We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 112–234 of 234. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

By the banks, with the Government as guarantor for the whole thing?

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this

The Government, in other words, would be responsible to the banks for the £5,000,000—the Government would be guarantor for it?

Comment on this

The Government is responsible for seeing that this money will be available for the local authorities who require it and will be paid to them up to that amount.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

As to the exact machinery, when the Dáil comes here with the Budget and the Minister says he wants £100,000,000, the House does not ask him for a guarantee that that £100,000,000 is in the bank. We all know it has to come in in various forms of taxation and will be spent in various ways. In the same way, when each Minister comes in and asks the House to vote a certain amount of money, technically speaking that money is available for him to draw on from the Exchequer as he requires it, as it becomes due for payment. But each Minister does not, as I said before when Deputy O'Higgins talked about "send us down the money", employ a big horse and cart with a caravan trailed after it and all the notes of his Estimates stuffed into it, and bring it back to his office and say: "There is my money, now I can spend it." In the same way, this £5,000,000 will be voted by the House for a specific purpose and will be there on call from the Exchequer as it is needed and required by the local authorities. I do not know whether that answers the question as to whether it is a guarantee or not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not be inviting interruptions.

Comment on this

I am not inviting interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It looked very like an invitation.

Comment on this

I am prepared to tell Deputy Hickey that I might be saying something which I do not understand and I would be very grateful to him for any assistance he can give me to overcome the mistake.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe to conclude.

Comment on this

I referred before to seasonal employment, and I say that this particular new development is welcomed by us anyway in our local authority here. We now know that we can set up a special works committee apart and distinct from the ordinarydepartments of the local authority's normal operations, and it will not inflict on the ratepayers, as some newspaper has been suggesting, unlimited increases in rates. It will be rendering a human service to our people who are in need of employment, mainly subsidised or mainly paid for by the State out of taxation. The city itself will be improved. I do not know, Sir, whether you have read, but I am sure you have, references to what were called the Wide Streets Commissioners of Dublin in earlier days. At the time that they were envisaging wide streets in Dublin and wide bridges they were abused, I tell you. They were called wasters and spendthrifts and madmen and I do not know what else, but to-day we look back on those men and we are grateful to them for their wisdom, for the foresight they had in enabling a city to grow as Dublin has grown since their time and still not be a little narrow street village.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheorais Labour Party

A pity they did not do that in Wexford.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the abuse that I shall get as a result of being chairman of this committee, I believe conscientiously that 100 years from now Dublin citizens will look back to this period and say: "Thank goodness for the wise men who existed at that period and who constructed extra bridges in Dublin and put better streets and roadways down." I do not think Deputy MacBride will be recorded amongst the wise men of his year.

Comment on this

I suppose Deputy Briscoe will. There will be a monument to him on Nelson Pillar.

Comment on this

No. I do not want to go on Nelson Pillar.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Anticipation is not in order on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I am not anticipating. I speak with absolute conviction of certain events in the future. Future generations are bound to look back on what happens to-day. Fortunately we live in an age where everything is recorded and they will be able toassess, without any regard for personalities, in a cool abstract manner who was who in these days.

Comment on this

And who was not who.

Comment on this

And who was not who. Anyway I, according to my lights, am serving those who sent me both here and to the corporation. I think Deputy MacBride will have to realise some day that those of us who serve our constituents faithfully and well will be supported by the people, who are not easily misled by all kinds of catch cries and things that do not concern them. We are living in an age where we must look to ourselves. Each one of us must do his little bit——

Comment on this

To look after himself.

Comment on this

——for the general good and the general well-being.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride, I think, should take a little more time for reflection. Deputy MacBride had the opportunity and "muffed" it. The standard of living was referred to and it was said that the Budget of 1952 was such a savage Budget that it caused a reduction in the standard of living of our people. Then Deputy Costello went on to prove that what Fine Gael, and himself in particular, had prophesied in regard to the 1952 Budget actually happened. I do not know whether Deputy MacBride will subscribe to that particular calculation. It was suggested that the 1952 Budget would show a surplus of some £9,000,000. It is now suggested or hoped that the 1953 Budget will show a surplus of some £5,000,000 or maybe more. Deputy Costello said: "We were right when we told you in 1952 that there was going to be a surplus of £9,000,000. You put that aside by what is called cooked book-keeping, and you are going to produce that in the 1954 Budget, if you are going for election in 1954. If you are not, it will be kept secretly hidden somewhere until 1955."

Comment on this

It shows the confidence they have in us.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Costello should know that if we are such good manipulators as that, and if we are going to have such a gift up our cuffs for the community, they will support us and put us back again.

Deputy Costello referred to the Minister for Industry and Commerce as going around, not building castles in the air but promising industries in the air. I do not think serious Deputies in this House will deny that the one thing of which Deputy Lemass as Minister for Industry and Commerce can be proud, is the success he has achieved in the establishment of a large number of industries in this country. He has been the spearhead for that development. He is the man who inspires confidence in the people who want to start industries, because they know he has a certain definite line which explains Government policy. They know what is wanted and where the country is heading in that direction; yet we are told that his promises amount to industries in the air. Deputy Giles, of course, is one of those who grumble at the rapidity in the development of industries. The agricultural community, he said, are being robbed of the agricultural workers. He thinks—it is a matter of opinion and he is entitled to his opinion—that from the agriculturists' point of view, we are going too fast in that direction, that we should concern ourselves with the development of production on the land and should not be wasting our labour on industries and factories that can produce articles which can be imported cheaply from abroad. I think he referred in that connection to bentwood chairs. That is a matter of opinion, but I think that Deputy Giles will be the first to concede that, whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce is right or wrong, he has at least succeeded in doing what he wanted, though that may not be in accordance with the expectations or wishes of Deputy Giles.

The Taoiseach when he introduced this token Estimate invited the Deputies to bring him over any ground they wanted and that he would meet them on the ground or grounds theychose. I can say with safety I am sure that the Leader of the Opposition has not confronted him with any great difficulty as regards answering questions. I hope that other speakers on the Opposition side will pinpoint the faults in the policy which was described by Deputy Costello as a policy that meant no good for the people. I hope Deputy O'Higgins will be able to show us what items of our policy are wrong. I hope he will tell us what we did not do that we should have done or what Fine Gael would have done in similar circumstances.

All I can say in conclusion is that I look to this day as providing a further valuable advance in the social outlook of this Government and of our people. I am glad to see the responsibility taken in a practical way for the employment of some of our people through Government aid and that this Government is not taking the line that it is not their duty to find work for the unemployed. I hope the Government will encourage other industrialists to come along and will see that existing industries are expanded so that a great many of our people who are now registering at the exchanges will be provided with employment. We want to see prosperity in the country. We want to see our people provided with the means of becoming prosperous. We want to see the savings of our people put at the disposal of the nation provided that these people get attractive terms for putting what they own at our disposal. I think this is a new step forward. I do not know whether it is being fully understood and fully appreciated or whether the local authorities in the country will follow the example of Dublin City and put to work, with Government assistance, as many unemployed people as they can. I hope that Deputy O'Higgins will race as quickly as possible after the Dáil rises to his constituency, to find out areas in which there are 500 unemployed people, what work they can be put to, and when he has got these particulars, with the assistance of the officers of the local authority, then I am sure he will be very happy when he is told by the Local Government Department: "We are glad you are able toput these people to work and we are going to give you a grant of 80 per cent."

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is rather a pity that the Taoiseach moved this token Estimate in a mere formal way and I trust it is not an indication of his attitude towards the situation in which the country finds itself at the present time. It is all very well for the Taoiseach in his opening remarks to invite the Opposition and the House in general to choose their own ground and he will meet them. But surely when every other Minister takes the opportunity to give some broad outline of his particular policy in regard to his own Department, the Taoiseach's Estimate should be introduced by a speech which would give a general review of Government policy, how it has worked out in the last 12 months, and what the changes, if any, are to be for the next 12 months, because I think the situation in the country at present demands that there should be some such statement from the head of the Government.

Let me say at the beginning of my remarks that I very much regret that the Taoiseach did not see fit as Taoiseach or as Leader of the Government to say on behalf of the Government and on behalf of the people of this country that he wished to protest against the imprisonment of Mr. Liam Kelly, M.P. for mid-Tyrone. I cannot understand the reluctance of the Taoiseach to do this. I am sure he will make some statement or is bound to make some statement on this in his concluding speech, but it does seem extraordinary that practically every public body in this country can make its protest, formal though it may be, that every responsible organisation, especially those of a political nature, can make a protest at the imprisonment of a man whose only crime has been to be a good Irishman, and yet this House could not devote even two or, say, three hours to a discussion, the conclusion of which would be a protest to the people responsible for the imprisonment of this man.

I have noticed in the British papersrecently that they have been inclined to regard this whole affair of Mr. Kelly, M.P., in a rather flippant way. I would suggest that the imprisonment of Mr. Kelly and his sham trial are of such seriousness that a protest is demanded from the Government to show the British people especially, and the people of the world generally who have any sort of interest in Ireland,that we regard this as being very repugnant to the majority of the people in the 32 Counties. If we make that protest, it does not necessarily mean that we concur absolutely in any sentiments that may have been expressed by Mr. Kelly. Many other good Irishmen have advocated certain other methods for the establishment of a 32-county Republic and I would suggest that we should not set ourselves up as the absolute judges of how we can best achieve the establishment of a 32-county Republic.

I think those people in the Six Counties who are desirous of seeing Partition ended are also very desirous that the Government of this country, or, should I say, the elected representatives who sit in this Dáil, should make our feelings and their feelings known through a public protest to those in Stormont and those in Westminister who must share the blame for the position in which we find ourselves in this country as far as Partition is concerned and as far as the imprisonment and hounding of Mr. Liam Kelly, M.P., is concerned.

I again seriously suggest that it was a bad precedent for the Taoiseach to create by the mere formal moving of the Estimate for his Department.

Comment on this

That precedent was established many years ago.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I have seen the Taoiseach's speech last year and he devoted quite a considerable amount of time to the introduction of the Estimate.

Comment on this

I think a Deputy wanted to know something.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I have a very good memory for these things. I think that was the Taoiseach's firstEstimate when he came back into power. He formally moved the Estimate and I think it was I who asked if he was not going to give us an idea of the Government's policy, and he continued speaking then, I think, for two hours. Last year he also made a pretty long contribution. We had statements recently to the effect that we are turning the corner, that better times are ahead and that the economy of the country is now stable, and I think it is only right that the Taoiseach should demonstrate how we are turning the corner, when we will turn the corner and where are the better times. Personally, I cannot see many signs that there is an improvement, and I think I can say, on behalf of my Party, that we will judge the Government or any Government, and we will judge ourselves if we happen to be the Government, on the figures for employment or the figures for unemployment.

As reported in column 504 of the Official Report for the 10th February; 1953, the Taoiseach said: "The figures for unemployment have been disturbing." How can it, therefore, be suggested that there is an improvement in the country when there is no improvement in the unemployment figures? If the figure for unemployment last year disturbed the Taoieach, surely he must be much more disturbed now to know that ten or 11 months have gone by and there is no substantial change and that, as far as we can judge, the situation has become worse rather than better? My experience in the last year is that many more people emigrated than emigrated even the year before. I can be challenged on that and I cannot corroborate it by statistics inasmuch as the Government have not yet devised a method whereby they can determine the number of people who emigrate. But from my knowledge of my constituency I can safely say that many more people have emigrated in the present year than emigrated last year, especially from the rural areas. I only say that from the experience I have in going around through my constituency.

The Taoiseach, in his concludingspeech last year on the Estimate, spoke about unemployment in the rural areas. In column 505, he said:—

"There is a great deal of unemployment, for instance, in agriculture. Yet we hear constantly that the farmers cannot get the necessary labour."

That may be extraordinary to the Taoiseach but it does not present any problem to me. It is true that in certain places there may be a scarcity of labour during the springtime and harvest-time, but surely it is not suggested that thousands of agricultural labourers should just hold themselves available in the rural areas until the farmer calls them? Unemployment is much more serious in the rural areas than in some of the bigger cities, because when there is unemployment in the rural areas there is a consequent flight to the cities, where the problem is enlarged to a very great extent. Unless we tackle this unemployment problem first of all in the rural areas, we will never find a real solution.

Let me say again, as I have said here on a few occasions in the last few months, that the situation in the rural areas is changing before our eyes. It has changed even in the last six or seven years. There is a limited scope for employment in the rural areas now for men and women who work for a weekly wage. With the cutting down of certain works under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, with the completion to some extent of the cottage building scheme and especially with the introduction of machinery into agriculture, there is less and less scope year after year for the employment of rural workers. Unless the Government can evolve some system, or can establish some industries, or define some work or, to put it simpler still, make available to the local authorities money to employ these people, not on relief schemes, but on productive work, I fear we will continue to have the drain of 16,000 or 20,000 men from the rural parts of the country.

Certain Deputies can think only in terms of relief schemes. I cannot visualise many types of work in thiscountry which would be mere relief schemes. The Labour Party and the Trade Union Congress approached the Taoiseach some few months ago about the provision of employment and suggested seriously to the Taoiseach and to the Tánaiste that the Government give serious consideration to the granting of more moneys to the county councils for drainage schemes. The only real objection I ever heard to the moneys that were spent on drainage under the Local Authorities (Works) Act was that there was no provision for maintenance.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There is no provision for maintenance—agreed— but surely the Government has often devoted—and will again, I am sure— free grants to local authorities and others without any provision for future maintenance. Maintenance should not be a bar to the Government giving money to engage in this work, which was of so much importance. I would be the first to admit and agree in regard to certain criticism that was made of that particular work. There was money spent from which the full benefit was not got. That was inevitable. On the introduction of any new scheme, whether by the Government or some public body, it is inevitable that things will not be done properly in the first stages. However, I have seen examples myself of places where work under this particular Act was so beneficial that fields of wheat were grown in an area that for years before the scheme was introduced could not even grow grass. I was in a village yesterday in South Wexford, Bridgetown, that had been subject to flooding for years, as long as people could remember and as a result of work done under that Act that village has not been subject to flooding for, I think, the last two years.

We may talk about the establishment of industries in rural areas, we may wait to establish industries that will go hand in hand with afforestation; but in the meantime we cannot do better than invest money in the land, investing it in agriculture. Undoubtedly, in recent years agriculture in this country hasknown a boom. Parties may want to give credit for that to this or that Minister for Agriculture. Because Britain was at war and production was not at the peak at which the British Government or people would like it, this country benefited. In my opinion, agriculture must prepare itself for something of a shock, if not next year then in the following year or the year after that. The boom will not continue always. The top prices paid for cattle, and probably now being paid, will not always be paid. The countries of western Europe which had been in the habit of supplying certain produce and stock to the British market seem now to be getting on their feet again and the competition in agricultural produce will become much more acute than it has been in the last five or six years. We have evidence of that, small or big though it may be, in the matter of the turkey trade this year. Whereas last year and the year before turkey producers were able to command a pretty good price per lb., this year they discover that, because the British people and, the British farmers are up and doing about the rearing of turkeys, there is virtually no turkey market for Irish farmers or their wives.

Speakers on agriculture have referred at length to increased production, saying that the only way we can secure a sound economy for ourselves and have full and plenty is by increasing production. The agricultural industry, the farmers and the people generally, cannot increase production unless we put people to work and unless we give them the wherewithal to produce. Unless we can provide money for agriculture—and in doing so provide work for the tens of thousands we have unemployed—there is no use in asking for increased production. As long as we have unemployed men and work waiting to be done, we are not doing our utmost about production.

In the discussion on the Estimate last year and this year there were certain comments on the Central Bank, the Central Bank Report and on banks in general. Last year in winding up the debate the Taoiseach made some comments about the Central Bank. I do not think he committed himself oneway or another. He did not subscribe to the views contained in the Central Bank Report, nor did he say he did not agree with them. He said that the Central Bank Report merely gives an opinion. There is, however, something that we in this country must realise. The Central Bank may give an opinion. We can all say to ourselves that they are only a crowd of stuffed shirt conservatives and that we do not have to have any regard for their opinions. The important thing, however, about the Central Bank and its report, and the banks of the country generally, is that we must have regard for what they say. They are all-powerful inasmuch as they control credit and control the price of money. If it is the policy of the present Government or any other Government to invest in this country, to borrow for works of a capital nature, then I say that our programme with regard to capital works will be governed by the attitude of the banks. We have stated, time and time again—Deputy Briscoe to-day seems to come some little bit of the way with us—that if our Government have not control over the issue of credit in this country and the price of money we cannot say at what rate our country will develop. The Central Bank advocated certain things in 1952. It complained, in its own inimitable fashion, that there were too many in employment: I do not think that is an unfair paraphrase of what they said. I see that the Taoiseach smiles. I have not the report with me, but if my memory serves me correctly the Central Bank bewailed the fact that there was not a large number of unemployed in the country.

Comment on this

No. They did not do that.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

That was my understanding of what they said.

Comment on this

They said that, in view of the unusually favourable condition of employment, public works could be cut down.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The inference was that too many people were in employment. They complained about certain other things also. They complained that the foodsubsidies were a burden and they advocated their withdrawal. They deplored the fact that people could get credit easily. Deputy Lemass repudiated that report. The Taoiseach said that he had no responsibility for it. The extraordinary thing, however, is that these three major factors—(1) the issue of credit facilities, (2) the withdrawal of the food subsidies and (3) the creation of unemployment—happened in 12 months. I will not say that I blame the Taoiseach for that: I will not say that I do not blame him. I will not give any opinion as far as that is concerned. What I am trying to drive home is that that little blue book, the Central Bank Report, is more important than many of us think. If it is their opinion and if they state in their report that credit should be restricted, they will make sure that it will be restricted.

Comment on this

And the Government are allowing them to do it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

If the issue of money is to be tightened up or if the Central Bank recommend or say that it should be tightened up, they will take steps to see that it will be tightened up. Whether or not they got the nod or the wink from the Government as far as the restriction of credit is concerned, I do not know.

Comment on this

You may be sure they did not.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The fact is that there has been a tightening up over the past two years. At present, it is very difficult to get a £1 on credit from the bank. Any bank manager will tell you that he got his directions from the top. Whether or not the Government or the Minister for Finance instructed the Central Bank to withhold credit or to tighten it up, I suppose we will never know.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get all the information he wants. The Government gave no such instructions. That is a fact.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is rather peculiar that since April, 1952, Governmentpolicy and the recommendations of the Central Bank Report seem to be going like two greyhounds neck and neck together. Whether or not that is a coincidence, only the Taoiseach and his Cabinet know.

Comment on this

They set up the Central Bank.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There has been a restriction of credit. Who is to blame for that? If the banks are to blame, then has it not been bad for the country? If the banks have that power over the economy of this country and if they have the power to determine whether or not men will work, surely it is a state of affairs that ought to be changed. In such a situation. surely the Taoiseach and the Government should give close consideration to the suggestions that have often been made from this side of the House.

I was somewhat amused by Deputy Briscoe's speech this evening in view of some of the events that have taken place in the past six months. During the past two years we have tried to impress upon the Taoiseach and the Government that an extraordinary unemployment situation had arisen. Every Government speaker and every member of the Fianna Fáil Party persisted in saying all during these two years that there was not an extraordinary unemployment situation. The Minister for Social Welfare and his Parliamentary Secretary made speeches here and answered questions and sought all the time to prove that as far as unemployment was concerned the position in the past two years was far better than it was in the three years of the inter-Party Government, from 1948 to 1951.

It is true to say that because there were marches in Dublin by the unemployed some consideration was given by the Government to the unemployment question. Now we hear, not from the Taoiseach, not from the Minister for Local Government, not from the Minister for Finance, not from the Tánaiste, but from Deputy Briscoe— whether or not he has any authority to say so, I do not know—that if any public authority want to engage in public work all they need do is totell the Minister for Local Government and he will provide 80 per cent. of the cost. Deputies who were present here this evening when Deputy Briscoe was speaking heard him make that pronouncement. Whether or not it is true, we do not know. Whether they be amenity schemes, local authority schemes or other schemes, our difficulty is that months and sometimes even years elapse before we can even get a decision on them from the Department of Local Government, let alone money. This sudden suggestion of generosity from the Government or the Department of Local Government does not impress anybody on this side of the House.

Comment on this

Because you will not get the money.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

We are now only two or three weeks away from Christmas. In Wexford, the furthest we can get now in regard to the employment of men on relief schemes is to start eight men next Thursday on the construction of a footpath. I do not know if preferential treatment is given to people in whom Deputy Briscoe is interested, but the position in my constituency is that Wexford could do with many thousands of the pounds which Deputy Briscoe says are available in the Department of Local Government.

With 67,000 unemployed persons in this country, is it not paradoxical to hear from Deputy Briscoe, and speakers on the Government side of the House, that the Government are going to insist that Dublin Corporation will spend £1,800,000 next year or in the next five years? If it is so very easy to get money from the Department of Local Government or the Department of Finance, surely we should not have 67,000 persons unemployed? Sewerage and water supply schemes, and other public works, are sent up to the Department of Local Government. Our experience is that the Department ask you so many questions and that there are so many letters and counter-letters, and letters again and more counter-letters, that many months elapse before a spade is thrust in the ground. I do not know whether ornot that is a deliberate policy which is being pursued by the Department of Local Government, but that is the effect which the policy has.

I want to repeat that there has been a very grave slowing-down in house building. That may not be as a result of specific direction. I should like to point out that the slowing-down may be as a result of administrative action or, if you prefer it, lack of administrative action. These tuppenny-halfpenny queries that come down from the Department about this, that and the other scheme are, in my opinion, only designed to delay a job so that whatever moneys are available for housing in the Department of Local Government in a particular year can gradually be shoved over until the next year.

We look forward with interest to the production of the National Development Fund Bill, and to the introductory speech by the Taoiseach or by whichever Minister is deputed to introduce it. If there is any country in western Europe which needs more development than this country, I should like to see it. The Central Bank itself complains that a lot of the moneys provided by the Government are moneys which are used in nonproductive works. It is very wrong for anybody to suggest that moneys spent by any Government, whether this Government or the previous Government, on schools, hospitals, houses, water supplies, roads, bridges or drainage, is money spent on works which could be classed as nonproductive.

These works are very essential. The provision of schools and hospitals is absolutely essential in a country which has, so to speak, been starved for years of decent schools, hospitals and other public buildings and amenities. Any money we spend on rural electrification goes towards the advancement of production in agriculture and in industry. Moneys spent on drainage are particularly productive and moneys spent by the Government in the production of turf could not be regarded by the Central Bank as moneys spent on works of an unproductive nature. I think I can safely say that, no matter to what extent the Government go toborrow money for works of this nature, they will have this Party behind it. We will take exception, as we have taken exception in the past, to the price which the Government are forced to pay for it, because we believe that only by the control of credit facilities and the price of money here can this country advance with any rapidity.

While the Taoiseach may have a lot of political questions to answer in replying to this debate, and while he may be tempted to score political points off his opponents by going back two or three years, or 20 years, he would be very well advised to deal with this money question and to deal with it exclusively. I have heard interruptions of speeches of members of this Party as to why we did not do such and such in three and a half years, but we could devote all day in Dáil Éireann to what we in the Labour Party or what Fine Gael did not do in three and a half years, and we could well list out here all the things Fianna Fáil did not do in 16 years, and all the things that Cumann na nGaedheal did not do in the ten years previously.

We should have arrived at a stage in the political life of this country at which we agree to give credit to Cumann na nGaedheal for what they did from 1922 to 1932, and I do not think it could be suggested that we went back in that period, to say the least of it. I should be prepared, as my Party are prepared, to give credit for the good things done from 1932 to 1947, and I merely ask that Fianna Fáil and those who support them, rather than sniping and attacking, should give credit for the good which was undoubtedly done in the following years. In the past two years, we as a Labour Party supported Fianna Fáil in certain of its measures, and particularly those in the field of social welware. We say that they are advances, but let us get away from the stage of going back to 1922 to 1927, and even to 1948 and 1951. Let us try to meet the situation we find ourselves confronted with at present. Let us examine it, and, as a House representative of the people of the Twenty-Six Counties, see what we can do to change that situation.

Comment on this

I am very glad thatDeputy Costello and Deputy Corish, on behalf of their respective Parties, raised the question of the arrest and imprisonment of Mr. Liam Kelly, the elected Member of Parliament for mid-Tyrone. I think that events in the Six Counties in the course of the last few months are of particular significance and of considerable importance to future development, not merely in the Six Counties but down here as well. For these reasons, I was extremely glad that, on behalf of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party, some voice of protest has been raised here.

I wonder do we appreciate fully what is happening? Do we realise that, for the first time in a period of over 20 years, a young man who has been elected by the people of his constituency has been arrested and thrown into jail for making an election speech? Possibly more important than that, do we realise that he represents a new inspiration in the Six Counties, an inspiration that refuses to lend the cloak of sanction to the continuance of Partition? I think it is important that this House should appreciate that the rise of Mr. Liam Kelly by being elected by the people of mid-Tyrone and his subsequent arrest are merely the early puffs of a new wind which is rising in the Six Counties.

I think it unfortunate that the Taoiseach did not make a clear-cut statement concerning the arrest of Mr. Liam Kelly when he was invited to do so. It would be much better had this question come before the House on the initiative of the Taoiseach himself.

Comment on this

There was no attempt to consult him.

Comment on this

I put down a question to the Taoiseach, in the first instance, in which I merely inquired whether his attention had been drawn to the arrest of Mr. Liam Kelly and whether he would consider making a statement to the House. The answer. and the only answer, he gave was in the negative. Because the Taoiseach did not make a statement on that occasion I felt it necessary to put down a motion. Had the Government given an indication of its attitude I would not have done so. I knew other memwarebers of the House, including members of the Taoiseach's own Party, would wish to have an opportunity of making their voices heard on the matter. I think it is regrettable that the Taoiseach, in introducting his Estimate, did not remedy the position then by making a statement dealing with the matter. Likewise, I think it is regrettable that the Taoiseach, knowing, as he does now, that every Party on this side of the House wishes an opportunity to discuss the matter, is not prepared to make Government time available to have this matter discussed.

As Deputy Mac Fheórais pointed out, surely this House is not so pressed for time that it could not, on an occasion of this kind, give at least two or three hours to that motion or to any motion which the Taoiseach would be prepared to sponsor himself. I think a matter of this kind should be sponsored by the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach should have been in a position to make a clear-cut statement concerning the views of the Government as to the arrest of one of the elected representatives of the Irish people.

Have we reached the stage where, through complacency, we do not care? Have we reached the stage where, through caution, we are afraid to say that we admire the courage and principles of a young Irishman who is prepared to stand up and go to jail for his convictions? Have we reached the stage when we are afraid to mention Partition in this House, or where we are afraid to applaud those who are suffering and who are prepared to fight back against Partition? If we have reached that stage, we must have travelled a very long way beyond the ideals and principles that motivated those who fought for the freedom of this country.

The Taoiseach has an opportunity, even now, of remedying the position. The Taoiseach could easily agree to make time available for the discussion of the motion which is down in my name or, if he does not like that motion, introduce a motion himself before the House to give the House anopportunity of expressing the views which I know 99 per cent. of the members of this House hold.

There is no reason why we should be ashamed of expressing our sympathy for the people of Tyrone because they have been deprived of their elected leader. There is no reason why we should be ashamed to say we admire Mr. Liam Kelly for the attitude he has adopted. I think it would be much better if expressions of sympathy of this kind came from the Government. I believe it is the Government's duty in a matter of that kind to give a lead to the country and not to have to be pushed into the position where it has to say something.

I hope the Taoiseach will, before this debate concludes or before the House rises, consider this matter. It is the desire not merely of this House but of the country generally that there should be a clear expression of opinion given by this House concerning the arrest of Mr. Liam Kelly.

As I said a few minutes ago, I think it is important that the Taoiseach and the members of this House should realise that this is no mere flash in the pan. These are merely the first puffs of a new wind, a new wind which is going to sweep through the Six Counties. We may as well face that fact and help and assist those of our countrymen in the Six counties who are trying to assert the sovereignty of the Republic there. We should not be afraid or ashamed to stand by them now. That should be done through the Leader of the Government.

We should remember, too, that this new movement, Fianna Uladh, which is starting is a movement which is pledged to the acceptance of our Constitution. Its aim is the extension of our Constitution over the whole of Ireland. That surely should be the aim of every member of this House. I felt so keenly about the matter that at one stage I intended not to deal with any other topic in speaking on this Estimate. However, there is a number of matters to which I should refer.

It is quite wrong for the Taoiseach not to give some indication as to thegeneral policy of the Government. He is the head of the Government. The debate on his Estimate is the one occasion each year upon which the country is entitled to expect some indication that the Government's policy will be given. I do not know whether the Taoiseach's silence was due to the fact that he had no policy or to certain possible differences of views within the ranks of his own Party as to the policy which should be pursued.

It is deplorable that on the one occasion in the year, when a statement of policy could be expected, we have had no statement of policy. Regarding the economic position generally, all I can say is what has been said by other speakers already on this side of the House. As I said already on the Appropriation Bill, the one recognised index as to the condition of any civilised community is the unemployment and the employment position. With over 67,000 people unemployed and 12,000 more unemployed than in 1950, we have a serious position in the country. It is a position which is not improving. It is no use the Taoiseach indulging in wishful self-deception in regard to the matter. It is a serious crisis—a crisis which results from the pursuit of the Central Bank policy by the Government. I saw the Taoiseach smiling when contradicting Deputy Mac Fheórais a few minutes ago but it is no use denying that the Government did follow the Central Bank policy.

The Central Bank advocated the removal of the food subsidies in order to reduce the purchasing power of the people. The Government did that. The Central Bank advocated increased taxation on consumer goods, again in order to reduce the consumption of the people. The Government did that. The Central Bank advocated rigorous credit restrictions and, in my view, the Government did that.

You will probably not find a written order from the Government to the banks telling them they must reduce credits, but the Taoiseach will remember that some 18 months ago I drew attention to a report drawn up by the O.E.E.C. on the basis of informationsent by the Department of Finance concerning the restriction of credits. It is quite clear from that report that it was the Government's policy to restrict credits, unless the Department of Finance was speaking in a voice which did not reflect the Government's policy. Presumably, the Department of Finance, which deals with the question of credit restrictions was speaking with the voice of the Government. If not, the Minister for Finance should be removed. The Taoiseach will remember that I drew his attention to that Department of Finance memorandum about restriction of credit. At the time he said he had not seen it, that he was not aware of its existence. I quoted it for him in this House—he was just back from his illness abroad. I assumed he would take some steps to remedy the position, but we have had no indications from the Government that they have a desire to see any relaxation in the restriction of credit. The only indication we had was from the Minister for Lands the other day at the bankers' dinner, where he deputised for the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Lands was most careful in his choice of words, and I think we may take it—I am not saying this in derogation of the Minister for Lands—that his speech was carefully written in advance and supplied to the papers. The only relaxation of credit suggested in that speech was the relaxation of credit by the bankers as far as the Government was concerned. Even yet we have no categorical indication from the Government that it is their wish to see credit restriction relaxed.

The fourth thing which the Central Bank advocated was the creation of unemployment. Here again the Taoiseach was inclined to contradict Deputy Corish when he mentioned that a few minutes ago. It is true the Central Bank did not say in so many words: "We advocate you should create unemployment" but what they said was this, that "in view of the unusually favourable conditions of employment" public works could be cut down; that was saying bluntly "in view of the unusually favourable conditions of employment" we should create unemployment, and that hasbeen done; we have created unemployment.

If the aim of the Government's policy was to create unemployment they certainly have succeeded. If the aim of the Government's policy was to reduce the value of real wages they certainly have succeeded.

The country is entitled to some indication from the Government as to what the Government's policy is in regard to these famous sterling assets. The Taoiseach and myself have had a long-range controversy at by-election times in Wicklow and South Galway about these famous sterling assets. The Taoiseach told us in Wicklow and Galway that they had reached a dangerously low level. We could not afford to spend any more sterling assets. We were told a very short time afterwards by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that we should use the sterling assets. What is the Government's policy? Is it the Govment's policy to keep on accumulating sterling assets and let our money waste away or is it the Government's policy to utilise them?

As the Taoiseach was at his tea this evening, I do not think he heard Deputy Briscoe's suggestion—it might surprise the Taoiseach to learn, if he has not already heard it—that the Government might well use the moneys of the Central Bank instead of investing them in British securities at 1 per cent. or 1½ per cent. interest. He declared that the time has been reached when our Government should be able to borrow that money and I cannot allow this occasion to pass without congratulating Deputy Briscoe on his conversion. It is not so very long ago since I was savaged by Deputy Briscoe and other Deputies for suggesting that. But is that the Government's policy or is it not? If it is the Government's policy I think the Government will receive the support of certainly 75 per cent. of the House, probably 100 per cent., in any measure it takes in that direction. It is a perfectly fantastic position, that we should lend money to the British Government at 1 per cent. or 1½ per cent. interest while we borrow at 5 per cent.

The only thing that worries me about the belated conversion that seems to have taken place is that it was brought about by the force of circumstances rather than by conviction. I would much rather see the Taoiseach adopting a policy of this kind because he believed in it. I am afraid at the moment it looks a little bit as if it is being adopted because he feels we need money: "We cannot float another loan; the banks are sticky and will not give us the money; therefore let us dip into the sterling assets." I do not disagree with that at all but I would prefer to feel the matter was being approached objectively on its merits. I would like to see the whole question examined on a non-Party basis, either by a committee of the House or by a committee of experts to examine the changes which are so urgently required in our whole financial system.

It is quite clear that both the Currency Act of 1927, and the Central Bank Acts which have been passed since, need revision in more ways than one. The investment of money here and the lending of it by the Central Bank to the Government, I think can be done without any amending legislation. I would like to see a matter of that kind approached objectively on a non-Party basis rather than becoming another football in a political field. I certainly would like to congratulate Deputy Briscoe and some other members of Fianna Fáil for their conversion, even if it is a belated one. It is a step forward. I seem to have been fighting a very lonely battle on this question a few years ago. I seem to have got quite a number of converts since then, from both sides of the House. Let us hope the Government will now take it up and have the whole position examined from top to bottom in consultation with the other Parties in the House.

There has been a great deal of talk about relief schemes and also about this new development fund which has been referred to by the Taoiseach. We do not yet know exactly the purpose of this fund or the manner in which it will be administered but what did occur to me was this: if it is another one of these paradoxical matters that seem to occur so frequently in the Government'spolicy, why is there such a blowing of trumpets about the development fund while at the same time the Government is strangling the Local Authorities (Works) Act? It probably was one of the best Acts ever introduced in this House from the point of view of providing employment on works of a useful nature. Why was the amount of money for that Act so systematically turned off by the Government since it resumed office? Was it merely out of prejudice, because this was an Act which had been introduced by the inter-Party Government? It was generally recognised by all local authorities as being one of the most useful pieces of local government legislation that had ever been introduced.

Why, too, should not more money be made available for forestry? If we have money to spend on development —I am very glad that the Government are spending money on development and the more money they spend on it the happier I shall be—why not spend more on forestry. It seems to me that forestry is one of the best capital development projects that we could have. On the basis of the expenditure already undertaken in forestry work in the course of the last 30 years, scrappy and all as it was, I think forestry shows a handsome return, and will continue to show an increasing return. Of all raw materials, the price of timber has increased at a much higher ratio than the price of any other raw material. We have the land, we have the people to plant it and we have the money. Would it not be a wonderful capital investment project? I would urge on the Taoiseach to consider this seriously. I do not think it is a matter that should form part of political controversy. It is one on which there is, I think, general agreement.

I know, of course, that all kinds of excuses can be put up as to why forestry has not been pushed ahead at a better rate, but I must say that I have never yet, either from within or without a Government, heard one satisfactory explanation as to the lack of progress that has been made inforestry. The Minister for Lands is here. I may say that I am not blaming him, but by and large, I think that our Forestry Department in its early stages approached the matter in a rather scrappy way, and that, being attached to the Department of Lands, it was the Cinderella of that Department. The Department of Finance, in consequence, had very little trouble in brushing aside any claims which were made for more money for the Department of Forestry. That is why, in my opinion, the Department of Forestry should be cut away from the Department of Lands and should be set up as a Department with the Gaeltacht Services. The Forestry Department is certainly not benefiting by the present arrangement. I think that forestry and the Gaeltacht Services could form one compact Department, and in that way could deal with many problems around the western seaboard.

I do not want anything that I have said to the Taoiseach to be taken as criticism of any other scheme of national development that he has in mind, but I think that, before indulging in, possibly, more speculative schemes of national development, he should consider whether something more could not be done in regard to forestry, and also whether the pursestrings should not be loosened in regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

A matter which, I think, I mentioned before to the Taoiseach and one which is well worth examining, is the labour content of public works. What, for example, is the labour content of road making, of main, trunk and county roads? I saw some estimates that were prepared before on that question and, speaking from recollection, I think that the labour content of road making is extremely small, particularly in regard to the big main trunk roads. A very large percentage of the total outlay is spent on machinery, tar and matters of that kind. I do know that the labour content of forestry is the highest of all the different types of public works undertaken. If that is not so, the Minister for Lands will correct me. I do think, however, that I am correct in saying that 80 percent. of the total amount spent on forestry goes in wages, and that 20 per cent. goes on materials of one kind or another. If I am not mistaken, I think that 80 per cent. of a labour content is the highest labour content in any public works. Inasmuch as many of the schemes which the Government are interested in at the present time are relief schemes, I think it would be desirable to have examined the question of labour content of all such schemes.

I would like to make one final appeal to the Taoiseach in regard to the question of the bank rate. I do not know whether he saw in the newspapers, within the last few days, a most interesting letter from Dr. Batterberry, who is a member of the Dublin Corporation, in which he pointed out that a four-roomed house which, in Dublin, costs the corporation £1,660 to build, ultimately, by reason of interest rates, costs £4,648. The house costs £1,660 to build, but by the time the banks have got their whack out of it, the corporation and the unfortunate tenant or owner have to pay £4,648. Surely there is something wrong there, and surely that is one of the matters that should be examined. That is why I have felt so keenly that the Government should not have so willingly allowed the bank rate to be increased.

When the bank rate was reduced in England, the Government should have taken steps to ensure that the bank rate would be reduced here, at least to the same ratio as had prevailed before. If it becomes necessary to prevent the outflow of capital from the country, I see no reason why we should not do it by legislation of the kind that exists in every other country in the world practically. I do not think there would be any great outflow of capital from the country if the bank rate here were kept at the same level, or even slightly higher than the English bank rate. Certainly, I think the Taoiseach must admit that when you reach the position where a £1,600 house costs you £4,648 by reason of profiteering— because that is what it amount to on the part of the banks—the time has come when some drastic action must be taken.

Comment on this

In listening to the comments of the speakers on the opposite side of the House in the course of this debate, it seemed to me to be largely repetition of the debate which followed the introduction of the Budget of 1952. Fine Gael seem to be going in the direction that they have no more respect for their conservative wing; that that conservative wing is latched on to them for life and that they can say or do anything they like to get the support of what they think is the Left wing of this House. They are going to great lengths indeed to point out that this Government, which has responsibility for the housekeeping of this country, is trying to cut down on expenditure, thereby depriving people of employment. I think that all the publications from the various State Departments, from the Central Statistics Office, and the various trade journals will contradict more effectively than I can, the arguments put forward here to-day.

All these statistics show that the national income has gone up, that agricultural output has expanded and that there are more people employed to-day in industry than there have been since this State was founded. The success of the two recent National Loans denotes that the people who are inclined to invest money in this country have confidence in the Government to the extent that they were prepared to lend the Government £45,000,000 inside two years for the capital side of their programme. That is more than can be said of the people's attitude towards the Coalition Government when it was in power.

It has been said that the cost of living has increased in this country in the last two years. That is quite true. Nobody is denying that fact, but in saying that, the Opposition conveniently forget that if the cost of living has increased, wage rates have increased considerably, too. Some of them ascribe the increase in the cost of living to Government policy. They say that import prices have fallen by 9 per cent. since 1951 and that the cost of living should have fallen accordingly, and that the decrease in import prices should have reflected itself in the retail prices inside our economy.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I want to draw attention to this very important matter, the matter of privilege in this House. I would like to say that since the debate started here this evening two members of the Fianna Fáil Party have been allowed to speak, a member of the Labour Party, a member of the Fine Gael Party and a member of Clann na Poblachta. During the course of that debate I offered, and showed myself as a speaker, as I was anxious to say a word as an Independent member, and I have not been called. I wish to protest very strongly as an Independent Deputy at the lack of appreciation towards the Independent Benches.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter to which the Deputy refers is one within the discretion of the Chair and the Deputy will be called in due course. It is customary to call leaders of Parties to speak in dealing with a debate of this kind, and the Deputy will be reached in due course.

Comment on this

Without criticising Deputy Carter in any way, it is not suggested that Deputy Carter is the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Briscoe has spoken in that Party, and the Taoiseach opened the debate for the Fianna Fáil Party so that there can be no suggestion that it is leaders of Parties only who are speaking. I think if we are going to have fair play in this House, the speakers from among the Independent Deputies must be allowed to have their say.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There cannot be any discussion on this matter.

Comment on this

I want to inform the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that this matter will be raised elsewhere.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may do that.

Comment on this

I might be entitled to point out that I offered to speak as a member of the Clann na Talmhan Party and although I was not called, I have not protested.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Various Parties have been called to speak with the result that so far as the debate has gone, the Government speakers have occupied one hour and 25 minutes so that the Opposition Parties have no complaint.

Comment on this

I am not complaining on behalf of the Opposition. I am speaking as an Independent Deputy.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will resume his seat. Deputy Carter.

Comment on this

It is apparent to me that all the Parties in this House will have time to express their views on the Taoiseach's Estimate and I hope when they are expressing them that they will give a little more fair play than the people who have spoken.

I was trying to deal with some of the suggestions made regarding the cost of living and how conveniently some of the speakers ignored the fact that wages both in agriculture and in industry have risen considerably since 1951 and the fact that increased prices obtainable for agricultural produce within the economy have a more direct bearing on the cost of living than import prices. The fact that the Fianna Fáil Government guaranteed an increased price for wheat, milk and beet certainly would reflect itself in increased retail prices. The Opposition seemed to buttress their argument on the basis that if the Fianna Fáil Government guarantee a price to the farmers they can at the same time raise a subsidy by some other tax on the taxpayers in order to cheapen that price to the consumers in general. That argument is not valid. Regarding development—it is a well-known fact that since Fianna Fáil first assumed office in 1932 they have gone ahead with their programme of capital development. Immediately on resuming office in 1951 they advised the sugar company and the cement company to expand in order to provide employment and at the same time cut down on the imports of these commodities.

I think it must be agreed that the Government has implemented a veryprogressive programme in relation to Bord na Móna. That applies also to rural electrification and the E.S.B. in general. That policy does not denote any restriction in credit or any intention to cut down on employment. The fact that agricultural exports have risen and the national income has increased indicates the increased prosperity of the country despite what members of the Opposition state to the contrary. Members of the Opposition are endeavouring to suggest as usual that by some action the Government could bring down retail prices, some action other than subsidies, so to speak. At the end of last year and early this year we had brought the Opposition Parties to the point that they did not approve of subsidies and I did not hear subsidies mentioned to-day in the course of this debate.

It was alleged that the withdrawal of subsidies was one of the planks in our political platform. It is true that subsidies were partially withdrawn. We must never forget that at the moment we are paying over £5,700,000 in subsidies on bread alone. It was suggested in the debate on the Supplies and Services Bill, and again to-day, that following the withdrawal of subsidies the price of sugar went up. That is not correct. As a matter of fact, there has been no subsidy on sugar since 1949. Owing to the operation of the differential the price of sugar in 1949 averaged 6d. per lb. The two-price system was in operation and therefore the withdrawal of the subsidy did not affect the price of sugar in the slightest degree.

The fact that the Government were able to raise £45,000,000 for the capital development side of their programme denotes that work was progressing in the right direction. It also shows that there is no lack of confidence in the Government and that employment is running at a high level. There is no use in the Opposition trying to shed responsibility for unemployment, because unemployment was running at as high a level during their term of office as it is at the moment. The facts and figures are there and they cannot be controverted.

I do not think that any Deputy would advance the argument in relation to retail prices that the farmer should receive a lower price for his milk or that he should produce a cheaper barrel of wheat, barley or oats or a cheaper acre of beet. I can see no way of tackling the increase in the cost of living, then, except by breaking the price the farmer receives and doing, as Deputy Dillon has suggested on various occasions, namely, importing wheat from Canada and sugar from somewhere else. If that is done the factories and the mills will have to close down. Where is the advantage in that if the people who are at present employed in these industries find themselves out of work? In the long run, that can only have the effect of driving up the unemployment figure. It is, therefore, hardly valid to suggest that we are the wicked bogeymen that the Opposition tries to pretend we are.

I am sure all of use would like to see employment running at as high a rate as possible. We would all like to see the retailer and the farmer doing equally well, both working in unison. But that is not always possible and the action that any Government can take in relation to retail prices is a very limited action indeed. We have a free economy here and the longer it remains free the better it will be. The fact is that the people who are advocating that the Government should take over the banking system and interfere in business are the very people on whose toes we would tread if we adopted their suggestions. If they believe in private enterprise and in competition they must know that there is no element that can be introduced in any price in a system of free competition to maintain a particular price level.

The only element that can be introduced in order to reduce prices is the element of subsidy and in the long run the price under a system of subsidisation may turn out to be a dearer price than the original. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has explained that the implementation of a subsidy entails extra administration and achieves nothing in the long run. Asubsidy may be all right in time of war. A subsidy may be altogether wrong in normal peace time conditions.

It has been forgotten in the course of this debate that the money saved by the partial withdrawal of subsidies has been paid back to the people by way of increased social welfare. The extensions in social welfare involve a sum of something around £7,000,000. That is much more than the sum saved by the partial withdrawal of subsidies. Agricultural output has increased. So has the national income and the situation cannot therefore be so black as the Opposition paints it. The Government will always have certain difficulties to face and certain problems to solve. The more prosperous the man on the land becomes the greater the danger of unemployment on the land because the more mechanised agriculture becomes the less employment there will be on the land.

A farmer who is able to purchase equipment, such as a manure distributor, may be able to dispense with an employee. We have always had that problem to contend with. The Government make no bones about the fact that there is a problem. They are coming to grips with that problem. Fianna Fáil have shown that they have the happy knack of turning hard circumstances to good account. They have amply demonstrated that over the last 20 years. It is not by bewailing the cost of living, unemployment, high prices or other circumstances that the problem will be solved. We must get to grips with it. In my opinion, the Government have been effectively coming to grips with this problem by their capital Budget this year and last year and also by the introduction of the development fund. The development fund seems to be exercising the mind of the Opposition. They do not seem to like it. It is a sign of the times, a sign that following the disaster of 1951 the country is again moving in the right direction, and is now in the position that it can devote £1,500,000 for this purpose. I welcome the establishment of the development fund.

I do not regard road-making as a relief scheme. I do not regard thespecial employments schemes as relief work but as work of national importances. There is no truth in the suggestion made to-day that the £1,500,000 that the Government are devoting to the development fund is a sop thrown out on the eve of a general election.

It is a great wonder that the conservative element in Fine Gael would not question the members of their Party more closely as to their economic policy. Their spokesman in the Seanad said that there is too much credit available while the responsible leader of the Party in this House said to-day that there is restriction of credit. I cannot reconcile the two statements. Senator Professor George O'Brien must be wrong in the Seanad or Deputy J.A. Costello must be wrong in this House. I am not an economist. Neither am I, as Deputy McQuillan decribed me, a leader of a Party. I would like someone to clear away the smoke. It is very popular for a member of the Opposition to advocate the setting up of a commission to inquire into emigration, the setting up of a commission to inquire into retail prices, the establishment of a body to fix prices. That is popular from the point of view of vote-catching but it does not always work out in practice because, in practice, these things must be related to facts. An ugly fact can always slay the most beautiful hypothesis. Fine Gael have a considerable conservative following. I do not know how they will reconcile the arguments they have adduced. They will be very skilful if they can get away with it.

I welcome the speech made by the acting-Minister for Finance at the bankers' dinner. It showed the Government's realisation of the problem that exists and that they are effectively coming to grips with it. The Government have established a development fund which the Opposition dub a relief scheme. I do not accept that argument. It is not a measurable argument. The allocation of £1,000,000 for the making of main and county roads and of £500,000 for the making of accommodation and country roads is not a relief scheme.

Why not say that if we want tobring down the cost of living we should import wheat, pay less for milk, let sugar go unguaranteed and seek cheaper foodstuffs abroad? Why not come out in the open and say that, because that is what is meant when Deputies say that we can do something about the cost of living. That is what they really mean. Deputies opposite alleged that we could do something to stop money going out of the country, that we could tamper with the savings of the people. Deputy MacBride advanced that argument. In my opinion the people of this country are quite capable of looking after their own savings. They have done it in the past, in times of stress and of greater upheaval than the present. They have done it successfully. The thrifty amongst them always knew where to invest their money.

I do not think that interference by this House would solve the problem of money or credit. As far as I can see there is no restriction of credit, and there is no recession in trade, because if any Deputy in this House went down the city yesterday he would find that several departmental store managers said that it was one of the best days that they had had in years—that yesterday was more like Christmas Eve, actually, than an ordinary holiday.

Comment on this

We would want Christmas Eve every day.

Comment on this

I do not think, Deputy Hickey, you will get it the way you are talking.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Yesterday was a very special day.

Comment on this

It has been advocated in this House so often that the repetition becomes tiresome what this House could do about money. I think it can do absolutely nothing about it, only leave it to the people who are competent to deal with it.

Comment on this

God help the poor country after that!

Comment on this

Yes, it is a free economy, as I said. Every man is entitled to invest his money where he likes, notwhere Deputy Hickey wants him to put it. I asked you before, when you were advocating in this House that we should pick five men from each side of the House who would control the money of the Government of this country, for a loan of a £5 note and you were reluctant to give it to me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is the Minister you should appeal to, not Deputy Hickey.

Comment on this

Sorry, I will ask you again. You might be a better mark.

Comment on this

That is a helpful, constructive remark.

Comment on this

Well, charity begins at home. That is my argument.

Comment on this

I cannot admire your innocence, though.

Comment on this

Sorry, Deputy, but charity begins at home, and if you were advocating that money and credit should be under the control of this House I do not see why we should not have a fellowship and borrow from each other—lend and borrow from each other whenever necessary. We could only show the rest of the country by example that that was the best way to regulate and control money and credit. That is the only solution I can think of. It is a fairly practical one, but it might be too practical for the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am afraid——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy reserve it for his own statement?

Comment on this

Especially if I was not a good mark. But I think it is all too childish altogether in 1953. We have had the example of Britain, that tried to nationalise industry and tried to a certain extent to control credit, and you can see to-day that five or six years afterwards they are making frantic efforts to decontrol it and put it in the hands of private enterprise again.

Comment on this

A conservative Government is in power.

Comment on this

Yes, and if Labour were there they would ensure that they would be defeated so that they would not have the distasteful task of doing it. I say that with conviction, because Labour have a lot of pretty theories that they cannot put into practice. That is my argument. I have as much regard for Labour as any Deputy in this House, and I think any labouring man in my constituency will bear testimony to that, but I do not like false prophets or false promises.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Certainly Fine Gael is full of them, and the people who believe them are as shallow as the Fine Gael promises.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the Taoiseach is not responsible for all this.

Comment on this

No, a Cheann Comhairle, but by the conversation here to-day you would imagine he was. That is what I am trying to prove, that he is not responsible for it. I think that the prosperity of this country is bound up in the type of policy that is being pursued at present, and any departure from it, any tampering with the credit or solvency of its people will not succeed, because the people outside are watching and they are reading and also writing, and they know where to invest their money, any of them who have a surplus of money, where it will get them the best return and the greatest security.

We always had a problem—it is not to-day or yesterday we were faced with it—of a high emigration rate. That problem existed when the other Government were in power, and it is hardly fair to try to hang that around the neck of the present Government. Deputy Corish struck a realistic note when he referred to exports of agricultural produce. I am inclined to concur with him there and to say that we will have a difficulty in a year's time in exporting our agricultural produce because we shall then be on the basis of competition alone and will be in competition with very shrewd and very well-managed economies abroad. As amatter of fact, I just want to mention one thing which I have been informed has been happening since Eggsport were dissolved. They are handling the trade this Christmas, but it has been alleged to me that certain agents are buying turkeys and throwing them in a heap without hanging them, and they are being rejected abroad. That is a bad thing, and I should like that the Department, if they have any knowledge of that, would inquire into it, because it is one of the things that could damage us in the market in Britain next year.

The handling of our turkeys and the way they are presented to the consumer abroad, as well as the handling of other foodstuffs which we may be exporting, will certainly count in future, and production at home is no use if it is not handled properly and presented to the consumer in an edible fashion.

I want to say with regard to housing, the subject which has been mentioned here, that naturally enough there would be a certain falling-off in housing. I think 51 or 52 of the local authorities have finished their housing programmes in various country towns, and that would suggest, then, that the spurt that obtained a year ago or two years ago would not obtain at the present time or could not obtain, because, first and foremost, the demand would not be there, and most country towns are complete as regards housing. If they are, then the Government have other ideas in view. They are turning to the bridges and the roads. That does not denote that they are turning a blind eye to unemployment. Certainly there is no suggestion that we have restricted any of the capital projects that I mentioned. It cannot be proved for a moment either in fact or in theory. Employment in industry and agriculture are running at a high rate, and if we are able to continue to preserve that and to increase it, then it will be an encouragement to the people to invest in their own country. We are not going abroad looking for loans. We are asking the money from our own people and guaranteeing them a decent return on it. I do not see anything wrong inthat. I do not see anything wrong if a man has £100 to invest in this own country and you pay him £4 10s. as a return for that £100 and guarantee him against depreciation. I think it is better than paying £4 10s. to a foreigner.

Comment on this

That is good conservative policy.

Comment on this

Well, I think it would be much better than to go out and take it, because if you took £100 from him he certainly will bury the next. He would not give it to you. You can call it what you like. I think it is practical business.

Comment on this

Did you hear Deputy Lehane saying that we were all going too much to the Left?

Comment on this

Let us go Left or Right, I think we should be straightforward in a matter of business. I am sure that the Deputy would be the first to agree with that. I do not think he really means some of the things he says in regard to money and credit.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy Carter is a married man, but if he is I think if he tells his wife that the withdrawal of the subsidies did not make any difference in the price of sugar, she will not agree with him. I want to say, in common with other speakers on this side of the House, that I regret that the Taoiseach adopted the procedure which he followed in the introduction of the Estimate. I will concede to the Taoiseach that what he stated in regard to one matter is correct; I do not think that the procedure that existed formerly of requesting heads of Parties to submit to the Taoiseach in advance notice of the topics which they wished to discuss proved a great success, because in many instances these topics were never adhered to. Nevertheless, on this occasion it is particularly regrettable that the Taoiseach did not give some indication of future Government policy. I say it is particularly regrettable on this occasion, in view of the speech which was delivered this evening by DeputyBriscoe, who did give some indication, if it be a reliable one, of what the Government proposes to do. I think the House would expect, and were entitled to expect, from the Taoiseach some suggestions as how it is proposed to expend this national development fund.

I want to make it clear that as far as I and my Party are concerned we do not brand this type of expenditure as relief because I would be very inconsistent if I adopted any such attitude. I am sure I have bored many members of the House with my references to the Local Authorities (Works) Act. There was scarcely any occasion on which I spoke that I did not refer to that Act. I always believed, and I still believe, that it was the finest piece of native legislation we have yet had in this country, that it was an Act, if it were continued in operation as long as necessary, that would confer untold financial benefits on this country. If it is now proposed to make money available under the National Development Fund Bill to local authorities to carry on that work, I welcome that proposal because the great crying need of this country is increased production, whether it be industrial production or agricultural production.

I think it is now admitted on all sides of the House that we must base our future hopes on the development and intensification of agricultural production and there is no use in attempting to expand agricultural production until you first drain the land. Before I ever came into this House I always held, and I shall always hold, that any money spent on the drainage of the land of this country is a wise investment and will pay good dividends. Following upon that, you must fertilise the land. For years and years, even before there was ever compulsory tillage in this country, the land was not in a condition to produce the maximum amount it was capable of producing. I do submit that with a proper drainage system and the maximum application of fertilisers—and I do not think I am exaggerating—you could expand production by almost 50 per cent. In another place and onanother occasion, in this connection I said 35 per cent. but I believe I was being conservative in that estimate because we all see pockets throughout the country where the people have reclaimed land by drainage, and where, by the application of fertilisers, in cases where they could afford it, production has been considerably increased, in many cases by 50 per cent. If I could believe that the Government would devote some of this money under the National Development Fund Bill to providing cheaper fertilisers for the farmers and a good system of drainage, I would feel sure that the Government was then on the road towards expanding agricultural production.

I am convinced that a necessary corollary to agricultural expansion will be industrial expansion. I do believe that if you have an impoverished agriculture, you have no business talking of industrial development. I often think that it was a pity that between the years 1932 and 1947 the Fianna Fáil Organisation or Party had not a man to take charge of the Department of Agriculture with the push, energy and initiative of the man who commanded the Department of Industry and Commerce. If they had, I believe that he would have made a good job of this country. It was regrettable, I think, that they never succeeded in putting in charge of the most important portfolio in the country a man who would put—I am not saying this to the disparagement or disrespect in any degree of the men who held that office—the push and the energy into the Department of Agriculture which the man in charge of Industry and Commerce brought to bear on the administration of his Department. I was often under the impression that Fianna Fáil disregarded agriculture as an important branch of our economic life. I hope now that they have altered that frame of mind, if they ever possessed it, and that we shall see in the new year a change in regard to the most important factor in our whole economic life.

There is one other aspect of increased agricultural production to which I should like to refer. I amglad that the Minister for Lands is listening, because I believe he and his Department can play a very important part in it. I refer to the speeding up of the division of land in this country. When is this work going to be completed? We have been dallying with it for 30 years, and I doubt if we are now much nearer to a solution. I know that the Minister can quote statistics or figures to show the amount of land that is being divided, but the way in which the Land Commission acted in this matter is deplorable. Every year we are losing the best young farmers that any country could possess, simply because the Land Commission will not give them land. I know it is possible that I shall be told that this Government, when in office before, had a policy of providing land for landless men, and I am quite prepared to admit that this policy, in the manner in which it was operated, was not a success. I have said here before, and I say now, that the best type amongst those who emigrate from this country is the farmer's son, who has spent all his life on the land but who, because his brother must inherit the place and he has not got a holding for himself, must go across the sea.

If the Land Commission would provide that man with a holding of land he would be a national asset; he would marry and found a family and our economy would improve. These are the type of emigrants whom I reget to see leaving this country and whom the Minister for Lands would keep at home if he would move the Land Commission into action and ask them to do something with regard to the settlement of that long-standing problem. I must confess that I do not understand the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Lands (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

Are we discussing the Land Commission?

Comment on this

It is a form of Government policy and it comes under the Taoiseach's Estimate. I do not want to discuss it in detail.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Not exactly. It is an element in the economy of the country.

Comment on this

In my opinion, it is a very important one. I do not want to go into detail, but I think the Minister for Lands should examine what they are doing and try to make them do something more, because I have come across recent examples where they moved to acquire land and, even though the price had been fixed by the tribunal, they decided that they would withdraw the proceedings and abandon the whole thing.

Forestry also has been referred to, and that is certainly one way in which we can solve some of our unemployment problem. But I do not think that any Government in this country is going to give serious thought to forestry, because, unfortunately, Governments are composed of politicians, and forestry is a long-term project and, therefore, would not serve the ends of politicians. In remote western districts it certainly would help to provide very much-needed employment and it would, of course, after the lapse of 25 or 30 years, prove a great financial benefit to the country.

There has been a lot of talk about credit and credit restriction, but I do not propose to deal very much with it. I would say, however, that there are occasions when it would be prudent to restrict credit, and there are occasions in which it would be prudent to extend credit, all depending entirely on the nature of the investment. For instance, I do not think it would be a good thing to extend credit to a man who would fritter it away on the racecourse or the dog track. I think you would be acting in his own interests if you refused him credit. I do not think it is a good thing that banks, as they appear ready to do, should extend credit for the erection of dance halls, which is about the easiest form of getting credit to-day, while on the other hand they refuse credit to a man to buy a farm or to erect a house. I say you must have restriction of credit where a citizen does not deserve it or where he is embarking on a project that is not a deserving one or nationally sound. But where he is embarking on a programme which will be of benefit to the nation and would help the nation socially, he is entitled to credit. I do not think youshould make the sweeping statement that we should restrict credit or we should not restrict credit. You must examine what the credit is required for.

I want to say in fairness to the Government and to the Central Bank that there is one particular aspect of our economy in regard to which credit should be restricted and that is the hire-purchase system. It could land this country into a very dangerous position. I think that the Central Bank was perfectly sound and sane in suggesting that we should have less hire-purchase credit. It is a thing which could land the country into a very serious position. On the other hand, I think the restriction of credit so far as it applied to housing was undesirable, although I would be prepared to say that it was a matter on which a serious business eye should be kept because it might easily go too far. To begin with, it was providing a very necessary social amenity and useful employment and, until it had got to a far more advanced stage than it did, it was undesirable to restrict credit in the building trade. I offer these few remarks in good faith and not in a spirit of criticism. I think it would have helped the debate very much if the Taoiseach had indicated in advance in what way it was proposed to expend the money from the National Development Fund.

I want to follow the example which has been given by other members on this side of the House in the remarks they made in connection with the imprisonment of Mr. Liam Kelly. It is a matter on which I do not feel very competent to speak, but I do think it would be very desirable that a unanimous protest—not a protest coming from any one particular individual or any one political Party—from this House should be sent both to the British Premier and to the people in Belfast. I think it is right to say that there is a new departure in the Six Counties to which we should wish success. There is no man who does not wish to see the country reunited. I agree, and I think it would be the view of the Taoiseach, that we do not hope to achieve much by such a protest, butI think it would encourage Mr. Kelly and those people associated with him to know that we in the National Assembly of the Twenty-Six Counties share their views and aspirations and are behind them morally, if not physically.

Comment on this

Judging by the tone of the official Opposition speeches, after the wails and the moans that we heard about six months ago, there seems to be an enormous change. I should like to deal with one matter before Deputy Finan leaves the House. He accused the Fianna Fáil Executive Council of disregarding agriculture. He gave us an instance that they had not put into the Department of Agriculture as good a man as was put into the Department of Industry and Commerce and stated that, on account of that, agriculture had lagged behind in this country. Deputy Finan was, I think, a supporter of the inter-Party Government. If he was not here at that time, he came into this House as a supporter of the policy of that Party. Therefore I say he was one of those who was responsible for inflicting the previous Minister for Agriculture on the people of this country.

Comment on this

I would not make any apology for that.

Comment on this

Probably you would not. Deputy Finan comes in here representing small tillage farmers and working farmers mainly. A man representing that class of people comes in here and takes a part in putting into office and in charge of agriculture the man who said the proper thing for the beet industry was to blow up the factories, that wheat was going up the spout after the peat and beet, and God speed the day. Deputy Finan takes part in putting that individual in charge of agriculture for three and a half years.

Comment on this

He made a better job of it than ever you did.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will wait, I will give him the results and there is no difficulty in finding them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how it arises on this Vote. This is an over-all policy of the Government.

Comment on this

It is my intention to make a comparison between that policy and the policy of the Government's predecessors.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should distinguish between departmental policy and the over-all policy of the Government.

Comment on this

I intend to deal with the over-all policy as it was—I take it there was collective responsibility— that drove 52,000 young men in three and a half years off the land. It was the policy that offered the agricultural community, at a time of rising prices, rising costs of labour and other things, 1/- a gallon for their milk.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is departmental policy. The Deputy must understand that 1/- a gallon for milk is departmental policy.

Comment on this

That was departmental policy and executive policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is departmental policy. That was the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, not the over-all policy of the Government or the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

So the rest of the boys want to wash their hands like Pontius Pilate, and say: "I am not responsible for Jamesie."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not make a joke of it or misconstrue what I am saying.

Comment on this

Let us examine the agricultural position to-day and compare it with that period. Let us take any item and see where it brings us. Let us take agricultural exports. I remember the wails and moans we used to hear over there, but they disappeared very largely during the last four or five months. Our total live-stock exports amounted to £19,930,000 for the first nine months of 1951. I compare that with the first nine months of this year, in which our live-stock exports brought us in £25,000,000—an increase of £6,000,000 on live-stock exports alone. Foodstuffs of animal origin, class II, brought us in in 1951 £21,125,000 and this year £43,530,000. Our total exports in those two classes for the first nine months of 1951 were £41,055,000 as against £68,602,000 for the first nine months of this year, an increase of £27,500,000 in the value of our agricultural exports in those two items alone. Then we are told that Fianna Fáil were lacking in the Minister they put in charge of agriculture. I think that is an answer in itself.

If you go further into these figures, you will find one rather extraordinary increase, that is in regard to chocolate crumb, chocolates and sweets. The total value of our exports in that item in 1951 was less than £3,000,000. For the first nine months of this year it was £14,000,000. Those are figures which show the way the country is going. I heard statements from all sides of the House that those in agriculture were not pulling their weight in the increased production drive. The total value of our domestic exports for the first nine months of 1953 was £82,048,000 as compared with £51,443,000 in the first nine months of 1951, an increase of £30,500,000. Of that £30,500,000 the agricultural community have contributed £27,500,000. Those are facts that cannot be denied and that any Deputy can get for himself by spending half an hour in the Library. Those facts speak for themselves.

The last year you had an inter-Party Government here there was a reduction of 84,000 acres in wheat. That was £2,000,000 gone out of the farmer's pocket. This year there is an increase of 98,000 as compared with last year. That is £3,000,000 less to be paid to the foreigner for bread to feed our people that are left here at home. That is the difference between the policy of our Minister for Agriculture and the other one that was inflicted on us here for three and a half years. There is an increase this year of 11,000 acres of beet, which means £2,000,000 to the farmer alone. It is 112,000 tons of freight extra to be carried by thelorryman and C.I.E., at an average of £1 a ton, making £112,000 more for freight. What is the extra amount it will give in labour, in the factories, to the workers? Those are the things that count. I have heard from all sides of the House that if the agricultural population are all right, everybody is all right. That is the picture of the agricultural population to-day. Compare that with the "back to grass" policy that was pursued here for three and a half years with the full connivance and assistance of the Clann na Talmhan Party and the Labour Party.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

And Deputy Moylan.

Comment on this

I am quoting Deputy Corish.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

What did Deputy Moylan say last week about it?

Comment on this

He was not a member of the Government.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He said it was good policy.

Comment on this

I am giving the policy as it is now and the result of it. I am not twisting what anybody said. I know he added that in——

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It was reported in the newspaper.

Comment on this

I have given the House the facts and Deputies would be wise to study them. Nobody will pretend to me that an increase in tillage of 100,000 acres of land under the plough will not mean increased employment all round. By our increased production of sugar, we have saved the £3,000,000 odd, which Deputy James Dillon paid to foreigners for sugar in his last year of office. We have done more than that. Practically all of the sugar we produce to-day in excess of our home requirements is exported in the shape of chocolate crumb, chocolates and sweets and its value for the first nine months of this year is £14,000,000. That is a different picture from the picture that Deputies hoped to be able to draw here some four months ago. It is a different aspect to agriculture. At the moment, we are not able to give the results of the last portion of thispolicy. It is only now that the extra 11,000 acres of beet are going into the factories. Next year, we will have the result of that. During the next 12 months we will know the saving effected by 98,000 extra acres of wheat that have been grown as a result of getting rid of the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, who hoped that wheat had gone up the spout. We will have the results within the next 12 months. Judging by the aspect of affairs now, and judging by the amount of seed wheat that is being purchased now, we shall have a further large increase in the acreage of wheat. You have the same satisfactory trend in other directions also. Our imports of maize have gone down by 50 per cent. Why? Because the farmers here are growing the feeding barley that is taking the place of the maize. The number of pigs in this country now, as compared with 1951, has increased by 160,000. These are the figures by which you can judge the trend of events. No less than 52,000 cows disappeared between the time Deputy Dillon offered us the 1/- a gallon for milk and the time we got rid of the Coalition Government. Those 52,000 cows have now come back and this year you have 75,000 more cattle in the country than you had on the day Deputy Dillon left office. Surely these figures speak for themselves—and they are the things that count as far as the agricultural community is concerned.

I share Deputy Finan's view in regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act, and I do so as one who has had definite experience of it. I supported it in this House when it was introduced. As I said here recently, the Fianna Fáil Party were not responsible for the reduced amounts under that Act. The lead was set by Deputy McGilligan, when he was Minister for Finance, and it was accepted by Deputy Keyes and Deputy Corish, two Deputies who held office in the Coalition Government. These two Deputies accepted a reduction of more than £500,000 under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. I believe that a lot of good can be done under that Act.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I always believed it. I might say that I took damned good care to ensure that my constituency got more than its share under that Act, when it was going—and I make no apologies for it. I believe a lot of good can be done under that Act. A lot of employment can be given and a lot of land that is at present waterlogged can be put into good condition.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Good man! Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I am only stating now what I stated in this House on the Second Reading of that Bill. I am making the same statement to-day as I did then.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

That is right. I agree with you entirely. However, I should like to hear some member of the Front Bench state that view.

Comment on this

I do not agree with you in that, either. Fianna Fáil found that the Coalition Government were so anxious to gallop things through this House that it was necessary to give very careful consideration to the proper drafting of the Bill. As a matter of fact we have found ourselves up against a few snags since. I also share the view that that money should not be entirely by way of grant. If money is being given for that purpose, I believe that steps should be taken either to lay aside portion of it for keeping the rivers clean afterwards or to see that it will be provided by the local authority.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The provisions are statutory.

Comment on this

In connection with this Vote, I am anxious to know how much of the development fund will be devoted to actual industry. The fault that I found with the previous Government was that they borrowed but that their borrowing left no permanent benefit in the way of employment. If I see money being borrowed on any capital issue, I want to see that money put into industry which will give permanent employment. At the beginning of this session I had reason to raise again a matter in this House which I have been raising here for the pastcouple of years, namely, the position as regards the extension of Irish Steel, Limited, in Haulbowline. At present, a number of skilled workers there are unemployed. I want to see employment found for these men. As I have frequently remarked in this House, I cannot see any better way in which money which is supposed to give employment can be used than by putting it into the extension of an industry that will, of itself, give permanent employment afterwards to a large number of men. I move to report progress.

Comment on this