National Development Fund Bill, 1953—Second Stage.
Contributions 410–609 of 609. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 32 of 1953 ›
The Deputy went a little further than that. This is a matter on which any representative from the rural areas could very well inform the Minister. The unfortunate people in the rural areas rearing and producing birds were in an extremely hazardous position, and the indications are that they are discouraged to the point that next year production may reveal their discouragement.
Comment on this
I can inform the Parliamentary Secretary that as far as my constituency goes I know of no market where 4/- a lb. was paid.
Comment on this
The consumer may pay 4/- but the producer would not get it.
Comment on this
I understand that an election is fast approaching in his constituency and naturally he is interested in the consumer, and more concerned about the price the consumer has to pay at the moment. I would say to any representative of the consuming interest in this House that there will be scarcity prices next Christmas that will amaze them, seeing that the organisation which existed and which ensured some fair play to producer and consumer was completely wiped away by the present Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
All I am saying is that I read a report in the papers yesterday that 4/- per lb. was paid at a certain market for turkeys.
Comment on this
It may interest the Parliamentary Secretary to know that the radio broadcast that turkeys were sold at a market in my constituency at 3/10 per lb. whereas, as a matter of fact, I know that they were sold as low as 1/4 per lb.
Comment on this
I want to say that the prices obtaining this year in my constituency have been considerably less than in former years notwithstanding increased production costs. In consequence, we shall have scarcity prices obtaining in future years since people will not feed turkeys. The inasloecome of these people in rural areas has been considerably reduced this Christmastide because of this development. I merely mention that in passing. I consider the moneys which we are now asked to vote towards this Development Fund could have been voted at any time by way of a Supplementary Estimate and made applicable to particular expenditure. To bring in a proposal in this fashion, throw it on the table and say that you want £5,000,000 more without giving complete details of the manner in which it is proposed to expend the money is not, I suggest, the proper way to approach Parliament with a Bill of this nature. One Deputy has remarked that a succeeding speaker gave more information than the Minister, but I say that it is the duty of the Minister who introduced the Bill to give us the details of the proposed expenditure, since the authority which this Bill confers on the Government will be exercised by the Minister. A full explanation of the purpose of the measure should be vouchsafed to the House by the Minister so as to enable other Parties in the House to make up their minds as to the attitude they should adopt in regard to it. There was no clear indication from the Minister as to what this sum is required for. I would repeat in conclusion that the Bill does not seem to be in keeping with the solemn undertaking given by the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement, and that, in a year in which we were told the Government were about to embark on a record borrowing spree, not alone is no effort being made to bring about the £3,500,000 economies which the Minister wants, but the Government now come in with an additional demand for £5,000,000.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Labour Party I am supporting this Bill. I think it is regrettable that we should have any opposition to the proposal to provide £5,000,000 to finance schemes of public work. I treat the remarks of Deputy Lehane, when he said that we were dangling a carrot before the eyes of the people, with contempt. I want to tell Deputy Lehane that it is a very poor carrot to dangle before the67,400 people who are looking for work and cannot get it. When Deputy Lehane presumes to lecture other members of the House as to the manner in which they should exercise their responsibilities here, I think that Deputy Lehane should try to apply that lecture to himself. What are we asked for in this Bill? The Dáil is being asked to vote £5,000,000 which it is proposed to expend on schemes to provide employment. Spread that amount over the Twenty-Six Counties and it works out at something like £192,307 per county or £74 per unemployed worker registered at our labour exchanges. It is annoying, not to say disgusting, to have to listen to some of the things that were raked up while we were discussing this question of providing money to develop our country. Who will deny that we have in this country a wide scope for productive work on the lands and in the factories? We have this huge army of unemployed labour, men whose skill has gone for nought over a number of years.
I think it well to point out that it is only usefully employed labour that can create social values and that all the money in the country could not put one brick on top of another, unless labour is employed. Listening to the debate here one would be almost convinced that the £ was mightier than the people. That is the mentality that has been displayed here since 10.30 a.m. this morning. I would suggest to the acting-Minister for Finance and the Government that £5,000,000 is not even enough to ensure that all our unemployed people will be provided with work. It is only when we produce goods and services and thereby provide work for our unemployed that we can maintain and improve our standards of living. If that conviction were impressed on Deputies on all sides of the House, we would not be wasting the time of the House in discussing whether we should give the Government permission to spend £5,000,000 on developing the country. Deputies should try to remember all the things that await development. Just think for a moment how agriculture could be developed by the expenditure of a further £5,000,000. I suggest too thatif we could purchase half a dozen ships, that would have the result of raising the standard of living of our people all round. There are hundreds of other things on which we could employ not alone £5,000,000 but £50,000,000 if it could be made available.
I suggest to Deputies who spoke in criticism of the proposed expenditure that they should give a little more serious consideration to matters of this kind. I do not propose to waste the time of the House further in dealing with some of the nonsensical talk we heard here. I am only sorry that it is not proposed to spend a much larger sum than £5,000,000 to provide work for the large number of our people who are at present unemployed.
Comment on this
I thought this morning that this Bill would be welcomed from every side of the House. Therefore, I was amazed when I heard Deputy Blowick, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Oliver Flanagan indulging in a most reckless criticism of the Bill. They would remind one of three novice heavyweights, swinging around without any sense of direction or balance whatever. They attacked this Bill and pointed out that as far as Dublin was concerned there was a fear that it would get too much money. We in Dublin welcome this Bill because we see that under it we shall be able to provide employment for at least 1,200 persons. I do not see what is wrong with that. I should like to know what the Fine Gael Dublin Deputies say about it. We have heard all sorts of cries that we should try to keep the unemployed off the streets. We say that if we get £500,000 spent under this Bill we should be able to provide useful work to take the unemployed off the streets. Only last week Deputy Blowick was crying salt tears about the condition of the Dublin people and saying that they could not get even clothes to wear. I am still looking forward to Deputy Blowick coming in here sometime in his underwear, having given his suit of clothes to some unemployed person outside.
Comment on this
Time and again on the various Estimates we hear references to work that should be done in Dublin. I remember Deputy O. Flanagan worrying because he could not get safely down from here to O'Connell Bridge owing to the density of traffic. He said that the traffic was something dreadful and that something should be done about it. Under this Bill we get 75 per cent. of the cost of building bridges in Dublin. What is wrong with that? It will provide useful work which should have been done 30 years ago. We will get an 80 per cent. grant towards amenity schemes and a 75 per cent. grant for civic offices.
I said on a previous Estimate that it is grand to see the provincial Deputies fighting their own corner. I can tell the Labour Party—who are claiming that they went to see the Taoiseach in June, and so forth—that Fianna Fáil Deputies went to see the Taoiseach long before June last and put up schemes and mentioned plans to provide employment when we had the money. We are not boasting about what we did. We feel that it is our duty to do that and I do not think anyone should claim credit for doing his duty.
What amazes me are the things which Deputy Dillon says in his reckless moods. He says that we always introduce a Bill of this type on the eve of a by-election. Deputy D.J. O'Sullivan followed along the same lines: it seems to be the Fine Gael Party line. The script-writers of Hume Street must have given them that line and they are following every word of it. You must remember that Fianna Fáil reduced the food subsidies when a by-election was pending. That was, if you like, a dangerous time to do such a thing. Still, we had the courage to do it because we considered that it was necessary. We will not go into all the reasons why it was necessary: that was explained last night by the Taoiseach. It must also be remembered that when the Shannon Airport project was first mooted, Deputy Dillon looked upon it as a crazy and a daft scheme and he referred to rabbits trotting around Shannon Airport.We were also told that the Bill to encourage the establishment of industries in the West of Ireland was a crazy scheme and a by-election scheme. Whatever motives the Opposition may allege, the results are good and that is what we want. I do not think we should approach the consideration of this Bill in a destructive fashion. Our approach should be that this Bill will do a lot of good and that it is needed.
During his speech this morning, Deputy Dillon got on to the subject of housing and once more attacked the Dublin Corporation. Any time, I try to answer remarks like that, I am told that I am out of order and that my remarks do not apply to whatever is under discussion at the time. It amazes me that members of the Opposition Front Bench, and even some members of the Government Front Bench, can get away with certain things while an insignificant backbencher like myself cannot——
Comment on this
I withdraw it, Sir, and I am sorry. I saw you looking towards me and I thought that you were about to tell me that I could not go into the matter of housing.
Comment on this
This morning, Deputy Dillon then got on to the subject of the increased interest charges on borrowings under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. He again claimed that there was a complete slowing-up in the building of houses due to the increased rates of interest. I should like, if it is in order for me to do so, to point out that the figurescertainly give the lie to Deputy Dillon's assertion. It is constantly being asserted by Opposition Deputies that the increase in the rate of interest, which took place in October, 1952, was mainly responsible for the slowing-up in the housing drive. The figures prove that there has been an increase of 50 per cent. in the issue of such loans between 1950 and 1952 in Dublin. In 1951-52 there were 2,181 loans, the amount advanced being £2,273,435. In 1952-53, there were 3,032 loans and well over £3,000,000 was alvanced by the Dublin Corporation. I think that these figures prove that Deputy Dillon's charge that the increased rates of interest have had the effect of slowing-up house building in Dublin is unfounded. We have 1,500 applications, and we are dealing with them as fast as possible. So far as the Government and Dublin Corporation are concerned, we are satisfied that there will be no shortage whatsoever of money for house building in Dublin.
Deputy Dillon referred to some acquaintance of his who is living in one room with four other persons and who cannot get a house. It is a pity that Deputy Dillon was not present in the House this morning when Deputy Briscoe was replying to that point. The impression which Deputy Dillon gave was that these five persons were living in one room. We have since checked up on that statement with the city manager and the Dublin Corporation, and it would appear that the man's mother-in-law is living in the next room. The position, therefore, is that five persons are living in two rooms. That is the reason for the holdup in that case. I hope that Deputy Dillon will agree that it is a question of five persons living in two rooms.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Gallagher would not recommend that they should all get together in the one room?
Comment on this
Nobody is more active than I am in getting houses forpeople. I know Dublin just as well as Deputy Dillon knows it.
Comment on this
Look at the Mayor of Drogheda. He is breaking his back in an effort to give Deputy Gallagher a word of advice.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon should cease interrupting Deputy Gallagher. These interruptions are disorderly.
Comment on this
The Mayor of Drogheda nearly fell out of his seat in trying to say something to Deputy Gallagher.
Comment on this
I will let it go at that. I welcome this Bill and we in Dublin welcome it because it means that we shall be able to get sufficient money to put at least 1,000 to 1,200 persons in employment. We in Dublin will make sure to avail of every opportunity to get our schemes going. I am a member of the works committee of the Dublin Corporation. We have placed many schemes before the Department of Local Government and I am satisfied that we will get co-operation there and get people to work on them.
This Bill should be welcomed by all sides of the House. It is a question of giving employment to persons who need it. We should not, therefore, be treated to reckless speeches by Deputy Dillon, Deputy Blowick and Deputy Oliver Flanagan.
Comment on this
I join with Deputies on all sides of the House in welcoming this Bill. The very fact that it has been introduced is an admission by the Government of the seriousness of the present situation so far as unemployment is concerned. Even at this late hour, so close to Christmas, they are making an effort—"small and all as it is", in the words of Deputy Hickey—to bring about some easement in the situation. Undoubtedly, £5,000,000 is a small sum when it is allocated between 26 counties and 27 local authorities. When you consider all the circumstances, it is obvious that it will not do a great deal of good,but nevertheless the Bill is to be welcomed because it is a sign that the Government appreciate how things stand outside Dublin City.
I am in full agreement with Deputy Finan that the Government should see to it that a big percentage of this money which will be allocated to the various local authorities in rural Ireland will be spent on drainage. I think that the Taoiseach and the Minister realise full well that drainage is a very important factor in our agricultural life. As my colleague pointed out, we cannot have increased production unless our land is properly drained. We cannot apply fertilisers or ground limestone to waterlogged land. That would be futile, a waste of money and a waste of good materials. Neither can you avail of the Land Rehabilitation Scheme unless the land is drained. It must be admitted that it is generally agreed that the Local Authorities (Works) Act was a good Act and that, apart from the fact that it provided substantial employment, it brought considerable relief to farmers. It is regrettable that, since the change of Government took place two-and-a-half years ago, that Act can almost be described as dead because of the very small and insignificant amount of money which has been provided under it by this Government in comparison with the money which was provided and the work which was carried out under it during the term of office of the inter-Party Government.
I often wonder why it is that the Government are not more interested in drainage. I do not know what grievances they have against the farming community. Many of their backbenchers represent rural areas and are themselves farmers, and how it is that they react so strongly against the farmers on every possible occasion, I do not know. The Taoiseach may smile, but that is a fact. Since the coming into office of this Government, not one drainage scheme in relation to arterial drainage has been put into operation. We find also that the Local Authorities (Works) Act. which brought the cleaning and opening up of brooks and small rivers and main drains and which did agreat lot of good, has been completely cut out, so far as the provision of the essential funds for local authorities. Am I not, then, entitled to conclude that the Government has something against the farmer and I should like some reasonable explanation from the Minister or the Taoiseach in that regard.
I want to say also, as I have said on many an occasion before, that, if we are to get the increased production we all desire, fertilisers must be made much more reasonable in price and brought within the purchasing power of the farming community. Admittedly, ground limestone is essential, but it is not everything. There are other fertilisers, as Deputy Finan said but the purchasing of these fertilisers is completely outside the capacity of the small farmer. I know of no subsidy or assistance given by the Government to any section of the community that will pay greater dividends than the provision of cheap fertilisers. The Minister and the Taoiseach know that, as does every Deputy. Yet we find this heavy load placed on the shoulders of the farmer, with the result that he cannot manure his crops sufficiently to bring about the increased production which he ought to get.
With regard to ground limestone, I do not know why it is that Mayo was left out of consideration by the inter-Party Government and by this Government.
Comment on this
I understand that you, as head of the Department of Agriculture, in conjunction with the Department of Finance, opened up the limestone quarries in Roscommon and elsewhere.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to make it possible to open up the limestone quarries in County Mayo, so that ground limestone can be manufactured there. In the area between Ballyhaunis, Knock and Swinford, and particularly in the parish of Aughamore, there is an abundance of limestone of the best quality and suitable for grinding and distribution. It is not fair that a large county like Mayo, the third largest in the country, should be importing ground limestone from Roscommon and elsewhere and sending it to the far ends of Belmullet and Achill.
With regard to what Deputy Blowick said about the Bill, Deputy Gallagher has stated that he misrepresented the Bill and opposed it. I do not think he did. He may have criticised it adversely—perhaps and perhaps not— but I do not think he is so foolish as to oppose the spending of £5,000,000 for the relief of unemployment.
I shall read what he said during the Christmas recess, but, so far as our Party are concerned, we are at one with the Government in the provision of any money or assistance for the relief of unemployment and increased production. However, I should like to say that the main roads in my county are reasonably good—I do not say they are perfect—in relation to the amount of traffic they carry. It is a peculiar thing that it is when you take away corners that you have the accidents. The wider and better you make a road, the surer someone is to be killed. If a corner is dangerous, the motorist will slow down, if only for his own sake. Although millions have been spent over the past 30 years on the reconstruction of trunk and main roads, the removal of dangerous corners and so on, the number of fatal accidents has increased, so that we are not effecting a saving in life.
I want to impress on the Taoiseach, who knows rural Ireland, on the Minister and on those who will administerthis money, the need for realising that there are boreens and agricultural and other roads leading into villages which require repair. In the case of the rural contributory scheme, which is very much availed of in my county, I know that people who made application over the past 12 months have got the reply that the matter cannot be dealt with as there is no money, and I hope that some of this money will go towards the reconstruction of these roads in order to enable machinery to be brought in and out, agricultural produce to be brought to market and so on, and so remove much of the drudgery of rural life. The man who lives in a remote part away from the main road is entitled to a decent roadway to enable him to get to the church, to the fair and elsewhere. He pays rent and rates just the same as the man on the main or the trunk road. I hope that, when this Bill comes to be implemented, there will be drainage first and, when that has been dealt with, they can do what they like with the roads.
Comment on this
The manner in which this Bill was introduced to the House is certainly an innovation. The acting-Minister for Finance asks the House to give him a cheque for £5,000,000, to spend when and as he likes. He told us that the reason for this request was that he required a little elasticity and elbow room. I do not believe it ever happened in any Parliament in the world that a Minister came before it and asked for such a substantial sum of money—and £5,000,000 is a very substantial sum, so far as this country is concerned—giving as his reason that he wanted a bit of elbow room and elasticity.
Despite the fact that the Minister was unable to give the House any information as to how the money was to be expended, his colleague, Deputy Briscoe, speaking after him, had no difficulty in telling the House how it was to be expended. It is a very peculiar position that the acting-Minister for Finance has no fixed ideas as to how this money is to be expended, but that Deputy Briscoe knows all about it.
Comment on this
He knew how much was to be provided for roads, for drainage schemes, for housing, and so on. That being the way the measure was introduced, I am very doubtful about it. My own firm and honest belief is that political expediency is the main motive for its introduction.
The Labour Party have always been consistent in their support of every move towards national development. They helped in every way possible any measure that would tend in that direction. While I hope that my calculations in regard to this measure are incorrect, at the same time I am of opinion that they are not. The purpose behind this Bill is not so much to promote Irish industry as to provide political fodder for Fianna Fáil speakers in the future as their status is now a bit on the low side. Particularly will that be the case in regard to the by-elec-tions. I am honestly and sincerely convinced that that is one of the main reasons behind this measure.
What is the constituency which I represent going to get from this measure? Is it going to get the same treatment under this Bill that it received under the Undeveloped Areas Act? That Bill was introduced by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government. We were told we were going to have heaven on earth in the congested districts. Unemployment would cease and every man would feel happy and contented but what is the position? Scarcely a penny was spent in West Cork. There was very little money spent in any other part of Ireland either under that measure. Promises were made during the by-election campaign in Mayo. At the present time there are more discontented and disgruntled people among the workers of West Cork than ever before—that is, among those of them who are left. The vast majority of the unemployed workers in West Cork have gone to England during the past seven or eight months to earn a livelihood which is denied them at home.
That is the position. I firmly believe that the Government is very anxious to see these unemployed people departfrom the country because that is one method by which they can reduce the unemployment figure. I believe they are very anxious to see these unemployed people leave the country. The National Development Fund Bill is supposed to develop our Irish economy. We heard a good deal about unemployment during the course of this debate. Deputy Gallagher and others referred to the marches of the unemployed in Dublin. I saw these 400 or 500 men marching in Dublin and I have sympathy for them.
The population of Dublin and suburbs is 624,000 people according to the latest census. The total adult population of Castletownbere and district is 2,750. If the Minister went down there, what would he find after two and a half years of a Fianna Fáil Government? He would find that out of that population of 2,750 people in Castletownbere and district 627 were registered in the labour exchange as being unemployed the week before last. If there was an organised march of the unemployed in Castletownbere and district we would find that the number marching would be greater than the number which marched in Dublin.
Is it any wonder that I, as the representative of the people of that district, Bantry and Skibbereen, am rather doubtful about this measure having regard to the fact that a measure was introduced in this House in October, 1951, without any benefits accruing from it? I am of opinion that the same will happen in regard to this measure. I represent a constituency where there is little or no industrial development whatsoever. The same could be said in respect of my colleague Deputy Desmond. Native industrial development has cost us a great deal. We do not mind that. We would like to see industries established in this country. We are as broadminded and as nationally minded as any other people but instead of these industries being a source of benefit to us the opposite is the case.
We have to pay in taxation to subsidise industries in other places, particularlya few industries which proved to be uneconomic. That is the position. We have to pay our proportion to help the people in other districts. I am afraid that the same thing is going to happen with this £5,000,000. The people of West Cork will again be asked to contribute so that industries may be established in Dublin where there is a big vote or in some provincial towns and we will not get any benefit.
I want to impress upon the Minister that that kind of work will have to cease and cognisance must be taken of the people in the isolated districts. I gave an illustration to the Minister in regard to the unemployment position in West Cork. He can look up the figures in the Department of Social Welfare to see whether I am correct. If he does that he will see that 627 people were registered as unemployed in Castletownbere and district. That is a scandalous position. No wonder these people flee to England. Who would blame them? The Government are quite complacent about the position. Here is what they did when representations were made to them by me—and I am very sure by my other two colleagues—about getting something done for the people of Castletownbere.
We were told that instead of doing anything for the people of Castletownbere they were going to withdraw from us every penny that was given annually by way of minor employment schemes. The reason for that was because £10,000 was devoted towards road improvements under the Gaeltacht Services Act. They gave us that £10,000 and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government made a lot of noise about it. He told us about all the benefits that would be conferred on the people. Now they are taking it back with the other hand by withdrawing other grants. That is a shame. It is a matter that deserves the immediate attention of the Government.
Since I became a member of the House, I have repeatedly suggested that something should be done to help the agricultural industry in the congested districts. I had hoped that,following the introduction of this white elephant described as the Undeveloped Areas Bill, some useful effort would be made to benefit the farmers and the workers of these areas who are labouring under difficult conditions. I do not want to delay the House by going any further into that matter. All I wanted to do was to refer to it briefly.
The casual workers in Dunmanway, Skibbereen and other towns throughout the country are unemployed with few exceptions at the present moment— that is those of them who have not gone to England. The Government has done nothing whatsoever so far as the constituency of West Cork is concerned. We have no industry. We have nothing and the Minister cannot expect the representatives of West Cork to be complacent about the position.
The Minister has solved the farmers' problems in a very easy manner in this House to-day. He has brought in a new formula which will make farmers rich in a very short time. Briefly it is this: you push £2 worth of limestone into an acre of land this year and over the next six years it gives an extra profit of £100 per acre. That statement would hardly be made by an inmate of Grangegorman. It has no substance in fact. The general bulk of farmers in this country know much more about agriculture than the Minister for External Affairs, and they are sick and tired, in my constituency at least, of applying fertilisers to their land. The land is below the average in fertility and if they do not feed it with fertilisers they will get very little out of it. But there is no justification for a responsible Minister making the statement to which I have referred. If that were the case every farmer in the country would be within the next six years rolling in money. The Minister got an opportunity of denying that statement, but instead of denying it he affirmed it.
Comment on this
It is interesting to know that the Deputy holds those views and to have them on record.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy Briscoe mentioned itor not, but I wonder what is going to be devoted towards the development of our fishing industry. If any industry is starved for capital, it is surely the fishing industry. The majority of fishermen have no modern equipment and they have not the capital to provide it. It is all right for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture to say that loans are available. You have to have very solvent sureties and you have to have some measure of capital yourself and the unfortunate position is that, while these people are exceptionally honest and decent people, because they have little or no means they cannot get guarantors and, therefore, cannot benefit from loans. I wonder could any scheme be adopted whereby reasonable grants would be made available to these people. It would be not only of benefit to the fishermen but to the country in general. Fishing was the second industry to agriculture 30 or 40 years ago according to the information I have from these people and according to the statistics, and I do not see why it should not be put back in that place to-day. It is a peculiar feature that in some coastal towns you cannot even get a pound of fish, and that in some of these towns and villages they have nothing but out-of-date equipment to endeavour to catch the fish.
I hope my views will not be in any way misrepresented as being in opposition to this measure. It is my Party's policy to support every measure such as this, but there is an obligation on every member of this House to express his own opinion as to what he thinks of a particular measure. I am afraid it is going to be a dead horse just the same as the Undeveloped Areas Act. However, if any benefits were to accrue we should have as much decentralisation as possible of industries. There is no use in increasing the population of this city up to 700,000 or 800,000, more than one-fifth of what is in Ireland, and rural centres becoming depopulated day by day. I could mention a particular section of the people who have got very little from any Government, the islanders, and I believe that island life will disappear altogether. I have offered that view in this House before,and that is the opinion which is strongly held by these islanders themselves. Things are becoming so difficult for them—on Whiddy Island, Bere Island and the other islands around the coast—that they have no alternative but to adopt the measures adopted by the Blasket islanders and depart from the islands altogether.
On the eve of Christmas I do not wish to delay the House to go into measures such as the Local Authorities (Works) Act and other measures that would be definitely of great benefit and give to the workers in towns and rural districts opportunities of obtaining productive employment. So far as the towns are concerned, the townspeople in West Cork have given up all hope of getting anything from this Government or, indeed, from any Government. I may say they have been disappointed by all. Business is not very good for many of them. I have had, in many cases, to make representations to the county council to get time on behalf of these people to pay their rates. I know a number of small business people who have to adopt that measure of asking time for the payment of their rates. Some efforts should be made to make money available to do something for these people.
I am fully behind the motives as expressed in the wording of the Bill. I agree entirely with my colleague, Deputy Hickey, that this House would have no objection even if the sum was much bigger than £5,000,000 but it gives me cause for doubt when a responsible Minister of State cannot give an indication to the House in regard to this £5,000,000 other than in connection with the two items I mentioned, and says that he wants elbow room and elasticity and it is not to avoid political discomfort that the measure is being brought in. I do not see why the Minister should use such a term. They say there is no smoke without fire and perhaps that is an intimation of the intention. It is very strange that the Minister for External Affairs could give no other indication to the House as to its value. I believe it is not honest on the part of theGovernment to bring in this measure and that it is purely for political purposes the Bill is being introduced. They have had plenty of opportunity over the past two and a half years to provide useful schemes and they have completely failed to do so.
Comment on this
Unemployment must be for every Government a matter of serious concern. Any of us who have been looking at world affairs over a number of years know it was a matter of very serious concern before the war in a number of countries and that it is a most baffling problem to solve. When we came into office in 1951, the most immediate and fundamental problems we had to deal with were the problems of bringing about a balance in the Budget and a reasonable balance in our international payments. At the beginning of this year it seemed pretty evident that we had succeeded in dealing with those two problems.
When I came back from Utrecht at the beginning of this year, the most serious problem facing us was the problem of unemployment. I was aware, of course, that the numbers on the register had been swollen considerably by the coming into operation of the Social Welfare Act. Investigations had been made and it was found that, as a result of the introduction of new classes, the increase of benefits, the relaxation of the limits of benefit and so on, there had been brought into the register, it was estimated at that time, about 10,000 additional persons. That is to say, in order to get comparable figures with previous years for that period of the year, you had to make a subtraction of about 10,000. Without the subtraction, I was aware that figures very nearly the same for that period of the year could be found back in 1949 when the Coalition had already been in office for a year. Figures of the same magnitude without the subtraction could be found back in the years before the war. Nevertheless, even with the subtraction, the figure was a very high one.
Anyone with any conception of what unemployment means for any family must feel that if any measures can be taken to deal with that situation they should be taken. The trouble is thatmany of the measures suggested, although they may ease it in one way, may eventually have the effect of worsening it elsewhere. No one who has given serious thought to the subject will deny that the best way is to try to put people to work at productive enterprises, enterprises which will give a return for the money spent on them. Purely relief schemes— which can degenerate almost to the type of filling a hole and emptying it again—are costly and give no satisfactory solution.
Some statements made by me were quoted last night by Deputy Norton. I was not as well acquainted when I made those statements as I am now, after the years' experience, with the nature of some of the problems. I thought that by putting people into industry, by building up industries where they had not existed before, we would absorb the unemployed element of our people and, gradually, unemployment would disappear. As I indicated last night, there was a counterflow. According as we were putting people into employment in industry, people were going off the land, there was less employment on the land, fewer people were being retained there and fewer people were continuing to live in the rural parts of the country.
Looking over the world, at some of the Western European countries, their statistics show that what unfortunately was happening here had also happened in many other countries in Europe, that is, there was a drift from the country to the towns and cities. However, although our work did not result in ending large-scale unemployment as I had hoped, we had the satisfaction of knowing that over 100,000 people were put into employment that would not have been available for them if industries had not been set up.
We believe that by continuing to develop our industries we will continue to give employment to more and more people. Therefore, the drive to develop industries is going to go on, as far as we can press it forward, as rapidly as before. At any rate, the effort will beas strong as before. The opportunities are not as great as they were. The cream has already been taken off, inasmuch as we have now a large number of enterprises which give large employment, as in the case of textiles. There is still, however, considerable room for building up industry to supply our own needs, the things we import from abroad and the production of which at present gives employment abroad.
An important aspect of the problem is that we have not got enough raw materials. Unfortunately, this country is not as rich in mineral resources as some of us thought in the old Sinn Féin days, before there had been a thorough investigation. Our greatest source of wealth ultimately lies in the land. Before I come to agriculture, I want to say that the best way to cure unemployment is to continue the old programme of building up manufacturing industries. After that, what can we do to increase employment on the land?
We are now experiencing a new movement affecting employment on the land, the introduction of machinery. To what extent that will cause unemployment and to what extent it will give increased employment are questions which we will have to wait a little longer before we can answer fully. It is obvious that the more we produce from the land the greater the population we will be able to support in the country.
The next best way of finding a fundamental cure for unemployment is to try to get from the land all that the land can give us. That was the reason why the acting-Minister for Finance spoke to-day on fertilisers and ground limestone. The figures he gave, which were controverted, were figures definitely got from the experimental station in Johnstown Castle. It might be argued that the circumstances were specially favourable there, but even if you discount the figures by a considerable amount, even if you do not get a return of £100 on an outlay of £2 but get only £20, surely it would be worth it? I would ask everyone in this Dáil not to try to stop the drive to get this thing done—the provision of ground limestone so as to improve the fertilityof the land to the utmost extent. Instead of saying and doing things which would counteract the effect of the drive, Deputies should put their shoulders to the wheel and help to move it along. The most important single thing that can be done for the country at the present time is to increase the productivity of agriculture and to improve the fertility of the soil. We know from experiments that it can be done. If we can get any way in which we can speed up the process it will mean that we can increase production by millions of pounds or, to put it the other way, that we are losing millions by reason of the delay.
I have not myself studied the statistics, but I have been told that per 100 acres of land they are able to get on the Continent some two, three, four and even, possibly, five times as great a yield from the soil as we get here. Surely that should not be. When you examine it and see how that is done, you find it is due to the attention that is given to supplying the soil with the proper fertilisers, with the ground limestone and other things which are necessary, and also to greater tillage. The reason these countries are capable of getting these big yields from the soil is that they use more fertilisers than we do and they have a higher percentage of tillage than we have. Our percentage of tillage is only about 15 per cent. It is 63 per cent. in Denmark, I think, and about 50 per cent. in Belgium.
Surely, then, every Deputy who wants to find a fundamental cure for unemployment will help the Government in that matter. It does not matter what Government is in power, the duty of every member of the House is to try and get our industries built up as rapidly as possible so as to give permanent employment and to have our land so treated as to get a greater yield from the soil. I hope that that will give greater employment on the land, though I am not so certain on account of this question of machinery. Before the war, there were only about 2,000 tractors in this country. There are now 19,000 tractors, or there were at the beginning of the year—more than nine times as many. Whether the extra production and the extratillage, if we get it, will give employment to counteract the effect of the machinery, I do not know. We have only to try and see.
I think we should do everything we can to enable us to put people at work and to keep them at work producing from the land, and I ask every member of the House to help us in making that a success. During the war years I asked the members of every Party to help us to get the necessary food grown in this country, to get the wheat and the crops for cattle-feeding grown in the country. I ask Deputies now, as head of the Government and for the time being responsible for trying to promote the well-being of the country, to help us in the drive to have the soil tested and treated properly. The facilities for testing are being expanded, and we should try to have the soil tested to see to what extent lime is required. Then let us all go out to try and see that the ground limestone is provided. The question of fertilisers will also have to be considered. I have given more consideration personally to the ground limestone question than to the other fertilisers, but both are necessary.
These are the fundamental ways in which unemployment can be cured, if it can be cured, namely by providing permanent employment for our people in the manufacturing industries, on the one hand, and on the land on the other. But, even while these things are being done, I am afraid there will be a fair amount of unemployment. I have looked over the figures for some years, to see when unemployment was at its lowest.
We were told by the Coalition that when they were in office unemployment had ceased, that there was full employment. The figures do not show that. For the last full year in which the Coalition were in office the figure for unemployment was 53,800; last year it was 60,800. I admit that there is a difference of 7,000. I do not want to see that figure continue. In fact, in the year 1951, for part of which we were in office, it went down to 51,000 odd. I think that is the lowest annual figure. These figures are the average of the monthly figures. The lowest figure on record at any time for anyone week was, I think, that for the 6th September, 1947, when the figure was 34,978. That is the lowest ever. But remember that 34,978 individuals, many of whom would-be breadwinners with families, were without employment.
A certain statement of mine was referred to. I said many years ago that if the existing system was not capable of dealing with the problem of unemployment then we could go outside the system. The reason we did not then suggest going outside the system was that we should wait and see whether there were other systems of organisation of society than that which we had which would give better results. But my own conclusion ultimately was that, although you could, by regimentation of the population, probably see that those who could work were not unemployed, that they were put at something or other even if it were only digging holes or something of that sort, you would have a host of other evils. For the regimentation of the population you would have to take control of each individual in the country.
One of the difficulties we have in dealing with unemployment is in regard to the mobility of labour. There would be little use telling people in the City of Dublin who were unemployed in the tailoring trade that there was good work for them in the bogs in Kildare or somewhere else. A young unmarried man can go into a camp in Kildare, or move from Mayo if there is work available in Tipperary. If he is a married man with a wife and young children, it is not so easy for him to move, and you cannot bring the work in Tipperary up to Mayo. Therefore it is a difficult problem.
Once you have tried the fundamental methods of getting permanent employment in industry and in agriculture, you can then see what employment can be given in improving the national estate in other respects. We ought not to go too far with that, however, because if you spend the resources of the country largely on amenities and if you have not got the economic sub-structure to support that expenditure, in a very short time you will get into a more serious positionthan the position from which you started. Therefore, we have to be very careful.
We are not an empire. I remember, at the beginning of the war looking at the area and the resources of several countries in the world. I saw that Russia, with Siberia, had a continuous stretch of about 8,000,000 square miles. The United States of America had about 3,000,000 square miles with a population of 150,000,000 people. The British Empire, as it was called at that time, in the book I was looking at, to my amazement covered an area of 18,000,000 square miles. It took in Canada, Australia and South Africa. All these areas were taken in as part of the British Empire. Remember that Britain, as the centre of that Empire, was benefiting by all the advantages which its connection with that vast territory gave it.
Now we are not the centre of an Empire. Nor have we 3,000,000 square miles with a population of 150,000,000 people to develop the resources of that area. We are a relatively small country, with unfortunately, except in the case of agricultural land, none of the great basic resources on which the life and prosperity of other countries have been built up. We must, therefore, move cautiously in regard to matters in which there is expenditure on anything that is not really productive.
Now, housing is essential. No matter what has been said here, the records prove that we have pushed on housing as fast as it could go. As far as this Government is concerned, there has been no lack of support for the building of houses. The time is coming when we will have supplied the most urgent needs. There is a considerable amount of unemployment at present in the building and construction industry. We require, therefore, to provide additional work for that industry. We want to get, as far as possible, schemes that will be productive in their character, or, in the last resort, schemes that will be of amenity value.
When I made an examination of all this I received deputations. I assured the members of the deputations that they were coming to a person who was already very troubled about this particularmatter. They said: "We can do so-and-so, if money is provided; there are in the Departments a number of useful schemes and what about providing money to see that these schemes are carried out?" There has been a great deal of talk about the reduction of the grant for the Local Authorities (Works) Act. In the case of that Act, there was a rush after it was passed to give employment on drainage, bog work and so on. As far as my information goes, there was good work and bad work done. I have not been able to go as an inspector myself to see these works, but my information is that there has been good work and bad work, and some very wasteful work, done through the operation of that Act. Now, I think that nobody, even those who brought in the Act, would like to see money wasted. They would want to see the money well employed and see some fruits, some permanent results, from the money that is spent.
I asked the Departments, and particularly the offices that are presided over and directed by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, what was the position as far as their works were concerned. We came to the conclusion that if there was a proper sifting of the various works had been in contemplation— that if these were sifted and examined by a committee from the point of view of seeing what useful works there were with a high labour content—we would try to see that the money was provided. But, again, money that is to be spent in that way ought to be spent, if possible, on works of a productive character. Now, are our roads works of a productive character? They are. It is essential to have good roads for transport. The vehicles working on them will have a longer life, and so there is an economic value in having good roads.
Again, I was told that, on account of the amount of money that has to be spent on some of the main roads, the plan, a sort of five-years' plan which was under consideration for the development of the whole road system —the main roads with certain branchesinto them and county roads—had to be operated more slowly than it would be operated if more money were available. We said: "Well, that is one piece of work which would have to be done in the national interest some time, and the sooner it is done the better." The question then was, can we supply the extra amount of money to enable more rapid progress to be made along these lines?
Similarly, in regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act. As I have said, the position, as far as I understood, was that there was good work and bad work. The problem was to pick out the schemes that were really good, get these things done, and then, perhaps, tail off on to the ones that were not of such high priority value. When we had considered the matter, we decided to make available another £100,000 to be added to what is in the Estimate, so that those concerned might go ahead more quickly with the schemes in hands and pick out the best of them, in accordance with the need for giving employment and their fundamental economic value.
The problem of the Gaeltacht is one of special national importance. Was there any additional way in which we could help the Gaeltacht and keep in that area the people who know the language, by trying to preserve these very small areas? We felt that if £250,000 was made available for schemes that would give employment in these areas they also could be considered.
It was for these reasons that we thought of having something like the Transition Development Fund That was brought in here in 1946 when the war had ended. There was the question of high prices at the time which we felt might deter local authorities from going on with certain schemes. We wanted to encourage them and not have them waiting until prices would fall, which would mean that work would be postponed and that there would be unemployment. We, therefore, brought that fund of £5,000,000 into existence. Our successors added almost another £2,000,000. When I mentioned earlier the figure of £5,000,000 someone said it was£7,000,000. I believe the Coalition Government added another £2,000,000, and actually used it. It was a good idea because it did give an opportunity for dealing with particular cases and dealing with them quickly.
The position we found ourselves in, this year, was that we wanted to act fairly quickly, and we did act even before we got the full authority to get this money, because we felt that every member of the Dáil who was concerned about the condition of the unemployed would support us in finding the money to try and deal with this which, I hope, as far as its magnitude is concerned, will certainly not be more than a temporary evil.
I ask the members of the Dáil to vote for this Bill. I do not think that any worse service can be rendered to this country than to suggest—always suggest—that everything that a Government is doing is from a sordid motive; that there is nothing but sordid intentions behind measures of this kind. This measure is brought in in good faith to try to give the Government an opportunity of dealing in the first place with unemployment, but dealing with it in a way that will at the same time be national development. It means giving us an opportunity of advancing in many ways schemes to be dealt with, which, if a fund like this were not available, would be put back in the queue and have to remain there for a number of years. I think I can appeal to all fair-minded Deputies to support this Bill.
Comment on this
The more the Taoiseach spoke in relation to this Bill, the more frankly I felt that he convinced me that my interpretation of the position is correct. When this Bill was being introduced this morning by the acting-Minister for Finance, he gave us no reasons for it except that he wanted to have elbow room in circumstances of grave economic uncertainty and danger —I think those were his words. Last night the Taoiseach spoke on his Estimate and the heading we get from the Irish Press—the Taoiseach's own newspaper—is: “We are on an even keel.” It seems to me that there is a slightdifference of opinion between the two ideas that were expressed.
But the Taoiseach at least did this in his speech: He made some effort— certainly more than the acting-Minister for Finance made—to explain what type of work was visualised and the more he explained the type of work that was visualised the more apparent it became that it was all work which comes within the ambit of one or other of the various items of the various Estimates of the various Departments.
We were told about roads. You do not need a Bill like this to deal with the road problem. You have the appropriate machinery for dealing with grants for roads out of the Road Fund. You already have appropriate machinery and if it is deemed desirable and necessary to supplement the income of the Road Fund by borrowing on the strength of the Road Fund, that is a method that has been adopted frequently before. If it was deemed necessary and desirable to have greater grants for roads than the income of the Road Fund would stand—and that, as far as I could understand, was what the Taoiseach had in his mind—then it could have been done perfectly satisfactorily and to the satisfaction of everyone quite easily under existing machinery and no such green document as this was required for the purpose.
We had another Deputy coming in to tell us that one of the things this Bill was required for was to get grants for bridges. Grants for bridges were given long before anybody ever thought of the National Development Fund Bill and they will be given long after it. There is existing machinery there for the purpose and this Bill was not necessary to ensure that those grants would be made available for local authorities.
It was mentioned also that there would be grants to local authorities for amenity schemes on the basis of the provision of a certain proportion of money which the local authorities would make up out of the rates and another proportion provided by this fund. Again the provision can be made under ordinary Estimates.
The Local Authorities (Works) Act was mentioned by the Taoiseach, whosaid that out of this Bill a proportion of the fund is going to be made available for the purposes of that Act. I ask the Taoiseach in all sincerity would it not have been more honest merely to increase the item in the Estimate that is already there, rather than go through this camouflage, for camouflage it is.
Comment on this
It is not. One of the difficulties, if I may explain it to the Deputy, is the time. There is a time factor in all these and if you are to go through all this with all the time factors you would have very slow progress.
Comment on this
I heard the Taoiseach talk about this in Ballinasloe. A great deal of time has gone since then and it would have been more than easy to get all the Supplementary Estimates that the various Ministers wanted in that time during which the Bill itself has been hatched.
Comment on this
I am not denying that, but I am denying that this Bill was necessary to do these things. They could all have been done quite easily under existing machinery.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I just want to clarify the position. I understand that the Dáil adjourns at 6 o'clock. I want to know—I think I am entitled to know—whether in fact we are going to get this stage of the Bill through by 6 o'clock or whether it is going to be talked out. I want to draw this to the attention of the Chair that this very constructive measure is being held up and that there is nobody on the Fine Gael side of the House except Deputy Sweetman.
Comment on this
I want to say this on a point of order. Here is a constructive measure to provide very substantial sums for constructive purposes and it is being held up, and we may have to meet again next Tuesday because of the time that is wasted.
Comment on this
If the Government wants to address a question to me on the Order of Business it will be answered without any question but it is certainly not going to be answered when it is addressed by this particular Deputy to me through the Chair. I have been here all day and the Deputy has just dropped into the House.
Comment on this
I have been in here the whole time and the Deputy has not.
The other thing the Taoiseach mentioned in his speech was in relation to special employment schemes under the aegis of Deputy Beegan, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, and therefore in charge of the Board of Works. Again I fail to see how it is that any schemes that are required in respect of any office could not have been dealt with by Supplementary Estimates brought forward. We have got no indication, no suggestion from the Minister for Finance as to how this fund is going to be operated because if it is going to be operated in a different manner from the manner in which ordinary funds voted on Estimates were operated it was the function of the Minister to make that perfectly clear to us. I think that the Taoiseach himself will agree that the greatest administrative delay in any project for the expenditure of money is the system which operates by virtue of which Departments must refer so much to the Department of Finance for financial sanction. I am not at this stage obviously going to go into the question as to whether that is a good or bad practice but it is a practice which has grown up over the years and it is the main cause of delay. I would suggest that if the Government were sincere in their anxiety to get a means of expediting the outflow of this amount it could have been done far better by permitting the various Departments to expand their Estimatesand expand them in such a way that they would not have, within certain limitation of figures, to submit them for financial sanction. That is the real cause of delay in the administration of schemes and that is the real reason why things are from time to time held up.
There is nothing that we have yet heard mentioned to-day on this Bill that could not have been dealt with quite easily under existing legislation, and under existing Estimates, by expansion of those Estimates and by ensuring that in the expansion of those Estimates there was going to be less red tape from financial control. This Bill is not going to touch that. This Bill is not going to short circuit any of the existing difficulty or existing delay.
In so far as the moneys that are provided under this Bill are going to relieve unemployment, all of us naturally are glad that unemployment is going to be relieved but it is unfortunate that the necessity for that relief is there. It is unfortunate that the positive policy of the Government which has been adopted over the last two years has caused that. I want to take issue with the Taoiseach on his analysis of the unemployment situation and point out that the worst thing there can be towards creating an unemployment problem is a lack of effective demand. One of the things that Government policy did deliberately and of design—because it misread the economic situation—was to prevent effective demand. Government policy set out to take more money out of the people's pockets for the Government, rather than allow the people to spend it themselves. That must of necessity mean that there is a lesser effective demand than there would be otherwise.
It is an unfortunate thing in which on both sides of the House we are prepared to agree with the Taoiseach, that after 30 years of self-government the last 21 of which, with the exception of three years, have been under the aegis of Fianna Fáil, we still have the twin problems of emigration and unemployment. So far as ourfuture is concerned it should be clear that it is in the land that the best hope lies. I can well remember some eight or nine years ago a Deputy speaking from this side of the House who is now gone to his reward and trying to impress on the Taoiseach's then Minister for Agriculture that one of the reasons why we were not able to get so much out of our land as we might get was that we were sadly behind in the provision—and in the awareness of the desirability—of fertilisers for the land. When the late Deputy James Hughes put that view time and time again from this side of the House prior to 1946, he was always told by the Fianna Fáil Government that it was ridiculous for us to compare our position with that of Denmark or that of Holland. I was delighted at least that the passage of years has shown that the Taoiseach has come round to the view advocated so frequently and so cogently by the late Deputy Hughes in those days.
There are others who want to speak on this Bill and the Minister for Finance knows the arrangements that have been made in respect of it, and I do not want to hold up others any longer. But I want to say quite positively I have yet to hear of anything that is going to be done under this Bill for which the machinery is not already available and which could not have been done equally well under the existing arrangements by the ordinary segregation in the Estimates. If something is required to be done as a capital service, it could have been brought in by way of Supplementary Estimate and put through, and it would have been through before the Bill itself even saw the light of day. In those circumstances, I fail to understand how it can be felt that the method—I am not talking about the money, the works or the relief of unemployment, all of which may be very desirable and are very desirable, but I am talking about the method—I fail to understand how anyone can see that the method itself was other than political.
Comment on this
It is now 5.15 p.m. and if we are to finish this Bill I would like to be let in now.
Comment on this
If you will allow me, I will not keep the Minister three minutes and I have been here all day. It was quite obvious having listened to the speech of the Taoiseach that, in our opinion at any rate, unfortunately the past two and a half years have shown that the policy of the Government has been what we may consider a careful and close-studied but undoubtedly conservative policy, and unfortunately we are now placed in the position because of the reaction to that policy of looking for this money. All we are sorry for, those of us in the Labour Party Benches, is that the amount of money which is asked for is not much greater. But we believe it will be of some small measure of help in some areas—very little in other parts—but in the present conditions and at this time of the year, Christmas, if it will help unemployment to any little degree let us get on with it, and the sooner the better.
Comment on this
I want to say only a few words. In respect of this measure where the Government have in fact done something for which there has been a very general request from the House one might have imagined that this measure would have been welcome and that there should have been no necessity for long explanations or long debates. I do think that to-day when the majority of Deputies have left the House and gone home, it is absurd that there should have been this delay and this opposition from a particular section of the House to this measure.
Comment on this
It is not being opposed but it is being criticised. The coldest of cold water is being thrown on it.
All of us who want to build up this country are fighting against a numberof problems, unemployment, the destitution that arises from unemployment, and are trying to do something constructive. We are being forced into a fight against a fifth column exemplified in the speech of Deputy Sweetman. It was a fifth column opposition to this constructive measure.
I am glad that Deputy Desmond welcomes the Bill. It is a vital Bill. We will not solve problems by increasing the departmental Votes by £5, £50 or £500. This is a new idea of dealing with a big problem. The Government has put forward this Bill and it should be accepted on the opening speech of the Minister. We are told by a Deputy that the Government might have approached this matter differently. There should be some reason in the House. The country wants this Bill. The country wants any constructive proposal that the Government may make.
Comment on this
The country wants it and the country needs it. Deputy Rooney says that this is not being opposed.
Comment on this
It is not being opposed, but Deputies are talking about it. I want to know from Deputy Rooney is the Minister getting this part of the measure this evening or not? Have Deputy Rooney, Deputy Sweetman and other Deputies decided to talk it over for a longer period? Deputy Sweetman is coming back to the House now. He has discussed this matter with the Chief Whip on the Government side. Do we take it that the measure will be finished this evening? Is that agreed?
Comment on this
Here we have the fifth column of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Rooney, and they will not tell the Government straight: "You can have this measure this evening."
Comment on this
I am a Deputy with a sense of responsibility to the people, and I find these fifth columnists trying to obstruct anything that we want to get done.
Comment on this
There may be a reasonable chance.
Comment on this
The House, the Minister, and the Government, when they are doing something constructive for the people, are entitled to cooperation. This measure is acceptable to the House and the country. Why cannot we get it through? Why must we talk a lot of nonsense about it?
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman has intervened in this debate and has talked the height of nonsense about it. Why does he not allow the Bill to be passed? If it is a good measure, that is not opposed, why should it not be passed? Why should Deputy Sweetman throw cold water on it? If there is anything in the Bill that the other members of his Party want to criticise, why are they not here to criticise it or to make constructive suggestions? Deputy Sweetman knows very well that when there is any measure that will benefit the Irish people he feels he must oppose it. I do not know why.
I had not intended to intervene in the debate. I thought the Bill would have been passed long ago. I object to the type of criticism to which the measure has been subjected. I take exception to the line that Deputy Sweetman has taken in regard to it. When a measure is proposed by the Government that is generally accepted and decided to be in the interests of the nation, Deputy Sweetman has no right to be critical of it in this House.
Comment on this
On a point of procedure.I will require at least 20 minutes to reply to this debate, which has been going on all day.
Comment on this
No. I told the Parliamentary Secretary that you will get your Bill and your Estimate.
Comment on this
I will require 20 minutes to reply. As Minister responsible for this Bill, which has been called a dirty fraud by the deputy-leader of the Opposition, I will require 20 minutes to reply to the debate.
Comment on this
This Bill has been introduced because it is needed. We must be clear on that issue. The necessity has arisen in consequence of the difficult unemployment situation created by the policy of the present Government. The position has become so serious that they find it necessary, on the eve of Christmas, to embark on this new departure. What they call the National Development Fund Bill is a departure from the financial pattern. On the eve of Christmas, the Government come in and ask us to accept the purpose for which this Bill is designed and allow it through to-day, the real purpose being to prevent it being properly discussed and to prevent Opposition Deputies from pointing out the real reason for the introduction of this Bill, the necessity for it and the activities of the Government which made it necessary.
That is why we on this side of the House have been particularly critical of the Government in relation to this measure. We have pointed out that the policy pursued by them has made this Bill necessary. It is a last minute move on the eve of Christmas because they realise that all the Christmas relief schemes in the country are unable to meet fully the needs of destitute families. I have a telegram here from the Commissioners of Balbriggan:—
"Unemployment situation serious in Balbriggan. Further relief schemes essential."
That is because there were hundreds of unemployed queuing outside the labour exchange yesterday and, I suppose, to-day. That is the reason for this measure.
The Bill asks for power to spend £5,000,000 between now and the 31st March and £5,000,000 annually thereafter. It asks permission to increase the national debt annually by £5,000,000. Instead of spending the savings of the people, the Government ask for an adjustment in relation to the national debt.
In Christmas, 1950, there was no need for a Christmas relief scheme in County Dublin because there were not sufficient persons registered at the exchanges in Dublin County to justify the planning of a relief scheme. In 1953 the relief schemes devised by the various county councils throughout the country have not been sufficient to meet the considerable destitution and hardship that exists. The Bill is clearly needed in consequence of the policy pursued by the present Government. We should be grateful to Deputy Briscoe for telling us actually in what way this money is going to be spent. He pointed out that, in fact, Dublin Corporation can expect over £1,000,000 out of it in relation to emergency schemes in the area of Dublin Corporation. I know that Dublin County Council got a letter from the Minister for Local Government saying that he was going to give the council £50,000 for the purpose of expenditure on various schemes to be approved which would be put up by the county engineer. He was not asked to write down to the county council, but offered them £50,000. He wrote down to them and he probably has written down to other county councils as well. We ought to be told how much is going to be spent in County Louth and in Cork City during the next few months. Is the power to be conferred by this Bill going to be used or abused in order to buy votes in those two constituencies where we will have elections? We know that we did have the buying of votes before.
We had the example of £11,000,000 being spent on ten years' fuel supplytowards the end of 1947 just before the General Election of 1948. Much of that fuel went waste but there was ten years' supply brought into the Park; and of course the purpose of it was to keep persons employed while the general election campaign was under way. I am critical of the circumstances which brought about the necessity for this Bill. It is unfortunate that it was necessary to bring into this House a Bill of this nature. It is unfortunate that the present Government did not pursue a policy which brought prosperity.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I want to point out that Deputy Rooney has repeated that at least four times already. This is from the point of view of talking the business out.
Comment on this
The acting-Minister for Finance is just imagining things now. He is happy to draw on his imagination in this matter. I wonder if the recent national loan was filled and if it had not fallen short by £5,000,000 in the form of subscriptions from the public would the necessity for this Bill have arisen? We know that the public subscribed £5,000,000 less than was expected from them in the last national loan. Strangely enough, £5,000,000 is the figure mentioned in this Bill. The only difference is that it is proposed now in addition to a policy of an annual loan from the public to use this device for the purpose of getting a further £5,000,000 which will be added in the ordinary way to the national debt from one year to another. We did did not hear from the Minister any detail, and we should have, of what it is proposed to spend this money on. We ought to be told, for instance, whether it is going to be used for the purpose of rebuilding a portion of Dublin Castle or whether, in fact, it is going to be allocated for the purposeof building the road from Dublin to Bray against which there is a good deal of public resentment. Anything we heard about what this money would be used for we heard from Deputy Briscoe. Obviously, it has been discussed in the Party room, and at least the House ought to be told something that may have taken place at that general discussion even if the expediency of having this money spent during the by-elections in Cork and Louth is not admitted as having been discussed there in the Party room.
Comment on this
We remember before we had the Fianna Fáil Party blowing about the Transition Development Bill of 1946 and all it was going to do for the nation. We found in 1948 when the Fianna Fáil Party were put out by the vast majority of the people that no arrangement was made to put any money into that fund and we found that in fact when the first national loan of £12,000,000 was floated, when the debts of the Fianna Fáil Party were paid, including the fuel in the Park, there was not sufficient money even to meet the £4,500,000 that was to be put up at that time in the Transition Development Fund. We must, therefore, beware of these devices and these Bills with nice names that are introduced in the House and carried in the Dáil by the Fianna Fáil Party, because we have seen from the past that many of these Bills, even the Undeveloped Areas Bill, are introduced here for the purpose of painting a picture and for the purpose of giving an opportunity for a certain amount of window dressing and giving an opportunity also to build up people's imaginations at election times. The nation deserves better from any Government in this House. We have seen from the record of the Fianna Fáil Party that they have not been honest with the people and that they have deceived them particularly in relation to passing measureswhich in the long run, in fact, they do not intend to implement.
Comment on this
In this particular discussion, I am not interested in introducing the motives that may have been operating in the minds of people in the formulation of this Bill. I intervene in this debate purely for the purpose of inquiring from the Minister what hope and expectation we can have under this Bill. Can I take back a measure of hope to the people in the Beara Peninsula, in Dingle Peninsula and in Kilcrohane, and in the far-flung areas towards the Mizzen? Can I take back a message of hope to them that many of the schemes so long in the files and offices of the Board of Works that would usefully benefit the area will now be expeditiously dealt with? This particular measure may have many defects, but from my point of view it has one saving grace, and that is, that the Government is subscribing to the principle of putting Irish money quickly into investment at home in Ireland.
I want to get this Bill in its proper picture. Is this Bill an expediency measure of only pointed or partial practicality? Is it a Bill designed to deal with problems that may be arising in by-election areas and problems that have already arisen in the City of Dublin, or is this Bill a genuine effort to come to grips in an expeditious way with the problem of rural unemployment generally?
Comment on this
None whatever; and if the Minister is going to take that attitude I will be talking at 6 o'clock.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to make this perfectly clear and I am glad that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach is in the House. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach knows that the position is that there was no agreement that the Second Reading and the Estimate would be finished by 6 o'clock, but that notwithstanding the fact that there was no such agreement he has been assured by me that he is going to get it.
Comment on this
If the acting-Minister for Finance wants to prevent——
Comment on this
At this stage I should like to inform Deputies that it would be possible to extend the sitting until 6.15 p.m., if necessary.
Comment on this
I can assure the Ceann Comhairle that if the Minister kept quiet, I would be finished by now.
Comment on this
I do not want to intervene at all but, if necessary, we could extend the time by the unanimous wish of Deputies.
Comment on this
I think that my colleague, Deputy O'Higgins, would like to say a few words and, to ensure that the Minister will have time to reply, we are agreeable that the time should be extended.
Comment on this
On the basis of the Minister's last remark, I object to any extension of the sitting. There will be no agreement.
Comment on this
Let the debate go on to 6.30.
Comment on this
We could allow the debate to continue until 6.30 by the unanimous wish of the House.
Comment on this
May I say that we are not disposed to grant any facilities to the Minister, having regard to the attitude which he has adopted. I am not taking the view that we are here to obstruct, but he has been interfering for the past 20 minutes. I would have finished long since, if it were not for his interruptions.
Comment on this
I suggest that it be agreed that the House sit until 6.30.
Comment on this
Will you take the responsibility for delaying the Bill before the unemployed who are waiting for work?
Comment on this
I want to know from the Minister if there is any hope that these schemes will be put into operation in cases in which they are already prepared and waiting for financial sanction. I want to put on record my appreciation of the fact that the Governmenthas somersaulted back to a practical belief in the inter-Party Government policy, that is, putting Irish money back into schemes to provide employment for the Irish people at home and the development of useful projects here in Ireland. I want to know in a specific way what message I am to take back to the people in the various outlying districts of the constitutency I have the honour to represent, the people, for instance, who are looking for a breakwater in Schull. Will the Bill provide a medium through which money will be made available for that one scheme in particular, the erection of Schull breakwater for the protection of the most prosperous and progressive industry we have in this country? There may be a lot of "ballyhoo" in the Bill. Many motives have been attributed to the Party responsible for the Bill. These allegations may or may not be true, but what I really want to know is, will it be a Bill under which the money available will be spent as the urgency of the situation demands, whether it be in Dublin city or county or in áiteanna iargúlta on the western seaboard or the south-western seaboard? If this Bill is to be anything but a "cod" then the particular type of financial support that flows from it will have to start flowing from the very beginning of the new year. If the Government were in earnest about the difficulties of the situation, this Bill would not be hanging fire for so long. That is why we must look on it with a great deal of suspicion. There has been immense difficulty in the employment situation and an immense increase in emigration for the last couple of months. If we were fully alive to that, and if the Government did not wish to prevent the effective financing of schemes, there should not be this kind of window-dressing at all.
I want to ask the Minister what he wants the Bill for. If he were in earnest about financing schemes of road development, bog development, bridge building or any other type of development, is there not every possible facility under our financial system, either by introducing a Supplementary Estimate or asking for an additional grant to get all the money we want?Why dress the Bill up under a grandiose name when, in fact, if the Government were in earnest, they already have facilities at their disposal to make the necessary money available for these purposes? Are we to be criticised then because we look with suspicion on the attitude of the acting-Minister? The acting-Minister for Finance knows as well as I do that if he wanted to pour money into these schemes, if he wanted to give Deputy Briscoe's committee in the Dublin Corporation a £1,000,000 for certain works, he did not have to bring in this Bill to do that.
Comment on this
You need not get "waxy" and show your bad temper. If the Minister wanted to give £1,000,000 for the Dublin schemes, he could have given it long ago without this Bill. He had only to ask for a Supplementary Estimate for this purpose.
Comment on this
I would not be so touchy about it if I were you. There is no use in dressing up this Bill with a grandiose name when the purpose which it is sought to achieve could have been easily achieved by other means. If there was any earnestness about it, the money could have been made available and schemes could have been implemented to give relief in areas in which relief is most needed around Christmas.
Comment on this
I move that the Dáil sit until 6.30 in order to finish the business.
Comment on this
I have made inquiries and I understand that Deputy Sweetman misunderstood what the Minister said, and that there was no offensive remark made by the Minister.He merely said that he wanted 20 minutes to finish.
Comment on this
That is not what he said. I could hear it over here. If the Parliamentary Secretary is moving that the House sit until 6.30, I have no objection. I heard what the Minister said but the Chair did not.
Comment on this
It is perfectly clear to everyone that on the passing of the Second Reading of this Bill, the House will be sending a Christmas message to the people of Cork and to the people of Louth, a Christmas message in the way of a by-election stunt.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to make a bet I will take him up on that. I will give him any money at three to one that Fine Gael will win that seat.
Comment on this
On the eve of Christmas I am offering that bet.
Comment on this
Here is the message that we are giving in the Bill, on the eve of the by-election, to the people of Cork and Louth: we want to cod you, the same as we codded the people of South Galway, by bringing in a National Development Fund Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe does not understand what we are talking about. He might at least keep silent. This Bill has had a notable history. It was announced and introduced not when this patched together Government came into office two years ago but during the by-election in South Galway. It was announced in thesummer of this year by the Taoiseach in the course of the South Galway by-election for the purpose of that by-election and for no other purpose. It would never have seen the light of day in this Dáil were it not for the fact that two by-elections now face this House.
Comment on this
It was on the Order Paper of the 20th October.
Comment on this
Nonsense. Any number of Bills that appear on the Order Paper and have their First Reading never have a Second Reading, as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach is well aware.
Comment on this
This Bill would not be on the Order Paper to-day were it not for the fact that two by-elections face this House.
Comment on this
Has the date of the by-elections been announced yet?
Comment on this
I take it that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach is beginning to regret the motion he proposed a while ago.
Comment on this
I regard this Bill as nothing but a stunt. I regard it as being designed merely for election purposes. It was first announced for that purpose and it is being brought forward again now for that very same purpose.
Comment on this
The people of this House have often had to stomach Deputy Briscoe. He might at least try to digest me for a while.
Comment on this
I am not Jonah, you know. We have had previous experience of Fianna Fáil Development Funds. The Transition Development Fund, which they introduced a few years ago, developed nothing but a national debt. That fund was proposed to deal with the situation after the emergency and during the twilight between the decadent Fianna Fáil Government and the taking of office by the inter-Party Government.
When the inter-Party Government took over, there was nothing in the kitty except a debt and a charge upon public funds. What is the idea behind this Bill? A sum of £5,000,000 will be spent, not as Oireachtas Éireann desires it to be spent, but merely in accordance with the wishes of the political chieftain of the Department of Finance from time to time. Why is it that in the past two or three weeks every county council in the country received a chit from the Department of Finance, saying: Spend all you like. Do what you like with public funds. There is money in the kitty now?
This is the greatest political ramp that has ever been seen, and it is designed as nothing else but that. I have no doubt but that, for the first time in three years, people in Cork City and in Louth will have carrots dangled in front of their noses as if they were donkeys, as a result of this Bill.
Comment on this
What about the Coalition Government's Social Welfare Bill?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government had better not talk along those lines. I have plenty of quotations from his speeches——
Comment on this
Recently, Deputy Lynch talked about the upright policyof Fianna Fáil. I hope that he will say that publicly in Cork City.
Comment on this
I shall be interested to hear the Deputy say that. This Bill is a stunt. In one of Deputy Briscoe's interruptions during the past 20 minutes or so, he said that if this Bill were not passed by Dáil Éireann this evening, men would not be put back to work. That, I think, is a very good phrase—"men would not be put back to work".
Comment on this
I did not say anything of the kind. Deputy O'Higgins is misquoting me. I said: "put to work"— to put the unemployed to work.
Comment on this
What is this Bill designed to do? Assume for it sincerity, assume for it a genuine desire to get something done: What is behind this Bill? Surely, the only thing behind it is a step to undo the damage done by Fianna Fáil since June, 1951. There is no other case to be made for this Bill except that. There are unemployed and impoverished people in this country who have been thrown out of work by Fianna Fáil and their policy since they resumed office. That is the only case to be made for this Bill. Deputy Briscoe must feel hot under the collar whenever he walks around the south side of the city and sees the people whose votes he asked for in June, 1951, rubbing shoulders with one another in the unemployment queue. No wonder the desire of Fianna Fáil is to see this Bill passed in order to put back into work some of those whom Fianna Fáil threw out of work.
Comment on this
The word "back" is Deputy Briscoe's own word.
Comment on this
I never used it. Deputy O'Higgins is deliberately misquoting what I said and is trying to mislead the people.
Comment on this
"To put men back into work." That is an important statement by Deputy Briscoe. That is why this Bill is before this House now, with two by-elections pending. Fianna Fáil like funds. They loved the Transition Development Fund. They regard the National Development Fund as something which also must be revered. What the people want is work. What they want is a stable Government and a decent policy. Not one of these things can they get from Fianna Fáil, whether or not this Bill is passed.
For the past two-and-a-half years we have had little or no national development. We have had a retrogression and a very serious retrogression in the capital programme that the inter-Party Government had in operation. During the past two or three months, Fianna Fáil have begun to see the sense in what we were doing. There are no longer speeches from Deputy Briscoe and the quondamMinister for Finance, the present Minister for External Affairs, about the danger of borrowing. There is no longer talk by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs likening our external assets to troops of occupation in Britain. There is no longer talk by Deputy Major de Valera about money in the Bank of England as being in the safest place in the world. That is all beginning to be softened down. Now we have the present Taoiseach saying that it is desirable—that it is necessary—to have a loan not once in a while but every year, if you please. Because Fianna Fáil are now beginning to realise the havoc, the hardships and the real damage they have done by their policy in the past two-and-a-half years we will have a series of Bills of this kind. The National Development Fund Bill, 1953, will be followed by a number of similiar measures garbed, cloaked and designed to cod the people of this country. The fact is that every single one of the 4,000 or 5,000 persons to whom this Bill is designed to appeal would be in constant and permanent and decent employment if Deputy Cogan, and the rest of them, had not put Fianna Fáil in as the Government of this country. May I come back to theParliamentary Secretary? I guarantee to him that, when the result of the Cork city by-election is given, he will find that the people of Cork City think as I do of a Bill of this kind.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins thought he was down in Cork when he said there had been a retrogression in the rate of spending on capital development in the last few years. In the last year of the Coalition, they spent £24.6 million on capital development, below and above the line. Last year, the amount was £32.27 million and at the time of the Budget this year, Fianna Fáil proposed to spend £39.29 million, to which we are now asking the House to add £5,000,000. It is quite natural that Deputy Dillon should describe everything introduced by Fianna Fáil as "a dirty fraud". I remember introducing a proposition to the House in 1947 which he described —Deputies will find it at column 1035 of Volume 108 of the Dáil Debates— as "a dirty fraud", a "dirty and detestable game", "flat-footed incompetence", a "shuffling, cloutish way of dealing with the problem", and a "vicious contemptible jab". Within two years, the Coalition confirmed the very same measure as he described in those terms.
If we get down to this Development Fund, it is on all fours with the Transition Development Fund introduced in 1946. Exactly the same powers were given to the Minister for Finance to spend ahead of detailed Dáil sanction, and, when the Coalition came in, do you think they regarded it as a "dirty fraud"? Not on your life—they continued to operate it for the time they were in office, and, not only did they operate it, but they added £2,000,000 to it making the fund which we had fixed at £5,000,000, £7,000,000.
Comment on this
It was not a "dirty fraud". They continued to operate it —they had that much sense.
There are a few matters which were raised by Deputy Dillon and others to which I want to reply. Deputy Blowickwould not advise any farmer to take money from the bank on which he was getting one per cent, and put it into his land, although he afterwards patted on the back a number of people in his constituency who took some money out of the bank and put it into industry. I should like to know what industry in this country offers the same opportunities for profitable investment as some of our acid soils. I gave figures that are incontestable, and they apply not only to Johnstown but to probably 80 or 90 per cent. of the land of the country which is acid and requires lime. I know that Deputy Dillon does not like ground limestone and that is the reason he told me to "have a bit of sense" when I described the Johnstown experiment. "Can you imagine anyone saying," he asked, "that, if you spend £2 on lime, you gain £100?" What I pointed out was that the results shown in Johnstown confirm what every practical farmer knows, that, if you have acid soil, you must put on the limestone, if you are to get proper crops and results from the other manurial constituents which you add to the soil.
It is too bad that, in this year of Our Lord, a man who was Minister for Agriculture for three years and who had the experts available to him should come out against the liming of the land of the country. We know that one of the first things he did when he came in in 1948 was to order that the ground limestone subsidy scheme which Fianna Fáil had in operation should be discontinued.
Comment on this
Ground limestone, in 1948—when he sent a circular to the county councils. Deputy Cogan was on the deputation to him and it is on the files and was all published.
Comment on this
In December, 1948, the county councils got notification that the then Coalition Government were not proceeding with the Fianna Fáil scheme for the subsidisation of ground limestone. It was later on that he abolished the subsidy on burned limestoneand it was only a couple of months before the Government left office, when he was kicked into it, that he agreed to expend some dollars on the subsidisation of the transport of ground limestone. If Deputies want to see the file, they may do so. When it was first suggested to him, he said: "This makes me mad" and wrote it all over the page. He tried to get his officials to prove that money spent on superphosphate would be better, but, to their credit be it said, they reported to him that the right thing to do was to adopt the scheme Fianna Fáil had and get the ground limestone on the land.
The figures for ground limestone are now, thank goodness, going up. It was started only a month or so before the Government left office. When the Agricultural Estimate had been before the House for nearly a month and when they were shivering in their boots about putting it to a vote, the scheme was announced. Scarcely two tons of it had been distributed under their scheme when they went out of office. That went up to 73,000 tons in the first year of our time and now it has gone up to 500,000 tons. It should be going into millions of tons, because there is a shortage of 12,000,000 tons which are required in order to put our acid soils into a proper calcium state.
If we do not put it on, we are not going to get the results we should get from the other manures, and it is crazy—I want to repeat this—that our farmers should be keeping money, say, £2, in the bank and getting 5d. a year interest when, if they put it into their soil, after proper analysis, and with other constituents, they might gain something like £16 13s. per year from additional crops. It is absolutely crazy. Deputy Blowick credits himself with repatriating our external assets and then objects to the farmer taking steps to buy fertilisers with his bank deposit which would operate to cash in some of our external assets for a real capital asset in the soil.
Deputy Finan was really interesting because he was so completely wrong in certain regards. He said that the great advantage to this country was the production of cattle versus tillage.
Comment on this
He said our live stock were of greater advantage than tillage, because it was live stock we could sell abroad. I want Deputy Finan or any other Deputy to make this calculation with me. Is there anyone who will claim that two acres of average land in this country will keep more than a bullock? That represents a product of, say, £10 per acres for two acres, or £20 extra when the bullock is sold in the British market. Let us take the same two acres and put them under wheat. You would get, on the average, for the same sort of quality land—two acres to a bullock—at least one ton of wheat to the acre.
Comment on this
How could the Minister make out that increased exports could be credited to canning?
Comment on this
If, instead of putting on the bullock and getting an increase of £20, we put the same two acres under wheat and got a ton of wheat to the acre—and that is small—it would be £64 for the two acres. Surely to goodness it is a good proposition, if we want to balance our payments, that we should use our land to help produce at home the wheat for which we pay an additional £44, or $126, rather than use the same two acres of land in order to get an increase of £20 in our sterling assets?
Comment on this
Those are my calculations. It is bad economics and bad social policy for this country to concentrate on building up sterling assets through a cattle population if there is any conflict between that and building up our wheat crops to avoid the necessity of importing dollar wheat. Having said that much, I want to say again that if we adopt a proper wheat, beet and tillage policy, instead of having less live stock to send to Britain and elsewhere we will have more live stock or dead stock for sale on the hoof or on the hook.
Indeed, the extra 100,000 acres of wheat that we produced last year saved us, I suppose, at least 6,000,000 or 7,000,000 dollars. That was a reasonable sum and it certainly helped our balance of payments particularly with the dollar area. One of the things I cannot forgive the Coalition Government for was that they allowed Deputy Dillon so to decrease the tillage of this country that it fell by 500,000 acres. If one takes the value of the wheat or barley they produced at that time to be even £20 an acre one can see the number of dollars we had to spend in order to buy the substitutes for our own native tillage products. It was, in fact, a criminal policy.
Comment on this
The fact is that Deputy Dillon spent the dollars. We had a series of advertisements asking farmers to grow wheat in the winter of 1947-48. The moment Deputy Dillon came in, down came the shutter on the wheat. A few months afterwards he asked the people to grow oats and when the time came to sell the oats and the price collapsed Deputy Dillon went to America and let the late Deputy Dr. O'Higgins hold the baby. We will not go into that any further.
What Deputy O'Higgins said was not enough will, we believe, enable the Government to take effective measures to deal with pockets of unemployment should they occur. It will also enable the Government, should the balance of payments and other conditions be right, to go ahead very much more quickly with national capital resources than we could without its assistance. There is no doubt that the Government will have a better opportunity of boosting production and providing additional employment. I ask the Dáil to pass the Estimate which will give us the £5,000,000 for this year.