We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance.

Contributions 185–373 of 560. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

We got on well while the Minister was away.

Comment on this

The present Government came back to power in 1951. At that time, the inter-Party Government handed them back a country which was running smoothly like a new machine. They found things were so good that they had to try and create a scare. What was the scare? That we had left debts behind us. That squib exploded in the Taoiseach's hands, so that the Minister for Finance had to stand up some weeks later and make a statement in which he admitted that, instead of leaving debts, we had left £30,000,000 of unspent Marshall Aid money. They said that we had destroyed the country by leaving debts after us. But when they came back what did they do? They proceeded to float a loan of £25,000,000 at 5 per cent. interest, and another one inside of 12 months, £21,000,000 of which was subscribed at 4½ per cent. interest. Apparently, even if we had left the country in debt, the cure which the present Government offered was to clap on a dead-weight debt of £46,000,000.

The reason for what has happened, particularly in Cork, in Dublin North-West and in Limerick is that the people can no longer be fooled by the propaganda of the people opposite. The Minister for External Affairs is very anxious that we should have a contest across the floor of the Dáil. He seems to assume that the ordinary men and women of the country are incapable of seeing things for themselves. Surely, he must be very dull or must have become very much estranged from the people when he forgets last Thursday evening's results. The ordinary men and women can no longer be fooled. They are keeping closely in touch with things through the radio and the newspapers, and have not lost their memories. They remember the promises that were made. They remember the promise that was made by the Minister for Finance that, if the Government did come back to power, he would not reimpose the taxes on tobacco and drink, and would not cut the food subsidies. If a stranger were listening he would imagine that the Minister was conferring some favour on the Irish people when he proposed to take off the food subsidies, and reimpose the other taxes. He was followed by the Minister for Local Government who put another blister on the owners of motor cars and lorries and on farmers who owned tractors. Further burdens were imposed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. We had one Minister after another coming in and imposing burden after burden.

In the meantime, the Government were preparing plans for the building of a new Parliament House that was to cost £13,000,000. Deputy Beegan told us that Dublin Castle was to be rebuilt, and that it would provide work for 100 men from around Dublin. I do not think the people will be likely to forget the generous gift of £140,000 which the Minister for Finance gave to the dance-hall proprietors. All these things are having their effect. We want to facilitate the Government in every way we can with regard to the Vote on Account, and in the passing of the Central Fund Bill, provided they dissolve the Dáil as soon as possible.

On last Thursday night, within half an hour of hearing the results from Cork, the Taoiseach apparently decided that he had no mandate to run the country, and was willing to dissolve the Dáil. To-day, he told Deputy Norton that he has a mandate. I cannot understand where he got the mandate since last Thursday night. Clearly, the people want an election. I am not going to prophesy what the outcome of it will be, although I have a shrewd suspicion. The fact is that the people are clamouring for an election. Look at what has happened in one single constituency. There, 9,000 people out of 40,000, who voted for the Government Party two and a half years ago, have felt compelled to change their views. Surely there must be something radically wrong when a Government has been treated in that way by the people. I think there is no good in the Government just waiting and hanging on, and hoping, like Wilkins Micawber, that something will turn up. That will not achieve anything. The present Government will achieve nothing by waiting to bring in a Budget in which nobody will place any credence. We all know that the Minister will not bring in a Budget cut to the same patterns as his previous ones. We can all make forecasts. We can all make a guess. There may be a penny off the pint, or something like that; but so sure as the penny comes off, if the Minister is restored to office on such a promise the people can bet their last copper there will be 3d. on the pint after that. Probably the flour subsidy will be further slashed. That is what the people expect. The promised Budget will be one well worth seeing.

Comment on this

Wait and see then.

Comment on this

We will wait and see, but in the meantime I suggest the decent thing to do is to go to the country immediately. If the Dáil dissolves to-night, the Minister will be back, if he is elected, on 25th April in plenty of time to introduce a Budget. We will give him £36,000,000 to-night and that will be sufficient to run the country until the 31st of next August. The Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance cannot say that the Opposition are denying him the necessary moneys on which to run the country.

Not one word of the Minister's Budget will be believed in the present situation and for that reason it is a waste of time bringing it in. It is not fair to keep the people in suspense; that suspense will come hard on many sections of our people. It will upset and disturb the farming community and the shopkeepers. It will hit the tourist trade. That has happened before. It will happen again now. It is very inconsiderate of the Government to keep things hanging fire until 18th May. The Government has got its beating; take it like a man! The Government will get this £36,000,000 and the Central Fund Bill to-night. Dissolve to-night and let the people have their say.

Comment on this

I have listened with great interest to the speeches here this evening. I have made some notes. I thought that the Book of Estimates would be in the hands of every speaker. There is one interesting item in relation to the Book of Estimates. In 1947 the cost of this publication to the public was 3/6 or 4/6; the cost of the present Book of Estimates is 10/6. The cry is: "Reduce prices." How can we reduce the price of this publication. Government publications are not sold for profit. The Government is not a profit-making institution. Obviously the wages of those engaged in producing this publication and the cost of paper and printing have gone up considerably. The Book of Estimates itself is slightly bigger than the 1947 Book of Estimates and it is at least twice the price. I suppose when the Coalition of the future is brewing they will promise, amongst other things, that they will reduce the cost to the public of the Book of Estimates. They will bring it back to the 1947 price. How they will do that is nobody's business. They will not suggest reducing the wages of the workers; they will not be able to get cheaper paper. They will probably tell the people they will do it in the wizardly way they reduced everything during the three and a half years they were in office; whatever deficiency results from their reducing the price of the Book of Estimates will be met by some loan which will have to be paid off then over a period of years. For every year they are in office the deficiency in everything will be met by means of loans.

Deputy Costello seemed to be very disturbed and uneasy because the date fixed for the general election is later than it was thought it would be. All of us mix with people outside. Most of those people are common-sense people. When it was announced that there would be an election shortly—I am speaking now of the ordinary man in the street and the people one meets in one's social comings and goings — the public, generally, were horrified at the idea that there might be an immediate dissolution of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Oh dear!

Comment on this

Oh dear! Deputy Morrissey knows quite well that the public are not going to vote in the dark. They will know this time who they will vote for; they will be selective.

Comment on this

And they know it now.

Comment on this

They may know it now, but they may change between this and the date of the election.

Comment on this

That is what the Government is hoping for.

Comment on this

That is what is worrying Opposition Deputies. I do not know whether the Opposition is or is not a Coalition. Why should there be uneasiness or dislocation? Can any common-sense person say that anyone will be disturbed? Does the man in the street become uneasy and disturbed because he fears there may be a return to a Coalition Government? If that is what they mean by being uneasy and disturbed I agree with the Opposition Deputies that a number of people look with horror on the idea of the return of a Coalition Government, such as we had in the past.

Comment on this

They were not horrified in Cork or Louth or NorthWest Dublin.

Comment on this

If that is not the reason for their uneasiness, what is the reason? The Deputies who have spoken have given no indication of the changes they would make in present conditions. Will those who follow them given any indication of the changes? Do they intend to abolish protection? What will they do? Why are the people uneasy? They were not uneasy up to the returns of the last by-elections. Perhaps they were uneasy because Fine Gael interpreted the Taoiseach's statement as meaning we would go to the country this week or next week. The Taoiseach said: "No; we are going to conclude the financial business, including the Budget." Opposition Deputies say the people have become uneasy, unsettled and disturbed; businesses have closed down.

Comment on this

Nobody said that.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here apparently when Deputy Costello indicated that there was almost a closing down of certain businesses.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy Costello and he did not say that.

Comment on this

What did he say?

Comment on this

He did not say that. That is a complete twist.

Comment on this

Did he not say there was uneasiness?

Comment on this

Of course he did.

Comment on this

Did he not say there was dislocation?

Comment on this

He did not say business would close down.

Comment on this

Did he not say the publicans would not know whether or not they could bring their whiskey out of bond?

Comment on this

Of course he did.

Comment on this

Did he not say that businessmen would stop making profits in order to avoid income-tax?

Comment on this

So they will.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe is in possession.

Comment on this

What is the cause of all this uneasiness? Is there some policy that has not yet been announced? Is the uneasiness due to the fact that there might be an election before the policy is announced? Of course there is uneasiness in the ranks of the Opposition Parties. Deputy Norton suggested that he knew Fianna Fáil back benchers who were anxious that the election day should be postponed. I know back benchers in other Parties who are very anxious that it should be postponed as long as possible. Anybody who was around the House since last Thursday will know of the anxiety of members of all Parties with regard to that. I say that the Opposition fear the result of this postponement.

It is suggested that the reason for the postponement is that the Minister for Finance is going to introduce a fake Budget; that it will not be a realistic Budget, real in relation to the whole set-up of the State as this Party sees it; that it will be something to try and cod the people. Deputies know that this Party have a record of facing up to facts and introducing unpleasant Budgets; of facing up to them and going down because of them because, as the Minister for External Affairs said, the existence of a political Party and the existence of the State are two different things. We put the country first and the fate and fortunes of the Party second. We have knowledge that the 1951 Budget was not a real Budget. An ex-Minister of the Coalition Government described it in this House as a cooked Budget, that figures were cooked to mislead and that it was a misleading Budget. Fortunately, it did not mislead successfully.

We have had a number of years of hardship, if you like, for the country. The people expected the Government to keep the management of the affairs of the State on an even keel and, in order to do that, the Minister for Finance in his last Budget pointed out that it was a severe Budget, a Budget to correct certain things that had happened. He looked forward to the time when, as a result of good management of the affairs of the State, he would be able to bring in some relief. I believe that the Budget will be a good Budget. I believe, just as much as the Opposition believe, that it will be a good Budget. That is why I am glad that the Government are going to introduce it and that is why the Opposition fear its being introduced. If we left a situation here where the Opposition, if they came into office, could introduce our Budget, they would have no hesitation in trying to take credit for all the benefits that would flow to the community from it as a result of the good management of the Fianna Fáil Government. We know each other in this House. We know the tricks of politics.

Comment on this

You do, every one of them.

Comment on this

Both sides of the House know them, but the public are beginning to understand these tricks. That is why the public will have an opportunity of examining, not only the speeches that will be made, but also the facts that will be in the Budget. They will know then where they stand and where they are heading. Deputy Costello referred to a statement by the Minister for Finance to the effect that there was no fat in the Budget.

Comment on this

You mean the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Yes, I am sorry. Then the Deputy said there would be dripping in this one. Does anyone know what dripping is? Dripping is a form of refined fat and there will be a certain refinement in this Budget, so that he is quite right. Deputy Morrissey can laugh. We sometimes laugh when we are in an awkward situation; we sometimes cry and we sometimes remain silent. Deputy Costello also stated that we had made promises and did not keep them; that we said that we were not going to reduce the subsidies. Did ever a group of Parties go before the country and make so many diverse promises and not keep any one of them as the Parties who subsequently formed the Coalition Government?

Reference was made to the fact that Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll had joined this Party after having gone up as an Independent. Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan, the Labour Party and Fine Gael all went up as independent groups with conflicting policies. Did they get a mandate from the people who sent them here to form a Coalition Government? Was there ever greater deceit and deception than was shown by that performance? Then a Deputy of outstanding character is singled out here, and it is suggested that he committed a breach of his undertaking to his electorate because, having had experience of the Coalition and of Clann na Poblachta and having seen Fianna Fáil operating on its own, he is prepared to share his future political life with the Party which he believes will do best for the people of the country. People have the audacity to make these statements thinking that the public are deserving of the contempt in which they are held by Deputy MacBride and others. But the people have sense; the people understand what has happened.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us about his salami business?

Comment on this

I am not a bit ashamed of it. I made as good salami as the Deputy made strawberry jam. The salami is still being made, but the strawberry jam is not. The Deputy should get into a manufacturing business and show us what he can do.

Comment on this

That would be a sweet mixture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should keep to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

If we are to be interrupted by these personal observations about a person's activities outside the House, the people who make these observations deserve an answer.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think that the Vote on Account is not being properly discussed and I think the interruptions from all sides of the House are disorderly. I am asking Deputy Briscoe to keep to the Vote on Account and those who are interrupting him to restrain from interrupting.

Comment on this

The suggestion has been deliberately made that the Budget when put before this House and the country will be a promise which will not be kept.

Comment on this

Hear, hear

Comment on this

People who did introduce a Budget which was a promise which could not be kept probably have a right to assume that others will do the same. I believe that every Deputy on this side of the House and a great number of members of the Opposition know very well that the Budget which the Minister for Finance will introduce will be an honest Budget.

Comment on this

A good election Budget, honest or not.

Comment on this

If the management of the State has been so good in the last couple of years as to enable the Minister to bring in a good Budget surely the Party of which he is a Minister is deserving of the confidence of the people so that they will be returned again to office.

Deputy Norton said that everything went up. He gave a list of everything that went up, but he did not tell the House, and I do not suppose that he will tell the country, that when the price of milk went up, when the price of bread and butter went up, with the penny on the pint or whatever it is, and with the price of whiskey going up, the social services also went up, that children's allowances went up, and that the great bone of contention in the ebbing life of the Coalition Government and in this Government's career during the last year, the Health Bill, has become law — another advance in social legislation. Why not tell the public that these things have gone up? In the Book of Estimates one can make a comparison——

Comment on this

The health service Estimate has gone down.

Comment on this

He has not looked at it yet.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means by health.

Comment on this

The Estimate for the Department of Health has gone down.

Comment on this

That is like when the Coalition Government came into being the Minister for Agriculture took from Industry and Commerce the payment from his Department of certain items of the subsidy, and then he said: "Look at how much we are spending in the Department of Agriculture — £30,000,000."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Are we discussing this Vote on Account?

Comment on this

I have been challenged and I have stated emphatically that our expenditure on social services has shown in this Book of Estimates a substantial increase and that it will be reflected in the Budget. I have illustrated that on the return of Fianna Fáil to office when they removed the subsidies, or the parts of them that they did remove, that was done with a certain amount of consideration. Certain people thought to make politics out of it, but we have to have regard to this situation: there are a number of people in the community who are in the upper income levels; is it fair that the general community should pay by taxation, direct or indirect, for the subsidies to give these people items essential to them at a reduced price, or is it not better to kill that situation and make sure that the benefit that you want to have accruing to the vast masses, or, if you like to call it, those not of the high income levels, by removing these subsidies and doing as we did, increasing the family allowances, and the children's allowances? Maybe in this Budget that is coming the Minister for Finance — of course I know nothing about it — will be able to further increase those children's allowances and to give further benefits of a social nature to the people who most need them.

Deputy Norton spoke in a manner that amazes me, coming from a leader of a Labour Party, summing it up that we will throw a crust, another crust, to the public, as though our people were concerned with crusts. Surely to goodness he should by now know that this Party values on a far higher level the masses of our people than that we could be accused of thinking of them in terms of throwing them a crust.

Comment on this

That has always been the Fianna Fáil policy.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Norton will use that language in their election campaigns.

Comment on this

The crust costs 3d. more as a matter of fact since the loaf went up 50 per cent.

Comment on this

The loaf went up and so did the children's allowances. I am talking of the suggestion that the vast bulk of our people will so neglect their appreciation and understanding of the general walfare of the nation as a whole as to be prepared to sink the future of this country for the sake of getting a reduction in the crust. I believe more of our people. I believe that they are of a better calibre and better standard and that they have stood a great deal more privation. They are now a free people. I suggest that some of the Deputies in the Opposition should look into their Bible again and see the picture of the children of Israel who were liberated from slavery, brought out into the land of freedom, and the moment their leader's back was turned they immediately turned themselves to worship the calf of gold. It is suggested here at this hour of the day that the Taoiseach who led this country out of slavery— that now the people are going to turn their backs on him and worship the golden calf, solely and exclusively thinking of the price of bread.

Comment on this

I have heard the Taoiseach called many things but I never heard him called Moses before.

Comment on this

I did not call him that, but still, according to the Bible, Moses was a person of some standing also.

Comment on this

A new name for the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I did not say that. That is the same horrible critical attitude——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The whole thing seems to be very far away from the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

The Constitution has been invoked here to-day a couple of times as to whether what the Taoiseach is doing in his declaration of date is constitutional. I am sure you will be surprised if I tell you that I listened to a Fine Gael speaker in the Louth election telling the audience that Mr. de Valera claimed to be the author of our Constitution.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What has all that got to do with the Vote on Account?

Comment on this

Nothing, only he is put up to kill time.

Comment on this

I am not put up to kill time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to kill it some other way. Anything said in the by-election is not relevant to this Vote.

Comment on this

Or anything done over the by-election.

Comment on this

The by-election in Cork has been discussed here a number of times, and the 9,000 votes we were supposed to have lost.

Comment on this

You did lose 9,000 votes in Cork.

Comment on this

It was discussed here down to the nine thousandth vote.

Comment on this

Nine thousand, two hundred and eighty-eight.

Comment on this

Whatever it is, let it be 10,000, I am not quarrelling about that. What I am quarrelling about is that Deputies discuss that, and if I make references to other by-elections it is not in order.

Comment on this

We will not worry you in the slightest. We will have references to them.

Comment on this

I believe that this Vote on Account which has been introduced to-day must have been looked at by the various opponents of this Government, but not one Deputy who has spoken has yet produced the volume and has gone through any single item on which he found fault with an increased expenditure or a reduced expenditure or some suggestion of an amendment that the Minister might have done this or done that, or a question as to why certain things were done.

Comment on this

All that is out of date now.

Comment on this

I say that it is the Vote on Account which this House is going to carry this week.

Comment on this

It is the vote in the country that we are concerned about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe should be allowed to speak without any interruption.

Comment on this

It is a good thing that the country should know it — Deputy Morrissey has expressed it in the words that he has found, that it is not the Vote on Account we are interested in; it is the vote in the country. Those of us who are here from the country are interested in this Vote on Account on behalf of the country and for the country.

Comment on this

Trying to keep yourself going.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I am hard of hearing, getting a cold in my ears, but Deputy Sweetman's usual loud objections seem a little bit far away from me now. Perhaps he will shout them in his usual trombone voice.

Comment on this

The voice is a bit hoarse after Louth. It was put to much better use there.

Comment on this

The suggestion was made to the public that the postponing of this election to the 24th April was for the specific purpose of enabling those of our Parliamentary Secretaries and Ministers who had not had the full three years' service to qualify for the pensions. Of course that is not true. The election will be held before they qualify for their pensions. That comes very well from a Party which held its election and went to the country immediately after the qualifying date, and not two months before it.

Is it fair that these untrue allegations should be bandied about hoping to get headlines in the papers and, as a result, to get votes from innocent uninformed people, who might believe that these allegations are true? The Taoiseach, the members of the Cabinet and the Parliamentary Secretaries— and there are quite a few of them— are not concerned as to whether they are to get pensions after three years' service. Is it not far better to recognise that or to ignore it, if you are not prepared to admire it, rather than to state that the reverse is the situation? I think it is a great credit and a great tribute to these men that their personal interests are of no concern to them. When we look at the manner in which the predecessors of this Government behaved, they should keep at least quiet about it.

Comment on this

That is a nice implication, from the innocent quiet man who does not wish to say hurtful things about anybody—the slimy way.

Comment on this
Patrick Beegan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Beegan) Fianna Fáil

Deputy O. Flanagan said it to-day.

Comment on this

Was Deputy Morrissey not here when a member of his Party said to-day that the election was being postponed in order that these men might qualify for pensions?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It was not said on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Unfortunately it was first said by Deputies on the opposite side of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must keep to the Vote on Account and the interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

I asked before in relation to election promises, will the members of the Coalition, if there is going to be one—Clann na Talmhan, Labour or Fine Gael—state before the election this time, that they stand for an inter-Party Government or a Coalition Government, and what their policy is going to be?

Comment on this

We are not going to do what the members of the present Government did before the last election —say that they would not put any additional duty on cigarettes, spirits or beer and put it on immediately they came into power.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These interruptions are out of order.

Comment on this

If he kept to the Vote on Account, he would not be interrupted at all.

Comment on this

I was present during the whole of the speeches made by Deputy Costello, Deputy Norton and Deputy Blowick, and I heard not a single reference from either of them to any item in the Book of Estimates. I heard only the kind of talk which I am trying to answer now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I hope the Deputy will do better.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Ceann Comhairle means by that. Does he mean that I am not performing very well?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Keep to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I see. Included in the Vote on Account is a subsidy for flour. I think that is admitted. The suggestion was made that if we get back again, the subsidy on flour will be removed. I think I am in order in talking about that item which is related to the price of bread. I think that it should be understood and recognised that the security of the State in having its bread produced from its own native wheat is of far more importance to the nation than the fact that you can import foreign wheat at a much cheaper price.

Comment on this

Why did Deputy Lemass buy so much of it then?

Comment on this

If we went back to the position which existed for some years before we came into office in 1932, we could easily have a situation where on account of some world disturbance, we would have to dance to the tune of some outside authority in order to secure a supply of wheat and flour for our domestic requirements. Surely, we should argue with the public—as I intend to do in the elections and as I want to point out here now—that it is far preferable to pay a higher price for bread produced from native wheat than to be dependent for our bread on imported flour? There is involved first of all the question of the security of the nation, and secondly the return which such a policy brings to the farmer and the worker on the land engaged in the production of wheat. These factors are all bound up in the question of the price of bread. I say that consideration has been given by the State to what the cost of bread entails for the poorer sections of the community. There was an increase in children's allowances, calculated as near as possible to meet not only the increased cost of bread but also the slight increase in the price of other commodities.

I have great sympathy with the type of man who is not concerned about income-tax, who does not earn enough to be worried about it, who has a certain maximum income which, because he does not pay income-tax, cannot be very high. I feel that to that man bread and butter are of vital importance. We must think about him, and believing, as I do, that this Budget will be a good one and that it will be possible for some reliefs to be made, I suggest now that certain additional benefits be given to that type of person—the type of person with the large family about whom Deputy Blowick spoke, the man with the ten children and the 12 mouths to feed three times a day. I am interested in him because he lives in Dublin as well as in Mayo and I want to see reliefs given to him. An increase of 1/- or 1/6 per child would be a big relief to that individual.

The Minister for External Affairs spoke about the method of the Coalition Government in financing State expenditure. There is a big difference between the mentality of the former Coalition Government and that of ourselves. There is what has been called above the line and below the line expenditure. We will not borrow for items which should be met out of taxation, for consumer goods——

Comment on this

Name one.

Comment on this

We will borrow money for capital purposes, where we are creating an asset by that capital expenditure. We are not going to borrow, either, to make up a deficit in the usual social services expenditure, something that has to be met year by year. The difference, therefore, between ourselves and Fine Gael is very marked in that respect. They borrowed for that type of expenditure and they borrowed heavily.

Comment on this

Will you name a single item of that sort for which we borrowed?

Comment on this

It was named several times here.

Comment on this

Name one now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must be allowed to make his statement in his own way.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman can make his speech later on and can reply, if he wishes.

Comment on this

We know that you are telling an untruth now.

Comment on this

I am not going to be cross-examined by Deputy Sweetman. I am making a statement, and I want to challenge him to get to his feet and repudiate it. A colleague of mine will give him the answers to the questions he puts. I challenge him now to take that line. I am not going to answer questions by way of interjections at all.

Comment on this

I challenge you to name any item, and you cannot do so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe should be allowed to make his statement in his own way.

Comment on this

There were items of expenditure which should have been above the line and which were put below it.

Comment on this

Name them.

Comment on this

They will be named. If the Deputy makes a speech and categorically denies what I am saying, he will get his answer.

Comment on this

I am asking you to name one.

Comment on this

The Minister will be concluding this debate and he will answer the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am asking you to name them now and I will have the same transaction with you as I had with you about Louth.

Comment on this

All through the by-elections and the campaign in this House which is now a general election campaign, the suggestion is made that two things can be done at one and the same time—that the cost of living can be reduced and that taxation can be reduced. These gentlemen opposite are going to do both and they know very well that both these things cannot be done, because they are in conflict. The cost of living can only be reduced, if wages are not increased, by restoring the subsidies and, if the subsidies are to be restored, the money has to be found somewhere and it can be found only by increased taxation.

We will let the public know now where they stand in relation to these slogans. I quite believe that the Labour people would be vitally interested in a reduction in the cost of living and that they honestly and sincerely hope that it will be possible to restore the subsidies to lighten the load of the cost of living, but they will agree that, in order to do that, some other taxation will have to be put on the backs of some people. Fine Gael say they are going to reduce taxation and the cost of living—two things which are entirely in conflict and which cannot be done. The most humble individual during the course of this election will begin to analyse the situation and to find out that it cannot be done. Let us hope it will not take him any longer than the period up to 18th May to make up his mind on it.

Deputy Blowick also amused me. He said that in a particular year our exports of agricultural commodities had gone up by some £20,000,000, but that that sum did not necessarily mean increased production, that roughly one-tenth of it was due to increased production. He then said that the very fact of these goods leaving this country was proof positive that our people were not able to feed themselves, that, if they had enough money to buy this food, it would never have been exported. Surely there must be some conflict between the Clann na Talmhan Party and Deputy Dillon of Fine Gael? We all know that there is a surplus of agricultural produce in a variety of lines which we have for export and that the better the price we get for these commodities and the more we can export, the better it is for the welfare of the agricultural community, certainly. Is it suggested that we should put a prohibition on the export of surplus agricultural commodities and give them at as cheap a price as possible to our people, whether they are able to consume them or not?

Two things which have been abolished in this country are destitution and starvation. There are some of us here who remember when there were destitution and starvation, but I challenge any member of the House to deny that the standard of living of our people in every branch of life has improved. Surely if we want to maintain that progress, we have to continue on the lines on which we have been going. I invite Labour, before they make their statement, if they propose to make a statement, to make sure that on this occasion when they coalesce with Fine Gael, if they intend to do so, the terms and conditions of their association will be clarified, and that there will not be retrograde steps taken or excuses given in connection with social welfare matters and the standard of living of our people. They had three years of it.

One of the leaders of the Labour Party, speaking in Louth, announced that there were 17 items of social legislation which Fianna Fáil had introduced from 1932 until 1948 and he added—I am satisfied that he believed it at the time—that these improvements in social welfare matters were due to the fact that they were in association with us and supporting us as a Government. Whether that is true or not is immaterial, but it happens not to be correct. We were a majority Government at the time we introduced these pieces of social legislation. I admit that the only grouse the Labour Party had with regard to them was that we did not go far enough. They would have liked to have seen us going further. In the three years they were in coalition with Fine Gael, not a single item of social legislation was passed. Yet here we are, less than three years in office, and we have improved children's allowances and introduced the Health Act, with which Labour is in complete agreement—agreement with regard to the extent to which we have gone, but hoping we might have gone further. I do not think I am misrepresenting the Labour point of view. Deputy Corish can say whether I am or not.

Comment on this

You would say that I was interrupting then.

Comment on this

I would not mind the Deputy's interruptions for correction purposes, if I needed it. We have travelled that road, and we are still travelling it and we intend to continue to travel it. I say to the public: Beware of all this mixed grill that is going to be offered, unless there is a commitment.

We were accused of breaking promises. Did Fine Gael not go to the country on one occasion as a Commonwealth Party and did they not break their promise by the introduction of the Republic of Ireland Act and did they not let down all their loyalist supporters? Is it fair for me to point out that that was a promise broken? There were so many broken promises that, if we could have breach of promise actions in respect of them, there would be plenty.

Deputy Blowick cried about the manner in which we were postponing the election date. Every member of his Party wants the election immediately and they are horrified that the Dáil is not to be dissolved to-night. Deputy Cafferky may well laugh, but that is what is being said. The Deputy talked about the high cost of certain articles, but Deputy Blowick is the first man to cry loudly when eggs fall, as they have fallen in recent months. They are coming back somewhat now, but they did fall very low. The Deputy, however, also cries if they go up because the cost of living goes up when the price of eggs goes up. What way do we want it? Are we going to have a dictatorship? Are we going to lay down every day rules to govern the operations of every individual during that day? What are we going to do? We are a democracy. This Vote on Account is put before the Dáil in, I believe, a democratic manner. I am sure it will be passed. I cannot see any vote against it. I have not heard much genuine talk against it. As time goes on and as we get through the final requirements in connection with financial matters, we will introduce our Budget.

Our Budget will disclose to the House and to the country exactly where we are heading during the coming year. Deputy Blowick said that during the years of the Coalition Government the country was running smoothly on greased wheels. Might I ask some spokesman for the Coalition Government to tell us, if the country and the Coalition Government were running smoothly on greased wheels, why they made such a hurried exit immediately after introducing a Budget? Surely it cannot be correct that the country was running smoothly, that the Coalition Government was running smoothly and that the finances were perfect since they made a hurried exit.

Comment on this

I will give you one reason.

Comment on this

I should be glad to hear it.

Comment on this

One of the reasons was that Deputy Cogan objected to a scheme of social welfare for which he voted when he joined Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I thought it was because the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture was likely to be defeated.

Comment on this

That was purely personal.

Comment on this

I do not know how that could be called personal. A Vote was being discussed in the House. It was postponed and the Budget introduced and then you went to the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The motion before the House is to vote £36,000,000.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick in a ridiculing manner said that there was going to be something like £2,000,000 spent on rebuilding Dublin Castle.

Comment on this

£2,000,000? You mean £9,000,000.

Comment on this

There is no sum of £9,000,000 going to be spent. This business of Fine Gael thinking of a number, expressing it and expecting everybody to believe that it is the correct number would lead one to think that they must have always played these funny little games when they were young children. Deputy Blowick told us that there was to be a sum of £2,000,000 spent on rebuilding parts of Dublin Castle and that 100 people would be employed.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary said it was only going to be £400,000.

Comment on this

£2,750,000 over a period of 20 years.

Comment on this

Is it fair when a person makes a statement and says £2,750,000——

Comment on this

I thought he said £4,750,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

All interruptions are disorderly. I have said that on several occasions. I am asking Deputies to restrain themselves. If they wish to make a contribution to the debate they can do so later. It is quite simple.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick stated that there would be a sum of £2,500,000 spent on the reconstruction and rebuilding of Dublin Castle and that only 100 men would be employed. That is what will be said down the country but what will not be said is that this money will give work to 100 men for 20 years. If you add up the amount of wages per week accruing to 100 men you will find that almost 50 per cent. of the money spent will go in wages to the workmen about whom everybody on the opposite benches weeps such crocodile tears saying that if they cannot get work at home they have to emigrate.

We cannot have it both ways. We cannot have a reduction in the cost of living and a reduction in taxation at the same time. You cannot have a prohibition against the expenditure of money on capital schemes to give employment to people and object to the schemes because they are extravagant.

Comment on this

Nobody objects to expenditure on sensible schemes but to expenditure on wild cat schemes.

Comment on this

While we are going to debate between no scheme and a wild cat scheme 100 can go idle.

Comment on this
A Deputy

One hundred of the men you put out of work.

Comment on this

Am I supposed to have put these 100 out of work? It works out at nearly £1,000,000 in wages at present rates. I am glad to see that Deputies are getting out their pencils at least.

Comment on this

To see whether you are codding us.

Comment on this

I am not codding. In the Book of Estimates there is for the first time a figure of £5,000,000, National Development Fund.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

There is not.

Comment on this

If Deputies look at practically the last item in the last column they will see the figure £5,000,000. I have not the book in my hands but I know the figure is there. Deputy MacEoin asks where, but during the recent elections he was one of those who said that this was a myth, that this National Development Fund was just so much cod. I am delighted to be able to say that I have some experience in the Dublin Corporation of spending quite a lot of that money and putting to work quite a lot of the money out of the National Development Fund and the Road Works Fund.

Comment on this

That was out of the Special Employment Schemes Fund.

Comment on this

The National Development Fund gives a substantial grant in Dublin of 80 per cent. of the costs of capital schemes, not maintenance schemes. The Relief Fund used to give us 70 per cent. of the maintenance works for the benefit of the unemployed. We also get 80 per cent. from that and 100 per cent. from the Exchequer on any moneys spent up to £1,600,000 in five years on road work. We have bulked these three together and we expect to get from the State for a period of five years, mainly from the National Development Fund, approximately £800,000 a year. We will have employed constantly by the time we reach the month of November 1,400 men. We have nearly 500 men employed at the moment. As our schemes take shape and as they are submitted to the Board of Works and the Department of Local Government and receive approval, we will gradually get into a different kind of scheme. We are doing this because the figure is included in the Book of Estimates. Has Deputy MacEoin found it yet?

Comment on this

I do not think it is in it.

Comment on this

There is no such figure for the National Development Fund for the coming year. Note G at the bottom of the summary page is what you want.

Comment on this

We are spending the money anyway and if Deputy Sweetman is active in his local area he will prepare a few schemes to employ the seasonally unemployed people——

Comment on this

Look at Note G and see what it says. "It is going to be introduced" but it is not in it and we are the people who have not read the book. The Deputy is showing himself up as one of the people who have not read the Book of Estimates. No part of the £108,000,000 or of the £36,000,000 is for the National Development Fund.

Comment on this

There is a provision of £5,000,000 here.

Comment on this

For last year, nothing for this year.

Comment on this

Surely last year's £5,000,000 has not been spent yet.

Comment on this

You were caught out. You did not know and you might as well be honest about it.

Comment on this

Not at all. Is Deputy Sweetman prepared to say now that the Government did not set up a new fund called the National Development Fund to spend £5,000,000 a year for a certain number of years in assisting local authorities to meet unemployment situations——

Comment on this

Which the Government had created.

Comment on this

I want to be sure we are not going to be surcharged for this money we are spending in the Dublin Corporation. After all, I am chairman of the committee; by the end of this month we will have spent some £250,000. We on this side of the House are taking an absolutely clear view of the situation as it confronts us and we want people to know what is our policy. We want the people to know what is the policy of our opponents. They will have an opportunity of examining in relation to our Budget what our financial provisions mean to the country and to the individual. I believe it will be a good Budget. I am convinced it will be a good Budget because——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Of an election.

Comment on this

——of the terrible howl that is going to arise in the Opposition Benches because we have the neck to introduce our own Budget ourselves. I can quite see what Fine Gael would like. If we went out and they could come in by any chance, they would like to be able to say that this was their Budget but the public will know whose Budget it is. They will be able to judge and they will not be voting in the dark.

There is opposition to the procedure here, to the introduction of this Vote on Account, which is a continuance of the financial business winding up in the introduction of the Budget. It seems there is unanimous opposition by the three Parties opposite, Clann na Talmhan, Fine Gael and Labour. They have all spoken in the same voice, why I do not know. They can begin to prepare their election literature now. They know there is to be an election on the 18th May. That is zero hour. They know the last date for nominations and they can make their announcements now. Do not let it be said this time that they are going on different policies and that only if they combine between them they can get a sufficient majority in this House to form a Government and that they are then going to bargain, as they did the last time, on policy and on place. I want the public to be well and clearly educated on this occasion: vote for the Party with whose policy you agree, but vote for the Party that will stick to its policy and not mislead.

I only refer to that because my colleague in my own constituency, Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll, was attacked in this House to-day for having joined this Party. It was suggested that this was a breach of faith with those who elected him—that coming from a member of a Party which consistently feeds itself and exists solely on the number of people it can suck in, notwithstanding the election speeches or promises those people made or the independence they claimed before they came into this House.

Comment on this

For the information of Deputy Briscoe, I have looked up the Estimates for 1953-54. He will find that the £5,000,000 is not included in the £108,000,000 for this year.

Comment on this

I said there was £5,000,000 provided for that work.

Comment on this

You asked me if I could get it in this year's Estimates. You cannot get it in this year's.

Comment on this

It was voted in this financial year, not so very long ago.

Comment on this

You asked me to find it in this year's Estimates and it is not in it.

Comment on this

Try to make out it is a myth.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to give you the answer you are entitled to get.

Comment on this

I would like to compliment both the Minister for External Affairs and Deputy Briscoe for their capability in filibustering. Obviously, their sole purpose in rising to speak to-night was to waste time. Whatever the reason may be, the tactics of the Government Party are designed to delay and waste as much time as they can. If I am not mistaken, I see some rather long-winded speakers ready to take up their position in the queue. The two speakers to whom I referred were certainly able to waste a good deal of time but while they may be able at filibustering, I am afraid it gives us rather an indication of the type of speech we are going to have to endure in the course of the next couple of months here. Apparently, this House will be used, no doubt by all Parties, as a kind of crossroads election platform and I do not think there is much to commend the adopting of a course of that kind.

I agree entirely with the proposal put forward by Deputy Costello in regard to the immediate dissolution of the Dáil. I am sorry we have had no indication yet from the Government Benches as to whether they propose to make time available to-morrow for the discussion of the motion which has been set down by Deputy Costello calling for the immediate dissolution of the Dáil. If all the Opposition Parties combine in the request that time should be made available for a motion of that kind, it should be made available without any further ado.

The Taoiseach to-day referred to the public interest. He has a habit of referring to the public interest whenever he thinks the argument he uses can be squeezed into the claim that he is acting in the public interest. It seems obvious to me, and I think it will seem obvious to the country, that it is contrary to the public interest to delay the holding of an election any further. Obviously, the delay is bound to create more instability and more uncertainty. It is extremely difficult to expect that this House—or, indeed, the Government—will be able to carry on its work properly in this election atmosphere. I do not think I would be unfair to the Ministers and to the Parliamentary Secretaries if I suggest that the next two months will be spent by them not doing their work as public servants but preparing for an election campaign and that in effect the people will have to pay the Government— consisting of a dozen Ministers and I do not know how many Parliamentary Secretaries—for the next couple of months not to do the work of the Government but to run an election campaign for the Fianna Fáil Party.

I think that the Taoiseach should reconsider the attitude he has adopted and should realise that he will only help in creating more contempt for this House if he persists in delaying the election for two months and in allowing this House to be used as a crossroads election platform. Nor will it enhance the prestige of the Government—of any Government—and of Government institutions if in the next two months they are to be used practically as the election headquarters of a political Party. It will be a most undignified and indecent political tangling in the market-place which is not going to benefit the country and which probably will lead to a considerable amount of inefficiency in the administration of government within the next two months.

I am not going to delay the House any longer. I support entirely the proposals that have been made by Deputy Costello, supported by the Labour Party and Clann na Talmhan. I am not going to follow any of the arguments that have been put forward by the Minister for Finance—indeed, I should like to say I was glad to see him back here in the House and looking in good health—nor am I going to follow the arguments advanced by the Minister for External Affairs. Let me say this, however. In the years 1950 and 1951 we had fewer people unemployed than in any other year in the history of the country. In 1950 the average number of people unemployed was 53,000; in 1951 it was 51,000; in 1952 it had mounted to 60,000; in 1953 it was 70,000; and on the last Saturday in February of this year we had 14,000 more unemployed than on the last Saturday of February, 1951. In my view, the test as to the prosperity of a country, the test as to the efficiency of a Government, the test as to the soundness of an economic policy, is the unemployment figures. This Government has now succeeded in creating mass unemployment, a higher rate of unemployment than we have had for the last 12 years; and they should get out as the people of Louth, Cork and other constituencies have told them.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride professes to be extremely anxious for an immediate general election. Judging by his success in the last general election, I think he would be well advised to adopt a more cautious attitude.

Comment on this

Why not give him the opportunity this time, by having an election now?

Comment on this

From being the leader of a powerful Party of 8, 9 or 10, after a number of expulsions and a number of resignations, he came out of the election with nothing left but the head and tail of a Party which had been completely engulfed by Fine Gael, which he was supporting. Now he is endorsing the attitude taken by Deputy Costello. Deputy Costello has been described recently by one of the intelligentsia as an illiterate. would not be so harsh; I would say he is usually in this House absolutely incoherent. Never was he so incoherent as in his blustering here to-day. He professes to want to put the issues to the people and yet he knows the Government has taken a decision by which the issues will be put in the clearest and most definite way possible. The people will be given a chance to sum up the entire economic position, to weigh up the difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael and to make a decision carefully and in due course.

It is not intended to rush the election before the main financial business of the year is completed. It is intended that, the Book of Estimates having been presented to this House and the people having been given a chance to see the bill for expenditure for the coming year, they will also through the Budget be given an opportunity to see the financial provisions to meet this expenditure. That is wholly a sound and reasonable policy. It would hardly be right or proper to present to the people the bill for the costs of running the State for the coming year without giving a clear indication as to how these costs are to be met and the Government's estimate of revenue and their decision as to the means by which that revenue can be raised.

Deputy Costello made one statement which was coherent. He said it was wrong for a dying Government, as he put it, to bring in a Budget that would tie its successors. He probably thought that the memories of this House and of the people are short and that they do not remember that three years ago a dying Government, a Government on its deathbed with the death rattle gurgling in its throat, brought in a Budget which was designed to tie the hands of its successors. The last Budget of the Coalition Government was introduced on the very last day that that particular Dáil was in session. It has been acknowledged and proved beyond all question that it was a fake Budget. That statement was made not only here but outside the House. No one has been in a position to controvert it.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

As we all know, a number of commitments were definitely entered into, in regard to the increase of salaries for public servants and in regard to pensions, for which no provision was made in that particular Budget. It was introduced on the last day of the life of that Government.

Since 1951, the State finances and the trading position of the country have been put on a sound basis. It is ridiculous to suggest, as Fine Gael speakers have done, that you can increase expenditure year after year without increasing taxation. A remarkable feature of our accounts over the last ten years is the substantial yearly addition to Government expenditure. Fine Gael claimed that they could deal with that increased expenditure and reduce taxation. They did, I suppose, attempt to deal with it in that way. When they took office their first effort was to slash expenditure ruthlessly. The Fine Gael element in the Coalition Government, on that issue, came into conflict with Labour and some Independents. When they slashed road construction grants I found myself bound to vote against them. Some Labour Deputies also protested.

That was the original policy of Fine Gael but, on reconsideration, having regard to the fact that the Government of the United States of America, in their generosity, were offering us £40,000,000 they decided to abandon for the time being the Fine Gael policy of ruthlessly slashing grants in aid of employment. They decided to avail of Uncle Sam's generosity and to leave it to their successors to pay. As a result of that decision, their successors in 1980, 1981, 1982 and 1983 will be paying at the rate of 9,000,000 dollars per annum to the United States of America. The money is repayable in dollars. If dollars are not available, it will be necessary to send goods produced or manufactured in this country across the Atlantic to pay for the policy of Fine Gael of continuing to increase expenditure while cutting off sources of revenue. It was a good thing that that policy was brought to an end.

No Government has been able to put an end to the annual increase in expenditure but at least this Government has ensured that our accounts will be kept on a proper and solvent basis, that current expenditure will be met out of current revenue, that current revenue will be equal to current expenditure, that there will be no going cap in hand to some generous nation across the Atlantic or the Irish Sea or elsewhere for alms or loans which the people of the future will have to repay.

There has been an attempt made to evade discussion of this Vote on Account. There has been an attempt made to bluff and bluster. These are the usual tactics of Deputy Costello. Facts must be faced. If Fine Gael are sincere in their declaration that it is their policy to reduce taxation, they must tell us where and how they propose to reduce expenditure.

The chief increases in expenditure this year fall under a few main headings. There is increased provision for public works and buildings, for the building of schools, hospitals and other essential institutions. Is it the policy of Fine Gael to reduce that expenditure? There is a substantial increase in the agricultural grant for the relief of rates. Is it the policy of Fine Gael to cut that grant and to add the burden to the rates? There is a substantial increase in the provision for various schemes which the Department of Agriculture operate in order to get increased production. Will Fine Gael tell the farmers that they will cut the grants that are being provided for the reclamation and improvement of land, the distribution of limestone, the building of granaries and the provision of drying facilities?

There is a substantial increase in the Estimate for Public Health. Is it suggested by the Fine Gael Party that that should be cut? They cut the old age pensions on the last occasion that they had a clear majority in this House. Will they repeat that process? There is an increased provision of, I think, £2,000,000 as compared with the last year when the Coalition were in office, for old age pensions. Is that to be ruthlessly cut down?

These are questions which the Fine Gael Party are not prepared to answer. They have no answer to them. They are building a policy on a basis of dishonesty. They are seeking to convince the people that they will reduce taxation while giving the same benefits to our people. Nobody will accept that. Nobody will be deceived.

One of the rhetorical questions asked by Deputy J.A. Costello was what guarantee have the people that, if the Fianna Fáil Party are returned to power after the Budget for the present year has been passed, they may not increase taxation again. I should like to know of what value are the guarantees from Fine Gael. Fine Gael is a Party which for years gave their loyalty to the British Commonwealth of Nations but which woke up one morning and found themselves transformed into rabid Republicans. That would indicate that they are hardly the type of people who can be trusted to keep any guarantee that they are likely to give and, at the moment, they are prepared to give any guarantee or any promise whatever in order to secure power. They are prepared to secure power at the expense of those who aided and abetted and helped them to attain the position which they occupied for three and a half years. They evince no gratitude either to Deputy Norton or to Deputy MacBride. They used them simply as a ladder to enable them to climb into power. However, they have been out of office for almost the past three years.

I think it is no harm to reply now to one of Fine Gael's official muck-spreaders who said in this House to-day that it is the intention of the present Government to postpone the general election until three years have elapsed from the date they took office so that certain members of the Government will qualify for a pension. The Dáil will be dissolved and a new Government will be formed before the three years in question will have expired so there is no truth whatever in the despicable suggestion which was made by a Fine Gael Deputy in this House to-day. The present Government will act honourably and they will not allow themselves to be influenced by mere personal considerations of that kind. If the present Government are to go out of office, they will go out of office just very little short of completing three years in office. Therefore, those members of the Government who have not already qualified will not qualify for a pension now.

After nearly three years of office, it is of interest to note the results of sound and prudent government. Agricultural production has expanded. Our industrial output has expanded. It is no harm to contrast the sphere of social services as they exist to-day and as they existed in 1951. Some time ago, I happened to ask for certain statistics from the Central Statistics Office. I believe it would be well to give them to the House now with a view to showing that the condition of our main industries and of our people generally has improved as a result of wise and prudent government. According to this document, so far as essential items are concerned, the cost of living shows an increase of 14.7 per cent. in August, 1953, as compared with May, 1951. That means that there has been an increase of 14.7 per cent. in the cost of living since 1951. Against that I might point out that the percentage increase in the weekly earnings of workers in transportable goods industries was 13 between June, 1951, and June, 1953. When I got this reply, the September figures were not available. The weekly earnings of agricultural labourers increased by 18 per cent. as between July, 1951 and July, 1953. That shows that while the agricultural labourer suffered an increase of 14.7 per cent. in the cost of living he secured an increase of 18.6 per cent. in his wages. The average hourly rates in 23 industrial occupations were 22.4 per cent. higher at the beginning of 1953 than they were at the beginning of 1951. The average earnings per week in transport were 17.4 per cent. higher at the beginning of 1953 than at the beginning of 1951. Therefore, you will find that, on an average, wages generally have increased at least 17 per cent. over the 1951 figures while the cost of living has increased by 14.7 per cent.

If you leave aside those who are engaged in work which commands a weekly remuneration and turn to the farming community which forms much the largest section of our community, you will find that the agricultural price index, which corresponds with the income in respect of agriculture, increased by 14.1 per cent. over that two-year period. Therefore, even for the farming community, the cost-of-living increase was offset by the increase in agricultural prices. In the light of these facts, all the outcry we have heard about the terrible effects of the increased cost of living on the community sounds very hollow.

I might point out that the increase in the cost of living did not begin when the present Government took office. There was an increase of at least nine points in the cost of living in the last three years of the Coalition Government and that Government did nothing about it: I suppose they found that there was very little they could do about it. In fact, that may have been one of the many reasons that drove them to the country in 1951. If we survey the position even more broadly, we find that over the past three years—I have, of course, the figures for only two years here— the national income has increased. In 1950, the national income was estimated at £350,000,000. It went up to £373,000,000 in 1951, and, in 1952, it reached £404,000,000. We may assume that, as last year was one of the best years in agriculture and in industry, the increase in the national income for that year was greater still. Despite all the groaning and moaning that we hear from the Opposition Benches this nation is making progress. They talk about unemployment and emigration. We know that in one of the last years that the Coalition Government was in office 45,000 people left the country by way of the emigrant ship and there was nothing that the Labour Party could do about it, nothing that they could say about it at that time except to appoint a commission to inquire into the incidence of emigration. But nobody has ever been able to tell us what became of that commission of inquiry and it would seem that they too emigrated and left the country along with the 45,000 others who went at that time.

The points I have mentioned only touch on one aspect of this Government. If the cost of living increased substantially under the present Government it has been offset to a considerable extent by the increase in earning power of the farmer and the worker, but as far as the poorer section of the community are concerned it has been offset to an even greater extent over the last few years. We have an increase in children's allowances which are very important for a working man with a family or a small farmer with a family. The allowance has been increased by 1/6 a week and the second child is now included in the benefit of children's allowances. That, I think, means a very substantial additional sum coming into the homes of our poor people.

Old age pensions have been increased by 4/- a week over the last two or three years. I dwell upon that with some satisfaction because there were gentlemen of the Coalition Government, Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries, who went through my constituency like a mighty wind in 1951— and not a clean wind by any means——

Comment on this

They also went there in 1953.

Comment on this

Yes, and I think they repeated in 1953——

Comment on this

And again in 1954.

Comment on this

——the same falsehood that I had voted against an increase in the old age pensions. I am glad that Deputy Everett is here because I have challenged him to prove when, where and how I voted against an increase for the old age pensioners on many occasions and he has evaded it. I even offered to pay a substantial sum by way of contribution to the funds of the Labour Party if he would prove that I ever voted against an increase in the old age pensions.

Comment on this

I will be here when you are forgotten.

Comment on this

Deputy Everett knows that a falsehood at the crossroads is very effective and when you are challenged to prove it a good run away is better than a bad fight.

Comment on this

You are on the run now.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Everett's motto. I want to say that, so far from voting against the old age pensions, I was associated with the demand which was made on the Coalition Government in 1951 that they should immediately introduce legislative proposals which could be passed through the House in three hours, making provision for that increase and bringing old age pensions up to £1 a week. That request was turned down and the old age pensions were left at 17/6 a week until the present Government, with my support and the support of some other Deputies of this House, took office. That increase was then granted and was further supplemented by an increase of 1/6, which gives the old age pensioner 4/- a week more than he had under the Coalition.

Comment on this

The 1/6 would not buy a quarter-pound of butter for them.

Comment on this

I suppose there are people who will try to disparage and despise those concessions, but I live among the working people in a rural area and I know these benefits are appreciated—benefits by way of increased children's allowances and old age pensions and benefits that have been conferred by the present Government upon those who are sick and infirm. Those things are very much appreciated by the ordinary working people.

There is no reason why Deputies who were members of the inter-Party Government should get annoyed when I refer to those things, because they are facts that cannot be denied.

I have asked what is the attitude of the Opposition towards the proposals for expenditure under the broad heading of agriculture. Are they going to cut down the ground limestone subsidy to what it was when the inter-Party Government went out of office? At that time about £60,000 was provided by way of subsidy for ground limestone. To-day, it is ten times that amount. We have an Estimate for £600,000 in the present Book of Estimates. There is a member of the Fine Gael Party who has declared again and again that only an egg-cupful of ground limestone was being produced when the Coalition Government took office and that it was increased to 60,000 or 70,000 tons then, but it has been proved by a question in this House that there were two limestone plants actively engaged turning out limestone in 1947 and that there were a number of other plants being erected at that time. I suppose Deputy Dillon's hens lay bigger eggs than anybody else's and that therefore his eggcup would be of a substantial size, but it would have to be very substantial to hold the thousands of tons of ground limestone that were being ground out at that time. The amount being produced then has been increased tenfold and it is still on the increase.

Land reclamation about which so much has been heard, said and talked is to-day being carried out on a scale six times greater than it was in 1951. For every £1 that was spent on land reclamation at that time, nearly £6 is being spent to-day and that policy will continue. So, too, will the policy of wheat and beet and peat. Production of peat has been very greatly expanded over the last three years. Peat has now taken its place as a national product which can compete on level terms with any imported fuel. That industry was first developed by Fianna Fáil in the face of the fiercest opposition and ridicule by the Fine Gael Party. It is now on a sound basis and can compete on equal terms with imported fuel, particularly for industrial purposes. Peat is now an established product, and its production will go on expanding, giving increased employment. If the Fine Gael Party get into power they will, no doubt, seek to close that down as they did before. They will seek to make the generation of electricity dependent on imported fuel. They did that to a certain extent, as far as lay in their power, while they were in office, and they will probably do it again. The guaranteed price for the growing of wheat will be withdrawn if Fine Gael gets into power, and the men who are employed on the land, ploughing it, will be dismissed. I do not know whether the Labour Party will support that or not. I suppose, as they did in the past, they will be as quiet as mice.

Comment on this

We will see if the people will support you.

Comment on this

They will be as quiet as they were to-day when there was applause from the Fine Gael Benches. If the guaranteed price for wheat is withdrawn, that will mean the dismissal of men. If it is withdrawn, as Deputy Dillon has forecast, then a number of agricultural workers will lose their employment and the smaller mills throughout the country will be closed down. The men now employed in them will then have to seek the dole or the emigrant ship. If Fine Gael get into power with the support of some of the smaller groups, they will immediately carry out the policy that was also forecast by their leading spokesman—that is the policy of closing down on the manufacture of sugar in this country. Their leading spokesman, and their potential leader, I must say, has stated again and again in this House that the Irish people would save money and be better off if we blew up the four sugar factories with dynamite. I suppose, if Fine Gael get back into power, there will be four loud bangs which will be enjoyed by Deputy Dillon, but will they be enjoyed by the Labour Party?

Comment on this

Mind your own business.

Comment on this

I am minding my own business, and in minding my own business, I am also minding the country's business.

Comment on this

You represent no one.

Comment on this

We will see where some of you will be.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cogan should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

I am making my speech in my own way, and I do not want to be eliminated in the same way as Deputy Everett eliminated Senator McCrea.

Comment on this