We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1953—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–143 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1953
Lapsed

No. 36 of 1953 ›

Patrick Smith Minister for Local Government (Mr. Smith) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. It is proposed in this Bill to make certain changes in the system under which counties and other local government areas are administered by managers under the general supervision and control of elected bodies.

Under the County Management Act, 1940, six pairs of counties were each grouped and assigned a single manager. The grouped counties were Carlow-Kildare, Kilkenny-Waterford, Laoighis-Offaly, Leitrim-Sligo, Longford-Westmeath and Tipperary North Riding-Tipperary South Riding. It soon became evident, with the strain of the years of emergency and with the increasing functions of local authorities and the growing complexity of local business, that the grouped system made too much demand on the time of the manager concerned and did not afford him a fair chance of attending at meetings of all the elected bodies for which he was manager. There has been a growing feeling in many of the local areas concerned that each county should have its own manager. It is now proposed to de-group these counties. Section 4 contains provisions consequent on the proposed degrouping and gives the existing manager a choice of the county which he wishes to retain.

Criticism has been expressed in this House and elsewhere that the 1940 Act did not leave enough real control in the hands of the elected members. The contrary view has also been expressed that the "power of the purse" given to them in the reserved functions gave them full and final control over policy and the broad features of local administration and that the exercise of these functions could not be overridden by the exercise by the managers of their executive functions. My own view is that much depends on the manner in which the Act is administered and that examples to sustain both points of view may be found in different counties. In any event I have been concerned to ensure that if their general powers of financial control have not proved to be sufficiently effective and if certain managers can and do without prior consultation, commit the local authorities to expenditure which they must meet, that position should be remedied.

I am, therefore, proposing in Section 3 that the elected members may exercise direct control over additions to their staffs and over general increases in remuneration. The creation of new permanent offices by managers for which a Minister's sanction is necessary will be subject to the consent by the resolution of the county council or elected body. The intention is that additions to staff and general salary or wage increases will be brought under the direct supervision of the elected members. I am also proposing in Section 9 to give greater freedom to the elected members in dealing with the annual estimate submitted to them by the manager. At present, if the manager objects to an amendment of his estimate, the council must either drop the amendment or adjourn the estimates meeting. Under Section 9 of the Bill, the council will be able to make a final decision, either accepting or rejecting the manager's views as they see fit, without the necessity for adjournment.

Section 5 substitutes an improved procedure for the appointment of deputy county managers for that in the original Act which has shown some defects in operation. The procedure remains, however, much the same in substance. The manager will normally be in a position to nominate his own deputy. Where that is not done for any reason the chairman of the county council may make the appointment. It is proposed that the Minister will have what may be termed a residual power of appointments of deputy managers. His approval is also required to appointments made by the manager or chairman, but this approval may be given beforehand to specified persons being nominated from time to time.

Sections 6, 7 and 8 propose some minor amendments of the Act of 1940 where the wording of that Act has given rise to doubts or defects.

The purpose of Section 10 is to remove doubts about the applicability of age limit Orders to county and city managers. These Orders are made under the Local Government Act, 1941. It was considered that Section 23 of that Act enabled age limit Orders, requiring officers to retire when they reach a specified age, to apply to all local offices, including those of county and city manager. Doubts have been raised as to the validity of such Orders in relation to managers, in view of the terms of the County and City Management Acts relating to the tenure of office of managers and the section proposes to clear up the position.

Section 11 is also a clarifying section. The Local Government Act, 1925, requires the secretary or clerk of a local authority to make formal objection at a meeting where a proposal is made for an illegal payment or one which is likely to result in loss to the funds of the local authority. With the introduction of management this provision lost much of its relevance and the object of Section 11 is to restrict this requirement to reserved functions and to requisitions made by the elected members under Section 29 of the 1940 Act, at the same time making it clear that it is the duty of the manager, or his nominee if he should be absent, to make the necessary objection.

Section 12 proposes to regularise the management position in Dublin City and County where the situation has grown up over a number of years that the Dublin Board of Assistance lies outside the purview of the Dublin City Manager and certain assistant city managers hold office on a temporary basis. This section and the repeal of the Local Government (Dublin) (Temporary) Act, 1948, which the Bill also proposes, will bring the board of assistance within the management system as the 1940 Act originally intended, and will also put the present acting assistant managers on a permanent footing.

The provisions of Section 14 are included to enable the local appointments commissioners to deal expeditiously with the several vacancies which will occur as a result of the de-grouping of counties referred to earlier. The selection of persons for appointment as managers and also of persons to fill any posts which may be vacated by persons who previously held other local offices is involved. The section will have effect for a period of two years only.

The county management system as introduced was in the nature of an experiment. Its operation over a period of nearly 12 years has proved that on the whole it has conduced to an improved system of local administration at a time when the growing complexity of local government would undoubtedly have paralysed the former cumbersome system under which all business had to be transacted and all statutory acts had to be done in deliberative assemblies. The new system has certain defects and I do not claim that this Bill will cure all of them. But the defects are, in my view, not such as are in the main remediable by legislation. They arise in isolated instances and in only a few areas where the elected body and the executive management fail to attain a proper harmony in co-operation and mutual understanding. The fault may be on one side or on the other or on both. So far as I and my Department are concerned we shall continue to do our best to encourage the attainment of the necessary balance between extremes of popular criticism and a too narrow official approach. In this effort we have, on the whole, the co-operation of the leading public representatives and the majority of the managers. We must rely on time to do the rest.

Comment on this

This Bill is notable not so much for what it includes as for what it omits. Those of us who believed that the Minister was going to bring forward a management amendment——

Comment on this

Did the Chair see Deputy Keyes rising?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the point of the question?

Comment on this

I understood that when a matter like this arises, the former Minister always leads off for the Opposition. I want guidance. I think the former Minister for Local Government should be the person to move in this matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

When a Front Bench member of the largest Opposition Party offers——

Comment on this

Apart from the point raised by Deputy Cowan, I suggest I offered myself first.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The member of the largest Opposition is always called to meet a motion of this kind.

Comment on this

I understand that is standard practice.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this

I understood that there is no regulation laid down but that an ex-Minister has a prior right over an ordinary Deputy, and that would apply to the principal Opposition.

Comment on this

I understand the standard practice is that the main Opposition Party commences, but if Deputy Keyes personally wants to commence, I am perfectly happy to allow him to do so, provided the request comes from Deputy Keyes and not from the other side of the House.

Comment on this

I am not raising that point. It is not a personal matter at all. It is a question of what is to be regarded in future as recognised procedure. Has an ex-Minister a right over an ordinary Deputy, no matter what bench he sits on?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no rule or regulation governing the matter. It is purely a convention. An ex-Minister would get precedence within his own Party as against an ordinary Deputy. If a member of the main Opposition Party offers, then the member of the main Opposition Party is called. That is the convention as far as I know it.

Comment on this

But the Chair would agree that within the ordinary courtesies the former Minister should be the person to deal with the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not dealing with the rights or wrongs, or the pros or cons. I am dealing with what is the convention.

Comment on this

Apart from being an ex-Minister, I am wondering whether any particular seats enjoy a special privilege of being called in order of preference.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

A member of the main Opposition Party is always called to meet a motion by the Government.

Comment on this

Then this is not a Coalition Opposition.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not asked to interfere in this at all.

Comment on this

If Deputy Keyes wishes to speak, I would prefer if he did.

Comment on this

I am accepting the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

Am I not entitled to withdraw in favour of Deputy Keyes?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Sweetman is not entitled to say who will speak or who will not. It is the Chair who calls on the speaker.

Comment on this

If I had seen Deputy Keyes rise I would have sat down in favour of him. I am informed now that he did rise before me and, in those circumstances, I would not rise against Deputy Keyes.

Comment on this

I want to assure Deputy Sweetman through the Chair that this is not a personal matter.

Comment on this

Deputy Keyes and I know each other well enough to understand that.

Comment on this

I would raise the same point if Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Sweetman rose together. I would say that Deputy Cosgrave had a right of precedence.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Sweetman does not want to speak I shall call on somebody else. Deputy Keyes.

Comment on this

I regret the incident which has taken place, but I want to assure Deputy Sweetman that there is nothing personal in this matter as far as I am concerned. At the outset, I should like to congratulate the Minister on the brevity of his introduction of this measure and I hope that my address will be equally brief. I do not think he would be justified in making a long drawn out oration. The long Title of the Bill is:—

"An Act to amend and extend the County Management Acts, 1940 and 1942, and to make further and better provision for the local government of counties and certain other areas."

If the Minister has succeeded in living up to that, he has done so with the minimum of offence against any section. He almost overreached himself in keeping himself in a perpendicular position. Budgets which do not show very much imagination are generally described as "as you were" or "stop gap" Budgets. I think these adjectives would fit in as classifying this measure.

I wonder what induced the Minister to introduce a Bill of this character at this particular time? On reading the Bill I probably would find justification for it in Sections 12 and 13. I wholeheartedly endorse the provisions in these sections. I think that is where the Minister will have to go for justification for this measure, in that justice is being done to individuals who have given service to this country in a very critical period and who have been retained in the local government service. I think nobody in the House will cavil at the first of these sections or the section dealing with the Dublin County Council and the Dublin Corporation.

The only interference I can notice apart from that is in Section 3, where the Minister has certainly made some kind of gesture, which will be welcomed, by restoring some of the powers that we feel ought to be vested in local elected representatives and which have hitherto been wielded by county managers. I do not say the county managers generally have abused their powers. On the whole, I think they have shown themselves to be a very correct, efficient, intelligent and wise body of men who have exercised their powers by holding consultations with the elected representatives and keeping the big stick in the background. That is the way in which the best results can be got from local government and it is in keeping with the tone of circulars issued by a previous Minister for Local Government telling the local representatives of the great powers they have. In contradistinction to that, we had county managers who did not display the same wisdom as the majority and, when they saw themselves vested with powers, proceeded to use them mercilessly.

I think a section such as this is to be welcomed. It restricts a county manager from increasing staffs without having the consent of the council, and that is as it should be. The elected representatives are the people who put forward the money to keep the services going and it is only fair and right that they should have some say in the expenditure of the money. While I am not inclined to think that the average county manager will pile up staffs, if he feels like putting on additional staff, I think he should do so with the consent of the council and I therefore welcome that section.

Sub-section (2) of the same section provides:—

"A county manager shall not fix an increased rate of remuneration applicable to any class, description or grade of offices or employments under the council of the county or an elective body for which he is the manager save with the consent by resolution of such council or body."

That will be welcomed. It is a belated extension of the rights of the elected representatives so that they shall have some say in the fixing of the payments of the staff. I wonder, however, if there is any significance in the fact that there is no reference to the fact that the county manager may not reduce the remuneration of the staff. I should like to see the words "or reduce" inserted there if that is not a significant omission, because we will be creating fresh grave anomalies if we are to take from the manager the power to increase staff's salaries or wages without the consent of the council, and, on the other hand, we find a manager proceeding to slash wages or salaries without consultation with the council. I am hoping that that is only an omission and that there is no significance behind it. While I would trust councils and county managers to be able to interpret this Bill correctly and wisely, we have to have regard to the odd man out, and one or two exceptions in the general body would create a serious position.

We have had the case of a manager who not only refused to send up a resolution passed unanimously by his council dealing with the question of the remuneration of staff, but actually sent on another resolution purporting to be the resolution of the county council which bore no relation whatever to the resolution passed by that body and which was publicly and unanimously repudiated by the county council. When a man is prepared to carry on tactics of that kind, it is necessary that steps should be taken to see that each and every one of them will come into line and operate this as it is intended they should operate it in a harmonious way with the elected representatives. For that reason I welcome the restriction of the right of the county manager to increase salaries without the consent of the council, but I should like the Minister. When replying, to say whether it is inherent in that that he shall not reduce salaries or wages without the consent of the council.

In Section 14 we have the names of the various officers. There seems, however, to be a wonderful lack of enthusiasm such as was shown when we were dealing with county administration previously in this House. The protagonists of the Irish language on the Fianna Fáil Benches were then very enthusiastic about providing the correct nomenclature in Irish for the various officers. The county manager, the secretary, the accountant and the assistant secretary all got the correct description in the Irish language. There was a great deal of research for the correct description of these officers and determination was expressed that in any new legislation all the appellations must be in the Irish language. One looks in vain through this Bill for a single reference to that. The Deputies who were so enthusiastic then have transferred themselves to the Government side of the House and there is a waning of enthusiasm in regard to the progress and promotion of the Irish language. It is not without significance that there is not a single provision dealing with it in this Bill. Perhaps in the Committee Stage Deputies who were so keen on that matter and who gave us so many headaches in trying to get the correct appellations in Irish will now provide them for the officers mentioned in this Bill.

The Bill does not call for very much attention. I welcome the changes made limiting the powers of the county managers and revesting them in the elected representatives. It is a step, but only a small step, in the right direction.

Many powers are still withheld from the elected representatives, but the amendments that are being made are an indication by the Dáil to the manager that he shall not do so-and-so in dealing with wages and salaries, that he shall not employ additional staffs without the consent of the council and may furnish a pointer to such managers as are getting out of hand that it would be wiser on occasions to act in consultation with the elected representatives. In matters dealing with the allocation of houses, a very vital factor in the administration of some county councils, in some places there has been generally consultation between the manager and the elected representatives, but in some other places that co-operation is hopelessly lacking and the absence of it results in great friction at times. I should like if the Minister would introduce some provision to deal with the allocation of houses to tenants, particularly in rural areas. At best, I suppose we can only hope that the managers will take the hint that they will not act in a dictatorial fashion and that they will work in conjunction with the elected representatives in the same way as is indicated in Section 3 of the Bill in relation to wages and salaries and the employment of staffs. I think the Minister is deserving of full commendation for the provisions contained in Sections 11 and 12. Having given expression to these few remarks, I do no intend to take up the time of the House further.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

It may be argued that the Bill does not contain everything that one would like to see in it but as the Minister pointed out in his opening statement the point whether or not the County Management Act has succeeded or failed is a controversial question. One would seldom find even members of local authorities themselves in agreement as to whether a particular section of the County Management Act should be amended and I think we can describe the present Bill as a careful step forward, introducing a few provisions which it will be definitely agreed by everybody are necessary. The emphasis is on shifting power to members of the elected body and even though that is being done on a limited scale, it is certainly a step in the right direction, particularly in regard to those powers formerly held by the manager in relation to the creation of new offices, the expansion of staffs or increases in the salaries of the staff. I think it is only right that the elected representatives should have the whip hand in that respect. I think the Bill, in itself, and the comments which we have so far heard upon it particularly from the previous speaker, are a vindication of the County Management Act. Despite the fact that when the Act was first introduced it was held to have taken from local authorities all the powers which the elected representatives at that time enjoyed, it is significant that at this stage one would not get a single member of the House to advocate a return to the old system.

I do not for a moment suggest that the County Management Act was perfect or that the system which it introduced has worked perfectly. I agree with the Minister when he says that managers may, in some instances, have interpreted their duties, not exactly in the way we intended under the original Act, but I personally think that most managers have taken on themselves too much work of an active kind. Instead of concentrating their efforts more on supervision of those under them, they felt that they had specific duties assigned to them in different offices. I think managers who have taken their duties very seriously in that respect and who have tried to be at the beginning and end of every bit of administration within the county have found the burden unbearable.

The effort to carry out all these duties imposed too much of a physical strain on many managers throughout the country. I do not know whether those who are not members of local authorities realise all the work a county manager has to attend to, particularly when he opts to carry out his duties according to the interpretation which most managers have put on the duties imposed on them under the County Management Act. Those of us who are members of local authorities realise that, unlike the work of the members of the staff of the local authority, the manager's work does not cease at five o'clock and that very often when the members of the staff go home to rest or to indulge in some healthful recreation, the manager has to pull out his car and drive many miles to another centre to attend an urban council meeting which frequently lasts into a late hour in the night if not into the early hours of the morning. The fact that he has to remain out to a late hour at night to assist in administering urban affairs at some other centre, does not excuse him from turning up in the morning at the county council office to enter on his usual duties for the day.

In counties where there are two, three or four urban councils, the manager may find that his hours of work in the year are far in excess of those which any other officer may have to devote to the performance of his duties. Considering this aspect of the activities of the manager, I think that the Minister should take power in this Bill to have appointed in large unworkable counties, if we may use that term, an assistant manager to whom the Minister at the request of the council or the elected members of the local authority can delegate certain powers of the manager in order to lighten the load on the manager. I am not referring to the deputy manager provided for in Section 5 of this Bill but to an assistant manager who would be appointed on the advice of the local authority to take charge, say, of the work connected with urban councils or any other particular section of the manager's work, in order that the manager might not be overburdened with these particular functions and so that the administration of the county might be carried out with the greatest possible measure of efficiency without imposing an undue strain on the manager.

All of us know of instances where the county manager makes a desperate effort to arrive as near as possible at perfection in the administration of the county affairs. In doing so, he tries to be at the beginning and end of every deliberation. He becomes an executive officer who feels that he must be responsible—he is actually responsible under the County Management Act— for every decision taken. The Minister may argue that the manager need not expend so much personal effort in his attendance to these duties. It may be argued that he has the county medical officer of health, assisted by the county health officer, responsible for health, and the county engineer and the county secretary are responsible for the particular duties which come within their sphere. That theory, however, does not always work out in practice. At least, it is not always the practice of the active county manager, who must see that the decisions taken by these other officials are justified. He must examine them and feels that he must be present when they are arrived at. I think that that imposes an unnecessary strain on one individual who attempts to be at the beginning and end of every single decision taken in regard to the administration of the local affairs of the county. I think it would be wise, therefore, if provision were made in the present Bill to enable the Minister to appoint an assistant manager, whenever advised to do so by the local authority, to undertake some of the duties hitherto allotted to the manager who may find it impossible at times to deal with matters as expeditiously as they should be dealt with. We have the very heavy burden of housing in most counties which, in itself, would require the almost constant attention of an executive officer. I know it may be said that the manager can easily delegate these powers to the engineer in charge of housing, but I do not think it is always possible to do so, and when a manager is responsible for every decision he does feel he must take an active interest in every detail leading up to important decisions to be taken in that respect. That is only one example of the many duties a manager has to undertake.

I think, on the whole, the Bill is a careful step forward in the right direction. One might like to see more in it. Some will argue that the elected representative should be given more powers. Others will say they have sufficient powers already but I remember when the Act was first introduced one thing that was said was that public men would take little or no interest in local government in future, since the powers were filched from them by the Managerial Act. The lie, I think, has definitely been given to that allegation made by the people who were opposed to this Act. I think it is proven that a good type of public representative has come forward since the Managerial Act was put into operation. If anything I would say the standard of local authorities has improved so far as the elected representatives are concerned. I feel that it itself gives the lie to the allegation made at the outset. It is a sign that the Managerial Act did give a reasonable outlet to elected representatives to exercise their interest in public affairs and to take a full part in shaping local administration.

This Bill gives a little bit more authority to them and that is to be welcomed. If it does not go further in that respect it is because, as I say, we ourselves who are members of local authorities are not able to agree as to whether we should have greater powers or not. Those powers which are retained absolutely by the elected representatives are not always administered in a perfect manner. That might be said to be a reflection on elected representatives but I think one can say that since the managerial system came into operation various matters, particularly the allocation of houses, have been administered in a much fairer manner in accordance with the regulations laid down than they might be administered by the actual representatives if it was left in their hands.

The manager is guided by a set of regulations in the allocation of houses and if he does not comply with or conform to these regulations he knows that the members of the council will very quickly bring to his attention any lapse or indiscretion of which he may be guilty. For that reason his one object is to ensure that he keeps within these regulations and that anything done by him is something that he can stand over in any discussion or against any censure that may be brought on him by the local authority of which he is in charge.

On the whole, the Bill is to be commended and I think while there are some items which may be corrected or enlarged on the Committee Stage it is a careful step forward in the right direction justifying, as it does, the Managerial Act. While there is no doubt it is not a very comprehensive measure, it makes no mistakes with regard to what it proposes to do. I welcome the Bill.

Comment on this

This Bill is noticeable not for what it includes but for what it omits. Even Deputy Brennan who has just spoken admits it was a very small step indeed. So far as the small steps are concerned in it, I agree absolutely and entirely with the comments made on it by Deputy Keyes. The step that is included in respect of the powers of the managers in regard to increasing the number of officers is one that has been necessary for some time. It is one which as a matter of fact I advocated in this House on a previous occasion.

I would absolutely disagree with the view expressed by Deputy Brennan that it was necessary to appoint additional assistant managers. Any man who tries to see to every detail of the administration under him is a bad administrator. The type of administrator who should be there as county manager is not the person who would go down and see that the office boy licked the stamps. If he goes down twice a day to see that the office boy licks the stamps and gets involved in small details like that he is going to be completely overwhelmed. There should be only one person responsible for the type of things for which the manager is responsible and to try to divide responsibility as Deputy Brennan suggested would mean very much additional officialdom and it would be entirely unnecessary.

Take, for example, housing allocations. I do not know what the procedure is in Donegal, but long before the Managerial Act was in operation the Kildare Board of Health handed over recommendations for the allocation of houses to the chief medical officer. I think from what I have heard that is pretty universally the position in the country, that the chief medical officer makes recommendations and brings them forward to the housing committee not for the purpose of the housing committee challenging those recommendations but for the purpose of enabling the housing committee to get and to bring certain local information to bear on the problem and to get local verification of the claims that have been made by the allottees.

I cannot see what necessity there would be for putting in another official to do that work. The whole difficulty that has arisen in respect of the County Management Act since its implementation in 1942, following the passage of the Bill in 1940, arose out of the manner in which the managers were sent out to do their work in that year by the then Minister for Local Government. The then Minister for Local Government sent out those managers primed with the view that they were to take a far too literal interpretation of the Act and that they were to be the bosses and that the elected representatives of the county council were to have only the minimum powers reserved for them by the principal Act. As the years have gone on the managers in most counties have got away from that rigid dictatorial view. In some counties as a result of fairly heated rows between the elected representatives speaking on all sides of the table without regard for Party on the one hand, and the manager on the other hand, the managers have got away from the original interpretation with which they were sent out by Deputy MacEntee when he was Minister for Local Government in 1940.

One of the difficulties that exist at present in the administration of the managerial system is that it is very hard for the elected representatives of a county council or an urban council for that matter to know what exactly their powers are and what rights they have. I have always felt that it was necessary that there should be some official who from his specialised knowledge would be able to advise the council as to what their rights were. I think there should be put into this Bill on the Committee Stage a statutory provision binding a secretary of a county council to give advice to the elected members of the council as to what their powers are vis-á-vis the county manager, so that that would be there under statutory provision. If it is not there under statutory provision, the secretary would feel that in giving advice to the elected members of the council as to what powers they had vis-à-vis the manager he would be disloyal to the manager as his superior administrative officer.

Only yesterday I was asked about a case where the elected representatives of a council wanted to bring forward a motion in the county council to call for a sworn inquiry into a certain appointment by the manager. They were calmly told by the manager that he would not accept the motion, that it was an executive act and that they had no right to discuss it. Of course, it is perfectly clear that the elected representatives on a county council have an absolute right to discuss a motion such as that if they so desire. They have an absolute right to discuss at their meetings anything that they may wish. That was a clear case where the elected representatives did not know and, from the nature of things, could not be expected to know what their rights were and were browbeaten by the manager. If there were a statutory duty on the secretary of a county council to advise the members "you are entitled to do that" or "you are not entitled under the statute to discuss such a matter, to take such a decision", the elected members on local bodies would know where they are.

When the Act was brought in in 1940, the nearest commercial analogy that could be taken to the manager that was set up at that time was a governing director, a governing director who was limited only in respect of certain specified matters in the articles of association. I have never felt that that was the right way in which local bodies should be administered. I have always felt that the right way for local bodies to be administered was to have a local council laying down the general lines of policy, leaving it to the manager to carry that policy into detailed effect. The members of a county council cannot go into details. It should be for the members of the council to say that such-and-such a job is to be done in a particular way and to leave it to the manager to do the details. The manager should not be empowered, under any circumstances, to refuse to carry out the wish of the local body or to say that it is a function of his and that he will not heed what the council, as a whole, desire in the general direction of policy. In other words, as in a commercial concern, the manager should be the general manager, subject to overriding control of the board of directors.

If the Act had been introduced in that spirit, and if the managers had been sent out in that spirit, there would not have been a great deal of the outcry that there was in the beginning, because they were sent out to deal with matters in an autocratic and overriding way.

I blame the then Minister for Local Government almost entirely for the misconceptions that arose in the minds of honourable men trying to carry out their duties, who felt it was their duty to carry out what the Minister of the day directed.

The present Minister is perfectly correct when he says that the system of grouping counties is most unsatisfactory. Carlow and Kildare have had experience of that. It has been most unfair to the manager and to the two counties concerned. It is almost impossible so to arrange the business of the two counties as to avoid a clash between calls on the manager for Carlow when Kildare County Council is meeting and for Kildare when Carlow County Council is meeting. It also means that there is a more difficult situation in respect of urban areas. Division of counties into single units rather than groups is overdue and will obviate some of the difficulties that have arisen.

I regret that the choice is left entirely to the manager. It would be desirable that the choice should be made after consultation with the local authorities concerned. Lest anyone may think that I am saying that about the joint manager for Kildare and Carlow, may I make it clear that I am not? I do not mean the word in any insulting way, but after that manager received his education in the County Management Act jointly from Deputy Harris and myself, he now complies with the universal wish of the council as a whole and, so far as his operation of the County Management Act is concerned, I do not think that Deputy Harris or I, or the members of the Labour Party in Kildare, have any criticism to offer. It is wrong that the choice should be left entirely to the official. There should be some method by which there would be consultation, at least, between the chairmen of the councils concerned.

The real difficulty in regard to the rate estimates meeting, to which the Minister has referred in Section 9, is not really the question as to whether the council must adjourn or not but the question as to what details must be put before the county council. So far as we are concerned, we get details in Kildare now, as a result of requests made over the years, which I have shown to members of county councils in other areas. They have all told me that if they got the estimates presented in the detail in which we receive them there would not be any of the complaints that they get. The managers in some counties — and I am afraid this Bill will not make any difference — apparently the Minister has not given any direction to the contrary to managers — produce the barest and most meagre figures and expect members of the local authority to make up their minds on them. In one case the manager complied merely with the minimum requirements of the Public Bodies Order in this respect and showed so much for health, so much for main roads, so much for county roads, so much for public assistance, so much for general purposes, giving no details at all of the manner in which the figures would be divided. That displays very little confidence in the council and is treating the council with contempt.

If the power of the purse is to be the controlling power of the elected representatives on the council over the chief official in the area, that power can only be effective if a detailed estimate is put before the council at the estimates meeting, in the same way as the detailed Book of Estimates is circulated to the members of this House in regard to governmental administration.

The provision of a section directing the details to be furnished by county managers to elected representatives on the council would be a cumbersome method of doing the job. Managers should do it without being directed by statute to do it.

I am glad to say that our experience is very happy in that respect. We may differ very often with the manager about the items on which there is to be expenditure or about the amounts in particular cases, but at least we can say that we get the fullest information in the estimates which are put before us. I have seen estimates circulated in other counties, and I know for a fact that the local representatives there do not get as much information as we get. I think that provision should be made, either by an Order under the Public Bodies Orders or under a statute, to ensure that members of county councils would have before them at their estimates meeting not merely a global figure but the fullest figure. They should have at their disposal detailed figures so that they may be able to see where a saving can be effected, and in that way make a proper estimate. Otherwise, what happens is that members merely say they are going to take 5, 10 or 12 per cent. off the estimate. That amount is first put on and then it is taken off, but that is not the way to get the job done.

Comment on this

My remarks on this Bill will be brief, firstly, because I think it is so scanty and inadequate that it does not permit of close or detailed examination. I understood from some statements that were made by the Minister in public some time ago that we were going to have a very elaborate amendment of the County Management Acts, and that the sole purpose of the amendments would be to put back into the hands of the members of the local authorities a substantial measure of the powers which were wrested from them in 1929, 1930 and since then, under the various county and city management Acts which have gone through this House, every one of which met with strong opposition from the Labour Party. So far as these Acts are concerned, the Labour Party was the one Party which was opposed to having the powers of local authorities filched from them in the wholesale fashion in which they were filched under the various Acts passed through this Dáil.

Whether we look at the 1929 or the 1930 Act, or at all the Acts which have gone through since then, I do not think the House can feel satisfied that it has yet evolved a system of democratic control in local affairs. The very fact that there has been this agitation for an amendment of the County Management Acts and that it has been found necessary to have amendments to them from time to time — that you have all Parties on local authorities asking for these amendments — is clear evidence that we have not yet found a satisfactory and democratic medium for dealing with local government affairs.

This is a most inconsequential Bill. Apart from recognising a few mistakes which have been made in earlier Bills and of adjusting a few obvious wrongs to individual officers of local authorities, the Bill, in fact, leaves the whole question of county and city management just where it was, and whether or not this Bill is passed does not matter twopence so far as the powers of local authorities are concerned.

The whole difficulty, of course, in connection with the County Management Acts was that, even if a case could be made for some kind of a county management scheme, they never were launched in a climate that gave them a chance of succeeding. The managers, when they were appointed in the first instance, took on the function not of being a manager to a local authority but manager of a local authority, and once you gave these administrative brass hats the notion that they were the managers of a local authority then, of course, it was going to be the devil to wrest back the powers which they had arrogantly assumed to themselves.

That has been a source of trouble throughout the country. It is perfectly true, as Deputy Sweetman has said, that down through the years there has been a fight by members of local authorities to hold the powers which they properly believed were theirs, a fight by the local authorities composed of representatives of the local people to be consulted on matters on which they were better judges in the opinion of the local people than, say, an imported manager could be. Quarrels arose on such matters as that the manager was exceeding his powers. So far as the county managers were concerned, there was a disposition on the part of some of those insufferable brass hats to hold on to powers which they thought they had under the County Management Acts. Talking about these insufferable brass hats, I knew a few of them. I am not speaking of the county manager for Carlow and Kildare. Whatever the position may have been there in the early days, an atmosphere was created in which we have now a reasonable blend of wisdom, flexibility, sanity and toleration which has been properly distilled and enables the local authorities in Kildare, irrespective of the political views of the members, to team in with the county manager and to do things in a reasonable and amicable way. That, however, is very different from the position that obtains in Laois and Offaly. If I go there, I come out of it with a raging headache, having listened to the way in which the local authorities there are being thwarted and defied by one of these insufferable brass hats. Where a thing like that happens, you have in the job of manager, a person who is clearly a temperamental misfit and an administrative misfit. I think that what should be done with a person like that is to take him out of the position and give him his full pension, tell him that he is not capable of handling a local authority, and that he has not the disposition to blend with the different shades of view represented on that local authority. The thing to do with him would be to put him on pension and send him to the Riviera. As it is, he is merely thwarting the wishes of the local people and doing everything that he is not supposed to do.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair feels that the Deputy should not single out county managers for attack.

Comment on this

I do not want to attack them, but I hope that when the Bill is in Committee to get a section into it which will enable a local authority, or will compel the Minister to remove an administrative misfit because such a person is a blister on local government in this country. Where you get an intelligent manager who is prepared to team in with the local authority, who does not insist on exercising despotic powers, who does not feel all the time that he is the Caesar of the local authority, you get a fair measure of satisfaction. The Labour Party, however, would prefer, since they believe in democracy, to see much more power given to the local authorities.

In so far as a manager exercises power, he should exercise it in the same way as the manager of a public company, the secretary of a trade union or as an employee of any other particular organisation throughout the country. The difficulty, as I have said, with the county managers is that they regard themselves not as managers to the local bodies but managers of the local bodies. I think that the Department of Local Government and the Minister could usefully spend some time trying to hammer that fact into the heads of county managers who, so far, apparently have been able to put up an impregnable defence as to what they are supposed to do in the matter of working in co-operation with the local authorities.

I think the section in this Bill which separates two counties from single administrative control by county managers is a recognition of the fact that this scheme never worked satisfactorily. Where a manager has two counties it is not fair on the counties and not fair on the manager, and in some of those cases I have heard allegations made that the manager is more interested in one county than in the other, and going to the next county you will hear that story in reverse, whereas the real situation is that the managers try to do the best they can for both counties. Of course, he is always travelling in a case like that, and once he is in one county the people think that therefore he is necessarily on the side of the other county. This is a wise recognition of the fact that that scheme never worked satisfactorily. It could never give you effective administrative control, and it was unfair both to the counties and to the managers. It is extraordinary, in fact, that it survived so long, but it is now well to recognise that we are abandoning it, and its abandonment ought to make for better relations between local authorities and the county managers. It will also relieve the county managers of a burden which I think it was unfair to put on them when they were doing their job to the best of their ability, seeking to attain the highest measure of efficiency.

Section 3 of the Bill is welcome too. It is the kind of provision which should never have been necessary, because here again quite clearly the local authority should have been consulted in any matter of either reduction or increase in staff or reduction or increase in remuneration.

I do not think that Section 10 is going to give back to the local authorities very many of the powers which have still been withheld from them. I am interested in Section 10 because I find some difficulty in understanding what exactly is intended. I am rather wondering whether we are deliberately setting out to break legal contracts or whether there is going to be any adequate compensation for the persons concerned. So far as I can judge from the section and from what the Minister said, it is now intended by Section 10 to remove some doubts. I gathered from what the Minister said that apparently the four persons mentioned in the section have a tenure of office which does not require them to retire at a particular age limit and, therefore, this section is put in for the purpose of saying that they shall hold office, unless they die, resign or are removed from office, and retire on reaching the age limit. Presumably, therefore, the Minister does not feel that he has power to remove them at the moment on reaching what is described as the age limit. Apparently they are not subject to an age limit at the moment and I take it that they must, therefore, have a contract which does not require them to retire at a particular age. I could conceive, of course, that it might be desirable to require people to retire at an age fixed, an all-over age limit, but if these people have contracts with the local authority, surely we ought to respect the contract, and if we are breaking the contract and saying that they will be pushed out of the service of the local authority we ought to recognise that that requires from us that if we are cutting the contract short and cutting the service short we have an obligation to compensate them either by the grant of additional years of service or in some other way.

I think that the Minister has power under the 1948 Superannuation Act to grant additional years of service in such cases. In any case it is a well-known provision in the Civil Service code that additional years may be granted where a person is removed from office for any reason outside his own control. If there is to be an age limit fixed for these people under the powers conferred on the Minister in legislation, then I think that in equity we ought to recognise that the Minister should, up to the limit of his capacity, and all the time acting within reason, give those people compensation by way of additional service. I do not know whether that interpretation of the section is correct.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say that if they have a contract giving them an additional age limit, would that fact affect the contract unless they so agreed?

Comment on this

Frankly I do not know the circumstances of these cases. I am only jut thinking that this is an effort to terminate contracts which exist, presumably because the Minister has no power to terminate them under any previous legislation. If they are going to be terminated we ought to be fair to those people. If we are going to tear up the contract and going to say that we are doing that in the public interest we ought to say that we are going to compensate them adequately for terminating the contract. I can conceive, of course, that a person might hold an appointment for life but I do not think anybody wants to see a centenarian as a county manager and, therefore, we might say to a person in such circumstances: "Really, time is having a devastating effect upon you and upon the municipal affairs, and what we propose to do is to require you to retire at a certain age. But while we are breaking your contract by terminating your service with the local authority before death claims you we are going to give you x additional years of service so as to compensate you for doing that." Deputy Cowan says that you might not in a case like that do full justice to the person, and perhaps it is not easy to measure scientifically or with precision what is full justice in a case like that, but what I am concerned about is to prevent an obvious injustice which would arise if we gave a person who had a contract a bonus based on less than he would get if he retired at the normal age limit.

I do not know how many other cases the Minister hopes to apply this compulsory retirement section to, or whether he feels he has power in other cases but no power in this case, but frankly if we are going to terminate this solemn legal contract we ought not to be niggardly and ought to act fairly to the people concerned. I do not want to measure their compensation in any excessive terms of money. All I want to do is to prevent obvious injustice being imposed upon them. The Minister ought to be reasonable and, indeed, generous if those persons have to retire under circumstances which involve a breach of their contracts.

Comment on this

It is very refreshing indeed for anybody who listened to the opposition to the County Management Act, 1940, to hear the debate as it has progressed so far to-day. Anybody remembering the opposition at that time must feel very satisfied that the County Management Act has justified itself. Surely it is untrue to say that any Act is a failure because it must be amended. We have over the years here amended very many Acts. None of them were failures so far as we know but they were amended in the hope of improving them. Surely Deputy Norton's argument that the amendment has proved the failure of the Act is ridiculous in the light of all the Acts being amended in order to improve them over all the years. As one who has had some experience of local government for more than 30 years, on boards of guardians, rural district councils, county councils, boards of health and boards of assistance, I think that the County Management Act was a great blessing to the people of this country. Surely no Deputy wants us to go back to the days when if a poor man with a big family living in a bad house wanted a labourer's cottage he had to go without, while the fellow with no family and a good house but more pull who wanted a cheaper house was facilitated. I saw that happen very often and I was glad when the present system was evolved for the allocation of houses.

In relation to all the functions deputed to county managers, we in Cork have reason to be proud of the manner in which the County Management Act has been administered over the years. We have not had any of these insufferable "brass hats" that appear to have been imported into other counties, according to Deputy Norton. We have been very lucky in having managers who gave of their utmost in the administration of the affairs of the county, who consulted with the council on every possible occasion and who always permitted the councillors to consult amongst themselves and to make recommendations on any matter affecting their administration.

Deputy Sweetman complained of the manner in which the estimates are presented. I understand there is a set legal method through the medium of which the estimates must be presented. Every year when the estimates are presented to the council in Cork an explanatory memorandum is also circulated setting out in detail under each heading the increases or the decreases and the reasons for them. We have no reason to grumble in that respect and that procedure is in keeping with all the other functions of the manager. Managers, if possible, anticipate the wishes of the council and its different boards. People who opposed the County Management Act here and in the various county councils are now glad that it has proved such a success. The fact that we are improving it still further in the light of the experience gained over the years is also a tribute to its success.

Comment on this

That statement is a bit too sweeping.

Comment on this

I will listen to the Deputy later on, through the Chair. Section 3, sub-section (1), of this Bill says:—

"A county manager shall not submit any proposal to increase the number of permanent offices under the council of the county or an elective body for which he is the manager for the sanction of such Minister as may be empowered to sanction the proposal save with the consent by resolution of such council or body."

In the past we have had occasion to complain in connection with the numbers and remuneration of staff because instructions were sent down from the Department of Local Government; it was reserved to the manager to employ and appoint staff. The council could, of course, object when the time came for providing the money to pay, but I think the amendment is to be commended, together with sub-section (2) which says:—

"A county manager shall not fix an increased rate of remuneration applicable to any class, description or grade of offices or employments under the council of the county or an elective body for which he is the manager save with the consent by resolution of such council or body."

That gives the council complete power in relation to the numbers and payment of staff, and for that reason it is welcomed. I do not see anything in this measure with regard to the appointment of rate collectors. That has been a somewhat difficult proposition in many counties for some time past. There have been vacancies for the rate collectors in our county, and when these vacancies occur all kinds and classes look for them; the canvass begins, and the racket, and it is the fellow with most pull who is appointed. That applies to all Parties. I do not think it is an improvement to leave that appointment still in the hands of the county council. Possibly some more reasonable method of making appointments can be devised either through the medium of competitive examination and interview or in some other manner. At the moment it is the candidate with the most pull who is appointed irrespective of whether or not he is fit for the job; if he fails, his friends will have to pay up for him if he is not sufficiently insured.

I have not heard anything said against this amending Bill. I have not heard anyone say that it should not be passed. I think under Section 12 better provision should be made for the management of County Cork. At the moment we have a manager and two assistant county managers. The county is divided into three sanitary and public assistance districts, north, south and west. The total expenditure in the county is £2,750,000. In the north it is £289,690; in the south it is £459,800, and in the west it is £180,000 odd. The smallest of those areas has a larger expenditure than the smallest county and expenditure in the others would compare favourably, I think, with a normal county. In addition to that, we have an expenditure on roads of £892,000 and on the mental hospital of £218,000, as well as health £278,500.

Special provision is being made in this Bill in Section 12 for Dublin County. There is a demand for another assistant manager in Cork, and I am of opinion, and so are many Deputies who are members of the Cork County Council, that there should be a third assistant manager. We have two assistant managers and the county manager. Those men are definitely overworked. Surely there is nothing more injurious to the administration of any Act or the carrying out of any work than that the official responsible should be overworked. In the County Cork we have nine urban authorities, six sanatoria, a mental hospital and all the district hospitals.

I think it was Deputy Sweetman who said that the county manager should not be expected to see that the office boy licked the stamps. But surely he must be acquainted with everything connected with the administration of the body which he manages. As I say, we have six sanatoria in the county and a mental hospital. Surely before the manager can make an order dealing with any of these he must be conversant with its administration. He need not go to the extent of ensuring that the office boy licks the stamp, but if he is to be an efficient manager he must know what he is making an order about. One of these men in Cork at the moment is seriously overworked; as a matter of fact, he is seriously ill because of overwork. We have a county manager who is retiring under the age limit and a new manager is to be appointed. Now is the time to ensure that there will be good administration in the future in Cork as there has been in the past, and Section 12 should be amended so that there can be a third assistant manager in Cork. I am satisfied that county management has been a success in Cork. I think that tribute must be paid to the members of the council of all Parties for that, as well as to the managers. We trust that this Bill will be a help in administering the affairs of the county for the future.

Comment on this

I have no fault to find with anything contained in this Bill. My only complaint, like that of some other Deputies, is that it does not contain enough. I am one of those who were at all times opposed to the County Management Act. I was not a member of this House when it was passed, but as a member of a local authority I felt that it was a negation of democracy. I always thought it was absurd that expenditure should be incurred by electing a county council which, when elected, could exercise no authority, and that is my view still.

Anything I have to say in regard to the Act does not relate to any county manager I know. I am not speaking on personal grounds at all; I am speaking of the Act itself. I know some of the individuals who operate that Act and I believe that some of them very considerably altered their ways since they came to operate the Act as it stands. I believe they are improving every year and making themselves more tolerable. I agree with Deputy Norton that some of them were definitely intolerable in 1942 and for a few years afterwards. That may have been due to the fact that they were called county managers. I think that if in this Bill the title could be altered and they were called executive officers it might be worth while.

Comment on this

What is in a name?

Comment on this

There is something in a name and the Minister knows it. I did hope that when a County Management Bill was being brought in by the Minister, who was for a long time, I think, a member of a local authority, he would have far-reaching changes in the measure, but I have been disappointed. I think I am right in saying that opposition to the county management scheme does not come from any one particular Party in this House. I think I would be right in saying that when that Act was put through the House it was only by a very slender majority of the Party then in power. I know that in my own county there are members of the Minister's Party as violently opposed to the County Management Act as I am. I do not think it is a political issue at all.

In regard to whether it is a success or a failure, I contend that the County Management Act was justified on the ground that it would bring about more efficient and economic administration. I challenge anybody to say that there is to-day more efficient or economic administration than there was prior to 1942. The county councils as they existed prior to 1942 were efficient, their staffs were efficient, and the ratepayers got as good service from them as they have got since.

With regard to economy, one has only to look at the level of rates to-day, although I concede that that is not a fair argument. The Act must, however, bear some part of the blame for the present level of rates. I admit it is not a fair argument, but there is no evidence of economy in local administration. There is no evidence of greater efficiency and it is for that reason that I would say it has been a failure. I think that the greatest evidence of its failure is that we have to bring in amending measures which go nearer every time to reverting to the position which existed prior to 1942. Each amending measure is welcomed by members of the House because it approaches nearer and nearer to what obtained prior to 1942, and it is only because it approaches in that way that it is welcomed.

I think, too, that when county managers were being appointed it would have been far wiser to pick in each local authority area some man with long experience of local administration as a member of that local authority rather than an official.

He would be in a position to know the official side and the people's side and he could hold the balance fairly. But when you put in charge of a local authority, in a position of supreme authority, a gentleman imbued with a bureaucratic mentality, giving him the name of a county manager, you could not escape from the position of despotism that has existed since 1942 amongst local authorities. There was no possibility of escape. I am sure there could be found in any Party in any constituency a capable man who has been on local authorities and who has given unselfish service, who would far more ably and equitably discharge the duties of county manager than any official who has been appointed. I know that the Minister could not satisfy me with any County Management Bill except a very brief one, and that would be one that would repeal the County Management Act, 1942. I am convinced that until we revert to the position that obtained then, we will have no really democratic local authority.

It would be far better if the Government in 1940 or in 1942 had gone the whole hog, abolished county councils and appointed county commissioners, because here is the position that obtains. People who go to the trouble of going to the polling booths to elect county councillors will not believe that they have no authority on the local body. They naturally say: "Why elect you at all, if you cannot do something to remedy the position?" That is a natural thing to ask. I could not agree with all that Deputy O'Sullivan says with regard to certain corruption which did occur in different counties. They were extremely isolated cases and there was always a method to deal with them. The law was enforced in cases where that corruption was exposed.

What I would like the Minister to do would be to bring in a comprehensive Local Government Bill that would alter the whole scheme of local government and put it on a proper democratic basis with each unit represented, the parish being the first unit. We have the position that county managers embark on grandiose schemes, extravagant and expensive schemes, schemes which, of course, are good in themselves but which this country cannot afford. That is the whole trouble. No man could reasonably object or say that these things would not be desirable but we have got to remember that this country was over 700 years in bondage and neglect and we cannot expect to achieve in a lifetime or in one generation what it took 700 years to destroy. I say that local authorities and central authorities are putting too much before themselves and before the people. Here is the trouble. If you object to any of these schemes you are dubbed as being very backward. "You are not progressive," my colleague Deputy McQuillan will tell me.

Comment on this

I will keep the skids under you, all right.

Comment on this

What we want is somebody to keep the financial skids under the people who have to finance these schemes.

Comment on this

What is finance?

Comment on this

An intelligent Deputy like Deputy Cowan surely must know what £. s. d. is. At least, I am sure his clients do. I do not want to delay the House in this matter because, as I have indicated, I cannot oppose anything in this Bill. I welcome it. My only disappointment is that the Minister did not go a lot further. I believe that he or some of his successors will ultimately have to go a lot further, before satisfying the people who are trying to exist under local administration as it is to-day.

Another point to which I should like to refer is the presentation of the local estimate. The statutory form of the estimate is not satisfactory. It is not sufficiently explanatory for people who have not an opportunity of attending the estimates meeting, or having it explained in the manner in which it is explained, in our county at any rate, at meetings, both orally and by memoranda. It is all right for members of the county council who can attend the meetings, but I think that there should be a more explicit form used so that the average ratepayer may know what he is paying for. The statutory form, as it is now compiled, means nothing to the ordinary person. The items are grouped under four or five headings and they convey nothing. I think it is desirable that some change should be made in that form.

Comment on this

This amending Bill should be assured of a speedy passage. I am surprised that a revolutionary type of Minister such as the present Minister, a Minister of a Republican Party, was not willing, in view of his own knowledge and experience, to go a little bit further than he has gone in the provisions of this Bill. I and my colleagues who are members of this group at different periods violently opposed the managerial system. I thought it a ridiculous thing that, in 1929, five or six years after we had received the authority of the people to form a Government to manage our own affairs—and the electors who are responsible for election of Deputies to this House were equally responsible for the selection and election of members of local authorities—the Government of the day should proceed to deprive members of local authorities of power to manage local affairs.

I violently opposed and voted against the first Bill that was brought into this House in 1929 by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government of the time to impose a system of management on Cork City—the Cork City Management Bill. Everybody who remembers what happened immediately after the coming into operation of that measure will know perfectly well that there was violent opposition and controversy created between the local authority and the manager who was appointed to run the affairs of the city. At a later stage we had Bills brought in both by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and the Fianna Fáil Government providing for the management of the affairs of the Cities of Dublin, Waterford and Limerick and depriving the elected representatives of the people of having practically any say whatever in the management of local affairs. That was followed by the County Management Act. I could never understand why the Fianna Fáil Party, who originally when they came into this House opposed the managerial system——

Comment on this

We did not.

Comment on this

——should take up the cudgels to perpetuate that system by bringing in the measure now known as the County Management Act.

Comment on this

I am denying the charge that has been made by Deputy Davin and if he refuses to withdraw it, I will ask him to show cause to prove that we in fact at any time opposed the managerial system.

Comment on this

I see. That makes it worse. I accept what the Minister says as an apology on behalf of his own Party. In any case I do agree with the Minister that the system was introduced originally and extended by the Fianna Fáil Government subsequently as an experiment. This Bill —this milk and water measure—is a confession of failure. I welcome the introduction of this measure so far as it goes towards restoring the powers originally held by members of local authorities. If the system has failed, it has not failed because the system itself was fundamentally bad but because in many cases the people who were appointed had no previous experience of local government administration and in some cases were temperamentally unsuitable for the positions to which they were appointed.

I thoroughly agree with the suggestion made by Deputy Finan that an attempt should be made by the Minister and his advisers and whoever is responsible for making these appointments, either as city or county managers, to have qualifications laid down so that the individual applicants for the positions of city or county managers would have to have a minimum period of service with some local authority and thereby have some experience in local administration. I think it is a ridiculous thing —personally, I have nobody in mind in this matter—that a person should be taken from the Army, for instance, and planked in as manager of a local authority over the heads of the servants of the local authorities who have service ranging up to 30 or 35 years. It is a reflection upon the officer of a local authority who has 20, 30 or 40 years' service and experience if somebody who has no knowledge or experience of local government is to be taken from somewhere else and put in over his head. It is a bad thing for the county council, but if the county council has no power over that system I do not suppose it matters to them.

I would urge acceptance of Deputy Finan's system—and I hope this suggestion will receive support from the other side of the House — that preference should be given or marks allocated to anybody who is an applicant for the position of county manager in the future who has service and experience with a local authority.

Comment on this

What kind of service?

Comment on this

The Minister, who has long experience, knows much more than I can ever learn about the running of local authorities and the essential qualifications of an officer and he would know perfectly well and would, I am sure, admit that a secretary of a county council—if you happen to have a secretary with 25 or 30 years' service and aged about 50— would be a much more suitable person to be county manager, from every point of view, than a person taken from some sphere of activity where he had no knowledge of local administration.

Comment on this

Deputy Finan's suggestion differed from that.

Comment on this

Well, I am making that suggestion. I hope the Minister understands me. I do not mind whether he turns me down or not. This is an occasion when one can make suggestions, and I am not the most competent person to do so, and I bow to the Minister's greater knowledge and experience in matters of this kind. But I would object strongly, and I am supported in my objection by influential organisations, to the introduction into the transport service, for instance, of a fully qualified chartered accountant as an executive officer of a rail or transport service. He might be the best accountant in the world, but he would come in there lacking the technical knowledge that a man in such a service requires in order to make him a competent man.

There is another aspect of it. The people working under the county manager in local government administration have not got the same respect for the man who is planked into the job without previous experience that they would have for the man who has earned his promotion in the school of experience. I do not think it is necessary to elaborate that matter any further with the Minister, but I hope it will be taken into consideration when the powers that be—the Minister included—come to make future appointments of this kind.

It is quite correct to say that because certain people got glorified titles as county manager or city manager when they received these appointments, they suffered from swelled heads at the beginning. Some of them were temperamentally unsuitable for the position, and did not believe in the democratic system of government. They believed in their own authority and believed in exercising it in a rather dictatorial way. But I am glad to acknowledge from what I know and from what my colleagues in other areas have told me that many of the managers who originally took up the attitude of tin-pot dictators—brass hats, as Deputy Norton called them—changed that attitude or had it changed for them by the members of the local authorities.

I know one county manager who caused such irritation and opposition to the members of the local authority of which he was supposed to be manager that he was suspended, but he is the best boy in the world since the day that suspension was imposed on him by the majority of the members of the county council. Even in the last couple of years I drew attention in this House to the attitude of a county manager, not county manager of either county in my constituency, who when a resolution that he did not like was passed by the majority of the county council politely defied the county council and told the members that he refused to send the resolution to the Minister for Local Government. The same county manager was asked last week—and you will see evidence of this in the local papers if the Minister wants to make inquiries——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing individuals.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going very close to it.

Comment on this

I am merely quoting an instance of where this county manager, when asked by the same county council last week if he would send a resolution to the Minister, answered "yes", and according to the report in the local paper when he answered "yes" he was loudly applauded by the members of the county council who were responsible for passing the resolution that the county manager had to forward.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I still feel the Deputy should not discuss individuals so that they can be known in this House.

Comment on this

I am entitled to make my case for more extensive powers than are contained in this measure.

Sub-section (2) of Section 3, referred to by previous speakers, I am glad to say, restores powers in certain matters to members of county councils. It says:—

"A county manager shall not fix an increased rate of remuneration applicable to any class, description or grade of offices or employments under the council of the county or an elective body for which he is the manager save with the consent by resolution of such council or body."

I congratulate the Minister on inserting that sub-section because the power held by certain managers gives them the right to ignore and defy members of local authorities in regard to a matter of that kind.

It is a bad thing from the point of view of local government employees, road workers in particular, that a county manager who is manager of two counties should operate different rates of wages in those two counties. Unfortunately, that is the position in my area. The members of this group have been advocating that there should be the same rates of wages for the same kind of work.

Can any Deputy give me the answer to the argument that a road worker employed by Laois County Council should have 5/- or 3/- more per week than the road worker employed by Offaly County Council? There should be some standardisation of rates of wages for road workers, especially those employed by local authorities outside the principal cities.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does that arise on this Bill?

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) of Section 3 will give the sensible, reasonable and decent members of local authorities an opportunity to regularise the position.

Comment on this

How would a member of your council know what they are doing in Donegal?

Comment on this

The ratepayers of County Offaly are in as good a position to pay the same rates of wages to their workers as the ratepayers in Laois. I am glad that this power is being restored in sub-section (2) of Section 3 and I congratulate the Minister on having agreed to do it in a Bill that is otherwise a milk and water measure.

As Deputy Finan briefly said, the managerial system was originally introduced for the purpose of giving us a more efficient and cheaper system of local government. What is the cost of administering the engineering section of local authorities in rural areas to-day compared with the cost when the County Management Act came into operation? I addressed a question to the Minister on that subject recently, having some knowledge of the huge increase that had taken place in my area, and the Minister said that the information was not in his Department. I knew it was not in his Department, but the Minister had power, if he liked to use it, to get that information and to let it go on the records of the House. The Minister either did not want to give me the information or did not want to ask the county manager to disclose the figures. The figures would be flabbergasting. They will be obtained through the usual and proper channel—by questions by members of the local authorities concerned.

I ask the Minister, have we been given a more efficient and cheaper system of local government than obtained when the first Managerial Bill was introduced in 1929? Staffs have been trebled. Can anybody say that there is treble the amount of work being done?

Comment on this

Of course, there is.

Comment on this

There is one member of the House who is satisfied. I asked a rhetorical question and I take it Deputy Killilea knows why he said "yes".

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy himself know the reason?

Comment on this

I would like to be satisfied that, so far as the engineering side of the local service is concerned, the huge increase in cost is fully justified.

Comment on this

Take the number of road workers, and all the rest.

Comment on this

There has been a complete change.

Comment on this

There is satisfaction in the fact that there are more road workers employed and that the road workers get a longer term of employment than they were getting in, say, 1929 or 1940.

Comment on this

Do you object to that?

Comment on this

I give due credit to the Minister and his predecessors, and the officials of the Department, for endeavouring to work out a policy whereby the majority of the men employed will have continuous employment and qualify for pensions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is dealing with questions of administration that do not directly arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

If they do not arise directly, they arise indirectly.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They do not seem to be relevant.

Comment on this

The Deputy objects to the increased number of road workers.

Comment on this

Not at all. I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

That is the engineering service.

Comment on this

No. I am talking about the cost of the engineering service.

Comment on this

That includes road work.

Comment on this

A road worker is not an engineer. The Deputy should know that better than anybody else.

Comment on this

Road work is the biggest part of it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Davin should get back to the Bill.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy Killilea has not yet given the House the benefit of his wisdom and experience. I will listen in silence to his eloquent address, if he has the courage to tell us what he thinks of this Bill, its shortcomings, or any other aspect.

Comment on this

I will not object to an increase in road workers.

Comment on this

Is it right—and if it is not right will the Minister correct it— that certain county managers who cannot be made conform with the wishes of members of county councils, should withhold from them important documents that are addressed to the county council by his Department? I have received complaints in writing about cases where most important policy circulars—I would not mind if they were minor matter—were addressed to the county council by the Department and the first that the members knew about them was when they were read out by the secretary at a meeting. This has some bearing on local government administration and some relevance to this discussion. When circulars are sent out by the Department to county councils, especially if they are dealing with policy matters, copies should be sent to the members before the next meeting. Is there anything wrong about that?

Is it right that a county manager or other officers of the county council should refuse to put on the agenda resolutions sent in by a member of the council and should write a letter to the member explaining that his motion was not in order and stating the reasons why and the position in regard to the matter? I do not think a manager should have that power. If managers have been exercising that power, as I know they have been in a small number of cases, they should be told where they get off.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is not it the law agent that rules in effect on this?

Comment on this

In taking part in this discussion I had no intention of making political capital. I should like to see every side of the House dealing with the question of county managers on a non-political, non-Party basis. There will never be a final settlement of this question if it is discussed on the basis of Party politics. I apologise to the House if anybody thinks that I am speaking on this matter with Party bias or for Party purposes.

Comment on this

Labour Party policy on county managers!

Comment on this

The Labour Party opposed the managerial system, and there is evidence of that on the records of this House. I am not making any apology for that. I should like to think that the members of all Parties, including the Labour Party, were approaching a solution of this matter on a non-political basis. I am not going to blame the present Minister for the misdeeds of a few county managers who act in an autocratic way. Neither am I going to blame his predecessors or the officials of his Department. I am certain that no Minister, past or present, or any official of his Department, would direct county or city managers to do some of the things that I know they have been responsible for, namely, ignoring and treating with contempt the elected representatives of the local people. Democracy is based on the working out of a system of central and local government that will give the greatest possible power to every citizen who has a vote in the selection of local authorities and of members of this House. Surely, if our citizens have the intelligence and the privilege of electing Deputies to this House, they should have some say in selecting the members who are to run the affairs of the local bodies.

I have heard it said in this House— it was hinted here to-day but it has never been proved to my satisfaction— that there was such an amount of corruption in this country at a particular period that this dictatorial system had to be brought in. Deputy O'Sullivan talked to-day about taking away from local authorities one of the two powers which they possess, namely, the appointment of rate collectors.

The members of local authorities exercise two powers: (1) the appointment of rate collectors, and (2) the striking of the rates. If it becomes necessary, they have to back up the county manager in sending out the sheriff to collect the rates from the ratepayers in their area. It has been suggested, and it may be true, that in a very small number of cases there was at a particular period some corruption. That was hinted at here to-day. It was hinted at that all over the country, wherever a number of rate collectors are to be appointed, there is widespread bribery and corruption. That, I think, cannot be true, but Deputy O'Sullivan seems to think that there is something like that still going on and to such an extent that the members of local authorities should be deprived of that privilege, and that the appointments should be handed over to some more competent and more honest to God type of body.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I think it is too far-reaching to say that there is widespread corruption. I think the better thing to say would be that there is widespread canvassing.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, from what I have been told of local authorities in my own area, I accept Deputy Madden's way of putting it. I do not believe that there is widespread corruption. Is there any member of the House who believes it? Therefore, I think it would be wrong to suggest that this power which the members of local authorities have should be taken from them. I am speaking as a Deputy without any experience as a member of a local authority.

Comment on this

That is quite obvious.

Comment on this

Yes. I do not get up and say that I am infallible. I have never done that. I hope that, as long as God gives me life and health, I will learn something every day. Perhaps Deputy Briscoe does not believe in that kind of outlook or mentality.

Comment on this

The Deputy was speaking as if with authority on something that he has had no experience of.

Comment on this

I have had the advantage of listening to members of my own Party who discuss these matters, and who have had long experience as members of local authorities. As a Deputy, I do not want to interfere with local affairs in Leix or Offaly, but if I am asked to do so by any organised group in my constituency, then I will do so because that is my job. I shall do so whether Deputy Briscoe likes it or not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The suddenness with which Deputy Davin sat down surprised me for the moment. I do not want to follow the line that he was on. The Deputy mentioned rate collectors. Many people think that is a function which might be dealt with as an executive function rather than in the way it is at present. On the general principle this Bill is a simple one in many respects. It is a minor amendment of the principal Act and of the amending Act of 1942. Many speakers on the Opposition side gave one the impression that they would wish to change the whole system of the County Management Acts as we know them. Deputy Finan was very definite on that.

What is the case for the County Management Acts? In a nutshell it is that under modern conditions where government, local or otherwise, intervenes in a large number of aspects of the life of the community, it has to be organised on a businesslike basis. The old system whereby one tried to carry on the day-to-day business of a body through committees was just not adequate for modern requirements. That, to a certain extent, is a fact that will have to be grasped and appreciated in regard even to central government. It is becoming more and more obvious every day that this House, for instance, cannot in detail control all the ramifications of the subjects that come here for legislation or for comment. In short, government to-day, both at the top and in local government, with which we are specifically dealing here, is so interwoven with all the aspects of the life of the community that it will have to be organised on a businesslike basis, in which sense the community as a whole has to go through its life very largely in a competitive environment such as a big commercial concern has if it is to survive.

In these circumstances it is clearly necessary to organise the local authorities as regards the ordinary day-to-day running of their business affairs. The scheme set upon eventually was the County Management Acts which, in effect, appointed county managers to administer the affairs of the county councils or other local bodies, and to schedule certain functions as reserved functions. The general idea could very roughly, but not completely, be compared to a commercial arrangement where you had a board of directors representing the shareholders to manage the concern, with a managing director to run the concern and carry on its ordinary business. In the commercial case, in the ordinary case, the powers of a board would be rather more wide and less defined than the relationship of a county council with a county manager, but I think some kind of idea such as that inspired the Act. But there were certain complications there. One was that it had to be done by statute and there was a necessity for definition. That necessity arose from historical circumstances. You were going to change to a new system and it was necessary to define clearly what the change was and secondly the overriding interests and control of Parliament, of the central Government, had to be allowed for, particularly where the Minister for Local Government was concerned. The scheme as originally proposed very clearly on paper, at any rate, worked out as—shall I say?—an independent county manager with the local authority there to provide for its reserved functions and it was hoped that the two would work in harmony. That can be said for the letter of the law. Undoubtedly the intention was that, and the intention is being worked out fairly well if one can take the opinion of the Deputies who have spoken already from the country. The intention was that the elected body and the county manager would work in harmony and discharge the business of that local authority in harmony and with the safeguards working both ways —the safeguards that were there for efficiency, for attention to detail, and shall I say protection from temptation in certain matters, that were there in the set-up of the county manager would be to the benefit of the council, and, on the other hand, the fact that the council was overriding with its functions would be a guarantee that the interests of the local area and the electors would be looked after, too. That was the spirit of the Act as far as I can see and it seems to have worked out.

Deputy Sweetman made an attack upon it, but then he completely weakened his own argument by immediately disclaiming any suggestion that he wanted his criticisms to apply to the local authorities of which he had direct experience, thereby saying, in effect: "Where I know myself the system is working it is working perfectly, but I am told it is not working so well somewhere else." What use is that kind of evidence? You have Deputy O'Sullivan, on the other hand, who talks about his own experience, that it is working. Deputy Davin, when pressed, disclaims all detailed personal knowledge.

Comment on this

No, no. Be fair to me. Experience.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Experience. Sorry. Experience. Deputy Finan again safeguards the region of his own experience and again gives the impression that he is merely talking hearsay, he is talking about somewhere else. That is very easy for any of us. I may meet somebody in the House and hear something said and come to the conclusion that in some distant county everything is all wrong, but I do not know anything about it really. I would be prepared to listen to Deputies who will come in and say: "This is my experience on the local authority of which I am a member or with which I am associated, and this is wrong." I would listen to that, but I think we may be pardoned, those of us who are not members of local authorities, for being sceptical when we hear Deputies like Deputy Sweetman coming in and saying: "This is wrong and that is wrong," or Deputy Norton talking about autocratic brass hats. Then we have the qualification straight away, like Deputy Sweetman's saving qualification, when he declares positively that the system is working very well in the area of which he has experience. I think that a lot of what might at first flush pass for fact here in this argument can be brushed aside.

What are we really dealing with here in this? I get the feeling that the main difference of opinion will boil down to this—those who believe that modern times demand a system of organisation where you will have officers like county managers directly responsible and, at the same time, having a discretion and the power to exercise that responsibility reasonably, that you will have such officers to administer in many ways, perhaps, the bulk of the business of the local authority, the routine business anyway, and the local authority there working, as it should work, in co-operation, and which has certain reserved overall functions as a public safeguard and as a local safeguard for the population of the area which that local body represents. That is one view. It is the view I think that I, from what I know of it, subscribe to. I feel that in present circumstances—take questions of contracts, tenders, take questions of employment particularly, take questions of the routine that is involved in the ordinary business running of a local authority and its relations with headquarters, and take, in particular, the smooth working and smooth co-ordination of the local authority with the central Government —all those things create a demand that there should be something in the nature of a county manager there, and I think that in order to enable him to work he must have, generally speaking, the powers that were prescribed for him in the principal Act. I said "generally speaking". I will come back to that.

There is another point—let us face it. The question of the rate collector was mentioned. Let us not say that there is any evidence or any particular evidence, but take Deputy Madden's words that there certainly is an extraordinary canvass done; and it is extraordinary how personages in the local authority, political or otherwise, get involved in the issue of the election of a rate collector and it is extraordinary the amount of recrimination and accusation that can come from that simple administrative function. When one finds that the system of appointment to local authorities generally under the appointments arrangements now in force is by and large satisfactory, and that the system of appointments to the public services generally in the country, the Civil Service, is by and large satisfactory— when you compare the two things I should rather want to be convinced that there was some very good reason for excepting that one type of appointment from the ordinary run rather than the reverse.

There are reasons of that nature which could also be advanced in support of the 1940 Act, and in fact were. If I were to go into that I would simply be repeating what was said in the debate on the County Management Act. I do not intend to do that. It is on record already, very freely thrashed out. But there is something else. From the legal point of view the old machinery was very cumbrous. I am not sure what the statistics would show, but certainly from some experience in the past one found that local government machinery was very prone to give rise to all sorts of litigation from mandamus up to fully fledged actions and so forth and so on; and that machinery, which was very well in an age when the function of government in the first place was considered to be a rather wide and less defined field than to-day, largely concerned with law and order and peace and war and very little concerned with economics and accounting, and, in the same way, the functions of local government in their initial concept were largely concerned with such questions as the poor law, rates and certain aspects of local government administration of that nature without all the ramifications that have been introduced and are in existence at the present time. These ramifications have come in both at the top and at the bottom and if we are to have an effective system of government here we must have a proper businesslike organisation. The old local government arrangements under the 1898 Act, its predecessors and successors, were certainly not calculated to promote efficiency. The position would be somewhat akin to our saying here—and this might have been much more reasonable a couple of hundred years ago—that we will get rid of all the secretaries and Departments and do everything here ourselves. I wonder how we would do it even with a much more restricted field than we have to deal with at the moment.

In relation to the principle involved, from a number of points of view we are constrained to say that the factors of modern life force us to some such system. I personally would like to see it develop in this way: we have to face the fact that government, whether local or otherwise, has its finger actually in every aspect of community life and, indeed, in almost every aspect of the individual's life either directly or indirectly. Government, in the broad sense, has such a multitude of activities to deal with, and these activities —economic, political, social and so forth—are so interdependent that one can only get reasonable efficiency in the life of the community and a reasonable degree of comfort by means of organisation. What I would like to see is our gradually moving towards a situation where that organisation can be simplified. Frankly, I sometimes think we try to do too much at central headquarters. That remark might be very definitely directed to the activities of government which are specifically in point under this Bill. The ideal would be to try to delegate, as far as possible, power to local authorities. I think a very strong case can be made for that. The central Government should then try to evolve into the position in which it will have an overriding control and co-ordination, looking upon both of these as its proper functions, and where it will be content to leave detail as far as possible to the local authority or to the sub-strata in the organisation of local government.

If that concept is to be developed, it is absolutely necessary that we should have an efficient, clearly-defined, continuous and continuously responsible set of links in the chain of local government machinery. I cannot see a democracy, for instance, whether in this Parliament—and we will take our own particular case—or elsewhere, functioning in local bodies, taking the totality of the democracy as the central democracy functioning in this Oireachtas and the local democracies functioning down the line, I cannot see that working——

Comment on this

Why not do away with democracies altogether?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Allow me to make my argument. I cannot see that working were it not for the fact that associated with it we have a Civil Service and the other necessary services, including a local government service which has the virtues of continuity and detachment and is in part relatively independent of day-to-day fluctuations in policy, which is one of the good features of democratic control. Lest I be misunderstood let me explain what I mean by fluctuations in policy; the machinery that is in existence has the virtue of reacting to policy very quickly. The machinery is such that it is not affected by the changes. It adapts itself to the changes. It is the one continuing machinery and therein lies the strength and, in my humble opinion, a fundamental reason in the practical sphere for our being able to make democracy work.

This could expand into a very long debate if one were to follow that particular line. The essential point is that one needs a competent service or organisation, namely, a central Government; that is, the Oireachtas, through the Government, which is, in theory, a Committee of this House operating through its present service, plus the local authorities, each functioning through its permanent service. In that sense it seems to me that the case for the county management system is unanswerable, at least in face of the old system as its only rival, and I certainly have not heard anyone put any other argument forward.

I might pursue that point a little further. I have dealt with it from the point of view of the fundamental argument. There is another practical viewpoint. It has been rather interesting listening to members of the Opposition —I am not making this now as a political point—saying again: "Scrap the County Management Act." Deputy Norton pointed out that they opposed it in the beginning. The interesting thing is that when all the Opposition Parties had coalesced in power and were sitting on these benches they did the same kind of talking and they produced an Act called the Local Government (County Administration) Bill of 1950. When that Bill was introduced here it was patently obvious, both from the memorandum accompanying it and from the debates on the Bill itself that, finding themselves faced with the job of Government, the last thing to which they could face up— they were evidently coerced by reason —was to throwing overboard the principle of the County Management Act. Deputy Finan says that is the only thing that would please him. It would have been very simple for them to have scrapped the county management system, if that were practical politics.

I think it is reasonable to assume that would have been done at that time if it were the right thing to do, but quite obviously the Parties who were then in power found the arguments coercive. There was a certain amount of smoke-screening. The county manager's name was changed to county officer. He was restricted to performing certain functions which were defined as tenancy functions, health functions, employment functions and so on. The Bill did provide for certain executive committees which were to have certain residual powers but the reserved functions of the county council as we have known them since 1940 were left.

I would be out of order if I were to digress into discussing the 1950 Bill, but I want to point out that when the matter was examined by the Parties then in power the best they could do was to make an adjustment. They changed the name of the county manager. Possibly there is no point in that Frankly I think it is scarcely a matter worthy of legislation, except in the most incidental way. It provided that certain of the functions of the county manager would be discharged by certain executive committees of the county council; but, otherwise, it left the powers of the county council or the local body as they were because if one examines the Schedule of the 1950 Act one will find that the scheduled functions comprise the more important of the reserve functions which are at present discharged directly by the county council. In other words, they purported to restrict the powers of the county manager, but actually, you will find no significant difference. There was reserved to the county manager just the things which Deputies are talking about, employment functions, tenancy functions and individual health functions. When you went through the whole thing you found that you had the County Management Act essentially the same as it was before with a few changes.

That is rather important for this reason, that obviously the principle is sound. It has been considered and tested by two different Governments, if you like to put it that way. It was passed by one Government and criticised severely by Parties who were then in Opposition. All those Parties became the Government in the Coalition and they considered the matter to the extent of bringing in this Bill from which I quoted. It was debated in this House and, on analysis, you find that the fundamental principle is the same in the two measures. In that situation it is very hard to accept some statements such as that made by Deputy Finan.

Let me say, while admitting all that, that probably in all legislation there is room for adjustment. I think some of us back in 1950 were prepared to consider certain things, though we pointed out that this 1950 Bill was a sham. We rather suggested at the time that it was an attempt to give an appearance of change rather than to make any real change. There may have been some things in the Bill which would have been helpful amendments to the 1940 Act. There is nothing inconsistent in that but, as I say, the principle was obviously examined by two Governments and found to be the right thing. The fate of that Bill is interesting. It got amended out of all proportion in the House. I have only my own personal recollection of what happened when I was on the far side of the House. My recollection is that the Bill got into an extremely confused state and subsequently died a peaceful death.

As far as this Bill is concerned, frankly I think it is minor in its effect, but that it is a move in the right direction. While I will fight vehemently with Deputy Sweetman or anybody else on the general principle, let me say that certain adjustments in the scheme may very likely show up and should be made. I am very chary to talk about what has been said. Let me, for Deputy Sweetman's benefit, repeat what I said when he was not here since I said it about myself. I said that Deputy Sweetman's arguments would be very convincing were it not for the fact that at the heel of the hunt, when he attempted to make a disclaimer in regard to the community area of which he has personal knowledge and where he can claim to be an authority on local government, I think he will admit as a lawyer that he weakened the value of the things he stated.

Comment on this

It strengthens them, because we changed his tune.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Do not change yours now.

Comment on this

My tune is quite clear. It is very different from the Deputy's, because it has always been consistent.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

So has mine. I was making a point about the principle of the Act and about its adjustment. I said I was rather chary about talking of what was said. But, there is one thing I would concede, and this goes for administration generally whether it is at the top or whether it is down the line, that it is fundamental to the harmonious working of democracy that there should be full disclosure and full information to the elected body, unless for some very serious security reasons or something like that. I think it is our prerogative as the supreme elected body, to get all information from what I might call the organisational parts of the State, and I also think it only right that members of local authorities should be adequately informed. If there were any question of that, I think that would be the attitude I would adopt.

On the question of estimates, I think it is only right that, just as in regard to the question of estimates here, detailed information should be given as the elected representatives require it. In the same way, there is something in Section 3 which I think is a move in the right direction. It does not go to the root of the principle of the organisation, but it certainly is an adjustment to which I would agree. After all, it is the electors, the community in the local authority area who will pay the rates and, apart from Central Fund grants and things of that nature, they will have to finance the administrative expenses and so forth of the local authority. In this case, I think it is very equitable that this power should be given. I think that the original intention, a very proper intention, would have been that the county manager would have regard to the intentions of his council and to local circumstances in making such decisions. I think the Minister was quite right to the extent he has gone in Section 3. A person with an executive job, somebody who wants to do something, is rather keen on doing it in the best way possible and, with human nature being as it is, certain counter-balances are necessary so that all factors will be properly weighed.

There are probably other instances in the local government code where a similar type of adjustment would help, but I am not sufficiently aware of the situation to pin-point where that could happen. I am just thinking of the question of housing which does not arise on this Bill but, by way of putting across an idea, I might mention it. I have often thought in regard to such a question that the central Government could leave much more to the local authority in regard to questions of detail which would obviate delay. A combination of that, plus a provision such as this, will make the local people realise very much that they are paying for these houses, because they will pay in some way or another. You might in that way get efficiency and, shall I say, contentment, and a move in that direction seems desirable.

Sections 12 and 14 are important where they are applicable but, from the overall point of view of local authority organisation, they are relatively minor. I would be inclined to comment on this Bill, at this stage anyway, in regard only to the principle contained in Section 3. It may be necessary to work a little further in that direction to get a balance. I would strongly urge, at the same time, that the general framework of the 1940 Act should be strengthened and kept and that we should put out of our minds this talk about going back to the old system and abolishing county managers. That is really no help and is causing difficulty. If there are personality problems, that is a question for Ministers and Deputies and goodness knows there are enough people to get after headquarters in regard to a matter of that character. Where we have personalities working all right, then the minor adjustments that are necessary to make should be our concern and we should not distract ourselves by such impossible suggestions as to go back to the old system.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy mind my asking him a question?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No.

Comment on this

The Deputy has commercial experience. Does he want the manager to be a controlling director or a general manager?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

When the Deputy was outside the Chamber I spoke of the position of managing director.

Comment on this

Is he a controlling or governing director?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Without being offensive, the Deputy is exaggerating. He has autonomous powers but he is not a governing director in any real sense.

Comment on this

He is.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

He is not.

Comment on this

In respect of everything except the reserved functions.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is only in a certain sphere.

Comment on this

A managing director would not be autonomous in a certain sphere. He would be subject to the overriding powers of the board.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Frankly, I would prefer working in that direction. At the same time you have to face a certain difficulty. The Deputy has used the analogy of the board and the managing director but the difficulty is with elected bodies as you have them; you have something of the same type, but never forget your Ministers and Secretaries Act which seems to be necessary for the smooth working of this Assembly. With the peculiarity of the elective system, with the necessity for a business organisation in the modern world, particularly in relation to the Custom House, I am afraid you have to make certain things clear. You must put a manager in a position——

Comment on this

Of controlling director.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No, but of some independence. At the same time I would be all for, as far as possible, the views and the actual power of the local authority being effective. Frankly, I am afraid when you boil this down and analyse it you will be thrown back on the question of tact, because in the modern situation the managerial concept is essential and we have to combine it with committees of elected representatives. It is a question of getting smooth working between the parties involved. One thing I can see is necessary and that is that on the part of the elective body there should be a reasonable control of power and understanding and, shall I say, a fair facing of a problem, a facing of problems on a realistic basis to make the working of the administrative section smooth and, on the other hand, a full and candid disclosure of information and loyal co-operation by the officials with the elected body. Now we are into a discussion of democracy generally, but that is in fact what is involved in this. Finally, you had it yourself. You adopted a lot of things that you could have got away from in the 1950 Act.

Comment on this

We got away from more than that.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The record will bear that out. On the whole, I think we are going to say that this Bill should pass. The Opposition's criticism is that it does not go far enough. I am just wondering how far it could go, perhaps in some details but only in details.

Comment on this

As many Deputies have commented, this is a minor amending Bill, but the one section which alters the functions of the manager in relation to the members of the council, Section 3, does, I think, tend towards the description of the manager given by Deputy Sweetman, that of a general manager, carrying out the wishes, in so far as certain defined functions are concerned, of the local authority. To that extent the tendency, I think, is in the right direction. Members of local authorities have expressed the view that the system works satisfactorily, provided the manager works in harmony with, or in conformity with, the views of the elected body. I think that the proposed alteration in Section 3 which will ensure that no additional offices may be provided or remuneration determined without the consent of the elected members of the local authority will ensure the effective recognition of their views, and will generally meet with approval throughout the country.

The other major alteration in this measure is the decision to end the grouping of counties and to appoint a separate manager for each local authority. Deputies who have experience of a county manager functioning under two local authorities have expressed the view that it is much more satisfactory to have a manager for each single local authority.

I want to direct the Minister's attention to the problem as it exists in Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire. The Dublin County Council and the Dún Laoghaire Corporation have requested that separate managers be appointed for each body. That does not in any way imply a reflection on the different managers or assistant managers who perform particular functions and who have particular responsibilities to these local authorities. The position in Dublin is that there is one Dublin City and County manager and three assistant city and county managers who perform certain defined functions. These functions are defined on the basis of a particular manager or assistant manager being responsible for health, another for general administration and a third for housing. I think it is quite true to say that, while the appointment of a manager or an assistant manager for a specific function may be satisfactory in Government Departments, the functional division of responsibility is not suited to a local authority. The three local authorities concerned, the Dublin Corporation, the Dublin County Council and the Dún Laoghaire Corporation, differ in area and in various degrees from the point of view of the various matters that have to be attended to.

I would suggest to the Minister that he should consider acceding to the request of the Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire Corporation for separate managers. The problem of local government in Dublin which includes Dublin Corporation, Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire Corporation has been considered by Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire Corporation. The matter requires careful study and consideration. Dublin County Council did suggest that the proper division of functions might be determined on the basis that the administration of impersonal and planning services such as main roads, sewerage, water supplies, regional planning, hospitals and similar services of the entire city and county could be administered as one unit with a view to economy in administration, but that the administration of the more personal services such as housing, health services, public assistance, secondary roads, lighting and paving, in which the need varies from area to area and any other personal service should be administered on a local basis and that local policy on such matters might be fixed by the local representatives to suit local needs.

I would suggest to the Minister the establishment of an informal committee or body on which there would be a representative of Dublin County Council, a representative of Dublin Corporation—although that might not be necessary—but certainly representatives of Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire Corporation and subsidiary bodies. At the moment the task of administering these three local authorities is a very big one for a single manager and three assistant managers particularly when these managers have defined functions and when they are responsible for these functions for three local authorities comprising in population one-fifth of the country.

I am glad to notice that provisions in Section 12 and also in Section 13 will clarify the position of these assistant managers. I would like to know from the Minister why it has been decided in sub-section (5) of Section 12 to take power to fix different remunerations for the different offices of Dublin assistant city manager.

The other matters I have referred to —the question of providing separate managers for Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire and for giving careful consideration to the proper system of local administration and a proper system of local authority to administer the affairs of Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire and whatever part of the city may be involved in it—should be the subject of investigation by representatives of the bodies I have mentioned. Unless a definite decision is taken to endeavour to get a proper system for Dublin City and County—and that includes the subsidiary bodies—I believe the system will tend to be more expensive and less effective.

I believe the Minister should accede to the wishes of the elected representatives of these two bodies I have mentioned. If it is being done for other local authorities there is no reason why it should not be done for Dublin County Council and Dún Laoghaire because both of these authorities exercise jurisdiction or have responsibility for a population in both cases bigger than many of the local authorities that will have separate managers. In these areas the growth of the population has been more marked, I think, than in any other local authority in recent years. The growth of housing and the development that is taking place in these areas and in areas on the fringe of the city which have been recently given to Dublin Corporation by Dublin County Council is an indication of the very rapid and continuous development taking place over a number of years and which has been accelerated since the end of the emergency. These factors tend to call for an early decision on the problem of local government as it effects Dublin Corporation and Dún Laoghaire.

Comment on this

I am very interested in this Bill which purports, by its title, to amend the County Management Acts of 1940 and 1942, but which, in fact, also amends the City Management Act of 1930 and amends it in a rather comprehensive manner although that Act is not cited in the Long Title.

I am not going to take up the time of the House in going into the theories of local government or discussing the effect that city or county management has on democracy. I want to get down to this Bill to see to what extent what is in it can be improved and what is missing from it can be added.

Deputy Sweetman, when he talked about the county manager being a dictator and when he said that the reserve functions of the elected representatives were not sufficient and did not give them sufficient strength, likened the position of a county manager to a governor or dictator. He forgot to recognise that there is over and above the county management— whether it is a combination of both elected representatives and a manager or not—the Minister for Local Government and the Department of Local Government to examine and decide all matters which they decide to do.

That brings me to Section 3 of the Bill. I have heard Section 3 commented on very favourably by those who feel that this is an advance from the previous position and that it means a restoration to elected representatives of certain functions from which they were previously precluded. I do not think that goes far enough and on the Committee Stage I want to bring in certain amendments to Section 3. In fact, I am going to add three or four amendments and I will explain why. Sub-section (1) of Section 3 definitely states that a county manager shall not submit any proposal to increase the number of permanent offices under the council of the county or an elective body for which he is the manager for the sanction of such Minister as may be empowered to sanction the proposal save with the consent, by resolution, of such council or body. That is all right. Sub-section (2) says:-

"The county manager shall not fix an increased rate of remuneration applicable to any class, description or grade of offices or employments."

That appears to be good. That appears to mean that the council will have control of increased remuneration to specified types. Again, it does not go far enough. I want council members to be made fully aware of all the things that the city manager or the county manager may have in mind in regard to staffs. Not only should he submit what is stated here but, every month, he should submit to the elected representatives particulars of all staff proposals, which would include promotions of existing officers. That is not specified in the sub-section. I have prepared an amendment to bring that about and to give that control to the members over staff matters where the members have to be responsible for remuneration.

I also want an amendment, and I will deal with it on the Committee Stage, to the effect that the council may by resolution appoint a committee to investigate the working of any department under the council and submit such recommendations as the committee may think necessary or proper for the more efficient conduct of business for examination by the manager. In other words, I want the council to be in a position to criticise and examine with a view to making suggestions for the more efficient performance of the authority's departments. The question was discussed this evening as to whether a county manager was efficient or not or whether the County Management Act brought about efficiency or, as Deputy Finan felt, the reverse. It is necessary in view of the move the Minister is making towards giving the elected representatives adequate control of the authorities' affairs that there should be full control, without interference in the day-to-day administration and without getting into a position where individual councillors might attempt to interfere in day-to-day matters.

Appointment of certain local government officials takes place through the Local Appointments Commissioners. Up to the present the city manager or the Department of Local Government laid down the conditions attaching to the appointment. I want the Minister to agree to accept an amendment to the effect that when the Local Appointments Commissioners are requested, under Section 6 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, to recommend a person for appointment to an office under a council, the terms and conditions of such appointment shall be subject to the approval of the council. I feel that the council are entitled to vet the terms and conditions and to amend or approve or disapprove. Then the candidates can go before the Local Appointments Commissioners who will see that they qualify not only in regard to the requirements of the Department of Local Government and the city manager but in regard to the requirements of the council itself.

These are a few samples of the types of amendments that I intend to suggest for Committee Stage.

The Minister and most Deputies who have spoken agree that the grouping of counties under a manager is bad. We have learned a great deal by experience of county and city management legislation so that we can make it a better instrument for the welfare of the people. I agree that grouping is bad. It is particularly bad, as Deputy Cosgrave has pointed out, in Dublin County, Dún Laoghaire Borough and the City of Dublin. If there is to be individual management of counties, let it be individual management and, where this Bill refers to the county, amend that and let us in the City of Dublin have our city manager, and our deputy or assistant city managers to ourselves and let the Minister appoint for the County of Dublin and the Dún Laoghaire Borough whatever managerial control is necessary. I shall put in an amendment to bring about individual management to the extent that it concerns the County Dublin and the City of Dublin.

In order to bring that about I shall have to move an amendment to sub-section (3) of Section 3 of the main Bill, to sub-section (2) of Section 10, sub-section (3) (d) of Section 10, sub-section (3) (e) of Section 10, all of the main Bill. Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the main Bill will have to be repealed in order that Dún Laoghaire will be separated from Dublin administration. Section 10 of this Bill brings in the City Management Act, 1930, under which our present city manager was appointed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Does the Deputy intend to separate Dún Laoghaire from the county as well as from the city?

Comment on this

I am not speaking for the county or the Dún Laoghaire Borough. I am only speaking for the City of Dublin.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I am not questioning the Deputy. I was only wondering.

Comment on this

There is a problem there which the Minister will have to get over, because Dún Laoghaire Borough Council is in a peculiar position. It has county representatives on the Dún Laoghaire Borough Council as well as Dún Laoghaire representatives and there is not a division of the area. If you go out to Dún Laoghaire during a local election period you will find 30, 40 or 80 candidates on one list for the whole place, instead of having it divided. That is a matter that I am not fully acquainted with. We agree that there should be a manager for each administrative area and we want our manager and our assistant managers for ourselves and the Minister can then deal with the county and the Borough of Dún Laoghaire in whatever way he finds it necessary.

I agree that it is sometimes a good thing to have an age limit for the retirement of certain classes of persons. In our case in the City of Dublin, we have a city manager appointed under an Act, which is now being amended, and under which there was not an age limit. I am not going to quarrel with the bringing in of an age limit if there is equity for the present occupants. All of us who have had experience of local authority affairs know that under this system it is impossible to get a first-class individual with sufficient experience to qualify for the post of city or county manager under the age of 40 years. In fact he may be 50 in order to have the qualifications and experience necessary. Do we think that we are going to get the most suitable person if, when we are looking for him, he is told that he is going to be retired at 65 on a pension calculated on the basis of one-fortieth for every year served? I submit that, at a time when we are trying to improve the managers, as well as the management system, and of getting perfect co-operation between the elected representatives and the managers we should be sure that, at the start, we are not going to bring about a position which will cause trouble in the future, and which might deny us the possibility of getting the best people for these positions.

I intend to put in an amendment, if necessary, dealing with the case of present and future occupants to the effect that the Minister shall have power, if applicants have not a certain number of years' service in these positions, to add years as he does in the case of professional people. Everyone knows that if you are looking for professional people for the public service you cannot get them under 27 or 28 years of age. Consequently, if you want to get the best type of person, who has to look to the years when he is retiring, the Minister has the power to add ten years so as to ensure for such a person full pension rights. I suggest that managers should be put in the same position, and that the Minister should take power to give added years to enable a person to retire as if he had actually served 40 years or alternatively, to calculate his pension on the basis of two-sixtieths rather than one-fortieth. In that way, the occupant of the office would be treated equitably as regards his retirement.

I take this opportunity of referring to some slight adjustments which should be made in the Managerial Act. To what extent there is a difference between the County Management Acts and our City Management Act, I do not know. I do know, however, that there are certain flaws which need to be attended to. I have referred to the managerial control of staff which I hope will be extended to our Act.

The question of the striking of the rate was discussed. Under the terms of the Act, we in the City of Dublin find ourselves in great difficulty from time to time. We have to give three weeks' notice of the striking of the rate. The Minister then fixes the day for the meeting to adopt the rate. We have a lot of rates to collect in the City of Dublin and every day, from the beginning of the year, has an important effect on our collecting machinery. Because of the particular method laid down in the Act, we have from time to time been unable to adopt the rate until we were two or three weeks in the new year. To meet that difficulty, I suggest that a week's notice should be sufficient, and that the council itself should fix the day for the striking of the rate, this to be confirmed by the Minister.

The adoption of the rate requires that there is a two-thirds majority of the councillors present. That sometimes causes a difficulty. We do not want to lose one day of the new year in getting the rates in. Some Deputies may not be aware that there are very big ratepayers, the owners of considerable property, who pay their rates almost immediately the new rate is struck. They are allowed a nominal discount for doing so. It is of advantage to them and to the city, because the corporation is saved thereby from paying bank interest on an overdraft.

I do not know whether the Chair will insist that, to adopt in this measure the amendments which I suggest and which affect the city particularly, the Long Title of the Bill would have to be widened—that it may be necessary to include 1930 in the Long Title. I know, of course, that the Dublin City Management Act is being interfered with in this Bill, notwithstanding the fact that 1930 does not appear in its Long Title. I feel, however, that amendments affecting the City of Dublin will be in order. We have power in the City of Dublin to put 1d. in the £ on the rates for decoration purposes. We want the law, as it stands, changed in connection with that. We think that a majority of the councillors present should be sufficient for that purpose, and that we should not require to have a majority of two-thirds of the councillors. Deputies know how difficult it can be to get a full attendance of members at meetings. The members of the corporation are members of other bodies and committees and it is not always easy to have a full attendance. There must, however, always be a two-thirds majority of the councillors present for the striking of the rate.

There is another matter that we should like to see dealt with in the City of Dublin. It is when an aldermanship in the corporation becomes vacant through death. It is not clear whether the new co-opted member becomes an alderman or a councillor. We should like some amendment dealing with that so that the person highest on the list at the last meeting immediately preceding election should become an alderman on the occurrence of a vacancy.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

In that particular area?

Comment on this

Only in that particular area. The position at present is that, for the purpose of the Act, we have two areas without an alderman. I I have spoken about the managerial control over staff. That will require amendment and I think an amendment will also be required to Section 15 of the 1930 Act.

There are peculiar things, phraseology, that we are concerned about in the City of Dublin and that I take it will apply equally in county management. We will want a proper method of the circulation of orders. The present position is that orders are made by the city manager or county manager and they are supposed in theory to lie on the Table of the House, but every member of Dublin Corporation knows that we have no Table of the House on which our orders can lie. Therefore, the simplest thing is that they should be circulated to the local authority members who will get them and know what they are all about. I heard Deputy Davin talking to-day about secret communications between the Department of Local Government and the manager, and they were secret because he only notified the councillors on the day the council met about them. Maybe what he had in mind is what I am talking about, that orders of that nature should be circulated to the members and then there is no question of secrecy and no question of a sudden springing of something on people without their being able to prepare to consider it before hand.

I am going to press the Minister to apply this good idea of his of a single manager for each area to us in Dublin. We want him to relieve the situation that we are suffering under. We have a city manager in the City of Dublin who is county manager and Dún Laoghaire borough manager. We are adjacent communities and we have conflicting interests at times and we have a city manager who has to be protecting each of the interests of those three bodies. Of course, that is humanly impossible. We had it in the case when we were in conflict with County Dublin on what was called the taking over of the added area. We have it at the moment in connection with the supply of water to Dún Laoghaire. They have a point of view and the city manager there, I suppose, has to take notice of the local point of view there and try to meet it, and we have a point of view. If we supply water from the City of Dublin to the ratepayers of Dún Laoghaire on agreement on a fixed pay basis, we cannot be expected to put a tax on our ratepayers in the City of Dublin to give somebody else water in another area without recouping ourselves as to its cost and the low cost that it is. These are only just, as I have said, a couple of instances.

The discussion here also referred to the relationship between managers and the local authorities. It is a very strange thing that every member who spoke about the evils of the managerial system excluded his own manager in his own area. He was a good fellow. He was all right. But we did not get a single instance—maybe it was just as wise—of anybody saying that they had bad managers and as a result of that bad management the area had suffered.

We have a good relationship with the city manager in the City of Dublin to the extent of where he is free to be ours fully, and with our officials generally. We have a very good relationship because there is a spirit of co-operation. Deputy Sweetman talked about the Minister for Finance when he was Minister for Local Government, Deputy MacEntee, having set up a dictatorial system. Deputy Sweetman apparently does not want to know or has forgotten that it was Deputy MacEntee when he was Minister for Local Government who sent around letters to the managers informing them that co-operation was essential if this form of county or city management was to work at all. There had to be confidence and an exchange of views.

I heard some Deputies talking to-night about managers causing rates to go up by producing extraordinary plans not necessary at all. We in the Corporation of Dublin know that if any one of us gets up at a council meeting and has a proposal down to bring an amenity to a particular area and it is passed by the council it is going to cost money, but the order of the council is to do this job and the manager has to provide an estimate and to include the estimate of its cost in his estimates. All the expenditure that the councillors bring about by requesting this addition or amenity or so forth is responsible for the increase in the costs.

I do not know how the counties operate in the striking of the rate or in the adopting of the rate or the examination of the estimates, but I do not know why there should be such great difficulties as were suggested here. In the Corporation of Dublin we have managed by dint of persuasion and effort that if the local authority have a desire to know as much as possible what is going on, we have inaugurated a system where we have a number of meetings to which the city manager comes with his officials, and the estimates for each department are produced item by item, department by department. Every single thing and item is explained and every member is in a position to ask why it costs so much or if it cannot be done cheaper or should not more money be spent on it. Every single item of expenditure is then related to the exact amount that will be as an imposition on the rates or a saving on the rates. It takes time, but I believe that we in Dublin Corporation have a greater knowledge of the details of our estimates than the members of the Dáil have of the departmental Estimates which are produced to them in the form that they are.

I believe that we are getting to the position that it does not matter on the local authority, fortunately, to what Party a person belongs or what political view he has, we all try to work together for the benefit of the citizens. Some members may want a bit of kudos for something done, but generally speaking we try to help and understand each other and to get agreement in the best interests of the ratepayers generally. I say—I am open to question, I suppose—there are members of Dublin Corporation who are members of this House and who know that the facilities are there and the goodwill is there and the city manager co-operates and we can, if we want to, know the cost of every job that is done or that is being budgeted for in the rates.

When people talk of rates going up it is not fair to blame the managerial system, nor is it fair to blame the elected representatives. Blame ourselves here in this House. This House has put on the backs of the local authorities such a substantial amount of money in statutory demands that the amount of money which the local representatives can spend themselves is negligible when it comes to examining it from the point of view of adding to the rates.

Comment on this

It is not this House did that. It is the Party opposite, your side, that has done so.

Comment on this

It is this House. I am not opposing and I am not against the social legislation which has brought about these statutory demands. I am not against the great deal of help that is involved. Notwithstanding the vast sums of money that we in Dublin have to give for all kinds of social services—Dublin Board of Assistance, our mental hospitals, our general health schemes, our old aged people, and so on—notwithstanding all that we all believe and hope that the time will come when we can do more.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not discuss social services.

Comment on this

I am discussing what has been discussed here already. Deputy Finan deliberately stated that the rise in the rates throughout the country was due to the appointment of managers. That is not so. The managers have to carry out their obligations. Deputy Finan stated that the county manager comes along with grandiose schemes and that is the reason why there is an increase in the rates; but a local authority can embark on no scheme unless it has the sanction and consent of the Minister for Local Government.

It is only fair to point out that in the present development of local government the local authority is getting very substantial assistance through the medium of recoupment of expenditure from the State. What was originally called an experiment in local authority management has now come to be accepted and it looks as if it is here to stay. Certain amendments have been made to Acts dealing with local authority administration as a result of experience. I believe every member of the Dublin Corporation, including even the Labour representatives on that body, now understands this managerial system and would be very sorry to see it go.

There is a fair, personal administration. Everything is done on the basis of rules and regulations. Housing has been discussed here. Our authority is the biggest builder of houses in this State. The Dublin Corporation is the biggest landlord in the country. Yet, I do not believe one would find anyone able to suggest—certainly anyone able to prove—that there has been maladministration in relation to housing or that the wrong people are getting houses. It is true that many people in need of houses have not been able to get them because of the priorities laid down. Nevertheless I do not think the conduct of the authority itself, the manager and the corporation together, can be questioned. They are administering their particular job in an honest and humane way.

I have made a few suggestions as to the amendments I would like. First of all, I want the Minister to separate Dublin City from Dublin County and the Borough of Dún Laoghaire. I want consequential amendments then to bring about separation of the assistant city managers who, by virtue of another Act, are still assistant managers to the county and to the Borough of Dún Laoghaire. Above all, I want him to consider the position that will arise because of the appointment of managers on the basis of the pension position. The Minister should do one of two things; he should amend the Act to give a sufficient number of added years or amend the method of calculation from 1/40th to 2/60ths.

I have no grouse in relation to the present Minister or his Department. I have had many battles with him. We will probably have a good many more, but I think it is only fair to say that in the preservation of the managerial system the Minister is preserving for the ratepayers a better form of local government than we had in the past. I am not casting any reflection on the 65 or 75 members of the Dublin Corporation when Dublin was a much smaller city. To-day, as compared with then, local government and local authority administration has a much more comprehensive scheme of things with which to deal. It is a much more efficient organisation and it will become more efficient still. I appeal to the Minister to confer now, rather than postpone, the benefits to city management that are being conferred on county management. As Deputy Cosgrave pointed out, we have in Dublin 1/5th of the total population of Ireland. If it is the intention to legislate for 4/5ths, legislate at the same time for the remaining 1/5th.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

There are some matters adverted to by Deputy Briscoe with which I am in full agreement; there are other matters with which I am in violent disagreement. One can hardly describe as marked coincidence the spiral of rising rates and the development of the managerial system. I am not as naive in my approach to this problem as Deputy Briscoe is. I think there is no doubt that the introduction of the managerial system has created on the administrative side of the machinery of county management an administrative incubus.

This Bill raises for discussion the hardy annual of for and against the managerial system. If there is any merit at all in the system the Minister will have to consider very seriously the observations of both Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Briscoe in relation to city and county management. If there is any individual unit of administration by virtue of its size entitled to management—should one describe it as an exclusive hierarchy? —it must be the City of Dublin itself. It would be better to frame Section 10 and Section 12 in such a way as to make it possible to have an individual city manager with such assistants as may be deemed necessary in the City of Dublin.

Is this Bill anything more than another nibble at the problem? I do not think it is. In so far as it has any merit at all it will not meet with any opposition. There is some hint at returning powers, limited though they may be, to the elected representatives of the people. But I will never be convinced that the Civil Service or the local authority executive mind is the best that can be brought to bear in the formulation of policy and development within this State. Indeed, I am convinced it is not. It has been our experience in dealing with administrative machinery that the greater the responsibility vested in that machinery the more conservative and unreal becomes the approach to the various problems that present themselves.

I think the Minister might, in the light of his own experience in local authorities, be prepared to subscribe more to the view that in policy shaping and policy conception for a county or local authority area the more broadly diffused and experienced views of elected representatives might serve a useful purpose. However, county managership has been the child of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

That is not correct. It was introduced by Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not in its present conception and certainly not with emphasis on the trend towards dictatorship which has become a significant part of its development.

Comment on this

I am not denying our responsibility for the approval of the principle even when we were in opposition, but it was introduced by Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

No. I think the Minister is possibly confusing matters that may have called for immediate remedies with what might be considered to be a fait accompli in the line of administration and direction.

Comment on this

I was a member of the Opposition at the time.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Anyway, we have succeeded in copper fastening this now hoary old man to the development of the Fianna Fáil Party, and possibly the apparent cracks in the facade of that once great organisation will lead to a more realistic view of its future. There is no doubt that years of experience have revealed many weaknesses in the managerial system which I had hoped this Bill might tackle. There is no doubt that the people of the country do impute an immense responsibility to this House and to the method of local administration fostered by this House for the amazing spiral in rates charges over the years. We have reached a stage where rates and the incidence of them have become of more consequence to the people than the extortions of the rack renter were at one time.

The Minister has an opportunity on this measure of giving some explanation to the people as to why there is this ever increasing spiral in rates. I am not a person who has ever in this House in any way opposed or impeded social legislation that might ameliorate the lot of those who deserve our attention, but I have always argued on the basis of the capacity of the country to carry the load. Many people, suffering as they do the direct burden of Exchequer taxation, have grievous cause of complaint in regard to the incidence of rates. Whether the managerial system was responsible for it or not, there is no doubt that this significant spiral has followed in its wake. There is no doubt, if you look at the figures and statistics, that another significant feature of the managerial system has been the growth of the number of local authority employees in every shape and form and the costly machinery of administration that has become a feature of its development.

Comment on this