Dissolution of Dáil—Motion.
Contributions 175–329 of 483. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Deputy Costello's motion is that the Dáil be dissolved forthwith. He gives as the reason for that motion the fact that the Government had an adverse vote in two recent by-elections. That was the main reason given. No motion was moved on prior occasions and nothing has happened since this Government took office three years ago to influence the situation and the Opposition Party did not see any reason on previous occasions to move such a motion at any time in the last three years until now. That is the reason they gave. If the Taoiseach had not given any indication of a general election we would not have had any such motion. The Fine Gael Party and the other Opposition Parties were not anxious or ready for an election.
Comment on this
I am sure that is what you said at the Fianna Fáil meeting.
Comment on this
We are concerned that every democratic Party organised in this country should get a fair opportunity and that the people should get a fair opportunity of understanding every detail of their policy. We would be delighted with that. As a member of this House I can recall an occasion —I am sure Deputy MacEoin and Deputy Morrissey can recall it also— during the term of office of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government— Fine Gael had another name then— when there were two very adverse results of by-elections, but the then Taoiseach was not so democratically minded as the present Taoiseach and he did not go to the country. He had not a majority in the House of his own Party, very far from it. Cumann na nGaedheal never had a majority in this House yet.
Comment on this
There is one important aspect of this matter that influenced the Government. One of the reasons that influenced the Taoiseach and the Government in postponing the election for a few weeks was this fact. It is well known to some members of the Opposition that we are just on the eve of the spring sowing of the largest tillage area we have had in this country for many hundreds of years. The farmers have made a magnificent response to the appeal of the Government and the Minister for Agriculture to give the country increased tillage. All over the country we see very significant indications that we are going to have the largest area under tillage that was ever seen in the Twenty-Six Counties. The farmers who are concerned about having their crops sown in the next three or four weeks should be given an opportunity without any distraction of doing their best to have that tillage area sown for the nation. It is most important for the economy of the country, irrespective of what Government may be in power, that good crops well sown should be produced. We are going to have the largest area that was ever under tillage. The farmers are busy with that and great numbers of them are interested in the policy of the Government. They are interested in taking part in this election and they should be given an opportunity, after having sown that large area of tillage, of taking their full part in the election, whatever side they may take. We have not heard Deputy Dillon, who claims to be interested in the farmers, speak yet. The busiest seasons for the farmer are the sowing season and the harvest. The sowing season is a critical and difficult period and it is most important that the farmers should have their crops sown before the growth comes. That is full and ample justification for not having the election at the present time.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary knows very well that if a man is in a tillage field all day he has had enough work for that day. He should be able to take his full part in the election. It was quite plain when Deputy Blowick was speaking that he was embarrassing the Front Bench of Fine Gael. He referred to milk prices and the efforts of the farmers a few years ago to have them increased. I have no doubt that we will have some leaders on the Front Bench opposite getting up and pointing out that one of the sins of this Government is that butter and milk have gone up in price in the cities and towns. They will not go down where the milk is produced and point that out. They will not tell the people in Dublin, Cork, or any other city or town that the farmers are entitled to an economic price for the milk they produce and send to the creamery which is afterwards made into butter. They will not tell the city-dwellers that for every pound of butter which they can buy for 4/2 the farmers are paid 3/9 for the milk that produces that pound of butter. None of them will say to the townsman that the farmers are getting too much for their milk. They will not go down the country and say that. They dare not do it. If any member of the Party opposite will say that the farmers are getting too much for their milk, that will be proof of whether butter is too dear or not.
Let us have some honesty about the price of milk and butter. Is the farmer getting too much for his milk or is he not? That is an important matter for the Party that claims they are going to be the Government of the country. It is important that they should make a public pronouncement on it, and the sooner it is made the better. They should also make a pronouncement as to whether or not the price the farmers are getting for wheat this year is too high or whether it should be substantially reduced in order to give a cheaper loaf to the people. That is also an important matter. They might also, when telling the people that the subsidies were done away with by Fianna Fáil, tell them that, in the present year, in order to allow the loaf to be sold at its present price, the taxpayers are contributing about £6,000,000 or £7,000,000. The people in the towns, I am sure, will be told that we could buy cheaper wheat in Canada, Australia or America, and that it would be far better for the economy of the country to allow all the land to remain in grass and buy all our wheat abroad. Deputy Morrissey understands this matter, and I am sure he will not get up in this House, or anywhere else, and say the farmers are getting too much for their wheat, that it would be good national economy to import all our wheat. But Deputy Dillon, time after time in this House, has said so. He prayed to God that he would see the day when wheat, beet and turf would go up the spout. That is the pronouncement he made and repeated time after time.
At the general election, we want frank and full discussion. We want honesty, and the people should be informed of all the factors that go to make up the cost of living and the price of bread or butter or anything else. Time should be given to the people to bring all these factors to their notice. That is all-important. I hope that Fine Gael will assist the farmers of this country by showing the townspeople that the farmer is getting 3/9 for the milk which is going into the butter for which they pay 4/2. I hope they will also tell the people the price the farmer is getting for his wheat to enable him to pay his labour, his rates and his other taxes. He has to get £4 a barrel to grow wheat in the present year. It could be indicated by the Party opposite during the coming election whether it is Fine Gael policy that the price of wheat is too dear. We would like to hear from them whether the price the farmer is getting for growing beet is too high— that he is getting too much and that we could produce sugar cheaper by giving farmers less for growing beet. These are all-important matters. I have not a bit of doubt that in the cities and towns Fine Gael will make every possible effort to mislead the people who depend for their very existence on the prosperity of the rural community and to try to show them that if they vote in a certain way they will have cheaper bread, sugar and butter—at the expense of whom, we would like to know. Is it going to be at the expense of the farmers?
These are some of the important matters affecting the economy of this nation upon which the people will be asked to vote in the coming election. They will also be asked about some other items that went to increasing the cost of Government. It was necessary to provide money for the Social Welfare Act, which is now fully in operation, and they will be asked to consider how much it takes to finance that Act. I am sure that every Party in the House will claim some credit for supporting that Act and for the fact that none of them voted against it, but if it costs so much to finance it the money has got to be obtained in some way and no doubt they will explain that to the people.
The Health Act is not fully in operation yet but parts of it are. I am sure it will be explained to the country whether in the opinion of Fine Gael or the Labour Party that Act is for the benefit of the poorer sections of the community or whether it will serve their needs. They may challenge it. They challenged it before in this House. The chief Opposition Party challenged it for many reasons, but on the question of the cost I doubt if they did challenge it.
Comment on this
They will be able to point out that they did not even vote against the Final Stage. Already some Fine Gael Deputies are pressing local authorities to get the benefits of that Act into operation as fast as possible —a most extraordinary thing. I am sure that they will explain that when the Act is fully in operation it will cost considerable sums of money and the Minister for Finance, whoever he may be, will need in some way to procure that finance from the people, and that it has meant in the last few years that extra money had to be provided to finance the Health Act.
I am sure that it will also be explained that in order to have rural electrification many millions of borrowed money had to be provided for the E.S.B. Are Fine Gael opposed to that? Are they opposed to borrowing money to provide rural dwellers with the benefit of electricity?
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs is saying something. Is he talking through his top hat?
Comment on this
There are a great many claims about who started rural electrification, but if you want to go back, I suppose, 100 years ago, Thomas Davis talked a lot about the electrification of this country, and Sir John Keane talked a lot about electrification, and many others did before there was any native Government in this country.
Comment on this
Many people gave a lot of thought to providing white power to this country, and there are many documents on record before this House was ever set up advising and advocating that we should have electrification.
These people said that the rivers should be harnessed, and it is no credit to any native Government that we have electrification—none in the world—but it is to the credit of the people who have been paying for it out of their savings and otherwise.
Comment on this
The chief Opposition should explain to the people that the full cost of rural electrification plus electrification of the towns is going to be in the neighbourhood of almost £80,000,000. That should be fully explained, and that a big portion of the borrowed money of the last few years has gone into rural electrification.
We hear complaints about the spendthrift Government and high taxation, but they should explain to the people also that many millions of pounds have been put into housing the people —many millions of borrowed money. The housing programme is not finished yet. It will take another five or ten years before it is completed, at least in many areas, and before the housing programme is at an end many millions of pounds will have been sunk in it. Fully 80 per cent. of the total population in this country when the first native Government was set up had to be rehoused. All these are important matters which I am sure will be explained. I am sure that the Opposition will also tell the people that considerable amounts of borrowed money had to be provided for organising three extra sugar factories and that they were a good proposition. They might mention incidentally in a whisper to the crowd that one of the chief leaders of their Party had stumped this country for many years advocating that these beet factories should be blown up and that it would be cheaper to buy beet sugar or cane sugar from Cuba rather than grow beet here. They might whisper that to the populace when they are talking about this borrowed money and where it is going. It has all been invested in this country in the interests of the Irish people, to provide them with better houses, with electrification of town and country, to provide them with sugar beet factories, with cement factories and with turf.
Comment on this
They might also whisper how we converted our native turf into electric power and, when they are talking about the money invested by Fianna Fáil and under Fianna Fáil, they might point out that this was a scheme inaugurated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass. We are quite proud of that scheme. It has provided employment for many thousands of people. Many millions of money have been invested in organising these schemes. These are factors which the Opposition might consider. They, I am sure, like to see a well-organised, well-conducted community and I feel they will do their part in educating the people as to where the people's money has gone.
Comment on this
They will point to the fact that these drains which the Deputy has in mind—indeed, which he has got on his brain—were the drains constructed under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. The money went down the drain under that Act all during the time that the Coalition Government were in office.
Comment on this
You are forgetting all about the Minister who said it would be a good thing for this country if every damn ship was at the bottom of the sea and who appealed to the people to burn no British coal.
Comment on this
We all hope that that prophecy of the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Aiken, will be realised in a few short years when we get our turf resources and our water power resources developed to the full and to the point when we shall be completely independent of British coal. We shall have no need to burn any of it then.
Comment on this
Thank God, the day will come—even if we do not see it, I am sure younger men will see it—when we shall have sufficient resources developed from native fuel to provide us with heat, light and power.
Comment on this
There is still the American coal in the Park brought in by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It is hoped that any Government in power in this country will be in a position to provide sufficient capital to enable the full organisation of that great industry to be continued. A Bill was circulated this morning under which it is proposed to provide capital up to 1961 to enable the E.S.B. to develop our turf resources, to use Arigna coal and to put the country in the position in which it will not be dependent for an electricity supply upon foreign fuel. That was the method adopted by the Coalition when they were in office.
Comment on this
It is well known that the Coalition gave the E.S.B. directions to go ahead with the erection of two coal stations.
Comment on this
I have been slightly annoying the Opposition. I am trying to remind them of some of the duties they owe to the community if they claim to be responsible citizens and to be persons to whom the country could entrust or might entrust—the wish is father to the thought in their case— the Government of the country. If they claim to be responsible persons, coming before the country and asking the people to give them their confidence, to elect them in such numbers that they might form a Fine Gael Government, independent of Labour or other satellites, they have a duty to inform the people of certain facts. The hope of Fine Gael is to have a full Fine Gael cabinet. I am sure that in the course of the election campaign they will explain in every single respect where all the money borrowed by Fianna Fáil for the last few years was invested—that it was invested for the benefit of the Irish people, for the production of electricity, for the production of turf, for housing, beet, et cetera. These are big capital investments. Unfortunately, if you like, some of them are social investments, in so far as that for a great number of years they will not pay any actual cash dividends, but they will pay dividends in the long run in the health and prosperity of the nation.
When we took over the Government here, we had to try to overcome the conditions brought about by years of neglect. There had been practically no capital development for hundreds of years. As I say, we had to provide capital for the housing of our people. That was an investment that will not pay any cash dividends to the Exchequer, but it will pay dividends by way of the improved health of the community. I am sure that when Deputy Mulcahy goes down the country to seek votes in a rural community, namely, South Tipperary, he will tell the rural community down there that, when he was Minister for Local Government in a former Government, he told Dáil Éireann that until the workers of the country were prepared to accept less wages and to work harder, and until the builders' providers were prepared to take less profit, we could have no rural housing in this country. That was a statement made by Deputy Mulcahy when he was Minister for Local Government. I am sure he will explain whether his viewpoint or the viewpoint of Fine Gael has changed. The country will remember the stand they took between 1932 and 1939 in this House in opposing every effort made by the then Minister for Finance and the then Minister for Industry and Commerce to provide protection for industry, when they voted hundreds of times against the provision of protection, in the way of tariffs and otherwise, to enable industries to be started in this country. They were bitterly opposed to that.
They will explain also why the Labour Party of that time fully supported Fianna Fáil in their industrial drive. Fine Gael will explain all that away to their own satisfaction, I am sure. They will explain away also their form of the past. They will explain how between 1932 and 1939 they tried to prevent the barriers to complete independence that were in the Treaty from being wiped out—the Oath of Allegiance, the Governor General, the appeals to the Privy Council and the other 26 sections of the British dictated Constitution that was in operation in this country from 1922 to 1939. They will explain all that away. They will explain why they, as a responsible Party seeking the votes of the people, opposed protection for Irish industry and every single effort of this nation to shake off the shackles that they, by their efforts, tied to the ankles of the Irish people between 1922 and 1939. They will also try to explain why they opposed the Constitution that was enacted by the Irish people in 1937 or 1938. There is an explanation of their attitude on these questions due for many years.
Comment on this
They will explain also I am sure, if Deputy O'Leary allows them—I am sure he will help them to explain this——
Comment on this
They will explain why it was, when under the 1938 Agreement with Great Britain the ports of this country were given back—the ports which the British in times of war or strained relations were to occupy under the Treaty; they were also to take possession of the railways and roadways—they belittled the efforts of the Taoiseach to remove these provisions from the Treaty, and why they said that they could have got the ports years before but that they considered the cost of maintenance was too high. There are many other things that are due for explanation. They will also explain why they wanted to rush the election and why they would not give the farmers time to sow the biggest tillage crop, under Tom Walsh, Minister for Agriculture, ever grown in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to get a new record for the general election. That one is worn out.
Comment on this
This is the first occasion in my experience in this House upon which I have found that there is complete agreement between both sides of the House on a major political question. There is apparently now complete agreement that there should be a general election. This agreement apparently arose by reason of the results of nine different by-elections, culminating in the two most recent ones. The Taoiseach, presumably realising that he lost the confidence of the country, or that this House had lost the confidence of the country, then decided that there should be a general election, as soon as the urgent financial business was disposed of.
So far, we reach a position where at least there was complete agreement that the country had lost confidence in this House and in the Government and that a general election had to take place. In view of that, it does seem incomprehensible that, once that admission was made, the election should be delayed. Our Constitution, as, indeed, the Constitutions of, I think most other countries, provides that, when the Government or the Parliament is deemed to have lost the confidence of the people, it should be dissolved within a specified period of time. I think our Constitution provides that that should take place within three to four weeks.
I know that the Taoiseach is strictly within his legal rights in declining to dissolve the Dáil until he is actually defeated in the House by a vote of the House, but I suggest that it is amounting somewhat to sharp practice for the Government to continue in office and to decline to dissolve the Dáil when the Taoiseach has admitted on their behalf, on behalf of the Government, that the Dáil and the Government have lost the confidence of the people. It does seem to me that the proper course to adopt as soon as the Government is forced into a position of admitting that it has lost the confidence of the people is to dissolve the Dáil and go to the country. Certainly, it would be acting in accordance with the spirit of the Constitution and the recognised constitutional usage in most countries if that were done.
I think, indeed, that that must have been the Taoiseach's original intention when he made his announcement last Thursday night. At that time, I think the Taoiseach must have contemplated an immediate dissolution of the Dáil, and that it was only as a result of other advice he got, no doubt from some of his Party managers, that, on second thoughts, he decided to postpone the evil day for as long as possible and, certainly, until he had introduced a Budget.
My objection to the postponement of the election is, first, that the Government, having admitted impliedly that it had lost the confidence of the people, or, to put it even at its lowest, that there was some doubt whether this Parliament had the confidence of the people, it then becomes indecent for this Dáil and for the Government to remain without seeking the views of the people. Secondly, it is quite obvious that the next ten weeks will be wasted, so far as public business in this Dáil is concerned, that this Dáil will become for the next ten weeks a market-place on which each different political Party will seek to peddle their political wares. It will become a cross-roads election platform and will be a complete waste of public time and public expenditure.
We have already had yesterday and to-day a number of samples of the type of speeches we will get and which we will probably get from both sides of the House. We had a sample from Deputy Allen, who is himself a decent man, but who apparently thinks it necessary, when he comes into the House, to make an election speech in preparation for an election, to try to refight the civil war and to try to cast aspersions on the pedigree and antecedents of different Deputies. That comes from Deputy Allen, whom I regard as one of the decent men in this House. It is quite obvious that there can be no reasonable discussion here from now until the election, that the House will be just a political platform, and, God knows, this Parliament is already held in sufficient contempt by the public generally by reason of the type of speeches and the type of things said in the House day in and day out.
It is quite obvious that the situation will become much worse if this House is to sit for another ten weeks with an election in the offing, and, no matter how well-intentioned Deputies may be, they will be unable to resist the temptation to use the Dáil as a platform for their election campaign. That will be done on both sides of the House, so that, so far as the people are concerned, it will merely result, first, in a waste of public money and public time, because, whether we like it or not, we are public servants being paid by the public to discharge the business of the nation. We are not being paid to come here to play Party politics. We have a specific task to do and, in my view, it would be indecent and nearly fraudulent for the Parliament to remain in office for another ten weeks when we, all of us, know in our heart of hearts that this Parliament will be used for the sole purpose of preparing the ground for an election campaign by the different Parties. We know that no useful business of any kind will be conducted. We know, too, that the type of discussion, speech and interjection that will take place here in the course of the next ten weeks will only serve to bring public life and Parliament into greater contempt and disrepute than it is already held in by the people, and probably with good justification.
My third reason for opposing any postponement of the election—I am trying to discuss this on the merits of that issue and that issue alone—is that it is quite obvious that not only will the time of this Dáil be wasted during the next ten weeks but that the whole time of the Government will also be wasted. I am not saying that in criticism of this particular Government more than any other Government in a democratic country, but it is quite obvious that the Government, instead of being the Executive administering the affairs of the nation, will become the election committee of a political Party and that the whole machinery of Government will for the next ten weeks be used practically exclusively for the purpose of building up the election machinery and the election platform of one political Party.
That is the reason why our Constitution, like the Constitutions of most other countries, provides a maximum and a minimum period of time in which Parliament can continue after it has lost the confidence of the people, and no Government can continue after it has lost the confidence of the Dáil. It is admitted, or implied, if not directly, by the Government—there is certainly complete agreement as far as the Opposition is concerned—that they and Parliament have lost the confidence of the people.
It would seem grossly indecent, therefore, that we should continue to maintain in office a Government which is to act, in effect, as the election committee of a political Party for the next ten weeks We know that for the next ten weeks the only question that will agitate the mind of every single member of the Government, every single Minister from the Taoiseach down, and of every single Parliamentary Secretary will be: "How can I use my office and my position in order to try and ensure the return either of my Party or of myself at the next election?"
I am not saying that in criticism of Fianna Fáil. Inevitably, any political Party will approach a situation of this kind in the same way. Therefore, the postponement of the election is really, in effect, a way of placing at the disposal of one political Party a readymade election machine which would be paid for by the people in public time. During that period, it is quite obvious that the affairs of the nation will only receive secondary or casual consideration, that every Department of State, every Minister and every Parliamentary Secretary will be mainly concerned with the question of how he can utilise his position in order to try and secure a political advantage in the coming general election.
Having regard to these factors, I do urge strongly on the Taoiseach and the Government to reconsider their opposition to this motion and accept it. I have refrained from trying to deal with the various election speeches that have already been made in this House. I should like just to say this. I issue it as a word of warning to the Government and also to the other Parties in this House. I think that, by and large, the people of the country have no great confidence in this House. I think we should have a sense of responsibility towards them by trying to behave ourselves at least with some degree of responsibility and we should try and set them a better example than we have in the past.
What the people of the country want is an efficient and competent Government. I think they are sick and tired of these internal wrangles about the civil war and about personalities of one kind or another. I think what the people of the country really want is a national Government with certain fixed objectives, such as the ending of Partition, the development of our resources and the saving of the Gaeltacht. We should at least in any discussion we have here seek to minimise the degree of rancour and bitterness that continually mar political discussion. That is one of the reasons why I should like to see this Dáil dissolved as soon as possible.
I think that the Government and the Taoiseach would render a service to the country if they would accept that viewpoint even though they have committed themselves now not to have a dissolution. They know in their heart of hearts that the country wants a change of Government. They certainly want a change of Parliament. In view of that, it is indecent to try and hold on for an extra few weeks in order to execute a political manoeuvre based on a Budget to be issued two or three days before the election. It is a political manoeuvre which will have a damaging effect on the nation and also on the Party which is responsible for it.
Comment on this
When Deputy MacBride assumes the rôle of sky pilot, one has to beware. Whenever he wants to put across a very dirty political idea against his opponents he dons the robes of a preacher.
Comment on this
It is not to-day or yesterday he carried on that game. He has been at it for a number of years and, indeed, he was very successful in it at the beginning. The Deputy will remember that a candidate of his won a by-election in 1947. With scurrilous propaganda, innuendo and slanders, they succeeded in reducing the Fianna Fáil vote in North Tipperary to 17,000 votes in 1947. The Taoiseach announced that there was going to be a general election some time after and, in Tipperary, the vote went up from 17,000 to 29,000. We know that Deputy MacBride's candidate, who won at that time, disappeared from the House, and the vote that Deputy MacBride got by his tactics in 1947 disappeared like snow off a ditch once the matter was fully discussed.
Comment on this
Of course it shook us, but there is an old saying: "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me." I do not think that the Irish people will be fooled twice by the same sort of game that the Coalition played in 1948 and the game they played from 1948 on. The people voted in these two by-elections from the irritations against the Government, but when the issue is placed squarely before them, not as to whether a son of an ex-Deputy is going to be elected but as to what sort of Government they want in this country for the next five years, they will take a longer and a much more sensible view of the situation before they vote. It would not surprise me that the same thing will happen as happened in Tipperary between 1947 and a few months later in 1948 when the Fianna Fáil vote went up from 17,000 to 29,000. But whether it does or not the people are entitled to know what sort of Government the Opposition propose to take over from Fianna Fáil. If they do not know what sort of Government, it is merely dictatorship of a number of groups, of a number of conspirators.
For two days the Opposition speakers have avoided most carefully giving any indication of what they would do in regard to the services provided for in the Book of Estimates or by what means they would collect the money to pay for those services if they were given the responsibility of Government or if, having sought authority to speak for the people on various policies, they came together in secret to make a bargain and form a Government. If the proposition is that these groups should get together after an election to agree upon a policy, surely the people have the right to know and get some indication as to what that policy is going to be and what the agreement and the bargains are going to be.
Deputy Costello said that after the election "some sort of Government would be formed" by the groups in opposition. Those were his words—"some sort of Government will be formed from this side of the House," but what the people want to know is what sort that "some sort" will be. What are they going to do with the Book of Estimates? Are they going to spend the money that Fianna Fáil proposes and if they are going to spend the money how are they going to collect it? There are two ways of meeting the bill of £108,000,000 plus whatever is to be spent on the Central Fund Account. One is to cut down the services for which provision is made in the Book of Estimates and the other is to raise the money for them. There are two ways of raising the money; one is to tax for the current expenditure and the other is to borrow or in some way to create it.
I know that Deputy Dillon and a few of the sly merchants in the Opposition have their eye on that £71,000,000 that the Central Bank has. They want to use it as they used the Marshall Aid money and other moneys to support them in a borrowing campaign that the people will not support. For three years they avoided taxation and borrowed from Marshall Aid and Government funds to meet ordinary current expenses. They are looking around for another fund and Deputy Dillon has put his finger on this £71,000,000. He has been going around the country telling people that there is £71,000,000 which they are going to take from the Central Bank and invest in Government securities. That is their plan. They are going to leave the Central Bank and Government funds without any reserves or securities except Irish Government securities. They will make them translate these British Government securities into Irish Government securities. Where the Central Bank is to get the reserves to meet the day-to-day clearings, the demand for notes, and so on, is not their business.
It is known and well known that if a group came in here and deprived the Central Bank and the Government funds of these reserves which they have that they are merely tying this country hand and foot to the ordinary commercial banks. We can only spend the £71,000,000 once. The Central Bank under orders from Deputy McGilligan could get rid of this "waste paper" as he used to call it and invest it in Government securities in order to carry out some of the crackpot policies that would be put forward to them. They did that once. £30,000,000 a year was added to the dead-weight debt and the country is paying £4,000,000 a year and will for the next 40 years pay for the deficit financing of the previous Government in a time of inflation. I would not put it past the present Government——
Comment on this
I would not put it past the Coalition Government to repeat their performance of 1948 and to reduce the tax on cigarettes and to reduce the tax on beer. We tell the people quite candidly that the difference between a Fianna Fáil Budget and a Budget produced by a Coalition, that has to bargain in order to keep the groups together, may be the level of the taxation on beer, cigarettes, and so on, but it is the difference for one year, because the next year the people must pay in some way. If the present taxpayers are not prepared to meet the outgoings of the Government in current taxation, then they have to meet it by raising the interest and sinking fund on the debt, which is the substitute. I want to know, and the people are entitled to know, if the Coalition Government are going to get rid of all this austerity, of charging what is being charged on cigarettes and tobacco, charging what is necessary to keep the current expenditure going, if they are going to get rid of the austerity and of paying their way what is the alternative? Are they going to add another £90,000,000 on to the dead-weight debt, another £4,000,000 a year for the next 40 years to pay for the debts they created in order to avoid doing their clear duty to pay the current expenses of government?
Comment on this
It is like going into the bar and calling for drinks for the house, telling the publican to put it on the slate. For three years Deputy McGilligan called for drinks for all the Coalition.
Comment on this
Drinks for all their projects, and they put it on the slate for Fianna Fáil to pay. The result of those three years, in not collecting the normal taxation, which was necessary in an inflationary time to meet their outgoings, is that in this year and every year for the next 40 years the people will be paying £4,000,000 in taxation more than they would otherwise have to pay.
Comment on this
If the people had believed you, you would have won the by-elections with that stuff.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, is to reply on this debate. I want to give him a challenge. Which of the services in this Book of Estimates does he propose to cut? This £108,000,000 is a big sum.
Comment on this
In addition to the £108,000,000, there will be about £12,000,000 for the Central Fund, £4,000,000 of which will be to pay for the debts left by the Fine Gael Coalition.
Comment on this
Of this sum of money, what part is he going to cut down in order to reduce taxation and to give people better times, as the slogan is? Which is he going to cut, to reduce taxation? If he is not going to increase taxation and if he is going to give the services the Labour people want, he will have to get additional money some way. How does he propose to do that? Is he going to proceed on the same old game that left us with £4,000,000 a year for 40 years to pay for his debts?
There is another aspect of the Coalition policy which will have a very permanent effect on the economy of our people. In 1948 Deputy Costello, who was then Taoiseach, came back here and groaned in these benches about the disastrous effect of the unbalanced economy of the country and the way we were going through our external assets. I pointed out before that in the previous year, in 1947, we had reduced our external assets by £30,000,000, after having, in the previous five, built up £160,000,000. Deputy Costello groaned with horror at the fate that was facing the nation because we had decreased the £160,000,000, plus what had been built up before, by £30,000,000. But when it became necessary to maintain their political life and when their deficit financing created a situation in which our external assets were disappearing, they turned and described it as a virtue. They gave the disappearance of our external assets a new name, they called it repatriation. They may call it all the names they wish, whether it is repatriation or dissipation, the result to the Irish people of their few years in office was that they had dissipated or got rid of £59,000,000 of our net external assets in three years. They had set the cards for a further net deficit of £60,000,000. In three or four years they got through £122,000,000 of our net external assets.
That £122,000,000 was more than half of the net external assets that this country had. Remember, those assets do not belong to any Government or to any generation: they belong to the people of this country. They have been built up over many generations and the people are entitled—especially the young people who are growing up— to see that if those assets are realised they are invested in something that will maintain or increase their standard of living and that they are not just frittered away by a Government that refuses to accept its responsibility as a Government. A few people can get together and change the name or nomenclature of a lot of these processes by which the £120,000,000 was used to give the people a good time, a better time and lower taxation.
Comment on this
On that £120,000,000 the country was earning, I suppose, £3,000,000 or £4,000,000. If they get back and spend the remaining part of our net assets, another £100,000,000, it will probably mean another £3,000,000 or £4,000,000.
Comment on this
That means, unless these assets are put into proper productive enterprise, the national income will be decreased by £8,000,000 a year, and that permanently. I would like to know, therefore, from the Leader of the Opposition when he is replying to this debate, and the people have the right to know from him, when he says he is going to "form some sort of Government" out of the groups that are going to come back to this House in opposition to Fianna Fáil——
Comment on this
Unfortunately, they are not going to get the right, because the Opposition groups are going to deny them the right. For two days we have been here discussing a Book of Estimates and we are going to discuss the Budget, with the help of God.
Comment on this
It is not my way. I think to-night we will show you you are not going to get a chance.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan had better keep his mind to himself. Some of the times he discloses it here he discloses a very poor sort of mind.
Comment on this
I want to ask Deputy Costello as the proposed leader of this secret meeting that proposes to "form some sort of Government" what will their policy be in regard to that Book of Estimates?
Comment on this
It is the people who are entitled to know. If there is not a clear-cut answer to that, the people will know that there is something to be concealed, because they have been galloping around the country talking about the high rate of taxation and complaining about the taxation that we are going to impose upon them. We have to raise the amount of money that will meet that bill and the Central Fund Bill. We propose to do it and to show the people how exactly we propose to do it. The money will have to be met in some way. If it is not met in the way that Fianna Fáil propose to raise it, would a new Coalition propose to seize the £71,000,000 in the Central Bank, and seize the £30,000,000 odd that is in Government Funds and spend it to meet the deficit? We know what the result of getting rid of the external assets in the hands of the Central Bank and Government securities would mean. They would simply swell the assets of the ordinary commercial banks. Other countries that have responsible Governments make certain that the reserves of the nation are held by an institution that is under the direct control of the State or under the influence of the State, such as a Central Bank, to which the State appoints directors, and not by institutions such as the ordinary commercial banks. In the United States of America the commercial banks are not allowed to carry gold or foreign exchange. That must be put into the Reserve Bank of the United States of America. In Britain an ordinary bank is not allowed to retain gold or foreign securities. They must hand it over to the Exchange Equalisation Fund.
A few years ago, in Australia, they passed a law prohibiting the ordinary commercial banks holding these funds. They insisted that they should be handed over to the Central Bank of Australia.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride sets himself up as an expert on our Constitution. It is a rather recent interest on his part to know anything about the Constitution, and I am afraid he gave it a very cursory glance. He completely misinterpreted the Constitution in relation to elections and in relation to the time when an election must be declared. The Taoiseach has the right, when he has a majority in the House and is not defeated in the House, to recommend the President to dissolve the Dáil and the President, according to the Constitution, must agree. The Taoiseach has also a right, when defeated in the Dáil, to advise the President to dissolve the Dáil. The President might not agree. There is nothing in the Constitution saying that a Government, if it loses a by-election or two by-election or three by-elections, must dissolve the Dáil. The assumption is that when a Government holds a majority in the House it has not only the legal but the moral right to carry on as a Government.
Every person who has experience of public life in this or any other country knows that often, if a Government is doing its duty, it may become unpopular from time to time and that the people will express their resentment in by-elections but would not repeat their judgment in those by-elections as a clear-cut, considered judgment in a general election. The example that is on the tip of my fingers is North Tipperary, in 1947. The Fianna Fáil vote was reduced to 17,000, and in a couple of months afterwards, in the general election, it went up to 29,000. How would anybody at that time, on the results of the Tipperary and other by-elections, say how the Government stood? After 16 years of office and after having imposed an unpopular Budget in order to meet the additional subsidies that we gave on food at that time, the Government were unpopular and the people took it out of them in the by-elections, but when the general election came along they gave Fianna Fáil as many votes as they ever did and practically as many seats. It was the trickery of Clann na Poblachta and a few of the others, who asked the people to vote for one policy and then combined to impose another, that defeated the object of the people in selecting Fianna Fáil as by far the largest Party in this House. They gave us a majority over the other Parties in 1948, even after these by-elections in which we were defeated. They gave us such a majority that we had more members in our Party than all the organised Parties combined— the two Labour Parties, the two Clanns and Fine Gael.
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride is a great advocate of an all-Party National Government. Deputy MacBride's ambition is to be a member of a Government to which there are no critics.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary must restrain himself. If he wants to say something, he can make a statement but not by way of interruption.
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride is in favour of a National Government to which there is no opposition and in which all Parties will combine. We have heard of single-Party Governments but at least a single-Party Government, allowing no opposition, has to take the responsibilities for its acts before the people and before history. An all-Party Government, over whose acts people have no control from day to day, and week to week, for five years, is the worst from of dictatorship that has ever been proposed because, being composed of all Parties, each group can, like a Coalition, deny responsibility for anything the all-Party Government did for the five years.
It is true that there is an all-Party Government in one country in Europe where the system has worked well, but it has worked well because the people have retained for themselves most of the power and the Government, instead of being an executive and having a Dáil which puts through its legislation, is rather a high-class Civil Service which prepares Bills which are put to the people from week to week or day to day. We know that the Swiss Government is composed of elected members from all Parties, but it is not a Government in our sense of the word.
Comment on this
It cannot pass a Bill through Parliament: it can only do so through a referendum to the people.
Comment on this
I am not saying anything is wrong with it as far as the Swiss are concerned. What Deputy MacBride wants here in our circumstances, where the Dáil has the right to impose taxation and where even the Seanad cannot hold up a Bill for more than three months, is to put in a Government which has no opposition and which has the right to ímpose its will upon the people for five years— and if they had that power for five years, the Lord help the people if they objected or tried to have any other sort of Government in the future. Some folk in this country should have more wit than to allow themselves to be led away by that sort of game and want to have that sort of Government here.
Deputy MacBride says the people have no confidence in this House. Well, they have damn little confidence in Deputy MacBride. He put up 90 candidates after the flash-in-the-pan of 1947, on the bluff that he was going to control the reins of Government. The people threw out, kicked out, 80 of the candidates and he was returned with nine others. When the break-up came in 1951, Deputy MacBride went with his ten good men—not all of them because most of them had seen through him and got rid of him——
Comment on this
He went to the country again. He put up 40 candidates. Himself alone and one other from his Party were returned—and he got in on the twenty-fourth count.
Comment on this
He obtained 2,500 votes on the first count—what any county councillor would get. After all his galloping and parading for years, all he could get in the City of Dublin was less than what a normal person would get in a corporation election.
Comment on this
The Minister was very lucky to be elected himself.
Comment on this
Then he talks about the people lacking confidence in this Dáil. They had very little confidence in him. The people have as much confidence in this Dáil as they have in any other Dáil. They have elected all of us here and we have to carry on the work which we were elected to do. From time to time, groups of them may not like what the Government proposes or sometimes may not like what an Opposition group opposes but, whatever it is, that is the system of government we have whereby to govern ourselves in this country and in my opinion it is as good as that in any other country.
Deputy MacBride said that, from now until the general election, the departmental State offices will be the committee rooms of a Party. Deputy MacBride is judging this Government by his own actions. For three years that did obtain in one office of Government. In one ministerial office, Deputy MacBride had a staff of eight—an office which is now run by two girls. He had a staff of eight employed, not to carry on his work but to take clippings in reference to Deputy Dillon and other political work of that nature. I should like Deputy MacBride to give us the clippings on which State servants were engaged for years— clippings in reference to Deputy Dillon's extravagances. The wheels of fate turned in some queer way so that, instead of Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacBride parting company—as he thought they might—they were brought closer together. The only reason why Deputy MacBride has made that nasty allegation is because he was quite capable of doing it himself and, in fact, did it for three years and had a staff of eight employed in his office which is now run by two girls.
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride had eight people in an office where the ministerial work can be carried out by two girls.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I think it is totally wrong that this House and the taxpayers' money should be used by the Minister for ballyragging. I think that the exhibition we are now having from the Minister for External Affairs is a disgrace.
Comment on this
I should just like to intervene for a moment, a Cheann Comhairle, to give you notice of my intention to raise on the Adjournment to-night, with your permission, the subject matter of Questions Nos. 10 and 11 which have appeared on to-day's Order Paper.
Comment on this
I have not finished yet. Deputy Cafferky raised some point of disorder and I was merely giving way to him. Of course, Deputy Cafferky is now lining up with all the other groups to demand that—instead of waiting for this Budget and giving the people a chance of seeing how the bills are going to be met, and what the propositions are on both sides of the House as to how they should be met—we should have a general election forthwith. If we had declared a general election within these past few days, Deputy Cafferky and all the rest of them would have been denouncing us for rushing the general election. We would have heard remarks about "another midnight ride to the Park"——
Comment on this
Well, we did not rush the election, as they would have described it, and while we gave the people time to think over and consider the proposition, the Opposition was not satisfied. We did not intend them to be satisfied. We intended them to be thoroughly dissatisfied with our decision because we wanted to give them plenty of rope with which to hang themselves.
Deputy Costello talked about the upset to business caused by delaying having a Budget introduced. There were other speakers on the same lines. I need not quote them as everybody remembers them. What is the basis of that argument? The Budget will be introduced, according to our timetable, on 21st April. If we had declared a general electionand held the election, say, around Spy Wednesday or Holy Thursday we would have had the election over in the week before Easter. Then we would have given the usual fortnight for the Dáil to assemble. That would bring us practically to the 1st May, and then any Government coming in would take at least one month to pull itself together to produce a Budget. The Budget, therefore, would come about the end of May or the 1st June. Instead, we are going to have the Budget over by 21st April, five or six weeks before the time the Budget would be over if Deputy Costello's advice was taken. If there is going to be any upset in business pending the Budget which we will produce on 21st April surely there would be ten times as much upset if it were delayed for another five or six weeks. That is just a foolish point that Deputy Costello made.
Comment on this
It will be the right sort of a Budget and it will do a job for the Irish people not alone this year but it will help them and their children to increase their prosperity in the future.
Comment on this
The 1952 Budget did no harm. It was the Budget that the times and financial circumstances demanded.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello said the people would try to anticipate what the Government will do in the Budget on 21st April and that business will be held up until then. As I pointed out, if his advice were followed there would be time to anticipate for another five or six weeks and there would be still further upset to business. I think it is better that there should be some slight delay in the general election in order that all Parties seeking the votes of the people in this election will put their policies before the people. The Budget would have come in any event about that date whether there was an election or not and if there is an upset about the Budget for a few weeks this year we have had the same sort of upset in other years. But one thing that is more important and outweighs any extra upset about the Budget this year is that there should be no uneasiness and upset for the next five years. The people are entitled to know in this general election what sort of Government the Opposition propose to offer them and what sort of policy, economic, financial and social, they propose to implement if they are left in office for a period of five years.
Comment on this
I think we are all glad to see that the knock the Minister for External Affairs got in the by-election in Louth did not do him any harm, but I do not think that any of us can say that it did him any good.
The motion before the House is a simple one—that, in the opinion of the Dáil, Dáil Éireann should be dissolved forthwith. I believe that anyone who has been present at this debate since it began will recognise the need for an early dissolution. The speeches indicate that we are in for a period of intensive electioneering, not for the normal period of three weeks but for eight or nine weeks. This motion is put down because we consider that in the public interest it is better that uneasiness and uncertainty should be ended at the earliest possible moment. At any time in anticipation of a Budget there is a certain amount of speculation. Business, trade, certain aspects of commerce, all look anxiously to the period of the year when a Budget will be introduced and business arrangements, assessments of what may happen, are made by business men in anticipation of changes or otherwise which may be made in the coming Budget. That is normal in any year. It is customary if one examines withdrawals from bond of either tobacco or spirits, to find many examples which indicate that business people decide either to withdraw at the particular time or postpone withdrawals, in order to await the introduction of the Budget. They have to take as a matter of luck whether their speculation at the particular time is correct or not. This year, the circumstances are entirely different. The decision to dissolve the Dáil was taken by the Taoiseach and announced in the statement which he issued on 4th March:—"In view of the results of the two by-elections, I am of the opinion that it is necessary that a general election should be held as soon as the financial measures required to provide for the public services have been completed." Subsequently, that decision was further interpreted to mean that an election would be postponed until after the introduction of the Budget.
In order to consider this matter, we have to reflect on the circumstances in which not merely these two by-elections occurred, but the seven previous by-elections. This Government was elected in 1951 after they had failed to secure a majority from the electorate. Many Deputies heard the Minister for External Affairs a few moments ago describe how the Coalition, or inter-Party, Government was formed. He referred to it as a bargain, as a combination and as a conspiracy. He used all these words to describe what took place. No matter how he describes it, Parties come together and agree to form a Government, but when, in 1951, the present Fianna Fáil Party failed to secure a majority, they sought the votes of certain Deputies outside the Parties and published a 17-point programme. Leaving aside whatever interviews, discussions or talks took place between the representatives of Fianna Fáil and these Deputies, we are told that when other Parties discuss these matters, when they talk about them, meet and come together in order to agree on a common programme and to elect a Government, it is a conspiracy. In fact, one of the phrases used by the Minister for External Affairs was that it was a dictatorship by a number of groups and a conspiracy by these groups, but apparently when Fianna Fáil approach Deputies to secure their support it is an act of statesmanship.
That support was secured on the basis of a 17-point programme published after the election. Point 15 of that programme read that:—
"It was the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government to maintain subsidies, to control the price of essential foodstuffs and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation."
That had followed emphatic declarations by two prominent members of the Fianna Fáil Party during the 1951 election which I propose to refer to in a moment. Both of these declarations emphatically indicated that, if Fianna Fáil were returned to power, they would not reimpose what were known as the penal taxes which had been imposed by the Supplementary Budget of 1947, and which had been repealed by the inter-Party Government. Deputy Lemass, speaking in Cork, is reported in the Sunday Press of the 13th May, 1951, to have said:—
"A Coalition Minister had said that Fianna Fáil, if elected, would increase the taxes on beer and tobacco. Why should such taxes be necessary? There is no such reason why we should impose those taxes."
Deputy MacEntee, speaking in Rathmines Town Hall, is reported in the Independent of the 15th May, 1951, to have said:—
"A number of persons in the licensed trade were spreading the rumour that Fianna Fáil, if returned to power, would reimpose the tax on drink which was imposed by the Supplementary Budget of 1947. There is no truth in such a rumour."
There you have two specific statements referring to a matter which had received much attention, and which, as far as the community were concerned, was of vital import to them, as to how they might cast their votes in the election that was then pending. There was a subsequent statement printed and issued by the Fianna Fáil Party after the results of the election were made known. That statement undertook to maintain the subsidies, to control the price of essential foodstuffs and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation.
A few weeks afterwards Fianna Fáil succeeded in getting into office. There was no Supplementary Budget. The Budget was introduced at the normal time, although in that year it was introduced slightly earlier than usual. They could, of course, do the same this year. In fact, the Budget was introduced on the 2nd April, 1952. That Budget, in flagrant defiance of the promises given by two prominent spokesmen, and in defiance of the statement published after the election, not merely reimposed the taxes that had been repealed by the inter-Party Government but slashed the food subsidies, resulting in increases of 2/1½ on the stone of flour, of 5d. in the price of the 4 lb. loaf, of 10d. a lb. on butter and of 2½d. a lb. on sugar, of an increase in the price of tea from 2/8 to 5/- and ?, the increase ranging from 2/- to 3/10 a lb. according to grade, an increase of 7d. on the packet of cigarettes, of 3d. on the pint, of 6d. on the glass of whiskey, of 4d. on the gallon of petrol and of 1/- on the income-tax.
If there is one decision more than another which the people have given an indication of at all the by-elections which have taken place, it is that they do not want another Fianna Fáil Budget because, in the last two Fianna Fáil Budgets, what happened was this: in the first one fresh taxes were imposed and in the second one they were continued in defiance of expressed statements made less than nine months previously by responsible leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party and with the authority of the Party in a statement published after the election.
Most Deputies are familiar with the line of propaganda that has been pursued by Fianna Fáil and by apologists for it, during the last few months. Following the by-election in North-West Dublin where the Government was defeated by two to one, it was freely stated that the defeat was due to the fact that it was an urban constituency, that there were peculiar local circumstances which secured a majority for the inter-Party candidate and that the same result would not accrue if the elections had been in a rural area. Time went by, and two by-elections were held, one in East Cork and the other in Wicklow, two rural constituencies with, of course, towns in them. Again the lesson of North-West Dublin was reinforced, with a clear indication to anyone who was either present at the count or who examined the preferences when published, namely, that the people supported the various Parties pledged to work and collaborate in an inter-party Government. After expressing their first preferences for Fine Gael or Labour, they then gave their second preference to Fine Gael or Labour, or to other Parties supporting the inter-Party Government, as the case might be. Then Galway occurred and, although Fianna Fáil retained their seat there, the inter-Party vote rose substantially. In every constituency where by-elections have occurred, whether Fianna Fáil held the seat or whether they lost it, the same pattern is quite clear: the inter-Party vote has increased substantially—in some cases, so far as Fianna Fáil is concerned, catastrophically.
Deputies will recollect that when the results of Wicklow and East Cork were declared the Taoiseach issued a statement, in the course of which he said it was difficult for a Party that had only one out of three seats in a general election to hold that seat when there was only one seat being voted for, and that is true enough if the Party has not a majority. But when Louth and Cork occurred, Fine Gael won Louth where it had only one out of three seats at a general election, and won East Cork where it had only one out of five, clearly reinforcing the emphatic repudiation that had already been expressed by the other constituencies which have had an opportunity of expressing their views where by-elections have occurred.
It is quite clear that in any constituency, whether rural, urban or semi-urban, which has been fortunate enough to have available to the voters in it an opportunity of expressing their views on Government policy, the same pattern has been clearly indicated, in some cases more emphatically than in others. There has been a rising tide of opposition to the policy, economic and social of the present Government. Now, faced with that situation, the Government proposes to introduce a Budget before going to election. I do not think it will make any difference to the Government, however attractive they may endeavour to paint the Budget. The Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke some few weeks ago at the Publicity Club luncheon and he said there that as far as all indications were there was no fat in the Budget.
In recent years we have exported in considerable quantities a commodity known as sweetened fat. It does not matter to what extent the Government will attempt to distribute sweetened fat in the coming general election; their case has always been that, given time, the people will react favourably. Time has now passed to such an extent that each election that has occurred has emphatically indicated more clearly than that which preceeded it the rejection by the people of the economic policy of this Government. It is significant that, despite the adherence to the Government of some former Independents, their fortunes appear to have declined more dramatically since that decision took place than they did at any time before it.
When Deputy Costello put down this motion he put it down for the purpose of ending the unnecessary expense which will inevitably accrue if this election is postponed. I think that any person closely associated with the Opposition Parties or closely associated with Fianna Fáil recognises there can be only one outcome from the general election, whether it occurs in three weeks or ten weeks : it will mean a change of Government.
That is what the country hopes for: that is what the country expects and that is what, I believe, the people by their votes will achieve. But, in the meantime, because of the proposed postponement, unnecessary expense, unnecessary loss, uncertainty and confusion—all the normal circumstances which attend a Budget until it is passed—will be doubly present because the people naturally expect that a Government, faced with the unpopularity that attends the present Government, will attempt to improve their position by budgetary reliefs by an election-incentive Budget. Normally the people might vote in a particular way if such a Budget were introduced but they have now to reflect on the statements which were made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he spoke in Cork, and by the Minister for Finance, when he spoke in Dublin, during the last general election; they undertook then not to impose the penal taxes and in nine months they put them back.
Nobody will believe now, whether or not Fianna Fáil grant remissions in this Budget, and if by any misfortune they should be the Government again, that they will not reimpose the taxes either by a Supplementary Budget or by a Budget in the normal course. The position is that the people are anxiously awaiting an opportunity of expressing their view on the present Government and are anxiously desirous of a change of Government. That view is reinforced, not merely by Deputies who are members of the Opposition Parties in this House but by an organ which is very friendly towards the present Government, namely the Irish Times, which published a leading article on Saturday last in which it devoted three-quarters of the article to praising the present Taoiseach and saying how much they thought of him and finished up by stating quite bluntly that he had run his race and should retire.
Comment on this
The Irish Times has been one of the Government's greatest supporters.
Comment on this
The Irish Times has been one of the most consistent supporters of the present Government. Last Saturday it devoted an editorial to the Taoiseach, three-quarters of which was highly favourable to the Taoiseach, giving him a great deal of personal praise, but the article finished by saying:—
"Whatever his station may be, when circumstances force him to recognise that he has served his purpose and that further delay must eventually do more harm than good to the cause which lies closest to his heart he should rest from his labours."
What Fianna Fáil are now trying to do is to postpone or delay a decisive result, if possible, from a general election. They recognise that time is no longer in their favour and they are trying to give themselves an extra few weeks in which to introduce a favourable Budget. They recognise that the years are telling on them and that their policy has told on the people.
Several Fianna Fáil spokesmen have asked during this debate and during the recent by-elections what our policy is: we should come together and explain it before the election, and so on and so forth. That type of talk does not wash any longer with the electorate. When we got the opportunity in 1948 we not merely agreed on a common programme, we implemented it. So far as the people are concerned they have clearly indicated in the various by-elections—and I still believe that in the general election of 1951 they wanted an inter-Party Government—that they want to get rid of the Fianna Fáil Government and the Fianna Fáil policy for two reasons: firstly, because it has imposed unnecessary and excessive burdens on the people and, secondly, because the electorate were deceived by the Fianna Fáil Party and the Fianna Fáil spokesmen when they went to the last election and subsequently published the statements I have read out. The people do not want any Fianna Fáil Budget. That is the one thing the people want to avoid and they recognise that, the sooner a general election takes place, the sooner they will be relieved from the oppressive and unnecessary burdens that have been placed upon them by the present Government.
We have taken the full opportunity during all the by-elections to place our policy before the people and to explain that policy to them. We are quite satisfied with their verdict on it. We await the opportunity for the rest of the country to express a similar verdict, but we want to see that that opportunity will not be long delayed so as to remove the uncertainty, confusion, and unnecessary loss caused by the obvious postponement of the same result, because the most ardent Fianna Fáil supporter recognises, if he does not admit it, that Fianna Fáil will not be the Government of this country after the election on the 18th May or, if it occurs before that, whenever it does occur.
Comment on this
I wish to indicate as briefly as I can the reasons for the Labour Party supporting this Fine Gael motion. It is not because we hope to form a Government with Fine Gael or any other Party. It is primarily because we hope to put out the present Government. We believe that the question of what Government will succeed them will have to be dealt with following the election. The primary thing now, however, is to put out a Government that has, in our opinion, failed both in governing and in keeping the promises they made to the electors when they sought to be the Government. Therefore, it is essential for the Labour Party to support any Party which moves a motion that the Government should go out of office.
The main reason why any Labour Deputy would vote against the present Administration is that they gave their word to the electors and put it as a point in their programme that if they were returned to power they would not interfere with the subsidies that were then being paid on the essential foodstuffs from the point of view of the ordinary people, namely, flour, butter, tea and sugar. Any Deputy knows that these are the essential foodstuffs of an ordinary working-man's home. Fianna Fáil gave their word and printed it and practically before the ink was dry they had broken it. The Labour Party recognises that this hard blow fell mainly on the people we seek to represent here, the people in the lower income groups who derive their living from labour, the people who have to depend on social welfare benefits, such as those on the dole, the widows and orphans, the blind, the unemployed and the sick. It was these people who were hit hardest. It is because of that the Labour Party welcome this motion and hope that this Government will be removed from office.
We are not concerned with Party advantage or with what place we can secure in any future Government. We have a policy and a programme and the first point in our programme is that the cost of living must be kept within the means of the ordinary people. It does not need any argument or any figures or facts to convince the ordinary people that the cost of living has gone beyond the means of most of the people. In fact it is only a privileged few who can afford to indulge in the luxury of a full meal. Most of us who are working people have to be content to ration ourselves to whatever we can afford to purchase at present day prices. The question of the cost of living must always be of the first importance to a Labour Party Deputy.
There comes a time in the life of all Governments when some action outside their control causes such a change that they often have to take the responsibility for it when, in reality, they have no control over it. But that was not the case with Fianna Fáil. By the direct and deliberate action of the Fianna Fáil party and of certain so-called Independent members, in the 1952 Budget they increased the price of flour, sugar, tea and butter. It is true that they gave certain compensatory increases to people in certain social welfare groups, but no one can sustain the argument that these compensatory increases were in any way calculated to offset the impact on the family exchequer of the immediate rise in prices caused but the removal of the food subsidies.
On the night following that and at various times in the years following the Labour Party stated clearly that they would not either associate with or take part in any Government that would not so amend the position as to make these essential foodstuffs again available to the people. The Labour Party repeat that by saying that it is an essential point of our programme that the price of these essential foodstuffs, flour, butter, tea and sugar, must be reduced, if necessary by further subsidisation. I think Fine Gael have themselves indicated that it is their belief that the cost of living has gone beyond all bounds. I am quite satisfied that should the Labour Party, Fine Gael, Clann na Poblachta and Clann na Talmhan be associated in any Government there will be very little divergence of opinion in our attitude on that particular question.
That is the question the answer to which has put Fianna Fáil in their present position; that and others, but that primarily. That is why the Labour Party believe that they must support this motion. We believe that unless Fianna Fáil are removed from office the position, which is bad now, will gradually get worse. We do not forget that in 1952 when eight subsidies were being removed there was implied the threat of a further removal of subsidies. Were it not for the result of certain by-elections in the last few years we are satisfied that that threat would have been carried out.
There is also the fact that, no matter how Fianna Fáil compare the unemployment figures this year with last year, or how they add up or juggle with figures and refer to certain improvements under which people can apply for benefits, every man and woman in this country knows there was more unemployment between the year 1951 and the present year than ever there was between 1948 and 1951, except possibly the first year when the inter-Party Government took over, and that was because of the fact that Fianna Fáil had been in office up to 1947. It was a record, and a proud record, for the inter-Party Government that for every month in office of their three years 1,000 further people went into employment in this country. The Labour Party are proud of the fact of their association with a Government that had that proud record at the end of three years. We would hope that whether we are in an alternative Government or outside it whatever Government is in will take pattern by that and endeavour to continue that work.
It is because of these two points in particular, coupled with the fact that at least 30,000 boys and girls have yearly had to leave this country, that we feel a change of administration is necessary. One has but to read the newspapers, the comments at G.A.A. meetings, meetings of any organisation of non-political people bewailing the fact that a football team has become extinct because all the young men have had to go to England or elsewhere; read any extract from any organisation of people and you will be satisfied that the life blood of this country is slowly draining away due to the fact that there is not employment. Those who, like myself, are bringing up a family see no hope for the future, and see that if things remain as they are the boys and girls whom we have spent all we have on, whom we have educated, will have within a short year or two to flee from their home and go into exile somewhere to secure the living that we cannot give them here at home.
I suggest that Fianna Fáil are guilty of reading and understanding the Central Bank Report, but they are more guilty because after promising that it would not influence them they immediately set about the implementation of it. We have the result. Labour speakers and speakers from other Parties warned the Fianna Fáil Party and warned the Independent Deputies who supported them that if that policy was carried out this country would pay, and pay dearly for it. The present position indicates how true were our warnings and how dearly we have paid. What have we got? Unemployed people, the high cost of living and all price controls removed. Deputy Norton as Tánaiste in the inter-Party Government secured from the Government a statement which he made on their behalf that as and from a certain date no further increase in the prices of commodities would be permitted without a full and thorough Government investigation. Within a short period of coming into office that order was rescinded. The sham of price control was kept on but those of us who know realise that in the price control section of the Department of Industry and Commerce there is but a skeleton of what was in operation during the inter-Party Government. We know to our cost that prices are no longer under control but are subject to the whim of supply and demand irrespective of which town or city a person happens to live in.
It is because of these facts and because of Labour's desire to see that things are good for the people of this country, because we believe that in putting Fianna Fáil out we will be helping in the formation of a Government that will carry out Labour Party policy and principle in some general measure, that we are in support of this motion.
Comment on this
When I was listening to some of the speeches on the opposite benches an Irish phrase kept recurring constantly to my mind—"Sás a dheanta a chuimhneoch air"—which simply means that it is one who is a good hand at doing it who will think of it. It has been suggested that the purpose of postponing the election until the Budget could be introduced is in order that a false Budget might be introduced. It comes very badly indeed from the people on the opposite side to talk about that— or perhaps I should say it comes very well from them to talk about that, because in 1951 when they went to the country to avoid defeat here they introduced a Budget which was a false Budget, which did not make provision for millions of pounds of expenditure which it was easy to see would have to be incurred in accordance with their commitments.
I assure the House that we have no intention of doing anything of the kind. We believe that in politics as in other things honesty pays best, and the Budget which we will introduce will be a Budget designed, as all our Budgets up to the present have been designed, to meet current expenditure by current revenue—that and nothing more. The suggestion has been made in the past that we have some special delight in imposing taxation which was not necessary. The Leader of the Opposition came in here when the 1952 Budget was being introduced and suggested that we were imposing £10,000,000, if you please, of taxation which was unnecessary. Why any Government, any democratic Government, would seek to do that was not ever indicated, and no reason for that was given. It was simply a statement which was blown to pieces within five minutes after it was made. Nevertheless it formed the basis of a continuous propaganda by Fine Gael and their associates. When the year's accounts were closed last year it was seen that instead of imposing £10,000,000 of unnecessary taxation we had actually a deficit of £2,000,000—in other words that the revenue from taxation did not meet the expenditure. They pretended that by some wave of the wand, by doing some extraordinary thing, some hocus-pocus by means of a double Budget, as they called it, and by means of some schemes which nobody has got a definite example of, the 1952 Budget could have been balanced.
There is one way, and one way only, in which you can reduce taxation if you want to pay your way, and that way is to reduce expenditure. But whenever there is a question of the reduction of expenditure we have Deputies on the opposite benches crying out for more expenditure. We will have the Labour Party calling for more social services. But when there is a question of meeting the bill then they all run away from it and charge the Government with imposing unnecessary taxation.
Coming back to the motion, it is that we should go to the country at once. I examined that and I came to the conclusion that it was only fair to the country that those who had produced and sanctioned the Book of Estimates should show their good faith in regard to this by indicating how the revenue was to be raised. I do not know— nobody can know definitely until the end of the financial year—what the out-turn of the year will be, whether we shall have, as we had in the past, a deficit for the past year, whether we shall make ends meet or whether we shall have a surplus. I think that the chance of a surplus is very slight. I do not know whether ends will be met this year but I do know that next year's Book of Estimates, indicating certain expenditure, will require certain revenue to meet it and it is our duty to show the two sides of the account to the people.
When the Minister for Defence was speaking, he suggested that if we had said we were going to have an immediate election there would have been an outcry from Opposition Deputies. It is the privilege, some would say it is the duty, of an Opposition to oppose. It does not matter what proposition we brought in here, whether it was for an early election, an election before the Budget or an election after the Budget, there would have been reasons put forward by the Opposition to suggest that there was a political trick in it. We would have Deputies, no doubt, suggesting that I was peeved, as some of them have already suggested here, because we were beaten in Cork. I do not want to suggest for one moment that I was not disappointed with the result of the Cork election and that the election in Cork indicated, as other elections have not done, that for the purpose of safe Government here, a Government that would have full authority here in every respect, it would be desirable to go to the country and test public opinion.
In saying that I want to say also that by the Constitution and by the law, the Parliament that assembles here after a general election has a mandate to continue in office until the legal period expires if it wants to. No person is entitled to interpret public opinion. We had as many interpreters as people whose wishes and whose desires were an interpretation of their personal judgment. The position is that when the previous Government came into office we challenged them on the basis that they came into office without telling the people before the 1948 election what they were going to do. We said that a Government was formed which the people had not been expecting, and that no policy had been presented to the people by the Government that took office. They smiled at us and told us: "We are here elected by the people; it is our right to form a Government. We will form that Government and we will continue that Government until we are beaten by a vote in the Dáil." I appreciate the force of that argument.
In regard to by-elections, I do not think that by-elections under our system necessarily represent public opinion over the country as a whole. I do not know yet what real interpretation is to be given to some of the elections, but in any case there is a way— and it is going to be used—in which public opinion can definitely be tested. It is not a question now of saying whether we shall or shall not go to the country. It is the question of the proper time to do it. I have fought many elections, both general elections and by-elections, and I never remember an election being fought just about this time—never. They have taken place either before farming operations began, early in March, or they have been held after the bulk of the ordinary spring operations on the farm have been completed. The only difference there can be between a rushed election and an election at the time which I have proposed, is a matter of some weeks. The country will have to put up for five years with the Government that it gets, if that Government wants to keep in office and has a majority. Therefore, whatever Party or Parties have a majority here in this House after the election will have put into their hands the welfare of the country for five years.
I think it is right that the people should have before them, when they are giving a judgment of such importance for the country, all the facts. If, as Deputies on the other side say, public opinion has changed so much, what are they afraid of? Is it that the people will learn more of the different policies of the various Parties or of the different kinds of Government which might be formed? I believe that every sensible person who wants to form a judgment would like to have the facts before him. Evidently Fine Gael and those on the opposite benches do not want that. They would love to come along and say that we were running away from our obligations, that we were presenting a big bill to the country without giving any indication as to how the bill was going to be met. I think it is right, because we are coming to the end of the financial year, that we should complete the job, present completed accounts to the people, give estimates as far as we are able to arrive at them of expenditure for the coming year and, when we have done that and the figures are before the people, go to the country.
The fact is that the financial year does not end until the 31st March. It takes some time after that to examine the accounts thoroughly and form a proper estimate of the rates or projected rates of taxation and an estimate of the amount of revenue you are likely to receive. That requires a week or two so that the earliest time the Minister for Finance could introduce his Budget would be about the 21st April. Easter Sunday falls on the 18th and the Dáil obviously would not be in session the week before. The experts, whose opinions the Minister would like to have, would require some time to form their opinion on the estimates so that the earliest date at which you could have an election in which the electorate will have the two sides of the account is that which I have suggested.
Our opponents are presenting another side, one side only, to the electorate. I was listening just now to Deputy Kyne speaking about the cutting down of the subsidies in 1952. He did not tell the House that that was done because there was £15,000,000 of a deficit between the expenditure that had to be met and the revenue available to meet it. He did not suggest how that deficit could be met otherwise. We had unfortunately to introduce taxes to the extent of something like £11,000,000 but had we taken away the whole of the subsidies, amounting to £15,000,000, and given no compensatory allowances, we could have bridged the gap. We tried to lighten the burden as much as possible but some part of the burden had to be met. There is no use in the Labour Party or members of the Opposition suggesting that it was not there. It was there; it was a reality that had to be faced. We faced it in the way we have indicated. For this coming year something like £7.7 million will have to be provided for subsidies on bread and flour. Had that £7.7 million not to be provided, the total expenditure would be that number of million pounds less; but it is there and it has to be met. We are subsidising bread at present and the burden of subsidies in our case is relatively as high as in Britain. We hear talk about people not having food. I suppose there are individuals in that position and I am sorry, but the fact is that all the records show that our food prices are fourth lowest in Europe and that we are, in fact, better fed than most nations in the world. There is no use in going round all the time belying the situation, so far as this country is concerned.
Fine Gael and the inter-Party Government claim credit for things that happened about 1951. They have just as much right to claim credit for what happened at that time as they would have to claim credit for the weather. The changes which took place during that time took place as a result of world conditions, conditions which were paralleled in every other country. The Korean war meant that there was activity in every direction from the time it started until it was clear that it was not going to expand into another world war. That danger existed between 1950 and 1951, but the moment that danger disappeared, things began to change and then, instead of the boom for which Fine Gael claim credit—as I say, they had no more control over it and no more to do with it than they had with the weather—the activity of that period changed into inactivity. Manufacturers could not get rid of the goods they had just then manufactured. Raw materials had been bought at high prices and wholesalers, retailers and even private individuals had stocks to meet their needs for the coming year and longer. They had them in stock, and they did not need to buy in the coming year, and therefore, in the coming year, there was a slump which was reflected here, but a slump which was found in practically every other country.
The pretence that in this country things happened that did not happen elsewhere is all nonsense. Every figure proves quite the contrary. It has been suggested that here, and here only, was there a decrease in manufacturing production. That is not the truth. Look up the O.E.E.C. records and you will find that it is not true. You will find that of the 14 countries, including Ireland, which reported, in seven of them there was a decrease in production. It did not take place here alone. There was no over-all increase in the year 1952. As regards unemployment, of 13 countries which reported, unemployment increased in 12, and I tell the Leader of the Opposition, who has been saying the contrary on several occasions, that, in five of these 12, the increases were greater than the increase in Ireland. The same is true with regard to the cost of living. Of 17 countries which reported, only two showed a decrease in the cost of living, so that what happened here in 1952 is something which was paralleled in most of the other countries—a reduction of manufacturing production, an increase of unemployment and an increase in the cost of living.
On this question of the cost of living, the suggestion that it was altogether due to deliberate action on the part of the Government is sheer nonsense. It had begun to increase long before we came into office and the index reached 109 points before we took office. From February of 1951 to last November, it increased by 22 points and, of these 22 points, seven were attributable to the fact that the food subsidies were reduced. No credit appears in these figures in respect of the increase in children's allowances or other compensatory increases given to offset the burden imposed by the reduction of the food subsidies. There is a continuing expenditure of about £3,750,000 due to the fact that there was that offset, but of course you never hear of that expenditure with the money—which offsets and lightens the burden on the weaker sections of the community. You never hear of that and you never hear of the benefits which the expenditure confers.
We cannot have it both ways—even Labour cannot have it both ways. If you want to have social services, if you want to have health services and these other social welfare benefits, you have to pay for them and you have to get the money somewhere. You can, of course, behave as the prodigal and waste your substance and get a lot of people to advise you to do it while you are wasting it, but the day of reckoning comes some time or other. We are not a very wealthy country, but we have certain resources and we can be reasonably comfortable. We have not, however, got huge material resources. If we want to continue to have a decent living for our people with these resources, we must be careful to conserve the assets we have. If we squander them, if we use them for purposes that will not give us any direct return to enable us to build up other reserves, the day of reckoning surely will come.
It was coming fast so far as we could see when we came into office. There was a £15,000,000 budget deficit in the ordinary current account. We had to meet that and we also had to meet a deficit in our balance of payments of practically £62,000,000. A wave of the wand of the Leader of the Opposition and those with him and that £15,000,000 disappeared, just as he had only to wave a wand and he gave us a surplus of £10,000,000 on the basis of our taxation ! When you undertake the responsibilities of government, you have to deal with, not one side of the account, and not one side to-day and the other to-morrow, as if they had no relation to each other. You must deal with the two of them together, and we have done that during the whole time.
We did balance the Budget relatively, and, when I say "relatively," I mean that it was not as well balanced as I would have liked it to be, but it was balanced up to a deficit of £2,000,000 compared with £15,000,000. I should have preferred had we been able to strike the balance hoped for when the Budget was produced, but we did it to that extent. I hope we will do better this year. As regards the deficit in the balance of payments, we met that, and that deficit has been reduced to a level that can be tolerated, but, had the £62,000,000 level continued for a couple of more years, we would have changed our position from that of being a creditor country to that of being a debtor country. Of course, the ordinary person in the street who has not been considering these things does not see the full effect these large extreme deficits would ultimately have on his standard of living. The woman who goes to the shop to buy bread or butter does not think of the larger issues that are involved. That is precisely why a Government is formed and that is why a representative assembly like this is formed in order that people who give attention to these things should consider the bearing of these matters on the welfare of the community as a whole. We did that. We settled the finances and put them on a proper basis. Then the slump year of 1952 passed and we had the recovery in the year 1953. I do not say that we ought to take all the credit for that, just as the Government should not be blamed for things outside their control.
The year 1953 was a year of recovery. The year 1952 is always pointed to by those on the Opposition Benches but they ignore the recovery which took place in the year 1953. To start with, there are grounds for believing that it was a year in which our national income and savings increased. The output of manufacturing industries increased; in fact, during the first three quarters it was the highest on record. Industrial employment at the present time is nearing the record, if it has not already passed it. A figure was given just a day or two ago which seemed to indicate that the record was passed—that we are reaching the highest figure that has ever been reached. Employment has gone up and unemployment has gone down. The difference between unemployment this year and the early part of 1953 is about 12,600. Of course, there are people who want to compare 1953 with 1951 and 1950 and so forth, but the fact is that as a result of the Social Welfare Act the figures for those years are not comparable with the current figures. There are 12,600 fewer people unemployed this year than last year. Output in agriculture has increased. We have increased tillage, increased output of wheat and beet. We have a greater number of cattle than at any time since 1921. We have an increase in the milk supplies to the creameries; they have reached the highest figure since 1936. We have an increase in external trade. Our external trade position has improved tremendously, not merely because the terms of trade moved in our favour, but also because there was an increased volume of exports. The year 1953 was a year of obvious recovery and the graph is upwards. If the country is governed properly, the burden of taxation will be automatically lightened by the increase in production. We hope that that will be the case.
It has been suggested, of course, that we broke the promise we gave when we said that the food subsidies would be maintained. When we said that, we did not expect to have £15,000,000 of a deficit to meet. We were not then faced with the alternative of either reducing subsidies or putting on £15,000,000 extra taxation. We issued that statement not before the election but before the formation of a Government here. If any Deputies felt that they had been deceived by that they were in a position to turn out the Government.
With regard to retail prices, the index is now about 231, the index of industrial wage earnings has gone up to 249, and that is all on a pre-war base of 100. A comparable figure for agricultural wages, which have also gone up, is 299. These figures indicate that if there has been an increase in prices, there has also been a compensating increase both in regard to industrial and agricultural wages.
As I have said, we have a question to ask: what is going to be the alternative policy? I do not think that the people will let the Leader of the Opposition get away with the hocus-pocus sort of statement he has made about a double Budget and that through such a Budget they are going to get a new heaven on earth. It is natural enough to try to have good times always but very few of us can have good times unless we strive to earn them. If we are going to have good times continuing in this country, we will have to make the efforts necessary to maintain them.
Are we going to set out to live here on our reserves, on what has been accumulated in the past? It is not easy to accumulate reserves and most of our foreign reserves have been built up in times of war. I do not think that we add to our reserves in ordinary times. These external reserves are not to be wasted. They should be used for capital purposes and productive purposes at home. That has always been our policy.
As regards this double Budget, what is meant? Nothing new whatsoever except the formal segregation of those items that are regarded as capital. That has always been done. It is true that we did not have large capital items in the past, "above the line" as it is called. Most of the capital expenditure was what is called "below the line" expenditure. There is more of that to-day than there was in the days of the Coalition Government. Even to-day, the amount of the "above the line" capital expenditure is not much more than half of that "below the line", that is, the moneys provided for the E.S.B. and other services of that kind.
We have not unlimited resources in this country. We all can have unlimited desires. There are very few of us who could not in a short time indicate desires that would require many millions to satisfy but we just have not got the means. We have to limit our desires to our means. There is no use holding out to our people ideals and ideas which are incapable of achievement. The Coalition Government were fortunate to be in office in the year 1950-51. We were unfortunate in the time we came into office because we had to meet the slump that followed the boom. The country's economy is on a rising tide. I use the word "rising" in a different sense from that in which it was used on the opposite benches. If we act sensibly and properly and do not start in a competition of expenditure, one Party against another, this country can have a continuing future of reasonable prosperity, and that is what we are aiming at.
I want to say now that we are not in the market any more than we were at any time. Whether in 1932 or on any of the other two or three occasions on which for a short time we did not have a complete majority of our own in this House, we took up the position that we were going to proceed with our own programme. If that programme commended itself to other members of the House who were not members of our Party and that gave us a majority, well and good; but we were not going to depart from our fundamental policy in order to win the votes of any Party.
We also make this challenge to the Opposition, a challenge I have put to them many a time. We have heard the chairman of the Labour Party expressing sentiments from the Labour point of view just before I began to speak. It is quite within his right and that of his Party to join with Fine Gael, with Clann na Talmhan or with any other group, but I think it is their duty to their own supporters and to the people in general in this country to indicate what is going to be the common programme. Are they going to add to the food subsidies and what amount are they going to add to the food subsidies? The economic price of the two-pound loaf, which costs the householder 9¼d. at present, is 1/-. It will be almost 1/0¾d. probably in the coming year. Therefore, for every loaf of bread the State is contributing 2¾d. at present and will contribute more than 3d. in the coming year. How much more are you going to add to that subsidy, if you are going to add to it? Are you going to subsidise butter, for instance, and, if so, how are you going to get the money? Are you going to reduce the price the farmer is getting for his milk or are you going to subsidies butter from the Exchequer? If you are going to subsidise it from the Exchequer where are you going to get the money? What tax are you going to impose?
In our Supplementary Budget of 1947 we introduced food subsidies on a large scale. What was the attitude of the Labour Party at that particular time? Did they say that this was essential, that bread and butter, for instance, were essential foods and that it was a good thing on the part of the Government to have these reliefs in the case of these foods? Oh, no! Their attack was that it was only a fake, that the subsidies were altogether false and that the household was not getting any real benefit. They went out against the tax which was necessary to provide this money. As I said before, even Labour cannot have it both ways. If you want to give these benefits, year in and year out, as part of your State housekeeping, you will have to find the money.
We propose, at any rate, to present to the people for their judgment the completed accounts. We hope they will have before them with the Budget an indication of how the money is to be provided so that they can form a judgement. We are going to present the two sides of the account to them and we are going to have the election on the new register. If we held the election a few days before the publication of the register, we would be told we did not want to have the young vote.
We would have been told also that we were running away from our obligations as far as the Budget was concerned, that we were having a rushed election and all the rest of the things the Opposition would conjure up before the people as a consequence of it. I have no doubt whatever that the right course in the public interest is the course I have indicated in the statement which I made here in the Dáil and which I issued earlier to the Press, the statement that the Dáil should be dissolved after giving reasonable time for discussion of the Budget. Two or three days would be sufficient. I do not know whether any financial resolutions will have to be passed, but at any rate the people when they come to judge will have all the facts before them, and I hope they will have sufficient time to see through some of the tactics of the Opposition.
Comment on this
The quotation that occurs most readily to one's mind after listening to the Taoiseach for the last three-quarters of an hour is one that occurs in a play in which one character says: "The strings, my lord, are false." That was my reaction when I heard the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach, in spite of the fact that his dishonesty in politics has been exposed over the last year, still declares that honesty is the best policy. Deputy Kyne spoke of the honesty that he had found at the hands of the Taoiseach in the present Ministry. I have here a document headed "The Great Betrayal", in which there is a statement made by the present Tánaiste on the 13th May, 1951:—
"A Coalition Minister had said that Fianna Fáil, if elected, would increase the taxes on beer and tobacco. Why should such taxes be necessary? There is no such reason why we should reimpose those taxes."
The present Minister for Finance spoke in the Rathmines Town Hall on 15th May, 1951, in these terms:—
"A number of persons in the licensed trade were spreading a rumour that Fianna Fáil, if returned to power, would reimpose the tax on drink which was imposed by the Supplementary Budget of 1917. There is no truth in such a rumour."
Honesty in politics. Also on the 15th May the present Taoiseach spoke in O'Connell Street, and said:—
"We brought down the price of sugar from 6d. to 4d. per lb."
Butter and a number of other commodities were also mentioned in this speech. He went on further to say:—
"Fianna Fáil began the system of food subsidies to keep down the cost of living by reducing the prices of essential foods. `Do not let the Coalition propagandists deceive you. The workers' interests are safe with Fianna Fáil' ".
Later, after the election was over, on 5th June, 1951, we had point 15 of the new Fianna Fáil programme which was, I think, the third programme, two before the election and one after it. Point 15 was:—
"To maintain subsidies, to control the prices of essential foodstuffs and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation."
The outcome was that on the 2nd April, 1952, they brought in what was called the hunger Budget in which subsidies, except the one on bread, were removed. The £6,668,000, less the so-called compensatory benefits, gave a net gain to the Government of almost £4,000,000. After that, the Taoiseach speaks of honesty being the best policy. He tells us that 1953 was the year of recovery. That was stressed several times during his speech.
In the last six weeks we had the spectacle of the Minister for Health having to come before the House and introduce a Supplementary Estimate. Why? Because unemployment had gone far beyond what he had expected and consequently there was an increase of 50 per cent. in medical certification. There was an increase in bad health in the country to the extent of 50 per cent. more than had been calculated at the start of the year. And that is the year of recovery! The Taoiseach says that when they made these promises about subsidies they did not know anything about the £15,000,000 deficit at the end of the year 1952 and yet do not know about such a deficit. When did the Taoiseach get the figure of £15,000,000? I ask the question, where did the Taoiseach get the figure of £15,000,000?