We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 201–414 of 613. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I think the Deputy is wrong about that, but it does not matter.

Comment on this

I thought it was 1932 and 1933.

Comment on this

1933, but not 1931 or 1932.

Comment on this

He was trying to represent a bankrupt country, with 7,000,000 unemployed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It was in 1934 and 1935.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Minister is just trying to find a mean point.

Comment on this

Six years later, he challenged the world at war. Did anybody ever hear him say that it was money that defeated him or destroyed his forces?

Comment on this

But were not all his labour men conscripts!

Comment on this

Yes, and I will answer the Parliamentary Secretary on that. Hitler recognised the fact that nothing counted only men and materials. Hedid not say like the Taoiseach here that money was a commodity. I will answer the Parliamentary Secretary by saying that it is labour that gives value to money. I could give the Parliamentary Secretary a cartload of golden sovereigns——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy answer this: is it a brown shirt or a blue shirt he is hankering after?

Comment on this

That is a mean, contemptible remark.

Comment on this

Typical of the Minister.

Comment on this

Because if anybody ever stood out against brown shirts and black shirts and blue shirts I did. That is what has left this country as it is. When anybody comes in here to discuss anything in a deliberate way dirty remarks like that are thrown at them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that the Deputy relates his remarks to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am trying to answer the Parliamentary Secretary when he put a question.

Comment on this

It was the Minister.

Comment on this

It is labour that gives value to wealth. I could give the Parliamentary Secretary a cartload of golden sovereigns and take it to a particular place but until you apply the labour of men or women to that, the money is no use. There is no value in money without labour.

Comment on this

Agreed, but there must be a little work.

Comment on this

I look upon it this way, that the most costly thing in the world is idleness and the most, profitable thing is well-paid labour.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is not this drifting into am academic discussion?

Comment on this

Well, Sir, the whole debate yesterday was largely a question of money. We could not put ourunemployed to work because the money was not available, and that is the reason I want to point out to the Taoiseach that he should learn a little more of what money stands for. I am prepared to admit, too, that the interest we are charging our people who want to build homes and to live here in this country is at a rate which I think no Government could stand for.

Last year the E.S.B. had to pay £1,428,000 on interest alone in order to give the people electricity and develop rural electrification. Public bodies paid over £2,000,000 last year in interest alone for building houses and drainage etc. To whom did we pay all this interest? What service did they give at a time when we have thousands of our men and women denied the right to live and to work and earn the means by which they could get the things they need? I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to think a little more seriously where money matters are concerned. We are trying to operate a system in which unemployment and poverty are inevitable. We are governed by a money economy and money is worthless and has no meaning unless you apply human labour to it.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give way while I put this question?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Surely that is not in order?

Comment on this

When an Irish citizen gets his dividends out of some investment does he not spend the money in Ireland? And does he not help to put goods and services and work in circulation?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davin should not interrupt.

Comment on this

You would want money to buy a hair shirt as well as a blue shirt.

Comment on this

I will now refer the Deputies to a report of O.E.E.C. on conditions in this country which we paid to have reported.

Comment on this

Is that long ago?

Comment on this

No, it is this year. What did they say? That at least 60 per cent. of the incoming and outgoing cargoes in Irish and international trade is carried on British ships and practically all the insurance business transacted in Ireland appears to be in the hands of British companies. The Parliamentary Secretary is asking me if an Irish citizen get a dividend, does he not spend it in Ireland——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to dilate on the relevance of the passage he has just read?

Comment on this

I was pointing out that 60 per cent. of all Irish cargo is carried in the bottoms of British or foreign ships when we should have at least 20 ships of our own instead of having £71,000,000 worth of the holdings of the Central Bank and £54,000,000 or £56,000,000 worth of Government Department funds invested in England.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that his Government cancelled an order for Irish ships?

Comment on this

I will answer the Minister by saying that I did not agree and would not agree with any Government that was slow in doing the things that ought to be done.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Keep to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

In 1944, there was £4,132,344 taken in premiums from this country by outside insurance companies. In 1951 it was 104 per cent. of that, or £8,432,000 and for the eight years from 1944 to 1951 the amount was £49,441,000—all taken out in premiums.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would it not require legislation to change that?

Comment on this

It would not require legislation to change that. If we were to continue sending the same amount of money out of the country—the 1952 figure is not available yet—for the next two years, we would have sent out £66,500,000 of our money. That does not include insurance on air services or marine services. These figures show how justified the experts were who came to this country to examineour economic conditions, in indicating our dependence on outside influences.

Comment on this

The trade is not a one-way trade.

Comment on this

Why should we not carry our cargoes on the bottoms of Irish ships and bring in here in these same ships the commodities we need from other countries? It is little wonder, having regard to that remark, that we have the position that exists in this country to-day.

I am asked by Deputy Allen what price I would pay for money. I have a very definite view about usury and about interest on money. I believe that the Government elected by the people should be in control of the money and the credit of the nation and that the capital we need for rural electrification, afforestation, bog development and everything else in this country should be issued and utilised to create work for our own people. It could be paid back as the revenue grew from these particular industries.

Deputy Allen rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Allen will not be permitted to carry on any further cross-examination. The Deputy will resume his seat.

Comment on this

He is making a skit of the whole thing.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin is himself always interrupting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davin should not interrupt either.

Comment on this

I am not interrupting. I am advising him not to take any notice of these people.

Comment on this

All I am concerned about is this. I do not care what side of the House is to blame but for the past three days, and for three days in the previous week, we have had to listen to speeches in this House which for the most part were political Party propaganda. That has brought us where we are. I would suggest to Deputy Carter, who is a young man— in fact, I would suggest to the young men on both sides of the House—that the time has arrived when we musttake a very serious view of the future and consider seriously the question of who is to control the issue of money and credit in this country. If we have people living in hovels and slums to-day—and I think Deputy MacCarthy and Deputy McGrath will agree with me that we have had that position for years, not alone in Cork but all over the country—that is a situation for which capitalism and private enterprise are responsible. We have got to change that system and we can change it without having anything revolutionary done in this country. I am suggesting to the Minister that the time has arrived when the representatives elected by the people should sit down calmly and deliberately make up their minds to take control of the currency and credit of the country. We are tied to the currency of another country that is any thing but solvent at the moment. I suggest, and I challenge contradiction, that this is the only country in the world where the curreney is tied to the securities of an outside Government.

Comment on this

Did you ever hear of stabilisation of credit?

Comment on this

You can call it by any beautiful terms you like but that is not solving our problem. We have thousands of unemployed people needing food, clothing, housing, and furniture in their homes. I am trying to deal seriously with the problems confronting our country and nonsense of that kind will go nowhere. I know there are men in that Party who stand for principles similar to those for which I stand. I am not advocating anything revolutionary but I am convinced, from the teachings of our own religion, that we should not be carrying on the system we are carrying on at the moment. We are asking decent workers who have barely sufficient to provide themselves and their families with food and clothing, to pay exorbitant rents owing to the excessive interest charges which public authorities have to pay for housing loans. That is what we call an economic rent. An economic rent of what? Five per cent. on £1,500 or £1,600, as these houses arecosting, means that they have to pay 30/8 per week for interest alone. I know there are decent men on the Fianna Fáil Benches and on these benches who will admit that that is quite wrong. I claim that it is even morally wrong. If I am told that what I am advocating is morally wrong. I am prepared to listen to argument, and if I am convinced that I am wrong I shall admit it. We are trying to operate a system which is out-moded and out-dated. While we are doing that, the Taoiseach came in her yesterday and told us that money is a commodity.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy but he has said the same thing about half a dozen times.

Comment on this

I think I have said sufficient on this subject. When the Minister is replying—looking at the pile he has in front of him, especially records of the House, I am somewhat apprehensive—I hope he is not going to indulge in political quotations. I want to hear something concrete from him.

Comment on this

Did you not quote from the Taoiseach?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Surely you are not going to deny me an equal opportunity?

Comment on this

I do not want to deny the Minister any rights, but I hope that what we shall hear from him will be some indication of the changes that will be brought about to deal with the pressing problems with which we are confronted. If the Minister brings forward some proposal to deal with these problems, he will have no stronger backing in any part of the House than from these benches. I want to repeat something which I have said before, that the Taoiseach and the Taoiseach before him had a better chance than any other political leader in the world of doing the things that our people desire. Why are these things not being done? I suggest that we are afraid to attack vestedinterests. Vested interests are so dug in in this country that it will take the fearlessness, the spirit of sacrifice and the patriotism that inspired the men of 1916 to uproot them and put them out. That is taking place all around us in the world and if we think we are going to have a solution of the unemployment problem while we are prepared to continue in the old rut, I say it cannot be done and it will not be done.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Hickey that a considerable amount of time has been devoted to this debate, Some of that time was spent usefully, but a lot of it was just wasted time. I propose to be brief in my remarks. I would say, first of all, that we seem to have run into very serious difficulties in this country. In my opinion, the reason we are up against these difficulties to-day—the difficulty of unemployment, the difficulty of emigration and many other difficulties—is that the present Government, or for that matter any Government in this country, did not pay sufficient attention to our basic industry.

All down through the years Irish agriculture has been neglected. It has never been given a chance. I remember—I am sure other members of the House remember it, too—when we had representatives of the present Government shouting about new industries. Their theories in that regard would have been beneficial had they been put into practice; but the great disadvantage was, and we see the results to-day, that while all this talk was going on about the establishment of new industries the industry that really counted was neglected. Indeed, it was smashed and the farmers' backs were broken. The proof of that is that to-day what were once happy homesteads in rural Ireland are now derelict buildings. That is true of my own native village where there were once 26 houses; to-day only 16 or 17 houses are occupied in that same village. The laughter of children is growing daily rarer in our countrysides. The youth of to-day has no confidence in native government.

Even at this late hour, I appeal to the Government to tackle the majorproblems that confront us. The Government must get down to the drainage of the main arteries, like the Moy and the Corrib and the Shannon and so on. It is only by a proper system of drainage that the water will be removed from waterlogged lands all over the country.

I listened to the Taoiseach last night and I heard him say that from now on particular attention would be paid to Irish agriculture, to the liming and fertilising of the land. Such schemes are in themselves very valuable but while hundreds of thousands of acres of Irish land are under water, liming and fertilising are of no value and we will continue to have a low agricultural output. I am sure Deputy I Carter and Deputy Killiea will agree with me in that; I pass through several counties travelling up here and I know that what is true of my own constituency is also unfortunately true of many others throughout the length and breadth of the country. It it no use pretending that one can reap a harvest from waterlagged lands. It simply cannot be done. Furthermore, to suggest that such land can be limed and fertilised is absolute nonsense. That is indeed putting the cart before the horse.

The land reclamation scheme, initiated by the inter-Party Government, will bring beneficial results if continued. I do not suggest that everything connected with that scheme is 100 per cent. right. It is a new scheme and for that reason mistakes are understandable. Until recent times we have not had any experience in this country of any major operations in the way of land reclamation. We had to purchase machinery. We had to implement the Local Authorities (Works) Act in order to open up minor rivers and streams to make the bigger scheme of land reclamatian possible and it is quite natural that there should be certain delays.

I would like to impress upon the Government the importance of going ahead with that work with all possible speed. If these schemes are put into operation forthwith they will go a good way towards relieving unemployment and our young people who are nowemigrating to England and other countries or migrating to the cities and towns will remain in their own native environment. To-day many of our young men are engaged on drainage work in England; these men would prefer to stay at home on drainage work here even if conditions were not as good as they are said to be across the water. Our farmers sons and daughters are flocking into the cities and towns because there is no occupation for them in the rural areas. They are seeking employment in the cities and towns in competition with the townsman and the city man. That is one of the reasons why we have recently been treated to the spectacle of hundreds of unemployed congregating outside the gates of Leinster House and squatting on O'Connell Bridge. I am very sorry to see such a spectacle.

We have unemployed in Mayo and in other counties, but they did not sit down on the main thoroughfares of this city or approach the gates of Leinster House. They were obliged, when they were unemployed and could not eke out an existence at home, to emigrate to England and America in order to keep body and soul together. It is a regrettable thing that from areas like Achill, Erris, Ballycroy and Ballina town, and indeed from over the length and breadth of my constituency, people are being forced to emigrate to Great Britain in order to seek a livelihood. I know that, in recent times, quite a number of houses have been locked up in Ballina town and that whole families have gone to England. The same is true of Erris and Achill. The tragedy is that the manpower of the country, those skilled in the production of food, is being forced to emigrate. We cannot have prosperity in the country while that is so.

It might be expected from me, as a member of the Farmers' Party in this House, that I would stand up and agitate for increased prices for farm produce. I certainly feel that one of my first duties is to see that the farmer is paid a fair price for what he has to sell, a price that will remunerate him for his labour and leave him a fairmargin of profit. As long as I am a member of the House I will always stand for that. While I think that the farmer is entitled to a fair margin of profit for what he produces, I, at the same time, feel that we should be able to make available for the workers of the country food at the cheapest possible price. The farmer, as I say, is entitled to a fair and a reasonable margin of profit, but we must consider at the same time that there is a limit to what the working man can pay, a man with a wife and family who is earning, perhaps, £5, £6 or £7 a week. I, therefore, would like to see, instead of putting up the price of farm produce and of continuing to agitate for increased prices for it, that we should try, by the introduction of more modern methods, and by the use of machinery to drain the main arteries of the country, thus making more and more land available to our farmers, to create a situation whereby the farmer would be able to get an increased output of every acre of his land. In that way, we could ensure that, during periods of emergency, the food supply for our own people would not only be guaranteed but that, possibly, we would be able to make food available for export.

I think there are very few Deputies, regardless of which side of the House they sit on or the political Parties they belong to, who would say or would be so stupid as to think that the whole set up and frame up of this country is built around agriculture. I would suggest to all Deputies, regardless of their political leanings, that they should unite to do all they possibly can to improve the conditions of the Irish farmer. If we could step up production on the land, and I believe we could double and treble it, then we could afford to live better, to spend more money and employ more people on the land and in our cities. If you have thousands of people employed regularly on the land, the result will be that industries will spring up in our towns and villages.

About this time last year we were discussing the Undeveloped Areas Bill in this House. I do not know of any benefit that has come to my area as aresult of that measure except one. I did give credit to Deputy Bartley, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, for a grant of something like £25,000 which came to Achill for the development of Purteen harbour. I did so as a member of the county council, and on behalf of the people I represent, I thanked him for that. I do not mind which political Party he belongs to so long as he brought that scheme to us. We appreciate it, and I want to say here what I said about it at the county council meeting. That is the only benefit I know of which the Undeveloped Areas Act has brought to my constituency. In my opinion, that Act has not brought any great measure of prosperity to constituencies such as mine. Perhaps there are other constituencies which have benefited from it, and perhaps later on something may come to my constituency from it. So far, nothing worth while under that Act has been done in my constituency.

When that measure was going through the House I expressed the hope that it would bring some measure of prosperity to the undeveloped areas and the congested districts. I think it was Deputy M. P. Murphy who said that if a lot of the money that is being spent under that particular act was pumped into agriculture it would be much better for the country. We know what the agricultural industry is capable of if given a chance, but it has not been given a chance. The proof of that is our low agricultural output, and, if further proof is necessary, we have it in the fact that this country is importing year after year considerable quantities of foreign butter. I know from personal knowledge, as one conversant with the trade, that at certain times in the year one cannot get an egg in the City of Dublin. That is the position for a month or six weeks in the year, and if yon can buy one, the price is 1/- or 1/2 in this city. Surely, there is something seriously wrong in an agricultural country when, for a period, it is not possible to buy an egg, and if one can buy one that the price should be 1/- or 1/2. It is time, therefore, that we examined the situation with a view to protecting our farmers and our agriculture whichis our basic industry, realising at the same time that those who buy the food we produce from the land are entitled to a fair and honest deal.

During the period of the emergency, Britain was glad to take from us all the food we could give her. She was prepared to pay dearly for what, in normal times, she would not be prepared to buy, or at least, would not be prepared to pay the price which she paid at that time.

We have got it into our heads that the boom which started in the war years may continue indefinitely. I know just a little about the set-up behind the scenes of Her Majesty's Government so far as the gentlemen who meet our Irish delegation are concerned. I have reason to. I have known some of the men on the other side of the water who met our Irish Ministers. I want to sound this note of warning for all concerned, that, not alone from the point of view of giving our own people a better article, better marketed, but from the point of getting other markets that other nations are anxious to supply, we should market our produce in a better condition. We are faced with opposition from countries such as New Zealand and Denmark. While our food is far far better in quality than the food from any other country in the world, I am afraid we are rather lax from time to time in the way in which it is handled. That is a matter in which the Government should interest itself to try to effect an improvement in the handling and packing of our produce.

When we go into a shop we are attracted by an article that is nicely wrapped and handled properly. We should realise that we have got in pretty well on some of the foreign markets. We should strain every nerve to hold the ground we have gained. Furthermore, we should not be too dependent on the British market. We should try to develop European markets.

Comment on this

Fly by nights.

Comment on this

I know something about it. Under the Fianna Fáil Government, during the economic waryears, we tried to get other markets, such as the Spanish market. Fianna Fáil were not so successful then. A war was not raging at that time. Later, efforts on the parts of various Ministers were successful to a certain extent. I would like to think that we would not be wholly dependent on the British market. A remark was passed on one occasion by a certain leading statesman in England. When British representatives were meeting Irish representatives who went over to strike a bargain, the advice the British representatives got was: "Get as much as you can as cheaply as you can from these gentlemen". That is all that the particular gentleman said.

Comment on this

What year was that?

Comment on this

It is a number of years ago. They were pretty independent then. The British market was being flooded with Canadian, American and other produce.

Comment on this

I remember a phrase that asked for that.

Comment on this

I notice from time to time, and have made inquiries and got reliable information, that the prices paid for pigs at bacon factories vary considerably. In some cases there is a difference of 10/- a cwt. as between one factory and another. That is very strange. If that is allowed to continue, our bacon industry will crash again. We all remember a time when you could not get throughout the length and breadth of the country a pound of rashers. People may say that that was due to scarcity of feeding stuffs. In my opinion the scarcity was due to a large extent to the fact that bacon factories took advantage of the situation that existed. There was a surplus of pigs and they so reduced the price that farmers lost so heavily that they went out of pig production and were reluctant to resume it. In recent times they have returned to pig production. The pig population has increased. I would like it to continue to increase. Every member of the House appreciates the importance ofthe pig industry both from the point of view of supplying the home market and the export trade. If this juggling with prices continues, if you have one bacon factory paying 10/- a cwt. more than another, the industry will certainly crash again.

Recently pigs have come down or 10/- a cwt. again. At the same time the price of bacon has not decreased. That is beyond the comprehension of the ordinary individual. We in County Mayo buy bacon from Deputy McGrath's area. I have often seen bacon from his city cheaper on delivery in County Mayo than the local bacon. That is rather strange.

Comment on this

Keep buying it from us.

Comment on this

It does not always apply but from time to time such a situation exists. Many of the matters. I have raised are matters that the Minister for Agriculture or some other Minister should pay more attention to. The pig industry is an important industry.

My colleague, Deputy Finan, spoke about cheap fertilisers. It is not the first time he referred to that matter. Since I became a member of the House he has been harping on that particular subject. I quite agree with him that fertilisers can be made available more cheaply to the farmers. It is of no use to tell me that they cannot. If the Government are serious about building up agriculture, if the Taoiseach is serious in what he said last night, there is one direct way in which results can be achieved almost immediately. It is the subsidisation of fertilisers or the reduction in the cost of superphosphates and other fertilisers by some other means.

At present farmers cannot afford to buy large quantities of fertilisers. They may be able to buy three, four or five cwt. or, in some cases, half a ton or a ton but that as not sufficient. If we could afford to increase substantially the application of fertilisers to good land, dry land, we would get almost an immediate return. Deputy Finan suggested that we would increase output by 25 to 30 per cent. As a matter of fact, we would increase it by muchmore. As Deputy Finan pointed out, we will get quick results. If the Minister would seriously tackle the problem of the cost of fertilisers the benefits would be immediate and enormous.

Comment on this

Or increasing the price of farm produce?

Comment on this

We must consider that John Citizen is entitled to a fair deal also. As to the point raised by Deputy Cunningham, I would not charge our farmers with inefficiency as they are doing a good job under difficult circumstances, but I would not like to think that, through our inefficiency, we are making the consumers in this country pay increased prices. For instance, if a woollen mill in Donegal or any other type of mill fails to put its house in order and through inefficiency cannot produce articles at an economic price, I say in all seriousness that that industry is not deserving of support if the consumers of the articles have to pay an increased price so as to keep the concern going. The same thing would apply to agriculture. We in Clann na Talmhan are not calling for an increase in the price of this, that and the other thing. That is due to the fact that conditions in this country at present are such that our farmers are getting a reasonably good price. As the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance said, that is due to the fact that the British find it is good business to deal with us although they are not very fond of us or inclined to throw anything away.

With regard to the question of bog development which in areas like mine is closely connected with agriculture, there has been a lot of talk about the development of the Bangor-Erris and various other bogs in Mayo. I am most anxious that these bogs should be developed. I will give every encouragement and help I can to any Government, whether a Fianna Fáil or an inter-Party Government, in that direction. It would be a bad thing if we, as Deputies, should try to obstruct or hinder in any way useful activities undertaken by any Government. I do not suggest that everything Fianna Fáil did was entirely wrong, nor do I suggest that everything the people on this side of the House did was right. Weall make mistakes. I would, however, like to see greater activity on these bogs.

I am aware that during the present year hundreds of men, women and children have left Achill and Erris in buses and trains to go to England. While there is a certain amount of employment given on the bogs, they are not prepared to stay there for the reason given by Deputy Corish and other Deputies, that the wage of £4 10s. a week is no good to a working man having regard to the cost of living. If we do not wake up to that situation we will be draining the life blood of this nation by allowing those people to emigrate. The same thing would apply in Donegal and other areas where the holdings are small as applies in my area. The fact that they can get work on the bogs is a great asset to people whose income from the land is limited because their holdings are small and uneconomic. The present rate of wages of £4 10s., however, is no use to these people. They are not prepared to stay in Ireland and put up with that.

Furthermore, no houses have been built for our bog workers in Mayo. We hope that at some future date houses will be made available to these workers. The shelters and huts where men have to take their meals or shelter from the rain are really only hovels and are not fit for human habitation. I would not like to see even animals going into some of these shacks which are on the bogs. I know that a great number of young people who were working on the bogs lost their health and are now in T.B. institutions because these huts are unfit for human habitation. I would impress on the Government the importance of treating the workers in the same way in which they are treated across the water where they have proper accommodation with hot and cold water provided. I do not say that that applies in all cases.

Comment on this

What about the bothies in Scotland?

Comment on this

I quite agree that in many areas everything is not just what we would like it to be. I regret to say that in parts of England andScotland there are bad living conditions but, generally speaking, they have advanced very considerably in the direction of improving living conditions for our workers who are forced to emigrate.

Some time this year I visited the town of Belmullet and saw a street there lined with buses. I was told that these were only some of the buses which were waiting for people to come along. Whole families emigrated from these areas to find employment across the water, while seven or eight miles away there was work to be done on the bogs, seasonable work, if you like. Naturally these people felt that they could make more money across the water. I put it to the Minister seriously that if we are prepared to give a reasonable increase, say 10/- or 15/- a week, to bog workers it would be an encouragement to these people to stay at home. We must take into account, of course, that if we increase the wages of workers and there are other increases, to some extent that may affect the finished product. There again you are up against another difficulty. The Government must try to hold the balance as evenly as possible between the consumer and the producer.

On the question of credit, I heard the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance saying that it was a bad thing to make credit too readily available to farmers for the purpose of stocking land and for other purposes. The Parliamentary Secretary can put his mind at ease, because as far as I can see there is not the slightest danger that credit will be made available so recklessly or so readily as he seems to think. He said that he would not like to see the system changed so that a man could walk into a bank and get a certain amount of money without his neighbours knowing of it. He would prefer that in trying to procure credit from a bank the farmer should undergo the humiliation of taking two of his neighbours with him and thus allow his neighbours to know all about his circumstances. We all have a little bit of pride and if we have to go to a bank to get credit we do not like totell the whole world about it. If one or two people know about it, you can rest assured that everybody else will know about it. The Parliamentary Secretary need not worry, as there is not the slightest danger that in the foreseeable future we will reach a position in which farmers will be able to walk into a bank and get £100 or £200 for any purpose.

The question of credit in this country seems to be about finished. The people who had the greatest security, people whose reputations are the very best cannot get credit from any bank or can only get it to a very limited extent. This has hampered business to a very great extent. I am engaged in business myself in a small way and I meet commercial travellers. As sure as I am addressing this House I had the experience of meeting travellers at 6 o'clock in the evening who had gone the whole round of the countryside without collecting a cheque for the day.

That state of affairs is very serious. I am not going to charge the Government, although other Deputies have done so. I do not want to stir up bitterness, but whoever is responsible has to answer for putting many businesses out of action. I was told a story in the City of Dublin about a publican who has to send out for a few dozen of stout every time a customer comes in. The poor man has almost reached the stage of bankruptcy. He has, his children to maintain, and due to the slump which has come he is unable to carry on. He is only one of many. The Minister for Finance or the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance need not be one bit afraid that bank managers are going to come out to the doors of the banks and start throwing out £100 to the farmers. He can sleep peacefully. He is dead safe.

The Parliamentary Secretary also said he was convinced that there was no unemployment in rural areas. I regret to hear the Parliamentary Secretary say that because every Deputy here who comes from a rural area knows well that, particularly in the congested areas where the holdings are uneconomic, there is mass emigration.It was going on in the days of the inter-Party Government also. I will not say it was any less or any more, but the truth is that it is still going on. I have not the figures before me at the moment in connection with emigration, but it went on in the days of Fine Gael and it goes on in the time of Fianna Fáil. It is regrettable that that should be so, but for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance to say that there is no emigration from rural areas and that there was no unemployment in rural areas is fantastic. If Deputy Beegan, the Parliamentary Secretary, cares to come with me I will bring him free of charge around my constituency and show him that there is wholesale unemployment.

Comment on this

Will you stand him a bottle?

Comment on this

I would not mind doing that.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

A drop of poteen.

Comment on this

That is going too far.

Comment on this

However, I regret very much to hear that coming from a man in the responsible position of Parliamentary Secretary in charge of the Board of Works in St. Stephen's Green. I am sure the people of my constituency will be very sorry to know that is the opinion he has formed about conditions in various parts of the country, with particular reference to my own part of the country. He had better change his views completely because I can produce the figures of registered unemployed for Ballina, Ballycastle, Foxford, Belmullet, Achill and other centres, contradicting that. In fact, he need only check on those figures which are available in his own office to discover that statement is fantastic. I do not know whether he was serious or not but he appeared to be.

I will conclude by saying what I said at the outset, that if the Government are serious about putting this country on its feet, let them tackle Irish agriculture and put it on its feet. You can build prosperity in the City of Dublin if you forget about the main industry. For five years I have workedaround this city. I have done business with the people here. I know them well and I know how they live. I have worked with some of those lads who came to the gates of Leinster House. I was sorry to see them there, and any assistance I can give any Irish Government in helping to solve that problem I will gladly give it. I do not wish to set up animosity between town and country. It is no use talking about producing agricultural commodities if you have not someone to consume them. The townsman is important. He is a cog in the machine. Our own market at home is better than any other market.

If we are able to build up Irish agriculture the cities will look after themselves. Money will start to pump into the concerns of the business people. They, in turn, I hope, will loosen the purse strings on which they have held a fairly tight grip for a long number of years. During the war years they did make money. It is a tragedy that they are reluctant to invest money at home and that they have not more confidence in their own country. I am not satisfied in my own mind that this Government is serious in regard to the difficulties which confront us, having looked back on their past efforts, on what they promised to do and what they failed to do. I am not very hopeful of what is likely to happen. We hear about the things that are around the corner and on the other side of the hill but I wish they would come a bit nearer, because we want them badly just now.

Comment on this

I have been intrigued by some of the speeches made from the opposite benches in the course of this debate on the Vote on Account. We have people advocating that we should reduce the cost of living and, at the same time, give a smaller return to our farmers; and last but by no means least, we have our old friend, Deputy Hickey, a man whom I like very well as a personality, telling us that the credit of this country should be handed over to this House. I wonder would Deputy Hickey like to lend me a £5 note in the morning if I told him that I was going to invest it in County Longford in 20 hens as a venture. That is avery small illustration of what Deputy Hickey means. Deputy Hickey wants to take the credit and money of this country out of the hands of the banking institutions and hand it over to this House.

Comment on this

No. He wants you to control it.

Comment on this

He wants this House to control it. I am glad to get that admission from Deputy Everett. If a Party liquidated £120,000,000 of our assets, increased the national debt, in fact, doubled it, borrowed £40,000,000 from America and yet had no tangible assets to show for it, would you entrust such a Party with your money? It is a fair question and it merits a fair answer.

Comment on this

You would trust England with it first.

Comment on this

On the question of the external assets which Deputy MacBride only recently seems to have brought up after he put his policy in abeyance when he came into this House, if Deputy MacBride had any opinions regarding the use of our external assets why did he not stand on his feet at the head of his own Party when he came into this House and advocate them from his own benches?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Did we liquidate them or increase them? What did you say a moment ago?

Comment on this

I said that if Deputy MacBride had any opinion to offer this House regarding our external assets why did he not stand at the head of his own Party and formulate a policy for the withdrawal of our external assets?

Comment on this

I thought you were abusing us for having withdrawn them.

Comment on this

Now, now, now.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Why do you not try to make up your mind.

Comment on this

The Chief Whip of Fine Gael can blaze around Wicklow or Kildare——

Comment on this

We blazed around them very successfully.

Comment on this

The Chief Whip of Fine Gael can blaze around Wicklow and Kildare and Deputy O'Higgins around Leix and Offaly but you will not misrepresent what I am saying in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You are misrepresenting us.

Comment on this

I did not misrepresent you.

Comment on this

Now I am just asking you which way you say we did it. Whichever way you like it we will deal with it.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey—and I am afraid it is bad business—wants the money and credit of this State handed into the hands of this House. I ask Deputy O'Higgins and the Chief Whip of the Fine Gael Party would they entrust this House with £1,000 of their money in the morning? That is the question. I would even ask Deputy General MacEoin would he lend me £500 in the morning.

Comment on this

Not likely.

Comment on this

If I tried I think I would go borrowing.

Comment on this

Sure the Transport Union gave £50,000 to Fianna Fáil on one occasion.

Comment on this

I have listened to a number of wild suggestions about money and credit since this debate commenced. I do say that while Deputy Hickey may have offered his opinion in fairness and while he may hold that opinion I think he is not wise in that——

Comment on this

It is a good job he is not here to hear you saying that.

Comment on this

He would have heart failure if he heard it.

Comment on this

—— because we know what happened in America in the 1930's, when you had the banking institutions in that country in the hands of private individuals and in thehands of politicians. He also instanced the case of Germany and Italy and I want to answer that back by saying what end did Hitler ultimately achieve. What position eventually did Hitler achieve? Did he not die in a bunker in the heart of Berlin? I have nothing against Hitler for doing so.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is that certain? Some say he did not die there at all.

Comment on this

I have nothing against Hitler for doing so. That was his own opinion in doing that. And the end of Mussolini was to hang by his heels upside down from a petrol pump.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is completely irrelevant. It does not arise on this Vote.

Comment on this

Yes, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, it does. It arises because in the course of the debate both the names of these two men have been mentioned in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

But we are not responsible for them.

Comment on this

They were both mentioned and it is only fair that we should be given an opportunity to answer back. Deputy Costello, Junior, is a rising young man and according to the speech he made here this morning, a text-book economist. It is easy for him to stand up and suggest that our cost of living has risen to 126 points and that we have a higher cost of living than most countries of Europe. I do not subscribe to that view; but he did not quote the conditions that caused that cost of living, and he did not quote, for instance, the wages in any of the countries he mentioned. He quoted the cost of living figures, but he did not quote the wage increases or the living conditions in any of those countries.

Now I should have thought that a Party who seemed to be as interested in the welfare of the country as Fine Gael are would not have allowed over 100,000 people to emigrate during their period of office. When you speak of emigration you have to look at the picture as a whole from the famine timesalmost down to the present, and I think it is the height of cheap political publicity to come into this House, as Deputy McGilligan did, after spending the best part of 30 years in the service of his country, and trying to make cheap political propaganda of our rate of emigration or the rate of unemployment. Deputy McGilligan was Ministsr for Industry and Commerce in the first Cumann na nGaedheal Government. He was the most conservative Minister for Industry and Commerce that ever stood in the Government of this country.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Glory be to God, did you ever hear of the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this

For political purposes, he has done a series of handsprings and he now stands left of the extreme left, but for political purposes only. I am surprised that some of the Labour representatives—because very good suggestions have come from Labour and very good support in the past—I am surprised that Labour should be led along the path on which Deputy McGilligan is displaying his agility as an acrobat, and I hope that Labour will not continue in that direction.

Comment on this

We had to leave you when you put on the standstill Orders.

Comment on this

Wait now, till I am finished. You might come back to it again.

Comment on this

Right.

Comment on this

You are going a long way.

Comment on this

I am not criticising you, Deputy, and I would not say one word against Labour.

Comment on this

You have to do something about the unemployed before we will join you.

Comment on this

Time makes strange bedfellows.

Comment on this

You might even come over to us.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Deputy Cowan is sufficient.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will be given an opportunity of saying something later on.

Comment on this

The best of men are but men at best. We heard a tirade from the Deputy who sat down about prices and the cost of living. While advocating cheaper prices and more efficient production he was advocating higher wages and better living conditions in the towns at the same time. I want to remind Deputy O'Hara that he supported a Government that in 1950 had the audacity to suggsst to the butchers of Dublin——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He was not even in the House then.

Comment on this

Well his Party were in the House. At the outset he suggested to the country that the then Government were cutting down the cost of living by what they were pleased to call their dual price system. I propose to show the House that that dual price system was a cheap political racket. In the spring of 1950 when the butchers of Dublin demanded an increase for meat from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when they were causing a bit of a clamour over the price they were paying for cattle in the Dublin cattle market, when they were likely to cause trouble for the Coalition, he sent a note to the butchers and called them to his office. He told them he realised they were paying a high price for cattle in the Dublin cattle market and he further realised they were not getting enough for their meat sold across the block, but he also told them it would not be politically convenient for him at the time to allow an increase in the price of beef, mutton and so on.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That has been contradicted three times in this House and it is a damned lie, a damned lie.

Comment on this

I challenge that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins must withdraw that.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I withdraw the word "lie" and substitute the word "untruth."

Comment on this

Is it a damned untruth?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

If the Minister for Finance wants to speak, he will get his opportunity, if he remains in the House long enough.

Comment on this

The Deputy used the expression "damned lie." He has risen and says he is withdrawing the word "lie" and substituting the word "untruth." I want to know what has happened to the word "damned."

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It is a great deal more parliamentary than the filthy language that the Minister for Health used in this House during the past week.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins should not indulge in personalities.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins can indulge in personalities outside the House but not inside.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is wonderful. Dissolve the Dáil and meet me in Longford-Westmeath.

Comment on this

I will meet the Deputy there, too. Do not worry. In the course of the debate I heard no suggestions, except from a few speakers, as to the remedy they would apply to present conditions— which are only very slightly different from those that obtained during the term of office of the former Government. Listening to the various speakers, one would imagine you had full employment then. Deputy Declan Costello had the effrontery to stand on the Front Bench to-day—I am glad to see that he disagrees with the view expressed heretofore by Deputy McGilligan—and say it was the duty of the Government to carry full employment. I want Deputy Costello to go back to the test book and examine it further. He will see that at the moment in the most prosperous countries in the world you have not full employment, and you never will. There are various factors that contribute towards that situation— people losing their jobs, jobs becoming outmoded, and so on. The three thingsthe Opposition are using at the moment are unemployment, emigration and the high cost of living.

Comment on this

Starvation.

Comment on this

Those three things have been used against us since we became the Government. The former Government carried, on an average, a pool of 55,000 people a year unemployed during their three and a half years of office. The figures are there in the Library for anyone who wants to see them. Notwithstanding that, they ran a deficit in the Budget and in the balance of payments. Notwithstanding the fact that they withdrew £120,000,000, doubled the national debt and borrowed £40,000,000 outside that, they spent less than we did on the capital side of our programme. They adopted what might be described as a valid expedient for classifying the Budget: it was only a book-keeping expedient. They have not the temerity to suggest that we are spending less on the capital account than they were. The capital account on our side of the Budget this year runs into something like £40,000,000. After all, if you devote £40,000,000 to capital services, it must be circulating somewhere within the framework.

Comment on this

Some of it is going to the Racing Board.

Comment on this

It is depressing in the extreme to hear some of the statements made here on our economic and fiscal policy. The last Deputy who spoke suggested that the workers were not satisfied with their wages from Bord na Móna. In the course of my duty as a Deputy—and if he were doing the same thing it would profit him more—I made inquiries from Bord na Móna regarding the payment and conditions of the workers and I was told by the chief engineer that 75 per cent. of the trade unions in this country were satisfied with the conditions and wages of Bord na Móna. That should be sufficient to nail that allegation. Just before that he said a man could earn £4 10s. at most. I disagree. They are earning up to £7 and some of them up to £9.

Comment on this

Why are they leaving it, then?

Comment on this

I will answer that, too. If you were in England and left your job, you could not get any employment benefit, because there they have direction of labour. The workers can leave it here.

Comment on this

They will not get anything from the exchange for six weeks.

Comment on this

They are not coerced as in England.

Comment on this

I never heard of a worker leaving a £7 a week job to go to the exchange.

Comment on this

I did not say that any individual did that.

Comment on this

You said he could sign at the exchange.

Comment on this

He can leave his job with Bord na Móna, and take up a different one if he wishes.

Comment on this

He said he could go to, the exchange and sign. He cannot in England.

Comment on this

I said there is direction of labour there. I want to emphasise that the workers have full freedom to leave their jobs here.

Comment on this

They are held up for six weeks.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Leary might cease interrupting and let Deputy Carter make his speech.

Comment on this

It is all right. I like to, be interrupted on a fair basis. I do not like misrepresentation in any shape or-form—and all we have had here, as Deputy Cowan said, since the discussion on the Vote on Account was initiated is misrepresentation. I submit that Fine Gael are responsible for that and responsible for wasting the taxpayers' money and holding up the business of the House, in order to try to cash in on the country's difficulties, as they cashed in in a previous year.

Comment on this

Who put them in diffi— culties?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

They are the Party of expediency and they use the ring for what it is worth. They make use of all the political rules in the game to gather all the strength they can and they make use of the country and its position to belabour this Government or any other body which they think stand in their way to power. Power is all that counts with the Fine Gael Party and I want the Labour Party to realise that fact.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Ha! Ha!

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins need not laugh. The crack is not so far away.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The crack?

Comment on this

Does that mean the crack in Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Does that mean that there will be a general election?

Comment on this

I have not heard any suggestion whatever to-day regarding subsidies—especially from the centre seats in the House. That is very significant. All last year, they belaboured us with the question of subsidies. Now, apparently, it is not popular in Fine Gael to mention subsidies so we hear nothing about them.

We are told that we should control prices. If you want to give the farmer a decent return for his labour and to encourage increased production, it is very difficult to control prices. If you want to give the wage-earner a decent wage, you cannot live in a planned hot-house economy. Fine Gael talk about agriculture and of what their Minister for Agriculture did during his term of office.

Comment on this

He was a very fine Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

His record does not bear that out.

Comment on this

It is there to be seen by anybody who wants to see it. The evidence is there.

Comment on this

I can give the House the figures for agriculture during Deputy Dillon's term of office as Minister: itmakes melancholy reading. The number of sows went down by 400 and the total pig production went down by 90,000.

Comment on this

It went up. You could not get a side of bacon in the country before Deputy Dillon took office.

Comment on this

The statistics are there to prove what Deputy Carter is saying.

Comment on this

There was not a rasher in the house until Deputy Dillon took office. You could not hear the squeal of a pig in the country.

Comment on this

We heard Deputy O'Higgins expound on the price of butter. I asked him if he would be in favour of subsidising the production of butter: he did not concur. He talked about the present price of 4/2 per lb. and said it was an exorbitant price to extract from the consumer. He made that statement in Dublin. When he goes down to his constituency of Laois-Offaly, or to the country, he will talk about the poor price which farmers are getting for their milk. Whether you are running a business or a farm, or any other type of undertaking, you must face certain facts. If you want to give the farmer 1/6, 1/7 or ? a gallon for his milk, you must, on the costings of butter, charge 4/2 a lb. retail for it. The 5d. a lb. represents the cost of production. Deputies can take note of that.

Comment on this

The objection is to paying 4/2 per lb. for New Zealand butter.

Comment on this

I will come to that. It was not until after Deputy Dillon's period of office that that situation came about. He tried to tell the farmers that he would give them a five-year plan of 1/- a gallon for their milk—a plan to which the farmers were not inclined to agree. We found that we were in the position that we had to import New Zealand or Danish butter, as the case might be——

Comment on this

And put the farmers in Mountjoy. That really happened.

Comment on this

If you had your way you would confiscate their lands.

Comment on this

Oh, are you there? Idid not know you were there at all. You are becoming so small, Mr. Minister, that I did not see you.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey wants to overthrow the whole system.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister for Finance is behind the pile of books over there.

Comment on this

If you want to pay the farmer a decent price for his milk you do not want to undercut the whole market by the sale of foreign butter. If you want to see that money operating within the country, and the farmer and his working man getting a decent return for his labours, you require to pay farmers an economic price for their butter. Butter is the only commodity, within the whole range of commodities, over which the Government have control. One would imagine that the Fianna Fáil Party were composed of a crowd of wicked persons who wanted to tag our people, to invest money abroad to the detriment of our people, to increase the cost of living and to do all the evil things in life without any consideration for our people or our country.

Since I became a member of this House I have listened to a spate of propaganda from the Opposition Benches—propaganda on the lines which I have mentioned above. I do not think that such tactics are conducive to good business in the country. I do not think it is calculated to help our economy or to help the unemployed. I do not think that the theories put forward by the Opposition are meant to cut down the emigration figures and, in general, I do not think that their suggestions are in any way helpful. Those tactics of belabouring and lambasting the Government for this, that and every other evil can be carried too far. That is why I suggest that the time of this House is not being put to the best possible use. If the time of this House is taken up in order to promote the prestige of the Fine Gael Party, it is a bad day's work. I want the various other Parties which comprised the former Government to consider that position. We are not elected to this House to shower bouquetson any Party, but we like fair and honest criticism and, if a helpful suggestion is made, I think it can be said that our Party, at any rate, give heed to it. What is the suggestion for our difficulties at the moment? What is the suggestion to help our agricultural exports? What is the suggestion to help to boost production in agriculture?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

A new concrete apron at Baldonnel.

Comment on this

What is the suggestion to absorb some of the unemployed? I notice that, recently, the unemployed carried a placard which read: "We want work at trade union rates." That is all right in a free economy, but it did not suggest what sort of work the man wanted, whether or not he was qualified to do it and how many hours he would work. No matter what Fine Gael may try to put over on the electorate about our assets abroad, which, by the way, represent only one year's purchases from abroad——

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

I do not care what Deputy MacBride tries to slip across us, as an ally of the Fine Gael Party. He had not the courage to stand at the head of his own Party and advocate that policy when he would have a chance of, going before the electorate at a subsequent election and seek the suffrages of the people in support of it. Why did you not do that in 1948 when you got a mandate? Instead, you came in here and started whining and then put your policy in abeyance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might use the third person.

Comment on this

The people of Ireland will not go into a corner to whine because Deputy MacBride suggests that this Government are not facing up to their responsibilities, because they are leaving money abroad. We get all this false propaganda and I am fed up listening to it, as are a great many other people. As a member of the former Government, Deputy MacBride increased our assets abroad. Since then he has told us a good deal withregard to the control of money and credit—so much, in fact, it is rather fortunate that this House does not control money because the people of this country would go a-borrowing and a-sorrowing as a result.

There are rules in every game, as Depnty Larkin has on occasion said, but there are also rules governing the rules as to how the game should be played. The Minister for Finance, when he came here in 1951, had to undertake one of the most unpleasant tasks any man in a democracy ever shouldered. He had to defend his policy from every angle of the House in his efforts, with the help of his advisers, to put the country in such a position that we could do something for tho unemployed, for the people who emigrate and for the people who are seeking houses—all the people in whom Fine Gael seem to be so interested. If everything goes well for the future, we should be in a position now to consolidate our gains. No matter what advance an army makes, if they have to advance in the face of adverse conditions they have to consolidate their ground before they can make any further spectacular advance.

The Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Kennedy, was misrepresented by Deputy Declan Costello in his references to the Army. Deputy Kennedy did not suggest conscription for a moment. He did not suggest that every young man should go into the Army, but he did suggest that any young man in good health, whose physical fitness would suit him for Army service, could conveniently join the Army. I see nothing wrong with the Curragh or its environs. I spent a while there myself and I am not ashamed of it. I can recommend our Army to any unemployed man from the age of 17 upwards. Deputy MacBride would make use of this trouble we were faced with from 1931 on——

Comment on this

This crisis.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

You nearly said it.

Comment on this

It is not a crisis or anything like it. It would be a crisis, wereit not for the fact that Fianna Fáil have in the past displaced a knack of turning hard circumstances to good account. That is what is wrong with Fine Gael—they see that time is on our side.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

And Father Time has a scythe.

Comment on this

You are wasting a lot of it.

Comment on this

Deputies opposite have wasted quite enough time since this discussion opened.

Comment on this

The Minister is looking worried.

Comment on this

That is quite untrue. I am full of admiration for the speech Deputy Carter is making. I think it is an excellent speech.

Comment on this

We need to consider our standard of living and our unemployed and those who are emigrating. We require to look at our efficiency. But there is no suggestion from Fine Gael as to how we could improve our agricultural methods and our output and what we could do to create more efficiency. The trouble in agriculture, as I see it, is that the more prosperous a farmer becomes, the more people leave the land, because the more farmers become mechanised, the less labour they require. That is what is happening in agriculture to-day.

Comment on this

So you want poverty amongst the farmers?

Comment on this

Let Deputy Giles not try to misrepresent me because he will not succeed, either inside or outside the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Carter please continue with his statement?

Comment on this

The more prosperous a farmer becomes, the more mechanised his methods, the less labour he will require. The policy that Fianna Fáil implemented back in 1932, the policy of industry, is the only alternative of absorbing that labour. I have heardDeputies speaking about housing conditions, about living conditions, about wages and hours of work. One would think they never heard of Irish Shipping Limited, the Cement Company, the sugar factories, Bord na Móna or any of these semi-State institutions founded under the patronage of Fianna Fáil and which went ahead with the provision of our requirements.

I want Deputies opposite to remember that, unless we can produce something which we can sell abroad at an economic price, other than agricultural produce, it is going to be tough for industry. One of the richest countries in the world, America, is standing now where England stood 100 years ago. We hear the hardboiled American Republican businessman advocating free trade, if you do not mind; and we have articles appearing in various magazines suggesting that America should do now what John Bright and Richard Cobden did for England 100 years ago, that is, go back to free trade. The substance of their argn-ment—there is a good deal in it; as a matter of fact, I am not qualified even to discuss it—is that trade is not a one-way street. It flows to and fro and that is what I want some of the Opposition Deputies to remember when they talk about our trade and our sterling balances abroad. Trade is not a one-way street. As a nation we have survived for a long time in the face of divers difficulties, but our survival was not attributable to the whining tactics of Fine Gael. That will not help us. If we want to survive we will have to become efficient in our methods of production just the same as the Germans. In that respect there is no substitute for hard work.

Comment on this

Now you are talking.

Comment on this

There is no substitute in this or any other country for hard work, and I should like to get that into the Deputy's head before he speaks. No doubt the workers of the past were exploited and the workers of the present day would be exploited, but it is up to us, as workers, to acquaint ourselves with the outline ofthe job we undertake in order to become as efficient in it as possible and to work for the people who employ us with an eye on production and on the methods by which we finish an article and so on.

I detest some of the speeches deprecating the morale of our people. The morale of our people stood fast in the face of foreign oppression for 700 years and I think the Opposition are doing a bad day's work now by harping on the wrong side of life. The country has passed through a difficult period. I am sure that as a Party and a Government Fianna Fáil are not unaware of that. They do not need to be told. They have their advisers to advise them in regard to industry, commerce and agriculture. It is only by realising that efficiency means hard work that we will get out of the difficulties in which we find ourselves with regard to trade.

It was grand during and subsequent to the war when a Minister for Agriculture could go across to England and make a bargain with the British Government at fixed prices. What is known as the bulk buying system obtained then. A Minister for Agriculture was reasonably sure, when he returned, that the home price of the commodity would be the equivalent of what it would realise abroad. He could give a reasonable undertaking to producers to go ahead and produce. He was not required to go to the London market, stand over a commodity and sell it at a competitive price.

Some of the farmers and business men who make up the Fine Gael Party ought to realise those facts. They ought to realise that it is much easier to go over to London, sit at a table and make a bargain than it is to stand over a commodity and sell it in competition with Danes, New Zealanders, Dutch or any other foreign competitors. At the moment the British people are even becoming selective in the meat they use. They are complaining about too much fat and too much weight in the meat. But they are under the bulk buying system and they have got to abide by it. How long will they continue to abideby that if they can buy in a free market?

The live cattle trade might help us in the British market. That is one branch of our business which has helped us so far but the pace has been speeded up in England to the extent that the British customer will not in the future buy a, four and a, half or a five year old fattened bullock if he can buy a two year old for baby beef. Therefore, the British consumer has become selective. He will look for baby beef as he did in the early years.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know what beef is. A four year old fattened bullock is the tenderest meat you could eat.

Comment on this

It is not as tender as baby beef. I am not finding any fault with the four year olds.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

I know it is quite good beef. I did not cast any reflection on the four year old cattle and the Deputy should not misrepresent me.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Carter on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

These are some of the things we will have to study if we are to make progress in regard to agriculture. Similarly, if we are to make progress in regard to industry there is no substitute for method and hard work.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

We are told that the Vote on Account for £30,000,000 is to put the Government over the next ten weeks. During that ten weeks the House will stand adjourned. Deputies will have no opportunity of discussing the Estimates of the various Departments. There will be a sort of a closure on. Deputies will remember that on the last occasion—this time 12 months, I think—when this House was adjourned the price of butter was increased. What we fear is thatthey want to get the House adjourned to increase the price of something else without consulting the Dáil.

On the 21st May I asked the members of the House to come with me and see for themselves the queues of people lined up at our labour exchanges. It was regrettable that waited until the people concerned came away from the exchanges and came out into the open to show the way they were being treated before this House woke up to the difficulties of the unemployed and the conditions under which they were living. I told the House on the 21st May that I noticed a queue of from 500 to 600 yards long waiting for over an hour at the female branch of the labour exchanges in Victoria Street. You have not yet seen the unemployement that is among the female workers in this city, and I would suggest that those of you who go to Amiens Street station should go around by the employment exchange in Beresford Place any morning and see the large number of women workers signing up, seeking employment and hoping that the Government will do something for them. You have only to go around the corner into Gardiner Street and see the employment exchange there aud the thousands of workers that are waiting and hoping that you will do. something for them. Again, go over to Werburgh Street and see what goes. on there.

Certain members of the House developed an interest when the organised workers came out into O'Connell Street and made their appearance felt. It was regrettable that that had to happen. But, at least, it has succeeded in drawing the attention of this House and other public bodies to the fact that there is a very serious emergency position in Dublin City to-day among the unemployed. I am going to express the hope that this House will not adjourn until it is satisfied that that emergency is being properly handled and that such large numbers of unemployed as we have are being attended to and something done for them.

It must be remembered that the Minister for Social Welfare said it wasnot the intention to increase unemployment benefits. That was stated in reply to questions by Deputy Kyne and other members of the Labour Party, and later on to myself. We implore the Minister to give an increase to help the unemployed to overcome the difficulties which they are meeting while they are passing through these bad days; something to help them to meet the increased cost of living, of which we all know.

As far as unemployment is concerned, the last speaker and a Deputy behind me spoke about meat and the cost of meat. I want to tell the members of this House that in Dublin City meat has been removed from the tables of a very large number of people and especially from the tables of those whom you see marching in procession. One or two might be able to provide a small piece of meat for the Sunday table, but not many. Members spoke about butter and milk and the prices of these commodities, but I want to say that some of our workers in the City of Dublin do not know the taste of your 4/2 butter. We find that margarine production has increased due to the fact that those who used to use butter when they had good jobs and believed in giving the best to their families now have to find a substitute in margarine. I appeal to the Government to wake up and see what is going on.

In Dublin, we have a very good corporation, a good city manager and splendid officials, and they recently got together and they are producing relief schemes for the unemployed. That is all very fine, and I welcome them and I say they must come to give that temporary employment to put the workers over the emergency period. But these schemes can last only a short time. The cleaning of ditches, widening or concreting laneways and the making of playgrounds will be all over in six months, and I want to know what is the Government going to do about the thousands of unemployed when the relief schemes are over. Will they increase the grants for housing?

I want to be fair to both Governments. Since this State was founded both Governments were very energeticabout the housing position in this city because they felt they became heirs to an old tenement, broken down system, which was neglected for many years before the State was founded. They had to give housing grants but now these are not sufficient to encourage municipalities to build houses at rents which people can pay. We are housing people under differential rents and under what are called economic rents, and we have some thousands of young married couples with one or two children who are not eligible at all for municipal houses. We have a public draw at Christmas and Easter, and one of the troubles is the fact that the Government gives only £250 of a grant towards a house for newly-weds or persons with one or two children. For the ordinary houses they give us grants up to £800—for houses for families. But if the Government would go further into the matter of making grants available and if they would encourage private builders and companies by giving better grants and help young married couples as well as those with larger families to get houses, I think they would be doing valuable work for the city—much more valuable than temporary relief schemes. We will always have to have relief schemes. They must go on to relieve the emergency of the day. We all talk as if all the unemployment concerned those engaged in the building trade, skilled and unskilled, but what are we going to do for the storemen, the shop assistants, and those men whose industries have-slackened or closed down? And what about all the other types of trade? The docks were never so bad at any period of our history. At the North Wall and the South Wall you will find numbers of men unemployed and asking what is going to be done for them. Even the shipbuilding industry is suffering. Six months ago, I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce what he was going to do about getting us steel. I was on a board in Dublin which gave £530,000 worth of shipbuilding away to a British dockyard simply because we had no agreement, or if we had we were not able to enforce it, and we could not get the steel or materials at proper prices from English manufacturers. That is a casewhere the trade agreement broke down badly, and almost closed down the Irish dockyard and left people unemployed who had to follow their work to England and are now trying to send back half their wages to keep their families.

All these are things which should be done immediately. I want to impress on the Government and on my colleagues that there is a serious emergency problem in the City of Dublin to-day. Many of the people who are unemployed and drawing the small benefits which they get and which the Government refuses to increase are in new houses. They had accepted higher rents than formerly and a good many are now in difficulties, deprived of employment and wages and the ways and means of paying for their houses. I think the Government has been asleep for a long time. It is very hard to wake them up to tackle this emergency. In any case I found it difficult to waken up local authorities to face the emergency.

May I draw attention to a question asked on Thursday, the 21st May, and reported in column 2206 of the Dáil Debates in which the member for Dublin North-West asked the Taoiseach if he would state whether any proposals were being made to bring about a reduction in the growing unemployment in the City of Dublin and, if so, what was the nature of these proposals. Remember that it is two months ago since that question was asked. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach gave a review of the possible work that might be undertaken—the building of houses, etc.—and then he went on to say in the last paragraph of the reply:—

"Finally as regards industrial development by private enterprise, the Minister for Industry and Commerce has at present before him 33 proposals which, on the information so far available, seem likely to lead to the development of new industries, or the extension of existing industries in Dublin City and County."

That reply was given two months ago and we have not heard one wordsince about the 33 proposals which on the information then available seemed likely to give suitable employment. I want to know whether we were being deceived when we were told that there were 33 proposals for new industrial development? If not, will the Minister tell us who is holding up the 33 proposals that might provide decent employment for those who are now anxiously waiting for it?

I said on that occasion, as reported in column 2259 of the Official Debates:—

"The most important and immediate problems this Government has to face are unemployment, emigration and the cost of living and the sooner they face these problems, the better it will be for themselves and the country, because people can have patience for a long time but when they see their families suffering their patience becomes exhausted. Therefore, unemployment is the most immediate problem they have to face."

Their patience is now becoming exhausted. Deputies will now realise why I said that it was difficult to wake up the Government. They have slumbered, day after day, and week after week, without making any effort to increase unemployment benefits, unemployment assistance or increase the grants for relief. Nothing was done until the people made their voice effective.

I ask the Government now, before the Dáil breaks up—I understand it is to adjourn for ten weeks and it may be that most men are anxious to get back to look after their farms—that some emergency committee, a skeleton Dáil, if you like, of 20, 30 or 40 members should be ready to be called together to deal as an emergency matter with immediate problems.

Comment on this

A new Dáil.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Perhaps something of that kind. I tried to avoid bringing politics into this discussion. I do not want to tell my colleagues that the 6d. loaf is now 9d. I do not want to remind them that they gave £140,000 of relief to the dance hall proprietors at the same time as they voted for anincrease in the price of bread. If they wish, I shall go on to deal with these matters, but I intended to speak only for about ten minutes. May I say that I endorse the remarks of another speaker, who yesterday raised his voice in protest against the practice of Deputies standing up and speaking for an hour? What has gone wrong with the Dáil when a Deputy is not able to tell us what he wants in a quarter of an hour and then sit down and give other people a chance of getting in? It was thought that this House would be able to adjourn at 2 p.m. to-day, but instead, a proposal has been made that we should sit until 12 o'clock.

I do not want to delay the Dáil but I could not but avail of this opportunity to tell the Dáil and the Government that the most important problem they have to face is unemployment. I heard a Dublin Deputy repudiating a statement by somebody else who suggested a new way of finding employment, that our people should be induced or encouraged to go into the Army. We are all proud of our Army but it should not be regarded as a substitute for employment for men who want work to earn good wages to keep their families. I understand that the Army offers a very fine way of life to young men but no attempt should be made to introduce any form of conscription by refusing to give young men employment or to submit them to hardships of any kind in order to force them into the Army. I remember when a Fianna Fáil cumann in the city passed a resolution expressing the opinion that conscription was the only remedy for emigration. That resolution was passed by a Fianna Fáil cumann in Dublin City some years ago and the idea apparently has not yet got out of some of their minds. The resolution was from the Fintan——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Rathmines.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Quite right, from a cumann in the constituency of the Minister for Finance. They carried that resolution that conscription was the only remedy for emigration.

Comment on this

Would you prefer that they should join the British Army?

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Deputy Killilea has given me the chance for which I have been waiting for a long time. Perhaps you would allow me to deal with an interjection intended to hurt me and my family. A member of the Seanad some time ago stated that Deputy Alfie Byrne voted for conscription. I afterwards went to the trouble of getting the corraspondence and the records from the British House of Commons which showed that the whole Irish Party, with Deputy Alfie Byrne, voted against conscription for Ireland. I thank Deputy Killilea for giving me the opportunity of having that entered on the records of the House. I think Deputy Killilea was on the platform when Senator Andrew Clarkin stated, in the course of the by-election in North-West Dublin, that Deputy Alfie Byrne voted for conscription. He knew that was a lie. The whole Irish Party led by John Redmond and John Dillon voted against conscription.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy would get back to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I would have finished five minutes ago only for the interruptions that were made with the hope that they would hurt. I shall go no further. If I went any further I would be merely repeating the statements I made in the last two months when I invited my colleagues to go to Werburgh Street to see the females signing up there and to go to Victoria Street and Gardiner Street to see the males signing. One does not have to wait for a demonstration on O'Connell Bridge every week to see what is happening and how our people are being treated. Thousands of unemployed are looking for decent jobs and decent employment. They should not be emigrating to England as they have been doing in their thousands over the last 12 months. We appear here to wipe our hands completely of these young boys and girls when they leave our shores. That is not playing the game in relation to Irish people in charge of educational matters in England. It is not playing the game to allow our emigrants to go over there and give them no help when they become unemployed.I think it is disgraceful the way this country allows its emigrants to be treated. After all, they are only an hour's journey by air and three hours' journey by water from their native land.

Comment on this

Were you not told by way of parliamentary question and answer——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not cross-examination, and Deputy Byrne is entitled to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I would like to ask Deputy Gallagher a question.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Byrne is not entitled to ask questions.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

It was alleged that I voted for conscription.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We have had enough about conscription and the Irish Party. It is quite irrelevant.

Comment on this