We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 1–200 of 613. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

When the House adjourned last night, I was suggesting to the Minister that, with a view to getting the best possible return for the money spent by the Department of Local Government under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, and, further, with a view to relieving unemployment in certain areas, it would be desirable that the Department should immediately sanction the schemes which have been passed by the local authorities so that the work could be carried out now, and so that the best possible return would be got for the money spent. If that were done it would have the effect of alleviating the conditions which exist in many areas throughout the different counties where there is unemployment. I think that is a suggestion which should commend itself to the Minister. I sincerely hope that he will get in touch with the Department of Local Government with a view to getting my suggestion put into effect without delay. I believe that the carrying out of this work now, in conjunction with an intensification of the work to be done under the land project, would be very beneficial to the country.

In connection with the land project, I want to say that there is great disappointment amongst the farming community at the slow speed at which it is being operated. I know farmers in my constituency who made application in the first month the scheme was made applicable to the county, and they are still waiting for inspection and approval. Speaking generally, I think it would he futile to deny that the people are very much perturbed at the change that has taken place in the economic situation of this country over the past two years. Whether the Government like to admit it or not. it is a fact that during the lifetime of the inter-Party Government there was a reasonable standard of prosperity amongst every section of the community. That is not the case to-day. Whatever may be the reason, whetherworld conditions generally are to blame or whether it is the policy of the Government that is to blame, the fact is, without exaggerating it by rhetorical language, that there is a very high cost of living figure, a very high degree of unemployment and an economic situation that gives cause for alarm.

The marches of the type that we have been witnessing for the past couple of weeks in the capital city give every sensible man pause and must give whatever statesmen have control of the destiny of the country a check and make them realise that there is a situation that must be dealt with. I am not taking any sides in that matter. I am not conversant with the conditions which obtain in this city. When I speak of unemployment I speak of it as I know it in the country. We realise that an unemployed man in the city is in a far worse situation than an unemployed man in the country. That position, if allowed to develop, will bring this country to the verge of ruin.

No member of the Government can any longer pretend that it was the recklessness and extravagance of the inter-Party Government that brought about the present situation. I do not think there is any use in riding that horse any longer. The Taoiseach—the country owes him a debt for doing so— exploded that theory in Cork when he revealed, after a long silence, that more than 50 per cent. of the Marshall Loan was still unexpended.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

That is not so. It was committed. It had to be paid out to fulfil the commitments.

Comment on this

It was not spent. There was £24,000,000 there. It was not spent.

Comment on this

It had to be paid out to fulfil the commitments.

Comment on this

Could not you do what we did with the Constellations?

Comment on this

Commitments and undertakings are different things.

Comment on this

We scrapped the Constellations.

Comment on this

You want us to scrap the E.S.B.?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

I hope we will have none of the Party political propaganda that we had for the last six days.

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

You have been doing the humbugging.

Comment on this

On both sides of the House.

Comment on this

You should take off your halo now and again.

Comment on this

I share the view of Deputy Hickey entirely. It cannot be alleged that since I became a member of this House I have indulged in a display of Party politics. I have a very open mind on this whole question. The statement of the Taoiseach in Cork left very little doubt in my mind that that part of the propaganda of the Government had failed.

It was also alleged that the inter-Party Government had dissipated our external assets and bad brought the countiy to the verge of bankruptcy. I realise that when people get on platforms they are liable to make extravagant statements. We had the admission of the Minister for External Affairs the day before yesterday that they did not dissipate the external assets but increased them. Some proper reason must be given to the people as to why the circumstances have altered so considerably in the last few years. They will not believe that propaganda any longer. I admit that a great number of people who are not bigoted politically did accept the statements that were made during those two years. A great many sensible people said that perhaps we did need this check, that perhaps the last Government were spending extravagantly but, in the light of the two statements which I have referred to, the one by the Taoiseach and the other by the Minister for External Affairs, they are now disillusioned.

Frankly, I do not think it was the statements alone of Ministers for the first 12 months after they took office that created the trouble. Sensible people usually do not pay a lot of attention to politicians' statements and they are right. What affected the economic situation was the fact that the Minister for Finance had to pay 5 per cent. for a national loan. That created the situation that money was dearer here than it had ever been before. Every aspect of economic life was affected by the fact that the Minister for Finance had to pay such a high rate of interest for money. It will be found on examination that economic stagnation dates from the time the Minister made that announcement.

It is now understood that there will be another national loan issued this year, possibly at an even higher rate. If so, we may safely assume that those who have to borrow money will pay a substantially higher rate of interest than they are paying to-day. Does any Government suggest that that will solve the economic situation in the country?

These are not politics. These are hard economic facts. The sooner every member of this House realises that, the sooner a solution will be found. I freely admit that if I were saying these things for the purpose of belittling or lowering the standard of the Government, no matter what Government it might be, I would not be worthy of the slightest attention. Cannot we all admit frankly that there is an economic situation here which calls for immediate attention by every honest citizen? If we do, I am quite satisfied that there is sufficient patriotism, business acumen and intelligence in this House to solve whatever problems may confront us. He would be a poor man, he would be a poor Irishman, no matter where he sits in this House, if he would regret that such a solution could be found.

I have no intention of prolonging this debate. To be quite candid, I had not intended to speak in the debate. I expected last night that the debate would conclude and for that reason I had not prepared my statement as wellas I might have. When I came into the House last night it was not my intention to speak. As the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government knows, there was a great expectation that we might be able to conclude the business last night. I did not intend to participate in the debate. I made a statement from memory which the Minister challenged and told me to give the reference. I shall do so.

Paragraph 3 of the Annex to the Trade Agreement with Great Britain says:—

"The Government of Ireland further undertake that in any year 25 per cent. of total exports of live cattle from Ireland to countries other than the United Kingdom shall consist of second class cattle."

Will the Minister challenge that statement?

Comment on this

What about paragraph 5 of the 1948 Agreement?

Comment on this

I was not a member of this House when the Trade Agreement was made in 1948.

Comment on this

The Deputy was a member of the Seanad and supporting the Coalition.

Comment on this

It was equally bad.

Comment on this

I said last night, and I want the Minister to believe me now when I say, that I regarded it then as wrong and I regard it now as wrong and, as I told you, two wrongs will never make a right.

Comment on this
John Lynch Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. Lynch) Fianna Fáil

This debate has been rather like a snowball. Most of the speakers started by telling us that they had not intended to speak. That is common to practically all debates, because something that an opponent says or even a colleague stimulates argument, stimulates some Deputy's interest in the debate. I was here during the course of the first part of Deputy McGilligan's speech and I heard him giving us in broad perspective what he described as the results of the economic policy of Fianna Fáil in so far as they affected emigrationand employment. In view of some of the facts he gave rather in a general way, I think I might be permitted to refer to one or two of the comments he made. First of all, he told us with regard to the balance of payments, which his own chief, Deputy Costello, viewed with alarm in 1950 when the figure was in the region of £30,000,000, that when it reached £60,000,000 their advice to Fianna Fáil as a Government which had recently assumed office was not to worry, that the terms of trade were about to turn in our favour and that agricultural output as a result of Deputy Dillon's policy was on the increase, with the result that agricultural exports were bound to increase.

Let us examine the sage advice given to us on these two points. First of all, it did not need the wizardry of any ex-Minister for Finance to tell us that the terms of trade were about to turn in our favour. Everybody knew that on the outbreak of the Korean war there was panic buying and stockpiling throughout the whole world. Therefore, any commodities that this country, or any other country for that matter, had to import were bought in a seller's market. These goods were either scarce or there was a great suspicion and a serious expectation amongst nations that they would become scarce, which in itself created a scarcity and inflated prices because of that seller's market. With the situation easing as far as Korea was concerned, with the attempts to get a settlement of that situation, it was perfectly obvious even to the most superficial thinker that the terms of trade were about to change. Therefore, there was no force in Deputy McGilligan's argument that as a result of that advice the Government should not have taken the adverse balance of payments situation so seriously. The Government knew exactly what the situation was, as any other Government would have known.

Take his second point, that our main export, agricultural produce, was bound to increase as a result of Deputy Dillon's policy. Let us look even at the general figures of agricultural output in the year preceding Deputy Dillon's departure from office. Heifers-in-calfhad declined by 3,700 head; milch cows by 20,000; tillage by several tens of thousands of acres. Is it not ludicrous to suggest that as a result of Deputy Dillon's policy agricultural output was on the increase and therefore exports must have increased as a consequence?

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Give us the figures for agricultural exports.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I have not the figures. I am going back to the fundamental figures. Heifers-in-calf and milch cows had declined very seriously in the last year of Deputy Dillon's régime, and it is only natural that if we were to pursue that line of agricultural economy our exports were bound to decrease as long as milch cows, heifers-in-half and tillage were on the decrease.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy not agree that an in-calf cow is at least three years old?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Yes.

Comment on this

They are only coming to maturity and we are seeing the benefits now of Deputy Dillon's policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The point I am making is that it cannot be denied that not only cattle, but sheep, poultry and pigs had declined during Deputy Dillon's régime, as well as tillage. Therefore it cannot be honestly claimed that agricultural output in volnme was on the increase. It may, well have been increasing in value as a result of the increased value of agricultural products.

The Deputy then went on to deprecate the result of Fianna Fáil policy over the years on our population generally. He said that in the 21 years since 1932, 500,000 of our population were forced to emigrate and that on the average during each one of these years 60,000 people were on the unemployed register. As Deputy McGilligan brought us back to 1932, it might be no harm to jerk his own memory and bring him back to three or four years before 1932 when our emigration figures in some of these years stood at 25,000, 28,000 and 30,000. From 1932 to 1938, the last yearbefore the war, there was a steady decline, until we had the lowest figure ever reached since statistics were compiled, a figure very little over 8,000. I do not intend to go into the figures during the war years.

We knew they were unduly high then, but there were good economic reason for that. But immediately after the war the figures again began to decline and in 1947, the last year before Fianna Fáil left office, the emigration figure was 10,000. In 1948 it jumped again to 28,000, in 1949 to 34,000 and in 1950 to 41,000. Therefore I suggest that if the figures quoted by Deputy McGilligan are correct they would have been much worse but for the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government in 1932 and the embarkation on the second arm of our economic policy, the expansion of our industrial projects.

I forget whether it was in this debate or during the debate on the vote of confidence that Deputy Larkin commented on the figures of those in gainful employment in the country over the past 25 years. He commented in particular on the fact that, while Fianna Fáil claimed—and he readily admitted—that 100,000 odd people more had been put into industrial emloyment during their years of office, nevertheless the overall figure of the increase in employment as between agriculture and industry was only about 12,000 people. Is it not pertinent to suggest that were it not for that industrial expansion policy of Fianna Fáil, these figures would have been far worse?

I know that the fact that industrial employment was being created in the cities, in the towns and in some rural areas was having the effect of inducing people to leave the land. Notwithstanding that, there was the kindred problem, if you like to call it that, as far as the employment content on the land is concerned, namely, mechanisation on the farms. That, too, was having its effect. The tractors and combines appearing on the farms were creating less opportunity for manual work there Apart altogether from theattraction of industrial work, that also was driving people from the land. Therefore, is it not only right to suggest that were it not for the opportunities created by the industrial programme of Fianna Fáil in 1932, when well over 100,000 people were put into employment, the flight from the land and the unemployment figures as between industry and agriculture in this country would have been seriously worse at the present day?

In that connection I might comment on Deputy Larkin's speech. One automatically associates Deputy Larkin and most of what he says with the trade union and the labour movements. Deputy Larkin, like myself, is not too young to remember the years before 1932 when his trade union and other trade unions were not in existence, that to belong to a trade union was in many cases considered some kind of a badge of serfdom and certainly was not looked on with any favour by those in authority.

The growth of the trade union movement is allied to the Fianna Fáil industrial expansion programme. According as workers were being put into employment, according as there was a reasonable prospect of continuity of employment, the workers combined and went into their different unions. As far as I can judge—and I have not looked at the figures too closely—the registered membership of trade unions in this country in the last 25 years has increased by anything from 700 to 1,000 times. Therefore, is it not only right to claim that apart altogether from the separate measures that were taken over the years the security of employment, as a result of the combination of the workers in their different unions, went hand in hand with the advancement of Fianna Fáil agricultural and industrial policy?

As I indicated at the outset, Deputy McGilligan reminded us that he had given us that wonderful advice about changing the terms of trade when agricultural output was about to increase, but neither Deputy McGilligan nor any other spokesman from his Party gave us any indication as to how the gap of £15,000,000 that he left between the provision made to meet current expenditureand what current expenditure actually proved to be at the end of the year when he introduced the Budget which he knew he would not have to defend. Neither he nor anybody else has told us how they proposed to bridge that gap then or even now if they assumed office. Is it by way of increased taxation or by way of a reduction in many of the services that we have now or that even in the past year have been increased by Fianna Fáil? Deputy Hickey, I know, deprecates this line of argument but it is only pertinent to ask these questions when so much capital is being made out of a serious situation.

Comment on this

Is it not somewhat useless?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

It is not a bit useless. If we can get someone from that side of the House to make a reasonable approach to these problems or at least attempt to answer the question I put, I do not think it will be in the slightest degree useless. Much comment in the course of this debate has been made on the unemployment situation. I do not intend to indulge in platitudes that might be interpreted as an appeasement of those unemployed people. However, it is very easy for me to say and to mean that we all deprecate the position that has arisen. I would say to the people who are demonstrating that, apart altogether from their parades and their protests, the situation was very much present to the minds of the Government and to the minds of us who have any authority on local councils. They have made their protest and let them claim that it has been effective inasmuch as it may have stimulated more interest in their problem on the part of those in a position to remedy it. But I would suggest that, having made their protest and having been assured by the Government, by the corporations of the two main cities and by many county councils that every effort is being made to relieve the situation from now on, they should give an opportunity for these efforts on their behalf to materialise.

It has been suggested also that there is no point in meeting that situation by relief schemes, that to meet the situationin that manner will only create a similar situation in the near future; that we would again have to resort to a system of relief schemes to keep-down the figures on the live register. But the Taoiseach last night outlined, as far as Dublin is concerned, two or three major schemes that were on the point of being ready to go ahead. He referred particularly to the runways at Baldonnel and to the construction work that is urgently necessary in Dublin Castle, which was under consideration in 1948 and is now being brought to a stage when work can commence at an early date. These, surely, cannot be construed to be relief schemes. They are productive works which will have a high labour content.

There are, however, throughout many parts of the country, works that might be considered as relief schemes, but works which county councils and corporations by a little advanced planning—for example, clearance of derelict sites—could immediately embark upon, and while at the moment it would appear non-productive, ultimately it could the up with their town planning and housing programmes, with the result that even at this stage that work which could otherwise qualify for the title of relief would ultimately assume the title of productive work.

In Cork, in my own area, I know that the employment situation is not what I would like it to be. I get every week a quota of people, as well as looking for houses, looking also for jobs; in fact, those are the two main categories of the people who come to me looking for my assistance in the relief of their problems. But I think many of the people coming to me at the present time are people who have left jobs in England, or if they have not left jobs, have lost their jobs in England through slackness of one sort or another and have come back to Ireland looking for work. Many of them by their skill have been able to find it readily. Others for lack of skill or opportunity in the jobs for which they are skilled have been unable to get it. But in Cork the position is well in hand and schemes are being prepared and in many cases about to start thatcan absorb a large proportion of those who are at present unemployed.

Worthwhile works must, of necessity, take some time to plan properly if they are to prove ultimately to be of value, but even at the present time one of the most worthwhile jobs, that is, the development of our natural resources—and I refer particularly to the Lee hydro-electric scheme—is in full swing and there have been numbers of unemployed absorbed into it and according as the activities there will expand, more and more people will be able to find work there.

I referred earlier on to the effect of Fianna Fáil's industrial policy on the general relief of unemployment in the country and I suggest, and I think it cannot be denied, that their agricultural policy as well as stimulating work on the land has reflected the value of the policy by creating work in the towns and in the cities. Fianna Fáil policy with regard to agriculture is to encourage the maximum utilisation of our land, and in order to do so that land requires as much fertilisers as we can possibly apply to it. I am informed on good authority that in the fertiliser factory that we have in Cork more people were working during the season this year than there ever were in living memory. I think that is in itself a tribute to the manner in which our farmers are responding to the call for greater output and the manner in which the agricultural policy of the country is being handled. I believe that our fertiliser output is still falling far short of our normal needs, and I think that there is a field in which expansion of employment opportunities should at an early date be availed of. There is no doubt that more and more of our land will be brought into production and as a result more and more fertilisers will be used. If our present fertiliser manufacturing outfits are not geared or are not big enough to handle the output required, I think they should now seriously consider increasing their plant or modernising it, whichever will have the desired effect or both, in order to meet the already increased demand for fertilisers in this country.

We often hear of wild speculation as to this type or that type of commodity which heretofore has been imported and which should be produced at home, but here we have a commodity capable of being produced at home which at once benefits the land, benefits agricultural employment and benefits urban employment, and I believe here is a field in which the fertiliser manufacturers themselves should explore, and if they do not, they should be told firmly that unless they can do it some other means will have to be found and that since we can do the job ourselves there is no point in further depending on imports for these essentials. That is another aspect of increased employment being made available as a result of wise and long-term planning.

Housing has been referred to so often as being of the highest importance in absorbing labour that I could not pass at this stage without commenting on the position as it exists in my own constituency. Next to Dublin, in fact in some cases I am often inclined to think ahead of Dublin Cork's housing problem is the most serious, and realising the position all Parties represented on the Cork Corporation approached the Minister recently or at least some months ago and put the position seriously before him. There are in the neighbourhood of 4,000 odd families in Cork urgently needing housing accommodation and our output is only in the neighbourhood of 300 houses a year. The Minister, I must say in common with his two predecessors, indicated very forcibly that money was to be no obstacle whatever in the advancement of that housing programme whether it be city or rural, and as a result of that assurance it has been found possible now in Cork to plan ahead with more and more housing schemes. We have in one area a scheme of 366 houses, for 134 of which tenders have been invited aud have been submitted and I am sure in a very short time contracts wili be placed. At the present time there are 150 of these in progress. Extra staff has been recruited in the technical offices of the corporation, and our ultimate programme, our target, is 400 houses per year. That,in itself, is another means whereby the unemployment problem in Cork at any rate is being faced up to.

I do not have to dwell on other aspects of building programmes in Cork. We all know that several churches are planned, but I do not think it would be fair for me to go into it in any detail in this House because another authority is responsible ultimately for it; but, nevertheless, it can be readily seen that there is going to be another high absorption of unemployed skilled and unskilled labour in the immediate neighbourhood of Cork in the very near future.

Coming back again to works shared by the central and local authorities, a new school of music is planned and about to start in the present year in Cork City.

Comment on this

Who is going to pay for that tune?

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

It is good productive work, anyway, and it makes us happy. One can hardly pass from employment without commenting on the position in the textile industry. It affects Cork possibly more than many other places in the country, as in the city and in the immediate and remotely surrounding areas there are many textile factories of one kind or another. Two years ago we knew the serious position that existed in many of those industries. There was a general recession in the textile trade. The public, not only here in Ireland but throughout the entire world, were reluctant to bus textile goods. As well as that, you had the stockpiling that had taken place in the preceding 12 months. Much of that stockpiling was prudent, but I must comment seriously that the imports of textiles had all the appearance of a panic-stricken campaign. Much of the stuff imported not only was capable of being manufactured here but was not needed in the country.

The fact that it remained on the shelves of many of the retailers and wholesalers throughout the country was sufficient proof of that. Nevertheless the remedial measures that were taken by the Government and theTánaiste immediately on assuming office, brought back those textile workers who were completely out of work, working half-time or quarter-time, in and around Cork City, in places like Blarney, Midleton, Youghal and Dripsey, but all those workers were gradually restored to their jobs and more work was provided in most of those factories for other workers. As a result, most of the factories are now working two or three shifts and in almost every case their output to meet the current demand is almost six months behind time. That is not a desirable situation, either, but it is better that the workers should be working at full stretch to meet increased demands rather than be put on three-quarter time, half-time or quarter-time and ultimately get no time at all. The remarks I make regarding Cork can be applied generally throughout most of the other industrial areas.

With regard to the non-industrial areas, there has been adverse criticism, but the fact is that plans are being prepared or are in existence and no worthwhile work can go ahead without these plans. In regard to the rural areas, particularly in the West, there are plans for the provision of six major fishery harbours. There are plans—I am sure Deputy O'Donnell will again interject: "When?"—for the Clady hydro-electric scheme.

Comment on this

An excellent idea.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

There are plans for four small turf generating stations, for an electricity generating station based at Arigna, for a station based at Lanesboro' in Longford. No one can suggest that these works can be started overnight, but as long as we are assured that the technical surveys and examinations are taking place, those who are depending on these project either for work or for amenities can he assured that both work and amenities will be provided at the earliest possible moment.

Therefore, apart altogether from immediate works that must be put in hands, there is the assurance that as long as the policy now being pursued is followed, plans for the utilisation of our natural resources for the economic,industrial and agricultural development of our country will go ahead. There will be no deviation from that policy as long as this Party has any say in government.

There have been many opportunities here, particularly in the last six months, to discuss the Government's financial policy and it has been discussed inside out, starting with the original Vote on Account and continuing through the Budget, the Finance Bill and the vote of confidence to this debate. Even at various stages of the prolonged debate on the Health Bill, Fine Gael in particular have seized every opportunity to cash in on the difficult situation which has persisted and which was largely of their own making. They have blamed the Government for introducing a Health Bill that nobody wants, but if they were close to the people for whose benefit primarily this Health Bill has been introduced, they would realise that the health provisions in force at present are by no means adequate. I am not casting any reflection on the efficiency of the out-patients' departments of many of our big hospitals, but it is not a very pleasant thing to see queues of poor people sitting on benches placed on cold terrazzo floors, even in winter, waiting for outpatients' treatment. You find that one visiting surgeon or physician, assisted by a few students from a medical school, has to deal with all these people. I do not have to tell any Deputy Who may be a member of a hospital board of the position that arises almost daily in centres of large population, where they are approached by relatives of very sick people, imploring them to use what influence they can bring to bear on the hospital authorities to provide a bed for that sick relative.

Comment on this

The Health Bill will not give them any more.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Our health policy, allied to that Health Bill, is designed to ease that situation. More hospitals are being built, more hospitals are being planned, and the situation will soon be reached, please God, when any personwho needs a hospital bed badly will not be denied it for one hour longer than necessary.

Comment on this

We would all like to see that situation.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Health Bill has been debated here on and off since last March or early April. As long as the Opposition continue the tactics they indulged in, in trying to delay the passage of that Bill, so long will our people be denied the hospital and health treatment they require.

Comment on this

Nonsense. Might I inquire, as the Parliamentary Secretary has taken that line, whether this Vote includes anything for Health? It is the one Department for which nothing is included.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

As far as I know, there is a rather big provision.

Comment on this

It is the only thing for which nothing was provided.

Comment on this

That is because full provision was made on the last Vote on Account. This is for the general conduct of the public services.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

If Fine Gael can comment on the general outlook of the economic position at almost every stage of the Health Bill, it is hardly irrelevant for me to comment very briefly on the Health Bill on this Vote on Account. Last night we witnessed what I hope will not occur too often in this House: we witnessed attempts by the Opposition to shout down a statement which was being made by the Taoiseach. I have in mind in particular younger members of the Fine Gael Party deliberately trying to misrepresent the Taoiseach in the course of his statement and deliberately trying to lead him off the line of debate which he had chosen for himself. I hope that, so long as I am a young member of this House, if I happen to be on the Opposition side I shall never address a Taoiseach in a manner similar to that in which some Deputies on the Opposition addressed the Taoiseach last night. Apart altogether from blaming the Government for holding on to office, theseyoung members of Fine Gael, and older members also, know that the situation is now about to change for the better. Their disappointment is that they cannot get into office and ride once more on the ship of State that has been guided into calm waters, with full steam ahead.

Deputy Seán Collins commented last night on the vigorous approach to the problems in hand which was displayed by the Taoiseach last night. That vigorous approach displayed by the Taoiseach is indicative of the Government's vigorous approach to meet that situation in the immediate months ahead. I appeal to speakers who may follow me, and whose intention it will be to criticise the Government, to try to be constructive in their criticism and to suggest what they, in similar circumstances, would do in face of the existing situation. Do they propose to increase the social benefits? Do they propose to restore subsidies? If they do, in what way are they going to provide for these increased benefits and the restoration of the subsidies which have been reduced? I think these are pertinent questions and ones which they should be in a position to answer.

In conclusion, I would say to the Opposition Parties and to the people of the country that the Fianna Fáil Party is not the type of Party which the Opposition are trying to make out that it is. Fianna Fáil are not taking a fiendish delight—as the Opposition try to allege—in creating hardships for the people. The members of this Government fought too hard, before they ever assumed office, in the interests of our people, to do such a thing. As members of the Government, they toiled hard and effectively in the interests of our people. Surely, it cannot be suggested now that, after three and a half years of Opposition, they return to office with no other motive or objective than to impose hardships on the people from whence most of them sprang? Man for man the people on this side of the House had to combat hardship during the course of their lives to a greater degree than the people on the opposite side. They had to fight harder fortheir existence and, man for man, they fought harder and more effectively for the freedom of the country. Therefore, it is ludicrous and sheer misrepresentation to suggest that, if hardships were imposed, it was done merely to penalise the people. What has been done was done by men who have served the people long and faithfully, who have worked hard and effectively in their interests and who intend to continue that work. So long as the Government follow the lines they are now pursuing to restore financial stability and balance to the country, to ensure that moneys expended on capital works will show a return in the future and that so-called "capital works" are not merely bolstered-up relief schemes—so long as that policy is continued and the Government get a chance to show the fruits of that policy—the people will realise more and more that their best interests are being looked after by the Government.

Comment on this

I think everyone here recognises that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government is an honest and intelligent member of the House. However, having listened to the attempt he has made to apologise for the inactivity of the Government in relation to the major economic problems that face the country at the present time, one is forced to conclude —because of his record of honesty and ability—that he has very little material with which to indicate any promise for the unemployed men in the future.

One of Deputy Lynch's statements was to the effect that since Fianna Fáil came into power in 1932 they did better than the Cumann na nGaedheal Government did prior to that. He said that Fianna Fáil's agricultural policy was better than that of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and that Fianna Fáil's industrial policy was so good that, even if the agricultural policy were bad, the industrial policy counterbalanced it.

The Labour Party have very little interest in whether or not Fine Gael's record is better than that of Fianna Fáil, or vice versa. Our interest is in how the country is to progress in the future. I desire to take advantage of this debate to draw attention to theserious position which many of our people—in particular, working people-find themselves faced with. Members of the Government and Deputies of this House are about to go on a prolonged holiday without any definite plans having been announced for the improvement of that serious position.

It cannot be denied that, in the past two years, prices have sky-rocketed. The prices of essential commodities such as bread, butter, tea and sugar, in addition to other foodstuffs, have increased considerably. So much have they increased that, I suggest, these commodities are almost beyond the purchasing power of the normal working man. If he is to secure sufficient for himself and his family to eat, then he must certainly go without some other necessity.

It is well known to many of us that in certain small shops throughout the country the sale of butter has fallen considerably while the sale of margarine has doubled. It is not from choice but dire necessity that a workman's wife will feed to her children not wholesome Irish butter but a poor substitute, and the only reason that is done is that the pries of our butter is beyond the means of the ordinary people.

Unemployment is stalking the land and it reminds me—Fianna Fáil will perhaps take pleasure in this fact—of the days between 1930 and 1942; but again, we in the Labour Party have no interest in the Party or political programme under which unemployment creeps in. Our interest is in seeing that all our people, in so far as is humanly possible, will be able to exercise their God-given right to secure work for themselves and their families. It is not necessary, I suggest, to go to the employment exchange and look up the records to find proof from the returns there of unemployment. Anyone passing by an exchange can see that, in the queues standing outside, and particularly in the cities, there are men and women anxious and available for work to whom work is denied. At the street corners in the small towns, there is unfortunately ample evidence of unemployment,with people parading the streets seeking work which up to now they have failed to secure.

In Dublin City, mass parades of hungry unemployed men and women have become an almost daily feature. I realise that many even in this House will say that these are led by agitators and by people of doubtful character. I am not in a position to dispute such a statement and neither am I in a position to confirm it; but I do know that, unless there were thousands upon thousands of unemployed hungry people, these agitators, if they exist, would find it difficult to persuade well-fed, satisfied employed men to parade in the name of any "ism" or cause through the streets of Dublin. It is only because the evil is there that any "ism" is in a position to exploit it, if exploited it is being, for their own purposes.

Neither do I accept that there are agitators and I regret to say that I have heard it said that at some of these meetings—it has been made a joke of in this House—one of the leaders is supposed to have remarked: "We have not got the crowd to-day, lads, because they are working." That is an implication that this is a frame-up. I remember it being said of our unemployed in 1940 and prior to that year, that they would not work in a fit, but when the bombs fell on England and when work was made available for men at the risk of their lives, our Irish unemployed men and even our women were not afraid to go across to face starvation, bombs and doodle-bugs, so that they could send home to their people who were depending on them the money necessary to keep them alive.

I label it as the same slander on the unemployed to suggest that the men who march the streets to-day are men who have come out of jobs and who are parading for political or any other reasons. I have personally spoken to them; I have addressed them. I am not on such terms of intimacy with the leaders that I can indicate the complete background of any or many of them ; but I am satisfied that 98 per cent. of the unemployed who aremarching and demonstrating in Dublin to-day are doing so to draw attention to their plight and to show that their desire is not to march the streets but to be employed in their own country at a decent wage.

While I say it is not necessary to produce figures to convince anybody who a wishful of seeing things in proper perspective in the matter of unemployment, it is desirable, in making a protest against the evil of unemployment to say that these facts can be gathered from the register of employment in Dublin, and hard facts from Government offices are difficult to disprove. In April, 1953, in the Dublin metropolitan area, there were 20,133 insurable workers unemployed; in April, 1951, in the same area, there were 12,571 insurable workers unemployed. That is an increase in, two years of 7,562 insurable workers, or an increase of 60 per cent.

That percentage of insured workers unemployed in a two years' period does away with the statement that the new benefits caused the unemployment in Dublin, because excluded from these figures are the people in agricultural employment, in fishing and in private domestic service, and it was from these sources that the vast increase came on the register when the new scheme came in. No matter how things are examined in Dublin, from the point of view of observance of the mass demonstrations or examination of the figures available, in the light of our circumstances, it can be clearly shown that unemployment is not only there, but is there to an extent that is alarming and frightening to those of us who have responsibility for examining the position.

The figures of unemployment throughout the land, plus the high cost of living, as I hope to show, have a two-fold effect upon the population. It is but to be expected that where you have the twin evils of unemployment and the high cost of living, their natural ally and support, the evil of emigration, will follow close on their heels.

I understand that this country normally exports between 20,000 and 25,000 people per year. Should the positioncontinue as it is with unemployment growing and with the cost of living ever increasing, is it not clear that the life blood of this country will be drained off within a short period by the added force that will be behind the emigration drive until the time will come when the people leaving this country, plus those dying through natural causes, will offset those being born and the population will begin to decline?

I think it can be fairly stated in this House, without fear of contradiction, that the main cause of price increases over the past two years has been the removal of the food subsidies. That was the deliberate action of the present Government and it was supported by the Independent Deputies who helped that Government. On them must be placed, be it for good or for bad, the consequences of the deliberate action committed by them. If the Government and their Independent followers have increased the price of the most essential of the workman's food—bread, butter, tea and sugar— and if the people have suffered—and I suggest they have suffered grievously— the Government or those Independents who carried out that action must not expect from the people loyalty, love or affection, but their rightful detestation and the promise of the people that, if given the opportunity, they will bring the perpetrators of that deed to justice and to the punishment they deserve.

The cost of living at the present day is 132 per cent. above that of pre-war figures. In ordinary English and in terms that the ordinary people appreciate more, that means that a £ in 1939 would buy as many commodities as 46/5 would buy at the present moment. The effect of that loss in value of money on people such as old age pensioners, widows and orphans and people on fixed incomes, irrespective of whether they receive those incomes from a private employer, investments, pensions secured in a foreign army or elsewhere, is that the purchasing power of those people between 1939 and the present day, unless they were granted increases from the sources where they secured theirincomes, has been reduced by over 50 per cent. Even the ordinary worker who has the good luck to be employed is affected by the reduced purchasing power of the £.

For the past two years prices have increased by 22 per cent. but wages, even after the fourth increase, have lagged far behind and now reach only 9 per cent. The overall effect of the reduction in the purchasing power of the old age pensioners and of the workers has been that he or she has to do with less. A Government case was made at the time of the Budget, when these alterations were effected, that they would give in, the form of increased children's allowances and increased social welfare benefits granted to the poor with one hand that which had been taken from them with the other by the reduction of the subsidies. They also stated that they hoped the workman would, through trade union activity, and the goodness of his employer, be able to secure increased wages that would make up for the increased cost of living. Even had it been true at that time that the old age pensioners and the widows and orphans and those in receipt of social benefits of all kinds got an increase that was equal to the then cost of living, must it not be clear to everyone that, if the cost of living has continuously increased since, without any further adjustments in these benefits, a further grave reduction of spending power must have taken place in their incomes?

Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll, speaking, I think, on the Budget, expressed the view that he had hoped the increase in wages would take up the slack in the increased cost of living for the workers. He expressed grave doubts that that had happened over the past two years. I would whole-heartedly agree with Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. That did not happen, and I suggest it could not happen. If we examine what really happens when the index figure increases, and if we examine its effect on the ordinary trade unionist we can see that it could never happen that wage increaseswould catch up with the increase in the cost of living. A new index figure is got every three months. That has to be published, examined and claims for wages framed. These claims have to be lodged and negotiated. Very often there are protracted negotiations lasting six months. Agreements are finally reached which give the worker something better than he has but not the whole of what he looked for.

With the time factor of the delay in the negotiations, plus the fact that the worker did not secure the full amount of what he was looking for, on each occasion when the index figure is published and shows an increase, the employed worker is some little bit worse off until he finds it practically impossible to keep himself or his family without gradually eating into any savings that may be there or going deeper and deeper into debt.

It may be said to me: what can the Government do in regard to price control, or what can the Government do in regard to the cost of living? There are factors outside the control of the Government that have a part in prices and because of that the Government may claim that they have no responsibility. I would suggest that, by the deliberate action of the Government itself, it broke down the control established, at the request of Deputy Norton in the last year of the inter-Party Government, over a whole range of commodities in this country, and while it kept up the appearance of keeping in force the Prices Advisory Body, by non-reference to that body of certain important applications for price increases, it permitted in a deliberate manner private enterprise to satisfy itself as to the prices at which they would sell their goods. I am aware that the Tánaiste has expressed the belief and hope that private competition would fix a ceiling and eventually a reduction, if left to itself, but I am afraid that the Tánaiste has forgotten the fact that the employers have now learned that organisation pays dividends, and by their rings and combinations they see to it that their prices will not only be fair but generous.

The effect of the high cost of living and reduced purchasing power of ordinary consumers in this country has had a terrific effect on employment content. It is a well-known fact that three-quarters of the money spent each year in this country—and for goods mainly to make up employment content in the country—is personal consumption buying. In 1951, £360,000,000 out of a total of £483,000,000 was personal consumption buying. That is practically three-quarters. The effect of a reduced figure for personal consumption buying will naturally mean reduced trade for the traders. This in effect will go on to the factories and right on to the source of production leaving in its trail unemployed men and women. The vicious circle will continue and the falling-off of employment of those thousands of men and women will in itself add to the depression and, if permitted, as apparently it is going to be permitted, we will have nothing to face but economic ruin, unemployed men with no solution but the emigrant ship.

In May, 1953, 76,200 unemployed men and women, boys and girls, were in this country. I suggest that at the very lowest you could double that figure because of the fact that on each of those unemployed to some greater or lesser extent, depends either a wife, a child, a brother, or sister or some other relative. Last week the figure was 62,400. Unemployment is dropping, but let us not get any false opinions from that fact. It is a well-known fact that January each year is the peak period of unemployment, and that the valley period is July. That has been so over the last 20 years. It is a seasonal change. If the indications give any clue as to the events that are to come, we have very little to look forward to from the month of August up to next January.

The winter period when more food is necessary, better clothing is necessary and more heating, will, if things follow the usual trend, mean that more unemployment is to come until we reach again the peak in the bitter month of January next. And all this time this House proposes to go on holidays. Aswell as the seasonal drop in the valley period being reached at the present moment there is the fact that the second Employment Period Order is in being. Were it not for that, and were it the month of January, I would suggest that the indications are there and clearly there of the highest record figure of unemployment unless something drastic is done by the Government. There are certain indications that not only are we not providing employment, but that certain major industries of this country carrying the highest labour content are on the verge of wholesale dismissals of workers. Should that happen, added to the present unemployment position, it will be a miracle if the workers of this country do not in their anger and in their bafflement forget there is local government and endeavour to force from us what it is our duty to provide for them by good government.

I suggest to this Government that there is an emergency on at the present moment just as serious and just as dangerous for this country as during the 1940-1945 period. At that time almost overnight we had built up an army. We had put into operation the darkening of lights, the obliteration of street signs and cross-road indications. Everything was treated as if we were on a war footing. Is there anything wrong with having the same attitude now when over 100,000 people in this country are starved for want of the necessities of life, because they cannot secure work in the country. I appeal to the Government to give to every local authority complete autonomy, to go ahead with any of the schemes they have planned without requiring sanction from the Department of Local Government. Give them that autonomy for a period of 12 months. I can assure the Government, from my knowledge of local authorities, that they will not squander either Government or local authority money; that they will put into operation emergency schemes carrying big labour content that will be of some use to every local authority and will absorb the majority of unemployed people in the rural area.

How the matter can be dealt with in Dublin and the bigger cities I am notin a position to advise, but I am quite satisfied that if that autonomy, that automatic sanction for large schemes is given by the Minister for Local Government and if his partner, the Minister for Health, will co-operate, within a month, instead of seeing queues at the labour exchange, you will see returning from work happy and contented workmen.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I am not going to delay the House at any great length. I feel that the matters discussed over the last few days here have been amply discussed in debates over the last couple of years and that we might have hoped to get from this discussion what we have not got for the last couple of years from the Government —a statement of how they propose to ensure that the standard of living of our people is improved, a clear statement of policy of how they propose, in particular, to deal with the urgent situation in regard to unemployment and the cost of living which is now facing this country. Instead of that, we have been entertained by Government speakers and their supporters with the sort of speeches which would be quite simple now for anybody, who has taken any notice of what has been happening in the Dáil or in the country for the last two years, to prepare beforehand. We have heard the old themes trotted out. We have heard a discussion of how the inter-Party Government are to blame for what is occurring at the present time. We have heard statements of how the inter-Party Government had dissipated our external assets, how they had brought this State to the verge of bankruptcy, how they had dissipated the Marshall Aid funds and how the present Government had put finances of the State in order. We have heard all these things in the last few weeks from the Government Benches and the benches supporting them, but we have not heard any concrete statement of policy from them as to how they are going to remedy the situation, the very serious and critical situation, which the country is now facing.

Recently, however, a new theme has been struck by Government spokesmen. We are now being informed bythe Government, in the words of the Minister for Finance in the Seanad last week, that this country, far from being in a parlous condition, is very much on the upgrade. The Government are now making the case, and their supporters are taking up the tune, that things are looking better and that all we have got to do is to wait and see and the proofs of Government policy will soon be evident. We heard the Taoiseach last night and on the vote of confidence the week before, waxing indignant at the idea that his Party had no policy. I want to say that with some of the things the Taoiseach said yesterday, and earlier on the vote of confidence motion, I do not think there is one person in this House would disagree but I say further that what he said yesterday and earlier on the vote of confidence was not policy. Who is going to disagree with any man when he says that he is in favour of increasing industrial production? Who is going to disagree with any body who says he is in favour of utilising the resources of the State to the maximum? Who is going to disagree with anybody who says that he is in favour of keeping the cost of living figure at the lowest possible level? But that is not policy. These are merely pious aspirations. They are agreed ends which we would all like to achieve but what we want to hear from the Government and from the Minister when he is replying to-day, is how they are going to achieve these ends. Let the Minister for Finance tell the people who are unemployed, who are marching the streets of Dublin to-day, how they are going to get work. Let him tell the harassed housewife how they are going to bring down the cost of living. Let him tell the business community how they are going to increase industrial production.

I do not make any excuse for reiterating what has been said here before or for bringing to the notice of the Government the serious situation in regard to unemployment and the cost of living which obtains in this State at present. Before doing so, however, I wish to make a few remarks on some of the figures which the Minister forFinance gave to justify his statement that things are now very much on the upgrade. The Minister in a letter to the papers recently, and also in the Seanad last week, gave figures which he regarded as evidence that things were getting better, that people were beginning to spend more and that the country was now very much on the upgrade. The figures which he gave were the figures of expenditure in the first three months of this year as compared with the figures for the same period last year on beer, spirits and tobacco. What I want to give to the House is not the figures for expenditure on these items, because everybody knows that the cost of these items has increased very much over the last 18 months; the figures I want to give are the figures showing the actual consumption of these items which in my opinion are a better guide as to what the people are consuming and the ability of the people to spend. The figures for beer retained for home consumption show that in the first three months of 1952 there were 204.99 thousand standard barrels retained for home consumption. For the first three months of this year that figure was reduced to 175.70 thousand barrels. These figures are a clear indication that during these three months consumption had been drastically reduced.

Similar figures are available for potable spirits retained for home consumption. For the first three months of last year the figure was 235.82 thousand proof gallons, and for the first three months of this year the figure was 173.81 thousand proof gallons. The figures in respect to manufactured tobacco released for home production also show a reduction. For the first three months of 1952, there were 4,043,000 lb. of manufactured tobacco released for home consumption. The figure for the first three months of this year showed that there were 3,344,000 lb. released for home consumption. The reason why I am delaying the house by giving these figures——

Comment on this

The Deputy should be a little bit more up to date. He is just three months behind the times.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The Minister has, I presume, figures that are more recent and I will be very glad if he will give those figures. I will wait with eagerness for the Minister to give the consumption of these items. I want to make it clear that if there was an improvement in the economy of this country, if things were getting better, if the cost of living was remaining static or coming down, if unemployment was being reduced and production was going up, nobody would be more pleased than members on this side of the House.

Our case is that this Government has carried on now for two years. We have had economic conditions which, we all admit, have deteriorated in that time. The Government says now that things are getting better; that we have only to wait and see and there will be an improvement in the situation. If that were true, we would be only too glad, but unfortunately it is not true and the figures which the Minister gives to demonstrate his case and to prove his case—the evidence which he adduces for that purpose is evidence which only proves expenditure on the items he has quoted and not the actual consumption.

The cost of living makes interesting reading. The cost of living in May, 1951, was 109. It went up in May, 1952, to 115, before the Budget. It went up in August, 1952 to 122, the result of the Budget. It went up in February of this year to 123; and it went up again in May to 126. Various excuses have been given by Government spokesmen. One excuse was the Korean war. One excuse was the fact that import prices, which affect the cost structure of this State, had gone up and we were suffering as a result of that. It was also said that we were suffering from conditions which obtained in other European countries.

I would like now to quote what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said last December at column 888 of Volume 135 of the Official Report:—

"I think it is true to say that only internal factors are causing prices to go up now."

That was in December of last year,about eight or nine months ago. Since then he has admitted that internal factors are to blame for the rise in the cost of living and those internal factors are under the control of the Government. It is not import price. It is not the backwash of the Korean war that is now causing our prices to go up. It is internal factors of which the Government has control.

The figures for the import price index make very interesting reading. Import prices reached their maximum in September, 1951, when they stood at 324.1. Since September, 1951, Which is about 20 months ago, they have been going down steadily every month and in December, 1952, they stood at 290.8, a decline of 33.3. All through last year import prices were going down but, despite that fact, the cost of living was going up.

I do not think it is irrelevant in view of the charges that we are making against the Government, of their failure to implement their promise and their policy to maintain an effective system of price control—I will leave out, for the moment, their promise to maintain the subsidies—to quote the figures which were recently made available demonstrating similar experiences in European countries between 1951 and the present time. Remember, the Korean war has been blamed for the rise in the cost of living here, but other European countries were just as much affected by that war as we were.

I would ask Deputies who are interested in these matters to study the figures given in The Economistof last week. In the statistical supplement to that they will see what happened to the cost of living in other European countries during the period that the Fianna Fáil Government was in power here. There were two countries in Europe which had since 1951 a greater increase in the cost of living than we had. One of them was Austria and the other was France and the French cost of living went up by one point more than did our cost of living. Perhaps Belgium provides a better analogy than France. Belgium was able to keep its cost of living stablefrom 1951 to the present time. In Denmark, where there is again a close analogy with this country, the cost of living went up by four points since 1951. In Germany, which was devastated by the war, the cost of living has remained stable since 1951. In Italy, another country which suffered very adversely from the war, the cost of living has gone up by only seven points since 1951. In the Netherlands it has remained static since 1951. The other figures are available. They will show that the cost of living went up in other European countries but, with the two exceptions I have mentioned, Austria and France, in no other country in Europe did the cost of living go up to such an extent as it went up here within the last two years.

Comment on this

Give us the wage increases.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The wage figures are available if the Deputy likes to see them.

Comment on this

They are not a quarter of what they are here. I was in Germany and I know what they are.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

What about France?

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I do not think the Deputies understand the figures I am giving.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not understand them either.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The figures. I am giving are relative figures. If the cost of living in Ireland was 101 in 1951 and if it is 126 in May of this year it has gone up by 15 points and, relative to the Irish consumer and the Irish wage earner, goods are now costing him 15 per cent. more.

Comment on this

And his wages have gone up.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I shall deal with wages when they arise. At the moment I am dealing with the cost of living. Deputies on the Government benches made the excuse that the cost of living had gone up here because of the impact of the Korean war. In May of 1951the cost of living was 109. In May of this year it was 126. It went up by 15 points. The cost-of-living figures in these other countries, irrespective of the level of wages, remained static in spite of the Korean war. The cost of living in Denmark, in spite of the Korean war, went up by only four points. The cost of living in the Netherlands remained static in spite of the Korean war. I am not denying for a moment that there have been wage increases to compensate for the increase in the cost of living. Indeed, I think it would be a terrible thing if there had not been such increases. In other countries where the cost of living went up there were also wage increases to compensate.

Comment on this

Quote the wage increases.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The Government is making the case that the cost of living went up because of the impact of the Korean war.

Comment on this

Your stockpiling had something to do with it, too.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The Taoiseach on the vote of confidence, the Minister for Finance and his colleagues said that we were only to blame for an increase of seven points in the cost of living—the cut in the food subsidies; the rest of the increases were due to forces outside our control. The evidence I am giving—Deputies can check it if they wish—is that in no other country in Europe, with the two exceptions I have quoted, was there a similar experience. I hold that is a very strange thing indeed.

Comment on this

The subsidies came off a year before in Denmark and there was a big rise in the cost of living as a result of that in 1951.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Between 1951 and this year the cost of living has gone up here by 15 points. Between 1951 and this year the cost of living in Denmark has gone up by four points.

Comment on this

And it rose ten pointsthe year before when the subsidies came off.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

The reason the Government has endeavoured to advance for the fact that this country is suffering from such an appallingly high cost of living is the Korean war. The evidence I have given is eloquent of the fact that other countries were able to take effective measures of price control to stop the rise in the cost of living, whereas this Government failed. I do not know what excuse the Government are prepared to give for the unemployment situation at the present time. I do not think the people have accepted the excuse that stockpiling is to blame for the fact that, two years after the alleged stockpiling took place, there are 22,000 more people unemployed. It is quite evident to anybody who is willing io face facts in a realistic fashion that there has been a serious depression of trade and that we are, in fact, experiencing a serious slump. People are not buying. Factories are not producing. Imports have been reduced.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I am perfectly certain in all innocence, is just making statements which are not true.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I would like the Minister to explain to me why industrial production in the June quarter of 1951 stood at 181.8 and why industrial production for the December quarter of 1952 stood at 170.7—a reduction of ten points.

Comment on this

There is a great difference between June and December. Perhaps the Deputy's knowledge of industrial conditions does not go that far.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Is the Minister alleging that industrial production has increased?

Comment on this

Yes, industrial production has increased in the first quarter of this year compared with the first quarter of last year.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

And it is still below the June figure.

Comment on this

And it is still going up.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

It is still below the June figure. The Minister cannot deny that. I do not understand what the excuse of the Government is, whether it is that things are not as bad as we say they are. They cannot get over the fact that industrial production is less than it was in the June quarter of 1951.

Comment on this

It depends on what you call industrial production.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I call it what the Trade Journalcalls industrial production. The Minister can take his figures from theTrade Journaland I will take my figures from theTrade Journal.

Comment on this

The creation of real wealth in this country is greater than it was in 1951.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I am dealing with industrial production, and I would ask the Minister to deal with it. The facts are absolutely self-evident that industrial production has gone down and they are now making a valiant effort to say that, because it has increased, things are a bit better, ignoring the fact that, industrial production is below what it was in 1951, two years ago.

I do not believe that there was any valid reason for the expansion experienced up to 1951 to have been halted. I do not believe there was any reason why the increased employment in industrial employment which we had experienced for the three years of the inter-Party Government should not have gone on further. I do not believe that there was any reason why we could not have reduced still further the level of unemployed. I see no reason why industrial production should not have expanded beyond its peak figure of June, 1951, or why it should be up several more points now, two years later.

I believe the Government took a fundamentally wrong view of the economic situation. I believe that, no matter what excuses they make now, no matter what speeches they make now, the result of taking that wrong view of the economic situation and the natural consequences of it were thatwe have the trade recession and slump Which we are now experiencing. The wrong view which the Government took was that they regarded it as vitally necessary that immediate action be taken to remedy our balance of international payments. I would like Deputies to read and re-read the speech of the minister for Finance introducing his Budget last year, because in that speech is contained the Fianna Fáil present policy. It is not in what they say they would like to be doing. Largely from the economic policy enshrined in that Budget of last year have flowed the economic ills that we are suffering from. Deputies who read it will see studded throughout that Budget speech statements that we are consuming too much, that we must spend less, that we must consume less. That was the economic policy which the Government followed. The Government set itself the task last year of righting the deficit in the balance of payments by reducing home consumption, and they have been successful. They have reduced the deficit in the balance of payments to £9,000,000 at the expense of raising our holdings of sterling assets. Is the Minister denying that our sterling assets have increased?

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I saw a question mark in the Minister's attitude. Our sterling assets increased last year as a result of the fact that the deficit in our balance of payments was only £9,000,000, and as a result of the policy of reducing consumption at home. Let it be admitted that the deficit in the balance of payments was reduced to £9,000,000 and that, to achieve that end, the Government reduced consumption at home with the attendant consequences on employment and prodnction, also, let it be added, by raising the cost of living by reducing food subsidies.

That has been the economic policy of the Government for the last two years. There has been no change in that policy in the last Budget. Our complaint of this Government is that that was the policy they put into operation. If they believed it was a right policy,they should have put it into operation, but we believed it was the wrong one. We believed that the balance of payments did not require the drastic treatment that the Government employed. We believed—as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Deputy Lynch, has said here earlier this morning—that import prices would come down, that exports would expand and that there were automatic factors in the situation which would remedy it without the drastic steps that the Government took. They adopted that policy they took those steps last year and that is the policy which is still an operation. The Budget of this year has made no change.

I would like to sea this Government, for whatever length of time it will remain in office, changing that economic policy. I believe it was fundamentally wrong. I believe that what was right for Britain in 1951 under their British Minister of Finance was not right for Ireland in 1951. I believe that we should be having this year what the British Chancellor of the Exchequer gave the British this year, namely, a reversal of the deflationary Budget of last year. We have not got any such reversal. We have the same Budget, we have the same policy. Until we have a reversal of that policy, until we have an acceptance of the fact that what this country needs is an injection of purchasing power and the ability of the consumer to spend more the economic situation cannot be improved. What this country needs greater stimulus to demand for all types of goods. Until we have an acceptance of that point of view we will not have any change in the economic situation. This city is seeing what it has never seen since the foundation of this State, mass unemployed marching to Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

Young men who should join the Army.

Comment on this

Have you not got 5,000?

Comment on this

We saw them here in 1931.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Is the ParliamentarySecretary suggesting that those people who are umemployed in the City of Dublin should be in the Army?

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

That is very interesting. I hope that due publicity will be given to that fact——

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

—— that the Parliamentary Secretary believes that the unemployed in the City of Dublin should be conscripted into the Army.

Comment on this

No. I never said "conscripted".

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

What then—that they should go in voluntarily?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Voluntarily, instead of going into the English army.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I regard this as very fundamental.

Comment on this

So do I.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

It now seems clear that the Government regard it as desirable that the unemployed persons here should go into the Army. So that is their solution.

Comment on this

I am speaking for myself, and I am not afraid to say it in Dublin or elsewhere.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Not for the Government, then?

Comment on this

They can go to Bord na Móna. It has 300 vacancies in my constituency at £7 a week.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

It is not the Army then?

Comment on this

Both the Army and Bord na Móna. I am not ashamed of the Irish Army as you are.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

I am asking them to go into the Irish Army.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I want to say that I regard it is an obligation and aduty on the part of the Government not to say, when we have a critical unemployment situation, that the unemployed should go into the Army.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary speaks for himself only. He does not speak for me when he makes that statement.

Comment on this

I said that I was speaking for myself.

Comment on this

There is not agreement on that side of the House then.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I take it then that there is one sensible man on the Fianna Fáil Benches who repudiates the idea of the parliamentary Secretary that the unemployed should be made or, if not made, pushed quietly through economic circumstances into the Army. I want to say that I repudiate that idea. It is an abnegation of the duty of a Government, when there is a critical unemployment situation, to suggest that the unemployed should go into the Army. The Government of this country, like the Government of every other country, has a duty to provide full employment.

Comment on this

Will they get selective work?

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

No man should be forced to go into the Army if he does not want to.

Comment on this

In England, they go where they are sent, and they cannot be selective.

Mr. Carter rose.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

If this is not a point of order I refuse to give way.

Comment on this

On a point of information.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

I refuse to give way. I am entitled to go on with my speech. I think that this discussion, even if it has become somewhat ragged, has been very useful all the same. It has brought out now what the Government, or at any rate the Parliamentary Secretary, wants. I do not know if the Minister himself willrepeat what he thinks should be done with the unemployed in the City of Dublin.

I want to say, in conclusion, that I think the Government should be judged on its results, on the results of the index of industrial production, the index of agricultural production, the index of employment, and on the cost-of living index. Let the Government be judged by these figures. We were prepared to be judged by them when we were in office and I see no reason why the present Government should not be judged by them also. We are judging the present Government by these results. We are judging them by measuring up their results against those figures, and we have found them sadly wanting.

I am against what has been going on in this House in the last couple of days. It went on before in this House —that is, going back to what happened before the war, going back to what happened, perhaps, before many of the thousands of people who are unemployed at the present time were born, going back to the days of the civil war, going back to the days of the Treaty in 1922, and to the days of the economic war. I am against going back to all that for this reason, not because I am afraid of dealing with these things but because I believe that this is not the place to deal with them. Let the historians deal with them. Have a debate on them which might interest the populace but not in this deliberative Assembly, where there are so many important economic factors to be dealt with. Who was right or wrong in 1922 is no longer of any relevance to the people who are now unemployed in the City of Dublin.

Let the Government tell us what is their economic policy. Do not let the Government tell us that they are in favour of increasing production, that they are in favour of industrial expansion, that they are in favour of agricultural production and that they are in favour of getting the cost of living down. That is not policy. All of us are agreed on these aims, but let them tell us how they are going to bring these desirable aims about. If they have no way of doing that, and if wehave a way of doing it, then tell the people and let the people decide. Let the people decide whether they think, in view of what is happening, they can trust the Government. In view of the last three by-elections, I think there can be no doubt as to what the answer would be.

Comment on this
Patrick Beegan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minster for Finance (Mr. Beegan) Fianna Fáil

I did not intend to intervene in this debate because I feel, like many other Deputies, that it is a repetition and a rehearsal of what I have been listening to, if not for the last two years, perhaps for 21 years, as far as our position is concerned.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I have intervened in this debate to refute most emphatically and with all the vehemence I command a statement that was made here, not by a greenhorn Deputy or by an inexperienced person but by an ex-Minister in the Coalition Government, Deputy Blowick, when he referred to the Corrib scheme. I am quoting from yesterday's Irish Press.This is the quotation:—

"He said the Government had deteriorated into a state of bungling and mismanagement that had brought distress to the country.

In that day's issue of the Irish Pressthey had a big heading: ‘£2,000,000 Drainage Plan—Western Counties Will Benefit’. That scheme was ordered by Deputy Donnellan, when he was Parliamentary Secretary, in May, 1948. A month after the inter-Party Government went out of office, the Corrib drainage scheme was to start and the machinery had been ordered down there. But when Fianna Fáil came into office they cancelled the scheme.”

Now, I know that if I used a certain word that would be the most applicable and appropriate word in refutation of that statement, the Chair would call me to order. But I say that it was a deliberate untruth on the part of Deputy Blowick who should know far better, particularly as he had been a Minister in a Government forthree and a half years. I will give the facts about the Corrib here and now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The expression "deliberate untruth", is still not in order.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling. It is misrepresentation and also a very incorrect statement. I know quite well, and I am ready to admit, as I have done everywhere, that Deputy Donnellan did insist on having the Corrib survey started in 1948. But, when Deputy Blowick comes along and states in this House that the Fianna Fáil Government in 1951 clamped down on that scheme and that if the Coalition Government had been in office, operations on that scheme would have started one month later, I say that Deputy Donncllan as well as I and also Deputy Blowick, have got to take advice from people who are capable of giving it, and the people capable of giving it in the Office of Public Works are the engineers, particularly the chief engineer, Mr. Candy, and at no stage did the chief engineer advise Deputy Donnellan that the Corrib scheme could start in 1951.

Comment on this

On a point of order. May we now cite by name an official of a Department to develop a statement made by one of us in the House? The Parliamentary Secretary has established a precedent.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not usual to name officials.

Comment on this

The official is very well known. Perhaps I should not have mentioned his name, but even if I only mentioned the chief engineer, anybody interested would know quite well who he was. Consequently, the mentioning of his name does not very much matter in my opinion.

Comment on this

The point of order is that it is not customary to mention a civil servant by name or appointment. If it is sauce for the goose it will be sauce for the gander.

Comment on this

I do not think there is anything wrong in mentioning the name because I am very proud of theman whose name I have mentioned and I am sure if Deputy Donnellan were here that he would say he was proud of him, because he has a worldwide experience of dealing with problems of this kind.

Comment on this

That is not what you said.

Comment on this

I will not be talked down by misrepresentation anywhere. My word is as good in Galway, Mayo or Roscommon as Deputy Blowick's or anybody else's.

Comment on this

You delayed the Corrib scheme for two years.

Comment on this

I certainly did not. That is a most incorrect statement.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

I challenge Deputy Blowick to have an inquiry into it, which I will give him, and produce evidence to show that there was no such thing.

Comment on this

Why did not the work start in autumn, 1951? Because the Fianna Fáil Government stopped it.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick is now trying to plead innocence. He is not such an innocent man at all.

Comment on this

I am giving the facts.

Comment on this

You are not giving the facts.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary had no right to allow himself to be dictated to by the Government in that regard.

Comment on this

The Government did not dictate to me in that regard. If Deputy Blowick will come over to the Office of Public Works and meet the engineering staff there they will explain to him the complications with regard to that scheme.

Comment on this

I know that. I suppose since Fianna Fáil got into power water has started to flow uphill.

Comment on this

What is wrong with theOpposition, particuarly Fine Gael, Clann na Talmhan and one of the tandem Clann na Poblachta Party is that they do not want to hear the truth.

Comment on this

Tell us about the Corrib?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order! The Parliamentary Secretary is in possession.

Comment on this

What about the biscuit factory in North Mayo?

Comment on this

We will reply about that, too, but I do not think it is relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

The biscuit factory.

Comment on this

The survey was commenced in May, 1948. It was concluded in December, 1951. The survey was not a simple matter considering the vast extent of the Corrib catchment area, the complications regarding milling and fishery rights and what is commonly known in the country as the swallow hole.

Comment on this

These were all ironed out before you took office.

Comment on this

It is easy to make a statement of that kind. It is easy to come in here and cash in on the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945 which brought benefits to the people of this country who were burdened with the 1925 Drainage Act. (Interruptions.) The riparian owners, who were being burdened with charges owing to the type of schemes carried out under the 1925 Act, were unable to meet them and had to be relieved from the charges placed on them and county-at-large charges brought in instead. We hear Deputy Sweetman from time to time worrying about the farmers in his constituency and in various other constituencies. But when the 1945 Arterial Drainage Bill was going through and when certain concessions were being made to the Barrow drainage rate-payers, Deputy Sweetman, who, was then a Senator, went into the Seanad and proposed an amendment to the Bill whereby he was not prepared to unburden the Barrow drainage rate-payers of what had been inflicted onthem under the Barrow Drainage Act.

As I was saying, the survey commenced in 1948 and the survey proper was completed in December, 1951. But the survey is not everything. There has to be a considerable amount of time spent in properly plotting and designing any drainage scheme of a comprehensive nature. That took a considerable amount of time. You had certain lands within that catchment area not requiring drainage, and you had other areas of land which did require drainage. All these had to be segregated, and the reports of the engineers regarding the level of the main channel and the level of the channels flowing into it had to be taken into consideration and very closely examined and a plan designed. That plan has been designed and the Corrib drainage scheme plan is now on exhibition.

I will tell Deputy Blowick something about what happened between Deputy Donnellan and himself. The intention in the first instance was to have a survey of the Corrib-Clare-Dalgan-Mask catchment area. But that would not be going fast enough for Deputy Donnellan to have a spectacular——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Could not these details about the Corrib scheme be discussed better on the Estimate for the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick raised this matter. You are too cute.

Comment on this

He will not get away with cuteness.

Comment on this

I have raised a point of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blowick raised a point to which the Parliamentary Secretary is now replying and I take it if Deputy Blowick was in order the Parliamentary Secretary is in order in replying.

Comment on this

General MacEoin is trying to prevent the exposure.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The point I raised about the Corrib drainage scheme was in connectionwith the publication in that day's issue of the Irish Pressof the fact that the Corrib scheme was now reached. As I said, theIrish Pressdid not give the credit for the Corrib scheme where the credit was due. At the same time, of course, they were careful to give credit to the present Government. The Parliamentary Secretary raised this matter in detail without replying to my question.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick raised a point of order.

Comment on this

I am quoting from the Press and I am giving the facts in connection with this, and I challenge refutation as far as the facts I have given are concerned. It is all right for Deputy MacEoin to chip in; he thinks he is going to make me lose the trend of my arguments. I have as much knowledge of drainage in this country as Deputy MacEoin, Deputy Donnellan or Deputy Blowick, and I have been as much interested in drainage as anybody else.

Under the Drainage Act of 1945 the Corrib-Clare-Dalgan-Mask catchment area was to be surveyed in the first instance, but it would not bring a return sufficiently spectacular for the Opposition and the Mask section was left out of the survey.

I dare Deputy Blowick to deny that. There was talk about the Corrib being under way but I have never made any foolish, reckless promises to anybody to gain a few paltry votes at election time. I told the people immediately after I took over office in St. Stephen's Green that it would be an optimistic date to state that any operations would even commence in 1953. We have in the Estimate a certain amount of money for proceeding with operations. The scheme is now exhibited. According to statute and according to the Drainage Act of 1945 the county councils of Galway, Mayo and Roscommon have three months in which to make observations. The exhibition was commenced, I think, on the 21st of this month. The peopledirectly concerned through whose land the main Corrib artery runs and also the tributaries leading into it have one month to make their observations.

There is also a provision for certain Departments of State to make their observations as well notably, Agriculture and industry and Commerce. Industry and Commerce comes into it in two ways, both from the point of view of electrification and also as regards Bord na Móna. We hope to have the operations on the Corrib started about February of 1954, and there is no unreasonable or avoidable delay as far as that is concerned. I think that should answer Deputy Blowick.

Comment on this

Put it off for another while.

Comment on this

Anybody who gives this matter a little thought knows that it is a very complex problem. Even the Drainage Commission appointed in 1938 pointed out that it was a complex problem. It is agreed by everybody that to carry out a proper drainage scheme you have to go into very great detail and examine every factor within it. I have people running to me or making appeals to me to receive deputations from them regarding drainage schemes in their areas. I am leaving, as far as possible, the decision as regards priority to the people who are not going to play politics, who have been appointed by statute of this House to undertake the national drainage of this country, and they are the people most capable of judging.

It would be quite easy for me to meet, as they were met by Deputy Donnellan, the people from the Suck catchment area and tell them in the month of February, 1951, that the Suck could he the next for survey after the Corrib had been finished, but three months previously he had gone down to the Mayo County Council and told them that the Moy would be next after the Corrib. I am not going to carry on in that way. I might gain a few paltry votes if I was prepared to do that kind of clodhopping from one part of the country to another, but I amnot going to do it even if I never came into this House as a result of it.

Comment on this

You are an honest man.

Comment on this

I am not going to do that.

Comment on this

Give him a clap.

Comment on this

I do not claim to be any more honest than others but I am giving the honest facts regarding the whole business. It is outlandish for Deputy Blowick to make that bald statement that we had held up the scheme and that if the inter-Party group had been in power that scheme would have been started in June, 1951. It would be started, I suppose, like the Feale in Kerry was started, when it was started actually six months before it should start as a result of pressure, in order to be put in the election propaganda in May of 1951. I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

It started before it should start?

Comment on this

That is the best, yet.

Comment on this

As I said, I did not propose to intervene at all were it not for those very incorrect statements. I could describe it in a much smaller word, a word of three letters, were it not against parliamentary procedure. It was interesting to listen to some of the Opposition speakers, particularly Deputy McGilligan, who is an experienced member of this House, when he took us back 21 years to 1932. He told us bluntly that the country was in a very prosperous mood until it happened unfortunately to fall for Fianna Fáil promises and that since then there was nothing but want and misery in the country. We did take over in 1932, as everybody knows; there is one yardstick that the Opposition always use in measuring prosperity and that is the agricultural community of this country.

I would take those Deputies who are old enough back to the position in 1932. What percentage of farmers were in several years' arrears to the Irish Land Commission with their annuities? Thefarmers are honest people and always inclined to pay their way, but at that time they had been brought to the level that not merely were many of them three years in arrears with their instalments but there were some of them seven and eight years in arrears.

Comment on this

You told them not to pay.

Comment on this

I did not tell them not to pay. I never told anybody not to pay what they were legally and morally obliged to pay if they, could pay it. What was the percentage of farmers at that time who were unable to pay? Was there not a big percentage who, under the Land Act of 1933, had a number of years remitted altogether and three years funded? In that state of affairs, was the agricultural community then in prosperity? Talking about all the fine things that were done —I sold pigs at 28/- a cwt. in the town of Loughrea during that régime.

Comment on this

And you sold bullocks for 18/-.

Comment on this

That was at a later stage when we were fighting a national fight to save the country from the consequences of war and Fine Gael were stabbing us in the back.

Comment on this

You paid dear for it with a lump sum you could have paid at the beginning.

Comment on this

I am not going to allege against Cumann na nGaedheal that they were altogether responsible for that state of affairs. They were not. I hear a good deal from a number of Deputies in this House about the restriction of credit. In my opinion, if credit is needed for worth-while schemes of advancement that should not happen; but there is no greater danger to the farming community than unlimited credit. We got unlimited credit from the commercial banks in 1919 and 1920.

The commercial banks were paying to their depositors 4 per cent. interest and they let it out at 7 per cent. and, in some instances, as high as 8 per cent., and what happened? We had that great boom period which aroseas a result of the 1914-1918 war and a great many of the farmers in this country went in for the credit that was actually being forced upon them by the commercial banks of this country. They went into the buying of live-stock all over the country, and if they had not sufficient, area on their own firms they went into the auctioneers where land was being let and they purchased it at a highly inflated valuation; and in September of 1921 what was the position as a result of that unlimited credit? With a stroke of the pen—that would be about the most apt description of it— the whole capital was reduced to half. We then had the 1929 slump which came along too. That was a World wide slump and the Government here had no control. Neither had we control over what happened in 1921 when our capital as farmers was reduced to half with one stroke of the pen in the month of September of that year.

Comment on this

Who was responsible?

Comment on this

I believe in giving credit, as I say, for schemes that will be of lasting benefit to the people of this generation and future generations but I do not believe in unlimited credit. Now if a farmer goes into a bank and he says to the bank manager that he wants £200 or £300 or £500 or £1,000 credit, the bank manager should, and I am sure that he does, ascertain in what way he was going to expend that money. If he is going to expend that money on machinery, and if he is going to expend it on the improvement of his holding, then I say that the banks, certainly if that man is fairly solvent and if he has guarantors to guarantee his solvency, should provide him with the, cash he requires. But if he goes in and says that he wants it to purchase more live-stock he is then treading on very dangerous ground and it does not matter what trade agreement any Government makes, that is a disaster as far as that is concerned.

I am not going to throw bouquets at Deputy Dillon for his 1948 agreement. Neither am I going to throw bouquets at the present Minister for Agriculturefor his trade agreement. It was the duty and the bounden duty of both the one and the other of them and their Departments to do the best thing they could for the people of this country and to be advised by the people who are competent to advise them. But we must remember that as far as a bargain is concerned there are always two to a bargain. It is all very well to say that in Deputy Dillon's time and in Deputy Walsh's time as Minister for Agriculture, Britain is prepared to take so much, to take all if necessary, but that does not govern prices. It is supply and demand that governs prices periodically. When I heard Deputy Dillon on the opposite benches saying that he trusted the word of an English statesman regarding a certain legal defect that was in the agreement that he signed, I said to myself: "You trust an Englishman all right, but certainly if there was a defect of that kind that an Irishman tried to get over in that way you would not trust him, though he was one of your colleagues in the Fine Gael Benches".

What is the point regarding unemployment which Deputy McGilligan tried to describe? Well, I know that while there are a number of people unemployed in this country and that it is a sad thing that we have any genuine unemployed person without work, it was the Fianna Fáil Government that made it possible to show what were the real unemployment figures in this country. Up to 1932 the only people who could and were permitted to register as unemployed were the people who had already been in employment and paying unemployment insurance. We altered all that situation in 1932. We made it possible for everybody who was unemployed to register at the local labour exchange, and the local labour exchange as far as any State works were concerned bad to be called upon to supply the personnel for the carrying out of that work. Was that how Cumann na nGaedheal carried on? They carried on so that the only passport to work during their term of office was the membership card of the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation in the area ora letter from the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy.

Comment on this

That was being done by Fianna Fáil. They used to practise the same policy.

Comment on this

They never did it, Deputy. That is where you are making a mistake, and I challenge you or anybody in this House to say that Fianna Fáil ever stooped to that thing. As far as State schemes are concerned, the regulations provide that the people registered at the local labour exchanges are the people to get first preference on that work irrespective of what their political affiliations are.

Now there is a great deal of talk about unemployment and, as I say, it is most unfortunate that we have any unemployment as far as the people who are genuinely anxious to get work are concerned. There are people anxious to get work and genuinely unemployed if you had the type of work that would I suit them. It was mentioned to-day by Deputy Lynch, the Parliamentary Secretary, that mechanisation is causing a considerable amount of unemployment, and it is causing it. It would cause even more in the countries of the world were it not that many of them are involved in the situation that concerns them at the present time. But you have the craftsmen of 30 years ago, the carpenters, the tailors, the harness-makers and the coach-builders, in every town and city in this country, and even if the Labour Party were in power to-morrow they would not be able to provide employment for such people because at that particular age they could not adapt themselves to work the machines that are installed in factories.

What is the best thing to do for that? What can you do for them other than place them on the unemployed list and give them as much as the country can afford by way of unemployment assistance? You have a small number, of course, who, as Deputy Giles said, are not anxious to work; but, unfortunately, the flock is always discerned by the few black sheep. It does not weigh with me when people say that none of these fellows would take employment. I know very well alot of them would take employment, but with the exception of the City of Dublin and other borough cities and some of the larger towns, the people who tell me that there is real and grave unemployment in rural Ireland to-day will not convince me that such is the case.

It is seldom that I interject here, but yesterday, I think, Deputy Corish, for whom I have a very high regard, said when somebody mentioned about Bord na Móna offering work which was not accepted: "How can they accept work at £4 10s. a week?" According to Deputy Corish's standard, perhaps £4 10s. does not look very much, but what about the employment that they are all talking about, that they say we took from them, employment under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, where it was £3 10s. and you down to the hips in water in mid-winter, the coldest period of the year?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Parliamentary Secretary will not mind my saying that when I said £4 10s. I meant £4 10s. in the case of a man who goes to Bord na Móna and out of that has to pay £2 for "digs". If he is a married man it is not very much.

Comment on this

I will not argue with you for the ?.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is £2 for "digs".

Comment on this

When a man comes to Dublin, foolishly comes to Dublin, what has he to pay for "digs"? Three pound for "digs", unless he is in a real doss-house altogether, and I would be very sorry to see any of our people reduced to a standard of that kind.

We had Deputy Dillon yesterday talking about unemployment in Dublin and telling us that Communism was leading it. It is all right to plead Communism when it suits, but on another occasion, on the Health Bill, they plead the Hierarchy and the Church. That is the kind of jumping from one place to another we have now. Deputy Dillon had great solicitude for the unemployed in Dublin. He said those leading them were most anxious that their blood would runalong the streets of Dublin. If what Deputy Dillon wanted to have done, for which he was expelled or forced to resign from the Fine Gael Party in 1941, was done how much blood would have flowed in the streets of Dublin? He had not much solicitude for the people concerned on that occasion. Fine Gael has fomented and encouraged every agitation of the kind that is on now, during all their time in the House since they became an Opposition. They intervened in the teachers' strike, when Deputy McGilligan said: "Why should teachers work here for the salary they are offered, when there is a golden opportunity for them across the water?"

Contrast that with what we did, with our attitude from 1948 to 1951. We had strikes in Dublin—we had the bakery strike during our period out of office. Did the Minister for Industry and Commerce of our time—Deputy Lemass, as he was then—try to foment that or accelerate it and make it more troublesome for the Government of the day? When the C.I.E. strike started in Dublin and carried on for six months, as a result of a row between two unions, there was none of that fomenting by the Fianna Fáil Party. The way Fine Gael and the Coalition got out was by giving two particular gentlemen full pay for doing nothing. That was the way they solved the question. I do not think that was a proper way of solving it.

Comment on this

Who fixed that?

Comment on this

It was the Coalition that was in office at that time. It is a very annoying situation when you remember that Deputy Morrissey inserted in a section of his 1950 Transport Bill, that the general taxpayer was to be responsible for any losses incurred on C.I.E. when two members of that staff are left off work, given an indefinite holiday and still given full pay. If that is not a loss to the general taxpayer, I do not know what a loss is.

Comment on this

You are on a slippery slope.

Comment on this

There is a lot of talk about the Local Authorities (Works)Act, that we have clamped down on it and have reduced the expenditure. That is true, but in the year before the Coalition Government went out of office, by how much did they reduce it? Did they not reduce it by £50,000? Deputy Keyes, the Minister for Local Government then, agreed to that when it was put up to him by the Government. Perhaps he reluctantly agreed, but there must have been some convincing facts when he agreed to it. It has been reduced further still. I always agreed with the principle of that Act, both inside and outside the House, but I certainly did not agree with the way in which it was administered, nor do I agree with it yet. Where you have rock, shoal or sand-hills in a river there is no use in putting men to try and do the job; you have to bring machinery onto it. What really happened was that at the end of 1949 that Act was brought in to neutralise the effect of what had happened as a result of the hand-won turf scheme being abandoned by the Coalition.

That is why it was brought in. Rushed orders were sent out to every county manager and county engineer to get on with the work, to spend the money anyhow. They did so, and undoubtedly the gangers were humane men and so were the county engineers. They could not see their way to put unfortunate men down in the bottom of a river to cart up the "spoil." They skimmed in the brinks and threw the soil down into the flood and as a result in two years the river was worse than before they started. People have come to me, even last Sunday, and said so much money was expended on the local river but that it was no use. They said that was needed new was to approach the county surveyor to see if he could send a, dredger on the river to clear up the "spoil" left in the bottom, as otherwise the position would be worse than ever. I am not in disagreement with the principle of the Act. In fact, I made out application forms immediately it was enacted and sent them all over the constituency to the people concerned, so that they would give the proper particulars andhave them submitted to the county council.

Comment on this

You voted against it eight times in this House.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

Yes, eight times.

Comment on this

I have a very great respect for Deputy Seán Collins who is sitting on the front Opposition bench. I listened to a number of speeches in this debate and if there was one constructive speech or an attempt at a constructive speech by any Deputy on the Opposition Benches it was made by Deputy Seán Collins. He mentioned turf development. I am glad to see that he is so enthusiastic and so anxious about turf development. I could bring into this House the records of the debates when turf development was first mooted by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce and I could prove to Deputy Seán Collins that a number of his senior colleagues in the Fine Gael Party who are here to-day went into the Division Lobbies and voted against it. I could give him the names of at least 11 of those Deputies.

Turf development is one of the finest things that was ever started in this country, thanks to the vision and wisdom of Seán Lemass. If we go down to the Midlands now we can see beautiful towns and houses where formerly there was nothing except marsh and water.

Comment on this

That is one for you, Deputy Davin. What about Offaly?

Comment on this

What help did we get from Fine Gael when that legislation was going through? I am glad that there is now a change of attitude in regard to it. The help that we got at that time was that we were opposed at every stage by the people who speak and, I believe, speak with responsibility and authority, for Fine Gael in this House even at the present time.

There was talk about the land project. I heard Deputy Finan say thata number of persons who made application complain that their applications have not yet been investigated. Deputy Finan could not understand why that was so. I am sure there are numerous applications and I expect that a number of the inspectors are doing their best. I am sure that there is no change except in a few instances in the personnel of the inspectorate staff, who were appointed by Deputy Dillon. Rome was not built in a day and people have to be a bit more reasonable. The only place where I found applications left unattended was where an inefficient inspector had been appointed by Deputy Dillon. Such persons were given any amount of time by the present Minister to make good their inefficiency before he took drastic action— and that has happened in a few cases in this country. I am glad to say that they have been replaced by men who were already in the Civil Service, and had an idea of what it is to try to be efficient and to discharge their duty to the State. No new men were brought in.

I am sorry for having delayed the House so long but, as I said earlier, I would have not intervened were it not for the misrepresentation—and I would say that it was not innocent misrepresentation—by Deputy Blowick as regards the Corrib scheme.

I heard Deputy Oliver Flanagan give us the usual recitation the other night. Everyone could be provided for: every wrong could be righted and, at the same time, we could have lower taxation and so forth. However, he made one point—a point of which the smaller Parties in this House should take cognisance. He said that he joined Fine Gael because they are the bigger Party and that they will be the bigger Party after the next general election. In other words, they will swamp all the rest of you here.

Comment on this

We have listened to a very nice and frank speech by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. For the past three days, and for three days last week, with very few exceptions, all the speeches Were purely political Party speeches. Even after the debate this week, I have not yet got any indication of what stepsare to be taken to solve the problems with which we are faced. I heard the speech made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs last Tuesday and, on the same day, I also heard Deputy McGilligan. The Minister for External Affairs spoke yesterday. I hope that everybody in the House will read the speech which he made, and re-read it, especially his references to inflation. I listened also to the speech which was made by Deputy Dillon yesterday. I am disappointed to note that no change is evident in either of the two major political Parties in regard to solving the problems which face our people.

Having listened to many speeches, and having read the others as best I can, there is one thing which I think this House and the people should be told and it concerns our external assets. I heard the speech which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs made on Tuesday last and I read the speech which the Taoiseach made last week. The figures which both of them give in regard to external assets are most confusing. I am interested in this matter and I am trying to find out where the truth lies. In April, 1952, the Taoiseach said in this House, as reported at column 246 of Volume 131 of the Official Report:—

"I gave the House already the position in regard to our external assets. I showed that they had been reduced from £225,000,000 which was the calculation of the net reserves which was made around 1949. They have been reduced in the last three years down to £125,000,000 which is now the amount of our net external reserves. Two years more of a deficit of that sort and we will have wiped them out."

Three weeks later, I read a report in the Irish Timesof the 17th May, 1952. of a statement which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs made at the inaugural meeting of the Literary and Historical Society, University College, Dublin, regarding our external assets. The report was as follows:—

"There are about £210,000,000 of visible, touchable, controllable external assets, and about £80,000,000 to £100,000,000 are on reserve for trading, he said——"

It is well that everybody should read these statements. The report then continued:—

"——and stated that Fianna Fáil had about three to four years to reduce the sale of foreign assets at a rate that would neither paralyse industry nor prevent production permanently increasing.

If all the people of Ireland started talking about increased yields per acre and stock density and ceased discussing the Budget, the Budget would not worry anyone in a, few years."

To judge by the speeches made to the people of the country at that time, one would imagine that the country was bankrupt.

On the 9th February last, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs addressed the Institute of Secretaries at their annual dinner and I remember reading that he said that this country was worth in capital nearly £2,000,000,000. I should like to know the exact figure for our external assets. I suggest that, judging from all the contradictory statements we have heard on this subject, we have not an accurate record of the total amount of our external assets or of the money that is invested in this country by people from abroad. I submit that it is as easy to transfer money from London to Dublin or Cork as it is to transfer money from Liverpool to London. Therefore, I suggest that the people in general and the members of this House require to be told the truth as to where we stand so far as our external assets are concerned.

Both this week and last week, we have heard a good deal of criticism of the Central Bank. The Taoiseach still maintains the Central Bank have the power to guarantee the integrity of our currency and to safeguard our currency. I submit that they have no such power. Last Tuesday, I heard the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs state that in the year in which devaluation took place we lost £120,000,000. What power had the Central Bank of safeguarding our currency and credit during that year?I ask the Minister if he can tell us what one action of the Central Bank has done any kind of safeguarding of our credit. I have always been opposed to money belonging to our people being invested in England or elsewhere outside the country, and, whether that was done by the previous Government or the present Government it was wrong all the time. As a member of Cork Corporation, I can tell the House that we pay 5 per cent. for the money we borrow and we are charging decent honest men who are trying to build their own homes 6 per cent. to-day for loans for that purpose, while we have money invested in England in war stocks and transport and electricity undertakings at from 2½ to 3 per cent. Can it be denied that money transferred from our commercial banks to London at 1½ or 2 per cent. is not lent back here to the Irish people at 1¾ per cent. cheaper than they are charged by the banking system here? I know that is true and these are the matters I should like to hear being discussed here, rather than the political propaganda which has been indulged in by both sides.

Where has this political propaganda brought us? We heard the Minister for External Affairs telling us what happened with regard to our external assets and how they were all increased by the previous Government. I say it was wrong and I was not silent while the inter-Party Government were in power. I read a statement by that Minister in Youghal on 7th last month in which he said that, of the £46,000,000 the Americans gave this country, every penny was spent when they came back to power. On the very same day, the Taoiseach said in Youghal that, when they came back to office, they found the remnants of the Marshall Aid, amounting to £23,500,000.

Comment on this

It is not the remnants of the Marshall Aid. That is where you are wrong.

Comment on this

What we got from America.

Comment on this

It is the Loan Counterpart Fund—the money taken from our own people.

Comment on this

The Minister is not going to drive me off my track at all. I am not going to talk political propaganda. I want to talk about the position of the country because the unemployment problem, the housing problem and the conditions of a big section of our people are too serious matters for the playing of Party politics. The Taoiseach said that they found this remnant of £3,500,000 and that, on the advice of their experts, they had used the money which was readily available. I should like to know who were the experts. If the Taoiseach places any reliance on financial experts, I refer him to what Lloyd George and Mr. Churchill said about such experts in relation to going off and coming back on to the gold standard. He will find a good lesson in what these gentlemen said about taking the advice of financial experts.

Speaking in Bray last month, the Taoiseach said:—

"Some of the Coalition people want to bring the entire banking system under their control. I think we should not be very happy if that happened. I do not think the nation's interest would be well served if the banking system was to come under the control of these gentlemen."

Comment on this

Of politicians.

Comment on this

You are not one.

Comment on this

And Deputy Hickey is not a politician, either.

Comment on this

I am ignoring these remarks. I look upon that statement as true-blue conservatism and Toryism. I could select men from the Fianna Fáil Benches, from amongst those on this side and from outside the House, of proved capacity and social worth who could look after the banking interests and the credit of this country better than some of the major-generals, the colonels, the lords and right honourables who are in charge of our banking and credit system to-day. What is the meaning of all this pandering to these men who never wanted to see this country politically or economicallyfree? Yet, we have that statement from the leader of this country that we could not find men here who could run the banking system and control our money and credit better than the men who control it to-day. Then the Taoiseach wonders why the Labour Party are not supporting him in all he says and does. I listened to Deputy Dillon yesterday wasting the time of the House talking about all the things that are happening and all the things that have been done. He said in this House last year that he was not inclined to make any change in the present system of control of money and credit. I read a statement by the Taoiseach on 18th March, 1953, at column 573 of the Dáil Debates, in which he said:—

"I am convinced that the policy which the Government are pursuing is the only policy possible, even assuming that one had a number of policies to choose from."

I have often asked my self what is the cause of all this change. On 29th April, 1932, the Taoiseach said here:—

I never regarded freedom as an end in itself, but if I were asked what statement of Irish policy was most in accord with my views as to what human beings should struggle for I would stand side by side with James Connolly."

I would not expect the man who made that statement to tell us, in 1953, that, if the banking system were under the control of people whom we could select, the country would not be very happy, and I am quite satisfied that the back benchers of Fianna Fáil do not stand for that.

Many questions have been put down here about the unemployed—as to how many were unemployed this year as compared with previous years—and we had the Taoiseach talking of the average number of unemployed over several years. Listening to these statements, I wonder what is the reason for the change. He said in 1934:—

It would be possible, with the resources of this country, for 17,000,000 people to have a higherstandard of comfort than that in which the present people are living."

He emphasised that by saying:—

"I stand up to that. I believe it is a fact that the resources of this country, with proper organisation, are sufficient to give 17,000,000 people a higher standard of living than the present people are getting."

In a period of 19 years after, we have not yet reached a figure of 3,000,000 people. We have almost 70,000 people registered at the labour exchanges. We have 57,000 drawing home assistance. I do not want to paint the picture too badly, but it would be interesting if the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance or the members of the House would tell us and the people outside why that should be so. After all those years we have not yet 3,000,000 of a population and we have thousands of unemployed. The Taoiseach did not refer to that yesterday but, of course, he told us that it was easy to make scapegoats of the bankers. I do not want to talk about bankers or to make scapegoats of them. They are doing their own business in their own interests and in those of the groups they represent. The banks are responsible to nobody. I would suggest to the Taoiseach that money is not a commodity, as he stated yesterday. Money is a man-made system, invented to serve as tickets for the exchange of goods and services.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is becoming academic.

Comment on this

Yesterday the Taoiseach said that the banks were dealing with a commodity and that that commodity was money.

Comment on this

What do you suggest as an alternative?

Comment on this

I am quite certain I will not get the alternative from Deputy McGrath.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This matter can be settled in Cork.

Comment on this

Let us talk seriously. Unemployment is only one of the results of our present system. Itrepresents the failure of private enterprise and capitalism to solve the problem of the distribution of wealth. I will probably be told by some people that I am advocating socialism or communism. I claim that I am speaking common sense. The problem of unemployment is by no means new. I will prove that by quoting from a booklet entitled The Trend of Unemployment and Employmentissued by the Department of Industry and Commerce in 1938, a copy of which many members of this House got. On the live register for 1938 there were from 100,518 to 106,613, and an average of over 70,000 per week during the employment period Order. That is 15 years ago. In 1939 there were 100,096 to 118,734 for 27 weeks of that year and from 93,737 to 98,776 for four weeks of that year, and from 70,470 to 81,719 during the employment period Order.

What improvement can we boast of in the past 15 years? I saw recently a report from the research committee of the United Nations. They made investigations in regard to the population of 52 countries. We were the only nation in the 52 whose population was reduced notwithstanding the fact that the population of the world increased by 60,000 per day since 1945. Would it not have been interesting if, during the past three days or the past three days of last week, responsible Ministers and the members on this side of the House told us what should be done to change that position? No, they think that political propaganda is going to solve unemployment. Is it not a fact that production from our land is the lowest of any country within reasonable reach of this country? Why a that so? Is it not because we are not in control of money and credit, the vital bloodstream of this country?

I submit that to-dar our army of workless is only the inevitable culmination of years of development to the point where new methods must be applied. Were it not for the employment period Order we would have anything from 75,000 to 80,000 out of employment. There are 38,000 in the Six Counties. There are roughly from 140,000 to 150,000 people for whomsociety can find neither employment nor adequate allowances. Those thousands represent all grades and classes of workers. I think Deputy McGrath would bear me out when I say that there are thousands of that number in Cork, Dublin and elsewhere who have not had jobs for the last 12 months. Yet their labour, of which productive use could be made, is not in demand. There lies a challenge to the Government, private enterprise, capitalism and, indeed, a challenge to all of us. To imagine that we will have a real solution of the problem of unemployment without a drastic change in our economic system is just wishful thinking.

The problem is to discover the faults in the system. We have a country which was never better equipped with knowledge and machinery which could be employed to produce the necessaries of life. This country is well equipped with knowledge and machinery of which no use is made and thousands of our people are in want. I suggest that the fault lies in the link between production and consumption. That link is money. Therefore, I submit to the Minister for Finance—and I am not one bit upset by his cynicism to anything I have said from time to time —that the time has come when we will have to be more serious than we have been in the past. The fundamental issue upon which we will have to decide is whether this country is going to be governed by the principle that public welfare must come before private interests. Are we going to ensure for all our citizens the material means of life and freedom from pressing want or are we going to continue the conditions where large sections of our people live continually in poverty, ill-clad, ill-fed, badly housed and workless?

I submit that we have to make up our minds to plan our economic system based on the control of money and credit. What we will do in the immediate future will decide the future of this country and the future of ay-Government. If we are going to be opposed to change, I feel that the future will be determined for us. We ought to be prepared to make sacrificesto bring about the necessary changes. I know that the real obstacle to progress in this country or any other country is the fear of change. And there I find fault with the Taoiseach when he talks about the question of control of money and credit, and goes on to raise clouds just to terrorise the people and frighten them by telling them that if these things are going to be done, we might find ourselves in the same position as the Germans found themselves when it was cheaper to paper the walls with marks than to buy wallpaper. I have in my possession a 100,000 mark and I bought it in the streets of London for 2d. when they were no longer valid. But I would like to say that if anybody demonstrated the myth of money, Hitler did. I hold no brief for Hitler, but we can take a lesson from many things. When he represented Germany in 1932 and 1933——

Comment on this