We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Development Fund Bill, 1953—Second Stage.

Contributions 219–409 of 609. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill National Development Fund Bill, 1953
Enacted

No. 32 of 1953 ›

As a matter of fact, the export of sweetened fat and minced meat has virtually disappeared as a result of the derationing of sugar in Great Britain. Nevertheless, that gap is being taken up and, in addition,agriculture has forced up the level of exports to £105,000,000, so that they were all wrong about the panic in 1951. It was not necessary and it need never have been embarked upon.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

The Deputy could not expand the 200 tons per week or the tonnage per year in regard to the meat trade.

Comment on this

Another aphorism laid down by the acting-Minister for Finance was——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

There was no provision made for expansion there.

Comment on this

——that we have no rights to expend past savings held in external form for current consumption. Will any Deputy ask himself what is the purpose of exporting? Is not the purpose of our people producing an exportable surplus, say, of beef, over and above all we want to eat ourselves, to sell the beef abroad so that we will have the means wherewith to buy whatever we want, and if we sell beef in a market anywhere in the world with the result that we cannot buy what we want with the proceeds are not those what are called unrequited exports? Other people seem to have the daft notion in their minds that we ought to export for the purpose of looking at the figures in a bank book. People who get into that frame of mind end up in lunatic asylums gone mad with avarice.

We know elderly people in our own circle down the country who ultimately drift into the madness of sitting in cold garrets with one candle counting their money and warning their relatives that they are going to die in the poor house although they have £2,000 or £3,000 in the bank and about £150 in the stocking which not infrequently takes fire from the candle and gets burned.

Comment on this

What about the jug? I am not being funny.

Comment on this

Does not the House see the dangers of our approach to this business? During the war our exports went unrequited to Great Britain because we could not get anythingfrom Great Britain in exchange for what we sent, and was there anything wrong in getting from Great Britain and elsewhere, after the war, what we had not been able to get during the war? Is it a desirable thing to set before our people the destiny of the individual who ultimately cowers in a garret in a large house by the light of a halfpenny dip candle counting his money? That is literally and metaphorically madness. Your object, if you have any confidence in your future, is, as you earn money, profitably to invest it in a higher standard of living for your own people and so increase their productive capacity.

It is a good thing, if a man is hard working and has the spur of ambition of raising a family, to give him a decent house where there will be a couple of rooms which he has not furnished. His ambition will be to work harder in order to furnish the rooms, but if you leave him in one tenement room and tell him that there is no prospect of getting out of it no matter how hard he works the great danger is that, if he has a wife and two infant children, there is a powerful inducement for him to go down to the pub. If he goes down to the pub to get out from under the feet of the housewife who has two infant children, the danger is that when he comes back he will not be as active a man as when he left.

Some of these pests, the professional economists, will tell you that money spent on housing is non-productive expenditure. That is because they reckon on the assumption that human beings are economic machines but they are not. A man who has a wife, a couple of children and a good house with two rooms unfurnished is a powerful potential producer for the community in which he lives. The same man; the same wife with the same two children in one tenement room, is on the high road to becoming a drag on the national economy and an affliction to everybody. The man has no inducement to work or save. He has no pride in the work he is doing because the results are not those which he legitimately wants.

I think it is daft to talk of its being wrong for our people to get for ourexports between 1939 and 1945 a return in the shape of goods in 1946, 1947, 1948, 1949 and 1950. I think they were right to get it. It would have been mad for them not to get it and I glory in the fact that we turned a good deal of those savings into houses, hospitals, drainage, improvement of land, provision of lime and a variety of capital projects that we financed when we were in office and which we left after us as commitments to our successors when they took over office.

The highest tribute to the quality of those commitments we left after us was that not a single one of them was brought into Dáil Éireann to be cancelled by our successors. Every one of them is being honoured. I ask the Fianna Fáil Deputies in this House to examine their consciences. Since they returned to office has there been a single new service thought up or embarked upon, one single new service thought up or embarked upon for the improvement of our people? The acting-Minister for Finance gloried in the fact, in which I do not think he is right—I wish he was—that our exports are 48 per cent. in volume higher in the January-October period of 1953 than they were in 1951. If that is true I rejoice with him but I would like to find out where that reference can be found. The latest figures I happen to have naturally are those in the Trade Journalof September, 1953. Does the acting-Minister for Finance confirm that our exports in the January-October period of 1953 were 48 per cent. higher in volume than they were in 1951?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In volume?

Comment on this

Yes, in volume.

Comment on this

Is that not a remarkable thing? I ask the House to remember that in 1953 our exports are 48 per cent. higher in volume than they were in 1951. Do not forget the economic policy of this State was founded in 1951 on the proposition laid down in the White Paper of October, 1951, that there was no prospect of there being any relief forthcoming in the balanceof trade figures through increased exports. Do you remember that? Do you remember when the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party were sent down the country to explain to their own neighbours that there was no prospect of any relief in the balance of trade situation forthcoming from an improvement in exports and that was the reason why it was necessary to put the tax on tobacco, the tax on stout, on whiskey, on bread, sugar and tea? We said to them: "Be assured there is an immense expansion of our exports coming along and the increase will amount to 50 per cent." I will ask this House to throw their minds back a little further. I remember the first time I moved the Vote for Agriculture in this House, prophesying that it should be possible for us to increase our exports by 50 per cent., and I remember being derided by the Fianna Fáil Party for hot air. Does Fianna Fáil now realise that if you compare the value of exports for 1953 with that of 1947 the increase is nearly 70 per cent.? Does Fianna Fáil now realise that they were sent down the country to make the case that there could be no increase in exports and they are now obliged to tell the House that there has been an increase of 48 per cent. in volume?

On the 12th October, 1951, Deputy Lemass is reported in the Irish Independentas having made a speech on the previous day at the Publicity Club which evoked the heading: “The Nation's Economy in Danger.” He said: “The simple facts tell us what has to be done. We must reduce imports. The current output figures for our normal exports rule out the possibility of any large increase in the volume of exports in the near future.”

Those are the words that were spoken in 1951 and on those sentiments was founded the policy that has brought about the catastrophic consequences of which we have all been witnesses and which the Government now says require exceptional measures to redress. Is 48 per cent. in volume not a substantial increase? Think where we could be now if the follies founded on the Tánaiste's, DeputyLemass's illusions of October, 1951, had never been embarked upon. Think where we could be now if we had gone full steam ahead and kept the men at home and prevented them from becoming unemployed and had not to bring in an emergency measure involving an expenditure of £5,000,000 to give employment to those who are unemployed to-day or who are exercising the right to emigrate. Think where we would be if for the last two years their energies had been harnessed to work that Fianna Fáil stopped them doing when they came into office.

I ask Deputies of Fianna Fáil to question themselves to-day—why did they do it? Was it a shameful conspiracy to denigrate their predecessors in office? Did they want to approve a policy adopted by their leaders designed to suggest that their predecesors in office had dissipated the national resources and had been improvident and reckless and put the national economy in peril? Do they now see how criminally wrong that despicable conspiracy was? Do they now appreciate the horrible price they have paid and that we are paying and are going to pay in unemployment and in emigration for that vicious conspiracy to denigrate the people who had gone before them? This Bill is a dirty fraud.

Comment on this

We heard that before.

Comment on this

This Bill is designed to make good the proposition that those in need—and there are many of them— can look to Fianna Fáil for benefactions from the public purse. This Bill should not be called the National Development Bill; it should be called "The Prostitution of Father Christmas Bill." I would be ashamed to belong to a Government that came to Oireachtas Éireann for authority to spend public money to buy votes. I do not think even the poorest member of the Fianna Fáil Party is happy about this Bill. The decency of Irish public life, no matter who is in office, is a matter of consequence to us all. This Bill does very little to maintain decent standards in our public life. It will be long remembered as the "Prostitution of Father Christmas Bill" and as suchis a disgrace to the Government which introduced it.

Comment on this

I have been ten years a member of the House and have been present when many Bills were presented for Second Reading by various Ministers under three Governments, but I have never witnessed such an evasion of putting the purpose of a Bill as I did this morning when the acting-Minister for Finance introduced this Bill. He ranged over every possible aspect of Government policy, he touched on agriculture, unemployment, ground limestone, external assets, housing and other things, but gave us no idea of what it is intended to do under this Bill. He spoke for the best part of an hour and I eagerly awaited information from him of the Government's plans for spending this £5,000,000. I waited in vain, as did the other Deputies who were here this morning. While the Minister was speaking on ground limestone, I recalled that about 200 years ago someone advocated the use of burned lime to increase crop production. The idea caught on and gave good results during its early years. The people of those days had not as much information as we have at present, the habit continued once it had started and, as a result, in practically the whole 32 Counties no field was considered right unless it had its own lime-kiln. The day came 120 years ago when the use of lime had to be completely abandoned, as the land had been exhausted. In my native county there are fields pointed out yet which were so exhausted they did not even grow weeds, much less crops.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon says: "Hear, hear; it is bad for the land." He is up here behind me.

Comment on this

I want to check any possible damage that may arise as a result of the Minister's foolish statement this morning. I want to warn all farmers who might read his statement, not to take it at its face value. They should have their soil tested first by the soil testing section of the Department and should follow their instructions as to the correct amount of lime to use. The Minister spent about 22minutes—I timed him on the clock— telling us about the demonstration which took place at Johnstown in Wexford. I do not question the Minister's figures for that particular plot, which might have been only a few perches. I do not believe it was a full statute acre. He said that by the expenditure of £2 on the statute acre on the plot in Johnstown Castle the yield from the application of ground limestone was £100 over six years. There again, the Minister should know more than to give such a dangerous example. I presume he is a farmer himself. He should have qualified his statement by saying that, while that result was gained on a certain piece of ground, some of the land of this country deficient in lime would not yield similar results. He should have warned the farmers to get their soil tested first and then follow the instructions.

I am glad to say, from my own experience and knowledge of the farmers—and particularly the activities of the Young Farmers' Clubs—that most of them know it is more than foolish to experiment with any fertiliser without expert knowledge beforehand. They should know in what the soil is deficient and then should use fertiliser with prudence and skill, according to the advice given by the soil testing section. The lands of Johnstown Castle on which this demonstration was given—and which the Minister took 20 minutes to tell us about—are some of the most fertile lands in the country but they have never been tilled or broken. Deputy Dillon said it was a deer park since 1120. Without question, an application of ground limestone to that land would give astonishing results.

Comment on this

It depends on the land. It might not require it.

Comment on this

We know quite well that it is particularly fertile, it has been left untilled for 700 or 800 years, and we know that by the ordinary action of worms and gravity the soil has come to the top, the lime and other valuable clay sediments have sunk to the bottom, out of reach of even the deepest root plants except trees. Theapplication of lime would give astonishing results. The Minister's account of £100 profit over the six years does not surprise me.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said it was a complete exaggeration. I am glad to hear that Deputy Blowick is contradicting him and putting him a bit wise.

Comment on this

Without casting any reflection on the Chair a good deal of what the Minister said, apart from being harmful, was completely irrelevant. For that reason I do not want to go into those points in detail. If the Minister said he intended to give grants under this Bill for ground limestone plants, I would be the very first to welcome it. I hold strong views on limestone and any farmer from Connaught must also. It must not be forgotten that in our part of the country there are many short pithy sayings warning people against the immoderate use of lime and those sayings still live with us. The statement made by the Minister this morning could lead the farmers astray into overdosing the land with lime. Land can have too high a limestone content, to the detriment of certain crops. The Minister should know that and should have advised farmers to seek the expert advice of the soil testing section. That would be plain common sense.

Would the Minister tell us, when replying on the Second Reading, what the Bill is for? I listened for an hour and must confess that, even now, beyond giving the Government a free hand to spend £5,000,000 a year, I do not know what the Bill is for.

There is another point I am puzzled about. When any Department begins to outrun the amount of money voted by the House, it is usual to come in here with a Supplementary Estimate. When was a Supplementary Estimate ever denied to any Government here? I have never seen it happen. Every Minister knows all he has to do is to introduce it, and unless it is for some foolish scheme the House will not question it and the debate is usually short. I have known a Supplementary Estimate for £250,000 to be passed without debate, once Deputies knewwhat it was for. I do not see why the Government could not adopt the same attitude. This is a dangerous departure from the usual procedure, particularly when the Minister was silent as to the way in which it is intended to use the money. Clann na Talmhan will not deny the Government the use of any money which is necessary for any good purpose, for capital development or for meeting unforeseen contingencies which may arise despite the best anticipations of Government Departments.

I do not like the principle embodied in this Bill. If the Minister had told us, for instance, that revenue may become more flush at a particular time of the year, say, in September, October or November, leaving the Government with money in hands which they would like to put to some useful purpose, I would take that as an explanation. If he told us that at the time the Estimates were prepared a certain inflow of money which took place since was not anticipated with the result that works were whittled down in the preparing of the Estimates this time last year, I would take that as an explanation. But the Minister walks in and calmly tells us that he is asking the House to give him this Bill and does not give a single word of explanation as to how the money is to be spent. That is treating the House in a cavalier fashion and treating the country in a way in which it should not be treated.

Some time ago the Tánaiste stated that, anticipating the passage through the House of this Bill, £500,000 would be spent on Local Authorities (Works) Act drainage. That was a little bit high-handed on his part. I am delighted, however, to see that because on several occasions I have deprecated the Government's attitude in cutting down the money which should be available for county councils under that Act because, from the farmer's point of view, that was one of the best measures ever passed in this House. From the point of view of increased production of land, I think that and the land project have contributed more to increased production than anything else from which this country hasbenefited for very many years. I am sorry, however, that the Government did not go back to our figure of £1,500,000 and give £1,000,000 out of this £5,000,000 for Local Authorities (Works) Act drainage. If the Government are keen on increased agricultural production, on which the Minister spent a lot of time this morning, one way to do that is to subsidise fertilisers.

The Minister made a rough shot in the dark and said that the farmers have from £70,000,000 to £80,000,000 in savings. How does the Minister know that? Has he any accurate figures for it? I do not believe the farmers have that amount of savings. He also said that the best thing they could do would be to plough that back into the land. This Government have given the farmers very little encouragement to plough their profits back into the land. The farmers have been so crushed by Fianna Fáil that they are very chary of ploughing back anything into the land. Any time they did that, they were treated in the same way as they were treated by the landlords in the past by having further impositions put on them.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy and the Minister must appreciate that if a certain amount of money has been accumulated by farmers it is intended for providing for their daughters.

Comment on this

It is only ordinary foresight for an intelligent farmer to set aside a sum of money for his family. Furthermore, apart from the fact that the average farmer, if he has a couple of daughters, must make provision for their marriage or education or setting them up in some business or way of life, a good deal of the £70,000,000 or £80,000,000—if it exists, and I do not say it does—must come from emigrants' remittances. In my part of the country the custom is for boys and girls when they go to England to send their savings home to their parents to bank for them. To say that the farmers have savings amounting to £70,000,000 or £80,000,000, and to tell them toplough that back into the land is absolute rubbish. I do not think the sum would be one-fifth or one-sixth of that. I should like the Minister to give us more accurate figures than he has given us.

Comment on this

They could use some of it on the land rather than getting 1 per cent. interest on it in the banks.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Hickey does not suggest that a farmer should gamble with the money that he has put aside for the setting up of his daughters. I put it to Deputy Hickey and to the Minister that the amount of money the farmers have which can be called real savings is negligible.

Comment on this

It was well earned, anyway, whatever they have.

Comment on this

There may be some money lying to their credit, but we must remember that remittances from abroad come to about £15,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

It should be better used.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister at this stage if he has the figures for the actual savings. I do not think he has.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He said £70,000,000 or £80,000,000.

Comment on this

He did. In the Province of Connaught, most of the savings consist of money that sons and daughters have sent back from England for the parents to lodge in their names in the bank for safe keeping. The Minister is only talking through his hat if he thinks any father or mother, having money in trust for children which has been sent to them from abroad, will gamble with it by ploughing it back into the land. They will not do it, and I would not advise them to do it.

Comment on this

Then they can keep it in the bank at 1 per cent.

Comment on this

It is easy to say these things. These things work out grand on paper. But the Minister is a farmer and he must know the thousand andone blows which a farmer gets from the weather, unforeseen accidents, mortality and losses in many other ways that nobody can appreciate except the man who suffers from them. Take the case of turkeys. There is one item of production on the land. Most farmers were certain that they would get 4/- a lb. for turkeys this year the same as last year, but in every town in Connaught the producers have been selling them at 10/- apiece this year.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how the price of turkeys arises.

Comment on this

It is one of the items of production.

Comment on this

The price of turkeys last year was not 4/- a lb.

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

The Deputy should know.

Comment on this

I know what I got myself. I know that I got 4/- a lb.

Comment on this

It was 4/4 when Deputy Dillon was in office.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy get 4/- a lb.?

Comment on this

Yes and more some years before that. The Minister is asking the farmers to plough their profits into the land. How much of their profits are the dairy farmers ploughing into the land? Take the farmers in the West who go in for mixed farming instead of a specialised line of farming, as I may describe it. Are they going to plough their profits into the land? Every single one of these blows has a psychological effect on the average farmer and makes him very conservative.

The Minister talked about ploughing back farmers' savings into the land. I do not believe that the savings are there. If a farmer, as a result of his hard work over a lifetime, has saved a few hundred pounds, £1,000 or £2,000 to make provision for members of his family, I am not going to ask him to invest his £2,000 in his land. I would advise him to hold on to it forthe laudable purpose which he had in his mind.

The Minister also dealt with the question of external assets. He seemed to blame the inter-Party Government for repatriating certain assets which had accumulated in England from the sale of our produce to that country during the war years. I have no apology whatever to make for being a party to that. In fact, I am proud of it. My view is that these assets were built up in England during the war years as a result of the agricultural produce which we sent across at that time. We got nothing in return for it except paper tokens. We sent over during that time produce from our land amounting to about £161,000,000.

Comment on this

And got nothing at all for a lot of the cattle that went over at that time.

Comment on this

That is right. We sent over cattle, sheep, eggs, poultry and pigs. England was then engaged in a big war and was not able to give us any value in return for what we sent to her—the world's best food. All that produce came out of our land and, therefore, I say it was right to reinstate these assets in the land. The Minister talked glibly about ploughing back savings, which the farmers have not got, into their own land, while at the same time he wants these assets amounting to £161,000,000 to be left in England, although she is only paying an interest rate of 1½ per cent. on them. Will the Minister tell me what right we have to make England a present of £161,000,000, the value of our agricultural produce, and not ask her in return to send us the fertilisers, machinery and coal which we require? We repatriated £148,000,000 to buy machinery to drain our land and to buy fertilisers, because we held that the land out of which the produce we sold to England came, was best entitled to receive the benefit of that money.

The farmers were better entitled than anybody else to have those assets repatriated. Our policy was to repatriate every penny of them for the benefit of the country. We have no apology to make for doing that. I amrather proud of it. What is wrong with the Minister is that, when speaking of the repatriation of external assets, he is mixing up the investments by private people with the moneys which had accumulated in England during the war years when, as I have said, we got nothing for the agricultural produce that we sent across at that time. I would like the Minister to know that we never touched the investments of private people. As regards the other assets, which had accumulated during the war, we held that it was the land which produced what we sent to England at that time that had first claim on them.

My prophecy is that not one penny of this £5,000,000 will be spent on the establishment of ground limestone plants and on the provision of ground limestone for the farmers. If the Minister is able to contradict me on that he can do so when replying. I should like to know if the rebuilding of Dublin Castle and the erection of new Houses of Parliament are to be regarded as projects within the meaning of Section 4 of the Bill which reads:—

"The Minister may apply the fund for the purpose of financing projects which, in his opinion, are projects of development of a public character and are in the national interest."

The wording of that section is very vague. In fact, I do not think I have ever seen in any Bill such loose wording. Almost two years ago the Undeveloped Areas Act was passed through this House. I said at the time that I had high hopes of something useful being done under it for the undeveloped areas in the West. Now, I have to confess that that Act has been a complete flop.

During the by-election in North Mayo, the Tánaiste at a public meeting in Ballina said that Ballina was going to have a biscuit factory. I say that it was a downright piece of black-guarding for the Deputy Prime Minister of the country to say that from a public platform. It was fooling the people of that whole constituency to tell them that they were going to get a grant of £80,000 for a factory. Whenquestioned on it in the House by Deputy O'Hara the Minister gave some lame excuse to the effect that the project had fallen through. In view of that, how can anyone have any faith or confidence in anything which this Government brings in? There has been nothing done for the West under that Act except the establishment of a small factory at Kiltimagh. I am proud of that factory. Its establishment was assisted by An Foras Tionscal. But since that Act was passed that is the only thing that I have seen done under it in Mayo or Galway. In fact, I want to say that it was not the Undeveloped Areas Act that was responsible for the establishment of that factory at Kiltimagh, but rather the initiative of the townspeople who put their money into it and got it going.

Comment on this

You did not advise them to keep their money in the bank at 1 per cent. You had that much wit.

Comment on this

That is not a very intelligent observation from the Minister. It is not even witty, and I fail to see what the Minister can smile at. Will the Minister tell us how this Bill is going to benefit the towns and the cities? I have no hope that it is going to benefit the people of the country. I agree with the view that was expressed by Deputy Dillon that, in bringing forward this Bill, the Government are asking for a free hand to spend money for vote catching. I will deal with that down the country. If the Government can throw about £5,000,000, I will take jolly good care to see that my supporters, and the inter-Party supporters in general, will get as much good out of it as the Fianna Fáil supporters and maybe a whole lot more.

The Minister dealt with the increase in the volume of exports. Deputy Dillon got the admission from the Minister that, since 1951, the volume of exports has increased by 48 per cent. That is true. I am afraid, however, that the volume of exports does not provide an accurate yardstick for measuring actual production. This Government, when it came back to office, proceeded to make things asdifficult as possible for the people. If their object was to compel youngsters to fly out of this country, then they have achieved that object, because within the last 18 months 27,000 boys and girls have left this country, while the withdrawal of the subsidies, coupled with other taxes, has resulted in increasing the cost of living. That increased cost of living has denied bread, butter, meat, milk and other necessaries of life to the people.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see how all these things arise on the National Development Fund Bill.

Comment on this

I am trying to deal with points made by the Minister in introducing the Bill.

Comment on this

I did not deal with the cost of living; but it does not matter, nobody minds what the Deputy says, anyway.

Comment on this

Did not the Minister deal with the volume of exports? I do not want to dwell very much on that particular aspect of the Minister's speech except to say that the volume of exports as a yardstick by which to measure increased production is not an accurate one. Say we send out an extra tonnage of goods to England, the next question is, how was that extra tonnage come by? It could be either of two ways: by increased production, or else by cutting down on the amount of that particular commodity used at home. I say that the increased production was achieved, to some extent, by reduced consumption at home. It was admitted, in the Budget speech of the Minister for Finance last May, that the increased production was due to the fact that our own people, because of the increased cost of living, were denied the wherewithal to purchase the ordinary necessaries of life which they enjoyed under the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does that arise on this Bill?

Comment on this

I quite agree that it should not arise and how the Minister sought to make that relevant in hisopening speech I do not know. If I go any further than that I will find myself casting reflections on the Ceann Comhairle, who was in the Chair at the time, and that is something I do not wish to do. I do wish to take the points the Minister made when making his speech and deal with them.

I am afraid this Bill is nothing more than a vote-catching business. If the Minister could point to one occasion on which a Supplementary Estimate was denied or even delayed in this House, then I would say a Bill like this might be necessary to by-pass delays and hold-ups that might occur. I do not like the principle involved in the Minister coming in here and asking for leave to spend £5,000,000 in any way he likes. The wording of Section 4 of this Bill is as loose as any dictator could wish for. It is a complete departure from any established practice in this House. If the Minister said he was going to use this money, for instance, to bring down the cost of living for the unfortunate people in the towns and cities who were forced from butter to margarine and are now forced off margarine by the price, I would not speak at all. I would give the Bill my silent consent.

Comment on this

All we have to do is to bring down milk to 1/- a gallon.

Comment on this

The Minister will not get away on that. Butter was only 2/8 a lb. during the period of the inter-Party Government and milk was 1/4 a gallon.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The price of butter does not seem to be relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

Then the Minister should not interrupt on a point like that.

Comment on this

Would we not like to see some provision for development?

Comment on this

That is the cause of my trouble and my grumbling—the Minister never told us what development he had in mind. I do not believe he had any development in mind, and I believe the cause of his silence is that he does not mean to spend themoney on development. I believe he means to spend it on how best to catch votes for his own Party. That is the cause of my trouble and grumbling.

I am very slow to make an accusation, but I do say in view of the Minister's extraordinary speech this morning there is no other construction left to be put on the purpose of this Bill. If I were acting-Minister for Finance and in a position to come into the Dáil and ask permission to spend £5,000,000, I would be boiling up to give information on what I was going to spend it, and I think any other decent Deputy who would find himself in a Minister's chair would do the same. Instead, the Minister calmly asked permission here to spend £5,000,000 but does not tell us what he is going to spend it on. In the hope of catching out farmers down the country, he talked for 22 minutes on fertilisers and ground limestone, and when I asked him a few questions by way of interruption I discovered to my horror and amazement that the Minister knows as much about ground limestone as the man in the moon. He simply hustles his colleague the Minister for Agriculture aside as he has been hustling him since this Government was formed—a very decent man, I must say, judging by my experience with the few requests I had to make to him. The poor man came in and sat beside the acting-Minister for Finance, but every time he attempted to open his mouth he was hushed by the acting-Minister for Finance and told to shut up.

Comment on this

That is completely untrue.

Comment on this

I have every sympathy with the Minister for Agriculture, but I have a certain amount of contempt for him, too.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know how we can discuss the Minister for Agriculture on this Vote.

Comment on this

The acting-Minister for Finance took the Department of Agriculture to small bits this morning with the Minister for Agriculture sitting beside him. It is a good job I amnot Minister for Agriculture in the present Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The acting-Minister for Finance would find that he could not walk over me quite as easily, physically or otherwise.

Comment on this

He would have to get a ladder.

Comment on this

He would find there was an obstacle in his way. I want to close on this note. I am very perturbed about this new method of coming to the Dáil and asking for money without any explanation as to what it is for. I am afraid at the risk of repetition I must say that if the Minister had £5,000,000 at his disposal to spend I would not see anything wrong if he wanted to develop forestry or speed up the work of the Land Commission which has been slowed down. Forestry has also been chiselled down and it was shocking to see during the last 12 months men being laid off in practically every nursery and forestry centre throughout the country. If the Minister had come in with a Supplementary Estimate for anything like that, it would have been passed without a murmur. If the Parliamentary Secretary had wanted money for the Special Employment Schemes Office or the Board of Works Office I am sure all he would have to do would be to ask for it and there would be very little debate.

All I can say is that it now appears that as a result of taxation which was imposed by way of withdrawal of food subsidies, tax on petrol, and the flood of taxes that were imposed, it emerges that the Government has made a saving of a few million pounds. I do not think it will be great comfort or relief to the people to know that they had to go without butter, with less bread, less milk, less clothing, less fire, than they ever had before at the behest of the Fianna Fáil Government in order that the Minister for Finance might be able to walk in here and ask Dáil Éireann for leave to spend £5,000,000. That is the net result of Government policy. All the scrimping and saving for two and a half years of blood and sweat andtears and privation have the net result of leaving the Government with £5,000,000 on their hands and they are asking this House for a blank cheque to go and spend it for catching votes.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

On a point of order. It has been my experience here, and I think it is the practice, that one speaker from each Party is allowed to speak before a second member of the Government Party speaks.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And that has been allowed.

Comment on this

Two members of the Opposition have spoken.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I am talking about Party representation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Opposition Deputies have been called.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I do not want to cast any reflections, but there was one speaker from Fine Gael and one from a Party with six members. Our Party has a membership of 14 and it has not been allowed a speaker yet. Now we have a second speaker from the Government Benches.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Deputy Corish, by raising a point of order, prevented me from extending an invitation to Deputy Blowick to remain here while I was speaking, because I was hoping that the boiler that threatened to burst in giving the Dáil information as to how he, Deputy Blowick, would spend £5,000,000 might be relieved of a certain amount of pressure in absorbing some information relative to this very simple issue before the House.

It is some three months now since the Taoiseach and his Government announced their intention to set up a special fund for certain specific purposes, and to bring before the Dáil in the shortest possible time a Bill to implement that intention. At the time that that announcement was made it was suggested that it was made specifically for the purpose of vote-catching in the Galway by-election. Now that we have the Bill before us, it is suggestedthat it has been introduced specifically for the purpose of vote-catching generally. Possibly some of the people who take that point of view may fear that there will be a dissoluion of the Dáil during the Christmas recess and that it might do them some harm in their political activities.

Deputy Dillon, in his amazing performance here to-day, made certain definite statements and allegations. One of them was that under all the heads of money for capital expenditure the Government was providing something like £43,000,000 and he could not see how that money would be spent or how it could be spent, and that this Party is now coming along in the guise of Father Christmas with another £5,000,000, the fund to be replenished when that money is spent each year. He said this was just a promise of a Father Christmas present.

I do not know why it is that people are so dense or why they pretend to be so dense. I do not know whether it is that some of the statements they make arise from ignorance of what is going on around them. Here is a sum of money being made available in order to permit capital expenditure on special works wherever there may be unemployed people—it does not matter what area they are in—and where the local authority in the area in which they happen to reside can put up schemes for their employment without the cost of these schemes falling on the shoulders of the local ratepayers. I think that is a very simple proposition.

Every local authority has been notified by circular of the Government's intention and desire in this matter. We in the City of Dublin have also been notified and, in fact, I can say on behalf of the Dublin Corporation that we have been more than generously treated in order to enable us to do our part in helping to solve a problem which must be solved in a proper way.

Now Deputy Blowick wanted information about certain works and in the course of his speech he condemned the type of work that may be done. We in the City of Dublin have been notified that we may now build bridges across the Liffey to solve our trafficproblem as a result of the growth of the city. We have been told that a sum of money will be made available to us equal to 75 per cent. of the cost of the proposed bridge, or bridges. We will be permitted, too, to build certain much-needed offices in order to improve the accommodation for local authority officials, of whom we have some 2,000 odd. Again, we will get a grant of 75 per cent. and, over and above that, we have been notified that we may now employ people on what are described as amenity schemes for the improvement of the city as a whole. These are schemes which would not normally be carried out by the corporation in particular areas and streets and laneways which do not happen to come under the charge of the corporation; but, for carrying out these schemes, we will be given a grant of 80 per cent. We do not look upon this as an election promise.

We have already set up a special works committee. We have appointed to that committee an enthusiastic and efficient engineer to take complete charge. He will recruit his own special staff. Already we have in employment over 400 people and the schemes submitted for the 80 per cent. subsidy from the State from this fund have been notified and we are now in the position that we can plan ahead, not for the purpose of dealing with an immediate problem of a relief nature but for the purpose of long term employment. We have schemes on our files, planned, designed, costed and approved by the Department of Local Government. We can go ahead and we are invited to do so on the basis of the five year period during which this Bill will operate. We estimate that we will spend in Dublin City about £1,200,000 per year on these special works and extra schemes.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Will that come from this fund?

Comment on this

The greater part of it will come from this fund. We will ourselves contribute 20 per cent. In negotiations with the Taoiseach and the Government, we agreed that in large-scale expenditure on amenity schemes, in particular, it was only fairthat some contribution should come from the city itself. In certain cases, we have agreed to contribute 20 per cent.; in other cases we have agreed to contribute 25 per cent.

Now there will be, on the one hand, an outcry because the rates may go up 6d. in the £ in order to enable us to give employment to something over 1,000 people; on the other hand, the same people will scream about the unemployed. We are serious in this matter. No man could have been more genuine in his approach to this problem than the Taoiseach himself. Not so many months ago, when he saw and understood the trend of things, he sent for the representatives of the corporation who happen to be members of this House and he discussed with them the problem. He gave us his views and asked us for our suggestions as to how we could help and how we could get from the corporation as a whole unanimous agreement as to what we would do. Because of his approach, because of his understanding of the human aspect, we, as a corporation, composed of members of all Parties, are delighted by the manner in which we have been treated in this respect.

I do not know the extent to which individual local authorities will participate in grants but it is up to them. Deputy Hickey, probably, is as interested in this as anybody else.

Comment on this

We suggested it to the Taoiseach long before now.

Comment on this

I am not being offensive to Deputy Hickey.

Comment on this

I know you are not.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey will see that as much as possible of this money will go to Cork, by Cork itself putting up schemes for which they need assistance from this fund.

Deputy Dillon talked about Louth being notified of this because we are on the eve of a by-election in Louth. Did he expect that, in sending out the circular to local authorities, Louth should be left out because there is to be a by-election? He says that this particular announcement is made on the eve of the recess. It was made three months ago and, to my knowledge andthe knowledge of many members of this House, was being studied by the Government six and nine months ago. Deputies of some years' experience in this House must know that a serious body such as the Fianna Fáil Cabinet will not make an announcement in the Dáil without first having examined the feasibility of the project, the expenditure on which they are asking the House to endorse.

Deputy Dillon has very many years' experience of State accounting and of the Public Accounts Committee. When he says that the savings on various Estimates could have been diverted to this purpose without the announcement the Government are making, he knows that he is saying something that is incorrect. Does not Deputy Dillon know that if the money voted by the House for a particular Department is not spent in strict accordance with the Vote, it must be surrendered to the Exchequer, and that if money is required for any purpose not envisaged in any of the Estimates, the House must decide that matter as a separate issue? There is no sense in pretending that the ordinary Departments of State can implement this particular item. There are two or three Departments involved, who will support local authorities in the special kind of works they will suggest.

It was clear throughout part of Deputy Dillon's speech that he had an obsession about losing future by-elections. He is under the delusion that this particular money is for the specific purpose of winning a by-election. His exhibitionism and histrionics tempted me to say it was a pity we were not discussing an amendment to the Mental Treatment Bill to-day instead of yesterday. He talked about Dublin Corporation housing. It is obvious that he has no knowledge or experience of local authority administration. He referred to a single instance of a family of four people living in a single room who were not housed by the corporation, notwithstanding the fact that he had brought the case to the notice of the city manager. He inferred from that that nothing wasbeing done as far as housing is concerned.

I want to put on record, so that people who read the debates will have a correct view of things, that in 1932, when this Government took office, there were 18,000 families in Dublin living in single rooms in tenements. There are in Dublin to-day more than 20,000 houses which have been built since that date. Deputy Dillon seemed to be under the impression that unless the condition as to the number in family was complied with, housing would not follow. He does not seem to realise that the Dublin Corporation have agreed on certain priorities. We do not give houses solely on the ground of number in family. There is priority where there is a case of T.B. in a family living in a tenement or slum. There is priority for people living in a dangerous building or in a clearance area.

In connection with the case referred to by Deputy Dillon, of a family living in New Bride Street, I telephoned the housing officer and asked for particulars. The Deputy did not tell the House that the mother-in-law also lives in the same house in another room and that it is really a family of five sharing two rooms and that the position is not as bad from the point of view of rat infestation as he suggested. As everybody knows, the health section deals with that matter.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How could this arise on the Bill?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon spent a considerable amount of time showing that the Dublin Corporation and the Government were not dealing with housing by instancing a case of a family living in a room that is infested by rats. Houses can be built only at a certain rate. There are 11,000 more families on our list for housing. We cannot build 11,000 houses in a month or a year. That is physically impossible. We can only build them at a certain rate taking into consideration all the circumstances—the availability of sites, the development of sites, sewerage, water, acquisition and so forth. In Dublin we have reached what we think is the maximum we can deal with inour aim, which is somewhere between 2,500 and 3,000 houses per year, with a certain number of dwellings in addition. The Deputy talked about the Government not being serious, and when he talked about the £43,000,000 capital investment and the rates of interest he got all confused. Strange to say notwithstanding all the talk of the increased rate of interest charged in the last few years the Dublin Corporation has to-day the largest number of applications for loans under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act that they ever had in any single year in the whole history of that Act. We have something like 1,500 applications at the moment of people who are seeking to borrow money at present rates of interest and with present charges for houses.

Comment on this

Is not that a matter for the Dublin Corporation rather than the national questions we should deal with here this morning?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon tried to show, in the course of his argument, that the reason we have unemployed is because nobody now is engaged in the building of houses due to the high rate of interest and with particular reference to the borrowers under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act. I am just telling the House, notwithstanding everything that Deputy Dillon has said in that matter, that we have never had as many applications as we have this year under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act, which means that, in addition to the houses the corporation themselves will build either for sale or for letting, over and above the flats that they will build, there will be these numbers of houses built by people under the Small Dwellings Act loans, plus others who get their money either through building societies or through the banks.

The Government is responsible for making it possible for the building of houses to go on as it is going. They subsidise by grant and by contribution to the interest charges, and they make it possible for us to do what we can. I agree with Deputy Hickey that if we could give people better houses at cheaper rents or cheaper prices we would like to do that, but what we areconfronted with on that particular aspect of the problem is that there are large numbers of families still needing to be housed and our job is to provide the houses as soon as we can and as best we can. There are 400 families to-day listed on our books, consisting of five members in single rooms, and there are 1,200 families living in one, two or three rooms with six in family listed also. There was a time when we had families of eight, ten, 11 and 14 to deal with but they have been dealt with. We are down now to what we call reasonable numbers.

This Bill has been lost sight of. Deputy Blowick was talking and I thought it was on an Estimate for the Department for Agriculture that he was talking. At a later stage I thought it was on the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce, with particular reference to subsidies and the cost of living. The Bill has been lost sight of. It is a very simple Bill. I think that Deputy Corish and the Labour Party understand what is behind this and I am sure that they will indicate that they welcome it and that they will do their part in trying to make it a success——

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

When we get an opportunity.

Comment on this

——and seeing that every penny of the £5,000,000 is spent in every year. I am not going to delay the Deputy very long.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Ceann Comhairle will determine that.

Comment on this

I am not going to talk about the imbalance in payments or about capital investments. I am not going to be drawn into it, although I would like to say in regard to the manner in which it was attempted to draw this red herring across this particular issue that it was deliberately done to mislead.

Deputy Blowick did make one statement which I would like to have repeated so that when we get a chance during the recess we can look up the statistics. He said that in the three and a half years of the inter-Party Government—I was almost going to say interparliamentary Government;the manner of his speech put me in mind of it—£149,000,000 was repatriated from our external assets to bring into this country machinery and fertilisers and other items for the improvement of the lands. That is a most statesmanlike and, what I would call, well-informed statement from a man who was willing to burst his boiler in explaining how this £5,000,000 would be spent if he was trying to do it. How in the name of goodness could we tell? Every one of us who is a member of a local authority—and there are a good few of us in this House—will in the next few months, I hope, when the Dáil is in recess, be looking for schemes and sending them up to the Minister, saying, "Here is a good scheme." We have it in Dublin, going on deputations to the Minister for Local Government and explaining that a particular scheme is a good one.

The Government is insisting on this, too, and perhaps it is well for the House to know it—and on this I am sure there will be full agreement from the Labour Party—that the Government does not want this money spent on edifices where there is no labour content. In Dublin we are trying to average out the money spent as near as possible so that 60 per cent. of the expenditure will be on wages content. In other words for every £100 we spend on whatever we are doing we want to see that there is £60 of that in wages and £40 for material and whatever the other costs may be. That is what the Government wants. The Government wants this scheme to be elastic so that if a situation arises such as has arisen now in Kildare where there is seasonal unemployment in turf work, there will be ready and available in the local authority some other scheme to employ those people for the period when they will not be needed on this other work.

Comment on this

Surely it would not be a question of looking for schemes. Deputy Blowick wants the Government to come in and mention them.

Comment on this

There will be no difficulty in looking for schemes. We found no difficulty in finding a greatnumber of them. I hope that if this Bill gets a speedy passage, and is allowed to go into operation quickly, in a matter of 12 or 18 months we will all be able to see the benefits it will create not only in each local authority area, and that we will also be able to realise the extent by which it is possible to reduce the number of unemployed and to employ them on worthwhile schemes—not on what we call a relief basis but on special works in the ordinary way of ordinary employment for people available for them when the circumstances are such that they need other employment.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It seems to me, and I am sure it must seem to anybody who has been listening for the last 20 minutes, that Deputy Briscoe knows much more or has displayed much more knowledge about this Bill than the acting-Minister for Finance. If, as Deputy Briscoe suggests, the Bill will be put to such uses, then the acting-Minister for Finance never got it into proper focus. If I express dissatisfaction at the speech that was made by the acting-Minister for Finance, it does not at all represent my attitude or that of the Labour Party towards any proposal to make moneys available and to spend them for capital development and for any work that would go towards the general development of the nation. I want to say, following an earlier interjection by Deputy Hickey, that the trade union organisation in this country, plus the Labour Party, as far back as last June, issued a statement with regard to unemployment, and in July sent representatives to see the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, put before them exactly what is contained in this Bill and described exactly the type of work to which Deputy Briscoe referred this morning and which he also referred to when he spoke on the Estimate for the Taoiseach's Department. The attitude of the Labour Party and the trade union movement then was that the unemployment situation was such that it was the duty of the Government to make money available for schemes that were already prepared by the various local authorities in the country and which, in the majority ofcases, have been submitted to the Department of Local Government. From that point of view I have no hesitation in saying that this change of attitude by the Government is welcome as far as we are concerned.

The acting-Minister for Finance was side-tracked this morning, and shame on him for being side-tracked, because he devoted much of his speech to types of work to which money would not be devoted and did not indicate to the House how it was intended to spend this money. I had a general idea as to how it would be spent and Deputy Briscoe has also a very good idea but I think every Deputy is entitled to complain that the acting-Minister for Finance did not throw much light on the Bill. Would it not be right to say that the unemployed in Dublin City, and indeed all over the Twenty-Six Counties, are entitled to feel very angry and very cynical towards a Government which has been in office since the 13th June, 1951, having regard to the fact that the unemployed were since compelled to live on the miserable pittance of the dole, that some of them were forced to emigrate during that period and that only now, after two and a half years, have the Government awakened to their responsibility with regard to the 67,000 unemployed in the country? Even though this is a rather belated change of attitude, we welcome it as a change in any case.

We can only take the Bill at its face value, as expressing the intention to provide money for certain types of work. We can, however, judge this Bill only in the months to come, say after three or six months' time, when we hope we shall be able to see some benefits from it.

Comment on this

That is very doubtful.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

I am a trusting sort of Deputy.

Comment on this

It is operating already in Dublin.

Comment on this

It is operating on a greater scale in Dublin than in the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Murphy should refrain from interrupting.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

There was no indication from the Acting-Minister for Finance that part of the money would be devoted to roads but it has been announced by some Government Deputies, or information has leaked through from the Department, to the effect that £1,000,000 is to be spent on the roads.

Comment on this

Exclusive of the cities.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It applies to the county councils.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The suggestion was made this morning that £500,000 was to be given to the county councils by way of grant to enable them to undertake drainage schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. Is that a fact?

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

£100,000.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

We are grateful for that information but why did the acting-Minister not say that? Surely his introductory speech should have been of such a nature that we could have discussed this Bill in relation to what it contains, and not behave in the way we have been behaving, talking about everything but what we should talk about.

Comment on this

You do not include me in that "we".

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You have got your acquittal. The Parliamentary Secretary says that £100,000 is being provided for schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. That is not half enough. Whilst some members of the Fianna Fáil Party welcomed the Act when it was passed in 1949 and approved wholeheartedly of the idea of devoting a big sum to these drainage schemes, there has been in the last four or five years a further gradual conversion amongst the majority of rural Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party. If they were to speak their minds, they would agree, I think, that £100,000under this heading is not adequate to do the good work that could be done in this form of national development. Deputy Blowick mentioned some places which had benefited considerably from the Local Authorities (Works) Act and, speaking here some time ago, I also gave examples of the success of these particular schemes in my own constituency.

Virtually every day Deputies stress the importance of agriculture and the need for investment of money in the agricultural industry. I submit there is no better way in which we could develop and encourage agriculture and invest money in the industry than by drainage work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. I very seldom delve into the subject of agriculture, but I heard references here this morning by some people who object to farmers ploughing their profits into the land, in the sense that there might be no return for it. Surely it is not a question of ploughing profits back into the land but rather a question of reinvestment for the benefit of farmers themselves in the agricultural industry? I would humbly suggest that it is a far better proposition that the savings of the country should be put back into the land rather than that they should be kept at a very small rate of interest lying in the banks. I am not suggesting that farmers should be forced to do that. I suppose the farmer himself is the best judge, but there seems to be a long-standing tradition in this country that we are saving as long as we have money in the bank. Our people are not an investing people and never have been. Whether or not that is the tradition handed down from the time when we were under foreign rule I do not know, but I think it will not be denied now that any money we invest in the land will show a return that will be of benefit to the country generally.

As I have already complained, the acting-Minister for Finance did not specify the type of work which it was intended to finance by the moneys to be paid into this fund.

I have approved of the idea of the expenditure of some of the money onroads. I have advocated that a substantial portion of the fund be devoted to drainage work in the rural areas. I believe that if we can make any contribution towards solving the unemployment problem in the rural areas we shall be going a great deal of the way towards solving the problem in the urban areas. There is evidence that there is a gradual increase in the number of workers in industrial employment in this country. Everybody welcomes that trend. The reason we have an unemployment problem is because unemployment springs, in the first instance, from the rural areas by reason of the fact that the agricultural industry does not now employ as many as it did when we had not modern methods of working the land, that is, in the matter of up-to-date machinery.

The average flight from the land or unemployment in rural areas in the past few years runs to about 14,000 or 15,000. I think that, last year, 22,000 persons left the land. These persons have drifted into the towns and cities. If we could make any contribution towards relieving unemployment in the rural areas we would be going a good part of the way towards relieving unemployment in the towns and cities.

Housing has been discussed at length on this Bill. I would advocate, also, that portion of these moneys be devoted to housing—if not for the actual building of the houses by the local authorities at least for the clearance and preparation of sites. Many local authorities have clamoured for assistance in this respect for years and years back. If the Government are sincere in their statement that they want to have this country developed, I suggest that one of the best contributions they could make would be to reduce the cost of housing by having applied to the work of clearance and preparation of housing sites some of the moneys that will be paid into the National Development Fund.

Another very desirable type of work in this country—and something that has been neglected to a very great extent over the years—is the development of our harbours. I believe thatif we could develop our harbours we would make a contribution towards reducing the cost of living in the areas which these harbours would serve. The best example I could give in that respect would be coal. If some of this money were applied to the development of some of our harbours that are not at present fit to take big ships, then the larger ships could enter and discharge their cargoes there. That would substantially cut down carriage and other transportation costs. Take, for example, Wexford town or even Wicklow town, both of which have harbours. It is remarkable that the larger type of boat cannot enter these harbours. The alternative is that coal, for example, must be imported through Rosslare Harbour or Dublin or Waterford and then transported from these places to towns such as Carlow, Wexford and Wicklow.

I approve of Deputy Blowick's suggestion that part of this money might be applied to afforestation, in addition to what is already provided in the Estimate. Many of us could give a long list of suggestions as to how this money might usefully be spent, and the obvious reply would be that only a limited amount of work can be done with £5,000,000. I think that drainage in rural areas, housing, harbours and afforestation are four admirable headings for general development in this country. I trust that the acting-Minister for Finance will mend his hand and undo the damage which he has undoubtedly done to this discussion and to the general idea of national development. He should list at least some of the national development projects which it is intended to undertake with the moneys in the National Development Fund—and not leave it to Deputy Briscoe or the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach or any other member of this House to suggest, merely by way of interjection, the objects of this Bill. It is the duty of the acting-Minister for Finance to do that. He should have done it this morning. I trust that when he comes to reply to this debate he will be a little more constructive in his attitude and a little more informative than he was when introducing the Bill this morning.

Comment on this

I have the honour of being a member of this House for the past 12 years and during that time I have never seen a Bill as extraordinary and peculiar and strange as this Bill. The National Development Fund Bill was first mentioned by the Taoiseach at Ballinasloe during the South Galway by-election. In the course of a speech which he made there he told his audience that it was the intention of the Government to introduce legislation whereby a large sum of money would be provided for development works in the national interest. He went further and said that the title of the Bill under which this fund would be organised and allocated would be the National Development Fund Bill. It is very strange that it was practically on the eve of a by-election that the Taoiseach promised the National Development Fund Bill and that the country heard nothing further about the matter until now when we are, perhaps, on the threshold of two other by-elections. I have not heard some of the speeches which were made earlier to-day. For my own part, however, I feel that this is a most dishonest piece of political trick-o'-the-loop. In my view, there is no sincerity whatever behind the Bill.

Comment on this

For the Deputy's information, we advocated this last June and July.

Comment on this

This House is asked to vote a very substantial sum of money for the Minister for Finance to spend as he likes. Let me quote Section 4 of the Bill:

"The Minister may apply the fund for the purpose of financing projects which, in his opinion, are projects of development of a public character and are in the national interest."

A scheme which, in the opinion of the Minister for Finance, is of a public character and in the national interest might not, in the opinion of anybody else, be a scheme of a public character or in the national interest. It is very wrong for this House to lend itself to passing legislation which hands over millions of pounds to be spent bythe Minister without his first giving details of the manner in which it is proposed to spend it. There is nothing in this Bill which proves to me that one penny piece will be spent on road works, nor is there anything in it to give us an idea of the amount which will be spent on drainage works. The only thing we can see from the Bill is that the Minister will have power to spend this money at his own discretion and in accordance with his own wishes and desires and that he alone may decide what a scheme of a public character is and whether a scheme is in the national interest or otherwise.

I thought that, when this Bill was circulated, we would find in it a section giving details of what national development schemes were and confining expenditure under the Bill to these various schemes, which should be set out. We should have information as to whether this money is to be spent on road works, on drainage, on the provision of playing grounds or parks in the cities or large provincial towns, on the development of forestry, the construction or reconstruction of parish halls in rural areas or on the repair of cul-de-sac roads, for the maintenance of which country councils have no responsibility and on which they cannot legally spend money, in spite of the fact that the Minister for Local Government on more than one occasion promised to introduce certain legislation which would enable county councils to take over and maintain these cul-de-sac roads. There is nothing in the Bill to show the extent to which money can be spent on any scheme.

Let us assume that the Minister gets an idea for another wild or crazy scheme such as the Dublin Castle scheme. He may feel that it is a scheme in the national interest and a development of a public character. What guarantee have we that this money will not be spent on some of the insane and unsound ideas that have been at the back of the minds of the Fianna Fáil Ministers for many years past? I am strongly opposed to voting large sums of money to Ministers to spend without being given in advancean idea of what the money is to be spent on. If money is to be spent on roads, are we again going to have additional grants made available to local authorities for the taking off of corners and the widening of main roads? If I thought that type of work was to be financed by a measure such as this, I would ask the Minister to see to it that such funds were not spent on work on ordinary main roads but on by-roads, lanes and cul-de-sac roads and on schemes in respect of which local applicants find great difficulty in raising the necessary percentage to qualify for a grant under the rural improvements scheme.

There are many such roadways, lane-ways and byways in rural Ireland and on another occasion some time ago I indicated to the House, and particularly to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, a scheme on which no public money could be spent, a scheme in Ballycommon, County Offaly, where there is a Catholic Church with no road whatever leading to it so that people have to take to the fields to get to Mass. The situation there has now become such that clergy cannot enter the church. The Grand Canal runs beside the church and the repair of the canal line will not be permitted by C.I.E., with the result that it is the only Catholic Church in Ireland to-day——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that is a matter of administration?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

What is the county council doing?

Comment on this

I was merely suggesting to the Minister that a scheme of that kind is a scheme which could be dealt with. There are cases in which county councils have no authority to expend public moneys on roadways which are in the interest of the general public and I think there should be some fund for the provision of roadways to houses of worship. It is most unfortunate that we have this particular case in County Offaly and I believe there are many other similar cases in which the local authority has no function or responsibility. I would pay a compliment to any Minister who would bring forward legislation to enablelocal authorities to spend money in cases where they were prevented from spending in the past.

The Minister said that this is a Bill to provide employment and that is what was at the back of the Taoiseach's mind in Galway when he was endeavouring to capture votes, and succeeded in doing so, on the promise of this and similar legislation. Are we to understand that it is only now the Government realise that there is an unemployment problem in the country? As soon as this sum of £5,000,000 is available for the provision of employment, I should like to know whether the unemployed in a particular area must be registered at the local exchange and whether they will not be employed on these schemes unless they are sent out from the various exchanges. The full benefits of such a scheme will not be made available if we have to depend on the unemployed who register. In the remote parts of Ireland, you will not get people to register. They will not waste their time registering, but will find something else to do—helping a friend or neighbour. They look on signing on at the labour exchange as a waste of time, and I strongly recommend that anybody who is unemployed or who wants to work should be given work and that it should not be confined to those sent out from the labour exchange.

I agree that there is a huge volume of work which can be very usefully undertaken, such as the erection of bridges and the development of all bog roads to assist in the production of turf. In the constituency I represent, no increase in road grants has been given to compensate for the amount of road work which was not undertaken during the emergency, when all the council staffs were engaged in the production of fuel. I feel that in the case of counties like Kildare, Offaly, Laois, Mayo and Kerry, which were particularly concerned in turf production and which, during the years of the emergency, were unable to keep the county roads in a state of proper repair, in recognition of the very great national services rendered by these county councils and workers on turf production, they should at least begiven special financial consideration to bring the roads in their areas up to the same standard as the roads in other counties, where the men were employed all during the emergency.

Under this scheme, I would recommend that the Minister for Finance should ascertain the number of counties actively engaged in turf production during the emergency. When he has ascertained that, he should provide a larger sum of money from the National Development Fund for the county councils who produced turf than for any other county council. Up to this, no special scheme of grants had been provided for those county councils to bring back the county roads or other roads within these counties to at least as good a state as the roads in other areas where county councils were not engaged in turf production.

I should like to hear whether consideration would be given to the provision of funds for the development of sports fields or playgrounds in large provincial towns. There are no funds whatever to provide sports fields or playgrounds. When housing schemes are erected in accordance with the present-day design, you may have anything from 300 to 400 children playing on the streets. We have all seen the rising number of accidents among young children playing on the streets. It is only right that some consideration should be given to the provision of suitable parks or playing grounds. There are no funds available for this purpose to local authorities, urban councils or town commissioners. I think corporations have been given some consideration in this respect. Funds should be provided in order to keep the children off the streets for their own safety.

I do not know whether we are going to have further regulations governing the amount of money to be spent in particular areas or whether the money is going to be provided by the Minister for Finance to the local authority on the amount of work which the various county engineers or town clerks, or whoever is responsible, submit to the Department.

I want to say that it is very late in the day the Government thought ofgiving a helping hand towards the relief of unemployment. I say, as other speakers have properly said, this Bill is a stunt. It has come in practically on Christmas morning to be passed at express speed so that an allocation will probably be made either to Cork City or Louth before the by-elections take place so that it can be used, as has been stated, and rightly so, as an instalment on the purchase of votes to keep the present Government in office. I think this Bill is a bribe. It is nothing but throwing out a sprat to catch a salmon. I think the Bill is nothing short of a very cheap and mean trick for the purpose of purchasing votes at the expense of the taxpayers of this country. If I thought that the Bill was going to have all the useful consequences which Deputy Briscoe said it would have, I might be inclined to pause for a moment to see whether I could give any favourable consideration to the Bill on the merits as he presented them. There is no comparison between what Deputy Briscoe said of the Bill and what the Acting-Minister said when introducing the Bill. From Deputy Briscoe's statement in regard to so much being spent on roads, he seems to know more about the workings of the Bill than the Minister who introduced it. If Deputy Briscoe has that knowledge, I am certain that it is for the purpose of vote-catching. That is the responsible department that Deputy Briscoe for many years has held in Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will not make any charge of that kind. That is a personal charge.

Comment on this

I do not agree. Surely it is a political charge?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

To say that the Deputy is in charge of a department to purchase votes is a personal charge.

Comment on this

What Deputy is that?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know. The Deputy will not make that charge.

Comment on this

That cannot be suggested.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is what the Deputy has suggested.

Comment on this

That could not be taken by any reasonable person.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Am I not reasonable then? I feel that is the charge and the Deputy will not be allowed to make it.

Comment on this

I believe the £5,000,000 will be spent buying votes. That is the charge I make. I believe that the £5,000,000 will be spent on the eve of the by-elections and in those areas where the Government will get the best support and where particular schemes will be submitted by the Fianna Fáil Party and organisation. If we see that this Bill works on the lines suggested by Deputy Briscoe, then we will probably have a different view to express on it when it comes up for review at a later stage. I think the Bill is a very cleverly designed political trick for that purpose. This Bill should be entitled the Vote-catching Fund Bill of 1953.

Comment on this

And you will vote against it.

Comment on this

That in my opinion is what the Bill should be called. I am sorry that any Minister should ask for public moneys to be spent in the fashion provided by this Bill without any consideration whatever being given to providing the details of the schemes which the Bill proposes to have carried out.

Comment on this

I intend to be very brief in regard to this Bill. I sat very patiently for an opportunity to say a few words in regard to the Bill. I listened to and heard a very considerable amount said against the Bill which to my mind was a complete waste of time. This is simply a Bill to provide employment for our people on work of national development. The Clann na Talmhan Party and the Fine Gael Party are opposed to such a measure and their spokesmen spoke ferociously in deriding this Bill.

Deputy Flanagan described the Bill as a dishonest piece of political trickery and Deputy Dillon described it as a dirty fraud. I think we allheard those words, particularly the phrase, "dirty fraud", applied before to describe every scheme of capital development in this country which was designed for the purpose of bettering the lot of our people and improving the national output and income. In replying to the statement of Deputy Flanagan that the Bill was a dishonest piece of political trickery, might I draw attention to the fact that Deputy Mac Fheórais stated the proposal in this Bill was approved of by the trade union movement as far back as last June? Is it suggested that the whole trade union movement is linked up with the Government in a dirty fraud, as Deputy Dillon pointed out, or in a piece of dishonest political trickery, as Deputy Flanagan suggested? There is nothing dishonest or dishonourable in providing a special fund for the provision of employment for our people in work of national development. It is a common-sense policy dictated by the circumstances that prevail in this nation.

It has been suggested that adequate funds could be made available through the annual Estimates for the various Departments and that there is no need to supplement those funds by a special development fund such as is provided here. Those of us who are members of local authorities and those of us who have contact with the ordinary people of the country know that it does very often happen that unemployment might occur in a particular district and through the operation of the various regulations governing the Civil Service it is impossible to apply immediately the funds that are required to relieve that unemployment. Our economic circumstances in this State make it necessary to have such a flexible fund always available to the Government and I am sure the leaders of the trade union movement, who have apparently studied this matter carefully and discussed it with the Government, are convinced that that is so.

Many of our main sources of employment are of a seasonal nature. We have such things as turf production from which men may be disemployed at a particular period of the year. Wehave the beet-growing and sugar-manufacturing industries which are seasonal in their operations. I have experience of the Irish Sugar Company in Carlow having to send out as far as 20 miles from the factory in order to secure men, and I have experience of men having been cut off the dole because they did not consent to travel 20 miles to work. That is an indication that in one particular area at a particular time of the year you may have the need for works. In the Carlow area I can assume that in a few months time the sugar-manufacturing industry will be closed down and a number of men will be thrown on the exchange. That is why we need a special measure such as this in our economic set-up. I would entirely disagree with Deputy Flanagan when he says that work should not be confined to men on the labour exchanges. I think the labour exchanges should be the main source from which the men are taken.

There is always a certain risk in providing large sums of money in a particular area for the relief of unemployment inasmuch as you might draw men away from employment. I had that experience under the Local Authorities (Works) Act when it was in operation in Wicklow and large grants were made available for certain rivers. The net result was that in these areas for a few months—and it happened to be the busiest months of the year—it was almost impossible for farmers to secure workers. The system of employment should be so flexible that we should be able to provide work to suit the number of people on the labour exchanges and take them into employment without disorganising or dislocating in any way the ordinary productive work in the country.

This can be done by dovetailing special employment and work of national development, such as is provided for in this Bill, into our ordinary economic life. We cannot leave the matter entirely to the funds that are provided in the annual Estimates. Circumstances will arise from time to time in which additional money may be required for perhaps a short period in some area and it is very desirable that the Government should have thefunds at their disposal to utilise for this purpose.

Some people supporting this Bill might be inclined to question the wisdom of confining the fund to £5,000,000 per year. I believe there are certain reasons why it is desirable to have some limit. We cannot, as a national Parliament, abrogate our control over expenditure and what the Minister has asked for in introducing this Bill is that a sum amounting to about 3½ per cent. of the total annual Estimate should be given in such a way that it could be applied to any particular purpose for which it might be found necessary.

There is nothing to be condemned in the fact that this Bill is now coming at the end of the session. The Bill has been on the Order Paper for a considerable amount of time and it simply was not reached. As far as the local authorities are concerned they have received information of the grants that are to be provided under this Bill and they are working on schemes to be put into operation. Deputy Dillon suggested that this Bill is designed for the particular constituencies in which by-elections will shortly take place. Those of us who are members of local authorities know that that is not so, that all the details of this scheme have been circulated to all the county councils and they have been asked to prepare schemes with a view to seeing how best the money could be allocated. Deputy Dillon is not a member of a local authority and, therefore, he may be excused for his ignorance in regard to this particular matter. I think he made such a public nuisance of himself in the county council of which he was a member that they got rid of him.

Comment on this

Will we ever stop going into these matters?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There are Ministers of this Government who were treated like that, too.

Comment on this

I am dealing as briefly as I can with this legislation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might have excluded that reference.

Comment on this

It is a very important measure and it has been to a very large extent misrepresented by two speakers from Fine Gael and one speaker from the Clann na Talmhan Party. It is right that the Bill should be presented as it really is, and it is a tribute to Deputy Corish that he has done so. He did make it clear that the purpose of this measure is not in any way associated with political intrigue, fraud or dishonesty, but that it is a measure introduced in consultation with the organised trade union movement. For that reason we can take it that it is reasonably sound. I do not know why some Deputies have to introduce matters connected with agriculture. Deputy Mac Fheórais blamed the acting-Minister for Finance for that, but I do not think that is correct. When Deputy Dillon decides to put on a performance here, he will put it on regardless of how the debate may be going. When he decides to come in his red feathers and hula hula skirt no one can stop him. On one point he should be contradicted emphatically. He claimed that he alone was responsible for the ground limestone scheme and its being supplied to the farmers. Those of us who were in this House in 1946-47 know that the scheme was under way then, and that limestone was being produced. I had the unhappy experience of having to go on a deputation to Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture to protest against his refusal to provide a subsidy for ground limestone. The subsidy was there for burnt lime and Deputy Dillon issued a specific Order prohibiting county committees applying that subsidy to ground limestone. The seven farmer members of the county committee of which I am a member waited on Deputy Dillon at his own office and, to put it figuratively, we were thrown out on our necks; we were told there was no need whatever to subsidise ground limestone. It was only later, when the American E.C.A. representative insisted on its being done, that it was subsidised—nearly two years later. It is foolish of Deputy Dillon to go on in his brazen way asserting that he alone should get the credit for this beneficial scheme.

Some Deputies said the Government waited too long to bring in this Bill and have done nothing until now. There has been a substantial increase in labour employed on capital works over the last two years. The land rehabilitation project was increased in scope and the amount expended on it was increased five-fold over the last three years. We did not have to wait for this Bill in order to find ways and means of providing additional employment. Afforestation and drainage works have been increased. Over and above those, there is need for the special scheme envisaged in this Bill. It will enable the Government to provide special funds in whatever area they are required, by making special grants to the local authorities for drainage or road improvement.

I am not in favour of spending too much of this money on main roads while some larger mileage of the county roads is still unsurfaced. I believe the £1,000,000 being allocated to the county councils under this Bill, or a very large portion of it, will go to the reconstruction of county roads, in the provision of employment, widely distributed over the whole country, as it is work that has a fairly high labour content. Many of our county roads have very narrow surfaces and need to be widened. That means the employment of a considerable amount of local labour in widening those narrow roads and rolling them. In the same way there could be careful investigation of rivers and streams which could be widened and deepened by human labour. This is a matter to which the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, now present, should give close consideration in the Office of Public Works, in consultation with county councils. I had a little experience of such work done in my constituency and in Carlow. In some places there was good work, but there was also bad work in other places. Where it was unsatisfactory it was not due very much to the fault of the engineer but to the urgent need to provide work immediately for large pockets of unemployed.

Comment on this

The Minister forLocal Government blamed it on the engineers.

Comment on this

I suppose that in the last analysis you could express a certain amount of blame. I would say the other factor came into it very strongly. The engineers were trying to provide the labour convenient to these large pockets of unemployment. There were mistakes made in South Carlow.

Comment on this

Surely this is not dealing with the National Development Fund Bill?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter the Deputy is referring to was mentioned earlier in the debate.

Comment on this

Yes, unfortunately a lot of other matters not dealing with development work were mentioned in the debate.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is that a reflection on the Chair?

Comment on this

Not at all; the Chair cannot watch everybody. It is necessary to outline the two main points—that these are flexible funds that can be made over to county councils and used for the reconstruction of roads and for works of drainage wherever suitable. In some counties there is a large volume of such works; in other counties the amount of work is not so great. Between the drainage and the roads it should be possible to absorb the great majority of the unemployed.

Some Deputies have spoken of the desirability of providing various local amenities, playing fields, village halls and so on. In so far as some may have a high labour content, money should be provided for them. At frequent intervals in this House I have strongly advocated the recognition of local or parish councils and the provision of money to them out of local funds to relieve unemployment and to help them to provide these amenities. They could clear derelict sites, provide small gardens, brighten rural districts and villages, provide footpaths and generally add to the amenities of a village, a town or a parish.

As this Bill is a very important one and is a far-reaching measure of reemployedform, in that it provides something which did not exist before in our administrative system, it ought to be welcomed and should not be as violently misrepresented as it has been. It will provide work for a very large number of people scattered throughout the length and breadth of the country. It will not draw those men from existing employment but will take them off the labour exchange. It will raise their standard of living and their standard of self-respect and will also add not only to the local amenities but to the wealth of the nation.

Comment on this

I should like to correct the impression which has been created by the speech just delivered. I made it clear when I spoke on the Taoiseach's Estimate that this Party welcomes any scheme the provision of which would tend towards increased production and greater employment, and that is our attitude now towards this Bill. I do not think it is right or fair that Deputy Cogan should try to misrepresent what Deputy Blowick said. I was not present during the whole of Deputy Blowick's speech, but he did not convey the impression to me which he evidently left on the mind of the Deputy. At any rate, I want to make it quite clear now that as far as I am concerned and this Party are concerned the introduction of any measure which, in our opinion, serves the two-fold object of increasing production and providing employment in rural areas will have our approval. For that reason I am not prepared to accept suggestions which have been made that this measure is put forward for any other purpose. I am prepared to accept that until I find the contrary proved. If and when I do find the contrary proved, I will give voice to my opinions, too. I may say, however, for the information of Deputy Cogan and to have it on the records of this House that, while I do not hold any brief whatever for Deputy Dillon, as Deputy Cogan is aware, he was not got rid of from Roscommon County Council. He resigned from Roscommon County Council, and while he was there he proved a very valuable member of that council.

My main reason for intervening in this debate is this. It has been indicated to-day, and it was indicated at our county council meeting, that the ratio of expenditure under this scheme as between drainage and roads will be in the nature of ten to one; that is, that for every £1 spent on drainage there will be about £10 spent on roads. It is with that point alone that I want to deal. I think that that is a mistake both from the point of view of the productive value of the scheme and from the point of view of employment. It is quite obvious, as far as the Local Government Department are concerned, that when they come to road expenditure they have in mind main roads. I submit that the expenditure of large sums of money on main roads does not serve either of the two objects which this scheme should serve, because (1) it does not provide the labour content which minor roads would provide, and (2) it does not increase production.

If we proposed that a ten-to-one ratio should exist in favour of the drainage of land, I think that scheme would be a very considerable improvement because, as was indicated in the Taoiseach's speech, our first important consideration is increased production, and we can never maintain the services or the standard of living we have without a constant effort to increase production. The essential preliminary to increased production is the drainage of the land, because it is the principal weapon by which we can bring about increased production. The Taoiseach indicated quite clearly that he accepted that as an axiom of his policy, and I was gratified to hear the Taoiseach agree with what I said on his Estimate, that our production can be stepped up 50 per cent. by the application of fertilisers.

I do not want to enter into the discussion as to who was responsible for the introduction of the ground limestone scheme or who was not. I am not interested in that as long as the scheme is there. But ground limestone alone will not bring about the fertility and the production which we would all like to see. It is a useful adjunct, but it is not sufficient initself, as ground limestone only assists other fertilisers to bring about the fertility necessary for increased production. If, as a result of this Bill, some system could be introduced that would make fertilisers more readily available to the farmer I believe that we would reap vast benefit from it.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy admit that there are great tracts of land in this country on which you can put all the phosphate and potash you can pour on them but unless at the same time you correct the calcium standard you will not get any increased production?

Comment on this

I am accepting that. I also want the Minister to bear in mind, however, that there are areas of land in this country which are not capable of full production but which are not in need of lime. Does the Minister accept that?

Comment on this

Yes, but they are only a tiny fraction of the total.

Comment on this

I would not think so. What I want to bring to the Government's attention, and I do not want this to be taken as opposition to the scheme, is that in my view it is far more important to spend public money on the drainage and the improvement of the land than on the roads. When it is indicated that £1,000,000 will be spent on roads and £100,000 on land drainage, I say to the Government, and I would say it if I were a member on the Government side, that it is a mistake. If you reverse the ratio and spend your £1,000,000 on the land and your £100,000 on the roads, you will be rendering far greater service to the community.

I feel that very much of this money which will be spent on roads will be spent on roads which are already quite good enough, will be spent on removing corners, as has been stated, and that the roads which ordinary people really need will be neglected. You can spend a colossal amount with advantage on roads far removed from main roads, because in many rural areas I know that farmers cannot get threshing machines intotheir haggards because there is no access to them. They cannot get tractors into their fields to do tillage because of the condition of the narrow little boreens leading to their homes and to the fields. In this age, when agricultural mechanisation is growing every year, how can we claim that we are assisting the farmer towards increased production if we do not recognise his difficulties and endeavour by expenditure on a scheme like this to remove the many obstacles which are in his way and which he is labouring under and will continue to labour under? Can he hope that this measure, valuable and all as it is, will make his problems any more easy if he sees the ratio of expenditure of public money ten to one against the drainage of the land?

During the next five, or perhaps ten years, State money could, and should, be usefully spent on the drainage of land. I do not want anyone to think that I want the farmers pampered. I do not, but I want it borne in mind constantly that our one hope of survival here is the improvement of agricultural production. When mention was made here to-day about the recovery in our balance of payments position, I wonder did it occur to people how that was brought about? I suggest that it was brought about almost entirely, if not entirely, by agricultural exports, in the main of live stock. There are many in this House, and outside of it, who contend that the farmer who produces live stock is a national loss and that, because he does not embark on tillage, he is not doing his duty. If we had to depend on the export of tillage crops— potatoes, corn, root crops and so on— could we ever hope to reduce the balance of payments which, while they exist, adversely affect the national economic interest? It is pure nonsense to suggest that anything, other than our live-stock industry, is the important industry here. I know full well that tillage is a valuable asset in the production of live stock. It helps it enormously, but what is important is what is walked off the land from the produce we get from our tillage. Our greatest asset in agriculture is represented by our store cattle.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be getting away from the Bill.

Comment on this

I only mentioned it because the Minister referred to the question here this morning. It is to be regretted that the Minister for Local Government was not present at this debate because it is obvious that this scheme will be operated almost entirely by his Department. Therefore, I think it only right that he should have heard the views of Deputies in this debate. I think that the best thanks of Deputies, on all sides, are due to Deputy Briscoe for his exposition of the scheme. Without that exposition, many Deputies who are not members of local authorities would have found it very difficult to follow what is in the mind of the Government.

Comment on this

Are you contending that Deputy Briscoe was speaking on behalf of the Government? Did he not only make his contribution the same as any other Deputy?

Comment on this

He explained the scheme as it is intended, I understand, by the Government. In view of what I was told at a meeting of my own local authority, I am prepared to accept what Deputy Briscoe has said as being correct. I think myself that this debate could have been ended long ago if it had not been for the uninformative way in which it was introduced. I want to say, in conclusion, that I think it is highly desirable that Ministers should present their facts clearly to the House, because if not it is quite possible that erroneous opinions may be formed and that acrimonious discussions, which otherwise would not take place, will ensue.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay the House very long. I understand that this Bill will deal with depressed areas. I would ask the Minister to take a particular interest in two very depressed towns in my constituency, Passage and Kinsale. They are ghost towns, not due to any fault on the part of individuals in those areas, but rather to the fact that times havechanged. The shipbuilding industry has been removed to Dublin, and Kinsale was a garrison town. If the Minister has a lot of money to use for the development of industries, I think he should consider these two very depressed areas in the County Cork.

I have been trying to take an intelligent interest in the discussion that we have had on this Bill. I may say that I am in a complete fog as regards the Government's policy and the policy of the Opposition. As far as I can gather, the Opposition want the Government to do certain things that are quite impossible, certain things which the Opposition would never even suggest doing themselves if they were on the Government Benches. I do not subscribe to, nor do I believe in, a policy of a person saying: "You do something that I would not do if I were there." I know, of course, that if the Government were on the Opposition Benches they would do exactly the same. They would exploit every weakness which they could find in an inter-Party Government and would say: "Why are you not doing this, that or the other thing?" Obviously, the inter-Party Government could not do the things which the Opposition would ask them to do.

I think that we should have some respect for the intelligence of the people in the country. There is no use in the Opposition now asking the Government to do some things, because we are in the very fortunate position that we have a very intelligent electorate.

Deputy Blowick, when speaking, indicated that he wanted to disperse all our external assets. I think it would be a bad thing for us to disperse or to get rid of our external assets. I know that Deputy Hickey will refer to me as "Lehane, the reactionary Deputy", but I think it is a very safe and sound thing to have credit that is more or less internationally recognised. If we had not that credit, we would have to buy everything on the name of the goods and services of the Twenty-Six Counties. If we were Ireland, which we are not, we could probably give a blank cheque and say, "Ireland will pay this", but we are not Ireland; weare only the Twenty-Six Counties of Ireland. A great deal has been said about development and about Borders and, again, even at the risk of being called reactionary by Deputy Hickey——

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy make his own speech and not mind about mine. I have certain views and let the Deputy not attempt to interpret my mind.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that I believe a great deal of harm is being done in relation to the development of this country by speakers from the Opposition Benches who make outlandish statements. I am an Independent Deputy. I can make any statement I like. I do not tie anybody to anything.

Comment on this

Like Mahomet's coffin —in mid-air.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Lehane should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I am not like Mahomet's coffin at all. I will leave it at that. I am an Independent Deputy. I have stated my policy. Deputy Hickey has described it as reactionary. We have on one side of the House, Deputies speaking from the same benches with completely different policies. I want to know where I am. I will support the Government, as I have already announced, in any question of development in relation to this country and in relation to the maintenance of law and order. I now want both the Government and the Opposition to tell me what their respective policies are. Deputy Cafferky says "Mahomet's coffin". I want to know where I am with Fine Gael. I want to know where I am with Labour.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows where he is with Labour.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey tells me I am reactionary.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Personally, I think I amthe most progressive Deputy in this House.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entitled to his opinion.

Comment on this

I am dubbed reactionary because I object to increased expenditure being laid on the people as a whole to provide the plums that Labour, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael are dangling in front of them. I believe that our people are, or were, a decent, respectable people who do not want any free this, that or the other until these plums are dangled in front of them by the Labour Party, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. There is now a sort of competition between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, and this Bill is just another effort in that respect. I have come to the use of reason and, if this £5,000,000 is now being dangled before the people, I think I am legitimately entitled to ask the Minister to use some of that money in the two depressed areas in my constituency, even though I disagree with the policy. I think I am reasonably entitled to point out to the Minister that there are two very depressed areas in my constituency and he should consider them in relation to this £5,000,000.

Deputy Blowick, speaking earlier to-day, mentioned the fact that turkeys are being sold at 10/- apiece. I have turkeys at home. I have sold turkeys. If Deputy Blowick will give me turkeys at 10/- apiece I guarantee I will resell them at a very considerable profit. I have been looking in the shop windows, in Lipton's and in a number of other places, and I saw small, miserable turkeys marked £2 10s. and £2 7s. 6d. These statements are ridiculous. When we come in here as representatives of the people we should have a certain sense of responsibility and there should be some little weight behind what we say. When we come in and talk utter nonsense, the prestige of this House is lowered.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I believed that the introduction of this measure would meet with the unanimous approval of every Deputy here. I was here for the introduction this morning and I was amazed, if not disgusted, when I heard the speeches made by Opposition Deputies. Deputy Dillon's speech canonly be stigmatised as one calculater to lower the reputation of this House everywhere. He described this measure as a dirty fraud. I do not think it is good politics, even for an Opposition Deputy, to describe something introduced for the benefit of the country as a dirty fraud. Deputy Dillon referred to it as a prostitution of Santa Claus. I do not think there is any justification for such an attack.

I do not come from either of the areas in which by-elections are pending but I come from an area where capital development is very badly needed. I am perfectly satisfied we will get our fair share of anything that is going, irrespective of whether or not there is a by-election pending. I am perfectly satisfied that by-elections have nothing whatsoever to do with the introduction of this measure at this stage, and to portray us as having been influenced by such events is a mean political trick which will not redound to the credit of any Party here.

I can understand the mentality of Deputy Dillon when he tries to portray this measure in the light of the circumstances in which he painted it to-day. I have a pretty good recollection and I remember a by-election held not so very long ago in West Donegal. Prior to the lamented decease of the Deputy concerned the land rehabilitation project was launched by Deputy Dillon. It applied to a number of counties, but Donegal was not one of them. Indeed, Donegal was more or less on the long finger then in relation to the counties to which the scheme would apply. The Deputy was not dead a week when the scheme was switched to Donegal. That was simply a political trick; and there was not a single inspector at the disposal of any Department, particularly the Department of Agriculture, who was not rushed into West Donegal at that time. I remember canvassing votes in a very congested area of that constituency and as one was going in the front door the free chick inspector was going out the back door. The people were so confused they did not know who was who.

The man who was behind that is theman who now comes in here and accuses this Government of introducing this measure because there are by-elections pending. In all fairness, it must be admitted that this scheme was announced long before any of these by-elections could be foreseen.

Comment on this

It was announced in the middle of a by-election.

Comment on this

It is when there are by-elections that we hear about these things. That, in itself, is rather peculiar.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Fianna Fáil have brought in many schemes and, let it be said to their credit, they have been administered fairly and squarely. This scheme will be administered in the same way. As a member of the Fianna Fáil Party I have absolute confidence that the scheme will be administered fairly and that not one penny will be improperly devoted to the two constituencies in which by-elections are pending. I am satisfied we will all get our share and I would not support this measure if I did not think that were true.

An attempt is being made to blacken this scheme by pronouncing it a dirty fraud. At some future date when this fund will have been found to be the most useful fund ever established, as it is bound to be, the Opposition will be sorry that they ever branded it in the way they did to-day. I can see the desirability of having a fund of this type. Those of us who have experienced the red tape and the intricacies surrounding every scheme for which money is required will appreciate how necessary it is to have a fund such as this which will allow of some elasticity so that we can go ahead with urgently needed schemes without delay. There are all sorts of ramifications when one approaches Government Departments; there are reports and counter-reports, approvals and submissions, inspections which go on and on and, finally, there is the difficulty of getting the money out of the Department of Finance. A fund of this type will short-circuit a good deal of the red tape at present involved in getting schemes under way. We will, in future, be in a position topromote schemes of urgent national importance without undue delay. That is why I think this is a good scheme.

Deputy Lehane mentioned some areas in his own constituency which require attention. Every Deputy here could mention 100 schemes in his own constituency for which he would like to get funds. We do not expect to get approval for all our schemes, but we do expect to get our just share of this fund. The fund out of which these moneys will come will not be to us a dirty fraud. This measure will be administered irrespective of political affiliations and nobody here believes anything to the contrary. Nevertheless, there are Deputies who will stand up here and say the contrary in order to damn the scheme at the outset. There never was a useful scheme introduced here that Opposition Deputies did not endeavour to damn it at the outset. I listened to the speeches made on another occasion on the introduction of a very beneficial measure. I refer to the Undeveloped Areas Act. The statements made in relation to that measure have not been justified by the passage of time.

Comment on this

That is a dead measure.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Not so dead at all. Deputy Dillon to-day discussed the entire scope of his office while he held it. He referred to the emigration figures as if emigration was something that only started in 1951. I think there is far too much propaganda being made in relation to emigration. Can anybody gainsay the fact that during the years in which the Coalition was in office, with Marshall Aid and money from various other sources, 40,000 people left this country? I do not accuse the Coalition Government of deliberately sending them away but let us recognise the fact that they did just as little, if not less, to stop emigration as any other Government.

The Local Authorities (Works) Act is held up as something that was supposed to be a panacea for all our ills. That measure had some good points and it had some bad points. The money spent under that Act was money spent on schemes of atemporary nature. While it provided employment for a time for those who would otherwise be registered as unemployed, it did not keep one solitary individual from emigrating because no man would stay at home for the sake of a fortnight's work on a drain along a roadside. I have always said that, too, in relation to special employment schemes. Such schemes do not create a feeling among the people that they can stay at home and look forward to permanent and stable employment. Such schemes are of a purely temporary nature. I would rather see ten men going into permanent employment in a factory than 100 men employed on what can only be described as a relief scheme for a fortnight. As far as I remember other counties got far more money under the Local Authorities (Works) Act than did Donegal. The money was strictly confined to drains along the roads or directly associated with main and county roads. We had a B. list which deviated slightly from that but, in the strict terms of the circular issued to local authorities at the time, the work done had to have some connection with county or main roads.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

That was our interpretation of the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will permit me to say so, it was a misinterpretation.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

If that is so, I would like to know if under that scheme local authorities were permitted to go in and drain a farmer's land one mile from the county road?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I have listened to this Local Authorities (Works) Act being discussed for a long time. I have listened to election speeches in which we were condemned for not taking full advantage of it. The fact is that we submitted schemes for much more than we were allowed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see how that arises on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Play has been made on that in this debate; otherwise I would be slow in referring to it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going into too much detail.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I will leave it at that. A circular has been issued to every local authority in the country in relation to this National Development Fund. Deputy Dillon insinuated that it was introduced for the benefit of two constituencies which were already informed and compiling schemes. We are compiling schemes in Donegal at the moment for submission under this measure and we are very hopeful that a fair proportion of them will be sanctioned. We would be very jealous if any county got more than their just share of the money. I have not the slightest fear that that will happen. I take a very poor view of the effort to brand the Bill as a measure brought in for ulterior purposes, for political corruption.

Deputy Dillon went to great pains to explain that stockpiling took place just before the Coalition Government went out of office and that it was the depletion of stocks that caused the slump. If stockpiling took place, as he insinuated, as a result of laxity in regard to bank credit, it was very ill-advised and had serious reactions on the national economy.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot have been listening to the Taoiseach last night.

Comment on this

Did not stockpiling take place arising out of the Korean war?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

If stockpiling took place, the manner in which it did was very ill-advised. The County of Donegal is not industrialised, unfortunately, but the people of Donegal jealously watch and guard the few industries they have and for which they have a tradition, such as the manufacture of cloth second to none in the world and knitwear of first quality. What was the position of theseindustries as a result of stockpiling? When Deputy Lemass was returned to power he imposed an embargo on the importation of woollen goods as our industries were almost ready to close because imported knitwear was selling at a lower price than the price at which we could produce in our factories in Donegal.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be getting away from the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I am replying to the insinuation that stockpiling was essential. Our few industries were almost on the verge of closing down as a result of stockpiling and it was not until an embargo was imposed on the importation of these commodities that they got into full swing and reached the happy position that they are in to-day, with workers on full time and overtime, exporting high class goods rather than importing inferior substitutes. The Government which allowed stockpiling to take place, whether in the guise of precaution against war or anything else, was not carrying out the duty that is imposed on any responsible Government. They add insult to injury by coming into this House two years afterwards to hold up that policy as a laudable policy and to take credit for it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not seem to have any relation to the Bill before the House.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Did the Deputy hear the Taoiseach's reply last night?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I am not refuting one word that the Taoiseach said. That type of stockpiling did unfortunately take place. The depletion of the stocks caused many headaches to shopkeepers and manufacturers and workers who were on short time. What is the position of firms like Salts of Tullamore at the moment?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does this relate to the National Development Fund that is at present before the House?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

To be quite honest, it has no relation to it. I am replying to statements made, in spite of attempts to keep him to the point, by Deputy Dillon. Any Deputy who was in the House at that time would agree that he dealt in detail with these matters and I feel that I have some right to reply. Any Deputy who was not present can read the official report of his speech.

Comment on this

I hope I will be allowed to follow the same road.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I agree that these matters are not strictly related to the measure before the House. The fund for national development covers any or every grant. Deputy Dillon said it covers even slush. I have no misgivings about the administration of the measure. I am perfectly satisfied that it is a good measure that will be used to finance important projects of national development. I have no fear that it will be used in a corrupt political manner.

One can see the object of the Opposition in trying to brand this as a political measure. It is a good measure but in order to serve their purpose, the best line is to attack it at the outset and to condemn it in the minds of the people.

I welcome the measure as a step in the right direction. In so far as it may help to speed projects of national development that would otherwise remain in abeyance for years it should be welcomed by every Deputy.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The country and the House should be able to draw a picture from the Budget statement of the Government's proposals for the year. One remarkable statement in the Budget speech for the current year was that economies to the extent of £3,500,000 would be effected. Now, on the very eve of Christmas, the acting-Minister for Finance comes into the House and adopts as his Christmas carol: "Give me £5,000,000 more." We cannot be blamed if we associate this proposal with by-elections because it was originally announced by the Taoiseach at a political rally in the largest town of a constituency in which a by-election was in progress.

Comment on this

How long ago?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

During the South Galway by-election, in Ballinasloe.

Comment on this

Is not that sufficient notice for you?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It was mentioned there and introduced there and conceived during a by-election, and it is now put before us in these rushed few hours before Christmas.

Comment on this

That is a most unworthy statement.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is claimed that it is designed for work of national development. As I understand the procedure, each Department estimates its expenditure 12 months in advance and the Minister outlines the proposals for expenditure in the Budget statement. If something unforeseen arises in the course of the year, as the acting-Minister for Finance referred to, he is at liberty to come before the House and by way of a Supplementary Estimate obtain the additional moneys that may be required, but he is required before obtaining those moneys to give an indication of the works for which they are intended. This morning the acting-Minister gave details as regards £1,500,000 of the £5,000,000.

I would support Deputy Finan in saying that the proposed ratio of spending £1,000,000 on roads compared with £500,000 under the Local Authorities (Works) Act development is not a good one. If the work under that scheme which was interrupted a couple of years ago was continued the country would now be able to make an even greater contribution to increased production. Many works under the land project have been delayed because of the practical cessation of work under that scheme. I put a question to the Minister for Local Government quite some time ago as to what was expended in Cork County in the previous year under that scheme and he told me it was £48,000. I asked him what was proposed to be spent under it this year and he said half of that amount, £24,000. Consequently there was no intimation to the staffs of the countycouncils that they might expect any increased moneys under this. They got no opportunity to pave the way for the work which is now proposed. This is a complete reversal of Government attitude to the good work that can be done under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. When a motion was put here by the Clann na Talmhan Party the member of the Cabinet responsible in his reply indicated that he was not in a position to accept its terms. The Tanaiste's statement that the Government had at last seen the light and was now prepared to give even £500,000 towards this scheme is something to be welcomed, because we have ever held the view that there was never a scheme initiated which gave such valuable employment in the rural areas and did such valuable work for people who needed it most as did that scheme. As well as that, without going into further detail much road repairs would have been completely unnecessary if the work had persisted which operated some years ago under that Act.

Deputy Brennan seemed to be surprised to know that it was possible to get work done under that Act far removed from main roads. My experience was that in my local authority area such work was carried out under the Act, but some priority was given, naturally, where possibly roads were in danger by flooding before attention was given to those secondary streams and rivers. I would ask the Minister for Local Government to see that those schemes which were put forward by local representatives and sanctioned by the county engineers as being valuable works and were then left in abeyance when the moneys were curtailed would now get priority in the expenditure of the proportion of this fund designed to renew operations under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

I agree with Deputy Finan that we have been pretty generous towards road improvements in recent times and that the degree of labour content in the operations that have been in progress has not been enough to ease the situation which the acting-Ministerfor Finance described so clearly this morning as being not so good. It is hoped that the implementation of these moneys will in some way mitigate the circumstances in which people have had to exist—people in unemployment, people in part-time employment throughout the country in the course of the last two years. If Deputies on the Government side feel that we are unfair in ascribing any political motives to them I would say that we will be extremely watchful that no political credit will be looked for by some local potentates arising out of the distribution of moneys under this, that any schemes introduced will be legitimate ones, and that it will be realised that it is the country that is putting up the money and not the Party in office. Deputy Cogan referred to employment on the land project having been increased fivefold. That is a good tribute to the scheme which Deputy Brennan says Deputy Dillon initiated at a time when Deputy Brennan was unsuccessful in a by-election in Donegal.

The Deputy, unfortunately, again resurrected a matter which was very controversial some time ago and which was completely disposed of by the Taoiseach last night. That was in relation to the stockpiling of the inter-Party Government in their time. The vindication by the Taoiseach last night was one which I thought would not be questioned by any member of the House, let alone a member of the Taoiseach's Party, and it comes badly from a Party which in the last year of their office before the inter-Party Government took over brought into this country £1,250,000 worth of Dutch chocolates which are still cluttering up the shelves of unfortunate small shops throughout rural Ireland.

These are the comments I would propose to make on this measure. Some left-handed references were made by the acting-Minister for Finance to the advisability of farmers extending the ground limestone scheme and using more fertilisers. He did not indicate that any of these moneys would be directed to reducing in some way the difficulties farmers have in paying the very high prices charged forfertilisers to-day. They recognise the need for fertilisers, but at a time when perhaps they are incurring additional expense in relation to rural electrification, mechanising their holdings, increasing many of their activities, though realising the importance of increased production they may not be able to face additional costs. After all, it is recognised by all Parties that costs have increased considerably in recent years, and if it would be possible for some of this money to be set aside towards in some way reducing the cost of fertilisers to the farmers it would serve a very useful purpose. As a little measure towards that aim the Government should remove the present tax, the £12,000 profit which the Exchequer is making on the land of this country by the tax on fertilisers.

I was amazed that Deputy Lehane, in the course of his remarks following some earlier statements by Deputy Blowick, said that he was in a position to make some considerable profit this year out of selling turkeys. My information from my constituency is that there was never a Christmas in which cottiers' wives, small farmers' wives or daughters, who looked to doing their Christmas shopping out of their little income they would get from turkeys, did so badly. They looked to the returns, extremely well earned, after overcoming the many hazards that face turkey rearers. Deputy Lehane states that notwithstanding the reduced prices this year some profit accrued. He may have been fortunate. Deputy Blowick told us about people getting 10/- a head for turkeys.

Comment on this

That is not the full story about 10/- a turkey. The Deputy said he could get £2 10s. That was all.

Comment on this