We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 223–470 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has been doing most of his bleating around Westmeath—God help the people of Westmeath——

Comment on this

They have been saved from Deputy MacBride in two elections.

Comment on this

I do not know if they will continue to save the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs for very long, by all accounts. These figures have been prepared by O.E.E.C. They are based on an index of 100 in 1950. I had better give the figures again so that the Minister and Deputies can check them for themselves. In February, 1951, taking the base as 100 in 1950, the figure for Portugal was 99; in August, 1953, the figure had gone down to 97. In Belgium, in February, 1951, the figure was 106 and in August, 1953, it was 110. In the Netherlands, in February, 1951, the figure was 106 and in August, 1953, it was 110. In Switzerland, in February, 1951, the figure was 102 and in August, 1953, it was 106. In the United States, in February, 1951, the figure was 107 and in August, 1953, it was 111. In Germany, in February, 1951, the figure was 103 and in August, 1953, it was 108. In Luxembourg, in February, 1951——

Comment on this

These figures have no relation to one another.

Comment on this

I know the Minister for Finance does not like this. He denied a statement which he made here yesterday and he was proved to be wrong.

Comment on this

I have the quotation here and I can show the words were a paraphrase of what your colleague said.

Comment on this

The Minister is not going to prevent me from reading these figures. I am not going to be deprived——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will get an opportunity of making his statement later.

Comment on this

The only argument which Fianna Fáil Ministers have is to deny a thing, when it does not suit them to admit it. The truth does not matter; it is quite immaterial. If they are proved wrong, they still maintain they are right. To continue with the figures; in Luxembourg, in February, 1951, the index was 104 and in August, 1953, 110. In Canada, in February, 1951, it was 106 and in August, 1953, 112. In Denmark, in February, 1951, it was 107 and in August, 1953, 116. In Italy, in February, 1951, it was 106 and in August, 1953, it was 115. In Turkey, in February, 1951, it was 99 and in August, 1953, 109. In Sweden, in February, 1951, it was 109 and in August, 1953, it was 125. In Britain, in February, 1951, the figure was 104 and in August, 1953, it was 123. In France, in February, 1951, it was 108 and in August, 1953, it was 128. In Norway, in February, 1951, it was 108 and in August, 1953, it was 129 and in Ireland in February, 1951, it was 102, while in August, 1953, it was 124. In Ireland it had increased by 22 points, a higher increase than in any of the other countries named.

Comment on this

It increased by 12½ points during your period of office.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy is wrong. The index did not go up that much. If the Deputy would look at the figures he would save a lot of argument.

Comment on this

That is what they issued from Mount Street.

Comment on this

I have quoted these figures in such detail only because it has been said by the Minister that the cost of living had gone up less here than in any country in the world.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say what was the cost-of-living index in May, 1951? I will tell you.

Comment on this

How much was it?

Comment on this

It was 109.

Comment on this

Was that 12½ per cent. increase?

Comment on this

In February, 1951, it was 103 and it had jumped by almost 6 per cent. after three months under the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

Give us the figures.

Comment on this

It had not gone up by 12½ per cent.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacBride is in possession.

Comment on this

I take it that in his more serious moments the Minister for Finance does not believe what he said in his Budget statement yesterday— certainly the country does not believe it—that last year was one of the most prosperous years the country ever had. I am sure he does not believe it nor, I am sure, does he believe that the cost of living fell. Certainly the public do not believe it. I think that we ought to have some sense of realism in these matters. The cost of living has increased in the last three years by something over 20 per cent. In regard to the value of social services, the truth of the matter is that, by-and-large, the benefits which people now receive in the way of old age pensions or unemployment or sickness benefits now, in terms of real money, are lower than they were before the war. Indeed, the man who interrupted from the Gallery last evening——

Comment on this

The Deputy should keep off that because that man in the Gallery was invited by a legal member of the Opposition. He was neither unemployed nor hungry and he was applauded by the Deputy.

Comment on this

He certainly——

Comment on this

He was neither unemployed hungry nor ill-fed.

Comment on this

He was not invited into the House by me. I did not know him. I did not know his name nor had I ever seen him before.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have a discussion on yesterday's incident in the Gallery. It does not arise on the Resolution.

Comment on this

I defy the Minister or the Taoiseach to get up and tell any unemployed man in this city with a wife and two or three children how he is to live on 38/- a week.

Comment on this

Would it not be better to ask him how does he exist?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy McGilligan how did he exist under his Government.

Comment on this

It is all very well for Deputies and Ministers to come in here to interrupt and behave like a crowd of naughty schoolboys. Remember, you have over 70,000 people unemployed. Many of them are on the borderline of starvation. The only outlook for them is emigration. Again, let me remind you that this thing of saying that you have no reliable information in regard to emigration is all balderdash. It is quite true there are no reliable statistics, no positive statistics in the definite sense, but the returns of passenger movements by sea are a clear and reliable guide as to the trends of emigration. Again let me refer you to these figures in case some Deputies are not familiar with them.

In 1950 the outward balance of passenger movement by sea was 17,854 and by 1953 it had risen to 31,113. That is to say that 31,113 more people took a boat from Dún Laoghaire or from Cobh or North Wall to leave the country than came in. That is a pretty good indication of the trend of emigration. It is quite true that other people may go from Derry or Belfast, they may emigrate from the Six Counties and we have no records; so it is not a complete guide but it is an indication of the trend.

There is one other matter I wish to deal with before I conclude. When I came in yesterday I did not come armed with figures and what I said was denied. In referring to the review made by the Minister for Finance on foreign trade, I indicated some concern at the falling off of exports to America and to countries other than Britain. I think that is an extremely serious matter. I have since looked up the figures. This was promptly denied yesterday when I mentioned it. It was laughed at; the Taoiseach split his sides laughing at it; it was all nonsense and there was no truth in it. I do not want to weary the House with too many figures.

Comment on this

The Deputy never does anything else but weary the House.

Comment on this

I know the Minister does not like this.

Comment on this

The Deputy poses to be a highly superior person. We are bored by it.

Comment on this

He would not interrupt otherwise. If he were merely weary, he would doze without listening to me; but he does not like this, so he interrupts every few minutes and behaves like a childish schoolboy, a rather badly brought up schoolboy.

Comment on this

He will soon get a more comfortable seat—over here.

Comment on this

Do you find it more comfortable? If so, you are not likely to change it.

Comment on this

In the last year of the Fianna Fáil Government's rule before the change of Government, in 1947, the total exports to countries other than Britain, from this State, were £4,499,000. In 1951, through the inter-Party Government—and, if I may take a certain amount of credit there, through my own efforts and the efforts of Deputy Morrissey—that figure rose from £4,499,000 to £13,033,000. It was trebled in a period of three years.

Comment on this

Do not forget that Deputy Dillon did something, too, in the export of meat.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon was not very much concerned in his Department with exports to countries other than Great Britain.

Comment on this

He certainly was not.

Comment on this

We did not export an awful lot of agricultural goods to such countries.

Comment on this

We are in agreement for once—that Deputy Dillon was never concerned with exports to other countries.

Comment on this

They do not like this and want to prevent me from getting these figures out, so naturally they interrupt. By now we are accustomed to these tactics. By 1951 we had succeeded in trebling exports to countries other than Britain. By 1953 where are we? By 1953 that figure has fallen by £3,000,000 to £10,703,000. Would anyone opposite tell me those figures are not correct? Come on, let somebody deny them. Will anyone deny it? I have the Taoiseach's reply here to a question last week. Will anyone deny that the figures are correct? We find that our exports to America have fallen off, despite the Tánaiste's visit to America.

When I first became Minister for External Affairs, I found that our total exports to the American Continent amounted to £361,000, that they were practically non-existent. By 1951 we had built them up to £3,716,000. By 1953 they had gone down to £2,934,000. I think that is a dangerous trend. From the point of view of the economic independence of the country —which the Minister for Finance has so often referred to—it is vital that we should develop other markets throughout the world, that we should not be economically bound, hand and foot, to Britain. Therefore, I deprecate anything done by the present Government to try again to divert our trade exclusively to Britain. Probably a certain amount of the fall in our exports to countries other than Britain—and particularly the fall in our exports to America—is due to many of the irresponsible statements made by the Minister for Finance himself in regard to America, with the able assistance of some of the Deputies in this House. I deprecate that trend and I think that some effort should be made to try to build up our exports to countries other than Britain, or at least restore them to the position in which they were in 1951.

I am afraid I have spoken longer than I intended, but that was probably due to some of the interruptions.

Comment on this

I propose to alter the programme I had for speaking to the House to-night on this Budget, by beginning with Deputy MacBride. When he started to speak he apologised for his rather meagre contribution last night. But since last night he had an opportunity of studying the Budget statement and therefore he was now in a position to come here and tell the House and the country what it meant and what it did not mean. He started off in a most dishonest fashion, by attempting to make it appear to the public that the payment to the Exchequer from C.I.E. was going to be made by an imposition of an extra penny on bus fares in Dublin.

Comment on this

We have not been told now.

Comment on this

A seasoned lawyer who gets up here and says he read this Budget statement carefully, perused it and understood it, drives me now to read the particular page of the Budget statement dealing with that point, so that the House will know how far they can rely on anything stated by Deputy MacBride. The Deputy said that C.I.E. were going to have extracted from them in this current financial year £1,500,000. The Deputy will not stay here to be educated—he knows he has misstated it. This particular reference in the Budget statement is quite simple. I propose to read it, so that I cannot be accused of misinterpretation. Remember, Deputy MacBride alleges this seriously and hopes to start a scare that there is going to be a penny increase on bus fares in order to enable C.I.E. to meet the demand for this £1,500,000. The statement is very simple. It is on page 29 of the financial statement of the Minister for Finance:—

"For several years past it has been necessary to make Exchequer issues to C.I.E. to cover operating losses, interest and other revenue charges. These issues were made on request, subject to adjustment when the accounts of the year became available. The accounts for 1952-53 were published last autumn; and the examination of them has shown that the requests for subsidy payments from the Vote and for Central Fund advances to meet debenture interest had been framed on the assumption that a large proportion of expenditure on renewals and replacements was chargeable to current revenue. It would appear, however, that various items to which the board proposed to apply the funds received from the Exchequer were proper to be borrowed for under the Transport Act of 1950 which authorised the issue of up to £7,000,000 of State-guaranteed stock."

Comment on this

That is not what you said in 1951, though.

Comment on this

I will deal with what I said in 1951 when I have finished with your ex-colleague, Deputy MacBride. The statement goes on:—

"This limit of £7,000,000 was, indeed, fixed in contemplation of the need for C.I.E. to overtake heavy arrears of renewals and replacements, as well as meeting some additional capital expenditure.

Now, the accounts of C.I.E. have shown an increase, year by year, in the provision of depreciation, until by 1952-53 it reached a figure of £1,483,000. On the other hand, Sir James Milne in his report considered that the average 1945-47 allowance under this head of about £800,000 was more than adequate. The line which in my view should be taken on this is a simple one. Where gross profits are sufficiently high, it is sound policy to make the largest possible allocations from profits to meet expenditure on replacements and renewals; where, however, profits are non-existent or inadequate and public funds are, in effect, being called upon to supplement revenue, it is necessary in protection of the taxpayer to take a less liberal view. This is particularly so where, as in the case of C.I.E., expenditure to overtake arrears of renewals may, under legislative authority, be charged to borrowing.

Up to the close of 1951-52, in recognition of the straitened financial position of C.I.E., almost all of the exceptional outlay on renewals was borne directly by the Exchequer. The position regarding expenditure on renewals in 1952-53 and 1953-54 is under discussion; in both years the Exchequer appears to have borne expenditure which would more appropriately be a charge to public borrowing."

Comment on this

That is not what you said in 1951.

Comment on this

I will deal with 1951 later.

Comment on this

You burst a button then when somebody else said it.

Comment on this

What I said in 1948, probably, the Deputy means.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement goes on:—

"The information we now have indicates that the Exchequer would already have benefited from the marked improvement in the traffic receipts of C.I.E., but for the greatly increased charge against revenue for renewals—necessary though these were to make good arrears of proper maintenance and replacement. The position in fact is that, before allowing for depreciation and other charges, a working loss in 1951-52 has been converted into a working profit in 1953-54.

C.I.E. is liable under Section 30 of the Transport Act, 1950, for the repayment to the Exchequer of moneys advanced from the Central Fund to meet interest payments on Transport Stock. The aggregate amount advanced for this purpose to the 31st March, 1954, was £1,924,000."

Comment on this

You used to say it was £2,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

The statement continues:—

"The improvement in the financial position of C.I.E. which is an occasion for congratulation to all concerned, raises for consideration the question of repayment by the organisation of some of its liability to the Exchequer.

The precise extent and form of the necessary adjustments in favour of the Exchequer are at present under consideration, but I am satisfied that no vote payment in respect of operating losses and revenue charges will be necessary in 1954-55 and that £1,000,000 or so will be repayable to the Exchequer in respect of previous years. I have already allowed for £500,000 of this repayment in the estimate for non-tax revenue and, as the total relief to this year's Budget is of the order of £1,500,000, I should, at this point, take account of the remaining £1,000,000."

Comment on this

So C.I.E. is now going to subsidise the Government instead of the Government subsidising C.I.E.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey was not in the House when his colleague or ex-colleague or possible future colleague—he is welcome to him; they are all welcome to him—stated categorically, having, as a learned lawyer, studied this, burnt the midnight oil, that he extracted from that statement that that £1,500,000 would come by way of increase in transport fares.

Comment on this

Where is it going to come from? Where is C.I.E. going to get it?

Comment on this

They have already got it.

Comment on this

They have not and the Minister knows they have not got it and I know they have not got it. Perhaps Deputy Briscoe will tell us now where it is going to be got, if not from fares.

Comment on this

I see the Deputy has also read this and has also misunderstood it.

Comment on this

I am asking the Deputy to enlighten me as to where they are going to get the £1,500,000 for the Government.

Comment on this

Certainly not by putting it on the fares. Do you want me to read it again?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy dispute the statement of the Minister that the losses of 1951-52 have now been turned into a gross profit in 1953-54?

Comment on this

I not only do not believe it but it is a complete perversion of the whole position.

Comment on this

If we are to take it that a financial statement of this kind of a Minister for Finance has to go on record as a document containing a deliberate misstatement of facts——

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

——then I am afraid we are dealing with people who are in public life in a manner that I do not understand.

Comment on this

All I am asking is where is the £1,500.000 going to come from?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Briscoe might be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

He said it is very simple. I do not understand it.

Comment on this

It is very simple. I have read it. It requires no explanation. Certainly it does not require an interpretation such as Deputy MacBride has put on it. That is only an attempt on a par with what the Deputy did when he was leader of a Party seeking the confidence of the people in 1948 when he produced a film depicting the misery of our people. He had the audacity to think that the people of our country were of such a mean mental state that they would believe his propaganda when he showed pictures of buildings in Dublin being torn down by the Dublin Corporation to be rebuilt and substituted by flats. He showed a torn-down wall in his film.

Comment on this

I thought Senator Hartnett was the producer and Deputy Dr. Browne was the principal actor.

Comment on this

He showed the slums of Dublin. He showed also a rusty plough in an abandoned field as his evidence of Fianna Fáil's contribution to the development of agriculture. That is a type of propaganda which may have deceived a certain number of people in 1948. The proof that the deception was discovered was the vote he received in 1951 when he was removed from the top of the poll to near the bottom.

Comment on this

By traitors.

Comment on this

The vote in 1954 will count.

Comment on this

It will. I am prepared to say now that I believe the people of this country will not fall a second time for misrepresentation.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They know now what is misrepresentation. I represent in this Dáil and I hope to represent again, a working-class district of the City of Dublin—and that will be as a result of intelligent people scrutinising carefully this time what has been said to them by people who have deceived them in the past. So much, therefore, for Deputy MacBride's reference to the improved position of C.I.E. and Deputy Morrissey's cheers and his "Hear, hear" to the Minister's statement that the situation in C.I.E. has improved. Either he believes it has or he does not.

Comment on this

Of course it has improved.

Comment on this

Very well then, if it has improved it has improved.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And how do you count improvement in C.I.E. unless you measure it in terms of pounds, shillings and pence and in terms of the employment given to workers in that concern?

Comment on this

They have not £1,500,000 and I want to know where they will get it. I put them on the road to improvement. It is on the machinery we gave them that they improved.

Comment on this

The Minister concluded his reference to C.I.E. by pointing out that dieselisation has been a great help towards bringing about the improved position.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I should like to remind Deputy Morrissey of what I said about C.I.E. when that Bill was brought in. At that time I pointed out that the decision to cut out the acquisition of diesel engines was delaying prosperity. It was only after 1951, when Fianna Fáil resumed office, that the policy of dieselisation was properly implemented.

Comment on this

That is not true. You are getting the Minister into more trouble. Five diesel engines came from America. Where are they now, and what is being done with them? Tell us about that.

Comment on this

I recommend Deputy Morrissey to read the speeches made as a result of the suggestion that C.I.E. would not be allowed to spend the capital necessary for the complete dieselisation of the——

Comment on this

I know the facts. The present dieselisation scheme was started under our Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

The Deputy is challenging me all along the line. I know more about it than he does.

Comment on this

Be patient.

Comment on this

I should hope that the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce, who had the responsibility of bringing in a Bill to this House with the object of trying to put C.I.E. on the road to prosperity, would know a little bit more about that side of it than merely a person who represents the public in an area where they work in C.I.E.

Comment on this

According to the Budget, it was a good Act.

Comment on this

The Deputy made C.I.E. a bankrupt concern.

Comment on this

I should love to make a speech on that.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an opportunity of making his speech. He will be able to criticise what I have said. Deputy MacBride talks in a sort of superior manner—away above the heads of the masses. It is like something that you read about in connection with the aristocrats in ancient France.

Comment on this

It is just that it is above your head.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride talks about external assets. He waves his hands and talks about bringing them back. He talks about how this Government is, in his estimation, bowing down to the gods of the Central Bank and taking dictation from them as to what to do and what not to do. He talks about our having £400,000,000 in external assets. According to the latest report which I have, we have something like £400,000,000 in external assets—but we owe about £250,000,000.

Comment on this

Including Guinness's Brewery.

Comment on this

Therefore, all we can really call our own for net transfer back here will not exceed £150,000,000. That is all you can bring back and you can only bring it back to employ it. That particular matter has been discussed and discussed——

Comment on this

On a re-check, tell us what we have and not what we have not. I think there is no genuine check.

Comment on this

A blank cheque.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputies of the Labour Party, among themselves, take a different interpretation out of words. Deputy Hickey is talking about "check" and Deputy O'Leary is talking about "cheque". They are talking about two different things. Deputy MacBride talked about the restriction of credit by the banks. He quoted from a series of articles. He mentioned the names of some of the authors and just said of the others that they had appeared in the Irish Press. The latest information I have is that in March, 1952, our joint stock banks had advanced for all purposes £122,000,000—which is recorded as the highest figure ever in the shape of credit accorded by the banks. In December, 1952, it had fallen by £5,000,000: it had gone down to £117,000,000. In December, 1953, it was up again to £119,000,000. There is always bound to be fluctuation.

When the farmers are sowing their crops and making their arrangements for a good harvest they probably borrow from the banks. When they sell their harvest and have a good crop they pay off their debt and put a little bit on deposit. That is why our deposits on the farming side are on the increase and it explains certain fluctuations. Time and time again, this Government have stated—and the previous Government agreed and stated likewise—that any pressure by a Government on the banks to reduce credit has never been done by the Government as a policy. It may be something the banks do themselves. We have discussed that on a number of occasions: I do not want to discuss it now. However, when Deputy MacBride comes in here and makes the silly allegation that our Government, through the Central Bank, are influencing the ordinary banks to restrict credit so that the purchasing power of our public will be reduced, all I can ask is if anybody believes that statement or if anybody believes——

Comment on this

I believe it.

Comment on this

The Deputy should have waited until I had finished the sentence. I was going to ask if anybody believes that if Deputy MacBride is sane and not daft, he believes it himself.

Comment on this

You do not come into that category at all.

Comment on this

Not only do I believe it but I know it to be true.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Briscoe aware that every farmer who has asked for credit since Fianna Fáil took Office in 1951 has been refused credit?

Comment on this

The farmers were never as well off.

Comment on this

No thanks to you. You did your best to pick their pockets.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride talked about exports to America. He talked about the increased turnover with countries other than Britain in exports. He patted himself on the back as being one of the two—he and Deputy Morrissey—who were responsible for the increase of trade—and not a word of praise for Deputy Dillon. I want to say to Deputy Dillon's face that I know he had some interest—at one time, anyway—in trying to help the development of the export of meat to America. The development of that trade did create a big part of the turnover of our exports to America. Why? Because of the Korean war. It was because of the number of American troops abroad that had to be fed with meat and meat products and because of a situation of shortage of supply of meat in America that we had a bumper few years here. People buying cattle, slaughtering and exporting them in carcase form to America were making as much as ? per lb. net. That is perfectly true and Deputies know it. That is a business which grew up overnight and which has since crawled down a little.

Comment on this

We know that you on that side killed it.

Comment on this

I suppose the Deputy will hold us responsible for the ending of the Korean war. We fought them to a standstill and they had to give up— the Americans and the Communists. That is the war which the Deputy, when he was a Minister, was a party to describing as a mythical war when it was drawn to the attention of the then Administration. We had nothing to do with the stopping of that war——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

——but we do, at least, know that wars, when they are expected or are being conducted, affect world prices of all commodities and there was bound to be an effect on the price of commodities such as those we have for export, commodities which are essential in war-time, namely, foodstuffs.

Deputy Costello spoke here this evening and I was again amazed by the bad brief to which he had to speak. I wonder who prepared that brief? Just imagine an ex-Taoiseach saying here, seriously and categorically, that the total borrowings of the inter-Party Government in their three years were £23,000,000 and that the borrowings of the Fianna Fáil Government since 1951 was in excess of that amount, having reached a figure of £28,000,000. That was the categorical statement made by Deputy Costello, as if none of us here or in the country had ever heard of the $128,000,000 borrowed from America, the equivalent of £40,000,000, in their three years. What was the reason for leaving that transaction out? Is it not a fact that £40,000,000 were borrowed which were to be the greatest contribution to the prosperity of this nation for ever?

Comment on this

I take it that the Deputy does not wish to misquote the ex-Taoiseach and the future Taoiseach. What he said was:

"During the three years 1948-49, 1949-50 and 1950-51, the total net borrowings of the Central Government and local authorities amounted to £28,000,000, most of it raised at 3 per cent."

Comment on this

He does not include the £40,000,000 borrowed from America.

Comment on this

These are the words he used and they are quite accurate.

Comment on this

If there is to be a comparison made between the borrowings of one Party during their administration and the borrowings of another during theirs—Deputy Dillon is always talking about "busted" flushes—why withhold that card? Why keep that ace in the hole?

Comment on this

In the next sentence, Deputy Costello said:

"During the three years of the present Government, that is, 1951-52 to 1953-54, the total net amount borrowed was around about £65,000,000, the bulk of it raised at 5 per cent."

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here the whole time his ex-Taoiseach was speaking.

Comment on this

I was.

Comment on this

I was here the whole time the future Taoiseach was speaking.

Comment on this

I was here and Deputy Dillon's statement is correct.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello made two statements——

Comment on this

He said that you borrowed £65,000,000 since you came into office and that is correct. If it is not, deny it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know that it is correct? Is he prepared to assert that it is correct?

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe is in possession and he can disprove it, if it is not true.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blowick cannot make a speech at this stage.

Comment on this

What Deputy Briscoe should realise is that we cannot borrow ourselves into prosperity.

Comment on this

That is an old cliché which Deputy Hickey uses at every street-corner.

Comment on this

It is a fact that we cannot borrow ourselves into prosperity.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not even know how to get away from the meaning of it. I, too, could quote a lot of clichés.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy deny that it is so?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Hickey control himself and allow the Deputy in possession to make his speech?

Comment on this

I was saying that Deputy Costello made a comparison between the borrowings of the inter-Party Government, or Coalition, in their three years of office, and the borrowings in the past three years by Fianna Fáil. He said that the borrowings in these three years amounted to £28,000,000.

Comment on this

Net.

Comment on this

What happened the book-keeping transaction of the $128,000,000?

Comment on this

The present Taoiseach described it as an act of unprecedented generosity on the part of the American people.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputies will not allow Deputy Briscoe to speak, I shall have to ask them to leave the House. These interruptions are completely out of order.

Comment on this

He is looking for them.

Comment on this

I take it that Deputy Blowick is amazed by his beginning to realise what is being said and what the facts are. Deputy Costello also referred to the rate of interest which, in the case of their borrowings, was 3 or 3½ per cent.

Comment on this

Three per cent.

Comment on this

We know that the Marshall Aid Loan, if it costs us anything in the rate of interest, taking into account the fall in the value of the £ since, will cost us at the rate of about 6 per cent.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

Put down a question for immediate answer before you go to the country and have the information so that you can check it. Is it not a fact that we borrowed dollars to be repaid in dollars, that we sold these dollars to Britain for sterling and that, notwithstanding the fact that we have to repay in dollars—no great part of them were used when we sold them— the £ was re-valued since then, so that we have to pay back the dollars at a greater cost to us from the point of view of the pounds necessary to provide them and the same applies to the interest. There is your 3 per cent. for you. How can a body of people who consider themselves sufficiently responsible and serious to form themselves into a Government, or to hope again to be a government——

Comment on this

We are going to be.

Comment on this

——forget on a serious occasion like this that they borrowed £40,000,000?

Comment on this

One hundred and twenty-eight million dollars.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello also spoke about the question of secret agreements or no agreements.

Comment on this

How much of the £40,000,000 did you spend?

Comment on this

All the dollars had been spent and had been sold to the Bank of Ireland. The whole transaction was the result of secret negotiations with the late Sir Stafford Cripps.

Comment on this

You spent £24,000,000 of the Marshall Aid money in seven months.

Comment on this

And what did he do with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Deputy Dillon spent it in one afternoon.

Comment on this

It seems to be a fact that if you touch a person on a tender spot, he will squeal and shout loudly.

Comment on this

Is that why the Minister for Finance got up to intervene?

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that Deputy Sweetman has a number of painful spots at the moment, and the shouting will not ease them or alter the result.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows what I think the result is going to be.

Comment on this

We will discuss that privately, you and I.

Comment on this

Couéism.

Comment on this

I am ready.

Comment on this

And so am I. Deputy Costello and certain other Deputies, including Deputy Dillon, were very concerned at question time about agreements between this Government and the British free market, as if one could make a contract with individuals who have the right to buy or not to buy as they wish, and to seek to get goods at whatever price they can get them. These Deputies wanted a contract with such people.

Comment on this

With whom else would you make a contract?

Comment on this

You cannot make a contract between a Government and individual people in any market.

Comment on this

What is happening with regard to pigs?

Comment on this

Will it put Deputy Sweetman in good humour if I tell him that I know absolutely nothing about pigs, human or otherwise?

Comment on this

That is the truest word spoken this day.

Comment on this

There is a contract in existence in regard to the buying of pigs.

Comment on this

There was a contract made a certain number of years ago.

Comment on this

In 1951. It lasts until 1956.

Comment on this

Correct. I suppose there will be some means by which the contracting parties will endeavour to keep the contract. The position now is that there is no contract on beef.

Comment on this

There is a contract on the others.

Comment on this

There is no contract in regard to pigs.

Comment on this

There is an agreement now that the Irish producer or shipper —I do not know exactly who—will get on the English market a price not less by so much than that paid to the British producer.

Comment on this

There is no such agreement as far as I know.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister for Finance a question.

Comment on this

He knows nothing about it.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister for Finance to answer this question.

Comment on this

The Minister is not listening to you. Minister for Finance, Deputy Briscoe is talking to you.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister for Finance whether he could tell the House if any agreement exists between the inter-Party Government and Sir Stafford Cripps on their dollar transaction at the time?

Comment on this

There is a quite definite agreement. As a definite result of the negotiations which took place in 1948, it was agreed that you should borrow that money.

Comment on this

That was not the question the Deputy asked at all.

Comment on this

Was that agreement made known to the Dail?

Comment on this

What contract?

Comment on this

Or any other secret contract such as the contract to sell the dollars.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that.

Comment on this

The dollars the inter-Party Government got were sold by agreement with Sir Stafford Cripps long before they were needed.

Comment on this

The Deputy is as daft as a coot. He is as daft as a halfpenny watch. The Minister for Finance is laughing at him because he knows the Deputy is as daft as a halfpenny watch. I do not blame him.

Comment on this

There are many things on which I would wager.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not indulge in these personal remarks.

Comment on this

I know. Deputy Briscoe does not think I think he is as daft as a halfpenny watch. I am speaking figuratively.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is out of order in speaking at all.

Comment on this

I am not taking offence at all. I should like to make this wager. If Deputy Dillon and I were to go to a psychiatrist I would come out certified sane and he would not.

Comment on this

The lad always thinks that. He always thinks he is the sane man.

Comment on this

There is not a man or woman in Grangegorman who would not say the same thing. That is their greatest grievance.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy come back to the motion now?

Comment on this

I am interested in this Budget statement—very interested.

Comment on this

No one would ever guess that.

Comment on this

This document is not a document which is produced for the purpose of an election because if it were it would be a whole lot better. We could have had a concealed deficit of £6,000,000 or so, so that if we did not come back our successors might have to deal with it, just as we had to do when we came back after the 1951 election. It is a balanced Budget.

Comment on this

That is another way of saying you made a mess of it.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello to-day challenged the statement that the 1951 Budget was a balanced Budget and that there was no deficit in it. He also challenged the accuracy of the statement by spokesman on this side of the House that there was a substantial deficit due to certain causes, one of which Deputy Morrissey must know about. The expected loss to C.I.E. was not included in it.

Comment on this

This is not a subject about which it is wise to talk because it might make the Minister embarrassed.

Comment on this

After reading page 29 of the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has an imagination which I envy. Six weeks after he sat in these benches as Minister for Agriculture, he was taking world-wide credit for the sudden large increase in the production of eggs. In other words, he claimed that our hens were his hens. To-day he tried to take credit for the fact that we had the best agricultural year ever in this country because of his work when Minister for Agriculture three years ago. He has it both ways. If we leave him a sufficiency of hens to lay an increased number of eggs, they are his eggs.

Comment on this

The Deputy is going to leave us a lot of dirty eggs.

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy who interrupts in a loud voice to say what he means clearly.

Comment on this

He did not slaughter the calves, anyhow.

Comment on this

I will come to that. I am not afraid to deal with that. An attempt is being made on the eve of the election to convert this Budget debate into an election platform.

Comment on this

Oh, dear!

Comment on this

"Oh, dear," says Deputy Morrissey. Deputy Morrissey knows that better than anybody.

Comment on this

Of course it is.

Comment on this

Why was the election put back for the Budget?

Comment on this

The election was put back for very good and sufficient reasons, and I am glad.

Comment on this

Because the back benchers kicked.

Comment on this

I was one who thought we should have the election immediately. The Deputy knows that. I was very sorry it was being postponed, but I must publicly confess that I was wrong and that the Taoiseach, in his decision to put it back, was right.

Comment on this

We all thought the Taoiseach wanted it at once.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggested the Taoiseach made up his mind to do one thing and that the back benchers forced him to do another.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Now he is suggesting the reverse.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that the Taoiseach wanted an immediate election and that the back benchers wanted it deferred.

Comment on this

That is the way it is done in the Coalition.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Briscoe should be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

An appeal is being made to a lot of young people to-day, who may be voting for the first time or for the second or third time, to have regard to what is called the cruel Budget of 1952 which scourged and whipped them and took all the joy of living out of life. I am pleased to say that I met quite a number of young people in recent weeks who recognised that it is not so long since a generation of Irish men and women were prepared to make any sacrifice in order that this country might be saved. They did not weigh the price of a loaf of bread against the sufferings they might endure in making their contribution whether it was big or small. Let us now come to the interjection by the Deputy from Wexford in regard to the slaughter of calves.

Comment on this

Connolly died for the workers of Ireland.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I will come to that also. We will deal with the calves first. We had a serious situation in this country, too, after the start of the economic war. The farmers were the hardest hit, but when they were appealed to for their verdict as to whether we should go on or the country give in, they returned this Party stronger in numbers than ever in order to fight that fight to a finish. They were prepared willingly and gladly to sacrifice their calves rather than give away the freedom of this country.

Comment on this

You gave them free beef and they did not want it.

Comment on this

The young people realise that that generation had to make sacrifices to secure freedom in this country. Having achieved that freedom in some part of the country anyway, it is the duty of those of us who belong to the generation that struggled in that period to lay secure foundations on which future arms might be built. We do not pretend we can build the Ireland we want to see in our lifetime or in the lifetime of one Dáil. We recognise we have a responsibility and the young people, in making the little sacrifices they are asked to make by paying perhaps a little bit higher than what the Opposition gentlemen tell them they should pay, are doing it gladly and willingly. They are helping to lay the foundations of a free Ireland.

Comment on this

They are emigrating out of the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Leary interrupts time and time again.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not unemployed. He is all right.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must restrain himself.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary understands the position better than Deputy Briscoe because he represents the workers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Leary must understand that Deputy Briscoe must be allowed to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this

May I say this? I am very proud of the fact that I represent a constituency in which I am accepted by the working class as a good representative of the working man.

Comment on this

I doubt it.

Comment on this

There is no Labour representative in my constituency in the Corporation or in the Dáil.

Comment on this

It is a poor thing that Dublin can get no one but a man like him, not a Dublinman but a foreigner, to represent them.

Comment on this

I represent the workers.

Comment on this