We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 471–705 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I cannot listen to you because you know nothing about the workers. You do not come from where the workers are. You are living in luxury.

Comment on this

I will go down to Wexford to see you.

Comment on this

I will not say what the Deputy is.

Comment on this

It takes all kinds of people to make a nation and I suppose it takes all kinds of people to make even a Dáil, but I am sure that what is on one man's tongue is not shared by many. Deputy Corish spoke about the number of persons signing on the labour exchanges. At first he spoke about them as being unemployed people and unable to find work. He then altered that saying that they might not be able to find the kind of work they wanted. I must say I have had a bit of an eye-opener and I think there must be some change made soon in the method by which what are called unemployed people are registered in these registration offices. Recently we set up a special works committee in Dublin and we wanted to find out the incidence of unemployment in Dublin and the extent to which we could make a contribution to bringing about some relief. To our amazement we found that of the approximately 18,000 signing on the labour exchanges half of them were females and of these half were juveniles; the rest were adults, some of them married women who had to leave employment for a certain period and who went on the register. However, we were concerned with the male side and we found there were three categories signing amongst the male persons. There were boys; there were able-bodied men, and there were old, chronically ill people who could not possibly be employed on the type of work we required men for. We found that the maximum number of men suitable for the type of work we were undertaking did not exceed 4,000. In fact we believe it was somewhere around the neighbourhood of 3,500.

I began to consider this problem very seriously. It was quite obvious that ordinary house building, ordinary work such as a local authority could do could not bring full relief to the number of people signing. I suggest to the Minister for Social Welfare that he ought to take off the register all those old people, those unfit for work and unable to work, some of them rheumatics going to the labour exchanges on sticks, and put them on another register altogether—call it a register for sick people or something of that kind or for persons not suitable for employment.

Comment on this

Retired on pensions.

Comment on this

That is the proper thing to do. Give them retiring pensions.

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows there are a number of people who are unfit for work and certainly would not be employed. What is the sense in having these people signing up with no further attention being paid to them? I suggested privately and I say it publicly, that it would be far more charitable to everybody concerned and to ourselves to create some form of new register, even if it meant giving these people a slightly increased benefit more than what they are receiving now as unemployed people on assistance.

Then we come to another aspect of it. There are many young people in this city getting employment as messenger boys mainly at 14 years of age when they leave school. When they are 16 and the employer becomes liable to make a contribution to fulfil stamp requirements, he sacks them. Those boys then go and sign on at the exchange with no other knowledge and no other occupation in view than that of being a bicycle messenger boy. I have suggested again to the Minister for Social Welfare that it might be possible to give these young boys some slightly increased benefit in money on the condition that they would attend classes in vocational schools and be taught some form of semi-skilled work, instead of hanging around looking for occupations they cannot get, because as 16-year-old or 17-year-old youth's they certainly will not be considered for the work we want done in the building of houses.

Publicising and shouting that 70,000 people are unemployed is of no avail. Those who shout it either do not know the meaning of the figures or they have not taken the trouble to examine them in their own areas. I know that everybody wants to see people who are willing to work in employment, but there is no use in our attempting to deal with the figure of 70,000 when that number is not there at all. I say here and I say it before Deputy Larkin, who should be the best qualified person in this House to correct or contradict me, that the maximum number of men we can employ on what you call unskilled work will not exceed 4,000.

Comment on this

This is not a new situation. Everybody knows it. Deal with the 20,000 increase.

Comment on this

Deputy Alfred Byrne, apparently, does not know it because he gets up time and again and refers to these 18,000 people as 18,000 heads of families.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Did he do it on this motion? If not, it cannot be discussed now.

Comment on this

It was referred to by Deputy Corish and I promised him I would give him a little analysis of this problem as I understood it.

Comment on this

Why was something not done about it long before now?

Comment on this

Nothing has been done about it before in this House, not even in the three years of the Administration of the Deputy when he was going to abolish unemployment in 24 hours.

Comment on this

I reduced it to the lowest figure ever in this country.

Comment on this

Are we to take it now that if unemployment is, if you like, a sin against any Government of this country, the sin is going to be measured as to whether it affects 50,000 or 70,000 people? Are not the 50,000 just as badly off as the additional 20,000 would be, making it 70,000? What does the Deputy think he will get credit for there? The story of the big baby and the little baby—that is what it amounts to.

Comment on this

For what purpose is the Deputy trying to change the rules at this hour of the day?

Comment on this

I am not trying to change any rules.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to say that there are 4,000 unemployed instead of 74,000.

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite are going around screaming things they know to be untrue. There is no such thing as 70,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

There are 74,000. That is the official figure.

Comment on this

The Deputy admits my analysis of the Dublin figure, which reduces it to 4,000 males.

Comment on this

4,000 able-bodied males.

Comment on this

I do not admit the Deputy's analysis. Tell us about the 20,000 increase. That is the point.

Comment on this

I have listened very carefully to everything that has been said. I will go back again to Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

There are 66,000 males unemployed.

Comment on this

Are they grown-up males?

Comment on this

That is the figure in the industrial analysis of the live register as published the day before yesterday.

Comment on this

Then there must be 250,000 unemployed if that figure is correct. Let the Deputy first of all analyse it and, when he has got it clear, he can make a statement. Deputy Costello drew attention to the fact that the 1951 Budget——

Comment on this

66,000 males and 10,000 females; 76,278 persons of whom 66,049 are males and 10,129 females.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe is in possession. Deputy Briscoe on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

The last Budget to which Deputy Costello referred was 1951-52 and it amounted to £90,000,000. He drew attention to the rapid increase as between that Budget requirement and the present one. It rose in the next year to £93,000,000, then to £111,000,000, then to £108,000,000. But the Deputy did not go back to 1948 when the last Budget was £58,000,000. That was the time the inter-Party groups—singly, because they were not collective then prior to the election; and I exclude the Labour Party from this—were going to reduce taxation by £10,000,000; but in the very next year it went up to £64,000,000; in the year after that to £73,000,000, then to £75,000,000 and then to £90,000,000. Those were the people who were going to reduce taxation by £10,000,000 from £58,000,000.

Comment on this

What has this debate to do with taxation?

Comment on this

We are talking about the Budget.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about expenditure, audited net expenditure. He thinks he is talking about taxation, which he is not. We reduced taxation by £6,000,000 the first year we were in office, and we took 6d. off income-tax the year after.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I will come to taxation and to the hurt feelings of Deputy Costello about the suggestion that their Budget——

Comment on this

On a point of order. When a Deputy purports to quote an official document and describes it as a record of taxation, when the document is headed, "Audited Expenditure", is it not germane to intervene to say the Deputy is making a slight mistake?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I did not make any reference to any document.

Comment on this

The Deputy had the document in his hand and he shook it at us.

Comment on this

I did not make any reference to it. I had the document and I gave round figures from it.

Comment on this

Duncan's Ghost shook his hoary locks at Macbeth.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Shakespeare is not relevant to this Budget debate.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon says this is a statement showing net audited expenditure on public services. Would the Deputy look at the last column? Estimated expenditure for 1954-1955: how did that become audited? The Deputy did not see that. Look at him now. Surprised! I can be just as smart as the Deputy.

Comment on this

That is not under the heading of audited.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated I was reading from a document showing the net audited expenditure.

Comment on this

Yes, but the last two columns are not under the heading of audited.

Comment on this

I did not subdivide it.

Comment on this

No, but the auditor did.

Comment on this

If the Deputy goes further he will find that 1953-54 is also not under the heading of audited.

Comment on this

Because it is supplementary and, therefore, excluded.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The format of this document is not in question.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has carried away with him some memories of the time when he was chairman of the Committee on Public Accounts, but he has lost a lot of his alertness.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us get on now with the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I was referring to Deputy Costello having indicated to the House that every year since Fianna Fáil came into office, following on the exit of the Coalition Government, national expenditure has gone up.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

And I am entitled, I think, to make the fair comparison that, notwithstanding the fact that Deputy Costello and his colleagues came in here on a promise that they would reduce taxation by £10,000,000——

Comment on this

Which they did.

Comment on this

——they, in fact, doubled it.

Comment on this

No. We reduced taxation.

Comment on this

I wonder who briefed Deputy Costello to-day. I wonder if it was his prospective colleague standing with him in his own constituency, who is supposed to be an expert on economics?

Comment on this

Who is briefing the Deputy?

Comment on this

I am not briefed by anybody.

Comment on this

The Deputy ought to confine his remarks to people who are in the House.

Comment on this

When a person becomes a candidate in an election he is just as public as anybody else.

Comment on this

Fair enough. He will soon be here to answer the Deputy anyway.

Comment on this

We must be prepared. He has already started his campaign and, in fact, has discussed matters publicly with me. Deputy Costello said, and whether he misunderstood his brief or was a bit tired, I do not know, that all the expenditure in this Budget requirement was coming out of revenue and taxation. I interrupted to ask what about capital borrowings. It is unfair to say that all this money is coming out of taxation. We admit we borrow a great deal for capital purposes; borrowing represents something like £36,000,000 of the expenditure envisaged in this Budget. Has not that been clearly stated? Must I read the particular page for those who burnt the midnight oil studying the Budget but failed to find the proper meaning of certain parts of it?

This Budget brings relief, and I am sure everyone is pleased that it does so, to those who were never intended to belong to the class of income-tax payers, namely, the ordinary working man or the white collar worker on the lower salary scales. The figure of 40,000 has been disputed by Deputy MacBride. He thinks the Minister put that in as a guess. How an ex-Minister could believe that the Revenue Commissioners and the officials of the Department of Finance would permit a Minister to put in a figure which was not correct passes my comprehension. I am glad to see that relief for 40,000 people. I hope that number will be increased. I know it will benefit certain people who were recently making representations to their trade unions because living-in conditions were reckoned a part of their income for income-tax purposes. From the figures which I have seen, this will go a long way to bring some relief there.

Deputy Costello also referred to the saving of £800,000 in expenditure on equipment for the Army. He apparently did not read the Budget statement properly. It shows clearly that, because of the fact that for two years prior to the return of Fianna Fáil, practically nothing was spent in the way of equipping the Army with the materials to make it efficient and reliable, money had to be spent on it. The money was spent and the position has now been retrieved, just as it has been in the case of C.I.E. In the case of the latter, the position has been substantially retrieved and Government expenditure is now drawing to a close. The same is true of the Army, and therefore it is right to create the saving which is represented by the figure that has been mentioned.

Deputy Costello also talked of austerity. I do not know what he calls an austerity Budget, or where austerity ceases. If you are going to make everything cheap you have to start somewhere and go down the line until even the very lowest figure can also be reduced. In view of the fact that consumer goods have to be purchased out of the earnings of the people, there is always a form of austerity, whether it be severe or otherwise. I conscientiously believe, and I am quite satisfied, that once the people understand why it is necessary to have even what appears to be austerity, so long as it is in the best interests of the country generally, it will not be mistaken by them and will be borne by them with goodwill.

The Deputies opposite hope, when they go out, to be able to appeal to what one may call the lower instincts of the people, and are going to make the election, as Deputy Corish said, a bread-and-butter election. I believe that the people, once they understand things, will be quite content to decide for themselves. They will decide as people with a pride in themselves and in their country, and are not going to decide on the basis of the suggestions made here.

Deputy Corish said that we had no right to impose severe conditions on the present generation when concerned with the question of planning ahead; in other words, that it was not right to make this generation bear burdens which were going to bring benefits to posterity. I do not think we would agree with that approach. If one may put it so, it is quite human for parents, for example, to bear burdens so that their children will have at least as good a life as they have had themselves, if not better. It is quite human for them to provide for the training and education of their children. The same is also true of the nation. We just cannot sit here and consider what we can do for ourselves from day to day without having any regard whatever for to-morrow or the generation that is to follow us. We have got to plan ahead. All that is part of our allegiance to the country. We want to make it by whatever means we can, a country in which future generations of Irish people can live happily, and one that will be a proud inheritance from those who went before them. Are we to dissipate every possible means at our disposal by not planning for the future just for the sake of our own immediate welfare? I do not subscribe to that. I would be quite willing to be rejected if I felt that was the opinion of the public, "Live for to-day for to-morrow we die."

There has been talk about prices dropping. There was a kind of groan rather than a cheer when the Minister, in his Budget statement, referred to the fact that there was now a drop, even if only a small one of one point, in the cost of living.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that in his Budget statement.

Comment on this

What did he say?

Comment on this

Read the statement and you will see. He said that last year was one of the most prosperous in the nation's history.

Comment on this

The cost of living fell and prices generally were being smoothed out.

Comment on this

The cost of high living fell.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by high living?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not so innocent as he looks.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means by high living. I have heard of people living low lives.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy supposed to finish at 9 o'clock?

Comment on this

I was not given any indication as to when I was to finish. If the Deputy is anxious to get in, perhaps he would listen to me without interrupting. He would then get in all the sooner. When the Minister referred to the fact that there had been a drop of 1 per cent. there were what I would call groans and not cheers. But, at any rate, we will be able to say that there is a beginning in the fall in the cost of living. We have now reached the stage where the peak in the cost of living has been reached, and it is on the way down, through Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that two years ago.

Comment on this

We have turned the corners and have crossed the hills.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey was a member of the Labour Party when ex-President Cosgrave used to say that prosperity was around the corner.

Comment on this

It was a lot nearer to it then than it ever was under this Government.

Comment on this

I come now to the beer reduction. I saw in the paper this evening a statement made by the secretary of one section of the Licensed Vintners' Association, and another statement by the chairman of another group of licensed vintners. I take it that Deputy Morrissey will agree that, if a candidate at the forthcoming election makes a criticism of the Budget, it can be referred to, particularly when it appears in the Evening Herald.

Comment on this

You do not want my permission to refer to your friends.

Comment on this

They are your friends. I have some amongst them, too. This is the report of a special general meeting of the Dublin (City and County) Section of the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association. This meeting was held at the Gresham Hotel to consider the Budget. Mr. J. Hedigan, chairman, presided. The report goes on to say:—

"A statement issued afterwards by Mr. C.E. Reddin, secretary, said that the meeting recorded its emphatic protest against the failure of the Minister to remove the penal duties of 6d. per glass on spirits and 3d. per pint on beer imposed in the Budget of April, 1952, and called on the Government to take steps to do so now."

That is a peremptory statement I must admit:—

"The Minister in his Budget reduced the beer duty by 8/6 per standard barrel. This amounts to 6/- on a barrel of stout as sold to the trade and 5/- per barrel of porter. `It is equivalent to an average of ¼d. per pint on both commodities.'

The Minister stated that the cost of this concession would be £350,000. Divided between the 13,000 licensed establishments in this country the reduction works out at an average of £27 per year for each establishment."

I would like just to stop there. Does anybody believe that that thing is true?

Comment on this

No, it is 5,000 in one case.

Comment on this

That is quite right, it is 5,000 in one case. The Minister has so arranged it—according to this—that publicans are going to get £27 per skull remission. That is nonsense. Some publicans will sell a lot more than others and, consequently, they will have a bigger benefit.

Comment on this

Some dance hall proprietors got a lot more than others also.

Comment on this

I have a note about the dance halls also.

Comment on this

I just wanted to remind you.

Comment on this

I notice the face of the Minister for Finance is getting long.

Comment on this

I noticed no great screaming on the other side of the House because the Minister has, on this occasion, given the public-house owners a concession such as there was in the case of the dance-halls. The Deputies over there are not upset on this occasion.

Comment on this

The Minister himself said it was for the consumers.

Comment on this

I know that for a number of years past since the imposition of these increased duties a certain number of licensed premises were, through their owners, hot-beds of propaganda against Fianna Fáil. The line taken was that this Government was robbing the poor man of the pint, that the Minister was putting his hand in the pockets of the poor workingman whose only luxury was the pint. It now emerges that these same gentlemen who were crying to the public to beat Fianna Fáil—for their own sakes, mark you—had themselves approached the Prices Advisory Body to get permission to increase the price of the beer that they were complaining to their customers about as being too dear. The Minister has now come down on the side of the consumers and has said: "I think the beer is high enough and I would like you to withdraw your application to have the beer go up one penny a glass or a pint, and I will see if I can find some way to meet you." But the only concern of these gentlemen was not that the consumers got the beer any cheaper, but that they themselves got a better margin of profit on the sale of beer. Their grouse now is that it is not enough—not that they want to pass it on. As a matter of fact, I have been asked to ask the Minister to assure the House—and somebody else stated it here to-day—that when the Minister refers to "the brewers may pass this on" that it will be incumbent on the brewers to pass that on to the traders.

Comment on this

Has he answered the question yet?

Comment on this

I am asking it now and I trust he will answer it when he is replying.

People never seem to understand simple language and simple suggestions. I read the Budget speech—or rather I listened to the Minister making the speech because I had not the benefit of reading the speech as it was being delivered and I was not able to look even a few pages ahead so that I would be in a position to make my mind up quickly about something when it came up—but I understood, and I would like to be corrected if I am wrong, that the intention behind this reduction is to prevent the traders approaching the Prices Advisory Body for an increase in beer prices to the consumer and that this concession is intended to meet them.

Comment on this

How is it going to be passed on?

Comment on this

It is not going to be passed on to the consumer.

Comment on this

Oh, I see.

Comment on this

It is going into the pockets of the publican and they want to be sure that it is not going to go into the pockets of the brewers.

Comment on this

Now I suggest the Fianna Fáil Party should stand up and cheer.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a difficult situation for the Minister much more difficult.

Comment on this

"The Minister sought to attach two conditions to the concession——"—this is what Mr. Reddin says:—"The first was that the trade should not proceed with its application for an increase in retail prices made by the association to the Prices Advisory Body in December last and which was withdrawn pending the Budget, when it was expected that a substantial reduction of duty on beer and spirits would remove any necessity for the trade to increase prices on the public still further." There is nothing about a reduction for the public: it is a case of, "We want it". These are the people who were supporting the inter-Party Government. These are the gentlemen who were abusing Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

All of them?

Comment on this

No, not all. There are a great many in that organisation who are backing away and who now support us and are not a party to this.

Comment on this

Now, you are letting it out.

Comment on this

They will stop their propaganda.

Comment on this

If you look at your colleagues' faces you will see how you are doing. You are doing well.

Comment on this

"The second condition was implied in a reply made to Deputy Costello by the Minister in the Dáil last night, namely, that the trade should share the ¼d. with the public." I do not think that was stated.

Comment on this

It was not stated.

Comment on this

It was, and it was reported in the papers to-day.

Comment on this

It was not so stated.

Comment on this

The Minister for Health, Dr. Ryan, referred to certain reports in the papers already in the terms which they deserve. I understand the Minister never said anything of the kind.

Comment on this

Has the record been corrected?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not accept the word of the Minister now?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

We have reached a strange stage of order in this House. There was a time when the Chair used to rule that the word of a Minister should be taken by the House.

Comment on this

With your permission, a Cheann Comhairle, I would like to be allowed to intervene in order to clarify Deputy Morrissey's mind on what I was supposed to have said in reply to Deputy Costello. I said nothing of the sort, but Deputy Costello, like the skilled lawyer that he is, tried to put words into my mouth. Deputy Byrne, following on the same line, tried to put the same words into my mouth. I pointed out that I was not managing or running the licensed trade and that the trade was getting this remission and were at liberty to do what they wished with it, but that I did hope they would be fair to the consumer.

Comment on this

Did you not say it was intended for the retailer and the consumer?

Comment on this

I said I hoped they would be fair to the consumer.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to correct Deputy Briscoe's reference to the Chair. The attitude of the Chair has not altered in respect of the veracity of any Deputy making a statement in this House. The veracity of every Deputy is accepted. That is the basis of all the discussion.

Comment on this

I am not accepting the Minister's amendment of what he said last night.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe has now been speaking for more than an hour. Deputy Aiken had an hour, and is it fair that Deputy Briscoe should take an hour and a quarter when the debate finishes at 5 o'clock to-morrow evening?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not proposed to limit Deputies' statements.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello, when he led off, said he had nothing to say on this Budget, that he was going to be very brief and going to deal with only two or three specific items and was rather contemptuous of the whole thing. But as minute followed minute he waxed eloquent and spoke for a considerable period of time.

Comment on this

About half the time you were speaking.

Comment on this

At least, the courtesy of the House was extended to him and he was not interrupted as much as I have been.

Comment on this

We have been very helpful to you.

Comment on this

This reduction in the beer duty is made for the purpose of meeting the request of the licensed traders in order that the public will be protected against their requesting an increase in the price of beer to meet their increased costs. It is a concession similar to what has been done in connection with matches. There are rising costs, possibly because of increased wages or the increased cost of materials and there is this body which Deputy Morrissey has some recollections of anyway.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Briscoe on at least three occasions has tried to suggest that I have some association with the licensed traders' organisation. I wish I had some association or some contact with that organisation, but I have not. I have very great respect for them though.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey is suddenly developing a very thin skin. He knows quite well that I had passed on from our friends, his and mine, the publicans, and I was talking about matches. When I talked about a body that he had some responsibility for I meant the Prices Advisory Body that he and his colleagues set up in order to put the profiteers behind the bars in Mountjoy for overcharging. No one could increase prices without showing just cause. Then he gets up and calls me a publican or something like that.

Comment on this

There was a much earlier reference to publicans and somebody else. The Deputy should tread very lightly when talking about publicans.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this

He does not know what I am referring to.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about it. I have never been put out of a pub.

Comment on this

Were you ever caught after hours?

Comment on this

Perhaps if the Deputy were put out of a pub he might know a little bit more about life.

Comment on this

I do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Briscoe deal with the Financial Resolution?

Comment on this

Deputy Corish stated quite frankly that their Party, in whatever numbers they came back, would be concerned with reducing the cost of living. I asked Deputy Corish had he any idea as to how this could be done or in what way it was to be done. Deputy Corish reminded me of certain questions which had been put to the Tánaiste and to the Minister for Social Welfare when in opposition and the answer which they then gave, which was, if you like, "no information". But the fact is that the cost of living from the Government point of view can only be reduced when the Government are prepared to subsidise a number of commodities. If you are to reduce the cost of living and you have to employ the subsidy method, then the money has to be secured from somebody and somebody has to pay taxes for it.

The statement made by Fine Gael that they can reduce the cost of living and also reduce taxation is beyond the comprehension of anybody. It is true that a certain spokesman of Fine Gael in answer to a challenge by me said that if the price of beer and whiskey were brought sufficiently low the consumption would be so increased that there would be a means of reducing taxation even if portion of the income from the duties was used for subsidies. My answer to that is that I would hate to think that the future prosperity of this country was to be based upon the policy that the more the people drink the better off they will be.

Comment on this

It is a good tourist attraction.

Comment on this

It may be, but I am not prepared to subscribe to the policy that for the sake of reduced taxation and a lower cost of living the price of drink should be made so cheap that we would develop a drink-sodden race of people. We now come to the references made to social security.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy been put up to block out debate on the Budget?

Comment on this

Of course he has.

Comment on this

That is a fair question.

Comment on this

I have not been put up to block anything.

Comment on this

I will take the Deputy's word.

Comment on this

I give you my word. I made a number of notes while others were speaking, 28 pages altogether.

Comment on this

Tell us what page you are at.

Comment on this

I am at page 15.

Comment on this

Then I will have time for a cup of tea.

Comment on this

Pages 16, 17, 18 and 19 were dealt with by me in relation to Deputy MacBride.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

You are at the last page then?

Comment on this

The second last. I think this is a good Budget, and from what I have heard from people I have met I think it has been very well received by most of our people. If an attempt had been made to deceive the people by a Budget that was not honest that deception would be found out before May 18th and we would have to pay the price for it. The people to-day are a great deal more educated in regard to municipal and State matters, and they are able to make up their minds as to what is best for themselves and for the country as a whole.

I am glad to see that in this Budget adequate provision is made to enable the City of Dublin to complete as rapidly as possible its housing programme. I am glad to see that provision is made to meet the increased demand for money by persons building houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. I am glad to see that the so-called myth of the National Development Fund is there in all its glory. As we know, it is operating in our area to the great satisfaction of these people, and bringing relief to numbers of people, and I am glad that provision has been made so that this will be continued for some considerable time. I am glad to see that provision has been made for extended health services for our people and for improved social welfare conditions. I shall be quite happy to go amongst my constituents without fear and tell them that I stand for a Party that is doing its best for everybody in this community and, particularly, for those who are least able to look after themselves, namely, the masses of our working people.

Comment on this

I believe that the Fianna Fáil Party recoiled from debate in this House on their financial record and the proposals they now make in this Budget.

I accept Deputy Briscoe's assurance that he was not consciously employed to prevent that debate, but I assure him that he was invited to intervene for no other purpose than to frustrate debate; and I invite him to read the report in the Official Report of this House of what he himself has said over the last hour and a half, and I defy him to read it through, because there was neither head nor tail to it, end or beginning.

Comment on this

Not even the interruptions?

Comment on this

No. I want to say at once that if this Budget statement is a true record of the financial condition of this country then we all might as well make up our minds to it at once, we are in a bad way. I want to ask the House to inquire what has happened to put us in a bad way. Three short years ago it was pretty generally believed, not only by our own people but by foreign observers who came here to see, that Ireland and her people were better off and had a better prospect than they had had for generations past. The wind did not cease to blow since 1951, nor the rivers cease to run, nor the grass cease to grow in Ireland. What has happened that has reduced us to the condition set out in this Budget statement? Consider what that condition is. We are invited to welcome tax remissions for the benefit of income-tax payers, publicans and match manufacturers, and the further subsidisation of bread, out of a fund consisting of £1,000,000 to be levied from the profits of C.I.E., other specific reductions of £950,000, general overestimation and savings, £4,000,000, a reduction in Army equipment of £800,000; and I ask the House was there ever a shakier foundation on which to found a Budget surplus of £30,000 than the £7,400,000 revenue that I have read out.

Let us begin with the £1,000,000 from C.I.E. C.I.E. are to contribute £1,000,000 to the Exchequer this year. C.I.E. was down in County Cork last week, eight members of its management committee, explaining to the people of a country town in Cork that, as there was a saving available to C.I.E. of £8,000 a year by closing down a branch line, which would involve every farmer who sold a beast in that town in the loss of 25/- a head, they could not keep the branch line open for another month. Their resources would not permit them to do so; but they are going to provide £1,000,000 for the relief of the Exchequer. How are these two tales to be reconciled to the taxpayers of this country? A rural community in Cork is to contribute 25/- a head on every beast they sell because C.I.E. cannot find £8,000 to operate the branch line, but the Minister for Finance says that his Budget surplus of £30,000 is founded on the confident expectation that out of their surplus profit this year they will provide him with £1,000,000. What is the meaning? We all know that is cod, but, mind you, there is a sinister element in the cod. Do not forget the record of this Government. Do not forget the havoc which Deputy MacEntee, Minister for Finance, deliberately wrought upon our people in order to discredit his predecessors. Do not forget that the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, and the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, were warned in this House again and again and again that the policy of the 1952 Budget meant throwing thousands into unemployment. They denied it, but the event proved that they were wrong, and they now admit that by providing relief works to draw back into employment those whom they cast into unemployment. They cannot bring back the emigrants. They are gone. Either that Government were not fit for their job if they did not understand that of which we warned them, or they did it with malice aforethought; and I say that that is the way they did it. They were not primarily concerned to throw men out of employment; but they were primarily concerned to denigrate those of us who had gone before them and they wanted to prove that the Ministers of the inter-Party Government were irresponsible and profligate, and for that base purpose they wrought great evil on our people.

Remember it is the same principle that actuates their allegation that this year's Budget can be balanced on a contribution of £1,000,000 from C.I.E., which says with the approval of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that they cannot find £8,000 to keep a branch line open in County Cork, because when that £1,000,000 does not inure to our administration when we take over from Fianna Fáil after the general election, the failure of C.I.E. to produce that money will be charged against them as a failure in the discharge of their duty in the management of C.I.E. Now listen. Surely the time for wreaking havoc on this country in order to vent private spites ought to be over. Surely if the picture contained in this Budget speech be true I have a right to ask the Minister for Finance how often does Fianna Fáil claim the right to take over this country, wreck it, and hand it back to somebody else to build up again? I say that this is the third time that Fianna Fáil has taken over this country, wrecked it, and is now about to hand it over to somebody else to try to get them to build it up again. There is no country on the face of God's earth which can stand a repetition of that performance.

I want to say that if I believed in the literal truth of the picture here portrayed I would have the gloomiest anticipation of the future of this country and all of us living in it. But I am encouraged to believe that when we take over the Government of this country much more will be possible than now appears possible under the dispensation of Fianna Fáil; and I am encouraged in that belief by my recollection of what the present Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce had to say in Letterkenny on September 14th, 1947. The Minister said on September 14th, 1947:—

"We are now entering four years of most acute difficulty in which economic disaster will threaten on every side."

Now that was his vision of the years from 1947 to 1951. We then took over the Government. Let us read the record of the economic disaster which he foresaw threatened on every side. Exports in 1947 were £39,000,000; in 1948, £49,000,000; in 1949, £60,000,000; in 1950, £62,000,000; in 1951, £81,000,000; in 1952, £101,000,000 and in 1953, £105,000,000. Who was right and who was wrong? We reduced taxation in that first year by £6,000,000. We took off the taxation that Deputy Aiken, the then Minister for Finance, imposed in the autumn of 1947, taxes designed to draw £6,000,000 into the Exchequer. In addition to that we reduced the rate of income-tax by 6d. in the £ and we increased the allowances for a variety of categories of persons under the income-tax code. Yet we had it to tell that while in 1947 the total outlay on education in this country was £6,000,000, in 1951, after we had reduced taxation and after we had surmounted the economic disasters which Deputy Lemass foresaw as surrounding us on every side, we found £9,000,000 per annum for education. In 1947 the charge for old age pensions was £3,700,000. After we had reduced taxation, the charge in 1951 and in the years thereafter was £7,021,000. The charge which fell on the Exchequer in 1947 for widows' and orphans' pensions was £798,000. After we had reduced taxation and surmounted this disastrous period, the charge in 1951 was £1,756,000. In 1946, the payment of State grants for housing amounted to £609,000 for the whole country; in 1947 it was £812,000; in 1948, £1,184,000; in 1949, £1,976,000; in 1950, £3,817,000; and in 1951, the last year of our administration, it was £5,806,000.

The gross agricultural output of this country rose from £111,000,000 in 1947 to £156,000,000 in 1952. Now remember this was the out-turn of four years which Deputy Lemass, the Tánaiste, had warned us in Letterkenny were going to be years of the most acute difficulty in which economic disaster would threaten on every side. The national income in 1947 was £300,000,000; in 1951 it was £373,000,000 and in 1952, £404,000,000. When we took office we found a situation in which there were fewer live stock on the land of Ireland than at any recorded time before in the 20th century, but during these four years we exported 405,000 cattle in 1948, 523,000 cattle in 1949, 591,000 cattle in 1950, 642,000 cattle in 1951 and 739,000 cattle in 1952. In the year, for which disaster was prophesied there were 3,900,000 cattle on the land. We increased our exports of cattle in every year and yet at the end of these four years, four years of presaged disaster, there were 4,037,000 cattle left on the land. Deputies may ask how did it come to pass. Because by our exertions, with the collaboration of the farmers, in three short years we had reduced the annual slaughter of calves which had taken place every year during the 16 years of Fianna Fáil administration from 80,000 calves a year to 8,000. The cattle that did not die constituted the wealth which went to build up these exports and contribute to the national income.

I quote these figures, not only to challenge Deputies in this House but to provide myself with the reassurance that the job that lies ahead is possible. I conceive that Fianna Fáil in the last three years has done immense damage. I recoil from the prospect of sharing in the task of trying to repair it but I plead the events of these four years, the subject of Deputy Lemass's prophecy, as a justification for hoping that we may yet succeed.

I ask some Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches to answer this question before the debate ends. After all the suffering that has been imposed—and no one will challenge that there has been a good deal since 1951—who is better off? What section of our community is better off to-day than it was in 1951? I think I am entitled to an answer. Is it not a striking thing that Fianna Fáil has the effrontery to allege against their predecessors that they burdened the people with taxes and that they prejudiced the integrity of the State by profligate finance, when the record is that the average amount collected for central taxation and by local authorities was about £82,000,000 in each of the three years, 1949-50, 1950-51 and 1951-52, and that that average figure has risen from £82,000,000 to £102,000,000 for the three years 1951-52 to 1953-54, and is still going up? Fianna Fáil would have us believe that the inter-Party Government was profligate in expenditure which led to to-day's standards. Let us define what is fundamental. There are two fundamentals in public finance. One is that annual recurring expenditure must be met out of annual recurring revenue; and the second and equally important canon of public finance is that it is not the amount which the State borrows that really matters, what matters is the purposes on which borrowed money is spent.

I challenge Fianna Fáil to mark down one single purpose for which we borrowed money to spend, which has not justified itself a thousand times. I invite Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party now to go out and look at the projects on which a great deal of the so-called National Development Fund is being spent at the present moment, under the over-all orders to county surveyors to take down everything and spend money on everything but to spend it before the general election. Look at the footpaths wandering out into the countryside; look at the corners being excavated on the main roads of this country; contemplate the picture of the autobahn to Bray. Then I ask Fianna Fáil to ask themselves this question: "By that canon of finance, on what is the borrowed money being spent?" Their record is disreputable and they know it. The humiliation is that these relief works have been called into being to provide the livelihood for men who had permanent work three years ago and who are now chronically on the dole.

I do not know what reckonings Deputy Briscoe is able to make that half the people attending at the employment offices are cripples. I understood that people disabled by chronic ill health were entitled to get benefits under the Social Welfare Act as chronically sick people. I did not understand that anyone who was chronically sick was eligible for registration at the employment exchange. I understood he was entitled to receive benefit under what used to be called national health insurance.

Comment on this

Outdoor relief.

Comment on this

Is not a person chronically ill able to get benefit if his stamps are correct?

Comment on this

Not if he is over 70.

Comment on this

But is he entitled to be registered at the exchange if he is over 70?

Comment on this

He gets the old age pension.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe paints the picture that half the entire roll at the labour exchange in Dublin consists of old and crippled men who are not fit for work.

Comment on this

If you are past 60——

Comment on this

The Deputy and myself are nearly 60 now and we are well able to work. Or are we already ordered to the scrap-heap? A doctrine seems to be growing up around us now of a kind I never heard of before. I do not want to see any man who is sick or ill forced to labour, but it is an entirely new method to me for expunging the problem of unemployment, to say that those who are old and sick are all unfit for work. Maybe some of them are. I do not believe it is true that the bulk of the people registering at the labour exchanges ought not to be registered.

I want to warn this Dáil and the country of a very grave development of which we heard only to-day under the pressure of strong interrogation. Did any Deputy in this House know before to-day that the Trade Agreement of 1948, in so far as it applied to cattle and sheep, has been abrogated and that we have no agreement now? I did not know it. The Trade Agreement of 1948 with Great Britain in respect of cattle and sheep has been abrogated and we have no agreement now. We are simply in the position that we trade on the British market as best we can. I do not want to suggest for a moment that the Tánaiste or the Minister for Agriculture were actuated by any evil motive in accepting that position. I do not know their mind and I was not in their confidence. I know that when we made the 1948 agreement the preamble to it envisaged that there was mutual collaboration to maximise production and supplies of live stock and meat products from Ireland to the British market and to that joint purpose we jointly put our hand by the agreement of 1948.

Now, the present Minister for Agriculture says: "How can you carry on that agreement on an uncontrolled market?" But I made an agreement on identical terms for pigs and bacon in June, 1951, and that agreement is being carried on. It was expressed to operate until 1956. The Minister for Agriculture says to-day that when they were in London the question of pigs, pork and bacon was raised and that they carried conviction to the minds of the British Government that the British Government was bound by the agreement of 1951 up to and including 1956, and that although they were decontrolling pork, bacon and pigs this summer, they still had obligations which they must discharge under the terms of the agreement they signed with me in 1951. If it is possible to carry out the 1951 Trade Agreement in the new conditions, with suitable adaptation, in respect of pigs, bacon and pork, why was it not possible to renew the 1948 Trade Agreement, with similar suitable adaptation, to cover cattle, beef, sheep, mutton and lamb? Do not forget that as a result of the pig and bacon agreement our pigs are fetching 236/- per cwt., while the continental pig is fetching in exactly the same market about 189/-.

Are we wise to have let go, if it were possible to retain, the provisions of the 1948 Trade Agreement? Perhaps it was that the Tánaiste and the Minister for Agriculture were met with a blank refusal when they went to London. Did they use the weapons that we had left with them in pressing the British to honour the spirit of their bargain— that was, to do in respect of cattle, sheep, mutton and beef what they have been constrained to do by the terms of the 1951 agreement in respect of bacon, pork and pigs? Do not let any of us here say that the fault is to be laid at the door of our Ministers for I do not know and I do not want to minimise their difficulties or increase the difficulty of the task that lies ahead. But, does not the Minister for Finance and does not the Taoiseach think that the House is entitled to be told?

Before departing from that subject, I want to say—the Minister for Agriculture should take occasion to say it, too—I do not believe that the abrogation of the cattle provisions or the sheep provisions of the 1948 Trade Agreement will develop in any early collapse in the price of cattle or of sheep and influential warning should be given to our people forthwith not to be tricked, jockeyed or deceived into throwing their cattle away in the apprehension that the price is likely to collapse at an early date. I do not believe it will, and I do not believe it would be legitimate for any of us to spread that rumour abroad in order to persuade our people to vote one way or the other to their own detriment.

I remember too bitterly the vicious activities of certain Fianna Fáil Deputies in East Donegal when they went amongst their own neighbours and persuaded them to throw their modest modicum of oats on the market and sell them for half their value only to buy them back at twice their price the following spring just because they wanted to get votes. Do not do that to the small farmers of this country now for any reason. It is the duty of us all rather to sustain and protect them from any attempt to exploit them.

The Minister for Agriculture has probably learned from his improvident winding up of Eggsports how easy it is for the rapacious to exploit our people. Do not let him stand wringing his hands and flapping while he says that while he knows the people are being exploited, he can do nothing about it. I never was so humiliated as when I saw an Irish Minister for Agriculture stand in that place and wring his hands and say that he knew that eggs were being bought for 18d. a dozen by unscrupulous people who were exploiting our people but that he could not do anything about it. Do not let him have that tale to tell again. He has only got six weeks to go. Let him contrive to look like a Minister for Agriculture in the meantime in any case.

He did not present a very pretty figure as he trotted to London with his fingers twined in the tail of the Tánaiste's coat but as he came back carrying his bag and looking obsequious beside him as the Tánaiste announced the agricultural policy of the future, I was sorry that he made himself party to what seemed to me to have been a deliberate deception of our people. I exhort him to exert himself now to prevent the damage that may be done by his fraudulent conduct that unscrupulous people should try to avail of it to exploit our people as some egglers did to exploit the egg producers of this country.

I want to know, and I think I have a right to know from the Government before this debate ends, why was it not possible to keep the 1948 Trade Agreement in respect of cattle and sheep in being in the new conditions when it has been admitted as being perfectly simple to keep the pigs and bacon agreement functioning, albeit on a free and uncontrolled market?

I want to refer briefly and indeed in conclusion to a few of the more outstanding observations of the Minister for Finance in this Budget statement:

"The year which has just closed has been one of the most prosperous in the nation's history."

May I suggest to Fianna Fáil T.D.s, hoary and new, that they would stimulate a great deal of interest in their election meetings if they would open them all by saying: "The year which has just closed has been one of the most prosperous in the nation's history"? May I suggest to them a canvassing slogan in the towns and villages: "It has been a year of increased trade and higher incomes"? I urge the Deputies, when they canvass Killybegs, say, or even Ballyshannon, Donegal, Kilcar, just to put their heads inside the door and say: "It has been a year of increased trade and higher incomes." There will be a lot of glassware broken in Kilcar if you do that. I beg of you to listen to this — page 4: —

"In an effort to stimulate the use of fertilisers and raise agricultural output substantially, the Government made arrangements to ensure the availability to farmers generally of credit for the purchase of fertilisers. The co-operation of the commercial banks to this end was readily secured and a special scheme was inaugurated by the Department of Agriculture..."

I wish to God you would line up the farmers who got credit from the joint stock banks under that scheme. Who knows a farmer who got credit under that scheme from the joint stock banks? The preliminary qualification was that he should be a credit-worthy farmer. Why should not a bank give credit to a credit-worthy farmer? What compliment was it to the Government? What else are they there for? How else do they make their money except by levying interest on credit-worthy farmers?

Just picture the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture, again with his fingers twisted, this time in the coat tails of the Taoiseach, not the Tánaiste, meeting the bankers to know would they provide credit for the farmers, the bankers saying "Certainly sir, we will provide credit to credit-worthy farmers" and the Taoiseach saying: "Oh, that is awfully decent of you, my dear fellows, very kind. I will issue a statement to the papers. Thank you," and the bankers saying: "Not at all, not at all. Good morning sir, good morning." Really, life in this country almost reaches circus proportions.

Did you see the picture in the paper of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Agriculture looking up with adoring eyes and the Taoiseach looking benevolently on the bankers and the bankers saying: "Certainly sir, certainly"? Thanks be to God, when the bankers came to visit us there was very little gratitude from one side of the table, and there was very little "certainly, sir" until late in the evening.

Page 10 of this document: —

"The recent negotiations undertaken by the Tánaiste and the Minister for Agriculture have been eminently successful and have removed much of the uncertainty as to the course of cattle prices after the British meat market is decontrolled. In fact, the agreement which was reached assures to Irish live stock the benefit of full British market prices."

We then asked the Minister for Agriculture: "What agreement?" and, if I may be pardoned for the vernacular, he said in substance: "Damn fool, there could not be an agreement", quite oblivious of the fact that the Minister for Finance had announced in his Budget statement that there was an agreement, that they made an agreement. Do I exaggerate when I say that the Minister for Agriculture to-day said that it was obvious to the meanest intellect that in the new circumstances there could not be an agreement? Is not that so? Would I be unduly severe if I described that paragraph in the Budget statement as being disingenuous?

Comment on this

Told to him by a rabbit.

Comment on this

I want to turn to page 22 of the Budget statement. Do you remember when Deputy Aiken used to say that the inter-Party Government had gone on a spending spree, that they had become intoxicated and had scattered public money far and wide? Listen to what the Minister for Finance has to say in this year of grace: —

"The record of national development in recent years is very satisfactory, not only because of extensive progress achieved but also because of the degree to which it has been defrayed from current savings.... The fruits of this capital investment are already appearing in the development of native fuel and power, in better roads and communications, in new houses in their thousands to replace unsuitable dwellings, improved amenities in the home and in farm and factory, modern schools and hospitals and more employment."

He did not think it right to include in that category the land rehabilitation project or the work of the Department of Agriculture — but my poor successor is so accustomed to getting kicked about the floor that he did not seem to mind.

A great deal of the capital spent in recent years has been spent on the land of Ireland. Is it not typical of the Fianna Fáil mentality that they referred to the houses, the farm and the factory, roads and communications, fuel and power, but that they never mentioned the land?

Comment on this
Patrick Beegan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Beegan) Fianna Fáil

What is a farm?

Comment on this

It can be the kitchen or the building. The Minister talks of the "improved amenities in the home and in farm and factory". Does the Deputy call land rehabilitation an amenity? I call water in the kitchen, light in the bedroom, power in the byre, an amenity, perhaps, but it is not the land — and it is because Fianna Fáil do not believe in the land that they forget the land. It is true. To Fianna Fáil, progress, development and the creation of wealth means the building of a factory. It does not matter that the factory is for the purpose of assembling lipsticks. It does not matter that the factory, so called, is for the purpose of putting Aspro on a string. If it is a factory, if it is a building standing in a city, we are all meant to go out, uncover our heads and bow down to development. But if it is the land — what do Fianna Fáil care for the land? In their judgment, any business——

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Has the Deputy read the reference to wheat? He has a very important reference to wheat.

Comment on this

Yes, he has a reference to the fact that it cost him £1,000,000 to produce wheat this year which we shall have to sell abroad for half the price it cost us to grow it. Yes, there ought to be 3,500,000 to 4,000,000 barrels of wheat off this year's crop of wheat. Eating all of it we can, we will consume 3,000,000 of them but we shall have 1,000,000 barrels to reduce to seed or to sell abroad. The French are selling wheat to-day in London at £25 a ton.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

So you will not continue it?

Comment on this

We will continue, as we continued before, a guaranteed price for wheat. May I remind the House that I was only one week in office when I told every agricultural committee in this country that our Government's conception of democracy was not the size of the majority the Government had to govern but the degree of respect it showed for the feelings of the minority they defeated? Therefore, to carry assurance to the most obscurantist Fianna Fáil devotee in this country, we guaranteed the price of wheat, not for one year but for five years. Were we right? We were right, because we wanted to show them that in our hands they were safe, unlike the fate our friends experienced when Fianna Fáil were in power — their fences broken down, the gates opened, and civic guards——

Comment on this

And their cattle seized.

Comment on this

Yes. Page 26 of the Minister's Budget speech describes the adoption by the Minister for Finance of the Capital Budget Plan. I quote this sentence from page 27: —

"The White Paper shows that against a prospective revenue of £106,558,000 there is set, after deduction of £14,362,000 for capital services, a possible expenditure on Central Fund and Supply Services of £111,335,000."

Did you ever see somebody swallow a camel with less of a grunt? Even Deputy Beegan, who now sits judicially in the Minister's place, was moved to paroxysms of righteous wrath in 1950 when the capital Budget procedure was introduced in this House. He wept to see depravity in Government finance bring a Government of Ireland so low. What has happened? Why has he changed his mind? Has he been educated or has he determined to collaborate and to live in sin?

Comment on this

Like many people, I have indeed, for my education.

Comment on this

For a moment I thought that, like so many others, he had decided to live in sin. However, it relieves me to hear that, like so many others, he has received education. It is a very heavy burden to conduct his education at this time of Deputy Beegan's life but, you know, I suppose it is something we ought to be proud of though I am not——

Comment on this

There is not so much between us.

Comment on this

That is quite true. However, I should regard it as a serious reflection on me if anybody suggested that Deputy Beegan educated me. If Deputy Beegan says that I educated him, not only on the facts of life, but on rectitude and on standards of conduct, it is a revelation. But we cannot go on doing it at this expense time and time again. I want to refer to what I said at the beginning. This is the third time Fianna Fáil have wrecked this country and have proceeded to pass it on.(Interruption from the Gallery.) It is the like of you who would do it. I hope the Taoiseach recognises that it is not only his opponents up in the Gallery——

Comment on this

You cannot accuse the Taoiseach of planting that interrupter in the Gallery.

Comment on this

I do not grudge him his enthusiastic friend.

Comment on this

He was not very enthusiastic.

Comment on this

I like somebody who is loyal in adversity. Any man who has the spunk in him to say: "Up Dev." finds a soft corner in my heart. There is something decent about a fellow who sticks to the ship when it is going down and I like him better than the rat that skips off when he sees it is sinking — and, God knows, there are plenty of rats. There are fellows who salute me now when I walk the streets who have not seen me in the past five years. Every old political barometer in Dublin City is getting a cold in his head now from saluting me but, so far as I am concerned, they can keep their hats on. I have much more respect for the poor goof who has just been thrown out of the gallery.

I want to draw the Taoiseach's attention to this, because it is a grave matter. It has been a source of boasting on the part of the Minister for Finance and, indeed, of the Taoiseach himself that the adverse trade balance has improved, and it did. After the stockpiling done by our Government, increased agricultural exports plus the running down of accumulated stocks did effect a very striking improvement. I would ask the Taoiseach to look at the first three months of this year. Remember, when looking at the first three months of this year, import prices have been moving in our favour and export prices have remained pretty stable. They are pretty stable still because the volume of eggs going out has been trivial to date.

The adverse trade balance figures in the first three months of this year are up by £2,800,000 and the trend appears to be for them to rise. Bear this in mind: there stands between this country and utter disaster nothing but the capacity of our farmers to export profitably. This Party has said again and again that one of its prime purposes is to bring down the cost of living, because, unless you can bring down the cost of living, you cannot bring down the cost of agricultural production. Now that the Minister for Agriculture accepts the proposition that he is no longer able to influence the price of our live stock on the British market, remember that, unless our costs of production come down to meet the costs of our competitors in that market our profit margin may disappear and with the disappearance of our profit margin in that market, our exports will dwindle, and, should they dwindle, industrial activity will virtually come to an end in this country for want of raw material.

There is nothing between us and that dialectic leading to stagnation but the capacity of our farmers to produce profitably.

Comment on this
Thomas Walsh Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Walsh) Fianna Fáil

Produce more and import less — no wheat and no maize.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will agree with me that the basic thing is to produce more of what we can export profitably?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

And import less. You do not like that.

Comment on this

That does not matter a damn. Why does the Minister for Agriculture say that it is a good and a desirable thing for Gentex in Athlone to bring cotton from Carolina and process it into cotton cloth for export to Great Britain or America——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Why bring in £5,000,000 worth of wheat?

Comment on this

If it is good to bring in cotton from Carolina and process it in Athlone for export to Great Britain and the United States, why is it wrong——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

£5,000,000 worth of wheat from America.

Comment on this

——to bring in the raw material of increased agricultural livestock production, process it on a 25-acre farm and ship it to the United States of America or Great Britain for a profit? Why is it wrong to have a factory on a 25-acre farm, if it is desirable to have a factory in the town or village to be subsidised by the Exchequer?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Sell in the dearest and buy in the cheapest market, and drive the people out of the country.

Comment on this

Why it it that the Minister will not only promote that, but is prepared to give £70,000 of a free grant to a factory in Kiltimagh to bring in tailors' clippings from Bradford, process them into shoddy yarn and ship the yarn to England for manufacture and congratulate the people who are giving industrial employment in that way? Why is it something to be subsidised, praised and admired to do that in a town or city, and why is it a crime, why is it wrong, for the small farmer, by his enterprise, to use all the stuff he can produce on his own 25 acres, and then bring in more raw material and process that on his little 25-acre factory and ship it at a profit to America or Great Britain? Why can we not think of the land of this country and the people who live on it as having the capacity to expand and expand and to build up greater and greater exports on which to build a higher and higher standard of living?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

And less imports.

Comment on this

What imbecility this is! What is the purpose of exporting, if not to import? Why send your goods to England, if you do not intend to get back from England something in exchange? Would the Minister have us feed them with pork, beef, eggs, butter, chocolate crumb and bacon and then say to them: "Write in your book that you owe us £100,000,000, £200,000,000, £400,000,000, £600,000,000 or £800,000,000," and every time we try to bring back £100,000,000 of it in the shape of goods our people want, to say: "No—import less and export more". Where does that lead to? If you are going to go on exporting and always importing less, does it not mean that the very substance of our people is ultimately going to be located in the bank vaults of New York, London and Paris?

What is the purpose of exporting, if not to enable our people to raise their own standard of living by commanding the services and supplies of the greater section of the world? What is the purpose of sending the product of our labour to foreigners, if it is not to make them labour for us? Is that not the whole end of international trade and is it not our purpose surely to manufacture here in Ireland, whether it be foodstuff or anything else, that which will command a price in foreign countries which will equip our people to command these foreign countries to furnish us with the things we want?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Why should we not produce from our land what it can produce?

Comment on this

Exactly, and then add to that as much more raw materials, manufacture them, too, and ship them out, because the more we ship out, the more we are entitled to bring in, and the more we are entitled to bring in and able to pay for, the higher becomes the standard of living of all our people and the more employment we give in city and town.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

We lost 50,000 people from the land and 500,000 acres while you were sitting over here.

Comment on this

The Minister should buy a halfpenny book with the first halfpenny he saves on the loaf after 1st June.

Comment on this

It is suicide — utter economic suicide — to say that we should export more and more and import less and less. I beg the Minister to pause some night and ask himself what is the logical end of that. Is it not that we should ultimately convert all the wealth, actual and potential, of our people into sterile deposits abroad because we would not use them to purchase the things we wanted? Let him ask himself the question: what is the purpose of exporting at all? Surely the only purpose of exporting is to enable ourselves to import. Why else send your goods abroad? Let him ask himself does he now realise the economic insanity into which he has allowed himself to drift. Does he understand the meaning of the doctrine he lays down — export more and import less? The ideal to which he aims is that we should export everything and import nothing. Is that not the end? He says: "Export more and import less". Carry that to its logical conclusion and we reach a stage at which we export everything and import nothing.

Comment on this

What about the dangerous balance of payment trend about which the Deputy was talking?

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach trying to come to the Minister's rescue?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is an old dog for the hard road and he knows the Minister for Agriculture is making a fool of himself. I do not want to rub the Minister's agricultural nose in his own folly, but the trouble is that a great many simple colleagues of his accept these idiotic aphorisms as truth and there are amongst his friends— perhaps he himself believes it — those who believe that it is a sound aphorism to say: "Export more and import less", but it is standing on your head economically.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Mind you, it pays good dividends.

Comment on this

Exactly, and that is where the Minister has gone daft. He would sooner invest money at 2 per cent. with the British Government and say: "Look at my lovely 2 per cent." than buy with the money the materials wherewith to employ, to house and to hospitalise our people or develop our land.

Comment on this

We were giving £5,000,000 of a gift to Britain at one time and there was no protest made by Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary now referring to the land annuities?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us get back to the Budget.

Comment on this

Let us get back to the aphorism so aptly voiced by the Minister for Agriculture. Let us export more and more and import less and less.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Of the articles we can produce ourselves.

Comment on this

Of course, it is time that the Minister for Agriculture mended his hand a little. Pop has just said "turn" and when Pop says "turn" you all turn together. As I know, Pop does not often get caught in a controversy of this kind. He tipped the wink to the Minister for Agriculture to mend his hand as he was getting into trouble. I sympathise with the Minister for Agriculture. It is economic imbecility of that kind which has made Fianna Fáil what it is. It is the belief in Fianna Fáil that there is a virtue in an aphorism of that kind which has wrought the economic havoc for which Fianna Fáil is responsible in this country. I think, as I think they think, they are finished.

I noted the Minister for Education in this morning's paper thanked God that the miseries he experienced as Minister for Education were shortly to be ended by the general election.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Could the Deputy give an explanation as to the volume of output from 1950 to 1951 under his direction?

Comment on this

I am talking about——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

The Deputy is talking about something.

Comment on this

I am in possession. I am now talking about the disintegration of the Fianna Fáil Party. I have only five minutes left. I talked about a wide variety of topics.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

To-morrow is a new day.

Comment on this

I now propose to talk about the disintegration of the Fianna Fáil Party. I noted the Minister for Justice said that he proposed to postpone certain decisions so that his successor might have the responsibility of making them. I notice that Fianna Fáil has made up its mind that it is going to quit. I think it is good for the country that Fianna Fáil is going to quit.

Comment on this

The Deputy said the same thing about Sinn Féin one time.

Comment on this

I rather welcome Deputy Killilea's intervention. His second cousin interrupted me in Ballygar last Monday and I venture to assert that his second cousin will not interrupt me again for a long time to come. Deputy Killilea is welcome to interrupt just as his charming second cousin was in Ballygar.

Comment on this

The Deputy got a poor reception in Ballygar. The Deputy will not go to Ballygar for a while again. He got his answer.

Comment on this

I found the people, including Deputy Killilea's second cousin, extremely agreeable. I think Fianna Fáil is folding up. I prophesied two years ago that the general election would be held in June. I think it would have been held in June but for the two by-elections. I think the plan was that the present Taoiseach was to retire in June and hand over to Deputy Lemass, Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

It is not the first time the Deputy prophesied that.

Comment on this

I think what I say is true.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see that this has anything to do with the Budget?

Comment on this

I think it has.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with the Budget.

Comment on this

I think it has. Fianna Fáil's whole economic philosophy has brought them to the country now. I think they have done an infinity of damage to the people and the country. I admit that if I believed their diagnosis of the situation was accurate, I would recoil from any part in the responsibility of setting right what is wrong, but it is in the belief that they are as wrong now about the true state of affairs as their Tánaiste was in November, 1947, that I think we have a right to hope that with the final disappearance of Fianna Fáil we can make this country a decent place for decent people to live in. I look forward to the five years after this general election, when the land can be exploited and when the people can make a living on it and get from it the highest standard of living enjoyed by any agricultural community in the world.

Comment on this

It was most interesting for me to watch the attempt of the Leader of the Opposition to do the trick of standing on two horses without real reins while the horses were turned in opposite directions. I am sure he envied some of his predecessors in the leadership of Fine Gael who had, at least, only one horse to manage and not two. In those days to throw my mind back I could imagine——

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach would allow me to interrupt. It is now 28 minutes past ten and if the Taoiseach would like to report progress I am sure no one would object.

Comment on this

Let him finish the story about the horse.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

We like to have a little sanity after all the insanity.

Comment on this

It is a matter of complete indifference to me whether I have the next three or four minutes. If it was going to save the House and myself the need of any repetition and in order that when we resume to-morrow my initial statement might be connected, I would be willing to report progress but if there is anybody who wants to listen now——

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

——I am quite prepared to go on.

Comment on this

Téirigh ar aghaidh ansin.

Comment on this

Yes. As regards the attitude of the Leader of the Opposition, I said I was sure he envied some of his predecessors in Fine Gael who occupied that seat and who had at least only one horse to ride, or stand on its back circus fashion, and knew exactly what he was doing and where he was going. He did not have to use two contradictory sets of arguments.

I can easily imagine what his predecessors would have said had a Budget of this character been introduced in these days, but Fine Gael has changed its position and now they have to try to reconcile two things that are not reconcilable. They have to try, on the one hand, to suggest that there can be a considerable reduction in expenditure and, on the other hand, that there can be considerable development both of a capital nature and in social services.

These two things are not compatible, and those who say at the present time that they are going to have a Coalition are deceiving two sets of supporters. They are deceiving, in the first place, those to whom they promise a considerable reduction in expenditure and in the second place they are going to deceive those to whom they promise a considerable advance in social services and considerable development in capital formation.

Comment on this