We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1953-54. Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 415–613 of 613. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. A. Byrne

With all respect, there was an interjection.

Comment on this

I was helping the Deputy. I was only three years old then so I could not say what the Deputy did in 1916.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Before this debate concludes, most Deputies will, I think, have expressed their views in relation to the serious position now facing the country. Some criticisms have been levelled at the Opposition by Deputies on the other side of the House suggesting that we have been obstructing the Government in the execution of their programme and in the implementation of their policies. If that criticism is levelled at the objections we raised in relation to the Government's policies, then it is well founded: it will be recalled that two years ago when the present Government embarked on the financial policy embodied in the Budget of 1952, and repeated in the last Budget, we on this side of the House foretold the sequel there would be in unemployment, emigration and hunger amongst our people. We arenot now being wise after the event.

In April, 1952, when what is called the "hunger Budget" was introduced we stated that if those policies were implemented, unemployment would come to this city, unemployment would hit the rural areas and would, in turn, breed emigration and a general economic recession in trade. The Government cannot complain now, two years later, that we are speaking about unemployment because we see it taking place; that we are speaking about hunger and hardship because we see them taking place. As day follows night, all that had to follow on the financial and economic policies initiated by the present Government two years ago.

I do not want to travel over the ground that was covered in the autumn of 1951, and the spring of 1952 by the Leader of the Opposition when he was endeavouring to get the Government to have some economic and financial common sense. Suffice to say that in the autumn of 1951, when the Central Bank Report of that year was published, advocating a restriction of credit, a reduction in purchasing power, a reduction in subsidies, a reduction in imports and a reduction in employment, and when the Irish Presscommenced to write editorials praising the views of the Central Bank and the Minister for Finance published his famous White Paper underwriting the sentiments contained in the Central Bank Report, the Leader of the Opposition asked the Government whether or not they had gone crazy. He pointed out that if the sentiments contained in that infamous document, the Central Bank Report, were accepted as Government policy serious visible harm would be done to the economy of this nation.

But the Government paid no attention to the warnings given by Deputy Costello in the autumn of 1951 and the spring of 1952. They went ahead and implemented in totothe recommendations of the Central Bank Report by their Budget of 1952. I pay no attention to the denial made here last night by the Taoiseach when he said that his Government did not advocate and was in no way responsible for the restrictionof credit in this State. I am prepared to accept that the Taoiseach makes that statement, sincerely believing it to be true, but he says it in ignorance because every responsible statement made by the Minister for Finance on financial matters in the autumn of 1951 and throughout the spring of 1952 was directed towards the restriction of credit in this country.

That suggestion was contained in the Minister's White Paper. It was contained in the many statements he made on financial matters, and it was represented to those who controlled credit in this State that that represented the new financial policy of the Fianna Fáil Government: credit should be restricted; excess purchasing power should be taken out of the pockets of the people; that, in turn, would correct the adverse balance of trade and everything in the garden would be lovely. All the hardship has come about because the banks were prompted to take that action.

I recollect the Minister for Finance in this House in July, 1951, when he had just become Minister for Finance, making his first statement on policy, a statement in which, having attacked what had been done by his predecessors, he proceeded to set out five or six points towards which his policy must be directed. That entire speech had one vein running through it: the three years that had just gone before represented the nation's "Rake's Progress"; we had all been spending too much; there was too much money from too many sources in the nation's economy; wages were too high; credit was too high; from every source our people were getting too much money and that excess of purchasing power had caused—so the Minister described it—a staggering adverse trade balance in our trade with Britain.

Comment on this

On borrowed money.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

If the Minister saws that, then he is more irresponsible than I had conceived he could be. The Minister who says: "on borrowed money" is the Minister who, as Minister for Finance in June, 1951, took over the entire Marshall Aid loan to this country and has administered itsince, apart from the money that was spent on the purchase of land reclamation machinery.

Comment on this

That is quite untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is completely true.

Comment on this

The figures will contradict it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

If the Minister has a faulty recollection, I refer him to a speech made by the Taoiseach about nine weeks ago, I think during the by-elections, in which he admitted that, when his Government came into office I think he said £26,000,000 of Marshall Aid was available and was being administered. But, in any event, the position two years ago, was that the Minister for Finance, by the speeches which he made and by the statements of policy which he uttered, called for a restriction of credit and he got it in no uncertain way. The summer of 1951, and the autumn that followed, were bleak periods for the people of this country, for decent, honest, hard-working business people who, having received, in good faith, accommodation and credit from banking circles here, found demands made upon them which were a sentence of insolvency.

I charge the present Minister with being responsible for those demands by creating in the minds of banking circles the fallacious belief that the economic and financial conditions of the country demanded those restrictive policies. Everything that has been done since by the Minister, and other members of the Government, has confirmed ths people in the belief that the commercial banks, the Central Bank and the Government have gone hand in hand playing a ring of rosies around the credit of this country.

It was idle for the Taoiseach to come in here last night and say: "I knew nothing about it; I was not responsible for it and my hands are clean". That is as it may be, but his Government's Ministers, in their policies of the last two years, have been responsible 100 per cent. for the restriction of credit in this country since they came into office.

I know that it is far too easy, whentalking about banks and talking about credit, to err on the side of advocating extreme measures on matters of that kind; but I do want to express, however, this personal view that our situation to-day in this country, and indeed the situation in other countries also must drive the people to this conclusion, that it is suicide for any State to permit a banking policy to run counter to the State's own economic policy. Once that happens, only harm can ensue.

I give the present Government full credit for believing that, when they took up office, they desired to maintain employment, at least on the same level as it was when we were in office. I give them credit for believing that they desired to continue a policy which had brought greater production in agriculture and in industry and that, if they could manage it, they want to see this country progressing, emigration dwindling and employment increasing.

I think it would be quite impossible for any political Party in this country to hold or to follow a policy contrary to that; but I do blame them for this, that by irresponsible speeches, by a desire to wound the personality of Deputy McGilligan, they created, in an irresponsible manner, the belief, amongst commercial banking circles here and outside, that Ireland was insolvent, that the country was heading for the rocks and that those who had money invested here had better look to their money. In the last two years, our conditions of under-investment, the fall in employment and increasing emigration, demanded a credit policy which would pump into the nation's economy millions and millions of pounds while the Government have allowed the commercial banks to follow a contrary policy. That is wrong, and whatever economic or financial structure permits that to take place must be changed, and I believe it will be changed.

Now, we are reaping the harvest, a bitter, bleak harvest. Unemployment stalks this land; emigration is as bad now as it was during the days of the famine. There is uncertainty in business, there is doubt as to the future, and the only concern the Governmenthave is how to weather the storm. That kind of situation cannot last. Despite the very boastful sentiments expressed by the Taoiseach last night, people are not impressed. There is no Government Minister, and no Government Deputy, who can suggest that the people there ever consulted with regard to the policy which is now being pursued by the present Government. Everyone knows that they were not, and everyone knows that, prior to the General Election of 1951 and during the course of that campaign, not a single leader of Fianna Fáil told the people that, if they were elected, credit would be restricted, that taxation would be increased, that subsidies would be abolished and that food would be made dearer. Not one part, and not one iota, of the policy pursued in the last two years was submitted to the decision of the people of this country.

It is under those circumstances that we are accused of obstruction, if you please, when for the last two years we have consistently stated here that by every constitutional means in our power we would prevent the present Government from pursuing a policy which they never put before the people. On the odd occasions, by the coincidence of events, when the people have been consulted, has there been any doubt as to their answer? In the last two years we have had the discreditable sight of a Government, without support, in Ireland clinging on desperately to office in the face of an angry people. We are not going to let that continue, no matter what the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance or any other member of Fianna Fáil may think, and we do not believe that the people will permit it to continue. Ireland could not afford a continuance of the present policies for very much longer.

The unemployment that exists now is, as I have said, the direct result of the policy of Fianna Fáil. That is now accepted by every member of Fianna Fáil, including the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach because the very announcement of relief schemes is the greatest admission of failure that any Government can make. There is no other Government in the world that could say it hasfollowed a sound policy when, after two years of coming into office, it has to consider seriously the imposition of relief schemes in order to deal with unemployment.

I wonder does the Taoiseach know what is going on. I wonder is the Taoiseach kept informed as to what happening in this country. I wonder does the Minister for Finance not know, not realise, that his policy has been as harmful as it could be in the last two years. Remember the phrase contained in the Central Bank Report. Remember the "unusually favourable level of employment" to which they referred in 1951 and which they thought created an excess demand for the import of goods from Great Britain and caused an undue amount of money to be in the pockets of the people. Is there now a favourable level of employment in this country? We know there is not.

Does the Minister for Finance not realise that his advisers in 1951 committed him to a policy aimed at reducing employment? Does he not realise that he has been prodded and pushed by Victorian economists into the greatest mistake that has ever been made? Unemployment has increased. The purchasing power of our people has been reduced. Our effective demand for imports has disappeared. We now balance our trading books with Britain. I am quite certain that the Central Bank Report for this year will contain chapter after chapter of flowery praise for the economic and financial policy that brought about this balance of trade with Britain. If there is a soft spot in the heart of the scribe who will write that report he may say: "Of course it is unfortunate to have to say that unemployment has increased, that the cost of living has gone up, that emigration has been doubled, that hardship and hunger stalk the land but, after all, some disadvantages must be suffered in order to balance our trade with other countries."

I suggest very sincerely to the Minister that he has been codded up to his teeth, that he was codded two years ago and that he has embarked this country on the road to economic and financial ruin. Now, two years later,when he finds that the policy he started and the things he did necessitate famine relief schemes again in Ireland, it is time for him to take stock of what is going on.

Painting the walls around Dublin City, putting down new roads leading to nowhere, putting up watch towers throughout Ireland—is that to be the economic policy of Ireland's Government in 1953? One hundred years ago, in 1850, a British Government was doing exactly the same thing for exactly the same reason—because their economic policy had failed in Ireland. To-day, 100 years later, after a period of two years in office, an Irish Minister for Finance has to bring in relief schemes to undo the harm caused by his own policy. I do not believe that the people will stand for it. I do not care what constituency the Government desire to consult, they will find the answer always the same—get out and stay out. That is because you cannot play a confidence trick on the Irish people and hope to get away with it.

I am reminded of one other matter that I want to refer to before I conclude. It is perhaps merely by way of reply to a matter that used to be associated, 12 months or so ago, with our debates on financial matters. This entire financial craziness that has been called a policy by the Taoiseach and the Minister in the last two years was embarked upon initially in a desire to injure the prestige and harm the reputation of the finest Finance Minister Ireland ever had, Deputy McGilligan, a man whose wealth of outlook and economic knowledge transcends by far that of any of these economic cranks that now are associated with the Minster for Finance.

One of the little brickbats that used to be thrown at Deputy McGilligan was made by Deputy Browne but thrown by the Minister for Finance. It was that the Budget of 1951 was a faked Budget—as harmful a charge as could be made against any Minister, a charge which I believe was made well knowing it to be untrue.

Luckily, those who are responsible for the publication of the financial accounts of this State are not politcal partisans or anxious to make a case.They publish in our official records facts as they find them, without gloss, without commentary, without underlining, without emphasising. If any Deputy, particularly Deputies on the opposite benches, would repeat now, sincerely believing it to be true that the 1951 Budget was faked, they should look at the Appropriation Accounts for the year in question—1951-52—where they will find very interesting figures. These accounts of our public services which, as Deputies are aware, represent the history of what happened to the money raised by the Budget and spent during the year, tell the story in respect of the financial year after it has concluded, and they tell it better than any politically-minded Minister can do it. In the 1951-52 accounts, Deputies will find that there was a surplus of £6.1 million.

Comment on this

There was no surplus.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Do not talk damned nonsense. There was a surplus of £6,000,000. Out of that surplus, provision was intended to be made and was designed in the Budget for the payment of the Civil Service award amounting to £2,035,000. Deducting that sum from the Budget surplus, there was a net surplus of £4,300,000 which, as was stated in the accounts, was certified by the Comptroller and Auditor-General. That speaks more clearly and more cogently than anything the Minister or Deputy Dr. Browne, the man who made the brickbats which the Minister threw, may say.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor-General has nothing to do with the Budget.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The accounts for the year 1951-52 published by the Minister's Department contained this statement——

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan's Budget was a faked Budget.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Do not talk nonsense. You do not represent anyone. You told enough lies outside.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

TheDeputy must not say in this House in connection with any Deputy that he told lies. You must not charge a Deputy with telling lies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I said outside.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Inside or outside the House.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Then I will say that he told untruths. The following statement was contained in the accounts for 1951-52——

(Interruption.)

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dr. Browne should not be interrupting.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I do not know whether Deputy Dr. Browne is junior to me or whether I am junior to him. Both of us may be adolescent, but we know that when a statement like this is made: "The total amount to be surrendered at the end of the financial year...", it means that the sum to be surrendered is in excess of the requirements of the Minister.

Comment on this

It does not mean anything of the sort.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

At the end of the financial year 1951-52. (Interruptions.) Deputy Dr. Browne in smutty little places outside has been telling untruths. If he remains in the House he will hear the truth, whether he likes it or not, which will keep him from running around telling untruths. At the end of the financial year 1951-52, the total surplus on the Budget, excluding the payment to the civil servants of £2,000,000, amounted to £4,300,000. That was the surplus which was contained in the financial accounts of this State for the financial year 1951-52.

Comment on this

Why did you quit if you were so well off?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We did not quit. The people did not want us to quit. A few bell-boys put us out, but the people will put us back. These financial accounts were published on the 14th February, 1953, with the authority of and under the name of the Comptrollerand Auditor-General. They were published some nine or ten months after these lies were spread, and this irresponsibility was indulged in by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not refer to lies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I have not mentioned the word "lies."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy did.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

If I did it was a slip and I will substitute the word "untruths."

Comment on this

The Deputy has no control over his tongue.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister obviously wants to prevent the truth coming out, but he will not. It is quite clear now, and it has been clear since last February that the last inter-Party Budget yielded a surplus of over £4,000,000, although out of the revenue raised by that Budget the Civil Service award amounting to over £2,000,000 had to be paid. These facts now known to us and to the people of the country must have been known to the Minister for Finance when making his speeches about budgeting for a deficit. He must have known that the revenue accounts which he took over were yielding a surplus of over £6,000,000 and a net surplus of over £4,000,000. We may then ask why, knowing that, he stated the contrary. I would be stopped by the Chair again if I referred to the way in which the people outside would describe the Minister's speeches. Knowing that he had a surplus of over £4,000,000, why did he say that the Budget was not yielding a surplus?

Comment on this

I had no surplus. The Deputy does not understand what he is reading.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I am telling you that the net sum which had to be surrendered at the end of the financial year 1951-52, amounted to £4,300,000.

Comment on this

We will deal with that some time.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

We have no doubt that, were it not for the Supplementary Estimates and the codology indulged in during the ensuing financial year, the net sum to be surrendered at the end of the financial year 1952-53, would have totalled £10,000,000. Of course, the Minister for Finance, carrying over that surplus having indulged in over-taxation last year and continued it this year if he is there next year he will be able to say: "I reduced taxation all around the place; what a good boy am I". If that kind of political trick commends itself to the Minister, it certainly will not commend itself to the people.

There is one personal matter which I should like to deal with before I conclude. Deputy Carter, I think, in ignorance and I hope so, repeated here some time ago, a statement originally made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to the control of meat prices in the spring of 1951. That statement was contradicted on three occasions by my father, who was at that time Minister for Industry and Commerce. The statement of Deputy Carter is completely inaccurate and untrue, and if he cares to inquire from what he believes to be the source of it, he will find it to be untrue.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Everett.

Comment on this

If I might intervene——

Comment on this

Is this in order? Deputy Everett has been called on.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Everett has been called on.

Comment on this

During this debate the Minister for External Affairs mentioned my name in connection with the sterling assets being increased in 1950. That has been dealt with by other speakers. What I want to refer to are matters that the Minister did not mention. He did not refer to the fact that in 1950 we had to remove Orders to keep the wages of the workers down to a very low level. He omitted to mention that we remedied the position in which the workers employed by public bodies had received something more than 2d. per day as an increase to meetthe cost of living. He omitted to refer to the fact that during that period up to 1951—let us give credit to Deputy Dr. Browne—a scheme had been brought in in which we removed the worry from the breadwinner who was suffering from T.B. We encouraged him to be examined early and to go to hospital without the worry of being dependent upon home assistance. A special allowance was made to him.

The Minister also ignored the fact that in 1950 there was a housing drive in which 13,200 men were engaged on the erection of houses in the Twenty Six Counties. In 1953 the number has dropped by 6,000. There are now over 6,000 skilled employees on the dole including 1,000 carpenters, notwithstanding the fact that at the present time there is a demand for the erection of houses all over the country. In agriculture you have over 8,000 men fewer employed than there were in 1950 and 1,800 people fewer employed in transport because of the Government's policy in notifying C.I.E. that they were to economise.

Comment on this

Pay their way.

Comment on this

And pay their way. The way they economised was to dismiss over 1,800 employees. There were 1,300 less men employed in the clothing industry; 600 fewer in engineering; 700 fewer in the mining industry and over 700 fewer in quarrying. However, the biggest problem of all is the large number of men unemployed in the city of Dublin. During the period I referred to, you had the erection of over 4,000 cottages in the County of Dublin. They were reduced to 1,000 last April. Why was there no scheme prepared by the public bodies on the lines of the 1948 and 1949 schemes? Why did the public bodies in 1951 not try to prepare schemes to meet the housing requirements of the various localities?

I can speak as one with 30 years' experience as a member of a public body in connection with the erection of houses. We are the first body in Ireland to have our own scheme of erecting houses by direct labour; wehave our own equipment; no public representative ever interfered with the engineers or the men in charge of the erection of these houses. Even during the war we were able to erect houses to meet the requirements of our people but unfortunately owing to the Government's action in increasing the rate of interest we have been unable to proceed at the same pace at which we were proceeding for 20 years.

During the last month a case came to my notice at a public board meeting where we had two houses to let. One was at 14/- and the other at 6/-; they were built in different years. The list of applicants placed in the order of preference recommended by the county medical officer of health numbered 20 for the house at 6/- and only 4 for the house at 14/- We tried to erect houses on an agreed scheme for the men in the rural areas but we found that on a £1,000 house the economic rent would be 25/8d. a week. We would receive a subsidy from the Government of 13/7 which would leave 12/1 to be met either by rent or by rates. We agreed to rent the houses at 10/- a week. We would have to put 2/7 on the rates which was equal to £376 a year on the house. We decided that in an endeavour to keep the people in the rural areas for the time being pending a change in the rate of interest we would only charge 10/- a week for the house and put the 2/7 on the rates.

Deputy Carter has made a case with which I do not think any Labour man will quarrel. He said that workers should be prepared to do their best in return for fair wages. That has always been the policy of any genuine labour man, but in increasing production we must ensure that if the worker does 12 months' work in nine months he will not be idle for the other three months. There must be some incentive given in industry, either by way of profit sharing or by providing some other inducement to the men to produce more. The position in industry to-day is that you have many factory owners threatening from week to week to displace men. Deputy Kennedy, the Parliamentary Secretary, made a grave mistake whenhe said in the House that there was alternative employment in the Army for these men. I interjected to say that I did not approve of such conscription and Deputy McCann immediately stood up and dissociated himself from the remark that the unemployed should be sent into the Army. We have no objection to any man voluntarily joining the Army, but I do not think that is the solution for unemployment. When we are spending something in the neighbourhood of £9,000,000 for the Army, we could quite easily allocate a couple of million pounds for the erection of houses at a 2 per cent. rate of interest. We must make some sacrifice in the national interest in endeavouring to keep our people in the rural areas. I believe it would go a long way towards absorbing the large number of men unemployed and be an incentive to public bodies to continue their work. I give credit to those public men who are doing their best to relieve the housing problem, but they are prevented from doing a great deal more by the high rate of interest charged.

I would ask the Minister to consider seriously making some concession to enable the public bodies to go ahead with big housing schemes and not talk so much about the erection of cinemas, and so on. That may be good in its own way but the housing of the working classes and other people comes first.

When I realise that 20,000 houses are required here in the City of Dublin and that they are building at the rate of 2,000 a year—and Cork must be in a similar position—what hope is there, then, for the person without a house if they are only certifying in a survey for the people living in condemned houses? You have probably a survey for the number living in overcrowded dwellings. It will take over ten years even to find accommodation for the 20,000. That is all wrong. I believe that with the skilled men we have available and with the men who are willing to come back again as they came back before, we could guarantee ten years' continuous work for our skilled men and tradesmen all over the country providing much-needed houses for our people. We are trying to inducemen to remain in the rural areas but we must provide houses there. I am afraid that the Taoiseach mentioned one thing yesterday when he said that some of the relief schemes amounted to £70. If that is looked up, you will find it was a relief scheme for the Board of Works. You can always pick out a case for or against a particular scheme, but I believe that the Public Works Act was a very important and a very valuable scheme. You were reclaiming land, and if we got greater production in the country in the way of reclaiming land we would enable the farmers to have more land and produce the food we need.

I will come back again, having considered the serious position in the City of Dublin, to the rural areas. When you talk about the rate of interest and the position of the agricultural worker, he has about £4 or £5 a week, and every increase in rent means that he is going to look for an increase in wages. Sometimes, as I have mentioned, the increased interest rate means 1/8½ a week increase in the rent to the agricultural labourer for the house we are going to erect in the county. We are erecting them as cheaply as we possibly can, giving first-class material and giving employment to our workers. Now the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs points out that all the public bodies have their schemes nearly completed. There are 48 schemes completed; there are other schemes in preparation, but the public bodies, seeing the rate of interest, are afraid to proceed in case they would be unable to get suitable tenants.

When I am talking about suitable tenants, I am talking about tenants, not in the cities but in the urban areas whose wages are only £5 a week. I can state that in my own area, in my own town, we built houses for what we call white-collar workers apart from the men out of condemned houses or overcrowded houses. But it is difficult to enable them to pay since the high rate of interest even for Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act houses. For the last 18 months—I think that the Minister can check up that—we had not even one application for the erection or for a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition)Act, because it means 10/- or 11/- a week to shop assistants or skilled men or tradesmen and they are unable to pay. We did then proceed to build 20 or 30 houses to meet the requirements of those men but the rent would amount to 30/- per week. A labouring man with £4 or £5 a week would be unable to pay 30/- a week. What is our position, then? We must try to do the best we can, and I would ask the Minister to consider that point no matter what has been his opinion. We are paying £9,000,000 for the Army to defend the country and that is not giving us production. If we can give those millions, surely we can leave some millions there, free of interest or at 2½ per cent. even, to enable us to solve this problem that we are faced with at the present time. The Government members, naturally, are not going to admit that the Budget of 1951 has been responsible for all the trouble. They make the best case they possibly can. I do not want to exaggerate the position at the present time in any way, but we have 8,000 men less employed in the rural areas than we had in 1950. This is a serious matter for any Government and a matter of which the Government must take serious notice. If the agricultural areas become depopulated, what is going to happen in another few years?

Boards of guardians were asked to erect cheap houses for the farm labourer and let the ratepayers pay by way of subsidy on the rates because of the low wages paid to the farm labourer. Now we must provide houses in the rural areas at a rent which the farm labourer can afford to pay without looking for a further increase in his wages. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs pointed out as his excuse for increasing postal charges that the postal charges are cheaper to-day than they were ten years ago. If this is so, the unemployment benefit to-day should react in the same way that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has followed. The unemployment benefit should be increased to meet the demand.

I do not want to detain the Houseand I only want to refer to the practical position we are faced with on the public boards. I give credit where it is due. I have known all the members of public boards for years and they are all most anxious to provide employment for our people. You have seen that the two congresses of trades unions have passed resolutions about which I believe the Taoiseach is meeting them, requesting that the work of erection of houses and public works should be proceeded with immediately. I believe they can be proceeded with and that they are works of production, work that will not be called relief work. There is no council that I am aware of that could not absorb 200 or 300 men in the county more than are employed at the present moment. Some county engineers try in getting the estimate for the roads to reserve full employment until the winter period during the Christmas when work will be scarce. To enable us to meet the present difficulty I believe that the Government will have to change their whole financial policy in connection with the treatment of public boards. If we are going to proceed with big sewerage schemes, which is a matter for the improvement of our health, or with water schemes, we must not be charged 5½ per cent. or 5¼ per cent., the same as for other business.

Why must the ratepayer bear his share of any increase that takes place in connection with this development of their towns? They have to make sacrifices by paying increases in the rates to meet the cost of the improvement of the social services, sewerage or water or housing. Why should the banks then not make some sacrifice, they being in control of credit, for doing a national work of national importance? Why should they charge the full amount of 5¼ per cent.? I maintain that banks should only charge for a national project such as the erection of houses, sewerage and water schemes 2½ per cent. and not any more. You should not be asking them to reap the benefits and you should put the interests of the people first. I would appeal to the Minister to consider the problem not from any pointof view except that of the position we are faced with at the present time. I think that any public representative must feel the position of the number unemployed in his respective area. It is not nice to see a large number of men unemployed, when we could find useful work for them if we had money at a cheap rate of interest. I ask the Minister to consider that. If he does, the public bodies will be able to proceed within six months, as they did some years ago, and redouble their efforts to provide more employment, in the erection of houses and the provision of sewerage and water supplies. If that occurs, we will not be next year in the position as we are in to-day, as we will have done something about it in the meantime.

Comment on this

I want to reply to charges made by a Fine Gael speaker in which he said that recent figures have shown that I was lying when I suggested that the Fine Gael Budget of that year was a faked Budget. The charge is a serious one and it has surprised me that the answer has been delayed and that it should be delivered in this way, at the tail end of a long debate during which the person who is charged with the faking of the Budget should have remained silent. It is surprising that the speaker, in providing what he described as proof, should have admitted that he has had the proof since February of this year, yet no one in Fine Gael would relieve Deputy McGilligan of that charge. This is an attempt by Fine Gael, using every despicable trick in their pack of conjuring tricks, to discredit myself. So far, they have not been successful. In this particular case, they are not successful either.

At that time, the principle was put forward that at all costs the figure on the cover of the Book of Estimates, as we were all informed, must remain at the same figure as the previous year. At all costs, our Estimates should enable Fine Gael Ministers to keep the figure the same. It was very fancy finance, very Fine Gael finance. In the ordinary course, on my responsibility as Minister, I submitted a figure which was put forward by myofficials and which I accepted. That figure was referable to health services and in particular to the mother and child services. I was asked to reduce it and produce a smaller one. That request was not made as an ordinary one by a Minister looking for curtailment of expenditure. It was made in the clear knowledge that that money was likely to be required for the mother and child scheme, if it had been allowed to go ahead, as had been announced by me on behalf of the Government. That request was made. It was a request to fake the figure, to give a dishonest, untrue figure. It was made deliberately, in order to mislead the public. I was encouraged to take the step to submit the false figure by the inducement that other Ministers in the Government had accepted this practice as honest and normal acceptable practice in the administration of their several Departments. I repeatedly refused to accept that figure, in spite of the cajolments and the inducement of the different members who were sent to me to mislead, to produce the wrong figures. Eventually, two things were arrived at. I felt that my responsibility would be met if the public were made aware of the total likely commitments required by my Department.

Normally, in a normal Government, that total likely requirement is mentioned in the Estimates. If you refer to the Book of Estimates, you will find there is a footnote to the requirements of the Department of Health and in that footnote—I cannot recall the exact figure—it says that £400,000 or £600,000 was likely to be required for the health scheme on its coming into operation. I, as Minister, in that curiously assorted, largely dominated from the financial point of view by Fine Gael, Government, had discharged my responsibility to the public in letting them know what would be the likely charge on their purse under my Department. In consequence, I felt I had discharged my responsibility.

In addition, the matter had to be discussed in the Party to which I belonged and I have no doubt there are members within that Party—then a Party—who would be prepared to comeforward and repeat the charges I have made, in their knowledge at that time, which arose from the fact that I had refused to connive in that cospiracy, in what I believe was an attempt to defraud the public.

Comment on this

That, of course, is completely untrue.

Comment on this

Of all the Fine Gael failures in the inter-Party régime, that was one of the most disgraceful interludes—upon which Deputy McGilligan, at some time or other, can give us his version of Catholic social teaching or the moral law.

Comment on this

Here is the moralist now.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to wait one moment for the moralist.

Comment on this

If I have to suffer on this earth, I may as well listen to you.

Comment on this

When a Minister sneers here at somebody who tries to do his best under all circumstances, when a Minister tries to hold him up to ridicule and scorn, apart from the single word "moralist" the Government has fallen even lower than Deputy Dr. Browne would have us believe.

Comment on this

Are you not the canonist of the Party?

Comment on this

I am not. I am an ordinary, straight, decent country blacksmith, who became a soldier in the service of Ireland and did his best, no more, no less. I never repudiated any comrade that ever I had, never did and never will, and that even includes you, sir, you little Minister that does not deserve the friendship of good real men in this country, because you are trying to sneer. The Minister is trying to sneer at the name of every person who did not agree with him at the time, whether that person is a Liam T. Cosgrave, a Sean MacEoin, a Collins, a Griffith, a Peadar Cowan or a Dr. Browne. Then he sneers at us who tried to do our best. I propose to apply myself to the issues of to-day, in a straight andsimple way, factual and without embellishment. The Minister has said, time and time again, that the reason he brought in the harsh Budget of 1952 was because of the failure of his predecessor to make provision for the necessary expenditure for that year. Every Fianna Fáil spokesman and every Minister of the Government, including the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who is now sitting on the front bench, admitted that it was a harsh Budget. They said that they could not do otherwise than bring it in because, they alleged, their predecessors did not make sufficient provision in their Estimate of 1951 for the expenditure that was required. Not only that, but they also alleged that the Marshall Aid loan and all Marshall Aid moneys were completely spent by their predecessors in office. They went from pillar to post declaring that as a fact and they alleged that not only did their own supporters believe it fully but that some of our supporters believed it likewise. It was agreed that we had prosperity but Fianna Fáil said that that prosperity was brought about by a "spending spree," to use the words of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, by their predecessors-in-office.

The former Minister for Health, Deputy Dr. Browne, asserted in this House that he was asked to fake the figures for the Estimate for the Department of Health for 1951. He said that he told members of his own Party about what he was asked to do. The truth of the matter is that each Minister was asked to sub-edit his proposals. Is that not the practice yet? Has it not been the practice— as it always will be the practice—of every Government to ask each Minister to estimate the lowest possible figure he is likely to spend in the year?

The Estimate for 1949-50 was £70,000,000 on the face of the Book of Estimates. For 1950-51 the Estimate, on the face of the Book of Estimates for that year, works out at £81,000,000 and for 1951-52 it works out at £82,000,000. Where, in view of these facts, does Deputy Dr. Browne get the story that the Minister for Finance wanted to keep the same figure on theBook of Estimates for the year 1951 as was there the previous year, 1950, when, in fact, it was not so? I have here in my hand the Book of Estimates for 1951-52 which shows on its face a sum of £82,000,000. According to the Minister for Finance, the moralist, according to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, the moralist, and according to the Taoiseach, the moralist cum plus—according to each one of them—that Book of Estimates was a fake. Then we have the Comptroller and Auditor-General—a matter to which Deputy O'Higgins has already drawn attention—certifying what the actual expenditure was in the year 1951-52. This certificate, although it was signed by the Comptroller and Auditor-General in February of this year, was not published until May of this year. The Comptroller and Auditor-General certifies—and I hope nobody will impugn the Comptroller and Auditor-General of this country with having faked figures—that the total amounts of the surplus to be surrendered was £4,302,556 15s. 11d., after paying the £2,000,000 odd to the civil servants, the Army and the Gardaí.

While Deputy O'Higgins was making his speech, the Minister for Finance interrupted him and asserted that he did not know what he was talking about. I should like to say to the Minister for Finance and the Fianna Fáil Deputies and, in particular, Deputy Dr. Browne, that if they do not like the 1950-51 certificate of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, they should take the year previous to that. Take, for example, the one issued by the Comptroller and Auditor-General in respect of the year 1950-51 and dated the 23rd February, 1952. In that certificate, the Comptroller and Auditor-General certifies that the sum which Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, had to surrender to the Exchequer, after that year's operations, amounted to £4,611,277 6s. 6d. Was the Budget of 1950-51 a fake Budget?

Because Deputy McGilligan had that surplus in respect of 1950-51, he was able, in his Budget of 1951-52, to give relief in taxation. He was able to give 6d. in the £ relief in income-tax, amongother remissions, and he was able to make increased provision for children. In fact, he presented the best Budget that this country ever got. But Fianna Fáil were as mad as mad could be because anybody could do better than they could and, therefore, Fianna Fáil went out on a smear campaign, aided by Deputy Dr. Browne who broke with his comrades and his colleagues.

What is wrong with telling the truth? I hope the day will never dawn in this Parliament when the only thing that can succeed is the untruth. In his speech to-day, Deputy Hickey appealed to the Government to say where the truth lies. The former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, said that there were stocks of fertilisers in the country when he left office while the present Minister for Agriculture said that there was not a grain. Then it was found out.

One Minister asserted that the Marshall Aid funds were all spent and he consistently maintained that, until the Taoiseach, for some reason, got up in Fermoy and said that there was a remnant of £24,000,000 left. When I asked him why he would not describe it as a tailor's clipping, he was very indignant and said that he had not used any such phrase. The word "remnant" has only one meaning—a very insignificant part of the whole— and therefore £24,000,000 was a good lot more than a remnant of £40,000,000, being more than half. All that has brought about restriction in credit and I know business men in this country to-day who were doing well, who were giving first-class employment, who to-day cannot maintain their employees. They tried to get credit from the banks and failed.

The Taoiseach told us that that was not their design, but, in the next breath, he told us that the Government had decided to take the hard path, the hard line. They decided at all costs to rectify the balance of payments and then the little Minister for Posts and Telegraphs goes down the country and says that the people should be very proud of the fact that Ireland was able to lend money to Britain. I should be twice as proud if Britain would pay us back what she owes us.

I am not suffering from any inferiority complex and I never did, but I do not think it is right that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs should tell the unemployed in the City of Dublin that they ought to go hungry and be proud because we were able to lend money to the British Government at 1½ per cent., while charging 6½ per cent. to our own people. Outside of bedlam, was there ever anything like it?

When somebody gets up to attack that system, a Minister of this State has no better phrase to offer than "moralist". He does not say that to other Deputies; he does not say that to Deputy Dr. Browne, who is a moralist, who is able to say whether the bishops are right or wrong and who tells the bishops what he thinks of them. The Minister for Finance is mum and mute of malice because if he did not agree with that, Deputy Browne might not go into the Lobby with him and if Deputy Browne did not take that walk, the Minister would be walking up and down through Rathmines telling the people who were the moralists and who were not.

Every Fianna Fáil Deputy and supporter will agree that the inter-Party Government, in its term of office, brought prosperity to the country and brought an era of peace. It did everything necessary for the safeguarding of the interests and wellbeing of the country, but, as they could not find any ground for complaint from the point of view of peace, they took the untruthful line that our prosperity was due solely to the failure of the then Minister for Finance, then Deputy McGilligan, to extract from the people the taxation which, in his opinion, should have been extracted from them. They alleged that he did not make provision sufficient to cover the Book of Estimates, but that has been exploded now completely and yet we have Fianna Fáil back benchers repeating that charge, as does the Minister for Finance, I regret to say, whenever he gets an opportunity of doing so where he cannot be contradicted. We have reached a poor time of day when that situation arises.

I should like to hear the Minister for Finance defending his programme, which is now a total failure, which has created unemployment and which has increased the cost of every piece of capital expenditure the State or the individual undertakes. If a local authority proposes to build a labourer's cottage to-day, it will cost the individual or the local authority the sum of £18 a year more than in 1948-49, 1949-50 or 1950-51—and that is progress. They say to-day that the only way they could get money was by paying 5 per cent. The British Government last year paid 4½ per cent. for their money, and, only about three weeks ago, they issued an Exchequer loan of £100,000,000 at 3½ per cent., and they got it.

Comment on this

For how many years?

Comment on this

If you could get it for four years, would it not do you? Why cannot you not borrow on short term as well as the British? Is your word any worse than that of the British? If we are to judge by the conduct of the Ministers of this State, your word would not be equal to anybody's and that is a hard thing to have to say. If they are as untruthful in other matters as they are in relation to what takes place in this House, nobody could accept their word. However, I do not take the view that they are that bad. I take the view that if any Government of this country, whatever Government it is, borrows for one, three, five or 15 years, at 3½ per cent. or 2½ per cent., they are doing good work; but that if they have to borrow or pay the moneylender and the moneyringer 5 per cent., they are working for the moneyringer and not for the people of the country.

The Central Bank lends £80,000,000 at 1½ per cent. or less per annum, justifying it on the basis of liquidity and short term. Liquidity of what? There was a time when, if you went into a bank to change a £10 note or a £100 note, you got what it promised on demand—100 gold sovereigns or ten gold sovereigns. Is that the situation to-day? If you go into a bank to-day to change a £100 note, you will get 100 bits of paper—they will not give it toyou all in silver—so that there is no such thing as liquidity to-day. The Government, in talking that way, are working on the basis of an obsolete machine, of something which died in 1914 and which was put on the scrapheap. I assert that the Government have failed.

The plan and programme they put into operation here asserting it was going to bring about financial stability has failed. If they had any decency they would put that test to the country. I presume they will get the Vote on Account and thus the decks will be clear for them to put the facts before the country during the recess. We shall abide by the decision of the people. We on this side of the House challenge the Government to do that, and even though some of us are growing old and not, perhaps, as fit to fight the battle as we were in days gone by we will, nevertheless, take on the responsibility in the belief, the hope and the knowledge that, joined by the younger men in our Party and in the various Parties on this side of the House, we will bring the country back to prosperity and hold what has been won after a hard struggle.

Comment on this

I did not intend to take part in this debate until I heard the Taoiseach last night and read his speech in this morning's papers. I wonder are some members of the Opposition fair in their condemnation of members of the Government Party or even of Ministers when we take into consideration in a fair and honest manner the words used by the Leader of the Government as quoted in this morning's newspapers. He said:—

"I think always that the time that is best for the country——"

He was speaking of an election,

"——is when it is best in the interest of this Party, because I believe this Party is working in the country's best interest."

I believe it is a tragedy, when we are trying to approach our problems in a fair, honest and constructive way, that the one person who should be imbued with a greater sense of responsibility than anyone else in this country should say that it was only when it suited himand his Party that there would be an election. At the present time we are faced with the problems of unemployment, the increased cost of living and emigration but it is a waste of time for us to try and offer any suggestions when it is clearly known by each and every one of us that this is in reality a one-man Government.

The Taoiseach, when speaking last night, tried either to take the Deputies of this House for a ride, to use an American expression, or else he was acting in complete ignorance of what is going on all round him. Members of this House, who are members of local authorities, are fully conversant with the problems in the various local authority areas at the present time. Members of the Government Party who are members of local authorities must have found it rather strange to hear their Leader and their Taoiseach say that there were more men working on the roads with the local authorities now than at any time during the reign of the inter-Party Government. Surely those members know in their hearts that that was not a true statement. They know as well as I do that there is more unemployment in the ranks of road workers in the South of Ireland, including County Cork, than there ever was for many years past.

I know many road workers who asked the help of some of us in the Opposition and also the help of Government Deputies. Those Deputies were anxious to help if they could but, unfortunately, the money was not there for them. It may be said that increased grants have been given to the local authorities. What use is that if we have to rob Peter to pay Paul? Local authorities who got increased grants were faced with the problem of a greater reduction in the money provided under the Local Authority (Works) Act.

Every member is fully aware that practically 100 per cent. of the money provided under the Local Authorities (Works) Act went towards the paying of wages, which was a tremendous advantage so far as the workers were concerned.

If the Taoiseach is so simple minded or if he thinks that we are so simpleminded as to believe what he tried to tell us last night, he is making a mistake. It might well repay the Taoiseach if he spent a few hours in the Department of Local Government at the Customs House inquiring as to why so many important projects, including the building of local authority houses, are being held up there. The hold-up in connection with these important projects is bringing to a climax a problem the Government must face. It is a problem that we are honest and anxious enough to try and help to solve. It is the problem of unemployment in the rural areas. It is quite true that unemployment is undoubtedly causing worries in the Cities of Dublin and Cork, but it is also equally bad in rural Ireland. May I say, in passing that it is no use even for a member of the Government to believe—mind you, I will say that the member who used the words I wish to draw attention to, was honest in expressing his view— that in Cork City, in the near future, everything will be grand in the case of employment, because a few extra churches are being built there? Thank God the stage has now been reached when there is no need to apply for a licence for the building materials to construct a church.

But if a few extra churches are being built down in Cork City, the Government cannot say that it is a Government project. Surely it is the people, and only the people who are striving through their own contributions to help in building these. I believe it is ridiculous and fantastic for the Government or a member of the Government to say that because such works are going on in the City of Cork that everything will be grand there in the near future.

The Taoiseach, apparently, took pride in quoting the words of wisdom used by his Minister for External Affairs, and apparently the Taoiseach was highly offended when the poor ordinary country boys, as it were, here on these benches did not take into consideration and did not give full value to these wonderful golden words of wisdom spoken by the Minister for External Affairs who was trying in his own way to have us believe that some of ournew-found economists, including the Minister for External Affairs, have discovered a way of living that is unknown to anyone else but which in the near future is going to remedy all the ills of unemployment in this country. What is wrong, in my opinion, is, as I said some few weeks ago, that the Taoiseach and the one-man Government that unfortunately is in power at the present time is living in the past while the unfortunate people in Dublin and elsewhere are faced with the problem of unemployment and the problem of keeping their children and their homes while depending very often on home assistance and are not able to exist on the glorious policy of 20 or 30 years ago. It is time we got away from it.

The last speaker, General MacEoin, did at least say something that I believe is true. He said some members in this House may be advanced in years but they are depending on the younger members to help. The tragedy of it all, in my opinion, is that the present Government fails to realise that the younger members in this House even in their own Party are not considered worthy of giving suggestions which these young members know represent the only possible ways of helping to solve the problems of the present time. Who is going to believe that? Nobody outside this House will believe it except the solid Government Party supporter. Not a word offered here by the Taoiseach last night is going to solve the problem before us. How strange it must be for anyone to read in a certain newspaper this morning of congratulations being offered to the Minister for Local Government because he was so generous as to receive a deputation here from the Corporation of Dublin. In his generosity again, he told them that he is behind them in cleaning some of the lanes, in clearing some of the river beds around the rivers of the city. Surely as one or two members said in the course of this debate Government policy cannot be restricted so much, or reduced to such a low, dead and shallow measure as to have to say that our only contribution is to tell the members of Dublin Corporation: "We are behind you inthese small projects." The people are expecting something more than that. If the Taoiseach would develop his point, and if he told those members of his Party on the back benches who are merely supporting this one-man Government, that the Government was satisfied that the capital investment programme at the present time must be extended, then the people might have something for which to live. Then they might say that even while the Taoiseach reminded them of the necessity of tightening their belts owing to economic conditions over the past two years, that there might be some hope for the future. But not a word from the Taoiseach, and I am sorry to say that in our opinion so long as that policy is in operation in this country so long will we have from the Government a policy which is futile and hopeless.

The Minister for External Affairs apparently, is satisfied, an attitude so different from his views if members will read some of his contributions here in the early years after his entry into this Chamber. If Deputies compare these views with the views of the present Minister for External Affairs they may wonder whether it is really and truly the same person who was offering these various contributions. And when we take into consideration the fact which is commonly known in this country that this particular Minister of State is almost the guardian angel of the Taoiseach, surely the words expressed by that Minister must have the august apostolic blessing of the Taoiseach. We still believe that the tragedy perpetrated on the people by the continuance of a false economic policy is a tragedy which in the years to come will bring nothing but despair and misfortune for the people of this country.

We are told that the Government is determined to help the local authorities in connection with house-building and again the Taoiseach who is so fond of statistics—statistics that can be used in any way, to suit anyone, except the hungry because they cannot unfortunately live on statistics—was satisfied to tell us that they were offering inducements to local authorities to goon with housing. It was strange to hear this when, as members of local authorities, we are faced with the problem of the new rates of interest. We will take for instance a house costing £1,200 before the introduction of the new system, even including the new grant. The old system meant that on a £1,200 house the annual loan charges, etc. worked out at roughly £23 per year, and the new system introduced by the Government with the blessing of the Taoiseach, means that the annual loan charges which ultimately must be paid for by the tenant and, to a certain degree, by the local authority, rise from £23 or £24, up to roughly £33 a year—over £9 a year more in annual charges under the wonderful new system offered to local authorities and indirectly offered to the poor unfortunates down the country who find it difficult enough to pay the rents that are being asked.

All these problems including others that have been mentioned and which I have no intention of going into, are problems that unfortunately the present Government are not showing any desire to tackle.

There is no attempt being made by members of the Government to answer to the call of the Leader of their Party when these problems have to be solved. Yet, they accuse us of criticism of a destructive nature when we draw attention to these problems.

The Taoiseach, of course, wandered over the whole sphere and I would go so far as to say that the contributions he offered were in no way helpful. The only thing he forgot to mention, in my opinion—I really did believe he would include it, because he mentioned it even in the by-elections in East Cork and also in Dublin recently—was the close proximity of his policy, and incidentally, of Government policy, to that of a famous clergyman of long, long ago, who believed that he had found a cure for all ills in nothing less and nothing more than tar water.

I have nothing to say, needless to add, about the man or his religion, but when the Taoiseach tells us that the policy of the present Government was just a continuation of the policy of that famous bishop, and when eventhe supporters of the Taoiseach down in East Cork, plain, honest-to-God countrymen, ask: "About whom was he talking when he mentioned the name starting with B.", is it any wonder when they hear who the man was, they say: "We know nothing about his tar-water but certainly, so far as we know, his policy was anything but Irish"? These are the views expressed by the people in East Cork and yet the Taoiseach tells us, according to reports in the papers, that he is following the policy of this person.

Is it not a calamity to have to admit that we are almost at the cross-roads in regard to problems, economic and otherwise, facing this country? Yet we have the one person who should be most responsible, telling us how intimate he is with the policy of this great individual, this great man who found a cure for the ills of the poor human frame. It may be well to advise the Taoiseach on one matter. He is quite satisfied—either through lack of information on his part or from a desire to avoid the whole issue—that the Government are encouraging, and almost forcing, local authorities to go on with projects that should be carried out in various areas.

If the Taoiseach wants to go ahead with these projects, his first step should be to insist on an attempt at solving the problem of the lack of coordination between the famous Custom House, the Ministry of Local Government—and the local authorities. The Government must accept responsibility for the hold-up in many schemes of vital importance through red tape or through other devices which involve the sending of continual letters of inquiry on various aspects of different schemes. Deputies here often bemoan the increases in rates, but if the Taoiseach went on a tour, even though it might be a tour of pleasure, and called to the offices of local authorities, he would find that a certain percentage of the staff in these offices had to be recruited for one reason above all else and that was to deal through a filing system with all the inquiries from headquarters including some of those we got a few years ago advising the use of thatchedroofing for cottages in rural Ireland. I say that the fewer letters sent down from the Department of Local Government and the quicker sanction is given to schemes of local and national importance, the quicker we can solve the problem of local unemployment.

We are told about the increased money provided for capital works. Again the Taoiseach reserves for himself the right to judge whether these works should be undertaken or not. He of all the Government or amongst all the Ministers will decide whether the spending of this money should be proceeded with. I should like to know, reverting to a very important subject dealt with here some time ago, the undeveloped areas, how much money has been spent already under that heading. We were told that there was roughly about £2,000,000 to be made available, but that that was, so to speak, only the key to the door. We were only opening the premises of this new sphere of activities to help the people in these area. It must be roughly about a year and a half ago since that was said. I honestly believe that even at the end of this year the money spent on works under this particular heading will fall far short of the amount that should be provided for these areas.

The Taoiseach also, of course, laid emphasis on the fact that he is a believer in private enterprise. He may consider that some of us who may not agree with him in that policy are primitive in our outlook, or that our knowledge is so restricted that we should not discuss the matter. I believe, as other members of this Party who have spoken already believe, that private enterprise on its own will never succeed in solving the vital problems of this country. There are many enterprises and many factories carried on by private enterprise which certainly are a credit to this country, but because the Taoiseach is living in the past and because his policy is an old obsolete policy, he fails to realise the significance of semi-State or State concerns which, since we regained self-government, have justified our claim that there are many industries which should be controlled and run as State concerns. While I will not go so far asto say that State enterprise is the sole remedy for all the evils of unemployment in this country, the history of the monopoly by private enterprise, even under a foreign régime, justifies our claim that private enterprise alone will never help to ease the unemployment problem. The philosophy behind many of those running private enterprise is that they should have a good pool of unemployed from which they can draw whenever they want to. The time must come when the old, obsolete policy of the Taoiseach and his Government must be put before the people so that the people may be given an opportunity of deciding as to whether they want progressive economic policies here, or whether they prefer to drag along in the way in which they have been doing for many years past.

We find no pleasure in listening to members of this House comparing policies as between Party and Party or Government and Government, comparing failures and successes. What is the use of that? There are some of us here who speak with a proper sense of our responsibilities and we are not satisfied that time should be wasted here listening to the warriors of the past recounting their glorious deeds. Some members went so far in that to-day that I was convinced that at any moment we would see Brian Boru sitting in the middle of the floor. Some of them alleged they were in the Fenian movement. The Government will shortly produce Robert Emmet on a postage stamp but they are not producing any schemes to combat unemployment.

The Taoiseach stated last night that many of the contributions here were not helpful. There was one speech we were all waiting for during this debate, hoping that there would be some ray of light thrown on the situation or that some hope would be held out. I refer to the Taoiseach's speech. What did we get? I know that there is many a back bencher in the Taoiseach's own Party sadly worried about the unemployment position. Many of them are worried about the continuous emigration of our young people. They came in last night and the Taoiseach had them roaring excitedly during hisspeech. When he finished the curtain came down. The three-dimensional spectacle was over. They went out believing that everything would be all right because the Taoiseach told them that he, and he alone, will decide whether or not we will have an election.

Let me sound a note of warning. The Taoiseach's policy may suit himself; the last two years have proved that it does not suit our unemployed; it does not suit the old age pensioner; it does not suit the people in the rural areas. It does not suit the people who have to struggle to meet an ever-increasing cost of living. The Taoiseach may hope that there will not be an election until it suits himself. The tragedy is that between now and then the people all over the country will have to endure many a day's hardship and suffering and many a day's hunger and it is one man, and one man alone, who is and will be responsible for their miseries.

Comment on this

I merely want to refer to some matters in connection with my own constituency. I heard the Taoiseach say last night that he would not allow any money to be spent on capital development unless that development were productive. I have here a list of works that will definitely be productive if schemes are put into operation. I put the Taoiseach and his Government to the test now to see if he will carry out the promise he made last night.

First and foremost, there is the land project scheme. We in the western counties are not large farmers. The holdings there are small and uneconomic. An acre of land reclaimed there is more valuable to the smallholder in the West than ten acres or 15 acres to the rancher or the farmer in the Midlands. I would impress upon the Taoiseach, the Minister and the Government the imperative necessity for intensifying the land project scheme in the West of Ireland. Every £ spent there on land reclamation will mean increased agricultural production and will help to rear a greater number of store cattle for the man in the Midlands and the rancher who come to buy cattle two or three times a year at the fairs in the West.

I regret the statement made by the Taoiseach that the reclamation of land at £70 per acre is not a good proposition. Any money spent on reclaiming land is money well and wisely spent. Land is fetching very good prices in the West, and on occasions it has realised as much as £100 per acre. The Taoiseach adverted to the fact that he had examined this land project scheme and discovered that in one instance, where an acre of land had been reclaimed at a cost of £70, the money was wasted because the land would never grow anything but rushes. He condemned the whole scheme on that one experience. That work, of course, had been carried out during the régime of the inter-Party Government. If the Taoiseach comes down to Sligo, he will see land now being reclaimed there— cutaway bog—that is not even fit to grow rushes. The money spent on that will be money wasted. If he wishes to investigate that I will give him all the particulars.

Another scheme which will provide very useful employment in Sligo and ultimately lead to increased agricultural production is the drainage of the five rivers in that county. At the moment the land project scheme is held up because of the condition in which the rivers are. They are not able to carry the extra water flowing into them. I suggest that the Minister should consult the Parliamentary Secretary and ensure that these rivers are cleaned. The cost would not be very great and, if the rivers are done, the people will be able to avail of the land project scheme.

Another scheme which will provide employment and increase production is the development of the bogs. I refer, in particular, to Gowla Bog. A survey is being carried out there at the moment. There are 5,000 acres in it and I understand it is the intention of the Government to erect a power station there. Now part of this bog extends into County Mayo but the biggest portion of it is in County Sligo. There is a difference of opinion as to which county these stations should be erected in. Now the Fianna Fáil Governmenthas always neglected County Sligo and I suggest that this power station should be erected on the Sligo end of Gowla bog.

Another useful scheme on which money could be well spent is the improvement of Sligo harbour. An extra grant should be provided for that work. During the inter-Party régime a grant was allocated for the repair of that harbour, but it was not sufficient to carry out the necessary repairs. The harbour board are continually seeking assistance from the Sligo County Council to help them out of their difficulties in maintaining the harbour. I would ask the Minister to consider that matter. If money were made available for it employment would be provided and the harbour could be fully developed. That would tend to relieve the very acute unemployment problem we have in Sligo. In fact, the only industry we have in Sligo Town now is the labour exchange. On the appointed day, we have men, who are willing to work but cannot get it, queueing up until 5 o'clock in the evening to sign on.

Comment on this

The national dividend.

Comment on this

Those men would certainly rather get employment at a fair wage than have to spend the whole day waiting at the labour exchange to sign on.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary wants to conscript them into the Army.

Comment on this

There was a suggestion made to-day by a Deputy on the Government Benches that these men should join the Army. That certainly would be a handy way out, but I wonder if joining the Army would be considered reproductive employment. How do the Government expect to have increased production, and how do they think the farmers can grow more wheat and other cereal crops unless there is more employment provided on the land? It is the responsibility of the Government to have a proper policy so that the maximum amount of employment can be given on the land.

Another scheme which would be of great benefit, not only to Sligo and Leitrim, but the country at large, is the proper development of the Arigna coalfields. Full-time employment is not being provided at present in some of the coal mines there, so that a number of the employees have been compelled to go to England. The coal produced there is of first-class quality, equal to any that is being imported. I seriously suggest to the Minister that he should have a survey made there. The roads leading to the mines should be properly constructed, and Government assistance should be given to some of the mine owners who are at present in financial difficulties.

Some Deputies on the Government Benches who have spoken here have gone to great pains to look up statistics bearing on the volume of unemployment in other countries. We should not worry about the unemployed in any other country. We have our own country to look after. The ways and the means of meeting the unemployment problem are here, but I think that the Government have neither the will nor the desire to put reproductive schemes into operation.

The cost of living is worrying the people of the country at the moment. It has increased considerably since the present Government came into office. Butter is now 4/2 per lb., and the loaf of bread is 9½d. Of course, the people are very well aware of that, and I made that known to the Government in the recent by-elections in Wicklow and Cork.

I wonder if the Minister for Finance, when he is enjoying the luxury of his own home, gives a thought to the hardships and worries of the people throughout the country, and of the unemployed especially? There is nothing left for them only the blue book, but the miserable amount provided through it is not sufficient to support a man and his wife and five or six children. The price of food has increased to such an extent that some of those people are actually begging. That has been my experience. If the Minister makes inquiries he will find that my statement can be verified.

Comment on this

It is three times what it was a year ago.

Comment on this

Evidently the Taoiseach is not concerned about the prosperity of the people, or how they are faring. All that is worrying him is the balance of payments. He is more worried about easing the position in regard to the balance of payments than he is about the people who are going hungry. The Taoiseach should know that, unless the unemployment situation is eased and production increased, the balance of payments position will become a very serious problem in the near future.

I will conclude by referring to the Taoiseach's statement last night when he was challenged about a general election. I think it was typical of the Taoiseach, but I will not say it was of all the Fianna Fáil Party. He said he would go to the country when it would suit himself, and when it would be in the interests of his Party. He is a shrewd politician, and he qualified that by stating that he believed the interests of the country could only be served by his Party. I will conclude my few remarks by asking the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach to make good the Taoiseach's promise last night, that he will only allow money to be spent on schemes of a capital development nature which are reproductive.

I have given the Minister a list of such works that could be undertaken. I think the list will bear the closest scrutiny. If the Minister thinks it worth his while to take that list he can, through the Board of Works, get all the data that he requires in regard to the carrying out of the schemes I have suggested on the hundreds of thousands of acres of land in the Counties of Sligo and Leitrim that need to be reclaimed.

Comment on this

You will have the House sitting until 12 o'clock to-morrow night.

Comment on this

That is what you are paid for.

Comment on this

It is a pity that you could not get a better job then.

Comment on this

Who knows but some day I may be occupying the job that you have. You must be terribly anxious to get back to enjoy the luxury of your own home.

Comment on this

I do not see what the luxury of my home has to do with this debate, but at least it is an honest home. I hope yours is just as good.

Comment on this

It is when you are out of it. This is a shocking way we are being treated in the House by the Minister for Finance. This dapper little man—the boosting he gets in the English papers must have gone to his head when he will not listen to a country Deputy speaking of the genuine grievances which the country is suffering from at the moment. The Minister and his Party, for 17 years, ignored the warning they had got. From 1948 to 1951 it was proved beyond yea or nay that there is an alternative Government, and that the people are clamouring for the day when they will get the chance of putting that Government back into power again, so that the prosperity and peace which they enjoyed then will be restored.

Comment on this

There is a saying that there is honour among thieves. After listening, however, to the speech of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins here this evening and apprehending the despicable trick which he proposes to play on the people of this country and his lame-legged attempt to convict me of falsehood, I am doubtful if any sense of honour lies in the breasts of some members of the Fine Gael Party.

Deputy O'Higgins alleged that when I stated that the Budget of 1951-52 showed a deficit of £6,680,000 I was misleading the House and the country and, as proof of that, he had recourse to the Appropriation Accounts for 1951-52 and, turning to the summary of these accounts, he referred to a statement at the end of that summary which said that an amount had to be surrendered and on the basis of that statement, he alleged that so far from the Budget of 1951-52 showing a deficit, it showed a surplus of something like £4,000,000.

Now, of course, I do not know whether this was merely the natural disposition of Deputy O'Higgins to try to mislead the public——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Being personal again.

Comment on this

——or whether it was merely infantile ignorance on his part. Most members of this House who have been here for two or three years at least know that what appears in this summary of the Appropriation Accounts is a statement of the authority to expend moneys which has been given to the Government by the Dáil and that this reference to surplus to be surrendered merely indicates the extent to which that authority was not used. It has got nothing whatsoever to do with the Budget statement.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is a fair excuse.

Comment on this

It has nothing what-sover to do with the balance on the Budget, whether it shows a surplus or a deficit.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is a fair excuse.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins ought to have been a little bit better informed before he tried to play that trick on an experienced member of the House, because, if the Deputy will turn to the Appropriation Accounts for 1949-50 he will see at the foot of the summary this statement: "Total amount to be surrendered, £7,074,000". On the basis, on the lines of the argument which the Deputy used when he was speaking a little while ago in this debate, it would appear from that that Deputy McGilligan had a surplus on the Budget for the year 1949-50 of over £7,000,000.

Comment on this

It was not faked then.

Comment on this

Of course, while Deputy O'Higgins may want to make a liar out of me when he misuses the Appropriation Accounts of 1951-52, does he now accuse Deputy McGilligan of making a liar of himself? Because, if the Deputy will turn to the Budget speech of 1950 made by DeputyMcGilligan and turns to Table 1 of the tables which were appended to that speech, he will find that Deputy McGilligan himself admitted that on the Budget for the year 1949-50 there was a deficit of £2,665,000.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is taken out of its context.

Comment on this

That is not taken out of its context. Here are the two things.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister knows well that he is taking something out of its context.

Comment on this

I have here the table. Deputy O'Higgins will not get away with that falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It is taken out of its context.

Comment on this

Here is the word: "Table I. Comparison between (i) Budget (May, 1949) Estimates and (ii) Payments into Exchequer and Issues Therefrom in 1949-50." Looking at the revenue side, I see No. 1, tax revenue, which is stated and No. 2, non-tax revenue which is stated. Then on the other side giving the expenditure there are four items, all of which are given and then, on the revenue side of the 1949-50 Budget account there appear under item (3) the words: "Deficit, £2,665,000." But, in the Appropriation Accounts for that year on the summary there appears that the amount to be surrendered—the extent of spending authority which was to be surrendered and to be revoted by the Dáil for supply in the following year— amounted to £7,074,000.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Will the Minister answer a question?

Comment on this

I am perfectly well aware of the fact that although I have convicted the Deputy here of a mean and shallow trick, I will not be able nor will the members of the Fianna Fáil Party be able to overtake that misrepresentation in the country.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Will the Minister answer a question?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will resume his seat. Deputy O'Higgins has no licence to interrupt when the Minister is concluding.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is a phrase that might have been applied to the Minister when I was speaking. He was consistently interrupting.

Comment on this

I called the Deputy's attention to the fact that he was deliberately endeavouring to mislead the House by quoting a figure which had no reference whatever to the Budget Table.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You were caught out on a falsehood.

Comment on this

I cannot stigmatise Deputy O'Higgins in terms which would be parliamentary in this House, but I leave any member of this House——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You have done it before.

Comment on this

——I leave any member of this House to read what I have said and to read what Deputy O'Higgins said and then let us see between which of us truth or falsehood lies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Let the people decide.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let the Minister make his statement without interruptions.

Comment on this

The Deputy, of course, is full of Dutch courage because in four Fine Gael constituencies——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Five.

Comment on this

——in four Fine Gael constituencies we did not manage to defeat a Fine Gael candidate. We did not manage to defeat the Coalition candidate, but do not let the Deputy forget that out of the six by-elections which were fought the one constituency in which the majority changed sides was that of North Mayo, which we won for the Fianna Fáil Party. In that case a minority was converted into a majority. That is only by the way—I know that merely to try and nail here this puerile attempt at misrepresentation by Deputy O'Higgins before it gains further currency will not be enough. I know that the factory has started and that we will have all sorts of little surreptitious clandestine pamphlets and circulars sent out from Fine Gael headquarters, and it may not be possible for us to overtake them, but here in this House, at any rate, the trick has been shown up.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You were caught out.

Comment on this

What are the reasons for and why should the House concede this Vote on Account? First of all, as to the reason why the Vote on Account should be given, it is that if it is not given, virtually all the public services will close down at the end of this month. It becomes therefore a matter of urgent necessity to place the Government of the day in funds to enable it to carry on the public services. It is true that it is unusual to have a second Vote on Account in the course of the year, but it is not unique. As the Minister for External Affairs showed yesterday in reply to Deputy Blowick, we had a second Vote on Account in 1928-29; one in 1932-33; a third one in 1943-44; and this is the fourth time in which it has been necessary to introduce a second Vote on Account.

The reason why it has been necessary to introduce a second Vote on Account this year is that no fewer than 43 of the Estimates have not yet been discussed and voted upon in this Dáil. It is usual every year for Dáil Éireann to appropriate the necessary money to enable the public services to be carried on long before the end of July. As a general rule, the Estimates are passed and the Appropriation Bill goes to the Seanad about the first or second week in July. This year is one of the four signal occasions on which it has not been possible for Dáil Éireann to dispose of the ordinary business of the session. Why? Because, though those Deputies in opposition pretend that they are full of concern for the public well-being, they have embarked on apolicy of deliberate obstruction, particularly on the part of Fine Gael. For days the members of that Party repeated themselves 100 times on the Health Bill. They obstructed that measure, despite the almost open dissatisfaction of the Labour Party at the attitude which they had taken up.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is this an attack on the Chair?

Comment on this

I want to put a number of questions to some members of the Labour Party. In the debate on the vote of confidence, Deputy Larkin addressed a query to certain members of this Dáil. Let me put this question to Deputy Larkin and those in the Labour Party who stand with him. If the Government had been defeated on that vote of confidence, what would have happened to the Health Bill? If the Government were to be defeated on this motion for a Vote on Account, what would happen to the Health Bill? The Labour Party, at least here in Dublin and I think elsewhere, I am sure quite genuinely and sincerely purports to be concerned not only with the manual workers, but with the white-collar workers, with the salaried officials, with what you might describe as the man who is in the lower middle-class income group.

The Health Bill, with whatever imperfections it may have and whatever its deficiencies may be from the point of view of the Labour Party and of some other members of this House, is the first social measure that has endeavoured to make any provision for the white-collar worker or for the man in the middle-class income group. It is, therefore, germane and relevant to this discussion to ask the members of the Labour Party, if they propose to vote against the Government on this Vote on Account, to let us know what they think will happen to the Health Bill?

Comment on this

Tell us about the unemployed and never mind the Health Bill.

Comment on this

I will come to the unemployed in due course. If this Health Bill were to be defeated and ifFine Gael were to come back and hold office for a little while, who would be their real rulers, who would be the people who would make policy in this country?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Not Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

Would it be Dáil Éreann or the Irish Medical Association? Does not the Labour Party know as well as I do that the Fine Gael Party is a Party which is dominated by vested interests?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

That is not so.

Comment on this

During the debate on the Finance Bill, during the debate on the Budget, during the debate on this Vote on Account, we have listened to their leaders speaking here as if the one supreme specific for all our national ills would be that the people of Ireland should have cheaper drink. Then they come and tell us they are not dominated by vested interests.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Cheaper dances.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order!

Comment on this

Is it not quite true, as I have said, that the Fine Gael Party are dominated by a philosophy which has always been opposed to progressive social measures in this country? At the end of 1946, or early in 1947, when the Bill to enable the Department of Health to be set up as a separate Government Department in order that the question of the people's health might receive closer attention than it had been possible to give it heretofore under one Minister, did not Deputy John A. Costello, when the new health services were foreshadowed, refer to them as "just a row of medicine bottles"? Have we not heard Deputy McGilligan even in this debate refer to social welfare as leading up to the servile State? Did he not make a speech immediately before the East Cork election, in which he quite clearly indicated that, so far as social reform and social progress in this country were concerned, if he had his way there would be a full stop to them?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He was not in Cork during the election. He never put a foot there.

Comment on this

The point I should like to put to Deputy Larkin, who was good enough to say that for many years there had been a close association of ideas and a spirit of co-operation between the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is this the man you called a Communist some years ago?

Comment on this

I am speaking of Deputy Larkin as I have come to know him in this House and I am referring to the speech which he made on the Vote of Confidence and in which he pointed out that there had been a spirit of co-operation and a similarity of outlook in regard to these social problems existing between the Fianna Fáil Party and the Labour Party. Then, apparently because we had not consulted them sufficiently often, or for one reason or another, the Labour Party determined to take it out on Fianna Fáil. Is is just that for such a reason as that the Labour Party should place in jeopardy the Health Bill and the other measures of progress which this Government will undoubtedly put forward before the Dáil in due course? Is it just that the Labour Party should try to unseat us to put Fine Gael in office merely for the sake of paying off an old grudge?

Deputy Larkin told us in the course of his speech that the Labour Party desires to assert its independence. That may be his desire. I am sure it is. I think that has been the line which Deputy Larkin has been very anxious to pursue for several years past. He was particularly anxious to pursue it during the period that the Coalition was in power.

If that is his desire, does he think he can make it effective having regard to the composition of the Labour Party as it is to-day? Is it not well known that many members of the Labour Party have closer association with some members of Fine Gael than they have with their own colleagues? When it became necessary for the purposeof serving the political interest of Fine Gael to try to oust Deputy Dr. Browne from the Cabinet, who was the man who wielded the bludgeon against him but the present chairman of the Labour Party? Was not his voice the decisive one? Even though Deputy Larkin was anxious to uphold and support Deputy Noel Browne, Deputy Norton, to serve the interests of Fine Gael succeeded in killing——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is this definitely related to the Vote on Account and the discussion? Are the Labour Party activities the proper subject matter for a reply? We will look after ourselves without your assistance. You look after Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

This may be very uncomfortable.

Comment on this

This is a falsehood.

Comment on this

I am putting these questions to the Labour Party. They tell us they are very anxious to have a general election. These are questions that will be raised on public platforms.

Comment on this

Can we have your ruling, Sir? You are the Chairman.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister, as far as the Chair can see, is replying to points made by the various Parties during the debate.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to reply to those points.

Comment on this

Do you not know perfectly well that the Minister who is speaking has no access to any record that would verify what he is suggesting?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a matter for the Chair.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He is taking advantage of Deputy Larkin's absence.

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin is here in the City of Dublin and so isDeputy Norton. They will be in the Division Lobby in due course.

Comment on this

Will you bet on it?

Comment on this

I thought you were not a betting man?

Comment on this

I would not mind betting with you.

Comment on this

I am putting it to the Labour Party, who have consistently supported Fine Gael during the last few years, questions they will have to answer, not here in this House, but in the country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is, if they should succeed in unseating this Government before it has completed its programme. They are very germane and very relevant questions and I think they are questions which Deputy Davin and Deputy O'Leary are finding very uncomfortable. They do not like the suggestion that there is working inside the Labour Party a fifth column for Fine Gael.

Comment on this

You are the leader of it.

Comment on this

Every worker in the country who has ever supported the Labour Party in the past is asking that question. We have heard a great deal about general elections and we have heard a great deal about by-elections. What is the significant thing about one particular by-election?

Comment on this
A Deputy

In North-West Dublin?

Comment on this

Take the by-election which occurred in an industrial centre, in the third largest city in Ireland, Limerick. What happened in that constituency?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

What happened to Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

The Labour Party's vote was cut by almost two-thirds.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

So was Fianna Fáil's.

Comment on this

The Labour vote was reduced from over 6,000 to just over 2,000.

Comment on this

You lost the seat anyhow.

Comment on this

We had never any hope of winning that seat because there was a Coalition majority against us.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

That is an insult to Mr. Clarke.

Comment on this

From the beginning to the end we had no hope of winning that election for the simple reason that there was a Coalition majority of 3,000 against us in Limerick East. This happened again in East Cork. What happened to the Labour vote there? There was a decrease in the Labour vote in East Cork of great significance. When the Labour vote was distributed quite a substantial slice of it went to the Fianna Fáil candidate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In what proportion?

Comment on this

Let the Labour people take care.

Comment on this

We will get it back again.

Comment on this

There was quite a large number of votes which were not transferred to the Fine Gael candidate but remained non-transferable. Let the Labour Party watch its step.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister is avoiding percentages.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

For goodness' sake let the man talk. He is doing terrific.

Comment on this

It is quite clear from the manner in which the Labour Party preferences went in West Cork and in Wicklow——

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It was Fianna Fáil votes that gave Fine Gael the seat in Wicklow.

Comment on this

It was Clann na Poblachta who gave them the seat. They double-crossed you. Anyhow, let Labour keep these things in mind.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I do not pretend tobe a prophet—I am merely basing my estimates on past experience—but from the figures of the by-elections it looks as if there is going to be a very blue look-out for the Labour Party at the next election.

Comment on this

What about the Dublin by-election? You had a big, strong man up against a young man.

Comment on this

Naturally, I cannot make what you might describe as a well-balanced, well-formed speech, having regard to the multitudinous matters that have been raised here. However, there are one or two things I think I ought to deal with. Deputy Dillon, the moonstruck Demosthenes, occupied two hours of the time of this House telling us what a wicked thing it was that our Central Bank or that our commercial banks should hold any sterling assets whatsoever.

I remember prior to 1939 when we were endeavouring to repatriate sterling assets and to build up the capital equipment of this country the man who was most bitterly opposed to that policy was Deputy Dillon. Every week that the Dáil was sitting we had a long repetitious speech from Deputy Dillon which apparently had been carefully rehearsed before he came to the House in which his one theme was that this country was going headlong into bankruptcy because the external assets of this country were being repatriated and invested in our cement factories, our sugar factories, development of our bogs and housing activities and in the various social amenity schemes which we launched over the period from 1933 to 1938.

Yesterday the Deputy complained that we were lending considerable sums of money to the British Government at 1¼ per cent., and he seemed to think that that was the source of all our ills. While the Deputy may complain about the fact that the Central Bank has its assets invested in short-term securities, upon which the yield is, of course, correspondingly small, what has the Deputy to say and what have the members of the Labour Party to say about borrowing on behalf of another country, about pledging the credit of the State on behalfof another country, about mortgaging the future production of this State on behalf of another country? That, of course, is what the Coalition Government did.

We have heard something in the course of this debate about the Marshall Aid loan and about the manner in which the proceeds of the loan were supposed to have been disposed of. Let us see, why was it that the Marshall Aid loan was raised at all. We will find the answer to that in a statement which was issued, an official statement issued and published on the 23rd June, 1948, in which the concluding paragraph contains this sentence:—

"The Government of Éire will use its utmost endeavours to obtain the maximum amount of aid available under the E.R.P. with the object of ensuring, as far as practicable, that their resources to the sterling area pool for hard currencies will not involve any ultimate drain on the pool."

There was an undertaking given by the delegation of the Coalition which went to Great Britain to pledge the credit of this country on behalf of another nation or group of nations. I want the Dáil to keep that fact in mind because I hope to show that the manner in which that money was borrowed, the manner in which that money was spent, plays a very large part and has been a very great influence in creating the economic problems with which we are faced to-day.

Let us see what the general position of the Government is. Capital expenditure as far as the Government is concerned is higher than it ever was before and accordingly the volume of employment should be correspondingly greater.

Comment on this

Never was it less.

Comment on this

Expenditure on social welfare in the year 1952-53 amounted to £16.9 million as against £12.3 million in 1950-51. That is to say that there has been an increase of transferable expenditure amounting to £4.6 million. That money goes out intothe hands of people who do not hold it and do not hoard it. It goes out to be spent. It goes out into circulation. It ought, if anything, to help the volume and velocity of trade. We can have a dozen other proofs that the Government's policy is not deflationist.

There is no truth in the suggestion made here in this House that there has been any curtailment of credit. On the contrary, there has been a loosening of credit, particularly in the first six months of this year. It is quite true that for a period while stocks were being liquidated and while prices were falling there was a reluctance on the part of commercial banks to advance money to traders to enable them to hold their stocks. That of course, was normal, for a proposition which never appeals to a banker is to advance money to a trader to enable him to hold stocks at a time when the price trend is downwards. As soon however, as the excess stocks have been liquidated and as soon as overdrafts which were represented by them began to be paid off the general policy, I should say, of the commercial banks has been to try to make advances to those of their customers who are creditworthy. But they cannot make advances—let us face up to this fact— to people who are trembling on the verge of bankruptcy or who they think will not honour their commitments.

It is true—and a great deal of attention has been devoted to it in the course of this debate—that there has been a considerable increase in the live register over the first six months of this year, but as I explained, I think, in concluding on the first Vote on Account, a very large part of that increase arises from the fact that many people who were formerly on unemployment assistance have come on to the unemployment benefit section of the register, and many people who were excluded altogether from unemployment insurance have now been included within its scope and accordingly are in a position to register; and, of course, there is a very great inducement to people to register in the category of "others" in order to secure credited contributions, people who formerly by reason of theoperation of employment period orders would have been cut off the register altogether. These people are now coming in and registering even during the summer months in order that they may become entitled to the 26 contributions which enable them to go on to the unemployment benefit part of the register and draw unemployment benefit in due course.

Now, as I have shown many things, each and every one of them, should be operating if you like to increase employment here, but we have the fact, and nobody is trying to blink it, that there is, if one might say so, trying to compare like with like, trying to compare the conditions of last year with those of this, and leaving out of consideration the general effect of the new Social Welfare Act, that there is an increase of about 6,000 unemployed persons. I have pointed out all the inflationary factors in the Budget—the huge increase in Government expenditure, the increase in the capital expenditure of the Government, the increase in the transferred expenditure in the form of improved and extended social services—and each and every one of these ought to operate to increase consumer expenditure and to produce employment. But there is some nigger in the woodpile which is not permitting that to be done, and what is it? In my opinion, the one predominant positive deflationary factor in our economy is the interest which we are called upon to pay for the Marshall Aid Loan.

Last year, in round figures, we paid £600,000 out of the circulation of this country in hard cash to America. Let us not talk in terms of hundreds of thousands. Let any businessman sitting opposite ask himself this question: "If I take £600 out of my business every year and pay it away as interest on a loan which I raised in order to buy maize and tobacco and petrol— corn which has been eaten, tobacco which has been smoked four or five years ago—to what sort of condition is my business being reduced?" Just any of you ask yourselves that question in these simple terms. If, instead of £600 it is £600,000, as it was last year, it is £1,200,000 this year, what doesthat mean? This year we will have to find in round figures £1,200,000 for interest. That sum will be withdrawn from our capital resources—£1,200,000 which would have flown through the whole of our economy, enriching it, stimulating trade, stimulating production to eight times the equivalent of it. No exact calculation has been made or attempted, but just let us consider that position in the light of the well-known multiplier effect and visualise what the consequence of this Marshall Aid Loan is to the Government which has succeeded the Government that contracted it.

That is the one positive deflationary factor in our whole economy. So far as Government policy is concerned, it is not deflationary. We do not want wide open inflation, but want to develop our national resources and try to keep the ship on an even keel. We want to try to defray the amounts involved in capital development out of current savings.

The one thing, I repeat, that is operating to restrict credit and to make trade bad is that in this year we have to withdraw £1,200,000 from the use of business and pay it over to the United States. I do not say that in any criticism of the United States. I say it in criticism of those who entered into that loan without fully considering what it involved and what the economic consequences of it would be.

It has been suggested that the Taoiseach, in particular, and the members of his Party had some responsibility for the Marshall Aid loan. Deputy MacBride, taking statements of the Taoiseach out of their context, has endeavoured to create that impression many times. Before I go on to deal with that I want the House to consider one aspect of the matter here and now. We have heard a lot in the course of the debate about the 5 per cent. interest which the last National Loan carries. Does not everyone realise that the interest on the National Loan is paid, in the main, to our own people? As to 95 per cent. of it—I am making a guess, but the figure is of that order—the interest is paid to our own people. Those to whom itis paid pay income-tax on that interest, so that the net charge to the Exchequer, after the deduction of income-tax, is very much less than 5 per cent. On the other hand, the interest paid to the United States carries no income-tax. It is a net payment and in gross terms it very closely approximates to a gross rate of 5 per cent. chargeable to tax.

I said a moment ago that Deputy MacBride had endeavoured to make the Fianna Fáil Party carry responsibility for the Marshall Aid Loan. He has indulged in the very discreditable procedure of quoting statements made by the Taoiseach out of their context. So far from this Party showing any ill-considered, impetuous desire to raise a foreign loan, the Party took quite the opposite and cautious view. In order to establish that, I propose to quote what the Tánaiste said in the debate which took place here on the 1st July, 1948, on the O.E.E.C. As reported in Volume 111 of the Official Debates, column 2014, Deputy Lemass said, criticising the suggestion that we might be forced to take a loan:—

"I am speaking from recollection. I say that there was good reason to believe, as a result of personal contacts by Government officials with American officials in Washington, that the details of the aid that was to be made available to this country by way of grant and the specific commodities that were to be shipped had been informally agreed, and that the agreement would be carried into effect as soon as the legal position permitted of it."

Then Deputy de Valera, speaking as the Leader of the Opposition, reported at column 2058, said:—

"An international agreement is a very serious matter. I think it is highly desirable that every clause and every sentence of it should be examined carefully.... It seems to me that this agreement appears to be objectionable to a number of Deputies here from the fact that it is in a general form."

Then he went on to say, dealing withthe reasons, notwithstanding the fact that we had not had time to consider it in every line, every clause and every sentence:—

"The agreement is intended, I think, to serve two purposes from our point of view: first of all to enable us by co-operation to do something to aid the other countries of Europe to recover and to establish themselves on a sound economic basis and it is also intended to help ourselves."

He said then, with regard to the first question, that it was his view that we should do everything we possibly could to help Europe. Then he went on to say:—

".... when I say that, I mean, of course, that we are restricted by what is right for us to do as a nation —everything within our power in that sense to help Europe back to normal conditions."

He went on—and these are very significant passages—in column 2059:—

"If we come actually to the point of asking for a loan, I think it would be very unwise for us to ask for any loan unless we are able to see clearly our ability to repay it."

Later he said:—

"It is a matter for very serious consideration that—if the accommodation must be by way of loan— before we ask for it we should clearly see our way to repayment."

He went on again to refer to an Irish proverb which we have often heard him quote in this House, "drinking is very pleasant but paying for it is bitter". Paying the interest on this Marshall Aid is a bitter thing, from the point of view of our Irish economy— not because we are paying it to the Americans but because of the fact that it represent a withdrawal from the use of our people and this nation of a vast sum in capital resources. He then went on and said:—

"I would prefer myself if we had more time to study the agreement. For my part, I have not studied it in full detail."

—and he went on, again, to repeat his warning:—

"For our own part, I think that before we ask for either a gift or a loan, with this agreement in front of us, we ought to ask ourselves how we are going to be able to repay the loan and to pay the interest, and, if it is a grant, whether the obligations which we enter into are of such a character that we can enter into them with the necessary degree of confidence. As I have said, I would rather if this matter could be left over for further consideration..."

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

But it was celebrated in the British Embassy in Paris.

Comment on this

A celebration at the British Embassy in Paris had nothing to do with it. Deputy MacBride was then Minister for External Affairs and he replied to this debate. In doing so, he took the attitude he has made so familiar in this House of the very superior person reproving the irresponsibles who happened to be opposed to his point of view. As reported at colunm 2072 of Volume 111 of the Official Report, Deputy MacBride, who was then the Minister for External Affairs, said:—

"I do not know whether or not to get cross with Deputy Lemass, but I do wish that in matters relating to external affairs, he would display a somewhat greater sense of responsibility."

If Deputy MacBride had sat in the Cabinet of this country during the period of the war years, when we were bringing this country safely through— instead of, as he was, trying to rock the boat—he might have found some justification for talking to Deputy Lemass in those terms.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Again, the Minister is availing of the absence of Deputy MacBride to make these remarks.

Comment on this

Who is responsible for his absence?

Comment on this

Why is he not here?

Comment on this

We have been hearing quite a lot from Deputy MacBride about good conduct and good behaviour in this House and about how we should all be models of department in this House. One thing which I think no honest man should try to do in an Assembly like this is to sell them a gold brick. Listen to the sort of bait which Deputy MacBride was holding out on July 1st, 1948, as reported at column 2067 of the Official Report:—

"Under this agreement this country will, in effect, over a period of four years, receive a sum ranging from £100,000,000 to £150,000,000."

Of course, we received nothing of the sort. What we did do was to sign three promissory notes under which we have borrowed, I think, a sum equivalent at current rates to £41,000,000 or £42,000,000.

Let me come to another aspect of this transaction—and the only reason I am dealing with it now is to refute the suggestions which have been made on Opposition platforms that the Fianna Fáil Party were in any way involved in or carried any responsibility for the negotiations which led up to this loan. So far from being precipitate in looking for it, so far from being anxious to accept a loan on any terms, the Fianna Fáil Party, through the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Aiken, who is the present Minister for External Affairs, raised the whole question in this House on the 7th July, 1948, as to whether, before any commitment or agreement was entered into or any obligation was accepted on the part of this State and our people, this House would have an opportunity of discussing the terms of the proposed arrangement. Deputy Aiken, as he was then, raised that question on the Adjournment. In doing so, he referred to a statement which I have quoted earlier but which I think I should quote again. It was the last paragraph of the official statement issued in relation to the negotiations which took place in London in June, 1948, and it reads as follows:—

"The Government of Ireland haveundertaken to the British Government—"

We have been hearing a lot about a Minister for Finance who is—it has been falsely alleged—subservient to the British Chancellor, but listen to this:—

"—to use their utmost endeavours to obtain the maximum amount of aid available under the E.R.P. with the object of ensuring as far as practicable that their recourse to the sterling area pool for hard currency will not involve any ultimate drain on that pool."

In a speech on that Adjournment debate, Deputy Aiken said:—

"The Minister for External Affairs, when winding up the debate on the recent American agreement, said:—

‘Under this agreement this country will, in effect, over a period of four years, receive a sum ranging from £100,000,000 to £150,000,000'."

Then Deputy Aiken went on to say:—

"I put a question to the Minister for Finance to-day asking him whether he would give the Dáil an opportunity of considering the terms and conditions as to repayment of any proposed foreign loan before the Government agrees to accept it."

Deputy McGilligan, the then Minister for Finance, said, as reported at column 238 of the Official Report:—

"I am prepared to acquaint Dáil Éireann with the terms and conditions applicable to the proposed loan and, if necessary, have a discussion on the matter."

He said, however, that if it were a question of clinching the loan at a particular time he thought he was entitled to clinch it and to get approval afterwards. He did clinch it at a particular time—at a time when the Dáil was not in session. He signed the first promissory note on 28th October, 1948, and the Dáil did not reassemble until, I think, the 17th November of that year. While he tabled the papers, he neverbrought the question of the loan forward for discussion.

We have heard again a great deal about the improvident way in which Fianna Fáil are alleged to have managed the country's finances. I want, in that connection, to advert to a statement which was made by Deputy Lemass, in July, 1948—a statement in which he said, among other things, that, according to the information which was available to him when he was a member of the Government in 1947-48, he thought we were going to get substantial aid from America by way of grant and not by way of loan. Of course, whatever the prospects were of getting a substantial amount by way of grant from America in 1947 or 1948, they were killed the moment that the statement appeared in the newspapers to the effect that the Coalition Government had given pledges to the British Government that they would use their utmost endeavours to obtain the maximum amount of aid available under the E.R.P. They had given hostages to fortune. They were in a cleft stick. What Government, knowing that the Irish Government had committed themselves to that—and the statement was published—would give the Irish Government a substantial amount by way of free grant for that purpose? It is on the level of the flat-footed diplomacy which led us into the mess about the Republic of Ireland Act, when the members of the Government had to go flying over to Great Britain to try and protect our people from the consequences of that ill-timed and ill-prepared announcement.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

What were the consequences?

Comment on this

You had Deputy McGilligan, Deputy MacBride and the Attorney-General all flying over to Chequers, and then flying over to Paris and back again, trying to fix up things that should have been a matter of agreement long before any announcement was made about their policy. Here again, as I have said, they gave hostages to fortune when they issued that statement. Of course the consequence of that blunder is that to-day we are saddled with thisexceedingly burdensome payment. Again, we have been told a great deal about the dire position in which this country is. I am going to leave Marshall Aid because I think I have fairly well disposed of the suggestion that the Fianna Fáil Party was in any way responsible for or had any hand, act or part in the negotiations which led up to the contracting of that loan. Before I do, however, I want to mention the fact—if I may revert to it for one moment—that under that agreement we are paying this year £1,136,000 which has to be converted into dollars. Whatever the rate of exchange will be, payment has to be made in dollars so that if there should be any depreciation in the £ the burden upon this country would be very much heavier. That is the position this year. I have pointed out what its effects are so far as the general economy of the country is concerned. I want also, however, to remind the House that in the year 1956 we shall be paying not only the interest on the loan but we will be called upon to begin to repay the principal and that however disadvantageous the present payment of merely the interest may be to our economy, and to our present circumstances, the repayment of the Marshall loan is going to be very much more disadvantageous still and is going to continue for a generation.

We have heard a great deal in the course of this debate about the depressed condition of this country and some people suggested that our agriculture and industrial output have been on the decline. A Cheann Comhairle, if there is going to be a hum of conversation from the benches opposite it will be useless for me to address the House. It has been suggested throughout the course of this debate that there had been a general decline in the productive activity of this community over the past year. The extraordinary thing about it is that for the first time since 1938 there has been an increase in the volume of agricultural production. It has increased, as I said in a letter which appeared in the paper, by 1.6 per cent. in volume and I think it is going to be still higher this year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputiesought to know that it is not proper to carry on a conversation in the benches.

Comment on this

The Minister's speech is so dreary that we cannot bear it.

Comment on this

There should be a little bit of respect shown to the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick is not compelled to sit in the House and he might relieve an overburdened Chair if he left it. This morning we heard a great deal from Deputy Declan Costello about transportable goods. The fact of the matter is that the volume index for the production of transportable goods was 4.4 per cent. higher for the March quarter, 1953——

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I want to call the Chair's attention to the fact that the two Deputies whom he corrected for shouting across the alleyway are at it again—Deputy Blowick and Deputy Collins.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I can only repeat that conversations of that kind are interruptions of the speaker in possession. Deputies should not conduct a conversation on the benches.

Comment on this
Oscar Traynor Minister for Defence (Mr. Traynor) Fianna Fáil

It is very bad manners.

Comment on this

Deputy Declan Costello this morning stated that the volume of industrial production had declined. I want to put it on record for the information of the House that so far from there being a decline there has been an increase of 4.4 per cent. in the March quarter of 1953 as compared with the March quarter of 1952. Not only that but the national income —and we have been hearing a great deal here about the shortage of purchasing power and so on—in real terms increased in the year 1952. The data to support that statement will be available I hope to members of the Oireachtas and to the general public within a few weeks. Farmers incomes went up by £10.6 million in 1952 and employees, incomes went up by£9,000,000. Exports rose by £20,000,000 in 1952 and are still rising. In the first six months of 1953 they were 5.8 per cent. higher than in the corresponding six months of 1952.

Comment on this

I want to call the Chair's attention again to the fact that the two Deputies are talking to each other.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputies will please restrain themselves. I can hear the conversion on the benches.

Comment on this

Is it not that the Minister for External Affairs is exasperated at the "bags" the Minister for Finance is making of his speech?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that last year the balance of payments deficit which had been £61.6 million for the year 1951 had been reduced to a tolerable level—one which we can control. At least it is of manageable dimensions and will enable us to proceed in an orderly and prudent way to repatriate such of the external assets as we can usefully use in this country.

An attempt was made—and I am going to recount some figures which the Minister for External Affairs gave to the House yesterday—to depict the people of this country as if they were haggard and starved for want of food. I will take the year 1950—I am not counting the year 1951 because we were in during the latter half of that year and the Opposition were in during the first part. Take creamery butter, about which we have heard so much. I heard people saying that they could not buy creamery butter in this country. I heard Deputy Roddy and a number of others say it. Deputy Blowick seems to have said that also. Perhaps, I was not listening to him with the attention he ought to have.

Comment on this

Tell us where to laugh.

Comment on this

The consumption of creamery butter per head per week in the year 1950 amounted to 8.63 ounces. In the year 1952 it amounted to 8.95 ounces.Clearly it had not gone down. It might not have increased very much but there was no decrease and there were fewer tourists here in 1952 than in 1950. Take the case of beef. The average consumption per week per head of beef in the year 1950 was 10.14 ounces and in the year 1952 it had increased to 10.74 ounces.

The average consumption per head per week of mutton in 1950 was 3.09 ounces and in 1952, 4.03 ounces. In 1950 the average consumption of fresh fish was 2.52 ounces and in 1952 it was 2.70 ounces.

Comment on this

Red herrings.

Comment on this

No. The general public did not consume these and Deputy Davin's consumption of red herrings was not taken account of in the average. In the year 1950 the consumption per head per week of sugar was 18.55 ounces and in 1952 it was 21.16 ounces. In the year 1950 the consumption of bread amounted to 3.49 lb. per head per week and in 1952 it was 3.60 lb per head per week. In the year 1950 the consumption of household flour amounted to 2.12 lb. per head per week, and in the year 1952 it amounted to 2.18 lb.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What about the first half of 1953?

Comment on this

Deputies may laugh and snigger at these figures.

Comment on this

It is the butter ration he is talking about.

Comment on this

What is the consumption of margarine?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We are anxious to hear something about the unemployed.

Comment on this

Perhaps you will talk about the £100,000,000 Deputy MacBride was to get from America or the £1,136,000 for which we have to tax the people this year in order to send it to the United States. Perhaps that is what the Deputy is thinking of. In any event, whether they gibe, snigger or interrupt, these are the plain facts of the situation and they do not bear out the exaggerated statementswhich Deputies have been making in the course of this debate.

Undoubtedly, there are people suffering some privation in this country. Many of the people who are on the unemployed register are suffering. As, however, someone else has pointed out, under the Social Welfare Act of 1952 they are getting three times more than they were getting under the social welfare legislation of the Coalition Government. It may not be enough. It would be very much better if the people concerned were employed and at work. Let us not forget that when the first demand on our economy and upon the sweat, toil and labour of our people, is a demand to meet the interest we owe to the United States, certainly some elements of the population are bound to suffer.

It is our duty as a Government, however, to try and make sure that the suffering thus arising, the hardship and the privation, are spread over the greatest possible number of people and over the population as a whole. The only way that can be done is in the manner laid down in the Budget. It is the only way by which those who are well off in any community can help those who are less well off and more hardly pressed. That is what we have tried to do particularly in our first Budget in 1952. In the 1953 Budget we have again made provision on a scale that was never made before for widows' and orphans' pensions, old age pensions, children's allowances, unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance.

I have shown you the extent to which the Government is asking the taxpayer to contribute to ameliorate the lot of those people who are unfortunately deprived of the opportunity of earning their livelihood.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

How are they going to get work?

Comment on this

The fact that they are unemployed is partly accidental and is partly due, as Deputy Cowan mentioned, to the fact that the building programme of the Dublin Corporation seemed to have run into slack water at a particular time. Private building—I know Deputy Collins may not be pleased to hear this nor will those Deputies who wish our people to think things are blacker and darker in this country than they are—is beginning to revive. There has been a greater volume of applications under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy Cowan explained the other night that the Dublin Corporation had a full programme in progress.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy got over 16 hours in which to speak.

Comment on this

I was saying that the number of applications under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act is increasing and that the amount of allocations under the Local Loans Fund and the Labourers' Acts is increasing, so that we may hope for a revival of private building in the near future. In any event, the main consideration is that, as the Taoiseach said last night, the worst of our task is over. We have succeeded in putting the finances of this country upon a sound basis and without sound public finances you cannot have a good or progressive Government. Now we are in a position to give the people that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Before the Minister sits down, will he tell us where the unemployed are going to get work?

Comment on this

Somebody got drink somewhere.

Comment on this
Division

Question put:—

Tá 64
·
Níl 57
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?