We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Development Fund Bill, 1953—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–218 of 609. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill National Development Fund Bill, 1953
Enacted

No. 32 of 1953 ›

Frank Aiken Acting-Minister for Finance (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. The understanding is, I believe, that when we complete the Second Reading of this Bill the Estimate which is associated with it will be put automatically to the Dáil. This capital Development Fund Bill, as Deputies will see, proposes that the Dáil should give the Government power in any year to spend up to £5,000,000 for capital development which is in the national interest. The £5,000,000 which we are asking the Dáil for this year is in addition to the £40,000,000 or so of works of capital development which the Minister for Finance announced at the time of the Budget. In order that we can see the total picture, we have to put that £45,000,000, which is proposed should be available for capital development this year, in comparison with what was done in previous years. In 1950-51 the total sum spent on capital development works by this State was £24.61 million and in 1951-52, £32.73 million.

Comment on this

Or £35,000,000, which?

Comment on this

My figure is £32.73 million and I think that the Deputy will find that that is the correct figure.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will find that the other figure is £35,000,000.

Comment on this

That may have been what was estimated but I am talking about what was spent.

Comment on this

I am talking about the actual spending.

Comment on this

We will see about it. That is the figure I have got for 1951-52. The actual expenditure for housing, sanitary services, agricultural development, electricity development, touristdevelopment, telephone development, schools, et cetera, et cetera, was £32.73 million. The estimate for this year at the time of the Budget was £39.29 million, and if we add the £5,000,000 we are asking for now, if it can be spent in this year and there is a necessity to spend it, the total sum asked for by the Government in this financial year would amount to £44.29 million.

Comment on this

Did not the Minister once say that that £44.29 million would be reduced to £36.30 million?

Comment on this

The Deputy, I think, is talking about the sum of money that would be required to borrow for the objects of expenditure set out by the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement, as reported in column 1194 of the Official Report. He gave an estimate of the capital required for each item in the financial year and the total came to £39.29 million. The question, of course, which any citizen must put to himself, if he takes an interest in public affairs, is whether it is right that in this financial year the Government should ask the Dáil for power to spend an extra £5,000,000 on works of capital development.

Comment on this

Without knowing what they are?

Comment on this

Without knowing what they are. Is it right that the Government should ask the Dáil to entrust them with the power to spend £5,000,000 within the financial year without the items upon which it will be spent being put before the Dáil and passed in the normal way by means of Estimates? The question is whether it is right that an extra £5,000,000 should, in fact, be spent at all, no matter from where the Government get it, even if the Government got it as a gift. In order to satisfy reasonable persons with regard to that, I would refer them to the balance of payments. The balance of payments is the indicator, the best barometer that a Government has, with present statistical knowledge at any rate, as to whether there should be further expansionist activity or not.

When the balance of payments isgood and unemployment is not so good, that indicates that there should be an expansionist policy to make use of the energies of the unemployed and to develop the country further. It indicates that every opportunity should be taken to use the energies of people who are idle to the greatest extent possible and in the best available directions. When, of course, the balance of payments is dangerously adverse it indicates the necessity for internal adjustment rather than a total expansion.

It is the national duty of the Government to balance the total national economy. We have no right to spend for our own immediate comfort, or for the avoidance of political discomfort, the accumulated past savings of our people. We have a right and a duty, if we can, to translate those savings which are held in an external form into savings of an internal form if the opportunity should arise, but we have no right to spend them for current consumption and the Government certainly would be very neglectful of their duty in the last few years if they had allowed a continuance of the expenditure of £62,000,000 a year of the external savings of our people without making sure that there was an equivalent saving and addition to capital at home.

At the present time the indications are that we can add to capital expenditure in this year, over and above what the Government contemplated at the beginning of the year, without doing damage to our balance of payments and for the benefit of our people. The reason I say that is that last year the adverse balance of payments amounted to about £9,000,000, and this year coming now as we are to the end of the year, it is estimated that it will be somewhat below that figure. Now, even with modern statistics, we cannot have accurate forecasts of Government expenditure and of economic trends too far ahead, particularly in turbulent days such as those in which we live. Under the present system of preparing Estimates for the Dáil, Ministers and Departments may be trying to forecastwhat is going to happen at the end of 15 months or more. The Estimates are usually prepared in the Departments during November-December. The Estimates deal with what is thought likely to happen and with the funds that are likely to be required in the period from the following April to the end of 12 months later. It is very difficult to forecast accurately, and, therefore, we are asking the Dáil to give the Government the right to spend and to meet the needs of the next four years provided an Estimate is passed in the Dáil for the required amount—the right to spend up to £5,000,000 without having to justify in advance the purposes for which the money is going to be spent.

The Dáil might very well refuse. In normal times, the Dáil might very well say: "It is up to the Government to do its job and to prepare the Estimates well ahead, bring them before the Dáil and get them passed, and if they make a mistake in under-estimating in any way, they should, during the course of the year, introduce a Supplementary Estimate and pass it through in the normal way." Well, I am putting it to the Dáil that in times like these the Government should have a little bit of elbow room, that we should have a little bit more elasticity than would tie the Government down to the full 100 per cent. of all State funds expendable, and to the getting of approval in advance from the Dáil. What I am asking the Dáil to do to-day is to give to the Government a little bit of elasticity to the extent of 3½ per cent., or thereabouts, of the total State expenditure. After all, we did put through the Dáil Estimates for £100,000,000 odd.

Comment on this

On which you are pledged to economise to the extent of £3,500,000.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Now, you are coming in to ask for £5,000,000 to skite around with although you promised to save £3,500,000.

Comment on this

That is just because we do not believe that we are completely and absolutely accurate prophets.

Comment on this

You are telling me.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is a man who knows not only what has happened in the past in every country on every particular day, but he is quite prepared to foretell what is going to happen in every country every year for the next 1,000 years. We cannot do that, and on that basis we are asking the Dáil, in this particular year, to give us a 3½ per cent. liberty to overspend on particular items. The Dáil can refuse that. They can say that the Government should know in advance every particular item, and should get prior sanction for it. We can have no quarrel if the Dáil says that, but I am putting it to the Dáil that in times like these when the normal person at any rate cannot forecast very far ahead—if Deputy Dillon does not behave himself I shall ask the Ceann Comhairle to ask him to do so. This is an important matter.

Comment on this

Temper.

Comment on this

There is no temper at all but a slight indignation.

Comment on this

Calm down. It is too early in the morning.

Comment on this

I am quite calm.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should send out for some iced water.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister should be allowed to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt.

Comment on this

You have been erupting there. If the Deputy wants to do that he should go out and give the people who want to discuss this in a reasonable way a chance.

Comment on this

Keep me out of it.

Comment on this

I did not accuse you of doing it. It was Deputy Dillon who was erupting.

Comment on this

Someone got out of bed at the wrong side this morning.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! EveryDeputy will have an opportunity of making his own statement.

Comment on this

I would say that ordinary mortals like the members of this Government cannot accurately forecast in these turbulent times the result of all the activites of the 3,000,000 people we have here to the extent of 3½ per cent. We are asking the Dáil for liberty to spend £5,000,000, which is 3½ per cent. of Government expenditure this year, if the circumstances from month to month and from week to week should warrant drawing on this money for capital expenditure, and when the balance of payments is reasonably right, when the unemployment situation is wrong and when there is an opportunity to utilise the energies of the unemployed to increase the national wealth.

Now, our export trade has increased enormously in the last couple of years. In fact, the volume of domestic exports in the January-October period of this year was 48 per cent. greater than in the corresponding period of 1951.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is an indication that if imports are kept reasonably below the point at which they will absorb total exports, based on the current year, we can accomplish national expansion without doing national damage. The one good point about our exports is that they are more largely based on real national production than heretofore. We do not spend so many dollars on maize in order to produce pigs and beef for sale in the British market. There is better production at home. Our farmers are beginning to see the value of lime and artificial fertilisers as well as good farmyard manure for the production of crops and that has had the effect of increasing our ability to export. As I say, in the last nine months ending October our exports were 48 per cent. greater than in the corresponding period of 1952.

Comment on this

1951.

Comment on this

Well, you are now after giving the wrong date.

Comment on this

I sometimes make a slip of the tongue. We are not all as perfect as the Deputy.

Comment on this

God help you.

Comment on this

When a man has repeated a figure three or four times and makes a slip of the tongue, the normal intelligent person does not pass remarks. He does not want to show that he is so clever that he could pick up a small point. He rather concentrates on large points.

Comment on this

I am now waiting for a large point to be made. I have been waiting since 10.30 this morning but one has not turned up yet.

Comment on this

Would it not be refreshing if we had something about the Bill now?

Comment on this

This particular measure is in keeping with what the Government did at the end of the war when the Transition Development Fund was introduced. The Transition Development Fund at that time was for £5,000,000 in a single sum.

Comment on this

Was it not £7,000,000?

Comment on this

No. £5,000,000.

Comment on this

It was £7,000,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies can make these points afterwards if they wish.

Comment on this

It is not from the point of view of correcting Deputy Dillon, it is merely from the point of view of getting the matter accurately stated in the Dáil that I am stating deliberately that the figure was £5,000,000. I think that if Deputy Dillon and Deputy Mulcahy check up they will find that I am right. The fund was for a single sum of £5,000,000. I was then Minister for Finance, and the fund was brought forward in order to give the Minister for Finance a little freedom in supporting capital development of variouskinds. That was a time when things were changing rapidly and one could not foretell exactly what was going to happen a few years ahead. I asked the Dáil to give me £5,000,000 so that I could promise a Department that if it went ahead and kept reasonably within the bounds of prudent expenditure I could support them out of this fund.

Take housing, for instance. In 1946 it was difficult to know whether prices were going to rise very rapidly or, perhaps, fall. People were rather inclined to the view at that time that prices would not rise very much after 1946. We felt that rather than make a permanent readjustment upwards in the level of housing subsidies we would say to the local authorities through the Minister for Local Government: "Go ahead; build your houses and we will give you what is reasonable out of the Transition Development Fund." That had the effect of enabling some local authorities to proceed with house-building much more quickly than if they had to wait until the Government made up its mind on what was likely to be the level of housing costs a year or two ahead. The fund did good work also in getting organisations like the E.S.B. moving on development work. No one could say what wire and electrical equipment was going to cost in 1947, looking forward from 1946, but we could say to the E.S.B.: "Go ahead with your plans for rural electrification and if there is a deficit we will pay it out of the Transition Development Fund." That was a system adopted at that time and it had the effect of getting development going very much more quickly after the war than that development would have proceeded if the Government had to wait in relation to that sum of £5,000,000 to expend it until detailed Estimates were passed by the Dáil.

I do not want to leave anybody in this House or in the country under the impression that I think that capital expenditure by the State is anything but a very slow and cumbersome substitute for capital expenditure by private individuals. If you can get a few thousand or more private individualstogether to take advantage of the present situation to build industries, and if we can get a few hundred thousand of our farmers to take advantage of the present situation to improve their lands, a lot more good would be done in a permanent way for the national capital wealth than if the Government spends in this year £39,000,000 or £45,000,000 or whatever number of millions it spends.

There is at the present time a magnificent opportunity for both farmers and industrialists to develop their business. We are not short of funds. A great number of individuals in the country are not short of funds. The State has provided many ways to help out those who have some funds of their own, but whose ideas for development reach beyond their own private means. We have ways and means of coming to their assistance in the form of loans and grants. I want to say I think that there may not be better times in the future for people to invest their capital than at this present moment. Our farmers are reputed to have £70,000,000 or more in the banks. I think the best bank that a farmer could put his money into is his own land. No matter what price levels may be, whether they go up or down, the farmer whose land is well cared for, well-limed and well-fertilised will be in a better position to make money than the farmer who neglects his land. I would emphasise this this Development Fund is no substitute for the efforts that private individuals should themselves make to develop their own capital resources by using their liquid capital to improve their fixed capital in land and buildings and machinery.

Consider for a moment the demonstration that is being given to farmers all over the country by the Department of Agriculture and its experts of the profitable use of some of their savings in putting lime on the land. In 1946, the then Minister for Agriculture was fortunate in getting an extensive piece of what was perhaps the most neglected land in this country. There was a magnificent building on it but the owners had not been living there for a number of years and it had almost reverted to something below its natural state. Itproved to be a magnificent place in which to carry out experiments as to the profitability of the use of various manures and fertilisers and the amount which it was profitable to apply in particular cases. By the mere expenditure of £2 on 55 cwt. of ground limestone per acre, the experts in Johnstown found that in the following six years the six crops yielded £100 extra from one acre. Therefore, by an expenditure of £2 many farmers could put themselves into the position of earning an extra £100 over a period of six years. That is a fact that cannot be denied. Possibly in some cases the original expenditure might be more than £2; in some cases it might be less but an average expenditure of £2 would yield that result in relation to the vast majority of our farmers.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if it is the intention to use this fund for the distribution of ground limestone?

Comment on this

That is one of the purposes for which this fund is being opened. Again I want to emphasise that this fund is not offered as a substitute for what the farmers, the industrialists and the people with money should do themselves in order to increase the national wealth. It is both unreasonable and unwise for farmers to keep £2 in the bank from which they will get over a period of six years, perhaps, a few shillings when, by investing that £2 in lime and putting that lime on their land, they could get not a few shillings extra in six years but £100.

Comment on this

That is an exaggerated statement. There is no sense in that statement.

Comment on this

I will refer the Deputy to an advertisement which was issued.

Comment on this

Have sense, man.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister should be allowed to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is almost airborne, and everyone knows that.

Comment on this

Can you imagine anybody saying that if you spend £2 on lime you will gain £100?

Comment on this

It is our misfortune that the man who was in charge of agriculture here for three years does not know that by the expenditure of a couple of pounds on lime one can, in fact, get an extra £100 in six years. It is a damned disgrace on the part of the people who put him in charge of the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

Is the Minister getting that out of his own land?

Comment on this

Of course, and more.

Comment on this

Do not be talking through your hat.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon denies that by the expenditure of £2 on ground limestone a man can get an extra £100 from six crops in six years. I will read for him now what the experts of the Department of Agriculture who were put in charge of this work in 1946, and who continued it in spite of the Deputy's antipathy to ground limestone, have to say. I will put this on the records to show exactly the results that have been obtained. In 1946, they applied 55 cwt. of ground limestone per statute acre to land in Johnstown. It cost them £2. No more care was taken, no more fertilisers applied, no better seed applied to the acre that got the limestone as compared with the acre that was not limed and, everything else being equal, the following results were achieved. In 1947, the limed land produced 16½ cwts. of malting barley. From the unlimed they got 7 cwts. There was, therefore, an increase of 9½ cwts. In 1948, the land was under sugar beet and mangolds. From the limed portion they got 16½ tons of sugar beet per statute acre and 11½ tons from the unlimed. They got an extra 5 tons of sugar beet per acre from the limed land as against the unlimed. In one year they have an extra £25 for an expenditure of an extra couple of shillings. In the case of mangolds, from the limed land they got 36½ tons and from the unlimed, 20½ tons, or a surplus of 16 tons ofmangolds. Put the price at no more than £3 per ton and there is nearly £50 extra in that particular year for an expenditure of not more than a few shillings. In 1949, in spring wheat they got 39 cwts. from the limed land and only 20 cwts. from the unlimed land. They got 19 cwts. extra, probably £30 worth of wheat extra, for the expenditure of an extra few shillings on ground lime.

In 1950, limed land produced 12½ tons of grass for silage. Unlimed land produced 10 tons. There was an extra 2½ tons in the case of limed land over unlimed land. In 1951, the limed land produced 21½ tons as against 16 tons for unlimed land, an excess of 5½ tons of grass for silage from the limed land as against the unlimed land.

In 1952, limed land produced 18½ tons per acre of grass for silage and unlimed land 16 tons, an excess of 2½ tons from the limed over the unlimed land.

In these six crop years, taking typical crops produced over a large part of the country, for the expenditure of £2, the farmers got an extra £100 worth of produce per acre. I say to the farmer who has money in the bank or who can beg or borrow money to correct the calcium status of his land, that he is a fool if he does not do it. If he keeps his £2 in the bank, he will get only a few pence interest on it. By putting it into his land he can get an average of almost £20 a year interest.

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate how the money under this fund will be used to increase the use of lime?

Comment on this

I will come to that point. First I want to contest what Deputy Dillon said here and I want to give the farmers the fact that, without touching this fund or any other Government fund, if they have a couple of pounds themselves and if their land is acid and if they restore the calcium status of the soil, without doing anything more, they can improve its capacity to produce wealth for themselves, for their children and for the country.

I have taken up sufficient time of the Dáil in explaining what the Government has in mind in introducing this particular capital Development Fund. I trust that the Dáil will give the Government power to spend in this year by means of the Estimate a sum up to £5,000,000 if, in their opinion, the objects of this expenditure will tend to boost development and to provide additional employment.

It is urgent that the Government's hands should not be tied in this regard in times that change so rapidly as the present. People are uneasy in many countries as to what will happen in a few years' time. Only a very great prophet could predict with any great conviction what will happen but, no matter whether the waters that lie ahead of us be smooth or rough, we will be better able to do our work in the Government and to get better results for the people if the Dáil gives us this little bit of elbow room to deal with the situation, gives us the power to spend up to £5,000,000, which, as I have pointed out, is about 3½ per cent. of the total sum for which the Government asked the Dáil in the Budget for both current and capital expenditure.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how exactly this fund will be used to encourage the greater use of limestone?

Comment on this

It can be used in a variety of ways, as I pointed out.

Comment on this

For brazen-faced, cast-iron effrontery and audacity, commend me to this Government. The Minister for Finance, introducing the Budget here not 12 months ago, nailed his reputation to the mast on the proposition that he balanced the Budget by economising to the tune of £3,500,000 on the published Estimates and the Taoiseach came in draped in sanctity to show how everyone was going to sweat for this end. The same Government comes in and announces that they want elbow room, if you please, not to the tune of the £3,500,000 that they pledged their honour to the people they were going to save out of the published Estimates, but to the tune of £5,000,000, £1,500,000 more than thesum they solemnly undertook, when they introduced the Budget, to save.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not understand the difference between capital and current expenditure. It was current expenditure.

Comment on this

We know the difference between elbow room and palm grease.

Comment on this

Wait a minute until we expose this ramp for what it is. This is a Bill to put white whiskers and a red gown on Eamon de Valera, the Taoiseach, to provide him with a sleigh and reindeer to function as Father Christmas in Louth and Cork City. The late Governor Al Smith, of New York, was once asked what their prospects were in an election and his reply was: "Who votes against Father Christmas?"

The purpose of this Bill is plain and simple. People have been saying that the Taoiseach is contemplating retirement and that he is graduating into the ranks of our elder statesmen but he is going to turn out at the next campaign with a large white whisker, a long red gown, seated on a sleigh led by six reindeer, and doubtless the acting-Minister for Finance will be sitting beside him not to recall the Taoiseach's advice in Arva, when he announced that the British market was gone for ever and that the farmers should turn over to keeping bees, and if they took his advice it would be Egyptian bees, but he will be turning out as the demonstration farm for the raising of reindeer in Ireland to supply all the Father Christmases all over the country. Whiskers, gown and reindeer for sleighs and bells complete.

Comment on this

And the Deputy to supply the pantomime.

Comment on this

Now listen. I was portrayed recently on the cover of Dublin Opinioncutting the plum pudding down on top of the Taoiseach's head, and, mind you, coming events cast their shadows before. There he was portrayed as Father Christmas on the reindeer sleigh with the three bluebells sitting on the tailboard as he drove them away in triumph. Do youremember that? Here is a Bill to implement the cover ofDublin Opinion.Never was a truer word spoken than what the Taoiseach has now said. Is it not a shameful, degrading business when we come to examine what lies behind this—really the impudence of Deputy Aiken, the acting-Minister for Finance, in talking about ground limestone in this context. In February, 1948, there was not to be had in the 26 counties of Ireland enough ground limestone to fill one eggcup.

Comment on this
Thomas Walsh Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Walsh) Fianna Fáil

It was there and you tried to stop it.

Comment on this

There was not a single plant grinding limestone in the 26 counties of Ireland.

Comment on this

That is not true, of course.

Comment on this

Oh, it is true. There was one plant grinding limestone flour somewhere in Kilkenny the price of which was approximately twice that of ground limestone as we know it.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Not twice.

Comment on this

Very near it, but in any case it was a great deal more expensive and there was not a single ounce of ground limestone to be had in the whole of Ireland.

Comment on this

Of course that is not true.

Comment on this

When we went out of office unlimited supplies of ground limestone were available for delivery to the gate of every farmer in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

No.

Comment on this

At 15/- per ton. By heavens, Deputy Aiken, acting-Minister for Finance, is making the case in this House this morning that Fine Gael is opposed to ground limestone and that Fianna Fáil desires to promote its use.

Comment on this

You were kicked into doing it by the Americans. Did you not say that it made you mad? Did you not reduce the subsidy, cut down the subsidy on both ground and burned lime?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is entitled to be heard without interruption.

Comment on this

Res ipsa loquitor. In February, 1948, there was not enough ground limestone available in this country as would fill one eggcup.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has said that already.

Comment on this

It is a complete exaggeration.

Comment on this

In June, 1951, ground limestone was being delivered at every farmer's gate at 15/- or 16/-.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

75,000 tons——

Comment on this

And there are now nearly 1,000,000 tons a year. You stopped the subsidy on burned lime and also on ground lime and did your damnedest to refuse American money for it.

Comment on this

There was never a subsidy on ground lime.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

There was.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Never a ground limestone subsidy.

Comment on this

There was.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Every Deputy is entitled here to be heard without interruption. Deputy Dillon is entitled to be heard without interruption. The Chair will have to see that every Deputy is heard without interruption. Otherwise we will never get this concluded.

Comment on this

Is there anything in this Bill about ground limestone?

Comment on this

This Bill can be used for slush, and the primary purpose of this Bill is to provide the present Fianna Fáil Government with a slush fund with which to buy votes that they cannot get any other way. That is the plain unvarnished fact. The Government of this country has power and authority to borrow any money that is required on the credit of this State for any approved projects, capital or current. Is not that so? They claim that in this year under their general powersthey propose to borrow £43,000,000 for capital projects. Now the plain fact is that keeping the whole machinery of the State geared to its maximum output—and I am talking of the Administration—to expend £43,000,000 would be a task beyond the limit of the Government's capacity to do. The only distinction between the proposal in regard to this £5,000,000 and the general programme of capital expenditure estimated to be £43,000,000 is that in regard to the £43,000,000 Oireachtas Éireann has to be told what the money is going to be spent on. They cannot tell us what this £5,000,000 is to be spent on, because they want it to buy votes, plain, open and unadorned. Now listen. If they had a purpose, if they knew a service that wanted further subyention or financing, without going into precise detail is it any excessive burden on a Government to ask them to come into Oireachtas Éireann and say: "We want £1,000,000 for this service or that," before coming to ask for the money? Is there any Deputy in this House who can accept the explanation as to why on the eve of the Christmas recess a proposal is brought in giving the Government authority to spend £5,000,000 for a purpose no man knows what? Did you hear the acting-Minister for Finance describe all the purposes for which he intends or believes the Government intends to spend the money? Do you remember the man who commended the South Sea Bubble to the investors of London? He said he wanted a large investment of the people's capital for an unprecedented enterprise of unexampled dimensions, and he raised very large sums of money on the ground that any project so eloquently described must have great potentialities, and he decamped with the money and the bubble burst and people were ruined.

The only proposition here is that the Government want £5,000,000 in case something should turn up. They have promised to save on the current Estimate £3,500,000, every penny of which they have a perfect right to spend under the law, but in addition to that they now want another £5,000,000 and the only reason they want it in this form is because they donot want to tell anybody in advance what they are going to spend it on. Why? There is only one distinction between the means whereby they ask Oireachtas Éireann to give them this £5,000,000 and the ordinary procedure of the Estimates where they would have to tell Dáil Éireann in advance what they are going to do with it. The only distinction involved in this procedure is that they ask the money without telling anybody what they want it for. Why? We all know that in the by-election in North Mayo the voters were told—and remember they were talking to people who had been thrown into unemployment by their activities, people who had lost their jobs—they went to them in Mayo and told them: "Vote for our candidate and we will employ you to make chocolate biscuits in Ballina. We will give the man who is going to build the factory £80,000 free gift to build the factory in Ballina to make chocolate biscuits and employ you all." They did not make a dog biscuit in Ballina from that day to this.

Comment on this

Nor will they. They had not the slightest intention.

Comment on this

Remember when they went to South Galway, they had been in the meantime to Cork and Wicklow and while there they announced their intention of stealing £500,000 from the ratepayers. When that was exposed they lost both the elections, so they reverted to the previous tactics when they went to Galway. In every town they went into—in one they were going to turn over to seamsters, the next was going to have a weavers' factory, and I do not know what was to happen in others. Now circumstances which we all deplore precipitate by-elections in Louth and Cork. Now we have rung the changes on chocolate biscuit factories, weaving sheds and devious other methods to give the people what they most want, an opportunity of earning their living. Now they have to go to Cork and Louth. There are not many more tunes of that kind they can play, so they are going to fare forth with £5,000,000 of public money to announce that, for every vote that is polled, there is money from thepublic purse to pay for it. Come, how low are politics going to be dragged?

Comment on this

Very low, indeed.

Comment on this

Do you deny a word of what I say?

Comment on this

I say it is the dirty political mind of the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is the truth.

Comment on this

It is a lie.

Comment on this

Do you allow that observation, a Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I had not an opportunity to intervene.

Comment on this

I shall give you an opportunity now.

Comment on this

I withdraw the word.

Comment on this

It is the truth. This Bill is designed to present the Taoiseach to this country as Father Christmas, a rôle which he charged the Tánaiste to play when he was announcing the biscuit factory in Ballina and the weaving factory elsewhere. We have now got to the stage when we are going to dream, not of prospective earnings but of the pounds, the shillings and the pence. Why else should Oireachtas Éireann be asked to give the Government money for purposes they have refused to disclose in advance? Deputy General Mulcahy, the Leader of the Opposition, asks how can this be used for the provision of ground limestone. It can be used for anything. Whatever suits the Party machine of Upper Mount Street—that is what it will be used for. The Tánaiste has already had the brazen-faced impudence to go cut and announce that there is £500,000 of it going to be used for the Local Authorities (Works) Act wherewith to clear the drains. They virtually closed down the Local Authorities (Works) Act two years ago. Did these drains cease to carry water in 1951 and begin again to carry water in 1953? Were not the drainsclogged and waterlogged, and was not the land served by these drains waterlogged from 1951 to 1953? Why does the Tánaiste say now that there is £500,000 to be found to do work in 1953 that he condemned us for doing in 1948, 1949 and 1950 and that he would not allow his own Government to do in 1951 and 1952? What has happened to the drains that they suddenly began to cry out for clearance on the eve of an election in Louth? You cannot clear drains in Cork City.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Consequently there is no use saying that you are putting money into drainage to win the by-election there.

Comment on this

Not in Cork City but a sum of £5,000,000 is being raised. £500,000 is going into the drains and £1,000,000 is being made available for the Road Fund. That leaves £3,500,000 available for votes in Cork City. Come now, let the paragons of virtue protest again. Is it or is it not true that the engineering staff in County Louth have already got notice that they are to put their schemes into operation and that on a basis which will carry them on beyond the end of this financial year?

Comment on this

They have got the same notice as the engineers in every other county.

Comment on this

So they have got it! The bluebell has let the cat out of the bag.

Comment on this

In the same way as the engineers of every other county.

Comment on this

The red gown and whiskers are on already. The largesse is being distributed. The sleigh-bells are ringing and the reindeer are trotting in every county in Ireland. (Interruptions). The three bluebells are out with a placard travelling with Father Christmas and saying: "We are on the bandwagon too!" Is there any limit to the depths to which politics can be drawn down in this country? (Interruptions). Picture Deputy Cogan seated on the bandwagon, piping here to-day to say: "Father Christmas is abroad not only in Louth but in every county in Ireland."

Comment on this

Shades of the United Irish League.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davern should restrain himself.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

If the Minister for Local Government were disposed to speak on that subject, we might find out something.

Comment on this

Politics can bring strange and horrible things into this House.

Comment on this

Indeed that is so.

Comment on this

Yes, strange and horrible things. I want to stigmatise as disgraceful the blatherskite of the Minister for Finance about lime. It is like the low-down bucket-shop operator's commendation of shares. It bears no relation whatever to the truth. He has described as exceptional the experiment on a piece of derelict land in Johnstown which happens to be the one deerpark left in Ireland on which no operation of husbandry was carried out since 1120.

Comment on this

There was work carried out there before ever you tried it.

Comment on this

This work was carried out in Johnstown on a derelict piece of land——

Comment on this

Two years before your time.

Comment on this

Except for a building which fell down which I had to rebuild——

Comment on this

There was liming of land.

Comment on this

There was no soil testing.

Comment on this

There was indeed.

Comment on this

The only soil-testing facilities were one man and a boy with a bicycle wheel and a medicine bottle tied to it with a bit of string, in one back room in the agricultural college in Ballyhaise. That was the entire soil-testing facilities of this country.

Comment on this

The usual exaggeration.

Comment on this

That is the literal truth —one man and one boy using for their agitator an old bicycle wheel, turned on a 4d. nail with a disused medicine bottle tied to it with a piece of string. These were the boasted soil-testing facilities.

Comment on this

There was proper soil testing.

Comment on this

It is sheer rot to describe the work at Johnstown about which the Minister knows as much as my foot.

Comment on this

You were against it.

Comment on this

Whether the land of this country requires lime which is now available to farmers at a price they can afford to pay is a matter on which the farmers are the best judges. On land which is deficient in lime it is prudent, economic and profit-earning to put lime but on land with a sufficient calcium content it is not economic, prudent or desirable to put lime.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

I say it would be wrong to put it on it.

Comment on this

Exactly. On land that wants lime, the more lime that is put on it the better but on land which has an excess of calcium content it would be a great mistake.

Comment on this

Do you remember——

Comment on this

Sit down.

Comment on this

Do you remember——

Comment on this

Precious little he knows about agriculture. His opinions are utterly disreputable.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

The Deputy gave us an example in 1951.

Comment on this

The acting-Minister for Finance says that when the balance of trade has improved the unemployment situation is not so good.

Comment on this

The balance of payments, not trade.

Comment on this

When the balance of payments has improved the unemploymentsituation is not so good. What made the unemployment situation in this country not so good? Was the unemployment situation in this country in 1951 not so good? I can remember later years than 1951. For the first time they beheld a situation approximating to total employment. I remember that in 1950 the grant made to the Sligo County Council under the Local Authorities (Works) Act could not be spent because the engineering staff of County Sligo reported that, having employed every available man, there were certain schemes that could not be put into operation because there were no unemployed men to employ on them.

Comment on this

They were not there. They were in England.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Who exported them?

Comment on this

I am talking of the comparison between 1951 and 1953. Since 1951, a flood of emigration has taken place to England.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

At the same time, I am told by the acting-Minister for Finance that he justifies his action in asking Dáil Éireann to give him £5,000,000 for unrevealed purposes because the unemployment situation is not so good. What made it not so good?

Comment on this

Because not so many of them went to England as during the Coalition Government's time.

Comment on this

I invite the Minister for External Affairs to pay a visit to County Mayo and to examine the position for himself there.

Comment on this

I want these words to ring in Birmingham, Manchester, Cardiff, London and every industrial city in Britain where our people have been going for the past 18 months. Let them hear what the acting-Minister for Finance has to say——

Comment on this

In 1950, during the Coalition's term of office, 40,000 emigrated.

Comment on this

I want it to ring in Birmingham, Cardiff, London, Glasgow and every other industrial city in Britain that, so far as the acting-Minister for Finance is concerned, he does not know they are gone. He does not know they are gone! What made the situation in 1953 not so good?

Comment on this

If Deputy Dillon had his way, every young Irishman would be gone.

Comment on this

That is the justification for this Bill.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Unemployment cannot be discussed in detail on the Bill.

Comment on this

The acting-Minister for Finance asked for money without stipulating the reason. He just said that the unemployment situation was not so good. That is the ground on which he asks for this Bill. If I cannot discuss that, then I cannot discuss the Bill at all. Let us grasp this problem, then. What made the unemployment situation not so good?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

The Deputy's policy helped quite a lot.

Comment on this

Come now. Did housing cease to employ as many people as it had been employing up to 1951? That is a fair question. I think it did cease to employ them. I knew a number of small building contractors of the very kind mentioned by the acting-Minister for Finance—small entrepreneurswho were investing their own capital and employing labour themselves—who went bankrupt and who joined their own employees at the labour exchange. I knew them. Then people who wanted to build a house for themselves found that it would cost 10/- a week extra to pay for the house under Fianna Fáil than it cost under the inter-Party Government —and the men who would have built houses for them became unemployed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does the question of housing arise on national development?

Comment on this

Good God!

Comment on this

The acting-Minister for Finance has come to the House to say that because of growing unemployment he wants to relieve the situation. For that purpose, he wants £5,000,000 of public money to employ those who fall into unemployment. I am putting it to the acting-Minister for Finance that instead of draping the Taoiseach in a red gown and white whiskers as Father Christmas he should allow the average small builder to build houses and employ the men who have been put out of employment by the policy of the acting-Minister for Finance. That is what I am after. Is what I am saying not true?

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Is it not true that yesterday the Government itself announced that local authorities, borrowing from the Local Loans Fund for the purpose of giving loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, would have the rate of interest on their borrowings reduced by ½ per cent? Is not that true? Why did they do that? Did they not do it as some contribution towards the repair of the damage which they had wrought? Do not forget, however, that it has not been done in respect of Dublin and that it has not been done in respect of Cork and that it cannot be done in respect of Dublin and that it cannot be done in respect of Cork—because Dublin Corporation was sent to borrow £5,000,000 from the banks and insurance companies at 5 per cent. interest——

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

I am informed that it is correct.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon talks a lot of nonsense. I will answer him on that point.

Comment on this

Did the Dublin Corporation borrow money at 5 per cent.?

Comment on this

Not for what you are talking about. I will deal with that matter later.

Comment on this

They did. Of course, they did.

Comment on this

They borrowed money at 5 per cent. at the behest of our own Government.

Comment on this

Continue speaking. I will deal with what you are saying afterwards.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon does not mind whether he is right or whether he is wrong.

Comment on this

Let us have no joking or jeering at the expense of people who cannot get houses. I brought to the attention of the corporation and of the Government the case of four persons living in one tenement room in a ratridden house who were told by the corporation: "We cannot even consider your case for 18 months. We are dealing now only with cases of six and five persons in one room."

Comment on this

When did you do that?

Comment on this

A week ago.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

And then Deputy Dr. Browne comes along and says that the housing problem has been solved.

Comment on this

Can it be that members of the corporation do not themselves know of these things? If so, more shame on them. If Government Deputies are not aware that the Dublin Corporation are writing to every applicant for a municipal house, where there are less than five persons living in a room, to the effect that at present they are attending only to cases with six and five persons living in a room, and that they cannot deal with lesser numbers in a room for 18 months, then shame on Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

That is untrue. Deputy Byrne can tell you that that is untrue.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon does not mind.

Comment on this

It is not untrue—and I have a letter from the city manager to say that it is true. Come now, and, on that, let us join issue.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe will nail your hand to the desk.

Comment on this

I will nail his ears and his hands.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon must be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe would like to try. Let us not, however, get into acrimonious discussion across the floor of the House. There are too many Fianna Fáil Deputies who like to make smart remarks and to stick their necks out. Then, when they get hit, they cry like babies that someone has been rude to them. You are all very tender-skinned when you get a slap but you are as brave as lions when you are giving the slaps. If you do not want slaps, do not give them and do not cry if you get a slap for the slap you give. There have been too many occasions on which I gave some of you your answers and you were crying all over the place that we were slapping you.

Comment on this

The corporation housed a man from Monaghan with three children and I can give the Deputy his name.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy should boast of that.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There were people in Belfast making similar claims.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy O'Sullivan has interjected a remark suggesting that Deputy Gallagher got somebody from Monaghan a house on the same basis as the houses in Belfast.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

I made no such interjection, and I know Deputy Gallagher better than to say any such thing.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that the municipality made available a house for a man with three children. Had he a wife?

Comment on this

Of course, he had. Where did he get the children?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He could be a widower.

Comment on this

Was it a case of five people in a room—a man, his wife and three children?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That is perfectly right. The city manager said that the corporation was dealing with families who were six and five in a room. It is very relevant——

Comment on this

He never said anything of the kind.

Comment on this

——to know whether he was a widower or a man with a wife and three children. Such a man is entitled to a house under the present schedule of distribution. The person I recommended to the city manager was a man with a wife and two infant children—four in a room—and what the manager said was that they were dealing with only five and six at present and could not consider four. If the Deputy got a house for a man, his wife and three children in the city, he got it on the basis on which the city manager said the municipal housing authority was at present proceeding, and, in fairness to that authority, I think anybody could have got that house. I am complaining that a man with a wife and two children who is ready and willing and anxious to pay a rent cannot get a house, at a time when the acting-Minister for Finance says that he is actuated to ask the House for £5,000,000, without assigning reasons, because the unemployment situation is not so good.

The case I am making is: "What do you want asking us for money for unknown purposes to relieve unemployment when there are people in our own capital city eager to pay a rent who cannot get a house, when there are 200 carpenters unemployed in the city, when hundreds of building contractors are on half-time and hundreds of building labourers out of a job? There is no scarcity of cement, no scarcity of timber and no scarcity of material. What do you want £5,000,000 for an unascertained purpose when the houses are not there to house the people who wantthem and when you are preventing people, by charging a high rate of interest on the Small Dwellings Act loans, from building houses for themselves?" That is the only case I am making—that you are making people pay that high rate by driving the Dublin Corporation to borrow from the moneylenders at 5 per cent. on which they have to make a further charge when they lend that money to the person borrowing under the Small Dwellings Act. I believe that, if the truth were told, Deputy Gallagher and Deputy McCann agree with every word I say, but they do not think it is Party loyalty to say so in public.

Comment on this

We do our best in the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this

I am not blaming the Deputy. I am merely explaining to him that I am demurring to the raising of money in this way for the relief of unemployment as if there was no means of relieving unemployment readily available to our hand such as housing of the municipal kind and, much better, the kind available under the Small Dwellings Act, if the rates charged for money would allow that Act to function.

"When the balance of trade is adverse," said the acting-Minister for Finance, "it indicates the need of internal adjustment." The acting-Minister for Finance—I ask Deputy Gallagher to listen to this—explained the austerity provisions of his colleague's Budget on the ground that, when the balance of trade is adverse, it indicates the need of internal adjustment. Deputy Gallagher must have been in the House last night when his leader was explaining that the balance of trade in 1950 and 1951 was brought about by the stockpiling, the liquidation of which caused stagnation in 1952.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

And the purchase of consumer goods.

Comment on this

Was it not stockpiling?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

No.

Comment on this

There are some Fianna Fáil Deputies who are not absolutely obtuse and who remember what theTaoiseach said. Did he not say: "The stagnation in 1952 which was such an embarrassment to us was largely caused by the liquidation of the stockpiling"? Deputies will remember that he said the manufacturers stockpiled, the Government stockpiled, the wholesalers stockpiled, the retailers stockpiled—even, he said, the individual citizen bought two and three suits of clothes. He said that it was because of that that we had a kind of stagnation in 1952 and that we are only coming out of that now.

Comment on this

A buyers' resistance.

Comment on this

I can understand that case being made on Thursday night, but, on Friday morning, when I am told that the adverse balance of trade made austerity necessary lest it continually recur year after year, although I know that the Taoiseach says that the imbalance of trade in 1950 was due to the stockpiling which was so great that it created stagnation in 1952——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

It was partly stockpiling and partly the buying of consumer goods.

Comment on this

Either there was a stockpile accumulating in 1950 of such size that it created stagnation in 1952, or there was not. That stockpile which was coming in in a magnitude sufficient to take three years to liquidate was superimposed on our normal imports. Is that not what we told the Government in 1951? There is no need to panic, we said. The adverse trade balance in 1950 is purely exceptional, due to stockpiling.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

No. What about wheat and maize? You did not stockpile them.

Comment on this

We said: "This was purely stockpiling and there was no need to throw men out of employment, no need to cut down, no need to drive people into emigration. This thing will right itself by a dual process: the exceptional purchases of 1950 will not recur, and, in 1951 and 1952, imports will tend to go below the normal because this stockpile will be running down and agricultural exports aregoing to rise and will give very material help to the balance of trade figures."

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

What provision was made for the replacement of the imported maize and wheat?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see how that would be relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

He is talking about stockpiling.

Comment on this

All I know is that, in June, 1951, there was more wheat——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Produced.

Comment on this

——in store in this country than at any time since Brian Boru lost his life at the Battle of Clontarf. There was more wheat in store in Ireland in June, 1951, than at any time in previous recorded history. The only point I am making is that we said to the Fianna Fáil Government of 1951: "Do not get panicked by the trade figures of 1950 or 1951, because superimposed on our normal imports there is a very extensive stockpiling operation. It will not recur and its liquidation will bring our imports to practically normal in 1952-53 while, at the same time, the exports of our agricultural industry will certainly expand in dramatic style." We had good reason to expect that they would amount to £100,000,000 sterling in 1952. They did, and they will reach £105,000,000 in 1953. It is really all live stock. They are reaching those figures after you eliminate all the exports of sweetened fat and minced meat.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

There is no limitation on them.

Comment on this

Let the Minister not get cross or silly.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

I am not getting cross.

Comment on this