Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance.
Contributions 374–560 of 560. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I have heard a good many people on the Fine Gael Benches protest, prior to elections, that I would never again be seen in this House. Well, I have been seen and heard in the House and as long as I am elected by the people of Wicklow I will speak in the House and do my best for them. I know that will not please Deputy Everett. That is his own business and I am not worried about his feelings. It is important that the people should know what is the attitude of Fine Gael towards the growing of wheat and the growing of beet. I have told the House that the growing of wheat and beet has been attacked in the past from the Fine Gael Benches in the last 20 years. That being so, I am asking will they continue, if power is put in their hands, to pursue that policy so as to vindicate their past anti-wheat and anti-beet record over the last 20 years? Fine Gael has attacked industrial development in every shape and form in my own constituency of Wicklow where a number of industries have been established in the teeth of the most vicious and rigorous opposition from Fine Gael. We have had the people engaged in these industrial processes described as racketeers and profiteers, and the workers in these industries described as parasites.
Comment on this
I invite Deputy Norton down to support his old friend, Deputy Everett, in Arklow, to demand that the people who are engaged in the pottery factory in Arklow be imprisoned. I doubt if he will be sufficiently logical or sufficiently honest to take that particular course. (Interruptions). It is significant that many of my old friends in Fine Gael and some of my friends on the Labour Benches feel a little bit disturbed at the argument I am making. They feel perhaps that it is not going to be a very attractive policy to put before the people—to follow the line that Fine Gael has followed during the past 20 years, and followed, even while they were in power in coalition with Labour, and in spite, I am sure, of some opposition from Labour. That is the policy of preventing tillage, preventing intensive production on the land, promoting permanent pasture and promoting the closing down of Irish industries. That is the policy which they have consistently advocated, and it is the policy which they have consistently operated in so far as it was in their power to operate that policy.
I hope that some speaker from that side of the House will have the courage to repudiate that policy and to stand up and say that, in the main, on broad fundamentals the policy of the present Government is the best one: that is a policy of intensive development of agriculture, a policy of intensive development of our industrial and mineral resources. The leader of the Fine Gael Party in County Wicklow wrote to the then Minister for Industry and Commerce and asked him to close down the mining works in Wicklow because the workers were earning too much money and suggesting that they were not working hard enough. That is the attitude of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
I suppose there are not enough being dismissed for Deputy Everett. That is the policy of Deputy Everett. He would like to see them all dismissed as was suggested at that time.
Comment on this
I agree that the people desire to hear the facts as I am putting them before them and not the interruptions that we hear from the Opposition. As I have pointed out, in our programme which is embodied in the Book of Estimates that has been laid before the House, there is provision for further development. There is provision for the maintenance of those social services so essential for our people. The Fine Gael Party says it will cut expenditure or, at least, reduce taxation. Logically, taxation cannot be reduced without cutting expenditure and we may take it, therefore, that that Party will repeat the policy they put into operation before when they reduced the old age pensions by 1/- in order to cut expenditure.
Even my friend, Deputy Everett, must agree with me that there has been considerable development in County Wicklow. I think the development there is typical of other counties, particularly in relation to afforestation. There are more men employed in forestry now than at any time in the past. Road works have been extended. Road construction is being carried out on a scale that has never been surpassed hitherto. Land reclamation is going ahead all over the country. In all these works of national development there is progress. There is even greater progress in the fundamental industry, agriculture. Our friends on the Opposition Benches need only to go to the country to-day to see the thousands of acres of extra land put under the plough. In the last year the Coalition Government was in office tillage went down by over 80,000 acres. In the three years of Coalition Government tillage went down by 500,000 acres. They say their policy is: "One more cow; one more sow; one more acre under the plough", but the number of cows during their régime went down by 80,000; the number of sows went down. In every field of agriculture there was a reduction.
Comment on this
The fact cannot be disputed the number of pigs generally was reduced in the last year Fine Gael was in office. There was a downward trend in agriculture. To-day there is an upward trend in agriculture. Over the whole field of agricultural and industrial endeavour there is increased production. I hope that those who have ploughed their lands and sown their wheat, barley, oats and sugar beet will not be discouraged by the Opposition speeches. I hope they will not be intimidated by the loudvoiced brawling of Deputy Dillon, who once said that he would not be got dead in a field of wheat and would not insult his land by growing wheat.
I would like to tell the farmers to go ahead and grow these crops and not to fear the worst that Fine Gael can do. It is true that the only real menace to increased agricultural production, to the growing of wheat and the growing of beet is the Fine Gael Party. If that Party was to get its way these two branches of our agricultural industry would be brought to a standstill. In the industrial field it is noticeable that there has been a very substantial and significant advance. One small instance comes to mind. I happened to be passing through the town of Baltinglass last week and I called to a newly-opened factory there.
Comment on this
This factory has been opened by enterprising local people for the production of meat products. Five or six are employed at the moment but the aim is to extend and give increased employment later on. The significant thing is that that factory has been established in the very premises in which the Coalition Government tried to establish a subpost office.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil, in seeking to provide employment for our people, seeks to provide new employment of a productive nature. The Coalition Government sought to take employment from one and give it to another.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not be very long until he gets the present Government out also. The Deputy will not be any help in keeping them in.
Comment on this
Instead of a policy of taking employment from one person and giving it to another, we have now in Baltinglass a new industry giving employment to six or seven young people. That is the kind of thing we want. If that was repeated in every little village there would be no unemployment problem and there would be no emigration problem. The country is in a sounder position economically and socially to-day than it was three years ago.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I am waiting, Sir, for the Deputy to sit down and obey the rules of the House. I will put the point of order as soon as the Deputy resumes his seat. It is the custom for a Deputy to resume his seat but perhaps I am expecting too much from Deputy Cogan in the way of manners and courtesy. I want to ask the Chair if there is any limit to repetition in debate. Is there any limit to the number of times a Deputy may repeat the same thing?
Comment on this
If the Minister wants it that way he can have it that way. We are not in nearly as much of a hurry as the Minister is. I want to know is there any limit to repetition. I want the ruling of the Chair on that.
Comment on this
I know it should be but, listening here for the last three-quarters of an hour, I wondered if it could be.
Comment on this
I am going to do something else: I am going to repeat a statement made by the Minister for Finance on the Vote on Account in 1951.
Comment on this
I have said the country is in a sounder position. One of the proofs of that is that we have not to-day ever-increasing imports, such as we had in the past, threatening to destroy our productive effort and engulf the nation in bankruptcy. I will quote now from the Official Report, column 789 of 28th February, 1951. The Minister for Finance at that time was Deputy McGilligan. He did not then paint the picture that he and his colleagues try to paint now of the position that existed at that time. Dealing with the serious situation prevailing at that time, in February, 1951, he said:——
"The disturbing feature, of course, is the deficit in the balance of payments, particularly when that is marked by the great increase in consumption here, especially when that great increase in consumption is attached to the non-essential goods. The continuance of such a situation for any period would be highly dangerous. It would jeopardise the policy, popularly, I think, approved of, to repatriate sterling assets. But repatriation of sterling assets is only of use if they are used solely or mainly for investment and development. If the development policy must be continued, that policy can only be continued without danger if the savings of the community are increased. They can be increased if people refrain from expenditure on non-essential goods. There is a tremendous margin over what was spent in 1938. There is plenty of slack to be gathered in. That is the chief lesson to be learned from the economic trend of 1950."
So that we had not the paradise of prosperity which some people tried to suggest we had at that time. We had a very dangerous and menacing situation, and we had Deputy McGilligan claiming that the people were consuming too much. It was stated that people were consuming too much. I say that the person who made that statement was Deputy McGilligan. Then Deputy Blowick comes in here to-day and claims that he is being starved and that we are all being starved. But it was Deputy McGilligan who first announced in the clearest possible terms in this House that the people of Ireland were consuming too much and that steps would have to be taken to prevent them so doing.
One of the reasons why the Leader of the Opposition bluffed in this House to-day was because he had no answer to the case that has been made for the Book of Estimates which has been presented to the House. He had no case to make against the policy outlined in this Book of Estimates. He had no case to make against the policy of continued progress in the field of agriculture, in the field of employment and in the field of full production. He had no case to make against the increased and better social services provided for the poorer section of the community. Therefore, Deputy Morrissey could only threaten and seek to bully in an arrogant way because there was no case to offer to the House.
Comment on this
I must at the outset apologise to the Deputy who has just sat down for interrupting him. There are two occasions during a Deputy's occupancy of his seat in this House that he is not interrupted, during his first speech and during his last one. I apologise to the Deputy for interrupting him during his last speech. I am glad the Deputy spoke. I am sorry that I was not able to refrain from interrupting him because he might have gone on to speak for a much longer time than he did. I do not think, however, that any better case could be made for the dissolution of this Dáil than Deputy Cogan's. The Deputy has the habit occasionally, like the Taoiseach, of talking about decency in public life, about truth in debate, about refraining from bitterness. The Deputy could not exist except on these qualities. The Deputy is, I know, not overburdened with intelligence, but he is not so stupid as, through stupidity, to twist and distort figures and statistics in the way he did here. It was done through sheer dishonesty, through a desire to vent his personal bitterness and hatred of Deputy Dillon, which is the only reason he is sitting on the Fianna Fáil side of the House.
The Deputy had the effrontery to take statistics and so misuse them as to tell us that in fact the position of the workers in this country was better to-day than it was three years ago; that not only had they been recompensed for the full increase in the cost of living, but over-recompensed; that they were actually getting more real money to-day than they were three years ago. Then the Deputy talks about other people moaning and groaning. He neither moans nor groans, but whines in that whining way of his. I do not know whether he is now going over to Deputy Allen to get a few things he should say to me but does not know himself or whether Deputy Allen is giving him a bit of good advice. (Interruption). Deputy Allen should keep out of this.
Comment on this
The Minister did not reprove the last Deputy who spoke. I am not going to remind the Minister either of his oft-expressed opinion of Deputy Cogan or of Deputy Cogan's oft-expressed opinion of the Minister. I have neither the desire nor the vocabulary to describe Deputy Cogan as fittingly and precisely as the Minister has described him on occasions.
Comment on this
With respect, I was here for one hour and 15 minutes listening to the Deputy blackguarding my Party and blackguarding my colleagues. I appealed over and over again to the Chair to bring the Deputy to the Vote on Account, but he did not come to it, nor was he brought to it. I was told by the Chair that Deputy Cogan was replying to certain things said in this House and he had a right to do so. I consider that if Deputy Cogan has a right to make such statements, I should be allowed to counter them. The Deputy, as I was proceeding to say, told us whiningly that he lived amongst the workers, that he understood the poor and their circumstances. His knowledge of them was so intimate, he was able to tell us that, far from being in any way hurt by the Minister's Budget of 1952 and the Minister's Budget of 1953, in fact they had made a profit out of it. He went further, and out of his boasted knowledge of the poor and of the conditions of the poor he said that the farmers had been recompensed to meet the increase in the cost of living, the workers had been recompensed to meet the increase in the cost of living, and that nobody has benefited to the same extent as the very poor, the old age pensioners and the blind. Is that a stupid statement or a downright dishonest statement? The Deputy suggested that there has only been a 14.7 increase in the cost of living. Does the Deputy suggest that there has been only a 14.7 increase in the cost of the essentials which the old-age pensioners, the blind pensioners, the widow and the working man have to pay?
Comment on this
The Deputy did not quote statistics. He misused, misrepresented and distorted them, but I will quote figures which will be more easily understood.
Comment on this
That is the sort of thing that makes one wonder whether we should not reconsider paying for the production of statistics in this country when they can be misused and distorted. The Deputy's 14.7 per cent. increase! Would the Deputy tell us what is the percentage increase in the price of a loaf of bread from 6½d. to 9½d.? Would the Deputy tell me what is the percentage increase raising 1 lb. of sugar from 4d. to 7d.? Would the Deputy tell me what is the increase following the Budget of 1952 in the price of a stone of flour? Is it 14.7 or 50 per cent.? Will the Deputy tell me what is the increase in the lb. of butter from 2/10 to 4/2? Perhaps the Deputy would work out for us the percentage increase in the price of tea between 2/8 and 5/6. That sort of clap-trap that the Deputy tries out here would not even go down at the crossroads for him, much less waste the time of the House insulting the intelligence of the people.
Comment on this
The people there would understand statistics better than Deputy Cogan. Deputy Cogan's swan song was worthy of him, worthy of the contribution he has made to this Assembly during his time here. The Deputy talks about agriculture and tries to contrast what was done by the present Government and by the inter-Party Government. He knows that the inter-Party Government, in so far as he is a farmer, put more money into his pocket than Fianna Fáil ever put into it, but he has not the manliness to admit that. The Deputy talked about there being a decrease in sows. As against when? A decrease in cows— as against when? The Deputy boasts about the increase in agricultural exports. Why? Who laid the basis for it? Who laid down the policy for it? I suppose the cattle which the Deputy sold last year and which he sold this year and the cattle which he sold in 1952 were all born under Fianna Fáil. Mark you, if the Deputy has any calves either to rear or to sell they were not exchangeable on the market for a 10/-note, or if they were good ones, not exchangeable even for a £10 note.
Comment on this
The inter-Party Government wanted to give 1/- a gallon for milk.
Comment on this
A Deputy from West Limerick should be the last to open his mouth about calves, but I do not want to say anything about the Deputy because he is a decent man.
Comment on this
The Deputy is a decent man and I have not a word in the world to say about him. He has his political convictions and has always had them and has stood by them, and for that, even though I cannot agree with the Deputy, I can respect him. The Deputy told us about health services. He told us—we heard it earlier, of course, from the Government, from what I call the real Fianna Fáil people—that we were the best-fed nation, according to some statistics.
Comment on this
According to the International Labour Office—and the Deputy used to be a Labour man.
Comment on this
I have a fair knowledge of the conditions of the working man even yet, and perhaps I am a lot closer to him than some people who claim from every public platform that they are the worker's real friend. We are told we are the best-fed people, and it is boasted of here and boasted about outside. We are told we are spending millions more on improved public health services. But in the same breath the Minister for the best-fed people on the earth, the Minister for Health, tells us that claims for sickness benefit are up by 50 per cent. Let him reconcile that—that claims for sickness benefit are up by 50 per cent.; 2,000,000 sickness certificates.
I will give the Minister one little bit of what I hope will be joy to his heart —the Deputy who has just sat down will not be much longer an embarrassment either to himself or to his colleagues. Mark you, I have a feeling that if the Minister and his colleagues who sit behind him had to advert to other considerations they might not be so much against the motion to dissolve the Dáil forthwith as they are at the moment. The Deputy wants to say something. Does he want to say it himself or through the mouth of Deputy Cogan? The Deputy is another decent man.
Comment on this
The Deputy, with that relevance to which he adhered so strongly all through his speech, referred here to a private person outside who cannot defend himself in this House, named him in such a way that he could be identified, and then told a lie about him, a lie I had already successfully nailed where it was uttered in Avoca about the letter which the Minister who used it, or misused it, said was a personal letter addressed to me. The Minister was not above talking of what he himself described as a personal letter.
Comment on this
The man whom under the cover of this House the Deputy has tried to blackguard was publicly vindicated in Co. Wicklow and in Avoca, and very well Deputy Cogan knows that. Deputy Cogan talked about some of us going down to Wicklow in 1951. Might I remind him that we also went down in 1953 and some of us were so really interested that we were even present at the count; and one of the most vivid pictures in my mind of that count was that when the papers of a certain candidate whose position was of vital interest to Deputy Cogan had been dealt with Deputy Cogan did not walk out but slunk out of where the votes were being counted. I would not advise the Deputy, unless his heart is in a remarkably strong condition, certainly much better than mine, to go to the count at the next election.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I call attention to the fact that Deputy Morrissey seems to be able to raise a laugh in the galleries. Is it in order that the people in the gallery should laugh at what Deputy Morrissey says?
Comment on this
If there is any disorder in the gallery, Deputies should know that they are responsible for the conduct of their visitors. I am not cognisant of any disorder at the moment.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not very big but I would not exactly describe him as a little nonsense.
Comment on this
"A little nonsense now and then is relished by the wisest men." I do not see why people should not laugh.
Comment on this
Honest to goodness, I can never understand these Fianna Fáil people no matter how long I am listening to them or looking at them. They are the grandest people to give out or to laugh at any channel from which the "giving-out" is done so long as they are not the victims. They will not utter any comment other than one of approval but immediately somebody hits them back, instead of turning the other cheek, they begin to squeal.
Comment on this
The Deputy, I hope, will not get many interruptions, in the short time that is left to him.
Comment on this
I do not want this debate to degenerate into a series of interruptions. Deputy Morrissey is in possession and should be allowed to speak.
Comment on this
I started off by saying that I owed an apology to Deputy Cogan. Perhaps I owe a greater apology to the House for having taken up so much of its time with a Deputy who is almost an ex-Deputy. We had a rather interesting speech to-day from Deputy Briscoe. If I were to accept that Deputy Briscoe believed what he was saying, then I would have far less respect for the Deputy's capacity as a businessman than I have. I am perfectly satisfied, too, that he has the contacts, which he said he had, with various types of business people in the city but I do not believe that he got from them the reaction which he said he got from them here to-day. I think Deputy Costello did not in the slightest exaggerate when he said that the position such as was announced by the Taoiseach in his second statement could not be helpful to business. It is bound to create uneasiness, dislocation and an upset in business, not merely in the City of Dublin, but throughout the country.
Deputy Briscoe expects that we shall have a very good Budget in two months' time. I suppose from his point of view that is a reasonable expectation. Let us assume that he is right. Are we going to have a reduction in the price of tea, in the price of sugar, in the price of flour, or in the price of bread? Are we going to have a reduction in the price of tobacco and cigarettes?
Comment on this
Will there be a reduction in the price of milk?
Comment on this
I realise the Deputy does not want liberty to interrupt me. If we are going to have that, and people in business are inclined to hope that we shall get a good Budget, is there any businessman who is going to stock up at present prices? Is he going to stock up with flour shortly before the Budget, at its present price? Is there any shopkeeper who is going to take out of bond and pay duty on spirits at the present rates, if we are going to have a good Budget? Are we going to have a reduction in the rates of interest? Is there going to be a reduction in the rates of interest on loans? Is there going to be a reduction in the price of beer? Surely these are questions that any businessman may legitimately ask himself.
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out that there was a 25 per cent. duty on certain property sales.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Deputy is trying to be personal or not. What is the explanation of the Deputy's interruption?
Comment on this
One of the things which we might reasonably expect to see introduced is a reduction in the duty on property sales.
Comment on this
I have a much more important one to talk about and I am glad the Deputy has reminded me of it. The Minister knows, if the Deputy does not know, that the 25 per cent. duty on certain property sales does not matter very much to the revenue, but what did matter very much, and the 25 per cent. duty was brought in to camouflage it, was that the stamp duty was increased from 1 per cent. to 5 per cent. in the case of sales to our own nationals.
Comment on this
Who brought in a clause nearly as big as the Book of Estimates to ensure that the 5 per cent. would be collected and would not be evaded except Deputy McGilligan?
Comment on this
When we went into office we found that the Minister and his colleagues had increased the stamp duty on our own people from 1 per cent. to 5 per cent. It was on that the fat was obtained from the treasury. When we left office it was not 5 per cent.; it was 2½ per cent., and if we had remained for another 12 months it would be back to 1 per cent. The Deputy can talk to his colleague about that.
Comment on this
He would have to throw the net very wide in this Budget if he is to succeed in that. Of course, the Minister should be the last person in this House to be drawn into that particular argument because we do not forget, either, that in order to restrain people from becoming owners of their own homes, he was the Minister who brought in the provision that tax was to be paid on five-fourths of the valuation. It was not enough that you had to pay tax on the full valuation; you had to pay on your full valuation plus 25 per cent. as well.
Comment on this
I knew that before ever I became an auctioneer. I am not a bit ashamed of my occupation, and I hope the Deputy is not ashamed of his.
Comment on this
I should like to get from the Deputy at some time a rather fuller explanation of that particular crack. I may say, in passing, that, in my opinion, it was not worthy of the Deputy. One would refrain from even attempting to follow the line which was pursued by the Minister for External Affairs in this debate. I notice that no member who spoke from the other side made any reference whatever to what Deputy Costello said, and we have not got so far any opinion from the Government regarding his suggestion that, knowing as we do that the money must be provided to keep the public services going, no matter which Government is in office, we are prepared, without delay, to give to the Government the Central Fund Bill and the Vote on Account, provided we can get down to grips with this question of the dissolution of the Dáil.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious you do not want to discuss the Estimates? All this is a smoke-screen because you are afraid to face up to your responsibilities.
Comment on this
It is easy to say these things when running away out of the House. Either the skin of the Minister for Finance is getting a little more tender or my tongue a little more sharp. He did not formerly run away like that. All the ballyhoo we have listened to to-day, all the ballyhoo we had from the Minister for External Affairs, all the long and laboured speech we had from Deputy Briscoe and all the whining we had from Deputy Cogan was all devoted to one purpose to try to get the minds of the House and the country off this fact, that, on last Thursday, the Taoiseach got the biggest shock he ever got in his political life, and that, side by side with the announcement of the final result of the Cork election, came the announcement from the Taoiseach that, following on the two by-elections, a general election, in his opinion should be held and would he held as soon as the financial measures necessary for the carrying on of the public services had been completed.
Now we are told that we misunderstood the Taoiseach. It is not to-day or yesterday that we heard him for the first time or read him for the first time. It is not to-day or yesterday that we knew that he was apparently incapable of saying in a straightforward manner anything about anything. We made full allowance for that fact, but it was quite clear, and is still, beyond any shadow of a doubt, to any person who has any knowledge whatever of parliamentary procedure that that statement on Thursday night could mean one thing and one thing only—that, when the Vote on Account was passed by the House, the Taoiseach would ask the President to dissolve the Parliament. There is no question about that. As surely as I am standing here, that is what the Taoiseach meant. He had no reservation whatever about it and he practically admitted it here to-day at Question Time.
We were told that he consulted with his Cabinet colleagues, that he consulted the Tánaiste in London and that he had given full and careful consideration to it, but he was able to do all that in an amazingly short time, because, within five minutes of the final result being telephoned or telegraphed from Cork, the Taoiseach's statement was on the air and if we had any doubt in our minds as to what he meant, he let it out to-day himself here and it will be on the records of this House.
What happened in the meantime? Did the new leader when he came back from London change the record? Did the new leader of the Party tell the Taoiseach that he was losing some of that political astuteness of his, that he had taken a hasty decision? Did the new leader lead a revolt of the Party against the Taoiseach's decision? Did the Party feel that the Taoiseach was making the same mistake as that which they accused him of making early in 1948 about a general election? What pressure was brought on the Taoiseach to get him to issue last night over the radio a statement completely and absolutely opposed to the statement he made last Thursday night? Those are the questions to which the House and the country are entitled to get an answer.
If the Taoiseach was satisfied, as he said himself he was, that he had lost the confidence of the people of the country to such an extent that he believed a general election should take place, if the present Government is a discredited Government, as it is, in the eyes of the people, what right have they to prolong their own lives for a period of ten weeks? Did any Government in this or any other country ever get in such clear and unambiguous language a notice to quit as the present Government got last Thursday? To use an expression which is more familiar to Deputy Vivion de Valera than to me, the Taoiseach wants a stay of execution for ten weeks; I hope the House will not give it to him. Certainly he has to make a much better case for it—he would have to make that in the District Court much less here—than he has made.
The Goverment did get a notice to quit and are now looking for a stay of execution for ten weeks. What they are really looking for is an opportunity to bring in here, to concoct or to devise by some or any means, a Budget which they believe, or hope, will fool the people. It is beyond the wit even of Fianna Fáil to devise a Budget that will deceive the people in their present mood. It cannot be done. The people are not going to be deceived any longer, and all the tripe we get from Deputies like Deputy Cogan is not going to alter the position. This Government is a discredited Government—completely discredited.
Deputy Cogan talks about the programme of this Government and about the honesty of this Government, and he had the audacity to assert here within the past hour and a half that the Fianna Fáil Government had kept every promise they made. Deputy Cogan himself, Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll, Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Cowan were induced to give, in the first instance, their support to Fianna Fáil on the Minister's and the Taoiseach's emphatic promise, not merely verbal but set down in writing in their famous 17 points, that the food subsidies would not be reduced or interfered with. That was a clear and most emphatic promise. That was the promise made which got certain Deputies, so-called Independent Deputies, to give their support before they were finally admitted to membership—that admission to membership being, in my opinion, another piece of evidence of the straits to which the Fianna Fáil Party were reduced.
Those Deputies, this House and the country were given the unqualified promise that the subsidies would not be touched. The Minister for Finance, when it was asserted that if they got back into office they would reimpose the duty on beer, tobacco and spirits, said he would not and his colleagues reiterated that statement inside and outside the House. When he got back into office, not merely did he reimpose the duties on beer, spirits and tobacco but he said, in the course of that speech, that the additional duties which were imposed by his colleague, Deputy Aiken, as Minister for Finance, in 1947 should never have been removed by us. That was said—it is on the record—by the Minister who said it was not his intention to reimpose those duties. That was said by his colleagues.
What is the use in talking when we had to listen to Deputy Cogan speaking about a 14 per cent. increase in the cost of living? What are the essential foodstuffs for the majority of our people? What are the essential things for the poorest sections of the people of this country? What figures most in their daily lives but bread, tea, sugar and butter? Does the 14.7 per cent. cover these? What increases have taken place in a wide range of articles that do not figure in the cost of living index figure at all?
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs consoles himself and tries to console the people down the country by telling us he discovered in his world tour that there are three unnamed countries in the world where the cost of living has risen more than it has risen in this country. The Minister, his colleagues and his Party have been beaten fairly and squarely. They were not beaten by a doughty opponent. They were not beaten by a Party with what they would admit was an intelligent policy but they were beaten by a Party which, according to Fianna Fáil, was a dead Party or a dying Party. They were beaten fairly and squarely on first preference votes.
I venture to say that after Louth and Cork we will not hear as many whispers or even as many audible remarks about the desirability of changing from the proportional representation system back to the old system of the single vote. It might not suit Fianna Fáil so well now as they thought it would suit them on one occasion. They may make all the excuses they like. They may twist and distort everything. They may talk at the crossroads about the debts left to them by the inter-Party Government. They may talk in the Dáil or write in the leading article of the Irish Press about commitments—they were driven away from the word debts—but it does not alter the fact that they have lost the confidence of the people of this country in a most remarkable and spectacular way.
The results of Cork and Louth, not to speak of the other places, are the angry reactions of the people against the infliction on them of a harshness and of hardships to a degree they are satisfied it was not necessary to inflict on them and to a degree they should not have to suffer. I know there are certain members of the Government who will try to be rather supercilious about the people—perhaps, they do not express the feeling although the Taoiseach once said that the people were never right unless they were in step with Fianna Fáil—and who pay a lot of lip service to the rights of democracy and the people who choose the Government and this House but who want to deny the people the right to change the House at the time the people themselves want to change it.
There is only one reason why the Taoiseach was forced. I am perfectly satisfied he was forced whether entirely or partly by the representations of his own colleagues and his own Party. Deputies will remember the leading article in the Irish Times on Saturday last, where the editor patted the Taoiseach on the back of the head and, at the same time, gave him the boot. He had served his purpose and he should now get out. That was worthy of the Irish Times. I will leave it at that. I may have my own view about the Taoiseach's politics, but even that got a bit under my skin. That is the position, and all the speeches Deputies opposite made here and outside will not improve the position one bit.
Notwithstanding the results in Cork, Louth, North-West Dublin, East Cork, Limerick and so forth, I do not believe the Fianna Fáil Party fully realise yet how angry the people are with them. I do not think they have any idea of the present mood of the people. I do not think they realise for one moment the landslide or, perhaps, they do. Perhaps, that is the reason why the Taoiseach for the first time in his life was forced off his own course. Perhaps, he was not perfectly conscious of it. I am satisfied that if he dissolved the Dáil now and went to the country he would not stand a dog's chance. You would have the greatest landslide in a general election since this State was founded.
Perhaps, it is the gambler's throw in the hope that something may turn up, either internally or internationally, that might help the Taoiseach to stall the election off for another ten weeks. Perhaps, it is also possible that, if the Minister is not able to bring in a Budget with a bit of gilt on it, the Taoiseach may have another interpretation of what he said, as was adverted to to-day, in regard to the financial arrangements having to be completed. He has not yet, of course, advised the President, but when the time comes he may tell the House and the country that he did not mean at the end of the Budget, that, when he fixed the 18th May, he overlooked the fact that in order to complete the financial arrangements he would have to pass all five stages of the Finance Bill and the Appropriation Bill and that that could not be done until the middle of August and that we might have a long and detailed discussion on the Estimates. Am I not entitled to say that in view of what happened since Thursday night? Would there be anything more far-fetched in the Taoiseach taking that line if he thought it desirable in the interests of his Party still further to postpone the holding of a general election? As Deputy Costello pointed out to-day, strictly speaking the financial arrangements, interpreted as the Taoiseach interpreted them in his statement of last night and not last Thursday, are not completed until the Finance Bill and the Appropriation Bill are passed. Why do you not admit you have had it? Why do you not admit that you did not quite succeed in fooling all the people all the time? You did it for 20 years and that was not a bad try. I do not think there is any other Party in Europe that succeeded for so long. But you are found out.
Like myself, the astute Leader of the Party is not getting younger although I would still back him against some of the boys who have been advising him between Thursday and last night. He has forgotten more about politics and political manoeuvring than some of them will ever learn. They may be a little more slick or appear to be, but it is not merely a difference in technique. No, there is more than technique at stake there. But may I presume to offer you this little bit of advice? Do not think that the people in their present mood—they have reason to be bitter and you are not going to improve the mood by the way in which you have been carrying on for the last couple of days—are going to suffer lightly any tricking about with their fundamental rights, particularly their fundamental right to elect the personnel of this House and the Government of the country.
The Taoiseach has always been free to talk about all power being derived from the people. He has been very free to talk about the people being allpowerful—some of his colleagues following that line have been even more eloquent—but he has not always been as ready to accept that will when it has been demonstrated and when there has been a clear indication there. Never was a clearer indication given than has been given over the last two years.
If there are two men responsible above all others for a lot of the misery and hardship, emigration and unemployment which has occurred, for the increase in interest rates, for restriction in credit, those are the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. We do not forget the autumn of 1952 when in an effort to discredit their predecessors they bansheed from one end of this country to the other about the insecure credit standing of the country, saying it was on the verge of bankruptcy, about their concern as to whether we would be able to meet the demands made on us and to meet our debts. Those are the two principal spokesmen in that particular line of country who are more responsible than any others for the state of emigration. The Minister can afford to smirk; he has not had to emigrate and leave his family behind. I want to assert—it does not give me any pleasure to do it and I am closer to it than the Minister—that for the last year and a half emigration from this country has reached almost to the highest level it reached during the war years. There may not be statistics in the Statistics Department for that but the knowledge is in every city, town and village of the country. It is known to the authorities in every village, town and city and to the committees and officers of every sporting club whether it is rugby, soccer, G.A.A., or lawn tennis.
I am giving the real picture of this country. We are told that 1953 was the best year in our history. What evidence is there to support that? We are told that there has been a complete recovery in the business of the country. That is untrue. There is not a businessman, whether he be attached to Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, or any other Party, no matter what Party (if any) he subscribes to or supports, who can honestly say that business is anything like as good as it was three or four years ago. There is not a Deputy in this House—and I know I am speaking in the presence of some people who know what I am talking about—who will dare to assert that, with the possible exception of land, any piece of property is nearly as valuable as it was two or three years ago, and that there has not been a drop in values of from 25 per cent. to 50 per cent.
Comment on this
If the Deputy was listening he would have understood me to say that, with the exception of land, all property had fallen in value.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought not deliberately to give a wrong impression of his own intelligence. That is the picture, not the sort of picture we get from Deputy Cogan or the sort of picture we get every week-end at some cross-roads in the country from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.
Comment on this
That is a very peculiar statement. What do you mean?
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is entitled to make his speech and he does not have to annotate his statement for any other Deputy. Deputy Morrissey on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
If the Minister would add that one, I think the country would survive it, although, believe it or not, I would be nearly sorry to see him go. I suppose we ought to keep our suffering to ourselves as well as our blessings. The Deputies have been beaten—they are absolutely afraid, and they have reason to be afraid, to face the country. They are facing political extinction—there is no question whatever about it.
Comment on this
If the Minister and myself started to remind each other of what we have been saying for the last 30 years, I do not know when the election would be held. The fact of the matter is that those opposite are on their political death-bed.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be saying that for the next 20 years, in addition to the 30 he has been saying it.
Comment on this
The Minister is slipping a bit. Does he remember when he used to be talking about the dead Fine Gael Party?
Comment on this
Yes, £36,000,000. I am glad you reminded me of it. I have been here since 3 o'clock and have not heard a reference to it since then, so you cannot blame me for forgetting it. The £36,000,000 is only one-third of the bill, if it is a third. Deputy Aiken has reminded me of the time it used to be £21,000,000 and Deputy Dr. Ryan used to say we were £7,000,000 over-taxed and the country could be run for £14,000,000. Even this £36,000,000 Vote on Account is not sufficient to keep the country going while we are changing the Government—which could be done within three weeks. The Taoiseach could dissolve the House to-night and we could have the new House meeting about the 2nd or 3rd April. We could have a Budget and a policy and a programme and a bit of hope for the people.
The Deputy talked about our promises. I would like to hear the Deputy telling us about the promises we made and did not keep. One of the promises we made before the election was that we would remove additional taxation to the tune of £6,000,000. We did so and we did not wait for the Budget to do it. In the same year, the people for whom the Deputy is weeping—the old age pensioners, the blind pensioners and the widows and orphans—got an increase. The Deputy might remember that increases in those times were real increases. For two and a half years, while wages and salaries went up to a greater extent than in any similar period in the history of the State, there was not an increase of even one point in the cost-of-living index in those two and a half years. The Statistics Office were able to produce figures and a graph to show that, for the first time since records were kept, the earnings had passed out the cost of living.
Deputy Cogan tells us that the poor and the workers are no better off. He says that the increase in the loaf from 6½ to 9½., the increase in sugar from 4d. to 7d., in butter from 2/10 to 4/2, in tea from 2/8 to 5/6, means you are only increasing the essentials by 14.7 per cent. Listen to me, do not mind about that sort of thing going down here—it will not go down even in Wicklow.
I have tried to put the position as I see it. Some Deputies may think that I have been rather severe. To tell you the truth, I have been trying to think if there were any words or phrases which I could use, within the Orders of the House, that would provoke the Government into dissolving. Apparently, they are conscious of their danger. Apparently the reports and the cries of panic that must have poured in from all the cumainn and from some of the Deputies and maybe even from some of the Ministers, following on the Taoiseach's announcement on Thursday night, have turned the scale. I know some Deputies and some Ministers who must be feeling rather uncomfortable. They had very little left in the kitty the last time when they just got into the seat here in the House. They might do better this time—you would never know. If you believe, as you do believe, that the people are against you, why do not you get out, why do you not dissolve to-night or at the furthest to-morrow; and we will give you the £36,000,000 to get rid of you, and it will be cheap at that price.
Comment on this
After Deputy Morrissey's entertaining contribution, I am strongly tempted to follow on the entertainment line but I thought we were going to discuss the Vote on Account, which is a serious national business.
Comment on this
I will. Anyone who has been in this House for any length of time can see how an Opposition must oppose. Apparently, it does not matter what opposition it is. When Deputy Morrissey was speaking, I could not help supposing what the tune would be if we had announced the dissolution for to-day. That would be wrong, too. An Opposition will always have to say whatever the other side of the House does is wrong.
Comment on this
Could Deputy Hickey not keep his mouth shut, as he did when Deputy Morrissey was speaking?
Comment on this
When the announcement was made last Thursday, the big question with everyone was whether the dissolution would be to-night or after the Budget. It was perfectly clear that there would be a further announcement and, in fact, the newspapers started to ask that question immediately. In face of that, much of what has been said on the far side collapses. There is a more serious aspect to all this. This Book of Estimates is an extraordinarily important thing for us, no matter to what side of the House we belong. It contains the Departmental Estimates and the provisions for the financial year, as already estimated by the Government and by the Departments. These Estimates will have to be considered and dealt with by some Government on these benches, to run the country for this year. One wonders why the Opposition completely ignores them. There are some very important questions to be answered on these Estimates, as to whether certain expenditure herein set out should be provided for, or whether reductions should be made under some heads or increases under others.
A function of this Vote on Account in every year has been to give Deputies an opportunity of examining the proposed expenditure and of expressing their views on that expenditure and on the items involved in it. It also provides an opportunity for the various Parties to express their support or opposition, or to make suggestions for amendment in regard to the provisions in those Estimates. This we have not got from the Opposition or any Party in the Opposition.
I am afraid the cat was let out of the bag to-day by a remark by either Deputy Morrissey or Deputy Sweetman that it is not the Vote on Account which counts, it is the vote of the country. That may be all very well but the Vote on Account is a very substantial part of the national business and if the Opposition are regarding this as a game and that the serious business we should be doing in this House does not matter, it is an extremely serious thing for the country. That is the Opposition's attitude. There is a direct quotation, which I took down myself, from their front bench and, if it means anything, it means that they are interested in the competition for political power and, apparently, are not interested in the serious business of running the country. That is an appalling thing. It is an appalling thing when one looks at it from the background of the principal Opposition Party.
First of all, there is their propaganda at the present moment—taxation and the cost of living. The question of a general election was not mooted until the Press which supports them came all out on it. What was the line?— exorbitant State expenditure. They made immediate attack on the Estimates—the State was spending too much. On all their platforms they stressed taxation and called for reductions in taxation and at the same time they talked about the cost of living and, in particular, they talked about food subsidies. That is all very reminiscent of things that happened in the past.
It would be well if the people of whom Deputy Morrissey was talking a few minutes ago would have regard to the facts of the situation. In 1948 that very same Party was the Empire Party. Thanks be to God, they threw that over. They were willing to sacrifice supporters who voted for them on that basis in order to get the support of another group who made the Coalition but, before they threw it over, while they were the Empire Conservative Party, their big platform was "squandermania; cut the Estimates". They are leading off their Press talks in the same tones to-day.
If that is their genuine policy, why should they not come in here about these Estimates now? Now is the time to talk about them rationally. There is a complete list published in this document. It is very fair for me to say: "Now is the time for you to say what should be cut and where you will reduce State expenditure".
We had it all in 1947. You promised the country you would reduce the cost of running the State. You got a large part of the conservative vote for that. What did you do? I have the actual Book of Estimates here. There was a Book of Estimates which was in the region of £70,000,000. There was a great show at reduction. The Fine Gael element in the Coalition was dominant and they made a show at reducing expenditure. There are people in this country to-day who remember turf workers being thrown out of employment. There are people in this country to-day who remember what happened the road grants and the road workers. There are a number of people in Inchicore and there were a number of skilled workmen who remember that there was machinery for an Irish factory that was sold because of the show of economy. There were many other things. There was the bus station. There were the Constellations, and all the rest and, more significant, and worse still— Deputy Morrissey ignored this fact when he was talking—the statistics are there—we rubbed it into you when we were on the other side—emigration and unemployment soared in the first two years in which the Coalition were in office. Emigration and unemployment went up severely and the favourable trends that were there in 1948 were reversed.
Perhaps a good deal of that could be excused but the terribly sorry and sad fact is that, after all that, the Coalition failed in its object of reducing expenditure. One might be prepared to excuse or to understand that, because one cannot work miracles and if you are to get results you must take positive action. One might have let that go if the results had been there. What happened? In the last year, 1947-48, before that Coalition took over, the expenditure was £59,000,000, approximately. In 1950-51, the expenditure was up to £75,500,000. Since 1951, for which the Coalition was responsible— they prepared the Estimates for that year and introduced the Budget for that year and set the whole financial machinery for that year—it was up to £90,000,000. After all that was said and all that was done at the expense of the Labour Party and at the expense of workers, there was a complete failure to control expenditure and, on top of that, there were the other things that happened.
They talk about the cost of living to-day. Let us take the cost of living. Deputy Morrissey claims that the cost of living was stable for two years. Yes, it was. It had been stabilised by their predecessors and remained stable in satisfactory circumstances, but we all remember the fiasco in this House when a Parliamentary Secretary came in and told us that the cost of living had not been increased. Incidentally, it is very interesting to see that the Opposition have taken a leaf out of my own book by having the actual list. That was the obvious thing to do. What happened? The cost of living just went out of control. Actually it was this Government that stabilised prices afterwards again. It just ran out of control and you had the panic from the then Tánaiste, who called for price freeze. That did not work and Fine Gael called it off. There was a complete fiasco and the cost of living went up notwithstanding the fact that there were concealed devices. Whatever can be said about the present Government, what they did was done in a straightforward way.
Comment on this
It was done honestly in the interests of the people. There was a Government here that had the moral courage to do what they thought was right by the people and did not juggle around for political expediency either to get power or to stay in power. At least, it cannot be thrown at this Party and the people on these benches that they went around the country hawking the Empire, as the Conservative Party, and then, to buy the support of other Parties, threw the whole thing over and reversed everything they had promised the electorate.
Throw it all there. I certainly would be very much ashamed if I found myself associated with that. However, I want to get back to this Estimate. Here we have all the signs of the same thing again—the same things again; the Press talking about squandermania, taxation, lower the cost of living. I am going to say a surprising thing. If a rational, practical, sound approach could be found to doing these things, many people would be with you. But I have in mind and I can send for the quotation here—it was on the 21st or 22nd March, 1951, in the Seanad—when Deputy McGilligan, the then Minister for Finance, warned that old age pensions could not be increased without an increase in taxation.
Comment on this
I understand that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach has a statement to make.
Comment on this
I want to inform the Dáil that an agreement has been reached between the Whips of the various Parties that the Vote on Account and all stages of the Central Fund Bill will be passed to-night unopposed. A motion from the Opposition will be taken to-morrow after questions, which reads as follows:—
That, in the opinion of An Dáil, Dáil Éireann should be dissolved forthwith.
The debate on that motion is to conclude at 10.30 p.m. to-morrow night.
Comment on this
Perhaps I was a little bit over vehement in saying what I had to say in these matters. But I must say that in the face of things that have been said I think it is rather pardonable to put things as brutally as I have put them, if you like to put it that way, because the fact is that what I have stated are facts and cannot be contradicted and what I do say, which is a point of very great importance for the country and for its Government and for its institutions, is that if democracy in this country and our Parties do not approach the business of Government with a serious mind and if the ideal of service to the people and doing the right thing is not put before mere competition for power or for office then there is a danger light there that anybody who thinks does not like to see there.
By all means let the Parties come out with their policy. By all means let Fine Gael come out and say: "We will reduce expenditure. We will cut taxation." If they mean to do it and if they show us how to do it, I think the electorate are entitled to have that shown to them. If Deputy MacEoin and his colleagues can come forward and say: "That Bill is too high"— incidentally, now is the time to say it and why are you not saying it here? This is the place to say it, if that is what you want to say. I can understand that, and it is a very legitimate approach if you are sincere in it, if you really mean to do it. If you mean to cut taxation and expenditure, by all means pursue that policy, advocate it and get votes on it. But let it be a sincere and honest policy and, if you have the power to implement it, implement it. We had a sorry experience the last time when you had the power —when you made a show of implementing and when, in the end, it was "a sorry fiasco", to quote one of your own newspapers.
Comment on this
To quote one of your newspapers I said—one of the newspapers that support you pretty consistently. It was a sorry fiasco after all the damage that was done— and damage was done; long-term damage as well as short-term damage. I have already given you the immediate damage. The long-term damage was that in the years 1948, 1949 and up to the outbreak of the Korean war in 1950 we had three years of lost opportunity while you were fiddling and being more concerned with propaganda. We hand it to you for propaganda. Being more concerned with propaganda, your record of doing anything was very meagre. Those years of opportunity were lost and the hardship that the country has had to suffer since was your doing, and that is a fact. That is the hard fact of the situation. I talked about this show of reducing taxation—reducing expenditure. I have shown you, on the figures, that there was no reduction in expenditure: it was a failure. On the reduction in taxation: no matter how you will haggle about words—and I am not going to haggle about words—the fact is that in the 1951 Budget no provision was made for commitments that were there and for expenditure that could have been and must have been foreseen or else the only conclusion one could draw, if your statements are right, is that you did not intend to honour your word to the civil servants and others and, of the two, I prefer to believe that you simply did not provide.
As I have said, I can understand, and if Fine Gael honestly puts forward that policy I can understand—and they are entitled to and, on many aspects, many people will think it is reasonable. If you say your main plank is going to be as your Press is drumming in at the moment: "Reduce expenditure. Cut taxation." Understandable, yes, but let us see how it can be done and if you are sincere in it you have an arguable case if you go to do that. But what you cannot do is to have it both ways. You cannot have it both ways. There is a bill brought in here, and, as I said, I would have expected it to be discussed here to-night for the sum of £108,000,000 odd. Deputy Morrissey commented on how these bills had gone up. Very good. If your programme is to reduce State expenditure, where are you going to reduce in this? There is a list there.
We have here all these speeches from the Opposition and we have not heard what services would be reduced. What services will be cut? Instead, the line is taken: "We are not going to discuss this." That I have already characterised as a completely irresponsible attitude, betraying a mentality that is more interested in the competitive aspects of Government than in the serious responsible aspects. But let us take this. There are some sums here which are sizable. Supplementary agricultural grants for instance are certainly higher than they were—almost £1,000,000 higher. The Estimates for the coming year would be more than £1,000,000 higher than they were during the period of the Coalition Government. There is a sizable one. There is where a certain reduction could be made. Will you let that figure stand? Will you cut it if your policy is to reduce expenditure? There is one sizable figure which on a cursory glance will take examination. There is a fair question. I see the Garda Síochána are another item that is substantially up since the Coalition were in office. Presumably it is one of the heads where you complain that expenditure is going up. Certainly it is one of the heads that accounts for an increase in expenditure. A fair question to you is:"Will you reduce it to your previous figure or will you let it stand?" I find that the figure for local government and public health has not varied very much but it is a substantial figure. Do you want to alter that figure? The Office of the Minister for Education, I notice, is substantially up.
The Office of the Minister for Education is up well in the region of £1,000,000 too. You will get the exact figure on the sheet if you care to look for it. It is substantial. A very fair question to the gentlemen in the Opposition—through the Chair—is: Will you let that figure stand; do you propose to reduce it? I am getting no answers. Industry and commerce is another heading and it would be interesting to know whether the increase there is to stand? I am picking out items where the increases are substantial for the purposes of argument, and I take it that the sums you were expending when you were in Government under various heads— that we can take those as a basis to start from. I assume you will not go so far as to say that you are going to cut below what you had before.
Take the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. What are you going to do there? In the case of the Army, I suppose some show might be made to reduce the Army again. There was a drive on the unfortunate Army before, and I imagine they would suffer the next time.
There is one very significant item that I have left to the last where there is £5,000,000 to account for. What are you going to do about health and social welfare? These are very substantial items. We are here as a Parliament, the elected representatives of the people meeting to discuss the financial accounts for the year and the proposed expenditure of the people's money and all we can get out of the Opposition is their elation over the results of two by-elections and a lot of what I might describe as crossroad propaganda—to borrow your own phrase—and not one of you will get down to the business of the country.
Let me try to bring you down to the business of the country. What are you going to do about the last question I asked? It is of some importance for the Labour Party and other people who support Fine Gael. It is very important for them because they have done a lot of talking about health and social services. I have reminded you of the occasion when Mr. McGilligan as Minister for Finance, pointed out that you could not have increases in old age pensions without increasing taxation. I could dig up a whole lot of other references and I will do so if I am asked. You have this attitude, this approach of Fine Gael; you have had all this talk, but is it not before an election that the people should know, and that other Parties should know, where Fine Gael stands in all these things? I would imagine that the Labour Party who support you would like to know specifically where you stand in regard to social welfare and health. I would imagine these Parties would this time like to know— and know pretty definitely—whether a Coalition of which you would be the dominant Party—because certainly you have flourished on the blood of the others and the election results show it —and I would imagine that these other Parties would want to know whether the future, should Fine Gael have the making of it, hold in store for them matters like the chassis factory at Inchicore or reductions of that nature.
There are some things that are worth thinking of in that connection. I remember when I was on that side of the House during three years a social welfare scheme, and I remember a Health Bill. I remember being sorry to see Labour Ministers and people who claimed to be representative of the workers, being made a laughing stock of by the delaying tactics that held them off for three years until the dissolution came, and then they were gone with the wind.
I think these things are questions which not only the electorate are entitled to have answered, but that even we here in this House should be given some idea about so that we would know where we stand.
Are we to take it that these Estimates are accepted? There will be no vote on this, by agreement. But there has been such silence—are we to take it that the coming year is to be faced on the basis of these Estimates? Any reasonable man would assume that, in view of the situation here—and the question has been fairly raised—all Parties in the House are agreed that these Estimates should stand. If they are to stand, why is there this type of attack on them that is being made outside? If they are not to stand, are we not at least entitled to know where they are to be reduced or adjusted I think these are very fair question indeed, and I ask them.
We have heard a lot and we will he a lot more about the cost of living. First of all, let me start with subsidies without going into all the things that have been thrashed out before. Some £8,000,000 or so is provided in these Estimates for subsidies. We are already providing a very large sum of money for food subsidies. Is it proposed to increase that sum? If it is, that is arguable, and it is fair enough. If, again, Fine Gael says or any other Party comes in and says:— We will do this, and this is how we will do it," and keep their word, nobody can complain. But £8,000,000 is provided for food subsidies in these Estimates and that is very near to the total value of food subsidies some years ago, before there was any reduction, because of the way prices have gone. Is the policy of simply increasing subsidies to maintain prices stable at a low level to be pursued indefinitely—is that Fine Gael policy? If it is, we had better know about it.
I have a definite recollection of a discussion in the Seanad when the question of food subsidies came up and the Coalition Minister for Finance gave very definite reasons—we were accused of being unreasonable when we in opposition questioned some of the reasons, and when we gave the same reasons here as a Government we were accused of being unreasonable. That, I suppose, is human nature, and to get back, let us take Mr. McGilligan when he was Minister for Finance. He gave very cogent and definite reasons in the Seanad why he could not increase food subsidies, and the position to-day is that the £8,000,000 being spent now is not very far short of the total—it is within striking distance, anyway, of it—which was paid in respect of food subsidies some three years ago. If that is the situation it is obviously a major fiscal problem. If you are going to restore the food prices to what they were three years ago you will have to find a considerable amount of money over and above what was required for subsidies at that time. How is that to be done? Where will that money come from? I still hark back to the statements of the Coalition Minister that these things could only be got by taxation. I still hark back to that, and I must say I could never see it otherwise myself. If that is so, and if those moneys can only be found by taxation, what are you going to tax and how can you—unless you are some kind of wizards—in all honesty, talk on the one hand about reducing taxation and on the other hand about restoring food subsidies and reducing the cost of living in that way. Do you mean to tell us that if we could find a way out, some way in which this could be done, that we would not do it in the morning?
There is one thing that rather amuses me in all this. It is that, in one voice, the Deputies opposite talk about our political astuteness, our political cuteness and our political manoeuvring. They give us credit for being political wizards, but on the other hand, by implication, they seem to suggest that we are such political fools that we do such a thing as to bring in the 1952 Budget for the fun of it or for political reasons. That just does not stand analysis. The 1952 Budget was brought in because there was no other way out, and, because the interests of the people and of the country demanded it, the Government was faced with a most unpleasant and, in many respects, unpopular task.
Comment on this
I would ask the Deputy not to get me on to that. We heard all about it before. Deputy Hickey will remember that he and I had that out from the other angle when he was on this side and I was on the other side and, like Omar Khayyam, "out the same door as in we went".
Comment on this
There was a motion down and it was all very entertaining. I am dealing with Fine Gael at the moment. Perhaps they are the dominant factor, but I have a kind of idea that there were other people who used to talk about monetary reform and cutting the link with sterling. I think that the correct word for all that is "in abeyance".
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not mind, I think we will leave it in abeyance. To get back to the Vote on Account, I am glad to see that Deputy Dillon has come in. There are a few questions that I should like to ask him.
Comment on this
I thought there was an understanding that the Minister was to conclude on this to-night.
Comment on this
I was saying that I was glad that Deputy Dillon had come in. He has always been very courteous to me, personally and I intend to be as courteous to him in the questions which I want to ask him.
Comment on this
It is never courteous to ask a man questions which he has no opportunity of answering.
Comment on this
I will be very frank with Deputy Dillon. If I am not to ask them here, I will be asking them somewhere else. We were talking about the question of food subsidies. There is one thing that can be considered, and it is that, in certain circumstances, it might be possible to import foreign wheat more cheaply than to grow it at home. I mean that is a factor. The fact is that it was the other way for a while, to a large extent, when Deputy Dillon was Minister, but these are things of which a Government has not got complete control. When Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture he had to face the problem that, I think, the price of foreign wheat was rather more expensive than the home-produced. Now, there is the possibility of exploiting that from the consumer's point of view.
Comment on this
No. The Deputy, of course, knows that I am merely a private Deputy and that Budget secrets are kept very closely.
Comment on this
It may surprise the Deputy to know that I do not. I am merely a private Deputy on these benches and Government secrets are Government secrets and quite rightly so for any Government as regards these matters. As I was saying, that is a problem, and I think I was putting it reasonably. There is the problem as to whether, in fact, the interests of consumers and the interests of home producers might come in conflict. What is the answer to that? These are things that I think we should be discussing and discussing soberly. One of the things which I do not like in present trends here—I think it happens in a number of countries where urban populations are growing—is a certain tendency to conflict there.
I must say that I deplore very much whenever I hear people in the cities complaining of high prices—that the farmers are getting too much. The interest of the townsman and of the farmer is one fundamental interest in the long run. I am raising the matter in connection with this question of the reduced cost of living because it might possibly be an approach, but if it is there will be repercussions in other quarters, and the question is how these are to be dealt with. However, I am afraid that my time has run out. There are quite a lot of things that I should like to have said to Deputy Morrissey in reply to what he said. After all, let us realise this, because it is most understandable. Fine Gael have had a couple of good wins at everybody's expense, and, if you like, their friends have contributed to them very much.
Comment on this
I cannot blame them for exulting. After all, it is a natural and human tendency.
Comment on this
"Greater love hath no man"—we had a couple of political suicides on that basis already for the love and glory of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
I think, I understand, the exuberance of the Opposition. It is understandable, but, as we have serious business to do, I propose to let the Minister in.
Comment on this
The arrangement that the Minister should conclude has been agreed to by all parties.
Comment on this
The Minister must be allowed some time to conclude. That has been the general practice of the House.
Comment on this
If we were certain of getting the business disposed of by 10.30 p.m., I would waive my right to reply.
Comment on this
I do not propose to make any speech at all, but we should get the business finished by 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
Three minutes is all I require. I have listened to Deputy Major de Valera's fantastic contribution to this debate. He concentrated so much on other things and drew attention to so many other things that he made very little mention of defence. Last year Deputy de Valera tried to dope us on that particular issue. Does the Minister and the Deputy realise what the increase amounted to in relation to that particular Estimate last year and what is now allowed? Out of all that, will we be told again that we must be satisfied with 6d. a day increase for a soldier and 2/6 for a major. I tell the Minister that there is more "squandermania" in the Department of Defence than there is in any other Department of State. Not only should the amount this year be the same as that voted last year, but there could be a reduction I believe. Deputy de Valera must realise that it is not simply a question of reducing all the time as far as we are concerned. We want proper government.
What has the Minister to say about the wonderful National Development Fund introduced here? No mention is made of it in the Book of Estimates, nor has there been any mention of it on the Vote of Account to-day. Deputy de Valera put up a miserable argument. Deputy de Valera should understand that the present Minister gave an increase of 1/6 to the old age pensioners while at the same time, through his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, permitting the farmer to take 5/9 per day out of the agricultural labourer's wages to cover that labourer's keep.
We are on the eve of an election and the less bombastic political talk we have here the better it will be. It is not simply a question of reducing costs or reducing prices; it is a question of giving the people the services to which they are entitled.
Comment on this
Deputy Desmond asked what we proposed to do about the National Development Fund and stated that there was not a word about it in the Book of Estimates. If the Deputy will turn to the statement at the beginning of the Book of Estimates and look at the heading, National Development Fund, he will see there a footnote, q., which states that this Estimate will be introduced in the course of 1954-55.