Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1953—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–143 of 272. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 24 of 1953 ›
As a result of the attitude adopted by the Minister during the course of this debate, Deputies have experienced a certain amount of difficulty in making their speeches and in keeping within the Rules of Order so far as the subjects to which they can refer are concerned.
In my view the Title of this Bill— the Supplies and Services Bill—is a misnomer because this Bill gives vast powers to various Ministers of the Government. Its terms are entirely dictatorial. I believe that the proper Title for this Bill would be the Public Safety Act. Its terms and the powers it gives are such that it is entirely similar to that old Act of the British Parliament which was known as D.O.R.A.—the Defence of the Realm Act.
One would expect, having regard to the fact that eight years have now passed since the end of the Second World War, that there should no longer be any necessity for the introduction of a Bill of this nature—a Bill which gives power to the Government, if they so desire, to extend this Dáil, for instance, for a period of 50 years or any number of years and, in fact, to prevent certain Deputies from entering Dáil Éireann at all. There is no limit to the powers contained in this Bill.
Comment on this
It was a very astute move on the part of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to give this Bill its present Title—Supplies and Services Bill—instead of its proper Title, the Public Safety Act.
Comment on this
We cannot prevent the Deputy from attending the Dáil. He would have to be a service essential to the community before he would come under this Bill.
Comment on this
Under this Bill, the Minister can prevent the import of any commodity, even a very essential commodity. He can also prevent the export of commodities from this country. In fact, there is nothing that cannot be done by the Government under this Bill, which is absolutely autocratic in its terms. I understand, however, that in his opening speech the Minister stated that it would definitely be ended in the year 1955.
If we refer to this Bill as the Supplies and Services Bill, and if the Minister exercises his full powers under it, something has certainly been done by which the supplies available —supplies of all kinds: foodstuffs, clothing and everything else—have reached such a high price to-day that people in our cities and towns, in particular—working men and working women—find it absolutely impossible to live in accordance with the decent standard of living that they would expect a Government to maintain in this country. The position is so bad that many children are deprived of foods which are essential to build them up in a proper state of health and yet the Minister does not seem to have exercised any of his powers to keep down the cost of living.
The inter-Party Government set up a Prices Advisory Body to investigate any claims to increase the prices of commodities. Since the present Minister took office, we have not ever been told that he had recourse to that body in connection with the prices of essential foodstuffs or other commodities. The position in this State to-day is that, between high prices and high taxation, there is a good deal of unemployment—and where there isunemployment there will be emigration.
While the Minister possesses powers to alleviate the distress which exists in many sections of our community, he is not doing his duty in striving to keep prices at a reasonable level and to reduce the unemployment figure which affects a vast number of our people.
Comment on this
Last week, the Minister interrupted Deputy Blowick to say that he longed for constructive proposals. I need hardly say that I do not believe him. Nevertheless, I think it desirable that, when he makes that bluff, it should be called. The first thing to which I wish to direct the attention of the House in connection with this Bill is that, as a result of the constructive work done by the inter-Party Government, without very much help from the Minister or his colleagues, who did all in their power to harass and confuse while they were in opposition, the exports of this country, as a result of the prudent policy pursued by our Government, bid fair in this year to exceed £105,000,000 sterling, after eliminating the Minister's valuable contribution to our external trade of sweetened fat and minced meat which amounted last year to something like £4,000,000. They have vanished like snow in summer sunshine, but the agricultural policy of the inter-Party Government now coming to fruition not only takes up that entire deficit of £4,000,000 but promises to provide a total export value of £105,000,000 sterling, or perhaps a little more, the greatest figure ever recorded in the economic history of this country.
I think the House ought to dwell on that, because, if this event were not now transpiring, consequent on the work we did despite the unrelenting opposition of the present Government, this country would be bust wide open. When Fianna Fáil left office in 1947, the total value of our exports was of the order of £70,000,000 sterling. It now bids fair to reach £105,000,000 sterling, and if you study the exports, you will find that they are not sweetened fats, not minced meat, noneof the other exotic products sponsored by the Department of Industry and Commerce, but cattle, meat, sheep, pigs, bacon and pork, the despised products of the land of Ireland and of those farmers who Fianna Fáil had been concerned to say for the past five years are lazy, incompetent, old-fashioned and unworthy of continued occupancy of the land. When will Fianna Fáil wake up to this fact, that the performance of the farmers on the land of Ireland since 1948 outshines the performance of any agricultural community in Europe?
Comment on this
I do not want to raise the question of relevancy again, but this seems to me to be a terribly long way from the Bill.
Comment on this
I am giving Deputy Dillon an opportunity of relating it. I am expecting and hoping that he will endeavour to do so.
Comment on this
I understand that the Minister wants constructive proposals. I propose to give them to him.
Comment on this
And supplies and services have been interpreted by the courts to mean anything. I made Orders myself under the Act of the most extraordinary character.
Comment on this
They are very well delimited in the original Act and this is only a continuation of the original Act. We cannot discuss what was agreed on in that Act; we can only say whether we should continue these powers to the Minister.
Comment on this
Powers that we all of us exercised, when Ministers, and which the present Ministers exercise now.
Comment on this
I am only interestedin the powers the Bill proposes to give. I do not know what was exercised by any Minister.
Comment on this
And what we did under this Bill in the years in which it was in operation. God knows there were some strange things done under it, too, by our predecessors in office. I am trying to point out that all the things that were done made very little contribution to the economic welfare of this State in so far as they were done by the Minister or those for whom he is responsible, whereas the agricultural community of this country bore, are bearing and will continue to bear, the whole burden. It is on that front that constructive proposals can be made if there is any hope for the economic salvation of this country at all.
I am going to make three proposals and I will give 6 to 4 now to anybody that they will all be categorically rejected by the Minister in his concluding speech and will all be put into operation within the next five years. I will give 2 to 1 on that proposition to any amount and I bet there will be no takers, in the Fianna Fáil Party in any case, because generally any suggestion made from these benches they try to adopt in their own flat-footed way as soon as they hope the public have forgotten whence the suggestion originally came.
One of the purposes for which powers were granted under the Act was to control the cost of living, and I suggest a method now whereby 6d. per lb., and quite possibly 1/- per lb., can be taken off the price of tea within the next month, that is by declaring, as of to-morrow, that there is no control on the importation of tea.
Comment on this
Do not talk to me. I have forgotten more about tea than the Minister will ever know. I could buy tea to-day 7d. or 8d. a lb. cheaper if there were no control than we are at present paying.
Comment on this
Let the Minister take off control for a month and we will give him a demonstration that will take the breath out of him.
Comment on this
Take the control off for one month—there is no difficulty about taking it off for a month or two months and putting it back again, if the event does not transpire as I declare it will —and the price of tea can be reduced by at least 6d. per lb. My constructive proposal is: Take it off altogether. Why have we got it on? Why are the people of this country being constrained to pay 6d. per lb. more than they ought to pay for it? I will tell you, because I happen to know. A certain small group of tea wholesalers in this country came to know that the Minister had a bee in his bonnet and that that bee was that at the beginning of the European war, supplies of tea from London were suspended. The Minister's quarrel, however, is with the then British Government, which has long ceased to exist, and the existing British Government dislikes it more than the Minister dislikes either of them. He is quite resolved that he is going to carry on that quarrel, not with the British Government but with the wholesalers of tea in the City of London. They never wanted to cut off supplies of tea from Ireland. The more tea they sell, the more money they make.
Comment on this
Oh, go fish. Why should a wholesaler refuse to supply his customers? The British wholesalers did not rise up to wrap the green flaground them and then proceed to cut off their noses to spite their faces by refusing to supply tea to their customers. They would sell tea to Johnny Dog if they were paid, but they were told by the British Government not to sell any more tea to Ireland because the British Government wanted to keep all the tea for their own people. It is now rather late to start disputing the equity of that arrangement made in 1939 or 1940. If there was to be any argument about it, it could not go on because the other party to the argument is gone and they can never come back. That arrangement was made by a Government which was a coalition of Labour and Conservatives, and that you will never see again, in the Tánaiste's lifetime or mine. There is no use in arguing the past when the other party to the argument is dead or liquidated, gone like a puff of air. He cannot be found; he will never be found; and you are simply arguing with a blank wall.
Why should our people be asked to pay 6d. per lb. more for tea in order to wreak vengeance on something that does not exist? That is just draft. That would not work and the bee would not be allowed to buzz very long in the Tánaiste's bonnet if there was not a very powerful vested interest in Ireland that suddenly woke up to the fact that the bee in the Minister's bonnet was pure gold for them and then emerged this brilliant plan by which our tea was bought in Colombo and Calcutta, and only a limited number of persons would be allowed to purchase it—a few large wholesalers in Cork, Limerick and Waterford.
Once they get the wholesale trade of this country sewed up in a bag, there will be no agreement. But there will be a weekly luncheon at which current prices of Orange Pekoe, B.O.P., Fannings and Ceylons will be discussed in the most gentle way. There emerges this astonishing consequence that when you write to 15 wholesalers asking for samples, there will not be one-eighth of a penny per lb. between the samples forwarded, and if you do not like that, you can lump it. If you do not buy from them you will have no tea to sell.
It will be a great compliment to get any tea at all from them—loose tea. There will come a day when you will be told that the health officers wish all tea to be packeted before it is sent to a shop in the backwoods—shops which have no right to expect to have the same accommodation as shops in Ballsbridge or Rathmines. Of course, you will be told that the price for packing tea has gone up. It will be made up in a red packet, a blue packet and a green packet, all at different prices, and if you do not like it you can lump it. You will be told that your customers can drink light beer if they will not drink tea from a packet, and if they will not drink light beer you can put up your shutters. That is all there is to it.
You will discover this further amazing fact: that wholesaler A has packed his tea in red packages, white packages and blue packages at three different prices, and wholesaler B has packets in green, white and orange at three different prices and they are all at the same three prices. You can have any colour you like but there will be three prices and you will pay these prices or you can lump it or make your customers drink light beer, and if you cannot make them drink light beer you can put up your shutters. Then they tell the public that they deprecate this interference with the free practice of their trade and that they exhort the Minister to withdraw control. Did you ever see two fellows fighting at a fair? "Let me at him; hold me back!" The 15 wholesalers protest against this restraint and speak of delicate representations to the Minister when he proposes to consider the whole question but if he shows the slightest inclination to relinquish his control on tea they get a terrible shock. There was a panic a month ago when there was some talk of the Minister dropping control. The Minister said: "Now, boys, you put up a scheme." They protest that they will not put up any scheme, that they do not want any control. When the Minister says: "If you do not there will be no control scheme at all," there is immediately a desperate rush to place their servicesunreservedly at the disposal of the people of the Irish Republic, and they lodged a scheme before you could crack a match. I say that it requires nothing but an Order under this Act to suspend the control of tea and if that is done, within one week the price of tea will be brought down by 6d. per lb. I will give 6 to 4, even 2 to 1, on such an eventuality. If the Minister gives the slightest indication to-day that he is likely to do it there will be a deputation of wholesalers over in Kildare Street that will frighten them.
I make another proposal to the Minister. Here is a proposal that would reduce the cost of living ten points in six months and would provide better protection for those who seek it, and a better quality merchandise at a lower price and in greater volume for every consumer in the country. Let the Minister take any commodity he chooses, whether it be spades, woven underwear or children's readymade clothes and abolish the quota restrictions on the import of that commodity, inform the manufacturers of that commodity in Ireland that he proposes to reduce the tariff levied on that commodity to 20 per cent., and that he proposes to devote the revenue derived from the said tariff to give a subsidy per article on the corresponding commodity produced in Ireland. Let us take, for example, a pair of stockings. That pair of stockings is costing to-day, say, 1/- c.i.f. Dublin and we levy a tariff of 25 per cent. on that. That means that henceforward it costs 1/3 f.o.q. and the Irish manufacturer has to compete with that.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy not adumbrating an industrial policy rather than dealing with the provisions of this Bill?
Comment on this
I know, constructive proposals within the terms of the Bill before us. The question before the House is whether the House should continue to give the Minister the power he already has in respect of supplies and services. A debate onthat question does not extend to adumbrating industrial policy or criticising an industrial policy already in existence. It is only a question of whether we shall give him the necessary powers to control imports and exports and the cost of living.
Comment on this
I remember a debate on this Bill going on under your distinguished chairmanship or that of your distinguished predecessor for six weeks.
Comment on this
I know, but that is a thing which the Chair thinks should not continue. Surely it rambles over the edges of policy.
Comment on this
According to the Rules of Order, if I carefully consult the previous debates on the Second Stage of this Bill——
Comment on this
I am not admitting that I set any. I have communicated to the Deputy the confines within which he must remain and they are wide enough.
Comment on this
I propose that the Minister should make an Order under the Act on the lines suggested by me, which he could do perfectly easily, which would have the full force of law and bring down the cost of living by ten points; which would increase employment; which would serve the exact purpose for which this Bill is designed; that is by an executive Order to carry into effect certain reforms which will relieve the stresses in the economy of the country and so utilise the supplies of goods and the services in such a way as to derive the greatest possible benefit for the community. Surely if I can propose to the House plans which can be given effect to under the Supplies and Services Act which will reduce the cost of living by ten points, which will increase employment, which will reduce the burden on the consumer,I am advocating the use of these powers in a way which will be for the benefit of the community.
Comment on this
Is not that advocating policy rather than giving the Minister power to exercise the powers he has already within the terms of the Act?
Comment on this
I will judge whether we ought to give these powers by the answer of the Minister. He said: "Give me a concrete suggestion." I will give him that, and I will decide to vote for or against the Bill when he tells me whether he will adopt the suggestion which I am making by using these powers. If he does, I think he ought to have the powers; if not, I think he ought not to have them.
It would be an extraordinary thing if the Minister could deride the Opposition by saying that they are not making any constructive proposals and, if the Opposition do make constructive proposals, they are to be told that this is not the time and the place to make them. I look to the six weary weeks of precedent when the rights of Opposition Deputies were vindicated to speak trenchantly on unemployment and the cost of living. When I think of the three points increase in the cost of living which kept this House going for six weary weeks and look at the 22 points that the modest Tánaiste clapped on within a week, it is very interesting.
Do you remember, Sir, every Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party, some of them who sat dumb for ten or 15 years, getting up and shrieking to high heaven the time the cost of living went up by three points? Do you notice that not a single one of them has let a yap out of him or her ever since the cost of living went up by 22 points? I confidently expected my distinguished and charming colleague from Monaghan, Deputy Mrs. Rice, to be holding meetings at the crossroads in Monaghan and asking the Minister to make an Order to raise the price of turkeys at least to the level at which they were when I occupied the position of Minister. But every time the price of turkeys falls the heavier the silencethat shrouds my colleague. I am full of hope that she will call a protest meeting at any crossroads and I will be there to second any proposal which she has to make.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Has the price of turkeys anything to do with the Supplies and Services Bill?
Comment on this
Yes. There was a time when we had the right to enforce a price for turkeys and the right to make an Order under this Act that if a jobber defrauded a woman who had turkeys to sell we would take the licence off him and put him out of business. There has been no talk of that since the price of turkeys began to knock along the bottom. We had not even mention of the price of eggs. I would not wish to cause my distinguished colleague any undue distress on behalf of the women of Monaghan, but I remember when she would rise from these benches saying that she rarely interposed, moved by her solicitude for the women of Monaghan because her sleep was disturbed by the cackling of the fowl.
Comment on this
Is it unreasonable for me to make suggestions which will increase employment and reduce the cost of living by a device which the Minister can apply in respect of any commodity? I simply take one by way of illustration. We had reached the stage that one commodity is coming in at a cost of 1/3. I suggest to the Minister that he should use the revenue derived from the 20 per cent. tariff on that to subsidise the domestic product. Does not that suggest a new procedure which would relieve the consumer, stimulate domestic production, bring down the cost of living, and in fact do all the things we want to do? If the domestic stocking costs 1/- to produce and the British stocking costs 1/- to produce, I suggest that we should subsidise the domestic stocking by a levy on the incoming stocking of 3d. and pay the domestic producer 2d. per pair on each pair he produces. His competitive positionthen would be that he would have a 10d. article competing with a 15d. article. Can we not then go to him and say: "We started you off with an initial overhead cost of your product of 10d.; the incoming competing article we have levied to the point where its initial cost is 15d. Now go and compete and let the consumer derive the benefit of your more energetic competition with the incoming commodity"? I think that is a good idea.
I think that if a lady resident in Ballsbridge wants to buy stockings for her children with frills and furbelows and has to pay 3d. extra on them so that the woman in more straitened circumstances and perhaps with a larger family can get a comfortable and serviceable stocking and find herself in the advantageous position, if she wishes to forgo the frills and furbelows, and having access to the more serviceable garment, that is made available by the contribution to the cost of the more serviceable garment made by the levy on the imported article. Does not that reduce the cost of living and provide employment for our people in producing the kind of goods we want? Does it not give an assurance that we will by this device not only protect the existing market for the woman who has to pay a retail price based on a 15d. cost but that other people can buy stockings at a retail price based on a first cost of 10d.? In that way this proposal would not only reduce the cost of living but be a substantial material stimulation to the domestic market as a result of reducing the cost.
The Central Bank gets into a state of apoplexy if you increase consumption by raising the total quantity of spendable money available in relation to the quantity of goods, but they rejoice if you raise the standard of living by maintaining the volume of money stable and reduce the cost of goods. Come now. We can bring peace to the restless pillow of the Central Bank. That will appeal to the Minister for Finance. I often wonder if it is his four-wheel cab I see waiting outside the Central Bank. It is an interesting symbol because there is only one public building, I think, inEurope outside which waits a four-wheel cab drawn by an ancient horse and that is the Central Bank. The Minister for Finance is always solicitous of that institution. Here in my proposal is a method to bring peace and calm to the fevered pillow of the Central Bank, to bring down the cost of living and stimulate the domestic market. Would the Minister do it? I will give him 6 to 4 he will not—not at least until he hopes the House will have forgotten that it was I who proposed it and I will give 6 to 1 that by that time he will no longer have power to do it or not to do it.
I will make another constructive proposal. I make no criticism of past performances. We had 20 years of intensive concentration in this country on what we have been pleased to call industrial development with an obbligato from the same inspired sources which alternate between thanking God that the British market for live stock was gone for ever and fierce phillipics against the lazy farmers who would not produce for export to the British market.
The latest variation that we have to deal with is that we are bringing gentlemen from Denmark, Holland and all over the world to tell us how lousy we are, how incompetent we are and how we fall down on the job in the matter of research, modern methods, and everything else. We are all quite oblivious to the fact that for 18 years in this country anyone who dared to have a four-legged beast on his land was regarded as a quasi-traitor. Oh, yes. Deputy Ó Briain smiles at that.
I saw men in this country selling four-year-old cattle for £4 15s. apiece. My colleague, Deputy Mrs. Rice, saw people selling their turkeys in Monaghan for 4d. per lb. We all joined together to send over butter for the British, who eat it at 8d. per lb. and we paid them 6d. per lb. to eat it. We got back nothing but the empty boxes and they eat the butter. It was after that enjoyable 18 years that we found ourselves, in 1948, in the trough of despond and ruin agriculturally. Deputy Ó Briain doubts thatbut I notice that the rest of the faces on the Fianna Fáil benches are not quite as hilarious. They do not forget that in 1948, after 18 years of that, there were less cattle, less pigs and less sheep in Ireland than at any time in the 20th century. Some Deputies will not forget that cattle were dying of starvation on the land they grazed for lack of phosphates.
Comment on this
I am, Sir, but I hope I am travelling rapidly towards concrete and constructive proposals asked for by the Minister.
Comment on this
I am going to make concrete and constructive proposals in a moment, none of which will be adopted by the Government. If this country is to survive at all, I think we will all agree that we have got to be able to pay for what we import. The purpose of passing this Bill is to provide the Minister for Industry and Commerce with the powers to ensure that that will come to pass and, if it should not, to limit imports, restrict imports. This Bill is habitually used for that purpose. I want to suggest that it should never be used for that end. It should be used to ensure that there shall be exports of volume and value sufficient to permit the enterprising elements of our community to import whatever they require, employ their neighbours to produce and to enjoy the fruit of their own labour. It has been made abundantly clear by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that as regards what he describes as industrial activity he can make no contribution to that end. No industry is in a position to export.
We brought over a team of American surveyors and their answer was —when they were asked to recommend ten commodities ripe and ready to be stimulated for export—very simple, because the answer was there was none. The Minister for Industry and Commerce now regards himself henceforth, not heretofore, as dependingfor his reputation not on how far he succeeds in importing but on how far he succeeds in stimulating exports. He came down on the mineral water bottle manufacturers and informed them, if they were patriotic men, they would stand up and cheer when they were called upon to pay 36/- for bottles which were being sold in Northern Ireland and Great Britain for 22/-. Could he not make an Order prohibiting that? I asked him and he said he would not. Does the Minister for Industry and Commerce deny that it is quite within his power, under this Act, to make such an Order as might be requisite to prevent the continuance of that practice? I suggest he should do it. He says himself that it is the only basis on which industry succeeded in making exports to-day. I want to stimulate exports of a character which place no burden on the domestic consumer but which will ensure that the domestic consumer can have what he requires through the payments earned by the agricultural industry in the export market.
I suggest that the first step might be, in fact, should be, to anticipate the approval of the Congress of the United States for the proposal of the Veterinary and Agricultural Science Institute in this country and go ahead with that so that those services will be available at the earliest possible date. I suggest that a time has come when we should face the fact that the question of fertilisers and seeds is of primary importance in a country the annual rainfall of which is 42 inches as compared with the 22 inches for Denmark and 32 inches for Holland.
I could conceive a Minister under this Bill—the Minister for Agriculture —properly sequestrating to himself in successive years the task of allocating fertilisers, taking each year a different fertiliser, and, on the same principle that we adopted in regard to lime, making in each successive year a particular fertiliser, in which the land is peculiarly deficient, available to farmers on terms which would induce them to use it on a scale heretofore unprecedented. I think that a scheme to that end could be worked out, and in view of the manifest fact that thereis no other source from which to get money to pay for the imports that our people require than the land, I think it would be justifiable seriously to consider emergency measures over the next ten years to bring that land up to the level of fertility requisite to get the production to provide the trade balances which we require. I think that the parish plan should be brought into operation forthwith.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that he cannot discuss the whole ambit of agricultural policy on this Bill.
Comment on this
Well, what does the Minister for Industry and Commerce mean by constructive proposals?
Comment on this
Surely the provision of fertilisers for the land, so as to get increased production, must come within that.
Comment on this
That is all very well, but are we not discussing supplies and services? Where else can we get supplies of food other than from the land?
Comment on this
We are discussing supplies and services in respect to the powers given to the Minister in that regard under the terms of this Bill.
Comment on this
And how they should be used. This is the Second Stage of the Bill. Am I not entitled to argue how these powers should be used for the purpose of evoking abundant supplies for the common good?
Comment on this
Not in general. The Deputy cannot travel over the administration of every Government Department under this Bill.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste says: "I hear no constructive proposals." Here is one—the possibility of evokingsupplies and mobilising services for the common good. I am making that constructive proposal, to mobilise services and to get in supplies which are not at present forthcoming, but which could be made to come forth by the user of the powers under this Bill. I know of no more relevant matter than that. If I am told that I cannot discuss these matters generally, but in particular, I have no guide as to what particular I can apply my mind to.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be allowed to discuss any matter that is within the rules of relevancy. The Chair is endeavouring to prevent the administration of Departments being discussed on this Bill, and surely the parish plan is a matter of administration.
Comment on this
Not at all. On the contrary it has been denounced in principle by the present Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
It is a matter of administration to be discussed on the Estimate for the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
No. If I tried to do that and to advocate legislation on the Estimate for the Minister's Department he would tell me that he could not do so without an Order under this Bill or without legislation.
Comment on this
The Minister can operate the parish plan under the administration of his Department.
Comment on this
By the making of an Order for the better procurement of supplies and by the introduction of a system of intensive publicity. I invite the Minister for Industry and Commerce to deny that. He canmake an Order strictly within the rules of this Bill declaring that the Minister for Agriculture may incur certain necessary expenditure on the grounds that the purpose of it is to evoke additional supplies.
Comment on this
I cannot authorise the spending of a penny under this by the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he cannot empower or order the spending of one penny under the parish plan. Deputy Dillon knows that.
Comment on this
Is the Minister contending that he cannot authorise the spending of one penny under this, and is that the certificate that he is giving to the Chair?
Comment on this
Does the Minister contend that he cannot authorise the spending of a penny under this Bill?
Comment on this
Under the authority of this Bill you are entitled to bring in the Estimate in question.
Comment on this
If the Minister brought in an Estimate, I would not be allowed to discuss the desirability of legislation in connection with the parish plan.
Comment on this
Let us not discuss it then; let us leave it at that. I have already mentioned the institute, fertilisers, seeds and the parish plan. The fourth thing that I mentioned was the expansion of artificial insemination. I do not know whether that can be done under this Bill or not. Anurgent and vital necessity is my fifth proposal, namely, the restoration of the land rehabilitation project to its previous vigour and activity. I do not know whether the progeny-testing of pigs and fowl, at present in operation on a limited scale, is relevant to this Bill or not, but I think it should be developed and pursued.
I am sorry that Deputy Hickey is not here because I am now coming to something that is relevant to this Bill, and that is credit for farm buildings and machinery. I want to say, with full deliberation, that this is something to which I have applied my mind not for a month or a year but for a much longer period. If we are going to get effective progress in the equipment of the agricultural industry in this country, the time has come to make the money for that purpose, under approved schemes, available to farmers who use it free of interest. If that is not done, no effective progress is going to be made. I have myself seen in operation from both sides of the table schemes for the erection of farm buildings and the purchase of machinery. I have seen men lay out £500 or £600, and then finding themselves subject to a charge thereafter of £30 per annum in respect of their outlay, only to discover that they would be paying that annual charge in perpetuity, and still just as deeply in debt at the end as they were at the beginning, whereas if the money were applied to a reduction of the capital sum originally borrowed by them, the position would be that in 12 or 13 years they would be free of their debt, and over that period would have been able to produce that much more as a result of the equipment with which they had provided themselves. I am not sure that I would not be prepared to sponsor that proposal, whatever our past history was.
I am quite certain, looking back on the days of Lord Lucan of County Mayo, who, in the vicinity of Castlebar, was known as the great exterminator, that it is right for us, the grandchildren of those whom he sought to exterminate, to tax our resources to ensure that those who hung on and frustrated Bingham's purpose and succeeded inretaining the land for our own people, should have redressed in our time the appalling handicap he sought to hang upon them. It amused me to read some of our own neo-reformers in this our day telling us we ought to give up the idea of farmers owning and running their own holdings, and that we ought to lump the holdings together and ensure that the men who heretofore were little better than peasants would get a regular weekly wage to raise their standard of living. These gentlemen do not know that Bingham, the great exterminator, who filled the workhouse of Castlebar until the floors and passages were covered with men, women and children, was the first prophet to enunciate that doctrine in Ireland. He thought there were too many of the dirty Irish in County Mayo, and the only way to deal with them was to clean them off the land and group their paltry little holdings into decent farms and bring in industrious Scottish men to run these farms and employ the Irish. Bingham first proposed that in Ireland, and I make the suggestion that they ought to get a portrait of Lord Lucan and get a buttonhole made of it.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen would not know whom I was talking about. I am talking about Bingham. If the Deputy knew as much about the history of the West of Ireland as I do he would not be asking his neighbour who was Bingham.
Comment on this
Cross your heart and hope to die, do you know who Bingham was or do you know B from a bull's foot? There is not one in the whole Fianna Fáil Party who knows about this.
Comment on this
I was talking about credit for farm buildings and I was suggesting that under this Bill we could devise a plan whereby it wouldbe made available free of interest. This is a modest proposal which would not cost very much.
Comment on this
Poor silly Deputy Allen would greet its adoption or its rejection with the eloquent interjection: "Who killed Cock Robin?" so we need not worry for his peace of mind. That is the seventh proposal I have to make. The eighth proposal I have to make is, I think, of equal value. Seventy years ago, mark the date, there was a geological survey proceeding in this country. A Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer came to the conclusion that economy for the benefit of the British Exchequer required that the geological survey in Ireland should be suspended because if the drain on the Exchequer continued they might have to stop the survey in England. Therefore, the geological survey in Ireland was stopped, and it never was started again. We have some very competent officers for this purpose, but there is a standing injunction to do nothing at all because there is no money with which to do it. We are still eloquently repeating the observation of the Chancellor of the Exchequer of 1883. The Fianna Fáil Deputies are itching in their seats to say: "What did you do about it"? I did plenty and only for the disaster of Fianna Fáil scrambling back to office on the backs of the three tulips, the busted flush, who have now dwindled away to a lonely joker——
Comment on this
I did attempt to procure an aerial survey of Ireland. There has been an aerial survey made of Great Britain and, I think, of almost every square mile of inhabited land in the world except Ireland. We had estimates prepared to have that survey made and the usual skirmishes were going on with the Department of Finance to procure the money. That is the eighth of my proposals for the rapid expansion of supplies in this country, that the Minister for Industryand Commerce should resume the geological survey of the whole country, that he should renew the peripatetic ordnance survey and that he should direct the completion forthwith of an early photographic survey of the country.
All these things could materially contribute to the increase of supplies. I might warn him that if he tries to have the aerial survey made he will be obstructed by obscurantist elements in certain divisions of the Department of Defence. If he puts his foot on their face as effectively as he puts it upon the face of his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, I have no doubt they will be quickly expunged from the scene, but I am not so sure that he is willing to put his foot on the face of his fellow-townsman, the Minister for Defence, as he seems so happy to do, whenever opportunity arises, with his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture.
I feel that is a good series of constructive suggestions. There is not one of them that would not produce immediate and striking results. However, it is a comment on the kind of Government we have that we may be virtually certain that none of them will be adopted. I look forward with amazement to the contribution which the Government proposes to make to the solution of our economic difficulties. We are to borrow large sums of money for the purpose of rebuilding Dublin Castle and the Naas Road.
Let us observe the situation. Three years ago our problem was that there was a shortage of labour. We had actually to bring skilled operatives back from Great Britain, induce them to come in order effectively to mobilise the building industry here. Within three short years we are shipping the timber for building out of the country and we are using the Supplies and Services Act to start relief works in the City of Dublin and throughout the country. Is it not astonishing that Fianna Fáil now considers it one of its great achievements to say to the public: "Have no anxiety. We are going to continue relief works for the next five years"? One of the relief works, he said, is that we will spend an unascertained number of millionsrebuilding Dublin Castle. I saw the model of the plan they had to rebuild Dublin Castle. It lay in the ante-room to the Government meeting-room in Government Buildings for two years. I think the model cost £1,500 to make. It would occupy a large diningroom table. Our advice was that originally the rebuilding was estimated to cost £4,000,000 but it was more likely to cost £9,000,000—if undertaken in 1950.
Conceive the feelings of the people of this city when I am stopped by a friend of mine living in this city who has a good job as a motor mechanic at a fair salary and who tells me that he was up all last week chasing rats off the baby's cradle in one tenement room in the City of Dublin. He says it is not a question of his not being able to afford a house. He wants to rent a house and he is prepared to show what he is earning weekly and that he has saved a sufficiency to guarantee that his rent will be paid for any reasonably forseeable period. There is not a house to be got, he says. "Oh, that could not be," I said. He told me he has a wife and two children—one child is three and the other rising one in the cradle. I rang up the Dublin Corporation and said: "Here is a man with a wife and two children, living in one tenement room; he is not getting a right night's sleep trying to protect the baby from the rats." No one could have been more courteous than the city authorities, but their answer to me was: "Mr. Dillon, there is no question of considering him for a house; we have not yet dealt with the people who are living five and six in one room." Is not that right?
Comment on this
They said: "We are only coming to them; a man living four in a room cannot be given a promise that we will consider his case for 18 months to two years." Now, that is the context in which we are going to spend £9,000,000 on building the castle. Are we all gone daft altogether? Can you imagine the feelings of an unfortunate man who has the wages to pay the rent and who wants nothing but the opportunity of getting a house and paying rent for it so that he mayhave accommodation for his wife and children and be able to get a good night's sleep, when he is told that his case will not be considered for 18 months or two years? But we are going to start work on the Castle forthwith—we have £9,000,000 to spend on it. Can you imagine that fellow, when he turns in despair to see if he could not build a house for himself, and goes to the local authority and says: "Tell me how I would go about getting a loan under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act; I know a neighbour who got one and who is paying 22/- a week." The local authority says: "Yes, that man borrowed a couple of years ago but the same loan from the same local authority over the same term of years will cost you 34/- now." Can you imagine the exasperation of the average working man to whom the tale is told? When he goes to recite that to someone who wants to create trouble in our community, his exasperation is inflamed by being told: "Stay in your tenement rooms; they are going to rebuild the castle; they have finished Áras Mhic Dhiarmada, and when the castle is finished they will see about you and the baby and the rats."
What a metamorphosis has come over the country? Three years ago, I am proud to think, two things took precedence over everything else in the economic life of Ireland—the rehabilitation of the land and the housing of the people. Three short years, and these two projects are supplanted by Dublin Castle and the Naas Road. Three short years ago there was nearly full employment in this country, and now the Government glories in the fact that they forecast abundant relief works for the next five years. They are tearing up the tram rails, they are cleaning the Dodder, Glory Halleluiah! Ireland is on the march—down the Dodder and up the tram rails!
What has happened to them? Is it something to be ashamed of that we want to build houses for our own people? Is it something to be ashamed of that we were able to give the smallest, poorest farmer in Ireland facilities equal to those of the richestlanded proprietor in Europe? Did the results not show that our policy not only paid dividends in social amenities for our own people but in hard cash for the benefit of the economic life of the country? Why have we substituted for that, relief works, Dublin Castle and the Naas Road?
Comment on this
I am asking Fianna Fáil, together with all their recent recruits. Dublin Castle and the Naas Road— while there is many a citizen living in one room with a wife and two children and no place else to go. Does Deputy Allen think that is right? He will not say yes and he will not say no. You remember the person who would blow neither hot nor cold and what he was deemed fit for?
Comment on this
Is it not possible for the building of Dublin Castle and the housing to go on side by side?
Comment on this
I do not see that. I am told by the municipal authority there is no hope of considering anyone living with a wife and children, four in a room, for 18 months or two years.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not think more could be done if we concentrated our resources on housing the people first, before turning to build Dublin Castle, Áras Mhic Dhiarmada, or any such monster?
Comment on this
I do not think so, with all respect to the Deputy, for whose intervention I have respect. I do not blame the corporation; I blame the Government.
Comment on this
The question of housing can be raised on the Estimate. It does not seem to be relevant to Supplies and Services.
Comment on this
If I have the supplies and the services and put them down on Áras Mhic Dhiarmada and DublinCastle, how can I have them to erect houses for my friend, who has a wife and two children, living in one tenement room? If that is not "supplies and services". I am blowed if I know what it is.
Comment on this
How chastening it is to listen to it now! The Minister would not understand it, of course, but when the Minister has had time to think it over he may understand it.
Comment on this
I will read now for the Minister an extract from his favourite bible, the Report of the Central Bank of Ireland for the year ending 31st March, 1953. At page 17 the following appears:—
"There seems to be a desire prevalent in many sections of the community to insulate their particular sectors of the economy from the effects of changes in the outside world. With that object, agricultural and industrial prices are inflated beyond economic levels by means of guarantees, subsidies, quotas, tariffs and other arrangements. In a number of occupations, wage rates are higher than those in Great Britain and, unless these rates are offset by superior productivity, the prospects of developing an industrial export trade are not bright. Money incomes in many spheres have continued to expand without a corresponding rise in output, and so have tended to inflate domestic costs, thus reducing our ability to compete in foreign markets and lessening the attractiveness of the country as a field for investment and for tourism."
I do not often agree with the directorsof the Central Bank, but it is nearly time the Tánaiste came to brood on that paragraph.
I want to ask the House now a question I asked before. It is all right to raise the price of wheat, for that is something within the discreation of our own people; if our own people choose to pay £3,000,000 per annum extra for wheat grown at home, that is their own business and they have a perfect right to do so. That is what home grown wheat is costing us this year. Next year, if we have 4,000,000 barrels it will cost us £4,000,000. But that is our own business. That is something we can settle for ourselves. I want to remind the House, however, that if one is trying to produce, or if one is seeking to evoke supplies to be sold on foreign markets one is committing economic suicide if artificially one pushes up the cost of one's raw material, because no amount of hard work will offset an arbitrary increase in the cost of the raw materials on which our people have to work.
I told the House before, and I tell it again now, that I negotiated a trade agreement in London in 1951 and I am glad to see that Mr. Stanley Evans, a member of the British House of Commons, speaking on that matter yesterday in the British House of Commons, said that Mr. Dillon—and, strangely enough, he linked me with Mr. Péron—spent his time beating the British Minister for Food about the head and face——
Comment on this
——to get a price which Mr. Stanley Evans thought was too big. By heaven, if I beat them about the face and head with eggs, devil a much eggs they will be "bet" about the head and face with now. But I do not mind that. I told them that if they brought the price of eggs down they would get no cheap eggs from Ireland.
The 1951 Trade Agreement in relation to pork, bacon and pigs linked the prices payable for Irish pigs, bacon and pork to the prices payable for pork, bacon and pigs to the British farmer. I knew when I made thatagreement that the price paid to the British farmer was based on an index founded on the price of feeding stuffs and I reckoned that if the price of feeding stuffs came down in Great Britain it must come down in Ireland because we were both depending on the same sources of supply. The cost of imported feeding stuffs into Great Britain has come down twice in the last six months and there have been two consequential reductions in the price of pork, pigs and bacon in Great Britain and both these reductions have been reflected in the prices paid for these articles in this country. Over the same period the price of feeding stuffs has been artificially kept up here. Maize is being quoted for December shipment in the Irish ports to-day at £26 per ton and Indian meal is being sold at £38 a ton to the feeder. The price of that Indian meal ought to be 29/- or 30/- per cwt. There is a surcharge maintained on the price of feeding stuffs in this country by our own Government at the present time of at least 6/- per cwt. on a balanced ration. If one reckons that it takes 8 cwt. to feed a pig from birth to 12 stone weight that means that there is a levy of £2 8s. per pig.
I warn the Minister there is not that much profit in pigs and if there is an artificial levy imposed on every pig produced in the West and South-West for the benefit of farmers in another part of the country what will happen is what happened here before. Pigs will disappear and, remember, pigs will not come back again if they disappear. It was a hard, bitter fight to persuade the farmers to get into pigs again. If that trick is played on them another time, if the number of pigs rises and they eventually produce an exportable surplus and prices are allowed to crash or their profits are extinguished by the costs of production, while they have no means of raising their prices correspondingly, they will get out of pigs; and, if they get out of pigs for a third time, all the king's horses and all the king's men will not get them back into pigs again.
Comment on this
How is the question of pigs relevant to supplies and services? Would that notarise on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture?
Comment on this
Because, Sir, it is this foolish man and his colleagues who are juggling about with the prices of feeding stuffs through the medium of this very instrument we are now discussing.
Comment on this
Rubbish! Nonsense! The glib way he says that and he admitted a few minutes ago that the whole flour subsidy machinery is operated under this Act.
Comment on this
He is quite willing to say anything. He is prepared to contradict himself three times in the one afternoon and trust to Providence that everyone has forgotten what he said. The Chair may take it from me that this is relevant. I want to warn the House that the continued use of this legislation for the purpose of creating artificial conditions will end in irretrievable disaster. There is no getting away from that. There is only one hope for this country and that is to clear out the whole ging-bang lot. If one considers the question as to whether or not powers of this character ought to be put into the hands of this Government, the answer is categorically "No", for they are so preoccupied with fighting one another and struggling for the succession that they have no thought of anything else.
Comment on this
The House is being asked: Should we give these powers to this Government? The answer is "No" because they are so busy struggling for leadership they have no time to consider these important matters. Since the Tánaiste and the Minister for External Affairs fought one another to a standstill and the Minister for Health, Dr. Ryan, has become favourite for the succession, "General Chaos" has taken command.
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with supplies and services, and the Deputy should relate his remarks to the Bill.
Comment on this
Look at him blushing so prettily. I say the Minister is incompetent in the use of these powers. The Minister for External Affairs is manifestly incompetent to use these powers. The Minister for Agriculture will not be let use these powers. The Minister for Health is too lazy to use these powers. These are all good reasons why these Ministers should not be given these powers. They are an incompetent, quarrelsome lot. They have wrought havoc on this country on three separate occasions and on every occasion they have passed the buck to someone else to clean up the mess they have made and, one way or another, they have managed always to find some dross to hawk them back into office. They have now got back into office with the help of the three bluebells that they have now swallowed and are in process of digesting.
Comment on this
Can I not discuss the competence of these fellows to have these powers? Can I not describe their incompetence? Is it not relevant, or is it relevant, that everybody knows they are so incompetent that there is no need to argue the question any longer? You cannot laugh that off. There is nobody left to laugh at but yourselves. It is the record of the Fianna Fáil Party that is under examination in this House. It is a shocking one. In many ways it is a laughable record, but it is a record that Fianna Fáil should not laugh at; they should cry. If these men are got rid of at a reasonably early date, the powers contained in this Act can justifiablybe sought from Parliament in the times in which we live. I am not so sure that the Minister is right in his pious affirmation that at the end of 15 months the Government are finally and absolutely resolved to wind these powers up. Something has happened to the Minister. I suppose it is what happens to every other mediocre man —he was a socialist when he was young and he grows more Tory with the passage of the years.
Comment on this
There was a time when I would sooner be a Republican than a Spanish-American external relation.
Comment on this
I have plenty to say on the Bill, and I have said a damn sight more on this Bill than a lot of the Deputies that I have listened to. I am talking now of the competence of that man to exercise the powers he is asking for under this Bill.
Comment on this
Surely "man" has not become a term of opprobrium in this House. His worst enemy would not forbear to call him a man.
Comment on this
I am not saying anything about that. We will not argue about that to-day. I am suggesting that the Ministers of the Government might for the moment look back to their more radical days and inquire if this Tory passion for uncontrolled, free enterprise should entirely dictate their daily thought. There are powers in this Bill which, situated as we are, a Government might properly want and might properly have. Everything a Government does under this Bill is subject to the review of this House. I am not one of those who share the conviction that all delegated authority is intolerable because anyone who has experience of government now knowsthat government in a modern State could not be carried on without such delegated authority. What is important is that this House should retain its right to review whatever is done under delegated authority. We have that right and we should preserve it. But if you abolish all these and bring in a whole series of Bills to try permanently to replace these powers you may discover that you are setting up a forest of Bills in the place of this instrument which it will be subsequently very difficult to bring under control.
I ask the House to remember that when the Restrictive Trade Practices Bill was before this House I warned the House that if they passed the Bill in its present form, giving the vested interest a right under it to seek to have fair rules of trade approved, the Bill would become, not an instrument of liberation for the consumer, but an additional padlock on the chains in which the vested interest seeks to tie him up. Was not I right? There has not been a single reference to this fair trade tribunal of an alleged abuse, but there have been about 17 applications from vested interests to have schedules of fair trading practices approved so that thereafter no citizen will dare to object.
Comment on this
Every Bill has a certain relation to another inasmuch as all of them have a consequence. I am suggesting to the House that if we abandon this Bill with the power of review which is inherent in Dáil Éireann and substitute for it a whole series of Bills which will subsequently become Acts, designed to furnish forth each Minister of the Government with the powers he wants in lieu of the powers that he has declined in this Act, we will see a forest of statutes the outcome of whichmay be far different from what this House believes it to be.
Bear in mind what has happened in the case of the Restrictive Trade Practices Act. It is not a Restrictive Trade Practices Act any longer. It is a restrictive consumers Act, under which charters will be established for the protection of trades from consumers, not of consumers from trades. I would suggest to the Government that they might think again before the end of this debate with a view at least to qualifying the Tánaiste's unqualified undertaking to abolish this Act before the end of 15 months. We may all have bitter reason to regret such a decision if we take it.
The Minister said that up to the time Deputy Blowick was speaking he had received no constructive proposals. I have now made to him 11 separate constructive proposals, any one of which would be an improvement on the programme of this Government. I will make an even more constructive proposal before I sit down: resign quick; get out.