Committee on Finance. - County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1953—Second Stage.
Contributions 144–304 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 36 of 1953 ›
I do not think there is any instance in any part of the world where the expansion in the administrative costs of local authorities has been as marked in the last six or seven years as it has been in this country.
Comment on this
Yes, but it is the concerted burden of both that is driving the people to distraction and making the country ask for an opportunity to give its verdict on Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I am only saying that national taxation increased more than the rates, and why should we blame the managers?
Comment on this
The fault is not in the managers but in the system and the conception of the system. Wherever the fault lies, the fact remains in glaring, vulgar reality for the people that rates are going up to a point far beyond their capacity to pay. Many artifices and devices are available in the managerial system to make property find itself on a new rateable level without too much trouble.
I feel that this Bill is only an endeavour to bolster up certain flaws and, at the same time, to make a poor gesture to the collective thought or capacities of the local authorities. This Bill might more properly have been described in its Long Title as purely a Bill for the amending of the scheduled Acts and the insertion of certain titles for people who are going to assume them after the passing of the Bill. But that does not get away from the fact that there must be some inherent cancer within the system that has brought in its train unnecessary expenditure for the administration of local authorities and increased rates for the people to carry.
I should like the Minister to avail of the opportunity of this debate to try to justify the incidence of increased costs to the county council in maintaining certain essential services contributed to by the central Exchequer. How can the Minister justify the fact that the contribution is so high and that the spiral of contribution seems to be increasing, and why it is not possible to evolve some system whereby many of the charges levied on the county council could be transferred to the central Exchequer? Rightly or wrongly, irrespective of the undoubted efficiency of county managers and city managers, people have the feeling that there is far too much power of an unquestioned or an unassailable type in the hands of one man. We had long discussions, in the course of the passage of the Health Bill, about the powers that were to be vested by that Bill in county managers. We have had long and acrimonious debates in this House about the rights filched from local authorities and given to county managers. I feel that this Bill is a blister on an already overweighted system. As I said on a previous County Management Act of a more comprehensive nature introduced by the last Government, I feel that this whole problem resolves itself into an issue of principle—whether it is right that responsibility should properly devolve on elected representatives or appointees, by virtue of some machinery, to the office of county manager or city manager.
I cannot see why we, taking as we do, our power within this supreme legislative Assembly from the people, should deem it necessary to deny, in a more limited way, to local authorities the responsibility that the people entrust to them. I feel and have always felt that the managerial system has gone too far and that powers have been reserved to managers that should never have been reserved to them.
I also feel that a twin brother to the growth of this system has been the spiral growth of increases in rates. I have always felt that there was something inherently weak in the managerial system in that it deprived elected representatives of the right to evolve and formulate policy for themselves. An executive officer, no matter whether you style him a county manager or a city manager, only becomes an executive officer in many cases subject to the guiding rule of another executive machine in the Custom House. The cumulative effect of such a system is to clog effort and make progress in many cases and in many counties impossible.
Comment on this
I do not intend to say very much as regards this Bill which has received a general welcome but I have been encouraged to say a few words because of the contributions that have been made to the debate from different parts of the House. I feel myself that we are, as it were, groping our way in the matter of local government in the country and that at the present stage we are not really in the position when we can say that the amendments proposed to the Act will work satisfactorily or not, through a further experiment arising from experience in the administration of the previous Acts. In a general way, my view is that we want something more comprehensive in the matter of local government but perhaps the time has not arrived when we would be able to adopt a more comprehensive scheme.
County management has been subjected to very wide discussion over many years. I always personally took a line against county management because I felt it interfered too much with the rights of the elected representatives of the people. I always felt that while the county manager was necessary because of the difficulties that face our county administration, the county manager should be the supreme officer of the local authority rather than being a person who was to some extent independent of the local authority. That was a view I held for quite a number of years but my own practical experience in the last three or four years as a member of the Dublin Corporation and as a member of many of the subsidiary bodies of the Dublin Corporation, has given me to think perhaps more seriously on the realities of the situation.
I think it depends on how you look at things. If you have a capitalist system when you are a Socialist then obviously you must be opposed to county management but if you have a Socialist system and you are a Socialist, then I think you would welcome the county management system because in that way one can bring about more speedily a new system of society when you have county managers acting on the instructions of a central or superior authority. I feel, therefore, that in regard to this matter of the principle of county management, an awful lot really depends on the system of society a person wants to see adopted. Taking things as they are, I feel that our present unit of local government, the county, is not the most satisfactory unit and that there are historical associations and traditions—of not very long standing—but there are certainly some traditions in county organisation, the development of civilisation, the speed of communication, the complexity of matters that have to be dealt with now by local authorities, that would indicate some form of regional organisation. In a form of regional organisation I think it would be possible perhaps to have a more efficient system of local government and at perhaps something less in administrative costs.
There is a main problem in connection with local government that has caused me some concern for quite a long time. That is the relationship between the local authority and the Department of Local Government. When the system of county management was adopted, I have an idea that it was at the back of the minds of the people who conceived it that there would be much more freedom for local authorities than there was under the old system where the administration was in the hands of elected representatives only and in which case it was perhaps necessary that there should be a rather rigid control from the Department of Local Government. But where you brought in a management system and where you increased the control of the Department of Local Government you found in certain matters anyway that there tended to be a delaying of activities. That, of course, was particularly noticeable in regard to matters such as housing where every step from the very beginning to the end is subject to examination and confirmation by the Department of Local Government.
Where you are trying to carry out social services, such as the building of houses, it seems to me that some new form of organisation is necessary instead of having this continuous control step by step right up the whole way from the decision to acquire a plot of land to the placing of the contract. Where you have that continous control by the Department of Local Government, you slow up the carrying out of social services such as the building of houses.
I concede that it was not the function and was never the original function of the Department of Local Government to build the enormous number of houses that is being built— not only in this country, but in other countries—under the supervision of a Department such as the Department of Local Government. From the point of view of rapid progress where housing is concerned, it does appear to me that it might be better if the complete control of house building was under the charge of the Department of Local Government rather than under the local authority. There would, of course, be objections to that and there would be a lot of trouble—I am quite sure—about it, but if local authorities looked at it—particularly big local authorities like Dublin Corporation— from the point of view that their desire was to have the building done in the quickest possible time, the best machinery would be the machinery of the Department whose function and responsibility it would be to provide a particular number of houses each year for Dublin Corporation.
This Bill before us does suffer from a defect that has been mentioned by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Briscoe, in that it applies mainly to the counties rather than to the cities and only one section of it is brought in for the purpose of dealing with the question of pensions and retiring age of the city managers of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford. Dublin Deputies would be anxious that the opportunity should be availed of now in this Bill to straighten out matters in connection with local government in the City and County of Dublin that need to be dealt with as matters of urgency.
I welcome the idea that is in the Bill of having one manager as the official or as the manager of one local authority. I have said already that I believe in a regional form of organisation where counties would be grouped together under one council and with one manager for the grouped area, but where that system is not in operation —as it is not in operation at the moment—it is best that a manager should act for one body rather than for two separate bodies, because when he acts for two separate bodies that may be in conflict he must be guided to a large extent in each county by the advice of the council of that particular county.
As things stand at the moment it does not help to have a manager acting as manager for more than one county. When we were discussing in this House the Bill introduced by the previous Minister for Local Government I suggested then, and strongly advocated, that the system we had here whereby the city manager was also county manager was unsatisfactory and that it did not lead to any co-ordination of effort. In fact, it led to confusion and I instanced at the time particular situations where a county manager as city manager wrote to himself as county manager putting forward a particular proposal and as county manager wrote back to himself as city manager saying that he did not agree with the proposal. There can be no co-ordination of effort under that system, but at the time I was taken to task very severely in a leader of a prominent daily newspaper for advocating that there should be two separate and distinct managers, one for County Dublin and one for the City of Dublin. It was suggested that while we had the one manager acting for both bodies there could be co-ordination, co-operation and unity of effort between the two bodies but practical experience proved that while the law remains as it is and the responsibilities remain as they are, there is no co-ordination of effort. I certainly would like to see one manager for the City of Dublin unless the Minister were prepared to combine Dublin City and County in one administrative unit, in which case one must have an individual manager for that particular unit, but he would be acting for and with a council for the whole area rather than for two separate councils who perhaps did not see eye to eye on many matters.
I hope the Bill is but a step forward in giving to certain local authorities powers that they have not had and for which they have been asking in regard to particular functions.
One of the problems which must face the Minister and those concerned with local government is whether the existing organisation is a good one, whether this organisation of county council, committee of agriculture, vocational education committee, mental hospital boards and other boards in the various counties is an efficient or effective system of local government. I am inclined to the view that it is not. More and more we are coming to the position where the same individuals are members of the various boards. Whether that is a good thing for local government or not is a matter that must be considered in the near future. Local representatives are tending to become permanent members of the local government machine. Is that a good thing or is it not? That is one of the problems that must be considered. Obviously, after a while, members of local authorities who attend meetings and take an interest in the business must become proficient in all the rules, regulations and laws of local government. The desire seems to be that there should be more local control rather than control by members who are elected from time to time and who, because of the peculiar system, are selected to represent their body on a different organisation. I am only mentioning a very difficult problem that will have to be considered by the Minister and by everybody interested in local government in the very near future.
The parish has been suggested as a unit. There is something to be said for that. The parish is a very old traditional unit and there may be some aspects of local government that could properly be initiated in the parish and there may be certain matters that could be dealt with on some form of organisation built up from that so long as it was a purely voluntary organisation in which a person was selected by his neighbours to represent them on his own local council and perhaps on some higher council. If we had, in addition to that or perhaps arising from that, the regional form of organisation where counties would be grouped in the most suitable groupings, we might have a more efficient organisation for local government.
There are matters that are dealt with by local authorities here, there and elsewhere—the same matters, the same problems—and I wonder whether it would not be better to have these matters dealt with by some central organisation that would represent the whole country.
I only mention these matters because they were brought to my mind by some of the contributions to the debate this evening. While they are not strictly relevant to the Bill, which in its scope is rather limited but which could be made more comprehensive by amendment, it is perhaps as well to avail of the opportunity to mention them.
I want to support a point that was made by Deputy Norton and Deputy Briscoe this evening in regard to Section 10. Obviously, Section 10 has been introduced to resolve doubts and in fact it is clearly set out in the section that its purpose is the avoidance of doubt. I understand that the four managers referred to have, by virtue of the Acts under which they were appointed, tenure of office for life. I do not know why "life" was put in those Acts. There was a subsequent effort made to alter that. Apparently the Department is in some doubt as to whether that subsequent effort succeeded in altering the position or not. If the previous Act did not solve the problem, I think the present section will fall short also because, if a person has received certain rights by statute, those rights exist and it would be very difficult and certainly unjust to deprive the particular individual of those rights in an amending Act.
I agree with what Deputy Norton has said that it may be desirable and in the interests of local government that managers may retire when they reach the age of 65. I do not want to commit myself entirely to the view that I approve of the suggestion because there are many examples in the world of individuals who are much older than 65 and who carry much heavier responsibilities than a county or city manager carries.
However, I mentioned that aspect before on many occasions in the House, and there may be, as I have said, agreement that in the general interests of the service, in order to bring about a gradual development of ability from the bottom to the top, it may be desirable to retire county managers at the age of 65. In the case of those particular men who were granted something else by another statute, I think that what we will have to do is to encourage, by being generous in this Bill, particular individuals to avail of generous pension provisions. I do not think we will have any difficulty whatever in putting in an amendment to that section that will enable those men, if they are wise, to retire and enjoy life on the very generous pension to which undoubtedly they are entitled.
I think that is all I want to say in regard to the Bill. It raises many difficult problems and, like everything else, human nature enters into these problems. In the City of Dublin we, the elected representatives of the people, work in the greatest harmony and co-operation with our city manager and our assistant city managers. We find in Dublin that our city manager —I think the same thing applies to his predecessor although I was not then a member of the council—whatever his statutory rights were, has never endeavoured to exercise them against the wish of the elected representatives. On every matter which is a managerial matter that we think we should deal with, the manager has always been willing to allow us to discuss it, to come to a decision on it and to act in accordance with that decision. Clearly, that is a very sensible approach for the manager to take.
I was glad to hear from the debate that many of our county managers adopt the same line. As one who was opposed to this system of management for a long period, I felt that my most dangerous opponents were the managers who were co-operating with the local authorities because they were helping to nail down this new system and to keep it there; but the persons who are in danger in this whole county management conception and idea are the very foolish county managers who have not the common sense to co-operate with their elected representatives. It seems to me that you have a human problem in selecting 30 or so county managers and county assistant managers. One will, of course, get managers who are unsatisfactory, and where one gets a county manager who is unsatisfactory and is always pulling against his local council, who is always in conflict with them, who gets up every morning determined to have so many rows that day, I think that there ought to be some provision in this Bill whereby on the request of the majority of the members of a council, if submitted to the Minister on specific complaints and if those complaints are established to the Minister's satisfaction, there would be power to remove that county manager from that particular county. There may be opportunities of placing him elsewhere where his peculiar abilities may be utilised in the national interest; but, whatever system you have, one is bound to have individuals who cannot and will not co-operate with other people. I think that perhaps a section such as that in the Bill would have a very useful effect. I certainly would not like it to have the effect that it would intimidate a man, or prevent him from carrying out what he conceived to be his conscientious duty.
Comment on this
No, I do not want to intimidate a man from carrying out his conscientious duties. The peculiar thing is that there is never any trouble if a man conscientiously carries out his duty because it is recognised that he is doing something conscientiously in the best interests of the council; but, where one finds the particular type of county manager that I have referred to, who cannot and will not under any circumstances co-operate with the elected local representatives, then I think there ought to be a provision in the Bill whereby, on the establishment of a complaint against him, a complaint not made lightly but made by the majority of the local authority, the Minister would have power to remove him. I think in those circumstances the grounds of complaint would be much less than we have at the moment.
I hope that all of us who are keenly interested in this matter of county management will be able to put down amendments to the Bill dealing with the many different aspects of county management that have been referred to during the debate. It appears to me that the Title of the Bill is wide enough to carry a very large number of amendments entirely outside the four walls of the sections. I think there is a general feeling on all sides of the House that it is necessary to bring about some changes, not of a revolutionary character, that will in the present state of local government help to improve the administration of our local government law.
Comment on this
It is accepted on all sides of the House that this Bill is a step in the right direction. I think, judging by the attitude of a number of speakers on it and of the notices that have been given regarding amendments, that the Bill will be improved considerably in passing through the House. In considering it, I am more concerned with attitude than with rights, because if the attitude is correct the rights will come and will be established. I think that the managerial system, in some instances at any rate, has led to a weakening of civic spirit, even amongst local representatives, by reason of the fact that they have been taking up the attitude of leaving everything or at least too much to the manager to do and too little for themselves to resolve, determine and make effective. The whole scheme of things needs to my mind a good deal of reconsideration, and this Bill goes part of the way, in the first place about the numbers of the staff, that the manager cannot increase the staff without some authority from the public representatives who ultimately have to vote the money for the payment of the officials. Local government has grown so much that no suitable offices are available in many counties and the staffs are distributed here and there in the towns and cities, with the result that there is perhaps a certain amount of overlapping and a certain amount of supervision which would tend to more efficiency is lacking, which would be provided if some suitable county offices were available. However that is only one aspect of the matter. It is a problem that has to be dealt with locally, and this Bill does not propose to provide for it.
The other question is the giving of more power to local representatives in the matter of estimates. Even though local representatives may make mistakes now and again, the very fact that they have to take responsibility and ultimately face the public again on the results of their decisions will, to my mind, tend to raise the standard of public administration and to make those who are elected for that purpose feel more keenly their responsibility than if they were to leave a portion of it in the hands of the manager just from frustration because they see that they can do very little. This Bill goes part of the way to rectify that, and I hope that before it is through the House it will go further.
Take a county such as that of which I am a member of the local authorities, the largest county in Ireland, with a population of 268,000 people and with an expenditure by the local authorities of £2,750,000. I think that the work should be decentralised more than it is. That is not to contradict what I said at the start about having the administration in a number of offices here and there in a town. What I mean is that the services should be attended to in the areas where they are to be provided and that the local knowledge there should be of advantage both to the local representatives and the manager when those decisions are being reached. Apart from the general county administration of the roads and general purposes, you have the peculiar situation in Cork of a number of joint committees. The mental hospital committee is a joint committee of the Cork Corporation and the county council. So is the home assistance and dispensary service of South Cork and the city amalgamated by joint representation. The sanatorium service is also a joint body composed of a certain number of elected representatives of the corporation and of the county council, and the administration of these at the moment comes under the county authority where the county manager is in charge of the mental hospital and of the joint board of the South Cork and city area, and one of the assistant managers is in charge of the sanatorium or the various sanatoria. As well as that you have nine urban authorities, many of them very big towns like Cobh, Fermoy, Youghal, Mallow, and several others, and three towns like Bandon, Bantry and Passage West, which are administered by town commissioners, and you have at present a county manager and two assistant managers.
To my mind it is utterly impossible to have these urban authorities and the other services there consisting of three areas with 75 dispensary districts administered by a manager who has apart from his supervisory work to look after the mental hospital, look after the road services, look after the joint committee for the mental hospital and its work and also the joint city and South Cork area for home assistance and dispensary services. You have then two assistant managers, one for North and South cork and a certain number of urban areas as well, and another for West Cork and a number of the urban areas as well as the sanatorium committee for the city and county. To my mind North Cork itself and South Cork would require independent managers, because there is an administration of £289,000 in North Cork and £495,000, nearly £500,000, in South Cork, in area charges of various kinds.
I have seen myself where efforts are made in the urban areas to deal with local problems, to erect houses, to clear derelict sites and the acquisition of land and various other problems. They are such that a manager dealing with North Cork and South Cork cannot give to those matters the attention that they deserve. As a matter of fact what Deputy Ted O'Sullivan said to-day is quite correct, that one of those assistant managers has had his health broken down by reason of the amount of work he has had to do as the man in charge of North and South Cork. Very often we saw him there all day at meetings on housing, and when that was over he had to clear off to some urban area far removed to administer its affairs at night. Night after night as well as during the day these men were on the road carrying out public administration and unable, very often, to deal in the intimate and speedy way it required with much of the work which fell on their hands. It was envisaged in the first place in the original Acts, I think, and it was left to the manager or the Minister to make by order the appointment of an additional assistant manager.
I say that it is absolutely necessary in Cork if we are going to have the best service, and that it is time to do it. We have in the Bill here that three assistant managers are to be appointed for Dublin County and three assistant managers for Dublin Borough. I think that Cork which, as I have told the House, embraces with the county services in some cases certain city services as well, requires the same consideration and the same number of appointments if we are going to have efficiency in the service.
There is no need to go over all the points that have been dealt with by other speakers. It is up to each representative to give to the Minister some knowledge of the problems facing him locally. If we ask, as this House is asking now, for more powers for the county councils to enable them to exercise their jurisdiction and administration, I feel sure the Minister will recognise the weight of the views offered by those who have had years of experience in this matter and that they will get from the Minister serious consideration when amendments are brought forward in the best interests of the managerial system for the purpose of improving this Bill.
Comment on this
I think it is generally admitted by everybody, except the Fianna Fáil Deputies, that the county managerial system established some years ago was a first-class administrative blunder. The general body of ratepayers would not agree with some of the last speaker's observations. The growth of local government county administration is well worth study and consideration particularly in relation to the parent Act passed some 50 or 52 years ago. If we compare the work of county councils and their staffs then with local administration to-day we might perhaps get the problem in better perspective, something that many Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches have failed to do. If invention, science and civilisation had remained static we would not find ourselves confronted with the measure that is now before the House.
I believe, indeed, there would be no county management system in existence. The advance of science has brought into existence mechanically propelled vehicles. That has necessitated an improvement in our road system, such an improvement was never anticipated 50 years ago. We must keep pace with the times. The same thing is true of health services. Medicine has made tremendous advances in the last 20 years and we have to keep pace with those. When the Grand Jury system was abolished and the county and city councils were established in its place the problems of to-day were not envisaged. Times have changed and many things have been tacked on to the duties of county councils, things that were not even dreamt of when the parent Act was framed.
Many Deputies have referred to the increase in rates. If we examine the road system we find that in days gone by our forefathers built the roads, paid their local rates and they, and they alone, owned the roads. The coming of the motor car and the lorry has changed that situation. I am one of those who hold that the time has long since passed when roads should be taken over by the Government and no longer maintained by the county councils. Maintenance by the county council results in a lot of costly overlapping. A national road board should be formed to take over complete control of the roads and expenditure on trunk and main roads should be voted by this House. In the old days the roads built by our forefathers were ample for the needs of the ordinary horse and pedestrian traffic. As a result of mechanically propelled traffic, they have had to be widened and reinforced at enormous cost. It is true that mechanically propelled traffic subscribes very heavily to that cost but I believe there is a good case to be made for taking over control of the roads from county councils, and I will have a word to say in regard to health charges on the same lines.
Comment on this
That is so, but might I say that when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Chair this matter was gone into very fully?
Comment on this
It does not seem to me that the whole history of local government, road control and management and public health management come into this. This is a County Management Bill.
Comment on this
Yes, but that does not permit the Deputy to travel over the whole history of local government and back to the 1898 Act, dealing with how the roads were made and so on. That is a very long shot from county management.
Comment on this
If there had not been the original County Management Act there would be no amending Bill now.
Comment on this
That may be the idea, but it seems to me that he is not touching the matter before the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe blamed this House for the steep increase in rates, and he mentioned roads.
Comment on this
That is a different thing. The suggestion that there should be a national board for the control of roads and the suggestion that roads should be taken away from the control of local authorities could not possibly arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
Very well. It is unfortunate that I did not speak when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Chair.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is endeavouring to offend the Chair he is making a mistake because the Chair will not take it from him. The Deputy will keep to the Bill before the House and he will not offend the Chair in any circumstances.
Comment on this
No, Sir. I have never done so. I do not believe in doing so or in running counter to the Chair. I have always upheld the dignity of the Chair in this House.
Comment on this
The original Act was definitely in my opinion a bad administrative blunder in the first instance. It was introduced before I entered this House. This is a shabby attempt to catch up on what was originally a bad Act. Rates have increased out of all bounds. It cannot be said that that is due to individual county managers. It must be laid to the charge of the whole system. I am one of those who hold that the filching away of the powers of public representatives, powers vested in them by this House, is wrong. It reduces local representatives to the position of mere figureheads without any authority. They had only one function, namely, the power to appoint rate collectors. They had no other power.
Comment on this
No, they had not the power to strike a rate. They had power to say "yes" to the manager's rate, but if the county council refused to strike the rate the Minister had power to abolish the council and the manager could strike the rate when they were abolished. In actual fact, that means the county councils have nothing to say to the striking of the rate. The county manager strikes the rate, the council have to say "yes" or "no". It does not matter to the county manager. Two county councils have been abolished because they refused to strike the rate presented by the county manager. The Roscommon County Council and the Kerry County Council were both abolished. That has never been amended. The county manager to-day can strike the rate and tell the county councillors that it makes no difference to him what they may do. They can criticise and talk about it and grumble and grouse and use the council chamber as a place for propaganda. That is as far as they can go.
Comment on this
Perhaps I am particularly dense this evening. I would be grateful if the Minister would tell us where that is. There are a few little petty things taken away from the county manager. For instance, he cannot submit to the Minister for his approval an increase in staff or an increase in remuneration without getting the consent of the council. But I fail to see where in this Bill a county council are given power to strike a rate or that they cannot be dissolved by the Minister for running counter to the manager's wishes. Will the Minister tell us in what section that is?
Comment on this
I have gone through it and I am aware that a very feeble attempt is made to restore to county councils the power the Minister has hinted at. I do not believe it is there. If this Bill becomes a legal instrument after passing the two Houses and getting the President's signature, I do not believe it will work in that way.
Comment on this
If the Deputy was genuinely looking for information I should like to help him but I do not believe he is.
Comment on this
I say that this is a very feeble attempt to patch up what was a bad job in the beginning. I say that this House should never have taken from local authorities the democratic powers which the people gave them when they elected them. They have no power at present except the power to appoint a rate collector. Under this Bill they may have a say in regard to the increasing of the staff or if the county manager proposes to increase the remuneration of the staff and a few other things like that. I do not see why the Minister brought in this Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister will get them. I hope the Minister will get the backing of his Party to pass them into law.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe said that the increase in rates was due principally to the fact that this House imposed statutory obligations on the local authorities. I interrupted him when he said this House did it. Technically, I suppose it was this House, but in reality it was the Party in power that did it against the wishes of this Party and, I think, every Opposition Party. They have succeeded in passing burden after burden on to the local authorities, the latest being the Health Bill. I have said in this House on many occasions that if any Government was sincere in giving benefits to the people the surest test of their sincerity was to provide the money for these so-called benefits. That is the acid test of their sincerity.
During the period of the inter-Party Government many Local Authority Acts were put through this House but not one of them imposed one penny burden on the rates. The most useful one was the Local Authorities (Works) Act which the Minister got orders from his Government to scrap, or at least to nullify by withdrawing the money for it except for a small amount.
Comment on this
When Deputy MacCarthy talks to his constituents at the next election he will hear all about it.
Comment on this
It is down to a miserable £400,000 The difference between £1,300,000 and £400,000 is £900,000.
Comment on this
The whole purpose of passing legislation is supposed to be to confer benefit on the people. If the Minister wants to pass legislation to benefit the people he should prove his sincerity by finding the money from the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I say that the passing of legislation in this House which increases rates is all wrong.
Comment on this
In many counties with which I am familiar the elected representatives feel that they are perfectly helpless. They feel that if they do not dance according to the county manager's music they will be abolished by the Minister and the result is that rates are soaring and county management has proved to be so heavy a burden that it will rebound on the Government some day, and that not so far off. I would not object to some kind of higher executive officer in a county, but I should like to see that executive officer a servant of the county council and not their dictator. There is a huge difference between the two things.
I hold that the introduction of this system, in giving supreme authority to the various managers both in counties and in cities, has resulted in a very serious worsening of the whole position in this country. It is a blunder and a mistake that we should rectify. One of the most serious aspects of it is the fact, and very few Deputies realise it, that except for proved misconduct, the Minister or the Government cannot remove a county manager. That is a very serious thing. Not alone can county managers, whether they are aware of it or not, snap their fingers at the local authority of the county in which they are operating, but they can snap their fingers at the Minister. He cannot dispense with their services unless he can prove misconduct.
Comment on this
Is not that right? Why should a man be removed from office except misconduct is proved?
Comment on this
Will the Minister deny that he has no power to transfer a manager from one county to another?
Comment on this
Supposing it was desired that, in the national interests, the managerial system should be abolished, what would the result be?
Comment on this
Of course it is a different question. The Minister is trying to imply that I am saying that the Minister' should have arbitrary powers to remove a manager at will, whether he commits an offence or not. I did not suggest any such thing.
Comment on this
I have suggested, and I suggested it on other occasions, that the Government of the day is too fond of voting out of their hands and into the hands of permanent officials, the authority that the people voted into our hands at the time of the election. I hold that that authority is a sacred trust and that we should be careful on whom we bestow it. I know that in the case of judges this House has to hand over a certain amount of authority to other people in order to make for proper administration but there is a limit to the extent to which that should be done and it is about that limit that we should be very careful. I say now that in the original County Management Act, the Government of the day went much too far in giving this power to another authority. I never remember any Government asking a mandate from the people to hand over the authority which the people give them on the occasion of a general election. I say it is a wrong thing to do and that any Government should think twice before they hand over that authority. They should ensure when they do so, that they are handing over that authority into the hands of people who will not abuse it or disrespect it in any way. Inside the last 15 or 20 years we have had many examples in Europe that should be sufficient to make any Government sit up and think before they put into wrong hands the power entrusted to them by the people.
Comment on this
I think there is something good in this Bill which is a continuation of the Act under which managers were originally appointed. I should like to say to those who object to managers on the ground that they interfere too much with the local authority, that we, in the City of Dublin, have been very fortunate in that respect. In fact, we were very fortunate from the very first day that the Management Act came into force. We were fortunate in having as our first city manager, Mr. Gerald Sherlock. We were equally fortunate in having as his successor the present occupant of that post and in having as his assistant, Mr. Keane. If there is any question which demands attention these men call a sub-committee of the corporation into consultation and they generally hammer out an agreement on lines that are quite fair and which can be supported by the elected representatives. I have every sympathy for members of local councils who run up against a stubborn manager who will not consult them because he is armed with certain powers. In his own interest, I think it is very foolish to run up against the elected representatives. It should be remembered that the unfortunate public representative has to go outside the council afterwards and to render an account of the manner in which he has discharged his duties to the people who elected him. The county manager has not to render such an account. My sympathy, therefore, goes out to the elected representative.
In Dublin City, even under the city and county manager, demands are made on the corporation that we feel should be borne by national funds. Rates have already reached the extreme limit in the city but yet demands come in from other authorities which we are definitely of the opinion national funds should meet. We are all happy to see money from the Hospitals' Trust being utilised to build the very fine hospitals that render great service to our people, but the moment these buildings go up they are handed over for maintenance to the overburdened ratepayers of Dublin. We all know what the upkeep of these hospitals entails. Some people have a peculiar notion that when rates go up it is property owners only who will be affected, but the moment the rates go up the tenant of the very smallest room in the city has at least 1d. or 2d. per week added to his rent. Owners of property who have houses or tenements for letting increase the rents immediately the rates go up. Even the corporation puts up the rents of working-class people whom they house under the various Housing Acts. The demands that are made on the ratepayers from these outside sources should, therefore, in my opinion, be reviewed. There should be a review by the Government of these various charges and the Government should be prepared out of national funds to pay a fair share of these charges.
Comment on this
It is the city manager who prepares the demand.
Comment on this
The city manager prepares the demand and he has no power to do otherwise. It is a demand made on him and he has to put it before the council. We always feel in the council that national funds are not making a fair contribution towards the purposes for which these charges are made.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into the question of the distribution of charges. He will have to come to the Management Bill.
Comment on this
Let me say that the grievance which councillors from the country areas who are members of the Dáil have against the county manager for holding up various things and which they try to ventilate by asking questions in the Dáil, we in the corporation have against the Minister for Local Government and his Department. There is frustration there every day of the week. If we asked the Minister to look into his files to see how many letters from local authorities all over Ireland are awaiting a reply, I think he will find a good many. I put it to the Minister that if we are to work in harmony with the city manager and the county managers we should not have all that trouble.
Comment on this
The Minister has power to say to his staff that they should speed up decisions on schemes put before them by the corporation. The Minister knows that within the last couple of months we formed a special committee to deal with unemployment—the special works committee—and we gave him every assistance.
Comment on this
We contribute our share of the rates. Dublin accepted its responsibility. It does no harm to say we are finding the same fault with the Department of Local Government and its frustrating methods of dealing with Dublin Corporation. I want to assure the Minister that we have done everything possible to assist the city manager and the county manager but we feel we do not get a chance. I want to draw attention specially to the fact that the managerial system is working fairly well in the City of Dublin but suppose any member of this council wants to give 2/6 increase to a poor, unfortunate pensioner who went out of the serviced 20 years ago when the small pension he got then was worth something, we are not allowed to give a 2/6 rise now.
Comment on this
I know you are sympathetic to the idea as I saw your name on the list. We have no fault to find with the present manager so far as Dublin is concerned.
Comment on this
We are glad to hear, anyway, that there is a perfect system of management in Dublin City and the only fault found with it is that the Minister does not pay all the rates for the ratepayers of Dublin. He is paying a big share of them and we country people have a fair grievance in that respect, that the Minister is paying a big share of the rates in Dublin, much more than he is paying of the rates down the country.
Over the last 20 years this House has been quite generous to the City of Dublin in the matter of time provided for discussing the types of local government they might have in Dublin. Much of the time of the House, year in, year out, went on Dublin, and if we have a grievance about this Bill it is because the Minister unfortunately included a couple of sections in it dealing with the City of Dublin. I suggest to the Minister that the City of Dublin should be dealt with in a separate city management Bill, and give them their own form of local government in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
Yes. A super local authority is what is needed for the City of Dublin so that we would not have them coming into this House and upsetting the machinery of county management in certain directions.
None of the amendments in this Bill are very revolutionary and they seem to give satisfaction to all sides of the House. The proposal in Section 3 whereby the manager cannot increase the permanent staff—and I want to emphasise "permanent"—without consulting the local authority and cannot increase the remuneration of the permanent staff without consulting the local authority, may give satisfaction. But there is the other side of it also. I am sure that members of local authorities when they are consulted about all this and have to give their decisions, will discover that there are some among them who will not favour this when they have to commit themselves one way or another. It is not going to be all sunshine for members of local authorities.
Comment on this
It is not a question of hiding at all but when they have to make decisions in public in that respect some of them will find it difficult to make those decisions in the direction they think best for their employees and also for the community as a whole.
The other amendments in the Bill are not very far-reaching. They bring about certain alterations in some respects but not to any great extent. I think that the provision in Section 3 is one that from the point of view of a democratic body such as a local authority is good in so far as it gives more responsibility to the elected representatives of local authorities. It places a little more responsibility on them. I want to suggest to the Minister that there is an important aspect of Section 3 and it is this: it is very often found that the number of temporary officials or temporary officers on the staff of a local authority is quite considerable.
Comment on this
Ways and means are found to carry them on from year to year although they may never be permanent. They are still on the payroll and their total remuneration adds up to a considerable amount. There are temporary engineers, architects, and other temporary staff carried on year in, year out. They never appear on the records but they appear on the payroll. I want to suggest that the Minister should include temporary as well as permanent officers in order to safeguard the council funds and give the council the determination of the number of officers that should be in their employment. Many members of the council never know about these temporary officers.
One effect which I would admit right away of the County Management Act was to increase the number of clerical officers. I make another admission— that part of that increase was required because the boards of health and county councils were carrying on up to the coming of the County Management Act with very attenuated staffs. It was a mystery how they could carry on and do the work which they did with the small staffs they had. I do not agree that it was necessary to recruit so many extra clerical workers as are now employed. I do not believe it was necessary at all. What the managers think themselves to be a perfect system has been evolved and there should be no reason why everything should not run smoothly in local authorities from the point of view of staff. There are good officials doing their work well and, in addition, they bring in temporary ones whenever they feel the need. I think that should be referred to the council also just as the permanent officials are.
A good deal of discussion took place on the far side of the House in which I think the Labour Party and Deputy Davin joined. I think Deputy Davin stressed very much that it was the county management system which was responsible for the steep increase in rates that has taken place in the last ten or 15 years. I disagree with that. I doubt very much if the managerial system had anything to do with the increase in local rates.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy would like to be fair to me. I said the claim for the passing of the City and County Management Acts was that they would provide cheaper and more efficient administration.
Comment on this
The Deputy set out to point out that the engineering service and other services were costing far more now than before the manager came in. I am sure the Deputy was not referring to the increases in salaries and wages.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not object to the higher salaries. They are entitled to them. I can speak for the county I know best—Wexford. There is one temporary engineer in the employment of Wexford County Council more than there were on the coming into operation of the County Management Act. He is only a short time in the employment and is there for a specific purpose, the supervision of a certain job. That is the only increase in the engineering staff. The salaries of the increased number of staff has very little to do with the steep increase in local rates that has taken place over the years. Deputy Davin, Deputy Sweetman, Deputy Blowick and all the Deputies know the reason for that steep increase. Many Deputies said that the central authority should pay more of the rates than they are paying. I was checking up on that matter recently and was agreeably surprised to find that, as compared with 15 years ago, the percentage of the rates paid by the Central Fund is much greater. I would say that it has trebled. Apart from loans, the local ratepayers pay 40 per cent. and the Central Funds pay 60 per cent. If you include road grants it may be higher. That is a fair proportion.
The services for which rates are levied are too numerous. That is another matter. The services that have been handed over to the local authorities have been handed over by the deliberate action of this House, as the supreme authority. That cannot be questioned.
Deputy Seán Collins made a very extraordinary statement. He said the managerial system was clogging effort and preventing progress by democratic bodies. I do not know what he meant by that. Did he mean that the managerial system was preventing democratic bodies from spending more money? I can see no other meaning in the suggestion. He told us about the dire consequences of the Management Act and of the steep increase in local taxation and the effect it would have on the people's lives and fortunes. A moment after that he told us that the Management Act was clogging democratic progress.
Comment on this
The only meaning that I can see in the statement is that if the manager was removed the councils would spend more money. I doubt very much, if the manager were removed to-morrow morning, that any democratic body would set out to spend more money. They would try to spend less. I do not believe they would succeed in spending less because local authorities have full power to determine what they will provide and the manager cannot spend any more than the local authority provide.
Comment on this
Any supplementary estimate he brings in must be passed by the county council before he spends 1/-.
Comment on this
The county manager cannot spend money unless it is provided by the local authority. There were many supplementary estimates passed, as Deputy Everett knows, by county councils, before the enactment of the County Management Act. If the secretary of the county or the secretary of the board of health said that he was short of money for a certain purpose, he got it. The elected representatives control the provision of money now just as much as they did before managers were appointed.
There are other directions in which the Minister might have extended the powers of the council. I hope to make suggestions in that connection on Committee Stage. While local authorities have control of the sale of property, they have no control in the purchase of property. They provide the money but have no control. They are sometimes presented with a fait accompli in that respect. I suggest that there might be an amendment covering the purchase of property in addition to the sale of property.
Comment on this
You cannot, but you may be faced with a fait accompli; certain commitments might be made subject to the sanction of the council and you have no option but to provide the money.
Comment on this
There is a number of other matters that I will mention later. Deputy Brennan from Donegal suggested that in some counties at least there should be officers to whom the manager could delegate some of his powers. I am fully convinced that that should be so. The manager should have power to delegate certain of his functions to the county secretary, if he is fit and competent.
Comment on this
That is not what he said. He wanted an additional assistant manager. I would agree with what the Deputy says.
Comment on this
I do not think an additional assistant manager is required. Many county secretaries will be county managers within the next 12 years. They are fully competent and fully capable of carrying out some of his duties. The Minister may say that if the county manager sets out to do his business in a reasonable way and takes full responsibility for it, he should not be bothered with day to day details of administration. The fact that he is responsible and must answer to the council week after week, month after month means that he must take more interest in the day to day administration than, say, the works manager or managing director of a big industrial firm and must be prepared to answer at short notice at any time for the deeds or misdeeds of his subordinate officers and must keep himself fully informed of all the operations. That is why I make the suggestion that, subject to the local authority, if you like, the county secretary could take on some of the responsibilities that the manager might delegate to him.
There is power in the County Management Act to have assistant county managers. If a council desires it, I see no reason why its chief administrative officer, the county secretary, should not be made an assistant to the manager. That is not going to cost any more money. If the county secretary is found to be competent enough, I think he should be given the power to assist and help the manager. In most counties you have three or four urban authorities. They make a big demand on the time and services of the manager, perhaps more than he can afford to give them. The administration, on the health services' side, will be growing and will require the full attention of the manager or of his chief assistant. More and more decisions will be called for from day to day. I suggest to the Minister that if the county manager is to give all the attention that the administration of the Health Act will require from him, then, of necessity, he will have to neglect other duties. That is why I am suggesting to the Minister that he should bring in an amendment in Committee to enable the county secretary to be made assistant to the county manager.
Comment on this
I am of opinion that he should be appointed an assistant to the manager while at the same time discharging his duties as county secretary. There is no reason why he should not be able to fill both offices. I believe that, at the moment, where you have an active county manager, he carries most of the responsibility. The responsibilities of the county secretary are light compared with those of the county manager. Many of these county secretaries are very competent officials. I believe that it would be a good training for them if they were appointed as assistants to county managers, and that if my suggestion were adopted by the Minister it would do a considerable amount of good.
We have heard a lot of criticism of the County Management Acts. The only place where them seem to work perfectly is in the City of Dublin. One would gather from the debate that the managers in Dublin are perfect. Notwithstanding all that, Dublin seems to have a number of greater problems than we have in the country. I submit to the Minister that he should not mix up Dublin City and Dublin County management with the rest of the country. Their problems are different.
In the early years of the County Management Acts, the older members of local authorities who had been operating for a great number of years the old system showed a certain amount of hostility. Friction arose between inexperienced managers and those older members of the local authorities. There was a different outlook on life on both sides. One has to make allowance for that because human beings are not like machines. I want to say that I did not see any of that myself. In my county we had no difficulty in the world in getting the fullest co-operation from the county manager. We got full details in regard to all estimates. Every bit of information that we required was given to us, whether the expenditure was for £100 or £1,000.
Comment on this
I mention that because we did have members on the Opposition Benches to-day saying that the fullest information in regard to estimates was not given to members of local authorities. My opinion is that if the members of those bodies were prepared to spend sufficient time in doing the work that they were appointed to do they could have got all the information they wanted. What I imagine happened was that they got tired of the details before they had quite finished considering them.
In my opinion, the management machine is working reasonably satisfactorily. The councils have full democratic powers in operating the local government machine. I am convinced of that. I am certain that if the opinions of members of every local authority could be ascertained as to whether they preferred the existing machine, with some slight modifications and amendments, or the old system, that 98 per cent. of them would opt for some system such as we have at the moment. I believe that to be true, even though some of those members were hostile to the county management system when it was introduced. The administration of county services is such a big problem to-day that without some system such as the present, it would not be possible to carry them on.
I am glad to see that the Labour Party which, as a group, showed most hostility to the management system in this House, has come round to a good extent, as a result of the experience gained in the working of the system. We had an indication of that in the Bill that was introduced in the House by the Minister for Local Government in the previous Government, a member of the Labour Party. He did not propose in that Bill to give any more powers to the local authorities. There were to be the same scheduled functions, the same administrative functions and the same powers to the manager as regards the appointment of tenants to houses, the fixing of wages and all the rest. He did not propose to do away with the county management system. All that he proposed was to change the name of the manager.
Comment on this
Those were amendments by Deputy Childers, a man who knew nothing at all about the matter.
Comment on this
I take it that on the Bill before us all types of amendments, if in order, will be received. I am sure the Minister will be delighted if Deputy Davin suggests some good amendments for the smoother running of the local government machine. It has become a very big machine over the years. In the early 1930's the local government machine had very little to do. Very little money was being provided for roads. No houses were being built. It was only about that time that a start was made to improve an odd hospital here and there. A huge amount of work has been accomplished by local authorities in the last 25 years. That will be admitted on all sides of the House. In the matter of housing of the people, sanitation, water schemes, hospitals, medical schemes and all the other schemes that were operated by the local authorities anybody to-day would recognise the work that they had to do and the small amount of money that they had at their disposal for doing it. I think that by and large we can say that this Bill will bring an improvement to the existing management machine. I doubt if it will bring any great joy to the elected representatives, but I welcome it and I welcome the provision in Section 3. At one time when the first County Management Bill was going through the House the only right of appointing officials to be left in the hands of the local authority was the matter of rate collectors.
I say that 80 or maybe 90 per cent. of the members of local bodies would be glad to get rid of that right that they have at the moment and to save themselves the bother of the canvassing and the dragging around that there is by people who want to be elected to those positions. We call this a progressive age, and I believe that there is provision there already that any local authority if they want to can have their rate collectors selected in another way, by competitive examination. I have the hardihood, if you like, I do not mind suggesting it, and I do not mind bringing in an amendment if somebody will draft it for me, that all rate collectors should be appointed in future through a system of competitive examination. I am prepared to operate the other system. I have found no trouble. But still when we talk about wanting to give back to the county councillors powers, I have heard more complaints from individual councillors about the one bit of power that they have in the matter of selecting certain officials—complaints about the trouble it gives them, rather than looking for more power to elect some other officials. As the years go on the feeling will be that that bit of power that is in the Management Bill should be altered and let the rate collectors be selected by a system of competitive examination. I think that there is power there at the moment for doing it, if a council is so minded in that way, but I do not think that many of them do it. They have that power and it would be the best system if operated and accepted.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen in the course of his speech pointed out that this is a revolutionary measure and that it is going to be a great boon to public bodies, but then he comes on and appeals to the Minister to amend it. It was not giving enough power of control to public bodies, and now he asks that the Minister should take away some of the control that they have at present. I do not see anything revolutionary in the Bill. I pointed out to the Minister when he interrupted me that I do not see the necessity for the discussion in the House in connection with it. The Minister could have made these regulations through the manager that he is asking to put in the Bill. There are only two sections —the regrading of counties and Section 3, that the manager has no right now without reporting to the council to give employment to any permanent officials —that are important. There is nothing further in the Bill beyond these. You have all the other trimmings to give discussion and talk, but when you come back to the Bill those are the only two sections that are effective.
Deputy Allen pointed out that there is nothing in the Bill to prevent a manager having ten or 12 extra temporary officials. I agree with Deputy Allen. I know a county where you have nearly more temporary officials than permanent ones. They are appointed temporarily year by year and sanctioned by the Department. The greatest trouble we have is in the engineering section. Dublin Deputies refer to their manager but they have an exception in Dublin. I would say that the county manager in Wicklow consults the council on all matters, but here in the engineering section we find that there is in the Department always approval of anything that is put up by the engineering section no matter what they ask for. We have an expenditure at the present time of £80,000 or £90,000 for machinery. It is all right to have machinery for two adjoining counties but not to spend £70,000 or £80,000 for machinery, most of which is lying idle nine months out of 12 along the roadsides or in disused quarries and depriving a large number of men of permanent work.
If you look at County Wicklow estimate you will see an increase of 3/4 in the £. What do we find? We find that you have extra engineers appointed. I remember a time when we had more work, more houses being erected, when we had only half the engineers we have at present. Why? Because at that particular time the engineers were allowed their commission on the erection of all new houses, but then we got an order down from the Department during the emergency that as we were not erecting a sufficient number of houses to give the engineers their 5 per cent. on all new houses we should pay them on a permanent salary.
Comment on this
I understood that we had reference to Section 3, the employment of staffs, and I was pointing out to the Minister that we have a staff employed who under the new arrangement are not paid a commission for new houses. Where new houses are being built now the engineers who formerly worked as engineers on houses and would receive 5 per cent. now deem that they require to get assistant engineers to help them on a salary, as well as architects. I remember a time when they would not allow an assistant engineer into an area when they were getting 5 per cent, or £1,500 on a housing scheme. If there is any increase in the cost of county councils I do not put the blame on the managers. I put it on the Department of Local Government that sanctions all the schemes submitted by the engineers for the purchase of machinery. I could understand this if we had two counties joined together saying that they could spend £100,000 on bulldozers and other machines which could usefully be employed in each county, but I do not see why every county must have hundreds of thousands of pounds' worth of machinery lying unused for the best part of the year.
Deputy Allen pointed out that we should ask the Minister to take away the right of appointment of rate collectors, and said that a number of county councillors have been wishing that they had not that responsibility. I can understand Deputy Allen's difficulties. If three or four members of a particular Party are going up for a job it is rather awkward for the councillors for the area, be they Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil or Labour Party, where a number of their friends are going forward, to decide which they should support. Therefore, they would like to shelter behind the responsibility by having it a managerial function.
Some of the managers who have been appointed were appointed for academic qualifications and not on practical experience. I agree with Deputy Davin that practical experience should count in the promotion of officials when it comes to appointing county managers. I agree with Deputy Allen that the county managers have a colossal quantity of work to cope with and, indeed, I wonder how one man can undertake the responsibility of looking after an entire county, attending two meetings of the local authority as well as committee meetings, looking after the county hospital and the county home, the fever hospital and the health services. It is not possible for one man to undertake that work unless he works longer hours than any trade union permits. I agree with Deputy Allen that if the secretary is a competent official the manager should be permitted to delegate some of his responsibilities to him.
To a certain extent the local authority has power to strike a rate. They have the power to disagree with the manager's recommendation certainly. If the manager puts up an excessive rate the council may reduce it. I do not believe the Minister would approve of the manager asking a council to strike an excessive rate. I have never known that to happen. The manager puts forward the rate and the members of a county council naturally try to reduce the estimate of expenditure as much as possible.
We have no complaint to make and we have carried out some very big schemes in relation to delay on the part of the Minister and his Department. Certain matters require consideration before they can be approved. Where schemes are urgent we have never had occasion to complain of delay. We understand that in certain cases consideration must be given and consultations must take place before a definite decision can be given.
There are only two sections that really matter in this Bill. Deputy Allen thinks it is real boom and a wonderful concession. He thinks the fact that councils will in future have some say in the appointment of permanent officials makes this a revolutionary measure. I wonder are there any vacancies in any of the county councils at the present time? Personally, I do not believe they are overloaded and I would ask the Minister to consider the position of men who are acting in any and every capacity in the various county councils. I do not say that the county manager should be asked to submit the names of temporary staff that he might recruit for the purpose of writing up the rate books.
I cannot find any great ground for congratulation in relation to this Bill. I have no love for the managerial system. I even voted for the suspension of the managers. I have not changed my opinion in relation to the principle. In relation to the individual, as far as our particular local authority is concerned, the county manager has gone out of his way to meet the wishes of the council as far as possible.
As far as cottages are concerned I have always supported the recommendation of the county medical officer of health in relation to the selection of tenants. The tenants are selected by the county medical officer and the local representatives are called together so that they can satisfy themselves as to the needs of particular applicants. In some cases admittedly applicants stated that there were more in family than there actually were, but when the statement was found to be untrue a change was made in the priority list. I believe the doctor should be an independent official, independent of private practice. Naturally he is the best judge and he is the best qualified to decide as to the suitability of an applicant for a particular cottage.
I appeal to the Minister to consider my suggestion in relation to the delegation of some of the county managers' responsibilities to the secretary. If necessary, the secretary can be remunerated for the extra work and responsibility. I do not want to go into the health services but they are throwing a tremendous amount of extra work on to the county managers and their assistants and staff. I see no reason for congratulating the Minister on this amending Bill. There is nothing in it to bring any great joy to the hearts of county councillors.
Comment on this
From my short time as a member of the Dublin Corporation, namely, since 1950, and from the study I have made of the managerial system I am satisfied that it would be impossible for the system to work without co-operation between the members of the local authority and the manager. There is no doubt about that. In Dublin Corporation we co-operate to the fullest extent with the manager, and vice versa, and the manager has gone a long way to meet us. Indeed, at times, he has practically leaned over backwards to meet certain suggestions we have made. It should be borne in mind that without co-operation between the local authority and the manager it would not be possible to have any proper managerial system at all. I have heard people to-day criticise the managerial system but the people who have criticised have had no criticism to offer about the county manager in their own particular area. One would think they would come in here and speak from experience, saying: “In my county things are bad and the manager is the world's worst.” Not one word was said to-day by anyone opposing this system to the effect that the county manager in his particular area was a bad county manager. When Deputies are making a case they should start on their own home ground.
Some Deputies who have spoken are members of local authorities but they had not one iota of criticism to make against their own manager. If I had anything to say about the city manager I would not be afraid to say it either here or in the corporation. I have said my piece whenever I did not agree with things he was doing, but I must say that we find him very co-operative in many ways.
We would like to have Dublin separated from Dún Laoghaire and the County of Dublin. It is impossible for one man to carry out three jobs. Dublin City is continually growing, the population is getting bigger every day and it is only right that the city manager should deal with Dublin alone. In the Dublin Corporation we find that the city manager may have certain views of things happening in the county and we may have different views and it is unfair that he should be asked to try and hold the balance between the Dún Laoghaire Corporation, the county council and the Dublin Corporation. If any amendment is brought in by any Deputy or by the Minister, we in Dublin could make a very good case for having a manager for each of these administrative areas. The Minister would be wise to give every consideration to that matter.
My colleague, Deputy Briscoe, mentioned that he proposed to bring in various amendments to this Bill. I agree with some of the amendments he suggested but I do not agree with others. He mentioned that in the Dublin Corporation if we want to increase the rates by one penny to provide decorations for the city it requires a two-thirds majority to do that. He wants that done away with so that it can be done by an ordinary majority of the members. I think that when we are dealing with public money or increasing the rates the members should be there. That is what they were elected for. Nobody asked them to go forward. They fought hard to be elected to do a job of work and when it comes to increasing the rates they should attend. There are 45 members of the Dublin Corporation and it requires 30 to make such an increase. It would be a reflection on the City of Dublin if we could not get 30 members to attend a meeting to consider such an increase in the rates. I think this suggestion would be a retrograde step and I regret that I must disagree with Deputy Briscoe in regard to it. The members of the corporation are there to do a job of work and, when it is proposed to increase the rates even by one penny, it is only right that they should be there to do the job they were elected for.
Great play has been made about rate collectors. In Dublin we are in the happy position that the city manager gives us a lead in regard to that matter. I for one cannot see, however, that there is any necessity for rate collectors in Dublin City because most people pay their rates at the office or send in a cheque for the amount. I, therefore, cannot see what need there is for these rate collectors in the City of Dublin. If we had the power to do anything in regard to that matter it should be done. I do not want to put anybody out of employment. I have heard Deputies criticising engineering staffs. Engineers and architects are workers drawing salaries and that is a wrong line to take. But, in the case of these rate collectors who have very little to do because the money is brought into or sent into the office, when it is time for them to retire some other method of meeting the situation should be considered.
Deputy Cowan raised the question of housing and suggested that the Department of Local Government should take over the building of houses in Dublin so as to expedite matters and not have the corporation preparing schemes and submitting them to the Local Government Department.
Comment on this
The question of housing in general may not be discussed on the County Management Bill.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling. In sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 3 certain powers are given to the members of local authorities. I wonder if some members of local authorities will welcome this. The county manager can only submit to the Minister a proposal to increase the number of permanent officers or the rate of remuneration with the consent of the council. That is something which could be abused. In Dublin the cost of administration is very high. I am open to correction, but I understand that more than half the total rate collection goes to the administration of Dublin and that is quite a big sum. If the members of local authorities can now increase the permanent staff or the rates of remuneration it is quite possible that they would carry that too far. I hope members will be wise and see that this is not brought to such a stage that the cost of administration will go sky high. In Dublin it amounts to a colossal sum at the moment and every effort should be made to reduce it.
There, again, you have certain Bills passed by this House which make it obligatory on the Dublin Corporation to meet the demands. At the same time, the city is growing and you must have an increased staff to deal with all these things. But I do feel that the cost of administration in Dublin is very high and some effort should be made to reduce it.
Then there is provision for a manager to retire at 65 years of age. That is a very wise provision because it makes room for younger people. You will find some people who are not anxious to get out at 65 and I think that is wrong. Even in commercial and business circles a man of 65 should get out. When I reach that age, if I am here or in my own job, I will get out as quickly as I can because I think a man of 65 has earned a rest. The main thing, however, is that it makes room for younger people.
Comment on this
I am glad to see you are in good health. I suggest to the Minister, as mentioned by Deputy Briscoe, that where a man is appointed a manager at 40 or 45 years of age he should get added years for pension purposes. It is a pity that city and county managers when appointed are generally between 40 and 50 years of age. They are getting pretty long in the tooth for such onerous work. It would be better to have men between 30 and 40 years of age for such appointments. Deputy Davin made the case, and I think it was a good one, that a manager should be a person who had intimate knowledge of local affairs. I think it wrong that a city manager or a county manager should come from some other sphere of business into a technical job like that.
These are the few short observations that I wish to offer on the Bill. We shall have an opportunity of considering it in detail on the Committee Stage. I would merely say at this stage that the amendment of the Act effected by Section 3 does not offer a great deal of scope to councils. What is really needed is a full, comprehensive Bill dealing with local government. However, the present measure is a step in the right direction. I would again say that without co-operation between councils and managers there is no hope of getting the managerial system to work.
Comment on this
As the Minister probably wishes to get in to-night, I shall be very brief in my remarks. Like Deputy Gallagher, the one thing that has struck me about the debate on the Bill is that the various speakers who contributed to it started off by praising individual county managers and by condemning the system itself. I am afraid I must follow suit. I agree that the county manager we have in Donegal is one of the most capable officials one could wish to secure but, at the same time, there is no person who will deny that the system is wrong. The proposed Section 3 does provide some curb on county managers, one that in my opinion is absolutely essential, but there must be some reason for it. Has the Minister found county managers employing staffs which were not necessary? Has he found them increasing salaries without justification? If he has, then Section 3 is essential. If he has not, though I am in full agreement with it, why introduce it at all?
I think it is time we took stock and endeavoured to curb this lavish expenditure on local government. I represent a constituency in which the county council struck a rate the other day of 39/11 in the £. The personnel of our county council staff is numerically greater than the personnel of any industry in the entire county. I am aware of the numbers actually employed by our county council and they exceed the numbers employed by any single industry in the county. The engineering staff alone exceeds 20. In the old days, I understand, six engineers did the work which is now done by over 20. May I suggest to the Minister that in dealing with Section 3 it should be pointed out to local authorities and to county managers that one method of reducing local taxation is to utilise the contract system in preference to the direct labour system in the construction and repair of roads? I think that the contract system is one method whereby we could curb the tendency towards this lavish expenditure from the rates. I also agree with Deputy Gallagher that it is time we abolished the post of rate collector. Rate collectors in my constituency are earning as much as £1,000 a year.
Comment on this
More than that, sometimes. I think we could save all that expenditure. We have now reached a stage where the ratepayers know their duty to the local authority and, in my opinion, they would pay the amount due merely on receipt of a demand by post from the county council. I have considerable experience of the courts and within the past five years I have not come across a solitary case where the rate collector had to sue for the amount of cess due. When we have that spirit amongst the people who can afford to pay, we should encourage it and abolish the office of rate collector.
One flaw which I see in Section 3 is that it is not retrospective. If we are going to curb the power of county managers in regard to the employment of staffs and increases in remuneration in future, I think we should give some thought to the past and to cases where redundant staffs have been employed. If redundant staffs had not been employed by local authorities, Section 3 would not have been introduced. I think, therefore, that councils should have an opportunity of reducing staffs where necessary, but one thing that has to be remembered is that under the terms of employment of certain officials councils may be debarred from abolishing the offices to which these individuals were appointed. Something will have to be done, otherwise the ratepayers will be unable to meet the increased demands made on them each year. Since the passing of the County Management Act in 1940, the rates in my county have increased by 75 per cent. and we do not know the additional expenditure that will be involved when the Health Bill comes into operation very shortly. I tell the Minister now that Section 3 is very essential and, so far as I am concerned, he will have full support in operating it.
Comment on this
It was Deputy Norton, I think, who charged me with having made statements, I think outside the House, giving the impression that I was about to introduce a Bill which would, as he said, bring, or almost bring, the idea of county management to an end. I cannot recollect having made any such statements, having given an impression, or used words that could give an impression, such as that. I have in fact here before me a statement which I made on the 28th May, 1953, when speaking on the Local Elections Bill, as reported in the Dáil Debates, Volume 139, column 258. I was defending the introduction of that measure and this is what I said:—
"I did not mention the fact that I was contemplating introducing proposals—they are not very formidable—in relation to the managerial system."
I knew then that the amendments which I had in mind were not revolutionary in any sense and, as I say, I never gave either the House or the country the impression that they would be. I do not think it necessary, even if I had time, to go into a defence of what is proposed in this Bill or indeed of the system itself. I remember I was in the House when the principle was first introduced here in the Cork City Management Act which was passed in 1929. That Bill was introduced here by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government when we were in opposition. We, as a Party, then, as far as I know, rather approved of the principle which was introduced first in 1929 to Cork, next in Dublin City in 1930, next to Limerick City in 1934, next to Waterford City in 1939 and following that it was applied to the whole country. The very fact that in that progressive way over that extended period, the system having been tried in relation to a small area such as Cork City, extended to Dublin, Limerick, Waterford and to the whole country over a period of ten years is proof that there was a good deal to be said in its favour.
I remember once, when speaking on another measure dealing with county administration, giving my own view as to what I thought of this principle when it was first introduced and when extended by the Government of which I was a member. I never was enthusiastic about it. It was not that I, speaking for myself, had any desire to curtail the activities of public men and local bodies but because it appeared to me as one who had some service on local bodies that it was impossible to expect men to give all the time that was necessary to dispose of the detailed sort of work that was developing, especially from 1931, 1932, 1933, 1934 onwards and in order to relieve public men of much of that responsibility and the time its discharge entailed that I for one gave my support to the system. But as I say, I never had any great enthusiasm for it.
If the amendments contained in the Bill we are now discussing are not drastic, it is because in my view, it is necessary to maintain the balance fairly evenly while at the same time tilting it a little bit in favour of the elected body in the matter of general control. I am prepared to admit that there is something to be said for some of the criticism that was levelled against Section 3 inasmuch as it may restore responsibility to the members of the elected body in a way that many of them will not appreciate at all. But at the same time, having had experience of local government before the extension of the managerial system, having seen local government after the introduction and extension of the managerial system to the country, I think that the amendments which are proposed here will help in the long run to tilt the balance in favour of those who have to seek public support for whatever policies they preach to the electorate and who are returned by them to exercise control and give effect to these policies.
There may be other ideas in my mind as far as management is concerned. There may be other amendments that I could have suggested here, but because of the fact that the management principle is not the concern of any one Party here—it was introduced in the manner that I have described—and because it is not the concern of any single Party and because you will find critics of it in every Party, because you will find critics of it in every local body in the country and because you will find on every local body people who will defend it, I deliberately confined this measure to the matters on which I had satisfied myself completely that amendments should be effected.
I want to say to those Deputies on all sides of the House, including my own and members of the Opposition, that if they have any thoughtful amendments to put on the Order Paper for the next stage, I will be prepared to argue these with them, and I will assure those members before they submit these amendments that as far as I am concerned while I have not an entirely open mind on all the amendments that might be proposed, I certainly would have a fairly open mind on most amendments that could be proposed.
Comment on this
I would like to say to those Deputies who say "this is an ‘as-you-were' Bill, that it contains nothing except Section 3," or "that apart from Section 3 it contains nothing except what is in Section 9 and 10"—I would say to them now, those Deputies who have been talking about the managerial system and criticising it as the child of one particular party—I think another Deputy tried to make my predecessor responsible for it—let them spend some time between now and the next stage considering all these matters and if the amending Bill which I have here before me and which I am recommending to the House is not sufficiently wide, let them see to what extent, further powers may be given without detriment to local authorities and further powers taken from managers and given to the local bodies.
While not committing myself to what I will accept and not accept, I will give the House an assurance that I will argue any further proposals they may make with a entirely open mind and will be open to conviction if they will make a case in support of them.
Comment on this
That is all I have to say. I realise that most people who have spoken have spoken without regard to politics and although some were thinking of political considerations, they were very few. There is always the odd Deputy in the House who cannot speak on anything without making it political. In most cases the proposals were made by men with experience of local administration; they see weaknesses and strengths in this measure, and it is with this type of Deputy that I like to have discussions such as I hope we will have on the further stages of this measure.