Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1954—Committee.
Contributions 1–190 of 381. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1954 ›
I move amendment No. 1:—
In sub-section (1), lines 15 and 16, to delete "seven shillings and sixpence" and to substitute "six shillings and sixpence".
This amendment, which relates to income-tax, and all the other amendments on the sheet appearing in my name, have for their purpose the reduction of certain taxes to the level at which they were before the Budget of 1952; not merely to reduce the income-tax to the pre-1952 level but also to reduce the taxes on beer, spirits and tobacco. These are the taxes which members of the present Government stated at the time and on many occasions since were unnecessary, the taxes which they undertook during the course of the recent election campaign to repeal, the taxes which they stated could be repealed immediately. However, the legal members of the Government may parse and interpret the phraseology that was used during these election speeches, there is no doubt that they caused the people to believe that the Fianna Fáil Government had imposed unnecessary taxation, and that it would be the function of the new Coalition Government to rectify that situation by revoking these unnecessary taxes.
The purpose of submitting these amendments to the Dáil is to give Deputies opposite an opportunity, if they want it, of redeeming their election pledges, an opportunity, if they do not want to redeem those pledges, of withdrawing them, and an opportunity to the Government of explaining why it is not possible to do now what a few months ago they were saying they could and would do. These amendments, of course, pose to Deputies opposite a question which affects the reputation of the Government and of each individual supporting them. What is that question? Perhaps it would be better if I were to put it in words other than my own. I think it will help the Dáil to realise the character of the question they have to answer on these amendments if I put it in the words of a member of the present Administration, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. When these taxes had been put into operation and were subsequently under discussion by the Dáil, the present Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, Deputy Donnellan, spoke as follows in Dáil Éireann. I am quoting from Volume 131, column 639, of the Official Debates, and this is the quotation:—
"I notice in a Sunday paper that a certain question was asked by Deputy McQuillan. The same question was asked by Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. The question was that if there was a change of Government would the same taxes be left on or what would be done? That was an intelligent question and I congratulate both Deputy McQuillan and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll on it. As Deputy John A. Costello, the ex-Taoiseach, and Deputy McGilligan, ex-Minister for Finance, explained, the answer is that there is an overestimate here of, roughly, £10,000,000. With a change of Government and with the help of men like Deputy McGilligan again, taxation to the extent of that £10,000,000 could be reduced. That is the answer to the question that was asked."
That was the answer of Deputy Donnellan before the election. Are we going to get the same answer from the same Deputy or from his colleagues in the present Administration to-day? Do they still contend that the taxes to which these amendments relate were unnecessary and can now be revoked? Are they going to adhere to their undertaking to the people who elected them to revoke these taxes immediately ?
I note that when we discussed this matter last week there was some doubt raised as to whether the undertaking of the present Government was or was not to revoke these taxes immediately. The present Minister for Finance stated earlier that the present Government had not promised to reduce taxation at all, but Deputy McGilligan last week qualified it by asserting that the Government had not promised to reduce taxation immediately. He said last week—I am quoting from Volume 146, No. 4, column 506:—
"We made no promises about immediate reductions in taxes. Nobody who now holds ministerial rank"—
I want Deputies to note the subtle qualifications inserted there—
"and that is what is referred to in the motion—made any such promises and we will ask the ex-Tánaiste to go through any quotations in every newspaper and nowhere will he find a promise of that kind."
I do not know what is the exact significance of a promise to effect a reduction of taxation immediately. I asked how quick was "immediate" and I got no answer to that question. But we find on examining the records that a specific time had been mentioned by the present Taoiseach and by some of his colleagues in the present Government within which they would effect these reductions in taxation.
On the same occasion as that upon which Deputy Donnellan, the present Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, gave that specific reply to a question which some Deputies had asked, Deputy MacEntee, the then Minister for Finance, made a rather remarkable prophecy.
He foretold that if it should happen that Deputy Costello was transferred from the Opposition to the Government Benches there was not a single measure, a single tax, imposed in Deputy MacEntee's Finance Bill that he would repeal. Whether that was an accurate prophecy or not will be demonstrated, no doubt, in the next couple of hours. It was made, and perhaps it is worth quoting now because immediately Deputy MacEntee had made that prophecy—the prophecy that there was not a single one of those taxes that Deputy Costello would repeal if, in fact, he was transferred from this side of the House to the other side—Deputy Costello intervened in the debate and he said, as reported in Volume 131, column 1439:—
"I would repeal every one of them if I were over there."
Immediately afterwards, Deputy Mulcahy, the present Minister for Education and Chairman of the Fine Gael Party, intervened and said:—
"He would remove £10,000,000 in ten minutes."
Later on in the same debate, Deputy Costello again intervened and said:—
"I would resign the next minute, rather than proceed with any single provision in the present Budget. I would be no party to any provision in this Budget."
I urge Deputies opposite to consider carefully before they decide this afternoon to put the Taoiseach in the embarrassing position of either having to eat his words or resign.
Nor were the present Taoiseach and the present Minister for Education alone in that declaration. Deputy McGilligan spoke at a public meeting which was reported in the Irish Independent and said the following:—
"If we could get the present Government out by July 1st, a new Minister for Finance could in a ten-minute speech save £1,000,000 a minute and thus wipe out the £10,000,000 that was being asked for. I do not even despair of being able to save another £5,000,000 as well."
Deputy McGilligan said that members of the present Administration made no promises about immediate reductions in taxation. He said that nobody who holds ministerial office at the present time made any such promises. He went further than that last week—and Deputies sitting behind the Government will note how definitely their election speeches are now being repudiated. He said:—
"We do not believe that...there was anybody on this side foolish enough to say that big reductions in taxation, immediate reductions in taxation, were practicable."
Is it true that no member of the present Administration stated that neither big reductions nor immediate reductions in taxation were possible? I have shown that the present Taoiseach has said that he would resign the next minute if he became Taoiseach and found himself unable to repeal these taxes. I have shown that the present Minister for Education and Chairman of the Fine Gael Party said that these taxes would be repealed in ten minutes after the change of Government. I have shown that Deputy McGilligan, the former Minister for Finance, even put a figure on the amount of the reductions that would be achieved in ten minutes—£10,000,000.
Deputy McGilligan last week challenged me to show that any member of the present Administration promised immediate reductions in taxation. Well, I have covered two of them already. I do not have to remind the House of the very formal declaration made by the Chairman of Fine Gael in his election address:—
"The first task of the new Administration will be to lighten the burden of taxation which is now crushing the people."
Let us get down to other members of the Administration.
The present Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking at a public meeting in Naas, reported in the Irish Independent of the 5th May, said the following:—
"Fianna Fáil Deputies by voting for the increased prices of tea, bread, butter, sugar and flour and for the higher taxes on cigarettes, beer and tobacco, have been active conspirators in the attack on the people's standard of living. In this reactionary policy Fianna Fáil was implementing the policy which the Central Bank had sought to induce the inter-Party Government to adopt but which that Government had spurned."
Are the Deputies in this House who support the present Government now becoming active conspirators in the attack on the people's standard of living? Is this "reactionary policy" attributed to the Central Bank now being accepted as the policy of the present Administration?
During the course of the election campaign, the present Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton, issued a circular to all the licensed traders in his constituency, on the 3rd May, from his election headquarters at the Railway Hotel, Kildare. This is the circular:—
"A Chara,
As you are an elector in the County Kildare constituency, I take the liberty of enclosing herewith a copy of my election address and would kindly invite your attention in particular to the portion of the programme set out in page 3 under the heading ‘Reduction in Prices.' In view of the serious effect of increased taxation on cigarettes, beer and spirits, which no doubt has had an injurious effect on your trade, I trust you will find it possible to give me your No. 1 vote in the forthcoming election and kindly ask your relatives and friends to do likewise, so that with the aid of the Labour Party I may advocate in the new Dáil a reduction of the taxes which so adversely affect your business and consumers generally."
Now, this is the day of testing. Is the Leader of the Labour Party, and are his colleagues here in this House, going to avail of this opportunity to advocate a reduction of these taxes upon cigarettes, beer and spirits? Either this afternoon or to-morrow, they will have to advocate them and vote for them, or they will have to vote against them. No doubt those who, in response to the circular, gave Deputy Norton their votes—and their relatives and friends—will be very glad to see precisely how these election pledges are going to be redeemed.
Comment on this
We prefer to be honest with the people. No member who now holds any ministerial rank, said Deputy McGilligan here last week, made any such promises. The present Minister for Defence, Deputy MacEoin, made an abundance of promises. If any Deputy wants a pleasant evening's entertainment, he should go down to the Library and read up the election speeches made by Deputy MacEoin. I think he said anything that came into his head.
Comment on this
With or without the authority of his portfolio and whatever his military rank, he is now in this House as an important member of the present Administration, sharing collective responsibility with all the other members.
"Our policy is to relieve once again the penal taxes which have been imposed by Fianna Fáil in their 1952 Budget"—that is to say, to carry into effect the amendments which I am now proposing to the House. That was the policy of Fine Gael as declared in the election—to make in this Finance Bill the changes which these amendments represent. The Minister for Defence and his colleagues will have an opportunity in the very near future either of fulfilling that policy or, finally, abandoning it.
The Parliamentary Secretaries— those who are now Parliamentary Secretaries—were far more flamboyant in their promises and far more definite in their statements in regard to a new Government than even those who hold ministerial rank. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance just took Deputy McGilligan's declaration at a public meeting and repeated it with slightly more emphasis. Addressing a Clann na Talmhan Convention in Ballina, Deputy Donnellan, as he then was, said: "If there is a change of Government we will put in a Minister for Finance who will remit £1,000,000 for each minute of a ten-minute talk in the Dáil." The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is not here now, I know, but perhaps he will come in here in time to deliver that ten-minute speech and remit £1,000,000 in taxation in each minute of it.
I do not know if we have to take the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Oliver Flanagan, any more seriously now that he has been raised to the dignity of a Parliamentary Secretary. However, he was equally emphatic in his view of the justice of carrying through the amendments which I am now proposing.
Here is a quotation in point. "It is, indeed, a crime to rob the poor man of his beer, and it is, indeed, a laughing-stock to remove the tax of a farthing per pint, which will have no bearing on the price paid by the consumer." The report of Deputy O. Flanagan's speech appeared in the Leinster Express of the 24th April, 1954. It continued:—
"Declaring that there was no hope for the brewing and distilling industries, only greater unemployment and lack of business in the trade, Mr. Flanagan said the income-tax concessions given in the Budget only referred to the people from whom the Minister for Finance, Mr. MacEntee, could not collect tax at present, owing to the high cost of living, and many other commitments, which the middle class have to face. ‘In my opinion,' said Mr. Flanagan, ‘the Government cannot boast of taking a halfpenny off the loaf, after having put 3½d. on it without any justification whatever.'"
I find that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Davin, repeated on more than one occasion the pledge which I have already quoted for the benefit of the members of this House. I think that pledge is worth repeating in the context of the discussion on these amendments. He said: "So far as the Labour Party is concerned, the principal item in our programme in this election is the reduction of taxation on all essential commodities to the same level, or as nearly as possible to the same level, as that at which they stood before the Budget of 1952. I pledge my word of honour to the people of this area that if I am re-elected, as I hope to be, I will undertake with my colleagues to use that power given to us by the votes of the people to force whatever new Government is elected on the 2nd June to bring down these prices to the lowest possible figure." That quotation is taken from a report in the Midland Tribune of 15th May, 1954. The value to be placed on Deputy Davin's word of honour will be demonstrated during the votes on these amendments.
Deputy Crotty, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, also in the course of his election campaign, spoke at a meeting at Castlecomer, as reported in the Kilkenny People of 15th May. “They had, he said, unjust and unnecessary taxation and, in the Budget of 1952, £6,000,000 tax was put on beer, tobacco and cigarettes. Their food subsidies were slashed to the extent of £8,000,000. Fianna Fáil said the people were living too well.” I do not know if the Government are serious in trying to convince the House or the country that they did not promise to reduce taxation.
Every voter in the country considered that that promise had been made and every voter was left under the impression that it was not a problem for another inter-Party Government and that taxation could be reduced and reduced immediately. The impression was given to the voters that there was an abundance of money. When Deputy McGilligan was making his bid for the votes of the civil servants—his cash offer—he was at pains to emphasise that this was not a budgetary problem at all. He said that there was plenty of money available. In a letter to the Irish Independent on 17th May, 1954, the eve of the election, he said: “There is abundant money to pay the arrears and Fine Gael is pledged to that payment.” He also said that it would be immediately available to make that adjustment in Civil Service salaries.
Deputies, I think, know that these promises were made. They know that the people expected some effort to fulfil these promises at least in part. It is no answer to these expectations to say that the Government need time. They do not need time, if what they said is true. In his wireless broadcast, Deputy McGilligan said that the economies were there to hand: "They are immediately available for any Minister who cares to see them. There is little doubt that savings in the cost of Government amounting to several millions a year can be secured without much effort." Is it not reasonable, therefore, to ask the Government to make the effort and to fulfil the promises which were made?
The Government claim they have not had time to prepare amendments to this Finance Bill. Well, I have done it for them. There was nothing difficult about it. I drafted the amendments in a bus on the back of an envelope. They can be carried through without any change and will achieve what every Deputy opposite promised the electorate he would vote for, that is, a reduction in taxes on beer, spirits and tobacco and a reduction in income-tax to the pre-1952 level.
If it is not possible to reduce these taxes now, the onus is on the Government to explain the reason. Again, I do not want the House to be under any misunderstanding about our view on the matter. As I have already said, if the Estimates prepared for the various Departments of this State are accurate, if the expectations of revenue, upon which the Budget was framed, are sound, there is no surplus and these taxes cannot be remitted if enough money is to be available to the Government to meet the ordinary cost of administration.
We did not say these taxes were unnecessary or unjust. We did not contend that they were imposed for any reason except to bring into the Exchequer the minimum amount required to pay for Government services. Those Deputies who are now on the Government Benches argued that these taxes were unnecessarily imposed—that they were imposed not because the Exchequer needed the money but because the Central Bank wanted a restrictive policy applied.
If these taxes are unnecessary, they can now be remitted. The Irish Independent has stated that if these amendments are carried it will, of course, be necessary to effect immediate reductions in social welfare services. Government Deputies will not fall for that. They know that if what they said in the election is correct, the Independent cannot be right.
At Sligo, on 1st May, as reported in the Sligo Independent, the Taoiseach in the course of an election address was emphatic in asserting that there was no reason why taxes should not be got down while the same or even improved services, would be provided. That was the case made to the public —that, without any reduction in services, and even with an improvement in these services, it was still possible, because of the action of Fianna Fáil in imposing unnecessary taxation, to remit some taxes immediately. If what was said is true, there is no reason now why the Deputies on the Government Benches should not vote for these amendments.
If the Minister says that he cannot give the whole of the reductions I am asking for in these amendments this year, because three months of the financial year have already elapsed, then I shall be prepared to consider any compromise he may have to suggest. However, we do think that the pledges which Deputies opposite gave during the election campaign require them, in this Finance Bill, to make some contribution towards the reduction of the taxation on beer, spirits and tobacco——
Comment on this
The Deputy has put his finger on the point. I think the Deputy is correct in his view that the result of the recent election was due to the fact that the public were led to believe that the Fianna Fáil Government had imposed taxation unnecessarily. It was not. I do not believe—this is my own personal opinion—that it was the level of prices which put us out of office. It was the belief, carefully inculcated by Fine Gael and Labour Party propaganda, that the level of prices was unnecessary that was responsible for the result. It is the soundness of that belief I am testing now. Do you think that the present prices of beer, spirits and tobacco are unnecessary? If they are, then obviously you will vote for a reduction.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary will cease interrupting. The Deputy will get every opportunity of speaking later.
Comment on this
The case made, as I understand it and as the public understood it, is that unnecessary taxation was imposed and that the Fianna Fáil Government had imposed that unnecessary taxation for some reason other than the needs of the Exchequer, that we had obeyed the behest of the Central Bank or that we were following an austerity policy or had an idea that it was desirable to reduce public spending upon these classes of goods.
That was the case you made to the public and you even argued that a reduction in these prices would not result in a loss of revenue, that the increased consumption, following the reduction, would mean that the Exchequer would not suffer any contraction of income on that account. If that is so you can have no hesitation about voting for these amendments. If it is not so, you have got, as I said, either to formally repudiate these election promises or explain why they cannot be fulfilled. It is that explanation I am waiting to hear.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy Lemass for the last half an hour, I was struck afresh with his ability to make bricks without straw and to talk for 32 minutes about pure "cod". The Deputy spent 32 minutes trying to prove that every member of the Government and every Deputy sitting behind the Government made promises during the election. With his leader, he spent the whole of the election campaign trying to extract promises from the members of the present Government. He and the then Taoiseach complained bitterly, day after day, as the campaign went on, that they could not extract a promise, that they were making no promises.
Deputy Lemass came in here with newspaper cuttings. We could bring newspaper cuttings to show that if one took up the newspapers every day and read the speech of Deputy de Valera, there was not a word of policy in it or a word about Fianna Fáil. The whole speech was devoted to an effort to extract from the Leader of the members of the Government promises so that he could then play his own tune on them. At some of his own meetings, Deputy Lemass was rempant from the platform and at one meeting in particular, where the present Taoiseach was due to speak, he became almost hysterical on the Fianna Fáil platform. He said: "He is there now. Make him answer me. Make him promise you." The Irish Press came out the following morning with a streamer headline: “Fine Gael refuses to promise.”
Comment on this
"They would not tell the people what they were going to do." Was not that the whole tenor of the Opposition campaign during the election? Does not every one of your supporters in the country know it?
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Deputy is blind or whether he cannot read, but he must also be deaf.
Comment on this
He could read the Fine Gael literature with the 1951 prices on it. Deputy Lemass tried to pin the Deputy on that, and well the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
The lower taxes and better times will come. I notice Deputy de Valera has a good laugh at that.
Comment on this
I could not help thinking when listening to Deputy Lemass pouring out this nonsense, how solemnly Deputy de Valera recently asked to keep faith with the people and to trust the people and how often he has appealed for truth in public life.
Comment on this
His desire to help in the working of that policy and in being constructive was the speech made by Deputy Lemass. Was that speech by Deputy Lemass an attempt at being constructive? Is this series of amendments put down here for a constructive or a destructive purpose?
Comment on this
It is to educate the people in certain political tactics.
Comment on this
They will understand the Deputy now very soon.
Comment on this
The Deputy made only one promise. Here is an extract which is headed: "They are making you pay through the nose."
Comment on this
There is no doubt in the world about that. By the way, when the Deputy was reading I noticed that he read a circular which was circularised by Deputy Norton. Perhaps the Deputy would also read the circular that he himself circularised to the manufacturers and tell us the result?
Comment on this
Over the name of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and not over the name of the Honorary Secretary or Treasurer of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I read it very carefully. I have it here. I commented on it four times publicly and the Deputy did not come back on it during the election campaign. That was sailing pretty close to the wind, very close to the wind. Truth in public life! With regard to all the extracts Deputy Lemass read a while ago there was one thing missing, one thing which did not appear in any of the extracts and that was that those reductions would be made immediately.
Comment on this
The Deputy is at his old tricks. He is talking about the rate at which he put them on.
Comment on this
We are not going to spend £4,000,000 on Dublin Castle and there are a few more if you want them. The fact of the matter is that this is just an attempt to try and put it across the people outside, in a most dishonest way. It is not going to work. It will not deceive anybody in this country and it will not enhance the prestige or credit of the Fianna Fáil Party or the Deputy's own prestige. The Deputy is lending himself to a manoeuvre this evening that should be far beneath him.
Comment on this
Okay, accept the amendments and get on with the business.
Comment on this
Is not that the cheap sort of gibe we expect from the Deputy? The Deputy will not shake one person in the country and will not shake one vote in this House by his tactics.
Comment on this
We are much more concerned about reducing the oppressive load upon the people than the Deputy is, and we will do it. The people have seen to it that we got the time to do it. They will not tolerate any opposition that is sponsored either by Deputy de Valera or by Deputy Lemass to try and prevent the Government getting on with the work and working towards that end.
Comment on this
We are trying to help you to carry out the policy you enunciated during the election.
Comment on this
We will carry out the policy we set out to fulfil, and all the arrogant claims of being watchdogs are not going to influence us one way or the other. The Fianna Fáil Party and their leaders still talk as if nobody in this House had the right to speak for the Irish people but them. I do not want to quote one of the arrogant speeches given by Deputy de Valera since the election.
Comment on this
The same as the election promises. I am going to say what I set out to say and I am not going to be deterred from saying it. I am telling Deputy Lemass that he is wasting his time and is doing no harm to the Government or to those who support the Government. He is not only doing no good to his own Party but doing it positive harm. There is no use in Deputy Lemass getting up, as he did last week, and telling us that they would be helpful in their criticism, that they would be constructive and would only criticise the Government where the Government was doing something wrong.
You are not going to shift from your own shoulders by a series of amendments like these the responsibility for the position we are in. Why did you not let Deputy de Valera do the right thing when he wanted to do the right thing for once at least? The only time you interfered with him, and successfully, was when you prevented him from holding the general election immediately after the by-elections.
Comment on this
It is a thing which I know very much better than you.
Comment on this
You are talking about something that you cannot know.
Comment on this
And you always take very good care that there will be more than one meaning that can be taken from what you say.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought not to be so cocksure. The Deputy himself as a Deputy was taught a little lesson in the election. There was a motion moved in this House to hold the election, to go to the people in sufficient time to allow an alternative Government to bring in a Budget of their own and a Finance Bill of their own, and you refused.
Comment on this
To allow a lot of misrepresentation also—that is what you wanted.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot get away from it—if we are in the position to-day that we have to bring in a Fianna Fáil Finance Bill, the Fianna Fáil Party and nobody else is responsible for it. They voted in this House against a motion framed for the purpose of giving the people an opportunity of expressing their views and returning a new Government, and giving that Government sufficient time to bring in its own Budget and its own Finance Bill, and all the blather you are going on with there, with a series of amendments——
Comment on this
You cannot blame that Deputy. He has not much experience of some of the gentlemen on the Front Benches opposite. He probably honestly believes some of what Deputy Lemass has stated this evening, but he will get to know Deputy Lemass as time goes on, and to know his leader also.
Comment on this
Maybe he will even get to know me. He certainly would not have as much difficulty in getting to know Deputy Morrissey as in getting to know Deputy de Valera. I am afraid I am a lot more transparent, and I am certainly very, very far— miles—from being as subtle as the Leader of the Opposition.
Comment on this
I think I am getting as close to it, with respect, as Deputy Lemass did. He certainly made an excellent Second Reading speech. He was even prepared to compromise, apparently because he was not sure of his ground. The Deputy is not very ready to give away anything.
Comment on this
Will you take a penny off the pint instead of threepence?
Comment on this
I am very glad that you reminded me of that. This is being very helpful. The Deputy is one of the two members of the Front Bench opposite who in 1951 gave a solemn assurance, a solemn promise, that those duties would not be put back by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
The Minister said not only that they would not be reimposed but that there was no reason why they should be reimposed; but in the 1952 Budget not only were those duties on beer and spirits and cigarettes reimposed but in the Budget speech itself—and I am emphasising this, and the speech can be produced —the Minister for Finance said that they should never have been taken off. That is in the Budget speech.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot quote it because it was not in it.
Comment on this
All right, we will get a copy of the Budget speech for 1952 and I will quote it for you. Of course these interruptions by Deputy Lemass are to go into the Irish Press to-morrow morning but what I said will not go into the Irish Press. This whole debate, this whole series of amendments, is staged for the Irish Press.
Comment on this
And of course it will, unfortunately, fool a number of the readers of that paper—a diminishing number, I grant you. I do not say a diminishing number of readers, but a diminishing number of people who are ready to swallow everything they see in the Irish Press. The Deputy talks about promises. Did or did not Deputy de Valera solemnly promise verbally, and sign it in writing, that he would not touch the food subsidies?
Comment on this
I said it not before, but after, the general election. Before there was an election I said that this House and the people in this House were there to deal with it afterwards.
Comment on this
The Deputy said it when it was only a matter of two votes and he wanted to get the four Independents rejected by the people to vote for him.
Comment on this
Those people who were here are well able to pass judgment on anything I said.
Comment on this
And because they did pass judgment on them you are talking from where you are. You are no longer here; but whether the Deputy said it before or after the election the fact of the matter is that you did say it—not merely say it but wrote it down that you would not touch the food subsidies. But you flagrantly and deliberately broke that promise.
Comment on this
I want to make my statement. You did not go to the electorate until you were forced to. We spent two years trying to get you to go to the country and you would not go. Only that you had to make your broadcast that night immediately the result of the election came in Deputy Lemass would have been able to get at you.
Comment on this
You are completely wrong. On the contrary the argument was the other way around.
Comment on this
Not at all. We know you a bit better than that. Tell us about the definite promise, the written statement in the 15-point or the 17-point programme. Tell us about that. It does not matter where it was broken, but it was broken.
Comment on this
You cannot give it to the House without giving it to the people, because, when you give it to the House, you give it to the people and the representatives of the people.
Comment on this
I am not trying to get away with anything. That was a very definite and flat-footed statement that was made.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot get out of it. He cannot say that he is being misquoted because not merely was it given verbally, but it was written into the Budget. If it had been given only verbally, no doubt he would get out of it—he would have been misreported, misrepresented or something else—it is always one or the other. That was written into the 17-point programme and Deputy Lemass cannot get away from the fact that both he and Deputy MacEntee did give to the people of this country an assurance that these duties would not be reimposed, and so false was that statement that it was written into the Budget speech that not only were they being reimposed but they should never have been removed.
Does the Leader of the Opposition still think, even after the results of the recent general election, that he can fool all the people all the time? Does he think for a moment that anybody, either inside or outside the House, is going to be fooled by this childish— to describe it as childish is to dignify it—attempt to fool? What the Leader of the Opposition and Deputy Lemass are trying to do is to see if they can create any division between the Parties supporting the Government, if they can create any split. That is the whole aim of this, but it will not succeed. This Government will carry out its promises.
Comment on this
We will answer for that to this House and to the people of the country. The people took good care, when they made a change, to give to this Government a majority that will enable it to carry out the programme and to remain here long enough to carry it out.
Comment on this
Five years this Government is going to have and all the efforts being made will not do any good from the Fianna Fáil point of view. The harm will not be done to the Government and it will not have any effect on those who are supporting the Government, but it can have— I hope it will not—a bad effect outside on the country, on its industry, its trade, its commerce and its economic position. I do not say that that is the intention, but one is tempted to say it.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Deputy does not resist temptation. It is a great pity for everybody on that side that he did not resist the temptation to put down these amendments. I doubt if he himself was the person who thought of this scheme and I am sorry he allowed himself to be talked into being the spearhead in this House of other people. I grant you that, when something like this has to be done, the Leader of the Opposition has not got a very wide choice as to who will do it, but it is going to fail.
It has one object and one object only. These amendments are not framed in the interests of the people; they are not framed with any belief in them or in the honesty of their sponsors; they are not framed with any idea of doing any good. They are framed deliberately and put forward here for the purpose of trying to do harm. There is no question about that.
Deputies opposite ought to realise that the people in this country cannot be as easily fooled now as they were in the past years, that we are dealing with a different outlook in the country, that we are dealing with a younger generation, with a generation that wants to get away from the type of politics we have had in this country for many years. We are dealing to-day with people who are concerned with getting an opportunity to live in their own country and to get a living in it. We are dealing with people outside who do not believe that we can afford the millionaire mentality which has been disclosed by Fianna Fáil down through the years. We are dealing with those outside and inside who are concerned that first things should come first.
This Government was elected on a 12-point programme. That programme was framed and circulated and that programme will be carried into effect. There is nobody in the House, or outside it, on this side or on that side, who believes for a moment or expects for one second that that programme can be fulfilled within a month or 12 months of the Government taking office. But the programme will be fulfilled; the savings will be made; the extravagance will be cut out; the waste will be eliminated; and the crazy, unproductive schemes will be liquidated. We showed from 1948 to 1951 that we had a constructive programme. We showed that we were not afraid to spend money in this nation.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows much better than I that the spending of money in itself is not the important point, but the way in which it is spent and on what it is spent. I said we spent it on constructive programmes, on constructive projects, on something which was going to pay it back to us and the nation and we demonstrated that. Deputies on the opposite side should get this into their heads, that the Irish people have a lot more sense and intelligence than politicians are sometimes inclined to give them credit for.
Comment on this
The Deputy can also say "Hear, hear!" when I give him the piece of evidence upon which I base that point. I showed how the Deputy got his majority in 1951 with his 17 points and how the desire of the people for the continuation of the inter-Party Government was flouted on that occasion. The people, when they got the chance—and it took a long time to get the Deputy to give them the chance—showed beyond yea or nay that they wanted inter-Party government and they showed—and this is where I mark their intelligence and wisdom—not only that they wanted inter-Party government from now onwards, but, in no unmistakable way, their detestation of those primarily responsible for depriving them of inter-Party government in 1951, because the four Deputies who were primarily responsible for that deprivation were rejected by them. The issue in the election——
Comment on this
You are getting away from taxation. Stick to taxation. That is what we are talking about.
Comment on this
He cannot resist it. As long as he is campaigning, as long as he is sitting in this House, no matter how well he tries, he always reacts when somebody gets under the guard. I know he can have the poker face at times and sit there with a face like a marble statue.
Comment on this
I am not doing badly at all and well you know it. I was explaining, Sir, that there were two issues in the election. I grant you that taxation and the cost of living were a very important issue in the election but there was another issue. That was the issue, if you like, that we made but the Leader of the Opposition, the then Taoiseach, made this issue for his Party. The people were asked to vote—and this was fundamental—for a single-Party Government or an inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
——in which he quoted speeches made by every leader and member of the Parties that go to make the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
His case was against the inter-Party Government. I want again to repeat this, that the word "immediate" was the one word that was missing from any of the quotations which he gave. But when the Deputy is again talking about promises and when his colleagues are talking about promises, there are two promises I want them to address themselves to, the promise not to touch the subsidies and the promise not to reimpose the duties on beer, spirits and tobacco.
Comment on this
I must say the Fine Gael Party are good pickers when they want to throw out a smokescreen. Deputy Morrissey is the Labour man who was swallowed by Fine Gael and he was a good selection to put forward to cover up the Fine Gael Minister for Finance to-night in the Dáil. When you boil down Deputy Morrissey's speech the only excuse he had for voting against the amendment put down by Deputy Lemass was that it was not really fair to ask Fine Gael to change the Budget in the middle of the financial year or when three months of the financial year were gone. By inference, Deputy Morrissey wanted to convey to the people who are still left in the Labour Party, after he departed from it, that if this had been the first month of the financial year in which we were discussing this thing we would reduce beer, spirits, income-tax, and so on, down to the 1952 level.
But that was not the attitude of Fine Gael in 1948. They did not complain when they came in in February. 1948, that the year was so far advanced, as Deputy Morrissey said, that they really could not change the financial structure, that they could not, because there were ten months of the year gone, reduce the tax on beer or cigarettes. They did it even though there were ten months of the financial year 1948-49 gone. This time there are still nine months to run if the Fine Gael Party wanted to reduce the taxation on beer, cigarettes, income-tax and all the rest. If they wanted to do it it could be done now as it was in February, 1948.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins was not in then. Will he keep quiet for a moment? The reason was given by Deputy Morrissey. It was also given by the Minister for Finance here on the last occasion we were discussing this matter, that we were not reducing beer, cigarettes, tobacco and income-tax to the 1951-52 level as was promised because two months of the financial year had gone and it could not become operative in this financial year, but it could become operative in 1948, even though there were ten months of the financial year gone.
Another point of Deputy Morrissey's was that during the election the people voted not to throw high taxation and high prices overboard as they were promised on every hoarding and on every platform in the country by Fine Gael but to have a Coalition Government. There was more than a Coalition Government promised. It was not a single-purpose cow that was for sale; it was an all-purpose cow. It was not only a Coalition Government that was promised but a Coalition that would reduce taxation back to the 1952 level, and do it in ten months—reduce prices back to the 1951 level.
That was the tri-purpose cow that was for sale and that the people bought and now they find it is only a single-purpose cow, an old screw that will give no milk and put no beef on her back; all she has is a few bones. You have the bones of a Government but the meat that was promised and the milk that was promised of lower taxation and lower prices are gone by the board and they have the old screw left.
Comment on this
If the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party were really in earnest when they promised the tri-purpose cow during the election they would produce it, but the fact is that they were trying to fool the people into the belief that we could have a certain level of Government expenditure here, we could have a high standard of life, that nobody need work and that nobody need pay for it. All the people would have to do was to elect any of these groups in sufficient numbers to form a Government and then the sky was the limit. Everything would fall into their lap—lower taxation, lower prices. The people can see now that that was just so much hoodlum and that all the Coalition groups wanted was their votes, not an opportunity to lower prices and lower taxation.
The reason that we put on these taxes was because we had to put them on. At least the voting on these amendments will show the people that the Coalition groups now realise that the present level of taxation is necessary and they are prepared to take responsibility for it. If they do not think that level of taxation necessary, then let them vote with us. If, however, they vote for it we will know, and the people will recognise, that what they said all around the country was untrue and that they knew it to be untrue when they were saying it.
Comment on this
Deputy Aiken used the one word I believe most suitable for this whole masquerade of political hypocrisy introduced by Deputy Lemass in connection with these amendments. The word used by Deputy Aiken was "hoodlum". Nothing could describe so perfectly the contribution of Deputy Lemass, the interjections of his leader and the follow-up of Deputy Aiken.
Deputy Lemass spent some time in drawing attention to the fact that, in their belief, it is not possible to give this remission of taxation. Encouraged by their leader, Fianna Fáil are going so far as to say that if they were in Government to-night there would be no question whatsoever of a reduction in taxation.
Already an hour and ten minutes has gone in quoting speeches made by candidates during the election campaign, including those of members of the Labour Party as well as all the other Parties, in an effort to draw attention to allegedly false statements made by Deputies who are now members of this Assembly. Does it not strike Deputy Lemass that he is equally proving the case against himself for every word that he is trying to prove against us? Does Deputy Lemass not realise that he is now trying to say the reverse of what he said during the election campaign?
Comment on this
He will have on the amendment that he has just moved here the support of Deputy Aiken and of his leader. Deputy Lemass is the one member of Fianna Fáil who is now proving himself politically incompetent in relation to the statements he made during the election campaign. Indirectly, perhaps, they are saying to the members of the Labour Party that Fianna Fáil has 60 odd seats; we have only 18 or 19. It is obvious that the line of attack is directed towards one group on this side of the House; Fianna Fáil is endeavouring to cuddle the Labour Party in order to get that Party's support. For three years I believed Deputy Lemass to be politically honest and sincere. Truly, experience teaches. May I ask the Leader of the Opposition if the members of the Labour Party to-night voted with smug members of the Opposition Front Bench—and we know that under the Constitution a Government must, as it were, hand in its chips if it is defeated on a Financial Resolution—would they then tell the people that we were political hypocrites?
I do not think it necessary to waste time on this except to pin the attention of the Leader of the Opposition. I do not worry about Press advertisements. I believe all that is just so much cheap talk, unworthy of this national Assembly in which we should interest ourselves in trying to get on with the work of the country rather than waste money paying 2d. or 3d. for daily papers out of which to cut and file certain things.
On the 2nd June last, the first day this new Dáil met, at column 47 of Volume 146 of the Official Report, Deputy de Valera referring to the miserable 13 per cent. that kept himself in power for so long, said:—
"As far as we, as an Opposition, are concerned, if we at any time are appealed to in connection with matters of that sort——"
That is, to oppose the will of the 13 per cent. that he thought were going to overrun the country,
"——we will support what we think right and give support to any people who stand out against being driven in that particular way."
On 2nd June, Deputy de Valera was telling the members of the Fine Gael Party—not of the Labour Party—that if there was a danger of the miserable 13 per cent. making too many demands, Fine Gael could be assured of the support of the Deputy and his Party. The tables are turned now. He is now speaking as if we would be prepared to go with him. Let Deputy Lemass put that on his file and let the Leader of the Opposition realise that the less time wasted on political humbug and fraud in this Assembly and the sooner we get on with the work of Government and Opposition the better it will be for the country and for the Fianna Fáil Party themselves.
Comment on this
There are a few more quotations the Dáil might like to hear. In the Midland Tribune of the 5th May there appeared the following advertisement: “They are making you pay through the nose. The Fianna Fáil Government increased the price of cigarettes by 8d., of the pint by 9d., of the loaf by 3d., and so forth. The two Fianna Fáil candidates who are seeking your votes in this election stand for these increases. You can get rid of them by voting for Dan Morrissey.” In another advertisement it stated. “The Labour Party seeks the support of the people in the forthcoming election so that they can bring about a reduction in the price of tobacco, cigarettes, beer and spirits— Vote No. 1 Dan Desmond.”
Comment on this
On a point of order. I do not object to Deputy Lemass reading these things in the slightest, but might I point out that this amendment deals solely with income-tax? If the Deputy wishes we will discuss all the amendments together. I shall be perfectly happy to do that. If, however, the Deputy only wishes to discuss income-tax on this amendment, is it not better to keep to Standing Orders?
Comment on this
The main discussion will be on this amendment. I promise I will not refer to the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy can make any references he likes. Are we discussing all the amendments together or merely the one that is before the House? I will be quite satisfied to accept it either way.
Comment on this
We are discussing specific policy on this amendment.
Comment on this
I will confine myself to that. May I, for the enlightenment of Deputy Desmond, give this further quotation? It is from a speech made by Deputy Dunne and is reported in the Meath Chronicle of the 15th May:—
"Before Labour would participate in a Government with any Party or group of Parties they would insist on the price of bread, butter, tea——"
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I have a ruling on the question I put as to whether we are dealing with income-tax alone or with all the amendments together? I am quite willing to have it whichever way the Opposition wish, but they cannot have it both ways.
Comment on this
The Minister's point of order is a bit belated. Was the Minister listening to Deputy Morrissey?
Comment on this
I pointed out on the first amendment that I was raising the issue of the redemption of election pledges by Deputies on the other side of the House. It is true that the first amendment deals only with income-tax. If you like, the Chair can put amendment No. 1 now, and I can deal with the specific matters of tobacco, beer and spirits on the subsequent amendments. Perhaps the quotations which I have yet to read will be more relevant on these amendments.
Comment on this
We have now got from Deputy Lemass a very clear explanation of the purpose of these amendments. The Deputy did not utter a single word in the whole of his first speech or of his second speech about income-tax. Neither had we a single word about it from Deputy Aiken. That shows what little purpose they had in considering constructively the material that had been put down. I do not know whether it would be parliamentary for me to use the only word that I think I could use as regards the performance that we have had from the Opposition. I will content myself by using two words which describe, I think, the attitude that has been adopted here by the Opposition. The words are very popular amongst children, and they are "sour grapes". This whole performance has been nothing but an exhibition of sour grapes by the Deputies beyond. Deputy de Valera, when speaking here on 15th June last, at column 146, said:—
"The Government Parties having made, as we believe, false promises to the electorate, we are not going to force them to a still bigger crime against the country, that is, the keeping of the false promises."
Are we to take it that there is another split in Fianna Fáil, and that Deputy de Valera has been thrown overboard?
Comment on this
I am taking the Deputy at his own valuation. When the Deputy comes to the amendments with which he was dealing earlier, I may have a little to say on them also. We see now quite clearly what the position is. Deputy Lemass puts down an amendment and never utters one word about it. When he is challenged which way he would wish to have the debate, he runs away from the particular amendment that is in question.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is under some obligation to the House to explain why income-tax cannot be reduced? Is he going to ask the House to vote against the amendment without giving a single reason against it?
Comment on this
The country knows what the position is, and none of this play-acting by Deputy Lemass is going to change the views of the country in that respect. I know that Deputy Lemass is in a difficult position because I know that he is fighting a case in which he himself does not believe. I know that he is fighting a case— that he is in a position in which he himself would rather not be. I know why he was made fight this case by the Party and made do it. The Deputy knows as well as I know what are the facts in that regard.
Comment on this
Tell the House and do not be keeping that secret between us.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows perfectly well that there is a very distinct cleavage of opinion, not merely in the Fianna Fáil Party in this House but in the Fianna Fáil Party throughout the country. Some would wish to take the line of cheap attempted manae joinuvres, such as these amendments are, while others would wish to take a constructive line. The Deputy's Party has chosen the cheap line, and the only words in which I can adequately describe that are, "sour grapes".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 1, in the name of Deputy Lemass. I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In sub-section (3), lines 53 and 54, to delete "nine pounds five shillings" and substitute "five pounds, twelve shillings and sixpence".
All these amendments up to amendment No. 7 stand or fall together and have one purpose which I am sure will appeal to Deputies opposite, namely to reduce the tax on beer by 3d. per pint, that is, to the level at which it stood before 1952. If Deputies opposite will help me by repeating in this debate the relevant extracts from their election speeches, the case for this amendment will be overwhelming. Every Deputy opposite during the election campaign promised a reduction in the tax on beer and will, no doubt, be anxious to redeem that promise now if the Party Whips will let him. I urge even a brief revolt from the tyranny of the Party Whip, if Deputies want to fulfil their election promises. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Davin, was one of those who gave a most specific pledge in that regard.
Comment on this
May I advise Deputies opposite that if any Deputy is liable to get suddenly ill, we shall examine his medical certificate with great care? I hope they will all be present when the division is taken. They all waxed eloquent about the poor man's pint during the three weeks of the election campaign. There is an amendment down to-day to do what you said you would do—to bring the tax back to the pre-1952 level. Are you going to vote for it? Your pledges are on record. Are you going to repudiate them or vote for the amendment? Before I sit down, there is one important point I should like to mention. I do not think it is good enough for the Minister for Finance to brush off these amendments as mere Party manaejoinuvres.
Comment on this
I want you to take them as seriously as you pretended to take them a few years ago.