We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance.

Contributions 1–184 of 560. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I move:—

That a sum not exceeding £36,000,000 be granted on account for or towards defraying the Charges that will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1955, for certain public services, namely:—

£

1 President's Establishment | 2,500

2 Houses of the Oireachtas | 76,000

3 Department of the Taoiseach | 9,200

4 Central Statistics Office | 34,100

5 Comptroller and Auditor General | 11,380

6 Office of the Minister for Finance | 58,200

7 Office of the Revenue Commissioners | 614,950

8 Office of Public Works | 150,000

9 Public Works and Buildings | 1,600,000

10 Employment and Emergency Schemes | 232,000

11 Management of Government Stocks | 36,200

12 State Laboratory | 6,800

13 Civil Service Commission | 18,500

14 An Chomhairle Ealaíon | 6,500

15 Commissions and Special Inquiries | 4,400

16 Superannuation and Retired Allowances | 271,000

17 Rates on Government Property | 10,000

18 Secret Service | 2,500

19 Expenses under the Electoral Act and the Juries Act | —

20 Supplementary Agricultural Grants | 1,300,000

21 Law Charges | 39,000

22 Universities and Colleges | 270,000

23 Miscellaneous Expenses | 6,000

24 Stationery Office | 230,000

25 Valuation and Boundary Survey | 22,600

26 Ordnance Survey | 20,800

27 Agriculture | 2,216,000

28 Fisheries | 35,700

29 Office of the Minister for Justice | 28,400

30 Garda Síochána | 1,483,400

31 Prisons | 65,170

32 District Court | 31,180

33 Circuit Court | 41,080

34 Supreme Court and High Court of Justice | 31,500

35 Land Registry and Registry of Deeds | 32,100

36 Public Record Office | 3,110

37 Charitable Donations and Bequests | 1,680

38 Local Government | 1,796,680

39 Office of the Minister for Education | 122,000

40 Primary Education | 3,055,000

41 Secondary Education | 400,000

42 Technical Instruction | 400,000

43 Science and Art | 60,000

44 Reformatory and Industrial Schools | 115,000

45 Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies | 25,000

46 National Gallery | 3,460

47 Lands | 832,440

47 Forestry | 391,000

49 Gaeltacht Services | 160,000

50 Industry and Commerce | 3,000,000

51 Transport and Marine Services | 640,000

52 Aviation and Meteorological Services | 137,000

53 Industrial and Commercial Property Registration Office | 8,000

54 Posts and Telegraphs | 2,600,000

55 Wireless Broadcasting | 165,100

56 Defence | 2,755,700

57 Army Pensions | 491,460

58 External Affairs | 135,000

59 International Co-operation | 18,400

60 Office of the Minister for Social Welfare | 174,350

61 Social Insurance | 932,660

62 Social Assistance | 5,931,800

63 Health | 2,470,000

64 Dundrum Asylum | 15,500

65 Oifig na Gaeltachta agus na gCeantar gCúng | 2,500

66 Tourism | 160,000

TOTAL | £36,000,000

The amount of the Vote on Account now asked for is £36,000,000 and the individual items covered by it are set out on the Order Paper. With some exceptions, they represent one-third of the Estimate for each service.

The total of the Estimates for this year at £108,000,000 represents a decrease of £3.36 million on the total provision for the current year, which, however, included a Supplementary Estimate for the National Development Fund of £5,000,000 which is of course a capital expenditure and will be dealt with as a voted capital service. Other supplementary provisions falling into this category were £200,000 for University College, Dublin, and £95,000 in respect of grants for housing to Bord na Móna and £50,000 to Min Fhéir, Teoranta, for capital purposes. Deducting the total of these four items, the amount of the Supplementary Estimates which are chargeable against current revenue of the present financial year comes to £5,731,000.

Of this figure of £5,731,000, £2.4 million is in respect of increases in remuneration of State and local authority employees, arising out of the McKenna Arbitration Award of November, 1952, for which specific provision was made in the Budget, for this year. Further supplementaries, chargeable against current revenue, included an additional £420,000 in relief of rates on agricultural land, a further £193,545 for Army pensions, £186,000 for G.N.R. operating losses, £125,000 more for Garda pensions and £58,500 to Mianraí Teoranta for prospecting. Though this batch, at £983,000, exceeds by £233,000 the budgetary provision of £750,000 for supplementaries, our experience in this regard would have been much more satisfactory than it has been for many years, were it not for two quite unexpected demands which emerged towards the end of last year. The first of these, the Supplementary Estimate for Social Insurance, was before the House a fortnight ago and I need not repeat the statement of the Minister for Social Welfare in regard to it.

The other large supplementary and one which it would have been quite impossible to have foreseen and provided for, is the extra £753,000 required under Vote 50 to subsidise the price of flour and wheaten meal. The gross sum which it is estimated will be required for this purpose is, in fact, £853,000. Savings of £70,000 on other items in the Vote and an increase of £30,000 from sales of turf, reduce it to the net figure which I have mentioned. The gross figure of £853,000 itself reflects not only the increase in the area under wheat but the increased yield which a more scientific agriculture, under a beneficent Providence has given to the Irish farmer. Last year we had an exceptionally bountiful harvest and we have been able to do with much less imported wheat than was anticipated. In terms of economic self-sufficiency this is all to the good but from the Exchequer point of view, it has its disadvantages.

Whether our bread and flour and wheaten meal were made from Irish wheat, or imported wheat, we should have to provide a heavy subsidy to keep the prices of these foodstuffs at their present level. But the rate of subsidy on home-grown wheat is much higher than on the imported article. Accordingly, the better our harvest, the bigger the subsidy. On the other hand, if we were to revert in these dangerous times—let me emphasise that—to the position of almost absolute dependency on imported wheat, such as obtained here in 1931, we should still have to subsidise it very heavily, in order to sell bread and flour at their present prices. Thanks to the subsidy, the cost to the consumer of our bread and flour is far below the economic level, and far below the general level of world prices for these foodstuffs. Our loaf may not be quite the cheapest in the world, but it is among the cheapest. So far as I have been able to ascertain, in all the world only Great Britain, the Six Counties and perhaps Portugal and New Zealand, have a cheaper wheaten loaf.

Before discussing in detail the position for 1954-55, may I utter a word of warning to those who are speculating about next year's Budget on the basis that the Estimates represent an increase of £7.71 million on the figure for the current year? The fact of the matter is, of course, that in May last the Supply Estimates were increased by £2.4 million to give more pay to the Civil Service, the Army, the Gardaí and the teachers; so that the true increase on the bulk Estimates, capital and non-capital, is £5.31 million. Allowing for other adjustments made in the Budget and for items regarded as capital, there is an increase of £4.38 million in non-capital services. Admittedly, this is a substantial sum, but it would be premature and it would be, in fact, futile, in the absence of essential information relating to the Central Fund service and revenue prospects, to frame imaginary budgets on the basis of it alone. Only at Budget time can the situation be fully presented and intelligently discussed.

Comment on this

And the election?

Comment on this

I am thinking of it with much greater equanimity than the Deputy is. Coming now to the Book of Estimates itself, this shows, vote by vote, where the increases and decreases lie compared with the provisions for the respective service for 1953-54. For a clearer understanding of the picture, however, it is necessary to group similar services in order to see in what broad categories of expenditure increased provision is being made. When we do this, we find that there is an increase of £2,141,000 in the provision for Civil Service, Army, Garda Síochána and teachers' pay, while the provision for pensions for these classes is up, in addition, by £534,000, making a total increase for pay and pensions of £2,675,000. Taking Supplementary Estimates into account, however, there is, in fact, an estimated decrease of £44,000 on the total provision for last year.

For social insurance and social assistance there is a net increase of £689,000 compared with the original 1953-54 provision, but a decrease of £889,000 taking the Supplementary Estimate for social insurance into account. This decrease, I am happy to say, reflects the continuous improvement in recent months in the employment situation. Grants to health authorities are up by £717,000 arising out of the Health Act and increased pay for employees of such authorities.

There are increases of £355,000 on housing and sanitary services and of £1,024,000 on education, including, of course, new school buildings. For public works and buildings excluding schools and arterial drainage, there is an increase of £957,000. The increased provision for flour and bread subsidy, arising in the manner to which I have already referred, is £2,295,000 or, if we take into consideration the Supplementary Estimate which has just been voted by the House, the net increase will be £1,442,000. For agriculture, the increased provision is £565,000; for arterial drainage £44,000, and for forestry £19,000. The agricultural grant is up by £731,000 on the original figure for 1953-54 or by £311,000 on the revised figure.

To summarise, therefore, the position is that on pay and pensions there is an increase of £2,675,000 on the original provision for 1953-54; in the category of social outlay there is an increase of £6,037,000; and for agriculture, drainage and forestry an additional £1,359,000 is being provided. These increases total over £10,000,000. It will be interesting to see which of them the Opposition propose to do away with. The major decreases which go some way towards off-setting the foregoing increases are: £1,000,000 in the Grant-in-Aid of the Hospitals Trust Fund, for which the provision is £3.5 million as against the £4.5 million provided in 1953-54; and, secondly, £820,160 in the provision for repayment of advances for rural electrification, which is the result of adopting a system of repaying these advances to the Central Fund by instalments over a period of 25 years. This practice is defensible by reference to the normal life of the capital assets and will relieve the taxpayer of having to meet immediately as a current charge the 50 per cent. of the capital expenditure on rural electrification which ranks as subsidy. At the present rate of progress with the scheme, the full and immediate discharge of the subsidy as it arises would be an unduly heavy burden.

The third item on which there has been a decrease is in the provision to cover losses of C.I.E. and the G.N.R. The amount of the decrease in this instance is £535,000. I think, perhaps, I ought to point out that the sum of the Estimates for these items at £1,355,000 represents a very substantial reduction on the amounts which the present Government was called upon to provide for transport losses in 1951-52 and 1952-53. In the first of these years, the year in which we took over from the Coalition, the sum was £2,385,000, and in the second year it was £2,745,000. It is hoped that over a period of years the need to subsidise transport services will be further reduced and finally eliminated, that is provided that a progressive Government is here to give a lead to these undertakings, and not to set back the clock as was done when it was decided not to proceed with the dieselisation of the railways in 1948-49.

Comment on this

We do not know what the Minister is talking about.

Comment on this

The Deputy will soon hear a little about it. The fourth item is the figure of £118,000 in the cost of contract work for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs and £88,000 in respect of the purchase of engineering materials. Then, we have the fifth reduction of £120,000 in the provision for wireless broadcasting which last year covered exceptional expenditure on transmitters. It may be opportune at this stage to draw a comparison between the programme of expenditure on the Supply Services now put before the House and the corresponding programme put forward by our predecessors for 1951-52. In the three years which have intervened since the Opposition was the Government, there has been an increase of £25.2 million in supply expenditure of which £2.3 million is on "capital" account, and £22.9 million on current account. Using the same basis of comparison as I have used earlier in this speech, we find that on pay and pensions (for the Civil Service, Army, Garda Síochána and Teachers) there is an increase of £7,676,000 of which £6,281,000 is for pay and £1,395,000 for pensions. These increases, it would be well for us all to note, follow mainly from the two arbitration awards in the period.

For social insurance and assistance the combined increase is £8,062,000. This increase springs from the improved rates of benefit first provided for in the Budget of 1952, together with the broadening of the scope of the social welfare services under the Social Welfare Act, 1952.

For education (including school buildings) the increase is £1,444,000 apart from increases in remuneration and pensions. For health services, including hospital building, there is a net increase of £6,195,000 of which £3.5 million is a Grant-in-Aid to the Hospitals Trust Fund which, of course, is a "capital service"; and £2.7 million is for grants to health authorities.

For agriculture the increase over the period is £1,711,000 of which £600,000 is for ground limestone subsidy, £250,000 for Eggsports, Ltd., and £600,000 for grain storage loans.

The last mentioned sum represents an investment of capital necessitated, not only by the need to provide against a possible emergency but by the increased requirements for grain storage arising from our greatly increased grain production. Since 1951-52 the agricultural grant increased by £1,180,000; the combined Estimates for Lands and Forestry (excluding pay) have gone up by £336,000; and the provision for Defence (again excluding pay) is £2,089,000 greater.

At first glance it would appear that the subsidies for transport and marine services are estimated to cost £1,538,000 net more in 1954-55 than in 1951-52 due as to £1,000,000 to C.I.E., subsidy, £350,000 to G.N.R., losses and £186,000 to increased grants for harbours. There are here some noteworthy facts to which I think I should refer. In 1950-51 it was found necessary to bring in a Supplementary Estimate and vote £980,000 to C.I.E., to cover the operating losses of that concern up to 31st March, 1951. So far so good; quite clearly C.I.E. at that date was working at a loss and the transport services had to be kept going. There was no reason, however, to believe that a working loss of £1,000,000 in one year was going to be wiped out in the following year. Yet, strange to say, our predecessors made no provision whatever in the Estimates for 1951-52 for transport losses. Instead they left it to us, as their successors, to find the money to cover these losses and subsidise C.I.E., to the extent of £2,250,000.

Comment on this

And the Minister was able to buy Tulyar with £250,000—a quarter of a million—from the Aga Khan.

Comment on this

Yes; and to sell another horse at twice as much as we paid for him.

Comment on this

You said you found the country "broke" when you came in.

Comment on this

I was talking about C.I.E. We will try to keep even Deputy O'Leary on the rails.

Comment on this

The Minister is going off the rails.

Comment on this

As I was saying, so far from making any provision to cover the operating losses of this nationalised concern, which it was easy to foresee would inescapably arise in 1951-52, our predecessors made no provision whatsoever in their Budget of that year for this contingency.

Comment on this

It is a wonder your Party took over at all.

Comment on this

We, therefore, had to find the money to cover these losses and to subsidise, as I have said, C.I.E. to the extent of £2,250,000. So far, therefore, from the figure for this year representing an actual increase over the figure for 1951-52, it represents a reduction of £1,250,000 on the sum which our predecessors ought to have provided for in their Budget of 1951-52, but which we had to find.

It is clear from the general picture which I have painted that the increase in expenditure in this country has followed the same pattern as in other countries, has in many cases been conditioned by it, and that the funds collected from the public for the schemes I have mentioned have been returned to the community in the form of improved social welfare and health services, better housing, better educational facilities, subsidised public transport, agricultural improvements, higher pay for State employees to compensate for higher living costs, expansion of public works of an essential character and a better-equipped Defence Force.

All this expenditure is reflected in the conditions of life here. According to independent international observers, our people, by and large, are better fed than any in the world, with a level of nutrition higher than obtains even in New Zealand, Canada, Australia, or the United States of America. Despite the huge deficiency which had to be overcome when Fianna Fáil first took office in 1932, housing conditions in general are better here than in most of Western Europe. We have, as I have already mentioned, all but the cheapest white loaf in the world. With the exception of Denmark, we have the cheapest sugar in Europe, and with the exception of Great Britain the cheapest butter. We have, if I may mention them in the same category, the cheapest beer, the cheapest spirits, the cheapest tobacco. Yet there are some who, no doubt, will shortly argue that we can have all this and Heaven, too; who will promise to provide an earthly paradise in which everyone will be given everything for nothing—and not only be given it for nothing, but will be paid for taking it away. It just cannot be done, and the people know it cannot be done.

Comment on this

Things were cheaper before your Party came in, anyhow.

Comment on this

Before I make the few remarks I have to make on this Vote on Account, may I be permitted to welcome on behalf of myself and my colleagues the return, with almost his normal vituperative vigour, of the Minister for Finance? However much we may differ from him, we are all very glad to see that he is, apparently, fully restored to health. I, personally, would miss him in my constituency during the next few months, or weeks, as the case may be, because he is always a great asset to me when he speaks at street corners in my constituency during a general election. I am sure the Minister will accept our sincere congratulations on his recovery to health.

On this Vote on Account I intend to be brief to the point of being laconic. In normal circumstances, this Vote on Account provides an opportunity for Deputies to subject to close and critical examination details of Government administration and Government expenditure and to examine the underlying principles thereof financially and economically. On this occasion we feel that no such examination is permissible or desirable. We are living in the shadow of a dissolution. We feel that we would be discussing in an atmosphere of complete unreality the financial and economic policy of the Government or the details of its expenditure or administration and we do not propose to do so. We have at the present moment here, not merely the pending dissolution of this Dáil, but an atmosphere of political tension and unreality. Recognising that situation, we felt it was our duty to consider what ought best be done in these circumstances of a completely unprecedented character, having in mind always and first of all the public interest. We came to the conclusion that the public interest demands that there should be an immediate dissolution of this Dáil and that we should not waste the time of this Dáil or further add to the sense of uneasiness which exists in the country by entering upon any sort of detailed discussion of this Vote on Account.

I, therefore, propose to tell the House the decision that we have arrived at and to give our reasons for it. We quite appreciate that it is essential that the Government should be given sufficient funds to carry on the public services during the next few months. Our proposals therefore will be, that we would be prepared to give to the Government without discussion, or with little discussion, this Vote on Account and also all stages of the Central Fund Bill, on the condition that the Taoiseach and the Government in general should give time to-morrow after questions until the adjournment of the Dáil that night, or a little longer if desired, for the discussion of a motion we would put down in my name on behalf of the Opposition, and that motion would be:—

That, in the opinion of Dáil Éireann, the Dáil should be dissolved forthwith.

If the Taoiseach accepts that motion and gives us time for a discussion immediately of that motion, we will be prepared, as I say, to give him this Vote on Account without discussion, or with little discussion, and to give all stages of the Central Fund Bill.

If the Taoiseach and the Government do not accept that proposition, then what we intend to do is to give the Government this Vote on Account with little, if any, discussion, but on the Second Reading of the Central Fund Bill to move an amendment. The formal motion will be:—

That the Central Fund Bill be now read a Second Time.

Our motion will be:—

To delete all the words after "that" and substitute the words "Dáil Éireann refuses to give a Second Reading to the Central Fund Bill unless the Government consents to consult the electorate forthwith by an immediate dissolution of Dáil Éireann."

We recommend either of these courses to the Government. We are anxious that they should have sufficient funds to carry on. We will give them these funds by the Vote on Account. But we do feel that the public interest and the affairs of the business community and of all sections in general require that the state of uncertainty and uneasiness which has pervaded this country since the results of the by-elections in Cork and Louth were declared, followed by the declaration of the Taoiseach on the night of the 4th March following these results, should be resolved at the earliest possible time.

There is no doubt that, even in normal circumstances when a Government, having run its full course, decides to have a general election there is in the country a state of uncertainty and business dislocation for some time which is unavoidable. We feel that as much as possible of such uneasiness and dislocation should be avoided. We have had in the country for some months past, to put it no further, very serious political tension and political uncertainty as to the future of the Government. That has affected business and it has affected industry and initiative. Since the results of the by-elections everybody, following the Taoiseach's announcement of his intention to have a general election at the earliest date, thought that was the proper thing to do and that it should be done as soon as possible. The Taoiseach, when he announced this on the night of the 4th March, did so in a phrase, which apparently was very carefully manufactured and designed. We all know that the Taoiseach is an adept at verbal obscurity and is the master of the ambiguous phrase. Nevertheless, when he did announce that, in view of the results of the two by-elections, he was of opinion that it was necessary that a general election should be held as soon as the financial measures required to provide for the public services have been completed, although very many constructions can be put upon that phrase, the only sensible one was that if he received the Vote on Account and the Central Fund Bill was passed into law as early as possible, those measures would be sufficient to enable the Government to carry on until a new Government was elected and that, therefore, his intention was to have an immediate dissolution.

I challenge the Taoiseach to say whether or not that was his intention. What changed it? What was the purpose of the change that we learned about last night to postpone this general election for two months, which can result in nothing but financial loss to the business community in general? The proposal that this Government, which is under sentence of death, should bring in a Budget three days before the dissolution of the Dáil is one which, I think, is entirely and utterly reprehensible.

I am not in the least bit interested in whether or not those proposals are framed or designed to secure a measure of political popularity for the Government. It may be that that is their object; probably it is. I suppose they are entitled to grasp any political lifebuoy they may see in the stormy political seas in which they are battling at the present moment. But what I am concerned with and what my colleagues are mostly concerned with, is that it is utterly improper for the Government in the circumstances that exist to delay two months before the general election and to bring in a Budget just three or four days before the dissolution, thereby hampering or endeavouring to tie the hands of the future Administration, whatever the composition of that future Administration may be.

It is recognised that the Budget is an instrument of economic policy. It is recognised that through the Budget proposals, the framing of the Budget and the financial proposals at Budget time, the Government's financial and economic policy is put into effective operation. When the inter-Party Government were in office they devised the system of a dual Budget, a system by which the annual State housekeeping expenditure was put into one separate compartment and the proposals of the Government for capital expenditure were put into another compartment of the Budget. If the present Government carries out its present intention of waiting until the Budget is brought in then that will be impossible—it certainly will be extremely difficult—for any new Administration when they take office; and I do say that it is utterly indefensible for the present Government in the existing circumstances to bring in a Budget on their own lines which will have the effect of gravely hampering any development that may take place after the change of Government. It may be that the present Government will come back, but it is highly unlikely. I am no prophet, and I do not undertake to prophesy what is going to happen, but if any Government formed on the principles on which the inter-Party Government were formed and carrying out the economic and financial policy of that Government were returned as a result of this general election, then they would have been—and I think deliberately, as a matter of deliberate policy —placed in a position in which their desires to carry on the Government of this country and the financial and economic affairs of the country in accordance with their well-known policy would be very seriously hampered for very many months.

I have no doubt that if there is a change of Government that Government will examine afresh and reconsider anew the financial proposals of the present Government, but when it is considered that it will be somewhere in the month of June when there will be an opportunity after some weeks for that Government to determine what its policy is going to be the financial year will have been eaten into.

Comment on this

The Deputy's dates are wrong

Comment on this

The financial year will have been eaten into very seriously and the new Administration that will come into office will have been very seriously hampered in their efforts to ameliorate the conditions which have existed for the past few years and which have so harassed and ravished the affairs of all sections of the community.

I placed in the forefront of my proposals here grounding and giving reasons for those proposals to have an immediate dissolution those considerations to which I have very shortly adverted. There is no doubt that during the next two months while we are waiting, while the country is waiting, for the Government's proposals, very serious loss and possibly irreparable damage will have been done to the finances and to the business and industry of the country. We all know that people will expect that because the present Government is going to an election they will bring in what is for want of a better term called a "popular Budget". I am not in the least bit interested in that because I am convinced that no matter what Budget the present Government bring in, no matter what popular proposals they may have, no matter what they may try, the result will be the same— inevitable defeat for the present Government. Therefore I am not in the least bit interested or concerned in what the Minister or his colleagues propose to do in the way of bringing in a popular Budget. Nothing they can do will prevent the people, whose voice has already been expressed in Cork, Louth and North-West Dublin, from choosing and giving their answer to whatever may be brought out in anticipation of a favourable verdict. What I am interested in is this—that people will expect that that sort of Budget will be brought in. They will perhaps have forgotten that the Minister for Industry and Commerce—and I am sure the Minister and his colleagues would like to forget it—only a few weeks ago, speaking, I think, at the Publicity Club on 14th January as reported in the Irish Times of 15th January said—I quote: “Generally,” said Mr. Lemass, “it can be said that while the Budget position was sound enough, there was no fact in it.”

Cork and Louth had not then spoken.

Then the paper goes on to say:—

"It did not hold out the prospect of the Government finding it possible to undertake any substantial increase in expenditure, or to grant any substantial reliefs, until the expansion of economic activity which was anticipated had been achieved and had disclosed itself in a still further improvement in the revenue position."

There is the statement of policy of a few weeks ago—there is no fat in the Budget. It will be dripping by the time the Minister for Finance gets it on 21st May. Whether it is or is not, the people will expect it to be, and it does not require any very great powers of word picturing to conjure up the position of traders and merchants at the present time considering: "Will there be a reduction in income-tax? Should we hold off in making any more profits this year?"

Comment on this

The Deputy has never been in business or he would not say that.

Comment on this

"Is there going to be a reduction on whiskey? Are they going to take it out of bond? Are they going to bottle more stout?" There is going to be very serious loss in business, and the Minister and the Government are going to be responsible for that. We want to stop that if we can. For political reasons, I admit here freely, we desire a general election at the present moment. We have no doubt what the result will be. We have no doubt what the result will be in two months' time. It may be worse for the present Government than it will be now if we have what the Taoiseach calls a rushed election. We are anxious to meet the Minister on the political battleground chosen, as he said, by himself some time ago at his own time. The sooner the better as far as we are concerned, but at the same time the really serious consideration is the question of the public interest and the question that it is a wrong precedent for a dying Government to bring in a Budget which may very seriously tie the hands of whatever Administration may succeed it, and which incidentally and as a necessary and inevitable consequence prevents the amelioration of the financial and economic conditions and the conditions of unemployment which exist in this country. That is the real objection to the present Taoiseach's proposals to delay the election. Nearly a quarter of a year will have gone before any new Government can get into its stride—probably more. It will have been hampered in its efforts to carry out its policy by the budgetary proposals. The people will have acted upon those proposals and there can be no going back upon them. May I mention this—it has been known that the present Government went back on its promises? It has been known that Ministers said that not merely would they not withdraw the food subsidies but that they would maintain them, and it was only a few short months till they withdrew the food subsidies. What confidence can the people have in this Government if they bring in what is called a popular Budget, that if they succeed in getting a new lease of life, a new term of office they will not do what they did before, go back upon their promise and replace the popular Budget by something much more severe and much more austere than even the Budget of 1952?

We feel that the whole approach of the Government to this problem has been wrong. The Taoiseach said that he wanted to have all the financial proposals before the people. Strictly read, the Taoiseach's announcement of the night of March 4th is capable of being read that it would entail postponing this election until the Finance Act and the annual Appropriation Act had been passed.

If the Taoiseach insists now, as apparently he does, that that phrase did not mean, as everybody who knows anything about parliamentary procedure knows that it did mean merely the passing of the Vote on Account, and the Central Fund Bill, but that it also meant the passing of the Budget and the Finance Act, then I would put it to him, in regard to the phrase: "A general election will be held as soon as the financial measures required for the public services have been completed," that the completion of the financial measures required for the public services involves not merely the Vote on Account, not merely the Central Fund Bill and not merely the Budget speech and Budget resolutions but the Finance Bill and the Appropriation Bill. In other words, if the Taoiseach's proposition is correct, it would necessarily involve the postponement of the general election until somewhere about next August.

Comment on this

Perhaps he means to do that.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

It is possible. As I say the approach to this matter has been entirely wrong and entirely contrary to the public interest. It has brought about and will still further bring about public uneasiness, financial insecurity, dislocation of business and very serious losses. Above all it will hamper the hands of the succeeding Administration and prevent it from carrying its full policy into effect within the coming financial year. Apparently now we are to have as the chief exhibition at the Tóstal the slow reluctant irrevocable march of the present Government on its way to the political guillotine. That is to be the chief show at the Tóstal.

Comment on this

Surrounded by £60,000 worth of flowers.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

It may be that Ministers may think that the balmy breeze of the month of May or the early summer will be more favourable to them than the chilly winds of March which produced the reversals in Louth and Cork but, whenever they decide to go to the country, they will get, in my opinion, the same chilly reply as they got in Louth and Cork at the recent by-elections.

Comment on this

I think it is a burlesque of parliamentary government that we should be discussing here to-day, or that we should have put up for discussion here to-day, a Vote on Account from a Government which has no authority whatever from the people to introduce a Vote on Account.

Comment on this

What nonsense!

Comment on this

We shall see "what nonsense" in a minute. I do not hope to compete with the Taoiseach in nonsense.

Comment on this

Can Labour speak for every constituency in Ireland?

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister for Finance is back in his place. Personally I wish him the best of health in the future but for the sake of the nation, I hope he will never be seen here again after the election. That does not detract from the fact that he has all our good wishes for his personal good health and personal prosperity elsewhere. Here the Minister is only a danger and a national menace. There are only two reasons why the Taoiseach does not want to dissolve the Dáil. One is the Taoiseach's well-known impetuosity when things go wrong with him. The lid is off and anything can happen once the Taoiseach is disappointed and thwarted in his desires. The Taoiseach has put it on record that when he wants to know what the Irish people want, he has only to look into his own heart. Apparently he has not looked into his own heart on this occasion because he has prescribed a course of conduct which he must have known is not acceptable to the Irish people. The Irish people have told him plainly: "We do not want any more of this; we are going to reject you and your candidates." Apparently now the Taoiseach believes that the people have done something they should not have done. The Taoiseach on another occasion said that the people had no right to do wrong, so we have got this peculiar mixture from the Taoiseach. Firstly he is a better judge than the people of what the people want. If the people question that and say to the Taoiseach: "We do not think you are the best judge of what our economic policy should be or what would be the best course for us to adopt," the Taoiseach will reply: "You have no right to do wrong". That means in other words: "You have no right to do anything whatever except what the Taoiseach's prescription lays down for you". Because the people have now declared emphatically that they do not agree that what the Taoiseach prescribes is best for the national life, the Taoiseach gets into a tantrum and proceeds to do something for which he has no mandate whatever.

If the Taoiseach believes that he has the people's votes still behind him now is the time to test it. The only reason that the Taoiseach does not want to dissolve the House now is that he realises that his Party has lost 9,000 votes in a by-election and although he knows he has no mandate from the people he is trying to postpone the date on which he will go out of office. Everybody who read the Taoiseach's declaration the other day came to the conclusion—indeed the members of his own Party interpreted it in the same way as others and as the Press did— that if the Government got their Vote on Account and the Central Fund Bill this week the Dáil would be dissolved forthwith and a new Government would be elected in time to introduce a Budget which would be fortified by an expression of the people's will. Of course the Party managers then set to work and brought their propaganda to bear on the Taoiseach, once his tantrums had passed, and said: "You cannot do it. We know that you were annoyed when you made that statement; it is not easy to lose votes in such abundance and keep a brave face but really you cannot go to the country at the present moment because the chances of coming back in present circumstances if there is a general election now, are even worse than they were before the by-elections."

The Taoiseach has been prevailed upon to change his mind. Of course that is no trouble to the Taoiseach. We have had several examples of that over the last 20 years in this House. Deputy Costello has quoted one instance in regard to the 17-point programme which the Government published before the last election. We had the declaration that their policy was to control the cost of living and to maintain the food subsidies. Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll issued an election address——

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Norton would tell us something about his own policy. Tell us what you are going to do about the food subsidies.

Comment on this

His policy is to lead Labour into Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll——

Comment on this

He is entitled to his last squeak.

Comment on this

——need not worry about changing his mind. He is in good company. If the Taoiseach can change his mind on an important public issue, surely some of the lesser fry like Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll can do the same. Somebody has said that consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, so Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll——

Comment on this

And to stand on one's head is the prerogative of little politicians.

Comment on this

I want to come back to the 17-point programme issued in June, 1950, and get away from all this airy-fairy nonsense of the Taoiseach. I want to concentrate for a moment on one point in that programme, namely, the promise to control the cost of living and to maintain food subsidies. That was the promise made to the people. So far from carrying out that promise, the Government viciously slashed food subsidies. Bread went up, butter went up, tea went up, flour went up, stout went up, whiskey went up, cigarettes went up, meat went up, milk went up—the price of a whole collection of commodities went up. Actually, the price of a whole list of staple articles went up because the Government did not keep its promise to maintain food subsidies and control the cost of living. If the Taoiseach can wreak that havoc with the people's domestic larders, what is a small change in the mind of the Taoiseach in regard to the election, a small error of judgment, compared with the crimes committed in the domestic lives of the people by the present Government?

The Taoiseach, however, as Taoiseach has certain liberties, one of which is to change his mind, and clearly somebody has beamed propaganda on the Taoiseach since last Thursday night, and so the Taoiseach now finds a scholarly collection of excuses for the change of front which was manifested in the declaration he made last night. He does not now propose to go to the country when he gets the Vote on Account through; he does not now propose to go to the country when he gets the Central Fund Bill through. Instead, the Taoiseach is concerned, though he has no mandate, to make sure that the people will see another Budget from the Fianna Fáil Party. I do not mind having this wager—I think Deputy Briscoe is the official commission agent of the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this

And you for the Labour Party?

Comment on this

Then you cannot make a wager with me. I only deal with principals.

Comment on this

It depends on how you spell the word.

Comment on this

Either way, he cannot do much business with you.

Comment on this

Let the Minister for Finance enjoy his last month here. I will make this wager— that there will be a few crusts in this Budget for the people. They will be just crusts, with the hope of deluding the electorate in the market place into returning this Government to office, and if the people can be deluded again, that, in 1955, they will get a Budget the same as they got in 1952.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that all the people worship the Golden Calf?

Comment on this

They worship bread.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the people who worship the Golden Calf better than I know them.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy thinks.

Comment on this

All the Taoiseach's advisers who have driven him off the path of rectitude on to which he stumbled on Thursday night have been specious advisers, so far as the Taoiseach is concerned. He was right last Thursday night. He ought to have gone to the country with the utmost expedition, and all that is necessary in order to enable that glorious event to take place is for the House to give the Taoiseach the Vote on Account this evening. Everybody is willing to do that and everybody is willing to give him the Central Fund Bill, and quite willing even to see that on this occasion the Taoiseach visits the Park in daylight.

Comment on this

Nobody was more relieved than Deputy Norton by the Taoiseach's announcement.

Comment on this

This hanging on business with all the excuses we got——

Comment on this

It is a reprieve for you.

Comment on this

——for this disreputable conduct which we had from the Taoiseach this evening is something which does violence to any decent concept of parliamentary government. The Taoiseach is always talking about the people being the masters and about the right of the people to elect a Government. Yet the Taoiseach says now. "I have no mandate to carry on," because that is the reason we are going to the country, but yet he will not give the people the earliest opportunity of deciding what Government they want to control the affairs and the destiny of this country for the next three or four years.

We come then to Fianna Fáil introducing a Budget—a Budget on behalf of whom? Is it to be a Budget on behalf of the people, or is it going to be another looking into the heart and finding out what the people want? The Government has no authority to introduce a Budget—no more authority than any other 72 people outside in the City of Dublin. That is admitted by the fact that the Government find their own mandate here faulty and now want to go to the country.

Comment on this

Not at all. According to the Constitution and the law——

Comment on this

Why then are we to have an election?

Comment on this

——so long as we have a majority here, we are the Government of the country and that is all there is about it. The Opposition would do the same.

Comment on this

There is nobody who can put a better look on a bad case than the Taoiseach, but the old box of tricks, skilfully wielded though they may be by the Taoiseach, will not fight for Fianna Fáil on this occasion. This is a clear dodge to hang on, to give the people crumbs in the Budget and torture when the Budget is over. Who has asked the Government to introduce this year's Budget? Nobody wants them to introduce it. The people still have painful memories and still endure the hardships of the 1952 Budget which were continued in 1953, and, except for a bit of decoration to deceive the people, will probably be continued in 1954. The people do not want a Budget from this Government and they do not want this Government either. They want to get rid of the memory of Fianna Fáil Budgets of the past few years, and the best way in which that can happen is by giving the people a choice at an election of saying whom they want on the Government Benches to-day.

What the by-elections have shown is that the people want a change of Government. There is no reason why they should not get it. The Taoiseach was right and was democratic last Thursday night when he said the people should have an early opportunity of electing a new Government. All those who have advised him to the contrary and who have induced him to change his mind are sheer political opportunists who want now to try to get another Budget passed through the House, or introduced, in the hope of saving their rapidly fading fortunes. It does not matter now what the Budget is like at all. It is clear to every person who can think decently that this Budget is an effort to do a bit of political tangling in the market place. This Budget will be used, and this is the only purpose of the delay, to try to ensnare unsuspecting people to vote for the Fianna Fáil Party, but it will not work. The people know the prices they are paying for foodstuffs to-day as compared with the prices they paid three years ago. They know that there is more unemployment to-day than there was three years ago and they know that there is more emigration to-day than there was three years ago.

Comment on this

They do not.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that, except the Taoiseach. When the Taoiseach is asked for figures, he says he has no figures. All he has to do is to go down to the boats and see what is happening there.

Comment on this

That happened in the last year of the Fine Gael Government—I might as well call it a Fine Gael Government.

Comment on this

It was denying those truths that got you the trouncing you got last week.

Comment on this

This Government has a reputation to bring before the people. It is responsible for the highest price level seen in the country in living memory. There are 14,000 more unemployed people to-day than there were three years ago and emigration, I say, has increased in the last three years to a greater extent than at any time previously. The people ought to get a chance of judging on these facts.

Comment on this

And they will.

Comment on this

In so far as they have been permitted to do so at the by-elections, they have judged unmistakably and they should get the chance to express nationally what they feel locally; but whether the election is to be in the month of March, April, or May the writing is on the wall. The Government Party, with its austerity Budgets and neglect of unemployment, is on the way out. The only reason for delaying the holding of a general election is to enable the Government to hang on for another two months, in the hope that they can box the compass in the meantime, but it is too late to do it.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I must say it was most amusing to listen to Deputy Norton and Deputy Costello avoiding the issues. The Government "wants to hang on for another couple of months" and they "want to deceive the people with the Budget." Deputy Norton says the people want a change of Government. I think the people are entitled to know what sort of Government is offered to them as an alternative to Fianna Fáil. At least, they know the sort of Government we are.

Comment on this

A bad Coalition Government.

Comment on this

They know what we have done and what we intend to do, but do they know what any alternative Government would do, faced with our proposals for expenditure for the coming year which are contained in this Book of Estimates. The Opposition say not a single word about them, because the Opposition groups, each particular group, wants to go down to the country and tell the people a different story about what they would do, if they had a chance to form a Government.

Comment on this

It is not as easy as the Minister thinks to cod the people.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton complains about the cost of living, the price of milk, bread and other commodities. What would any alternative Government do about these matters? Would Deputy Norton in another Coalition Government advocate that the Dillon policy in regard to milk should be implemented in order to bring down the cost of milk and butter? Would he support Deputy Dillon in paying 1/- a gallon for milk during the next few years in order to get cheap butter or would he increase the price of the pint or the cigarette in order to leave the farmers their present price for milk at the creameries and reduce the price of butter to the consumer? The country has a right to know if they are going to criticise the price of bread. If "the people worship bread," as Deputy Corish just interrupted to say, they have a right to know what is going to be the policy of an alternative Government towards this idol they worship? Are we going to reduce further the price of bread and, if so, by what means?

Comment on this

The people of Cork spoke about that, did they not?

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Norton does not want to run away now? I listened to him. I will put the questions and I take his absence to mean that he cannot answer.

Comment on this

Whatever the Minister says is no good.

Comment on this

The Opposition Deputies opposed our Constitution tooth and nail when it was going through the House and they tried to get the people to turn it down but they have now nailed it to their political masts. One would think they were the progenitors or the father and mother of the Constitution and that instead of opposing it they advocated its adoption. The Constitution lays it down that the Government, when elected, carries on until the Taoiseach, so long as he has the support of the Dáil, advises the President to dissolve it.

Following a defeat, there are two alternatives. One is to advise the President to dissolve the Dáil which the President may or may not accept and the other is to resign. The Constitution does not say that if a Government is defeated at a by-election it must resign or go to the country. If that had been the case, we would have had a very big number of elections over the years Fine Gael—Cumann na nGaedheal were in office. The Constitution lays down quite strictly what the Government may or may not do. The Taoiseach is entitled, as long as he is not defeated in the House, on his own wish to declare a general election. If defeated in the House, he may advise the President to have a general election and the President may or may not agree.

What the people are interested in is not the date, whether it is a week or two one way or the other, on which this general election is going to be, but what the Government will be which will follow and what its policy is going to be. I think the essence of democracy is that the people should have a right to decide as between policies offered by alternative Governments. We offer our policy to the people and we want to put it fully to the people. We believe that in the circumstances of Holy Week, the spring work and everything else, it is worth while waiting until we get the other side of the account and our proposals are put before the people as to how we propose raising the money to meet this expenditure of £108,000,000 approximately contained in the Book of Estimates and also the money to cover the Central Fund expenses.

There are two ways of meeting the situation where there is £108,000,000 being spent in the Book of Estimates and another £10,000,000 or £12,000,000 in regard to the Central Fund. One is to cut down the services and the other one is to meet the cost of these services in so far as they are current out of taxation. We will tell the people exactly what we intend to do in that regard.

Comment on this

They will not believe you any more, after all you told them the last time.

Comment on this

Wait and see. We are giving the Deputies more rope than they want to hang themselves and they are not going to rush this Dáil or anybody into an election. The people will get a fair chance of seeing both sides of the picture. People had the experience before in 1947 and in the first month of 1948 of hearing a Party going around this country saying they were going to reduce taxation by £10,000,000. We see what happened when the people who made that promise—Deputy Mulcahy was one of the most vociferous of them——

Comment on this

We took off £6,000,000 straightway and £2,000,000 immediately afterwards.

Comment on this

Let us see what happened about this £10,000,000 by which they were to reduce taxation. In 1947-48 the last year for which we were responsible —Fianna Fáil were not responsible for the last month or so—there was an expenditure of £58.9 million. That was to be reduced to £48,000,000 the following year when they got in. Ten million pounds from £58.9 million leaves £48.9 million.

Comment on this

Old time.

Comment on this

It was 1947-48. They are not all dead yet who remember Deputy Mulcahy going around the country promising that they would reduce taxation by £10,000,000. The sum of money which we spent was £58.9 million, and they were going to reduce it to £48.9 million the following year. But in the following year, in fact, it went to £64.7 million, and in the year following that again it went to £73.3 million, and then £75.4 million.

Comment on this

Without the beer taxes or the spirit taxes.

Comment on this

The year they went out they left us in the Book of Estimates alone a sum of £90,000,000, so that, instead of reducing it by £10,000,000, as they said they would, they increased it, in fact, by £41,000,000.

Comment on this

Why was the Minister so anxious to get back?

Comment on this

Without reducing beer, whiskey and spirits.

Comment on this

They were to reduce taxation to £48,000,000 but, instead, they left us a bill for £90,000,000. Of course, they reduced beer and tobacco. If they came in to-morrow, they could wipe out completely the tax on beer and tobacco, that is, if they carried on as they did before. They reduced the tax on beer and tobacco, but they increased the interest required for the dead-weight debt by £4,000,000 a year. They were complaining about the level of dead-weight debt, but they increased the dead-weight debt by £90,000,000 in three years.

Comment on this

What did the Minister do?

Comment on this

In order to avoid taxation they increased the dead-weight debt. They borrowed money to reduce the tax on beer and tobacco; they borrowed whatever money was necessary to give the few pence they gave to the old age pensioners and they have left coming generations to pay the debt.

Comment on this

That is the kind of stuff they would not swallow in Louth.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies will have ample opportunity to make their contributions.

Comment on this

He made all that speech in Louth.

Comment on this

Is this the kind of thing that is going to hold up the dissolution?

Comment on this

What would Deputy Costello and Deputy Norton do in regard to the proposition that this Dáil should pass a Vote on Account amounting to about one-third of this sum of £108,000,000? Deputy Norton indicated that he wanted more in the Book of Estimates; what was there was not enough for him. He wanted more for subsidies.

Comment on this

There is nothing being provided for old age pensioners as it is.

Comment on this

And Deputy O'Leary wants more for the old age pensioners. Is Deputy Mulcahy going to increase this £108,000,000?

Comment on this

Come down to the people and we will tell you.

Comment on this

I have a vote, only one vote. Surely I am entitled to know how I am going to vote——

Comment on this

We know how you are going to vote.

Comment on this

We will send you a special copy of our election address.

Comment on this

——whether it is for an increase in the old age pension, an increase in food subsidies or not.

Comment on this

We will even send you a few pictures.

Comment on this

The Deputy may refuse to answer me and he may not mind about my vote, but there are about 1,500,000 voters throughout the country and surely they are entitled to know. It is their money which is going to be spent and if their money is not collected for these services their children and their children's children will have to pay the debt. Surely they are entitled to know.

Comment on this

To know what?

Comment on this

Whether an alternative Government will carry on these services costing £108,000,000 or whether they are going to add another £10,000,000 or £20,000,000 to it which the Labour Party will promise, and if they intend to do that will they do it through an increase in taxation or an increase in the dead-weight debt? We can all have a very good time as long as we can borrow and get someone else to repay what we borrow. Fine Gael had a very good time, and the Labour Party, although they did not get very much, had a reasonably good time for a couple of years. Instead of raising the money that should be raised they borrowed——

Comment on this

Did you not borrow money?

Comment on this

——and left us to pay the debt. The people are entitled to know whether, if this level of expenditure stands, they should, instead of paying in the year in which the expenditure is incurred, go on paying for the next 40 years, along with their children, to meet the bill.

Comment on this

You agree we cannot borrow ourselves into prosperity, no matter who is in power?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan, who was a protégé of Deputy Hickey, tried that.

Comment on this

You also tried it.

Comment on this

He borrowed this £90,000,000 he should have raised in taxation. Did he borrow us into prosperity? Our expenses this year would be £4,000,000 less if Deputy McGilligan had not endeavoured to follow to its logical conclusion Deputy Hickey's thesis of borrowing us into prosperity.

Comment on this

Is the Minister taking into consideration the interest receipts on the Marshall funds he has invested?

Comment on this

There are no such funds invested.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants the question answered I will put it before the Minister for Finance and ask him to give the figure when he is concluding this debate. In the three years in which the Coalition were in office the dead-weight debt went up by £90,000,000 for which there was no interest coming in, and the additional interest in sinking fund we had to pay for the service of debt and against which there was no income was £4,000,000 a year. Of course, if we were dishonest enough to do it we could produce that popular Budget that Deputy Norton wants and that other people who are afraid to face up to their political responsibilities want.

Comment on this

You are afraid to go to the country.

Comment on this

We could increase the dead-weight debt next year and take 1/- off the cigarettes and 6d off the pint. We could borrow whatever we wanted but I do not think that would be good for the permanent prosperity of the country. It is all right for politicians who are afraid to face their responsibilities, and who cannot keep together if they do anything that is in the slightest degree unpopular with any of the sections they represent. However, people who have some regard not only for their immediate political advantage but for the permanent welfare of the people are prepared to tax as much as required in order to keep the economy in balance.

Will we have another promise in this election that the Opposition will reduce taxation by £10,000,000 and, if so, how is it going to be done? Are they going to avoid increasing the rate of taxation at the expense of adding more to the public debt? Are we going to add £4,000,000 a year to the public debt until £100,000,000 would not pay the interest upon it? £4,000,000 is a pretty hefty sum even in relation to the present level of public expenditure.

Comment on this

Of course it is, at any time. It is paying for a debt that should never be there.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Hickey's point. Will Deputy Hickey, Deputy McGilligan and the rest get together and let us know? All we want to know is what they propose to do.

Comment on this

Bring back the Irish money.

Comment on this

Instead of waiting until the election is over, instead of postponing the bargain, they should let the people know what they propose to do.

Comment on this

I would like to hear the Minister dealing with it now. He has the opportunity of telling us now what he intends to do if he gets back. He should tell the people, not the Parties.

Comment on this

There is plenty of time. On the first occasion, in 1948, when the Coalition came in here, it sprung a surprise on the people. You had Deputy Blowick running around the country and swearing he would never join a Coalition and talking about all the farmers' Parties that had been absorbed by Fine Gael. You had Deputy Norton saying that they would never join a Coalition.

Comment on this

And the present Taoiseach said he would break stones before he would join a Coalition.

Comment on this

At the present time they are all prepared to have a Coalition. I want to know what they are going to coalesce about and what the burden is going to be. The Deputy is trying to do now what Deputy Costello wants us to do. He wants us to have no discussion on this matter and let the people vote—let the people vote blindly without seeing what issues are involved and what issues they are going to decide by their vote.

Comment on this

As one voter, I would like to know what you, as well as Deputy Costello, are going to say.

Comment on this

We are going to say that. We are not only presenting this Book of Estimates to the House, but we are going to present a Budget to the House and we hope the various groups in the Opposition will not remain mute of malice, but will tell us what they require done.

Comment on this

I said the same when the inter-Party Government was in power.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey should cease interruptions.

Comment on this

Sorry, Sir.

Comment on this

The Minister is going off the rails.

Comment on this

It was amusing to hear Deputy Costello saying that a dying Government had no right to bring in a Budget a few days before declaring an election. Everyone knows that this Government is going to bring its period of office to a close on 24th April. The last time we had a general election, in 1951, the Coalition Government knew they were going to bring their term of office to an end immediately the Budget came in, but they did not tell anyone. All we got was an announcement of it on the radio. They knew for months that they were dying; they were tearing each other's guts out and they could not agree.

Comment on this

That is what you thought.

Comment on this

They brought in an Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. It normally would go over in a couple of days, but we found every Deputy speaking on it. Deputy O'Leary was even asked to speak on it for as long as he could, though the Coalition Government usually wanted him to say as little as he could. They knew the general election was going to come off. They knew they would be defeated if they allowed the Department of Agriculture Estimate to go to a vote. They dragged it out until after the Budget. They brought in a Budget which was quite definitely a dishonest Budget. As the Minister for Finance pointed out here to-day, although they knew there was a Civil Service award coming, they made no provision in the Budget for the millions that that award meant to the Exchequer. They knew that C.I.E. was in a bad way, that it was going to require another couple of millions subsidy in the financial year, but they made no provision for that.

Comment on this

And you begged four Independents who had no authority to put you in.

Comment on this

At least we are not rushing anybody. We are not being driven to a general election by fear of a vote in this House. We tell the people exactly and we have given fair warning that in a few weeks' time the Taoiseach will propose to the President that this Dáil should be dissolved. I think that between now and then we should do our utmost to clear up the issues on which the people will have to vote. Deputy Costello cannot avoid dealing with the issues by making the sort of speech that he made here to-day. After all, it is the people who are going to pay for all this business.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

And Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It is the people—not Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael—and the people have a right to know upon what the money is going to be spent. They have a right to know, if there are other expenditures proposed, how the "wind" is going to be raised. They have a right to know, if they are promised a reduction in the price of the pint and in the price of tobacco and in income-tax and everything else, who is going to pay for all these reductions. Are we going to pass it on—as they did, £90,000,000 in the time of the Coalition—to our children and our children's children? Have we any right to do that?

Comment on this

Of course we have not, and it should not be done; but we have been doing it for the last 30 years.

Comment on this

But Deputy Hickey and the Government he was associated with did it at £4,000,000 a year for the next 40 years. It is poor consolation to the people who have to pay this year on their pints, on their cigarettes and in their income-tax, for the £4,000,000 of Government expenditure that is due to the dead-weight debt created by the Coalition. They avoided putting something extra on the pint and on the cigarette for a year or two, at the expense of paying it each year for the next 40 years.

Comment on this

You have done nothing better than the former Ministers.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey should cease interrupting. It is not necessary to answer every point made by the Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello talked about the uneasiness and dislocation of business. What uneasiness and what dislocation of business? According to Deputy Costello, we are closing our eyes to all the circumstances. We could have declared an election within the next few days. Instead, it is coming within the next few weeks. What grave dislocation of business is that? Would it not cause even more grave dislocation of business if the people did not know what the alternatives were on which they would have to vote?

Comment on this

The ballot box will tell that. No one else can tell that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy O'Leary interrupts, I shall ask him to leave the House. He has been interrupting constantly since the Minister began.

Comment on this

One of the things that are bad for business, bad for employment, bad for every section of the community, is not to know what is going to be the financial policy of the State over a period of years.

It is much better that the election should be delayed for the necessary two or three weeks if we can get some sort of declaration of policy, particularly from the major group that is offering to form a Coalition. Do they propose to reduce the services in this Book of Estimates and, if so, what services do they propose to reduce? We know that there are some of the services in this Book of Estimates that Fine Gael do not like. There is an increase, as the Minister for Finance pointed out, over 1951-52 of something like £8.6 million for social services. We know that the Fine Gael people do not like it. Deputy McGilligan called it "medicine." They strung along Deputy Norton for three years on a Social Services Bill which they never allowed him to implement. If they will reduce taxation by cutting down these things, will Fine Gael wipe out that additional £8,500,000 for social services and, if so, will the Labour people support them in it?

It was all right for the Labour people to be strung along week by week and month by month, not implementing the social services that they had promised to implement, but cutting down is a different matter and we should be told if they will insist as part of their bargain in having these continued or increased.

Comment on this

Your opposition to it was very manifest.

Comment on this

There was a Health Bill introduced which was not very palatable to Fine Gael. They opposed it tooth and nail. The health services are costing us about £6,000,000 extra this year over what they cost when the Fine Gael-Labour Coalition were in office. The people are entitled to know whether that is going to be continued or whether it is Labour or Fine Gael who will get their way in regard to that.

I do not want to go through all the various items. There will be time enough, for the next month or so, to try to get Fine Gael to say something in the Dáil and not leave all the talk to the platforms in the country where they cannot be answered. We are prepared to answer them, to debate this fully with them here. The Minister for Finance gave them the facts and I rose simply to mark the fact that the two principal speakers, the Leaders of the Opposition groups, have refused to deal with this Book of Estimates, to say whether it is too big or too small, to say in what respects they would cut it down or in what respects they want the sums increased.

Deputy Costello would not waste the time of the Dáil, he said, in going into the details of this Book of Estimates. He and the Fine Gael speakers will waste a lot of breath and a great deal of people's time denouncing the £108,000,000 for which Fianna Fáil are asking. If he is going to denounce the Book of Estimates all around the country, he should denounce it here and let us know in what respects he differs from the proposals which we make. If £108,000,000 is too much, in what respects should it be cut down?

Deputy Costello need not have assured us that they were prepared to give the Vote on Account and all stages of the Central Fund Bill within a day. Of course they were, because they want to avoid discussion here; they want to talk where they cannot be answered. Here, they are mute. Down the country, they will be voluble. Deputy Costello, however, disclosed the type of speech which they will make down the country. He gave some indication of it. He said that we had harassed and ravished all sections of the community. This harassing and ravishing of the community must have hurt particular sections and hurt them in particular ways. We are entitled to know how we harassed them, how we ravished them, and how Deputy Costello would propose to cure the situation.

It is true that we put more on the pint and on tobacco than the Fine Gael people did. Is that what he refers to when he talks about harassing and ravishing the people? Does he propose to take it off?

Comment on this

The unemployment question.

Comment on this

If he proposes to take 1d. or 4d. or 6d. off the pint or 6d. or 1/-off cigarettes, how is he going to raise the money to meet this bill? Is he going to borrow another £90,000,000 in a couple of years and add another £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 a year of dead-weight debt? Is he going to reduce the price of the pint and cigarettes for the coming year at the expense of the people who will have to pay more for their cigarettes and their pint and in income-tax for the next 40 years, because that is the proposition.

Deputy Costello said that the Government will bring in a popular Budget. The Minister for Finance will bring in a Budget, as he has always brought in a Budget, which he thinks is an honest Budget to do its work whether it is popular or unpopular with any section of the community.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Who are you codding?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins, of course, judges us by his own standards.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

I judge you by my knowledge of you.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins is judging by his own standards. We know that the last Government, knowing for weeks before that they were going to have a general election and arranging for it but not pretending to the country, not telling anything about it, brought in a Budget which left us a £6.7 million deficit to meet. The Minisster for Finance went through the items and I do not propose to do so again.

Fine Gael are accusing us of wanting to do what they did themselves and what they would do in our circumstances, but the Minister for Finance and this Government will do what they have always done in relation to these things—they will bring in a Budget that will serve the permanent interests of the people, irrespective of whether it suits the temporary interests of this Party or not.

Deputy Norton accuses the Taoiseach of getting very angry when a by-election goes against him and of having the reaction of wanting to dissolve the Dáil in order to get his own back on the people. But that has not been done. Although there was an adverse vote in Louth and Cork, the Taoiseach is giving this Dáil and the people time enough to consider and discuss the issues upon which the next general election will be fought. The members of the Opposition need not expect that the people will not notice that Deputy Norton and Deputy J.A. Costello put down their heads and spoke about everything that they did but did not speak to this Vote on Account. We cannot expect that the people will not notice that.

I do not think, as Deputy Corish said, that the people of this country "worship bread". I think the people of this country have a proper respect for other values as well as just bread. It is right that the people should have a sufficiency of bread but it is wrong that anybody should worship bread and ignore human and all other values. If we simply want to worship bread alone, we can get down a lot of Government expense. We can take the risk of having this country overrun by cutting out the £8,000,000 or £9,000,000 the Army is costing us: we can cut out what is spent on education and on other things as well.

The sensible people of this country— and for most of the past 25 years they have been in the majority—want their Government to make orderly progress. They do not want a few lawyers to get together and simply throw dust in their eyes as to the difficulties of life. The people know perfectly well that if you do not go to the trouble of ploughing, harrowing and sowing you cannot expect to reap a harvest, and that if we are to have extended social services, if we are to provide money for houses and to provide money for safeguarding the community by maintaining the Army, and all these other things which have to be paid for, we must face up to our responsibilities and be willing to do our share. Those people in our community who are fairly well off are quite prepared to pay a reasonable standard of taxation in order that these services may continue.

We could increase the standard of life of our people at the present time not only by cutting out these services I have spoken about but we could also increase the standard of life for a few years by realising all the past savings of our people and giving these savings to them for a couple of years in order to enable them to have a good time. The Coalition Government did enough of that. In a couple of years they decreased the net savings of our people by well over £100,000,000—and I think that that was far enough to go with that game. These savings do not belong to the politicians of 1954 and 1955. They were created over the years by the hard work of our people and our people are entitled to see that they are properly safeguarded and invested for the permanent welfare of the community and not just to suit the convenience of a few politicians for a year or two. If, unfortunately, the politicians should not have regard for the permanent interest of this country, and simply want power for power's sake, and get a hold of those savings, they can spend them and we shall be that worse off. They would spend that money as they spent the savings of our people in the years 1948 to 1951.

I think it is the duty of the Opposition, if they are criticising the financial policy of this Government, to state exactly what the financial policy of an alternative Government they might form would be. Deputy Blowick cannot go down the country and say that he does not intend to coalesce again: he said that in 1947, but it turned out that he changed his mind in that regard. I think that in this general election he will have to admit that he would be quite prepared to form a coalition and, in those circumstances, I think he should tell the people the policy upon which he would combine to put into effect. What will be the financial policy of that Government as an alternative to the financial policy of this Government? The people have had three years' experience of the result of the Coalition Government, as it was composed. If it is proposed to form an alternative to the Fianna Fáil Government. I think the people are entitled to know ahead of time——

Comment on this

We will tell them.

Comment on this

All Deputy Corish told me, or anybody here, is that the people worshipped bread.

Comment on this

I will tell the Minister nothing here.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish does not speak for his Party. His Leader spoke here this afternoon but not a single word did he say——

Comment on this

He did not mean to say a word about them. He wants to tell the people of the country——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

He wants to say it down the country where he will not be questioned. He should say it here, so that he can be answered.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies can make their speeches later. The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

They are determined that they will avoid saying anything——

Comment on this

The Minister is in very bad humour this afternoon.

Comment on this

I am not. I am in quite good humour, and I am glad to see that Deputy O'Leary is here because he may say something, even though his leaders, Deputy Norton and Deputy Corish, are mute of malice.

Comment on this

We will see what we are like——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I submit that the Minister is irrelevant and repetitious and is drawing Deputy O'Leary into intervening by way of interjection to him. The Chair has already warned Deputy O'Leary that if he interrupts again he will be asked to leave the House. In these circumstances, I submit that there is deliberate enticement of a Deputy by a Minister so that the Deputy will interrupt and then be put out of the House, thus helping to weaken the voice of the Opposition Parties in the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has taken all that into consideration. Deputy O'Leary has interrupted five times since I gave him my warning——

Comment on this

Is the Minister not looking for interruptions?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Leary might now cease from interrupting.

Comment on this

I have finished what I propose to say on this matter. In conclusion, I want the various groups who are proposing to form a Government to tell us here in the House, so that the people may be informed, what they propose to do with the services in this Book of Estimates. Do they propose to cut them down or to increase them? It is the people who have to pay the money. If the present taxpayers do not continue to pay the money, the only way it can be raised is by passing the burden to future taxpayers. If they do propose to carry out these services or to add to them, are they going to meet that cost by asking the present taxpayers to meet their liabilities or pass on those liabilities to their children and their children's children as they did when they were the Government before?

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs is very anxious that we on this side of the House would tell him—tell him, mark you—what our proposals are, and he says it is not enough to tell the people down the country. I suppose we must now take it that the people down the country are, in the opinion of the Minister for External Affairs, incapable of knowing their business. They must come to such a light of lights as the Minister for External Affairs, who will tease out our intentions into small bits and inform them as to what we say so that their very limited powers can then digest it.

The recent by-elections, particularly in Cork, have been a command to the present Government to get out. For that reason—because the people in Cork have spoken on this Vote on Account before us—we believe that there should be very little discussion here on the Vote on Account because the people both in Cork and in Louth have already given their verdict on it. We believe the people want the present Government to resign as quickly as possible and to dissolve this Dáil as quickly as possible and for that reason we are willing to facilitate the Government in dissolving as soon as possible.

The results of the by-elections, particularly in Cork, were brought about in my opinion by the feeling of insecurity and instability amongst the people of this country since the present Government came into office two years and some months ago. Before they took over they told the people that they would retain the food subsidies and that one of their chief concerns was to bring down the cost of living. The Minister for Finance, who is sitting opposite, told the people of Rathmines in his own constituency that some maliciously-minded people were scattering the rumour——

Comment on this

Was the Deputy there?

Comment on this

——that if Fianna Fáil got back to power they would reimpose the tax on beer and tobacco. I think the Minister went to the trouble to get that installed in a window on the front page of the Irish Press the following day which, if I remember rightly, was a day or two before voting day. But he was not very long in power until the tax on beer and tobacco was back. The Taoiseach promised the people that the food subsidies would be maintained but since Fianna Fáil came back, instead of trying to keep the cost of living, which was to be their principal concern, within the reach of the ordinary wage-earner and small farmer, they have been taxing their brains to see how they will next pick the people's pockets in addition to what they are doing already. That feeling of insecurity and instability has been shown particularly in Cork.

I think it was only last Sunday in Louth that the Taoiseach assured the people that there would be no general election until the Government were defeated in the Dáil. Yet four nights after when he got a punch in the ribs from Cork we are to have the dissolution and dissolve at once. Last night evidently he came to the conclusion that it would be better not to dissolve so soon. The people are not blind to all this twisting and turning and saying one thing to-day and another thing to-morrow. The position the Government now finds itself in, due to these twists and turns, is not enviable, but I think the Government was doing the right thing in dissolving at once. I do not believe that this hanging on until they can bring in a Budget will deceive anybody because—the Minister for Finance is probably unaware of it — the people in the country will not believe anything the Minister for Finance says now.

Comment on this

Not after the last convention in Ballina.

Comment on this

That was a very special convention at which the Minister did not cover himself with glory. He told us last May, when introducing the Budget, that taxation rested lightly on the land. We know now what that meant because he has since increased taxation and rates and everything on farmers. He told us later that we were the best-fed people in Europe.

Comment on this

You do not look so badly fed yourself.

Comment on this

Is that a warning that the Minister for Finance is going to follow his old trail; that he thinks the standard of living of the people is too high and can be further reduced?

Comment on this

No. It is going to be increased — as we have done.

Comment on this

The Minister came to the House last year and boasted of the fact that £20,000,000 worth of agricultural produce was exported that year or the year before, knowing quite well, and admitting at the same time, that only £2.8 millions worth of the £20,000,000 worth of increased exports was due to increased production, leaving approximately £17,000,000 worth of food denied to our own people by taxation which the present Government put on.

The Minister for External Affairs is a great patriot but evidently his patriotism and that of the present Government works out in this way that our own people ought to be denied the means of purchasing food that our farmers are producing. Instead they must tighten their belts and live on less. Apparently they are eating too much, drinking too much and smoking too much and they have too much money to spend. The only remedy for that state of affairs, of course, is to increase the price of everything so that people cannot buy the food and then send it over to the country that the present Minister for Finance was at one time taking up arms against and at another time was going to take up arms on behalf of. £17,000,000 worth of food denied to our own people — that is a novel way to run the country. The twistings and the turnings are the result of what the Government knows now to be the biggest disaster any political Party met with since the defeat of the Party before Sinn Féin. Nothing like it ever happened before in this country, and no candidate ever suffered such a humiliating defeat as the Government candidate did in Cork. In fact, the word "defeat" is too mild a term to describe it. All that was due to the twistings and turnings of the Minister for Finance and the Government. The fact is that the people cannot be fooled any longer.

Before the present Government took office in 1951 they brought forward a 17-point programme. Not one point in that programme was ever fulfilled. I should be glad to hear the Minister for Finance telling me, when he is winding up the debate, if even one point in that programme was fulfilled. The Minister said at that time that they had a solution for unemployment. When we left office there was a hard core of unemployment numbering about 28,000. In the following winter, the figure went up to 90,000, and at the present time it is about 79,000. The flight from the land was never as great as it is to-day. There is one branch railway line in the West of Ireland which is mainly supported by emigrants flying from the Fianna Fáil lash. That is true.

Comment on this

Not at all. It is the eloquence of the Deputy that is driving them out.

Comment on this

They are flying from Fianna Fáil. In my time, I had forestry centres started all over the West of Ireland. These have been cut by more than half. Men have been sacked in most of these centres. Some of the centres have been closed down. Factories, too, are closing down. Last week-end, in Castlebar, a factory, not a very big one but one which was trying to do its best, was compelled to dispense with 14 employees. They have been thrown out on the roadside. The Minister for Finance and the Minister for External Affairs are not worrying about them, although perhaps they are the only breadwinners in their homes. The Minister for Finance calmly told us this evening, and clapped himself on the back in doing so, that this is the best-fed country in Europe. How does he think a breadwinner, in some town in the West of Ireland, who has no other means except the wage he earns, can make provision for a family of eight or ten children out of a wage of £4 10s. or £5 a week? There may be 12 people in that home to be fed three times a day. Out of his weekly wage, he has to pay rent and rates, meet the cost of food and clothing for perhaps 12 people, and do all that out of £5 a week. Is the Minister not rubbing the salt into the wound a little bit when he talks about this being the best-fed country in Europe? The Minister's statement shows that he has lost touch with the ordinary people when he says a thing like that. He says that we are the best-fed people in Europe after exporting £17,000,000 worth of food produced by the Irish farmer — which I say it was not possible for the Irish housewife to buy — over and above what we were sending out in our time.

Comment on this

So that the policy of Clann na Talmhan is to destroy the export trade.

Comment on this

The Minister does not understand. If he wants to test the people with regard to the policy of Clann na Talmhan, then I suggest he should try and influence the Taoiseach to dissolve the Dáil to-night. Of course, he will not do that, but will wait to bring in some kind of a trickof-the-loop Budget.

Comment on this

The dissolution is coming.

Comment on this

Let us have it so that, at least, we may save something out of the wreck.

Comment on this

The dissolution is coming. Deputy Blowick, like Deputy Norton, is a bit sorry about the dissolution.

Comment on this

Very good. If I am sorry for the dissolution, the Minister can take advantage of my unpreparedness and dissolve the Dáil. I suggest it will not be to his advantage.

Comment on this

The dissolution is coming.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blowick should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I would hate to rub the salt into Deputy Blowick's wounds.

Comment on this