Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–111 of 234. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Having failed to secure from the Taoiseach an apologia dealing with the result of his Government's policy up to date, so far as it has been in operation up to date, and also having failed to secure from him not merely an exposition but even an indication of whether or not there is going to be a change in that policy for the future and, if so, the nature of that change and when it is expected to be put into operation, we in the Opposition can do nothing but avail ourselves of the occasion of this debate to review past Government policy and its evil consequences, and to endeavour to assess from the evidence available to us at the moment whether or not there is any change of heart in the Government, whether they intend to change their policy or whether what they intend to do merely amounts to giving in to political expediency what they failed to concede to the facts, to reason and to argument.
During the course of the past six months and perhaps for a longer period, we have been discussing ondepartmental Estimates various details of Government policy. Government policy in action and its results have been examined, probed and exposed, and, accordingly, it will not be necessary for me to go in detail into every aspect of Government policy, or to consider in detail all the evil consequences which have flown directly and inevitably from the operation of that policy. I, therefore, propose to give only a short summary, at the outset of the remarks and comments I have to make, of the general results of that policy, and, in considering these results, it must be remembered that the policy of the Government has been in operation during a period when the war clouds have receded a fair amount, during a time when the dislocation of international trade and of the economy of world commerce has been to some extent eased and when import prices have been steadily falling over a period of nearly two years. It cannot be said or alleged, therefore, that the consequences which have flown from Government policy are in any way due to unforeseen circumstances or world conditions.
These consequences which have wrought such havoc in our economy and brought such unnecessary trials and sufferings to practically every section of our people were the inevitable consequences and the foreseeable result of putting that policy into operation. When that policy was first expounded here, particularly by the Minister for Finance, we on this side pointed out to him the economic facts and warned him and his colleagues in the Government of what would inevitably be the consequence of putting that policy into operation and, therefore, whatever those consequences may be, and evil as they are, full responsibility must be taken for them by the Government.
Let me give a short summary before I comment on Government policy. As a result of that policy, we have in this country the privilege of having the worst percentage increase in unemployment since 1951 and the greatest increase in the cost of living since that time of any western European country, with the possible exception of, I think,Greece. Again, as a result of Government policy, we have the consequence that in no year since the establishment of this State and perhaps in no year for many years before the establishment of the State has so large a percentage of agricultural workers left the land as left it in the year 1952-53. The purchasing power and standard of living of practically every section of the community has been seriously reduced. All forms of taxation have been heavily increased and bear hardly on the community, and have brought, in their train, unemployment, bad business and general suffering and austerity. Local taxation is mounting and will continue to mount and it bears very hardly on all sections of ratepayers. There has been a serious recession in trade and industry. The costs of agricultural production have been so seriously increased by taxation, and by the results of heavy and unnecessary taxation, and the operation of general Government policy, that our export trade is seriously jeopardised and on the prosperity of our agricultural industry depends entirely the prosperity of the country and the economic stability of the community. Notwithstanding what the Taoiseach and some of his colleagues have repeatedly said and notwithstanding what the Taoiseach, by way of interruption, said the other night when the debate was opened, there has been a restriction of credit to the business community.
Comment on this
I will have occasion in the course of the remarks I will have to make later on to comment upon the effect of that restriction of credit. It has had the effect of preventing business not merely from expanding, from making necessary expansion, but from carrying on at all, and there has been, in the result, a grave contribution to unemployment and distress.
That is only a general picture, the merest outline of the results of Government policy. Nothing I have stated there can be effectively controverted. I make no statement here that the humblest member of thecommunity does not know in his own experience. It does not require from me to quote statistics. It does not require from me any advocacy to put that case because everybody knows it. That is the strong case which we put in this debate. It is the experience of every section of the community, the workers, those people who are dependent on old age and other pensions, but particularly the middle classes, those people who depend for their existence upon the salary cheque that comes monthly or weekly to them.
All those sections of the community have suffered severely as a result of Government policy and the tragic part of it all is that it was entirely unnecessary. There is no necessity whatever for the policy which was adopted and which has brought in its train such austerity, suffering and avoidable misery. It was wholly unnecessary but it was all deliberately brought about by the Government.
Those are two facts which, I think, are now realised by all impartial people. The Taoiseach, when he was speaking at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis some few weeks ago, is reported in his own newspaper, the Irish Press,on the 14th October, 1953—I beg the Chair's pardon, he is not reported in his own newspaper of 14th October, 1953, but, strangely enough, he is reported in the ally of the Government, theIrish Times,of the same date as having stated: “To talk of austerity as the Opposition did was sheer nonsense.”
Comment on this
I am sure it will be of the greatest comfort to the workers, the middle classes and even to the commercial community to know that, although this Government set itself out deliberately to reduce the purchasing power of money coming into their pockets and to prevent them from spending that money as they liked, the Taoiseach now says that to talk about austerity is sheer nonsense. These people found that the food subsidieshad gone and wages had not, as they know to their cost, overtaken the cost of living, but they will be greatly comforted, having gone through a period of unexampled austerity in the past two and a half years, to know that to describe the conditions under which they suffered during that period, which were the direct and intended consequence of Government policy, as austerity, is sheer nonsense.
Those results were brought about as I indicated at the outset of what I said in a period when the threat of war was at least receding, when international trade was recovering, when the dislocation of world economics caused by the Korean war was improving and when import prices were going down for two years. All that austerity was brought about deliberately by the Government and by Government policy. It is no wonder that the Government finds itself forced back to that policy which appears to have been ever a fundamental plank in Fianna Fáil Government policy, the policy of relief schemes which we set ourselves out from the very earliest times as a Government in the inter-Party days to put an end to.
We set ourselves out to put an end to the conditions which gave rise to the necessity for relief schemes and formulated a policy which abrogated that necessity and which gave the results which were subsequently described by the present Government as false prosperity. In 1951, and particularly in the Budget of 1952, the Government, especially the Minister for Finance, made a wrong diagnosis of the country's economic health. In their efforts to cure non-existing economic illnesses, they injected into what was a fundamentally healthy economy harmful germs which have produced the economic diseases from which the country has since suffered and is now suffering.
At that time we pointed out what was going to be the result of their policy. This Government cannot say that the results were unforeseen or unforeseeable. The Minister for Finance, when he introduced his famous Budget of 1952, stated the philosophy uponwhich that Budget was founded. It is the basis of all the hardships that were inflicted as a result of the financial policy enshrined in that Budget. At an early stage of his diagnosis of the country's economic ills, in the Dáil Debates, columns 1137 and 1138, of the 2nd April, 1952, the Minister for Finance laid down these fundamental propositions:-
"In agriculture and industry earnings have advanced since 1948 by more than the cost of living."
He then goes on to say:—
"The Government have given careful thought to this problem over recent months. They are satisfied that, as incomes generally have already advanced more than the cost of living, and as essential foodstuffs are no longer scarce, there is now no economic or social justification for a policy of subsidising food for everybody."
There is the fundamental basis of Government policy, that incomes at that time both in agriculture and industry had advanced by more than the cost of living. The Government were satisfied with that.
Following upon that—it was the policy of the Government at that time, and still is, so far as we know, to prevent what they call increased consumption—they proceeded to do what in economic jargon is called mopping up the excess spending power in the hands of the community by putting upon the community burdensome taxation. That prevented the people from saving and doing what they liked with their savings. They took from them what they called the excess of income over the cost of living and put it into the Exchequer to do with it as the Government wished and not what the people wished. As a result, the standard of the people was lowered and the cost of living was increased. Business receded, and people suffered that austerity and hardship about which it is sheer nonsense to talk according to the Taoiseach.
It is interesting to note and equally interesting to speculate—when the Taoiseach at the Ard-Fheis uses almostprecisely similar phrases about the incomes of the people now having advanced in keeping with the cost of living—what that portends for future Government policy. His colleague, the Minister for Finance, on 2nd April, 1952, announced that the Government were satisfied that incomes generally had advanced more than the cost of living. The Taoiseach on 14th October, 1953, as reported this time in his own newspaper, the Irish Press, said:—
"Industrial wage earnings and agricultural wages have increased proportionately more than the cost of living."
Is there not a familiar echo about that phrase? In 1952, the basis of the unjust Budget and the unnecessary taxation imposed by that unjust Budget of 1952, was the proposition that incomes generally had then advanced more than the cost of living.
We know what has happened in the last two and a half years and the Taoiseach, as head of the Government, now announces that, whatever has happened, incomes, both industrial and agricultural, have again advanced more than the cost of living. We know what the result of stating that proposition and founding a policy on that proposition was in 1952. What does it portend for the future? We are now back again in position A as regards the relationship between incomes generally and the cost of living.
It will also be recalled that at that time Government policy was founded on the proposition stated in this famous, or I should say infamous, White Paper described as the White Paper on Trend of External Trade and Payments, 1951, and presented to the House in October, 1951. It was stated there—and it was the foundation of another proposition in the policy initiated by the Budget of 1952— that there were no indications of a fall in import prices. At that very time, in October, 1951, clear indications were available and forthcoming and were pointed out by us to the Government at the time that import prices were even then falling.
Not content with that the Minister for Finance also announced the followingas part of the basis for his budgetary policy justifying what he called his concern with balancing our international accounts. Justifying the policy of restrictionism, the policy of preventing imports coming into the country and reducing the spending power of the community, he said at column 1123, Volume 130, of the Official Debates of 2nd April, 1952:—
"While we may expect some increase in export prices the immediate outlook in agriculture would not justify us in counting upon any material increase in the quantity exported."
How wrong he was in every single piece of philosophy on which he based that Budget? How wrong he was in relation to the available ascertained facts, to the facts that were told to him from this side of the House again and again. Incomes had not advanced beyond the cost of living at that time to the extent the Minister had declared. Import prices were coming down in September, 1951, before this White Paper was presented to the Houses of the Oireachtas. They have since continued to fall over the last two years.
What about agricultural production? We told the Government at the time that their facts were wrong, that they were dealing with fallacies and fancies and that they were more concerned with making an attack upon their predecessors' financial and economic policy than they were in the economic facts then staring them in the face and told to them by us. They proceeded on the basis that incomes were too high and, therefore, the excess income might be mopped up by means of taxation. That was incorrect. They proceeded on the basis that import prices showed no material signs of a fall. But their greatest error, their unforgivable mistake was that statement of the Minister for Finance that:—
"While we may expect some increase in export prices the immediate outlook in agriculture would not justify us in counting upon any material increase in the quantity exported."
The Taoiseach and his colleagues now boast at every dinner they attend of the healthy state of our balance of international payments. We told them then what was going to happen, that import prices were coming down and that export prices, as a result of the agricultural policy of the inter-Party Government, were going to soar and that it would be as a result of that policy that the balance of international payments would be achieved. We said that and they neglected to take our advice, that it was a wrong policy, when as a result there would be grave unemployment and business recession, to allow our sterling assets to accumulate. I will deal with these matters later on in the course of further observations I wish to make. I am now dealing with Government policy. They were so set upon attacking the policy of their predecessors—and it does not matter whether it was done deliberately or through incompetence—that they diagnosed non-existing economic sickness in the country's economic health, the consequence of which we all have felt ever since.
The Taoiseach himself was eloquent telling the people throughout the country that the nation as a whole and the community in general were living beyond their means, that they had been living for three years in a false prosperity and it was time it was ended. Whether it was deliberate in order to denigrate the achievements of their predecessors or through incompetence I care not. They embarked upon a policy which was wholly unsound and which has caused tremendous evils which will take very many years of sound economic and financial policy to eradicate.
What was the real position that was described at that time by the Government and the Minister? So great is the effect of false and lying propaganda that many people were persuaded of the truth of the statement that the nation was living beyond its means and had been living for three years in a false prosperity. When we left office in June, 1951, there were never, since the commencement of this State, fewer unemployed than in that year 1951.In every month of our period as a Government we put an additional 1,000 people in industrial jobs. Our exports were doubled. Our industrial production and our industrial exports were multiplied by four. We had reached the point where we could see within sight the attainable ideal we had set ourselves out to achieve when we adopted in November, 1948, the policy of productive capital investment, the policy of using the savings of our own people and our external assets for the development of our natural resources which were described to the bankers the other day on behalf of the Government by the Minister for Lands as the neglected resources of the country. After Fianna Fáil had been in office for 18 years the official spokesman of the bankers describes the resources of our country as being neglected. At all events we set about putting an end to that neglect but that is what was described as false prosperity. In every year of our office we reduced taxation. Every year unemployment was decreased, industrial production increased, agricultural production increased, and a decent, forward, and courageous policy of agriculture was adopted, the results of which the present Government are now taking advantage of.
Having misread all the economic factors and misconstrued the facts which stared them in the face, they set out upon this policy. Possibly, it was through incompetence, and probably because they saw the opportunity of downing the achievements of their predecessors, but whatever the reason the result of it was that it caused a grave disturbance in every sector of the economy. We had talks from the Minister for Industry and Commerce suggesting to the people that they would not have enough money to pay the civil servants by the Christmas of 1951, while the Minister for Finance stated that the financial position was difficult to the point of desperation. Fianna Fáil lives on crises and disturbances. The effect of that crisis talk, notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had to get up in this House in the discussion of the White Paper on theTrend of External Trade and Payments and admit that there was no crisis although he and his colleagues had been battening on the existence of a crisis for the purpose of making political capital against their predecessors for some months before. The effect of that crisis subsists at the present moment, and people are still afraid, and are still timorous, of investing in this country because of that crisis talk which was so rife during the late summer and early autumn of 1951. We have not yet got over the effect of that. But, whatever the object of that particular type of campaign during that time, even though it has long since been abandoned, people still feel that there is something wrong.
That was the policy, at all events, that was initiated and put into practical effect by the Budget of 1952. That is the policy which has led them to the position where they must depend on relief schemes to cure unemployment. That was the policy which we warned them would inevitably and directly bring about unemployment. We have now the position that the country is overtaxed and out of that overtaxation, or out of borrowed moneys, more probably, works are being found throughout the country to employ people, but the unemployment is the direct and the intended result of Government policy.
I want to ask Deputies, and to ask the people outside in the country, to compare our policy with the policy which has been operated during the last two and a half years, the kind of policy which, we may anticipate, shall be in operation for the next few months before the general election which must inevitably take place very shortly. It was a fundamental point of our policy that we should put an end to unemployment. Our policy for the ending of unemployment was to get away from these haphazard and patchwork schemes of relief works which had been such a feature of Fianna Fáil's policy in the 16 years during which they had been in office. We saw, and we were so advised, that it was wrong for this country to have its resources neglected —that there were undeveloped resources of land, men and money—andthat we should get schemes of works of a productive capital nature on foot —that it was the way to give well-paid, secure employment and to increase the standard of living of our people. We set ourselves to devise a scheme of that kind, and we did so by means of a financial policy which we called a policy of productive capital investment. That policy was founded, unlike the policy of Fianna Fáil, upon the maintenance of a low level taxation, coupled with a high level of investment for national purposes and on a national basis.
We operated that scheme through the machinery of the capital Budget which we devised and which was set aside by the Minister for Finance in the present Government. It was an integral part of that policy that the savings of our people should be voluntarily lent to the Government by means of public loans for investment to finance schemes of capital works and to increase the standard of living of our people. We believed, and still believe, that high in the priority of governmental obligations is the necessity for not merely maintaining that level of employment and standard of living, but of increasing the level of employment and the standard of living of our people. It was also an integral part of that policy that while works of a capital productive nature would be undertaken, that other works, though not immediately productive of money returns but of human improvement and character, such as schools, housing and hospitalisation, should be undertaken by the Government and that the scheme of Government investment, through the medium of moneys borrowed from the people and invested by the Government, should be merely supplemental to the activities of private enterprise in carrying on and maintaining business and industry, thereby increasing the national income, increasing employment and the standard of living generally.
That was our policy. That policy did not mean, and I want to emphasise this because it is in direct contrast with the policy of the present Government, that there should be a disproportionate share of the investment borne by the Government, or undertakenby the Government, out of the proceeds of public borrowing. We always felt that private enterprise, engaged in schemes of a capital character and engaged in maintaining industry and business free, would give employment, and that such enterprise ought to be encouraged. We felt that the people should be encouraged to save and to lend their savings to the Government, but that their savings should not be taken from them by means of forced methods such as the taxation or overtaxation we have had in the last two and a half years.
I ask the indulgence of the House in order that I may justify the work of my colleagues and of myself, and to bury, once and for all, I hope, the lie that has been spread in such a widespread way throughout the country that, as a result of our policy, people were living beyond their means and in a false prosperity. In several speeches I made clear the basis of our policy of productive capital investment, its limitations and the precautions we were taking to see that no evil results, but only benefits, accrued. The Government are boasting here, and in the country, at dinners, banquets and elsewhere, of their achievement in securing a balance of our international payments in the last 12 months.
In the speech that I made to the Institute of Bankers on the 19th November, 1949, I said this:—
"A temporary disequilibrium in the balance of payments is inevitable according as the repatriation of capital takes place. There are greater evils, however, than a temporary deficit in the balance of payments. This Government——"
I was referring, of course, to the inter-Party Government,
"——believe that impoverished and unnecessarily infertile land, lack of housing and shortage of hospital accommodation are far worse evils, evils which we are determined to extirpate and which would even justify short-term economic loss for the sake of social and long-term economic gain."
The Government might boast—and if their boast was justified, which it is not, there might be something to be said for them—they may boast that as a result of their policy of restriction of credit, higher taxation, reduction of consumption, they have secured a balance in their international payments, but they have done so at the expense of having the unique privilege of being the only country in western Europe that has had an almost catastrophic increase in unemployment and an increase in the cost of living.
We were not prepared to pay that price. We thought it was good business —and we still think it is good business —prudently to spend a certain portion of our sterling assets to prevent unemployment and prudently to devise and carry into effect a scheme of productive capital expenditure which we did and which we told the people about and which no single economist of any standing has criticised in any way, or denied as being proper from an economic and financial point of view.
I developed the thesis at the Clonmel Chamber of Commerce on the 24th April, 1950, and I would ask the indulgence of the House to let me read two or three sentences from that speech. I said, in indicating the basis of our policy:—
"Unlike many other countries, Ireland's economy has never been marked by recurring cycles of employment and unemployment. The inherent defect has not been extreme fluctuations in economic activity but rather what is technically called a tendency towards economic equilibrium at an unduly low level. The result has been that a large part of Ireland's natural resources has remained undeveloped and that there has been altogether insufficient economic activity to provide employment for all the population. Ireland's economic ills have accordingly been chronic. For generations before the recent war lack of work has compelled some of the most active and energetic Irish workers to emigrate. Others who remained at home lived an unproductive existence maintained by unemployment assistanceor by casual periods of work on unproductive employment or relief schemes. There was a shortage of work because the capital resources of the country were not being used to create work. In addition, particularly in agriculture, under-capitalised projects in private hands were not giving rewards commensurate with the efforts employed on them. Many attempts were made to apply patchwork treatment for these unhealthy symptoms but most of the money spent was wasted because it was spent unproductively. The fundamental trouble was the failure to recognise that the basic defect in the country's economy was the absence of sufficient capital investment to ensure that the maximum of national resources in labour and land would be productively employed."
That is a short summary of the basis of our policy which produced those results to which I have very shortly referred and to which the Government had the audacity to refer as producing false prosperity.
The Minister for Lands proceeded to the Bankers' Institute the other night and told them that the payments barometer is set at "fair." He told the bankers the good news that the balance of payments problem has been solved, and then he said:
"In view of the present balance between savings and investments and other factors making for financial stability, no harm, but rather good, would come from a reasonable extension of credit facilities by the banks to the Government, particularly for projects designed to increase national productivity."
He did not tell the bankers that the Government's policy in producing that position here—the payments barometer set "fair"—had caused unnecessary suffering and human misery throughout the length and breadth of this country for the last two and a half years. He did not say that although unemployment has resulted, relief schemes have been slightly down on last year. He did not tell them why unnecessary taxation had been imposedor whether or not it was intended to continue that unnecessary taxation in order to continue this financial stability to which the Minister for Lands referred. He told the bankers: "You might as well, boys, now cease restricting credit," but mind you he did not say: "Cease restricting credit to the business or industrial community." He said: "Cease restricting credit to the Government."
Comment on this
In other words, this Government by its policy had brought the country to this position: that although it had offered a 5 per cent. loan last year—an unprecedented and unwarranted price which will have repercussions in this country for very many years—and although it offered that attractive price last year, and only slightly less this year, at the expense of the credit of the country, by offering terms to the banks to lend it money at a price they could not get in any other place in the world, at prices which even British provincial corporations do not have to pay—the Government has reduced the credit of this country to the point where there was one loan at 5 per cent. and the other at slightly less, 4¾, and I do not think they would get any more. The Taoiseach had already said that we were going to have a loan every year. Now because the last loan did not fill —there were no more savings in the country to finance Government expenditure largely on relief schemes—we must go to the banks and tell them: "Do not restrict credit to the Government; you are going to cease restricting credit to the Government." In other words, "cough up." It was not stated at what rate of interest nor are we told by the Taoiseach. We have to inquire; we have to prod.
We have the position then where the Government has balanced its international payments at an appalling price to the community in human suffering. We have the position where at a time when there is greatly increased unemployment and a balance held in international payments there has been a pretty substantial increase in our external assets in that set of circumstances.We have the position that the Government has scooped the pool from the point of view of the available capital for the purpose of financing business and private enterprise.
We have a position that is in direct contrast to that which obtained under the implementation of our policy, a policy through the medium of which we encouraged saving by our people and the lending of these savings voluntarily to the Government for the purpose of loans to supplement the enterprise of private industrialists and private firms in order to provide employment and expand business. Now, because of the restriction of credit, which the Taoiseach says does not exist, our business people and our industrialists have been unable not merely to expand but even to do the necessary day to day work to enable them to carry on; the necessary capital for that purpose has been denied them.
The Taoiseach says there is no such thing as credit restriction. That must have caused many a bitter laugh on the part of people throughout the country who were interviewed in the last year or 18 months by their bank managers and spoken to in a manner which those officials would not have dared to adopt two and a half years ago. They were spoken to by bank managers in a way that decent people with good security were never spoken to since this State was first established. That was probably done by direction of the directors and doubtless the directors thought genuinely and honestly that that was good policy. In that the directors were following the lead set by the Government.
In 1952 the Government announced their policy of restriction of consumption, the reduction of the purchasing power of the people, thereby preventing people from spending, and the preventing of people from saving: the directors of the banks said: "That is all right by us; that is the policy for us." The Government may say, and probably say truthfully, that they never gave any direction to the banks to restrict credit. That was not necessary: a nod is as good as a wink to a blind horse.
Whether is was that the Government were complacent about the restriction of credit that existed, whether or not the banks fell in with the wishes and policy of the Government, and whether or not the Government buried their heads so deep in the sand they did not know what was going on and would not believe the people who were suffering from it, there is no doubt that there was a restriction of credit. There is no doubt that that restriction of credit has been a great source of economic trouble in the country within the last few years. The Government may be complacent. They may be ignorant. They may not have directed the banks to restrict credit to business and industry, but is there the slightest doubt that if, in the last 18 months, the Government had said to the banks: "We hear that decent people are not able to get enough capital to expand their business and their industry, to keep people in employment, or to give more employment, and we think that is bad policy and you ought to stop it," the banks would have done what they were told? But there was never any direction given. There was never any hint.
Time and again it has been stated here categorically in this House and throughout the country by Opposition Deputies that there was a restriction of credit and that that restriction of credit was causing unemployment and a recession in trade and business. Surely it is futile for the Taoiseach and the Government to say now that in matters of banking and credit and the restriction of credit to industry they abrogate all control and all direction and even refrain from giving any advice in a matter so fundamental and vital to the people as a whole.
We have had the results and the effects outlined by the speaker at the meeting of the Institute of Bankers the other night. We have had the telegram that was sent to the Taoiseach asking him to use his influence to ensure that relief works will be supplied for the unemployed in his own constituency of County Clare. We have had another contrast between our policy and the policy adumbrated and implemented by the Fianna Fáil Government in thefact that while our policy was based upon low taxation coupled with a high investment rate for productive capital enterprises, the policy of the present Government is to borrow for public purposes and for relief schemes on the basis of higher taxation and a higher rate of interest. That contrast should be very carefully appreciated by those who are at present engaged in diagnosing the evils from which we are suffering as a result of Government policy.
Every year while we were in government we reduced taxation and we obtained money from the people at a low rate of interest. This Government has increased beyond all justice the rates of taxation imposed on the people and in addition to that they have borrowed money at unnecessarily high interest rates with disastrous repercussions on our economy. I have said that it was part of our policy in the inter-Party Government to leave something for private enterprise, private business and private industry. We did not scoop the pool. We let business and industry and enterprise get their money. We encouraged them to do that. The results of the policy of the present Government and of its borrowing in the last two years have been that they have grabbed so much of the savings of the people that there is very little, if anything, left in the way of capital for business or industry.
When I was opening this debate last week I stated that private enterprise and private business have been starved of capital as a result of three things: the restriction of credit by the banks; the high rates of interest given by the Government to people who lend money to them; and the high rate of borrowing by the Government for governmental purposes. It is no wonder we have the results that have accrued as a consequence of Government policy. We are in the happy position of being able to say that we have excellent people engaged in trade and industry in this country, people willing and anxious to expand, but they have not been able to expand over the last 12 or 18 months for the reasons I have stated.
I referred to the position as outlined by the Minister for Lands to thebankers a few nights ago. I said that the Minister for Finance, when announcing his budgetary, his financial and his economic policy emphasised that the first concern of the Government was to rectify the balance of payments position. I made the comment upon that, that that was not our first concern, though we were concerned with it. There were matters of higher priority for us. There was the matter of employment, of housing, hospitalisation, of providing schools and developing the resources of the country. In addition to embarking upon schemes of capital development in relation to land and other productive enterprises we financed these schemes not merely by loans and by the savings of our people but by the prudent use of part of the proceeds of Marshall Aid and by a policy of repatriation of external assets prudently undertaken and cautiously watched.
In 1951 and again in 1952 we were told by the Minister for Finance and his colleagues that the result of our policy was that our external assets were being dissipated and the country was facing disaster because the bulwark of our international trade was being eaten into and undermined. That was the case at that time. The acting-Minister for Finance, in the last few weeks, has engaged himself and embattled himself here in this House to demonstrate and prove that what we were doing was not expending our external assets but saving too much and not spending them. I do not know which way we are to take it. We were told at first that we were spending too much of the external assets and the acting-Minister for Finance and some of his colleagues have been repeating the charge recently that, so far from spending them, we were accumulating them. Heads I win; tails you lose. Have it either way.
The fact is that we had a policy about the repatriation of our external assets. He who runs may read. Every word that I uttered was published. It is there and available to the Government. Our policy in reference to the repatriation of external assets has been published, publicised and repeatedly made known to everybody.There is not a single economist or financier, with the exception of politicians of the Fianna Fáil calibre, who up to this has criticised in any way our scheme or method or approach to that problem.
I have already referred to this infamous White Paper of 1951. We have exposed again and again the fallacies and the inaccuracies that were in that White Paper on which the present policy of the Government was founded. The Minister for Finance, in his Budget speech to which I have referred, spoke of the fact that he wanted to make his first concern not the position of the unemployed, not the position of the poor, but that he would be able in some years' time to send a representative of the Government to a banquet of the bankers and tell them that the payments barometer is set fair although there has been unemployment, austerity and human suffering avoidably imposed in the last two and a half years. That was his first concern and was based upon the economic fallacies and disregard of facts to which I have referred.
In addition to that, he said that at that time they estimated that the deficit on the external payments account for the year 1952 would be £50,000,000 but that as a result of the budgetary policy which he was initiating and putting into effect that deficit would be reduced.
We were derided, scoffed at, sneered at by the Minister and his colleagues when we said, to use the words of the Taoiseach, that that was sheer nonsense. It was only £9,000,000 or £10,000,000, we said. We were laughed at. The Minister said £50,000,000. It was said originally that it was going to be £60,000,000; then that it would be £50,000,000 and finally £35,000,000. We said it would be only £9,000,000 or £10,000,000. In fact it was only £9,000,000, on paper. It was actually nothing. There was a great increase in the external assets that accumulated in the last year during which this balance of payments had been achieved. I use the word "achieved" in inverted commas. As I havealready stated, we told them their facts were wrong, that there were certain forces of a corrective nature operating which would bring about that situation automatically. Import prices were coming down, we told them. We told them that the high rate of import in the year 1952 was due to the Korean war and the stockpiling that took place as a result of that war by industrialists, private traders, individuals and Government Departments and that when that would ease off there would be a natural and automatic return to normality. But, more than that, we told them that the fruits of our agricultural policy would be garnered by them in the year 1952. The Minister for Finance said no, no, that there was nothing to show that import prices were coming down, according to the White Paper, and that he saw no signs and the Government could find no evidence that agricultural production for export would go up to any marked degree. What was the result? Last year our agricultural exports reached a point which they had never reached in the history of this country and which the present Government never thought they would see in their political lifetime.
Even Fianna Fáil cannot grow a three-year-old animal in a year. These exports were three years old. They were the fruits of the Government policy presided over by Deputy Dillon. They are now coming in to the advantage of the present Government. The Government is gathering the harvest that we sowed and that harvest is the unexampled increase in the value and volume of our agricultural exports last year, which are still going up this year and which were founded on the policy of the inter-Party Government. The cattle that were born and were prevented from being slaughtered in the three years that we were in office have been exported over the last two and a half years.
I want to finish on this topic by saying that there were three factors which contributed to the balance of international payments, which was the first concern of the Government even at the expense of human misery, sufferingand unemployment. First of all, there was the increase in agricultural exports which, I have said, have gone up to an unprecedented scale in volume and value, due to the policy of the inter-Party Government and the agricultural policy of that Government. There were the reduced imports. I admit that in some respects the Government were all too successful in the so-called correctives that they applied. The overtaxation of the Budget of 1952, bringing with it, as it did, decreased imports, brought about also a decrease of the standard of living of our people. Some of those reduced imports are due to these correctives and some are due to Government policy, at a very heavy cost, but they also occurred because there had been overbuying by individuals and firms and Government Departments in the previous year as a result of stockpiling. The third factor was a reduction in international prices which had been going on steadily ever since this present Government got into office and before it.
These are the three factors. For only one part of these three factors can the Government take any credit, if credit there be, and that is their policy of depressing the standard of living of our people by means of the reduction of imports. In that policy they were very successful and too successful. They would not have gone within £50,000,000 of closing that gap if it had not been for the contribution of a startling, dramatic character that was made by the increase in agricultural exports which has taken place since this Government came into office and as a result of the policy of their predecessors.
As I have said, I think there would have been trouble even if the present Government did not come into office, trouble due to world economic dislocation, trouble due to the Korean war. Taking all that into account, the best that can be said for the position at the present time from a financial and economic point of view, notwithstanding what I shall deal with in a few moments—the outlook of the Government on the present conditions —is that, approaching Christmas, 1953,we are just a little bit better off than we were at Christmas last year.
There has been an improvement, some improvement, for some people, but not for all. Quite possibly although we may not have a white Christmas, it will be a little less black than it was last year. That is no thanks to the Government, because what has happened is this, that because business was so bad last year as a result of Government policy, particularly budgetary policy, it had to improve somewhat this year, and we have only got back to where we stood. That is the contribution of Fianna Fáil after two and a half years to the prosperity and the happiness of our people. Trouble was there, as I have said, from Korea and from international methods, but it was added to by the budgetary policy and by the policy of decreasing consumption and decreasing the purchasing power of the community which was initiated by and put into effect after the Budget of 1952.
What industrial progress has there been made? Deputy Lemass, Minister for Industry and Commerce, is engaged very heavily in making speeches. What industrial progress has there been made? I have already referred to it. So far as industrial production is concerned we have the privilege—and I use the word "privilege" in inverted commas—of being classed as one of the countries in which there was the lowest percentage decrease in industrial production in western Europe during the period up to 1951. That is a proud boast. If there is to be any industrial progress, that progress should be a continued progress growing from year to year and the figures for industrial production should in every year show the increase, but not merely was there not an increase for 1951-52, there was a serious decline and it is only now in recent months that we have got back, after two and a half years of the operation of the policy of the present Government, to the position that we left it so far as industrial production is concerned in June, 1951. Two and a half years under the operation of the policy of the present Government has only resulted in reducing industrial consumption, and whatever improvementhas been made in the last few months has only effected the improvement of bringing this country back to the point where we left it two and a half years ago. That is not anything to be proud of. It is no wonder that the Minister for Lands, when he was at a banquet of the bankers, was only able to speak of the payments barometer being at set fair. There was nothing else in that speech except financial stability and the payments barometer being at set fair—no indication there of a policy of utilising the moneys, the capital, which he was threatening the banks they would have to give him and to his Government. What is borrowed from the people or from the banks does not matter very much. What is borrowed from the Government or from the bankers is of no very great importance. What is of vital importance is to ascertain the purposes to which those borrowed moneys will be put. We have no indication of that at the present moment, and the only thing that we can do is to infer from all those various speeches that there is going to be an extension of relief schemes. We are going to have an industrial development fund. I do not know what name they are calling it—a development fund. So far all the indications as to what this fund is to be used for demonstrate that it is to be used for what are in the nature of relief schemes.
The Government are very fond of trappings. They are very fond of funds. We had a Transition Fund which we found when we got into office. Deputy McGilligan has retailed to the House the disastrous history of that fund, in which there was nothing. A fund is a grand thing to tell the people about, but it means nothing. There is no difference between getting it from the banks or from a Transition Fund or from the people by ways and means advances. What purpose or object is there in putting a label on it and trappings around it and calling is a development fund? They could develop this country without calling it anything else provided that you get the money and put it into proper objects which will result in producing employment and increasing the standard of living for all sections of the people.
Before I pass from the matter of industry, there is one matter I wish to mention by way of protest. I have always objected to the Fianna Fáil policy of identifying Irish industry with the politics of Fianna Fáil. Throughout the whole course of their political career here they have dragged Irish industry as part of their stock-in-trade, trying to get it into the people's heads that the people on these benches are against Irish industry. May I, in order to put an end, if possible, to that very foul abuse of public policy which is part of the stock-in-trade of Fianna Fáil, refer to a speech I made within a few months of being appointed head of the Government of this country, in protest against that class of thing? I raise it here in this debate because of the fact that in every by-election that has been held since this Government took office, members of the Government, and particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce, have gone around the constituency in which the by-election is being held, not building castles in the air but building factories in the air. When I was speaking on the 7th April, 1948, in Cork, at a meeting of the Federation of Irish manufacturers, I made this statement, and I want to repeat it here to-day:
"It is to be regretted that in the past few years Irish industry has come to be regarded as dependent upon political views and likely to be affected by political changes. At the very outset of my remarks, I would like to emphasise the conviction which I have held for many years, that great disservice can be caused, as it has, in fact, been caused, to Irish manufacturing industry by the part with which it has been made to play in Irish politics, and to express the hope that an end will now be put to the use by politicians for political purposes of Irish industry."
Further on I said:
"A new chapter in our industrial and commercial history began with the establishment of this State. Since then it has been the policy of every Irish Government to encouragethe development of our manufacturing industry and to assist them against unfair competition from abroad. Whatever differences may have existed as to the methods to be employed no fundamental difference can be found as to the objective to be attained. The policy of selective protection may, in the views of some, have been too conservative. The policy of wholesale tariffs or quotas may, in the views of others, have led to dislocation in other parts of and so damaged the general economic structure of the State. However divergent the views may have been on machinery or method, there is unanimity on the necessity for fostering, developing and strengthening Irish manufacturing industry."
I want to repeat that again here and to protest against the use that has been made by this Government, and particularly by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, of Irish manufacturing industry as a tool for political purposes against the Opposition.
There would be far greater hope for the development of Irish manufacture and Irish industries if there was a sound financial and economic policy based on a sound agricultural industry. Such a sound financial and economic policy based upon a sound agricultural industry, would do far more for Irish manufacturing industry than any hawking round, for political purposes, of these factories in the air that have been so often mentioned by members of the present Government for political purposes. It is at least comforting to know that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has now seen—and he has emphasised it in several speeches he has made—that a sound agricultural industry is the basis of a sound manufacturing industry. Again, we are all at one on fundamentals—all in favour of Irish manufacturing industries, however we may differ as to some of the methods to be employed to that end, or whatever our convictions may be against free trade or for free trade. We are all in favour of developing an Irish manufacturing industry, but I want to stigmatise the efforts made by the Minister for Industry and Commercein hawking round these mythical factories on the occasion of by-elections for the purposes of securing votes, as something that should be ended and ended for ever.
Speaking of agriculture leads me naturally to draw attention to the danger that is facing agriculture at the present moment as a result of Government policy. It is very satisfying to know, from announcements made in the House within the last few weeks, that it is intended to discuss with the British Government the effect on our agricultural exports of the partial decontrol of cattle and other agricultural exports in England. I want to impress upon the Government the dangers that face the agricultural industry at the present time by reason of the fact that the industry has imposed upon it, by overtaxation and other aspects of general Government policy, a too costly system of production. Our average exports for the years 1948, 1949 and 1950 were value for £166,000,000. Our imports in 1952 were £172,000,000. Whatever figures are available for this year indicate that there has been an increase in imports. If these imports continue to rise, there must be a corresponding increase in our exports, both in volume and in value, to finance imports. As I say, if the costs of our agricultural production be increased, as they are in fact steadily rising, there will be a very grave tendency for our agricultural exports dangerously to diminish as they cease to be profitable. I put that warning, which has already been given by my colleague, Deputy Dillon, who knows the circumstances far better than I do, to the Government. Government policy has increased the cost of agricultural production. Markets for produce such as butter, eggs and poultry have almost disappeared. If we go on increasing the cost of production for our farmers, the remaining exports of cattle, sheep, wool, etc., may possibly decline to a point where our agricultural exports, on which the prosperity of this country and the balance of our international payments eventually depend, will decline. That is the picture, and my comments on the picture, as it exists, and on the Governmentpolicy in operation up to this, so far as we can ascertain it.
What of the future? In 1952, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, went to a banquet of the Insurance Institute, the same body at whose banquet he spoke on Monday night last. There he announced in December, 1952, that alarm was giving way to confidence. Then he kept quiet for a bit and on the 27th April, 1953, he spoke in Jury's Hotel, no less, at a Fianna Fáil cumann. There, as reported in the Irish Pressof the 28th April, 1953, nine months ago, he made this remarkable statement:—
"We are filled with some confidence that the country is again facing a period of expansion and development and that under Fianna Fáil leadership these opportunities will be fully utilised."
How did the country expand? How did it develop? After that speech there was inaugurated the policy of the present Government, a new policy perhaps, or perhaps the same old policy under a different guise, but it was a policy anyway, a policy that may be described as a policy of reconstructing Ireland by means of pulling weeds out of the Dodder, pulling up the tram tracks in the streets of Dublin and starting relief schemes all over the country. It was after that speech that we had the policy of pulling up the tram tracks and of pulling the weeds out of the Dodder in answer to the march of the unemployed. Is that the policy of expansion and development that we were facing in 1953?
In the very same speech he had the effrontery—and his effrontery knows no bounds—to state this:—
"The inability to expand agricultural output in three very favourable post-war years was the Coalition's greatest failure."
I could not allow that to pass without some comment. Deputies will recall that in September, 1947, at a time when the Minister for Industry and Commerce did not think that he was going to be thrown out on his ear in a few months, he warned the peoplethat they were facing "three or four years of unexampled difficulty, trial and danger". That was what he said they were facing when he was in the Government but when we became the Government for these three or four years of "unexampled difficulty, trial and danger", that period was turned into a period described by him, post factum,as “the very favourable postwar years”. I have already shown what we did for agriculture. As Deputy Dillon has pointed out, after the inter-Party Government was formed, as a result of the policy of fertilising the land, the eradication of disease in cattle and the other schemes put into operation by the inter-Party Government, more was got for an old hen than had been received for a calf in the preceding years. We now see the results in the fact that our agricultural exports have reached heights which it was never thought previously could be attained. It is in that situation that the Minister could say on the 28th April last that we were facing a period of expansion and development.
Then the Taoiseach proceeded to give his contribution some months afterwards. In the intervening period between April and the 30th October, 1953, when the Taoiseach made his speech at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, we had the policy of relief schemes going full blast. The tram tracks were being pulled up in the streets of the city and the weeds were being pulled out of the Dodder at great speed. Promises of relief works were being broadcast and, of course, it was a mere coincidence that during that period there were two by-elections going on in the country.
The Taoiseach came along in October and went further. What did he say? He said: "Our financial problems have been successfully solved and we are back again on the high road to recovery." Then he made the statement I have already quoted that industrial wages and agricultural wages have increased proportionately more than has the cost of living. I do not know if he will get a single agricultural worker, not to speak of an industrial worker, and certainly not tospeak of any of the so-called middle classes, who will agree with that proposition.
Then he winds up in a blaze of glory and high flights of eloquence:—
"The facts and figures which I have given all bear out the impression of a buoyant economy, a prosperous agriculture and expanding industry."
Previous to that he said:—
"It might be expected that the favourable indications which I have mentioned will be reflected in the Exchequer returns and such indeed is the case. In the first half of the present year the Exchequer returns showed an increase in revenue of over £5,000,000 as compared with last year, despite the fact that no additional taxes were imposed in the Budget."
There is the cat out of the bag. I will identify the cat later.
Then the Minister for Industry and Commerce, on Monday last, stated:—
"It could be asserted with some confidence that the outlook for 1954 was bright and that all economic trends were in the right direction."
About the same time, the President of the Builders' Federation—I cannot at the moment put my finger on the quotation—spoke of the restriction of credit and the unemployment in the building industry that existed, and said there were 400 carpenters seeking employment in Dublin alone. I heard one of my own colleagues last week asking another colleague in the Party could he by any chance get a job for a decent carpenter, and he said he could not. During our term of office I had to go on the air as Taoiseach and ask the carpenters and the plasterers and the skilled labourers to come back from England and work here, and there is the record of the present Government's policy—400 carpenters in the City of Dublin alone are unemployed at the present moment.
Is that the buoyant economy or expanding industry as described by the Taoiseach? Could conditions whichhave brought that about and which still exist at the present moment, be described as they were described about a month ago by the Taoiseach, as an impression of a buoyant economy, a prosperous agriculture and expanding industry? Can that be said, having regard to the fact that on Monday evening I saw in the Evening Heraldthat a telegram had been sent from the County Clare to the Minister for Local Government and also to the Taoiseach asking them to provide relief works for the unemployed in the County Clare? There is your buoyant economy and the result of your policy for the last two and a half years.
But there are indications in the speech of the Taoiseach and in all these optimistic utterances, however unfounded they may be, of a new policy. He is going to get money from the banks. The Government have asked the banks to cease restricting credit to the Government, not to private individuals. They want more money. They want to have their hands on all the money they can get in the next few months. The Taoiseach said that there was £5,000,000 more than last year coming in. There is the vindication of what I said about the Budget of 1952 when I spoke from these benches. I said that it was a cruel and unjust Budget, because the taxes were unnecessary and that there were contained in that Budget proposals which would bring in to the Government greater increases and far more from taxes than they required for the running of the country and for Government purposes: that there would be a surplus of £8,000,000 or £9,000,000. I was right at that time and I have been proved right.
The surplus which they anticipated by the end of the financial year can no longer be concealed. It can no longer be concealed that there will be a surplus this year emerging from a period when there was such unemployment as I have referred to, when there was restriction of credit, when industry had declined in the way I have stated, when there was no indication of a boom in trade or industry to justify the fact that the increased yield of taxes came from an increase in the national income such as we aimed at; when allthe indications were of economic distress and suffering. That is not the time when you get a surplus of revenue from taxation. You get a surplus of revenue from the taxes imposed under the 1952 Budget when unnecessary taxation was imposed for the express purpose, as we said, and as we repeat now, of getting a surplus in order that, at the proper moment, this Government would have in its hands funds to be used for the purpose of distributing benefits to the people, and to try and convince the people that this was a beneficent Government giving relief in taxation, having done a good job in clearing up the financial mess.
We said that that was the scheme, and we have been proved right. Now there is to be a surplus. It was concealed last year by a variety of methods, by Government book-keeping and other methods to which I referred in public. I referred in a speech at Youghal to the fact that Government method of book-keeping and public accountancy should be changed because by these methods Governments are enabled—I hesitate to use the phrase —to cook the accounts. They allowed money that should be given at the end of last year to flow into the next year's Budget. They did not want to show a surplus last year because we would be justified.
This time 12 months they were able to forecast that there would be a deficit. I challenge the Taoiseach now, in his reply, to say, inasmuch as he was able to forecast this time last year that there would be a deficit at the end of the financial year, what is his estimate of the anticipated Budget surplus that will accrue, or be allowed to accrue, this year. The Taoiseach was rejoicing at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis that there would be this Budget surplus of £5,000,000 more than last year. Then the Minister for Finance, or his officials more likely, as they always did if any unfortunate member of the Government ever showed the slightest indication that he believed there was anything prosperous about the country or anything likely to give an increased yield in taxation, cried "halt" at once and there was aspeech by the Minister for Finance, saying: "You will have to remember that Government expenditure is going up" and the inevitable happened. The Taoiseach having stated that there was a buoyant economy, a prosperous agriculture and expanding industry and £5,000,000 more than last year in revenue, the Minister for Lands, Deputy Derrig, acting on behalf of the Minister for Finance, told the bankers that there was plenty of money coming in, but they should remember that expenditure was going up. But remember that the expenditure is going to be so that they will have little safeguards in case there might be an election next year. They will have it both ways.
I stated here categorically that what is happening now is that, just as the Government in the country are making elaborate arrangements for a general election, so they are arranging their policy and are trying so to bring it about that by means of this surplus— which we said was there last year and which we say is there still—they will be able to pour benefit on the people and say: "We were able to reduce taxation; the inter-Party Government"—that put thousands of people additionally into employment and which was able to reduce taxation, increase pensions and take the taxes off the beer and tobacco—"were able to give you only a false prosperity; we will give you the real thing; now that we have cleared up the financial mess and have created deliberately as a result of our policy unemployment, emigration and austerity, we are in a position to put you back into a period of prosperity; and, in order to do so, we are tearing the weeds out of the Dodder and digging up the tram rails in Dublin."
I want to end on this aspect of the matter of the Budget surplus. I do not know whether the method of accountancy in the Department of Finance will be so utilised this time as it was last year to conceal what was, in fact, a Budget surplus, but I anticipate that there will be a surplus, and, apparently, the Taoiseach anticipates it also. Whatever surplus there is will be the measure of the overtaxation that was imposed by the unjust andunecessary proposals for taxation in the Budget of 1952.
There are some matters of a general character I want to refer to, I hope very briefly. There is one matter that very shortly indeed I want to draw attention to, as it is a matter of general concern—although it might be said to be more appropriate to a particular Department. It is a matter of general concern as it affects the rights of private individuals as against big corporations and possibly the Government as a whole. I want to know why the Government or some of its members allowed a law action to go on in the courts costing the ratepayers of Dublin at least £16,000, for the purpose of showing that the Dublin Corporation had not delayed in having a planning scheme. That is not a matter that affects merely the citizens of Dublin; it is a matter of very vital concern to everyone. There was litigation on the question whether the Dublin Corporation had a planning scheme in operation in Dublin or not. That was brought by a company that fortunately was able to finance the matter or take the risk. If it had been private individuals—and there have been many private individuals in this city and in the country who have been adversely affected by the threatened exercise of rights of that kind by bureaucrats without any legal authority—the Dublin Corporation would have gone on merrily exercising those rights. When they were beaten at the public hearing, there was no justification for spending money in going on any further. That is a matter of public concern and it should not happen again. There is general reluctance on the part of big public corporations throughout the country to settle cases with private people, just as the Civil Service prefers, because they are afraid of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, to allow Departments to be sued in courts to the bitter end at great cost, because then they can produce the judgment and that ends the matter with the Comptroller and Auditor-General. So corporations throughout the country put the ratepayers to unnecessary expense in putting down a court order rather than have to justify to someauditor or other the fact that they settled the case.
There are proceedings of that kind in every direction. There are cases where officials of a corporation, particularly in the City of Dublin, go round and get property owners to negotiate on the basis that they are going to buy the property from them for public purposes. They leave them then for 12 or 18 months and then come back and say: "Good-bye, we are not taking the property." As a matter of general policy, I would like that that be stopped. It is a matter that affects individual rights as against bigger public bodies who do not mind putting either the taxpayers or ratepayers to expense.
I want to make one remark about the Government's foreign and external policy. They have achieved this remarkable result in the matter of our external policy: they have no foreign policy, and they have succeeded in doing nothing very badly. The mention of foreign policy leads me inevitably to the question of Partition. The Taoiseach knows I have taken the line, in the last two and a half years since the present Government was formed, of not speaking in public about the problem of Partition. I took a certain risk of being misrepresented and misunderstood by adopting that attitude, but I did so, as the Taoiseach knows, because I believed in the first place that in all the circumstances it was the best contribution that could be made while the present Government was in office. The attitude of the Taoiseach and his colleagues in the Government is that the question of policy in reference to Partition is a matter for Government policy for which they are responsible and that they should be allowed to operate whatever policy they may have and be responsible for it. Accordingly, I said: "They are in office now: they took upon themselves the responsibility for policy towards Partition; I will not embarrass them in any way but will give them a free hand and no criticism, and let us see what results can be achieved." I make these introductory remarks to explain my reason for breaking that rule—I hope for the last time before the present Governmentgoes out. I do so reluctantly. I do so because I feel that I am bound in duty to invite the Government to explain their policy in regard to recent happenings in the North, particularly in regard to the imprisonment of Mr. Liam Kelly. That is clearly a matter of general Government policy affecting the question of Partition.
I have been criticised particularly by one newspaper for certain statements that I made in reference to Partition and the policy we had on it. However, I did make this one point at all events, so far as I was concerned and my colleagues in Fine Gael were concerned—the sub-title of the Fine Gael Party is "United Ireland"—that we wanted in ending Partition to do it on the basis that fellow Irishmen— Catholics, Methodists, Presbyterians or others—would come into a United Ireland with goodwill, with no fighting and no bitterness, in solid acquiescence in the creation of a United Ireland. As I said at meetings on many occasions and as I said at the meeting of the inter-Parliamentary Union held in the month of October this year, a United Ireland could give a wonderful contribution to international affairs. That being our attitude, I hesitated to speak here to-day on this subject. I am sure that the Taoiseach and his colleagues feel as strongly as I do about the matter and I have also felt, probably more strongly than I do, the difficulty of keeping silence during the last few years, in view of the happenings up in the Six County area. Our flag has been repeatedly insulted, our National Anthem derided and prevented from being played, and so on, as far as they possibly could; our people have been prevented from having processions to celebrate in the way they wish the national feast of St. Patrick. They have suffered injustice, economically, socially and in other ways. I and my colleagues—and I am sure the Taoiseach and his colleagues—have kept silence on that with great difficulty, because of our hope and our desire that ultimately, as we believe and as I still believe, events would inevitably press the Government of the North and the people of the Six Counties of the North towards a United Ireland.
We believed that, inevitably, they would come into that United Ireland with a spirit of goodwill and a desire to work in the interests of the people of all Ireland, of all classes and all creeds, and to give the contribution that we could to international peace and international affairs. What makes me speak now and break silence is that I am afraid that the events of the past few weeks—particularly the arrest and conviction of Mr. Kelly for making a speech during election time—will open the door to a kind of conflict which we all desire to avoid. I was reluctant to speak here on this topic—and I am sure the Taoiseach will accept from me that I was reluctant—but I do so now out of a sense of duty and because it was conveyed to me from various quarters that we could not remain silent and that I could not remain silent on this matter. Therefore, I invite the Government to explain their policy and attitude not merely in respect of the arrest and imprisonment of Mr. Kelly but in view of what these things may betoken.
I pass now to An Comhairle Ealaíon —the Arts Council. I have occupied so much time of the House already that I do not intend to spend very much time on this matter. In view of the part that I played in the establishment of this council, and as this is the first occasion on which their report comes before us, I could not pass over it in silence. It would be ungenerous of me not to express some appreciation of the work that has been done by the council. It does not come up to my expectations or my hopes by a long way but at least there has been a beginning. Only a small amount of money—only £10,000— was spent. I think that the Taoiseach, with his control over the whole situation, should now see to it that very much more money than £10,000 is expended in the course of the next 12 months.
When I conceived the idea of an Arts Council, and set it up with the consent and closest co-operation of my colleagues, I had a number of objects in view. Some of these objects are referred to in the report which has been presented to the House; some of them are not. One of these objects was thatthe Arts Council would endeavour to carry on the fight for the return of the Lane pictures and that they would help to educate and keep the people of this country and Great Britain alive to the facts of the case in connection with that controversy and in connection with the claim of the City of Dublin for the return of the 39 pictures which Sir Hugh Lane intended for it. A commission which was set up by the British Government in the middle or at the end of 1924, and which reported early in 1925, found that the codicil embodied Sir Hugh Lane's last wishes so far as the 39 pictures were concerned. I had intended to raise this matter, in any event, on this Estimate this year. When I was the head of the inter-Party Government, I took every occasion I could to press the claims of the City of Dublin for the return of these 39 pictures. The Taoiseach will find all the correspondence and references to that matter which I left behind me in the Department. I asked the Prime Minister of the Labour Government in Britain to give us back these pictures if not as a matter of justice at least as a gesture of decency and goodwill. I did not get them. We are not going to get them from the British House of Lords. However, that does not mean that we are not to keep up our claim. I believe that, in the end, the ordinary decent English people—not the ruling classes; not those who spoke with such complete ignorance of the facts of the case in the House of Lords the other day— will recognise our claims. We will not get the co-operation of the types of persons who spoke with such manifest ignorance of the facts of the case in the House of Lords the other day.
It is one of the objects and functions of the Arts Council to see that the people are educated. I think the people have forgotten the facts connected with the controversy over the Lane pictures. Certainly the people of England have. It is all very fine for Lord Rugby to cast it aside and to say that Sir Hugh Lane never signed the codicil and that, therefore, Dublin should not get the pictures. That was a piece of futile folly and ignorance on the part of an octogenarian peer. Ishould like to repeat what a friend of mine said about the affair in the House of Lords in the past few days. I am quoting what my friend said, and acknowledging it, without mentioning his name. He said: "It may be Rugby, but it is not cricket." When Lord Rugby was here, we were under the impression that he was sympathetic towards our claim for the Lane pictures. We have not any great delusions about Lord Jowett or some of the others. We will not get back the pictures from the House of Lords but we will get them back from the English people if we tell them our case. I suggest to the Taoiseach that it is part of the function of the Arts Council to put before our people and the British people all the facts in connection with this matter.
It was part of my scheme, which was formulated with the full approval of my colleagues, that the chairman of that council would be Dr. Bodkin, who was mentioned in that codicil to Sir Hugh Lane's will in which he left the pictures to the City of Dublin. I regret that circumstances prevented this country from having the benefit of the unequalled and unexcelled knowledge and experience which Dr. Bodkin has in relation to painting and the visual arts and also the enthusiasm which he has, and which he infused into me over a long period of years of friendship, for applying the arts to Irish industry and for the revival of our crafts and the encouragement of our craftsmen. I regret that our country has been deprived of his services. From the comments which he made during the proceedings in the House of Lords, he is still available to help us in our claim for the Lane pictures. I regret very much that our country has been deprived of his services in connection with the advancement of the arts and the application of the arts to industry. He is still available and knows the facts about the Lane pictures more intimately than any other person alive to-day. The publicising of our claim and the reeducation of our own people, as well as the British people, on the facts connected with the Lane pictures, is of very great importance.
As I am speaking on the question of the Arts Council, I should like to refer to this wretched affair on O'Connell Bridge. After that erection hit my artistic eye with a bang, I put down a question to the Government. I asked the Taoiseach whether the Arts Council had been consulted about it. The reply I received was a laconic "No"—one word, "No"—and the matter was left there. Why did the Taoiseach not personally check up that matter with the Arts Council? That was one of their functions. The matter of that contraption has been raised at home and abroad and it has been the subject of gibes. It has been referred to as the tomb of the unknown tourist to the Tóstal. It has been universally decried. To my utter horror, I discovered that some sort of a scheme was to be put into operation by a Deputy of this House whereby this contraption would be covered over with marble or else that in it, or around it or somewhere else a fountain would be erected by the same people as were responsible for erecting that atrocity which is now on O'Connell Bridge. However, when the Deputy of this House discovered in the Dublin Corporation that the new scheme would cost £3,000 he ran like a hare. Apparently he felt that £3,000 was an appalling price to pay for something in the City of Dublin. It is about time we learnt the value of spending money on artistic objects to beautify our city. I understand that the present proposal is to be put aside, not because a fountain might not be suitable, even a fountain by the same persons as were responsible for the erection of the present contraption on O'Connell Bridge, but because it would cost too much. It was the cost that frightened them and not its artistic value or anything else.
I suggest to the Taoiseach that it ought to be part of the activities of the Arts Council to oversee and give advice in these matters and, if necessary to go to the Taoiseach and to say: "Let the Government stop this sort of thing which is going to destroy our city." I could not express an opinion from an artistic point of view on whether or not a fountain, the mostartistic and most valuable we could get, would be a good addition to O'Connell Bridge. I would require expert advice on that. I would have my own inexpert views, but I would like the Arts Council to exercise that function, which I believe is one of their great functions, to ensure that there will be in the capital city and in other cities throughout the country some control over the asininity of people who erect things of that description in moments of uninstructed enthusiam.
There is one final matter to which I want to refer in a few short words. I do so because of the importance it has in general to the country. I think the time has come when the Government as a whole should review the educational system from the point of view of the country and from the point of view of general Government policy to see whether—leaving aside the question of Irish, the teaching of Irish and the methods of teaching Irish—our educational methods are in conformity with the needs of the country and whether they are so properly designed as to fit our people for carrying on their business here, for living their lives here, for earning their livelihoods and, above all, for fitting them for being Deputies and knowing the arts of government.
I want to appeal to the Taoiseach particularly, in the matter of higher education, with which I think he has some concern and in which he is interested. There ought not to be any niggardly outlook on the matter of supplying money for buildings for University College, Dublin. There is in this city University College, Dublin, as well as colleges in Cork and Galway, and I believe that, in these three colleges, there is a ferment of political excitement. Our young people are getting a chance. We have material which can be very valuable for building up the country—intellectual and scientific material—and I ask that there should not be this niggardly attitude, this provincial attitude, about having the university on Stillorgan Road. What we want is decent buildings with a decent campus and decent opportunities for our students, opportunitieswhich will prevent a body of people coming from abroad and making the report they made about our medical schools.
Comment on this
Before dealing with the main items of the Estimate, I should like to deal with one or two matters to which Deputy Costello referred towards the end of his speech. I want to assure him that he has not got what one might call a fair view of things. He referred here to a law case recently heard in Dublin, arising out of the suing of the corporation in relation to the Town Planning Act, and he criticised the corporation for going to law and having had to spend something like £16,000 in costs. The position is that an Act of Parliament was passed by this House which imposed statutory responsibilities on all local authorities and, in the case of Dublin, the obligation of completing a town planning scheme. The members of Dublin Corporation cannot be held responsible for the drafting of that Act or for the legal interpretation of words therein.
The Act contained a provision that this scheme should be finished "within reasonable time" and the question arose as to what was reasonable. The corporation realising that a war of some years duration had followed the passing of this Act and that progress was being made in the matter of adding to the size of Dublin, felt that, until the war was over and the added area became a fact, it would be useless and senseless to attempt to complete a town plan for the city, without taking into account the 6,000 odd acres which were to be added to it. We were brought to court. We took legal advice and we cannot be held responsible as a corporation for acting on the advice of the best legal opinion we thought we could get. We lost in one case, and we found that, unless the Act were amended to give us more time or to interpret the word "reasonable", we would have to appeal. We did appeal, again on the advice of eminent legal opinion and we lost the appeal and a date was fixed by which this town plan scheme must be finished. At present, officials are working overtime on it; plans arebeing prepared; and a new committee is being set up to consult weekly with these officials in an effort to have the scheme completed within the period of time specified by the court. Deputy Costello put that forward as an argument against administration by the Fianna Fáil Government.
Deputy Costello also brought up the ridiculous controversy which is raging in the newspapers about what is called the bowl of light or bowl of water in O'Connell Street. He has again a complete disregard for the facts of the situation. The holding of An Tóstal——
Comment on this
How does all this dovetail in with the responsibility of the Taoiseach for his Department?
Comment on this
If the Chair rules that I should not answer, I will accept that ruling, but the Deputy brought these matters up in relation to a suggestion that the ornamental bowl there should be erected to the design of the Arts Council. It was decided to hold An Tóstal, and, in a great hurry, the Dublin Corporation were asked by the Tóstal Committee to contribute money and help to make the festival a success. They voted the limit which they are entitled to vote under statute, a sum of £10,000, for the decoration of the city and this was one of the items which the city architect included in a hurry.
Deputy Costello has talked about the way it hit his artistic eye. So far as I can judge, artistic eyes can be hit very often not only by what a layman may design but by what artists may design, because there seems to be no unanimity amongst artists about anything. This was a first effort and a Deputy of this Party had a motion down for the last meeting of the corporation on the lines of what Deputy Costello has suggested, that the Arts Council should be asked to arrange a competition, in which they would be the judges, for a suitable ornamental design. My own reaction to it is this:there is a lot of talk about the neglect of all Governments, including this Government, in the matter of the erection of a suitable memorial to the 1916 Rising. I had hoped that when the artistic eyes got tired we might be able to erect even a temporary memorial to the 1916 men on O'Connell Bridge. In my opinion, it is the most suitable place for it, properly surrounded by a decent design.
There are other problems which confront us in that connection. For years the island on O'Connell Bridge was the cause of hundreds of fatal accidents to children and people who ran across the road. Since it has been blocked off from traffic, the death and accident rates on O'Connell Bridge have fallen to almost nothing. It is all very well to put something on top of O'Connell Bridge, but we have got to make sure that the bridge will carry it. Engineers will have to be consulted in order to ensure that whatever is put on top of the bridge will not endanger the safety of the bridge.
Comment on this
I am only suggesting that Deputy Costello might have sent us something in relation to O'Connell Bridge for the corporation to consider at the next meeting, when this matter will again be considered.
With regard to the Town Planning Act, all I can say to Deputy Costello and to the Deputy now occupying the front bench, who is also a legal gentleman, is that I do not understand what can be done and what cannot be done under the interpretation of the law, but I do remember that many years ago when Cumann na nGaedheal was the Government, there was a case in the law courts called, I think, the Bray Copyrights Case. An amending Act was brought in to ensure that the word "shall" in the main Act should now be deemed to mean "shall not." That was the end of that. The Government did not bring in an Act when we lost this case to provide that "reasonabletime" meant reasonable, taking into consideration all the circumstances.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but lawyers, artists and O'Connell Bridge do not seem to be the responsibility of the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello criticised the Government for having the corporation in the position where it was interfering with the rights of individuals under the Town Planning Act. I want to put it on record that under "reasonable time" you have also got to consider all the circumstances. If it is decided to plan, acquire and widen certain areas in Capel Street, for example, an estimate of the cost has also to be got. When planning in the City of Dublin regard must be had to the capacity of the ratepayers to meet what one attempts to plan. Certainly that was the position some months ago when we did not have a contribution from State funds for certain works.
I listened with great interest to the beginning of Deputy Costello's speech last Thursday and to the speech he made to-day. Frankly, I am not in a position to say whether Deputy Costello's speech was, in fact, an attack on the policy of Fianna Fáil or a defence of himself and his Government for the three and a half years they were in office. We had phrases about our policy and allegations about certain things but there were no specific facts to bear them out. Deputy Costello read out numerous speeches of his own that he made to bankers' associations, members of trade and commerce and the Federation of Manufacturers. They were compared, if you please, with the speeches made by some of our spokesmen at banquets.
The word "banquet" was used whenever the Minister for Industry and Commerce was referred to. In the case of Deputy Costello, it was always a meeting he attended. I am very sorry that when the Deputy, as Taoiseach, was invited and entertained by legal organisations they did not at least give him sufficient food for him to remember the occasion was equal to a banquet.
Deputy Costello started off by saying that the Fianna Fáil policy was a policy of expediency. As far as I understand it, there has been no compromise on any fundamental issue of policy announced by Fianna Fáil. Since Fianna Fáil's very inception there has been no change in policy. It is a very simple policy. I will later deal with what that policy is.
Deputy Costello related that particular statement to the situation that now confronts us since, as he stated, the war receded. Is it not fair and reasonable to assume that after every world crisis, particularly after a world war, there are bound to be changes? There is bound to be an aftermath. The main changes after a war ends are a leaving-off of war effort, a falling-off in the numbers of people employed in war effort and a fall in the prices of commodities. It is fair to assume that these things happen but why these things fall or for how long they will continue to fall is anybody's guess. We, unfortunately, live in conditions where nobody can say that we are receding from war.
When the Korean war appeared imminent and when we were in the benches opposite and referred to it, Deputy Costello, as Taoiseach, indicated that we were talking about a mythical war. That is on the record. Now he has taken this mythical war as a fact. He tells us it is over and that the prospect of war, as we understand it, is receding. I do not know if there is anybody anywhere who can say whether war is moving away from us or whether it may not affect us very rapidly and without any warning.
It is true that since the end of the Korean war circumstances have changed. There has been a lessening of war effort and there has been a falling-off in employment in war matters. In our neighbouring country there has been an improvement in the standard of living to the extent that they have more food, more clothing and so forth and that they can indulge more in their own housing development schemes. That has an effect on us also.
Fianna Fáil recognise that had therenot been over a great number of years large scale emigration we would have had here a large number of people for whom there would have been no possible employment at the time. We also recognise that there are conditions, due to our economy, which bring about what is called seasonal unemployment. In those periods of seasonal unemployment what is wrong with the Government sponsored organisations and local authorities with Government assistance trying to assist those people who have become unemployed through no fault of their own because there is no other alternative? The seasons are there. For that reason an effort was made recently to deal with such a matter. The Government decided to set aside a certain sum of money for expenditure on what are called capital works. There are also what we call short-term works. Deputy Costello chose throughout his whole speech to refer to all of the schemes envisaged under that expenditure as relief schemes and opposed the idea behind them. He said that there could be and should be full employment in the ordinary agricultural and industrial undertakings, that there would be no unemployment of any kind if there was proper management, and that therefore this idea of relief schemes was useless.
What has happened in the City of Dublin? I only can speak of an area of which I have some knowledge. We had in the City of Dublin a number of persons unemployed; certain factors were militating against the employment of great numbers of them; certain changes took place in the employment of others and they became unemployed; and the Government introduced some addition to the Social Welfare legislation which allowed others previously not signing to sign. However, there was and is a number of persons signing on the live register who by signing are normally presumed to be looking for work and willing to work.
The Taoiseach himself sent for members of the House who are also members of the Dublin Corporation. He said it was his desire and the Government's desire that a local authoritysuch as the Dublin Corporation should try to find ways and means of giving additional employment over a long-term period and the word "relief" scheme as such was to be removed. They were not to be relief schemes. These were to do what was called special works not normally done out of the ratepayers' money by the Dublin Corporation. As a result of the pressure of the Taoiseach and the Government a special works committee was set up in the Dublin Corporation. Matters were examined as to how we could help and we went back to the Government and said:
"We have examined this matter. We understand your pressure and why you are attempting to rush us. We know you do not want us to dig holes and fill them up again. If you will give us certain facilities and considerable financial assistance we will be able, at a reasonable flow, to make our contribution towards bringing about relief of this problem."
As far as I can gather, signing on the Dublin labour exchanges in the Greater Dublin area, there are approximately between 3,000 and 4,000 male unemployed persons employable by us on such schemes. We cannot employ little boys and little girls, nor old men or old women; we can only employ persons suitable for such work as is expected from an unskilled labourer. We find that there are somewhere between 3,000 and 4,000 such persons employable and we thought we could, with the assistance of the Government, bring about a series of operations which would employ between 1,000 and 1,200 people. We would thus be making a contribution towards solving a certain problem in accordance with the wishes of the Government. We had long sessions with the Taoiseach and pointed out the difficulty there is in dealing with the unemployed situation. You have periods when you have large numbers of unemployed and periods when the numbers fall off, depending on what happens in business and industry generally. However, we must remember that unemployed labour isnot mobile and each area can only deal with what is happening in its own area. Consequently this problem was given to us to solve and a start has been made. A certain number of men, somewhere between 400 and 450, have been employed constantly since August on what are termed short-term amenity schemes.
Comment on this
I would like to clear up one matter. The Deputy appears to be discussing some particular scheme in the Dublin Corporation. I presume it is in order. I would like to have a ruling.
Comment on this
Later on it may be that Deputies from other sides of the House may desire to discuss these matters. I take it that they would not be ruled out of order?
Comment on this
The Deputy, I take it, is discussing the method by which the Dublin Corporation is dealing with the unemployment problem as authorised by the Government. Is that the point?
Comment on this
No, Sir, not quite. What I am discussing is this: Deputy Costello attacked the policy of the Government in trying to meet the present unemployment situation.
Comment on this
I am not objecting to the Deputy discussing it. I merely wish to get the line of the debate.
Comment on this
I endeavoured to limit the debate, and I did not see quite clearly, and do not yet see quite clearly, how the Taoiseach is responsible for a good many things that the Deputy is discussing. Do I take it he is replying to the statements made by Deputy Costello?
Comment on this
Yes, I am replying to the statements made by Deputy Costello. He castigated the Government on its expenditure, on its making available certain moneys for what he called relief schemes. I am trying to prove that the Government has made available and is making available substantial sums of money over a long period of time, sothat local authorities will be able to tackle the unemployment problem from time to time by engaging large or small numbers of workers, that the Government's policy, as directed to the corporation, has been that we should create by examination, by investigation, by calculation, and have available a pool of works possibly five years ahead so that we will not have to face from time to time the situation of people being thrown suddenly into the arena of unemployment with nothing available for them there.
Comment on this
It is the overall employment policy of the Government the Deputy is discussing, not any specific one?
Comment on this
Yes. The Government can only spend money itself on direct employment on what one would call Government schemes, the money being spent on Dublin Castle, for instance. The Government cannot build a bridge across the River Liffey, but the Government can say to the bridge authorities that: "If you can build a bridge and give employment in the building of that bridge, the Government will give you out of the special fund to which Deputy Costello alluded a 75 per cent. grant of its cost."
I was beginning to point out, Sir, that, as a result of money flowing to the local authority in Dublin from this Government Exchequer Fund, 450 people have been put on what are called minor schemes. Deputy Costello alluded to one of them. He said that it was a scandal to be wasting money on cleaning the Dodder. This is one of the schemes for which a certain small amount of money was being paid—I think something like ten men were being employed for so many weeks in cleaning up the Dodder. The Deputy who spoke first of all about the offence to his artistic eye given by the Dublin City bowl might cross the Dodder bridge and his eye might be offended again by a river running through the capital city overgrown with weeds.
Comment on this
I did not wish to saythat, but I am glad the Deputy has pointed it out. A variety of schemes is being dealt with. The Government have made it known to our local authority, anyway—and I believe to others—that we have now £1,600,000 to spend in five years or less on road work in Dublin.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy say "and I believe to others"?
Comment on this
Yes. There is the sum of £1,600,000 available for the City of Dublin. I am grateful to the Deputy for his correction, because I was making a mistake. I should have said that all local authorities have been informed that they will be given a sum of money, up to 100 per cent. on road work, in their areas. The Dublin Corporation has been notified that it must spend £1,600,000 within five years. Deputy Costello talked of a scheme of taking up the Dublin tram tracks. The only two schemes to which Deputy Costello referred—what he called relief schemes—were the lifting of the Dublin tram tracks and the Dodder. I want to tell Deputies that the lifting of the tram tracks in the City of Dublin is not a relief scheme. It is a scheme that has been going on for years. It went on throughout the whole period that the inter-Party Government were in office, but they never knew what was happening. They did not know that the Dublin Corporation had decided that a certain number of men would be employed on this work until all the tracks had been taken up. We could not possibly take up all the tram tracks in the one day. If we were to attempt to do that, traffic in the city would be dislocated. We had to have regard to the density of traffic in this city. The work had to be done, but not in the way that we speak in this House—of saying something without having any regard to the consequences. Everything that is done by a local authority is the subject of examination by the Department of Local Government, and in that way everybody's interest is protected, including the interests of pedestrians.
The lifting of the tram tracks will take another few years. There are two bodies involved in that. There was away-leave agreement between the old Dublin tram company and the Dublin Corporation. We know that the old Dublin tram company became merged in C.I.E. It took over the commitments which were there when the trams were taken off the streets of Dublin. A capital sum was paid by the company as compensation for having been released from the way-leaves agreement. A new agreement was reached whereby, because of the terms of the original contract with the tram company, C.I.E. is lifting the tracks and the Dublin Corporation is remaking the roads. That is being done by the two bodies concerned. Something like 300 men are constantly employed on that work and will continue to be employed on it, but that work, as I have said, has nothing whatever to do with the new development by the Government of providing large sums of money for local authorities to enable them to carry out works and so give useful employment.
Comment on this
The Deputy has said that they have gone to every local authority.
Comment on this
I said the grants. As I said earlier, Dublin corporation has been advised by the most eminent legal opinion and the other side has been advised by the most eminent legal opinion, but only one side can win. That is why the Dublin Corporation lost its case in the courts recently. When I spoke about every local authority being notified, I referred specifically to the road grants. I want to say, further, that I understand the local authorities have also been notified in the last few days about grants being made available for amenity schemes, where they have unemployed in their areas. They are to send up plans in regard to what they can do, and indicate how they would propose to utilise certain moneys.
Comment on this
What we want is, that, instead of looking for plans, they should send down some money. We have plenty of plans already.
Comment on this
Fine Gael think in terms of money in this way: the loading of money into wagons and sending it down in big trunks, so that when it arrives everybody will get a bit of it.
Comment on this
I am thinking of the fact that in my constituency 500 men have been thrown out of work coming up to Christmas.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to do his duty, I suggest he should do what a number of us, in all Parties, have been doing in Dublin, namely, that on a few days or on a few evenings he should sit down and see what scheme he can recommend to his local authority which would give employment to the local unemployed, and for which the local authority can get a grant from the Government up to 80 per cent. of the cost.
Comment on this
The Government have made it known that money is now available to all local authorities for public works. We in Dublin are going to go in, possibly, for the building of one or two bridges and for the building of new civic offices. But we are going to spend the money that we are getting, without any contribution, on roads. We are going to keep that money for the people whom we can employ on a number of useful schemes. Is Deputy Corish about to say something?
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what the Central Bank may say to the Government. Deputy O'Higgins talks about sending money down the country. We, in Dublin, are quite satisfied if we get formal approval from the Department of Local Government for our schemes, and confirmation, in a letter, of their intention to give us the grant. We will not ask the Department to put the money on a lorry and send it to us to the City Hall. Fine Gael appears, on occasions, to be opposed to all capital schemes where employment is to be given.
Comment on this
Think of all the noise they made about Dublin Castle. What did they want substituted for it? Deputy Costello said to-day that from £6,000,000 to £9,000,000 should be spent on building universities. Deputy Costello, apparently, was not here the day that his own Party voted against the Government when it proposed to give £200,000 to the National University to put it in funds to pay for the land it has acquired, and on which it hopes some day to be able to build a university. I have seen circus acrobats from time to time. I have seen them loop the loop and, for humans, do all kinds of peculiar things, but could anything compare with the acrobatics, of a mental kind, which we have seen in this House on the part of Deputy O'Higgins who voted against the sum of £200,000 being made available for the National University?
Comment on this
Is this Deputy Briscoe on the National University?
Comment on this
No, it is not, but it is Deputy Briscoe on Deputy O'Higgins's behaviour in connection with the National University.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy should leave the subject.
Comment on this
We have the usual attempt of a threat from Deputy O'Higgins that I should get off the subject. I am not going to be driven off it.
Comment on this
I will not leave it. The fact is that the Deputy and the Fine Gael Party voted the other night against the Government proposal that the Dáil should authorise a payment to the authorities of the National University to enable them to pay for the site which they had acquired at Stillorgan. We had Deputy Costello to-day advocating, in his best oratorical manner, that it would be wise to spend money on the building of universities, and telling us of all the good consequences that would flow to the country generally as a result of that.
Comment on this
What I want to emphasise in that connection is that there is a building in Dublin called Dublin Castle. Dublin Castle, according to the experts in the Board of Works who have advised the Government, is in a very bad condition—a dangerous condition in parts and wholly unsuitable for the purpose for which it is used.
Comment on this
The part we are talking about is going to be put into the utility side and a certain amount of employment is going to be given on that. It will be capital expenditure but employment will be given to skilled and unskilled people. In the same way other authorities over which the Dáil has not direct control can devise schemes for employment in their particular areas and come to the Government and say: There is something we think is essential to be done; what are you going to give to help us?
I believe my colleagues in the Dublin Corporation, irrespective of Party— there are none here from the Labour Party but there are some here very close to them—are all—Labour, Independent, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil— happy to give employment to the large number of men over a number of years —five years as far as we can see in advance—and that we are not going to be restricted by lack of assistance from the Government in going on with this work. I think it is well that the House should know that.
Deputy Costello talked about a speech made by the Minister for Lands. That speech was referred to a couple of times earlier in the session, but there was one word left out on those occasions. When it was referred to to-day, that word was added. The Minister for Lands was accused of speaking on behalf of the Minister for Finance and asking the bankers to remove the restriction on credit, and the implication was—when previously discussed in the House, and which we had always denied—that there was a Government directive to restrict credit and that this was an admission that something like that had been done and that we were now asking for that restriction to be removed. To-day, Deputy Costello read an extract from the speech, and the word added was "Government,"—that the restriction of credit to the Government should be somewhat lessened.
I do not know whether the banks have restricted credit to the Government or not, as a policy. I only know certain things that have arisen from time to time. First of all, when Deputy Costello talks about a restriction of credit to manufacturers, industrialists and traders, he does not seem to have any appreciation of the fact that the banks are responsible to the depositors for the money they lend to their other customers, and if 50 customers come in and want overdrafts to buy what in the opinion of the bankers might be large quantities of speculative articles which they feel might fall considerably as a consequence of the receding of the war, surely to goodness, the bankers' refusal to finance such transactions cannot be classed as a restriction of credit.
The fluidity of credit and cash has to be considered, and the velocity with which they flow along. I might be one of those who might feel very aggrieved in going along to the bank and asking for an overdraft to buy something which I think is good and which they think is bad, and being refused, but it is not a restriction of credit. It is a protection of the assets of those who have entrusted their money to the bankers.
I heard talk about the miserable conditions we are confronted with. Deputy Costello started off by saying that and wound up by saying that the conditions were better because their efforts had come to fruition. If Deputies read the speech they will see at the beginning that almost-skinless bones were being rattled around as a result of this hunger and starvation in the country. But I want to say that I had a number of people coming to me and complaining about bad trade. Is the Government to blame? We have had a very mild winter up to the present and a number of drapers and manufacturers of men's overcoats have been sadly affected. Surely that bad trade is not a direct responsibility of the Government, which cannot regulate the day that frost will come and the day that spring will come. A number of coal merchants have been complaining this year about bad business and we are all getting circulars inviting us to select coal described in its nugget form, simply because most of us have not been burning much coal this winter, as the weather has been very mild. Consequently, the merchants are suffering bad business, but it is not as a consequence of Government policy.
The Government is anxious to encourage industry—and nobody need emphasise that Fianna Fáil as a Government is not anxious to encourage the development of private enterprise. Deputy Costello suggested that the restrictions following the 1952 Budget on imports of consumable goods from England brought about (1) privation to the people and (2) prevented them from spending their savings. We knew when the war ended that there would be altered conditions in England and there might bedumping here and there was, in fact, a great attempt at dumping here of certain commodities now no longer commanding high prices. There is competition again in England for certain types of business, particularly in relation to a number of items manufactured in this country, but the Budget restrictions, while they mainly had the task of bringing down the adverse balance, also had in mind the protection of our own native industries.
I was very glad to hear Deputy Costello getting up and saying what he did say about native industries and we are all in agreement that there should be native industry. I am glad to know that the days have passed when industrialists in this country were accused of being in the business only for the purpose of fleecing the public for their own gain. We now realise, that for the purpose of development, industries are necessary and we also realise what Fianna Fáil has been preaching since its inception and what Sinn Féin preached. We have not to be told that agriculture is the main industry of this country. We know that, but what we have been talking about all these years is that we need industrial development in this country in order that our economy might be balanced. We do not need Deputy Costello coming to tell us about agriculture.
Comment on this
I was just using the phrase that the late President Griffith used.
Comment on this
I said that this fact was well known and expounded not only by us since our inception, but also by Sinn Féin before us.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not refer to President Griffith in relation to what he himself stood for. President Griffith was on this side of the House.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins did very little to give effect to the principles of President Griffith.
Comment on this
That comes well from the men who fought against and did their best to ruin the late President Griffith.
Comment on this
If the Deputy read a bit of history he might change his mind.
Comment on this
The Minister for Social Welfare pointed out recently that the money spent on social services during the last two years has risen from £3,500,000 to £7,500,000, clearly proving that some of the taxation of which Deputy Costello spoke was not taken off the backs of those least able to bear it and given to those who need it least but was taken off the backs of those best able to bear it and given to those most in need of it.
Deputy Costello used a lot of phrases of which I could not understand the meaning. He spoke about analysing the health or the illness of the body politic. Now, the body politic is either healthy or ill. It cannot be both. He talked in relation to the bankers about a nod being as good as a wink to a blind horse. I have yet to learn that bankers are blind; they are anything but blind as far as I am concerned. How a nod can be as good as a wink to the bankers I do not know.
Deputy Costello talked about this Government making it impossible forpeople to save. Early and late, he talked about people not being allowed to spend their savings on imported goods. He said he would get the people to save and to invest their savings at home by giving them on loan to the Irish Government, to the local authorities and to Irish concerns for the development of industry and the employment of our people generally. How can the people be induced to put money at the disposal of the Government? First of all, one has to give them as good a return for the money they lend as they will get elsewhere. Money is not as patriotic as individuals may be. Consequently, if people have been prudent and have saved money they want that money to earn for them by investment as much as it possibly can. They certainly will not give it to a Government, even their own Government, for a lesser return than they are getting at the moment. Therefore, when the Government floated a loan at 5 per cent. and the Dublin Corporation did likewise, those loans attracted a considerable amount of the savings of the Irish people.
Deputy Costello made comparisons between the manner in which Fine Gael and the inter-Party Government were able to get money cheaply and the extravagant rate of interest we are now paying. I remember when the Dublin Corporation, at the request of the then Government and with the sanction of the Government, floated a loan for housing, 10 per cent. was subscribed by the public and the rest had to be underwritten and given by the Government. When a slightly higher rate was offered 75 per cent. of the loan was subscribed by the public out of savings, and, be it remembered, by the largest number of small subscribers ever contributing to such a loan.
The Government now intends to seek another loan, and that money will be utilised on a variety of schemes of a capital nature. Deputy Costello talked about reproductive schemes. Many of our schemes are reproductive. We are hoping that those in which we will invest this money will be reproductive over a long period of years and providevaluable employment for our own people.
Deputy Costello said that Fianna Fáil lives on crises and disturbance. For 16 years we survived in face of a variety of disturbance. We did not create disturbances. We are not anxious for crisis to follow crisis. As a Government, it is our aim to create normal conditions. We want the people to take a long-term view in the acceptance of the policies we adumbrate. It is a good thing to know that there is unanimous acceptance now of our industrial protectionist policy. To-day Deputy Costello endorsed that policy. Now we know where we are, and so do those who wish to invest money. They need not fear that a change of Government will put them out of business. Of course, I am not speaking for Deputy Dillon, though I am sure Deputy Costello, as Leader of the Opposition, did.
Deputy Costello gave very few illustrations of the points he made. He indulged in theories and generalities. He mentioned that one of the things that the inter-Party Government insisted on doing was the building of houses, the building of schools and the building of hospitals. Surely Fianna Fáil cannot be reprimanded for lack of appreciation of housing needs. It was the 1932 Act that made it possible for large-scale housing development to take place. From 1932 to 1948 the number of hospitals built by Fianna Fáil has so far not been exceeded, even in the three and a half years of inter-Party Government. Every day we read of the construction of new schools.
Apparently we are no longer apart on that policy. We are glad the House is unanimous on the need for speeding up and continuing the projects we have on hands. Deputy Costello also referred to the development of our natural resources. The only single item that he mentioned was in connection with drainage work. Surely the House and the country know that Fianna Fáil is committed to a policy of developing our natural resources. That is one of the fundamental principles in its political programme. It was Fianna Fáil that started turf development in the teeth of the gibes, ridicule and threats of the Fine GaelParty. Turf is one of our natural resources. It has now reached an advanced state of development and that development is now accepted to the extent that even the Fine Gael front benchers are the greatest protagonists in the argument that there should not be any laying-off, even of a seasonal nature, of the workers engaged on turf development.
The land is a natural source of wealth. Fianna Fáil now at last has succeeded in making the country and the House unanimous on the subject of wheat-growing and beet-growing.
Comment on this
I suppose you started the sugar industry also.
Comment on this
The sugar industry was started by a private concern and was purchased by the Government shortly after the change of Government in 1932 and the production of sugar became a Government responsibility. The Government set up additional sugar factories and we are now producing almost if not all of our requirements of sugar from home-produced beet. It was this Government that recognised the advantage of the development of electricity, not the Shannon scheme itself, but the development of other natural resources. As a result, we had extensions to the Shannon scheme and rural electrification, which the Government is sponsoring to the extent of £10,000,000 capital outlay. Many Deputies seem to have forgotten that the cost of the rural electrification scheme will be £20,000,000, of which the Government will pay over £10,000,000 which has to be found somewhere.
I heard Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan telling the House that they had warned the bankers that if they did not open the coffers the Government would have to do something about it. It was believed that that conversation—put it at that—implied a suggestion that the banks might be nationalised. We are not going to commit a breach of the Constitution. The Constitution recognises the rightof individuals to own private property. Money in the banks is private property. Therefore it would be wrong to suggest nationalisation and acquisition of property of that nature.
Comment on this
I said it implied nationalisation of the banks. Deputy Hickey on many occasions informed the House that he felt that people who owned money should be forced to put it at the disposal of the State, for the benefit of the people, at a reasonable rate of interest. That is compulsion of another form. It is interference with private rights.
Comment on this
I am not saying it is dangerous. I am not criticising it at all. I am just saying that the Constitution, to which I at least subscribe, recognises the right of a private individual to acquire, control and own private property. That is my personal opinion. That is what I understand the Constitution would ensure. We must approach this particular property, money, from that point of view. As between a policy that gives the impression that there is a threat and a policy of reasoning with people, it is far better to use reason than to risk the consequences that may flow if it were thought that there would be interference with the privacy and independence of our banks.
I will make Deputy Hickey a present of a suggestion with which I am sure he will agree. The Central Bank is gradually increasing its credit balance. It is somewhere between £60,000,000 and £70,000,000. Probably every year that sum will increase and will become a very substantial amount. I would agree with Deputy Hickey if he suggested that the time had come to examine ways and means whereby the State would be able to borrow at low rates of interest the money that is to the credit of the Central Bank, which is a State insurance.
Comment on this
My colleague from South-West has at last intervened. There was no sense in doing it when it was not there.
Comment on this
Why did not the Deputy do it when he was Minister?
Comment on this
Why did not Fine Gael do it when they were in power? Not a pound of it did you borrow. Why not be honest?
Comment on this
It seems that it is very easy to tread on people's bunions. Either that money was there in that amount 20 years ago, as Deputy MacBride says, or it was not. I say it was not; that it was there in a considerable amount during the three and a half years of inter-Party Government, and I have yet to hear or see any proclamation or announcement made by the inter-Party Government on that question. I am speaking for myself on this matter. I am not a member of the Cabinet and I can only speak here and advocate what I think right, the same as any other Deputy. In my opinion the time is ripe for examination. Maybe Deputy Hickey will support that.
Comment on this
The action that the Deputy did not take. This dishonesty is sickening.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is criticising Deputy Briscoe?
Comment on this
I am not criticising Deputy Briscoe. I am criticising Fine Gael and that gentleman over there.
Comment on this
When there is an interjection by Deputy O'Higgins he does not say it loud enough for one to be able to grasp what it is.
Comment on this
The ordinary commercial banks are in a different position from the Central Bank. The only way that we can get private individuals to subscribe to loans is to ensure that they are satisfied that the loan is good and secure and offers a reasonable amount of interest on the investment.
Deputy Costello again spoke in two tongues, if you like. He spoke about the shame of our not having repatriated more of our money. Deputy Costello referred to speeches made on this side about that. We never said anything other than that while Deputy MacBride and Fine Gael were talking about repatriation of capital, the investment abroad in spite of them was growing, and when they handed over— in one particular year, certainly— investment abroad was higher than it had been when they took over. Now there are probably explanations and reasons—manipulations and so on. The question is, how do you repatriate? There was one outstanding suggestion left entirely out of Deputy Costello's speech, and I was sick and tired of listening to it and reading about it during the 1948 elections, and Deputy MacBride is responsible for it: money was going to be repatriated by the millions for the purpose of reafforestation in this country so that we would become independent of foreign fuel as a result of the alcohol we would make from the pulp. He has forgotten about that particular investment at home of our external assets, and it isas dead as a doornail, because now people know that that was counselled without a bit of intelligence or a bit of examination, without any reference to whether it was practical or not.
There would not be any great shortage of money if there is only going to be a difference between the two sides of the House as to what rate of interest you will pay, and that is the only distinction, and not the purpose to which it is going to be applied. If that is so, we are getting near each other. I can quite understand anybody saying —I said it myself in the Dublin Corporation when we were seeking a loan from the banks—that we refused it because it was in our opinion at too high a rate of interest. That is a matter of opinion. Another man might say: "If you do not take it at that rate you will not get it at all, you will not be able to go on with your schemes." Which is going to be the greater evil —to pay a ¼ per cent. more, or to lay off thousands of your workmen engaged in corporation schemes of housing either by direct labour or through contractors? There are differences of opinion, but what must go on is work. Work must go on. We could have a splendid time and argue out the theories of finance and come to some agreement or some improvement, but what we are all concerned about, particularly among members of this House who do reflect and consider, is what can be done and how can it be done.
Deputy Costello talked about one member of his Party telling him the other day about a carpenter who could not get work at home. In all my 26 years in public life a day has not gone by when I have not been approached by some individual who is unemployed, skilled or unskilled, clerical or otherwise. Every one of us has this experience every day, and we are quite alive to the need that exists to try to see that as many of our people as possible can be employed in gainful occupations, and that as far as possible for people who are in employment, if through circumstances beyond their control they find themselves unemployed, the Government and the local authorities should be able to step in and fill the gap of that period. Thatis what all this approach is about. Deputy Costello poured scorn on us. He talked about our funds, and he talked about the Transitional Development Fund. I do not think that Deputy Costello knows at this moment the purpose of that fund, and I will tell Deputy O'Higgins so that it can be put on record. The Fianna Fáil Government at the close of the last war realised that materials would be going up considerably, that wages would be going up, and that the cost of production in houses would certainly rise steeply; and in order that there would be a period that they could bridge until they found the real level of things a Transitional Development Fund was created from which local authorities were given additional subsidies over those existing in the Housing Acts in order that the houses might remain as near as possible to the pre-war level of rentals. That is called a stupid fund, a stupid thought, a neglect of the majority of our people. Every single thing that this Party thinks of and that this Government puts before the House there is some ground for, in my opinion, and there is good common sense and practical decency and humanity attached to it.