done with the aid of a free grant from the Government without any cost to the rates. It gave employment to men in rural areas and ensured that the money expended on the land project would be utilised to the best advantage. Yet, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs in particular, has denounced that scheme bell, book and candle on a number of occasions. Speaking at Ballymahon he said that: “This scandalous waste of public funds must be stopped.” Grants under the Local Authorities (Works) Act have been reduced to one-sixth of the amount paid by the inter-Party. Government. They have not been cut off completely but for all the work that can be done with the amount of money now provided, it would be almost justas well if they were. Schemes approved of by the various county engineers and submitted to the Department of Local Government are still lying there, and some of those which had got approval from the Department have been knocked off owing, we are told, to financial stress. The policy of unemployment is apparently to have its way.

As I said, the Government have sown the wind and we can expect them to reap the whirlwind. If the Government now decides to bring in relief schemes it will not be because of any arguments advanced in this Dáil. It will be purely because of the force and the stress of the demonstrations which have taken place in Dublin. These people, by their parades through the streets, have focussed the attention alike of the citizens and of visitors from other countries to the conditions which prevail, not alone in Dublin but throughout the country, and they have succeeded in bringing to the Government some realisation of the hardships they are enduring. We are inclined to face the sufferings of these people with smugness and complacency. Apart from the suggestions that have been made by previous speakers as to the motive of these demonstrations, I do not know that there is any ulterior motive or any leadership from outside behind them, but the unemployed of the City of Dublin are undoubtedly entitled to demonstrate and to protest their right as citizens to get employment here. It is the first function of any Government to provide employment for its employable citizens. Our available money resources could not be used in a better way. Whether money is to be provided by way of internal loans or by Marshall Aid it could not be better employed than in putting people to useful work throughout the country. There are schemes in plenty and they are only awaiting attention.

As I said earlier, we had references to some of our people being slackers. I resent that strongly. Our workers are looking for work and they are prepared to work. They proved that during the European war when our people went from this country in hundreds ofthousands and were prepared to work under showers of German shells and bombs. They were not afraid to work under those conditions in England when work was denied them at home. The Wages Standstill Order was then in operation and the Taoiseach said that he could not allow organised workers to get any increase in wages that would give them an unfair purchasing power for commodities in a limited and diminishing market. Yet these men were entitled to go to England and to send back any money they earned to this country. England in all her trouble never refused to avail of the efforts of the Irish workers. They were welcome to go to work in England and to send back all their spare cash to their wives and families here, but evidently that was not considered as creating any unfair purchasing power on a limited commodity market.

Evidently the moral in those days was that people who could find work in England should be exported to keep down the figures for unemployment here. I say these men and women showed no hesitation in going over to England to make a living for themselves and for their families, a living denied to them at home. That they were willing and prepared to work at home if work was provided for them, is shown by the fact that they went to England where they had to work under the almost impossible conditions of German bombing and shelling.

We know that in some areas at present Bord na Móna has closed down certain bogs. Dublin men may not be 100 per cent. suitable for work on bogs, but if they do go to work on a bog the conditions under which they have to work are by no means attractive. A wage of £4 10s. a week, with £2 stopped for board and lodging, leaves them with only £2 1Os. for themselves. It is said that they can earn more by the piece-work system, but men who have gone on to piece-work are being constantly shifted from it and put on a low weekly wage. Before we condemn such workers as slackers, we should at least inquire into the conditions under which they are asked to work and promises should not be held out to them if there is no intention of keeping these promises.

I am not going to delay the House very much longer because as I say, any statements we make in this House are not going to influence the Government in their policy. They will be influenced only by circumstances, not by fair argument in this House, but at least it must now be evident that the policy which they have pursued up to the present has brought the country to the position in which it is to-day. It cannot be alleged that that policy was operated in ignorance of existing conditions.

They must have been aware of what they were doing. Whether their motive was for spite, to injure the inter-Party Government, irrespective of what ruin that brought in its train, they sowed these seeds of desolation and destruction. They have reaped the whirlwind and I repeat now the appeal made by other Deputies: before they sink the ship they ought to get out or else change their policy to a common-sense, constructive policy, and get away from the slavish regard for English bank balances built up by our internal assets, apart from external assets, in order to give us a happy and contented Irish nation, happy contented Irish workmen engaged in building Irish homes for themselves to enable them to marry in happiness and prosperity. That will not come, however, so long as Fianna Fáil sticks to the policy that has characterised them since they came in again to office in 1951.

Comment on this

It is very interesting to hear one's policy interpreted by one's opponents. One looks at the interpretation in a vain effort to recognise the policy for what it is. I have been listening to Deputy Keyes now for a little while and, having listened to him, one would imagine that ours was not a Party that did more for the workers of this country than did Deputy Keyes and his Party; and to-day we represent more of the workers in this country than does Deputy Keyes or his Party.

Comment on this

The standstill Order!

Comment on this

From the beginning we have striven to create conditions here which would enable our people tostay at home and find useful employment in their own country. All through, that has been the basis of our policy.

Comment on this

And the workers realise it.

Comment on this

Why have you failed?

Comment on this

Wait and see. What is this policy about which Deputy Keyes has been talking to-night? There were three fundamental points in that policy. The first part of that policy was that we should balance current expenditure by current revenue. Do Deputy Keyes and his friends stand for that or do they not? Do the former Ministers, now occupying the Opposition Front Bench, stand for that? Does Fine Gael stand for that? On the assumption that in 1952 there was a deficit of £15,000,000, will the Opposition say now that in order to bridge the gap there should not be the necessary tax impositions? Remember, it is only through taxation the money could be found to meet that deficit.

Comment on this

There was £40,000,000 in 1947.

Comment on this

The easy way out is to put one's head in the sand and pretend the deficit does not exist, pretend there is a surplus of £10,000,000 and allege that we are imposing £10,000,000 unnecessary taxation on the people. Deputies talk about the subsidies and the reduction in the amount of the subsidies. Had we not reduced the subsidies we would have had to find another £4,000,000 odd. It is true that we reduced the subsidies but, in order to offset that reduction, we gave compensatory allowances in other directions. When we first introduced subsidies the Labour Party tried to pretend that the subsidies were of no use: the taxation that would have to be raised to meet the subsidies was the important thing. Now, one cannot have it both ways. No human being can have it both ways. No Government can have it both ways.

We had a deficit and we had to meet that deficit. I challenge anybody to say that that particular item of our policy was not right. I challenge anyoneto say that it was wrong for us to seek to balance current expenditure by current revenue. Instead of having this surplus of £10,000,000 for which it was alleged we were imposing unnecessary taxation, in the end it turned out that even the taxation we imposed was not sufficient to bring about a balance. Deputy O'Higgins referred to this £30,000,000 that we are now seeking in order to carry on the services necessary for our people; he said that that sum was introduced in three minutes. When that money was being asked for in the first instance, a full explanation was given. Was there any Deputy in the House who, when Estimates were introduced, came forward and asked that they should be reduced? The Opposition wants to have it both ways. On the one hand the Labour Party wants further expenditure and an increase in certain allowances and benefits; on the other hand, the friends with whom they combine want to have it the other way. The Opposition cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

You are giving it to the bankers.

Comment on this

The bankers are always the scapegoats for people who have not got the courage to face up to a particular situation. I am giving the House hard facts. If the Opposition does not want to accept them, they should let the country know what their position is. They should tell the people they do not accept them. Let Fine Gael tell the country they do not accept them.

Comment on this

We told them in Wicklow.

Comment on this

You did not. You had again the two voices there— Deputy Davin, on the one hand, and Deputy O'Higgins on the other. Take the speeches that were made here and compare them and ponder on these two diametrically opposite viewpoints expressed by people who believe, or appear to believe, they could combine and stand over some policy in opposition to the policy of the present Government.That is one point of our policy. That is one aspect that is worthy of study.

We in Fianna Fáil have a policy. We stand over that policy and there will be no change in so far as we can prevent a change. So long as we are the Government here we will try to balance current expenditure by current revenue. If we fail to do that over a reasonable period of time, then we will admit that we have failed in one of the fundamental tasks of government. Wherever that task has been shirked in any country in the world, disaster has followed. That is point No. 1. That is our policy, to balance current expenditure by current revenue and not anybody else's policy.

Comment on this

Profits to the moneylenders.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a grand scapegoat. Those who think the people do not understand will try every misstatement and every piece of stupid reasoning.

Comment on this

Answer it.

Comment on this

The answer is that that is the first point in our policy and I challenge the Opposition to say whether or not they stand for that.

Comment on this

We do not.

Comment on this

What is the alternative? Let us hear the alternative.

Comment on this

Find work for the people.

Comment on this

Stay a while. I will come to that in due course. As to the next point in our policy. so far as capital expenditure was concerned it was we who initiated the idea of utilising the resources of our own country for State capital purposes. We never objected to the use of State capital or the resources of our own country by the State for productive purposes.

We hear a good deal about works under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. It is claimed that these are productice. It would be interesting to find out the extent to which they have been productive and the extent towhich they brought back any return for the moneys expended. We have never, at any time, objected to the use of the resources of the country for productive purposes.

That has been a fundamental part of the policy of Fianna Fáil from the day on which it was founded and we have consistently pursued that arm. Time and time again we have stated here that so long as productive projects are reasonably economic in their nature, there never was and never will be, so far as we are concerned, any difficulty in finding money to finance them. But we went further than that. We said that there were certain projects which were not economically productive in the ordinary sense, projects that made for the well-being of our people in a variety of ways. Housing was one of them. We were always ready to engage in housing and we always found the money necessary for housing. The entire housing programme that has been carried out in this country was and is based on Acts passed during the Fianna Fáil administration.

Deputy Keyes spoke about the progress in housing that was made during the régime of the Coalition Government. We have always admitted that that was the one part of their programme in which they showed any ability and all they did was to put into operation the schemes they found already in existence. They were handed over a working concern in full operation. The proof of that lies in the fact that in the year before the war broke out we had built more houses here than had been built by anybody who preceded us, and since we returned we have the next two highest figures. More work has been done in the last two years in relation to housing than was done during the régime of the Coalition Government.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

When were those houses started?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

There was about the same in the machine when we took over again in 1951 as there was when the Coalition Government assumedoffice. That is an incontrovertible fact.

Comment on this

It is nonsense.

Comment on this

I have studied it. I have seen that that is true. In the first year after coming back into office we increased operations. Now housing, like many other things, is limited in its scope. If one makes an intensive effort and employs a large number of people on a particular scheme, in time one comes to the end of that scheme. That is happening now in parts of the country and the task that the local authorities in those areas saw before them in 1947 has almost reached completion. The completion of that task will leave a problem behind it of providing constructive work for those who were engaged in building houses. We will not be faced with that problem in Dublin for some time, because we have yet some eight or ten years' building programme ahead of us here.

There was a hold-up in Dublin, not because of any action by the Government but because there was some difficulty affecting some 8,000 or 10,000 houses in connection with the carrying out of a main drainage scheme on the north side of the city. Everything that we could do to stimulate house building, as far as local authorities are concerned, we have done. There has been talk about the rate of interest. The Government have endeavoured to minimise any effect that could have on local authorities by increasing grants and so on.

As far as housing is concerned, we have a record which Will never be beaten, in my opinion, in this country, because probably there never will be a situation again in which there will be such a crying need for houses as there was when we took over the problem of dealing with the housing situation. We have, then, the second part of our policy, the use of the resources of this country, first, for economically productive purposes and, secondly, to the extent to which we can reasonably go, for amenity and other purposes. Is there anything obscurantist, as someone has said, about that? Is it notcommon sense? The point is that you have to organise to get these works done. Very often you have to find out the projects that, on the one hand, are productive and, on the other hand, are of the other sort, and you have to achieve a fair proportion between them. The private individual, no mere than the State, can spend too much of his income or resources in beautifying his estate. If he wants himself and his family to continue in a reasonable state of comfort he will have to see that there is productive work being done and, side by side with it, that only a fair proportion of his resources are used for non-productive purposes.

I ask anyone here: Who objects to that programme? What is wrong about it? Let us see what is wrong about it. Where is there a case in which there has been clearly productive work that we have not done, or in which we have not been ready to use the national resources in doing it? Where is there a project of an amenity character that is reasonable, having regard to our resources, that we have failed to try to carry out?

Comment on this

The Works Act.

Comment on this

I have looked into the land projects, and one of the things that horrified me was to find that there was £70 an acre or so paid for reclaiming land which, in a few years' time, will probably be producing only rushes.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The average was £8 an acre.

Comment on this

I am talking about one case. I say that we have not abandoned the Local Authorities (Works) Act, nor have we abandoned the land project as it is called.

Comment on this

You scrapped it.

Comment on this

We did not. It was we who started the whole idea of reclaiming land and improving land. We started it in our early years, and we did more, and are now doing more, of that work than was done by the Coalition Government. The point is that we are trying to use common sense, that we are trying, in regard toall these things, to use the nation's money in such a way that it will give reasonable results. I have already said in regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act, that the Coalition had already cut down the grant for it by £500,000 before we came into office. One of the reasons is that when a project is started there are certain things which it will be desirable to get done and, naturally, these will be done first. That has happened in a number of cases. The cream has been skimmed off, and the schemes that were reasonably useful have been dealt with. Wherever it can be shown that work is reasonably useful, it has not been the policy of our Government to deny money for that purpose.

There is another point. There is more money being spent on the roads and more employment being given on the roads now than in the time of the Coalition. There is far more money being spent on the roads which will give the same sort of employment as that which was given in the case of the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

Comment on this

What is the labour content?

Comment on this

Labour content? I can get any amount of labour content by digging a hole and filling it up again. What we want to do is to try and get the maximum labour content in works that are useful and productive. When the Labour Party are talking about these things they take care to put in the word "productive," but when we try to search for productive work we are asked what is the labour content as if that was the only thing that mattered. We have to try to get work that will be reasonably productive.

The second point in our programme is the use of our resources—the financial and natural resources of the country. Who was it that developed the bogs? Who was it that, in the main developed the rivers of this country? Was it not our Party, just as it was our Party that built the vast majority of the houses in the country? What is the use of talking to us as if we were people who had no interestwhatever in the development of the country or in the people of the country? It is all talk from some of those benches, and nothing more. We have done more than talk; we have done work and have got results, too, and we are going to get more results. We had a situation facing us and we met it in the proper way. As a consequence of it, we have a new situation. We did settle one thing, in the main, that is the meeting of current expenditure by current revenue. We have been developing the resources and the productivity of the country, and, in addition to that, we have succeeded in bringing about a reasonable balance in our international payments account.

Comment on this

And more unemployment?

Comment on this

In the year when we came back into office, the adverse balance was £61,000,000 odd. We had not the opportunity of dealing with it then, but the moment we got the opportunity we took measures to do so. Things could have happened in spite of us which might have given different results, but happily we secured a situation in which the deficit in our balance of payments now is one that we need not regard in the same way as the £30,000,000 was regarded by the former Taoiseach when he was in office. It was a matter of the deepest concern when it was only £30,000.000. When we came in, and found that it was £61.6 million, and expressed our concern, it was regarded by him as a trifling matter then. We had the same sort of attitude from him when we were told that we were putting on £10.000,000 more in taxation than was necessary to meet our commitments.

I have indicated what has been the basis of Government policy. It is now suggested that that policy was dictated by the Central Bank. Did the Central Bank need to dictate to us and tell us that, as far as the country is concerned, we must balance current expenditure by current revenue? We knew that before the Central Bank was set up. We knew that as one of the fundamental things that must bedealt with. As a matter of fact, some of the people in the Central Bank and who were on the Banking Commission found fault with us when we had a development programme away back in 1932 and 1933.

We did not need anybody to tell us to do these things. It is ridiculous to suggest that we were deliberately going out to produce unemployment in the country. You will not quote even the Central Bank's report fairly. The Central Bank's report said that the unusually favourable — or whatever word they used in conjunction with the word favourable—position of employment meant that the special State measures that have to be operated in times where there is heavy unemployment, were not necessary at the time. That is what they said and now that is being twisted.

Comment on this

Was that right?

Comment on this

That is what they said.

Comment on this

Was that right?

Comment on this

That has been twisted by unscrupulous people——

Comment on this

Was that right?

Comment on this

——to try to make it appear that the Central Bank were deliberately recommending unemployment. Every honest mind will recognise what it meant.

Comment on this

And is that Government policy?

Comment on this

The Central Bank meant that the situation was such that the special measures which are necessary in times of heavy unemployment, that is, State capital investment of a certain kind on certain public works, were not necessary.

Comment on this

And now we have the result.

Comment on this

Do not mind what we have.

Comment on this

We do.

Comment on this

If there is a house on fire——

Comment on this

The house is on fire now.

Comment on this

——and if the fire brigade is brought in, you do not want to be a prophet to know that some of the books will be wet.

Comment on this

The house is on fire now.

Comment on this

Do not cut the hose.

Comment on this

The fact is that the policy we followed had a basis which none of you over there have the audacity even to stand up and say was wrong.

Comment on this

Of course it was wrong.

Comment on this

It was not wrong. The Deputy says it was wrong. He has not said what he would do instead or what his Party had done.

Comment on this

I spent half an hour telling you.

Comment on this

He has not a Party. He does not speak for anyone. Speak with your own voice and do not speak for people who have different voices. The position with regard to our policy is that we have pursued that policy. There was a situation, as I pointed out, when I was speaking here some time ago, that followed the beginning of the Korean war, when there was a frenzied laying-up of stocks. Just as, when there is a tremendous effort in one direction, you lay up stocks or complete any task in a hurry, there is a new situation that will follow that, the fact that there was this urge to buy, to get in goods of all sorts, meant that you had stocking-up. It meant, consequently, that the needs of the community in that respect were, to a large extent, met, and, therefore, particularly in the circumstances that prevailed when these stocks had been bought at practically famine prices, there was a revolt on the part of the buyers; they held back. That, of course, meant that the shopkeeper was no longer busy, that transport services were no longer busy, that the factories were no longer busy producing and you had a period of slackness. The present situation is largely due to that. Wehad an example, for instance, in the textile industry until it was corrected by putting a stop on further imports and protecting the industries and trying to get the workers back at work in them.

However, the fact is that we have a situation in which there is unemployment. I did not at any time say that an unemployment situation is one which a Government should ignore. Whenever the Government has said anything about it, they have not said that it should be ignored. Because there have been demonstrations one would imagine that anything like that never happened before. I pointed out that, in February last, if you take account of the extra people on the register because of the Social Welfare Act, the figure was less in fact than it had been at the same time in February, 1949, when the live register total was over 84,000. We had the register examined at February last and as a result we knew that it contained close on 10,000 who were there because the Social Welfare Act had been passed. If you took, from the register figure, that number, the balance would be less than the figure at February, 1949. I do not want to say that even this figure, smaller though it was, was not serious. I only want to get the truth about it. I regard it as a serious matter. I said it was a matter giving serious concern to the Government. It has given concern to the Government, and the Government has been active in regard to the matter. There has been a rapid diminution, a bigger diminution from the unemployment peak of this year than there has been from the peak in the previous year or a number of other years. But, again, I do not want to say that we are complacent about it. I think it would be quite wrong to be complacent about it. Unemployment is not an easy thing to cure. It is by no means easy to cure.

Comment on this

It is easy to correct.

Comment on this

It is not easy to cure. You have the natural fact that labour is not mobile. We had some questions about the bogs. A young man may be expected to take up workon the bog but a married man here with a family might find it very difficult to go down to accept work of that sort. He might in fact be a man who had not been accustomed to manual labour at all. It is extremely difficult in a complex society to find suitable work for every class of individual who at one time or another might become unemployed. That has been recognised and that is the fundamental reason why an effort is made by the community to meet the needs of such a person temporarily during such temporary periods of unemployment.

There is a fair number of the present unemployed who could usefully be employed on constructive work. We recognise that, Back in 1933 and 1934. we were looking ahead for a pool of public works to have during a period of possible recession. What was the attitude of the Opposition? They said that we were extravagant, that we were trying to house the Dublin civil servants in Palaces. That is what was said about our having planned to have such a pool of public works such as in connection with Dublin Castle. Now we have taken certain steps in order to try to get constructive works going which will employ a number of those who are capable of work of that sort.

Again, I say, not every one of the unemployed can be put at work of that kind, but there is a certain section of them that can. We have been doing everything in our power to get things going so that these people will be employed in constructive work of various kinds.

I have said many times in talking about the general policy of the Government that our principal and fundamental aim is to try to create conditions which will give employment, create conditions which will mean that in industry, agriculture, and so on, there will be opportunities for earning a livelihood and doing useful economic work. That has been the fundamental point of our policy the whole time, and we have never, in regard to that policy, been hesitant to use the resources of the country for that purpose—never.

There has been talk about capital investment, capital development. Why,we have more money provided this year, much more, than was provided during any year of the Coalition for capital purposes.

Comment on this

It is in the banks.

Comment on this

Five per cent.

Comment on this

People who talk like that are just parrots who repeat parrot cries. They do not want to listen to reason. There is nothing one can do to convince them. I would be wasting my breath if I were to try to talk to people of that sort. The position is that we have a higher capital development programme this year than at any time during the period in which the Coalition were in office. It may be necessary even to extend that to meet the present conditions. If there is a crisis, if I have money in the bank and I am ill and need medical treatment no matter how much I may regret using my resources for a purpose like that, I will use them because it is fundamentally necessary to do so. We approach the resources of the nation in the same way. If there is a critical situation, just as if there was a war, we would be ready to use our resources to bring about a cure of that.

I have said that we have taken some measures and that we have provided for capital development and useful constructive works. The Castle scheme, which is an economic scheme from the State point of view, is being revived so as to give employment. It was stopped in 1948. In our opinion, it should not have been stopped. That is being revived. It will take some time to get it going. It cannot be done overnight. You can say, "Let it be done", but there is a certain time lag between the time you say, "Let it be done" and its being done. A certain interval of time has to elapse.

Another project referred to was the project of hard runways on the Baldonnel Aerodrome. That was a project which was considered originally both from the Army point of view and from the commercial point of view. It was felt that an alternative aerodrome in Dublin would be useful. It might be regarded as a necessity, but in any case it was highly useful. That projectwill be of a useful character in comparison with digging a hole and filling it up again. That project will give a certain amount of employment and is going to be continued.

We told the various Departments that where there were useful constructive works on hands these constructive works should be expedited and put in hand to give employment with the least possible delay. If there were other works contemplated, we asked them to send these forward for immediate consideration and for an early decision. That is being done. There were other projects which, for one reason or another, had been deferred. We told the Departments to have these projects re-examined immediately to see whether they were of a type that should or should not be carried out. We indicated that these things would be done. We have tried to expedite the building of houses in Dublin. In answer to a question here I have indicated the extent to which these projects are going ahead gradually. It cannot be done overnight but gradually the unemployment problem which showed itself in a serious light about the beginning of this year, is being dealt with. It is being done on a thoroughly sound basis because we have seen to it that the foundation is sound in regard to meeting our expenses and living within our means in the ordinary way.

There has been talk about people tightening their belts. The fact was that in the year 1951 we were actually using up more than we were producing. If you use up any more than you are producing then in a certain time, unless your resources are unlimited, you will come to grief and the people will suffer severely. We felt that the proper thing was to bring about a balance as quickly as possible, and it has been done. The position now is that everything we can do must be done to promote production, which is the basis of everything. If you have not production, you will not have social services, you will not have the standard of living that you desire.

We pointed out that one of the mostpromising fields in which to increase production was the field of agriculture and that it was a field which would give very rapid and good results if it were properly cultivated. One of the essential things was to see to it that the necessary ground limestone was available. We did everything we could do to encourage private enterprise to do that. Some members of the Labour Party may say: "You should have produced it directly by the State." There may be a case made for that where private enterprise is not meeting its responsibilities, so to speak, in the matter. But we have not done that because we wanted to try and encourage private enterprise to provide that instead of having it produced by the State.

This debate has been an unreal debate. Instead of coming to close quarters, as you would expect, it has been the sort of long-range fire which you have at cross-roads debates.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Propaganda.

Comment on this

It has been propaganda for the most part.

Comment on this

What about your own?

Comment on this

There has been no attempt to get down close to the problems which it is necessary to solve. Of course, you will have people who can wave a magic wand and then everything is right! You can say: "Fly away, Peter, fly away, Paul; come back, Peter, come back, Paul."

It has been suggested that all our external assets should be invested here. You know very well that they are not dealt with in that way.(Interruptions.)The Minister for External Affairs was pointing out—great care was taken to prevent him from making his point—that although it was a sin for external assets to increase if we were in office, it was not a sin if they increased when our opponents were in office.

Comment on this

When we were in office it was wrong.

Comment on this

It was not. It will be said that these increases took placebecause it was better to invest the Marshall Aid money in that way rather than to leave it idle here. If there was something fundamentally wrong in principle which made this course particularly difficult, the money need not have been sent out; it could have been preserved here, but this was not done. I am not finding fault with the previous Government for doing what they did in this respect, and neither did the Minister for External Affairs, but he pointed out the inconsistency of people who talked like that and who, when in office, did the very thing which they say was a sin when we did it.

With regard to these external assets, the figures that I have given have been challenged. It is a very easy thing to look only at one side of an account. We would all be happy if we could look only at the credit side and pay no attention to the debit side. When I spoke of £120,000,000 as regards our assets abroad, I always referred to them as net assets. Surely anybody who has any knowledge of accounts knows that the word "net" has significance. There was no quibbling about the word "net". The word "net" means the balance between your liabilities and your assets. If you take the external liabilities and the external assets and you subtract one from the other, you get a figure of £120,000,000. That is the figure which shows what your real external resources are. If we have external liabilities it means that money has to be taken out of the country every year in one form or another to meet the charges on them. These are external liabilities and they have to be met. The amount which you have left represents your real net reserve. If you look at the account and see on the one hand the assets and on the other hand the liabilities, that tells you where you stand, not the total gross amount of your assets. If I am given a legacy of a couple of thousand pounds and if that legacy involves paying £3,000, I do not think much of it, because instead of being given a benefit I have got a net debt of £1,000.

Comment on this

That is Victorian economics.

Comment on this

It is the economics which Deputy Davin uses in his own home. There is nothing Victorian about that. The other thing is used as a smoke screen. Another one of the charges made is that we are responsible for the tightening of credit. We are not responsible for any tightening of credit.

Comment on this

Who is?

Comment on this

Banking is a business. Bankers are dealing with a commodity which is money.

Comment on this

A commodity?

Comment on this

It is fundamentally a commodity and has all the characteristics of a commodity.

Comment on this

That is a fundamental error.

Comment on this

When it comes into use it is the equivalent in exchange of a commodity. It has all the characteristics of a third or intermediate commodity.

Comment on this

It should be dealt with as a commodity.

Comment on this

lf the Deputy's theories were useful, right or fundamentally sound, there is not a nation in the world which would not be happy to-day.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The Deputy only intervenes with those parrot statements. He never stands up and argues a case fully. The position with regard to our assets is that they were reduced to £120,000,000, as a result of a succession of heavy deficits in our balance of payments. They increased largely during the war period when we could not get certain goods. The moment the war was over we started to use them and the additions that were made have been exhausted.

Can we as a nation afford to blind ourselves to a problem and to a fact which other nations have to bear in mind, namely, that if they want to preserve their position so as to be able at any time to meet either a particularcrisis or to meet special changes in external trade, they must have some sum of money available which will protect them against such a situation?

Comment on this
Mr. P.J. O'Sullivan

Devalued money.

Comment on this

Devalued money? Why did you not stop it when you were in office? We have, in this island, a population of about 4,333,000. We occupy a relatively small area on the surface of the earth. The United States is about 100 times bigger than we are. Our country represents roughly the size of Lake Superior on the map of the United States. If you take the British Commonwealth or Empire, whatever it is now called, which covers a vast area of the earth and which possesses natural resources of all sorts, is it to be thought that we here, a small country, can succeed in doing things that they are not able to do in regard to matters of that kind? We are influenced by external factors. Take the cost of living, for instance. There are two chief factors in it. On the one hand, there is the external factor in relation to wholesale prices of raw materials, and so on, the index of which is about 300; and, on the other hand, it is calculated that about 40 per cent. of our personal expenditure is attributable to things that come from outside.

Comment on this

You say that now. You said the reverse in 1951.

Comment on this

I did not. I looked up some of the statements which I made and which have been referred to to-day—anybody who reads what I said and sees the misrepresentation made to-day, knows that it is misrepresentation.

Comment on this

Every member of Fianna Fáil said that.

Comment on this

Of course the Deputy will try to revive the old charge that I have never made a statement in regard to which there was not some back door by which to escape. When I am making statements I try to make them with the qualifications necessary to make them true because most statements,in order to be accurate, have to be qualified.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is true. You cannot make absolute statements if you want to tell the truth. It is only those who have no regard for the real truth who can make these absolute statements such as those I have heard during some of this debate. Most of them are not true. I said about 40 per cent. of our personal expenditure is spent on imports, on what comes from outside sources. Therefore, if the prices of raw materials or of the finished goods that come in from outside are raised, it follows of necessity that prices will go up here. Similarly if you pay increased agricultural prices the same thing will happen. We know it is necessary to pay these prices in order to get the produce. Of course, the tactics of the Opposition are that when they are talking to the people in the towns they will refer to the increase in the price of butter and when they are talking to the farmers they will tell them of the low price of milk.

If you are going to give the farmers the price which will induce them to supply the milk, of necessity that price goes on to the commodity sold unless it is subsidised. If you subsidise it you must tax tobacco and other items to pay for the subsidies. We did that in 1947.

Comment on this

You said you would do it again.

Comment on this

What we said was that we did not propose to reduce the subsidy. That was true at the time. We did not realise at that time we would be up against a deficit of £15,000,000 and that the alternative was either to reduce these subsidies or to add another £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 to our already heavy bill of taxation.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It was not our wish to reduce the subsidies, but we had to do it. We did not want to do it any more than any other democratic Government would. We had to face the situation of having either to reduce subsidies or to increase taxation. Itwas a very unwelcome choice we had to make, but we made it in what We regarded as the best interests of the country. We will find that these people who talk about this question will not come in and tell the people that they will, without taxation—because that is the point—restore subsidies. I will bet they will not do it. They will get some excuse for putting it in abeyance when they come into office, if they ever do.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You said you would not withdraw the subsidies.

Comment on this

We had no intention at that time of doing it. We are accused of having that as part of our policy. It was forced upon us by the cruel necessity that confronted us of having to bridge a gap of £15,000,000, and we had to do that by increasing taxation or by reducing the subsidies.

Comment on this

It was one of your 17 points.

Comment on this

We reduced the subsidies and we have to face the consequences. When an election comes there will not be such crowing as we hear now from the opposite benches.

Comment on this

You told us that before.

Comment on this

We have fought you many a time before and have beaten you.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The choice of the battlefield is in my hands. I will choose the one I think will be the best. I have much too long experience to play your game for you. You were not in any hurry to go to the country. When Fine Gael came into office as a Government they were supported by people who told the electorate they were not going to enter into such a combination as they entered into.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

As Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

That Coalition in 1948 was as much against democraticpractices as any could be. I do not intend, simply because you now think it would be a suitable time for you——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Any time is suitable.

Comment on this

It was not that way when you were over here. We can go to the country any time. We are as big a Party as we were before.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We challenge you to try it.

Comment on this

When I choose.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Try it.

Comment on this

How many of you want an election? Hands up.

Comment on this
Deputies

We all want it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You are a gang of political poltroons.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach is entitled to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He has made a challenge to us.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach is entitled to he heard without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He is entitled to dissolve the Dáil.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Every other Deputy has been heard without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Come on with that challenge.

Comment on this

Indeed, that challenge is there, and when the right time comes——

Comment on this
A Deputy

You are afraid.

Comment on this

I will choose. I am not a baby to be affected by a dare, not by any means. As long as I have the right of saying whether there will or will not be a dissolution I will see to it that the dissolution is at the time that I think is best for the country, and I have always thought that it was best for the country when it was best for this Party, because I believe thatthis Party is the Party which is working in the country's best interest.

Comment on this

In other words, your Party cannot be wrong. We know now.

Comment on this

We will see you all again in good time and you will not be so happy, perhaps, when it is over. We propose to go through with our programme. The hardest, bitterest part of our work, thank God, is done. We have the foundation laid, and on that foundation we mean to go ahead and to bring about as good conditions in this country as there were before the war.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

No heat of argument or no stimulated reverie of the Fianna Fáil Benches can for a moment change the unfortunate situation that we must face up to in the course of this debate. I do not propose to follow lines of either personal invective or cheap politics. We are here to-night to tell the Government what the real situation in the country is and I am going to answer the Taoiseach's challenge and put on the records of this House positive works ready for immediate action that the Government can put into being to-morrow to alleviate the position in West Cork if they are so disposed. It is a significant thing, standing here as a young man, to find that we have the extraordinary situation returned in this country, in 1953, under 20 years, virtually, of a Fianna Fáil Government, that this country is back to the situation of the famine years, where there was nothing for unemployment but Government relief schemes. Let us face the reality. Let the stupid little fop of a Minister for Finance snigger and laugh if he likes, but the situation is rankling from one end of the country to the other. In point of fact, now a situation has arisen where the Government say that relief schemes can meet an emergency situation. This is a poor tribute, not only to Fianna Fáil but to native Government here for 30 odd years that we have a situation where, instead of having a progressive plan that was going to improve the economy of the country and gradually envelop more and morepeople in employment, that we are an this divided state where we hear sneering gibes and hints and talk rather than getting down to the reality of trying to get a way to keep in work, to keep in decent comfort Irishmen and Irishwomen as worthy of our consideration as any of us in this House. I am sick and tired of looking to a past instead of building on a present and ensuring a future.

I am coming into this House to-night to make a plea, not on the basis of any Party membership, but on behalf of a generation that has in its day a right to maintenance and sustenance in its own country, and to try and direct the Government's mind to the fact that even though they may be the generation that is passing on, having given worthy service to this country, that they have got to face the reality of the present and the fact that if something is not done rapidly and courageously, we are going to find this country denied initially of the basic, fundamental essential necsssary to it—the manhood of its young men and the energy and trust of the young men and young women of this country who will not be here if something is not done to arrest the instability, the unemployment and the lack of security that now exists at home. One cannot blame the Government exclusively for what has happened. It is true that stupidity and blunders may have caused a recession in trade and a restriction of credit that is the atmosphere and breeding ground of the ills that we are now suffering from. The Taoiseach or the Minister may say that the Government have not control over the credit situation, but it is true, I believe, that a Government has some control over the situation of credit. If they have not, then I say this, that we have not any freedom in this country at all. If they cannot control that situation then we are, in fact, only legislating in name here while the iron grip of control of our a hole economic fabric is held somwhere else. I do not believe that that situation exists, but I do believe this and I am saying it quite seriously to the Taoiseach, that if something is not done forthwith in this country to ensure that hunger, unrest and unemployment rapidly wanethe Taoiseach may find himself with a situation that may lead to consequences far more far-reaching than we would like to envisage here.

We hear talk about schemes having to be brought to fruition. I am glad that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is here because I do not believe that there is any Department of State that abounds with more schemes technically complete, ready for going into action, than his Department. I want to tell the Taoiseach, who is listening to me now, that if he wants to keep young boys and girls at home in West Cork, which I have the honour to represent, there is the pier at Castletownbere falling to pices, which wants to be fixed up at once. There was a slipway built there by the Board of Works and they admitted afterwards that they did not know where they had built it. It was built for purposes which it did not serve. Go into Schull, where we have the nucleus of a revival of Irish fishing under way. They are crying out there for a breakwater year after year. The Taoiseach, as long as he has been Taoiseach and while he was in Opposition has heard me striving over five years to get that work commenced. The plans are there, the blue-prints are there, the engineers are there. There is employment there for 80, 90 or 200 people in the peninsula that stretches from Ballydehob to Goleen. God knows it is a hard, beautiful part of the country in which to grub a living. I tell the Taoiseach that if he will say so in the morning work could be given there to people that is not going to last them only one night. It will last a considerable number of years; not only in ensuring a safe resting place for boats that Irish money is being put into but for the safety of the craft that we are using to develop that industry.

These are instances of what is necessary in the islands that abound about West Cork. It is not so long ago since the Taoiseach took a corvette to go around to see them. He knows himself that in those islands where you have dwindling populations and rising unemployment there is an unlimited number of schemes for little harbour developments and amenitiesthat have to be added to the lives of the people down there that can be immediately put into operation. I say to the Taoiseach if he is in earnest that we people come here representing constituencies such as that to make an earnest appeal for the survival of our areas, not alone for employment in them but for the hope of survival for the people who have worked so hard for so long in those áiteanna iargcúlta.

We come here to make a plea for those people who played as big a part in establishing this very institution in which we now meet, we voice our views on their behalf, and I say to the Taoiseach if he is in earnest about employment schemes—not throwing any blame individually on anybody for what has arisen—that they should go into my constituency and put into operation any amount of those works. If that is done, there will not be 400 odd people on the unemployed register in Castletownbere, as I was told last week, nor 200 odd in Dunmanway, 200 in Clonakilty and 500 in Skibbereen. That is a very poor tribute of an Irish Government to a part of Ireland that certainly cannot be challenged on the sacrifice it made that Dáil Éireann having been established might persist and come into the existence that it now has.

We talk too glibly in this House and refer too often in the most scurrilous way to forbears or connections of forbears of this House. It would be better for us all here, as I said some time ago in this Dáil when talking on the Republic of Ireland Bill, to appreciate the worth of individuals in their effort for this State and, having appreciated it, to try to build on the foundations we have, rather than constantly recall something that most of us never knew of and do that with a bitterness that this generation should not be asked to perpetuate. When I come into this House as a young man to talk on the problems of to-day, I want the Government to realise that most of the people who are hungry in Dublin City and throughout the length and breadth of Ireland to-day are not worried about the rights and wrongs of 35 years ago, but about the immediate present and how they are going to exist in the State as it now it.

I will pay a tribute—and I always have, irrespective of the side of the House I was on—to anybody who did his part manfully and well in the formative days of the State. But we cannot live on that glory and put people into employment on that glory. We have need of a practical economic policy to meet the difficulties of to-day. Let the Taoiseach take this responsibility and let the Minister for Finance take it effectively, that his very financial policy must of itself beget some of the conditions we have to-day. You cannot have increased taxation to the level that it becomes a complete burden on the people, a nauseating unsustainable burden, without having the situation arise of increased costs of all essential foods. You could have, as we did have, the "Up Dev." with: "Up tea, up bread, up butter, up sugar, up milk, up beer, up tobacco, up cigarettes and all the rest. We had, with the same catch-cry retricted credit and a rapid growth of unemployment. That is the seed that was sown in the economic policy brought in here, in a hair shirt austerity vein, by the Minister for Finance in 1952. For that the Government is responsible.

You may not want a general election: that is a matter that is within the Taoiseach's own purview at the moment; but if you do not want a general election at least you must take cognisance of the message that is being sent by the people to the Government, that they do not approve of their present economic policy. I am a bit like Deputy Davin in this. If the Taoiseach recants his economic stupidities and gets down to the job and helps to solve the problems of the immediate present, I think he will he given credit for that, no matter whether we agree fundamentally with the policy of his Party or not. We do know this, that they have tried an economic policy on this country and the country has in a positive, effective and repeated way said they do not want it.

Now, the Government can do either of two things. One of them theTaoiseach has indicated to us to-night quite clearly in his speech. Let me Say this, in sincerity: it was a pleasant thing to see the Taoiseach back to his old vitality and virility in the course of his heated discourse here to-night; it was a good thing to see him back in energetic vein. Maybe it portends a reasonable drive by the Taoiseach himself now to make the Government meet the problems they are not meeting. We are glad to see that. Let me say this to the Taoiseach. that the answer to the immediate present goes deeper than relief schemes. It is appalling that the situation is that we must force the Government, or try to force the Government, to put into effect immediately relief schemes to give employment to the people throughout the length and breadth of Dublin and throughout rural Ireland.

Let the Taoiseach take this message from me. He can rant as much as he likes about the balance of payments and sterling assets. I am quite sure the Minister for Finance, when he gets the chance next week of replying to this debate, will rant and rave about, Marshall Aid and a lot of other things; but to the unemployed man, whether he is in Werburgh Street Exchange or Lower Gardiner Street Exchange, or Clonakilty or Skibbereen or Castletownbere or elsewhere, sterling assets and balance of payments are damned poor consolation to his empty belly. It is time we in this House realised that when we are talking here about the level of the balance of payments or the repatriation of assets, we are dawdling and wasting time, while in fact the very basis of all that, the primary factor in production, the very manpower and woman-power of this country is drifting as it never drifted before from the land of Ireland.

The Taoiseach made reference to the fact that we are only a small island. We have had a significant experience recently. If we study the census of population and the various statistical documents issued to us by the Central Statistics Office, we get a reasonable photograph of the situation that is arising in the country—a dwindling marriage rate, a dwindling population and increasing emigration.

What is the remedy? The remedy is not going to be found in the invective and counter-invective of ex-Ministers, or Ministers against each other here. The answer is to be found in some kind of cohesive, constructive plan that is going to envelop people, gradually assimilate them into industrial employment or agricultural employment that is of practical and permanent duration. There is no good in suggesting relief schemes as anything other than a temporary alleviation. The Government has to get down to the problem that I have pressed, not only on this Government, but on the last one, of getting established in this country, in their full solid foundation, industries that are germane to the country. I have said here before that it is pathetic to me—and I am quite sure it is pathetic to my colleague from Donegal, Deputy O'Donnell—that we have an excuse for a fishing industry left in Ireland, when he can gaze out, and I can gaze out in West Cork, on the trawling fleets of every nation in the world fishing under their initial expense and overhead expense off the coast of Ireland, to enhance and enrich the coffers of their own countries in the enhancement of the catches they bring home to the fishing of their own lands, while we here toil and labour without any conception of what the real national wealth of that fishing industry could be to us.

Has the Government come to grips with the problem of planning at all progressively for a future? Has the Government—and I mean not only the Government of to-day, but Governments before it—come to grips with the problem of stepping up the production of Irish land in the way it could be stepped up? Is the way to step up production in Irish farms the way this Government has elected to take? Is the making more difficult of credit facilities for the farmer, the impact of increased costs in every direction of his cost of production, a stimulation to further production? Is the present economic plan of the Government— that puts, as described by the Taoiseach himself, a crushing burden of taxation on the people—the type ofplan to stimulate a drive for production in Irish farms?

Is this driving of a wedge between town and country, as we have seen the Government try to do in recent by-elections, a way of producing balanced and stabilised economy at home? I am talking on the basis of the situation as it is to-day. Whoever is responsible for it, the situation to-day is that we have an abnormally high figure of unemployed. There is no doubt whatever but that we have one of the highest figures ever, since-the Famine, for emigration, and we have an even worse feature than that creeping into the economy of the country. We have people who were in employment here trying to find an alternative country to which to take their wives and children because they cannot see any future in their own country. I will readily agree that that cannot completely be the Government's fault, but nevertheless it is a situation that exists, and what are we, who purport to be the legislators and the guiding power of this country, going to do about it? The problem goes deeper than we can hope to solve by relief schemes. It is on that basis that I want to address my remarks generally to-night. We have to restore confidence in the people in this country. We have got to get rid of this cult which is growing up throughout the-length and breadth of Ireland and that is making the people shun politics. A situation is arising in this country whereby young people are not taking the interest they should in the development of their own land and are not making an effort to get into the scheme of development of their own land.

Rather are they more eager to get some profession or some kind of a qualification and to get out of their own land. That is a cancer that this country cannot stand for too long. But when to that cancer are added the three serious difficulties already adverted to, we have a situation in which the Government must take deliberate and serious action. I believe that, with a bit of goodwill in this House, as distinct from thrust and parry, and with the willingness of thisHouse to form a united front in an effort to meet the immediate emergency problem, we have the resources and the credit to enable us to surmount our immediate difficulties. But the Government must produce—and if this Government cannot, it must give way to one that can—some kind of an economic structure that is practical for this country, that shows a progressive development and that can be preached to our people as something that ensures a future not only for those ripening in age, as many members of this House are, but for those coming behind and for generations to come.

We have had too much talk in this House for too long about individual failures to do this or to do that. While we all come here and criticise each other for what has been done, and for what has not been done, we allow— apparently willy-nilly—the denudation of our own land to take place. It is little credit to any of us—and I am saying this with a full sense of responsibility—that, after 30 odd years of enjoying the fruits of sacrifice which was so honestly made in this country, we have not been able to establish a State in which the young people can have hope and are eager to stay and work in. It becomes more appalling to us all when we realise full well that no reason except lack of initiative and lack of drive within the Governments of this country has caused such a situation to arise. We have the grandest hit of country in the world here. We have some of the finest people, technically, that the world can produce. We have the solid basis of our own people that never wilted and that, generation after generation, have proved their worth and their love for their own land.

Comment on this

What are the obstacles?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The main obstacle that exists here is the one I referred to at the opening of my speech and that is that it appears from what the Taoiseach said to us to-night that we are a Government in name but not the Government of our economic destiny because somebody else dictates ourmoney policy and our rates of interest. I am not going to stand here and say that the fiscal problem is one that can immediately be solved by breaking the sterling link. It involves more difficulties than that. The difficulties are becoming greater as the years progress. However, it does involve this: some day, and somehow, somebody in charge of an Irish Government—if he wants to plan a, practical economy for the Irish people—will have to take in hand and in rein the control of that particular facet of our economy.

Is it not appalling to realise, as was mentioned here this evening by Deputy Davin, that for houses which we are building to house possibly the most worthy of all classes in this country, the hardworking artisan, farm labourer or worker——

Comment on this

The real producers.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

——we have to repay virtually 65 per cent. of the money that is charged by way of continuous rent in perpetuity on that house to moneylenders, bankers or whatever name you wish to put upon them. Only by coming face to face with the stark realism that exists to-day can we appreciate how essential it is for this country to have some positive control over credit and credit rates. It is quite true that you may, in theory, make the case which was made by the Taoiseach that money can be classed no better than a commodity but if we want to go into the analysis of money and the credit fiction of the world, it would take very little to topple that theory completely. Therefore, why should we be so frightened and afraid to grasp this problem of our monetary control when we know that we still have in this country all that made any wealth accumulated possible? We have the strength of the right arm of the Irish people and the soil that generation upon generation so proudly and earnestly helped to cultivate and protect.

Comment on this

It is the basis of real wealth.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It is easy, in the heat of a discussion like this, to fire, as have been fired across this House, variouspolitical darts apropos of 20 or 30 years ago. During the course of this day, thanks to disorderly interruptions by the Minister for Finance and by various people on my side of the House, and to disorderly provocation by the Minister for External Affairs. we have fought everything, including the civil war, and even things that occurred prior to it.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, would it not be a good thing if you gave the Deputy a halo because, apparently, he did not interrupt all day?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I would hate to take a halo from the hands of the little Minister for Finance, because I would be as sceptical of that as the Minister is in his present mood. The Minister for Finance has to realise that, even with all his cynicism and the type of sneer he can affect—and most of the Minister's "codology" here is affectation—I am trying to deal with a problem that exists, not only for the Government to-day but for every responsible Deputy and every responsible person thinking of the future of the country. The Taoiseach will readily agree with me that if we cannot keep our Irishmen and women at home, we will not have the basis on which to build any future Ireland, because they are the essential unit in production.

What is the answer to employment on the land? I will tell the Taoiseach, but I know the Taoiseach will not carry it out because, as I have already explained, he has not got in his power the real control to enable him to carry it out. The Irish farmer and farm labourer, given co-operation and help, are the finest production units this country ever had. They carried this country through many dark and bitter days of trial and tribulation, and what the small farmer and his men helping him need to-day is the wherewithal to get the necessary fertiliser, equipment and seed which will give the harvest which the Taoiseach seeks. Irish land can produce not only 50 per cent., but 100 and 200 per cent. more than it produces to-day, but that can be done only if there is made available to the farmer the equipment and the aids to the rehabilitationof this land which he needs at a price within his capacity to pay.

Speaking in my presence, the Taoiseach has said that fertiliser is a good investment for the farmer. If it is, let me answer the Taoiseach by saying that it is a better investment for an Irish Government seeking that increased production to ensure that the farmer haa readily available to him, by way of credit or reduction of cost, the fertiliser he needs to give us that added production. We must get more and more goods in the main from the land of this country in order to get back our standard of living. We cannot afford to get a better standard of life for our people than they can earn for us and the direction in which we can get the most rapid and ready increase in production is not in industry, no matter what the Minister for Industry and Commerce may think.

Industry is something that needs careful planning. It needs technical skill in its development and needs to be very solidly grounded in reality. It must not be of the mushroom type we experience to-day. The employment capacity of some of the new industries alleged by the Government is nil, while the profit capacity for its many foreign directors is immense. In the land of Ireland, in the small farms of Ireland, as the Taoaiseach, representing the constituency of Clare, knows full well, there is an industry which is starved of the essentials for production.

I hear Deputy Cogan prating about credit for farmers and about facilities for farmers. If this Government are in earnest—and the most important unit, the unit of its very existence, is Deputy Cogan—with regard to increased production in agriculture, the time has come when the resources of the country should be used where they will give the best return and create an atmosphere of solidarity and security at home by making available to the farmer the new equipment he needs, the fertiliser and seeds he needs and everything else he needs, to make his holding more productive. The money and the means must be made available as rapidly as possible and that is where one of the most serious difficulties arises.

There was a time when there was pride in the families of rural Ireland in their succession in their holdings, but now the farmers, with three or four sons at home, find it impossible to persuade any of the boys to succeed them in the holding. The young men do not want that type of drudgery and hardship and the answer to that problem is to make equipment and money for improvement readily available to these people. I am sounding a deliberate note of warning that, unless we can stabilise the continuity of the small farmer and the succession of their sons in the small-holdings of IreIand, we are going to have to deal in the very near future with an infinitely greater problem than the problem which may arise from the exigencies of immediate circumstances.

The general overall pattern of our economy has broken down. It has broken down from two different impacts. The first was undoubtedly the impact of the stupidity of the present Government's economy axe. The second is that the Government, screaming in seven or eight different voices for increased production, have put the entire means of securing that increased production out of the reach of the very people they want to provide that increased production. There is no excuse or no justification for the situation which the Government's economic policy, as portrayed in the Budget of 1952, brought about. Even if the situation were bad—and the Taoiseach suggests in his defence that it was—or even worse than he said it was, it was indeed an irresponsible Government which rushed to cure that ill too quickly, because it was obvious to a man of the Taoiseach's long experience in the public service of the country that such an action must bring in its wake exactly what it has brought. That action could not bring anything but the ills so eagerly sought by the Victorian theory of the Central Bank.

Fianna Fáil painted the situation as bad, but to-day we do not know what they are trying to paint. At one stage, they tell us that we put the country in pawn and to-day the Minister forExternal Affairs tried to prove that the greatest sin of the Coalition Government was that we allowed our external assets to increase. There will always be tweedledum and tweedledee and we never have an unequivocal statement from the Taoiseach himself. We have that situation rampant to-day.

The Taoiseach made a reference which rather amused me, to one thing being said in the town and another in the country. I had the pleasure of following some of the Taoiseach's senior Ministers and junior Ministers around East Cork, and I was staggered by the different chat in the towns and in the country. I had only one story to tell. I told the people you were no good. I believe you are no good. They had 40 other stories to tell. I still believe that the only way in which the Government can deal with the present situation is for them to rid themselves of the hair-shirt policy of the Minister for Finance.

The Taoiseach spoke glibly to-night about people in a certain type of employment who could not be readily put on the bogs. The Taoiseach must realise that his very action ensured the unemployment of thousands of the very people that he could not find employment for to-day. His bludgeoning of the wine and spirit retail trade put one out of every three men in that trade out of employment. His activity with regard to the distilling industry has closed some of the smaller distilleries, and that is bound to have its effect in the reduction of the staff of the bigger distilleries.

Comment on this

He was never in two places at the one time like you were.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I was never a furlong behind in a mayoral election. We have a Government who do not even come to grips with the problem of unemployment in the city of the vociferous mayor. I think little of his unseemly interjections. We are here to try and find work for workless people. We are here to try and give hope to people who have abandoned hope. We are here to find security for people in this country who are feeling insecurity for the first time. When the LordMayor of Cork interrupted me, I was dealing with the direct consequences of the effect of the increased taxes on the wine and spirit trade.

We have the biggest firm this country boasts of trying to induce people to retire earlier. It is experiencing unemployment of a serious nature for the first time in its history. That firm is the firm of Messers. Guinness. We have got to take note of these things. We have got to realise that the stranglehold has to be taken off industry if there is going to be any expansion of employment. We have got to realise that if things are inevitably to cost more the people who have to buy them will have to be given increased earning capacity with which to meet these increased charges or the Government will have to take some positive action to reduce the cost of essential commodities to put them within the reach of the pay packets of those who will have to meet the increased expense.

We can boast of certain achievements but if we want to hold on to those achievements we will have to get down immediately to the task of keeping in gainful employment the young men and women at home in Ireland. I say to the Taoiseach that he will have no difficulty regarding the immediate problem with practically every rural constituency in Ireland because over the years various Deputies of every Party have been pressing for local major and minor building schemes that are of practical value to the areas concerned. Those can be put into operation if the Taoiseach is in earnest.

I will give the Taoiseach credit for being in earnest. If the Taoiseach is in earnest, I think he can put into operation many of these schemes around the coastal areas and the fishing ports. Indeed, he can put many schemes into operation in Cork harbour that will serve as a palliative for the Lord Mayor of Cork and a relief for some of his problems.

The Taoiseach can do these things and bring about an immediate relief, but he and his Government will have to face the problem of getting more and more people into employment that shows a progressive potential for thefuture. We have got to tackle the problem of keeping young people at work not in centralised areas in Ireland but in diffused areas throughout the country. Big as is the disease of emigration, the drift from rural Ireland to the cities and in the main into the City of Dublin is bigger. It may well be that that drift itself aggravates the unemployment situation in Dublin. A way has to be found not only to deal with the immediate problem but to ensure that as employment on these various schemes of capital development wanes there will be an alternative type of industry and development in rural Ireland that will gradually absorb the unemployed as they become unemployed.

I was glad to hear the Taoiseach refer to the bogs of Ireland. I think that there are immense national fuel resources on the bogs. An immense labour content could be employed on the bogs. I am not afraid to say, no matter who dislikes it, that if it were within my province, I would compel, if necessary, every Irish home and institution to take a certain quantity of turf every year if that ensured that decent young Irish boys would be kept at home in gainful employment on the bogs. However, we have got to go further than that. We have got to ensure that the present generation, those aged from 18 to 20 years, will get back a sense of pride in their own country and a desire to stay at home to work and develop their own country. I do not exaggerate—and there are plenty of people in the House who know I am not exaggerating—when I say that the present generation may be described as being highly sceptical of all politicians and of politics. My attitude is that in the present situation the Government can take two steps to ameliorate the position.

They can, first of all, immediately put into effect substantial schemes as already referred to by various speakers, and some which were referred to by the Taoiseach himself. They can immediately recant this economic folly of over taxation. It may be that the Taoiseach would say to me: where are you going to find the money to do that? To my mind there are certain adjustments in theload of taxation that might take the heaviest burden off the most affected sections. As well as that I do think that some Government will have to face the curbing of administration expenses. The amount of money that is spent unproductively in the Supply and Services account in the general balance sheet of this country is inordinately high as compared with the amount of money actually put into productive work in the State.

These are big problems. I am not going to suggest that you can wave a wand to solve them, but I think it is going to take an immense amount of serious thought and hard work to evolve plans that can give hope for the future to the Ireland of to-day, and that it is going to take a very large earnest of goodwill by way of tax alleviation on the part of the Government to establish or regain any type of confidence from the Irish people. The Government has an extremely difficult task. It has not got the confidence of the people, but it has all the ailments of the present situation around its neck. The Taoiseach has said that he will choose the time and the ground to fight a general election. If he cannot find himself in the situation of being able to grapple witn the immediate serious problems of to-day, I would earnestly say to him as a man who has spent his whole life in the service of this country: go back to the people and seek their opinion; place, the problems and difficulties of the situation before the people and let them send back whatever Government they desire to continue with the problem of building an economic future for this country.

We have had too much bitterness and too much hate, too much dissension on unessential things, and I think it is time that the Irish people were given an opportunity of selecting a Government or a Dáil that would deal with the immediate problems of the present, hoping to ensure a future rather than waste time, as much of the time of many Dáils has been wasted in personal invective and hate about things that happened years ago that may have had rights andwrongs on both sides but were better left to the people of the days gone by. Let us build to-day for the Ireland of to-morrow, and let us ensure when building that the foundations are worthy of the sacrifice which made the First Dáil and the continuance of the First Dáil possible.

Comment on this

I think there is no person in this House, no matter on what side he sits, who will attempt in any way to minimise the importance of the subject under discussion to-night. I think further, from what I have heard with the exception of the last speaker—that there was very little contribution made to the solution of our problems, and those people throughout the country who were waiting for some assurance that their grievances and hardships will be remedied will find very little consolation from reading the papers tomorrow.

Nobody, I think, on the Government side has dared to suggest that the demand of £150,000,000 in taxation is a reasonable one. How that money has to be found or how it will be found nobody has suggested here, but that the money must be found to keep this State going is a fact, and not that alone, but to that £150,000,000 we must add practically £13,500,000 in local taxation, a colossal figure for 3,000,000 people to find for running the State for 12 months. It may be suggested that the question of local taxation should not be linked with the question of central taxation, but I want to point out to the members of the Government that their action contributed very largely to the demand of £13,500,000 in local taxation. The withdrawal of the subsidies imposed burdens on county councils and other local bodies in the upkeep of institutions in every county. The increase in wages justly demanded as a result of the increase in the cost of household commodities put a further burden on the local rates, and those two factors combined are, in the main, responsible for the very heavy increase in local rates this year. It has been said by different people that the only way wre can meet this expenditure is by increased production, and when we talk of increasedproduction we can only think of agricultural production. But can those who work on farms, whether as farmers or labourers, themselves be expected to increase production so long as the burden of overhead expenses is being inereased year by year? Some people speak of production and they are thinking of tillage, and tillage only, but I think one of the most important factors in our production here is the improvement of our grasslands to provide more live stock. If we look at our trade returns we will see that it is on the export of live stock that we practically depend here to preserve our balance of trade.

I said, when speaking on the former Vote on Account, that high national expenditure in itself was not an evil. The Minister for Finance either misunderstood or misrepresented that statement and he suggested that I called for increased taxation. I say again, with all the emphasis I can command, that high expenditure in itself is not an evil or leading to national disaster provided money raised in taxation is used in a productive manner. But unfortunately the vast amount of £150,000,000 contributed by the people of this country will not be spent productively but will be spent largely, as the last speaker said, mainly on administration, and the people who are called on to produce the money to carry out our social services schemes are getting no appreciation or return from this Government.

I said on a former occasion here that I thought it politically and economically foolish that the Government should reduce the grants under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. Schemes promoted as a result of these grants provided rural employment to a very high degree and at the same time vastly improved the land of this country. The Government say to-day that they have increased the grants for the land project work but, as I said on a former occasion, that money will not be needed for the simple reason that the reduced grants available under the Local Authorities (Works) Act will mean that there will be a corresponding reduction in the number of main outfalls which can bemade and the land project cannot be operated without first opening the main outfalls, as would happen if a sufficient number of grants were made available under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. The sale of the machinery provided for the land project scheme has created disemployment in my county and in a number of other counties. It is no excuse for the Government to say that more money is being provided for the land project because the report of the inspectors of the Department of Agriculture who have to examine the different applications for work under the land project in practically every case is to the effect: "We cannot carry out this work until the county council make the outfall". It is sheer absurdity, indeed a species of political myopia, for the Department of Local Government to reduce the grants by a further 50 per cent., seeing that the operation of the land project is impossible unless work is first carried out under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

In every emergency an appeal is made to the farming community that farmers must produce more, that the agricultural output must increase or we cannot maintain our social services. It must be remembered that the cost of living for the farmer has gone up for the last two years. In other walks of life the increase in the cost of living has been offset by increased wages, but for the man self-employed on his land, there is nothing to meet the increased cost of living. Still, the farmers are told that they must find this £101,500,000. It is they, and the alone, must find it and the Taoiseach and members of the Government know that just as well as I do.

I made an appeal here last year that assistance should be given to the farming community for the purchase of fertilisers because, in that way without any great effort, you can automatically increase by at least 25 or 30 per cent. the output from our land. When I mentioned it, the Tánaiste—he seemed to lose his patience or his nerve—told me to stop talking about it, that there would be no provision for assistance in the purchase of fertilisers. Does any man who ever worked an acre ofland not know that output would be considerably increased if we had sufficient fertilisers to apply to the land? The only reason why fertilisers are not applied to the degree to which they should be applied is that the farmers cannot afford to pay for them. Every farmer realises the vast improvement in his land that could be brought about by the use of artificial fertilisers. He knows that he could feed more live stock, increase his grain output and the yield of his root crops and potato crops. He knows that he could increase the yield from his farm in every form if he could apply sufficient fertilisers, but his financial position does not permit him to do so. I suppose it will be possible for this country to maintain its social services as long as the price of live stock remains high. Fortunately, or unforfortunately, whichever way we look at it, world conditions at present indicate that the price of live stock will remain high for some considerable time to come, but I have no hesitation in prophesying that if there is a sudden drop in the price of live stock our social services will crash.

I have heard some references here to live-stock farmers in certain parts of the country. One would imagine to listen to some of the speakers that these people have not contributed their share to the national income. Live-stock production and live-stock exports are a very important factor in Irish agriculture. I think that, taken on the whole, from the point of view of employment and national income, the store cattle trade of this country forms the most important part of our agricultural industry. For that reason, I should like if some member of the Government would indicate why under the recent agreement, second-grade cattle only are allowed to be exported to the Continent. I should like to know whether that was done at the instigation of the British Government or on the suggestion of some member I of the Irish Government, because I think anybody engaged in the cattle trade will agree that in years past in the Dublin market continental buyers often left British buyers standing and gave a far higher price for stock.

Comment on this

Stores?

Comment on this

Yes, stores. I can see the position arising that if only second-grade cattle are allowed to be sent to the Continent, the British will have the pick of the market, and it cannot be expected that continental buyers will pay for second-grade cattle the same price as the British pay for grade A cattle. I do not want to suggest anything that would be detrimental to the development of the carcase meat industry. I realise its potential economic value, but I say that if we are to build up the carcase meat industry at the expense of our store cattle trade, I would be very much opposed to it. A system operated in this country for a long time whereby farmers on the inferior land raised cattle until they were one and a half or two years old and then sold them to farmers on the better land in Leinster at a reasonably economic price. After being fed for some time on the fattening lands in Leinster, the cattle were exported as fat cattle. That was a system which operated very satisfactorily, and I do not think anybody in Leinster or Connaught could find any complaint against it.

Comment on this

Not now.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by that?

Comment on this

There were grounds for complaint on many occasions.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy is not very familiar with this question.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Finan might continue.

Comment on this

I want to emphasise again—and I say it in no critical or carping spirit—that any action by a Government in this country that would undermine or be detrimental to the store cattle trade would be against the best interests of the Irish farmer.

Comment on this

You are not suggesting that the Government has done anything in that way in the recent trade agreement?

Comment on this

I have pointed out that in the recent trade agreement the export of cattle to the Continent is restricted to second-class grade or grade B.

Comment on this

You had a different story some minutes ago.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary asks any man who attends the Dublin market who were the better buyers over the past three or four years in that market at certain seasons he will be told that the continental buyers often left the British standing. The continental buyers bought the best beef at the best price. That cannot happen now because the continental buyers will not be so foolish as to give a higher price for second-grade cattle than the British give for first-grade cattle.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote the article in the agreement which provides for that?

Comment on this

There is a copy in the Library.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be able to produce his authority.

Comment on this

I will produce it later.

Comment on this

Get the 1948 Trade Agreement as well.

Comment on this

I do not think it would serve any useful purpose if I were to compare one document with another. What I am saying, I am saying in the interests of the farming community. Was it on the suggestion of a member of this Government, or at the suggestion of a member of the British Government that that change was made?

Comment on this

What change?

Comment on this

The change to which I have referred.

Comment on this

What change?

Comment on this

There was no restriction put as to the grading of cattle.

Comment on this

There was in the 1948 agreement.

Comment on this

Deputy Finan is talking about grading.

Comment on this

And under that agreement we were not permitted to export more than 25 per cent. first-grade cattle, or, of the lowest, 50 per cent.

Comment on this

And cows and bulls were included.

Comment on this

I have not a copy of the agreement with me but, even if the Minister is right, that does not after the situation in the least. Two wrongs can never make a right.

Comment on this

The wrong that was committed by Deputy James Dillon apparently does not count; it is a virtue.

Comment on this

I condemned it for the very same reason. I hold no brief for Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture any more than I do for the present Minister. Neither will I take sides as between one and the other. I am not trying to misrepresent the situation.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy will find if he reads the 1948 agreement that what we say is correct.

Comment on this

If it is in it it should not be in it. It is in this agreement, and I say it should not be in it.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy has to find out.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy agree that the new trade agreement is a much improved document as, compared with the 1948 agreement? There is an improvement to the extent of 15 per cent. in regard to first-grade cattle and, in addition to that, there is the free export of bulls and cows without restriction.

Comment on this

Furthermore, it was not possible to make it without the 1948 agreement.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Deputy Finan would be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I hold that no one should tamper with our store cattle industry. It is an industry in relation to which no action should be taken either nowor in the future by any member of this House which would in any way endanger the store cattle trade. If I thought for a moment that the development of the carcass meat industry would do away with the store cattle industry——

Comment on this

How could it do away with it?

Comment on this

Of course it could. Everybody knows that.

Comment on this

Enlighten our ignorance.

Comment on this

We export store cattle to Britain and that is a very important trade.

Comment on this

You send some of them to Meath for fattening

Comment on this

I do not consider that export. If we were to turn over to the carcass meat trade entirely we would not have an export trade in store cattle.

Comment on this

We would send out more fat cattle.

Comment on this

We would fatten your stores and give a better price for them.

Comment on this

The situation could easily develop in the way in which the situation developed in relation to the bacon factories when the poor unfortunate farmer could only sell to one man in the district.

Comment on this

Is it cattle or bacon the Deputy is talking about?

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy Blaney that he could leave this matter to people who are better acquainted with the subject than he is.

Comment on this

I would if I could recognise them in this House.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's own fault. I submit that the agreement is liable to injure the store cattle trade.With regard to unemployment, I believe that if the local Authorities (Works) Act was fully implemented rural employment would become available. I do not suggest the rural unemployment problem is as serious as it is in the city, but there are pockets of unemployment throughout the country. County councils, in order to conserve money for the winter periods when more pecple are normally out of work, are slowing down on their activities.

Comment on this

They have been told to hurry up. They have been told to put schemes forward.

Comment on this

And they have more money.

Comment on this

I am glad that has been mentioned because last week I rang the Department of Local Government asking for sanction for three or four schemes in order to relieve the unemploy ment position and the reply I got was that they were holding the money over for the winter period.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will give me a copy of that reply I will look into the matter.

Comment on this

It was a telephone communication. I pointed out to the gentleman that that was an absurd suggestion because £1 spent on drainage in the summer months gives a better return than £10 spent on drainage in the winter months. In winter the drains are flooded and one cannot get near either the drains or the rivers. If the money is spent now there will be a better return and at the same time there will be some relief of the unemployment situation. I think any reasonable man with any knowledge of drainage must appreciate that winter time is not the time to spend either public or private funds on drainage.

Comment on this