We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1953—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 144–272 of 272. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1953
Enacted

No. 24 of 1953 ›

——and ask them to pass judgment on the patch-work quilt with the four bluebells embroidered upon it and the slippery joker left weeping alone. Nobody will inquire why the Senator who has joined your organisation is not on the hustings.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is discussing matters that are not in the Bill.

Comment on this

I wish to give notice that with your permission I shall raise the subject-matter of Question No. 25 on to-day's Order Paper on the adjournment to-night.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter will be considered and the Deputy will be informed.

Comment on this

What is the subject-matter of Question No. 25?

Comment on this

Find out.

Comment on this

That is very polite. Charming creature. On a point of order. Is it permissible for a Deputy at this stage of our proceedings to give such notice? Is not such notice, which refers to the naval dockyard at Haulbowline and some bargain that Deputy Corry thought he had made with the Government and which has not come off, given after Question Time?

Comment on this

Read the Standing Orders.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry is in order until 8.30 p.m. in giving notice to the Chair of intention to raise a question.

Comment on this

But not to the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To the House.

Comment on this

I will teach the Deputy a few more things before I am finished. I wonder if the unfortunate individual whom Deputy Dillon was bewailing with regard to his housing position here this evening had a house in 1945, or was the housing position in this country better in 1945 than it is now? I think that is a fair question, for in 1945 Deputy Dillon proposed here in the House the borrowing of some millions of pounds for the purpose of building a new Dáil Éireann. He entered into a long wail at that time as to the condition of the present House, the room that was in it, and the facilities in it for Deputies; and he wound it up by telling us about all the beetles that were in the roof at that time. I do not think that our housing programme was as well advanced in 1945 as it is now, but Deputy Dillon evidently thought then that we should spend some millions on the erection of a new Dáil which he afterwards endeavoured to father off on the Fianna Fáil Party or Government.

Comment on this

They do not like the Castle.

Comment on this

Deputies should go down and read it. In the 1945 Official Report they can read it all.

I know that Deputy Dillon is very much upset and saddened in regard to those loans for farm buildings. He was saddened when he gave up another plan that he had, a plan under which the farmer was to accept a bob a gallon for his milk and which had a very severe effect on supplies even up to the present when we had 157,000 milch cows disappearing in 12 months due to the activities of Deputy James Dillon and his offer to the farmers of this country of a reduction of 3d. per gallon in the price of their milk. I am well aware of Deputy Dillon's anxiety as shown here to-day and his worry, because the agricultural community were going in wholeheartedly for the Fianna Fáil tillage policy. I know his anxiety and worry of mind when he told us that beet was gone up the spout after the wheat, and I can imagine the upset it must be to him having to read in the papers that there was an increase of some 12,000 or 13,000 acres of beet this year, and that there is going to be an increase this year as a result of Fianna Fáil policy of some 200,000 tons of beet to the factories with resultant employment. I can imagine the misery that that must be to the individual who sent over to Cuba and out to Czechoslovakia for the sugar. I can also imagine the worry it must be to him whose boast and delight was that the beet was gone up the spout after the wheat and the peat. I can well imagine the worry it must have been to Deputy Dillon that there were produced in this country this year something like 80,000 or 90,000 extra acres of wheat. I can well imagine the worry it must be to him, and the upset it must be to his applecart, after the three and a half years he spent endeavouring to wipe out of existence that tillage policy. I can well imagine the worry that must be to him. This is not, I admit, the time for going into those particular matters.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

You are quite right.

Comment on this

But Deputy Dillon succeeded in getting pretty far into them and I think other Deputies are entitled to follow.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might relate his remarks to the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

That is very complimentary to the Chair.

Comment on this

So were the remarks of Deputy Dillon on that matter. I would like to assure the Minister for Industry and Commerce that that policy of increased production on the land is going to continue and that there will be further increased acreage of both wheat and beet next year. The agricultural community have always held to one dictum, that it was the duty of the farmers of this country to provide food for our own people.

Deputy Dillon stated that there was a loss of £3,000,000 because the people of this country grew wheat this year. That was his statement here, that we could not grow it as cheap as on the foreign market. That was just in keeping with the Deputy who made the very self-same statement in this House a few years ago as regards beet, and told us that he did not know how long the people of this country were going to continue on a policy of producing their own sugar which was costing the people £3,000,000 each year. Evidently the £3,000,000 has gone up where the beet was going. He stuck to that, and as a result of the manner in which he dealt with the beet industry he found himself two years afterwards having to go out to the foreigner and to pay the foreigner for 74,000 tons of sugar, £12 per ton more than for Irish sugar produced in the Irish factories here. That is rather a change. Deputy Dillon's policy has been tried by the agricultural community and was found wanting, and he got the high-road and the wattle on account of it. Now he comes in here endeavouring to bring forward the very self-same policy again, bewailing the production of wheat, bewailing the production and manufacture of our own sugar. Then he came along on the beet. Why? Because he wanted to kill now the market that the Irish farmer has found in this country for feeding barley, because he wants againto have a market in this country for foreign maize.

You would not need any land at all for the policy as preached by Deputy Dillon. All you want is one big yard into which you will shove the pigs and get the foreign material, foreign grain, in and feed them in the yard. You would not want any land, and it could be devoted fully to being the fruitful mother of flocks and herds and the production of beef for Britain. That was the policy that Deputy Dillon, with the help of Fine Gael and the Labour Party, set himself to carry out in this country for three and a half years. We have seen the result of it. Now we are on the march back. We are back again, not through any compulsion but through the free action of the people and the agricultural community of this country in the production of food for our own people. Against the best market for beef that existed in this country for many years the wheat and the beet are proving more attractive propositions to the farmers. So much for that.

I wish to protest against the manner in which Deputy Dillon has succeeded in insulting certain Deputies of this House. He comes up here and talks about the bursted flush and all the rest of this kind of vilification of certain Deputies.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon was informed by the Chair that those matters were not relevant and should not be discussed on the Bill.

Comment on this

All I wish to say about them is this—that those Deputies were the cause of a general election in this country because they opposed Fine Gael policy here. They were not elected to this House on the inter-Party ticket but as Deputies standing against the inter-Party interests.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry should come back to the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not wish to go further into it than to say that the people of this country—and the agricultural community, in particular —were very grateful and very thankfulfor getting rid of Deputy James Dillon as Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

I do not want to cover the wider aspects of our whole economy on this Bill. In so far as I raise economic matters, it will only be in relation to the Bill which is now before the House.

In his opening speech, the Minister told us that the Government propose, by 1955, to introduce some permanent price control machinery. I must say I was surprised that the Minister deferred the introduction of permanent price control machinery until then because, in this House in 1950, the Minister made a peevish and intemperate speech about the uselessness of the Supplies and Services Bill of that year, saying that it was quite unnecessary and unwanted and that, in fact, it should be scrapped and permanent price legislation introduced in its place. Although that statement was made in this House in 1950 by the present Minister when he was sitting on the Opposition Benches, we are now told by him that it will be 1955—five years after that speech was made by the Minister from the Opposition Benches—before we see the permanent price legislation.

In view of the length of time which has elapsed since the Minister stated that the Supplies and Services Bill is unnecessary and unwanted and that it should be scrapped and permanent price legislation introduced in its stead, I do not know whether we shall see that legislation by the year 1955 or what the character of the legislation is likely to be. I have an unhappy feeling about price legislation and all the talk we have heard about price legislation over the past two years. We can see clearly that the Government are slipping away, day by day and month by month, from their responsibility for the regulation of prices in this country.

Week after week and month after month, Price Control Orders have been repealed. Week after week and month after month, something else is taken out of the control of the Prices Sectionof the Department of Industry and Commerce. Now, a whole collection of commodities have been allowed to ride free of any control or any effective supervision by the Department of Industry and Commerce—and we are going to have a further period of 18 months of it. How much of the remnants of price control will be here at the end of 18 months it is not possible, at this stage, to forecast. If the Government continue to shed responsibility for price control in the next 18 months as they have, in an accelerated way, shed that responsibility over the past two years, I venture to say that, 18 months hence, there will hardly be a Price Control Order in operation at all.

I am one of those people who believed, and still believe, that price control is imperative. It is imperative not merely in the general public interest but particularly in the case of those sections of our community who are compelled to live on subsistence standards. Price levels for them are not the basis of a mere academic discussion. Price levels for them determine the standard of living in their homes. If the Government adopt the attitude that price control is unnecessary and can easily be relinquished then for those people there will be a still bleaker outlook in the future than that which exists to-day.

If price control is necessary, price supervision is even more imperative. One may say that there is a sufficiency of goods on the market to ensure availability of supplies, but we must not forget that it is possible for groups and rings so to orientate themselves as to fix prices on the market at levels which give them an unreasonable return on their money. These days, people are struggling to make ends meet, to get the best possible value for meagre wages and to see that they get access to the sweet things of life. It is highly desirable that no group and no ring should feel that it is outside the range of supervision and control so far as price levels are concerned. Nobody will attempt to deny that the public confidence in price control, as exercised by the present Government during the past two years,has been rudely shaken. The public have a feeling that the Government have thrown away from their own control the range of supervision which, during the past two years, at least assured the public that their interests would be protected in some measure against the rapacity of those who wanted to exact the highest possible price for anything they produced or sold.

I do not think it will be easy for the Minister or the Government to ride away from what should be their obvious responsibility—that is, to give the public an efficient system of price regulation, price control and, above all, price supervision so as to ensure that there will be no exploitation of the public and especially of the weakest and most defenceless section of the community. Price control and price supervision are necessary for other reasons also. Of course, the public do not take a deep and scholarly interest in the factors which affect price levels nor in the factors which go to make the ultimate wholesale and retail prices. All they know is that every time prices rise and wages remain static, their standard of living is correspondingly reduced. In the public interest, as well as from the point of view of promoting a wider knowledge of the factors which enter into price control and price regulation, I think there ought to be a permanent prices tribunal which, from time to time, would be asked to examine price levels in particular industries and, by means of a public hearing, to hold a full examination of all the factors which are involved in the fixation of prices.

In that way, the public would be enabled to appreciate the factors which are at work and which ultimately determine the prices which they pay for the commodities which they purchase. I hope that when the Minister is replying to this debate he will give us some more information in respect of the future character of the price control machinery than we have got from him so far. At most, we have an idea that, by 1955, some type of machinery will be produced. We have heard rather vague references to a Bill which the Minister introduced in thisHouse many years ago and which he subsequently abandoned. I think the Title of the Bill was the Price Regulation and Efficiency Bill. Beyond a vague reference to that Bill, and an intimation that we will see some kind of price regulation machinery in 18 months' time, we have no idea whatever of the direction in which the Government's mind is travelling, but we do know that, every day, the Government are shedding more and more of the responsibility which, previously, they had in regard to price control. I do not think it would be irrational to bet or prophesy to-day that when this Bill goes through both Houses of the Oireachtas, more Price Control Orders will be repealed.

It has lately become fashionable at dinners, functions and other occasions, for Ministers to talk in terms of approval and pride of what they describe as "price stability." What is the basis for all this ranting about price stability?

What are the facts about price stability to-day? Can anybody deny that prices are higher to-day than they have ever been in the past 30 years? Do the Government's figures issued by the Central Statistics Office not prove that the prices of commodities to-day are higher than they were in 1923, 30 years ago? Does everybody not know to-day that prices are higher in Ireland than at any time of peace in living memory? Never before in times of peace have we hit the price level we have hit to-day. In face of these unchallengeable facts, we get people preening themselves that we have reached price stability. We are now expected to take pride in the fact that we are paying 4/2 for butter that we could buy a couple of years ago for 2/10, but because we get the privilege of paying 4/2 for it, and have had that privilege regularly, constantly and with stability for the past 16 months, we are obliged to believe that there is a virtue in the stability which makes us pay 4/2 for 2/10 butter. That is called price stability.

We have another privilege to-day, of course, masquerading under the euphemism of price stability, that thepeople are now paying 5/- a lb. for 2/8 tea. They have been paying that 5/- a lb. for it for the past 16 months, and now they are told to cheer up, to forget their wounds and their sorrows because we have reached price stability, which takes the form of having to pay 5/- a lb. for 2/8 tea, or, as Deputy Byrne says, 9d. for the loaf they could get 18 months ago for 6d. Then we have people saying that is price stability. Would it not be a damned good job if we had no price stability, if that is what is masquerading as price stability—gearing prices up to this high level and telling the people that they ought to be glad they have that stability?

Let us look at the stability we have. I asked a question recently to ascertain the number of commodities that had varied in price since 14th June, 1951. A natural kindness and regard for the feelings of Deputies prevents me going completely through this document, but it is a document of six pages showing increases in prices since June, 1951, which is pretty good going in a short period. What is the range of commodities which have increased in price? I will not go through them all; I will be satisfied to touch on those that affect the ordinary man and woman. This document shows increases in sweets, milk, peas, yeast, fuel, petrol, paraffin oil, methylated spirits, coal, coke, electricity, gas, cigarettes, tobacco, agricultural machinery, bicycles, and various kinds of building materials. There is a source of consolation in the fact, as the House will be glad to hear, that one firm has reduced the price of pot scourers by 3/6 a gross on the wholesale price. Other commodities which have gone up in price are sewing threads, slates, tablet soap, springs of all kinds, steel of all kinds and tiles.

Coming to the food and drink group, we find that these are up in price: ale, beer, stout, whiskey, bread, flour and wheaten meal, creamery butter, cheese, cocoa, condensed milk, cream milk, unsweetened condensed milk, sugar and oatmeal. In face of these increases, what is the purpose of telling us that we have reached stability?Has this Government in the past two years not been responsible for lifting the price level in that short period by a percentage which has not applied to any other period of two years since this State was formed 31 years ago? In face of these facts, it seems to me to be nothing short of a cynical mockery of the people's sufferings that we should be talking about price stability at the same time and in the same year as the Government issues that long litany of price increases inflicted on the community by the policy of the Department and the policy of the Government.

Does everybody not know perfectly well that it is harder to live to-day for the ordinary man and woman than it has ever been in the past 30 years? At a recent meeting of the Sick and Indigent Roomkeepers' Society in Dublin, references were made by people, who are not members of political Parties but religious, indicating that there was widespread unemployment and poverty in this city. Anybody with any connection with these charitable organisations knows that their funds now are not capable of alleviating one tithe of the distress they are called upon to relieve in consequence of the worsening economic situation.

Let us look at the plight of those of our people who are compelled to exist on social welfare benefits. Thanks to this Government's policy of increasing prices by more than 20 per cent. in the past two years, grievous hardships have been inflicted on many helpless men and women and young children up and down this country. Take the case of the old age pensioner and relate the position of that man or woman to the problem of endeavouring to exist on the meagre pittances which they receive to-day under our social welfare legislation. According to an answer by the Taoiseach in the House, on the 1939 value the £ is now 8/7. The old age pensioner to-day receives as a maximum 21/6, and interpreting that sum in terms of 1939 purchasing power, that person is living to-day on less than he or she had in 1939. In other words, although the old age pensioner of 1939 had an old age pension of 10/-,which nobody was prepared to say was adequate for that person's requirements, to-day, because of the increase in the cost of living, that person is trying to exist on a purchasing power which is less than that of 1939.

Take then the case, in relation to prices, of widows and orphans. The new maximum widows' and orphans' pension, the pension paid to a widow with two children, is 38/- a week. Thanks to the rise in the price level, that person is now getting in terms of 1939 purchasing power no more than 18/- per week. Nobody will say that was a reasonable competence on which to expect a person to exist in 1939, and yet to-day we are giving that person only 18/- per week in terms of 1939 purchasing power to sustain herself and her two children.

When you move from that into the other categories of human beings dependent on our social services, you find the very same catastrophic effects on their economy. Their standard of living has been debased. Their efforts to exist are efforts which inflict upon them intense pain and suffering. I should like in that connection to refer to a letter which I received from a constituent this evening asking could she get any home assistance. Her husband is 73 years of age and she is 68. The two of them are living on 21/6 a week. I endeavoured to get home assistance for this poor unfortunate soul and the home assistance officer, when he visited her, asked her had she any live stock and how she fed the live stock. She had not as much as a hare on her bit of ground. She says in the letter that last week she had to pay 14/11 for a shirt for her husband and 3/10 for two ounces of tobacco. "You can imagine," she says, "how much I would have for feeding live stock, seeing that I have got to spend these two amounts out of 21/6 a week." It is idle to pretend that we have a healthy economy while you have cases like that. They can be duplicated up and down the country in every city and town, and furnish a clear indication that there is much yet to be done before we can view with any optimistic complacency the economic position of this country to-day. I think it is no wonder thatin consequence of the rise in price levels we have had an aggravation of the whole unemployment position.

Documents issued to Deputies in the past few days contain some startling news. We see that in the week from the 24th to the 31st October the number of unemployed in that week alone had risen by 8,000—8,000 up in consequence of the termination of the Employment Period Order.

Comment on this

It is 3,000 lower than it was this week last year.

Comment on this

We shall come to that in a second. They are all your figures. We are now in the position in which we have approximately 60,000 unemployed and, mind you, the whole effect of the repeal of the Employment Period Order has not yet been manifested in these figures. Next week the figures unfortunately will be up again. The fact that we have 60,000 unemployed is a clear indication of how much solid work remains to be done, if we are going to rid ourselves of this cancerous disease of unemployment which is having such an appalling effect on the whole national economy. I think every Deputy, particularly Deputies who represent rural areas, will have no hesitation in acknowledging the fact that there is growing unemployment in the rural areas. In my own constituency there are places in which there are very large numbers of unemployed, places where three years ago the problem was how to take unemployment schemes in rotation because it was not possible to line up sufficient unemployed there to work at the time. Deputy Dr. Humphreys, I am glad to see, is in the House. He knows Castledermot well. I venture to say that if he stops there on his way home this week and asks anybody in the town why the number of unemployed there is so large, he will be told it is going up. If he looks at the number registered at the Carlow Unemployment Exchange, he will find a different picture there from that which existed three years ago.

Let us look at the figures to see if, even by comparision, there is any cause for jubiliation. On the 5th Novemberthe figures were 59,390. On the 1st November, 1951, they were 53,580— practically 6,000 fewer than this year. On the 4th November, 1950, the figures were 50,600 so to-day we have about 9,000 more people unemployed according to the Government's own figures, than we had in 1950.

Comment on this

And many more emigrants.

Comment on this

That is the point I want to come to—all this, in face of the fact that emigration continues to rise at an alarming rate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does this arise on the Supplies and Services Bill?

Comment on this

In this way, that because of the general policy of increasing prices we have a situation in which people cannot buy the barest necessaries of life, much less the embroideries of life, although the purchase of these embroideries formerly gave a substantial employment to a considerable number of people. So long as we have our economy geared to a high price level, while doing nothing to take up the sag of unemployment, the whole economic fabric of the nation must suffer.

The discussion on supplies and services has always necessarily involved a review of the economic position from a prices and unemployment point of view, and, of course, as you probably know, Sir, on the Supplies and Services Bill last year, the whole matter was freely discussed. I do not want to develop it to any great extent now. I refer to it only from the point of view of showing the very serious economic position and the necessity for endeavouring so to bend our economy that, by an intelligent price policy, married to an intelligent economic policy, we can provide regular employment for our people under a price economy which does not impose on our people the staggering burdens inflicted upon them to-day.

The situation in respect of unemployment is high-lighted by the very serious position which has arisen in the past 12 months in respect to agriculturalemployment alone. I do not say that this is directly due to Government policy. This is a tendency which has been manifested for some years, but the tendency is now manifesting itself in more alarming proportions. The Government figures show that, comparing June, 1953, with June, 1952, there has been a decline of almost 22,000 in the number of males employed on the land. If we had a healthy industrial position that would, nevertheless, be a cause of grave concern, but with an industrial position which affords no ground for satisfaction from any standpoint, it is alarming to find that in one year alone 20,000 males should have shed work on the land. That is an economic portent which I think is not of healthy significance for the nation.

If by mentioning these facts one can induce Ministers to recognise the seriousness of the situation and the need for action, there is some value in these discussions. But I have before me a copy of the Irish Pressfor 5th November, in which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, speaking at the annual dinner of the Dundalk Chamber of Commerce, is reported as saying: “Unemployment recorded on the 17th October showed that there has been a dramatic recovery in the general position.” I want to underline these words: “a dramatic recovery in the general position”. On 17th October, according to the Government's figures, there were 50,900 registered as unemployed, and to-day there are 60,000 registered as unemployed. The figure of unemployment jumped up by over 9,000 in the meantime. What can you think of a statement by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, presumably one of the people directing Government policy, when he says there has been “a dramatic recovery in the general position”, when between the 17th October and the date upon which this paper was published the figures had jumped up by 9,000 or 10,000?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that is a complete misrepresentation.

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this

One set of figures does not bear comparison with the other, because the Employment Period Orders have now ceased to operate. There has not been that increase in unemployment, and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to box the compass. The Minister knows well that these 9,000 additional people who trekked into the labour exchanges between the 24th October and the 31st October were people who were unemployed. There was no use trekking to the labour exchange even though they were unemployed because of the fact that they would get no unemployment assistance benefit. The fact that they were not registered at the labour exchanges did not prove that they were not unemployed. It proved that they were unemployed and that it was not worth while trekking to the labour exchanges to record the fact that they were unemployed because there was no money or sustenance for them. The Minister knows perfectly well, even though he may try to use the interruption as a debating point, that what happened when the Employment Period Orders ceased to operate was that many thousands who had been put off the unemployment register in the rural areas came back on to the register the moment the Employment Period Orders ceased. They are there now in all their pristine economic unity to be examined and to attest the fact that they are available for work and they are unable to get it. Yet the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs finds some solace in the fact that, apparently, he thought there was a dramatic recovery in the figure on the 17th October. But the dramatic recovery has turned out to be one in which our unemployed people are now registered at the labour exchanges in much greater numbers than they were when the Minister spoke on that occasion.

The Minister made some further references in his speech. He talked about the increase in the volume of agricultural production and said that farmers' incomes were rising, that the rate of industrial output and the volume of exports were going up, thatthe price of agricultural produce was stabilising itself after an uninterrupted rise by 17 per cent. He went on to make some reference to "external assets cranks" and the Irish Pressgives this heading to the speech, “Real Economic Progress Now Evident.”“Real Economic Progress Now Evident,” and we have got, according to the Government's figures, many thousands more people unemployed than we had a fortnight ago. In addition to that, we have got about 9,000 more people unemployed than we had three years ago. How, in the face of these figures, it can be said that there has been real economic progress is beyond my comprehension.

Let us look at the situation in the rural areas again for a moment. My experience of the rural areas in many parts of the country is that there is considerable and growing unemployment. To some extent we have been able to hold that down in many places by the diversion or diffusion of housing activities in the rural areas. On these housing schemes, large numbers of persons secured employment. Now, two things have happened in respect of housing. The higher rates of interest charged have lessened the demand for house building. There is no new builder going into the building industry to-day. There are many, many builders going out of the industry and, unfortunately, some are going out through the bankruptcy court, as they have been badly stung by the fact that, having built houses, they find it difficult to sell them at an economic price, and they have heavy commitments to those responsible for financing their activities.

Anyone who takes a look at the sites around Dublin which were developed for housing can see that building has practically ceased, that there is less house building going on than at any time in the last five years. On many sites you could see 50 houses going up at the one time; now, if they are going up at all, they are going up in ones or twos. Many people who had built houses have "for sale" bills on them now because there is no sale for them.

In rural areas another situation developed. It is natural that you cannot build further houses if you have satisfied the need for them. In many rural areas a considerable number of houses have been built and, because of the fact that they have been built and that the local housing need is satisfied in some areas, there is no need for building further houses in those places. You may need houses elsewhere. But, if local authorities who have tackled the problem seriously in order to satisfy the housing needs of the people are finding themselves approaching the stage in which they have broken the back of the housing problem, the same need for the erection of houses does not exist to-day as it did in other years, with the result that there is a considerable sag in the building of houses in those areas and the opportunities for employment which went hand-in-hand with house building have ceased to exist in those areas.

What is the ordinary working man in those areas going to do? Deputy Corry drew some satisfaction from an increase in agricultural production. There is virtually no increase in the volume of agricultural production. We may juggle with figures anyway we like because of rising prices on the external or home market; we may say that our agricultural production to-day is X-million pounds greater than it was a few years ago, but we are all the time dealing with a static volume of produce. This year we increased the wheat acreage, but we decreased the oats and barley acreage, and the net result was that, taking the three crops together, the area under the cultivation of the three crops was less than it was last year.

I am not saying these things in any spirit of political partisanship, but the challenge to this House and this nation is the utterly inadequate use we are making of the enormous potentialities which reside in the land of Ireland. Whether this Government or any other Government is in office, we will never have a healthy economy until such time as we get out of the land the produce which it is capable of providing under an intelligentagricultural policy. If we can agree on what lines that policy should take and only disagree as to the speed with which we can put it into operation, I think we can make marvellous progress from the standpoint of gearing-up our agricultural possibilities to a greater rate than I see there at the moment. The fact of the matter is that our agricultural production has been stagnant for 50 years. It has been a challenge to every Government which has ruled the destinies of this country over that period.

Unless we get down to examine the basic causes of that and find the remedy, we will have the same stagnant agriculture, large pockets of unemployment in the rural areas with a rural area not capable of sustaining the industries which are inevitably associated with the towns and cities.

On this Bill, because it deals with food, services and supplies, I would call the Minister's attention to what looked to be a promising new industry —the development of the dead meat trade. I do not want to talk about it in detail and with all the knowledge I have on it, but I am bound to say that there is cause for grave disquiet in that particular field. About 40 of these meat packing plants were erected in the past couple of years. A considerable sum of money was invested in them and there were high hopes that we would develop a dressed meat trade which would provide a stable market for our cattle and employment in the small towns in the rural areas for many who were previously unemployed and that by building up that particular trade and dressing the meat at home we would get valuable offal which would, in turn, provide the raw material for many other industries.

The first difficulty these folk met with was the closing down of the American market. That in itself was not a serious or an insuperable difficulty but the position now is that apparently they cannot fulfil their contracts on the British market with the result that I do not believe there is one of these 40 meat-packing plants in full operation to-day. I know there are dozens closed down almost entirely andthere are some of them on which considerable money was spent, simply lying there as silent as a cemetery. I understand the reason is that they cannot get cattle at a price which would enable them to dress the meat for sale on the British market at the price decided by the British Ministry of Food. The Government might take steps to relieve the causes of that difficulty. I understand that one of the difficulties is that they cannot compete with those whose cattle are attracted to the British market via the Six Counties.

I am afraid we are now heading for a situation in which practically all the money which has gone into these plants will be lost unless some serious effort is made to devise an arrangement by which they will get cattle for dressing. If they can do that, then I think they can provide substantial employment in these plants. Close on 4,000 people would normally get employment in these plants but there only 400 employed in them at the moment due to the difficulty of buying cattle at a price that will enable them to sell the cattle in the British market. I do not blame the Minister or the Government. That is one of the things which has arisen out of the pattern of our live-stock industry and the methods of our live-stock trade but it is a great pity and it will be a national tragedy if these dressed meat plants are going to be allowed to die. Several efforts were made from time to time to develop a dressed meat industry. There are powerful interests here and elsewhere who do not want to see us do it. It is a valuable industry from our point of view. A considerable sum of money has been sunk in these plants and if these people should lose their money now the unemployment that will inevitably follow will burn as effectively as possible the fingers of anybody who wants to pioneer on that road.

I do not know what the Government's policy is in respect of this. I think it is highly desirable, because of the employment and raw materials which it provides, that we should encourage it in every possible way. Wedo not know what the Government's policy is, but the Minister could do few more useful things than indicate that the Government are determined to save that trade by making use of the devices which are open to them in order to effect the necessary assistance to the industry which is now passing through a particularly bad time. I hope, therefore, that the Minister will in his reply to this debate take some steps to indicate that the Government is alive to the dangers which beset this industry and alive to the loss of actual and potential employment which would follow if these industries are compelled to close down. It should not be outside the bounds of possibility to devise an arrangement by which these plants can be kept in operation and some arrangement made by the cattle trade as a whole with governmental advice whereby it would be possible always to siphon off a sufficiency of cattle to enable these plants to continue to provide the employment which undoubtedly they can provide in a much greater measure than the exporting of cattle on the hoof, and at the same time establish here a really indigenous industry associated with our cattle trade.

Deputy Dillon made some reference to the Central Bank Report, but I do not think it would be appropriate on this Bill or at this stage to make any references to what is contained in this customary blue book of despair which has been issued by the Central Bank. It seems to follow the usual pattern. The only thing changed on it is the date. It is substantially the same as it was five years ago and it will probably be the same in the next five years. I do hope, however, that it will not commend itself to the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon commended me to read and study it.

Comment on this

Somebody offered Disraeli a book on one occasion on which he was not terribly keen. He took it from the donor and said he would lose no time about reading it. I hope the Minister for Finance will adopt the same tactics in connectionwith this blue book of despair. It is only intended to make people miserable. It is only intended to irritate the Irish people and advocate the philosophy of loving rags, of being proud to live a poor, impoverished life in Ireland for the privilege of living in this motherland.

I do not propose to waste time on this. I hope the Minister will repudiate it as he did last year even though, subsequently, some of his colleagues really devoted time to an intensive study of it and wasted much public time in relating the dire and sad sentiments which were contained in the report. Notwithstanding what the Central Bank says or the occasional rantings which we get in this House from the Minister for Finance about impending gloom and disaster, I am convinced that there are only three ways in which we can build up an economic fabric to gain a decent standard of life for our people. We have in this country soil and climate which is the envy of every other country in Europe. We are economic and political lunatics if we do not ensure that the soil is utilised in a way that will give us a greater measure of agricultural and dairy production than we have to-day. It is no visitation of God that we have not a greater measure of industrial production in this country. All the difficulties and impediments are manmade and can be remedied overnight if the Government and the Minister take steps to recognise the enormous waste, actual and potential, which is inevitable when following our present-day agricultural policy.

In the field of industry, while we have immense difficulties, in the form of keen competition, in finding a foreign market, we nevertheless have at home a safe market by which we can shelter our people from the worst of the economic blasts that blow from other countries. We can ensure in the home market prices that will give a reasonable return to industrialists, and we are entitled to expect them, in return, to undertake to the nation that, within their capacity, they will supply the nation with all the commodities which it needs and will play their fullpart in endeavouring to find an export market for any commodities which they can produce for that market. Over and above these two considerations, we have got all the benefits which will flow, and which can flow, from the adoption of a capital programme of development, a programme which will give us national assets of a permanent and enduring nature, and which will add to the nation's wealth and will pay dividends, money if needs be, but in any case will contribute to human happiness and to a rising and ever-expanding national economy.

I believe that it is only by a full-blooded development of our industrial and agricultural possibilities, by utilising the nation's assets here and elsewhere, together with the savings of our people in a programme of capital development, that we can ever attain the targets which will mean a decent living, and rising standards of living, for our people. One thing is certain, and that is, that if we do not adopt a policy of industrial and agricultural expansion, geared to a higher level than at present, and do not pursue a policy of capital development which will provide employment and enduring assets for the nation, then this House will continue to discuss the difficulties of living and of life in Ireland.

It will continue to discuss the ever pressing problem of unemployment, the low standard of living for many of our people, and unemployment and under-employment will be permanent problems so far as we are concerned. If, however, we recognise that reliance on the methods which we have pursued in the past, will only give us the same bleak results in the future as they have given us up to now, then we can probably get broad national agreement on a policy designed to expand our industrial and agricultural potentialities. By doing that we can probably reach a production level which will not only finance our social services but will, at the same time, meet the capital charges in the development stages of valuable national works.

I think that while we have had some indications from the Minister in recent speeches that his line of policy was bolder and more courageous than someof the utterances we have heard from some of his colleagues, I feel that if the Minister would take steps to indicate in some detail what the Government's precise plans are in the field of industrial and agricultural development, it might be possible for him to get not merely in this House but outside of it a volume of goodwill and of enthusiasm for a policy calculated to remedy the economic defects in our agricultural and industrial fabric, which at the same time would provide some remedy for our continued unemployment and for what is worse still, the haemorrhage which emigration means to the life blood of a nation.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

This debate gives Deputies an opportunity of voicing their own opinions as well as those of the electorate on conditions as they have found them affecting the country over the past 12 months. In my opinion, if the people were asked to state in what particular way this Government has been most remiss and on what particular aspect of policy they had failed most miserably, the answer would be in relation to the twin problems of unemployment and the cost of living. Some people seem to think that these problems are principally identified with the urban areas.

There is no doubt but that they are, but it should also be remembered that there is not a part of the country which to-day is not gravely concerned by the numbers of unemployed in it. The fact is that those who are in employment see that they are able to buy only very little with the wages they are earning. The same is true of those on small holdings in regard to what they get for their produce. There has been an ever increasing rise in the cost of living over the past two and a half years. That certainly was not envisaged by the people when they went to the polls in 1951. At that time, the cost of living was a very prominent feature in the programme of the then Opposition Party, and in the criticisms which they levelled at the outgoing Government. They charged it with not having kept the cost of living stable during its three and a half years in office. These criticisms by the then Opposition wereaccepted by many people as indicating that a change of Government would secure for the entire nation a reduction in the cost of living, or at least an immediate cessation of any rise in prices. Far from there being any reduction in prices, we have seen in the past two years an extraordinary increase in the cost of living. That increase has not been due to any circumstances operating outside the shores of this country. It has been attributable, purely and simply, to Government policy. The result of that policy has been that the State has had to find compensatory benefits for many sections of our people.

In the course of the past two years, local authority and other employers have had to seek some measure of compensation so that their employees would be in a position to meet their ordinary commitments and to maintain themselves and their families in a reasonable degree of comfort and security.

The Taoiseach, when speaking recently at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis, said that we had now reached the point when we had compensated all these people. That, of course, did not give a true picture of the situation. Would the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste or any member of the Government or any back bencher supporting them tell us how an ex-employee of a local authority on 15/- a week is in a position to meet the fresh charges imposed on him or her by a further reduction in the purchasing power of the £? How can that person afford to pay present prices for bread, tea and sugar and other necessaries of life out of 15/- a week? There are many sections of our people who have got absolutely no increase whatever in their allowances to meet the recent increases in the cost of living. Can any member of the Government, or any Deputy supporting it, deny that the old age pensioner, whether he is receiving 21/6 a week, 16/6 or 11/- a week, is not seriously affected by the fact that he or she has now to pay ever so much more for every single item of food? Many of those people have to bear not alone the direct consequences of the increasein the price of the particular items they require because of the abolition of subsidies but also the burden imposed on them because so many people who have to meet these increased charges are in a position to pass these increases back again on the person at the end of the queue; and the person at the end of the queue is the person least able to bear these impositions.

It must be remembered that people who are self-employed have been unable to secure an increase in their income to meet the higher cost of living. We have provided some compensation for certain sections in the community but the general upheaval created has left its mark on every Department of State and on every section of the community. There has been an extraordinary increase in the cost of running our public institutions and local authorities have been obliged to increase the rates in order to meet their heavy commitments.

It is in connection with unemployment that we find most fault with this Government. The increased cost of living has imposed great hardship on the unemployed. Even if unemployed persons obtained an increase in unemployment assistance, it was swallowed up immediately by the price they had to pay for essential commodities. Let no one from the opposite benches shout across: "What about the producer? Are you defending a reduction for the producer?" We certainly are not because the buffer which existed as between the consumer and producer was completely annihilated when most of the food subsidies were abolished. It is only three years or so since the State was in a position to soften the impact of any rise in production costs; the consumer was not called upon immediately to bear it. The Government has thrown every aspect of public life into disorganisation and caused great distress among the people. It is a pitiable sight to see in our cities and towns the queues of people at the labour exchanges.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has been indicated several times already that unemployment, of itself, is not debatable.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I at least did not have an opportunity to refer to it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No other Deputy had.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I respectfully submit that unemployment is linked to the cost of living inasmuch as there have been repercussions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This measure is not designed to relieve unemployment. It is designed to look after supplies and services.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister is seeking the retention of certain powers for a further period. Government policy has made it impossible for a great many of our people to avail of either the supplies or the services because the Government has taken from them their way of living. They have embarked upon a financial policy which has made it impossible for many people to keep their families in reasonable comfort. Many firms cannot afford to keep their workers in full employment which they previously enjoyed; they are working only parttime and unfortunately some of them are obliged to have recourse to the employment exchanges in order to secure some means of supporting themselves and their families.

We await the reply of the Minister with interest. We await any comments his colleagues in the Government may have to make in the course of this debate so that they can explain how this small country which, thanks to Divine Providence, was spared from the horrors of war, should within a few years of the cessation of hostilities be called upon to meet an increase in the cost of living far in excess of that of any other nation in Europe with one exception. Most of these nations were imperilled and have had to face serious commitments since that time in trying to rebuild their country. We were led to understand in Ireland that we were as immune from the results of that conflict as it was possible for us to be but we can now point to the increases in the cost of living. We point to the fact that although the previousGovernment had many other great responsibilities to face up to, one of its greatest achievements was to keep down the cost of living which was continually increasing up to the time they took office. Then in their latter months of office due to circumstances over which they had no control—the diversion of shipping and other incidental happenings which arose out of the Korean conflict—there was a rise of a few points in the cost-of-living index. Now with import prices falling and the world returning to some measure of calm, we certainly wonder why so many people would be denied what is surely their birthright, employment in their own country. It is the duty of the Government to give them employment and to try to keep down the cost of living so that people may have a reasonable standard of living.

Everybody one meets, no matter what his walk of life may be, has a complaint about the present state of affairs, and it is unfortunate that the people who suffer most are those least able to bear it, the people in the smaller income groups who have to rely on the staple foods, bread, tea and sugar. It is those who have the very least by way of income, whether it be a pension or wages secured from employment, who are affected most rather than those with bigger salaries and income.

Those articles which were subsidised —and which, if still subsidised at all, are subsidised only in a very small way—formed their principal items of diet. For that reason, they felt the outcome of the abolition of the subsidies far more than others. We find now that those engaged in self-employment, those in production, particularly the small farming class, have to bear many other costs passed on to them by middle-men who are able to recompense themselves for any difficulties they had to overcome. Now the consumer has also to face the fact that those producing the vital necessaries of life are meeting increased production costs as day succeeds day.

I referred earlier to the effect on our public institutions. Anyone, no matter what his Party, who is a member ofany hospital board or board of assistance will agree that over the past two years we have had to meet extraordinary increases even in a few items relating to the maintenance of those people it is our duty to look after. That increase has been met by an increase in rates or by some other means. Therefore, we can assume that every housewife has to face the same responsibility. Very often they are very vocal on this matter and when given the opportunity they can record their displeasure very emphatically. That displeasure has no doubt increased because of the fact that they were led to believe by the Party opposite before they attained office that if given an opportunity they could do something useful in this respect. Naturally, the extreme criticism which the Party opposite offered to the previous Government, for failure to deal with a simple three points increase due to forces outside the control of any Government, brought to their Party a measure of support.

They presented a programme to the Dáil showing emphatically that if they secured election they would control the cost of living, which is one of the items they promised to deal with. In particular, they were to deal with rising costs, but now after two and a half years of the present Government, scarcely a month passes without some increase in the cost of the necessaries of life. That is in addition to the extraordinary increases people have to meet in regard to simple luxuries they may enjoy.

I wish also to express my grave concern at the numbers of young people who are leaving this country, seeking employment in England, Canada, Australia and elsewhere. We know there always was emigration, but it was never on the scale it is on at present. I do not think it was ever known for whole families to move completely out of this country, as occurred in the last two years. I cannot say it happens in my own constituency.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think it is relevant, either.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

However, we know that applications come in frompeople who wish to remove furniture to new homes in Britain. In my own constituency there are young men and young women emigrating as they cannot find work at home. Much of that is to be attributed to the failure of the Government in giving them some encouragement that they would secure employment and that what they would receive in wages would be left to them to buy the simple necessaries of life and the simple luxuries that should be available to them at reasonable prices. Now, they cannot see any future as long as this Government persists in the policy it has pursued since it secured election two and a half years ago. It is vital that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would appreciate that these conditions exist. It is up to him and to the Government of which he is Tánaiste to take immediate steps to ease this burning problem of the cost of living and to put into productive employment the large numbers that those in employment have to maintain on the dole at the present time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister, to conclude.

Comment on this

It is obvious that over the week-end the leaders of the Fine Gael Party held a conference and decided that the reports which appeared in the newspapers of the speeches which were delivered from their benches on this Bill last week were doing them political harm. I think they were right in that. I am quite certain the people do not like to hear their public men caterwauling about the adverse factors in the national position without making some effort to deal with them constructively, without taking some responsibility for the putting forward of positive suggestions for dealing with them.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The pawnbroker's sign?

Comment on this

They sent Deputy Dillon in to-day to make constructive suggestions. Whether his effort has repaired the Fine Gael dykes or not is a matter of opinion. No doubt some people may think the suggestions he put forward may have something in them; and if their propagandadepartment keeps on repeating often enough that they are constructive suggestions, an odd person here and there may believe that something of that character was put forward.

Many of the speeches which were delivered in this debate did not seem to me to have any direct relation to the Bill. I intend to confine myself to matters that do arise properly from the Bill before the House. I agreed earlier, when questions of relevancy were discussed, that the cost of living was one of those matters, because at the present time the powers that the Government exercises to control prices are conferred by the Supplies and Services Act, and if that Act should be allowed to lapse or be defeated by a vote of the Dáil then powers to control prices would disappear with it.

All the efforts of the Opposition speakers were directed towards establishing that increases in the cost of living are solely the responsibility of the Government. They endeavoured to suggest that some course of action was open to the Government which, if followed, would have prevented the cost of living rising. In order to secure whatever political advantage might be obtained by establishing that point, they sacrificed any lingering remnant of reputation they may have had for understanding the problems of this country; they sacrificed all honesty and any attempt at fairness in debate. Every Fine Gael speaker ran away from the real issue of prices.

One or two of them, such as the last speaker, who, in the course of his remarks began to get within reach of the realities of the situation, decided to duck at once and to get back to the old theme: the Government could have done something and, because it did not do it, the cost of living has gone up.

Deputy Declan Costello, who opened the debate for the Fine Gael Party and delivered the most dishonest speech of all those made during this debate, started off on that line. He took certain selected facts and based his argument upon those, suppressing all the other facts and every statistic available to him which appeared likely to invalidate the conclusion to whichhe was trying to lead the House. He said that it is an extraordinary situation that for two years import prices have been falling but the cost of living has nevertheless been going up. On the basis of that assertion he built his entire case that responsibility for the rise in the cost of living rests on the Government and that it was within the power of the Government to prevent that rise taking place by some administrative action.

It is quite true that since June, 1951, there has been a slight downward tendency in import prices. The import price index number showed, as between June, 1951, and June, 1953, a decrease of 9 per cent. As to when a decline in import prices might be expected to show itself in retail prices is a matter upon which we might argue, but that is not the argument I want to make.

The point I want to establish is that import prices are less important than internal prices in determining the cost of living. It was surely dishonest for a Deputy, who was seeking to establish the case that the rise in the cost of living could have been prevented by some action of the Government, to have quoted these import price statistics and to have ignored every other statistic bearing upon that question; to ignore, for example, the fact that during the same period agricultural prices increased by 15½ per cent. Most Deputies will, I am sure, recognise that the price paid to farmers for milk and vegetables and wheat has a far more direct bearing upon the cost of living than the price we pay for timber, fertilisers, newsprint or oils.

There was no straightforward reference to the rise in agricultural prices during that period or to the effect of that rise upon the cost of living and every Deputy who came by accident in the course of his remarks within range of the question of agricultural prices said straightway that he was not in favour of reducing any agricultural prices and then got quickly on to some other aspect of the problem. Surely it was relevant to remark that during the same two-year period since this Government returned to office in June, 1951, wage rates in manufacturing industry increased by22 per cent. The index of wage rates in manufacturing industry which was 170.8 in 1951 rose to 191.6 in 1952 and to 209 in 1953.

Comment on this

What was the cause of that?

Comment on this

Increased wages paid to workers.

Comment on this

It was the Budget.

Comment on this

The Deputy must understand me. I said the cost of living has gone up and if we propose to consider what action could have been taken then or should be taken now to deal with the question of the cost of living we have to consider something more than import prices. We have to consider the prices paid to farmers for the food produced by them and the wages paid to workers. The fact that agricultural prices and wage rates have gone up has surely a very direct bearing on the cost of living at the present time.

Comment on this

Farm labourers' wages have not gone up very much.

Comment on this

Let us take these four sets of statistics and see what conclusions we should draw from them. Since 1951, and notwithstanding the reduction and alteration in food subsidies, about which some Deputies have been so eloquent to-day, the rise in the cost of living as disclosed by the cost-of-living index number was less than the rise in wage rates or the rise in agricultural prices.

Again, let me remind Deputies of the figures. Since 1951 the cost-of-living index number has gone up by 12.6 per cent. Farm prices have gone up by 15.5 per cent. and wage rates by 22 per cent. Therefore, it is a fair conclusion that to-day as compared with 1951 both farmers and workers are better off in real terms than they were in 1951.

Comment on this

Of course that is not true.

Comment on this

It is certainly true of the worker in employment. It is trueof the worker who has secured the average increase in wages which the wage index number reveals. The average rise in wages has been greater than the average rise in the cost of living over that period. If the Deputy says that is not true what the Deputy is really saying is that the statistics published by the Central Statistics Office are to be discredited. I do not accept that. There is another conclusion to be drawn from these figures and it is that the level of agricultural prices and wage rates affects the level of retail prices far more than the cost of importing materials from abroad, the level of import prices. Any Deputy who gives a moment's common-sense thought to this whole problem must realise how obvious it is that there can be no reduction in the cost of living unless farm prices and wage rates come down as well.

Comment on this

And many other things.

Comment on this

I shall deal with some of the other things later on.

Comment on this

The cost of money, for instance.

Comment on this

I have been asked for a declaration of the attitude of the Government. We do not believe it is desirable that the Government should take action to force down either farm prices or wage rates. The Opposition's criticism of the rise in the cost of living, their refusal to face the realities of the cause of that rise and the whole implication of their observations, if they understood it, is that farm prices should be lowered and wage rates reduced at the same time so that the level of retail prices would come down.

Comment on this

What about the people who have no wages?

Comment on this

I do not agree with that view as adumbrated by the Opposition. I have said that the cost of living and the level of prices generally appear now to be more or less stabilised and are likely to remain so.

Comment on this

Why do you not control prices as you controlled wages under the standstill Order?

Comment on this

Deputy Declan Costello asked me for a statement of the Government's attitude on this matter and, in reply, I refer him to the statement I made on the Supplies and Services Bill on 4th December last. At column 880 of Volume 135 of the Official Report I said:—

"What is the position now, and what is the position likely to be in the future? I think it is true to say that only internal factors are causing prices to go up now. The import price index number has fallen fairly consistently since the first quarter of this year. The cost of goods imported into this country and used for industrial and agricultural purposes is tending downwards, but the effect of that fall in material costs on our price level is being offset by rising internal costs. There is a fair prospect that when these adjustments in internal costs are completed a position of price stability will be realised."

That is the forecast I made last year and the only claim I make now is that that forecast was borne out by the events of 1953. So far as it is possible for the Government to influence the trend of prices, and every Deputy who understands the matter knows that the power of the Government to influence the trend of prices is very limited indeed, its power will be directed towards keeping prices stable.

Comment on this

The Minister says the powers of the Government are limited.

Comment on this

Of course they are. It is not possible for the Government to control price levels absolutely unless they are prepared to control every factor that makes up prices, including wages, farm costs and all the other factors the Deputy has in mind. We do not propose to control any of these except to the extent that it is necessary and vital in the public interest and certainly control will not extend either to farm prices or to wages. In so far as it is possible to influence the trend of prices that influence will be exercised towards keeping prices stable. We think that stability of prices will facilitate our progress, that the consequencesof price fluctuations up or down are likely to be bad and that we are far more likely to improve the standard of living of our people and to secure the economic progress of the country if we can hold out the prospect that the value of money will remain stable for a reasonable period ahead.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the methods of financing industry to-day are satisfactory?

Comment on this

That is too wide a question to answer on this Bill.

Comment on this

You can talk for the next two days and answer it. That is one of the problems.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton said that price control is not being enforced, that there are groups and rings extracting undue profits—extracting, he said, the last penny they can from the consumer in order to enhance their profits. If the effectiveness of price control is to be determined by the profits made by traders and manufacturers —and may I say that I do not necessarily agree that that is so, but that is the test Deputy Norton wants to apply —then the contrast between price control in 1952 and the Coalition Government's effort at price control is very striking indeed.

Comment on this

Prices were far lower in the Coalition time than they are now.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton thinks the effectiveness of price control is to be determined by the amount of profits made by traders, and his suggestion is that traders are making more profits now than they were when the Coalition Government was in office.

Comment on this

Of course they are. There is no control. They can charge what they like.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should allow the Minister to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

Taking 1950 as a typical Coalition year, the last complete year in which they were in office, retail grocers in that year made profits whichrepresented 3.07 per cent. of their turnover. In 1952 their profits fell to 2.9 per cent. of their turnover. Milk distributors in 1950 made profits of 4.3 per cent. of their turnover. It fell to 3.6 per cent. in 1952. The whole food group of retail traders made profits equivalent to 3.2 per cent. of their turnover in 1950, and that fell to 2.9 per cent. of their turnover in 1952.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give the profit in terms of total money?

Comment on this

I cannot do that. The information which comes in from individual firms is not available to me.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give the percentage change in turnover in the two years?

Comment on this

Yes, I can. I cannot give it for 1950. The total turnover for all retail traders in 1951 was £46,500,000, and in 1952 was £44,500,000.

Comment on this

You have not it for 1950?

Comment on this

I have not the figure here for 1950. Traders dealing in clothing made profits in 1950 representing 5 per cent. of their turnover, and that had fallen to 3.1 per cent. in 1952. Other traders in miscellaneous goods made profits representing 5.2 per cent. of the value of their turnover in 1950, which had fallen to 4.1 per cent. in 1952. I can give similar figures for manufacturers, but I know that Deputies, having in mind the circumstances of 1952, would not be surprised to hear that manufacturers made lower profits in that year than they did in 1950. The fact is, however, that in the year 1952 many groups of manufacturers made profits which were altogether too low, profits which were disturbingly low because they held out prospects of future difficulties for these manufacturers. Certainly, in practically every case, the profits made in 1952 were lower than the profits made in 1950.

I am not proud of these figures. I do not want Deputies to understand that I think they represent a satisfactory position in this country. I produce them to answer DeputyNorton's argument. Deputy Norton contended that by reason of defective price control, traders and manufacturers are making more profits now than they were allowed to make when the Coalition Government was in office. The fact is they are making less profits now, and I think it is important for the future of industrial development that manufacturers as a whole should do better in 1953 than they did in 1952. If they do not do better, certainly, the prospects of promoting expansion of industrial activity through private enterprise will be considerably reduced.

Comment on this

That is a surprising statement for me to hear from you.

Comment on this

What is more, I am certain that every worker in this country will agree with me that it is a far more serious business for him if his employer is making a loss rather than a profit. The security of his employment, he knows, will depend upon the ability of his employer to remain in business.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners can remedy all that.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave said that the cost of living here was the highest ever. That is true. Of course, it is true of every country. It was giving a very false picture to say that and no more. The cost of living was the highest ever but wage rates are also higher than they ever were before. The average wage paid in 1953 was 14s. per week higher than in 1951, according to the Central Statistics Office.

Comment on this

What is the value of the £?

Comment on this

The Deputy must not misunderstand what I am trying to do. I am trying to deal with the false propaganda, delivered from the benches opposite and designed to misrepresent the national position, by putting it right, by putting the facts first. Later I will tell the Deputy the conclusions I draw from the facts.

When Deputy Cosgrave says that the cost of living was higher than it was ever before, that is true but it is notthe whole truth. The truth is that wage rates are higher than they were ever before. The truth is that the value of agricultural output is far higher than ever before. Net agricultural output in 1952, according to the Statistical Survey,was £21,000,000 higher than it was in 1950. The national income was higher than it was ever before. In 1952 it was £71,000,000 higher than it was in 1950. The level of investment was higher than it was ever before. The value of money has altered and it is completely misleading to describe the national position as affected by a higher cost of living than ever existed before and not to recognise that the same causes that pushed up the cost of living have pushed up values in every other operation carried on in the national economy which is calculated in terms of money.

It is true that many of our farm prices are higher than world level. We are guaranteeing to our farmers now a price for wheat which works out at £6 per ton on a dry wheat basis higher than the world price. What the future of the world price may be is a matter upon which experts are debating.

Comment on this

And the consumer is paying for that in the price of flour and bread.

Comment on this

The consumer is not paying for that, but the taxpayer is through the subsidy. We put up the price of milk last year to 1/6 per gallon. We permitted an increase in the price of butter and milk. We could bring down the price of milk again. Am I to understand from some of the speeches delivered by Deputies opposite that that is what is intended? I know that Deputy Costello said that he dissolved the Dáil in 1951 rather than give in to the blackmail that was being exercised upon him to increase the price of milk, but is that the present policy of the Party opposite? Will they now say that they think the price of butter or milk should be brought down by reducing the return to the producer? I do not think they will. There was not one Deputy in the course of this debate who attempted to suggest that the solutionof our cost of living problem might be found in that way.

Comment on this

The Irish farmers are not getting the New Zealand butter price.

Comment on this

They are getting a much higher price.

Comment on this

Surely not.

Comment on this

I thought that that was the complaint. Mind you, there might be something to be said for the argument occasionally advanced by Fine Gael spokesmen that New Zealand butter should be sold at the price it cost to buy so that the public might understand fully the difference between the price we are paying to the Irish farmer for milk to make butter and the price at which butter can be purchased abroad. But we thought it would be far better in the national interest that there should not be two classes of butter at two different prices available, and that the additional profit that was made by the sale of New Zealand butter should be used to offset the cost of storing Irish butter. That is the way it was used.

It is quite an easy matter for some Deputies opposite to compare the movement of the cost of living in this country with the movement in other countries by taking some arbitrary date and calculating the change from that date. It is quite true, as the O.E.E.C. report pointed out, that in the first six months of this year the cost of living was higher than in the first six months of last year. We all know it was. The effect on prices caused by the reduction of subsidies came into operation in the middle of last year. But to contrast that result with the position in other countries is misleading unless all the facts relating to those other countries are also known. Most countries subsidised foods to some extent or another during the war and most of them withdrew them before we did, so that the alteration in the cost of living in those countries just began a bit earlier. I could produce a quite different picture by choosing some other date upon which to base a calculation. In fact,however, all the O.E.E.C. price statistics for European countries are based on 1948. 1948 is the basic year, and if we contrast the change in the cost of living which has taken place here since 1948 with the change in all other countries we will find we were about average. In ten European countries the cost of living rose by more than it rose here; in nine countries it rose by less; so that we have not got the grievance which some Deputies opposite appear to want to exploit.

Arising out of a remark made last week by Deputy Kyne, might I remind the Labour Party of the fact that the whole saving to the Exchequer effected by the reduction in the food subsidies was devoted to increasing social welfare payments. Deputy Kyne said that he would never support a Government unless it was prepared to restore the combined level of social welfare and food subsidy payments to the point at which they stood when the Coalition Government left office. That has been done. The cost of the increase in social welfare payments, which came into operation since this Government came into office, exceeds £7,000,000 per year, and that is more than was saved to the Exchequer by the alteration in food subsidies.

Comment on this

Some people have lost under the social welfare.

Comment on this

I do not know if that is so or not; but the effect of this change is this, that £7,000,000 which was paid out of the taxpayers' money, the benefit of which formerly went indiscriminately to the wealthiest as well as the poorest in the country, to all people, whether they needed it or not, is now being concentrated upon those sections of our community that need help from the Exchequer most, and we think that that was a good change.

Deputy Dillon, as one of his constructive suggestions, made some irrelevant and completely misleading remarks about tea. It is untrue that if we were to permit our tea wholesalers to buy their tea supplies now from the London market instead of through the central importing organisation which is operating here they would get itcheaper. The last time I examined the position, I found that the lowest priced tea available through Tea Importers, Limited, was lower than the lowest price tea available in the London market. He said that I have a bee in my bonnet about this because the British Government let us down regarding tea supplies during the war and that I am getting my own back now.

It is perfectly true that they let us down, that they broke their solemn pledge to us in regard to tea supplies during the war, but my grievance is not with the British Government; it is with those tea wholesalers in London who had the monopoly of this market and would not raise their fingers or lift their voices with the British Government to secure a more reasonable allocation of the available supplies to this country during that period. I said then in the Dáil and on the radio that when the war was over, if I had any influence on Government policy here, I would establish an arrangement which would mean that we would draw all our tea supplies from the country of origin and cut out the British middleman. I think that is good policy now. It is good policy because it means that the reserve stocks, which we should have had before the war but which were then in London, will in future be held in this country. The normal trading stocks which the wholesalers and retailers must hold to meet their commitments will be available here in another emergency to strengthen our supply position. It surely must be possible for us to buy tea direct from India and import it into this country at a lower price than if we pay a British middleman commission for doing it for us. I do not believe that it is possible for tea to be brought through London cheaper than we can buy it direct. It is contrary to common sense, and I am hoping that when the permanent arrangements for tea importation into this country are in operation that will be demonstrated beyond all question of doubt.

Comment on this

But will the people as a whole be consulted as to who will get the monopoly?

Comment on this

There will be legislation to deal with this matter. On my Estimate I told the Dáil that I had hoped that a new arrangement, which would restore freedom to private traders, would be in operation this year but I found that it was not possible to put it in operation this year, and at the request of the trade it was decided to postpone its operation until the opening of the next buying season. The form of the legislation which will be required is at present being discussed with all the interests concerned. I will bring that legislation here and Deputies will have a full opportunity of expressing their views on its merits. It will be devised to give the maximum freedom to individual traders to operate in a normal way, while at the same time giving effect to the Government policy of ensuring that supplies are bought direct from the country in which they are produced without the intervention of foreign middlemen.

Deputy Blowick said that as a result of the Government's policy the level of consumption has fallen. It is quite true that various statistics suggest that the people of this country bought less consumer goods in 1952 than in 1951—very slightly less. There was a general process of stocking up in 1951 which operated amongst private people as well as among traders, and there was a counter process of de-stocking in 1952, so that the statistics for the two years are not strictly comparable; but if Deputy Blowick was trying to suggest that people bought less because they could not afford to pay for more goods, the statistics prove him to be completely wrong, because side by side with that slight fall in the level of domestic purchases there was a very considerable increase in the level of personal savings. According to the Statistical Surveywhich Deputies can study for themselves personal savings in 1952 rose to £30,000,000 whereas in 1951 it was estimated that there was actually a dissaving.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say who saved that money?

Comment on this

The people who putmoney into the Post Office Savings Bank, bought saving certificates and so forth. The figures are there for the Deputy to study, if he wants to.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. Is it not a fact that the well-to-do people who get children's allowances put that money back into the Post Office?

Comment on this

Not being in that class, I do not know.

Comment on this

That is how the Post Office savings are being increased. You will see it done in any post office in Ireland.

Comment on this

Let me turn now from the question of the cost of living to that of unemployment and consider some of the statements made regarding unemployment during the course of this debate. I often wonder if the Deputies opposite believe, themselves, some of the statements they make, much less hope to get other people to believe them. Deputy Blowick, a former member of the Coalition Government, said here that no time during that Government's period of office did the number of registered unemployed rise beyond 30,000. I read it in the Official Report of the debate. I was not quite sure, when I was listening to Deputy Blowick, if I heard the figure correctly but that is the figure which appears in the Official Report.

In the first year in which the Coalition Government were in office, the average weekly number of registered unemployed was 61,157. Deputy Blowick said that at no time during the term of office of the Coalition Government did the number of registered unemployed rise beyond 30,000. The average weekly number of registered unemployed in the first year of that Government's term of office was 61,157. The highest figure reached during that year was 80,667.

Comment on this

That was when we took over.

Comment on this

In the second year of office of the Coalition Government, the average weekly unemployment figuresrose to 61,817 and the highest figure to 84,475. At no time during the whole of the period of office of the Coalition Government did the number of registered unemployed fall to 30,000.

Deputy Dillon said here that the Coalition Government had to bring workers back from abroad in order to enable work to be done. He said that there was a scarcity of workers. Some peculiar scenes must have been witnessed at the ports during that period because the average number of emigrants per year while the Coalition Government were in office was well over 30,000.

Comment on this

They brought back skilled workers.

Comment on this

The Statistical Abstractsays that the average net emigration during that period was 30,000.

Comment on this

The highest ever recorded.

Comment on this

That means that the number going out exceeded the number coming in by that amount. That was the highest figure ever recorded in this country since 1924.

Comment on this

What is it to-day? They are all gone to Britain now. That is why they are not registered now.

Comment on this

There is another factor which Opposition Deputies are inclined to leave out of account. It is convenient for them that the unemployment statistics for this year are not comparble with those of previous years. They ignore the fact that a new Social Welfare Act has been passed. That new Social Welfare Act considerably extended the scope of the unemployment assistance scheme. It brought on to the unemployment assistance register a number of persons who would not have been on it if that Act had not been passed. The number of additional names on the register, consequent upon the passing of that Act, varied, according to the Central Statistics Office, from something over 10,000 in May last to 5,500 odd in October. If we make allowance for that factor, we have to record that during most of the past summer the number of unemployed was less thanduring the previous summer. As every Deputy who studies the figures knows, there was a steady improvement during the summer months——

Comment on this

How is it that there were no parades of unemployed in Dublin while the inter-Party Government were in office?

Comment on this

Because you did not organise them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Leary must restrain himself and cease interrupting.

Comment on this

What about the parades of unemployed which we witnessed during the past year? What about putting the leaders in jail? I could not listen to the Minister. I will leave the Chamber.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Deputy O'Leary cannot take it.

Comment on this

There are thousands of unemployed. I could not listen to the Minister.

Deputy O'Leary withdrew.

Comment on this

I have always argued here that our unemployment problem is serious, and I have never attempted to minimise its dimensions. When I was Minister for Industry and Commerce in the past, I took measures at various times to ensure that we had accurate statistics on unemployment so that we would know exactly the size of the task facing us. The practice of publishing weekly unemployment statistics was begun by me as Minister for Industry and Commerce. It is being continued by me now. I have objected to the magnitude of the problem being exaggerated; I would equally object to its being minimised.

If we are to deal properly with the problems of this country, we must know them exactly as they are. I admit that unemployment is the biggest problem of all. This Government are prepared to take, as a test of the soundness of their policy, its effect on employment. If we put more people in employment, create more jobs, then the Government's policy is successful. If there is not that result, then its policy is afailure. We will accept that test and will stand by the results.

Comment on this

Does that include the thousands of men who are on relief work?

Comment on this

I resent most strongly the suggestion that workers employed on road improvements are on relief work. Twenty-three thousand workers are employed on road operations at the present time, and they are doing a job which I think is essential to the development of the country. Their work will not merely save lives: it will save costs and it will increase the over-all efficiency of the national organisation. My view is that we are not doing nearly enough to improve the highways of the country. I have urged that, in addition to the new income to the Road Fund, secured by the adjustment of the motor vehicle duties last year, there should be put into it a proportion of the National Development Fund which is to be set up by legislation before the House. I think that is good work, work which is worth doing. I am sure that those who are engaged on it, and all who appreciate its importance will resent Deputy Dillon's contemptuous reference to the workers employed upon the Naas Road scheme or any other road improvement project of that kind.

Deputy Dillon said that we are substituting relief work on the Naas Road scheme and the Dublin Castle project for house building and land improvement. There is being spent on land improvement at the present time, and there are employed on land improvement at the present time, five times the amount of money and five times the number of persons as were employed when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture and administering the scheme. That does not suggest that anything has been substituted for it. May I say, in regard to the Dublin Castle project or any other project for the construction of public buildings, that not one penny, not one brick and not one worker will go into these public building projects which is or who is required for the building of houses either by local authorities or private contractors.

It is nonsense to talk as if we were still in the war period with limited supplies of timber, limited supplies of cement or limited supplies of other building materials. There is no scarcity of these materials now and, unfortunately, there is no scarcity of labour either. The more workers we can employ, using available supplies of building materials, on construction operations of all kinds, the better for the community. We can proceed with the rehousing programme, which Fianna Fáil initiated, simultaneously with the construction of necessary public buildings. No public building programme will diminish by one house per year the result of the building drive.

Deputy Blowick says that the Government are controlled by the Central Bank. Deputy Dillon read an extract from the most recent report of the Central Bank and commended it to the Government. It is very difficult to know the common line of policy between Deputy Dillon and Deputy Blowick. Deputy Norton tells me not to read that report. He made special reference to the extract which Deputy Dillon quoted in order to express his disagreement with it. If ever and whenever Deputy Norton and Deputy Dillon get into the same Government again, I hope that it will be Deputy Norton's view that will prevail and that, when that time comes, it will be Deputy Norton who will be able to talk about Deputy Dillon as being "as quiet as a mouse."

The Government has no responsibility of any kind, and never had responsibility, for the views expressed in its annual report by the Central Bank Board. The Act setting up that board makes it quite clear that it has the obligation of expressing its comments on the management of the public finances, but the Government is not bound to have regard to its views in the application of its own policy, if it does not agree with them. It certainly is a useful thing to have an authoritative body in a position to express an independent view upon these important public questions and to point out the possible dangers associated with any course of action the Governmentmay follow. No country is the worse for having an independent view of that kind expressed, but the fact that the Central Bank expresses that view in no way commits the Government to following it or to agreeing with it.

Comment on this

What banking functions has the Central Bank?

Comment on this

Deputy Norton says I repudiated the Central Bank Report last year. I did nothing of the sort. I indicated that I did not agree with it and there are certain observations in this year's report that I do not agree with; but Deputies who have been alleging that the Government is controlled by the Central Bank and does what the Central Bank directs, will, I am sure, have had their confidence in the correctness of their views shaken by the most recent report. The Central Bank is caoining as loudly as ever.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister read Mr. Colbert's statement.

Comment on this

We had here the expression of a most extraordinary opinion from the spokesman of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Declan Costello. He was put up to lead this debate and I presume he was speaking with the authority of his Party. It was quite obviously a carefully prepared speech he delivered and the views in it must be assumed to conform with Party policy. He told us that the important thing was to repatriate our external assets in any way possible and that they should be brought back even in the form of consumer goods. He said he favoured repatriation of external assets by deliberate planned deficits in trade. I think that is the policy of a madhouse. Apparently, the Fine Gael Party regard the possession of external reserves as something to be ashamed of, as some handicap to be got rid of as quickly as possible. Most other countries in the world would regard them as an essential bulwark of their economic independence.

There is obviously no sense in keeping abroad financial resources which could be more profitably employed athome, and, in case that observation of mine is misunderstood, may I make it clear that, in using the expression "profitably employed at home", I do not confine their use to purposes which are profitable in the financial sense. I disagree with the view implied in the Central Bank Report that external assets should be repatriated for utilisation here only if they can earn more money here than they are at present earning abroad. We could be satisfied with a much smaller financial return if the general economic or social consequences were sufficient to justify the change, but the aim of the Government is to induce people to bring back for use in this country any external funds they may control for the purpose of their productive investment here. We do not propose, as I think Deputy Costello suggested his Party might do, to confiscate or conscript these resources of private persons, at least not until it is clear that it is a life and death matter for the country. During the whole period I have been Minister for Industry and Commerce, I can say that no worth-while development of any kind, whether planned by a Government Department or some private group of people, ever failed to materialise because of inability to get the capital to finance it.

Comment on this

That worn-out argument will not stand the light of day. We had to pay a big price for the money you are talking about.

Comment on this

It is not an argument; it is a statement of fact.

Comment on this

And it just leaves us where we are.

Comment on this

The level of investment, whether on public or private account, is far higher now than it ever was under the Coalition Government. There was not a single project for capital investment started by the Coalition Government. Every form of investment they undertook was under the authority of an Act framed and passed through the Dáil at the instance of the previous Fianna Fáil Government.

To come back to Deputy Costello's point, I want to make it quite clearthat we do not propose to encourage the use of these external reserves to finance the importation of consumer goods, goods we are quite capable of making for ourselves. It is a good thing that Deputy Costello realises, and that others of his Party are beginning to realise, when they talk of repatriation of external assets that the only form in which they can come in is in the form of goods. As I said before, they have to visualise the process of repatriation in the form of ships coming into port and dockers going aboard and taking off goods for landing here.

We repatriated these external assets to the extent of a considerable sum of money when 4,000,000 square yards of worsted cloth were imported in 1951, but the effect of that repatriation of external assets was to put thousands of workers here out of their jobs for a year. We ended that type of repatriation. It is a good thing, however, that this keener realisation of the significance of what they are talking about is beginning to come to the Deputies of the Fine Gael Party, and that they now can talk about repatriation of external assets in a form that people can understand.

The importation of consumer goods, the bringing in of imported products we could make for ourselves, the putting out of their employment of Irish workers now engaged in the production of these products, is a policy we do not believe in and will vigorously oppose in office or out of it. Let Deputies remember that it is not a disadvantage to have external assets. It is a very considerable advantage.

Other countries are making substantial sacrifices at present in order to get into the position we are in, of having external reserves to call upon in times of difficulty. If the terms of trade should turn to our disadvantage, or if the policies of other Governments should make it impossible for us to expand our exports in sufficient degree, it will be a good thing to have these reserves of foreign currency with which to finance imports of essential materials required to keep the level of industrial activity going in this country. If we can, by utilising them,secure release from the necessity for imports by expanding production here, it will be something worth doing and something the doing of which we will encourage; but to dissipate these external assets, merely to get rid of them, on the importation of goods we do not need to import because we can produce them for ourselves, would be, as I have said, a policy fit for a madhouse.

Many matters were raised in the course of the debate which I am not in a position to deal with, including references to administrative details concerning the Department of Agriculture or Local Government. Deputies who want to talk about these matters will have other opportunities, and, so far as local government is concerned, they will have the opportunity in the very near future because the Estimate is ordered for debate.

This Bill is one which gives the Government certain powers they need to retain for the present to carry on certain important activities, including control of prices, regulation of imports, operation of currency control and other functions of that kind. It is intended to be the last Bill of its kind. By the time the Bill will be due for renewal, every Department will have brought to the Dáil proposals for legislation to give it such powers as it permanently requires. We think it undesirable that these very wide powers which some Deputies criticised should be available to the Government in normal times. We are proposing, therefore, to shed them, to get rid of them, but we cannot get rid of them until, in some cases permanent legislation gives the continuing powers we require. That is why we are asking the Dáil to pass the Bill for a further period of 15 months, on our assurance that they will not be asked to renew it at the end of that period.

Comment on this