We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–222 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

The Budget debate need not conclude at 5 o'clock to-morrow? The General Budget Resolution need not be put to-morrow?

Comment on this

It need not be put but I should expect the ordinary course would be followed.

Comment on this

In ordinary circumstances, there would be unlimited time for a debate on the Budget.

Comment on this

I think a discussion on the precise manner in which the proceedings of Dáil Éireann are to be brought to a close to-morrow should be more properly undertaken by the Whips.

Comment on this

In the circumstances in which the Minister's proposals for this Budget are being discussed, I do not think it is necessary and, indeed, very probably not possible, to discuss the Minister's statement in any great detail or to enter into a complete analysis of all the matters touched upon by him in the course of his speech. The time for that consideration is when there is a new Government no longer in opposition but in full possession of all the facts.

I should like at the outset of the remarks I have to make to reiterate the protest that I made some time ago against a procedure which has been adopted by the Minister and by the Government in general in introducing the Budget proposals before a dissolution. Many of these proposals will, by virtue of statutory provisions, fail to have any real effect but, apart from considerations of that kind, it is not proper, as I submit to the Deputies of this House, that a fading Ministry, one going to the country on the eve of a general election, should deal with the economic and national life of the country and, perhaps, hamper a succeeding Government in its policy and in the operation of its plans. Such a fading Ministry as we have at the present moment will necessarily be more concerned to justify itself and its past rather than to indicate a courageous action and constructive effort to solve the problems that are undoubtedly facing the country— problems of some serious and grave difficulty.

Having made that protest, I propose only to deal, very shortly I hope, with some of the outstanding features of the Minister's statement. I think, when it is realised how little the Minister's statement contains of any constructive economic or financial proposals to deal with the future difficulties facing the country and when it is appreciated how slight the reliefs that have been given really are, the question will be properly put by many was it for this that the country was allowed during a period of nearly two months to remain in a state of dislocation and instability, and with business practically brought to a standstill because of the proposals by the Minister in his Budget speech that were awaited?

Whatever may be said about the Minister's claims, I think three things stand out from his speech. The Minister's speech is really a recantation of the policies which he put into operation in the famous or infamous Budget of 1952. The proposals in the Budget as a whole are an admission of the failure of those policies and in many respects they furnish striking justification of the charges that we made on this side of the House, after the Budget of 1952, that the Budget proposals of that year contained wholly unjust and unnecessary overtaxation. With these three outstanding matters I propose to deal and I propose to confine my remarks very largely to those three outstanding features of the present Budget.

Deputies will recall the eloquence of the Minister for Finance in dealing with the proposals to do away with the greater part of the food subsidies then in question when on the 2nd April, 1952, he said at column 1136, Volume 130, of the Official Debates:—

"the largest item of current expenditure in which significant economies are readily possible and fully defensible is food subsidies."

The Minister there indicated his policy as regards the food subsidies then in existence, that their removal was readily possible and fully defensible. The proposal in this Budget to give £900,000 of the taxpayers' money towards the wheat and flour subsidies to bring about the rather insignificant reduction of a halfpenny in the 2-lb. loaf is a reversal of that policy and an admission that the statement which I have quoted was entirely indefensible. It will be remarked, I am sure, that at page 48 of his Budget speech the Minister did not say: "I am increasing the food subsidies on bread and flour". He referred very coyly and delicately to sub-head J (1) of Vote 50.

Of course, in restoring certain of the food subsidies which were, according to himself in 1952, an economy that was readily possible and fully defensible, he is going back upon his policy stated there. Now, at the end of three years' experience of that policy in regard to the withdrawal of the food subsidies, he goes back upon that and admits, not explicitly but impliedly, that that policy was wrong and incapable of being defended. As a matter of fact, those other reliefs which are contained in this present Budget are really in the nature of subsidies, because they themselves are rendered necessary by the consequences of the Minister's and Government's policy, particularly in reference to the assaults which they made upon the incomes of all sections of the people by the financial proposals of the Budget of 1952.

Slight as those benefits are to the income-tax payer, to the owner-occupier of a house, to the widows and the other persons who will gain by them, they will be appreciated, but they would have been of far more value to those people had their incomes not been irrevocably assaulted and injured by the policy enshrined in the 1952 Budget. The effects of that policy are still in operation, are still being felt by every section of the community. The electorate at the recent by-elections which have brought about the general election which is now pending and on the eve of which this Budget is introduced certainly did not agree with the Minister's statement and would not even now agree, nor will they agree at the forthcoming election, that the year which has just passed was a year of progress in industry and agriculture, of increased trade and of higher incomes. That preposterous claim, made as it was in different ways during the campaigns of the recent by-elections, was repudiated in a starting fashion by the electorate of Cork and in equally significant fashion by the electorate of County Louth.

The slight and comparatively trivial reliefs which have been given by this Budget are secured by a series of devices some of which are perfectly legitimate and in accordance with financial rectitude and some of which, had they been operated by the Minister's predecessor, would have evoked from the Minister for Finance quite a series of denunciatory phrases culled from his very abundant vocabulary of abusive epithets. We have heard from the Minister and from his various colleages the unjustified and outrageous charge that Deputy McGilligan's Budget of 1951—and perhaps some of the others but certainly that of 1951—was faked. I hesitate to use that word but I will say that some of the devices to which I will shortly refer are of dubious justification. Some of those devices are perfectly legitimate but when they were operated by the Minister's predecessor and the Minister's predecessors, the present Minister for Finance poured scorn upon them and stated that they were contrary to what he called "the principles of financial rectitude".

I want to recall the Minister's attention and that of the Deputies to what we said here in the discussion on the Budget of 1952 in reference to the failure of the Minister to take into account in considering the amount of taxation that he would impose upon the people in that year the traditional item for overestimation. At column 1274, Volume 130, of the Official Debates of 3rd April, 1952, I made the charge then in a series of counts in an indictment that the present Government were in that Budget unnecessarily and unjustly overtaxing the people. In proof of that statement I referred to the fact that the Minister had neglected, in considering the amount of taxation he would impose to balance his Budget at that time, to take into account that traditional item known as overestimation. I said:—

"The fourth item consists of failure by the Minister for Finance to take any account in his calculations for taxation for the amount of money that would be required to be met by taxation for the traditional item known as overstimation. That traditional item of overstimation is also sometimes spoken of as economies..."

May I pause there because the phrase which I then used is of particular significance and importance having regard to the use which the Minister makes of the expression "economies" and also of the euphemism he employs in relation to this matter of overestimation. He calls it undetected overestimation.

I went on to say:—

"That traditional item of overestimation is also sometimes spoken of as economies and consists of departmental savings. We estimate for that, and we think it is a conservative estimate, £2,000,000."

We pressed upon the Government at that time that by taking into account in the amount of taxation imposed by the Budget of 1952 overestimation to the extent to £2,000,000, taxation to the extent of £2,000,000—a not insignificant amount—could have been saved and the taxpayers would at least have been saved that amount of taxation. The Minister for Industry and Commerce purported to deal with the various counts in the indictment that I preferred against the Government at that time in relation to overtaxation. Dealing with the fourth item to which I have referred, the Minister dismissed it in a few words. He said:—

"The calculations which Deputy Costello made to support his contention that taxation is being imposed unnecessarily were based upon three assumptions."

The first is not relevant to the point I am making at the moment. He dealt then with the second point:—

"Secondly, that the Department of Finance is incapable of estimating accurately the interest on the public debt; and thirdly, that the accounting officers in every Department are incapable of estimating the cost of the services administered by their Departments."

He alleged that I was stating that officials of State Departments are incapable of estimating the cost of the services administered by the Departments. He then asked a rhetorical question: "Does anybody believe that?" He said that:—

"Deputy Costello's calculations were based upon such obvious fallacies that, I am sure, most Deputies saw them at once, and that it is not necessary to expose them further."

That is the way in which he threw aside the case I made that the Minister ought to have taken into account the conservative sum of £2,000,000 for overestimation. He tossed that aside, asking does anybody consider that departmental officials are incapable of accurate estimation?

The Minister for Finance then came to deal with the point in his reply to the Budget debate of that year. At column 940 of Volume 131 of the Official Report he referred to the arguments I had advanced, including my argument in relation to overestimation, as "specious and misleading" and tossed them aside, taking refuge in a publication that had been issued by the Irish Trade Union Congress as an answer to my charge.

What do we find now? Last year the Minister took into account overestimation, characterised as economies, to the tune of £3,500,000. This year, notwithstanding that he failed to make these economies of £3,500,000 last year, he proposes now to take into account in balancing his Budget and in giving the slight and trivial reliefs contained in his budgetary proposals the remarkable sum of £4,000,000. Now, I want to make it absolutely clear that we justify any Minister for Finance in taking into account some reasonable figure for overestimation. When the Minister was taxing the people in the cruel, unjust and outrageous way in which he taxed them in 1952 he refused to take overestimation into account. Last year he alleged that in order to balance his Budget he took £3,500,000 into account. We only suggested £2,000,000. This year he is taking £4,000,000 into account. It is essential and necessary and in every respect justifiable to take overestimation into account. What is not necessary, justifiable or defensible is that the Minister should take into account too great an amount for overestimation.

In 1952 we suggested £2,000,000. This year the Minister proposes to take £4,000,000, having failed last year to make economies to the tune of £3,500,000.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

That, of course, is not right.

Comment on this

I will prove that in the course of the remarks I have to make. Whether or not he made the economies last year, but assuming that he did, why did he not take into account in 1952 when he was imposing penal taxation of an unprecedented character, taxation which has had such disastrously continuous and lasting results upon every section of the community and every family in it, a sum for overestimation at that time? Does not that justify the charge we made here that to the extent of that £2,000,000 which we said he should take into account the country was overtaxed to that extent? But £4,000,000 is far too much to take into account for overestimation. It is roughly 5 per cent. of the amount of estimated expenditure on public services. No business concern would retain in its service an accountant who tolerated such a high percentage as 5 per cent. as a margin of error for overestimation. Yet, that is what the present Government is doing in order to balance its Budget this year and to give the slight and trivial reliefs contained in the Budget.

Comment on this

How much would the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

It is not for me to suggest now. I suggested £2,000,000 in 1952 and my suggestion was scornfully turned down. The people were penally taxed. The Minister refused to take overestimation into account at that time. Am I to suggest now that he should do so when he refused in 1952 and unjustly taxed the people?

Comment on this

The Deputy says £4,000,000 is too much. How much would the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I am making three charges in reference to this matter of £4,000,000. First, the Minister did not make the economies he said he would make last year to the extent of £3,500,000. Secondly, he is entitled to take some amount, a reasonable amount, into consideration for overestimation; he failed to do that when he ought to have done it in 1952. Thirdly, £4,000,000 is too much; it represents 5 per cent. and 5 per cent. is too much.

Comment on this

How much too much?

Comment on this

I am not making any suggestions to that Government that refused to do in 1952 what they ought to have done. This year, on the eve of a general election, they are doing what they refused to do in 1952. By refusing in 1952 they unnecessarily and unjustly taxed the people to the extent of at least £2,000,000, the conservative estimate that we suggested ought to be taken into account. Now they propose a sum that represents 5 per cent. of expenditure, a sum far in excess of the conservative estimate of £2,000,000 that we suggested should have been taken into account in the Budget of 1952.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

And they increased the loaf to 9d.

Comment on this

I would like to deal now with these so-called economies. Last year, the Minister stated that he proposed to balance his budget by effecting economies to the extent of £3,500,000. Looking at Table I of the Tables in connection with the Financial Statement of 1954 which was supplied to us yesterday, on the expenditure side there appears a figure of £87,867,000 as the original estimate of expenditure that would be incurred during the progress of the financial year 1953-54. They estimated that they would spend, in accordance with the figures in this Table, £87,867,000. Looking down at the last item in the last column of that expenditure Table, under the heading "Actual," you find that, whereas the estimated expenditure for the year was £87,867,000, the actual expenditure was £87,601,000. Subtract the actual expenditure from the estimated expenditure and you get something less than £200,000. In other words, had they made their economies of £3,500,000 that estimated expenditure of £87,867,000 should have appeared in the actual expenditure as £3,500,000 less, and yet it appears almost the same, something short of £200,000.

Let us see how they have done this. It is somewhat difficult to read this Table. It would seem, at all events, as an effort to conceal what is actually being done. While the columns on the expenditure side of the Table, the second and third columns, are headed "Estimated" and "Actual," in the first column you have, under the third heading, two sums, one on the left and one on the right. On the right it does not say what the sum is supposed to be. We have to deduce what it is intended to be. You have here three items. You have the original estimate of £87,867,000 on the right. On the right, again, you have that figure of £87,867,000, but it does not say what that is. Then you get, "Add: Other Supplementary Estimates £750,000," and on the right of that again there is the significant figure of £3,361,000. It does not say what that is, but we know what it is.

We interpret that Table as being this, that, whereas in the estimate which the Minister made for what he probably would require to meet anticipated Supplementary Estimates during the financial year, he put the figure of £750,000. Actually, the figure was £3,361,000. The amount of these Supplementary Estimates, of £3,361,000, was a startling increase on the figure of £750,000 which was the estimated cost of Supplementary Estimates during the year. That was paid for by increased revenue that was not anticipated but that came in and not by economies. But it was fully paid for in that way. What, in fact, was done was that the economies were eaten up by these inflated Supplementary Estimates of £3,361,000, and that figure ought to have been somewhat nearer the expenditure anticipated by the Minister when framing the estimate in the beginning. The economies are got on paper. The last entry under Item 3, on the right hand column, refers to "Economies, etc.". The anticipated figure is £3,500,000, but actually they got £3,627,000 by a remarkable piece of paper subtraction. In actual fact, the economies were never made.

There is the estimate for overestimation and other economies. That is the first method by which the Minister proposes to balance his Budget, by overestimation and by economies, or by economies which may be called overestimation. He referred to them in the phrase, which I have already mentioned, of undetected overestimation. The Minister could not detect overestimation in 1952 because, according to the Minister at that time, there was no such thing as overestimation. His colleague, the Tánaiste, cast that aside, and the Minister poured scorn on me when I suggested it. But the taxpayers have had to pay this year to balance his Budget and to give these comparatively trivial reliefs which are contained in this Budget. In order to do that the Minister must resort to too high a percentage on the total estimate for expenditure for these undetected economies—and undetectable.

The most remarkable of all the methods and devices by which the Minister proposes to balance his Budget this year, and to finance these reliefs, is by extracting from C.I.E. a sum of £1,500,000. This is remarkable in itself. I can imagine the statements that would be made by the Minister if he were over here if Deputy McGilligan had the effrontery to put forward this proposal to balance his Budget. I can imagine the scorn that he would pour forth. To speak of putting the State into pawn would pale into insignificance when he came to characterise that piece of financial rectitude if done by anybody other than himself.

What is proposed in this Budget is to extract from C.I.E., a body that up to this year had existed on the taxpayers, a sum of £1,500,000. Some time ago, the Minister's colleague, the Tánaiste, when speaking of this body, stated that it would have to get something between £1,000,000 and £2,000,000 by way of subsidy to keep it going in perpetuity. That body which, according to the Minister's colleague, required for its continued existence constant resort to the taxpayer, is now, if you please, to pay £1,500,000 to balance the present Minister's Budget. There is a more remarkable feature in it than that, because the net result of the operation proposed by the Minister was referred to by him in his speech yesterday. In the course of his speech he said, "that £1,000,000 or so will be repayable to the Exchequer in respect of previous years". He said that he had already made provision for £500,000 which is to be extracted from it and, therefore, he says that "the total relief to this year's Budget is of the order of £1,500,000". "The £1,000,000 or so" is, according to the estimate, more than £1,500,000.

The reductions in taxation afforded by the Minister's proposals in this Budget amount, as he stated yesterday, to a sum of £893,000. The cost of the reduction in bread and flour prices amounts to £900,000. With these sums, amounting altogether to £1,793,000, the, Minister proposes to give the reliefs contained in the Budget. In other words, the reliefs contained in the present Budget amount to £1,793,000, and of that C.I.E. is to give £1,500,000 or so. In other words, C.I.E. is balancing the Minister's Budget and giving the reliefs contained in the Budget—a most remarkable performance! Can anybody credit that—that the Minister's Budget is being balanced by C.I.E.? What would the Minister say if any Minister for Finance other than himself had the effrontery to come in and balance his Budget by means of extracting money from a concern that according to his colleague—and certainly according to a lot of people— and according to himself in previous years was dependent on the charity of the taxpayer for its continued existence. But that very board is balancing the Minister's Budget this year. £1,973,000 is the amount it will cost to give the reliefs that are given by this Budget and £1,500,000 or so is being furnished by C.I.E. Is it going too far to say that such a proposal is dubiously novel? But there is something of even greater significance contained in that proposal. Again the proposal underlines, emphasises and justifies the charge that we made two years ago in regard to the Budget of 1952/53, that it contained unjust overtaxing. Here we have the Minister basing his case for extracting £1,500,000 from C.I.E. on the basis that they should repay something in respect of previous years. We insisted that the proposal for the repayment of these renewals and so forth for C.I.E. were matters proper for borrowing. We urged that on the Minister in 1952 and he scornfully turned us down and said it was contrary to all the principles of financial rectitude, and he provided for two years' moneys out of the taxpayers' pocket only to do the very thing which he now says it was not necessary to do. He is now getting back from them the money that the taxpayer had to pay and which the taxpayer had been overtaxed to pay in the last two years. That money is now being repaid by the dangerously-novel method of finance which the Minister proposes.

Deputy McGilligan, when he was speaking on the Budget of 1952 at column 1155, dealt with the Minister's proposals as regards C.I.E. and he dealt with the charge that has been repeatedly demonstrated to be utterly false in this House and elsewhere throughout the country—that Mr. McGilligan's last Budget of 1951 had a deficit in it of £6.7 million. He dealt with that charge, but that charge is repeated again in the Minister's statement yesterday—that there was a £6.7 million deficit. He repeated that charge that has been demonstrated to be utterly unsustainable and completely false. Deputy McGilligan dealt with it at column 1155 and it is not necessary for me to repeat the entire statement that were made by Deputy McGilligan to refute the charge that there was a deficit of £6.7 million. I quote only that portion of the speech of Deputy McGilligan which dealt with the proposal for C.I.E. and I want Deputies to remember this, that the £6.7 million alleged deficit that the Minister referred to in his Budget speech of 1952 and which he repeated yesterday, contained an item in respect of moneys for replacements in C.I.E. and although the Minister is now taking back £500,000 from C.I.E. he still repeats the charge that there was a deficit of £6.7 million.

Deputy McGilligan, at column 1155 of the Budget debate of 2nd April, 1952, Volume 130, said:—

"I accept no responsibility for the bulk sum of £845,000, part of the £2.3 million that was said to be the charge in respect of C.I.E. losses during the year. Part of that was stockpiling, according to the statement made by the Minister in this House. Part of it was the best estimate C.I.E. could give of future charges for replacement and another part of it, almost £400,000, for extra charges of a replacement type, in addition to operating losses during the year."

Notwithstanding our efforts at that time to get the Minister to see that that was no part of current expenditure and matter proper for borrowing the Minister insisted on putting it in that year and the following year and he has now found it a pool from which to get back from C.I.E. the money extracted from the taxpayers by unjust and excessive taxation.

I again emphasise that we were justified in the charge we made in 1952 that this country was unjustly and unnecessarily overtaxed by the Budget of that year.

Another item that the Minister takes into account this year is deductions from the estimates for expenditure in reference to matters which are proper to be met by borrowing rather than taxation. What did he say in 1952 when he was full of financial rectitude about that and sneered at Deputy McGilligan's proposals? At column 1134 of the 2nd April, 1952, he said this:—

"...a distinction would be drawn in the Budget statement between current and capital expenditure and, in a prefatory note to the Estimates for Supply Services, it was pointed out that only in the context of the Budget would a full Estimate of Exchequer outlay on capital and current account be available. I am by no means satisfied that all of the voted expenditure described by the previous Government as `capital' merits that description."

I will repeat that sneer at Deputy McGilligan:—

"I am by no means satisfied that all of the voted expenditure described by the previous Government as `capital' merits that description."

And later on he goes on to say:—

"In this Budget, therefore, I propose to present the figures on current and capital account on the same lines as were adopted by the previous Government, leaving over to a later stage in the rehabilitation of our finances the determination of the extent to which it is strictly justifiable to treat items of recurring voted expenditure as proper, even in principle, to be financed by borrowing."

Here he does what he said he would have to give grave consideration to in 1952—"the extent to which it is strictly justifiable to treat items of recurring voted expenditure as proper, even in principle, to be financed by borrowing". Here he is doing it in this Budget. Why were not these things done in 1952? Why were not all these matters to which I have referred done in 1952? If they had been done it is possible to say that the load of taxation that has been raised from the taxpayers over the last two or three years would have been very appreciably lightened.

In accordance with the suggestion that he made in his speech yesterday, the Minister proposes by one means or another—leaving out of account altogether his fantastic proposals about C.I.E.—to balance his Budget by making deductions from the estimates of expenditure of no less sum than £5,750,000. He takes £800,000 by way of deduction for defensive equipment. We asked him to do that in 1952 and to relieve the taxpayer to that extent —of £800,000—and he refused. This year he does it. £950,000 is to be found by specified deductions from the estimates of public expenditure by way or economies or otherwise and then this sum of £4,000,000 for overestimation, amounting in all to the sum of £5,750,000.

That sum is to be got in that way and it is to be utilised in relief of the taxpayers and in giving the reliefs contained in this Budget. Had those methods been adopted in these three respects in 1952 the taxpayers could have been saved the imposition of £5,750,000 and the net estimated savings on the food subsidies could have been saved, or else the penal taxation imposed by the Budget of 1952 could have been very appreciably reduced.

Why was it not done? It was not done because the Minister, in his desire to denigrate and depreciate the achievements of his predecessors, the inter-Party Government, had persuaded himself that this country was facing imminent bankruptcy. He misread the economic signs and the economic statistics. He forgot that he was handed over by the inter-Party Government, in 1951, a country that was one of the three creditor nations in Europe. There were only two other countries in Europe at that time that were creditor countries. We handed over a country which was solvent and one of the three creditor nations in Europe. He wanted to denigrate and depreciate the achievements of the inter-Party Government and in this House he declared that we were facing ruin and bankruptcy. The position was desperate to the point of despair, or some such phrase as that. He refused to see what were the actual facts. He misread the signs. He diagnosed illness in the economic body that was non-existent. In any event, he provided the wrong remedies.

I ask Deputies to recall what he said about the balance of payments, the balance of our international account, and the possibility that was then existing or to be anticipated of an increase in our exports so as to bring about an easement in the disordered balance of payments which he said existed at that time. Remember, we on this side of the House drew his attention to the fact that the very thing he was worried about, the disorder in our international balance of payments, was even at that time rectifying itself. What apparent disorder existed was due to the fact that, because of the Korean war, we had stockpiled and the country had stockpiled. That very fact involved destocking, and destocking should ease the situation from the point of view of imports, and the Government got the benefit of the stockpiling and the destocking so far as the necessity for imports was concerned.

But that was not the real error they made. What did the Minister say about our prospects of increased agricultural exports? At column 1123 of his Budget speech on the 2nd April, 1952, he stated:—

"While we may expect some increase in export prices, the immediate outlook in agriculture would not justify us in counting upon any material increase in the quantity exported. The trade deficits for January and February of this year provide little ground for optimism, and it seems clear that, without an improvement in personal savings and a reduction in inflationary Government finance, the deficit in the balance of payments will remain excessive."

The Minister, therefore, framed his Budget and his economic policy upon that statement, that he was not justified in counting upon any material increase in the quantity of agricultural exports. What has been the result? Due to the policy of the inter-Party Government, led by the then Minister for Agriculture, we have had so much agricultural exports that we have reached the point where the Minister can say that the exports have gone up by 33? per cent. and that in point of fact we have reached a record in our agricultural exports, due to the policy of the inter-Party Government, which he refused to admit. Even the Minister for Finance cannot deny that the actual animals, whatever they were, and our agricultural products, whatever kind they were, came to fruition as the result of the policy pursued at that time under the leadership of Deputy James Dillon.

Comment on this

And not having their throats cut to the tune of £80,000 a year.

Comment on this

These are some of the outstanding features of the present Minister's proposals contained in this Budget. Might I recall now another statement which he made in his famous Budget speech of 1952? At column 1121, he made this remarkable statement:—

"A highly disturbing element in our economy is the continuing rise in the cost of the public services which in recent years has been very steep."

The public were invited to assume that he was going to deal with that situation by the rigorous and austere proposals he was imposing on the people by that Budget. On the eve of a general election, we hear very little about austerity proposals, and even the Taoiseach denied that they ever existed. The people know they were austere proposals. The Minister by that statement invited the people to consider that in his financial and economic proposals, which were based on the soundest principles of financial rectitude, he was going to see that this highly disturbing element in our economy, namely, the continuing rise in the cost of the public services, was certainly going to come down.

Let us see what happened. We go back again to these Tables issued yesterday in connection with the financial statement. In the last completed year of the inter-Party Government, as shown in Table VI, it will be observed that the actual expenditure of the inter-Party Government was £85,345,000. Let us take last year in which the present Minister and his colleagues in the Government were in charge of the finances of this country, when they still had, presumably, this bogey in their minds of the highly disturbing element in our economy of the continuing rise in the cost of the public services, when it rose from £85,000,000 odd in our last year to £121,000,000 odd. The Government that was complaining of the highly disturbing element in our economy, the continuing rise in the cost of the public services, as the result of their handling of the nation's finances in that period of years caused the public services to rise from £85,000,000 odd to £121,000,000. It is estimated according to the Table that next year if they continue in existence there it would be raised still further to a figure of £125,697,000. In the year after the Minister made that statement in which he referred to the highly disturbing element in our economy of the continued rise in the cost of the public service the expenditure on public services rose in one year thereafter by no less a figure than £40,000,000—that is in the second column of Table VI. It is relevant and proper to ask where is the money gone to and what have we got for it. That is the cost of the expenditure, but look at some of the other matters that we have to consider.

Every year since the first Budget of the Minister for Finance they have received—and the figures can be obtained again from these Tables to check it—a sum of £20,000,000 in taxation over and above what was got from the people by the inter-Party Government. In those years they got £20,000,000 extra in taxation or revenue. This year they are giving back to the people by one halfpenny decrease in the price of bread, costing the taxpayer £900,000, and in reduction of other kinds, £800,000, making in all, say, £1.8 millions, so that is what the Minister refers to in his speech as the first fruits of the Fianna Fáil policy of bringing order back to public finances. This year they are going to be up £20,000,000 less £1.8 millions. £18,000,000 odd of taxation is still going to continue on the people.

Comment on this

Surely not. Surely there is borrowing.

Comment on this

What have we got for all that? In addition to that the Ministers of the present Government have borrowed twice the amount of money borrowed by the inter-Party Government, and they have paid about four times the amount in interest, and we will be paying that for 20 years or more.

Comment on this

Paying it to our own, not to the foreigners.

Comment on this

And what about the rates? Let me first give some figures for the information of Deputies. During the three years of the inter-Party Government, 1948-49, 1949-50 and 1950-51, the total net borrowings of central government and local authorities amounted to £28,000,000, most of it raised at the figure of 3 per cent. During the three years of the present Government, that is, 1951-52 to 1953-54, the total net amount borrowed is around the figure of £65,000,000, the bulk of it raised at 5 per cent., so that the annual charge in interest alone on borrowings in the recent period of three years of the present Government is nearly four times as great as it was in our time, and that will continue for 20 years.

Comment on this

Where is the £40,000,000 Marshall Aid?

Comment on this

Take your medicine.

Comment on this

Look at the rates. Look at the amount of local rates that are being collected in accordance with Table VI during the régime of this present Government. In the last year that we were in office, 1950-51, the amount of rates collected was £11,600,000 approximately. For 1953 the amount collected in rates was £15,250,000 approximately; and it is estimated that in this year the amount of rates collected will be £16,250,000; so that as a result of the present Government's operations on rates alone the amount of rates collected rose, or will rise if they are still in office next year, from £11,600,000 in the last year of our administration to the sum of £16,250,000. What have we got for all that? What has the country got for that except increased unemployment, emigration, instability of business, insecurity in trade, restriction of credit, and general uneasiness and hardship on every section of the community?

The Minister in the course of his statement yesterday referred to the fact that there would be a new loan required this year. The Taoiseach announced some time ago that a new loan would be necessary every year. There was not one single word said about the rate of interest at which the present Government if they were in office would raise that loan. Does not everybody in all sections of the community know and realise in their own persons and their own pockets the effect which the abnormal amount of the rate of interest and the policy of dear money inaugurated by the present Minister for Finance has upon them? What chances are there of getting that loan at any reasonable rate of interest? What is the use of getting any amount of money at the rate of interest at which money has been borrowed in recent years by the present Government and by the Minister for Finance now in office?

The Minister in the course of his statement indicated certain improvements in the economy—that there have been slight improvements. He referred to the fall in the cost of living, but everybody knows that the cost of living at the present moment is the highest in living memory in this country. He referred to the fall in unemployment. In all these matters where he referred to improvements or so-called improvements the relative times were not the last year of our administration but they were the last year of this Government's administration, last year, 1953. He compared 1953 with 1952 but did not compare it with 1951. It is of some significance that even in that year 1953, the year which according to the Minister's statement we are supposed to believe was the most prosperous in the nation's history, a year of progress in industry and agriculture, of increased trade and higher incomes, he had to admit in the course of his speech yesterday that they had either failed to realise or were afraid to face up at the beginning of last year to the staggering amount of unemployment that was the inevitable and direct and necessary result of the policy that they had put in operation in 1952 in regard to unemployment.

The Minister in his statement said yesterday that one other item which helped to unbalance his Budget was the large supplementary sum voted for social insurance to cover a short-fall in the contribution income of the social insurance fund. That is nothing but economic jargon to conceal the fact that what happened really was that there was far more unemployment caused by the policy of the present Government for which they had failed to make proper provision at the beginning of the year, and they refused to have to admit that, and they covered it up by jargon of that kind—"shortfall in the contribution income of the social insurance fund." Short-fall in that contribution meant unemployment of a staggering character which they refused to face up to and which was caused by the direct and necessary result of their own policy. The Minister, as I said at the outset, failed in his approach to the problems confronting the country to use the Budget which is recognised in modern economic thought as being a potent instrument of economic policy. He has given no indication of what the economic policy or the financial policy for the future is to be if he is still in charge, unfortunately, of the nation's finances.

There is no indication of what the difficulties which undoubtedly face this country are or how they are to be solved. There is going to be no easy road for this or any other Government that succeeds it. If we were to take the picture presented by the Minister in his statement yesterday at its real value, ignoring the false facade of prosperity he put upon that picture, the outlook for the future would be bleak indeed. After three years of austerity, three years of human suffering and misery inflicted by the policy of the present Government and in particular the financial policy of the present Minister for Finance, the best that can be done on the eve of a general election is the few comparatively trivial reliefs that have been given at the expense of C.I.E. The Minister failed to notice, or if he noticed failed to refer, to the significant fact that the figure for external trade for the month of March shows an increase in imports and a reduction in exports. Is that any indication of an adverse trend or what is the explanation of it? It is remarkable that the Minister for Finance did not touch on that aspect in the course of his review of the economic administration of the country or the so-called prosperity which we are supposed to enjoy.

We have many difficulties to face. Nobody in opposition can know the real truth or have the full facts of the financial and economic situation or what has been done by the Minister with the money extracted from the people over the past three years. At all events, whatever the difficulties may be, they can be solved only by some Government other than the present and by some financial and economic policy other than that operated by the present Government, a policy that has caused so much suffering and misery to every section of the community. It is to be hoped that in the next few weeks that situation will come to a happy end.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Costello's speech was remarkable for what he did not say and for how cleverly he avoided the real issues before the country, the real problems that affect its prosperity in the long run. All round the country one can see the slogan: "Vote for Fine Gael for better times and lower taxation" but the complaint of Deputy Costello to-day, when he was presented with the Budget and had to face it, was that we had not higher taxation.

Comment on this

How do you make that out?

Comment on this

He said that we were giving too good a time to too many people.

Comment on this
A Deputy

In Cork.

Comment on this

He complained about the expenditure on the Civil Service and the amount that we were paying civil servants.

Comment on this

I asked how you got rid of the money and what we got for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I take it, would cut them down.

Comment on this

Your leader said he was going to do that.

Comment on this

And you want to give them better times.

Comment on this

We hope so.

Comment on this

By cutting them down?

Comment on this

We will not say how.

Comment on this

But the Deputy is going to increase taxation.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

He complained about the Minister providing £4,000,000 for overestimation which he said was far too high—fantastically high, I think he said. If the Minister does not allow £4,000,000 and goes back to the Deputy's £2,000,000, which he very tentatively suggested, it means that we would have to increase taxation by £2,000,000.

Comment on this

He could get it from C.I.E.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello is running out because, not having said anything, he is afraid he will be asked questions. There are other Deputies also going out. They are all running out as fast as they can, because they do not want to face the real issues that are before the country in relation to this Budget and in relation to our general financial and economic life. The Minister for Finance could, of course, have brought in a Budget something like the Budget that was brought in by the Coalition Government in May, 1951, in which the Deputy left it to future Governments to pay the deficit of £6.7 million that was staring them in the face. Instead of doing that, the present Minister has brought in a Budget which shows that he is facing up to his responsibilities. He collects in taxation the amount of money necessary to pay the current expenses of Government. How are we going to decrease the amount of money we collect in taxation? By cutting existing services? By going back to the standard of social services which the last Coalition Government left? We could save several million pounds if we did that. The Minister could give great relief in taxation if he was prepared to shut his eyes to the expenditure for this year. When the Coalition Minister for Finance was about to leave office, after the Coalition had burst up in April, 1951, he refused to budget or prepare to collect taxes to meet the commitments that were staring the Government in the face. The result was that he left the incoming Government with a deficit of £6.7 million. Although he knew that there was a Civil Service award about to be put into operation, he made no provision in the Budget for it. He left many other services as well without any provision and the net result was that in that year we were left with a deficit of £6.68 million.

Deputy Costello complained that by allowing for overstimation this year a sum of £4,000,000, the Minister was allowing far too much. Last year the Minister made an allowance of £3.5 million for overestimation; in actual fact it turned out to be £3.6 million, or £100,000 more than he had estimated. This year, with the total increase in Government expenditure on the various services which the State now performs for the people, it is reasonable to add £400,000 to the out-turn of last year and to increase the £3.6 million actually realised in savings to the sum of £4,000,000. Deputy Costello was not satisfied with that. He wants to put up placards all around the country about lower taxation, but here he wants the Minister for Finance to increase taxation by £2,000,000—not to give these reductions he is providing but to increase taxation by reducing the estimate for overestimation.

Deputy Costello complains about the fact that the general election was not declared a month ago. It is easy to see why he has a complaint in that regard. He would have much preferred to go around the country telling the people that Fianna Fáil were overtaxing the people, that they should make great savings, that his Party would make great savings; but he did not want to face a crossexamination in the Dáil as to how he proposed to make them and when I started to ask him a few questions after his long speech on the history of 1952, he ran out of the Dáil. I am perfectly certain that there is no single member of the former Coalition Government who will face up to the question as to what they would save in the services provided in the Book of Estimates or what taxes they would increase in order that the country should pay its way.

This Government, if it had the same reckless attitude to the responsibility of government as the Coalition, could have given the people over these last few years better times, easier times, lower taxation; but they could do that at the price of injury to the permanent interests and the permanent prosperity of our people. No individual in his ordinary private life can have a good time by spending his savings or his father's savings and not have that spree have an adverse effect on his own future and his children's future. The Coalition kept taxation at a low level by handing on commitments to future Governments to pay their debts. This Budget which the Minister for Finance introduced yesterday could be £4,000,000 less, if the previous Coalition Government had paid their way and had not handed him a deadweight debt of £90,000,000.

Comment on this

At 3 per cent. or so.

Comment on this

On which we had to pay over 4 per cent. a year. The Deputy justifies handing on £90,000,000 of deadweight debt simply because he thinks we had to pay only 3 per cent. We had to pay over 4 per cent. and will be paying it for the next 40 years. Portion of that debt will have to be repaid in dollars and that is a difficult currency to collect in these days. The Minister for Finance, of course, could have a very much nicer Budget, instead of giving these reductions in income-tax and on bread which Deputy Costello calls contemptible reductions. He could have made them greater by adding to the deadweight national debt. The Minister for Finance, as always when he was Minister for Finance, acted up to his responsibility.

He tells the people that if they want these social services and other services they must be paid for, whether by the present taxpayers or their children.

Deputy Costello referred to the "insignificant" decrease of ½d. in the 2-lb. loaf. When the Minister reduced the subsidies in order to pull the country's finances together and it resulted in the 2-lb. loaf going up by ½d., it was not "insignificant" then. From every platform all over the country you could hear the denunciations of that ½d. increase.

Comment on this

Threepence, not ½d.

Comment on this

At one point the loaf went up by ½d., about a year and a half ago, and all over the country they were doing dervish dances, they actually had loaves on the tops of sticks around Dublin complaining about that increase; but when it is decreased it is "insignificant" and "contemptible". We could reduce the 2-lb. loaf and the 1-lb. loaf and the flour very much more. We could abolish, as Deputy Dillon and a lot of the Fine Gael people want, the policy of wheat growing and so get a very cheap loaf. Our farmers are getting about £40 per ton for wheat and the American wheat is costing us about £30 delivered.

Comment on this

You paid £48 for American wheat before.

Comment on this

I know, but we are paying £30 now. Deputy Dillon objects to our paying the farmers £40 or anything like it. Deputy Dillon's boon companion, the second candidate in County Louth, was growling all around the constituency about the subsidy we had to pay the Irish farmers to grow wheat. His solution was to use Deputy Dillon's policy of depending upon the export of other agricultural produce in order to get the money to buy cheap wheat. We could adopt that policy. We would require only £18,500,000 worth of dollars to buy the wheat from America at the present price. It would take another £8,000,000 to buy the sugar and the feeding stuffs that we produce from our beet fields. Deputy Dillon would like to wipe out the hundreds of thousands of acres that are under wheat and beet and depend upon getting an increasing sale of eggs and butter and bacon in the British market to get £26,500,000 to buy these things. I would like any Deputy on the opposite side to make a calculation as to how many dozens of eggs——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

At ?.

Comment on this

——even at ?, we would have to export to England in order to get £26,500,000 to buy the wheat and sugar and foodstuffs at present being produced from our wheat and beet fields. That is the calculation. Which of the Fine Gael and the Labour people support that policy? Which of them are against it? We know Deputy Dillon. We know that he got his way before, in spite of the lip service that a lot of the Labour people and Clann na Poblachta and some of the Fine Gael people gave to the development of Irish agricultural resources. We know that in their three years they allowed Deputy Dillon to reduce the tillage of this country by over 500,000 acres. If they can conspire and get the people to reelect them in such numbers as to allow them again to form a Coalition, will they allow him to reduce tillage in these next three years by another 500,000? Is that 500,000 going to be the acreage under wheat and beet?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order. May I call for a House? We would like to see the Fianna Fáil Party for the last time.

Comment on this

We would like to see the ex-Coalition Ministers, wherever they are. Have they fled?

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

Let me repeat the question which Deputy O'Sullivan thought he could avoid answering by calling for a count.

Comment on this

The people will answer it.

Comment on this

I suppose Deputy Hughes is prepared to advise the people as to how to answer it.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

And Deputy Hughes will advise the people that, according to Deputy Mulcahy, if they get the chance again they will put Deputy Dillon in as Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Exactly.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

The cat is out of the bag now.

Comment on this

We can expect then the Dillon policy of reducing tillage, as he did the last time by 500,000 acres.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He will not welsh on it.

Comment on this

We can expect all this growling about the price of butter to result in an offer to the farmers of a reduction in the price of milk to 1/- a gallon. Deputy O'Sullivan would be satisfied with a guaranteed minimum of 1/- a gallon.

Comment on this

For five years.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What is the guaranteed minimum now?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should be allowed to make his speech in his own way. Deputies will get every opportunity.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister has been asking questions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies need not asking questions.

Comment on this

There are other little items that Deputy Dillon would gladly put into effect if he, as is proposed by the Coalition, were made Minister for Agriculture again. I expect Deputy Hickey, for instance, will support him again in reducing tillage by another 500,000 acres.

Comment on this

I will be asking you some questions before you are finished. You have said very little so far.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey is always very voluble, but he will not answer whether he will support Deputy Dillon in doing that or not.

Comment on this

From what the Minister is saying there is very little indication as to how he would deal with the affairs of the country.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey wants to go down to Cork and grow wheat in every field and put a power station in every bog and beet in every field that is not under wheat but when he is asked the question as to whether he will support Deputy Dillon in cutting out the wheat and the beet and the peat he is very mute.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey has a sound mind about what should be done.

Comment on this

Even though the Deputies will not answer questions here, the people are not such——

Comment on this

Is not that provocative?

Comment on this

The people will answer, do not worry.

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle prevents us answering questions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle does not prevent Deputies from answering questions. The Standing Orders of the House do.

Comment on this

The Chair is there to administer them.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish has got to the point where he calls to his aid the Standing Orders in order to avoid answering questions. He will have time enough between now and tomorrow afternoon to take a few notes of the questions he is being asked and to answer them. Deputy Costello would not answer them when he was on his feet and had the right under the Rules and Standing Orders to answer.

He would not do it. I expect in any Coalition, if it were brought about again, the result, in regard to social services, would be pretty well what happened the last time. The national health insurance stamp was increased but the national health benefits were not increased and it was left over to this Government to increase the sickness benefit by 27/6 in the case of a man and a wife and five children, without taking into account the children's allowances. The Labour Party, as in charge of social services in the Coalition Government, increased the national health stamp but they did not increase the benefit of 22/6 and they left it to us to find the 50/- that the man and the wife and the five children get in disability allowance at the present time. If there is going to be lower taxation in the Fine Gael style, as they did before, I expect they will endeavour to bring down the 50/- towards the 22/- which they were paying.

Comment on this

And reduce the old age pensions again.

Comment on this

Do not mention old age pensions.

Comment on this

They reduced them before.

Comment on this

Fine Gael does not change its spots. It may put a little whitewash over them occasionally but, fundamentally, it does not change its spots, and you can see from Deputy Costello's speech and other speeches that what they are dying for is to get into the position of getting a couple of Labour people to sit quietly in a couple of Ministries while they reduce these things again. They will do it all with a great flourish of trumpets and very long and detailed arguments such as Deputy Costello treated us to to-day.

Another complaint that I heard Deputy Costello make was that we were reducing expenditure on the Army this year by £1,000,000. In the last year of the Coalition, 1950-51, they spent on the Army £4,228,000. Last year, we provided for the Army services £8,200,000—just £4,000,000 more —almost double.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What was spent?

Comment on this

It was practically all spent. The year before that, we spent £7,000,000 as against the £4,000,000 spent by the Coalition. We spent £3,000,000 more and this year we have provision in the Book of Estimates for £8,207,000. The Minister for Finance proposes to effect a saving on that, with the consent of the Minister for Defence —a saving that will not affect the growth in strength of the Army from the very weak force that was left to us by the Coalition.

When we ask Deputy Costello what he proposes to do in the financial year 1954-55, and future years, he growls about what happened in 1952. He will not tell us what services the people are going to have in 1954-55. He will not tell us the level of taxation he would have in 1954-55 if he had his way. All he does is to growl about alleged overtaxation in 1952-53. For weeks here, and from platforms all over the country, we heard Deputy Costello complain about the "overtaxation" which the Minister for Finance provided in the 1952-53 Budget. What was the result? Instead of having the £10,000,000 saving which Deputy Costello said we would have because, he alleged, we were overtaxing to the tune of £10,000,000, the outcome of that financial year was a deficit of £2,047,000. In other words, Deputy Costello was out in his calculation to the extent of £12,000,000—and yet he still says that we should not have taxed as much as we did in 1952-53. He says, in effect, that we should have a higher deficit than the £2,000,000, because that would have been the result of any decrease in taxation in that year.

What was the situation which faced the Minister for Finance in May, 1952? He faced a situation in which we were running through the savings of our people—savings held abroad and in gold—at the rate of £60,000,000 a year. The decrease in our net balance of payments in 1951 was over £60,000,000. Did Deputy Costello want us to continue to have a deficit in our balance of payments to that extent? We could continue to do it for another year, because we still had a little left unspent of our net savings abroad. However, if the Minister for Finance had to carry on in that way, we would have been left a net debtor nation. If as a debtor we wanted to build up our resources either of industry or agriculture and wanted to buy foreign machinery or raw materials we should have to go to some foreign country on our knees and ask them to give us a loan in order to enable us to pay our way. The Minister for Finance quite rightly decided in May, 1952, that the current expenses of Government should be met by current taxation. Had he followed the advice given by Deputy Costello at that time to reduce taxation by £10,000,000, instead of a deficit of £2,000,000 we should have had a deficit of £12,000,000 in the Budget and a deficit of perhaps £40,000,000 or £50,000,000 in our balance of payments because that is the result of too much money being around the country instead of being devoted to national production.

Comment on this

Although we had over 70,000 unemployed who would not be let work——

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey need not talk about the 70,000 unemployed. What we are trying to do now and what we have always tried to do is to create a situation here where every person born and reared in this country can have a reasonable chance of finding a job in Ireland. However, we cannot conscript them to work or to stay in Ireland and when Deputy Hickey was supporting the Coalition Government I might remind him that all they did about emigration was to set up a commission to find out the causes of emigration. That commission sat for three years without putting in a report. That was the only single contribution to the solution of the problem of emigration that the Coalition Government made. They set up a commission.

Comment on this

You have not got the report yet.

Comment on this

They did not know the causes of emigration. They did not know that fewer men are required to attend to 500,000 acres of grass than are required to attend to the same number of acres under tillage. They did not know that if you stopped the extension of the Drogheda and Limerick cement factories you would increase emigration to the extent of the number of persons who would otherwise be employed in the production of our cement, rather than have Belgians or English producing it.

Comment on this

Do not tell me anything about the cement factories.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the cement factories?

Comment on this

Nothing at all, but——

Comment on this

Then why are you talking about them?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputies please cease interrupting? They can contribute later to the debate if they wish but they may not do so by way of interruption.

Comment on this

They did not know that one way of helping to solve emigration was to put the chassis factory in Inchicore going rather than sell the machinery to the British, the French and anybody who would buy it— machinery which was bought for dollars but which the Coalition sold for sterling, although Deputy Hickey does not like pounds sterling——

Comment on this

Who told you that?

Comment on this

They did not know that people could be employed to earn dollars by flying dollar passengers across the Atlantic Ocean. The Coalition Government sold aircraft for sterling that we had bought for dollars: they sold them for Deputy McGilligan's "waste paper". The people of this country are not interested so much in 1952 and 1953 as they are in what will happen in 1954 and 1955. 1955.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

The question is this: Are the Fine Gael people going to keep Deputy Hickey quiet while they cut down these social services by throwing Labour a couple of seats in the Cabinet or, perhaps, if they come back with as few as I think they will, a couple of Parliamentary Secretaryships, as they kept them quiet for three years? The Coalition Government promised an increase in the social services but the only increase we saw was the increase in the price of the national health stamp. For three years they promised better health services, with no result. We are giving the people plenty of time to ask this question—because they will ask it. As a matter of fact one of the reasons why I was altogether in favour of extending the time for the general election was for the purpose of ensuring that the people would have time to ask Deputies this question: If they are growling about the extent of the Government services and if they feel we are collecting too much money to pay for Health, Social Welfare, Agriculture, Industry and Commerce, and so forth, on what services or services do they suggest we should cut down? That is a fair question and the people recognise that it is a fair question.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Dublin Castle scheme.

Comment on this

The Dublin Castle scheme, which is a scheme to provide healthy working conditions for the civil servants rather than have them working in a tumbling building, is costing about £50,000 this year.

It is probably going to cost about £750,000 over whatever number of years are necessary. Are we not to build any houses for civil servants? Are we to take the line that we must not improve the conditions under which civil servants work? Are we to allow the buildings to fall down upon them or are we to do as the Coalition did——

Comment on this

It is a bad time to be building castles.

Comment on this

—and when they wanted extra housing for 1,200 civil servants steal a bus station? That is how they got over it, but you cannot go on stealing bus stations every year. They are just not there and we must provide reasonable accommodation for the Civil Service.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is easier to steal £1,500,000 from them.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I take it, is not satisfied with this Budget—he wants an extra £1,500,000 added on for the civil servants, if he thinks we have stolen £1,500,000 from the civil servants.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

From C.I.E.

Comment on this

The civil servants, the Deputy said first. I know the Deputy too well. I remember him coming in here some months before the remission of the dance-hall tax came into operation and saying that a dance-hall proprietor had told him of the thousands of pounds he had made from the Minister for Finance. He said that in July and the dance-hall tax remission did not come into operation until a month after the Deputy had spoken. He was caught that time and he has been caught on this occasion, except that he has changed his step. He is afraid to admit that he interrupted me to say that we stole £1,500,000 from the civil servants.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan and the rest of them are growling about what we stole from the civil servants——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

£1,500,000 from C.I.E.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in favour of increasing taxation in order to give the back pay to the civil servants?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Does the Minister want an answer? I am not in favour of taking £1,500,000 from C.I.E. and closing a branch line in my constituency in the same year.

Comment on this

They have no £1,500,000 to take.

Comment on this

Would Deputy MacBride be in favour of increasing taxation in order to pay this money to the civil servants?

Comment on this

I would be in favour of paying decent wages to State employees and keeping my promises to State employees.

Comment on this

Even by increasing taxation? If we are to add all the inferential promises made here about increased State services, we will have a pretty bill for increased taxation instead of the lower taxation which we see on the placards all around the country.

Comment on this

I am not in the least surprised that people outside take such a cynical view of this institution.

Comment on this

The people of this country are not cynical about the institution as a whole. They know that we have here an unfortunate situation in which the Opposition is split into a number of small Parties who cannot make up their minds what to say to the people, what to promise the people and what the policy is to be if they get power to form a Coalition in 1954 and who, instead, spend their time talking about the Budget of 1952. That is an unfortunate situation. Surely, if we are to have real democracy in this country, the people have a right to know the alternative policies that are put before them.

Comment on this

What policy did you put to the people before the general election of 1951? None.

Comment on this

The policy we put before the people has been there since 1932. We stood against any oath of allegiance to a British king when Deputies opposite were trying to ram it down our throats and when they shot and bayoneted very many people in order to put it down their throats. They know that we stood against any of that sort of business. They know that we stood for increasing tillage and giving farmers a fair price; they know that we were in favour of taking care of those in greatest need and they know that we counted the unemployed for the first time in 1932—they had not even been counted before that; they know that we restored the cuts in old age pensions and did something for blind pensioners; they know that we introduced the widows' and orphans' pensions; they know that we introduced legislation to ensure proper conditions of employment; and they know that we introduced children's allowances.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

And the Wages Standstill Order.

Comment on this

And they know that all the time we had the opposition of Fine Gael. What is worrying the people now is whether, if Fine Gael with their mentality are to get into power again, they will be able to keep the Labour people as mute as mice as Deputy Dillon said they were——

Comment on this

The Labour people will be able to look after themselves.

Comment on this

——whether they will be able to keep them as meek as mice while Fine Gael put into operation the old Cumann na nGaedheal policy about which they are laughing and smiling at present. The people are not, in my opinion, going to be led away by the silence, the avoidance of the issues, on the part of the various groups in the Opposition. Deputies need not run away with the idea that, because Fianna Fáil were defeated in a couple of by-elections, that in any way foretells the results of a general election.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

What is the general election for, then?

Comment on this

To get rid of a few people like you.

Comment on this

There are a few going already on your side, without even trying.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry should allow the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

I remember that, in Tipperary, in 1947, we got 17,000 votes against 38,000 secured by the Opposition groups at a by-election and, at a general election three months later, we doubled our figure to 34,000, while the other people came down by 5,000.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Can the Minister remember Louth?

Comment on this

What is going to happen in Louth will happen there, no matter what I say or the Deputy says, but my impression is that generally throughout the country the people are——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Fed up.

Comment on this

——fed up with the Opposition tactics—fed up to the neck —and do not like to be taken too obviously for "goms".

Comment on this

Have they not got a very odd way of showing it?

Comment on this

They do not believe that the ordinary decent workers and farmers of this country should allow themselves to be dominated by a group of lawyers in secret. They believe that the lawyers should be put in the dock, put in——

Comment on this

Go on—put in the dock.

Comment on this

——and made produce a policy which they can see. They do not want the games that went on before the election of 1948 when Deputy MacBride could go around the country proclaiming his republicanism and then negotiated in the Four Courts and round about with the principal architect of the Coalition who, at one time, at column 41 of the Official Debates on the 3rd May, 1932——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order. May I ask what relation this has with the Budget?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has little or none.

Comment on this

They will not allow this conspiracy to be repeated. They allowed Deputy MacBride to conspire and form the Coalition with a man who said in the column I have just quoted:

"I will not stand up when you play the Soldiers' Song, because I detest it, and it is associated, in my mind, with horrors...”

That was Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

All this will probably be said in another place.

Comment on this

In my opinion they could not be said in a better place.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Could we get to the motion before the House?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That would be more like it.

Comment on this

I want to know from the Opposition speakers who are going to talk whether they support Deputy Costello in the House in calling for more taxation by a reduction in the Estimate for overestimation and, if so, whether they are going to go out and put up a new placard over the placard they have all over the country about the lower taxation.

Comment on this

Which one is that?

Comment on this

The one dealing with "better times and lower taxation".

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

That is it.

Comment on this

That imprinted itself on the Minister's mind.

Comment on this

It did. There is no doubt that is what everybody would like to give the people.

Comment on this

And we are going to.

Comment on this

And we will do it in a way in which it will redound to the permanent prosperity of the country. We do not want merely to give, as we could easily do, better times and lower taxation to the people this year and, perhaps, half of next year. What Fianna Fáil has always tried to do is to make the people pay——

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

——that level of taxation which is necessary in order that this country might be built up and have its resources improved to give a better time to the generations of Irish people for thousands of years to come. We do not want to reduce taxation to the point when we can be kicked around by anybody outside who would want to control our policy. We do not want to have better times for a year or a year and a half at the expense of having to go on our knees or our children having to go on their knees when they want to buy machinery or raw materials from some outside creditor nation.

Those of us who have been in public life for a long time and have made a study of the matter have seen in the past a few very clear examples of what happens to nations which get into the position of having no external savings to fall back on. I myself saw representatives of the New Zealand Government coming to England in 1938. A mere £30,000,000 was falling due and they wanted to raise fresh money in London to repay it. They were told to go home and tighten their belts and that there was no £30,000,000 coming to them. Fortunately for them and unfortunately for the world, a few weeks afterwards the whole European and world situation blew up. Their young men were required and they were told to come back to London and they would get the £30,000,000. They did and they got it.

It is scarcely three months ago that I saw an article in a financial paper where a small country wanted a loan in a certain financial centre. They were told that they really were not deserving of loans because they would not let in foreign capital and because they had too high tariffs on the goods of this nation coming into their port. I do not want this generation or the next put into the position that if they wanted to buy some machines or some raw materials they would have to go to such a financial centre and be told that the tariffs were too high.

Comment on this

We are facing that position.

Comment on this

Or be told: "You will only get the loan when you reduce your tariffs" or otherwise please the country that had the credit. Deputy Hickey need not think that paying our way by the savings of our people in the form of external reserves is anything unique in Fianna Fáil. Every Government in every country which had the long-term interests of their people at heart rather than a little political gain took trouble to keep their external reserves at a reasonable level. Ours are not fantastically big.

They are only about £100,000,000. At the present time we are importing nearly £200,000,000 worth of materials, and if anything happened to the terms of trade we could go through that like a flash and be left in debt.

In 1951 we went through £60,000,000. Another one and a half years of that and we would be a debtor nation and in the position of the countries I have described. We do not want to get into that position deliberately. We want to see the resources of our country built up. We know that a private individual or a nation can build up their resources more rapidly when they have a little bit of capital to fall back on.

I must say it was very amusing to hear Deputy Costello—Deputy Hickey, I am sure, was listening to him—complaining about the rise in our adverse trade balance for the last few months. He was almost as alarmed about it as he was in 1948 about the adverse trade balance that occurred in 1946 and 1947. Although we had built up £160,000,000 of external assets during the war, when we exported and could not import, Deputy Costello was alarmed and despondent and wanted to take the most drastic action to save our balance of payments in 1948. I want to warn the House that Deputy Costello is back again to that particular point.

He complained to-day about the alarming increase in the adverse balance of payments. An adverse balance of payments means that we are importing more than we are exporting. Deputy Costello during the last couple of years he was in office and in order to cover up his inflationary finance boasted about the effect of an adverse trade balance. He then called it the "repatriation of our external assets." It was an "investment in human welfare," but you cannot have the liquidation of our external assets without an adverse balance of trade. To-day Deputy Costello complained about the adverse balance of trade whereas in 1949, 1950 and the early part of 1951 he boasted about the adverse balance of trade by means of which they were repatriating, as he called it, our external assets. The people, if they are wise, will require from the Opposition group——

Comment on this

They are wise now after yesterday.

Comment on this

——a statement of policy which they will agree to put into operation if they get into the position of forming a Coalition again. In 1948 Deputy Blowick was going around Mayo and other parts of the West saying that they would never form a Coalition and complaining about the "bad odour" that was in the Dáil when he came into it because of the other Farmers' Party that had been gobbled up by Cumann na nGaedheal. The Labour Party were also denouncing the idea of Coalition. Deputy Norton denounced Fine Gael—"join with Fine Gael, that out-moded, reactionary Party"; he would never have anything to do with them. Deputy MacBride was all out for Deputy Dillon's blood. He would not touch Deputy Dillon or anybody like him who would not stand up for the Soldiers' Song.

The people are not going to allow a lawyer's trick to delude them again. I would like to see the Opposition not too strong but reasonably strong. I do not want them wiped out altogether, and I would advise them if they want to avoid being wiped out to put some little face on it. They will have to offer the people some alternatives to the Fianna Fáil policy, and the people are entitled to it if there is anything in democracy. Not only must the people mark their ballot paper for a candidate but they must also mark their ballot paper as deciding between two policies offered. I advise the Coalition to give them that opportunity or they will come back with very much fewer numbers than they have at present.

Comment on this

It would suit the Minister for External Affairs to sit up and take notice of what is happening in his own Party rather than be concerning himself about the Labour Party or any other Party in the House. The one significant thing I heard in the Minister's speech was the statement to the effect that Fianna Fáil policy was designed to give better times to the people to come. It always seems to be Fianna Fáil policy to give better times to the people to come but surely it is not unreasonable to expect that the people who have to contend with everyday difficulties should be attended to. Whilst it may be all right to plan ahead—we can plan ahead for decades and decades of years—the people want to see some results and I would submit that they have not seen results in the last three years.

The Minister for Finance in his Budget speech yesterday, a speech that was contained in about 50 pages of manuscript, dealt with the economic situation as he found it in the country and having made the Budget proposals to the House, concluded with the sentence: "On these accomplishments the Government stands." Of course, if he is to depend on any of his accomplishments yesterday in his Budget proposals I have a fair idea how he, the Government and the Party will stand. But the people are not going to judge the present Government alone on the announcements that were made by the Minister for Finance yesterday and certainly a large number of them are not going to believe one tenth of the contentions he made with regard to the present position of this country. They are going to judge Fianna Fáil and the Government on their record over the past three years.

One of the most important things on which any Government ought to be judged—I think everybody in the House will admit this—is on their achievements with regard to the provision of employment. I do not think the Government have a happy record in that respect. I do not suggest that when we as a political Party were part of a Government we achieved Utopia in that particular difficulty but we certainly did much more than has been done in the last three years. The record of the Fianna Fáil Party in the last three years with regard to their failure to provide employment has been a very sorry one indeed. It seems to me that we always hear from the Fianna Fáil spokesmen that this country is either turning the corner or is at the crossroads. Ever since the Fianna Fáil Party took office and during their 16 years of office——

Comment on this

Nineteen years.

Comment on this

Nineteen years, the people have been promised better things, but have not seen all these things that have been promised. I do not deny any advances that are being made but I do say that the substantial advances that could have been made were not made in 15 years of Fianna Fáil office, and in the last three years especially when they had a very good opportunity to do things that they promised in 1932, they did not do them.

It is not much consolation for people who are now unemployed with no prospect of work or no consolation for thousands of people who have now, unfortunately, made their homes in Britain to hear from the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, or from the Taoiseach himself, that we are at the crossroads, we are turning the corner and we are planning for a better life for people in ten, 15 or 20 years' time. The Minister for Finance yesterday clapped himself on the back and boasted of it as an achievement that unemployment compared with last year had decreased by something like 12,000. Was that a fair comparison, especially when one remembers that in one particular month last year, February, we had a bigger unemployment figure for this country than we had since 1939? We had 90,000 Irish men and women who could not get work here in their own country. The comparison would have been fairer if he had gone back to 1952, 1951, 1950, 1949 or 1948. There is enough of a choice there. In April, 1951, there were 54,900 persons unemployed and in April, 1954, there were 74,800 unemployed, an increase of 20,000 odd.

Comment on this

Did you make any allowance for the extended register?

Comment on this

I will make the allowance for that but I cannot give it in actual figures. We have not got them. Apart from these statistics that have been given and that show this colossal increase, we have the evidence of our own eyes at the employment exchanges in every city and town in this country.

Comment on this

Did you look for any workers there?

Comment on this

What do you mean by that?

Comment on this

Did the Deputy look to see could he get a worker?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy trying to say they would not work if they got work?

Comment on this

No, but I have been looking for them and I could not get them.

Comment on this

I wonder where these 74,179 people are at the present time.

Comment on this

I would like to know that myself.

Comment on this

The Deputy had better ask Dr. Ryan, Minister for Social Welfare, because he gives us the figures every week and he said there were 74,000 unemployed last week.

Comment on this

Signing on at the exchanges.

Comment on this

What does signing on mean? It means they are available for work, suitable for work and genuinely seeking work.

Comment on this

A certain type of work.

Comment on this

I wonder what type these 74,000 are. I know there are builders' labourers.

Comment on this

All of them?

Comment on this

Not all of them. I know there are agricultural workers included in that number in the rural areas.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy describe them?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Corish must be allowed to make his own speech in his own way without interruption.

Comment on this

I am speaking as a result of experience and from example in my own constituency. The Minister for Social Welfare says there are 74,000 seeking work at the present time.

Comment on this

And neither Deputy Briscoe nor Deputy Killilea believes that.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corish on the Financial Resolution, without interruption.

Comment on this

Let us go a little bit further than the statement that the Minister for Finance made in relation to unemployment. Again, on the figures issued by the Minister for Social Welfare and by the Office of Central Statistics we know that the average number of unemployed in 1951 was 51,000; in 1952 it increased to 61,000; in 1953 it increased to 70,000 and at the present time it is slightly over 74,000. If we are to judge the Government on their record with regard to employment, I do not think we need go any further. Neither do I think it is a record of which they can be proud. Coupled with the unemployed—this has often been stated, but it is no harm to state it once more—we have the numbers who have been forced to emigrate. I do not want to exaggerate the figures, but a State Department gives the average yearly figure of emigration from 1946 to 1951 as 24,600, a very substantial number indeed. I think all of us will admit that. Last year, according to the figures given by the Taoiseach in reply to a parliamentary question, approximately 33,000 were forced to emigrate. The Taoiseach admits that those figures cannot be checked, but I think the figure will be generally acceptable because the information was given by the Taoiseach in reply to a parliamentary question.

As far as employment is concerned, the Government has a very, very sorry record indeed. As far as prices are concerned, I do not think it is necessary to go into the figure in detail. It is somewhat amazing that the Minister for Finance can come in here, as he did yesterday, and announce on the first page of his Budget statement that the cost of living fell and prices generally were smoothed out. It may be that prices dropped a point in relation to the cost-of-living figure. Who forced up the cost of living? If it dropped by a point, it dropped by a point as compared with what it had been forced up to by the Minister for Finance in April, 1952.

The whole country was looking forward to this Budget. What do we find? We discover that the only real concession—as the Minister for External Affairs described it a minute ago, a contemptible concession—is the reduction of ½d. on the 2-lb. loaf. That reduction is given by a Party which in the general election of 1951 complained that the cost of living was too high. In the town of Ferns I heard the Minister for Finance describing to his audience how little a person could now buy for £1 as compared with what could be purchased when he was Minister for Finance in 1947. He is the man who 12 short months afterwards in his Budget in 1952, increased substantially the price of tea, bread, butter, sugar and flour. He is the Minister for Finance in the Party, the leader of which said that they were pledged as part of their policy to retain the food subsidies, who throws this insult to Irish housewives and Irish wage earners of a reduction of ½d. on the loaf of bread.

Well may this Budget be described as the "½d." Budget. The Minister proposes to make a concession with regard to beer. We wonder to whom this concession will go. Is it to the firm of Arthur Guinness, a firm which made a net profit last year of £1,000,000? Is it to the licensed trade? What absolute provision is there in the Budget to ensure that it will go to the licensed trade? The Minister merely says that he expects the reduction will be passed on.

Comment on this

He has arranged it.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe says he has arranged it, but the Minister did not give us any evidence on the point, despite being questioned with relation to it yesterday. He did not give us any real evidence as to whether or not this reduction will be passed on to the licensed trade. There is no question about it being passed on to the consumer.

Comment on this

It is not intended to go to the consumer.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Norton and others, I welcome the concessions that have been given with regard to income-tax. Those concessions have been long overdue. They were overdue from 1948 to 1951. I have no hesitation in saying that, but the Minister's statement that 40,000 people will be relieved is just a huge joke. So far as the reduction in the price of bread is concerned, that reduction was forecast by the national organiser of the Fianna Fáil Party. I think he gave a fairly good indication at the time although none of us seemed to take the hint. Speaking at a Fianna Fáil Party Convention on last Sunday three weeks he is reported in the Sunday Independent as having said:—

"If their opponents succeeded in making this a bread-and-butter election it would mean that the Irish nation is becoming a nation of whingers and crawlers, weeping over the price of bread, butter and tea and exchanging their proud national heritage for a bottle of beer."

If it is any information to the Minister for Finance and the Fianna Fáil Party generally, the people are crying over the price of essential foodstuffs.

As far as we in the Labour Party are concerned, we propose to make it a bread-and-butter election. As far as we are concerned, no matter what our position is in the Dáil, and no matter what our numbers are, we say that the prices of these essential foodstuffs must be reduced because the people in our own constituencies and the people whom we canvassed in the last three or four weeks are more concerned about the cost of living than they are about practically any other problem in the country.

Comment on this

Will you tell us how you are going to do it?

Comment on this

You were able to get the money for Tulyar.

Comment on this

That is cheap. I believe that the Deputy is serious and I would like to know what he has in mind as to how they will do what he says.

Comment on this

I am not trying to keep any secrets from Deputy Briscoe, but I remember an occasion when Deputy Lemass was sitting on the Front Opposition Bench. He was asked a somewhat similar question as to how such and such thing was to be done. Deputy Lemass stood up and said that it was the duty of an Opposition to criticise and make suggestions, but that it was the function of a Government to put forward their proposals for the raising of money.

Comment on this

But you say you are going to be the Government.

Comment on this

I am not making any prophecies at all to Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corish should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I remember Deputy Dr. Ryan saying in the House that he was going to bring in a comprehensive scheme of social insurance, and that no insured worker would have to pay a penny. On that occasion he did not describe how he was going to do it. We did not discover until April, 1952, that he was going to give the people a comprehensive scheme of social insurance by drastically increasing the prices of tea, bread, butter, flour and other essential foodstuffs. As far as we are concerned, it will be a bread-and-butter election, no matter how much Fianna Fáil want to avoid it.

The Minister for External Affairs made great play with the oft-repeated allegation that the last Government left Fianna Fáil with the debt of £6.7 million. One may contrast that with the estimate by the Minister for Finance last year that he was going to save £3,500,000 on the Civil Service. If the Minister had been able to make that saving, then one must assume that he would have had much more money to distribute yesterday. Last year, he assumed that he was going to make that saving on the Civil Service, but yesterday the utmost that he could assume was that he was going to get £1,500,000 this year from C.I.E. We have all heard the moaning and the groaning of the present Government about the plight of C.I.E., and the burden it is on the Government and the taxpayers of the country to provide subsidies for it. I do not think anyone seriously believes that C.I.E. will contribute £1,500,000 to the National Exchequer next year.

These are the only few remarks that I want to make on the Budget proposals of the Minister for Finance. Personally, I think it is rather futile for us at this stage to be trying to make points in debate. It is rather futile to be trying to discuss the Budget proposals since we know that in a few weeks' time the people of the country will decide on them. I am not going to prophesy what is going to happen. As I said in the beginning, I suggest to the Minister for External Affairs that he should be more concerned about the difficulties in his own Party. As far as we are concerned, we will make up our minds independently of any other Party. The taunts that are made from any side of the House make no difference to us. We are an independent political Party and will make up our own minds as to whether or not we will support this, that or the other group or as to whether we will participate with, or merely support one. That is a decision which the Labour Party, as a whole, will make for itself and in doing so it will not be dictated to or be influenced by any other political Party in the country.

Comment on this

I have already indicated, in broad outline, my general views in regard to the Budget. There are, however, one or two points which escaped me when the Minister had finished reading his Budget statement. I know that the reduction of a ½d. in the 2-lb. loaf of bread was intended to be a bait to the weaker section of the community, to the working-class people of the country who do not happen to be as well off as the other portion of the community. It was a very small gift. I think it was Deputy Flanagan or Deputy McGilligan who christened the Budget on the spot as the "Halfpenny Budget". I realised very quickly that this was merely restoring the ½d. that had been added on, not by the Budget of 1952, but by an Order made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce some eight or nine months ago, so that in effect the Budget is merely restoring the price of bread to the same position as that in which it had been placed after the 1952 Budget.

So far so good. I must say that at the time I had not followed clearly the implications in the Minister's proposals in regard to C.I.E. Now, it is clear that, while he is giving £900,000 back to the taxpayers by way of the ½d. off the 2-lb. loaf of bread, he intends to collect £1,500,000 from C.I.E. We talk of C.I.E. as if it were some outside body, some institution or other that had no relation to the public; but I would like to know who is going to provide C.I.E. with £1,500,000 for the benefit of the Minister for Finance? I imagine it is the ordinary public who use the buses in the City of Dublin and elsewhere. Accordingly, while the working classes are being given a ½d. off the 2-lb. loaf of bread, they are going, apparently, to be fleeced a penny or more on their bus fares, because that is the clear implication in the Minister's proposals.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

He gives £900,000 by way of a ½d. off the loaf of bread and he finances that transaction by saying that he will get £1,500,000 from C.I.E. Presumably, his collector will go to C.I.E. and say: "You will have to make £1,500,000 available to me in the course of a year." I do not think that C.I.E. have any source of income other than what they collect off the public either by way of freight charges or bus fares. As most of us who are city Deputies in this House know, it is the Dublin public, it is the working classes of the City of Dublin that, in effect, pay a large proportion of the losses sustained by C.I.E., so that in effect it is the public in Dublin, the working classes in Dublin, who will have to pay for this ½d. off the loaf of bread.

A ½d. will be put into one pocket but probably a penny or twopence will be taken out of the other pocket through an increase in C.I.E. fares.

Comment on this

You know that is wrong —what you are saying.

Comment on this

I know that is right and if Deputy Briscoe had the interests of his constituents at heart he would have prevented the Minister for Finance from demanding more money from C.I.E. because he must know that inevitably the result must be an increase in bus fares in the City of Dublin. C.I.E. will have to find £1,500,000——

Comment on this

I will answer you afterwards.

Comment on this

And either the Minister for Finance is trying to cod the public into the belief that C.I.E. is going to make £1,500,000 or £1,000,000, or he is serious. If he is not serious and is trying to mislead the public, trying to cod the public, then he is not responsible and should not be Minister for Finance. If he is serious then he has to get this money from C.I.E. and I do not see that C.I.E. is in a position to obtain money from any source other than the travelling public and our experience has been that it is usually the bus passengers in the cities and more populous areas who are mulcted to pay for the deficiency on other services. So that if Deputy Briscoe was really interested in his constituents who are already paying excessive fares to C.I.E., he would have pressed the Minister for Finance into leaving C.I.E. alone.

Comment on this

You will be surprised when you hear my answer.

Comment on this

I will be surprised at no answer that Deputy Briscoe gives in this House or elsewhere. I know too much about him.

Comment on this

Do not try to get personal now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us deal with the Resolution. Personalities must not come into this debate.

Comment on this

Then Deputy Briscoe must keep quiet but if Deputy Briscoe wishes it the other way he can have the whole history. I have plenty of experience of him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I hope Deputy Briscoe will make his own speech and not interrupt.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I hope that when the Minister for Finance concludes he or, indeed, I hope some of the members of the Government, possibly, before the Minister for Finance replies will tell the House and the country how the Minister for Finance expects C.I.E. to find this additional £1,000,000 or £1,500,000 which will enable him to take ½d. off the loaf of bread.

Returning to the Budget generally, it has long been recognised that one of the main functions of a Budget is to be an instrument whereby the economic policy of the country is forged. The Budget and the economic policy of the Government—any Government—are the main instruments which are used by a Government to create certain economic conditions in the country. It is well recognised that the budgetary and economic policy of a Government can create employment and unemployment at will. It is recognised that the budgetary policy and the economic policy of a Government can control the amount of purchasing power of the public. In our case, not only does the budgetary policy of the Government and the economic policy of the Government generally control unemployment but they also control emigration, because the true unemployment position is always concealed by the heavy emigration drain. I was interested listening to the Budget statement yesterday in trying to ascertain the trends of economic policy which the Government was pursuing. The economic policy pursued by the Government since 1951 has been that laid down by the Central Bank in 1951, a policy which had a two-pronged aim.

Firstly, its aim was to increase unemployment and emigration, presumably for the purpose of maintaining low wages conditions, and the other prong of the economic policy advocated by the Central Bank was the reduction of the purchasing power of the public to enable the maintenance and accumulation of substantial foreign assets. I think now anyone examining the Report of the Central Bank will agree that these were the two main objectives of those who drew it up and that they considered it necessary in order to achieve these conditions to maintain a large unemployment pool, keep wages down and also necessary to reduce purchasing power so as to build up foreign assets. For the purpose of achieving that two-pronged aim the Central Bank advocated certain measures and the Government has faithfully and religiously carried out those measures. It advocated first the rigorous restriction of credit, the removal of food subsidies and additional taxation on consumer goods for the purpose of reducing the purchasing power of the public and the Government systematically took these steps.

I, therefore, examined the Budget statement and proposals of the Minister for Finance against that background to find out was that policy still being pursued by the Government. And it still is. You cannot say that taking a ½d. off the 2-lb. loaf and adding twice as much to bus fares probably, is a change of policy. The policy outlined by the Minister is clearly one which maintains the objectives set out by the Central Bank. That is why yesterday I expressed surprise that the Minister had made no reference to the attitude of the Government in regard to the expansion of credit.

I was anxious yesterday to ascertain whether the Government was in that respect also still pursuing faithfully the advice given to it by the Central Bank and its economic advisers. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance made a rather vain attempt yesterday to deny their own declarations in that regard. I am sure by now they have accepted that these statements were properly quoted by me in the House.

I think it is well, however, to review very shortly the position in regard to the restriction of credits. I raised this matter in the House time after time. I raised it on every economic debate and I raised it on every possible occasion in this House. For a long time the Taoiseach denied that there was any restriction of credits, denied it completely. His next line was that he did not know whether there was or not. I think, however, that now it must be admitted that there was a restriction of credits. He has never given a categorical indication himself that he wanted to see an expansion of credit. The Minister for Finance in his Budget statement yesterday remained completely silent. That must be taken in conjunction with the fact that the Central Bank had given very specific directives that, in their view, rigorous credit restriction by the banks was necessary and in conjunction with the declaration made by the Minister for Finance himself, a declaration in which he said: "Private and public spending are causing congestion that can be relieved only by a reduction of one or the other. Credit facilities are encouraging outlay on less essential goods." That is a clear indication of the view which the Minister for Finance, who was the spokesman of the Government in these matters, took and was an indication to the banks that in the view of the Minister for Finance credits should be restricted.

There has been an extremely effective restriction of credits for quite a while. It might be well if I recall to the House that even the Government's own newspaper had reported on the restriction of credits which was taking place in the country. On the 18th October, 1951, the Irish Press in an article headed “Banks Close on Credit” stated:—

"It was becoming increasingly difficult to get credit from banks for the past six months, and within the past two months this tightening of credit facilities has been intensified."

That is no mere idle propaganda from some anti-Government source. That is from an article in the Government's own newspaper, a newspaper to which the Minister for Finance himself contribues articles from time to time.

Comment on this

What is the date of that article?

Comment on this

The 18th October, 1951. We had, too, a number of very interesting articles published in the Sunday Press by the former chairman of the Industrial Credit Corporation, Mr. Colbert. I do not want to weary the House with long quotations, but I think it would be well to remind the House of some of these quotations. In the course of one of these articles, under the heading “Says Former Industrial Credit Chief,” Mr. Colbert reviews certain references made by the Tánaiste in the course of a speech, and goes on to say:—

"Mr. Lemass may have been referring to the astonishing fact that four of our leading banks have their headquarters outside the Twenty-Six Counties—two of them in London and two in Belfast—and that another leading `Irish' bank is totally Britishowned, or he may have had in mind the raising of the Irish bank rate following the increase in the Bank of England rate—which I for one regarded as quite uncalled for."

These are Mr. Colbert's views; they are not my views. Mr. Colbert went on:—

"Then, again, he may have been referring critically to the restriction of credit here on the directive of the Bank of England—an action which, again, I consider was also quite unnecessary."

It is very hard for the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance in the light of these articles to come here and pretend that they did not know there was any restriction of credits. I have relied on articles published in the Government's own newspaper so that they could not plead ignorance of them.

This credit restriction policy was very effectively carried out. Some Deputies, I am sure, will have seen a document circulated on the 4th February, 1953, by the Department of Finance. The Department of Finance sent out portion of a report compiled by the O.E.E.C. dealing with the financial conditions of this country. From my experience I know that reports of that nature are the result of information supplied by our own Department of Finance. This report was prepared by a committee on which Ireland was represented. From my experience of the O.E.E.C. and international organisations, I know that no report would be issued by them which was disapproved of by the country concerned and that there was consultation and discussion before the report was issued. Therefore I am prepared to accept that the views contained in this report are a true reflection of the view of the Government expressed through the Department of Finance to the O.E.E.C. I do not think I am putting it on a higher level than it should be put. That was a very interesting report and I would advise Deputies who may not have seen it to try and procure a copy and read it. On page 7 we are told that the purpose of the 1952 Budget was to replace a deficit on current account in the 1951 Budget by a balance, and thus—I would like Deputies to mark these words—"to obtain a reduction in the volume of consumers' expenditure"; so that the purpose of the Budget of 1952 was to reduce the purchasing power of the public. That was the aim of the Central Bank according to themselves, and it became the aim of the Fianna Fáil Government.

The report then goes on in the next paragraph to say: "The effect of budgetary policy on demand has been supported by a tighter monetary policy"—that is, by restriction of credits.

"In March, 1952, the rate on bank advances was raised from 5 per cent. to 6 per cent., that on bank deposits from 1 to 1½ per cent., and the bank rate from 2½ per cent. to 3½ per cent. The volume of bank advances fell by 2 per cent. in the second quarter of the year. The tighter credit policies now prevailing have no doubt, to a minor extent, been responsible for the change from accumulation to the running down of stocks."

So now, I think, the cat is out of the bag. We have it here in this document that the purpose of the Budget was to reduce the purchasing power of the public, and one of the ways in which that was to be achieved was by a tighter money policy, restriction of credits and increases in the bank charges; and that has been done, and done very successfully.

Then on the next page there is a very enlightening sentence that I think I must quote before passing from this report. It deals with the question of manpower and emigration, and says:—

"The fact that unemployment has not reached serious proportions is largely due to continuing heavy emigration."

I have no criticism of this report. It is an objective report of the position here and of what the Government policy was, and I am afraid still is. But in the light of these documents and the light of references to which I have referred I think it is somewhat difficult for the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance to come into this House and deny that they had favoured credit restrictions. My concern was that in this Budget they had failed to give any indication to the banks that they wished to see expansion of credit. And expansion of credit is in my view the only immediate solution which offers itself for the creation of employment and for the development of the country. This country has been starved for investment. There could be a certain amount of Government capital investment in certain schemes. There is always a danger that we may overdo that, but from the long-term point of view the only way to promote a higher rate of investment in the country is by a very substantial expansion of credit policy. This is contrary to the policy pursued by the Department of Finance and the Central Bank over a long period of time. It is the old equation as to which is more important—to keep an accumulation of sterling assets in London, probably depreciating in value, or to try and keep boys and girls at work in this country. I have no doubt as to the choice which I would make.

Some Ministers have in the course of speeches recently sought to suggest that the very high rate of increase in prices here was occasioned by circumstances outside the country, that the cost of living had gone up more in other countries than here, that there was nothing the Government could do about it, that as a matter of fact indeed we were very lucky to be living in Ireland because if we were living somewhere else the cost of living might have gone up at an even greater rate. Occasionally I am inclined to accept statements when they are made by persons in responsible positions in a categorical fashion—to accept them, believing them to be true. It always strikes me as surprising that any person holding a responsible position should make a statement which is capable of disproof. I accepted the statement that the cost of living had gone up proportionately in other countries as much as it had gone up here, and that it had probably gone up even less here than in other countries. I accepted that statement till one day I was rather interested to see exactly what was happening the cost of living in other countries. I took the trouble to get the relevant statistics, to find that those statements were untrue, and completely untrue, that according to the O.E.E.C. statistics—which I think are reliable and comparable because they have been prepared on the same basis—from February, 1951, to August, 1953, which was the last date for which figures are available, our cost of living had gone up from 102 to 124—that was an increase of 22 points—and that was a higher increase than in any one of 16 other countries. In Portugal the cost of living had gone down by 2 per cent. during that period; and indeed if I am not mistaken the Taoiseach and some of his Ministers were in Portugal this year, so they should have been aware of that. In Belgium from February, 1951, to August, 1953, the cost of living had gone up by 4 per cent.—4 points, rather. In the Netherlands, in Switzerland and in the United States it had gone up by 4 points. In our case it had gone up by 22 points in the same period. In Germany it had gone up by 5 points, Luxembourg 6 points, Canada 6 points, Denmark 9 points, Italy 9 points, Turkey 10 points, Sweden 16 points, Britain 19 points, France 20 points, Norway 21 points, and Ireland 22 points—so that those statements were completely untrue. I do think that in political controversy we should at least be able——

Comment on this

Oh, get off it, get off it. Deputy. Everybody knows your form in political controversy.

Comment on this

I know the Minister for Finance's form and I know that he was one of the first persons to rely on credit restriction to justify his own viewpoint, which has resulted in the Minister for Finance's policy, but succeeded in driving thousands upon thousands of young people out of the country, and I know that he does not care about them.

Comment on this

The Deputy is just misusing the O.E.E.C. figures. He can be answered. Every single word of what he is misusing will be answered. He is using a selected list of statistics.

Comment on this

If I am not mistaken it is the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, now interrupting, who has been going around the country preaching, saying that the cost of living had not gone up as much here as elsewhere.

Comment on this

Nothing of the kind. I have never used selected statistics.

Comment on this

These are not selected statistics. They are statistics published by the O.E.E.C. which the Minister can get. They give the cost-of-living figures in every country from the month of February, 1951, to the month of August, 1953. I shall, if the Minister wishes, quote the figures for each country in detail.

Comment on this

If the Deputy goes back a year, the figures change. If he goes forward for one year, the figures change again.

Comment on this