We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Dissolution of Dáil—Motion.

Contributions 1–174 of 483. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I move the motion standing in my name:

That, in the opinion of the Dáil, Dáil Éireann should be dissolved forthwith.

From the outset, I want to emphasise the fact that this motion is not put down as part of a political manoeuvre or a manoeuvre in the political Party game. While I make that assertion, I hasten to add that, while I have every sympathy with the desires of the present Government to bolster up their falling political fortunes by the method adopted in connection with the circumstances brought about by the results of the by-elections recently held, I realise it is part of the working of the democratic machine that there should be Parties and while, as a political Party, we would welcome—I am sure every Party on this side of the House would welcome for their purposes—an immediate dissolution in the belief and solidly founded conviction that we are rising with the tide, nevertheless, the real reason for this motion is our conviction that it is in strict accord with what the public want and in strict accord with the public interest.

The Taoiseach, when he was speaking on the motion in his own name last summer seeking a vote of confidence from this House, following upon the adverse results of the then recently held by-elections, repudiated the notion that the interpretation which the Opposition Party put upon those results had any foundation or that we were, in fact, entitled to interpret these results in any particular way whatever or endeavour to ascertain or interpret public opinion. Yesterday afternoon, in an interchange across the House, the Taoiseach again repeated something about the interpretation of public opinion following a by-election.

On this occasion we are not concerned with whether or not our interpretation of the results of the recent by-elections is a correct one or not or whether we are entitled to draw conclusions or inferences from those results because the Taoiseach himself has, by his actions and by his announcements in the newspapers immediately following the two results in Louth and Cork, strictly and accurately interpreted public opinion. Once the results came in within a few moments the Taoiseach had determined that there had to be a general election because of the fact that there was only one interpretation to be put on the results of the by-elections and that is that the electorate in those two areas representing, as I believe he believes, the vast majority of the electorate throughout the country wanted the Government to get out and get out quickly.

When I was speaking at the last meeting during the by-election campaign in Cork City, I recalled to the electorate of Cork City that North-West Dublin last year had given the clearest notice to quit that any Government ever got in this country since the establishment of the State. I directed their attention to the fact that no Government, since this State was established, ever received such a political reverse as the present Government received at the hands of the electorate in North-West Dublin. I asked the citizens and the electorate of Cork to remember that Cork always wanted to be ahead of Dublin and that in this election they should outdo North-West Dublin and give the Government a greater defeat and a clearer notice to quit than even the electorate of North-West Dublin gave. They did it and Louth did it and they are expressing the clear view of the people.

Last summer we asked, not that the Government should get out and let us or any Party on this side of the House in, but that the Government should submit their record and their policy or lack of policy to the verdict and decision of the electorate at a general election. The Taoiseach on the debate that occurred last summer asserted that as long as he had a majority, however small, in this House he was entitled to carry on and did carry on and in the course of the by-election campaigns recently held he again asserted that there would be no general election during 1954. The vibrations over the air announcing from Radio Éireann the results of these elections had hardly come in when he said there was going to be a general election, and everybody assumed and read into that declaration that there was going to be an immediate general election and that it was the greatest possible relief.

I do not know what happened to change the Taoiseach's mind. We can only surmise. Again, I express my sympathy with the Fianna Fáil Party in the dilemma in which they find themselves or would seem to find themselves as a result of the Taoiseach's immediate reaction to the results of the by-elections in Cork City and in Louth. As I said yesterday, I am not a bit interested in the political fortunes of Fianna Fáil or how they will try to bolster up their falling fortunes. Yesterday afternoon I gave the reasons why we believe there ought to be in the public interest and following on what we believe is the public desire and demand an immediate general election. I based the case for that on two grounds yesterday and I will add a third this afternoon.

The case is so clear and coercive for this motion being carried out that it does not require me to repeat the arguments I advanced yesterday or to give any particular consideration to the matter at all. I pointed out yesterday afternoon that general elections always cause dislocation of business, upset and uneasiness in any circumstances. People lose as a result of it. In existing circumstances, where the economic machinery had been slowed down, the inevitable results of a prolonged delay, as is contemplated, in holding this general election would be to slow down still more the economic tempo.

Merchants will not buy and customers will not invest. People will try to anticipate what the Government are going to do in their Budget. There must, undoubtedly, be a slowing down in economic activities in anticipation of the Budget. That is going to cause hardship and loss and it will take many months for the newly-elected Administration, whatever source that Administration may come from, to recover from the economic shock that will be caused to the country not merely by the long delay but also by the fact that the Taoiseach and his Government have said they do not intend to go for a general election until they introduce the Budget.

If the present Government were angels incarnate running this country and brought in a Budget, there is not a single person—and I believe there are a great many in the ranks of Fianna Fáil to whom this would apply —outside the ranks of the Fianna Fáil supporters who would believe, however good the Government were, that it was not brought in merely to catch votes and to save the falling fortunes of Fianna Fáil. That is going to be bad for the country and it is a bad precedent.

That is my first argument for this motion—economic dislocation and loss, the holding up of purchasing and buying and the fact that a bad precedent is being created, giving the impression, whether it be true or not true, that this postponement of the election was brought about because the rank and file of Fianna Fáil told the Government they had not a chance of being returned if they went immediately and without a Budget, and that their only hope of coming back anyway strong was to postpone the election and have some sort of popular Budget.

There is a still more cogent argument. Whatever Administration succeeds the present Government, even if it be the present Administration, will have a difficult and arduous task to perform. They will be faced with perplexing but not insoluble problems. They will have to face difficulties which it will not be easy to surmount. If the present Government do not come back and there is a new Administration brought into being as a result of the general election, their task of putting their policies, both economic and financial, into effect will be seriously hampered and the public interest may be seriously injured by having to work upon a situation which came about by the bringing into operation of a Budget by the present Administration, which is under sentence of death. That is not merely a bad precedent but it is thoroughly unsound politics and thoroughly bad for the country.

I visualise some sort of a Government coming out of this side of the House. Let us assume for the moment, without prophesying, that it is any Government with a policy different from that of the present Government, with a policy designed to bring about a complete and fundamental change in the economic and financial policy of the present Government; with a policy designed to do away with the austerity which was the fundamental result of the Government's policy; with a policy designed for expansion and not restriction; with a policy based upon the dual Budget which was a feature of the capital investment programme of the last Government. They would be faced with a series of economic and financial proposals enshrined in the Budget, all designed, and all put into operation, with an eye upon a different policy and different political and economic principles and philosophies. They will be completely hampered in their operations for many months. I do not assume, I assert that if any Government formed from this side of the House do succeed the present Administration, their financial and economic policy will be such as I have said, and they will find that the results which had been obtained by them before, and which they still think can be obtained again, will be postponed for many months— if not for many years—by reason of the fact that this barrier has been placed in their progress by the bringing into operation of a Budget by the present Government. That, in my submission, is something of which the House should very distinctly show its dislike and, in no unmistakable fashion, if at all possible, see that it does not happen in the interests of the public and not of any Party.

If I were to consider the interests merely of my Party, I would say: "Fire ahead. Do what you like with the Budget, bring in a popular Budget if you like; reduce income-tax, give extra children's allowances, take something off the whiskey, off the stout and tobacco. Go ahead with that, because we know the people round the country will not be mocked, deluded or deceived. They will shrug their shoulders in a cynical fashion and say: `We know they are trying to get votes now. They did not do it when they were there last year and when they could have done it' " Therefore, no one can question our reason for putting this motion down asking the Government not to postpone the dissolution until after a Budget has been brought in, and I say we are doing it in the public interest in order to see that a bad precedent does not occur, and in order to see that if any Government is formed from any side of the House with a policy such as we carried out in the inter-Party Government, they will have an opportunity of doing what they intend to do or hope to do unhampered by the financial arrangements which have been put as a barrier in their path by the present Government.

I think it was said by the Minister for Finance yesterday afternoon, by way of an interruption, that the inter-Party Government brought in a Budget before they went for a general election and that the present Government were only doing what we did. The situation and the circumstances are entirely different. We did not lose six out of nine by-elections. We had not been defeated in North-West Dublin by a majority against us of such magnitude that never before had a Government got such a censure from an urban constituency as the Fianna Fáil Government got there. We had not got the situation that was brought about by Cork City in the last few days, by Louth, by Wicklow, by East Cork, by Limerick, or by Galway, which the Government won, and where we went up—in a situation where we had no seat in a three-seat constituency three years ago, and even three years ago we had only 3,000 votes—to 8,200. That is an entirely different set of circumstances, and we went out for certain reasons unconnected with the Budget. Our Budget stood the test of every economist and everything except the virulence of Fianna Fáil and their followers.

I assert that whether this Government want to try to help their failing political fortunes, whether the Taoiseach, knowing as we do that he intended to have an immediate general election——

Comment on this

How did you know that?

Comment on this

Irrespective of the interpretation of his statement— and I yesterday drew attention to what everyone knows, that the Taoiseach is an adept at the ambiguous phrase and that he can read 40 things into a thing where anyone else could not—we know it aliunde. I will not give the Taoiseach the source of my information. Will the Taoiseach deny, when he comes to answer this, that he intended to have an immediate election?

Comment on this

I intended exactly what I wrote.

Comment on this

What was that?

Comment on this
A Deputy

It has two meanings.

Comment on this

It could have. As I pointed out yesterday afternoon, he could have said if it suited him, that this declaration issued on the night of March 4th, entitled him to postpone the dissolution and the holding of a general election until the 1st August—because the last phrase "that a general election should be held as soon as the financial measures required to provide for the public services have been completed" could include very legitimately in the interpretation of that phrase, the passing of the Finance Bill and the passing of the annual Appropriation Bill which must take place somewhere before the 1st August.

Comment on this

Supposing that had been necessary?

Comment on this

How do we know but you will find it necessary yet?

Comment on this

He may go to-night.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach yesterday gave some plausible reasons or supposed reasons for postponing the election until the people had a full picture of the financial state of the country. The people do not care about the full picture of the financial state of the country.

Comment on this

Do they not?

Comment on this

All they know is what they have suffered from the financial policy of the present Government up to this and, no matter what the picture is and no matter what any member of the Government says, they are not going to believe them.

I want to put this consideration to Deputies who are trying to consider this matter in the general interest and for the public good. The month of May is the normal month for the bringing in of a Budget and the passing of financial proposals. Therefore, it being not yet the middle of March, the passing of a Budget is not urgent and a new Administration could easily be formed if the Dáil were dissolved to-night before 12 o'clock and met on the 2nd April—a week before Holy Week. Then the new Administration that would come into office as a result of the dissolution and general election would be in a position to see where they stood. They would have the Financial picture before them and they would have seen how much money had come into the Exchequer and what the real financial position was. They could then frame their Budget in accordance with their own financial and economic policy.

Let me repeat what I said yesterday, that the annual Budget is the instrument of economic policy in modern conditions. That instrument has been taken away, blunted and made ineffective by the proposal of the present Government to have the Budget before the new Administration can take office and so tie their hands or thwart their efforts. We could have an Administration before Holy Week. Holy Week was mentioned by the Taoiseach yesterday. Dissolve the Dáil to-night and have a new Administration on the 2nd April. Then the whole picture can be seen and the whole circumstances understood and the Budget can be framed and moulded to suit the policy of the new Administration and to enable them without the slightest loss of time to put into operation their new financial and economic policy, to replace the policy of restrictionism and austerity which has been in operation here for the last two and a half years and which the country, north, south, east and west, has repudiated in such an emphatic fashion.

These are the two general principles on which I commend to this House the motion down in my name. There is one third and last consideration I want to put to Deputies. It is, perhaps, a somewhat saddening thought that with the dissolution of this Dáil an era is ending. I ask Deputies to let that era end as far as possible in peace and certainly with dignity. It is very nearly a quarter of a century since the unhappy circumstances occurred which so rived our country and divided our people. Political divisions have formed themselves upon the lines of the divisions that took place following upon the Treaty of 1921. We have been trying to get away from the antagonisms of the past. I want Deputies to visualise what is going to happen in the next two months. Those people who have carried on either side the brunt of those divisions and differences of opinion, they are on the way out, in accordance with the ordinary inexorable passage of time. People will vote at this general election, whether on the old register or on the new register, who were not born when Fianna Fáil first took office in the year 1932. If there is a prolonged election campaign and contest, we may be faced with a disedifying spectacle. We had some examples in the recent by-elections of that vituperation and vitriolic bitterness which has been such an unfortunate characteristic of our political history in the last 20 years. I want to have this election contest held in the shortest possible space of time, so that the bitterness—and that sort of thing we heard from Deputy Dr. Ryan, the Minister for Social Welfare—will not be brought in to exacerbate and embitter our people in this political contest, so that inside and outside this House, throughout the country and here in Dáil Éireann when it sits, we will not have that disedifying bitterness and conflict and animosity of which we have had such unfortunate experiences, headed by the Minister for Social Welfare and followed by some of his most recent followers throughout the country.

Comment on this

I formally second the motion and reserve the right to speak.

Comment on this

The Party opposite has been well named "the Party of Gloom". For pure sanctimonious political bunkum, it would be hard to beat the speech to which we have just listened. Deputy Costello takes the attitude that everybody interpreted the Taoiseach's statement in the way in which he interpreted it or wishes to interpret it. What is the real position? Take the Deputy's own organ, the Independent, and see how the correspondent of the Independent interpreted the Taoiseach's statement. On the morning following that statement, they had a ribbon heading which suggested that a dissolution would be unlikely for some weeks. Then, in the course of a written article, it was stated that the election would be held at the latest within the next two months. That is a completely different interpretation from what Deputy Costello and his followers wish to put on that statement. The Irish Times said: “Some political leaders think that the election will not be held until after his Budget in May”. That refers to the Taoiseach's Budget. Then there was published an interview with “ prominent Fine Gael Deputy”. I venture to suggest that the “prominent Fine Gael Deputy” could have been found on the Front Bench of the Fine Gael Party and, no doubt, the Deputies who are listening to me know who the Deputy was. What did the “prominent Fine Gael Deputy” say to the interviewer from the Irish Independent? He said:—

"An intelligent anticipation would be that the Taoiseach proposed to introduce his Budget and then either go for a general election immediately after his Budget statement or to go for a general election after he has forced his Budget proposals through the Dáil with the help of the Independents."

Deputy Costello, I am sure, knows the "prominent Fine Gael Deputy" who gave that interview.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

Indeed I do not. I have not the remotest idea who he is.

Comment on this

Look to your right.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

Nor do I care.

Comment on this

He probably had a facility for looking into the Taoiseach's mind.

Comment on this

I thought it was Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello should ask his sleeping partner.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

Who is he? Will the Minister tell me who my sleeping partner is?

Comment on this

This sanctimonious talk is like most of what we hear from the Fine Gael Benches. The speech we have listened to from the Leader of the Fine Gael Party may be described as the opening shots of the election campaign. This is the lead to what is to take place throughout the country. Deputy Costello knows that no matter what the Taoiseach had done he would have been wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

He is never wrong.

Comment on this

He is never right, according to the Deputy. Had the Taoiseach decided to go for an immediate election he would have been assailed by every Deputy opposite for having rushed the country into an election when he should not have done it.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

Indeed he would not. We would have been delighted.

Comment on this

When the Taoiseach decides that the opposite is the reasonable thing to do, he has done wrong again. Of course, according to the Deputies opposite, he will never do right. According to Deputy Costello, it was not the Taoiseach who made this decision—he was rushed into this decision by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Heretofore, the Deputies opposite always told us that this was a one man Party, that nobody could make a decision in this Party except the Taoiseach. Now, thanks be to God, we have the opposite allegation.

Comment on this

The Independents are making them now.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy Cowan is making them now.

Comment on this

I say, in the presence of the Taoiseach, that this is a political Party that is free to voice every and any opinion that it desires to voice, and we do it frequently and openly and no one endeavours to force an individual opinion against a majority opinion.

I am glad to hear Deputies opposite making forecasts about what will happen to this Party in the near future. According to what we are being told, sudden death awaits us— the guillotine.

Comment on this
Mr. Costello

No, a lingering death.

Comment on this

Time will tell. The Irish public and not Fine Gael have to make the decision. The only sad thing about it is that the opinions that are being voiced from the benches opposite are now being shared by Labour and by the splinter groups each side of Fine Gael because they, like the rotten apple, have become tainted. Their original independent opinions are now submerged in the opinions of the great Party opposite. That is the situation that exists at the present moment. Fianna Fáil are going into this election with our hearts up.

Comment on this

And your heads down.

Comment on this

No. That has never happened as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned. We have not ten years such as Fine Gael have to look back on. Our period has been a period of progress and the Irish people know that well. Whatever the result may be, whatever change of opinion may have taken place, as Deputies suggest, we will be prepared to accept the decision of the Irish people and there will be no question of arguing against that. I sincerely hope that when that decision is made it will be a decision with which the Irish people generally will be able to agree.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence has made a bold attempt to rally the vanishing fortunes of his Party. I do not blame him for that but he has not made a very good attempt. The Clann na Talmhan Party —this rotten Party according to the Minister for Defence—is supporting Deputy Costello's motion. Personally, I do not like an election. I do not think any Deputy likes an election but duty is duty.

Comment on this

No satellite of Fine Gael likes an election. They may be absorbed in the Soviet.

Comment on this

They like it better than the Fianna Fáil satellites.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Or senile delinquents.

Comment on this

We are supporting this motion because we believe, having regard to the results of a number of by-elections, particularly the by-election in Cork, that it is the proper course to take. The present Government got in by a trick. They deceived the Irish people. The Taoiseach took power by a trick.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Does not everybody know it is true?

Comment on this

You could not expect the truth from Deputy Blowick.

Comment on this

That trick has come back like a boomerang.

Comment on this

What trick?

Comment on this

The trick of taking office by a minority of Deputies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

And the Taoiseach said he would not do it.

Comment on this

He said he would break stones rather than do it.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this

You said it all over the country.

Comment on this

I did not say it. That is not true.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You said you would not form a Government unless you got a majority.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blowick is in possession and must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

I do not mind, nor do I mind for the inter-Party's sake, that the inter-Party Government was put out of office, but the trick that went into action on the 14th June, 1951, not three years ago, has had disastrous results for the people of this country. For that reason and for the people's sake, I am glad of the decision to hold a general election, to give the people a chance of saying what they think about the whole thing. We must regard the last two and a half years as nothing short of disastrous for the people.

First and foremost, the farmers of this country are the particular section of our community who seem to have incurred the enmity of the Taoiseach from the first time he took office 18 or 19 years ago. All down through the years he seems to have had an undying hatred of the farmers. The farmers have been his target for one blow of his sledge-hammer after another.

Comment on this

Tell us a new one.

Comment on this

Very well. Here is one that is fairly new. The Minister for Agriculture, by direction of the Minister for Finance, deliberately depressed the price of eggs by 6/- per 100 last June. The Taoiseach may laugh now but the Minister himself admitted it here in this House a few short weeks ago, on 11th February. Then, again, we must not forget the disastrous price offered for turkeys during the Christmas which has just passed. The turkey trade and the egg trade are two very promising trades for the small farmer. They are two of the principal mainstays of his economy—yet both of these trades have been singled out for attack by the present Government.

Comment on this

What sort of a statement is that?

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Killilea is still living in the clouds?

Comment on this

Deputy Killilea is living on a farm and he works it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He has another job, has he not?

Comment on this

Why should he not?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Killilea must allow Deputy Blowick to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I invite Deputy Killilea to tell his constituents that the price of eggs has gone up and that, last Christmas, the price of turkeys was better than it had ever been before. I invite him to repeat to his constituents the statement which the Minister for Finance made in this House last night when he said that the Irish people are the best-fed people in the world.

Comment on this

And so they are.

Comment on this

We may expect that, among other claims, Deputy Killilea will assert that Fianna Fáil started the ground limestone scheme in this country. Will he tell us that? The point I was making, when I was interrupted, was that the farmers of this country have been singled out, time and time again, for particular ill-treatment by reason of the enmity displayed towards them by Fianna Fáil since they first came into office many years ago. During the war years there was a ready market for wool. Then the Minister for Industry and Commerce, without any cause or just reason, deliberately depressed and fixed the price of wool at one-third of its then prevailing price. In one swoop, he slashed the profit which the farmers should have got on their wool.

The present Government seem to be oblivious of the appalling flight from the land that is continuing day by day in this country. At this point, I might mention that the inter-Party Government had almost brought emigration to a standstill by the time we left office.

Comment on this

41,000.

Comment on this

Emigration and flight from the land was not noticeable for the first six months, or so, of the present Government's office, but now it is worse than it ever was. Anybody who watches the trains departing from the West, particularly from now until the 1st June, will see large numbers of the very pick of our youth, both boys and girls, leaving the countryside to seek a livelihood in another country.

Comment on this

They are coming back—which is more than you are going to do.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The electors' lists do not prove that.

Comment on this

A short time ago, a number of farmers were peacefully picketing in Dublin City and, because of the Taoiseach's directions, they were stuffed into jail—for peacefully picketing here in Dublin City.

Comment on this

For the destruction of property.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What property did they destroy? Were the farmers' sons outside that gate destroying property?

Comment on this

The property of other men.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What has Deputy Cogan to say now?

Comment on this

They came from Fine Gael headquarters.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance will not be allowed to get away with that statement unchallenged.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would remind the House that when a Deputy rises to address the House he is entitled to be heard without interruption. Any Deputy who wants to make a contribution can do so later, without interruption. I call on Deputy Blowick to proceed.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has just stated that farmers who were peacefully picketing in Dublin destroyed property. If the Minister should avail of an opportunity to speak during the course of this debate, I challenge him to name the property which was destroyed because I will not allow him to add insult to the injury of stuffing these men into jail. Possibly the Minister for Finance thinks that he will get this in the papers tomorrow and that people up and down the country who may not be very familiar with the location of the picketing will assume, from his words here now, that the men in question destroyed property. I now challenge the Minister to show where sixpence worth of property was injured and where any damage was done by these men who were picketing. I would point out that the men in question were perfectly legitimately carrying out peaceful picketing in a constitutional manner. Of course, Fianna Fáil's way of dealing with the situation was to stuff them into jail and to fill the jails with them. I suppose the Taoiseach will tell us now and that he will go down the country soon and say that his heart is bleeding for the farmers of this country.

Let us consider some of the many schemes which were started by the inter-Party Government. Every single Party in that Government realised that agriculture is the basic industry in this country and that if we were ever to put an end to many of our economic evils our first task would be to restore prosperity to that industry. Deputy Dillon started the land reclamation scheme. The very name of that scheme was anathema to Fianna Fáil —just because the inter-Party Government started it.

Comment on this

That work was started years before the Coalition Government took office.

Comment on this

When Fianna Fáil resumed office in 1951, they did their very best to kill the ground limestone scheme and to go back to the burned lime system. That has failed, and now they are shamelessly— although they are welcome to do it— trying to claim the political kudos for the ground limestone scheme which is the most useful scheme which was ever started in this country. The average voter up and down the country is not as easily fooled as all that.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The Taoiseach will hear plenty about it when he starts his election campaign because the farmers are not that dumb. The Local Authorities (Works) Act, which was an essential subsidiary Act to the land rehabilitation scheme, has been completely choked off and the money has been diverted for other purposes. In our time, we voted £1,900,000 for a single year in respect of that Act. The amount has now been reduced to £400,000. The reason why the money has been reduced is that the inter-Party Government brought in that scheme. The people want a continuity of those Acts which are beneficial to the community and, no matter what Government may inaugurate a scheme, a succeeding Government should not injure something useful which their predecessors did. That is one of the principal reasons why Fianna Fáil got their answer from the people——

Comment on this

The Deputy got a fairly good answer from Mayo himself.

Comment on this

You got only one seat.

Comment on this

I invite Deputy Killilea to stand as a candidate in South Mayo.

Comment on this

I would not be a bit afraid to face it in the morning.

Comment on this

For all the votes he would get, he could put them in his vest pocket. I would not advise Deputy Killilea to go to North Mayo because there is the ghost of a biscuit factory there that might rise up and swallow him. We all remember the biscuit factory that was supposed to be erected there. Last June 12 months, a few evenings before the by-election there, the Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, came down to Ballina and promised a biscuit factory for the town. He gave a glowing account of all the employment that would be given in it and of the great quantity of biscuits that would be manufactured—so much so that the people of Mayo were seriously considering going off bread altogether and going on to the biscuits which were to be so plentiful there. The Minister told us that evening in Ballina that the seeds of the biscuit factory were sown. Those seeds must have come out of the old tombs in Egypt and been 3,000 years old. They have not germinated yet or at least the sprouts have not appeared above the ground yet.

A short time after the recent by-election in South Galway, at which the Government candidate was successful, a factory was opened in Ballinasloe. I think that, between Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries, seven were present at the official opening of the factory. That is very interesting in the light of what I am now about to say. In Ballina on the very same day, an enterprising businessman opened a small factory— not too small—which is giving employment to 40 or 50 men, but not one Minister or Parliamentary Secretary was present at the opening of that factory. They all went to Galway— which seems to indicate that they were afraid to cross the River Moy for more reasons than the factory alone. That kind of deceit is all right in between election periods but the people's memory is not short. Lest, however, is should be short, we will take very good care to keep these facts aired for them. It will be interesting to see the reception which the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance will get when they come to Mayo. I hope we shall be honoured by a visit, during the general election campaign, from the Minister for Finance; I hope he will not give us the cold shoulder.

Comment on this

We will gratify you, I hope.

Comment on this

We will give you a warm reception in Castlebar or in Galway, or any of these places, when you come along and explain these things to the people.

One of the latest tricks—and I describe it as nothing but a trick— was that in order to reduce the figure from 80,000 unemployed on the unemployment register, a scheme was introduced whereby a number of works were started on a Monday morning early in January down the country. Incidentally, it turned out to be the most bitter weather of the whole winter season, and the unemployed were asked to report for work as far as seven or nine miles from their homes. Of course, we know the result. They were struck off the register then for a period of 12 weeks, according to the regulations laid down by the Minister for Social Welfare or somebody else. I do not think that is a decent way to run a Government or to run the country. These kind of tricks give the people a very poor impression of Parliament, and I say these things are doing much to undermine the prestige of Parliament and pave the way for disrespect of Parliament and all that flows from it to such an extent that it has become a very serious matter.

When the present Government took office immediately after us, we found them going back on every single thing we did, whether it was good, bad or indifferent. So long as we had started it, that was sufficient reason to lay the axe to the root of it and chop it down. I had an excellent afforestation programme going ahead with the full consent of the Government, and every member of the Government was proud of that scheme, but it was cut down from 20,000 acres per year. Now the Minister for Finance told us that he was planning this year for 10,000 acres. The Fianna Fáil programme for 4,000 acres a year is now up to 10,000 a year, but when I left office plans were complete for 19,600 acres. Please God, it will not be long until that is back again.

Deputy Moran, a colleague of mine, had some question to-day on the relief of congestion. That is another aspect of Government work or administration that seems to be anathema to the present Government. They do not believe in the relief of congestion. They are anxious to revert to the position which came about in 1941 when the Land Commission was virtually closed down except for the vesting of certain holdings and the collecting of annuities. The present Minister is not anxious to acquire land for the relief of congestion, although I remember, when I was Minister, the present Taoiseach and then Leader of the Opposition, talked about 500,000 acres. He started his word-spinning to try to delude the people that if they were in office they would divide 500,000 acres, but he did not know where that land was. He said it ought to be there, somewhere. Word-spinning is too mild a term for that sort of thing. Quibbling is how I would describe it. The Taoiseach may not be aware of it, but the people are fed up with that kind of thing and a great feeling of insecurity has come about.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us what his correct word would be to describe a coalition? I think he said it stunk once.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The present coalition?

Comment on this

Have you not a dictionary under the desk? I thought one was always kept there.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance probably knows that I am approaching the question of the cost of living and he wants to put me off the trail. A growing feeling of insecurity has occurred during the last two and a half years, due to the fact that a man who was Taoiseach for 16 years and who had been respected and relied on by a great number of people at least not to mislead them went into power two and a half years ago with a 17-point policy or programme. He told the people, among other things, that he would maintain food subsidies, do his best to reduce the cost of living, give full employment and many other things, including drainage, afforestation, relief of congestion and providing work for the workless. All these things were to be done far better than the inter-Party Government could do them. But the very moment he took over office he swiped the food subsidies, increased the cost of living, and calmly told the people that they were eating too much, drinking too much, spending too much and that they must stop that kind of thing. The Minister for Finance—the man who wants to get a dictionary to define certain words— told us in the town hall at Rathmines a few days before the last general election that some people were scattering rumours that if the present Government was returned to office they would reimpose the tax on tobacco and drink. He said there was not a shadow of truth in that rumour, and he got that installed in a window on the front page of The Irish Press of 29th May, 1951. One of the first acts he undertook when he got back was to reimpose the taxes. When he took office he put an increased tax on petrol, an increased tax on cars, on tractors, on buses, on hackney cars and he increased charges for telephone calls, telegrams and he even attacked the modest 2½d. stamp and increased the price to 3d. That was not enough. He increased motor drivers' licences as well. He then attacked the income of the principal people of this country, the farmers, and sought by every means to depress prices and bring still more poverty to their doors.

In that regard I want to condemn emphatically what I can describe only as a ramp on both sides of the Channel to create an artificial scare that the prices of cattle and sheep will tumble in the near future due to the fact that Britain is going off the ration. I think that is nothing short of a scandalous ramp with no foundation in fact aimed at one thing only—to reduce the farmers to the particular state they were in before—producing food whether they got economic prices for it or not. That has been in operation for the last 20 years and it has shown terrible results and the havoc it has caused can be seen throughout the Irish countryside where you have nothing but vacant houses all over the place.

The cost of living has gone up so much that I must admit that I do not know how the ordinary worker living in a town, paying for practically everything but the fresh air and sunlight, can make ends meet or keep food on the table for his family or pay his normal outgoings on small wages.

Industries were just let sink or swim. The alcohol factories are the very latest, and they are gone down. I remember during my time in office—to speak of a purely local matter—a bacon factory in Castlebar established a canning industry employing 170 people over and above what were usually employed. That flourished excellently during the period of the inter-Party Government but from the very moment when the present Government came in, it was only some months later when these 170 employees in Castlebar were told to go home and that there was no work for them. That is only one instance I am quoting. There is another factory in Castlebar at the moment that has given notice to 14 of its employees that they are to be laid off. In every forestry centre the young men have been told to go home, that there is no more work for them.

Comment on this

There are more men employed in forestry work now than ever before in the history of forestry in Ireland.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows nothing about it.

Comment on this

What is a fact—"that the Parliamentary Secretary knows nothing about it?"

Comment on this

If there are more men employed in forestry now why is deputation after deputation coming to the Minister for Lands asking him to retain men in employment who have been given notice that they would be laid off?

Comment on this

There are permanent and temporary men.

Comment on this

What answer has the Parliamentary Secretary to that?

Comment on this

And temporary Parliamentary Secretaries.

Comment on this

I am grateful to Deputy Sweetman for that remark. It is in keeping with Deputy Flanagan's remark yesterday.

Comment on this

It has no reference to it.

Comment on this

It is in keeping with some other remarks that were made yesterday.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary may be getting vexed, but the fact is that men are being laid off all over the country. Of course, we are going to spend £2,000,000 on the rebuilding of Dublin Castle. Of what interest is that to the people in the West of Ireland, to the people from Donegal to Cork? I am sure they will feel very happy, even though they go to bed hungry when they know that a magnificent Dublin Castle is to be rebuilt. I am sure that, when the Taoiseach comes to the West, he will tell them all about it.

Comment on this

I will tell them the truth.

Comment on this

We are not able to see the full implications of how the rebuilding of Dublin Castle is going to benefit the people in the West of Ireland. I am sure that the Taoiseach will be able to enlighten them on the subject when he goes there. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance seem to be enjoying to a great extent the hardships——

Comment on this

We do find you funny. That is what you are complaining about.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is a happy man with a salary of over £2,000 a year. He does not feel the pinch, but what about the 9,000 people in Cork who voted for his Party at the last election two and a half years ago and turned against him the other day? I am sure that all these were not fooled, and that it was not for fun that they made the change. The same thing will occur in practically every other constituency when the general election comes. It is all very fine to laugh at what I am saying under the privilege and shelter of the four walls of this Chamber. But another day will come, and I will take very good care to say these things when it comes. I believe that the Minister will then be conveniently occupied in some more congenial air than in approaching those people whom he has blistered out of existence since he came into office.

The Minister now calmly proposes to bring in a Budget on the 22nd April. I dare say there will be certain relaxations in it, but personally I think the day is long past when the people will bother their heads. We are supporting this motion purely because we believe that the basic industry of the country has been cruelly wronged, deliberately strangled and punished without cause. That has been the case all down the years. We are supporting the motion in the hope that a general election will provide a change of Government, and I think there is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Will you join the Government?

Comment on this

The people have been suffering as a result of the insecurity created by the present Government. They were told that the food subsidies would not be cut and that certain taxes would not be put on. They changed face, however, a short time after they got back. The country was alarmed by the statements made by both the Minister for Finance and the Tánaiste. The people of the country were scared out of their minds by the statements that we had left the country in debt. That went on for two or three months, and lots of people believed it, until, one day, the Minister for Finance was forced to admit, in reply to a parliamentary question, that, instead of leaving the country in debt, we had left £30,000,000 of unspent Marshall Aid moneys. That little man over there benefited by that when he came in. That was what was handed over to him by Deputy McGilligan when he came in.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for a Deputy to ascribe to another member of this House what is a palpable untruth? There was no such figure as £30,000,000 in the Marshall Aid Fund, or in any other fund left by the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

There was £24,000,000 and £6,000,000 of grant moneys.

Comment on this

That disposes of that.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order. That is an untruth. There was £24,000,000 of the loan and £6,000,000 of the grant moneys.

Comment on this

Which had been spent.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride, when he was Minister for External Affairs, was largely responsible for getting that free gift of £6,000,000 for this country. To-day, in reply to a question, the Minister for Agriculture told us that he is now applying for permission to use that money. The outgoing Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, in our Government, handed you £30,000,000. You have told us that inside six months after taking office, you had the whole of the £24,000,000 scuttled. I believe that the present Minister for Finance was capable of that. We had been scraping and saving and we had brought the country to a grand pitch of prosperity, but all that we had gathered up, the present Minister for Finance proceeded to scatter with a shovel. That brought about a panic and a great feeling of insecurity. The man who has been Prime Minister stands over these misstatements, although I think he himself was very careful not to make them. He said that we had left the country in debt, and that it was an awful thing we had done. I agree with him that, if we had left the country in debt, it would be a shocking thing for any Government to do. However, a short time afterwards, the Minister proceeded to float a loan of £25,000,000 at 5 per cent., and, in less than 12 months, another loan of £21,000,000 at 4½ per cent., making a total of £46,000,000. The average man is not so blind or such a fool as not to see these things, to see the Taoiseach one day defending the charge that we had left the country in debt and then seeing him sink the country in a debt of £46,000,000 inside of 12 months. When the people see these things, they know quite well that there is something radically wrong.

We had a statement from the Taoiseach on Sunday week in Louth to the effect that the Dáil would not be dissolved, that they had a majority and that it would not be dissolved. He said that they had a majority, and that there would not be an election because, he said, we have a majority in the Dáil. But four days afterwards, in a fit of pique when he gets the result of the Cork election, he blows fire and brimstone out of his nostrils and says: "Oh! bedad, we will not have any of this from the Cork people." Who were they to say that to him? The next thing we learned was that we were going to have the two letters "T.D." taken from our names, and that overnight we were going to make preparations for an election. The next thing that happened was that he got cold feet on the job and put it off.

Comment on this

It was the back benchers who got the cold feet.

Comment on this

They got a hell of a fright. The feeling, the impression, that has been created amongst the people of the country is that they cannot rely on anything that comes from the Government side of the House at the present time. That is a very serious matter. I want to tell the Taoiseach that, after all, whatever our faults may be, we are the elected representatives of the people and the people trust us to come in here and look after their interests. The first things they demand are truth, solidity and integrity. They do not elect a Party that goes out and promises to do something, gets elected on that promise and then fails to carry out the promise. A violent change is created in the average voter when he finds a person gets into office on a certain promise and then turns round and rejects or goes back on that promise, without even an explanation in many cases. That creates a very bad impression.

I hope the Taoiseach will accept the motion as it stands, dissolve the Dáil and give the people the earliest possible opportunity of recording their verdict. As I said at the outset, I do not like an election. I do not think any Deputy likes an election, but duty is duty, and, since the Taoiseach and his Minister have brought the country to such a pass, the proper thing is to hand the formation of the Government of the country over to those who are best qualified to judge; that is, the average voter in town and country all over Ireland.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick has just told us he does not like an election. He would like it even less if it took place next week. We all know that.

Comment on this

Try.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick, who has been swallowed—

Comment on this

Some mouthful!

Comment on this

Some swallow! I would not like to have to get him down in one go.

Comment on this

Did you not do that with the Republic?

Comment on this

Fine Gael in 1948 were going to move closer to the Empire but, instead, they became the red, roaring Republican Party, and the Deputy—

Comment on this

We can swallow a lot after 16 years of Fianna Fáil, but we could not swallow Deputy Blowick in one bite.

Comment on this

The Deputy was going to come closer to the Commonwealth in 1948, but his Leader went over to Canada and declared they were the red, roaring Republican Party, and they swallowed Deputy Blowick who was also the leader of an Empire Party.

Comment on this

So the farmers are traitors now. They are political traitors. We will see what the Wexford farmers will have to say to that. I suppose the Deputy will stuff them into jail again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Blowick allow Deputy Allen to make his speech?

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick was swallowed up by Fine Gael long ago though Deputy Blowick had assured the Irish people on several occasions that he would never be swallowed.

Comment on this

I never did because I have always believed there is no one big enough to swallow me.

Comment on this

There are no sharks here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

It is interesting to recall the speech made by Deputy Blowick as reported in the Connacht Telegraph on 3rd January, 1948, when he said:—

"We went in there to the Dáil as a Farmers' Party, the only real Farmers' Organisation in the present Dáil and we hope to overcome a nasty odour as three other previous Farmers' Parties had been swallowed by Fine Gael."

Comment on this

Did I say anything about the Ballina biscuit factory?

Comment on this

Three other Farmers' Parties had been swallowed by Fine Gael, and that was a nasty odour. I wonder what kind of an odour permeates Fine Gael now?

Comment on this

After they have swallowed Deputy Blowick.

Comment on this

They have swallowed Deputy Blowick and the odour has increased.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not take that line. He is making Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll and Deputy Cogan very uncomfortable there behind him.

Comment on this

Immediately Fianna Fáil became the Government of this country Fine Gael changed the name of their Party. Not alone that, but they changed the name of their leader and they changed their friends all at the one time. Deputy Blowick joined that bad odour, the Party that will be the Government of the country in a few days, God bless the mark!

Comment on this

No—please God!

Comment on this

They will be the Government if only the people will select them. I have no doubt that if the Taoiseach had decided last Thursday night to go to the country, or even last night, we would have had an outcry from the Parties opposite.

Comment on this

Not likely!

Comment on this

We would have had an outcry from Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy MacEoin just as we had outcries in the past. I heard more wailing and whinging here from the Fine Gael Party after every general election than from anyone else because they were taken unawares; they did not get enough time. They will have enough time now and we will see what they will do in a few weeks. They have got full warning and I invite them to go to the country and do their best; and if they come back as the Government of the country there will not be any Fascist Blueshirts organised by the Opposition to prevent the Government from functioning.

Comment on this

That is something to know, anyway. I take it that is a promise.

Comment on this

There will not be any Blueshirts should there happen to be a change. We in this House remember a few things. We remember the effort to prevent the Government functioning. We remember the efforts made by the Opposition at that time, by Deputy MacEoin and Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy McGilligan, who were closely associated, to prevent the Oath of Allegiance being taken out of the Constitution—the Oath of Allegiance to a British King?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is that the oath you swallowed?

Comment on this

We remember that quite well. We remember the army that was organised to prevent that happening.

Comment on this

Do you remember when the Taoiseach told you I met an English Minister to get guns?

Comment on this

Indeed, you did. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not seem to have any bearing on this motion.

Comment on this

It is only a troubled conscience that has its memory troubled.

Comment on this

It is a good thing to have a conscience, even if it is troubled.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It was Deputy Mulcahy who made it perfectly safe for Deputy Allen to speak in this House.

Comment on this

There are a lot of things Deputy Mulcahy would like this country to forget.

Comment on this

There are a lot of things I would like to tell the Deputy were it not for the appeal made by Deputy Costello earlier to-day.

Comment on this

There are a lot of appeals to forget the past and not to look back on the form of the past.

Comment on this

The Deputy finds it hard to do that.

Comment on this

In reference to this appeal from the Leader of Fine Gael and his colleagues to forget the past, a man said to me the other day: "If you only had a greyhound running in a race you would look up his breeding and his form, and then assess the form he might be expected to have; you would do the same with a horse."

Comment on this

So you would, and the Deputy should look up the form and the breeding.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

You would look up the form in the hope of assessing the placing.

Comment on this

I seem to be having a bad effect on Deputy Allen. I shall give him an opportunity of getting back to the subject.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

And take your past with you.

Comment on this

And the odour.

Comment on this

We will have a look at the past now.

Comment on this

I will not find it as big a burden to me as the Minister for External Affairs' past is to him.

Comment on this

Is it in order on the discussion of this motion to try to discuss the antecedents or family relationships of different members of the House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think there has been any question of antecedents or family. I have asked Deputy Allen to come to the motion.

Comment on this

It would be a long time before I would make any personal reference to any member of the House. I do not believe I have done that.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Deputy tried this in Cork and Louth and he saw the result. This is excellent propaganda. Continue it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I was referring to Parties in the past, including the Fine Gael Party. Deputy MacBride has no Party now. He is just a stool pigeon. He does not count any longer.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think the Deputy should refer to another Deputy as a stool pigeon.

Comment on this