We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 50—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 1–170 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Major de Valera

On the last occasion I was dealing with some points raised by Deputy Larkin. On looking back I find that the difficulty, as I said on that occasion, is the difference in fundamental approach, and I prefer to deal with these on the basis of the policy which we have been operating, namely, to try to build our industry and our commerce in this country on a private enterprise basis as far as possible. Circumstanced as we are and starting late in the race, again quoting Deputy Larkin, there has been only one possible approach for us. It has been to stimulate private enterprise to supply the gaps on the industrialside of our economy as far as it is possible.

In the course of that stimulation it has been necessary to give certain assistance at State level. The necessity for that assistance arose in many respects from historical circumstances and from the fact of having to enter at a late stage upon the competition that was there. The assistance which is being given in fact stimulates, and did stimulate in the past, considerable activity and considerable investment here, and from two points of view, as I pointed out on the last occasion, the results have been beneficial. We have gone a certain distance, in fact, a long way, towards redressing the want of balance in our economy and making ourselves more self-reliant. We have, at the same time, provided a certain amount of employment, a certain amount of activity which is necessary for the well-being of the community.

The assistance which is given is the ground on which Deputy Larkin, for one, suggests that this private enterprise is not private enterprise, that the public has an interest in it. Of course the public has an interest. The community as a whole has an interest in the activities of any part, but that is not the point. The point of balance in Deputy Larkin's statement is that, very fairly, the public has an interest through the State and the Department in the development I have referred to. On the other hand, the public has reaped the benefit in the important economic sense I have already mentioned, but it also reaped a benefit financially, because from the activities of these industries the Minister for Finance has got a not inconsiderable return each year.

However, let me come back to the basis of the whole thing. What is the policy we are trying to operate here? Let us be clear about it. We are trying to operate as far as possible a private enterprise economy. I think that anybody who studies the matter is fairly convinced that for us it is the best overall approach. It is likely to be the most efficient approach. That is what we are trying to do and that is the outlook and the policy to-day. It hasbeen, as far as I can see, the continuous policy since this State came into being. It has been necessary to supplement purely private undertakings not only by such types of stimulation as tariffs and protection in particular which have been frequently referred to but by direct initiative on the part of the State in regard to certain projects.

It is possibly a necessity, arising out of the circumstances in which we were placed and from the size of our resources, because these projects, necessary as they were for the national economy, were not within the scope of purely private enterprise in the years in question. Certainly, it is questionable and arguable whether such projects under conditions of modern organisation, social and economic, can in future be initiated easily and maintained by purely private enterprise companies. So that we have to admit that there are certain aspects, in our particular case at any rate, where it is necessary for the State to take the active initiative and active interest in their development. Such concerns as the E.S.B., Bord na Móna and the Irish Sugar Company were all-important contributions but whereas these concerns are national concerns in one sense, national in their scope and national also in the sense that their finances basically have had to be built up by the State, nevertheless, these concerns have, as far as possible, been run very much on the lines of large public companies with considerable success.

It is the happy mean, so to speak, struck in the organisation of the E.S.B., the Irish Sugar Company and Bord na Móna, to take these three examples, that has enabled them to function as successfully as they have functioned heretofore.

I think we have found some kind of formula that is useful and helpful in our picture, but the concerns are not quite the same type of nationalised concerns which some people seem to have in mind when they talk about nationalisation. Before dealing with that, let me finish my remarks in regard to our economy as I see it. In regard to certain large undertakings, we will have to have State interventionand State support. That should, as far as possible, be confined—and I think it is the policy to confine it—to such large national enterprises as need it. In the operation of that nationalisation, if you like, or national control, every effort is made at decentralisation from the central Government, and every effort is made to run the concerns on business-like lines. Those which have been run in that way have been successful to-day.

After that, our aim should be to stimulate private enterprise and to have the private enterprise company or firm develop the rest of our economy. I think that was the policy. Anyhow, it is not without its advantages. In regard to the concerns I mentioned which have direct State intervention, these have been functioning very satisfactorily and can show a satisfactory record. Many of the private firms have been successful too. Perhaps, that is one of the causes why there is such considerable complaint about them from some quarters. It must not be forgotten that they are an essential part of the basis of the economy we are building. On the basis on which we are building the economy, they are serving the community in three different ways at least.

They are providing industries which have their own economic value themselves as commercial assets. They are providing employment and they are also providing for the interchange of money. Through their prosperity and activity there are many sections of the community benefiting indirectly. That is the basis upon which I want to approach the matters to which I referred the last day.

There is another approach—the socialistic approach. As I have said, it is very difficult to join issue with Deputy Larkin on this because his approach and mine are fundamentally different, but I think I could voice the conviction that to me socialism in the sense of the State undertaking direct intervention and partaking in every sphere of human activity is not, even from the economic point of view, likely to be efficient or beneficial in the long run.

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin did not say that.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am saying it about socialism. I am saying that socialism in the sense of indiscriminate nationalisation, apart from whatever other defects it may have, brings with it an inefficiency that changes the profit position to a loss position. We do not have to go very far to prove that proposition. One experiment at home in nationalisation has not been a happy one with all the problems that are involved. I refer to C.I.E. From the economic point of view, if that concern were less the subject of nationalisation and less the subject of direct intervention at that level, it might, from the efficiency and the profit point of view, be in a better position. I know there are other and very important problems. I am not suggesting that that might not be one of the concerns which should be taken in on the basis on which the E.S.B. and Bord na Móna were taken in. The fact is that the position has not been a happy one.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The next thing is that the experiments in nationalisation in England have not been happy whether it was the Coal Board, transport or anything else that was concerned. On looking at the facts, one is forced to the conclusion, I submit, that if you are going in for nationalisation you have either got to face up to this inefficiency which will bring you loss if you are going to have socialism or else you have to take definite corrective measures within your socialist scheme to make the scheme efficient and work. If you do that what is the answer? Look beyond the Iron Curtain and ask what is the reason for a lot of this regimentation? Why are workers directed here and somebody else coerced there? Why are the disciplinary courts and all the rest of it there? Because the system will not work without these sanctions. I do not want to go any further into the argument than that.

I submit to Deputies that the reason for all the tyranny, or at least one of the reasons for the tyranny associated with the socialistic type of economy that has been forced to be an economic success, has been due to the fact that, without such forcing, itjust could not work. As I see it, there is nobody in this country going to suggest that your socialism is going to be pressed to the point where you are going to regiment everybody, and mind you, that is the only point at which it can be made work. Well, if your socialism is not going to be pushed to that point, and as I say will not work unless it is pushed to that point, is it not better to sit back and take a sober view of the situation—to work the system that we are working here, one that will give a return, and the one that I have tried to outline?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy claiming that the present day system here is working satisfactorily?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am claiming that the system of private enterprise here, as far as industrial and commercial activities are concerned, is working reasonably well, and I shall try to expand that point for the benefit of the Deputy in a moment. What I am trying to say is that the Minister's policy in regard to the fostering of industry in this country is probably the best one from a rational point of view for us. That is all I am trying to say. I am also trying to say that nebulous socialism, or indiscriminate nationalisation, does not work: that to make it work you would have to bring in so many sanctions, so many controls and so much dictation that it could only be made work under a tyranny such as is being exercised in some kind of a way in other parts of the world, and nobody in this country wants that.

These remarks are prompted by the fact that I realise, as regards matters that I propose to go into in a moment, there is a fundamentally different approach, or, perhaps, I should say a difference rather between my approach and Deputy Larkin's approach to the problems that we are dealing with. All this was stimulated by the fact that I heard here in the House, and have read since, the remarks made by Deputy Larkin that capital bonuses and dividends were being paid to industry. Let me hasten to add, in case I should forget it, that I quite concede to Deputy Larkin, or to anybody else, that there may be exceptional cases here and there in any freesystem which could be legitimately criticised, and which might invite criticism, though, quite frankly, the cases proposed by Deputy Larkin are, on the face of them, quite answerable. They do not come into that category, though there may be individual cases, or particular matters, calling for correction. Well, let them be corrected, but do not tear down the whole system unless you have something better to offer, and the only thing I can see that is being offered is nebulous socialism. My answer to that is that if you start on that you will be coerced either to drop it with consequential chaos and be faced with a reorganisation, or you will be forced to come to the logical conclusion of having a tyrannical socialism which none of us wants. I am sure that Deputy Hickey, Deputy O'Leary and Deputy Everett want as little of that as I do.

Now, let me come to what Deputy Larkin had to say the last day. I answered him firstly by asking what is wrong with a firm which issues bonus shares? If a firm had a certain real value in 1938 or 1939, and is maintaining its position to-day in real terms— whatever these may be you can measure them in a variety of ways—let us say that in real terms the firm is as strong to-day and is as valuable to-day as it was then. I am asking no more than that at the moment.

Then, I have already pointed out that its monetary value will have at least doubled because of the change in the values of money. In case Deputies do not quite follow me, let me take the simple question of a machine. I know of cases where you could have bought a machine for £2,000 in 1938. You would pay £10,000 for that machine to-day. The relative proportions will vary in the case of different types of machines, but there is one example. The ratio of difference may be less in some cases and considerably more in others. The machine itself has the same real value, and when you try to express that value in money you find that it is five times as valuable to-day as it was then—I mean, of course, in figures but its real value is the same. On that basis I have tried to point out that I can see nothing fundamentally wrong in the issue of bonus shares.

On the question of dividends, Deputy Larkin said it might not be too bad if you only paid the same dividends— that is if you had doubled your capital. I think that would be inequitable because, surely, if the return on the capital at that time was, say, £10 on £100, why should the person who is getting that return to-day be limited only to £10? Would not the proper figure be £20, and that is just the effect of issuing bonus shares? I would grant to Deputy Larkin, and would not argue with him at all on that, if wages had been pegged down. If they had been, then by all means peg down the rate of distributed profit, but wages have gone up. There is there no lack of proportion but, in fact, to do what Deputy Larkin has suggested would be to introduce a disproportion, and that could hardly be justified.

These were some of the answers which I gave to Deputy Larkin on the last occasion, but there is something wider than that. There is this talk generally of profits being made by industrial concerns. Now, there are two aspects of industrial profits. Take your industrial profits in the gross. What are they required for? A firm has to live, whether it is a trading concern or a manufacturing concern. It has to make, during the year, enough to pay its overheads, to pay its wages and to pay all current outgoings, and, if it can do that at line ball, it just merely gets along, but in the meantime it is not getting along: it is slipping back. Its machinery is wearing out and there is no possibility of expansion. But its machinery will be wearing out and so that firm in order that it may live within the system has nothing to fall back on but its profit.

What are its profits required for? In the first instance for replacement. Replacements are necessary from time to time. The word "depreciation" looms largely in some of our discussions. From time to time its buildings will have to be repaired or it will have to replace its machinery. The resources or the money necessary to make these replacements, do not fall out of the skies. Its original capital, presumably, has been used up inestablishing the firm. Therefore, the only way in which the firm can maintain its position, let alone expand, short of calling for additional capital either from the public or from whatever other source it can command, is by making profits. Therefore, a certain amount of profit is needed for that. After that what about the question of expansion. Everybody knows that most industrial firms are depending on the profits they make for future expansion. Sometimes we forget that fact because of the transactions, borrowings, and so on, that can get in between. However, ultimately, if the firm is going to expand it needs money and that money must be got by profits.

Comment on this

Out of the workers.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In this particular case I am dealing with, the workers' wages have gone up. I would grant the Deputy every point if the workers' wages had not increased. However, I will deal with that later; at the moment I am dealing with overall profits and where they go. The size of the profits made by industrial firms was commented on by Deputy Larkin in his speech. Deputy Larkin instanced one particular case where the profits made were very much greater than the actual capital put in. That should be followed up. Where did those profits go? If they were distributed profits, if they went into people's pockets there might be something in Deputy Larkin's argument, but one will find by and large—I admit there may be exceptions here and there although I am not aware of any— profits of that nature go back into the concern, go back for replacement and expansion. Are we going to quarrel about expansion? If a firm makes profits and by ploughing them back into the business, is able to expand, surely that is a desirable thing rather than the reverse, because the community is getting the benefit. One will find if one examines the profits, particularly of manufacturing firms or firms that are producing things, that the bulk of the profits have probablygone back into machinery and for expansion.

Comment on this

A good lot went into the National Loan.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Supposing profits did go into the National Loan; is that money not going back into expansion at home in a more general form? Supposing a firm is going to use these profits on new machinery. They may have plant ordered in advance. It may take three or four years to get delivery and the money may be available. Surely the sensible thing to do is to invest it in that period and use it as the payments become due. This type of transaction is absolutely necessary in business because everything cannot be timed to the split second. If money is invested in the National Loan is it not invested in national development? I am rather shocked the Deputy should make a point of that. I should imagine that investing in the National Loan was going very near nationalisation. The bulk of these profits is going back into trade and commerce.

The next point is that a firm must keep a certain reserve. Again the Deputy will say, why not distribute it? The point is that the firm must keep up its outgoings, the wages of the workers and employees generally. Outgoings of that nature are certain and must be paid. The profits made by a firm are anything but certain; in fact, there are very few concerns which do not at some time or another experience a loss. They must have reserves unless they are to break up. Therefore, within prudent limits, a firm will put a certain amount by to secure its future, because not only is it necessary for their own benefit but it is also a necessary security for the workers employed in that business. If the directors of a firm are imprudent, take chances carrying flimsy reserves, the day may come when they cannot weather the storm and the workers are the people who will suffer by being thrown out of their jobs when the collapse comes.

We now come to the vexed question of distributed profits. I have gone to the trouble of checking the list of present-day returns of a number of concerns, quite apart from what onecan read in the daily papers, from various industrial securities here. I think I am fairly safe in saying—and I have not actually worked out an average—that it is below 10 per cent. Many of them are much lower.

Comment on this

Is that on watered capital? If it is, on how much water?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I do not follow the Deputy. If Deputy Dillon is making the point about capital, I thought I had already stated my view on that. In so far as there have been issues on bonus shares, is that what the Deputy has in mind?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is delightful to have Deputy Dillon and Deputy Larkin in such close agreement on this matter. In regard to dividends on that capital, as I pointed out already, it only keeps up the value in proportion with a change in money values. But there is another point involved in all this distribution of dividends. The average Irish investor, I think, is a small investor. As far as I can see from the starting capitals, the sums involved were quite small. I think that was the result of certain investigations, and the ordinary share list of a number of companies will show you that apart from exceptional cases the holdings are small. In some cases, I know, there may be big family firms which would be different. In either event, it is equitable that, as long as you have got the system, these dividends should keep pace with the rise in wages and with the rise which is alleged to be related to the cost of living.

If one examines the index numbers, one will find that the cost-of-living index has increased very much more than that of an index representing the increase in profits, that actually as output is increasing net profit is diminishing in proportion.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy excuse me for intervening, but I would like to see proof of that proposition?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Which proposition?

Comment on this

That the rate of increase in commercial profits has fallen steeply behind that of the increase in the cost of living.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think I can substantiate that to the Deputy. I can give him the reference afterwards. For the same reason as Deputy Larkin, I do not wish to deal with individual firms.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I would be very pleased to give Deputy Dillon the figures. I have a list here in regard to profits over the years. From 1938 to 1948 an index representing profits would have increased from 100 to 155, while in the same period the cost of living would have increased from 100 to 183. I would be very pleased to give Deputy Dillon the information at my disposal afterwards.

Comment on this

I would be much obliged.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Over all, the profits have not been excessive in the sense in which they are represented as being. Secondly, the bulk of those profits is going back into the business in one form or another and into trade and commerce and that is of benefit to the community. That leaves me with the question of distributed profits to deal with. The return on those investments is not excessive by ordinary standards and certainly not excessive by English standards. One must consider such cases as those of many widows, perhaps a widow of someone fairly well off, but nevertheless a widow deprived of means, who may be bringing up a family and who is dependent on some of these investments to some extent.

Comment on this

Hardy old widows most of them are.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not aware of how far nowadays institutions, say big religious institutions, invest their money in that way, but about 30 or 40 years ago investments in railways, and so on, were very common. In so far as that type of investor is concerned, Ithink it is equitable that the adjustment to decreasing money values should be made in regard to the return. What about the persons who are only a percentage of the people in receipt of dividends and who, apparently, are the target for the Labour Party's artillery? These are certain people in the commercial class; what about the dividends they get? There are two answers to that. One is that, surely, under the present system—and this is where we fundamentally disagree—if a man has capital and invests it with risk—and these people, remember, very frequently lose as well as gain in their investments—he is entitled to some return for the risk he is taking, because the community is getting benefit. It is getting benefit. If I or anyone else should have a sum of money to invest, or if a group of people have a sum of money to invest between them and establish an industry, make no mistake about it, they are risking their money. They could much more safely put it in the National Loan and get a return and no one would be talking about it. They are taking a definite risk by investing the money in that industry.

Comment on this

What about money invested in foreign countries?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If the gamble comes off the community still gets the benefit, the workers who are employed and the community as a whole, if that is the type of industry we want.

Comment on this

Where is the Hospitals Trust money invested? In foreign countries?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Hospitals Trust does not come into it.

Comment on this

It is invested outside. It should be working here.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The people I am talking about are the very people who have invested money here and who have been attacked because of the profit position. The first answer that has to be made is surely that they are entitled to a return. On the percentages as I see them in the ordinary way, they are somewhat less than 10per cent, on the average, which seems a fair enough return. There is another answer, and I wonder if members of the Dáil appreciate it. Do Deputies realise that when a company makes profits the Revenue Commissioners come in and take their share as tax? It is common knowledge to those people who know—and Deputy Larkin and others may smile—that in some cases, because of the amount that has to be paid in tax by the company on its profits, expansion is sometimes inhibited. That is all before there is any question of distribution. On the profits made by the company, the allowances for depreciation are insufficient, there is no provision to enable them to escape or to use those funds for capital expansion or development without paying the tax. The result is that certain concerns in this country have been inhibited in their expansion and development because of the claim of the Revenue Commissioners, which is collected. Let us recollect that. That is the first point.

If Deputy Larkin says, as he did say, that the community has an interest, that the community is giving protection and support through purchasing, we have all an interest. Let us also see, on the other side of the picture, that the community is getting its reward in the general sense and achieving selfreliance, as I said before; but in the more narrow sense, in proportion to the profits the company is making, the revenue, the Exchequer, is benefiting— in certain cases, at least, I would suggest, to an extent which is inhibiting the development of certain firms, that is to say, preventing the purchase of machinery and the expansion of activity that would otherwise take place. That is the first rake-off for the State. The next rake-off comes afterwards. Remember that when you talk about these dividends, and so on, they are in the hands of the private investor or the private individual, who is subject to tax. Everybody knows that as the income-tax code is now, once it goes to a certain level there is a great deal taken off.

Comment on this

Are we talking about corporation profits tax or income-tax?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am talking of general taxes, not segregating them. The Deputy may make the point that they could be the subject of additional taxation. I have more or less indicated an answer to that, whatever way the tax is taken from the company.

There is the position in regard to these companies. The reason that I have intervened, perhaps a little vigorously in this debate, is because of a desire to complete the picture painted by Deputy Larkin. As I said, if someone goes too much to the left and virtue is in the middle, the person who is trying to pull things back again into the middle of the road can scarcely avoid being depicted as going a little far to the right. I freely concede all that. But I still say, whatever the argument in the situation, that we have here a system: the alternative to that system does not appeal to me. The reason why Deputy Larkin and I cannot agree is because I believe that a nebulous, uncontrolled socialism and an indiscriminate nationalisation just cannot be made to work. The one grave defect about socialism is that, in order to make it work, one must regiment, control, coerce and, in fact, there must be tyranny; I refrain from using one particular word because I do not want to use it, but there are examples of it in the world to-day. None of us want to see those examples followed here.

I do not want to see that alternative. By and large the system we are trying to operate is the best one for us. Why should any Deputy deem it necessary to intervene at length, as I have done, on this particular subject? I will tell the House why. In order to make the present system work one must encourage our people to invest in Irish industry and Irish activity. The healthier the economic condition of the community, the more savings there will be. We want to see those savings flowing into Irish industry and Irish activity. To make an indiscriminate attack on the present system, without allowing for the factors I have mentioned, will certainly not encourage such industry or activity. People talk about external assets. People invite our own nationals to invest at home, and so forth, but in a small communitylike this, where the units of industry are relatively small, the kind of attack that has been made here will not help investment.

Comment on this

What must we do? Whisper it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No. If it is an attack, well and good. But it should be made clear that it is an attack. Deputy Larkin has used the word "whisper." What I am objecting to is the fact that there has been a good deal of innuendo. What I am trying to do is to bring things out into the open.

Comment on this

Just because a man talks about certain things that should not be interpreted as an attack. He is speaking of realities.

Comment on this

We are getting very mealy-mouthed in our old age.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If there are abuses calling for correction, by all means let us be told about them; but let us have the whole picture and a proper balance struck between the various factors involved. Deputy Larkin makes one case about profits. I could quite legitimately and justifiably plead with the Minister for Finance to give special concessions to concerns for the application of profits free of tax for the purchase of machinery.

Comment on this

There is a commission appointed to do that now.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Exactly. There are many sides to the problems involved. Let us try to see as many of them as we can. We want to encourage and foster the growth of Irish industry, of commercial activity. We want to make ourselves as self-reliant as we can. For hundreds of years, and particularly in the last century, this country was deprived of the opportunity of legitimate commercial expansion. Some hundreds of years ago it had a thriving wool trade. There were other possible activities nascent here, but in the 19th century we were driven to economic slavery by a foreign power and deprived of the expansion that would have come naturally had we not been so inhibited.Since we have been free in this part of the country at any rate to develop our own economy we have all paid lipservice—some have made a positive contribution—to the importance of trying to make the country more self-reliant, more productive, better organised and even freer. One of the ways in which that goal has been achieved is through the development of the industries that have been the subject of attack here within the last week.

Comment on this

Industries run by foreigners.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is another day's work. I do not know whether Deputy O'Leary does or does not want to help the industries that are flourishing here at the moment.

Comment on this

Irish industries, certainly.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am talking about Irish industries.

Comment on this

Not those run by foreigners and Jews.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am talking about Irish industries which are producing Irish goods for Irish people. With the help of Providence, I hope they will be able to go ahead and produce for an even wider market. These industries are employing our own people at home. These are the industries with which we are concerned here and I feel that the incomplete statements that have been made and the innuendoes that have been thrown out will be damaging in their effect. To say the least of it, they will certainly not be encouraging. I think those innuendoes should cease and the complete picture should be painted in all fairness.

I have undertaken to give Deputy Dillon some information. I shall gladly do so later on. I think it will be found that I have not misstated the case or the facts as I know them. If there are abuses to be corrected, by all means let us correct them. If there are better ways of doing things, let us have them. But let us be very careful about the one-sided statements; for, whereasthey may appeal in certain quarters, they may in the long run do such damage as to render the appeal worthless.

Comment on this

There is only one industry in this country and that is agriculture.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is the basic industry.

Comment on this

Let us clarify at once one issue to which Deputy de Valera has applied a long and thoughtful speech. He spoke about a complaint that he heard made, as it seemed to him without proper justification, of high profits in Irish industry. I want to make my position clear on that issue. If an industry is set up here, designed to meet competition from all quarters and if, in fact, it is giving the community better goods at a lower price, paying fair wages and providing decent conditions of employment, then in my judgment the more profits it makes the better company it is. Without limit. If it can make 100 per cent., 200 per cent. or 500 per cent. profit I think it should be highly commended, valued and encouraged as an important national asset, over and above the profits derived by its proprietors from its operations. But when I see a gang of chancers setting up in this country with protestations that they are motivated by nothing but the service of the public and who then manage to get their claws on to some commodity without which the poorest sections of our community cannot survive and post off to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to get a 90 per cent. tariff and a quota on top of that, and when I see the price of the commodity produced doubled and trebled and some of the poorest sections of our community told to pay the price or do without the commodity, and when I see that company issuing a 100 per cent. capital bonus and increasing its dividend, I thank God that I have not yet lost my capacity for sæva indignation.When I hear these crawling hypocrites holding themselves up as public benefactors when they are infact parasites sucking the blood of their own neighbour, trafficking in poverty, I revolt that such things are possible with the connivance and approbation of an Irish Government. I think it is particularly deplorable because the conduct of such parasites tarnishes and disgraces the reputation of honest industrialists in this country who are trying to give good value for the community's money, to pay fair wages and to reserve for themselves no more than a fair margin of profit.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I misunderstood the Deputy. I thought he was blanketing.

Comment on this

I do not charge Deputy de Valera with making that misrepresentation. It is a common Fianna Fáil falsehood to say that I have denounced all Irish industry. I never have. I and those belonging to me were concerned to promote Irish industry before Fianna Fáil was ever heard of, but we never tolerated and we never dreamt we would see a day when an Irish Government would hatch out in Oireachtas Éireann a brood of parasites to rob our own people.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy will pardon me but, I take it, the Deputy's exception covers the bulk of Irish industry?

Comment on this

It covers a large section of it but, I am sorry to say, that the Fianna Fáil breed of industrialist appears to me to be growing as parasites grow. Honest men and their wives have one child at a time. Parasites have frequently 1,000. I want to see industry which serves our people, which produces good things, sells them at a fair price, pays good wages and provides decent conditions, thrive and prosper in this country, and I salute people who promote such industry in Ireland, but I recoil with horror from the kind of industry of which the Minister for Industry and Commerce has begun to talk recently in public, the kind of industry for which the Trade Restrictions Act has been passed, the kind of industry for the control of which the Minister for Industry and Commerce thought upthe Industrial Efficiency Bill, the kind of industry the Minister for Industry and Commerce had in mind when he spoke to those who are promoting the Institute of Business Management and said that a great many industries in this country have enjoyed tariff and quota protection too long without showing the slightest sign of measuring up to the undertakings they gave when they first sought that protection.

What shall we say of an industry which must be supplied by the farmers of this country with its raw material at a lower price than they pay the Abyssinians for it? What shall we say of an industry that purchases raw materials from Abyssinia at 1/8 a lb. and pays the Irish farmer 4d. a lb. for the same or better raw material, but can issue to its own shareholders 100 per cent. share bonus, maintain its dividend and increase it in subsequent years and, when finally asked to pay the world price for the raw material supplied to it by the farmers of Ireland, sticks its heels in the ground and says: "We will not. We will shut down before we pay it," and who find the Minister for Industry and Commerce powerful enough in Kildare Street to tell the Minister for Agriculture to lie down and take it and like it? How shall we deplore the day when so mean a figure is in Merrion Street that he lies down, takes it and licks the boot that kicks him?

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

The first thing I did was to increase the price paid for hides—to raise the price that you had given.

Comment on this

I have got the prices here and, since I have stirred the Minister——

Comment on this

Why did you agree to lower prices?

Comment on this

Now that I have stirred the Minister from his pensive silence——

Comment on this

I am just giving the facts. You agreed to a lower price. Tom Walsh agreed to a higher price, with my consent.

Comment on this

I will a tale unfold that will surprise this House.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Are we still on the Estimate for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

Oh, yes. When the inter-Party Government was in office, agriculture was deemed to have an interest in hides. Since Fianna Fáil came into office, they are told that cattle hides, á laFianna Fáil, are none of the Minister for Agriculture's concern and he is bidden to take his snout out of them and he takes it out with a bandage round the end of it.

Comment on this

We got a higher price, all the same, than you agreed to.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he came into office, discovered that the price fixed for hides, flayed off cattle designed for export, was approximately 2/6 a lb., which was then the world price for hides. When he came back into office, he said he proposed to fix a new rate, beginning at 4d. per lb. for the lowest grade; 6d. per lb. for the second lowest and 1/- per lb. for the top grade.

Comment on this

And what was it when you left office?

Comment on this

Two-and-sixpence per lb. for every hide flayed off a beast designed for export.

Comment on this

But I abolished control of export.

Comment on this

I am talking about prices paid in this country by the grade.

Comment on this

I am talking about the prices of hides——

Comment on this

The Minister says he abolished export control altogether— will he repeat that?

Comment on this

What I say is that any person preparing carcase meat for export can export the hide as well.

Comment on this

That is another cup of tea. But he has not abolished export control and he has not abolished theimport control on leather. I will come to that in a moment.

The price of hides is to-day worth about 1/8 per lb. for top grade on the world market. The Irish farmers' hides must be sold in Ireland for a top price of 1/-, leaving a differential of 8d. between the two. There is an average of 60 lb. in a hide and eight times 60 is 480 pence, or £2. On every hide flayed off a beast consumed in Ireland there is a levy of £2 per beast.

Comment on this

What was the top price when you were Minister for Agriculture?

Comment on this

2/6 per lb.

Comment on this

Paid by the Irish tanners?

Comment on this

2/6 per lb. was paid for every hide——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy talk about the same thing?

Comment on this

For every hide flayed off an Irish beast for export. I do not deny that when I was in office a middle course had to be pursued in those days. Kildare and Merrion Streets were about on a level, fifty-fifty. My complaint now is that it is 99.9 per cent. Kildare Street and .1 per cent. Upper Merrion Street. I do not say I got all my own way when I was Minister for Agriculture but I never let more than half the bone go with the dog.

Comment on this

Did Irish tanners ever pay 2/6 a lb. for hides in the whole of history?

Comment on this

Somebody paid it.

Comment on this

It was not paid.

Comment on this

The Minister's complaint was that the Minister's darlings were so impoverished in paying what we wanted to make them pay that he had to set up a system of levies to pay off their debts. But who paid off the debts? Was it the tanners who are issuing a higher percentage share bonus? It was not. The levy fell on the butcher and the man who sold the beast.

Comment on this

What is the levy for? To pay this 2/6 a lb. which you said you fixed and which nobody paid.

Comment on this

When I was there, the boys that issued the share bonus paid up accordingly.

Comment on this

Whom did they pay?

Comment on this

It was paid, and they came clamouring to Kildare Street when I left office to say: "The Government that is gone out of office put us into debt to pay the farmers for their hides——

Comment on this

Utter nonsense.

Comment on this

——the Minister for Agriculture made us go into debt to pay for the hides." Under the new dispensation the Minister for Industry and Commerce said: "Well, if they made you go into debt to pay for the hides, we will make them go into debt to pay you back."

Comment on this

What was the maximum price paid for a hide? 8d?

Comment on this

I want to say that there is no use saying that agriculture is the fundamental industry of this country and paying lip service to agriculture if the business of the industry upon which we all depend has to be done in silence behind the Ministry for Industry and Commerce who kicks the Minister for Agriculture all around the lot. Wherever the interests of farmers clash with the disinterested industrialists flourishing in this country you have a tariff of 90 per cent. and a quota prohibiting imports also.

But the quota does not prohibit imports entirely in the leather industry. Leather may be imported under quota and there is a body to advise the Minister for Industry and Commerce as to who shall get a licence to import under that quota. When that arrangement was set up, behold a miracle! The body was there and if any boot manufacturer in this country wanted to import leather, his application for that licence was referred to the advisory body for determination as to whether a suitable grade of leather was available in this country. If thatbody said there was not a suitable grade, the importer would get his licence to import and he might bring it in. But one of the members of that body was himself an agent for the sale of leather. You were not very long in that trade when you came to know that if you wanted a licence to import leather it would not sour that gentleman to know that he was to get his 5 per cent. commission on anything you brought in. But, of course, if you bought it from somebody for whom he was not an agent, then his eye flashed fire and he was all vigilance to protect Irish industry and he was anxious to say: "No, if they want suede leather to make shoes, let them do with kip or split. Cock them up with suede leather, is it!"

But if you did take the prudent precaution to let it be known that you had a very high opinion indeed of the suede leather produced by a particular American firm and that all your inclinations would be to buy that firm's suede leather if you got the chance, tears of sympathy suffused his eye. He was apprehensive lest hardworking Irish bootmakers would be thrown out of employment or put on short time, and he urged the Minister for Industry and Commerce to come to the rescue and issue the requisite licence. If the importer double-crossed him, well, he was not a crotchey man nor was he a reckless man. He just said nothing but he made a mental note and the next time that importer went to look for a licence to import leather he did with kip.

Do Deputies consider I am unreasonable if my nose wrinkles and I reach for a clothes pin to protect it whenever I have to smell transactions of that kind?

Why did the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself sponsor in this House a Restrictive Trade Practices Bill? Did he believe that there were not any restrictive trade practices? Why did the Minister for Industry and Commerce, with his intimate knowledge of the whole business, introduce into this House the Industrial Efficiency Bill under which he sought powers unknown in a democracy prior to the introduction of that Bill tocontrol industry in which he said the scandals were so great?

Bear this in mind. My animadversions on these matters relate to industries which, sheltering behind quotas and 90 per cent. tariffs, plunder their neighbours.

Now, I will say something that may be unpleasing to the Labour Party. Side by side with these outrageous practices to which I refer, there are scandalous restrictive practices by certain of the trade unions and of which the trade union leaders well know—cases where industries install machinery to reduce the cost of production and discover they are face to face with trade union regulations which require them to maintain a staff standing idle if that staff is to work overtime; and during the overtime period not one staff shall operate the machinery but two staffs must be maintained, one to stand idle and the other to work the machines, but both get paid.

Comment on this

In what industry?

Comment on this

In the bakery industry. I am asking the Deputy to attack the restrictive practice that exists in certain parts of the bakery trade which involves the employment of double staff to operated certain types of machinery if that machinery works more than one shift in 24 hours. The truth is never sweet. I am just as bitterly opposed to restrictive practices designed to raise the cost of production to the detriment of the consumer on the part of the trade unions as on the part of the tariff racketeers. One is as bad as the other. I have the greatest admiration for trade unions whose aim is to give a fair day's work for a fair day's pay, and I have given ample proof of that. As Deputy Larkin knows, on occasion I have gone to him where persons were not properly organised and asked him to organise them, because I wanted to be able to proceed on the basis that those men negotiating for conditions were in a position of exactly equal strength and authority with myself, so that fair conditions should be attained. I admire the honest trade union seeking fair conditions and wages for its members just as much as I admire andhonour the industrial entrepreneurwho seeks to give better value with better conditions, lower prices and better profits for himself; but I detest and repudiate the restrictive practices operated by the trade unions at the cost of the consumer, just as I condemn and despise the tariff racketeer who, under the protection of a 90 per cent. tariff, tries to plunder the public.

Deputies on the Labour Benches have good reason to know that I have been on many occasions a good friend to the trade union movement, but I am never afraid of trade unions nor of employers' combinations. Both of you are powerful vested interests. The truth is the truth and will ultimately prevail.

Comment on this

I think you ought to read Deputy O'Gorman's speech——

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath will never face the trade unions nor the employers in Cork.

Comment on this

You ought to get a bit of unity in your own Party.

Comment on this

Go fish. The poor man will be turning somersaults.

I was led into that little digression by the remarks of Deputy de Valera, who I do not think differentiated sufficiently between the honest enterprising industrialist whom we all admire and respect and the tariff racketeer who is a public enemy. Fianna Fáil say that they agree that he is a public enemy and that they mean to do something about it, but they never do. I would be glad if some evidence of their intention to do something about the evils which they passed so many Acts of Parliament to combat were forthcoming. Now I want to compare the Minister for Industry and Commerce in 1953 with the Minister in 1951. I would ask Deputies for a moment to give me the benefit of their attention and to listen to this, because I think it is good. I refer the House to Volume 127 of the Official Reports of Dáil Éireann, columns 951 and 952. We were debating the Supplies and Services Bill, 1951, and the debate revolved largely around a White Paper whichhad been issued by the Government entitled "Trends of External Trade and Payments, 1951," presented to the Oireachtas by the Minister for Finance in October, 1951. I was explaining at column 951 that the imbalance of payments in the year 1951 was largely accounted for by the fact that at the instance of the Fianna Fáil Party the inter-Party Government had agreed to stockpile against the danger of the outbreak of a world war. Nobody was more loud-mouthed or eloquent about the perils of impending war than Deputy Lemass, as he then was in 1949, and Deputy Vivion de Valera, who used to make our blood chill and our flesh creep with the prospect of the urgent immediacy of the danger of war. I was explaining in 1951 that the imbalance of payments was not correctly described as a spending spree on consumer goods created by inflation precipitated by the folly and profligacy of the inter-Party Government but was due to a studied policy of stockpiling. I said in column 951.—

"We brought in tobacco, we stockpiled and we distributed continously great quantities of tobacco. Is there any more deflationary procedure than to make widely available an unnecessary comestible carrying a heavy degree of tax?"

At this point Deputy Lemass observed: "There was no stockpiling."

Comment on this

There was, mousetraps.

Comment on this

I am coming to the mousetraps, and the housing timber that was shipped up from Dublin to Belfast and the substitute timber brought in from Russia to replace it. I will come to that in my own good time. I went on, as reported in column 952, to say: "Although we have in this country a greater stock of leaf tobacco in bond than I believe ever before." Deputy Lemass interrupted me and said: "We have about a year's less stock than is normal.""Oh, the subtle creature!" I replied, and Deputy Lemass said: "Less stock than we had during the war." I continued: "The subtle creature knows fully that the people listening to himdo not know that consumption is almost double pre-war consumption and he compares the stock now with the pre-war stock." Deputy Lemass remarked: "Do not call it stockpiling. The stock is going down."

Deputy Lemass in column 955, when I was dealing with imports of building timber, said: "Mousetraps was one commodity which was stockpiled." Deputy Lemass was subsequently asked what were the trade statistics relating to mousetraps and he said that there were none, but during the debate he thought it was a good joke to make at the moment.

Comment on this

Special import licences were given for mousetraps.

Comment on this

Now wait a minute. I was able in column 958 to say: "Did you hear Deputy Briscoe to-day marvelling that we did not, when we were going to spend money abroad, buy timber suitable for housing? Has he not woken up to the fact yet that the Minister for Finance had been in hysterics all over the country because we brought in too much timber?" Deputy Lemass remarked: "You did not buy any at all," and I replied: "The items are listed in paragraph (5) in the White Paper." Deputy Lemass said: "There was no stockpiling."

Comment on this

Of timber, owing to the fact that you abolised the organisation to stockpile timber.

Comment on this

There was no stockpiling of timber, yet every Deputy in this House saw the timber placed on flat rail cars, rolling out of Amiens Street in wagon loads to Belfast. Fianna Fáil had stopped the housing for which that timber was purchased and so the owners who had brought it in in the belief that the inter-Party programme for housing was to be continued had to beg for export permits from the Minister, which he gave them, to export it to Belfast. And we saw pictures of that timber rolling in the flat cars to Belfast; but that is not all. I would not have drawn the attention of the House to that if I had not been struck by the moving eloquence of theMinister for Industry and Commerce when he got up last week and addressed Dáil Éireann as he did, reported in column 790 of Volume 142, No. 6, when he said:—

"I moved the appropriate resolutions yesterday and gave some information concerning the changes in the amounts required under the various sub-heads of the Votes. Then I proceeded to say that there had been a general improvement in the conditions as compared with last year, that the temporary trade recession which was experienced internationally in 1952 because of the liquidation of stocks which had been accumulated on the outbreak of the Korean war had ended, and our records show that industrial production here is moving up again to new records."

Has he yet made up his mind whether or not there was stockpiling in Ireland? I am asking that question not because I think people in the country attach much importance to the answer. By experience, we now know that the Minister for Industry and Commerce says whatever suits him. I am trying to carry light and illumination to some of the hardy old roots of the Fianna Fáil Party and to some of the blushing bluebells who have recently sought the comfort of integrity in the ranks where they will find themselves side by side with the gentle, gracious and courteous Deputy Pat McGrath.

Comment on this

Funny man, eh?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the Estimate which is before the House.

Comment on this

What has nothing to do with the Estimate? Is it my desire to illuminate the bluebells that joined Deputy Pat McGrath? I suppose I have not much chance of success but surely this is the occasion and the arena in which I ought to make the effort.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If it arises from the Estimate before the House, yes; if it does not, no.

Comment on this

I think it does. The Minister for Industry and Commerce,whom they have now joined, is a chancer who will say anything that suits him for the time being.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The expression "chancer," which the Deputy applied to the Minister, should be withdrawn. It is unparliamentary.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir, I withdraw it. The Minister is a thoroughly unreliable man whose solemn testimony, short of on a sworn oath, has to be taken with a grain of salt.

Comment on this

If I did swear false you would send me a telegram of congratulation.

Comment on this

I should be long sorry to see the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Irish Republic made amenable to criminal law for perjury.

Comment on this

I hope I shall never get a congratulatory telegram from the Deputy on that score.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister need lose much sleep on that score. I am glad to be able to console him in that regard. Having consoled him, I now want to draw the attention of the House to another of the Minister's interesting announcements. He was jointly responsible for the White Paper which was presented to this House explaining the economic problems that lay ahead. In paragraph 17 of that White Paper on the Trend of External Trade and Payments and which was presented to each House of the Oireachtas by the Minister for Finance in October, 1951, we read:—

"Prices of our staple exports are much less flexible than world prices and there are no grounds for postulating any pronounced favourable movement in relation to import prices. Again, the current output figures for our staple exports rule out the possibility of any large increase in the volume of exports in the near future to bridge the gap. The agricultural census returns for the 1st June, 1951, reveal a drop of 50,000 in the numbers of milch cows and heifers-in-calf as compared withJune, 1950, and the number of cattle under one year is also down."

Listen to this. Just listen to this:—

"The agricultural census returns for the 1st June, 1951, reveal a drop of 50,000 in the numbers of milch cows and heifers-in-calf as compared with June, 1950, and the number of cattle under one year is also down."

There is a footnote to the census returns for 1953 to the effect that they put their foot on a banana peel in June, 1951, and that their figures were wrong—with the astonishing result that we have more cattle between one and two this year than we had calves the year before.

Comment on this

And more sheep.

Comment on this

But that is not all. "The volume of our principal exports could not possibly expand"! All Fianna Fáil took up the cry that the dirty lazy Irish farmer was lying down on the job, that he ought to be made work more and kicked into producing more. They were all baying round the country that it was a pity they would not work like the industrial worker who was doing something about it, and like the tariff racketeer, who was doing something about it: that no one could expect any more production from the dirty, lazy Irish farmer. That is what Fianna Fáil said.

We repudiated these statements by Fianna Fáil. We told the Deputies of this House that nothing would salvage this country but the incomparable effort of the agricultural community which, left uninhibited, would float this country off the rocks in spite of Fianna Fáil. The answer came in the White Paper: Not possible. Irish agriculture is down and out, scatty, incapable of expanding production or of being anything except a burden on the great industrial revival. I, at least, told this House that the industrial revival would not last ten minutes if it was not built on the rock of agriculture, and that if that rock were further chipped away the whole daft house of cards would come crashing down round the gentlemen with their tariffs of 90 per cent, and their quotas and their restrictive practices, and the practices whichrequired discipline by the Minister's Industrial Efficiency Bill. Now we have got the facts. Here are the trade returns brought up to date by the Statistics Office as to the 24th October, 1953. I am going to talk first of the value of exports, and then I am going to talk of the volume of exports— exports expressed in terms of prices as at 1938. The value of domestic exports in January, 1952, was £6.9 million, and in January, 1953, £7.5 million; February, 1952, £7.06 million; February, 1953, £7.5 million; March, 1952, £8.55 million; March, 1953, £10.21 million; April, 1952, £6.93 million; April, 1953, £7.53 million; May, 1952, £7.17 million; May, 1953, £9.14 million. Listen to this: July, 1952, £7.88 million; July, 1953, £9.86 million; August, 1952, £8.50 million; August, 1953, £9.57 million; September, 1952, £9.43 million; September, 1953, £11.28 million. Bearing those figures in mind, let us also remember these words:—

"Again, the current output figures for our staple exports rule out the possibility of any large increase in the volume of exports in the near future to bridge the gap."

Then think of the figures I have read out-and remember, there is no sweetened fat in that: there is no mincemeat in that. Four million pounds worth of fraudulent flash-in-the-pan exports have melted away and agriculture has filled the gap and added what I have described by these returns. That is the industry that we were told in this House held no prospect of filling the gap. Let us look at the volume of domestic exports and compare those of the year 1952 with those of the corresponding period of the year 1953: January, 1952, £2.27 million, January, 1953, £2.51 million; February, 1952, £2.32 million, February, 1953, £2.52 million; March, 1952, £2.88 million, March, 1953, £3.48 million; April, 1952, £2.48 million, April, 1953, £2.73 million; May, 1952, £2.60 million, May, 1953, £3.34 million; in June, 1952, £3.12 million, and in June, 1953, £3.60 million; in July, 1952, £2.71 million, and in July, 1953, £3.41 million; and in August, 1952, £2.83 million, and in August, 1953, £3.15 million. Is that a performance to beproud of? Is that something the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his colleague, the Minister for Finance, certified that the farmers could never do? Was it on that certificate that he described them before the world as incompetent, antediluvian, static drones whose system of land tenure would have to be radically changed if they were to be made produce what was necessary to maintain his crazy empire in Kildare Street?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing the question of agriculture rather than Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

These are exports and imports. This is industry and commerce, and commerce involves buying and selling.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister whose Estimate is before the House is not responsible for agriculture.

Comment on this

I wish to God he was not, but in fact he is now. God be with the days when he was not, but I am talking not about agriculture but about exports, and exports represent one-half of commerce here. We were told in the White Paper the only way to deal with the situation, in these classic words, at the end of paragraph 17:—

"The inescapable conclusion is that substantial relief to the balance of payments can only be achieved by importing less."

That is the familiar old doctrine that our people were eating too much and living too well and they must be brought down to reality—let them import less, eat less, buy less, do with less, and live lower. If we had put our trust in that remedy, where would we be now?

I am going to give the House now the volume of imports. In June, 1952, imports were 3.81-this is volume or imports expressed in terms of 1938 values-and in June, 1953, 5.09; in July, 1952, the volume of imports was 4.2, and in 1953, 5.48; in August, 1952,the volume was 3.4, and in 1953, 4.5. The money value of these imports in June 1952, was £11.45 millions, and in June, 1953, £14.46 millions; in July, 1952, £12.26 millions, and in July, 1953, £15.61 millions; in August, 1952, it was £9.88 millions, and in August, 1953, £13.07 millions; and in September 1952, it was £11.89 millions, and in September, 1953, £13.40 millions.

What is paying for these? What is making it possible to bring these goods in? It is the superb performance of the agricultural industry of this country, and the thanks that industry has got for what it has done is a tariff of 20 per cent. on sugar phosphates, the machinery of the land rehabilitation project sold and scattered and a campaign waged against it at home and abroad that those engaged in it are antediluvian incompetents and that there is no way of salvaging the country but, in the words of our Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, by precipitating a revolution in agriculture that will blow them all out of their existing system of livelihood. Can you imagine Capel Street and Rathmines combining to teach the farmers of this country how to run their holdings when, between them, they have wrought more havoc on the economic life of the country than the unfortunate small farmers will be able to repair in the next decade?

I do not expect that the Minister's mind is even open to suggestions for remedial measures to mitigate the bitter damage he is doing, but I want to give the House a solemn warning, and I want, if possible, to arrest the attention of the Minister for this. I made a trade agreement in 1951 relating to pigs and, in that trade agreement, the price payable for Irish pigs was linked to the price payable for British pigs, the price payable for Irish pork with the price payable for British pork and the price of Irish bacon with the price of British bacon. I did that with my eyes wide open and, by that device, we escaped from the straitjacket of bacon prices as fixed for Denmark, New Zealand and a variety of other exporters to Great Britainwhose price levels did not suit our economy at all.

I knew when I made that price agreement that the price of pigs, pork and bacon in Great Britain was being hitched to an index figure for feeding stuffs and that there was an agreement between the National Farmers Union in Great Britain and the British Ministry of Food that, as the index figure for feeding stuffs fell, the price fixed for pork, bacon and pigs in Britain would fall in proportion. I was fully aware that, as the impact of that decline fell on prices in England, it would repercuss here, but I felt that, seeing that our sources of feeding stuffs are virtually identical, the likelihood of feeding stuffs coming to our farmers at the same time as to British farmers was very high. We are now in this appalling position that the British farmers have had two reductions in the prices of pigs and bacon, on the ground of a corresponding decline in the index figure for feeding stuffs and we are bringing maize into this country delivered c.i.f. Dublin at £27 per ton and the farmers of this country are paying 38/- per cwt.

I want to warn the House, whether they like it or do not—remember the export figures I have read out—that, if these exports do not continue, everything else in this country will go up the spout. There is nothing carrying the country to-day but the exports of the small farmers and the one most valuable, growing and expanding item in these exports is pigs, bacon and pork. I warned the House before that the differential between profit and loss on the production of pigs was becoming very low. There have been two reductions in the price levels in Great Britain, consequent on a decline in the price of feeding stuffs. If those adjustments in feeding stuff prices are not made accessible to our farmers, very soon pigs will disappear off the farms of Ireland.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy's remarks not be more relevant to the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture?

Comment on this

I am talking about exports.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is talking about pigs.

Comment on this

You know, Sir, that during the inter-Party régime we reversed the policy of Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil had succeeded in banishing pigs out of the economy of the country as an article of commerce and we reintroduced them. It is easy to forget that for about 15 years, while the Fianna Fáil Government were in office, pigs disappeared in this country.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on the Vote. The Deputy should relate his remarks to Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Pigs, pork and bacon are now articles of commerce in this country again. It is very understandable——

Comment on this

The Deputy is deliberately insulting the Chair and he should not be allowed to get away with it.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

On a point of order. I suggest that the remark which has just been made by the Deputy should not be tolerated by the Chair or the House.

Comment on this

What remark? The remark that pigs and bacon are again articles of commerce?

Comment on this

The Deputy's attitude to the Chair has been deliberately insulting and I think the whole House should resent it.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is most insolent. He had no small part in banishing these commodities as articles of commerce from the economy of the country. We brought them back, and I will rub his nose with that fact.

Comment on this

The matters to which the Deputy refers come within the purview of the Minister for Agriculture and not the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I suggest that the Deputy is flouting your ruling.

Comment on this

I am not, Sir.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I pointed out to the Deputy on three occasions that the matters to which he has been referring are the responsibility of the Minister for Agriculture, not the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I would again ask him to relate his remarks to the Estimate before the House.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the cost of feeding stuffs. When I was Minister for Agriculture, matters relating to cereals were within the province of the Minister for Agriculture. I was not a month out of office when the whole staff dealing with these matters went back to Kildare Street.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has no function in regard to the cost of animal feeding stuffs.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister states he is not responsible for animal feeding stuffs, the Deputy should accept that.

Comment on this

That is the plain fact.

Comment on this

Does not the price of bran and pollard come within the province of the Minister in relation to the flour subsidy? I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been talking about pigs. These are matters for the Minister for Agriculture. The Deputy is merely trying to circumvent your ruling.

Comment on this

Is the price of bran and pollard not within the province of the Minister?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has been the practice if a Minister states that he has no responsibility for a certain matter, to accept that statement. If the Minister states that he has no responsibility for the matters to which the Deputy has been referring, the Deputy should accept that statement.

Comment on this

I know with the same certainty that I know that paper is on that desk that the Minister for Industry and Commerce controls the price of bran and pollard. I dare him to denyit now. If he gets up and says: "I have nothing to do with the price of bran and pollard," I shall not refer to it again.

Comment on this

I have said that matters affecting pigs and bacon are not the concern of my Department.

Comment on this

I am talking of bran and pollard.

Comment on this

Do you know what you are talking about?

Comment on this

I shall nail the Minister's ear to the desk with the statement that he is solely responsible for the price of bran and pollard.

Comment on this

I withdraw my point of order in view of the Deputy's statement that he has not been referring to pigs and maize.

Comment on this

I am not saying any such thing. I am referring to the price of animal feeding stuffs, which include bran and pollard.

Comment on this

I thought you were referring to pigs and maize.

Comment on this

I have reminded the House that bacon has again been brought back as an article of commerce in this country. The Minister is not going to intimidate me. I know him. He is the most unreliable man in this House——

Comment on this

I have sat here for half-an-hour listening to the Deputy talking nonsense.

Comment on this

You will listen to me for some time longer. I am warning this House that if the price of animal feeding stuffs is now at a high level in this country and a lower level exists in Britain, there will be a disparity between the profit margins available on certain live-stock products in this country which will make exports dwindle away. The Minister has left the House.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You ran him.

Comment on this

I ran him. It is not the first time we had to run him. I want to draw the attention of the Houseto this interesting fact. There was recently a report of an interview granted to the Irish Pressby two gentlemen, Messrs. Silverstein and Nathaniel Morris. They said they wished publicly to express their appreciation of the far-sighted statesmanship of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in releasing from all control, including export control, rags and bones. They wished it to be known that they thought it eminently desirable from the point of view of Irish economy, that an active trade should be restored in these raw materials of the paper industry. Will it be taken amiss of me if I ask that if it is a statesmanlike thing from the point of view of Irish economy to remove all control, including export control, from the rags and bones of Messrs. Silverstein and Nathaniel Morris, how is it a crime against the economic foundations of the Irish Republic to suggest that similar control should be removed from Pat Murphy's and Tom McCauley's hides? Perhaps after the Minister for Industry and Commerce has had his tea he will think that one out and give us an answer.

I want to make a suggestion to the Minister for Industry and Commerce which, I think, would go a long way towards producing virtual unanimity in this House on the question of industrial protection. I ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce to consider this plan at least in regard to those things which are the raw materials and the equipment of the agricultural industry. I take, merely as an example, things like spades. There is a prohibitive tariff on the import of spades. I forget momentarily what the rate is. Let us assume that the rate is 70 per cent. That tariff operates to prevent the import of spades and leaves the domestic manufacturer to produce almost anything he wants and to charge the Irish farmer a stiff price for it. Our purpose in industrial protection is to ensure the continuous employment of men on the production of spades in Ireland. That is what we want.

I want to suggest to the Minister that a new system should be applied to duties of this kind, that we shouldbring the tariff down to, say, 10 or 15 per cent., that any imports that ensue would pay that tariff and that on the revenue thus derived, the domestic producer of spades should be given a subsidy per spade on his production. Let us say that a spade, c.i.f. at the port of Dublin costs 4/-., and had upon it a tariff of 25 per cent., which would be 5/- f.o.q. Dublin. If that tariff produced a revenue sufficient to pay the domestic manufacturer of spades a subsidy of 6d. per spade and you said to the domestic manufacturer: "The imported spades are costing 5/-. We are starting you off with a free gift of 6d. for every spade you produce; go and sell your spades in competition," would not that be effective protection for an honest domestic producer and a competitive price to the farmer who had to buy the spade?

If that proposition is valid for spades, think what could be done if it were applied to boots, hosiery and a dozen other commodities which at the present time constitute a large part of the cost of living of the poorest of our people. If you could say to the woman with a big family who had to buy clothes for her children: "The domestic clothing industry requires protection, but we are giving it in this way: we are levying 25 per cent. on the imported clothes and using that revenue to give the domestic producer a subsidy to bring down the price for you, the woman who has to buy;" let those who want style and fashion buy the tariffed commodities and those who want warmth for a large family buy the commodity which carries the subsidy and which is specially made cheap to meet their needs, I think if that device were operated here 90 per cent. of the acrimony which characterises the tariff controversy in this country would evaporate overnight. I believe the consumer would get a fair or fairer deal. I believe that the parasites who have a licence to suck their neighbours' blood under the existing system of quotas would disappear from the social life of Ireland.

I want to say a word about whatDeputy Vivion de Valera was talking about. He said he believed that private enterprise was the most efficient instrument of production. I agree, and I think every sane man in the world agrees with that proposition. But there are more things in life than efficiency. The untrammelled operation of competition produces a form of society in which I want no part. I loathe the social organism which contains millionaires and paupers, and I rejoice to think that any society which accepts that as its norm is disintegrating in our time. God speed the day of its disintegration. I believe that private enterprise is the most efficient instrument of production and distribution. But, holding that belief, I ask Deputy de Valera what does he propose to do with the classic rule when the byproduct of that system emerges into monopoly and eventually lays all competition low, and there is only one vested interest producing an indispensable commodity under this private enterprise system. Is society to stand silently by while that monopoly proceeds in that way? I say, "No!" I would suffer no monopoly producing or dealing in an indispensable commodity to remain in the control of any individual or group of individuals in any community.

I do not care a fiddle-de-dee if there is a monopoly controlling sable furs, silk stockings or lipstick, all of which are desirable things if you are able to afford them. I see no Deputies in this House who would prevent their wives or sweethearts or eligible daughters from using lipstick or nylon stockings. But they are not the indispensable minimaof existence, and it is only in respect of one of these that, if it comes within the grasp of a monopoly, I ask any democratic Parliament in the world what then?

Are we all to stand back and bow our heads and accept the will of those who claim for themselves the traditional prerogative of power without responsibility? So far as I am concerned, never, never, never. Neither by power nor credit will those things without which our people cannot live ever, if I can prevent it, pass into the uncontrolled dominion of monopoly.But, if it should transpire that in our despite such a monopoly should emerge, there is only one remedy and that is for the State to enter into it, sweep the irresponsible monopoly aside and substitute for it what is very much the second best, a monopoly responsible to Parliament and the people. Yes, private enterprise so long as it functions will give the best results in efficiency and in value. But, if it does not function and monopoly takes its place, we in a democratic State should rejoice that the resources of democracy are not exhausted and that we have the power and the means to protect our people from any such exploitation.

Then let us record in summation what I submit is the right attitude to adopt. Free enterprise and fair competition on a free market, furnishing goods or services of the best quality at the lowest price with fair and decent conditions of employment for those who work within the industry, that is the beau ideal. If there has to be a monopoly, let it be a monopoly responsible to Parliament. The last but least desired is a monopoly responsible only to those who seek profit from it, or nationalisation for the sake of nationalisation. Both are equally disastrous and ridiculous to reasonable men.

I want to conclude by asking the Minister for Industry and Commerce certain specific questions. He spoke loudly and proudly of Irish Industry, and these sentiments have been echoed by Deputy de Valera. I want to ask the House, if we had in our midst a monopoly industry which charges our mineral water manufacturers 35/3 for bottles ex the factory which they are selling carriage paid in Liverpool and Northern Ireland at 22/3, ought we to strike up the band? Is that something to rejoice about? If it is, I do not understand it.

If we have a monopoly industry functioning here which charges a mineral water manufacturer in Ireland 40/- per gross for a 10-ounce white mineral water bottle which can be had in Great Britain and Northern Ireland for 26/6, are we to put out flags and prepare the laurel wreath for the enterprise?That is not the most astonishing part of the story. Are we to hail as a public benefactor the firm which charges the humble beer bottler in Ireland 32/6 for half-pin bottles, sells the same beer bottles to a Dutch firm at 23/9, who brings the bottles to Antwerp, fills them there with Dutch beer, and ships them back into Ireland, claiming exemption from import duty on the ground that they are Irish glass bottles, and undersells the Irish beer bottle? Are we daft? Is this the type of industrial development we are all to hail as the hallmark of freedom?

Perhaps Fianna Fáil would think of a suitable remedy. If we decimated the publicans' assistants of this country and sent every tenth man to Antwerp after the bottles and let them bottle the beer in Antwerp—if they want to bottle it in Ireland the bottles are going to cost them 32/6—and if we transfer their activities even to Armagh, not to speak of Liverpool, they can have them for 23/9. Have we all gone mad?

When I directed the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to that situation, he said that the matter had been referred to the Prices Advisory Body on more occasions than one and that they were quite happy. I want to tell the House that if the matter was referred to the Prices Advisory Body nobody knew anything about it except the monopoly. Nobody was asked to come and give his opinion about it. Nobody was asked what he thought. Nobody even knew that the Prices Advisory Body considered the price of bottles. I do not believe it ever did. I believe the Minister for Industry and Commerce just said that in Dáil Éireann to make the puzzle a little more difficult. It is like the man who asked the riddle: "What is it that has two legs, feathers, a beak and barks like a dog?" When nobody could guess it, the man gave the answer—a hen. He said: "I put in the bark to make it a little more difficult."

There is another question I want to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Why is it that a motor car, designed for the least affluent element in the community, manufactured in Great Britain is selling at£275 but costs £350 in Ireland according to a half page advertisement in an Irish national newspaper? You would think we would find that out quick enough without publishing a half page advertisement to announce we were going to be privileged to pay £75 more on it than the price for which they are available in Northern Ireland and Great Britain. Would the Minister for Industry and Commerce tell me why we must pay £350 for a £275 car? Why is £100 put on to a £350 car to make it cost £450 in Ireland? The most stalwart buttress of Fianna Fáil shrouded in the moss of unquestioning adhesion to the chief must sometimes stir the moss a trifle as he cogitates that puzzle. I know their lips are sealed. Since my lips are happily unsealed—I was about to offer a passing vote of condolence to Deputy Cogan but he is gone—on his behalf, on behalf of the silent three and of the old reliables, the dummies by election, I ask why does a car costing £350 in Northern Ireland cost £450 in Dublin, Cork or Galway?

I want to ask another question. Can we not devise some method of adjusting the charges made to the aeroplanes availing of the facilities at Shannon Airport to bring the revenue of that enterprise more into line with its costs? In 1945, the total deficit on Shannon Airport was £153,000; in 1946, £188,000; in 1947, £240,000; in 1948, £259,000; in 1949, £305,000; in 1950, £385,000; in 1951, £399,000 and in 1951-52, £426,000. I think that this year it will be of the order of £350,000. Shannon Airport is of very great importance to all the transatlantic lines that ferry to and fro across the Atlantic to use when they want it. It must reduce their insurance and their risk by 50 per cent. Let us write off the capital. I must say that the deficit figures which I read out contain a proviso for depreciation and interest on the capital. Surely somebody could devise some means whereby we could get the people who use the airport at least to pay for it without leaving us any profit or leave us a modest loss which we could write off. We are told that Ireland is on its uppers but since we find it difficult to meet the annual salaries of the Civil Service, handing out £426,000 for theconvenience of transatlantic airlines of other countries is an unreasonable demand to make upon us.

There is another matter which I think is well worth considering here. I have no hope that it will even receive friendly consideration but it is none the less significant for that.

The Minister is responsible for the development of hydro-electric power in this country in so far as this House accepts responsibility for it. In its development, regard is naturally had to all ancillary considerations. I do not know if the attention of the Minister has been directed to a great hydro-electric development in Canada. There it was discovered that if the rivers running west to east in the western quarter of the country could, by tunnelling through the mountains—an unprecedented engineering feat—be changed to run from east to west, the resultant reduction of the journey of these rivers to the sea would produce a head of water of about 400 feet at the point of emergence to the Pacific Ocean, and on this unprecedented hydro-electric power station, built in the heart of the mountains, is to be founded one of the largest aluminium industries on the Continent of America. That much has been done.

I now look to the Deputy for North Mayo, because I think that, within less than ten miles of his home town, there is an opportunity for an enterprise of a similar design, though I would not say of equal magnitude. My interest was first turned to this possibility, and it is no more than a possibility deserving of examination—it may have no substance in it when the critical light of an expert survey is turned on it, but it is worth surveying—when I was perplexed with the problem of the Moy drainage. The Moy is a peculiar river. It has one egress to the sea, but it has two sources, one rising north of Crossmolina and the other rising west of Foxford, both joining south of Lough Conn.

I suggest that the question of reversing the flow of the Moy north of Lough Conn, carrying it through the high bogs to discharge between Killala and Ballycastle, should give a waterhead of close on 100 feet, with reservoirs in Lough Conn ample to sustainwhatever water power may hereafter be required, so that at the one stroke we would be opening up sources of power that could be made available to an area of the country where power is dear and scarce, while at the same time a large arterial problem would be brought into manageable proportions. Now, whether that question is relevant to the Parliamentary Secretary for the gCeanntar gCúng——

Comment on this

I did not catch what the Deputy has said.

Comment on this

I was asking whether that question was relevant to the Parliamentary Secretary for the gCeanntar gCúng or to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It is a matter, I suppose, which the Parliamentary Secretary for the co-ordination of Ministers will have to decide whenever he is authorised to consider it. I would be interested to know if the Minister for Industry and Commerce would honour it with at least its reference to a competent engineering body for a survey. If it is well founded it will be an enterprise well worth undertaking, and if it is not no great harm will be done by making certain, once and for all, that no possibilities lie in that direction. It is a thing that I would like to have a hand in doing. Maybe if the Minister for Industry and Commerce would make the survey now it will be ready in time for me to satisfy that ambition.

Comment on this

This is an Estimate which gives great scope to individual Deputies to raise matters which they consider to be of importance both to the general economic well-being of the country and the welfare of their own particular constituencies. Some months ago, I raised a question in this House in connection with the desirability of developing a well-known Irish industry, namely, the distilling industry. At the time I did so, I found that little attention was being paid to that very important aspect of our economy. However, in order to bring home the seriousness of the situation, and to convince this House as well as the general public of the tremendous importancewhich this industry could be, I decided to put a motion on the Order Paper so as to obtain the views of all the members, and at the same time focus the spotlight of attention on the necessity for expanding the industry.

The motion which I put on the Order Paper asked the Government to set up a committee representative of the Government and of the distilling industry, that the committee would examine the best means by which we could develop the distilling industry, and that as a result of its inquiries a report would be made to this House so that suitable action could then be taken. I asked that this particular motion, in view of its importance, would, if possible, be taken in conjunction with the Estimate which the House is at present discussing. I should like, at this stage, to thank the Minister for Industry and Commerce for his courtesy and co-operation in the matter when he stated that he had no objection to this motion being discussed with the Estimate.

The motion was not put on the Order Paper for the purpose of causing annoyance to any particular Party or of starting a controversy in the House. It was put down for the purpose of focusing attention on the desirability of expanding this industry, and of pointing out the benefits that would accrue if the necessary steps were taken for its development. What really put this matter in my mind at the beginning was the fact that I found that the exports of Scottish whiskey last year were worth £32,000,000, while in the same period the exports of Irish whiskey were worth less than £500,000. I am personally convinced that, if this industry received the attention that it justly deserves and was tackled with enterprise and initiative, within 15 years, which may sound a long period to many members, it would not only beat our tourist industry but could possibly beat our main trade to-day, which is the cattle industry.

I have here a copy of a publication which is issued in Britain every fortnight. It is known as the Beverage News.I find from it that a prominent distiller, speaking within the last fewweeks in connection with exports of Scottish whiskey, said: “We are actually the largest single dollar earner of any industry in this country.” We have heard a lot about the drive in Britain for the American market with regard to the export of motor cars and so forth, and of the tremendous sacrifices which are being made in Britain to-day so that they can earn dollars in America and thus provide themselves with the necessities of life in the purchase of food.

It has been established that the biggest single dollar earner to-day in the United Kingdom is the whiskey trade. I gave the figures which indicated that, last year, the Scottish export trade for Scotch whiskey was worth £32,000,000, while our export trade in Irish whiskey in the same period was worth less than £500,000. I felt that, in view of the interest that was being taken in the development of export markets, in the present year an effort would be made, small though it might be, to increase our exports of Irish whiskey. I put a question down which was answered to-day dealing with the export of Irish whiskey in the last six months and the comparable figures for the first six months last year. I find that from January to June, 1952, the export value of Irish whiskey was £292,000, and in the first six months of this year, 1953, the export value of Irish whiskey was £167,000. Therefore, straightway we have a reduction in the first half of 1953 of over £120,000 in the export value of an important commodity such as whiskey.

Those are the Irish figures. Let us see what has happened in Scotland with Scotch whiskey during the first six months of 1952 and the first six months of 1953. Between January and June, 1952, the export value of Scotch whiskey was £16,200,000; between January and June, 1953, the export value of Scotch whiskey was £17,400,000 —these are round figures. In other words, the increase in the earnings on whiskey in these two comparable periods was over £1,200,000, while ours showed a reduction of over £120,000.

In the last few days a certain gentleman who is the executive vice-Presidentof the National Association of Alcoholic Beverage Importers, Incorporated in America, said in London that the 1953 shipment of Scotch whiskey will be the largest in volume and value ever made. That gentleman was in a position to speak— I will not quote his name but what he said is quite true. So far, we have no indication in this country that any increase has taken place or is about to take place; in fact from the figures I have given it would appear that we are in for a reduction in the value of our export trade.

We may ask why is it that the position is so bad with regard to the export of Irish whiskey. First of all, I would like to say that I believe one of the troubles all along has been that this important industry has been left in the hands of very conservative people. Our major distilleries to-day are still family concerns and as such have argued that they cannot be expected to take the risks of expansion at the wish of any Government. Their attitude has been that an attempt made by them to break into the dollar area, especially on a large scale, would leave them in the position of incurring the grave risk of a heavy financial loss. Their argument, as outlined by the secretary of the Pot Distillers Association, has been that the Government should pay handsomely; in other words the distillers are prepared to take such a risk.

As far as I personally am concerned —and I am sure there are other Deputies on all sides of the House who will agree—that will not wash to-day. The greatest argument—and we have had many arguments in this House in the last week about private enterprise— that can be put up in favour of private enterprise is that it is enterprising. I feel that no Deputy can for a moment say that those who have had responsibility for the distilling industry have shown enterprise in the last 20 to 30 years. We have plenty of examples of where State or semi-State companies or enterprises have shown initiative and have shown themselves willing to adopt go-ahead methods in their various lines. When some months ago this matter began to receive publicitythe Pot Distillers' Association rushed into print to defend their position and at the same time, I suppose naturally, blamed the Government for the situation that existed. We find that their spokesman in a letter to the Press, which is available in all the daily papers, stated as follows:—

"We would expect our Government to assist rather than handicap the industry as they have done by the crushing weight of taxation imposed on it. The industry must depend on the home market as the export market is problematic in these times."

That statement has been made by the Secretary of the Distillers Association within the last six months. Let us examine the statement and see how it stands up to a little criticism. The first argument is that the Government by the crushing weight of taxation on the industry have handicapped its development. It is an extraordinary thing that the spirit duty is considerably higher in Scotland than it is here; yet that does not prevent the Scottish distillers from selling £32,000,000 worth of whiskey abroad. The Pot Distillers Association goes on to say that the Government have handicapped the industry and hindered its development. That argument can be exploded, too, because since 1939 the output of Irish potstill whiskey has increased by almost 70 per cent. If that is the case I cannot see how the Pot Distillers Association can suggest that the Government have hindered its expansion. Those two arguments put up by the Pot Distillers Association have been exploded. The fact remains and cannot be contradicted that the distillers have shirked their duty to the State and have failed in their duty of securing a foreign dollar trade. It is clear, to my mind, at any rate, judging from the pronouncements of those who speak as representatives of the distilling industry that they have no real intention of embarking on an export trade on a large or a grand scale. I personally would not mind at all if it were an unimportant industry—then it might not be worth arguing about in this House—but in view of its tremendousimportance to the nation I think we must take alarm at their outlook and that steps must be taken to ensure that, whether they like it or not, this industry is expanded.

I do not intend to go into the details of the benefits that this distilling industry would give the community, but I would like to touch on a few points that might be of interest. We have had a lot of talk here by Deputies on the importance of growing here at home as much of our foodstuffs as possible. Whiskey comes from the soil—in other words, the making of whiskey is based on agriculture. It provides a rich cash crop for the farmer; it provides work for the men in the distilleries; it provides whiskey for the maltsters; it provides work for those engaged in the glass bottle industry, in the printing trade, in the packing trade, in the manufacture of boxes, in Irish shipping and in Irish insurance. There are many services which can be associated with the production of this commodity known as whiskey.

Let us get back to the most important aspect of our economy, agriculture. Here is a product based on agriculture. Not one iota of all that is concerned in the manufacture of whiskey is imported. Everything in connection with its manufacture is produced here in Ireland. Incidentally, one of the things that urge me to take an interest in this matter is the fact that some of my own constituents have an excellent record for years past as growers of malting barley. Last year, out of the blue, all those men were told by their particular maltster that their contracts for malting barley had been reduced by 50 per cent. That was a blow to agriculture. The land of many of those farmers who grow malting barley is not suitable for the growing of wheat. If we are serious, as I am sure all Deputies are serious, about the importance of agriculture and tillage, here is an ideal tillage crop providing both foodstuffs for the farmer as well as a cash crop; and in addition, after the making of the whiskey, the effluent that has been allowed to flow into the stream can now be processed into an excellent feedingstuff for pigs. Therefore, not a thing is wasted from the time the seed is put into the ground until the final commodity is put on the counter.

I do not suggest that overnight a great change be brought about in this industry—I have no such illusions —but I am convinced that if it is tackled on the right lines there is hope for the future. One of the arguments put up by those who say that it is difficult to get into foreign markets for Irish whiskey is that many people find the Irish product rather strong. Here at home we all agree that Irish whiskey is the best in the world. I am not going to dispute its merits or compare it with any other whiskey, but I would just say that we are the only people who say that, for the simple reason that it has not reached to the general public in many countries. In so far as the opinion goes of those who have tasted it in those countries, their view is that Irish whiskey as it stands or as it is exported to-day is not suitable to the palate of, particularly, the Americans and the Canadians.

That raises a very important point. Are we on the right lines at all in producing the type of whiskey at present made in the country? The whole question of development depends on this— to blend or not to blend? We can go on and try to expand the whiskey trade with the present potstill whiskey which we have, but if that pattern is followed I am convinced that the expansion will be very small indeed. We will be going against all the advice of those who deal with the public, we will be going against the wishes of those who should know; and it is an acknowledged fact that, in any business, in regard to any commodity you sell, you must please the customer, not yourself. If the world does not want Irish whiskey as we know it, there is no use in trying to sell it to them. Why not sell them a product that they like? That is where we come up against the difficulties in the whole industry, and that is the angle I want to air in this House.

There are many interests outside at present taking a very keen interest in the progress of this trade. The minute the Potstill Association hearsa word of our going on to a blended whiskey, they will be up in arms. Consequently, there will be great difficulties in the way of the Minister if he is to overcome the opposition of those conservative interests who want no change from the product that they have been distilling for years. Perhaps we should not blame them as individuals—I am not blaming them as such—but in view of what can be done with the industry I think it is unfair to allow their conservatism or their prejudices to thwart or halt the expansion of the industry.

I have got reports from very reliable sources in many countries and the reports from all over are in favour of a lighter blended whiskey. We even have Deputies who gave publicity to Irish whiskey at Strasbourg, where representatives of many nations were present. It was admitted by many of those representatives that Irish whiskey was an excellent product, but none of them would care to drink a great deal of it, as they were afraid it was too potent. That should give us some idea as to the tastes of other nations in relation to this commodity, and it is for their tastes that we must cater. It is no use boasting that Irish whiskey is the best in the world if the rest of the world will not buy it. We must shed our conservatism in this respect. There has been a good deal of talk of the conservatism of our farming community and the way in which that section of the population hankers after the old methods: what was good enough for my father is good enough for me. But there has been a tremendous change in the agricultural outlook in this country to-day, and that change is particularly patent in the case of the most conservative element in that community.

We have the distillers on the industrial side of our economy showing a far greater conservatism than the farmers ever did. Had the farmers not been prepared to adopt up-to-date methods and put on the market the type of goods required we would still be looking for an export market. The distillers will have to do likewise: they will have to take steps to meet the wishes of potential customers abroadin relation to whiskey. We must not permit these very conservative interests to ram it down our throats that their product, and their product alone, is the ideal one and that we should help them to expand that industry. I hope the Minister will not be said by one or two of these people.

I said at the outset that there is need for co-operation. I have obtained the views of some of the distillers upon this matter. I had a communication from the secretary of the Irish Potstill Distillers Association informing me that they saw no reason whatever for such a motion as I have tabled here. I have already given the reasons why they saw no need for that. In the words of the secretary of the association, they believe that it is a chancy thing to go into the dollar market and that the future of the industry depends on the home trade. That is the view of the conservative element. I can assure the Minster and the House that there are distillers who are not tied to this particular association and who are willing to co-operate with the Government in the establishment of some national concern prepared to go into this question of expansion in a big way in relation to a blended whiskey.

The Minister has shown great interest in this, and I believe that he is keener than anyone on the question of expanding our industries. When the report of Córas Tráchtála is available he should call these interests together and discuss with them the production of a blended whiskey. There are certain matters in connection with it that I do not wish to discuss here. I have painted the situation as I see it. It is quite possible that, when all the avenues have been explored, the Minister will decide to call for a reorganisation of the industry on a co-operative basis. It may be too early now to make that as a firm suggestion. I want the Minister to know my mind in this matter. I want him to know that so far as the farming community, Macra na Feirme, and the industrial and business interests are concerned they will be behind him in any effort he will make to expand this industry, and novested interests should be allowed to stand in the way of that expansion. I am sure the Minister will find that Córas Tráchtála will be all out for the export of a blended whiskey.

The general impression in America and Canada is that people prefer a lighter whiskey. So far, the efforts made by the Irish distillers to advertise their particular brand can only be described as puny. There are superb advertisements for whiskey in the American magazines. The principal theme running through those advertisements is that a particular whiskey is as light as Scotch, as rich as Rye and as satisfying as Bourbon. The one thing they ask for is lightness; that is one thing that our product lacks. I am sure many Deputies will admit that from their own experience.

After this motion had been tabled, the Minister decided to set up a sub-committee of Córas Tráchtála to examine the position. I understand he is now awaiting the report of that body. As soon as the report is available I hope he will bring the various interests concerned together so that their ideas can be pooled and we can go ahead with a proper line of attack.

In connection with the undeveloped areas, I have had occasion to visit the office of the Department of Industry and Commerce and Gaeltacht Services. I have always been met with courtesy and assistance on the part of the officials but, despite that courtesy and assistance, I am still where I started in so far as getting an industry established in Roscommen is concerned. There seems to be too much red tape in the administration of the Act. Some time ago I received a comprehensive list from the Department of Industry and Commerce setting out particular lines of textiles that the Department was anxious to see established under the Undeveloped Areas Act. The list showed what our requirements were and how much of those requirements had to be imported. I made a very simple request: could I be given a list of British firms engaged in the textile business so that our development association in Roscommon could get in touch with a likely firm across channel and discuss the possibilitieswith it of expansion of its industry here? I received a letter from the Minister's office informing me that a list of these British industrialists could be found in the National Library. If the Secretary of the Development Association in Roscommon were to write to all these people, not knowing one from the other, it would be a six months' job. I could not extract from the Minister's Department a list of, say, five or six firms that I might contact. I could not get it because of red tape, because they had no authority to give me such information.

Compare that with the attitude of the British Board of Trade towards businessmen. It should be an eye-opener to the Minister. I have here booklets issued to businessmen by the Export Promotion Department of the Board of Trade, London. Every businessman leaving London or Manchester for Canada, South Africa, Poland, or any other country in the world, is issued with a booklet giving up-to-date information on trade in these countries. The booklets are printed annually. In addition, the Board of Trade have a special register information service. They issue documents every week or every month. Some of them come under the heading, in red, "A Dollar Export Inquiry". One such document, a copy of which I have here, gives information regarding a U.S.A. inquiry for jams, jellies and marmalades, and states that the British Consulate General at San Francisco has reported that a particular company are interested in making a direct contact with a United Kingdom manufacturer of jams, jellies and marmalades. Such documents are issued every fortnight or when any inquiries are made. In contrast, when I inquire about industries, I am told by the Minister's Department to go to the National Library and to search the files.

Is there any such service as that given by the British Board of Trade available to Irish businessmen abroad? In the documents I have here the inquiries range over fancy chinaware, jams, jellies and marmalades, hardware tools and cooking ware, wood,flush doors, woollen, worsted and tweed piece goods, honey, biscuits. The Board of Trade gives information about particular firms looking for these goods. In one case they say that: "The firm is known to be a moderately small concern, importing a wide range of merchandise; they are interested in expanding their business to cover as wide an area as possible in the U.S.A. and would be willing to carry stocks if necessary."

By getting this information, the businessman knows where he stands. If you were to make such an inquiry of the Department you would be lucky if you got out without a libel action. I have here information supplied by the British Board of Trade about an inquiry in the United States of America to the British Vice-Consul for frozen fish fillets; an inquiry in respect of another dollar export—high quality glass tableware; an inquiry for earthenware and dinnerware, and bone china and earthenware teapots; an inquiry for toys; an inquiry for foodstuffs, including biscuits; an inquiry for scarves in Canada; an inquiry in the United States of America for men's and women's footwear; an inquiry for medium grade small leather goods, including gladstones, dispatch cases and men's 2-suiters. These documents indicate markets in America and Canada. I have documents giving information for other places, such as the Lebanon, about inquiries for various goods, plastic materials, paints, radios, recording machines.

What are our so-called diplomatic representatives in all these countries doing to-day? There is a lesson to be learned in the approach of the British Board of Trade towards these matters as compared with the approach of our Department. I am not blaming the Minister. I know he has enough on hands without trying to deal with every detail of his Department. My complaint is with regard to red tape. I want him to try to get that matter remedied. If we are serious about the establishment of industry under the Undeveloped Areas Act, people who show an interest must be facilitated and helped. The argument all along has been that if the people in therural areas who are howling for industries do not make some move they cannot be helped but when they do make a move they are stymied.

The development association with which I was connected were fortunate in the fact that I have to come to Dublin to the Dáil. How could they conduct their inquiries if it were not for that? It would mean that the secretary and others connected with the association would have to travel to Dublin and possibly would be told to make inquiries at the National Library or possibly might be sent to the Museum and even to the Zoo to get a list of industrialists dealing with these matters. The Department should be able to supply me with a simple answer, giving the information that a particular company were anxious to expand and to set up here. That is the only aspect of industry and commerce that I wish to discuss. I hope the Minister will remedy the situation.

Comment on this

The Minister has the reputation of being one of the best members of the Cabinet at putting a good face on a bad question. He has the reputation of being able to get an Estimate or a Bill through the House with the least amount of criticism and with the utmost speed. I am afraid I must conclude from his speech introducing this Estimate that the position in his Department during the past year was very alarming. His speech was full of vague promises of improvements in future. There were significant omissions to comment on very important factors affecting the lives of the ordinary people. The Minister made no suggestion of a change of policy. We must assume that the policy in the year to come will follow the lines of the policy adopted in the past year, a year of unemployment, taxation and starvation.

A number of Deputies, ordinarily independent, within the past week sought refuge in another Party. It is not for me to question their right as to where they go, but they took occasion in the public newspapers to state that they went to the Fianna Fáil Party because of its progressive outlookand its broad-mindedness. I would have preferred if these Deputies took advantage of the Estimate to show the broad-mindedness and the progressiveness of the policy in connection with industry and commerce as carried out by the present Government. It would help, I think, to convince me more effectively if they were able to do that than by just a general, vague statement. I think every one of us will admit that Industry and Commerce, as a Department, has a great effect on the lives of the people, and its ramifications are so large that they affect every other Department of State and, because of this, it deserves the full, unqualified attention of every Deputy. But because it is so vast and because there are so many points that it would take so long to deal with, it is only possible for those of us who wish to speak, to take one or two points in which we are particularly interested and to hope that the Opposition as a whole, spread over the number of Deputies who are interested, will in some way cover the various heads of the sub-sections of the Vote for Industry and Commerce.

I would like to deal with one of the points that, to my mind, the Minister was rather vague on. That is the question of food subsidies. The amount of money available for food subsidies here has very direct effect on the lives of the ordinary working people of this country. Naturally, because of that, I, as Labour Deputy, have a very keen interest in that particular section of Industry and Commerce. The Estimate for 1953/54 shows that £5,386,000 is available. The Minister passed over that particular part very lightly, and I think, in fact, it was not until he was questioned by Deputy Cosgrave that he referred to it at all. I would like to know from the Minister whether there is any intention to reduce or discontinue in their entirety the subsidies on food that remain?

I was one who, on behalf of my Party, a year ago gave a promise that we would not associate with any Party to form a Government unless we got an assurance that the food subsidies as they then were would be restored in full. Because of certain statementsthat have been made and because of the passage of time, I think it is desirable to repeat in the name of my Party that our promise still holds good. We will not associate with or be party to a Government that does not restore the subsidies or the value of the subsidies to the standard that was there in the time of the inter-Party Government. We may not be able to do that due to the fact that rationing as such has been discontinued, and the actual form of direct subsidisation of essential foodstuffs, but we will in some way, either by children's allowances or social welfare allowances of some sort give back to the people purchasing power equal to the amount of the subsidies that have been withdrawn. Otherwise, Labour will reserve to itself the right to vote against the Government that is not prepared to co-operate on this matter.

Labour is conscious of the fact of the removal of food subsidies because that removal affects mainly the small people of this country and we could not be loyal to our Party and to the people we represent should we co-operate with any Government that will not be agreeable to carry out what we have already pledged ourselves to.

Tied up with the general question of food subsidies is the question of price control, because unless price control is continued in the same manner as the food subsidies the real value of the wages of the worker is going to be affected, and because of that we in the Labour Party take a particular interest in it. The Minister, I suggest, was vague, even threatening in connection with the life of the Prices Advisory Body. He indicated that the period of life of certain Orders concerning supplies and services would shortly be coming to an end. He did state—in fairness to him—that he thought if these controls were to be kept on some permanent machinery which would keep control should be established.

I believe that the Minister would be well-advised to keep control of prices, because while perhaps the prices of important or everyday major items are not increasing, there are innumerable small and perhaps in themselves pettyincreases in the prices of articles which unless looked for would not be noticed, but which nevertheless constitute an item in the everyday expenditure of the ordinary worker that has been steadily increasing. I believe it is essential that control or at least publicity of some sort should be established in regard to increasing prices, and that the Minister and the Department must undertake the responsibility of carrying that out.

I note with regret that in answer to questions last week and again to-day the Minister indicates the number of cases in which recommendations have been made to him by the Prices Advisory Body has been steadily declining. I would suggest that the Minister, or his Government should accept some responsibility for that state of affairs. I suggest that the Minister has made a number of Orders removing control without at first seeking the advice of the Prices Advisory Body. That body may not be a perfect piece of machinery but it was established with a certain intent and purpose, and I believe it has carried out very useful progressive work in its recommendations to the Minister.

I am aware that the Minister is a keen believe in competition and the fact that private competition between individuals as a means of reducing prices is most effective. We would all agree with him up to a limited point; but where, as he must know, there are in this country combines and rings and trade organisation groups which of themselves agree to keep a certain standard or level of prices, you will wait a long time before competition will bring down the prices of commodities to the level at which they could rightly and with profit be sold. I regret that the Minister in his speech had to forecast the dissolution of the Prices Advisory Body. I consider that a backward step, and I believe that irrespective of price control or not that body can still serve a function. I would suggest to the Minister that it should be continued and should get an instruction from him to investigate, at its own discretion or on recommendation from his Department or on application fromreliable sections of the public, any cases of the costs of a particular article of a particular firm, and that a public statement be made that in the opinion of the Prices Advisory Body the price charged for the article is a fair one, that it is made up of a certain content of wages and of profit —in other words giving the structure of the price and indicating to the public the reason why the price had to be charged. In that way we would educate our public who believe in our Irish industry and get them to accept the prices charged knowing that they would be fair. On the other hand if the firm investigated was overcharging it would be a method, by pointing this out to the public, of forcing it to come into line with those Irish industrialists, and there are many, who are satisfied with a fair profit on their investments. Decent employers and, I am sure, the ordinary public would welcome such a step by the Minister.

It would act in the same way as the Standard Mark Committee acts with regard to quality. It would say that this was a fair price and that the people who paid it could pay it content in the knowledge that they were getting goods at the lowest price that could be charged for them.

I welcome the fact that the Minister has indicated in connection with the Institute of Industrial Research and Standards that he is prepared to introduce legislation to provide for a much bigger grant than the present £15,000 per year. I believe that that is an excellent move by the Minister and one that should be welcomed by all Parties. It is most important that that research work should be carried out and extended and that money should be made available to do so.

I regret very much that on this day week in answer to a question of mine in the Dáil the Minister indicated that there were a number of Irish industrialists who had not taken advantage of the facilities afforded to them to have a mark on their licences as being of a standard. I feel that Irish industrialists owe it to the people that they would avail themselves of this opportunity of securing for their goods aguaranteed standard. Irish industrialists have asked, and successive Ministers of Governments have demanded, of the Irish people that we should buy Irish on every occasion. Tariff walls have been set up to help these industries, and not only to help them so that they might make a profit but to help to keep our Irish boys and girls at home. All of us in this House irrespective of what Party we are in desire to see that continued. But we also desire to see that Irish industrialists and their workers give of the best to the Irish people both for consumption at home and export abroad, so that the good name and reputation of this country will be held high. All of us can agree with the Minister in his efforts to see that that goes much further than it does at present.

Some months ago the time of this House was largely occupied by a Bill brought in by the Minister which dealt with restrictive trade practices. Most of us will agree that it was a very urgent and important Bill and that since the passing of it a certain amount of good has been done. I have come across, during the course of a month or two, certain happenings in this country which forced me to the conclusion that there is need for an extension of that Bill or of some other Bill to curb the activities of certain individuals who have formed themselves—and, I am afraid, with Government recognition—into control of certain industries. I know a young Irishman who by his own endeavour educated himself in a particular industry, went to night school and secured the highest qualifications. Having passed his examination, with the help of a few people who had money to invest and were anxious to set up an industry, he formed a company producing a certain article in this State. Many other companies were producing the same article, but he felt that he could produce at a price and quality that of its own would secure for him and for his partners a certain amount of business. He applied to the Minister's Department for a licence to carry on, which he secured, but a condition was that the raw material would be allocated through a certain company.When he made his application he was told that there was no raw material available. Imagine his surprise to find that, inside of a week or two, the person who had control of the raw material was himself a manufacturer and was refusing to supply him mainly on the ground that he had not enough for himself. In other words, there is in this country such a position that people who are engaged in industry for profit, and only for profit, have, with the sanction of the Department of Industry and Commerce, control of the allocation of raw materials. Thanks be to God, there is a happy end to the story. He was able to carry on without that allocation and secure on the open market sufficient of the raw material to make his industry a success, and he is at present carrying on his industry. But I wish to protest against the fact that that control of an essential raw material for an industry is held, apparently with Government sanction, by a group who are themselves engaged for profit in the very industry that they are controlling. I think that position should not be allowed to continue.

The Minister has bewailed the fact that a large number of industrialists have not seen fit to avail themselves of the grants made available for the undeveloped areas. It is regrettable that these backward parts of the country will not have the advantage of becoming industrialised, thus preventing the flow of men and women from those areas either to the eastern part of the country or across the Channel. However, I might be human enough to say: "I told you so." On the debate on the Undeveloped Areas Bill, both Deputy Desmond and myself stressed the need for inserting in it a provision whereby the Government itself could invest capital if private capital could not be secured. I believe that the Government of this country have not only the right but the responsibility and duty to invest Government capital in any industry that can be proved worthwhile. I agree that private enterprise should be stimulated by Government grants or by certain other concessions but, where that stimulation is not effective, I believe that the Government have a primaryresponsibility in the matter of investing money in industrial undertakings that will show a very small profit or, perhaps, no profit at all and that will not be attractive to private enterprise either because of the risk involved or because of the smallness of the profit. There are profits other than monetary profits. The keeping of our men and women in useful and gainful employment in their own country —even if the industry does not make a profit or makes only a very small profit —will, in itself, show a profit on the right side. The keeping of these people at home will, in turn, give a fillip to industry.

We must remember that one-third of the total enterprise of this country is composed of consumer goods. Unless our people are employed and receive wages sufficient for their needs you will have a continuous draining of the life-blood of our country in the form of emigration. That will result in a consequential reduction of industrial work which, in turn, will result in a further flow of emigration from this country.

I believe there is a grave danger of complacency in regard to this Estimate. There is a need, as anybody who has studied the question must know, for 25,000 new jobs each year to meet the number leaving school and seeking work and the number leaving the land. In fact, I am putting the estimate at a very conservative figure when I say 25,000. In reply to a question which Deputy Desmond put to the Minister last week, we were informed that a certain number of persons are engaged in industry this year as compared with last year. On examining last year's figure, however, I was amazed to discover that last year over 22,000 fewer male persons were on the land as compared with the year previous to that. That figure of 22,000 fewer male persons on the land in any one year is the highest figure that has been recorded, so far as I can discover. If new jobs have to be found for those 22,000 persons, plus all the young persons leaving school, then indeed my figure of 25,000 is very conservative and should be much nearer to 40,000.

I am afraid we cannot afford to haveany complacency. The Minister must not content himself with bewailing the fact that private enterprise has not caught up with the job and saying that he is going to encourage it. This Government, or any Government, must make up their mind that they will have to invest money in this country. Let them raise that money by way of loan, if necessary. They must get sufficient capital to put into industry so as to keep in employment at home those 25,000 to 40,000 persons who are leaving the country annually. It is necessary that the Government should start thinking on the lines of projects similar to the E.S.B. and Bord na Móna. These two schemes were started either with Government capital or with Government capital allied to private enterprise.

I do not care whether the schemes be started with Government capital or partly with Government capital so long as they are started. I suggest that the Industrial Development Authority are the ideal group to undertake the planning of that work. I am aware that at present most of their time is taken up in examining whether a licence should or should not be given for the importation of certain commodities. I think there is a bigger function there for them to perform. I believe they should be thinking on the lines of whether or not it is possible, with Government money or partly with Government money, to develop, say, a chemical fertiliser industry in this country. Everybody must be aware of the cost of imported fertilisers. Deputy Dillon suggested a likely scheme and I suggest a chemical fertiliser factory as a suitable project.

I believe that where very little profit can be shown from an industry, you will not get any private enterprise to touch it. I think, therefore, that it is the duty of the Government to utilise the Industrial Development Authority and to invest the money of the people within this country itself.

In his introductory speech, the Minister stated that 68 new factories were opened within the past year. I should have liked the Minister to relate the number of additional persons engaged in industry in the past year. There isthe possibility that some of the 68 new factories, which the Minister said were opened during the past year, are like some of the factories about which Fianna Fáil used to taunt the Cumann na nGaedheal Government—back-room factories where there might be maybe one man and a boy and, indeed, where even the boy might not be employed. There is also the possibility that, while 68 new factories were opened, 100 others have closed down. God forbid that that should be so. I should have liked to hear the Minister say, when speaking on this subject, that so many more persons are employed in industry now than were employed this time 12 months ago. I fear, however, that he was not in a position to make any such statement. My investigation, and the investigation of the Party to which I belong, shows that instead of an increase in the number of persons engaged in industry there has been a steady decrease.

The live register of unemployed cannot be regarded as an index in that regard on account of emigration, but it is evident from it that the position now as compared with that which existed 12 months ago does not show that there is anything like equilibrium in industrial undertakings. My experience as a trade unionist who has kept in contact with conditions throughout the country is that there is considerable unemployment in our industries. Thank God, there are signs of an improvement but I am not party and neither do I want to be party to the complacency with which this Estimate has been introduced, and the manner in which the Minister has dealt with it. One would think that everything was going on wonderfully. I do not accept that view and the Government, the Minister and all Deputies would do well to remember that while there are men walking the streets of Dublin and other cities and towns crying out for work in industry or anywhere else which has been denied to them or which cannot be given to them, the Government has not only a right but a duty as I have said to see that work is made available by the promotion of some industry which will occupy these idle hands.

I am not quite sure whether we can discuss on this Estimate the Tourist Board, for which, I understand, there is a separate Vote, No. 67.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not included in this Estimate.

Comment on this

As there will be another opportunity——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am sorry; it is included.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to it.

Comment on this

There was a drop of £2,000,000 in the income from tourism in 1953 as compared with 1951. All of us here appreciate the terrific value of the tourist industry. It is a help, and a very decided help in balancing the difference between our imports and our exports and one of the things in favour of which all Parties spoke, but it is significant that in 1952, in the year in which we were making our maximum effort, there was a drop of £2,000,000 in income.

Comment on this

The Coronation celebrations might have had something to do with that.

Comment on this

I hope they had, inasmuch as there will not be a Coronation this year and we may hope to do better. As well as helping to bridge the gap between imports and exports, the money that comes from tourism is of particular benefit to the country in so far as it spreads out through all the counties of Ireland. It affects all industries and trades pretty well equally and the raw materials of the tourist industry, the services provided and the food eaten, can be said to be home produced. It is of terrific value from this point of view and the Government cannot be too strongly urged to foster improvements in the industry.

I believe we are working on the right lines and I welcome the fact that increased grants have been earmarked for both An Bord Fáilte and Fogra Fáilte. I understand that the figure is £375,000, or £140,000 more than last year. That improvement in the grants is something on which I should like tocongratulate the Minister but I again want to impress on him that there is no room for complacency. While we have improved our position, and will, I hope, improve it further in the future, I want to point out that the grants are still very low by comparison with the amount of money we get in, being only 1½ per cent. of the net receipts from the industry. I suggest that that is not enough, that bigger propaganda and better planning are necessary.

While saying that, I want to point out that I believe too much attention is paid to the dollar side of tourism. Of a total figure of £32,000,000 received last year, only £2,500,000 came from the dollar countries. The balance came from across Channel or from Northern Ireland. I suggest that we cater more for our friends in Northern Ireland and across the Channel——

Comment on this

The Six Counties.

Comment on this

I stand corrected—the Six Counties. We should cater more for our people in the Six Counties and also encourage our own people here to stay here for their holidays. I believe that instead of emphasis being placed on the luxury hotel, the luxury airliner or other method of travel, we should cater for the ordinary people who want a good standard—cleanliness, good food and reasonably speedy travel. For that reason, I believe that the money spent on Aer Lingus is money well spent, but I am equally satisfied that money spent on transatlantic air services is of no great benefit to the people.

I suggest that the Minister should emphasise to the two boards which deal with tourism that they should concentrate more on the ordinary people and their needs, and should encourage not only the person who comes to stay in our hotels, but the very modest hiker who wishes to have a holiday on the lowest amount of money possible. All these hikers, with the limited funds in their pockets, added together can very well tot up to the same millions as a couple of hundred millionaires will bring. There is no particular reason why we should seek dollars now. We can get all our dollar requirements, I understand,out of the dollar-sterling pool. There was perhaps in earlier years an urgency about securing dollars at any cost, but now we should concentrate on the ordinary person who crosses the Channel, or comes from the Six Counties, or those of our own citizens who spend their holidays here. I understand that £7,000,000 of Irish money was spent abroad by Irish tourists in England and elsewhere last year and it would be well if we could divert even a portion of that money and retain it here.

Comment on this

We have to help other countries.

Comment on this

I suppose there is that to be said. If we do not go to them, they will not come to us, but I feel that we should show our beauty spots not only to the people in America and the people in the Six Counties and Great Britain but also to our people at home. I believe there is a good deal to be done in bringing the charms of the different counties to the notice of these people.

I did intend to deal with the question of Tourist Board property and, in particular, the selling of property in the town of Tramore by the Tourist Board to certain private enterprise. The people of County Waterford would like that I should deal with that matter and perhaps even some Deputies would like me to deal with it. While I might be able to give some surprising information about it in view of the fact that there is a motion on the Order Paper in my name which will probably be discussed within the next week, I will confine my remarks to saying that I believe the Minister should co-operate more with local authorities or encourage these boards to co-operate to a greater extent. Local authorities have a responsibility and they have a will to help that private enterprise can scarcely be said to possess. A particularly glaring instance of non-cooperation was the fact that the local authority in Tramore was deprived of the right of even bidding for a certain tourist property which, to my mind, was disposed of at a sacrifice price,but we will have more of that anon.

As a Labour Deputy, I feel that there is no room for complacency in discussing this Estimate. The Minister has not even attempted to make things look well. Any Deputy who is alive to the position in the country cannot feel that things are well while unemployment stalks through the country, while people are in want, while the goods, the raw materials and the man-power are available in this country to make the things people want and yet these things are not being made. That is the position at a time when people are flying out of the country in thousands. It is the duty of the Minister in such circumstances not only to introduce this Estimate but to include in it provisions which will ensure that our people will have an opportunity to live and work here and to receive wages sufficient to enable them to maintain themselves and their families.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

This is a very big Estimate for a very big Department. It covers so many different branches of endeavour that it is somewhat difficult to pick out the parts which are of most importance. I shall start by mentioning what I believe industry has done up to the moment and what perhaps we would wish it to do in future. We all wish to see the industrial arm developed to the fullest extent here in Ireland. We know that we have suffered very much from having an inadequate industrial arm. We entered the industrial field much later than many other countries. In some ways, that has been an advantage, but in other ways it has been a considerable disadvantage. At any rate, that fact has a very great bearing on our consideration of industry here.

One of the difficulties which we are up against, owing to the recent growth of many of our industries, is that we have not nationally worked out just what we expect our industries to do for us, how far we are prepared to help them and how far we are prepared to see that they get adequate capital and are permitted to make adequate profits to carry on. By that I mean that in countries where industries were established a long timeago, a working arrangement has been entered into roughly between the various industries, the Government and, indeed, all the people of the country.

We hear a lot of criticism of certain industries in this country from time to time. We also hear considerable praise of industries. Sometimes the blame and the criticism are as unjustified as the extravagant praise, but what we all want is to see industries here flourishing and playing their part in the life of the country, because we have suffered terribly from unemployment. We have suffered and are still suffering from the effects of mass emigration of the youth of the country every year. We wish industry to play its part in keeping people here at home and in providing them with adequate employment and all that flows from that. One of the criticisms that we hear from time to time is that Irish industries are making too much money, that there is, in effect, exploitation. That is a very easy thing to say, especially in a small country like this where we are apt to look on industries with perhaps the eyes of persons accustomed to looking at agriculture and the profits that agriculture can make. There is undoubtedly a certain degree of ignorance in these matters. That is where we have not yet, as a people, come to a working arrangement with regard to industries.

Deputy Larkin on Thursday spoke on the question of profits in industry, and whilst one would expect Deputy Larkin not to be in favour of large profits, he certainly spoke reasonably on the subject. He mentioned the case of certain firms which had made very large profits but actually it is impossible to discuss the rights or wrongs of profits unless we know the particular industry and, in fact, the particular firm concerned and unless you have the balance sheets and other relevant matters in front of you.

I am not advocating that we should mention the names of individual firms; I think that would be a very wrong thing to do but what I want to point out is that Parliament is not the place where you can go accurately into the question of profits. You can merelysay that the profits appear to be high on the one hand and you can listen to the argument of somebody who says that they are not, but, to come to a reasonable decision, the matter has to be gone into a great deal more closely than is possible here.

I should say, however, that you cannot consider the question of profits except in relation to turnover and the capital employed in the business. Deputy Larkin referred to several businesses but he mentioned one in particular which had a capital of £50,000, and its net profit from 1945 to 1952 totalled £351,000. I am just as much in the dark about that as other Deputies are. But, from my knowledge of business, small though it may be, I know that you cannot decide whether that was in fact a large profit for the business concerned, because it is very likely that the real capital employed in the business is many, many times more than £50,000. It may be in fact ten times that.

Take the case of two firms which were started, we will say, 50 years ago with the same capital. If one firm every year ploughs back the profits or a good proportion of the profits into that business, at the end of 50 years that particular firm will have what we call capital employed in the shape of loose cash, stock, land and buildings and perhaps some investments— although not many firms go in for holding investments; they usually invest the money in their own business— that has become enormous because that firm, by thrift and self-denial, has built itself up into a very big position.

If, on the other hand, the other firm in the same line of business and with the same capital has not ploughed back its profits into the business because the owners decided that they would have a beano every years on the profits, in a very few years there will be an enormous difference between those two firms. It may then look as if the firm which is making a large profit on the same capital is making an exorbitant profit. It is not. It is making the profit to which its skill and its conservative policy over theyears has entitled it. One of the reasons why businesses do that is that they hope, when bad years strike them, to be in a position to carry on and weather the economic storm with the reserves they have built up. That is a cardinal principle of commercial life.

In a paper which I have here, got out by the Statist, in which there is a review of the commercial life of Ireland, a writer says:—

"There has always been one paramount condition essential to the success of private enterprise. This is the necessity constantly to plough back a very substantial proportion of the profits earned to provide capital to revitalise and expand the business."

In those two sentences lies the whole secret of commercial stability and, in many cases, the secret of industrial success. Therefore, when we hear talk about profits I would ask Deputies to consider, wherever possible, the whole circumstances surrounding the case. It is impossible to say on this or that fact whether profits are adequate or are too high.

Deputy Larkin also raised a question about bonus issues. Certain firms do issue bonus shares if they are doing well. They do that for a variety of reasons. I know of one firm which issued bonus shares and it did so because during the early part of the war it made a purchase abroad and then, owing to war conditions, was unable to bring the commodities that were purchased back to Ireland. Eventually, after the war was over, they succeeded in getting them over and as a result they capitalised that purchase and made a bonus issue. There are a variety of circumstances or conditions in each case and it is necessary to know the circumstances before judgment can be passed. Certainly judgment cannot be passed on the whole of our trade and industry in that way, because, as I say, there are varying conditions, some of which arise through the skill and better business ability of certain firms.

Then there is another matter arising out of that. It is very easy to talkof profits by looking at a business for a short time only. Most of the successful businesses in this country have been established over a long number of years. If you look at the balance sheets of various companies over a period of 20 or 25 years, you will find a very different picture from what you will find if you take just the short number of years since the end of the war. Another matter in connection with the question of profits in industry is the value of the £. As we are aware, the value of the £ has twice fallen since 1938. It fell as a result of the war from 1939 to 1945 and then it fell as a result of the Korean war. We have had a very large drop in the value of money since 1947. It is only fair, therefore, when you look at the profits of a business, to consider the actual value of the £ because a business, be it retail or manufacturing, is geared up to do a certain volume of business in goods. It has the personnel to deal with it. It has the warehouses in which to store the raw materials or the finished articles it manufactures. It has also the actual buildings in which to carry on the trade. It is geared to produce a certain volume of trade and the endeavour of every firm is to keep that volume up.

If that firm did a volume of business which produced a turnover of £100,000 in 1938—I want the House to think of a volume of goods which kept its employees adequately employed and its warehouses and other buildings occupied to the fullest extent—to-day that sum would represent at least £300,000. In other words, that business would require to make a turnover of at least £300,000 to produce the same volume of goods. Therefore, if you look at the profit in 1938 and the profit to-day you will get a very different figure but a very different amount of money is employed. If that business made a profit of 5 per cent. or £5,000 in 1938, to-day a profit of 5 per cent. would produce £15,000. That business has to finance and run the extra turnover which is necessary. These are all considerations which we, as a Parliament, should have at the back of our minds when we are considering the industry and commerce of this country.

In that respect it is interesting to note the American report on the industrial potential of this country. That report was made some time ago and it refers several times to the low rate of profit in this country. Far from thinking it is high it considers it is low. In one part of the report it is said that profits had not been sufficiently high to attract domestic private investment. It also said—and we all know this— that this country suffers from chronic under-investment. Therefore, we have to consider how far our criticism of the profits of industry is real because those experts pointed out the effect that low profits have had on industry in this country. They say that should be borne in mind when considering the low industrial activity in this State.

The report also refers to the business tax structure which, it says, is slightly lower than in Great Britain or the United States of America but is the same as in Holland and Sweden. That means it is at a very high rate. We really have got to make up our minds as to how far we wish industry to be allowed to carry on under conditions which enable it to make sufficient to lay by for the uncertainties and difficulties of the future.

I was interested to hear the remarks made by Deputy McQuillan on the whiskey industry and its exports. I do not know anything about the intricacies of the whiskey trade but I would say that this criticism of the industry for not going into the American market is one that is not quite fair.

Comment on this