We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 50—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 171–341 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

It will not go down well.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Whiskey will go down well.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Whether it goes down well or up well, it is very easy to criticise a trade or industry for not expanding and going forward to a market but the whiskey industry would have very great difficulties to encounter in the American market. There would be difficulties of taste and large sums of money would have to be spent on advertising and working up the business generally.

We all know that potstill whiskey is not sold until it is seven years old. That means that a programme of laying by large quantities of whiskey would have to be carried out for something like seven years before any return could be made. It is, therefore, a very difficult matter for the whiskey people. It is a matter upon which I would certainly not criticise them. I think the Government should meet and discuss the difficulties which lie in front of any expansion of that trade in America.

Various Deputies have mentioned the tourist industry. We do seem to have hit a bad year this year, but of course there are reasons for that. It was Coronation Year in England and a lot of people who normally would have come here probably went to Britain instead. We hope that next year and in the future the tide will turn in that respect. Of course, what has happened might also represent a change, but we hope that is not so. It is up to the hotel people and to those in control of the tourist industry to make every effort to have the conditions as good for visitors as they can possibly be made. My own view is that we should concentrate on providing facilities for the middle-class tourist, for those who want reasonably priced hotels, and reasonably priced amusements and entertainments generally. I think it is in these respects that we can really show ourselves to the best advantage.

This year An Tóstal has come in for a great deal of criticism. Personally, I think it was a success. I think that we should carry it on and hope that there will be an improvement in each succeeding year. This was the first year that we had anything like it, and in my opinion it is worth continuing. People have pointed out that the number of tourists who came here this year dropped as compared with previous years, and argue from that that An Tóstal was a failure. I do not think that is fair criticism because even without An Tóstal the number of tourists coming here this year might have been smaller still. I think we should keep it on and endeavour to profit by our experience of this year.

Some people consider that An Tóstalis held too early in the year. That is my own opinion, too. I think it should be held as close to the regular summer season as possible. I also think that the committee of An Tóstal would be well advised to keep in touch with the various sporting people, and that it should endeavour to arrange sporting programmes well in advance of the holding of the festival. I understand that it is too late now to arrange racing fixtures for next year. That is something which the committee should be thinking about for 1955. I am also of the opinion that the committee should get in touch with the Royal Dublin Society which, I understand, offered it full use of the society's show grounds. I believe that, so far, the offer has not been availed of. The grounds were offered last year. That situation seems extraordinary, in view of the fact that the shows of the Royal Dublin Society constitute the greatest tourist draw in the whole country.

There is another matter which, as a Dubliner, I would like to refer to. It is that so many people, during the rush hours in this city, have to wait in queues for buses. One never saw queues when we had the trams on the streets. Nowadays, at every bus stop, during practically all hours of the day, one sees little knots of people waiting for buses. If that occurred only during the rush hours one might say that it was something which it was rather difficult to deal with. The fact is that you see groups of people waiting at the bus stops during the rush hours, and these queues are almost always there. That fact would seem to point to this, that there are not enough buses on the roads, and that the citizens of Dublin are being very badly catered for by the bus company. I would ask, as a city Deputy, that this matter should be very seriously considered, and that more buses should be put on the roads.

In conclusion, I would say that we in Ireland have been suffering for the last two years or more from a trade depression. Our unemployment figures are very high, and the Government are not doing anything very much to meet that situation. The building industry, about which I know something,provides one of the quickest and best ways of giving employment, but at present that industry is in a very depressed condition. I would ask the Minister to take steps to see that employment is encouraged by every means in his power in the country generally, and, particularly, that the building industry be allowed to make the contribution to employment which it and it only can make.

Comment on this

I had hoped that the Minister in his review of the activities of his Department would have made some reference to our position as a member of the O.E.E.C. I think that some importance lies in the fact that as a nation we are a member of that organisation. When it was formed in 1948 it had for its object to combine economic strength, to join together and make the fullest collective use of the individual capacities and potentialities of its members, to increase their production, to develop and modernise their industrial and agricultural equipment, to reduce whatever barriers there might be between them, and thus provide full employment, restore or maintain the stability of their economies as well as general confidence in their national currencies.

It was on that basis that a number of nations came together to form the O.E.E.C. In the years since it was formed in 1948 the data obtainable have been collected by the organisation and this material has been made available for this Government and for the Governments of the other countries which are co-operating in that organisation.

I would have liked the Minister to say how we are co-operating with O.E.E.C. in their general policy of promoting full employment, how we are fitting into their scheme of reducing trade tariffs and liberalising trade generally.

Another organisation has been set up known as the European Productivity Agency and that organisation has for its purpose: "To promote the most suitable and effective methods for increasing productivity in individual enterprises in the various sectors of economic activity in the member countries and over the whole field oftheir economy and to this end it shall undertake and promote measures tending to the acceptance and adoption of the best and most modern techniques and to the removal of factors limiting their adoption." I would have liked to hear the Minister say whether we have joined this European Productivity Agency and, if so, what benefits we have derived or are likely to derive from membership.

Then there is the third organisation to which I would like to refer briefly, that is, the organisation known as G.A.T.T., or the General Agreements for Tariffs and Trade. How far are we as a nation co-operating with that organisation and how far are we benefiting from the very valuable research and very valuable technical information that is available in that organisation?

When our membership of these organisations, in the first instance, became practicable, the tendency then was to run these organisations, as it were, through the machinery of the Department of External Affairs. I always felt that, being economic, having to do with industrial development, having to do with the promotion of full employment, these were matters that were peculiarly within the domain of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I think the House and the country would like to know how valuable these organisations have been to us and how much we have contributed in a general way to the objectives they have in mind. Perhaps when he is replying the Minister would deal briefly with these matters.

The Minister, the House and, I think, the country generally, welcome the efforts that have been made to get our feet into the American market. I just wonder whether this is a wise policy at the present time. Undoubtedly, if we could get into the American market and if we could maintain our position there it would be a most desirable development for this nation. As I understand it, economists of world reputation agree that there is a chronic, as they term it, unbalance of trade existing in the world which should be ended as soon as possible. Economists also agree that there is nopossibility of that unbalance being rectified unless there is a fundamental change in American commercial policy.

A very large range of potential exports to the American market are fixed with tariff rates of 50 to 60 per cent., or even more. There is the extraordinary complexity and difficulty of their customs valuation which increases the tax on goods imported into the American market. There is the Buy American Act. There is their own shipping policy which is generally described as discriminating against every nation except themselves, and there are innumerable other difficulties in connection with the American market.

I understand—and perhaps in this the Minister would be more informed than I am, but I think it is something the House might consider—that in actual fact in the coming months a very big political battle is developing in the United States in regard to whether there should be a lowering or a raising of tariffs or trade barriers. If that battle resolves itself in favour of those who apparently up to the moment have had control, that is, in favour of an increase or the maintenance of present trade restrictions, then efforts to get into the American market, however desirable it might be to get into that market, are not likely to meet with any success.

The Minister was most diplomatic— as he usually is since he became a Minister—in his reference to what happened in regard to his own efforts to establish a transatlantic air service in the last couple of years. The Minister mentioned at columns 814-15 of the Official Debates of the 20th October, the difficulties he encountered and there were two very main difficulties. We are anxious to establish this transatlantic air service. Everything that could be done on this side of the Atlantic to establish that air service was done by the Minister. It was the desire of the Irish people that we should establish that air service but the efforts to establish it were sabotaged, which is not putting it in the diplomatic way the Minister puts it. The decision as to whether we would be permitted to run it or notwas delayed for over a year until there was less than two years left to us to operate the service. As the Minister very properly says, no one would undertake the risk of offering a service limited to a life of two years. Consequently, the whole project was abandoned.

I hope that no one will consider that I am unnecessarily or unduly critical if I say that, if there had been a spirit of co-operation between the United States of America and this country in regard to the air service, the air service would be operating; but it was stopped, and it was stopped for the reasons stated by the Minister, that there was this delay, which he very diplomatically says may have been due to the election in America, but which we all know had nothing to do with the Presidential election in America. It was delayed just sufficiently long to make it impossible for anyone but a fool to attempt to run it in the short period that was left available. American business people connected with air lines had no desire to have this competition and consequently they successfully stopped it, just as they will successfully stop the imports of any goods from this or any other country they may consider would endanger a particular line of business of their own.

I am stating this as a fact that we have to realise when we talk about bursting into the American market. I think that Deputy McQuillan—who has excellent ideas in regard to the increase in the production of whiskey and the export of whiskey—will find that there are undoubtedly very many and very grave difficulties in the way of putting into the American market whiskey which will go into competition with their own ryes and their own whiskey and the business they have built up themselves over a long period with the Scotch distillers. What I am very anxious about is the danger that very valuable energy, time and money may be expended in an effort to get into the American market and that effort, in the long run, may be unsuccessful.

This is not a matter of difficulty only as far as we ourselves are concerned.Each Western European country faces the very same difficulties. Each and every one of them believes that unless there is this alteration in the American approach to imports it will not be possible to build up the strong Europe that those nations are anxious to build up.

The Minister—and many other Deputies—talked here about the temporary trade recession which was experienced internationally in 1952 because of the liquidation of stocks which had been accumulated on the outbreak of the Korean war. The Minister said that that temporary recession had ended and many Deputies have expressed their pleasure and delight that it has passed. Economists are worried now about another depression in trade. The economists from different countries who belong to the O.E.E.C. and economists who have debated this matter in the Council of Europe are of opinion that a major depression could now start in Europe and that if any depression does start it may start in the United States. According to these economists, several weaknesses have appeared in the economic situation of the United States recently. The level of stocks, they say, is rather high; there has been a reduction in the demand for broad categories of consumption goods; the number of houses begun has declined this year; the price of industrial securities has fallen; and there were other signs to indicate a weakness in the economic structure of the United States.

The danger is that the United States of America may be forced to take steps to avoid the recession or to bring about some readjustment in their own economy. American economists, to whom this problem has been put by European economists, say that they are able to stand any such strain. The trouble is, even if the United States can stand the strain of the measures they would have to take to bring about readjustment, can the nations of Europe stand the effects of those measures? In 1949 there was no slump in America, there was no falling off in the rate of fixed investment. All that happened in 1949 was that manufacturers ceased to accumulate stocks. American importsfell by only 7 per cent.—but that resulted in a devaluation of the British £ by 25 per cent. There is undoubtedly cause for concern. While that position exists, are we wise, I say, to expend time, energy and money in trying to get into the United States market?

It has been estimated that a 10 per cent. cut in American imports would cost the sterling area £1,100,000,000 a year. The O.E.E.C., and the countries in the O.E.E.C., including this country, feel that we must endeavour to avoid what would be termed just the ripple from that kind of disturbance in the American market, that we must expand industry and remove trade barriers. They say that industrial expansion and the removal of trade barriers are the most effective measures to prevent the worst repercussions of such a recession as I have mentioned in the United States of America.

Comment on this

It would be a bad thing for us if we had any recession.

Comment on this

I mention these matters as matters worthy of consideration. I want to make it clear to the Minister and the House that I am not speaking now as an expert; I am speaking as a student. What will our policy be in the light of these possibilities? First and foremost, it must not be a haphazard policy. We cannot take chances. If the other European countries decide that the situation must be faced in a uniform way, have we considered that matter and have we decided to keep in step with them or what, in fact, have we decided to do? I think the House would welcome a statement from the Minister in that regard.

The economists say that we should have a selective programme of expansion and that we should adopt a policy such as that rather than haphazardly try to establish an industry here, buttress up an industry there or let an industry go out of existence somewhere else. The general feeling is that there are certain things that all of us can do. We must concentrate on basic industries, the products of which are necessary for any general expansion in production, and industries such ashousing, because it corresponds to the urgent needs of the population.

We must concentrate as far as we can on new industries such as synthetic fibres and things of that kind, that is, on absolutely new industries. We must do everything we can to improve the balance of payments with the dollar areas.

It seems to me that there should be a greater concentration on agricultural development and agricultural production because agriculture is the one industry capable of a truly enormous expansion and the products of that industry are vital from the point of view of enabling us to pay our way and from the point of view of providing essential foodstuffs for humanity.

We should concentrate also on such other industries as will supply the needs of our people and, if possible, leave a margin for export. Generally speaking, looking over the economic tables, we find that most countries in fact retain 90 per cent. of their production for their own use and export 10 per cent. There are, of course, variations.

A good deal has been said in relation to industry and the improvement in the balance of payments. I agree with what was decided when O.E.E.C. was set up: our economic policy should be increased production and full employment. The people who came together to found O.E.E.C. were of that opinion. I think the Government, statesmen and economists generally are agreed that our economic policy should be increased production and full employment. A restrictive financial policy does not assist so far as increased production and the maintenance of full employment are concerned because such a policy limits the demand for imported goods and thereby reduces imports. That, in turn, means reducing the possibility of exports from other countries. We cannot stand alone. If we help to reduce exports from other countries we thereby contribute to stagnation in production in these countries. That has been described as an attempt to export unemployment to other countries.

I agree that when we had inflationarytendencies of a harmful kind it was right to insist on financial stability and to provide safeguards against real inflation.

Comment on this

How could there be inflation when we have so many unemployed not producing?

Comment on this

I do not want to digress at the moment. I have dealt with that point on many occasions here and, as Deputy Hickey knows, if there are two Deputies who are in agreement on this I think they are Deputy Hickey and myself. Real inflation can be a great menace. While there is a danger of inflation, the present viewpoint amongst Western nations is that deflation is the greater evil now. Every one of the Western European nations associated with O.E.E.C. and the Council of Europe agree that all of them overdid the policy known as financial stability. As one speaker described it, most Western European countries have become internally financially stable, but all of them have become internally economically stagnant. That is rather interesting, because last year in the fifth report of O.E.E.C., leaving Western Germany out of the picture, Western European industrial improvement was only 1 per cent., whereas in America it was 8 per cent. There are certain figures of importance which illustrate the general effect on Western European countries of this policy of financial stability. Taking the 1948 level of production as 100, Western Europe had a production index which reached 136 by 1951, and only 137 by 1952. The U.S.S.R., taking 1948 as 100, had reached 171 by 1951, and 190 by 1952.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is that a case for slave labour?

Comment on this

That is more than any of us can say, I am sure.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Concentration camps.

Comment on this

The satellite countries, as they are called, taking their 1948 figure as 100, reached 187 by 1951 and 223 by 1952. So that there hasbeen developing in the Western European countries a position of economic stagnation, and that is attributed to this policy that was adopted in all the countries a couple of years back of what was known as financial stability.

Comment on this

In other words, you can starve the people and have financial stability.

Comment on this

You can, yes.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

It was adopted here, too.

Comment on this

I have said that we were one of the countries in the O.E.E.C.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Do you say that you are in favour of it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Had the Central Bank Report anything to do with it?

Comment on this

I think Deputies will have to listen to what I am saying. I would not talk on this matter if I did not think it vitally important.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

We all do.

Comment on this

I would not have gone to the trouble of collecting the data that I have collected if I did not think it was of some importance to the House and to the country.

Comment on this

I find it very interesting.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his efforts to bring about full employment —because I know and I think the House knows that that is his objective —must take into account the wisdom of those European organisations that have considered the matter in the light of developments. If I may say this— now that the Government have created what is termed financial stability and political stability——

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

At what cost?

Comment on this

Do not mind the cost.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I am not talking about political stability but financial stability.

Comment on this

Now that they have created financial and political stability, they are in a position to change over to the policy of full employment, and I think that might perhaps be described as a policy of giving to the people— that is, not just a section of the people but all the people—greater spending power.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Conversion number one.

Comment on this

No. I think Deputy O'Sullivan might have been a student of mine on this many years ago. There is an effort to create markets for this country in Germany. What market can we create for this country in Western Germany? From the industrial point of view, because of their strength in industrial production, Western Germany could swamp the rest of Europe with industrial goods. So that we have no market in Germany for industrial goods. We have no market in Germany for agricultural products because if anyone will refer to this report of the O.E.E.C. he will see the duties that are imposed on agricultural goods in Germany. I shall not go into this fully, but I would refer Deputies to the volume. In respect of bovine cattle, that is, animals for slaughter, there is a 20 per cent. ad valorem duty in Germany. There is nothing in England. For sheep or lambs, there is a 20 per cent. ad valorem duty in Germany; there is nothing in Britain. In the case of swine the duty is 20 per cent. in Germany, nothing in Britain. In the case of meat of bovine cattle—beef, veal— there is a duty of 20 per cent. in Germany and in Britain, 13 per cent.

Taking the list of agricultural products or things that can be made from agricultural products, there is obviously no market in Germany for us. No matter what anyone may say about all the eggs being in one basket, we are forced back to the position that our only market, with the exceptionof small items here, there and elsewhere, is Great Britain. In order to build up and cushion this country against economic danger in future we have, as a free people, to enter into the closest and friendliest trading relationship with Great Britain. I feel that that is vital and essential. I should wish it were otherwise. I should wish that markets were open in Germany, France, America or elsewhere, but the fact is that they are not and they are unlikely to be for some considerable time. All our efforts, therefore, ought to be concentrated on the extension of our agricultural production and of such selected industries as will help to provide employment and will be able to cater for our home market.

The general policy as agreed on by the different nations who form the O.E.E.C. was that tariff barriers, as we know them, should be lowered to a large extent and that there should be a considerable amount of free trade. It is only right to say that this country is almost on a level with the other countries in regard to this particular matter of liberalisation of trade, but the tendency is to increase liberalisation and, while we are able to bring about financial stability to some extent and to reduce the margin in regard to our trade, that is being brought about, not only in this country but in other countries, by an attempt to increase exports and an attempt, undoubtedly successful, to reduce imports. The effect of the reduction of imports, as I have already stated, is to create unemployment in another country. If we are co-operating as we should be co-operating in Western Europe, those trade barriers all round will have to be lowered and in the reasonably free exchange of goods the people as a whole will find prosperity that is at the moment denied them. The grave danger is that in the event of a recession or any threat to some of our industries, we immediately hit back by high duties or by tariffs or by even prohibition of imports. If we are going to play our part as part of this new European unit, then I think we will have to take the rough with the smooth and in the long runI think it will react to the general good of the people in this country.

Comment on this

Previous speakers on this Estimate have adverted to what is perhaps the most important item under the Minister's domination and that is tourism. It is probably one of our biggest earners and one which I am sure everybody is interested to see developed to maximum capacity. I share a fear expressed by previous speakers as to whether the methods at present adopted are best suited to extracting the maximum that can be gained from tourism. I am referring to the two boards set up under Government control at the present time. That was decided on as the wisest course and I hope it will be the wisest method but I cannot help feeling some sort of fear that there is a danger of overlapping.

The old Tourist Development Association, in my opinion, gave good service in this country although its efforts have been belittled and written down by all sorts of scribes including the Press. But having regard to the limited means at the disposal of the old association and to the time when they started to put Ireland on the map as a tourist centre, I think they are entitled to a good deal of admiration and praise for the efforts which, if not as good as they might have been, were at least reasonably successful.

They had very limited funds and were not subsidised by the Government. They had to draw funds from contributions by local authorities and personal contributions from private members and hoteliers and others in the country. But they were working with the people and from the people. They were drawn from the publicly elected representatives of the counties and from people directly and indirectly interested in tourism.

Another board has been set up which is not short of funds, nor is it beholden to anybody for its sustenance. It is subsidised liberally and I congratulate the Minister on that because I believe that the industry is worthy of big subsidies to bring back a big return. There is a fear in mymind, however, that An Bord Fáilte, because of being financially independent, may take that independence a little bit too far and feel that they are themselves not in touch with the ordinary man in the street and say: "We are not going to come to you with our cap in hand like the poor old Tourist Development Association; so we will go and draft out our own policy and our own programmes without consulting you or anybody else."

I would like to suggest that perhaps they are setting a headline in deciding the date of An Tóstal of 1954. If they are going to follow the headline that they set in 1953, it is not going to be good for tourism if they hold to that decision. The festival which originated this year was an experiment throughout this country and it had the warm and enthusiastic support of everybody. Everybody took it as an experiment, a national effort to expand tourist revenue and extend the tourist season. I am sure the main object of it was to encourage tourists to come here, although sometimes we might not be able to see the wood for the trees. We were apt to lose the original idea because of the way in which it was linked up with certain national fixtures. It was decided to have it early in the year, in the month of April, and we know what happened. Despite the people's efforts and the efforts of local committees, the weather was bad and the first Sunday was what you might call "a washout". I think it speaks very well for the local people that they came up again, notwithstanding the inclemency of the weather, and splendid efforts were made to put An Tóstal across on the first occasion it was held. But there was a feeling that there should be some consultation as to whether or not it was a wise time to hold the festival, and if we are going to have the festival again next year we might perhaps do something better in regard to the date. I have heard various expressions of opinion—not from my own county but outside it—that An Tóstal should at least be extended to the month of May.

Common sense indicates that that is a reasonable suggestion, because youcould not possibly expect to have a successful festival in April, close down for May and start the normal tourist season in June, running on into July, August, and possibly September. Are we going to expect that Americans will come from their own country to seek Ireland in the winter and spring, when there are always, as the saying goes, "twelve days from old March that run into the days of April?" You might have very inclement weather around that period and I think it is unreasonable to expect the people when they are going to go back to a hot period in America to come here at a time when they can only get the cold draughts of April and May.

I think it would be much more sound and sensible if consultations had taken place and if a majority decided against having An Tóstal in April—well, we should be bound by majority rule. But this committee said: "We will have An Tóstal on a certain date and you are to accept that and you must not question it." Already certain committees in the country are in revolt. I hope that they will be brought round to fall into line, but I think this dispute is a bad start-off. There should be consultation, and An Bord Fáilte have several agents in touch with these committees down the country, agents who went around to see these people on the first occasion of An Tóstal, and I think that An Bord Fáilte should show that they appreciated what these people did in 1953 by consulting them in respect of 1954.

I mention this to the Minister purely because of the fear I have that it may be taken as an indication not alone for An Tóstal, but also as an indication that An Bord Fáilte might be thinking of itself as a self-contained body with power to go out and carry out its own proposals. The old Tourist Development Association acted in conjunction with the public boards of the country and the hotel-keepers and whatever shortcomings they had were of a purely financial nature.

They were working in co-operation with the people as a whole. I hope that we are not going to persist in the date now fixed for An Tóstal, that at least some effort will be made to indicateto the authorities throughout the country who co-operated so loyally with An Bord Fáilte that they are not being slighted in this way and will be consulted for the fixing of dates of national events in future.

In connection with C.I.E., another big item in the Minister's programme, I want to express congratulations to C.I.E. for the courageous approach they are making to the problem of popularising rail travel, and to congratulate the Minister on the support he is giving them. They are making a brave effort to restore to the railways some of the passenger traffic lost by means of the buses and motor-cars in recent years. The old steam engine seems to be becoming obsolete, and if you are to get people back from the roads you must give them regular, fast, up-to-date modern services. That is being done by the company in no small way at the present time, and I believe that with the development of fast trains between big centres they are going to attract back people at present utilising their own motor-cars. Some of these people are already worried about using their cars because of the dangers of the traffic and of the difficulty of transacting business in Dublin with a motor-car. I know many people in the South who would gladly avail of rail services to save themselves the trouble of getting parking space in the City of Dublin and running the risk of getting tickets from the Garda Síochána when they come up from the country.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Do not give that excuse to the Guards in Dublin.

Comment on this

We can always say that to the Guards and get away with it sometimes. I do think that there is a big desire by a lot of people to get back on the rails if we had a railway service which would give them a reasonable opportunity of travelling up from the country and transacting their business instead of having to drive up and back again. The company has put on a splendid service to Cork and I am sure that the Lord Mayor is anxious to know that I am glad to see such a good service.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Dublin people might be more anxious about it.

Comment on this

There is a splendid service which gives people plenty of time to travel from Cork to Dublin and transact their business and get back to Cork that night. That should be a good incentive to many people, who have business to transact in Dublin and who have been coming up by motor-car, to get back on the rail. I want to make an appeal in that regard. In the old 1939 days, before the war, there was a good service between Cork and Dublin also and we in Limerick got a service connecting with that at Limerick Junction. This is a branch line of 22 miles with a very fine permanent way, and we are a city of 50,000 people who are fairly useful travellers when we get the chance. I am only asking C.I.E. to give us back the 1939 standard. I am not asking for any progress on 1939, when we left Limerick at 8.40 in the morning, joined up with the train from Cork to Dublin at the Junction, and were at Kingsbridge at ten minutes to 12. I found myself frequently on O'Connell Bridge before 12 o'clock. Now a good service has been given back coming between Cork and Dublin and I have had complaints from business people in the City of Limerick that we ought to at least go back to what we had in 1939 and have a connection from Limerick through the Junction to meet that train. It would only mean stopping at the Junction to pick up the Limerick contingent but it would be a desirable effort on the part of C.I.E. and I hope that they will do this. I have been approached by members of the chamber of commerce and different people in Limerick who say that the Cork fellows get away with murder and have got this very fine train.

I believe that what is being done by the company is praiseworthy and creditable and the only reason why I go into this thing is that I hope that they will give this connection. We cannot expect the company to provide services that are uneconomic, but I am satisfied that in this particular instance, where there is this fine main line which is a credit to the companyand to the country, we should at least get this connection from Limerick through the Junction and pick up the contingent from Limerick and give them a connection back to the Junction also. That would popularise travel with that city of mine and would prove itself economic for the country.

Speaking about the railway company, I would like also to refer to the goods end of the business. They have become the biggest sinners in the matter of heavy haulage on the main roads. The railway company, I suppose, had to move on to the main roads in competition with the other hauliers, but anybody using the road to-day will have to admit that if you take a return of the big heavy lorries you will find that C.I.E. are the biggest offenders. I hope that they will not be getting road-minded and forget that they were originally pioneers of the iron road. Their big double-trailers will cause considerable damage to the roads, which were never intended for such very heavy vehicle and goods traffic. If I had my way, all those six-ton lorries would go completely back to the railway and let the rail services deal with the heavy merchandise traffic. On the main roads between Cork, Limerick, Waterford and Dublin there is traffic from heavy vehicles which the roads cannot possibly stand up to and we have roads collapsing under the strain of these vehicles.

I believe that the railway company came out on the roads to meet the competition of their competitors, the hauliers, but they have now outstripped the others and are the biggest offenders themselves. They have got so inured to it that I have a fear that they will forget that they have railway lines with steam engines which could not be scrapped very readily and which could do a splendid job in moving heavy loads of live stock and goods. The vehicles I am speaking about are carrying live stock, two or three vehicles tied on to each other, and they are also carrying timber and girders 20, 30 or 40 feet long. Weights are very difficult to estimate but it has been alleged that on the roads to-day there are loads of 25, 26 and 27tons, and apart from the damage that they are doing to those roads on which money has been spent for a very long time, something must be done to divert this heavy traffic back to the rail in the interests of the protection and safety of life. C.I.E. should set a headline by trying to divert as much of it as they possibly can back to the railway. If they are getting on with their programme of dieselisation of the passenger services they could utilise the steam engines for this purpose, as they did for years and years before they ever came on to the roads, carrying goods from fairs and markets and hauling heavy goods for buildings and other industrial purposes. I would ask the Minister to put that before C.I.E. I fear that they are forgetting that they are railway people and I as an old railwayman am anxious to see that there should be more regard paid to the fact that they originated from the railway. I believe that they would be doing a good job for themselves and for the country as a whole by taking as much as possible of this heavy traffic back to the steel road and leaving the roads for the ordinary passenger and vehicular traffic.

I was glad to hear the Minister's statement in connection with the programme of the workshops of Inchicore and Limerick. On a recent occasion I was very pleased to have an opportunity of discussing the matter with the Minister, leading a deputation of the men. Up to that time there was unrest in the minds of the men and I want to thank the Minister publicly for the readiness with which he acceded to my request to meet a deputation of the men. They came representing 12 or 14 unions and the Minister was able to allay considerably the unrest that was in their minds.

It was a genuine fear, because a considerable number of men had lost their employment—highly skilled men who could get no similar employment in this country if they were to be knocked out of C.I.E. The sore point of it was that many of them who had gone from here to England are now engaged in the manufacture of rolling stock to beused by C.I.E., built by men who had served their time and learned their trade in Inchicore and could get no employment there. I think that the discussion between the men and the Minister on that occasion resulted in at least a certain amount of assurance that the position is pretty well safeguarded, and I want to thank the Minister for the generous way he received me and the members of the deputation. I made one statement to the Minister concluding that day and I would make it here again if he will convey it to C.I.E.—that they should make what they can and import what they cannot. They have a lot of facilities there and materials are available here in Ireland and they could make a lot of things that they now import, because apparently some big adviser tells them that they cannot get them here. We had evidence at that time that they were importing stuff which we could make at Inchicore. I only want to draw the Minister's attention to this with the idea that we should utilise such materials, and especially that more native timber could be utilised by C.I.E. than at present. They are importing plywoods of all kinds, and wooden panels, but notwithstanding the growth of steel vehicles and wagons a considerable amount of timber has still to be used, and we have a fine supply of native timber and could make all the pillars, doors and sheeting for the roofs and sides of the wagons. I would appeal to the Minister to draw attention to this because we were told by some officials of C.I.E. that they could not get enough native timber. I would ask the Minister to address himself to this point because it is in the national interest from the point of view of supporting the timber industry that we should utilise native timber and there are splendid facilities available for kiln-drying it. We should concentrate as far as possible on the utilisation of native timber.

I am very pleased in regard to the extensions that are taking place in rural electrification. It speaks well for the progressiveness and adaptability of our people in the rural areas that they are tumbling over each other in their anxiety to have electricity supplied totheir homesteads. We realise that the E.S.B. cannot possibly provide an electricity supply for everybody the moment they demand it. Then, again, there are people who refused it when they were offered it before and who are now anxious to get it. I must say that I think the E.S.B. are doing a reasonably good job in extending electricity supplies as fast as their resources permit them to do so.

There should be a little more elasticity on the part of the E.S.B. in regard to the zones where electricity is to be provided. The trouble is that a man outside a zone—even if he lives only a very short distance outside it—is not connected. The result of these zones is that there are bound to be dark pockets. It is obvious that at some time or other the people outside zones will have to get a supply of electricity and, for that reason, I think it might be better if there were not such cast-iron rigidity on the part of the E.S.B. in regard to the extension of the supply of electricity. There should be a bit of common sense and where one pole might mean the extension of electric light to perhaps, two or three houses, the pole should be erected and the people should not be left without their supply of electricity. Instead of having circular zones, I think the E.S.B. ought to have square zones and then we would not have these dark pockets to the same extent.

The E.S.B., being a semi-State body, ought to recognise another State body, that is, the labour exchange. Unfortunately, unemployment is rife in rural areas at present. When the E.S.B. come to a rural area and have employment to offer under the rural electrification scheme I think that, for the sake of harmony and equity, they ought to go to the labour exchange and give employment to those people whose names are on the list there and who have been longest signing on. I think that that should be done in respect of any scheme that might last as long, maybe, as two or three months. There is the grievance that a man may drive in from his farm in his horse and cart and obtain employment on the schemefrom the day it begins until it ends, whereas some of the men signing-on at the labour exchange are unable to get employment on the scheme. The position of these registered unemployed men is that if they do not look for work they will be struck off the register, and yet they are faced with that difficulty when a semi-State body comes along to their area and ignores the labour exchange. That procedure does not make for harmony and equity. The E.S.B. ought to do what any employer is expected to do. They should take the list from the employment exchange and give employment to the men whose names appear on that list, irrespective of their political affiliations, and bearing in mind only their commitments and family requirements.

I was interested in Deputy Cowan's contribution to this debate, though I must say that I got cold feet towards the end of it because of some of his observations. As a result of his international experience, he proceeded to prove that there is no market in America for anything we produce in this country. As far as I could judge, he based that opinion on the fact that the Americans would give only a two years' guarantee in respect of an airline agreement between Aer Rianta and Seaboard and Western Airlines. Deputy Cowan considers that there is no market for our produce in America. He then produced what I regard as the Doomsday Book—O.E.E.C. Report No. 5. I do not think that that volume was ever intended to be used in the way in which Deputy Cowan used it this evening. It is the Doomsday Book as far as I am concerned. He said, also, that there is no market in Germany for any of our agricultural goods, or the produce thereof. I had hoped from time to time that this Government or any Government of this country who were aiming at expanding our export markets would have some chance of success in fields other than the British market but Deputy Cowan tells us that we have only the British market. I am not in any way decrying the British market: I hope it will be expanded. At the same time, I hope the Minister will not get cold feet about seeking other markets inAmerica and Germany, and elsewhere, as a result of Deputy Cowan's oration here to-night. I would advise the Minister to forget what Deputy Cowan said and to seek new markets for anything we may have for export wherever he thinks suitable.

There is one point on which I definitely agree with Deputy Cowan, and that is that agriculture is our basic industry and that anything else must take second or third place to it. The Minister may not be directly responsible for agriculture but I look to him as the best and most fruitful source in the Government in relation to the provision of employment, whether the employment be of an agricultural or of an industrial nature. Therefore, even if industries are established in western and other areas, there is no room for complacency in view of the parlous condition of our basic industry, agriculture.

Between June, 1952, and June, 1953, we lost 22,000 workers from the land. That does not speak well for the development of exports whether they be to Germany, Britain, America or elsewhere because, in the main, I believe that our exports will develop from our agricultural industry. We must have a greater concentration and a greater loosening of the purse strings and a change of outlook on and attitude towards agriculture if we are to put that industry into a healthier position. A total of 441,000 farm workers were employed on the land in June, 1952, and that figure was reduced to 419,000 by June, 1953. This House cannot look complacently upon that decrease of 22,000 land workers in a period of 12 months because, when all is said and done, these workers are the most important people we have in this country. During the emergency, they were frequently lauded in this House and we were constantly reminded of their value to the State as the producers of the food for our people. We were told that these men stood between us and starvation. All their good work has now been forgotten in these times of peace and they are regarded merely as agricultural labourers. Some people call them by a less laudable name— spalpeens or something of the kind—but, to my mind, they are agricultural workers and producers of food and the loss of 22,000 of these means that they have gone off the land because there is nobody to employ them. Their conditions of employment were regulated by the Agricultural Wages Board, and whether that is a completely successful institution or not, I am not going to say, but their conditions having been regulated by this House to the extent of providing a weekly half-holiday for them, it is a matter not for the scoring of political points but of grave concern for this Parliament that, in 12 months, we have lost 22,000 workers from what is, and must continue to be our main industry. While it may not be directly the function of the Minister in his capacity as Minister for Industry and Commerce, I hope that he will take that message into his consultations with the Government and that some steps will be taken to improve a situation in which the lifeblood of the nation is being drained away as indicated by that loss.

Comment on this

This Department being so large and cumbersome, there is much to criticise, but criticism has been made of most of its activities and there is very little left to be said. The nation's success or failure depends solely on this Department and on the Minister who controls it. The Minister is an able man, but I would prefer to see him in charge of another Department, a Department of which the nation has very high hopes, the Department of Agriculture. So long as we have this Minister in charge of Industry and Commerce and trying to make a success of his Department, he is going to overwhelm the Minister for Agriculture. That is happening, with the result that the flight from the land over the past few years has been intensified and agriculture is falling into decay, and in a few short years we will be back to the ranch and the dog because the small man is being squeezed out. I give the countryman's point of view, not as a critic of high standing, but as one who lives in the country and sees what is going on.

Industrial development to a certain extent has done good, but the indiscriminate industrial development whichwe have all seen over quite a number of years has done an enormous amount of harm. This crazy competition between political Parties to see who will put up the most factories is one of the causes of the failure of our nation, because too many slipshod factories have been put up and have fallen down after a year or two. They are nearly always in the hands of aliens, of foreigners or semi-foreigners, who use them for the purpose of getting cheap and easy money. Many of them have got away with it, and it is time we had a review of our whole industrial position. We have had 30 years now and that is long enough to decide whether we can make a success of our industrial arm. In this respect, we have almost failed.

Outside of those industries which have been developed as by-products of agriculture, our industries are practically nothing more than assembly stations, which are of very little use to the country. I see them employing almost completely female labour at cheap wages and drawing people five, six and seven miles from the country to the larger towns, while people are emigrating from the over-populated towns. There should be direction and control in industry, and agriculture which is so important, as the key to our whole livelihood, should be controlled and directed so that if industries are started in urban centres, they will be started for the urban population.

I do not believe in people coming in from country areas, where there should be plenty of work at reasonably good wages, and, instead of these girls flocking in on bicycles nine miles to work in these factories, where they earn 50/- and £3 and in some cases £1 a week—scarcely enough to keep them in lipstick, rouge and the little things they need—there should be direction to ensure that if industries are started in big towns they will be started for the population there. The Minister should have some powers to ensure that people will not be drawn into them from the country areas.

I live in the centre of Ireland, andif we allow things to go on as they are going, we will have nothing but a few big towns, a monster city or two and a decayed countryside. I see houses empty to-day where there were 40 and 50 families 30 years ago. A few strong farmers have bought up the land, and any land left has been taken over by the Land Commission for division, but as the occupiers of small-holdings find it uneconomic to carry on, they are selling and getting out. That is a bad situation, and one which calls for a proper review of our industrial policy.

The Minister's Department should be divided up because he has too much in hands. He has Aer Lingus, C.I.E., and a hundred and one other responsibilities which he cannot control and direct, and I would prefer to see one Minister concentrating on industrial development on a proper, balanced basis. If we had such a Minister doing that work, he would be doing a big national service. During our fight for independence, one of the things we wanted was an industrial arm, but we never believed that that arm should be as strong as our agricultural arm, or that it should injure our agricultural arm. At present, it is doing great injury to it, in that it is strangling it. The way in which we are allowing a certain type of people to get control of it is having the effect of strangling agriculture. The costs we have to pay for machinery, together with lack of machinery and lack of credit, are strangling us. If I had proper machinery and capital at my disposal on my own holding, I could increase my output of everything by 100 per cent, and I am not a bit afraid or ashamed to say that; but, like everybody else in agriculture, I am strangled and crippled. If we look for credit, we cannot get it. We may get £50 or £100, but if we look for £500, we are not wanted in any bank or the Credit Corporation, with the result that we are left with half-developed farms.

If agriculture were allowed to develop and if industrial development were on an ordered basis and within reason, we would get somewhere. I do not believe in this mad craze of industrial development, with the Minister running all over the country openinglittle factories here and there, with all the publicity and propaganda that activity gets. The people are sick of it, because they see these factories started with a blare of trumpets and, in a few short years, they see men being let go and cheap female labour being brought in. Many of these girls employed in these factories would be far better off working in the country as domestic servants, getting the same money but with better living conditions and better training.

Instead of girls in the country staying where they should stay, we are bringing them into big centres to provide this cheap labour, with the result that when they are there for a couple of years, the devil will not get them back. They will not go back to the country to marry a farmer's son or an agricultural labourer, and, if they fail in the little country town, they go to Britain. What is the use of talking about industrial development when we see the countryside being stripped bare? We hear a lot of talk about starting industries in the West. I do not believe that many industries will be started in these areas and in my opinion you will have the same condition of affairs in the future as has always existed there. Why not give agriculture the same chance as manufacturing industries are getting? Look at the credit facilities placed at the disposal of the people who come in here from across the Border and foreign countries to start industries. We have seen millions poured into these industries in the last 30 years. Many of these millions have been simply washed down the drain with the result that our people are becoming sick and tired of all the talk about industrial development. The removal of the food subsidies was a blow from which the people will not recover for many years. It crippled many families, left them in hunger and misery and destroyed their hopes for the future.

C.I.E. has also been a costly failure over a number of years and I suggest that the time has now arrived when control over it should be tightened. We hear now that not alone millions, but tens of millions, are required toput it on its feet. I earnestly hope that when these tens of millions are pumped into it, it will get on its feet and that getting on its feet will not mean that it will trample on the feet of everybody else and strangle private enterprise. There is no use trying to run it in the slipshod way in which it has been operated in the past. Unless it is put on a proper foundation and unless the Minister and the trade unions come together to devise some proper system, it will continue to be a colossal failure. There is no use in paying two or three men £8 or £10 per week each merely for driving a lorry or sitting in it. When one of these lorries is sent out to take in a load of beet and you ask one of the crew to take a shovel in his hands when the lorry is being loaded, he is almost overcome by the shock. I say that is a criminal disgrace in a country such as this. Both the trade unions and the Minister will have to get together to hammer out some regulations whereby C.I.E. can be put on a self-supporting or a paying basis.

I would ask the Minister to concentrate on establishing industries which will be of a permanent character and which will stand the test of time. I do not believe in the setting-up of mere assembling plants. They are nothing more than Jewish "contraptions" started for the purpose of giving some foreigners an opportunity of acquiring easy money. It would be far better scrap these Jewish establishments in the City of Dublin. Dublin is becoming a colossus that is eating up the whole substance of the country and we are not making the slightest effort to curb that tendency. There should be real direction in this matter and people who are anxious to start industries should be told that there is plenty of room for these industries outside Dublin. They should be told to go to places like Mullingar, a big town in the centre of Ireland which has not benefited from the industrial development programme as it should. Mullingar was a garrison town in the British days and a very big amount of money was constantly in circulation there. Since the British garrison left in 1921, hardly anybody has made the slightest effort to see that Mullingarwas compensated for the loss involved in the fact that it is no longer a military depot. It is now a skeleton of a town when one would expect it to be the hub of industry in this country. I would appeal to the Minister to see that some industry is established there.

We must pay more attention to our towns and villages if we want to keep the people in the country. In the present condition of affairs, the country is completely off its balance and our nation has become as lopsided as it could be. While the war situation lasted, there was some excuse for that condition of affairs but the war situation no longer exists. The war situation provided the Minister with many reliefs. He was able to cover up many of our failures and much of the mishandling of money that took place. We are now facing a position in which we may have to meet keen competition from many other nations. Germany and Japan are on their feet again and are keen to secure world markets for their products. Where shall we stand if these people are able to produce better and cheaper articles and flood this country with them? What is going to happen our industries after all we have spent on them for the past 30 years? I doubt if we shall be able to stand the first blizzard that comes.

We are facing a dangerous situation. If we are not able to stand up to world competition, these people are not going to stop at our borders. They will if necessary flood this country with commodities sold at prices less than the cost of production. The Germans, as we know, are a great people with a great industrial tradition, people of an inventive turn of mind who can produce commodities at the lowest cost. There is no use in thinking that we can stand up to such competition. If our industries are not able to stand up to that blizzard, flop they go, with the result that many thousands more will be added to the unemployment list and emigration on a greater scale than was ever known before will ensue.

I believe that we should concentrate on building up the one industry in which we have excelled for thousands of years, namely, agriculture, and thatwe should help the rugged men on the soil. That is an industry that will stand the test of time. It has stood up to blizzard after blizzard for generations and has survived them. It is there for the picking-up and backing-up. I would much prefer to see the money that is being spent on fanciful schemes of industrial development that may well prove unproductive, devoted to the development of that industry which is our mainstay. Give us then a balanced economy and let the decentralisation of industry take place immediately.

I have heard some reasonable speeches during this debate. I heard one from Deputy Major de Valera, a balanced speech which I am sorry he did not make five or ten years ago. I also heard the speech of Deputy Cowan. As my friend Deputy Hickey said, it was horrifying to hear him tell us that there is nothing left to us but the British market and to get into it as quickly and as quietly as we could. There is the great patriot who travelled the world recently, telling us there is no hope for us anywhere. I say that we are at the cross roads at the present time. For the past 20 or 25 years we have been flinging money about indiscriminately in efforts at industrial developments. That money was taken out of Irish agriculture. Agriculture has had to bear the brunt of it and the cost of it, with the result that we have cleared men and women off the land and that we have left the farmer impoverished. We have built up a national debt of £100,000,000 on high falutin' nonsense, in a race between a few big Parties here to see who was best able to capture a few votes. That same race continues to-day. I am one of the old school who does not want a race of that kind to continue. I want to see an Ireland of which we can all be proud, an Ireland in which we can forget the past and look to the future with confidence. Let us be sane and sensible in our approach to these matters and even though we may have to consider them from a political standpoint on occasions, let our actions be above board.

There is one matter in regard to which I have to express strong criticism—Iam not criticising the Minister because I do not think he is responsible—and that is the importation of timber from Soviet Russia.

That was a national disgrace and those who imported it should bow their heads in shame: I do not care what sect they belong to. That timber was produced not only by the sweat but by the blood of their victims and their slaves. I ask the Minister to speak in condemnation of bringing in any of that timber in future. For hundreds of years we suffered persecution and got the sympathy of the world. Other people are suffering persecution to-day and we want to give them our sympathy. The right way to do that is to let those who are carrying on in this criminal way fend for themselves and get themselves out of the mess in which they are by not buying their timber. I do not believe the Minister is responsible. I believe there is more or less a free trade in regard to it. But I ask him to give a direction in regard to the matter and I hope that direction will be taken heed of. It is time we did something about it.

I could speak for weeks on this Estimate but I am not going to criticise the Minister because he is an able man with tons of ability and experience and a national record. But I am satisfied that he is too strong and too powerful for the Minister for Agriculture. In trying to make a success of his Department he is absolutely strangling agriculture. I ask the Taoiseach to exchange the two men and put the Minister for Industry and Commerce in charge of agriculture. I believe that if that happened and the Minister put the same effort into agriculture as he is putting into industry we would have a better balanced country. But as long as he goes on as he is going there is no hope for the country. We will have the national debt piling up, emigration and flight from the land and Dublin being built up.

I ask the Minister, in any industrial development in the future, to see that the industries are native to the soil and to cut out the assembly stations,because they are nothing more than that. They are a blister and a blight and they employ only cheap female labour. If we build up industries on a solid foundation which would be a real adjunct to agriculture we can be confident that we are on the right road. I ask the Minister to call a halt as the people are sick and tired of the position at present. They are tired of false promises and of the drift from the country year after year. At election times they are given promises which are afterwards broken. They hear of industries which are about to be started, but when the election is over there is not a word about them. I ask the Minister to give no more promises of that kind but to face the people with a real sense of duty and tell them that we cannot do it. I was at a by-election in Mayo a few years ago and in Ballina I heard the Minister state that he was going to give them a factory of which they could be proud: He said: "Not alone will I give it, but I am digging the foundations."

Comment on this

I did not say that, anyway.

Comment on this

All the people clapped and cheered and shouted "Hurrah" for the Minister. The foundations are still there but there is no factory. He slipped that across the people. I do not care whether you win or lose the election, but it is mean and unfair to the people. The people are of a simple and innocent type. They want the truth and they would think as much about you if you told them the truth, if you said you were not able to give a factory. Cut out this cheap stuff and face the country in a real manly way. We should contest our elections in a clean way and tell the people the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

Comment on this

I was very interested in the speech of Deputy Giles because I have a distinct recollection of a speech he made on the Vote for Industry and Commerce two years ago. He complained then that the establishment of industries in this country was taking labour away from agriculture.

Comment on this

Did I not say that to-day?

Comment on this

No. The reason the Deputy gave two years ago was that they were being paid more in industry than the farmer could pay them for work on the land.

Comment on this

That is in real industry.

Comment on this

It does not matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe should be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

He said then that the reason the people were leaving the land was that they were getting paid better in factories than they could possibly be paid on the land. This evening he was complaining that they were leaving the land to go to work in industry as cheap labour.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Surely common sense ought to tell the Deputy that if they are being paid worse wages and have worse conditions in factories than on the land they would not leave the land. On that previous occasion the Deputy also talked about the need for industrial development in this country. To-night he said we would be better off if we had no industries and relied entirely on agricultural operations, as was done hundreds of years ago, or thousands of years ago. The Deputy must understand that since then there has been a certain development and a better standard of living for people. The standard of living of the vast majority of the people in this country must be better than it was hundreds of years ago, or may I say, 30 years ago. The Deputy knows that himself. He knows from his own personal observation and experience that the vast majority of the people in the country to-day are much better off from the point of view of their standard of living than they were 30 years ago, when he was one of those heroic persons who were struggling to free this country from the foreign domination which was keeping the standard of living here at the lowest level. I saythe vast majority of the people are better off, and the Deputy knows it, not only in his own neighbourhood but in every part of the country.

I do not know whether what has been done over a comparatively few years is really appreciated. We were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that we had now reached or almost reached self-sufficiency in the production of cement. Not only is it a national benefit to the country that we no longer have to export goods in order to get the cash to pay for the cement which was previously imported but we are employing labour in the production of our own cement. We are able to be independent of outside conditions in continuing the building programme required for the better housing of the people and we can utilise that cement for the improvement of our roads, for the building of our factories and, at an economic saving in the balance of trade, for the welfare and improvement of the country as a whole.

When Deputy Giles talks about settling people in industry in the centre of the country, does he not agree that the Bog of Allen is not a desirable place to settle people, that the Bog of Allen is very useful at the moment in connection with our turf development? Does he not agree that since the Turf Board was set up and the Minister made it his business to find ways and means for the production of native fuel from our own turf resources, turf production has reached a position to-day that was undreamed of?

Comment on this

At a very heavy cost.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means by cost. Apparently Deputy Giles is one of those Deputies who believes it is better to import coal from England than to produce our own fuel.

Comment on this

I do not believe it.

Comment on this

If we are to produce our own fuel, pay our own people the labour costs involved and create the necessary machinery to do that, andthereby save exporting large sums of money to bring in coal previously used, surely to goodness that is a greater saving than anything that could be imagined? When you weigh that against whatever capital expenditure is involved in the development of the turf industry it is a cheaper thing for the nation to invest its own capital in developing the production of native fuel.

I heard a Deputy from the opposite side on many occasions kick up a row because we were not repatriating our capital sufficiently quickly to employ it in native industries. Now, when a limited amount of capital is repatriated and employed in the development of a native industry, there is an objection also.

Comment on this

There is no objection.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

We believe in native industry.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe should not be interrupted.

Comment on this

I do not understand what is wrong. It is quite obvious to a great number of thinking people, people with common sense and expert economists, that unless we aim at a balanced economy we cannot have a standard of living that is desirable and we can never achieve independence. To get a balanced economy we have to make a start somewhere and a very considerable start has been made and very considerable success has been achieved. A great number of our people are engaged in good industrial employment and it is not all centred in the City of Dublin.

I mentioned cement. We are to-day self-sufficient in regard to the production of cement. We have a sufficient quantity of cement produced in our country now to make us independent of whatever happens in the world. We can use the resources for our own purpose. We are employing our own money in that industry and paying the wages to our own people. We are also saving millions of pounds perannum which were previously spent on imported cement. That money is put back into circulation. Deputies know that if money is being put into circulation in a certain place it keeps giving employment.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The 10 per cent. bonus.

Comment on this

I will come to that and I will deal with the farmers' products, too. The more money we save from going abroad for commodities, essential or otherwise, which we can produce here the safer it is and our people will be better off.

Let us cast our minds back some 20 odd years and make a comparison. Our electricity undertaking has developed far beyond the original idea that was behind the establishment of what was then called the Shannon Scheme. Our electricity undertaking to-day is not dependent solely on water. We are producing electricity to-day from native fuel. We are also producing electricity by other means. It gives benefits and amenities not previously heard of or expected, not only to those engaged in industrial pursuits in the municipal areas but to the people in rural Ireland. Does Deputy Giles and the Deputy sitting in the front bench not agree that the large amount of money spent on the development of the E.S.B.'s operations brings amenities to the farming community which they are happy to have?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Oh, it is not a white elephant.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to argue that point I can do so. I deliberately stated that the operations of the electricity undertaking to-day are not confined to the Shannon Scheme. They have now developed to the stage at which native fuel is used. Electricity is now being brought to rural users and it will make production on the part of the rural community easier. The time will arrive when we will become more conscious of electricity, more conscious of how it is to be utilised and we will have all our people benefiting from electricity in their own homes in whatever way theywish to use it. The housewife on the farm to-day can have electricity, an electric iron, an ice box and lights all round the place.

Comment on this

It is a costly installation.

Comment on this

She will cease to be a woman concerned only with burdens. Previously, she had to do all her chores through physical effort. The Department of Industry and Commerce deserves some genuine credit for what has been achieved. When people talk about spending money it would be no harm for them to ask: "Who are reaping the benefits from what has been achieved?" Do the Deputies opposite wish these things to be destroyed? Do they want those things closed down? Do they want the cement factory closed down and the country reduced to importing the cement again? Do they want the Turf Board operations to cease and the country resort again almost entirely to the import of non-native fuel?

Comment on this

South African coal.

Comment on this

Let me tell the Deputy with the brain that works in reverse that I have nothing to be ashamed of in connection with anything I have done in regard to my activities here or outside. If the Deputy or his colleagues could have found that there was anything wrong in my business outside this House, I would soon be told about it. I am not an insurance agent.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We will deal with the Estimate.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is going to be allowed to make dirty personal remarks which he would not make outside this House it is about time he was told where to get off.

Comment on this

Imported fuel.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney will please restrain himself and allow Deputy Briscoe to proceed. I am just warning him in case there are any further interruptions of that kind.

Comment on this

The Deputy shouldbring in a rubber comforter or a bottle of milk.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Now let us get back to the Estimate.

Comment on this

I am prepared to argue the matter on a proper basis and I am not going to be stopped from doing so by people who are qualified for a place of residence other than here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not being stopped by anybody.

Comment on this

I want to come back to the Estimate. Do the Deputies who talk about the agricultural side of the activities of this country realise that the Government and the Minister for Industry and Commerce recognise the basic industry of this country is agriculture and that those who are engaged in agriculture should get the best out of agriculture and that the rest of the nation should get the best out of it as a result? That is why we have tanneries to-day.

That is why we have boot factories to-day. We are trying to develop the sale of cattle, of sheep and of pigs, but mainly of cattle, not on the hoof as was the normal procedure up to comparatively recently. We are now trying to use the raw material to give additional employment at home. We want to see as many food processing factories in the country as possible. We want to see the meat leaving the country in a processed form and not the cattle leaving the country on the hoof. We want to see the slaughtering of the cattle done here and additional employment given by using up the by-products. All these by-products, including the hides, can be used and can provide additional industries. By that method there can be additional savings as regards imports.

In the case of the agricultural industry we have a more valuable asset than any that I have mentioned so far. We have, for instance, hides, an internationally required commodity and leather which is an internationally required commodity. Some day, I hope, we shall reach the stage when we will not only be self-sufficient as regards our home requirements but we will have a surplus ofprocessed leather for export, thereby adding to our external trade and bringing us in additional benefits in the shape of earnings.

Do Deputies on the other side want all that stopped? Do they want a reversal of the wheel and a going back to what the position was here some years ago? I remember that, when we first started to manufacture boots and shoes for our own people at home and when we gave protection to the clothing and woollen industry we had all kinds of outcries against that policy.

Now it has become an accepted matter. When the Deputies opposite were over here during the three years of the Coalition Government one of the grievances which they loudly aired was, as they said, that mismanagement on the part of the Minister for Industry and Commerce had almost shut down the boot and shoe industry because of the fact that a great number of boots and shoes were allowed in on an extended quota. Suddenly, those who had opposed the idea of native industries became the standard bearers and defenders of them. Now that those same Deputies are on the opposite side again they have gone back to their opposition to the development of native industries.

With regard to clothing, there is one matter which I would ask the Minister to consider. I am informed that the protection given to persons engaged in the manufacture of clothing, mainly ladies' clothing and ladies' garments, is being defeated by cross-channel houses with branches here, in this way that they are bringing in cut-out materials, just sewing them together and so escaping, in some way, what is the intention of the Government and, if you like, of the Dáil.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Mac Fheórais is aware of it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There is evidence of it.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to consider that position, and see how he can shut that door as quicklyas possible, because there has been, in the last six or eight months, a considerable falling off in the employment given in this industry, due, I am told, to the fact that I have mentioned.

We have new industries going up from day to day. The Minister has announced that some 60 new industries have already been started in the last few years, and that there are some hundreds under consideration. We read in the newspapers to-day of the formal opening yesterday of another new industry in the cotton line. Nobody had ever heard, say 25 years ago, of anything here in the shape of a cotton industry, but now we have substantial and successful concerns operating in the country. I remember that when we here first started making nylon stocking there was great opposition to the idea of a native-produced nylon stocking.

It was argued that it could not be as fashionable, or as good, as the imported article, that it would not have the right colour or shade. I understand that the position to-day is this, that people in countries abroad, from which we had previously imported nylon stockings, are now very glad to get the Irish produced nylon stocking. They certainly regard it as equal to, if not better than, what they can get in their own countries.

Surely to goodness, we should be proud of the fact that, with no tradition in the case of some industries, we should have so quickly achieved perfection in all these lines of production. We should be proud of the fact, too, that our people are now getting articles, the manufacture of which is controlled at home. There can be no misrepresentation by manufacturers or distributors as regards the quality of the goods because of the fact that there is definite and immediate control at home. If people bring in goods from abroad the position is quite different, because of the difficulty of telling outside manufacturers what to do and how to do it, but when you have control of what is produced at home, then our people can get value for their money. That is what is happening now.

I said earlier that I could give a listof items which are now produced here but which previously had to be imported. I talked about cement, the turf industry, the tanneries, the food processing factories, boot and shoe manufacture, clothing manufacture and the cotton industries. We are self-sufficient in the case of many of these industries. In the case of the sweet and chocolate industry, we have reached a big stage of development, and, as I have said, we are hoping that there will be further development.

A Deputy on the front bench opposite asked me what about the 10 per cent. I do not know what he means by 10 per cent. Does he mean that certain industries and limited companies have been able to pay dividends of 10 per cent. to the persons who invested their capital so that these factories could be started? Is that what the Deputy means?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Plus a substantial bonus.

Comment on this

The Deputy first asked me about the 10 per cent. Now he is talking about a bonus. When I spoke on this on a previous occasion I thought that I had made myself clear, and that people would understand what 10 per cent. on invested capital means. It does not necessarily mean that those who have their money invested in an industry are getting a 10 per cent. profit on the retail price of each article that is sold. That may not be clear to the Deputy, whose name I cannot recall at the moment.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

That is a great gag lately—to forget a Deputy's name.

Comment on this

I was confusing the Deputy with the former Deputy Linehan. I often meet Deputy O'Sullivan outside. We get on quite well and we do not fight each other. Let me put the point to the Deputy in this way. Assume that I have £10,000 available to start a new industry. Assume that I invest that money in the industry and that over a number of years I get a 10 per cent. profit on my investment. Does the Deputythink that my total turnover is £10,000? Does he not realise that industries in this country turn over their capital many times in the year, and that if this industry turns over its capital, in the shape of turnover, 12 times in the year, there is only the equivalent of 1 per cent. marginal profit on the goods sold? If there is a turnover 12 times in the year, that person at the end ought to be able to get 10 or 12 per cent. I invite the Deputy to take any particular industry he likes that publishes its accounts, particularly those that are accused of being monopolies, and to examine the position for himself. I suggest that he should take Dunlops—a very important industry in Cork, and find out for himself what does that firm sell in the shape of a number of items—how many bicycle tyres, how many motor tyres, how many hot water bottles, how many sleeping blankets. I suggest to him that he should add them all up, get the total turnover and relate it to the amount of money that is distributed by way of a 6 or 7 per cent. dividend, and then find out for himself if the 10 per cent. dividend he talks about were withheld from the investors, how much could be taken off the retail price of each commodity sold by the firm. We will find it will be negligible, if anything at all.

It reminds me of the occasion when a campaign was being waged against me that I was the cause of oranges being dear. There was such a campaign that I had to go to the Department of Industry and Commerce, Prices Control Section, and explain my profit in the transaction. My profit was 2d. per case of 66 lb. of oranges, and the officer said: "If I take that off I cannot reduce the price. Why do you not have more profit so that I can do something about it?"

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Who is he?

Comment on this

When this campaign was going on oranges were being sold at 7d. or 8d. a lb. I am not interested in the business now and they are being sold at 1/6 a lb.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not seem to be very relevant.

Comment on this

It is relevant to this extent. I am trying to explain that if I were to import 100,000 cases of oranges in a season and got 2d. a case profit, I would have what some people would call a substantial sum of money —100,000 times 2d., about £800. I have just explained, however, if my 2d. were not there the people would not pay any less for their oranges. Apparently, nobody is to be given the benefit of his own ingenuity in organising a business, in getting it going, in risking whatever capital he may have in it or risking the capital of others who join with him. Apparently, he is to do the work for nothing. Deputy O'Sullivan, I am sure, will recognise that when a farmer produces a beast on his farm and raises it up to a two-year-old, if he can get £70 for the beast he is quite happy and doing well. Nobody knows what profit he has made on it.

Deputy Giles spoke about the farmers having to carry the load of taxation on their backs and said they were all in debt. I am told the farmers were never in as good a position as they are in to-day, that the vast bulk of deposits in our banks are held by farmers. Farmers are quite content and satisfied with the agricultural and industrial policy, and the higher prices remain the better they like it. The city people are complaining that certain agricultural commodities are on the high side. Would the farmers like that we should fix a margin, not only of the level of prices that they should charge for their produce but that we should also limit their profits? When it comes to taxation, most industrialists and most people earning a living which produces for them a fixed income will tell you that the incidence of taxation rests more heavily on people other than the agricultural community. They are not bearing on their shoulders an unreasonable burden of the costs that arise from the borrowing of money for the purposes of industrialisation.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I hope the new recruit is taking this in.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that anything should be done. I amjust answering in accordance with facts an unfair and untrue allegation which was made. Nobody suggests that the burden of taxation weighs more heavily on the agricultural community than it does on the industrial and fixed income classes. Everybody knows that the farming community pays income tax on the basis of the valuation of their farms not on their earnings. Deputy Giles need not tell me that the farmers have not been earning substantial profits over the last few years and nobody is more happy about it than I am.

Comment on this

They are getting big prices and paying big prices. They were as well off getting low prices and paying low prices.

Comment on this

I do not believe that Deputy Giles, if he examines what he has stated, will agree with himself.

Comment on this

I certainly would.

Comment on this

Not at all. The farmer must also take into consideration the staff he employs. If he wants things so cheap that he can buy cheap, he will have to pay cheap wages; if he can buy dear and sell dear, and if his costs can accordingly be higher, he can pay better wages to his workers and attract them more to the land, and at the same time get a better margin of profit for himself and a better standard of living for his own workers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It appears to me the Minister is getting praise and blame for a great many things for which he is not responsible.

Comment on this

I am not blaming the Minister. I am only praising him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not his responsibility.

Comment on this

I am trying to answer what was suggested by Deputy Giles when he was speaking and I do not wish to infringe the Rules of Order. I am also trying to answer a question by interjection on the part of Deputy O'Sullivan. Deputy O'Sullivan thinks that there will be industrial development at the proper scale if the right ofprofit-making is taken away from those who voluntarily enter into industrial undertakings. He believes they should not be allowed to get 10 per cent. on their investments. I suggest by the same argument the Minister for Industry and Commerce should see that not only manufacturers but distributors also should not be allowed to make more than a certain limited percentage. If we believe in private enterprise we have to see that there is sufficient incentive, and in time competition will regulate prices. If there is an unreasonable extortion from the public by people who may have a monopoly there is always a control there and such irregularities can always be dealt with and inquired into.

There was a question in the Dáil the other day about a very important industry, the glass bottle industry. The suggestion was that because export prices were at a lower level than those charged for the home consumer, there was something wrong. The Minister, I think, pointed out that if there was not this export at the lower level of prices there would be a smaller production at the glass bottle works with a consequent increase even over the present price. Of course, people not engaged in industry will not understand that because they do not want to understand it.

Comment on this

And unemployment as well.

Comment on this

I have asked those attacking industrial development to say frankly if they want all those people who have now been put into what one can call, over the last 20 years, new employment, to be put out of employment with, as Deputy Giles said, no alternative open to them other than going into agriculture. It is a free country. People can enter into any vocation they like themselves. The responsibility of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is to see that as many avenues as possible are open, so that people who have bents in different ways, who desire employment in different ways, can find that employment themselves and not be forced intoone single form of occupation at the lowest possible level of wage-earning possibilities and uncertainties in employment.

If Deputies reason with themselves, they will have to recognise that, first of all, a balanced economy is essential, that as far as possible the main industry should supply the raw materials for new industries, that other industries which we can develop and items in which we can become self-sufficient all tend to enrich the country rather than impoverish it, that the continuation of the export of capital to import the things we must make means only that we impoverish ourselves with an adverse trade balance, and finally that we will have to reckon with taking as little as we can because we have not the means to get more; and by employing the money internally to produce these things we thereby retain that money in the country for continuity of that process. If it is money that is built up in excess of the requirements of a particular line, it can be employed in other directions. Surely that is the right line of approach and the right line to take?

In development of industry, the Minister has more than just industrialists under his care. I think this Dáil ought by now to have recognised —and I am sure the Labour Deputies at least will admit that is so—that the Fianna Fáil Government and the present Minister were the first to recognise that the ordinary worker, the working man, engaged in industry was entitled to his share of the benefits that would accrue to the country as a result of his labour in that industry. That is why we had legislation passed in this House to ensure conditions of employment, minimum wages and working hours, and so forth. There is now on the stocks a new Bill in this connection, the Factories Bill, which also will have results of benefit in many respects to the employee in industries.

If we are to improve the position of our industrial worker, we must also see that he will be satisfied that when he enters an industry the industry has some hopes of continuity. No working man wants to get into a particularline of business and when that closes down go searching everywhere for another line of business. The only way there can be normal life assured to any industry is by ensuring that there can be profits made.

Now we come to the bonus certificates that Deputy O'Sullivan talked about. Reasonable, sensible industrialists do not pay out all the profits they make. They plough back their profits into their business, they add buildings, they buy new machinery, they carry larger stocks and they employ more people. They get a certain return for the additional money in the business, which they could have taken out. Because that money is ploughed back and left in the undertaking on the capital side, obviously they get what is called a bonus share. In other words, if the business could have paid out 12½ per cent. profit but only paid out 5 and denied the investor the balance of what would be his dividend, and if after a number of years that dividend rose up to be equal in amount to the original amount invested by the investor, surely he is entitled then to a receipt for his money in the shape of a bonus share, the scrip which gives him ownership of his share in that business? Is he not then entitled to his dividend on that invested money, just as much as he is entitled to it on his original investment? For example, he has £2,000 invested then in a company in which he previously had only £1,000 invested. We are told that the dividend given to him and the bonus share issued to him constitutes a crime against society. Who shouts about it? Not the people who understand it. Everybody engaged in industry, whether it is the worker or the investor, wants to see stability in industry—they want to see security not only for themselves but for their workers.

We have now in this country developed considerably in the shape of stability in industry, from the point of view particularly of employment. We now have a vast number of our undertakings concerned with provision for their employees in their old age. There was a time when a man worked as long as he could and then had tomake way for a younger person who could do more work than he could in his older years. To-day, the working man has not got the fear of old age that working men had 25 or 30 years ago.

I have only one point to ask the Minister about and I hope he will deal with it—whether here in the House or in his Department is immaterial. Something should be done to close whatever leak there is in the protection, particularly of those engaged in the ladies' side of the tailoring business.

I do not know whether it is worth while arguing any further. Deputy de Valera spoke on the profit side of business, the initiative that is necessary to get industry going. I do not know whether it is suggested that every industry should be nationalised or whether those which cannot be nationalised should be put out of existence because someone is going to make a profit. We cannot all get into the farming business, as there would not be enough farms to go around. We cannot get into each other's business, as there are only certain limited fields of activity.

Now that there has been a new development, through this new Act passed recently to direct industries into what are called the undeveloped areas, I hope the Act will show results and that new employment will be given there.

I hope the Minister will see his way soon to stop the import into this country of what are called souvenirs, which are sold mainly to visitors. I hope we will have souvenir manufacturing industries in different parts of the country. Someone may say the visitors will not get cheap souvenirs made in Czechoslavakia or Japan, but they will have to pay a little more. I believe they will have to pay a little more in the beginning, but I believe they will get a genuine Irish article of greater value—both intrinsic value and sentimental value. I hope the Minister will consider the point, small and all as it may seem, that there is the possibility of developing the production of souvenirs in different parts of the western seaboard, or in Donegal, for all I know.

There is the possibility of trade abroad. I heard Deputy Cowan talking about whiskey, in reference to some points made by Deputy McQuillan. I have a little knowledge and experience of drinking whiskey. I hope the Chair will not call me to order for making that reference to myself. I have taken whiskey at home and I have taken it abroad, and particularly in America. If we want to get trade in America, our whiskey will have to be one that meets the requirements of the palate of the American. I know that here at home I find it difficult to smoke American tobacco, but if I am in the United States for any period of time I find it equally difficult to smoke the Virginian type of tobacco that we smoke here. I have come to the conclusion that something atmospheric controls our taste. I believe we could manufacture brands here to suit the requirements of the American trade. That is particularly so in relation to the non-Irish in America whom we want to drink our whiskey, for instance, just as we want the American or the Canadian public generally to buy the goods that we produce for export. I do not know whether the new efforts to organise trade abroad will have the results we desire, but it is encouraging to know that the export of Irish homespuns and Irish tweed is developing on a large scale to America. I recently saw an American here in an Irish homespun suit and a raglan overcoat, made in America.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

And a Sinn Féin tie.

Comment on this

He had a tie with his own trade mark on it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

That was a Sinn Féin tie.

Comment on this

It was not. I was astonished at the magnificence of that particular suit and at the manner in which Irish tweed had been turned out by whatever process they have in America. This man is starting a trade here and he told me that if we could not give sufficient material, properlyshrunk, he might take it from occupied Ireland if the payment could be made in dollars to this part of the country. That is a trade we can develop. It will be a slow process. Until such time as we become self-sufficient in relation to home consumption and until such time as we have established a certain experience and tradition in the production of goods and reached a quality equal to, if not better than, anything previously imported we will not be able to seek alternative markets.

Consider the manufacture of cement: it is possible that in the not too distant future we may find ourselves with a surplus for export. It should be possible to find alternative markets for that export. I do not know how our prices will compare with the other exporting countries, but it will ultimately be possible for us to keep numbers of our people employed in this particular industry. That is true of many other commodities.

The Minister does not want praise. He does not want compliments. All he wants is an endorsement of the policy which he has fathered so successfully. He wants the people generally to endorse that policy. So long as we have people objecting and finding fault and raising doubts so long will we retard the development of industry here.

Deputy D.J. O'Sullivan drags in the 10 per cent. bonus shares and forgets that when the inter-Party Government came into office the public expected half the industrialists in the City of Dublin—I do not know about Cork—to be put into Mountjoy for excess profiteering. The public waited during the three years of the inter-Party Administration and not a single industrialist found himself in residence in Mountjoy for being a profiteer. But the people were promised that and they related that promise to the attacks made by the Government on the cost of living and so forth. They believed that once the profiteers were destroyed everything would be all right; certain industries would disappear because they were only there to keep certain individuals well-off.

Has not the time come now when we should recognise that the developmentof our industrial arm is not only essential, imperative and desirable but is actually taking place? Nothing can stem its growth. But we must make further progress and, in order that that progress may be made quickly, industrial development must have the support of the people and that policy must be endorsed publicly. Let us get on with the job that has been so well commenced and handled in the years that have gone and that is now going ahead at the same speed at which progress was being made in 1948 when Fianna Fáil left office.

I am glad the Minister is taking steps to ensure that the railways will ultimately pay their way and that they will not be coming here every year to the taxpayer for a subsidy. I am glad to know that there is hope that this annual subsidy will be reduced and eventually wiped out and that this concern will continue to provide employment on a large scale for our people.

Deputies who talk as Deputy Giles did here this evening should, I think, first of all make a speech to themselves in their own homes, and read that speech the next morning as if they were reading the Official Report; if they do that, I believe they will make many changes and we will not have all the things that are said here in the heat of the moment.

Deputy D.J. O'Sullivan will probably show me where I am all wrong in relation to the right of an investor in an industrial undertaking to make a reasonable margin of profit and one that will provide for reserves to cover contingencies. We do not want to have industry working on the basis of such a limited margin of profit that some unforeseen circumstance will cause that industry to close down and never reopen. Every industry must be encouraged to make reasonable provision to cover bad periods and assure a continuity so that it can in time improve its production in relation to quality, output and cost because that is the only way in which we will eventually bring prices down. I appeal to the House to endorse the Minister's policy.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In company with Deputy Larkin, I found the introductoryspeech made by the Minister this year somewhat drab. There was nothing in it of very great interest. It was too complacent in its tone. There was one statement which recalled the intense heat that was generated in the political scene a few years ago; the Minister bluntly stated that the imports of the inter-Party Government in its last year of office were intended for stockpiling and were necessitated by the disimprovement in the international situation. When one recalls the many loud charges made, one must be thankful that in such a short time such an influential member of the Government as the Tánaiste would make reference in the Dáil recanting these unfair and extreme charges.

Reviewing the contributions that have been made to this debate, one is struck by the prominence given to our premier industry, agriculture, by Deputies who are particularly interested in industry and who represent city constituencies. It is regrettable that these Deputies did not see the light some years ago. In their contributions to this debate they pay that well deserved tribute to agriculture. It is a pity that in recent years, when so many extreme charges were made in connection with the economic aspects of the country, recognition was not given to the possibilities in agriculture and the contribution that agriculture can make to the development of industry.

Is it not a pity that such a rake-off was made on every single section of our people in the course of the past few years as took from them as much money as possible for the State coffers and left so much less in their pockets to spend as they wished? If they had had that extra spending power possibly many Irish industries would be in a better position to-day. It appears from authoritative sources that we must look to the home market for the disposal of our products to a greater extent as years go by. It is admitted by all sides of the House that for future prosperity it is essential to increase exports. If the contribution which agriculture had to make and was capable of making had been recognisedearlier, we would be in a much better position to-day.

Our Ambassador in London states that the outlook has its hopeful aspects, one of which is the upward trend in the volume of Irish agricultural production, but that world prospects are uncertain and, in view of current changes in import and trading policies, it is not unlikely that the competitive strength of Irish exports may be called upon to face new and rigorous tests in the years immediately ahead. That is a statement which should receive proper consideration. I would impress upon the Minister and the Government that it is vitally important that the raw materials of agriculture should be made available at the lowest possible cost.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing agricultural policy, for which this Minister has no responsibility.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I am referring to the export returns, which indicate the preponderance of exports of agricultural goods, live stock and processed foodstuffs.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question could be raised more relevantly on the Estimate for Agriculture than on the Estimate for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

A Deputy on the Government side, Deputy Vision de Valera, expressed the view, for which I give him full credit, that in order to bring about improvement in industrial development we must get right back to the basis; fundamentally we must regard the problem as one of developing our Irish agriculture and agricultural economy. I would like to point out to that Deputy and to others the great contribution being made by agriculture at the moment which can be enhanced if the difficulties relating to the supply of raw materials at reasonable cost could be overcome.

In the course of the past year the proportion of our total exports represented by cattle exports was 24.8 percent. and by foodstuffs of animal origin, 27.8 per cent. These are formidable figures.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Again I would point out to the Deputy that the Minister in charge of this Estimate is not responsible for agricultural exports.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I am afraid I was following the line adopted by previous Deputies, more than one of whom spoke down to the agricultural community, telling them what they should do to improve exports.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not object to a reference to agriculture but a debate on the whole question of agriculture will not be allowed on this Estimate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

In deference to your ruling, I will refrain from going into further detail. The constituency I represent is proud of having made a great contribution to exports in recent times in the manufacture of chocolate crumb. This provides industrial employment under good conditions. It amounted to the considerable figure of £5,000,000 last year.

We should bring home to the Minister that we regard the lack of price control as the greatest neglect in the last two years. The failure of the Minister to maintain effective price control has had very serious repercussions on the cost of living and renders it impossible for ordinary people to secure satisfaction out of the money they earn in wages or the prices they obtain for their produce.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy indicate the particular items the price of which he wants controlled?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There was the dreadful impact of the removal of subsidies on the purchasing power of the ordinary people, in particular, the poorer sections.

Comment on this

That is not what I asked the Deputy. I asked him the particular items the price of which he wants controlled.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I do not know if Deputy MacCarthy has intervened inthe debate but I am sure his constituents of Cork City, whether they are employed or unemployed—and there is a tremendous number of them unemployed—could indicate to him their resentment of the profits that this Government are giving to the cigarette manufacturers, for instance.

Comment on this

I will answer for my constituents.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Sullivan is in possession.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Deputy posed a question. I would cite the increase given in the price of cigarettes to the manufacturers as just one item that comes to mind but there are many others. Deputy Briscoe, in company with Deputy Vivion de Valera, who made an ultra-Tory speech, made a case for certain profits for industrialists. These people are afforded certain monopolies and protection.

There is no doubt that over many years it has been necessary to give certain monopolies and protection to Irish industries to get on their feet but even the Tánaiste of late has expressed some note of doubt in his speeches in that respect. Even at this late hour he is inclined to demand of those people that they give better satisfaction.

I do not accept Deputy Briscoe's statement that everybody who pays a 10 per cent. bonus are all just living on the verge of bankruptcy and they are not all free of the charge of excess profits. There is one gentleman who comes to my mind who is happy in the amount of protection afforded in this country. He declared bankrupt in Britain, came to this country and his lovely home there was sold to discharge his debts, and within five years I heard him say he was in a position to go back and buy back his home, "but," he said, "they salted me. I had to pay much more than I got for it when it was first disposed of." I maintain there are men like him who are obtaining undue profits in this country and the people who are paying for it are the ordinary persons in the street, the man who has to go into the shop to buy the necessaries of life. It is possible there are other industriesin this country which are seriously affected by the charges that are made. We have this instance of the bottles that has been raised in this House. Deputy Briscoe came in again in defence of selling to the foreigner at lower prices than you charge the native industries.

These people are pulling the poor mouth. The Minister has indicated that this thing was investigated, but we have no evidence that the people in the trade, the people who were mulcted, were aware of that investigation or got an opportunity of giving evidence. I know from a member of a deputation of mineral water manufacturers who came to this company, that they were very rudely received and were told that 90 per cent. of the cost of the charge made to Irish distributors was attributable to labour and overhead expenses. It was then pointed out to that gentleman that at that rate they must be selling to the foreigners at at least 20 per cent. of a loss. He had no comeback on that, of course. It is inexcusable that Irish beer bottlers should have to compete with a Dutch firm bringing in their liquors into this country in Irish bottles, and this Dutch company getting that unfair advantage of an Irish bottle manufacturer selling to them at a cost so much lower. That, again, must be met by little companies throughout the country and, in the intense competition which exists in that line of business, where can these people make that money other than by keeping down wages or reducing staff? They cannot increase the price to the public. We think that is unfair and it is merely one of the matters that should be investigated thoroughly.

There are other matters which indeed need mention. Deputy de Valera, when he was contributing to this debate, referred to one of the subsidiary industries that would look to agriculture in the future to absorb what it would produce. That was in relation to fertilisers. I want to express a hope that any protection that may be afforded them and which they may very well deserve will not be reflected in undue charges to the consumers, who in turn have to markettheir goods in competitive markets abroad or else charge the Irish consumers the extra cost which they have to pay for these goods.

The question of the price of motor-cars in this country needs very close investigation. Surely the people who require small cars in the remote parts of this country or even in the towns and cities, and require them not as luxuries but in order to carry out their normal avocations, perhaps as rural clergymen, doctors or farmers requiring a conveyance to bring milk to the creamery—surely some benefit should be obtained for the public in that respect.

I would draw the Minister's attention to the exorbitant increase in insurance premiums this year in relation to the increases that arose out of the trifling increases in workmen's compensation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Minister have any responsibility for the increases in the insurance premiums?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister told me he made representations to the companies this year.

Comment on this

The Minister or the Tánaiste?

Comment on this

I said the Minister for Social Welfare.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

At any rate you replied to my question. That was one of the several impediments to increased production in the country, the fact that these overheads are unduly increased.

Comment on this

I see that the question of food prices is being avoided.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will make his own speech in his own way.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I am prepared to meet the Deputy anywhere, any time, on that subject, and if there is an increase in the cost of living it is attributable to one source and one source only. The Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

What is it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

To the abolition of the food subsidies and in the way it was done, having regard to the programme which the Government was elected to implement and which Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll included in his election address when he was returned for the City of Dublin.

It is customary to refer to tourism on this Estimate. Other Deputies have referred to it, and I will not labour the point, but there is a feeling down the country that no central committee, no matter how well informed and no matter how well intentioned, is entitled to override the local committees and those responsible for organising in the country. The Dublin committee would be better advised if they had accepted some of the advice in regard to the time of the year in which An Tóstal was organised.

I think, in reference to the development of the tourist industry, we should make better use of films to bring home to the people outside the shores of this country the scenery that exists here and the facilities that are available. We have paid lip service to the need for the establishment of a tourist industry but it is not any consideration for congratulation that in one of the premier resorts of this country four of the better hotels have closed completely for the winter months and completely dispersed their staffs. How they will be ready to meet the tourist season when it comes along I do not know. I think some credit should be given to worthy hoteliers who employ staffs all the year around and engage in little subsidiary industries in order to keep them employed. I think it is a matter for grave concern that a very important resort would be without a single hotel open for many months of the year.

As to the time of An Tóstal, I am informed by many Americans who travel that it was an impossible time for them last year. They could only travel when their schools were in recess and it is a point to be borne in mind by those responsible for the timing of these events.

In relation to expenditure it comes as something of a shock to people inthe country to know that in addition to the £2,500,000 C.I.E. are to get this year, the Minister mentioned—he just dropped it in as something not of very great importance but I understand we are to get details at a later stage—that C.I.E. are to get £10,500,000 more and that we are going to fund the debt now.

Comment on this

That is not so at all.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Many Deputies on the Government side, and even one of the senior Deputies on the Government side, expressed some concern as to the expenditure of that amount of money.

Comment on this

Who said that they were getting it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Deputy who said that was Deputy Vivion de Valera.

Comment on this

I know he said that, but who said that they were getting it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The term used by Deputy de Valera was "funding the debt", that it would appear as if we proposed to fund the debt. In relation to C.I.E., in common with other Deputies, I would pay tribute to those responsible for the dieselisation of certain lines in the country and the improvements in that respect. I would be glad to support Deputy Keyes. Quite off the schedule we had two stops on the run of the diesel train from Cork the other night, yet we arrived on time, so it may be possible to meet the very fair representation made by Deputy Keyes to afford facilities to Limerick travellers. The popularity of the system would also be considerably enhanced if we had a stop at Mallow. These trains are capable of very quick acceleration, and there is very little time involved in stopping. In that respect I noted with some interest the report in an evening paper that some garage facilities are to be provided for motorists who leave their cars at the terminus here at Kingsbridge. I would make a case to the Minister for giving similar facilities at Cork and otherstations. I think that would induce still more motorists to abandon the long drive to Dublin with all its dislocation and avail of the excellent service of the diesel trains.

Comment on this

It would mean that they would have to go back.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It appears that it would be completely futile to be forced by various obstructions put in your way to park your car for days on end in the open when so much accommodation could readily be made available.

Comment on this

Is not the matter being improved now? Is not something being done about it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I merely suggest still further improvements.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy should be very pleased with the facilities and these may help to facilitate Corkmen on their way home from Dublin. It is regrettable that even in the very short time that many of these changes have been made the more recent timetable would be so grossly out of date, and even taxi drivers here in Dublin cannot inform their fares as to which stations the various trains are leaving from. We were told that some Press announcements were made, but if they were, they were not very noticeable.

A number of Deputies have said that we cannot congratulate ourselves on the increased numbers in industrial employment while so many leave the land. During the year I have heard Deputies here in Dublin complain in relation to the difficulties of rehousing, etc., the influx of so many country people who fall as a rule on the corporation. Well, in relation to employment trends, I would say as representing a country constituency that it is a fact in relation to the South of Ireland that we are not affected by that surplus labour that exists in other parts of the country in rural areas. We have unemployment in our towns and we have the terrible flight from the landcontinually. We do not like to see so much attraction to people to leave employment on the land to go into the town, and there to be disillusioned and to chuck up and disappear over across the sea to England. That is happening all the time; and in addition to the 25,000 that we know leave the land and those who come to the cities I think it was inadvisable for the Department of Defence to induce men to leave agriculture.

I know that this is not within the competence of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and it may not be quite in order, but I would say in relation to the production drive that it is not a fair thing to come in and induce men who are fully competent, trained and skilled in their particular avocation of agriculture, to leave it by those inducements of so much free time, of what they might be at in their spare time, off at five o'clock, and all the rest of it. Those are fully-trained men, competent to handle modern machinery. Earlier on, Deputy Briscoe seemed to lay blame on the farming community, that it was their fault if they were not paying sufficient to maintain those people at home.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely that cannot be debated on this Estimate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I agree but I feel that it is necessary to reply to the allegation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of agricultural wages cannot be debated on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The point was made by Deputy Briscoe that the conditions must not be at all good when such occurs, but I would point out to him that it is not for the actual money that they leave. It is the bright lights and other attractions; and it is vital to the country's economy industrially and agriculturally that we would give prominence to the remote areas in the contribution that may be made by the people in increasing the production of things that may be initiated to providevery valuable exports and to give good employment to our people at home.

In relation to the provision of industries it has been rightly stated by several Deputies that those industries which provide goods necessary for our premier industry or the processing of agricultural goods would be the best industries to establish in this country. With that in view I had occasion to be very displeased in the course of the past twelve months with this Government—not with this Minister but with the Minister for Agriculture—in our failure to secure an excellent industry in my home place in the way of the dressed meat trade. I want to say that it was regrettable that the insistence of a Department official in applying every regulation he could possibly dig up to discourage the firm concerned was not at all good.

Comment on this

The only regulations they enforce are those requiring proper conditions for the killing and handling of meat.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Quite, I appreciate that; but the regulation which the officer enforced in this case was the requirement of a minimum capacity, and it was felt by the firm concerned that though they could come up to that after some period the supply of live stock in the country would not warrant the outlay of such an amount of money on such a large scale at the commencement—that perhaps after they had learnt to walk then they could do some more.

Comment on this

There are no such regulations.

Comment on this

What about the regulations requiring local money?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Yes. All the requirements relating to local money were forthcoming.

Comment on this

Is not that all the more reason why the Department should take every reasonable step to see that the money was not lost?

Comment on this

There are no regulations regarding the size of a factory. The regulations apply only to the conditions in which meat is prepared forsale. It is quite obvious that even a small concern could damage the reputation of the whole country.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Quite. I understand the need for the regulations. It was the interpretation of them that gave some concern.

Comment on this

If it is a small concern is there not the danger of the money being lost?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The point was this, that they wished to engage in a particular aspect of the industry and to go into the other ones later when the operatives would be better trained in that particular work; but at any rate, as a result of a conference which took place, those people left in absolute disgust. I would say that they are one of the biggest firms in Europe engaged in that trade and they have a market organised in seven countries. It was a distinct loss to the constituency I represent.

There was one other outlet for employment and full production that it would be possible for us to engage in in my constituency, in Mallow. The Minister may recall the unsuccessful effort made to establish an earthenware industry. The soil has been tested and found excellent. The statistics available in our geological office are not very informative. A private enthusiast made some utensils from this clay and he has a report from British Ceramics which is borne out by our own office that the clay is very good indeed. The next step was actually the firing. The idea of going into the making of utensils was abandoned when this company gave up the project but we continued with a view to filling the need of the country in relation to tiles required under the land project. We were aware of the great number of tiles which had to be imported from the Continent and from Northern Ireland. Further, we ascertained that the higher land project officers were very interested inasmuch as the only concern then in operation was situated on the East coast. A supply came in from the North and, later on, there were developments in Clare. We in the South consideredthat, from the point of view of reducing transport costs, it would be advisable to establish a kiln in the South and, with this very fine and approved deposit available at Mallow, we thought we could go ahead. I should be very glad to hear the Minister say, when he is replying to this debate, that an assured market exists for these tiles so that that industry can be provided for the locality in question. It will provide much needed employment and, at the same time, it will supply the domestic market. It seems ridiculous to be importing such a considerable quantity of these tiles when we can produce them ourselves. I realise that, generally, the unprecedented expansion in the use of clay tiles in this country was somewhat unexpected but now that it is established and that it is expected that there will be a market for years to come for these tiles it would be well if the Minister could assuage the doubts of the promoters of this idea so that they will be encouraged to resume where they left off some months ago.

Comment on this

Get the market figures.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is vital that whatever advances are made by the Department of Industry and Commerce will not be made at the expense of our premier industry, agriculture. That feeling is now shared by many more people than formerly, in view of the increasing contribution which agriculture is making to industry in relation to the processing of its products. The majority of our people being engaged in agriculture, it is important that that industry should be prosperous. If that condition can be brought about, then our Irish industrialists will find an excellent market for their products here in their own country.

Comment on this

When the Minister was introducing this Estimate he gave us to understand that the trade recession, through which this country has been going for the past few years, had passed. One must admit that there is a little improvement in conditions as compared with heretofore, but I do not think that anybody canbe complacent about the situation such as we find it to-day. Let us pause for a moment and consider the vast number of unemployed we still have in the country. These figures are not the true figures of the people who, one way or another, have been put out of employment since the Fianna Fáil Government returned to office. No matter what may be said to the contrary, we all know that vast numbers of our people are leaving this country, and are leaving from centres from which we do not want to see them go. They are leaving, particularly, from the West of Ireland and from the country districts. People who have been put out of employment in the local industries come up to Dublin to look for work and from then onwards it is the route across the Irish Sea. I cannot understand how a responsible Minister such as the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is also the Tánaiste and second-in-command in the Government, can make the statement that conditions are improving here when, in fact, everybody knows that things are very much as they have been during the past couple of years.

Let us take the building trade as an example. Not only in Dublin City but in every part of the country, there is a recession in the building trade. That recession in the building trade not only affects the workers engaged in the actual building work: it affects the workers in many other industries that are associated with the building trade. It affects, for instance, furniture factories. It is well known that our furniture factories are not receiving demands for materials sufficient to enable them to work full time on full production. Generally speaking, industry in this country is not flourishing and it is not flourishing because, no matter what anyone may say, the purchasing power of our people has been considerably reduced. Therein lies the secret of the trade recession and the sufferings that have been inflicted on our people over the past couple of years.

Industry has been given many opportunities in this country that other sectionsof the community did not get. Our industries have been built up under a protective tariff and under a system of quotas. One can quite realise that these steps may be necessary to help an industry at the beginning but I suggest that what has happened over the years here in the industrial sphere is that these industries which were set up under a protective tariff and under a system of quotas have declared, when the time came when one would expect that they would be able to stand on their own feet, that unless the protective tariffs and the quota system are maintained they cannot continue and will have to close down—and with their closing down the people whom they employed would be thrown out of work. That has not happened in all industries but it has happened in a good many cases in this country. I want to stress that that procedure does not make for good and sound economics. We are bringing people from the land into the towns to set up industries. It is sound to set up industries—always provided that these industries are able to exist by the sale of their goods in, as far as possible, an open market in this country. However, the point is that when we start these industries we throw the burden of these industries on the Irish people as a result of protective tariffs and quotas.

That is one of the reasons why things are so dear to the consuming public in this country. These industries are being started, and when the time comes when it is reasonable to tell the industrialists that they have had a good opportunity of starting their industry and that now they should be able to stand on their own feet and that the quota and tariff protection which they formerly enjoyed cannot be continued, what do a lot of them say, and what do a lot of them do? Even though some of them have made a considerable amount of money over a short period, they say: "If we do not get the protection of these tariffs and quotas, we will close down," and the position simply is that a vicious circle is being created. In the case of some industries—not all—which are working under these tariffs and quotas, theIrish people are paying for them and that, in large measure, is responsible for the fact that we are able to maintain in Ireland, in that part of the country over which we have jurisdiction, only in or about the same population as we had when we first got freedom. That makes us think that there is something wrong with the economic fabric.

We have brought into industry, so far as I can get the figures, probably 100,000 more people in the past 20 years than were in industry up to then, but, as against that, we have taken the same number of people off the land. I do not want to refer too much to agriculture, but the agricultural industry is paying for itself and the point I want to make is that our industries are not always paying for themselves on a free and open market. They are working behind a protective wall and that situation, which is growing, is a situation which we shall have to face sooner or later. If we are to keep our own people at home and employ them here, as they are entitled to be employed, we will have to give up pampering industry and will have to put industry in a position in which it is able to pay for itself.

The industrialists are certainly making profits, but there is another side of the story I want to argue on their behalf. I have not got a great lot of sympathy with the industrialists, except those who are working on an open market and competing with industry in other countries, such as the two industries the Minister knows of in Wexford. These industries are working successfully without any protection, tariff or assistance from the State and they are justifying their existence. Some industries, as I say, are making big profits and they maintain that these profits-this is the argument I have listened to from Deputies on every side-have to be ploughed back into the industry again. That may be, but I do not think it is necessary that they should be enabled to make the enormous profits they are making in some cases.

I am not an expert on industry, but I know that in most other countriesindustry is allowed a substantial rebate in respect of the depreciation of machinery. It stands to reason that there have to be renewals of machinery from time to time, but in this country many of them have complained that they do not get the benefits that other countries get and that much of their profits—I am speaking now of the decent industries that are paying their way—is taken from them in taxation and that they are not allowed this remission. That is a short-sighted policy. If an industry is paying its way, it is a very foolish thing to tax it at the source and not give it an opportunity of establishing itself by replacing machinery and putting itself on a better footing to produce an article for the consuming public more economically and to expand its employment.

The fact that we have set up a body —C.T.T. I think it is called—to look for export markets seems to me to indicate that what has really happened here is that some industries which were able to pay their way well by producing goods for domestic consumption have found that there is a falling off in the demand for domestic goods. That is one of the reasons why this organisation has been set up to seek export markets. So far as I know from reading the Minister's statement, this body is functioning at the moment looking for markets in the dollar world and I should like the Minister to give us an indication as to what he believes the prospects are for markets in that area and what the principal exports to it are likely to be. Whiskey was mentioned by Deputy McQuillan but, so far as I know, our principal exports to the dollar area consist of bloodstock, wool and dressed meat products.

Comment on this

Donegal tweeds.

Comment on this

Yes, thanks to Deputy Dillon when he was in the previous Government.

Comment on this

No thanks to him —they are doing better now than ever before.

Comment on this

Yes, but he started it.

Comment on this

That is news even to me.

Comment on this

Had he not to peddle them round the world to sell them?

Comment on this

It was he started them in America. Deputies can laugh if they like, but that is what happened. I should like the Minister to give us an indication of what the prospects are for the dressed meat trade, because it seems to me from what I hear, the market has not come up to the expectations held in regard to it in earlier days. The Minister has made a good many trips from time to time with a view to expanding Irish industry, and I am not personally criticising him in that regard. If I thought that by travelling to different parts of the world the Minister could expand our industry, there would not be very much harm in it.

He seems to have been interested in trade with Germany and I think he has made a couple of trips to Germany seeking markets there. I know we import quite a number of goods from Germany. We import motor-cars and farm machinery and we seem to be very fond latterly of getting the Germans to build our ships. I should like the Minister to give us some idea of the return we will get in the matter of exports to Germany and the Continent of Europe as a whole. I am speaking now of the countries west of the Iron Curtain. I shall have something to say about east of the Iron Curtain presently. I do not know if I am in order in raising this, but there has been a certain amount of complaint in my part of the country about some of the farm machinery which has come in from certain parts of Europe and I should also like to know why—I asked the Minister a parliamentary question about this—when Irish Shipping, Limited, require ships—modern ships in the neighbourhood of 1,200 tons—we ordered these ships from German yards.

Comment on this

Irish Shipping, Limited, has not bought any ships from Germany.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister aquestion recently about a ship that was delivered here from a German shipyard.

Comment on this

Not to Irish Shipping.

Comment on this

To an Irish company.

Comment on this

To a private company.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Minister have any responsibility for that?

Comment on this

I imagine the Minister would have responsibility.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If a private company purchases a ship how would the Minister have any responsibility for that transaction?

Comment on this

The Government would be responsible in some way. If I cannot place the onus on the Minister, I must ask where can one place it? The Government would be responsible for issuing credit for the purchase of the ship, whether for a private or a public company. The point I want to stress is that an Irish company recently ordered in Germany a ship of a capacity of 1,200 tons or thereabouts. Why could we not have that ship built in our own shipyards? Are our own people so fully employed that we have to go abroad to have our ships built? We have quite a good shipyard in the City of Dublin and a number of smaller yards capable of building smaller vessels in other parts of the country. Why should it be necessary to have ships built abroad when it is possible to have them built in our own shipyards? I know it would have been possible to build this ship here because I addressed that question to the Minister and he said it was. I think it is quite unnecessary to have ships built abroad so long as we can build them at home.

I grant that so far as bigger ships are concerned, say from 5,000 to 10,000 tons capacity, it may be necessary to procure them from foreign shipyards, but, so far as small ships of the coast-trading type or even some ocean going ships are concerned, I feel that we should build these ships in our own shipyards and employ our own people.If we have not got the wherewithal to build such ships, I suggest that the Minister should consult his experts and use his influence to expand these shipyards. In his opening speech the Minister referred to the fact that it was the intention greatly to expand Irish shipping. I think it is very necessary that we should expand our shipping but let us build our ships in our own yards and go to other people only when, all things being equal, we cannot build them at home.

The Minister dealt pretty extensively with the subject of mineral exploration. So far as I could gather from his speech the total sum available for mineral exploration here is £85,000 per annum. That appears to have been earmarked for the mines in Avoca. I do not know what the position in Avoca exactly is but the Minister painted a very rosy picture of it during the byelection in Wicklow. I was one of the audience listening to his speech when he promised great things for Avoca. It seems to me that exploration—I do not know if that is the correct term—has been going on in Avoca for a considerable period and the House would now like to hear from the Minister what the potentialities in Avoca are. Is Avoca going to be able to pay its way—in other words, what deposits have been proven there? I think I am right in saying that this exploration work has been going on for a considerable period and that there must be other mineral deposits in this country. There must be other mines which have proved deposits of a certain amount of minerals and metals and which are entitled to some little assistance as well. Why should we put all our eggs in one basket? After all, we are very short of raw materials in Ireland and I do not think I can congratulate the Minister on the advances we are making in the mineral arena.

We import £200,000 worth of salt per annum. So far as I know no deposits of salt have been found in this country. I should like to hear from the Minister if such deposits are being sought. I understand from a private source that there is a possibility that deposits exist along the borders of the State inCavan and Monaghan. After all, there are salt deposits in practically the same latitude in Britain and is it not conceivable that they might be found here? Would it not be worth while spending some of this £85,000 in prospecting to see if you could find salt here? If it were found, we could start an industry for the products of which we would have a domestic market of £200,000 per annum available. I am sure we could mine it as cheaply as any other country. Of the salt we import, some quantity only comes from Great Britain and the rest we obtain from countries behind the Iron Curtain. If we found salt deposits here, we could develop them and provide useful employment for a large number of people.

Coming to C.I.E., I was not one of the Deputies who actually criticised the introduction of the oil-burning diesel units but I did raise the question that if an emergency were to arise or if a world conflagration were suddenly to develop—which God forbid; I hope we shall never see that again-we might have considerable difficulty in procuring oil. I also pointed out that a considerable quantity of the oil we use comes from dollar areas and that there might be some difficulty in purchasing it. Of course the situation at the moment in regard to the dollar area is easing somewhat and, so far as the Near East is concerned, it is still outside Soviet control although fairly close to areas which are under Soviet control. I should like to suggest to the Minister again that he should tell C.I.E. that if they intend to use diesel units on any extensive scale they should lay in considerable quantities of diesel oil in storage. I should like to know from the Minister if any steps in that direction have been taken.

There are advantages and disadvantages associated with the use of diesel units. It appears that down in my part of the country, on the main line to Wexford, over which tourist traffic is pretty extensive, these diesel units have one disadvantage in that they are not able to carry as many passengers as an ordinary train. Many of us were under the impression that if a diesel unit became overloaded, itwas just a question of adding another carriage, but the difficulty with the diesel unit appears to be that if they have not got sufficient room to carry all the passengers offering, you cannot add another carriage because their horse power, having regard to the gradients which they have to meet, is sufficient only to pull that particular unit and, therefore, if you wish to carry more passengers you have to add a complete new unit. That seems to be the only disadvantage in a diesel unit. I certainly think they have helped in turning people back to the railways. They are a cleaner and a speedier way of travel than the ordinary steam train.

With regard to the financial circumstancesof C.I.E., as I read the Minister's statement, the undertaking is still being run at a loss of £1,500,000 per year. The taxpayer has to meet that loss. We have no real proof from the Minister's statement that it will be possible to wipe out that loss. He merely stated that those who were in consultation with C.I.E. experts consider that they will be able to abolish this running loss by the purchase of new rolling stock and machinery. I move to report progress.

Comment on this