Dissolution of Dáil—Motion.
Contributions 330–483 of 483. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
In column 1130 the Minister for Finance, who sits beside the Taoiseach, said that the outcome for 1951-52 was actually a deficit of £6.7 millions.
Comment on this
He has the Minister to reply for him. The £6.7 millions was the deficit. How did that accumulate? People will remember that blot on the landscape that used to be called turf in the Phoenix Park, mouldering away, which cost £3,000,000 to the community. The Tánaiste said that if that were put on to the national debt, that was the best way in which that deficit could be met. That was £3,000,000 of the £6.7 millions. Does the Taoiseach suggest that £3,000,000 had to be paid in the next year or the year after, that that is a continuing item of deficit in the accounts? The Taoiseach knows well that in the same year, in order to achieve that £6.7 millions fictitious deficit, he piled into the account certain replacements and certain capital expenditure on the part of C.I.E., he put in the ground limestone figure that was to be met out of the American Aid, he put in the new money that they themselves, Fianna Fáil, had given for the price of milk, he put in extra money put on the community because the Fianna Fáil Government had given an extra price for wheat. Those may have been desirable additions to the taxpayers' burden, but they were not my additions. The £6.7 millions was the fictitious deficit that the accounts sought to disclose, but from an argumentative point the Taoiseach magnifies that to £15,000,000.
The Taoiseach has said that he never remembered an election being held at this time of the year. Does the Taoiseach's memory, ranging back over the years he has spent in this House since he came in, ever remember a by-election in which there was such a slump in one Party's vote as is represented by a tot of 9,000 votes? That is unique; there never was such a drop. It might get over the difficulty of having an election at this time of the year, when just earlier the Party had suffered that terrific demonstration, at the hands of the people, of how unpopular they were.
The Taoiseach tells us that he does not know what the out-turn of the year's accounts will be. The Revenue Commissioners must have changed their practice since I knew them. They used to report at the end of six months how revenue was running and give an estimate for the rest of the year. They used to report again at the end of nine months and give an estimate for the last three months of the year. Within six weeks of the last period of the year they not merely gave their view of how income and revenue of the year were going to turn out, but gave their forecast for the next year. No doubt the Taoiseach has all those figures in his possession. Anyone looking at the accounts published in Irish Oifigiúil can make an estimate near by £2,000,000 to the actual out-turn of the year's accounts. Everyone knows that this plea of honesty being the best policy, and the out-turn of the year, and the whole business about the weather, and how we are getting near to Holy Week, and that there might be disturbance through a rushed election is all recognised by the public as part of the programme presented earlier in 1953. The Taoiseach took steps to ensure that the local people would not get their chance to say through local elections how badly Fianna Fáil popularity had slumped. That has been continued right through. By-election after by-election rang out the knell of doom for the people who are facing me. Fianna Fáil still hid, they ran away, they sucked up whatever little in the way of support they could from the ragged group of Independents left in this House, some of whom are supporting them. They have come now to the point where, as one of that group has said, they are being dragged, kicking and squealing, before the electorate, the last thing in the world they want and the thing they will postpone to the last possible moment.
Yesterday into this House there drifted the Minister for Finance, returning here after a regrettable absence created through a period of bad health, which one hopes was merely a temporary period of deterioration. He came in in a much different way from that in which any of his colleagues would have faced the House yesterday. Possibly through that period of enforced leisure, he had not got the full effect of what had happened in the country over some months past. The Government to which he belonged had received what the American slang experts would call "six swift kicks in the electoral pants." The Irish Times last Saturday addressed a well-aimed, well-polished boot—but it was a boot—in the direction of the Taoiseach—the general view of the community is that Fianna Fáil have outstayed whatever welcome they thought they got in 1951. The Minister for Finance, aloof from all these problems of the day, must have astounded his supporters yesterday. I doubt if the postponement of the election for several weeks can do them as much in the way of good as he will have done them in the way of harm by what he said yesterday.
Do not forget that yesterday Cork sent to this Party Stephen Barrett, in an election which produced the greatest slump in any single constituency that there has been since this country became a State. Stephen Barrett campaigned, as did all his supporters throughout Cork, on the cost of foodstuffs, on the cost of such things as beer, tobacco and spirits. The Minister for Finance told us yesterday that in this country we have improved social welfare and health services, we have better housing and educational facilities, we have subsidised public transport, we have agricultural improvements, we have higher pay for State employees—that must have caused him a pang—we have expansion of public works and a better equipped Defence Force. He said that all these blessings are reflected in the conditions of life here. Then we are told—and this will go down well in the back streets of Cork—that "according to independent international observers, our people, by and large, are better fed than any in the world, with a level of nutrition higher than obtains even in New Zealand, Canada, Australia or the United States." Could we have a few moments' silence to digest that? Housing, nutrition, a better standard of food. Let us get the details. He said that housing conditions in general here were better than in most of Western Europe, that we had all but the cheapest loaf in the world, that with the exception of Denmark we had the cheapest sugar in Europe and with the exception of Britain the cheapest butter, that we had the cheapest beer, the cheapest spirits and the cheapest tobacco. Why, one might ask, are people fleeing from this country, if these are the ideal conditions we have?
The Minister ought to know just how people regard these things he counts as the blessings of the community. It was he who began it all. He came here with his Budget in 1952 and when, at this late period in 1954, excuses are sought as to why the imposts of 1952 were thought necessary, they forget that the Minister himself is on record as showing his view—and he spoke for the Government. In that year he deducted the saving on food subsidies—£6,668,000—less compensatory benefits—and they are set out. The net is £3,918,000, nearly £4,000,000, on bread and flour, to a certain degree. on butter, on tea and on sugar. Then there were taxes—income-tax to bring in £910,000; tobacco to bring in £5,500,000; beer to bring in £2,360,000; spirits to bring in £1,000,000 and a bit; and petrol and oils to bring in £1,500,000—a tot of £11,250,000 added to the saving on food subsidies making £15,250,000 in all. Why was that done? There is not a word in this Budget speech of a £15,000,000 deficit. There is no statement here that that was the gap that had to be closed.
At column 1138 of the Financial Statement of that year, made on 2nd April, 1952, the Minister tells us why these exactions were imposed:—
"The Government have given careful thought to this problem over recent months. They are satisfied that, as incomes generally have already advanced more than the cost of living and as essential foodstuffs are no longer scarce, there is now no economic or social justification for a policy of subsidies."
There it is: the people were too well off. The Minister had tried another trick on the people before in a period in which there were standstill Orders and the period, as we discovered, in which a new standstill Order scheme was being devised. The direct attack upon wages by keeping wages and salaries down was not possible in the mood the people were in in 1952. Indirect attack was the best. If you can raise the cost of living higher than any increase there has been in wages and salaries, you effectively reduce the purchasing power of those wages and salaries. That was the Minister's plan that year.
I interpose again that that was a course in complete neglect and flagrant violation of the promises that were made that subsidies were going to be maintained and that there was no truth in the story that the tobacco taxes were likely to be imposed.
The Taoiseach to-night has talked about the cost of living and has said, with a frankness that I think he did not understand, that the greater part of the increase in the cost of living, measured by the index figure, comes from the reduction or the removal of the food subsidies.
Comment on this
Twenty-three points were given in answer to a question, as usual. That is the Government's idea. That was the Government's plan. Notwithstanding that that was exposed in a parliamentary question and that the increase in the cost of living to that extent had been caused by Government activity, the Taoiseach laments that it is wrong for anybody to accuse them of having done this deliberately. One does not know whether economic ignorance could go to that point. But, if the Taoiseach did not will that increase in the cost of living as an end, he certainly willed the most effective means for bringing that end about.
We move away from 1952 to 1953. The 1953 Budget had no special mention of these foodstuffs. Again, the White Paper has no statement with regard to the subsidies or the taxes, but the subsidies and the taxes were continued again—every one of them. Four million pounds were still being subtracted from the people because they were made pay more for bread, flour, tea, sugar and butter and the community were still being taxed to the extent of £11,250,000 for beer and tobacco and spirits and income-tax and the other things I have mentioned.
Nobody in those days, when we were discussing these exactions, had the temerity to say that we were the bestfed and the cheapest-living community in Europe. Even if you were taking away some of the subsidies that used to go to keep the price of butter, flour, tea, sugar at certain levels, nobody then thought of saying that you have the cheapest white loaf in the world; that, with the exception of Denmark, you have the cheapest sugar in the world; that, with the exception of Britain, you have the cheapest butter in the world and that you have, in the world, the cheapest beer, the cheapest spirits and the cheapest tobacco.
Comment on this
That was the Budget, however, in which the Minister did say that he could not offer any great incentive or stimulus by way of reduction in taxation to the farming community of this country. His phrase was: "Taxation presses so lightly on the land that there is little scope for any stimulus under that heading".
Although we did not know it, in 1953, in the month of May, this country had the highest standards of the Western European world—nutrition at such a height that it was compelling the admiration of foreign observers; housing that could be compared to anything in Western Europe and, not merely our foodstuffs, but these amenities of life of the semi-luxury type like beer, tobacco, spirits, were cheaper in this country than they were any place else, with odd exceptions and, added to that, the farming community taxed so lightly that it was not possible to give them any stimulus by reducing taxation.
I count a lot on the speech that the Minister for Finance delivered yesterday. I point out to this House that there is in this speech the maintenance of a particular attitude of mind towards living costs in this country which was developed over the war years and which was only brought to a conclusion outside the war years by the fact that in 1948 the people refused to give Fianna Fáil control of government.
I need not go into these things in detail. People's memories are too bitter with regard to the standstill Orders over the war years—standstill Orders, the power to impose which was gained by the Government that is facing me on the plea that they would see that costs were kept down and, as a result of that desire to keep costs down, they wanted power to keep down also the level of salaries and wages.
They let prices soar and rocket but they kept ruthlessly the standstill Orders in force and kept wages and salaries battened down. When the war was over, the standstill Order was repealed and, in 1948, searching through the files of some of the Departments, we discovered the proposals for legislation that the Tánaiste was devising. At that time the Taoiseach himself had gone to the country and said that the Government must demand the right to impose some limit to the upward surge of wages. He said that if they were to have a stable condition—and he mentioned the war years—a stable condition like what prevailed in the war years, they must have power to regulate salaries and wages while they would endeavour —"endeavour," this time—to keep prices down.
In 1952, the Minister appeared before this House and told us that the Government had considered the matter of subsidies. He did not make any mathematical calculations about deficits or indicate any of those later thoughts that have now been found to excuse the performance of 1952. He said quite bluntly and quite brutally that there was no reason or circumstance why subsidies should any longer be retained because the Government had discovered that the general increase in salaries and wages had gone higher than the increase in the cost of living. I said before that the standard they took was a lamentable standard. They went back to the year 1939 to find out what was the standard of the people who depended on the sale of their services to get, in return, remuneration by way of wages or salaries. The standard taken was: "You are not to go beyond what you achieved in 1939 no matter what the years in between may have meant in the way of sacrifice imposed upon you. We will not let you go beyond that. As long as we can see that there is an advantage to the working or salaried classes in their wages we will take it out of you. We will reduce the subsidies and impose these taxes on things which you must buy."
Before medical science advanced to the point which it has now reached, the general way of treating disease was to look on everything as a fever, some disorder in the blood, some excitement in the veins of the people. The cure was a simple one—the knife. The surgeon barber bled the people. The Minister for Finance came in here in 1952 to bleed out of the veins of the salaried and wage-earning classes the little bit of increase which they had over and above the standards they reached in 1939, measuring it by the cost-of-living index figure. Can anybody believe that if the Minister had his way, and if he were not trying to pander to the community in an effort to recover the ground that his Party have lost and in which he may appear to be reasonable, his attitude would be different? Suppose the Minister were back again there in office, having got in by hook or by crook for another five years, is the mood reflected in yesterday's debate one that will appeal to the people of this House or to the community generally? With his eyes closed to the people's misery, to unemployment, to the flight from the land and from the country generally— neglecting all these things—the Minister tells us that we are the admiration of the western world for our standards of nutrition and housing, for the cheapness of our foodstuffs and the cheapness even of these things that are innate to life.
Bearing in mind the Minister's record and the fact that he said in one month that there was no truth in the story that certain taxes would be reimposed, and then reimposed them within nearly 12 months, can anybody believe, no matter how popular a Budget he might scrape up, or what the out-turn of the year may give him, that that would be maintained? The Minister wonders whether the out-turn of the year will give him any modest surplus with which he can play.
If there is any modest surplus with which he can play where should it go? Should it go to "the best housed and the best fed people in Western Europe?" Should it go to "people whose standards with regard to the cheapness of their foodstuffs, beer, spirits and tobacco are the admiration and envy of the western world?" Would the Minister now do what his colleague, the Minister for Justice, lamented we did when we got the chance? The Minister for Justice talked of the things Fianna Fáil wanted to prevent and would have prevented if the Taoiseach had only got six extra seats in Dublin. Salaries had to be increased. The salaries of civil servants had to be increased. Deputy Boland, the Minister for Justice, said that the Guards would naturally look for similar increases, so would the Army, so would the teachers, so would local authority employees and workers all over the country—and that was what Fianna Fáil wanted to prevent and would have prevented if the six seats that were lost in Dublin had only been retained by Fianna Fáil. Therefore, if there is a surplus, if the out-turn of the year that is so anxiously awaited, with 20 days to go, shows some modest surplus, does anyone expect that, if they were not playing for popularity for a brief period, the Minister would have the slightest compassion on the workers of this country? If he thinks their state is as good as he has said it is, why should he try to alleviate what does not require alleviation? Even if the Minister were to do anything of the sort, can we not hear, in anticipation, the burst of laughter there would be from the whole community at the Minister who said in 1951 that taxes of certain types would not be reimposed and who reimposed them in 1952? Who in the community would trust that Minister, even if he brought forward some alleviation out of whatever the out-turn of the year might give him, knowing that if he should be returned to power, a Supplementary Budget will be introduced within three months removing anything that was given by way of abate to the community?
The picture that the Minister has painted for the community is not the picture that appears to other people. Last year, in making his Budget arrangements, the Minister skinned things to the bone. He was very anxious last year about our liberties. He was very annoyed that when Fianna Fáil took over the Government in 1951 they found what amounted to almost a defenceless country. I quote now from columns 1204, 1205 and 1206 of the Official Report of the 6th May, 1953. The standard at which they found the equipment of the Army "was a source of concern to all who valued liberties which had been won so dearly." He spoke of the anxiety of the Government to which he belonged "when in June, 1951, in conditions of great international tension, they took over responsibility for the defence of the nation and found that the country had to rely on an ill-equipped and undermanned Defence Force." He was quite heroic in his attitude to this. "Under no circumstances will it"—the Government—"Seek to economise or improve budgetary appearances by shirking its duty to provide for the nation's defence." He said: "It is true that, defending those liberties and preserving them, we shall pass them on to succeeding generations, but it is we, and not the unborn, who are directly concerned that in this our day these precious things should not be taken from us."
After all that rhetoric, the Minister put in his Book of Estimates the sum of £4,000,000 as expenditure on defence equipment. He then subtracted £2.7 million as equipment ordered but not delivered during the year. He left himself to find a sum of £1,800,000, having told the community that he was not going to present a better Budget by any economies in regard to defence. He then told us he thought the proper sum to put against the citizens of the State last year was £400,000. He would draw £500,000 from the carry-over, which had increased from £2.5 million to £3,000,000 in the time he was telling the people the Budget was in deficit. As for the rest, he proposed to borrow £900,000. Therefore, the Government, who were so concerned that these precious things should not be taken from us, were asked to find £400,000 last year for a debt which was first presented as being £4,500,000. The Minister was then to get £500,000 from the carry-over and almost £1,000,000 by short-term borrowings. This year, we have another £1,800,000. Will the Minister present a better budgetary appearance this year from that £1,800,000, again subtracting £900,000 short-term borrowings and another draw of £500,000 from the carry-over? In that way, he may manage to present a better picture than the Taoiseach believes will be there.
The Taoiseach says that, on present appearances, the out-turn of the year will hardly show enough money to meet the expenditure of the year. I said before that the picture the Minister for Finance had painted was not the picture that presents itself to the other people in the country. I take from the many clippings that I have on the subject a statement made in Donegal within the last ten days. A county councillor there, faced with a rate that has gone beyond the capacity of Donegal people to pay, and begging for decreases, said, nevertheless, that the amount paid out in home assisance was a barometer of the times and depended on the amount of misfortune in the county. He could not neglect the amount of misfortune that was in Donegal. He accepted the imposition by way of rates on the community without seeking a reduction of one penny piece in the amount required for public assistance, but let it all go. The same county council, including those who represented the farmers of Donegal in the hardest year those farmers had ahead of them, at a time when there were fears that prices might break on them, and at a time when the price of everything they required was increasing, nevertheless, had to find a greater sum by many shillings for rates than they had ever been faced with since they constituted a county council.
The rates are soaring. Even if the Government succeeds in securing eight or ten weeks' respite, I believe they will lose on the rate swings what they will gain on the attempt to bring in a popular Budget, if that can be made. We know that emigration is at its peak and despite the Taoiseach's boasting that about 10,000—or as he puts it 12,000—less people are unemployed, the unemployment figure is still far too high for this country, and beyond what it was when the inter-Party Government was in control.
Housing in certain areas is at a standstill and it has been brought to a standstill by governmental policy on the restriction of credit. I would not like to stress too much, although they are a necessary part of the conditions of the time, the miseries that have been caused to people by what happened in 1952. I do feel that householders and housewives are at the end of their tether trying to meet the prices that the present Fianna Fáil Government imposed on them. But I believe that the thing that has done the present Government more harm is not that—severe and all as it may be— but it is the recognition at this late point that over their whole period in office Fianna Fáil have hardly advanced the status of this country. They have certainly not advanced its productivity and have made no better conditions of life in the 15 years that they controlled this country than what they found when they first came into office.
The Taoiseach spoke the other day of getting an opportunity to begin the agricultural drive—to begin the agricultural drive—in 1954. The Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Lynch, addressing the Publicity Club in Cork— apparently he was frightened by stories in Cork about the expenditure of the present Government—he talked of all the leeway there was to be made up. He spoke of the leeway that was to be made up and said that it was something that could not be approached in a timorous fashion, because the problems were so aggravated when he mentioned them, the development of mines, electricity, turf, harbours and everything else.
In 1954, Deputy Lynch, Parliamentary Secretary, appealed to the Cork people not to think too hardly of the Government to which he belonged if it tried to get a lot of money because of the leeway that had to be made up. Over what period had that leeway developed? The Party Deputy Lynch belongs to has been the reigning Party since 1932, and if there is leeway to be made up one can only ask that somebody should trace the deterioration in the productivity on the production side of the community.
It is too late to open the big subject of credit at this point. No matter where one goes, except in Government circles, there is recognition that the most important matter affecting the community since Fianna Fáil came into power the second time was the definite restriction of credit that there has been with knowledge and encouragement of the Government. That has been denied.
This sort of yellowish Press which emanates from the Department of External Affairs published the banking terms in summary for 1953. They hailed new records shown in the published returns for the year ended 31st December, 1953, of the ten joint stock banks operating in the country. Deposit and credit accounts at a certain figure showed an expansion of £22,000,000. Deposits were up by £22,000,000. Advances and bills show an increase of £1.2 million. But the ten joint stock banks achieved a record. The deposits went up to the record figure of £22,000,000 over the year before and from that the joint stock banks proceed to lend and their advances amount to £1,000,000 more than they were in the preceding year, and that as I am reminded was the year of recovery, the best year this country has ever seen.
I do not intend to go into the big subject of credit at this point but I cannot again refrain from reminding the House of the experience that we had as a Government when we met members of the standing committee of the Joint Stock Banks of this country over the £5,000,000 corporation loan that was then about to be made, and how the banks refused to take it up. When the banks refused to give anything in the way of a serious overdraft to the Dublin Corporation we brought them in to argue with them as to the necessity for the Dublin corporators being supplied with this money. As the day wore on, there was agreement that the objects for which the corporation required the money were good and sound and with our statement that the Dublin Corporation loan was at least good security and the only thing that we could be told about Dublin Corporation security was that it was not marketable quickly. For many hours that day the banks painted a picture of how what they called their portfolio of investments was a carefully prepared mosaic which would be broken up and fragmented if they had to sell any sterling holding in order to find between them £5,000,000 for Dublin Corporation. Towards the end of a weary day, they broke and said that if Dublin Corporation wanted this money and if it was the desire of the Government that the banks should support it, the money could be obtained. We then suggested an adjournment until the officials of the Department of Finance could meet the officials of the banks because they had suggested that if they had to sell investments they might require the Government to take upon itself some share of responsibility for whatever investment they had to sell because they would not interfere with that carefully-prepared mosaic. When we suggested meeting them later they then said that they did not require the meeting. When we said: "What about selling out some part of your portfolio of investments?", they told us then what had been said during the day that they did not require to sell any investments. They were going to make another entry, two entries on two sides of a book, and the £5,000,000 was at the disposal of the corporation. At the end of the day with a bit of double-entry book-keeping the money was found and there was to be no sale.
This year the Minister ineffectively approached the public for a large loan, and, to sweeten it for the investor, he announced that the banks had agreed to take up £5,000,000. Indeed, in the event, they had to take up more. I have asked repeatedly in this House, and I want an answer to the question: when the banks were to take up that £5,000,000 were they charging the Government the interest rate that they were offering to the ordinary investor, or were they merely getting that which they were entitled to, the operating cost of making a double entry in their books? I am sure they are getting their 5 per cent. or their 4¾ per cent. because, as I said before, they entered on the slippery slope when they gave that £5,000,000 Corporation Stock on the terms on which they did, revealing this to us that, if they did not halt themselves at this point, the whole system of the giving and the creation of bank credit in this country is on a new footing, and the sooner we get on that new footing the better for the people.
The Taoiseach and the Tánaiste approached the banks and they advertised afterwards, through the Department of Agriculture, the fruits of the magnificent victory they had with the joint stock banks. After the meeting, the Minister for Agriculture published an advertisement in the newspapers under the heading: "Credit—Fertilisers and Ground Limestone—New Scheme of Loans":—
"The Minister for Agriculture wishes to announce a new scheme of loans for the purchase of fertilisers and ground limestone. The following conditions shall apply."
The conditions are set out, and underneath, in regard to the things that relate particularly to ground limestone and fertilisers there is a special announcement. This is breath-taking; this represents a real revolution; this represents the defeat of the bankers faced by the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste. This is the special announcement:—
"The Government has been assured by the banks that credit-worthy merchants will be facilitated in obtaining accommodation for trade in fertilisers and ground limestone."
I had understood that one of the things in which banks trade was credit. We know that the banks' view of a credit-worthy person is sometimes difficult to understand. But consider the condition—two members of Government who allowed it to be promulgated as an advance that the Government had got an assurance from the banks that credit-worthy merchants would be facilitated in obtaining accommodation for trade in fertilisers and ground limestone. The part that follows I have never been able to analyse. I do not know whether it represents the depth of absurdity or the height of achievement, but this is the bald announcement:—
"Farmers who have money on deposit in Irish banks may obtain loans on the security of their deposits at a rate of interest of 1 per cent, above deposit rate."
Comment on this
A farmer with money on deposit in an Irish bank. The banks hold the money as security for the loan and they are to pay him out probably something less than what was deposited with them. For giving him something less than his own money, they charge him a rate of interest 1 per cent. above the rate they pay on deposits. Now, if there was ever mad finance in any community it is in that notice. It was bad enough to have the madness of finance displayed in the recesses of Government buildings at the time of the corporation loan, but this displays a juvenility of opinion in financial matters—that two prominent members of Government can publish that as an achievement, as something that they have wrung from the banks of this country.
The Minister for Finance, after telling us of all the standards that we have which excite the admiration of the Western world, came to the conclusion that:—
"There are some who will argue that we can have all this and heaven too, who will promise to provide an earthly paradise in which everyone will be given something for nothing and not only be given it for nothing but will be paid for taking it away."
Who has said that is no acquaintance of mine, but the Minister, apparently, knows someone who has made such promises. The Minister thinks it might cozen and deceive certain people, and winds up in this mood of optimism for his Party: "It just cannot be done and the people know that it cannot be done." It is the people who know that it cannot be done that we invite the Minister to make an early appearance before. It is so clear that the people do not want that and know it cannot be done! I cannot understand his reluctance.
I know that people postpone the evil day as long as they can. I know well that a development in the minds of many of us clearly brought home to many people in this community that there had occurred in 1948 in this country not a mere temporary interruption, an isolated interruption, of Fianna Fáil Government rule. What happened in that year was that there was not very decisively but to some degree a shift in Party political allegiances in this country. That pattern developed from 1948 to 1951. That pattern was again expressed by the people in 1951, but it was distorted by the activities of certain people like Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan and the two doctors, Deputy ffrench-O'Carroll and Deputy Browne. The Minister for Finance wants to know every time he looks at Deputy Cowan if they had only taken Deputy Cowan as a supporter in the last resort. I am not sure if, until recently, they knew how utterly last that resort was.
When these other three presented themselves to the Party nobody could say they were an attractive bait, but they were swallowed and absorbed, which is, possibly, a better word, hook, line and sinker. The downward pull on the sinker is what is telling now and is helping, again, to make clear the pattern which, as I say, was developed in 1948 and was again showing in 1951. As soon as we get the chance of an election, and it cannot be long delayed, that pattern will again show itself and this country will realise what a great many people have realised, that there is not, as I have said, a temporary interruption in the Party's programme and the Party's progress in this country, but a real decisive shift in political loyalties. That is the day that is ahead for the people who face me, for the people they have absorbed and the people they lean on; and that is the day they are anxious to defer. Even ten weeks count. Deputy Costello put here in the most matter of fact way the harm that has been caused; the confusion that there is politically; how that confusion will continue; the fact that businessmen will not buy because they know the prospective purchasers will not purchase from them so long as there is still a prospect that some alleviation may be given to the people in the new Budget.
When it comes to June and a new Government has to be formed, and that Government has to take on the task of looking at the out-turn of the year and what they will have as the proper expenditure for the year there will be at least four months of the financial year gone before matters can be taken in hand. It is criminal— and there is really no hope for the people who face me—it is criminal that in the end they should try to add to the damage they have already done to the community a little bit of extra damage, a little bit of extra damage which will be magnified over the short period in which they remain to do damage to the community.
Deputies Norton, McQuillan, Cowan, Corry and the Minister for Finance rose.
Comment on this
I am calling Deputy Norton. I cannot cram more than 60 minutes into an hour, and I am anxious to get an Independent Deputy because no Independent Deputy has yet spoken. I am calling on Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
May I put this point? This is a very important debate. We have already had a statement from the chairman of the Labour Party in relation to this matter. We have had alternate speeches from members of both sides of the House, and I suggest that, in view of the occasion, and in view of the speech to which we have just listened, it should be observed that if I am not permitted to speak we shall have no opportunity of replying.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance must understand that the Taoiseach had just sat down when Deputy McGilligan arose, and I cannot cross the House immediately to the Government side. I have to remember that there are other Parties to be considered.
Comment on this
Allow me to finish. Only one member of the Labour Party has spoken and, on its numerical strength, I think it is obvious that an ex-Minister and a Deputy ought to be allowed to speak. I am anxious that the Independent viewpoint should be expressed, and for that reason I am anxious that an Independent Deputy should speak.
Comment on this
And, if the Minister for Finance gets in, he will speak until 10 o'clock. That is his intention.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the leader of the Labour Party speaking, but some of us have been here since 3 o'clock to-day and I saw no sign of the leader of the Labour Party until a short time ago.
Comment on this
I am sure that if Deputy McQuillan asks the Labour Party they will tell him that they can expect no favours from me.
Comment on this
I am not swayed by any fact. I am endeavouring merely to give fair representation to all Parties.
Comment on this
I understood the main purpose was that the main Parties should express their views as to whether or not this Dáil should dissolve to-night, and we have had the views of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Deputy McQuillan must remember that each Independent Deputy is a Party to himself and I cannot call six Independent Deputies. I am calling Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
The debate on this motion affords the House an opportunity of taking stock of the political and economic situation and contrasting the situation to-day with the situation that existed three years ago or, indeed, with the situation that existed in 1948.
I want to go back for a few moments, and a few moments only, to ascertain what the position of the country was in 1948 when its destinies were entrusted to the inter-Party Government. I do not want to put my own assessment of the situation then; neither do I want to quote a Fine Gael member for anything he may have said, or say, as to the situation at that time. I am satisfied to take the testimony of Deputy Dr. Browne as to the condition of the country in 1948 and to see what has happened since then in the evolution that has taken place in the meantime. Speaking in June, 1948, Deputy Dr. Browne, from his exalted position as Minister at the time, said:—
"The inter-Party Government had taken over a very sick, tired country. There was possibly no phase of the national life that had not been affected to its detriment by the 16 years of Fianna Fáil mis-government. A lot had been said about Partition. There had been a lot of talk, particularly by the old gentleman——
Everybody knows who that means——
——who had 16 years to fix it and had done nothing and who now could do nothing because he now had no further power."
That was the economic position inherited by the inter-Party Government in 1948. If it failed in its efforts to try and right the country after a description of that kind, more reminiscent of the famine period than any other time, one could at least excuse it.
What did it do in the three short years to try to resurrect this very sick, tired country in which no phase of the national life had escaped the detrimental activities of 16 years of Fianna Fáil Government? In 1951 the inter-Party Government went out of office. It passed over the reins of office to the Fianna Fáil Party, who at the time got office by a trick and that trick is now recoiling on the Government. During its period in office the inter-Party Government with which the Labour Party was associated, repealed the penal taxes imposed by Fianna Fáil in 1947 on cigarettes, on beer and on tobacco. That cost this country £6,000,000 per year and that £6,000,000 went into the pockets of the ordinary, simple people who consume cigarettes, and tobacco and beer. We did not give £1,100,000 to the tobacco manufacturers, as the Fianna Fáil Government did, as a free gift. We did not give £140,000 to the dance-hall proprietors, as the Fianna Fáil Government did in their corrupt way, because they got the cheques of the dance-hall proprietors to help them fight the last election against the inter-Party Government. That was a piece of naked, political corruption. That was the way in which the Fianna Fáil Party accepted cheques from the dance-hall proprietors and then, out of the people's pockets, gave the dance-hall proprietors £140,000 per year in return for their cheques, the cheques that put Fianna Fáil back into office, though happily only temporarily.
We repealed these penal taxes that cost us £6,000,000 when we were in Government. While we were in office employment was rising as it had never risen before. We put 37,000 additional people into employment in three and a quarter years. Unemployment had been driven down to an all-time low record. Industrial production, as the Government's own figures have shown, was rising. Agricultural production was expanding. House building had been geared up to an all-time high record. There were more people employed in housing when we were in office than ever before or since. In spite of the deteriorating international situation we held prices level.
We did something over and above all this. For the first time in the long and chequered career of the Irish nation political peace was restored to this country and the gun was taken out of Irish politics. To-day all that situation has changed. To-day there is no question of repealing taxation. To-day there is no question of employment rising and the problem to-day is that unemployment is rising and emigration is increasing. House building has fallen off and in every sphere of our national life the same element of sickness and tiredness discovered by Deputy Dr. Browne in 1948 is back with us once more; every phase of our national life is again suffering under the baneful influence of the Fianna Fáil Government.
What is the present position in relation to these matters to which I have just referred? I do not want to talk for myself. I will let the Government figures talk. I have here a document issued by the Central Bureau of Statistics in February, 1952. That bureau is under the control of this Government. That document shows that on the 23rd February, 1951, there were 63,000 persons then registered as unemployed. Here is another document of the same type for the year 1954. It shows that on the 20th February, 1954, the number of persons registered as unemployed was 77,600, an increase of over 14,000 in the number of unemployed comparing February, 1951, with February, 1954. That is to the credit of this Government. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said in his famous speech in the Red Bank Restaurant in January, 1940, 14 years ago:—
"It was necessary to stress the urgency of the problem arising out of unemployment. If it persisted, our economic system could not survive. If unemployment persisted, it did not deserve to survive. There were obvious major defects in their methods of commercial organisation or their financial system if they were unable to provide an adequate livelihood for every man willing to work. If within the limits of the present system they could not cope with unemployment, then the system must be changed."
These were the brave words uttered after a meal in the Red Bank Restaurant on the 23rd January, 1940. Notwithstanding these brave words, we still have 77,600 persons registered as unemployed at the employment exchanges and every boat leaving this country is taking a human cargo to be spread over the cities of Great Britain and other cities throughout the world. There are 77,600 unemployed in this country with the same Government in office whose Minister made that speech in the Red Bank Restaurant 14 years ago.
We had a speech by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs recently. I said before that he sets out down the country on Saturday evenings to discover prosperity and he usually discovers there for the information of the Irish Press on Monday morning that some remarkable change has taken place in the whole economic life of the country. He said recently that there had been a striking fall in the number of persons unemployed. Somebody ought to read the figures for the Minister or get a blackboard and chalk for him. A striking fall, when the figures for 1954 were 14,600 above what they were in 1951. Where is the striking fall there? Test that actual fact certified by the Government's own Statistics Office with the brave words of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in 1940 and you can see that the major defects he talked of then are still present in our commercial organisation. Clearly there is no intention of repairing these major defects so long as this Government remains in office.
This is not the whole picture of the destitution we have got under this Government. There are 60,000 people still drawing miserably low standards of home assistance. There are 160,000 old age pensioners struggling to live on a miserable pittance of 21/6 per week at a time when the cost of living is higher than it was in living memory. That is the situation brought about by this Government. Then, of course, we had the famous 17-point programme of the Fianna Fáil Government. I do not want to go through the whole of the 17 points. It is sufficient for the purpose of my argument to quote one point in that 17-point programme. It read:—
"That it was the declared policy of Fianna Fáil to maintain the food subsidies, to control the prices of essential foodstuffs and the operation of an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary commodities."
Everybody knows that the whole system of price control has been completely strangled by this Government. The Prices Advisory Body is scarcely allowed to function. No public inquiry is to be held. The Minister is now treating that Prices Advisory Body with the utmost contempt. Price increases are being sanctioned by the Department from day to day and the Minister refuses to refer the question of price increases to the Prices Advisory Body. The Prices Advisory Body finds itself virtually defunct. While the Prices Advisory Body is virtually defunct and the Minister is increasing prices, the ordinary people are being crippled by the consequential effect of the Government's policy in having virtually abandoned all price control.
Let us come back to the food subsidies. In the 17-point programme there was a promise to the people to maintain the food subsidies. Somebody explained from the Government Benches why the food subsidies have been slashed. In the Budget of 1952 we had the most vicious slashing of the food subsidies. That, of course, was recommended to the Government by the Central Bank. The Central Bank recommended the inter-Party Government to do the same, but, of course, while that Government was there, the Central Bank bleated in vain in tendering advice to slash the food subsidies. There was no slashing of the food subsidies while we were there, and there would never have been any slashing. If we had remained there, the people of the country would be getting commodities to-day at virtually the same level as they were in 1951 and 1952. The Central Bank fooled this Government into making an attack which has wrought havoc with the internal economy of the country. Food subsidies were attacked and as a result of that prices rose rapidly, the purchasing power of the people was crippled, unemployment increased, the labour exchanges filled up with unemployed men and women and the ships and trains filled up with emigrants. All that is traceable to the fact that this Government put themselves in the hands of the directors of the Central Bank.
The Central Bank bleated in vain when they appealed to us to slash the food subsidies. They said it was a hidden subvention. It kept a reasonable price level in this country and brought a measure of prosperity to the homes of our people and a measure of prosperity to the nation. So long as these things were happening under the inter-Party Government, these were the things that mattered, and not the theories of the economists who adorn the building in Foster Place. We were not concerned with their economic theories for cutting down the consumption of food by our people and the export of that food to Great Britain to build up credits there which could not be effectively used for the benefit of our own people. So long as we had a choice between giving our people plenty of food to eat and a decent life and the austerity which they now know, they had not the austerity which they know since the Fianna Fáil Government came in.
The food subsidies were slashed. The result of that slashing was that the people have now the privilege of paying 4/2 per lb. for butter which they could get when we were in office for 2/8, and of paying 9¼d. for the 2 lb. loaf which they could get for 6½d. when we were in office. They now pay 5/- a lb. for tea which they were getting from us for 2/8; 7d. a lb. for sugar which they were getting from us for 4d.; and 4/6 a stone for flour which they were getting from us for 2/8. They pay more for beer, for tobacco, for cigarettes, for meat and for a whole lot of other commodities. It is because they are paying these in-increased prices that the Government lost 9,000 votes in the by-election in Cork. It is because the people are paying these higher prices that they will lose more and more votes. The people are being salted to pay these high prices, not because the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil want them to pay these high prices, but because the Central Bank made the Fianna Fáil Government swallow their advice to slash the food subsidies, which advice we refused to swallow for three and a half years.
I can understand the ordinary member of the Fianna Fáil Party, who cannot understand why these catastrophic increases in price took place, being bewildered by this development. There is no reason why they should have taken place. They did not take place during the three and a quarter years of the inter-Party Government, and they would not have taken place during the past three years but for the fact that the gentlemen on the front bench there were just putty in the hands of the Central Bank directors. They tried the same old bag of tricks on us but it did not work. We told them: "We will take all the advice you can express in your annual report, but do not expect us to act on that advice. We read it. We do not spend too much time applying your theories to the conditions of life of the Irish people, because we think we know better what the Irish people want than what the directors of the Central Bank want." But the Fianna Fáil Government swallowed the advice of the Central Bank and the people now have these higher prices. It is because they are paying these higher prices that Fianna Fáil are losing the by-elections. I can understand the Fianna Fáil Party not being anxious to go to the country. I can understand the Taoiseach cutting down his normally impetuous desire to gallop up to the Park and get the Dáil dissolved. That old trick used to work in better days, but there are so many people now paying more for bread, butter, tea, sugar, flour, meat, milk, tobacco, cigarettes and the ordinary bottle of stout that the Taoiseach knows that the moment he gets to the country he will have a collection of bees buzzing around his political bonnet so that he is going to be badly stung in votes when he meets the people in the next election.
Comment on this
Is it any wonder that the Government does not want to meet the electorate? Of course we are all human beings, with human feelings and human sympathies and human emotions. Deputy Cowan would sooner go up to North-East Dublin and tell his constituents: "Look, lads, did we not keep the cost of living down? When Fianna Fáil wanted to put the price of butter up to 4/2 I tried to keep it down to 2/8." That is a natural human feeling. We would all like to do that. Everybody knows that this dictation by the Central Bank was not in any way necessary. You swallowed the anchor as your Government in turn swallowed the anchor of the Central Bank, and now, of course, you do not want to meet the people because you know the political holocaust that awaits you as these by-elections have shown.
There is one hope for the people. Deputy Lemass had a recipe for it in 1947, at the time when Fianna Fáil had imposed the penal taxes on beer, tobacco and cigarettes—and, of course, there was never any need to do that either. The Fianna Fáil Party were told in October, 1947, that it was absolutely necessary to get £6,000,000 in the taxes on beer, cigarettes and tobacco. We proved it was not necessary at all, because within six months we gave it all back to the people and we maintained the subsidies on the foodstuffs which these taxes were supposed to be raised in order to underwrite. We gave those £6,000,000 back, and there was never any need for them any more than there was any need for slashing the food subsidies in 1952, but you swallowed that, too; but inevitably if you sow the wind then you reap the whirlwind.
When it was pointed out to Deputy Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, that this was going to inflict great hardship on the people, he had a remedy. He always has a remedy. The remedy was, he said, speaking at column 566 in the Dáil Debates of 16th October, 1947—and this suggestion is bewildering in its simplicity:—
"If a person objects to the higher tax imposed upon tobacco he can avoid paying it by reducing his consumption..."
There is a simple remedy—if you object to high prices, reduce your consumption. That is the same kind of remedy that the Fianna Fáil Party have given the people about butter. "If the price of butter is too high," they say, "do not eat so much butter. You can eat Stork margarine. That is better for you. If tea is too dear and you like this traditional cup of Irish tea, sometimes on your own or sometimes when an old friend joins you, just cut it down. Do not give them sugar in their tea either. Do not give them much bread when they call. Just cut down your consumption of those things. Send your butter to Britain. Send your eggs to Britain. Do not buy as much of the other commodities as you want. Instead of buying them, leave your assets in Britain and let your assets grow peanuts in Kenya for the Mau Mau. That is the best way to use your foreign assets."
Comment on this
I cannot limit the Deputy. I have asked Deputies to remember that I cannot put more than 60 minutes into an hour and I am trying to give everybody fair play.
Comment on this
I would give up if I thought that Deputy Cowan had an explanation for all this. There is the remedy, and that is the remedy that has been applied here over the last two years. The whole policy of the 1952 Budget was to prevent people consuming too much. The Central Bank said that they were eating too much and consuming too much.
Comment on this
——that people were consuming too much, their standard of living was too high, and that it was in fact quite undesirable to have so many people employed, because it would be a healthier economic condition in the view point of the Central Bank if you had a pool of unemployed because that pool of unemployed could be used as a check on the workers if they wanted to raise their standard of living. The Central Bank said therefore: "Have a pool of unemployed, cut down subsidies, make people consume less." This remedy was applied by the Fianna Fáil Government, of slashing subsidies, making the people pay more, and since they cannot pay more then the remedy still applied itself in this way that they would not eat as much, you can export more and chalk up credits in England. You will not need to buy as much and you can leave your sterling assets in Britain. That has been the result of this Budget policy of 1952.
We now have got this one achievement that ought not to be overlooked by the Fianna Fáil Party when it is preparing posters of the election—that we have now got the highest price level in human history in this country. Since the first day that records were made of prices in this country we are paying more to-day for these commodities than ever before. Is not that a marvellous record, one which could be described as a priceless record? The highest level ever attained in living memory—that is the record of the Fianna Fáil Government, and that is what they have to go to the people on. If there is no enthusiasm to make that record known, one can at least sympathise with the Taoiseach in the difficult position in which he finds himself. The truth of the matter is that the people are crippled by the high prices associated with this Government and their indignation has been shown in every by-election throughout the country. What the people's manifestation will be at the next election only the faces of the present members of the Fianna Fáil Party can indicate.
I want with some diffidence to raise the question of emigration, because this is one subject on which the Taoiseach has chosen to go as little as possible. The Taoiseach denied yesterday that emigration was increasing rapidly. I do not know who is advising the Taoiseach in this matter at all, but if the Taoiseach goes to the bishops around the country and asks them what is their experience in their parish records, what is the experience of the priests, he will find that from time to time in the last three years there have been sermons delivered by bishops and priests all deploring the appallingly high emigration taking place from the country. If you go to Amiens Street, Westland Row, Dún Laoghaire, Rosslare, Cork or Waterford, you will see cargoes of human beings being taken out every night in order to find employment in Britain, and is it not only natural when you have got nearly 15,000 people more unemployed to-day than you had in 1951 that inevitably people will go away in greater measure to-day because of the fact that employment is not here for them? We brought back large numbers of workers to engage in the building of houses here. We advertised in the English papers and asked these workers to return to their own country to engage in the building of houses for their own people. We said that the rates of pay they would get here were better than they would get in Britain, and that the inter-Party Government would provide continuous work for 20 years in the building of houses, schools, hospitals and public institutions. Large numbers of these workers came back. At that time, outside the painting trade, you could not get an unemployed building trade craftsman in the country. They were discharged from time to time and they walked from one job to another. They changed jobs two or three times a week, so keen was the demand for building trade operatives. Is that the position to-day?
Comment on this
More houses were built in two years since we came back than were built during the time of the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
That is the kind of performance that one would expect to see by a conjurer in the Theatre Royal. It belongs to the same pattern as producing a rabbit out of a hat.
Comment on this
I was not going to touch on that but now I will take another five minutes off the Minister's time to deal with it.
Comment on this
The plain fact is that emigration has increased substantially. The building trade workers who were brought over here during the time of the inter-Party Government are going back again. The unemployment exchanges are stuffed with lists of unemployed workers in the building trade. Every employment exchange has building trade operatives on its books that were not there in 1951 and they are there notwithstanding the fact that large numbers have got their books and have gone back to England. Let the Taoiseach go to the exchange in Gardiner Street or Werburgh Street, and find out the number of unemployed building operatives that have been registering there every week. Let him do the same in Cork and in each centre throughout the country. If the Taoiseach is doubtful about that information, let him go to the building trade unions and they will satisfy him as to the large number of building trade workers that have been signing on their books looking for employment. In fact, there are 6,000 fewer workers engaged in local authority building than there were in 1951. That statement cannot be challenged because that information was given in reply to a parliamentary question by the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
Everybody would be glad to know that the houses have been built, but we know that in Dublin City alone the problem of housing is of such dimensions that it will not be solved in 20 years; yet we have unemployed craftsmen registering as unemployed. Why cannot we get them to work on the provision of houses in Dublin? Let the Taoiseach get the figures and he will see that there are 6,000 fewer workers employed in local authority housing than there were three years ago. Is it any wonder that the building worker is not remaining here? What is the purpose of his remaining here, when he sees himself obliged to travel to the labour exchange each week and when, in juxtaposition to that, he can see regular employment available about 60 or 80 miles away?
Of course, it is the financial policy of the Minister for Finance that is responsible for that situation. The Minister launched a loan in 1952 at 5 per cent. Instead of borrowing money when he came into office in 1951 on a market that would have lapped up that loan at 3½ per cent., he spent his time in abusing his predecessors in office, in writing down the credit-worthiness of the State and in speaking at banquets asserting that the country was staggering towards bankruptcy. Having painted the country in the worst possible colours, how could you expect the people of the country to lend him money? Of course, he could not expect to get a loan at 3½ per cent. in the conditions which he had described, but he would have got the money in 1951 at 3½ per cent. if he had gone to the market at that time. We could have gone to the market in 1951, and got it at 3½ per cent. had we remained in office. At the utmost we would not have paid more than 3¾ per cent. We would never have dreamed of paying 5 per cent. but the present Minister for finance delightedly paid 5 per cent. When he was chided with that, he said that, of course, he did not want to spoil the ship for a ha'porth of tar. That was a very expensive ha'porth of tar. The difference between 3½ per cent. and 5 per cent. means that for 20 years we shall have to pay £300,000 each year for the Minister of Finance's ha'porth of tar. If the Minister goes into business selling tar, he looks to be a winner if he is going to get that amount of money for every ha'porth of tar he produces.
As a result of that increase in the rate of interest, every unfortunate white collar worker who has to borrow money under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act has to pay a considerably higher rate of interest on the loan than he had to pay when the inter-Party Government was in office. It is because the interest charges are too high and because such workers have now to pay much higher prices for commodities than in 1951 that they cannot afford to undertake these commitments and are unable to give orders for houses. The private builder is not able to sell his houses with the result that employment for building craftsmen in private building is lower than it has ever been in the last 20 years. Every Deputy knows that and that is directly due to the high price policy of the Minister for Finance and the Government. It is directly due to the same kind of advice which the Government accepted in respect to interest charges as they accepted in respect to the slashing of food subsidies from the Central Bank.
Comment on this
What does the Deputy mean by fair play? I want to deal now with the reference of the Minister for Finance to the Social Welfare Bill. When we were in office we put through the Second Stage a Bill which increased old age pensions, blind pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions by £2,500,000 a year. We did that six months after taking over from the Fianna Fáil Government who said they could not afford £500,000 to increase the pensions. We spent £2,500,000 in improving blind pensions, old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions.
Comment on this
I am glad that the day has passed when the Minister used to call the Deputy the Red Nuncio, and used to refer to a certain type of rat who occupied sewers. I am glad this touching reconciliation has taken place. Sometimes on reflection it must be awkward for the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I said that there is an hour left for the debate. Deputy Costello is entitled to half an hour according to the arrangement.
Comment on this
The Social Welfare Bill to which I have referred was put through the Second Stage, and would have been passed were it not that the going proved too risky for some of our supporters. We could not keep them steady when the boat began to rock. There were three valuable benefits which the Government proposed to make available in that Bill. We proposed to increase the maternity benefit from £2 to £5. That section was dropped from the Bill, and they got no increase from the Fianna Fáil Social Welfare Bill. We wanted to provide a death benefit in the case of the death of any member of the family. The insurance companies did not like it, and the benefit was dropped from the Fianna Fáil Bill. We proposed also to introduce a scheme of retirement pensions at 60 for women and at 65 for men. That section was dropped from the Fianna Fáil Bill. That section was dropped from the Fianna Fáil Bill, with the result that, because this Government has been inflicted on the people for the past three years, the ordinary working man does not now get death benefit, his wife does not now get the £5 maternity benefit and there is no retirement pension for the woman when she reaches 60 or the man when he reaches 65. If that is anything to boast about, well and good— Fianna Fáil can have it; but the mask will be torn from their faces during the forthcoming election.
When we sought to increase the compensation for an unmarried man or woman meeting with an accident arising out of or in the course of his or her employment, the Fianna Fáil Government, which could give £140,000 to the dance-hall proprietors and £1,100,000 to the tobacco manufacturers, could not give an unmarried man or unmarried woman one halfpenny increase in workmen's compensation, notwithstanding the fact that the Fianna Fáil Government have been responsible for an outrageous increase in prices since the present scale of workmen's compensation was determined. If that is anything to boast of, they can have it.
I propose to finish with one more quotation from a speech delivered by the then Deputy Lemass at Dalkey and I want to contrast the promise then with what has happened since. Speaking at Dalkey as reported in the Irish Press of 5th May, 1951, he said:—
"The constructive programme outlined by Fianna Fáil in the 1948 election stood unchanged, subject only to such modifications as were necessary because of the altered conditions or the ending of wartime difficulties or the wasting of the nation's resources by the Coalition. Fianna Fáil had learned much during its period in opposition. They had had time to study the wider aspects of national policy. They would be a better Government now than before."
We have 15,000 more unemployed to-day than when he made that speech; prices are higher than ever to-day; emigration is higher than ever; social benefits attractive to the workers have been dropped; interest rates are higher than ever before; and credit restriction greater than ever. But the Government would be a better Government now than before! Thanks be to God, they will not get an opportunity of getting any better, if these are the results of having a good Government.
Comment on this
This is the kind of document the Taoiseach ought to regard as his Bible to keep him on the rails, if this promise of better Government than before means that we will get that mess of 15,000 more unemployed, higher prices, higher emigration and many other things which were described by Deputy Dr. Browne earlier as constituting a sick and tired country.
The Labour Party are voting for this vote of no confidence. It is the only thing any decent person could do. This Government are now engaged in the barnacle-like process of hanging on to office. It is a discreditable rôle for a democratic Government to fill. The Government have no mandate from the people and that is the only reason the Taoiseach wants to go to the country, but, knowing that he has no mandate, he ought to pack up to-night and go. There is still time to arrange an appointment with the president. The Taoiseach ought to go to the country because he is not wanted by the people, and he can only get a majority in the House by dragooning and cajoling some people who make weight in the feet because they go into the Division Lobby in support of the Government.
I know that the game of delaying the election is for the purpose of enabling the Government to cook a Budget which they hope will be attractive, but, no matter what kind of chefs they get to cook it, it is too late now to cook it. The people know the kind of Budget Fianna Fáil would cook, if they had a clear majority. They know the kind of Budget they cooked in 1952 and they have been eating that Budget since. They want no more Budgets cooked in that kind of frying pan. They have finished with that kind of Budget and they have no use for the Government responsible for the 1952 Budget and do not want a 1954 Budget from the same Government.
This Government is discredited. It has no reputation left after these elections and it ought to go to the country and go quickly. That is the proper thing for a decent democratic Government to do. But remember that as on this occasion the people will have an opportunity of saying whether they approve or disapprove of the Government's policy, having regard to the way they have been treated in respect of prices, unemployment, emigration and every other aspect of national activity, I think the Government's attitude in not wanting to go is understandable. They know that a political boot is waiting for them and that it will fall with remorseless accuracy whenever polling day comes.
Comment on this
I am going to speak particularly briefly because I do not want to do as Deputy Norton did and speak at the length at which he spoke, in repetition, to a large extent, of everything said from the Fine Gael Benches already. Deputy McGilligan finished his speech to-night with some personal references to myself. I want to dismiss Deputy McGilligan very briefly. When Deputy McGilligan comes into this House on occasion—we have not seen him for a long time and, in fact, it was difficult to recognise him but one can always recognise his collection of Press clippings which he has read to this House on many occasions since I became a member. I had long ago been of the opinion that, in Deputy McGilligan, we had a master mind and a master brain, but he seems simply to be a wire recorder of his own Press cuttings. He spoke to us on the Central Bank Act and about how that Act should have been altered and amended. As a young student of politics, I read these same speeches of Deputy McGilligan when the Central Bank Bill was going through the House—exactly the same, word for word. The strange thing I want to refer to is that, in the three and a half years during which he was a Minister, he never did one thing to alter that Central Bank Act, but now, when he is in opposition again, and when he is coaxing the Labour Party to go to their destruction with him, he brings up the Central Bank Act again and if there is anything I can read into the speech he made, it is: "If I become Minister again, I will do what I did not do before—I will tackle the banks."
Deputy Kyne spoke here as chairman of the Labour Party and spoke in a reasoned way. He went out of his way to refer to the motion which, as he said, was introduced here by the Fine Gael Party. He deliberately pointed it out as a Fine Gael motion and what I cannot understand is why, if it is a Fine Gael motion, the leader of the Fine Gael Party has not got the courage to propose it in this House? What is the idea of selecting Deputy Costello to move the Fine Gael motion? Is it for the purpose of suggesting to the people that these Parties in the House are going to contest the election as an inter-Party group? Is that the idea? And if, in fact, Deputy Mulcahy's Party were successful in the general election, as the former Labour Deputy Connolly seems to think they might be, who is going to be Taoiseach and who are going to be Minister? Is Deputy Mulcahy to remain in the background again, or is he putting up Deputy Costello as a front for the purpose of fooling the people so that he will get into power? I think I am entitled to ask these questions and I think the country is entitled to have an answer to them. If people talk about the decision of the country, is it not right that the country should know whether there is an arrangement between Deputy Norton and Deputy Mulcahy to fight this election together as an inter-Party group under Deputy Costello?
Comment on this
I did not interrupt anybody to-night and I do not want to be interrupted in the few minutes I have at my disposal.
Comment on this
I will sit down and listen to the Deputy's answer. I invite the Deputy to give me the answer.
Comment on this
And he went down to Tipperary. I think we ought to understand the issue on which this election is going to be fought. Is it Fine Gael who are going to fight it for complete power or is there an arrangement between Deputy Norton and Deputy Mulcahy? Fine Gael put on the show of this motion here to-day. Yesterday they took a matter of £38,000,000 and said they were not interested. They said: "Have your Bill as well. We are not a bit interested in it." They put down this show of a business to-day which they knew they could not win. What is the idea of that?
Comment on this
Does not everybody know it? Does not Deputy O'Leary know that there are Deputies in this House who would keep out of the House rather than defeat the Government on this issue.
Comment on this
I think the people are entitled to object to the attempt to mislead and fool them with rhetoric in this House. Deputy Cosgrave, speaking to-night, said that people want an inter-Party Government. Deputy MacBride, speaking round the country, said they wanted a national Government. In other words, he is appealing to the Taoiseach: "Take me in with you and we will run the country." Is not that exactly what he is doing? Does Deputy Mulcahy agree with Deputy MacBride? Does he want to enter a national Government under the Taoiseach? Does he want to do that? Is the issue, inter-Party, Fine Gael, or a national Government I should like to know that and so would the people.
Comment on this
I will be prepared to meet the Deputy there and I can assure him that the people will not defeat me in North-East Dublin in the way they defeated the Deputy.
I just want to say one little thing about what has happened. When I came into this Dáil after the last election I had indicated in my constituency that there were three things I wanted. I wanted a Social Welfare Bill passed into law. Fine Gael had opposed it prior to that and prevented it coming into operation. I said I wanted a Health Bill which would include a mother and child scheme. That has been passed into law in spite of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
I said I wanted an Adoption Bill. Those were the three things I told my constituents I was going into this House to get. Those three things have been passed in spite of Fine Gael.
For the past three years we have had these continuous demands for a general election. I have mentioned the matter before and I do not want to spend any more time on it. The whole purpose of that was to create instability in the country and prevent the country from getting a chance of getting on. I want to declare that that continuous demand for a general election was not in the public interest.
I am sorry that, through being left so little time, I have been prevented from making the speech I would have liked to make.
Comment on this
I want to say this. Not only this country but every country in Western Europe has been faced, during the past three or four years, with a serious threat due to to what is called inflation. Measures were taken in regard to that, not only by this country but by every other country in Western Europe. Any Deputy who reads the latest report of the O.E.E.C. for the year ending 31st December, which is now available, will see that the efforts, not only of this Government but of the other Governments of Western Europe have established conditions from which there can be, and can reasonably be expected to be, an advance to better things. We have reached the stage now where we are just on the jumping-off ground to better things and that has been due entirely to——
Comment on this
——no, but to the serious efforts that have been made here and elsewhere in regard to that.
I see that we have to face very serious problems.
Comment on this
One of the big difficulties —it will not be solved by acting the omadhaun either here or on political platforms—that may confront us in the near future is the price of agricultural produce, due to the new steps that are being taken in Britain. The facing up to that problem is one of the most serious things that this country has had to deal with for a considerable period. I want to know, when the impact of the new British policy hits this country, who is going to deal with that in the right way?
If we had Deputies Dillon, MacBride and Blowick, dealing with that situation, could they agree on the measures that should be taken in the national interest to secure the Irish people in the situation that is fast developing? I think the farmers and people of this country have got to face up to that situation. I think that will be one of the vital issues that must be determined by the electorate in this general election. Any policy of wavering or instability; any policy of internal wire-pulling is not going to solve a situation such as this. It is not going to provide for the farmers of this country the security that they need to continue their prosperity.
We have this particular motion to-day. It is a motion which is intended to insult the intelligence of the country. As I have already said, it is known that the motion cannot be won in this House, but it is considered desirable that the time of the House should be wasted by the type of debate we have had here, the type of speech which was Deputy McGilligan's contribution and which he has made so often in this House—there was nothing new in it—and the other type of speech to which I do not want to refer. Every candidate if he is to consider himself as a personal individual when an election is coming is anxious to get it over and done with as quickly as possible. That is the desire of every candidate, but where the national interests are concerned it is not the interests of individual candidates that must count. It is the public interest and the public interest demands that the very grave matters of finance and other matters mentioned which are to be determined by the people should be determined after the people have got a proper opportunity of considering them.
I think every person in this House would agree that if we are to have an informed decision from the public, it is desirable that all the facts and factors should be put before them. When they come to make up their minds what the decision is we will have the decision of the Irish people. For that reason I favour in the main the decision that has been made in regard to the date of the general election.
There is one other point that must be mentioned, and it should not be overlooked. The Taoiseach has referred to the new register. There are thousands of young boys and girls in the country who will be able to vote in May who could not vote in April. Fine Gael as a Party says that they are the Party of the young people. If so, why do they want to prevent the young people voting in this general election? Young people of 21, almost 22, in fact over 22, are entitled to have their say in the running of this country. It is wrong for Deputy Mulcahy, through Deputy Costello or otherwise, to try to prevent that. Deputy Norton has been rather skittish, if I may put it that way, in regard to myself. I want to direct his attention and the attention of his colleagues on the Labour Party Benches to the Leader of Saturday next, the 13th instant, in which the general election is discussed. I merely want to quote this little part from it.
Comment on this
Ignorance and vulgarity. This is what I wish to quote:—
"The Labour Party, too, have reason to be dismayed by its performance. They have suffered blows from which they can scarcely hope soon to recover, and Mr. Roddy Connolly, the Labour candidate in Louth, seems to be aware not merely of his Party's plight but of the general significance of the by-election results. He was reported as having said that: `They had 16 years of Fianna Fáil Government and he felt that they were probably in for 16 years of Fine Gael Government.' His candour may have shocked many of his Party colleagues, but it probably expressed the secret thoughts—and fears—of some of them. In any event, Mr. Connolly's reading of the situation was more realistic than that contained in the week-end statement of Clann na Poblachta..."
I will not quote that.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Deputy one question. Would he read what the Leader says about Deputy Dr. Browne, just a little bit lower down.
Comment on this
I advise Deputy O'Higgins to read this issue of the Leader and I advise my friend, Deputy Hickey to read it because it is a reasoned, constructive examination of a problem that is dear to me as it is to the members of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I understand some agreement has been come to between the Parties that this discussion would end at 10 o'clock to allow the mover of the motion to reply. It is an extraordinary thing that in this House the political Parties pay little or no heed to Independents except when it comes to a tight issue or when a dramatic moment arrives as to whether the Government should or should not dissolve in this House. I was not consulted as an Independent as to the question of allowing——
Comment on this
If Deputy McQuillan is under the impression that I wish to filch any time I want to make it clear that I do not. The arrangement was made in accordance with the usual parliamentary practice. I am prepared to give way to Deputy McQuillan until 10.10 p.m. and leave myself only 20 minutes.
Comment on this
I did not suggest for a moment that Deputy Costello made this arrangement but members of his Party took up plenty of time after Deputy Costello spoke.
Comment on this
The leaders of the various Parties should have been free to express their views as to whether the Dáil should dissolve to-night but the Independents who have been elected to this House as Independents should have been allowed to make their views known to the public as well as the leaders of the Parties. I resent very strongly the fact that I am going to be confined to ten or 15 minutes to give my views as to what line of action I propose to take here to-night.
I listened very carefully and made it a point of being here practically all evening to listen to both sides of the House. This is a very simple motion and I heard Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Aiken and the Taoiseach emphasising this very important point that if an election is held in the near future we must all take into consideration the type of Government that will face the country and that will have control for the next five years. That theme of five years has been running through the speeches of the Government side and the Opposition side, that the next Government that is to be elected to this House is to have five years in which to carry out the policy which it puts before the people.
I came into this House in 1948, that is just six years ago, and inside that six years this is the third general election I have had to face. I am not worried about it personally but I want to point out the futility of any speaker from either Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil suggesting that the life-time of the Government that will come in in the next month or two months is going to be five years. Let there be no mistake about it. It may be only six months or at the most 12 months because if we had three elections since 1948 the political situation has not yet cleared itself. The fog has not risen from the minds of the people and I for one am not prepared to accept in any slick manner agreements in this House which I know nothing about but which may be there.
Let me make this quite clear because I know in the short space of time left every attempt will be made to misrepresent my stand in this House. Since I came here in 1948 I could never be described as an ardent supporter of Fianna Fáil. Due to the fact that I was a member of Clann na Poblachta, I was bound by Party rules to give my support to a form of inter-Party Government and for three years I loyally gave that support until the position became so bad with the treachery shown inside our own Party that I severed my connection with that organisation and the public believed I was right to do so. They returned me here as an Independent Deputy from a rural constituency and that in spite of misrepresentations from some of my former colleagues who are now sitting in the Opposition Benches.
I have no love for Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil. What am I asked to decide? The first intimation I had of the situation was on last Friday morning when I read the newspapers and saw where the Taoiseach had made a statement that he believed that to have an early general election was the right action to take. Naturally as an individual I dislike the idea of facing a general election but the fact is that the Taoiseach has the power to decide when that general election should be held. That is his business. I remember, however, that he made a statement in Louth in which he declared that the question of a general election did not depend on the results of the by-election. There was great speculation as to what the Taoiseach really meant—whether he would give three weeks or six weeks. Listening to the speeches made here this evening, anyone would think that a change of Government in the next three weeks or the next six weeks was going to undo the damage done for two, three, four or five years.
I have heard the Labour Party here to-night bemoaning emigration during the Fianna Fáil régime. Let us clear our minds of this fact. According to the census report, between the years 1947 and 1951, more people left Ireland than in any ten-year period previous to that. That included three years of the inter-Party régime and two years of the Fianna Fáil administration. So I see no practical difference. I see no improvement under one or the other, on the question of emigration. If I wanted to play politics, I could be far more easy on the Parties of this House, for myself, but I am not and I think it is the duty of someone, if the Labour Party do not do it, to point out the facts as they really are. The next three weeks or six weeks are not going to make a big difference; there is going to be no great change in the future of Ireland if this Government is allowed to stay for six weeks more.
If it were a question that this motion was put down, as Deputy de Valera put down one 12 months ago, calling on the Dáil to reaffirm its confidence in him as Leader and in Fianna Fáil as a Government for the next 12 months or two years, I might be taking a very different stand here to-night. I have never affirmed my confidence in that Government. My vote originally was cast in this House for the present Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Costello, but I made it clear at the time that if what I considered was good legislation was passed in this House, at no time would I hinder that legislation for the sake of voting against the issue involved because I did not like members of the Government or the Government itself.
In that time, the first thing that I would like to congratulate that Government on doing was their introduction of the Health Bill. It was a poor Bill in comparison to what I would like to have seen introduced, but at least it was much better than what would have happened if Fine Gael on their own were allowed to introduce the Bill.
Within the last 12 months I have seen that the Restrictive Trade Practices Act has been passed and a body has been set up to examine into profits, to try to break up rings that have existed in this country. That is useful; the people can see now where profits are going, they can see that some particular individuals have been able to get 50 per cent. profit on the sale of certain commodities. No Government was going to bring in legislation that would expose that, if they were afraid of these vested interests.
That is only one side of the picture. I judge Governments on their results, and if I have taken into consideration (1) employment, that is a black mark against this Government; (2) emigration, that is another black mark; (3) the development of the West of Ireland, that is another black mark. But I can give those three black marks to the Government that went before them, too.
I would not be in this House were it not for the fact that the people in my constituency do not accept either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. Neither would Clann na Talmhan be in this House if the people in Mayo, Roscommon and Galway accepted either of the major Parties. It is a well-known fact that every time a new Party came up in this country in the last 25 to 30 years, it was in the West of Ireland that Party nearly always started. Clann na Talmhan started in the West of Ireland, because no Government gave the consideration to the western problems that should have been given. The earlier Cumann na nGaedheal Government, the Fianna Fáil Government that followed it, the inter-Party Government and the present Government have all failed in their attempts to solve that great problem that lies west of the Shannon. The only time that I see the West being mentioned here is when the question of the Gaeltacht alone is mentioned. We have had a lot of pious talk and pious resolutions inside and outside the House about the revival of the Irish language and preventing the disappearance of the Gaeltacht, while no practical measures whatever are taken to see that the livelihood of the people in those areas is protected. We have miserable. miserly industries started in the West, giving little or no employment, when the real means of keeping the young men at home in afforestation and fishing are completely neglected. I have listened to Deputy Blowick talk here about what he did in afforestation. He did no more about it than the present Minister is doing. I do not want to get involved in this, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I merely want to give my reasons for adopting a certain line of action here to-night. I do not believe that if there were again to-morrow morning a change of Government, that will bring any great improvement in these things.
I welcome the idea of a general election. I am perfectly satisfied about the arrangements for the date and so forth. If I looked to my own interests, I would prefer to have the election in the next three weeks. If as an Independent I took the personal element into consideration, every Deputy knows that a short election and a snappy one suits the financial situation of any Deputy, and especially an Independent one, who has no organisation. But I feel this is essential. There is a real fog in the minds of the people at the moment. If this Dáil dissolves to-night, there are no issues involved except dissatisfaction alone with the present Government. I want to find out for myself and for the constituents who sent me here, what the policy of the Fine Gael Party is going to be when the general election comes along, and what the policy of the Labour Party is going to be. I make no bones about it to anybody here, that I am elected by the people to represent their interests and to bring home a message to them from Deputy Costello. Is he prepared to be Leader of an inter-Party Government the same type as we had from 1948 to 1951? If so, is he prepared to accept the Labour Party's proposals that the food subsidies be brought back? If that is the case, does he propose at the same time to reduce taxation? Is he prepared—and I hope he is, and if he is he will get my support—to make a change in the financial policy of this country?
Comment on this
Is he prepared to ensure that the credit that should rightfully belong to the State is vested in this House, to see that the power to use that credit lies in this House and not in the hands of the directors in the different banks. I listened here to Deputy McGilligan for 20 minutes talking about the way he brought the directors of the different banks before him and told them they should give a loan to the Dublin Corporation. Why should any Government go with their caps in their hand to a group of private interests and say: "Please give us this money to build houses or to make roads or to do afforestation?"
Comment on this
That power should lie in the hands of the State—not perhaps with the particular Government but in a body responsible to this House. I want to know if that is going to be brought to an end, as part of the policy of the next Government, whether it be an inter-Party Government or otherwise.
Comment on this
The House made an order that Deputy Costello would be called at 10 o'clock. Deputy Costello was good enough to extend ten minutes to Deputy McQuillan.
Comment on this
I want to apologise to Deputy Costello for taking up his time. What I have to say is not against Deputy Costello. I want to clarify my own position. I want to clarify it for the people who sent me here. I will finish on this note: we saw, in the course of the by-elections, that the people were dissatisfied with the present Government. The Taoiseach has accepted the decision of the electors in the by-elections and, as a result, he has announced that the Dáil will be dissolved within the next two months. All I am concerned with is the time. The motion states that, in the opinion of the Dáil, Dáil Éireann should be dissolved forthwith. I do not see what benefit that will confer on the community to-night. Personally, I do not care whether the Dáil dissolves to-night or in three weeks' time but I should like that we would have a statement of policy from the Opposition groups as to what they propose to put into operation if and when this general election takes place.
Comment on this
I have no intention of utilising my vote for the purpose of putting Fianna Fáil out at this moment. They are going out in the next six weeks. I am not going to be used by either side in the House. I am here as an Independent with allegiance to no Party, except the public which sent me and I will answer to them when the time comes.
Comment on this
I want to bring the House back to the terms of this motion. The terms of the motion are that, in the opinion of the Dáil, Dáil Éireann shall be dissolved forthwith. The operative word in that is "forthwith". I listened this afternoon to Ministers and to Deputies from various parts of the House supporting the Government. I heard no single reason given either by the Taoiseach or by his two Ministers who spoke or by any of their adherents, whether Independent or otherwise, who spoke upon this motion as to why this House should not be dissolved forthwith.
On this motion it is not a question of whether or not there will be an inter-Party Government, a Fine Gael Government or a Fianna Fáil Government. What is to be decided upon this motion is, the Taoiseach having interpreted the results of the by-election in Cork City and in County Louth as involving necessarily a general election, that general election should be given at the earliest possible moment.
I shall not be drawn into irrelevant discussions by any Deputy, Independent or so-called Independent or otherwise. I shall not give on this motion any indication as to what our policy shall be or shall not be. That will be given at the appropriate place and in the appropriate time to the electors and they will have to judge. What we want to force this present Government to do is to get to the people as quickly as they can so that the verdict which we know will be given as quickly as we possibly can get at them will be given at the earliest possible time in the public interest.
I gave three major reasons this afternoon why there should be an immediate general election. Not one single member of the Government, not one adherent of the Government Party, answered any of those three major reasons. In the speech which the Taoiseach made he did not deal with one single one of them. He tried to involve us in a discussion of what the future Government would do and what was our policy in the future and what it was in the past. All that is irrelevant on the present motion.
The last Deputy who spoke said that there was a real fog in the minds of the people. There was no fog in the minds of the electorate of North-West Dublin when, by a majority such as was never given before against an existing Government in this country they expressed their disapproval of Fianna Fáil, the Fianna Fáil Government and all their adherents. There was no fog in the minds of the electorate of Wicklow or of East Cork when, by a vote which was unmistakable in its meaning and significance, they said that they did not want either Fianna Fáil or any of their hangers-on, or those who were absorbed by them.
Whatever fog there may have been in the minds of certain people, Cork City spoke with a voice louder and more emphatic than was used by the plain, poor people of North-West Dublin, who repudiated the present Government and all their adherents who had brought upon them a régime of austerity and suffering such as was never inflicted upon the Irish people even by an alien Government.
All those Deputies who joined the Fianna Fáil Party—Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Cowan, Deputy Cogan and the rest of them—were responsible, each and every one of them, for bringing untold hardship, misery and suffering upon, not merely the poorest section of our people but upon our working people and on our middle class people. The middle class sections of our people had to suffer in silence. The working people, at least, can have the benefit of a trade union, but those people who are in the middle class, for whom we in particular stand, had to suffer in silence and had to suffer perhaps far more deeply than even the people for whom the Labour Party stood. It was to get rid of the present Government that Cork City spoke so plainly, so emphatically, and that County Louth also spoke in that fashion.
Let me recall what the Taoiseach said when he was called upon to do the decent thing and resign and submit himself to the verdict of the people last June or July. He said then that it was not possible for one Party that had only one seat in a three-seat constituency to win that election. That is why they would not go. That is why, he said, one could not interpret the verdict in Wicklow as being a vote of censure upon the Government and its policies. We won County Louth although we had only one seat in it. Is not that the plainest, most emphatic and clearest indication of the wishes of the people that they do not want to have the austerity and the régime and the suffering which has been inflicted upon them, and which every person knows has been inflicted by no deliberate action but by a policy, deliberately designed, which had as its inevitable consequence the infliction of suffering and hardship on all sections of our people?
I listened to the Taoiseach and I wondered when he would come to the point. With the exception of two or three short sentences, he did not deal with this motion. I challenged the Taoiseach, at the outset of my remarks, to say why he had changed the date of this election when we knew it had been his intention to go immediately——
Comment on this
I challenged the Taoiseach when he came to speak during this debate to say whether that was true or not. He sat down without answering my question. I repeat it now. We can only speculate on the reasons for this change. My reasons for moving this motion have nothing to do with politics. I stated yesterday that—speaking as a politician, representative of a political Party—I was anxious for an election. I gave three major reasons to-day as to why there should be an immediate election, but not one single one of these was answered either by the Taoiseach or by the Minister for External Affairs or by the Minister for Defence or by Deputy Allen who spoke——
Comment on this
Not one single answer was given to one of them. I put the first argument, based upon the dislocation of business. The Minister for Defence was the first to speak from the Government Benches. He contented himself with quoting from newspapers in order to show that a remark that somebody had made to the effect that everybody thought there would be an immediate election was not true. That was the sole contribution he made in circumstances where Cork City had spoken so emphatically to get out and where County Louth had spoken in its own way equally emphatically.
Comment on this
The sole thing which I could get out of the Taoiseach's statement dealing with the issues involved in this motion was that because they had framed the Book of Estimates they then had to frame the Budget proposals so that the country would have before it the financial situation in its true colours. What is that but political expediency?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's sole reference to this motion in the whole of his not too lengthy but long speech was that because they had framed the Book of Estimates they should therefore frame the Budget. That is political expediency. Many of my colleagues have said that no matter what Budget comes in, no matter how it is framed, the people will not believe that it is anything other than an election Budget, introduced and devised for the purpose of trying to salvage some part at least of the wreckage of Fianna Fáil's political fortunes.
The Taoiseach referred to the charge that had been made that he and his Government had broken the promise on which they had attained office—the promise to preserve the food subsidies. What were his excuses for that? He did not deny that he had broken the promise. He said that that promise was not made during the general election but was made after the general election. It was made for the purpose of capturing the votes of those people who were supposed to be Independent at that time because the policy they said they were satisfied with was the maintenance of the food subsidies. Within a few months the food subsidies were gone—and the Taoiseach's explanation is that he did not know there was £15,000,000 of a deficit. I do not know where he got the figure.
The second major reason I gave on this motion for a dissolution forthwith was that a new Government should be elected at the earliest possible moment —and if the Dáil dissolved to-night we could have a new Government on the 2nd April—so that the new Administration would be able to look at the real financial position and picture of this country and, itself, on the information which it can then get, frame its policy and Budget. We are being deliberately prevented from doing that. I believe and charge that this postponement of the general election —because it is an afterthought, I again repeat—in order to enable the Budget to be framed is deliberately designed, apart from its effort to bolster up the falling fortunes of Fianna Fáil, to hamper and hinder any new Administration that may take office.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach said he is not in the market. I presume that he intended to imply that somebody else was in the market. This Party, to which I have the honour to belong, is not in the market. I do not believe Deputy Norton's Party, with whom I had the proud privilege to be associated for three years, is in the market—nor my friend, Deputy Joe Blowick. The reason why the Minister for External Affairs spent all his time—all his time—when he spoke to-day making a personal attack upon my former colleague, Deputy Seán MacBride, was because of his jealousy of Deputy Seán MacBride.
Comment on this
It was also because of the fact that the Minister had no answer to the arguments that had been put forward in support of this motion. Fianna Fáil is not in the market because the bottom has fallen out of the Fianna Fáil market and their wares will not be purchased by anybody.
Comment on this
We are going to this election with the headlines that we gave during the by-elections—that neither I nor any of my colleagues wish to gain political office or political power; not one single one of us do. We regard ourselves as the servants of the people, not as their masters. We submit ourselves to the verdict of the people.
I was careful to say, in an interruption which I made during the speech of the Minister for Defence, that I never said I was going to form a Government. What I and my colleagues and, I believe, my friends, Deputy Seán MacBride and Deputy Blowick and Deputy Norton, are going to do is to submit ourselves to the people and say: "There is Fianna Fáil. Here is our record. There is their record. What do you want?" The people will have to decide. They will have to decide whether they want Fianna Fáil or some other form of Government. We say that they want to do that now and to do it quickly. The vote that was given in the Cork by-election represented a demand that this Government get out and get out quickly. Because this Government do not get out, they are flouting the wishes and urgent desires of the great majority of the ordinary people of this country.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
On the motion for the Adjournment, Deputy Dunne gave notice that he would raise the subject matter of Questions Nos. 10 and 11 on to-day's Order Paper.
Comment on this
I want to say that, in view of the fact that the Government is in a condition of nervous prostration, it is not my purpose to inflict any further suffering on them this evening. With the permission of the Chair, I would ask to have this question regarding the price of stout postponed until next sitting day.
The Dáil adjourned at 10.40 p.m. until 3 p.m. on Wednesday, 24th March, 1954.