Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1954—Committee.
Contributions 191–381 of 381. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1954 ›
That is not so. We went out to the electorate and we said the taxes were necessary to balance the Budget and to provide the Government with money to finance necessary expenditure. You said these taxes were unnecessary, did you not?
Comment on this
I agree. They said they were unnecessary. Are they unnecessary or are they not? Is there not an obligation on some Minister or some Deputy opposite to stand up and explain to the House, and through the House to the country, why it is necessary to keep these taxes at their present level? What has happened since the 2nd June except a change of Government——
Comment on this
There may be some sense in the Deputy's interjection but I cannot see it. There are sitting in this House a number of Deputies who promised the electors in the most definite terms that, if they were returned, they would vote for a reduction in the tax on beer. They are now apparently going to vote against the reduction and they say there is no obligation on them to explain why. Why is there not? Is this taxation necessary? Will the Minister say, in as many words, that he cannot accept this amendment to reduce the tax on beer because he wants money to balance the Budget?
Comment on this
Is this money wanted or is it not? Deputy Morrissey a moment ago said that this was a Fianna Fáil Finance Bill. It is nothing of the kind. It is a Bill produced by the present Coalition Government and brought to the House by the Coalition Government. It is being passed on their recommendation and by the votes of Coalition Deputies. Is that not so? So far as I am personally concerned, as a member of the previous Government, I never saw this Bill produced to the House until I was in opposition. It is true that the main purpose of the Bill is to implement the Budget which Deputy MacEntee introduced last May, but is that what you said to the electorate—that you were going to implement the Fianna Fáil Budget? Is there one of you who said it? Did not every Deputy opposite give the electorate to understand in his election speeches, in his election address, through canvassers and through advertisements in the newspapers, that he was seeking election for the purpose of reducing the level of taxation which that Budget involved?
Comment on this
Well, I shall have to go back again on my quotations.
Comment on this
This is what Deputy Davin said:—
"So far as the Labour Party is concerned, the principal item in our programme in this election is the reduction of taxation on all essential commodities to the same level, or as nearly as possible to the same level, as it stood before the Budget——"
Comment on this
Is this as near as the Deputy is prepared to go?
Comment on this
This is what the Deputy said:—
"I pledge my word of honour to the people of this area that if I am elected, as I hope to be, I undertake with my colleagues to use that power given to us by the votes of the people to force whatever new Government is elected on June 2nd to bring down these prices to the lowest possible figure."
Comment on this
When will the Deputy do it? Will the Deputy put a date on it?
Comment on this
This is what Deputy Dunne said—the quotation that I was about to read when the point of order was raised on the previous amendment:—
"Before Labour would participate in a Government with any Party or groups of Parties they would insist that the prices of bread, butter, tea, sugar, cigarettes, tobacco and the worker's pint must be reduced and reduced immediately."
Is that specific enough? How quick is "immediately"? Deputy Dunne said they were going to get that assurance before they joined the Government. Will Deputy Davin now say whether they got that assurance and was there a date put on it?
Comment on this
The question at issue here is the redemption of pledges given by Deputies opposite. That is the only question at issue. Every Deputy knows that all he has to do in a couple of minutes' time is to turn to the right at the head of that stairs and he will have fulfilled his election pledge to reduce the price of the worker's pint and, if he turns to the left, he is voting against it. I warn that the name of every Deputy who turns left will be taken down and, at the next election, outside every pub there will be handed out a leaflet and on that leaflet will be the name of every Deputy who this evening votes against the reduction in the tax on beer.
Comment on this
Before the Minister concludes, surely all the Deputies who were so voluble around the country have something to say about the price of the pint? How many hours were spent and how many millions of words were spoken in these last three years on the price of the pint? How many tears were wrung from the thirsty citizens around the country about the iniquity of Fianna Fáil in raising the pint? I wish the people who voted and who heard the Deputies opposite since 1952 complaining about the iniquity of Fianna Fáil in raising the price of the poor man's pint could be here this evening to see their sneers and their jeers and their sniggers when they are reminded about what they said to the people whose votes they hoped to get, and did get in some cases, on those speeches and on their promises to reduce the price of the poor man's pint. The speech was: the working man was entitled to it; Fianna Fáil were criminals, they were unjust, when they increased the price of the poor man's pint and they were going around in their high-powered motor-cars.
Comment on this
I am sticking to the pint. I would like that the voters who heard these people ranting about the Fianna Fáil injustice in raising the price of the poor man's pint could be here to see the sniggers at the wonderful fellows they are at having so deceived the people that they would reduce the price of the pint. It was not in the distant future that the price of the pint was to be reduced. That was to be done immediately. It was not in the dim and distant future that taxation of all kinds was to be reduced; it was to be done as quickly in 1954 as it was done in 1948. All round the country they said: "Fianna Fáil will tell you that taxation cannot be reduced. Of course it can be reduced. They put on unjust and unnecessary taxation. We will reduce it and we will reduce it as quickly in 1954 as we did in 1948." What was done in 1948? There was no excuse made then that the financial year was too far through to reduce the price of beer, cigarettes and tobacco. Even though the financial year was ten months through, it was not too late to reduce taxation. This financial year is only a couple of months through. The people are getting a lesson from the sniggers of the gentlemen who went around the country saying that this taxation was unnecessary and unjust. They are getting a lesson from seeing the gentlemen who so proclaimed it voting for it.
Comment on this
I do not think I have ever heard more shamelessly political speeches on a financial matter than we have heard here to-night. Deputy Lemass and Deputy Aiken accuse us of going back on our words. We have not gone back on our words but they have gone back on the Budget that they brought in themselves. They accuse the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party and the other Parties who are associated with the Government. Did they accuse them during the election of being extravagant in their promises? Yes, they did. They said that. They said in connection with the Budget that they brought in that not one halfpenny could be taken off and yet now they are walking into the Lobby in defiance of their own words for a purely political reason. There is no financial probity or financial sense associated with that.
We have to administer the revenues as we find them. We have been in only two or three weeks. We will reduce costs but what we first have to do is to reduce the extravagant set-up which has been built up here over years of Fianna Fáil administration. That cannot be done on this Budget but will be done by this side of the House as quickly as it can be done. That is what the country will listen to. We on this side of the House have laughed at the effrontery of a Party who brought in a Budget, said it could not be reduced and now walk into the Lobby and calmly vote against their own propositions which they assured the electorate could not be reduced in any way.
Comment on this
I wonder could I induce the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Deputy O'Donovan, to rise to his feet and to explain to the House in the precise, calculated way in which he explained to another house——
Comment on this
I am asking Deputy O'Donovan would he rise to his feet and explain, in the same precise, calculated manner as he explained in another house the proposition that taxation and cost of living could be reduced by a reduction in the tax on beer and spirits. On that occasion he said that if liquor and beer could be reduced in price the consumption increase would be so great that there would be moneys available for subsidies and so forth.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary says that he said nothing of the kind. Last week I said something similar. What the Parliamentary Secretary said was published in the Press. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary now to say whether he did or did not say that, whether or not that was his answer to my question as to how you can reduce taxation and the cost of living.
There was a great number of witnesses. It was a gathering of intelligent people, and I remember the noise and the cheers and the applause——
Comment on this
I remember the noise when you put that interpretation on it and the jeers you got and the raspberry you got.
Comment on this
——the cheers and the applause that were accorded the Deputy when he said that beer was going to be cheaper. I should like the Deputy to tell us whether since he became a Deputy he considers that possibly that proposition was wrong. Deputy Dockrell is very hurt and upset that we should have the effrontery to get up here and propose to amend the Finance Bill for which we were responsible.
Comment on this
One of the things outstanding in the election and which was to copperfasten the promises made was the continual reference to the fact that if there were a change of Government there was going to be an end to starvation by these reductions. If starvation is rampant, how long can they people exist; how long can they remain alive in circumstances of starvation? If it were true then and true now, then something must be done to bring down the cost of living in order to end starvation.
Deputy Dockrell ought to realise that Fianna Fáil were abused throughout the whole campaign for what was called their iniquitous Budget. It was described as an austerity Budget. It was stated that there was no need for austerity and that in various ways reliefs could be brought in to make it easier for the public.
When we were contesting the election, we tried to advise the people not to fall for these false promises. In the summing-up by the electorate of the position they were faced with, if the inter-Party Government could find ways and means of doing all the things they said they were going to do, then I say the public, in making their choice, were quite right. If the inter-Party Government were to reduce taxation and bring down the cost of living, reduce the beer and spirit taxes and balance their Budget without imposing hardships in future on the people by so doing, the people would have been perfectly right in making the choice they did. But what we are doing here is to show the public, by this effort of ours to get the inter-Party Government to do what they led the people to believe they were going to do, that they either did it or did not do it. If we can get that shown, then the public will know whether they chose wisely or well, or whether in fact groups of Parties were bought purely for the sake of office, having sold the public down the river.
Comment on this
I have been 21 years in this House and I always said Fianna Fáil were dishonest. I cannot stand listening to such hypocrisy. In 1949, they said they could not get along without putting an extra 6d. on cigarettes and so much on the pint. We took these off in 1948. They came back in 1951 and said that the country could not exist except they put back these penal taxes. Where are you now? I never saw such dishonesty. I went into politics because I was driven into it by the farmers to fight the dishonesty of Deputy de Valera. It is coming out now.(Interruptions.) Where are some of these farmers now? Some of them have the grass growing over them as a result of what happened in 1934, 1935 and 1936.
Comment on this
Stop this and get down to honesty. I always said you were dishonest. Many farmers were sent to an early grave by this.
Comment on this
I represent the intelligent voters who were not bluffed by the manoeuvres and the leaflets with the 1/2 pint on one side and the 1/- pint on the other side. These were shoved into every door in my constituency. On top of that, we had Deputy Morrissey down there. What was Deputy Morrissey's reply when he was asked whether this could be done or not. He said: "Did we not do it in 1948? In 1948 we removed the penal taxes on beer, cigarettes and tobacco." Was that a guarantee that they were going to do it again? Certainly, it was a guarantee. Much play has been made about the numbers in the Government Party now. Deputy O'Malley hit the nail on the head the other day when he said it was a "Tale of two Cities". It could not be described in any other way than as a "Tale of two Cities".
In the 1951 election there was a purchase price of £2,000,000, or 1/8 in the £ on the back of every ratepayer, to buy the votes of the local government officials. In 1954, it was £1,000,000 to buy the votes of the civil servants.
Comment on this
How many times, a Cheann Comhairle, have you and I listened to the wailing of these boys about the poor man's pint? How many times have we seen them weeping and moaning about the poor man's pint? How many times have they talked about the iniquitous Budget? How many times did they walk out of the House in anger because of the burden which they said was being put on the ordinary working man by the increase in the price of the pint which they claimed was a necessity for him? The Government were elected on certain pledges. They gave a number of them and the only pledge which apparently they are prepared to keep is the pledge about the bribe to the civil servants. They have forgotten the ordinary worker and the price of his pint. He has been put to one side and is not to be talked of. He is out of the way now.
This amendment proposes to restore the price of the pint to 1/—in fact, to 11d., which is better still, as they will have 1d. out of the bob now. Now we are providing a fair opportunity for the gentleman over there who has been telling us here, doubtless on the inspired advice that he got from the Licensed Vintners' Association, about the reduction of the value of the pubs in Dublin, how the value has fallen by thousands of pounds on account of the poor man's pint. Now we are giving those gentlemen, whose election funds were well fattened at the recent general election and at the election before it by the Licensed Vintners' Association, an opportunity to keep their word to that association and do their part now by reducing the price of the poor man's pint.
It will not cost that enormous sum that Deputies think. I had this matter out here a few months ago when we were over there on that side of the House. The farmers have already contributed to the reduction of the poor man's pint some £2,000,000. The breweries had authority to increase the price of the pint and when barley went up to 84/- a barrel the price of the pint was increased by 1d., with the authority of the Government.
Comment on this
I am showing how this will not be the burden on the community that people think. Due to the reduction of the price of barley from 84/- to 63/6, there is a big gap that will practically take 1d. off.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir. I am pointing out that there is 1d. there. Surely to goodness, for the sake of one copper would they not come along and do their part? It is only another 1d. I made that plea before to the last Minister.
Comment on this
Some five months ago I made that plea from the very bench in which Deputy McAuliffe is sitting now.
Comment on this
How did Deputy Corry vote on that occasion? He can make that statement, but how did he vote afterwards?
Comment on this
There was no vote on that occasion. As a matter of fact, I raised it on the adjournment.
Comment on this
The fact remains that I have seen those Deputies go into the pubs in my constituency and complain and moan and I have seen those Fine Gael publicans—acting again on the advice of the Licensed Vintners' Association—go round and take the 1s. 2d. We have seen that condition of affairs. Deputies over there are getting an opportunity now to keep their pledges. If it was such an outrageous thing for a Government to increase the price of the pint in the last three years, or during the last six years, surely it is time for that outrage to end? This is the manner in which they can end it. We are doing this because we consider that there should be honesty in political life. We do not believe that a Minister of this State should write a letter in February 1951 refusing to sanction increases in the price of barley and on the 4th May increase the price.
Comment on this
The Deputy is bringing in matters which are totally irrelevant. He will please keep to the amendments—there are several of them.
Comment on this
Beer, for a start. You have already guaranteed to reduce the price of butter—that is, if you are not disarmed before you have to keep that pledge—and, mind you, I would not be at all surprised. In 1948, those gentlemen came into the House and their first job was to remove the taxes —and to borrow to remove them £5,000,000 and put that on the backs of the people for the next 20 years.
Comment on this
There was £17,000,000 that you borrowed and squandered. That is part of the reason why the present Minister for Finance is endeavouring to keep this tax there to-day. When they came in, the principal and interest on public debt was £4,000,000 a year and when they went out there was a load of £10,000,000 a year. That was the reason why those taxes had to be imposed at that time. That is the reason why every Deputy over there now has to swallow every word he said in the last six years here and crawl around to the Lobby and vote against the reduction of the price of the pint. The burden and the load those opposite left after them has now fallen on their own shoulders and they have to carry it. I heard demands made here from those benches on the spirits amendment—are we on the spirits amendment now?
Comment on this
We are on the amendments to Section 13—Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7. There is sufficient opportunity there for the Deputy.
Comment on this
I can guarantee to the Deputy over there that that pint will be sticking to him. Those Deputies over there know now that they have the burden on their shoulders, whether they like it or not, and they are paying for the squandering they did. I do not know where they are going to get it this time. I do not know whether they can borrow as freely as they borrowed on the last occasion.
Comment on this
I can guarantee one thing, that they will be made keep every single pledge that they gave to the electors or they will have to swallow those pledges—one of the two— in this House.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has addressed himself to this House from the point of view of our forgetting the promises we made to the people. I want to refer to some statements made by Deputy Corry not so very long ago. In 1947, when Fianna Fáil introduced the Supplementary Budget and imposed taxation on beer and tobacco, a by-election was fought in County Waterford. I well remember Deputy Corry speaking during that election at Ballymacoda and Killaugh and promising the people that if Fianna Fáil won the by-election the pint would be reduced as a result of that general election. Deputy Corry is not in a position to contradict that statement.
Comment on this
It was a by-election and the Deputy with the late Mr. Ahearne went around to Ballymacoda, Inches and Killaugh. I was there in the presence of the late Minister for Local Government, Deputy Murphy. Deputy Corry made this statement and promised the people that, if they won that by-election, immediately after the by-election the price of the pint would be reduced from 1/2d. He did not say he would reduce it to 10d. but he said he could give a guarantee that it would be reduced to 1/-. That is quite clear.
What exactly was the campaign of the Fianna Fáil agents in the recent general election? I cannot be contradicted on this. The agents of Fianna Fáil in my constituency told the old age pensioners, the infirm and the blind people not to believe the statements we were making but, rather, to believe them. They told the old age pensioners that if they voted for those people they would lose their old age pensions or they would be drastically reduced. Is it not far more honourable at this moment to support the present Government and to vote for them tonight—this Government which has already announced a reduction of 5d. per lb. in the price of butter on the poor man's table? I should much prefer to consider the point of view of the housewives of this country at this particular time than sit on the seat on which Deputy Lemass is sitting——
Comment on this
You were dishonest during the election campaign. Not alone were you dishonest during the general election campaign but you are dishonest in the policy which you are pursuing in this House to-night. What you are doing now is nothing but dishonesty from the point of view of deceiving the electorate and the country at large—if you could succeed in doing it.
Comment on this
In case anybody might, for one moment, believe the figures that were given by Deputy Corry, I had better put the correct figures on the record of the House. Deputy Corry suggested that the figure for service of debt in 1948 was £4,000,000. As a matter of fact it was £4.8 million, but that is pretty good for a person who is as inaccurate as Deputy Corry. Then he went on to suggest that the figure for the service of debt in 1951 was £10,000,000; in fact, the figure was £7.2 million. Furthermore, the figure for the three years in question rose by £2.4 million.
For the benefit of anybody who might be foolish enough to believe Deputy Corry, let us take that and put it in juxtaposition to what occurred during the period from 1951—when Deputy de Valera took over the reins of office—to 1954, three years in which——
Comment on this
The figures that I have quoted here were given in this House in 1952 by the then Minister and were not contradicted.
Comment on this
I do not know what figures were given to the Deputy or how he phrased the question. If you phrase a question in a particular way you can get certain figures sometimes, but these are the true figures—and I know the Deputy does not like the truth.
Comment on this
Of course, anything that is said by Deputy Corry that is offensive will be taken by any decent man as a compliment. In the three years from 1948 to 1951, the figure for the service of debt rose by £2.4 million. In the three years from 1951 to 1954, the annual amount for the service of debt rose not by £2,400,000 but by £5,473,000.
Comment on this
——in the embarrassing position of having the policy adopted by Fianna Fáil during those three years contrasted with that of the three years of inter-Party Government. The liabilities of the State in each of the three-year periods increased by exactly the same amount—£71.9 million in one case and £72,000,000 in the other case. These are gross figures. In our three years of inter-Party Government, the assets side of the balance sheet showed an increase of £68,000,000 but in the three years of Fianna Fáil Government the assets side showed an increase of only £57.3 million—in other words, £11,000,000 less.
Comment on this
When did the Marshall Aid Loan interest become payable for the first time?
Comment on this
The way Deputy Briscoe gets a figure when you are making a comparision obviously is to subtract one from the other. If you take the increase of gross assets in one case and take it in the other case you will find that the comparison results in £11,000,000 against the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
Will the Minister break down the service of debt in the second three-year period? How much of it was Marshall Aid?
Comment on this
The Minister also remembers, as I mentioned the other day, that the day my predecessor walked into his office in Government Buildings he had £22,500,000 of the Marshall Aid Loan available for him to carry on with. The present Minister, myself, knows very well that he has no such money.
Comment on this
The Minister will not be too badly off. He will not even need a national loan this year.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would like me to deal with the short-term borrowing position, I have the figures available here. I do not think the Deputy would like that either.
Comment on this
What is the service of debt for the Marshall Aid Loan, please, for the three years since it began?
Comment on this
Sit down and take your medicine. I was very careful not to interrupt Deputy Lemass even once. The Deputy can put a question and he will get all the information. I was very careful not to interrupt Deputy Lemass, except in accordance with the rules of the House, because I remember hearing Deputy Lemass say on another occasion that he never interrupted anybody. I wanted to see if the Deputy would keep to his expression of hope if he was not prompted, so far as I was concerned.
As I said on the debate on the earlier amendment, this, in fact, is sour grapes. Deputy Lemass did say one thing that was true when he spoke on the earlier amendment, though it was not relevant to that amendment— perhaps I can deal with it now—and that is that it was not the level of prices which affected the people in the last general election. What affected the people in the last general election —and it was not merely a question that arose in Dublin: it arose in my constituency and everywhere else—was that they knew they had been promised by Fianna Fáil in 1951 that if only Fianna Fáil were elected at that time they would get reduced prices. The people knew that not merely had Fianna Fáil failed to keep their promise in that regard but, of their own deliberate action, increased the prices after that. It was anger against the Fianna Fáil administration for the manner in which the people had been duped in 1951 that is responsible for those Deputies being on the other side of the House. It was anger against the Fianna Fáil Deputies for issuing in 1951 the type of leaflet that was issued by my colleague, Deputy Harris, in Kildare in that election and for the way in which that Deputy, as other Deputies who did the same thing came along and threw their promises overboard in 1951 which had the effect of putting the Fianna Fáil Party on the other side of the House.
During the whole course of the general election they were at pains on every possible occasion to indicate, show, shout and publish in the Irish Press and wherever else they could get it printed that the Fine Gael Party and leaders were promising nothing. Now they have changed their tune and the people see quite clearly, judging by the comments which come to me, through the shallowness, the hollowness and duplicity of the type of thing we are hearing now.
Comment on this
I had hoped that the Minister would have answered my question. I do not think it is fair that the Minister for Finance should, by his method of accepting the case made for the amendment, attempt to put on record further misleading figures which, if they are not questioned now, can afterwards be quoted as facts. When the Minister was comparing the three years of Fianna Fáil Government succeeding the three years of inter-Party Government, he referred to a substantial increase in the service of debt charges. If the Minister will not give those figures now, I will give notice that I will put down a question for a parliamentary answer which must be in accordance with the facts, asking him to state the amount of money borrowed from the Americans under Marshall Aid, the amount of money or goods they got gratuitously in their three-years' period in office, the repayment that must be made, when that began to be made and if it had, in fact, to be included in the Fianna Fáil Budget as being free in their period of office for repayment. We can ask that. If the Minister wants to be fair, I think he should be factual.
Comment on this
No. The Minister in his statement just now indicated that as a result of borrowing by Fianna Fáil in their three years of office, succeeding that of the three years of the inter-Party Government, the service of debt charges increased far greater than those the inter-Party Government had brought about by their own borrowing in their time. I say that is not correct. That is definitely misleading, because in the service of debt charges in the succeeding three years there had to be interest payments made to the Americans in dollars as a result of the borrowings made by the inter-Party Government through the Marshall Aid Loan.
Comment on this
I am not going to be drawn into what I call a lawyer's quibble. I just wanted to get the facts clear. This evening we are talking about whether the public were misled or whether we were foolish to take the view that the public were misled by our opponents in the election.
Comment on this
I want to get this correct. Will the Minister now say what was the increase in the service of debt charges at the end of their three years' period of office and at the end of our three years' period of office? Would he say the extent of the amount that concerned the American Marshall Aid Loan when he talked about the previous Minister's predecessors having left him £22,000,000 or £26,000,000?
Comment on this
It was not left there for Fianna Fáil to dispose of as they chose or wished. It was left there to meet commitments already entered into by our predecessors. That has been made perfectly clear.
Comment on this
That is an admission anyway that £22,500,000 which we had in the Exchequer were earmarked for commitments entered into by our predecessors. Now the Minister says he has commitments without the money. I should like to know what commitments he has. Deputy Lemass interjected that in his opinion it will not be necessary for the Minister to borrow in this financial year. Let the Minister say whether that is so or not. If he has to borrow, he will again add to the service of debt charges. I should like to know what are these commitments. If the Minister will not give me those figures now, I will spend an hour this evening drafting the questions to get as comprehensive and as detailed a reply as I can on all these items.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Yes, all those amendments fall with that amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
Before Section 15 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The Finance Act, 1920, as amended by Section 8 of the Finance Act, 1952 (No. 14 of 1952), shall, as and from the 1st day of October, 1954, be amended by the substitution in Part I of the First Schedule to the said Finance Act, 1920, of the matter set out in the Fourth Schedule to this Act for the matter inserted therein by the said Section 8, and sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the said Finance Act, 1920, shall have effect accordingly.
(2) The duty of excise imposed by sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the Finance Act, 1920, shall, as and from the 1st day of October, 1954, be charged, levied and paid at the rate of £6 17s. the gallon (computed at proof) in lieu of the rate chargeable by virtue of sub-section (2) of Section 8 of the Finance Act, 1952.
(3) Nothing in this section shall operate to relieve from or to prejudice or affect the additional customs duties or the additional excise duty in respect of immature spirits imposed by Section 9 of the Finance Act, 1926 (No. 35 of 1926).
This amendment stands in a somewhat different position from that of the others I have moved. Is the Minister accepting it?
Comment on this
I thought he might, because it is true that the increased tax on whiskey imposed in 1952 did not produce, in that financial year, the revenue anticipated. In fact, Deputy MacEntee, as Minister for Finance, had to concede in his Budget statement of 1953 that the whiskey duty had yielded £1,500,000 less than the estimated amount. During the course of the recent election campaign, many references to this duty were made by leading members of the present Government and particularly the Taoiseach. He certainly gave the indication that, in the interests of the revenue, the tax on whiskey would be reduced, and, in fact, I think the only speech I need make in favour of the amendment is a quotation from a speech delivered by the Taoiseach during the election, on 7th May, at Wexford and Enniscorthy. On that occasion he said:—
"I may not be a mathematician, but I am able to add up, and I now challenge the Taoiseach to deny that the meaning of the fresh figures he has disclosed is that, in each of the two years 1952 and 1953, the Government got an average of £50,000 a year less from the higher rate than we got when whiskey was 5d. a glass cheaper in 1951-52.
In 1953-54 the Government only recovered £500,000 of the £600,000 they lost in 1952-53. What good did that extra tax do? The Government got less revenue; the price went up savagely to the consumer; the consumption dropped over the two years by 80,000,000 ‘half-ones'; the incomes of the publicans and distillers dropped and accordingly the income-tax they paid fell; people in public houses and distilleries lost their jobs; and it had been calculated that the farmers got from £150,000 to £200,000 less for their barley."
That is such an overwhelming case for this amendment, if it is true, that I need scarcely add anything to it. If the Taoiseach and his colleagues believe there was sense in that argument, surely they must accept the amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy's remarks, of course, must be taken as part of a picture. I have already made it perfectly clear why the picture cannot be disturbed.
Comment on this
If this argument is right, I am now trying to improve the picture.
Comment on this
Anybody who tries to deal with a matter like the Budget and general financial policy in that piecemeal way will find himself very quickly in difficulties. A matter like financial policy for a whole year should be dealt with as an entity and I regret that I cannot accept the Deputy's contention that we should take one sector and deal with it alone.
Comment on this
The Minister has now carved a niche for himself in history as the first Minister for Finance to refuse additional revenue on the proposition of the Opposition, if that argument of the Taoiseach is correct.
Comment on this
That is asking the Chair to decide upon the validity of Deputy Costello's argument. I will admit that if we cut income-tax, the Government would lose revenue. They said there was a surplus in the Budget and that is why I moved my amendment in that regard. I admit that if the tax on beer were cut, the Government would lose revenue, although there are Deputies opposite who, during the campaign, said that the tax on beer could be reduced without loss to the revenue; but it is undoubtedly the case for this amendment that, if the Taoiseach's arguments are sound, the tax on whiskey can be reduced and the Exchequer will get more money. That cannot possibly upset the Budget— getting more money into the Exchequer. The rejection of this amendment by the Government means that they agree that the present Taoiseach, when speaking at Enniscorthy and Wexford, was talking nonsense.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy understand his own amendment? Did he ever hear of an amendment dealing with spirits which provided that the change should come into force some months in advance? That would be nonsense.
Comment on this
I will accept any reasonable amendment to my amendment which the Minister may propose.
Comment on this
Might I point out to the Minister that during the election they promised that they were going to deal with the financial picture piece-meal. They promised that they were going to do in the 1954-55 Budget what they had done in the 1948-49 Budget.
Comment on this
I want it to be noted that the purpose of this debate is to get the people to realise that the smart Alecs who went around the country promising them the sun, the moon and the stars—a reduction in beer, whiskey, cigaretes and income-tax on the nail—did so with their tongue in their cheeks. When they said that the Fianna Fáil budgetary policy was unjust they did not believe it because if they did they would be forced now to curb the injustice; and when they said that the Fianna Fáil budgetary proposals were unnecessary they did not believe it because if they were unnecessary it would be up to them to abolish the unnecessary taxation. They did not believe it when they told the people that our proposals were unjust, unnecessary or immoral and they made these statements simply from the point of view of fooling the people. It will be a good deal harder for them to fool the people the next time.
Comment on this
We have been listening to two ex-Ministers wasting the time of this House with amendments, men who were in office for almost 20 years and who were the cause of the high cost of living. Deputy Aiken did not tell Dáil Éireann that he was going to introduce a Supplementary Budget in 1947, and when the election came we went to the country and told the people we would support an inter-Party Government, and his Party were put out of office.
The last election was a bread-and-butter election. We want to see food put before whiskey because the poor people are not interested in whiskey. We welcome the announcement of the new Government in regard to the reduction in the price of butter and were it not for the request made to the Government by R.G.D.A.T.A. to give timely notice before any reduction took place, I believe the date of the reduction would have been earlier than that announced.
Is it any wonder that the ex-Taoiseach is sitting there with his hand on his head listening to his ex-Ministers holding up the business of this House while people outside are waiting for some work to be started? It is regrettable that the people who were in Government so long and had increased the price of all essential commodities, should be play-acting, putting down amendments and asking a new Government who must work on their Budget to do everything overnight?
Deputy Lemass and Deputy Aiken will not humbug the working-class people of Ireland by their tactics here. I have every confidence that if the inter-Party Government is given a chance the programme which they put before the people will be carried out. In all fairness, I think the Government should be given a little time.
Comment on this
It will not be 20 years, anyhow. After 20 years of Fianna Fáil rule, our country is in a worse condition than ever and it will take the new Government some time to get to the straight road, towards which the ex-Taoiseach was pointing his finger, for better times and lower taxation. I heard Deputy Lemass speaking in my own town of Enniscorthy on many occasions as far back as 1932. Fianna Fáil have forgotten all the promises they made. The people are disgusted with the present Opposition, the Opposition who said they were going to be helpful but who, after three or four weeks, introduce amendments to reduce the price of whiskey.
For whom? For Americans? The poor man is not interested in the bottle of whiskey. We were glad to see the price of butter reduced and we will be twice as glad when the price of the loaf comes down because these are the necessaries of life and Deputy Lemass will not change one member of the Labour Party by his tactics.
Comment on this
Only for the Labour Party Deputy de Valera would not have become Taoiseach in 1932 and it was on promises to the Labour Party that he was Taoiseach in those years.
Comment on this
I made no promises except the promises that were kept.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputies in the Opposition to be honest with the people who sent them in. They did not send them in here to obstruct but that is what they are doing. If they want to see the country advancing, to see employment started or any progress made, let them join with us here and see that it is done. Of course we know they still want to be what they always were, warmongers.
Comment on this
I want to say a few words about this particular amendment. A very good friend of mine who happens to be a representative of a whiskey and wine merchants company came to me during the election campaign and told me that the retailers in County Mayo refused to take any orders from him because they had been specifically promised by the canvassers of the Fine Gael Party that whiskey would be reduced in price. They not only promised that but they were given the exact date on which whiskey would be reduced from 1/9 to 1/6 a half glass. The date given to the people of South Mayo, to the people who refused to give orders to my friend, was the 10th June, 1954. I wish to issue a challenge to the Minister for Finance on this particular point. If he wishes me to prove the assertion I have made now I can obtain 40 letters from 40 different retailers in County Mayo who were given that specific promise, and I can refer to them during the debate on the Estimate for the Department of the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
There used to be abroad in this country, a very foolish illusion that in the person of Deputy Lemass we had a clever and able politician. It was one to which many people subscribed, many people who voted against his Party. But I am happy to see that he has dispelled that illusion in the last few days for all time. I do not think this Dáil has seen for a long number of years, so brazen an attempt to make political capital in a weak and futile fashion.
Deputy Lemass has moved amendments which, if put into effect would mean that the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party would be completely negatived and a complete reversal of Fianna Fáil policy would take place. Everybody knows—I hope Deputy Lemass is under no illusion about this, and certainly I think the more practical members of his Party are under no illusion about it—what Deputy Lemass is trying to do; he is trying to embarrass the present Administration. There is no sincerity whatsoever in the amendment he has put before the House.
Comment on this
He is endeavouring to use this Parliament in order to buttress up the failing fortunes of the Fianna Fáil Party. In the past he might have succeeded in his object but, with God's good help, he will not succeed in the next five years. I have referred already to the chagrin evidenced by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. To-night there has been a bit of a rally. It is obvious that this effort on the part of the deputy-Leader is to try to put some life back into the corpse that once was Fianna Fáil; there has been some slight evidence of resuscitation, but that is only of a very passing nature. The people are not, although many slick politicians may consider them to be, political neophytes
They are not fools. The people when they went to the polls on the last occasion voted for a change of Government. I have taken an opportunity of consulting as many of those who voted for me with whom it was possible to get into touch since the election. I find they are very satisfied with the progress that has been made in a few weeks. Mark you, in a few weeks! They are very satisfied with the progress towards a reduction in the cost of living. The proposal to reduce butter by 5d. per lb. is a satisfactory one. It is a far more important proposal than the one we are discussing now.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows when it is coming in. The Deputy has heard all about it. What is breaking the Deputy's heart is the fact that it is coming in. I understand I was the subject of some comment on the part of the deputy-Leader of the Opposition earlier this evening. Though the question of the reduction in the pint may not be entirely irrelevant on this amendment, it has a certain relationship to it. Deputy Lemass may not be acquainted with the gravity of that particular beverage, but I assure him it is not possible to reduce the pint with one Act. As a Labour Party representative and as one who told the people that I stood for a reduction in the cost of living, I am satisfied this Government will reduce the cost of living; that it will reduce not alone butter, but bread, tea, sugar, tobacco, cigarettes and the workers' pint.
Comment on this
Long before the Deputy will have an opportunity of making any further misrepresentations to the Irish people at a general election. It is very obvious that these amendments are introduced here in a fit of pique. It amazes me that we should have elected in our Parliament a group of politicians which have shown themselves to be such obviously bad losers. The people are sitting back and laughing at Deputy Lemass and the Fianna Fáil Party. They are laughing at the idea that those now in Opposition should think that the electorate are so foolish as to believe there is one ounce of sincerity in what the Opposition is trying to do here.
They know this is a political stunt and is not intended for the good of the nation in any direction. The people are the final masters and they will eventually give their decision upon the actions of this Government and the actions of the Labour Party. I have no doubt what their decision will be. I do not think the Opposition Deputies have any doubt either. This is merely a time-wasting effort on the part of a broken and beaten Party.
Comment on this
What Deputy Dunne says now is in marked contrast to what he said a month ago. According to the Meath Chronicle on Saturday, May 14th, Deputy Dunne spoke to what is described as a large audience in the Market Square in Navan.
Comment on this
This is the report of the Meath Chronicle. Is the Deputy repudiating the accuracy of the report?
Comment on this
This is what the Meath Chronicle reports Deputy Dunne as saying on Saturday, May 14th last:—
"Before Labour would participate in a Government with any Party, or group of Parties, they would insist that the price of bread, butter, tea, sugar, cigarettes, tobacco and the workers' pint must be reduced, and reduced immediately. Unless they got agreement on that point they would not take part in the formation of a Government."
That is what Deputy Dunne said in the Market Square in Navan a month ago. We are not getting these reductions immediately. Yet, the Deputy is quite pleased about the whole situation. I wonder is the large audience which listened to him at Navan as pleased as he is.
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy tells us. He made suckers out of the people at Navan. That is a term the Deputy understands. He is very happy that they fell for the trick he played on them. They put their votes in the ballot boxes because of the undertaking Deputy Dunne gave, an undertaking he is now happy to repudiate. On the strength of the promise made by Deputy Dunne and by the Government now concerned——
Comment on this
This is the report of a speech made by Deputy Dunne. Deputy Dunne is the good-looking fellow sitting there behind Deputy O'Leary. The Deputy can be very happy about the result. Possibly that explains all the good humour of the Deputies on the Government Benches. The trick they tried worked once. Will it work a second time? The Deputy is gambling on the fact that he will not have to explain for five years.
Comment on this
The supporters of the Government are very bitter in this debate. It is not at all surprising that they are so bitter because they have been found out. They are now being exposed as the political hypocrites they are. I listened to them at the crossroads making promises knowing that they were telling lies. They were making promises that they had not a notion of fulfilling. They were telling the people that they were to reduce the price of the pint, the fag, the bit of tobacco and of course they always ended up by assuring the people that they would have to pay only half what they were paying then for tea, sugar and butter. The fact that they are not fulfilling the promises they made and that they are being exposed as people who made false promises is naturally causing resentment amongst them.
I suppose they thought that we were going to sit on this side of the House and forget what they said in the same way as they are now trying to forget that they fooled the electorate one short month ago. There can be no doubt but that if they had not promised to reduce taxation and the price of stout, whiskey and cigarettes they would not have been able to form a Government. It was these promises that swayed a small percentage of the people in their favour so that now they sit on that side of the House. The fact that they are sitting there is because they did make false promises. Is it any wonder that they should feel ashamed of themselves here to-night.
Comment on this
When this taxation was imposed we heard many of them, like Deputy O'Leary, who were wearing the Pin advocating a reduction in the price of intoxicating liquor. Surely that is contrary to what they profess. Apparently, they are prepared to profess anything and to state anything that will get votes for them. It is no wonder that they are feeling ashamed of themselves. They are being exposed now; they have been found out. I can assure them that we will keep on reminding the people of the fact that they did make false promises. As the former Tánaiste has stated, you tricked the people once, but we assure you that when the people get the opportunity again as soon they will——
Comment on this
—you will then be made realise fully and for all time that a crime like that does not pay.
Comment on this
The one difference that I see between the supporters of the Government and the Opposition is that while both sides spoke in an equally positive way on the question of subsidies and prices during the election campaign, it is quite obvious now that that has been dropped by supporters of the Government. The eloquence with which the Government Parties advocated their programme of reductions is now being replaced merely by sound, vehemence and resentment that their promises are not being forgotten.
The Minister has been asked by Deputy Lemass to accept this amendment for a very good reason, namely, that he wants more money to subsidise a reduction in the price of butter and that he wants it, as his Party and other Parties indicated during the election, to maintain schemes of national development and of public works so that employment may be continued. It was the reference to employment that induced me to rise to my feet. I want to tell the Minister for Finance that by the direct action of one of his Ministers people have been thrown out of their employment in my constituency within the past week. It is all very well for Deputy O'Leary, Deputy Dunne and others to tell us that the price of butter is to be reduced by 5d. per lb., but what about the people who have lost their weekly wage packets and are now on the dole? Was it not better for them to have butter at 4/2 a lb. and to have their weekly wage packets than to have a reduction of a few pence in the price of butter? These were the considerations which induced Fianna Fáil to speak as positively as they did during the election campaign.
Comment on this
The direct action taken by the Minister I have mentioned was responsible for throwing men on the dole. If Deputy O'Leary does not like to hear that, he ought to have the decency to remain silent about it.
Comment on this
That, surely, is no advantage to the people who have lost the entire of their weekly pay packets. I suggest that this particular amendment which has been moved by Deputy Lemass ought to be accepted by the Minister if only for the fact that it will enable him to get the extra money to keep these people in employment. What better authority can we have for making that request than the speech which was made by the Taoiseach and which was read to the House by Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
The men were out for only two days, due to the fact that the engineers were resiting the foundations, and they are now all back. I still have an interest in Galway City where you got your answer.