We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Purchase of Rejected Wheat—Motion.

Contributions 1–156 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I move:—

That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the Government should, in the exceptional circumstances of this year, make an arrangement with Grain Importers (Éire) Limited to purchase at a fair price, all wheat rejected as unmillable.

This motion was put down by members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the past week in order to get the Minister for Agriculture, if it is possible to do so, to do his duty by the farmers of this country who have unmillable wheat on hands and who have not been able to dispose of it. At the end of the last month and early in this month Deputies from this Party asked questions from the Minister about unmillable wheat. On the 3rd November he was asked by Deputy Moher and other Deputies from this Party if he proposed setting up any organisation for the purchase of unmillable wheat. His reply was taken to be in the negative, that he did not propose setting up any such organisation or making any provision whatever to take the considerable amount of unmillable wheat which, owing to the very bad harvesting weather that has just passed, farmers have on hands over the whole country.

I submit it is the absolute duty of the Minister for Agriculture to use the machinery of his Department to make provision for relieving the farmers, at a fair price, of this unmillable wheat. On the 3rd November, he told Deputy Moher:—

"In the circumstances, I do not propose to arrange for the purchase of unmillable wheat by Grain Importers, Limited, or other central purchasing organisation."

On the same day Deputy Ormonde asked him:—

"whether, in view of the very high percentage of unmillable wheat and the prospect of much of this wheat rotting, he will set up an organisation which would deal with the problem and which would consider the possibility of part of the milling industry's equipment being used for the purpose of turning the unfit wheat into animal fodder"

The Minister answered:—

"I do not propose to set up an organisation on the lines suggested. The drying facilities of the milling industry are at present being operated with the main object of saving potentially millable wheat. Up to the present, where circumstances permitted, quantities of unmillable wheat have been accepted by the millers, and, so far as my Department is concerned, every effort is being made to ensure that such drying facilities as it may be possible to divert for the drying of unmillable wheat will be available to farmers to have such wheat dried for disposal as animal feed."

The Minister will admit, I am sure, that up to the moment, as far as the House is aware and as far as the people of the country are aware, no provision whatever has been made to take over this wheat. Various estimates have been put forward of the amount of unmillable wheat in the country. In particular areas it is set as high as 30 per cent. of the acreage grown and it is down as low as 5 per cent. in other areas. Taking it at 5 per cent. would mean about 40,000 tons of unmillable wheat in the whole country, which would be a very conservative estimate. Forty thousand tons of unmillable wheat is a very considerable amount and many farmers found themselves in the unfortunate position this year that all their wheat was rejected as unmillable by the millers. I will come to the millers later on. I have something to say about those gentlemen, too.

The farmer has grown his wheat. He probably got the seed and the manure on credit, and he may have taken conacre at a high price or it may have been on his own land. Nevertheless, he has this unmillable wheat on hands —some of it for six or seven weeks— which was sent back from the mills, sometimes over a distance of 60 to 70 miles and thrown in the farmer's yard. Neither the Minister for Agriculture nor his Department were the slightest bit concerned whether 50 or 200 barrels of wheat rotted or not.

Comment on this

What is to prevent such a farmer from using that wheat as animal feeding himself?

Comment on this

It is unmillable unless it is properly dried and dried at once. Eighty per cent. of the farmers of this country have no proper granary in which to store wheat and the Deputy is aware of that.

Comment on this

After so many years of Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Hara made his case last night.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let Deputy Allen make his case himself. Other Deputies may contribute later if they wish.

Comment on this

With your assistance, I will make my case. Deputy Murphy will be given an opportunity of solving all these difficulties for his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture. It can be established quite clearly that there is on the hands of the farmers of this country a large quantity of what has been designated by the millers of this country as unmillable wheat. A large portion of it is undried and is fast deteriorating. It will become nothing but a heap of manure in a very short time unless something is done about it.

It is the bounden duty of the Minister for Agriculture to use the machinery of his Department and whatever agencies may be in the country to purchase that wheat, and enable the farmers to have it dried and processed into animal feeding stuffs. The nation, apart altogether from the individual farmer, can illafford to lose anything between 40,000 and 100,000 tons of grain because of the utter negligence of the Minister and the contempt he has for the farmers and for wheat-growing. On Friday last, after this motion was put down the morning daily papers came out with a big black heading: "The Minister's plan for wet wheat". He got a plan for wet wheat on Friday last after Fianna Fáil put down this motion.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Fine Gael

On Thursday.

Comment on this

He got the plan on Thursday, a day earlier. The newspapers published on Friday the fact that he had a plan for wet wheat. Wet wheat has been in existence in this country since the early weeks of September. The harvesting of wheat commenced some time towards the end of August, continued through September and up to last week or the week before. There is probably a small amount of wheat here and there not harvested yet. Wet wheat did not become available on the 12th November; we had it on the 12th September and even earlier. The Minister refused publicly here to make any provision for assembling and drying it and for paying farmers a fair price for it. He did nothing whatever about it. Several organisations of farmers approached the Minister and the Department over the last two months, but he sat back, he had no policy, he was indifferent to the problem staring him in the face. There are areas where it is claimed that at least 30 per cent of the total wheat grown has been refused by millers as unmillable — whether that is true or not. I am sure the Minister has ways and means of checking up on that. He must know from the millers and assemblers the percentage rejected. I am sure he has the figures; if he has not, he should have. This motion has not been put down in any political sense whatever.

Comment on this

God forbid. Perish the thought.

Comment on this

It is purely and simply trying to force the hand of the reluctant individual who now holds the portfolio of Minister for Agriculture — to force his hand and that of his Department, to request him, to beg him, to beseech him on behalf of the wheat growers who have a very serious problem that the Minister does not seem to appreciate. Some of them are faced with absolute bankruptcy — I am sure the Minister is aware of that—to merchants and people who have given them seed or manures and for their many other debts, to pay which they were depending on the wheat harvest. They see the wheat rotting before their eyes, yet the Minister sits back unconcerned until the middle of November doing nothing about this wheat that has been harvested over the past two months. It is his bounden duty to come to the rescue of those farmers who had the unmillable wheat on hands and take it off them and pay a fair and adequate price for it. It is a valuable product, it is as valuable dry as the maize meal we are importing, though it may be classified as unmillable. It is worth as much money to the nation as an animal feeding-stuff that we are importing from thousands of miles away.

I want the Minister to give serious consideration to this. Many members of his own Party sitting behind him are as much aware of this problem as the Deputies on this side of the House. They are moving amongst the people who have grown this wheat and who, owing to the unfortunate weather, found it was damaged and found they were unable to get a buyer for it.

Farmers are in an unfortunate position this year — a doubly unfortunate position — because they have in office a Minister for Agriculture who is hostile to wheat-growing and has always shown it; and they are unfortunate because of the tragic weather we had for the last two or three months. They are unfortunate, also, because they have millers who, in the main, are hostile to native wheat-growing. It is not to-day or yesterday that the farmers became aware that the majority of the millers who deal with the milling of wheat for flour are hostile to Irish wheat. They have shown that in no uncertain way and they have shown it more fully this year than ever before.

I suggest to the Minister that in each mill where wheat is going in he should have a representative, a man capable of knowing what millable wheat is. He could get someone from the farmers' organisations who would know what millable wheat is, but I suggest he put in an officer of his own who knows what millable wheat is. That man should act on behalf of the farmers and if a miller wants to reject any particular sample and if in the opinion of that officer it is millable, the miller should be compelled to take it. The farmer has no redress, no appeal court at the present time against the millers and against the arbitrary action many of them are taking against farmers about particular samples of wheat. We hear it all through the country. Only yesterday I met a farmer, a neighbour of my own, who told me he sent a load of wheat last week and three sacks of that lorry were all that was taken by the miller. He kept the lorry load for two or three days in his shed and did not even unload it; he put three sacks more on it and the full load was taken three days later — the very same wheat that was cast three days before. That is happening all over the country. These are things that the Minister should not allow to happen.

The farmers are very vulnerable at present and have been so for the past six weeks in the matter of what the miller may take as wheat. You have all kinds of discrepancies between one miller and another. A miller has been known to refuse wheat and another 40 miles away will take the same wheat. That should not be allowed to happen. It is the bounden duty of the Minister for Agriculture to see that these farmers are not unfairly treated. They have risked their all in growing a crop of wheat. We are asking nothing in this motion or in the suggestions that will be made but what is reasonable and what is due to the agricultural community. Wheat that is reasonable, that can be said to be millable, should be taken by the millers.

One morning newspaper last week announced the Minister's wheat scheme, but the Minister himself has made no official announcement, nor has his Department, and the farmers do not know whether a scheme is in operation or whether the newspaper was drawing on its imagination. Assuming that the scheme comes into operation, we want to ensure that the millers will not be able to take advantage of such a wet wheat scheme and designate all wheat from now on as wet and buy it at half its value. We want the Minister to ensure that. That is another reason why he should have a capable milling inspector at the mill, day in and day out, so as to prevent the millers putting it across the farmers and rejecting wheat as unmillable and paying a lower price for it. It is the Minister's duty to safeguard the farmer's interests. He has not done it up to now but has sat back, showing utter contempt for the whole thing.

We know that wheat-growing in this country has been a burden and a nuisance to the Minister. We know it has been a burden to others also. We know that quite recently the Trade Union Congress was very vocal against wheat-growing in this country. Perhaps they could throw their minds back four or five years. It is not so long since we had an emergency, when everyone was glad to see the Irish farmer, without manure and without machinery, trying to produce wheat to feed the people. They are getting very poor thanks for it now. We had hostile elements — the Minister for Agriculture, the millers, the master bakers and now the Labour Party and Trade Union Congress. They joined the ranks of the other elements hostile to wheat-growing. Things have come to a sorry plight. Certain elements of the Press over the last five or six months have been talking about the burden that wheat-growing is on the community. You have a line-up there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The policy of wheat-growing does not arise on a discussion of this kind.

Comment on this

It is all linked up.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think so.

Comment on this

It is linked up and if you will allow me for a moment——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have given the Deputy a fair amount of latitude already.

Comment on this

——and if I am out of order in any way——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow the Deputy to open a discussion as to whether a policy of wheat-growing is good or bad.

Comment on this

I am not going to argue that at all because it has long ago been determined that it is a good policy and it has been accepted by the people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might come to the motion then.

Comment on this

I do not propose opening up on an argument of policy. I just wanted to connect the present cost of living and the present indifference of the Minister and his Department to the problems of the farmers, with the campaign that has been carried on for the last four or five months.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that. I do not know anything about any campaign or about the Minister's attitude. I know it is what is on the Order Paper that ought to be discussed.

Comment on this

There was a campaign carried on and remarks were made in public that it was a blessing from God that the weather had been so bad as otherwise the Government would be embarrassed trying to pay the subsidy——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am sure that the Deputy will get an opportunity of making that point but not on this motion.

Comment on this

It is very closely connected with the motion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am ruling to the contrary.

Comment on this

If there was a Minister for Agriculture in office at the moment who was not hostile to the whole matter, he would certainly have taken action to relieve the farmer of this unmillable wheat which is being rejected by the millers and to ensure that every sample of wheat brought to the millers and rejected would——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is the fourth time the Deputy has made that point.

Comment on this

I am just summing up all the points and I am going to conclude. I will ask now that the Minister should treat this matter seriously and take even belated action so that the farmers will hear his melodious voice soon. He has been the most silent Minister in the Government for the last three or four months and people are wondering why. They love to hear his voice sometimes and like to get his opinion on things. They like him to say publicly now and again that he will defend their interests whether it be wheat or beet growing. I hope the Minister will answer the motion and announce that a wet wheat scheme is coming into operation.

Comment on this

I beg to second the motion.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Beegan going to come into the fray again.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Beegan may reserve his right to speak until afterwards if he wishes.

Comment on this

Any player with five aces in his hand ought to be able to play two of them.

Comment on this

I had rather hoped the Opposition would have approached this motion with a genuine desire to help but from the first speaker one could only deduce that not only is the motion unnecessary but that it is approached in a mischievous and unprincipled manner.

When the present Minister for Agriculture assumed office, his first action was to realise that his duty was to find for the Irish farmer the best price he could get for all his produce and get the farmer his raw materials at the lowest price at which he could buy them abroad. He has always adhered to that and in his approach to the present motion he has adhered to it also.

The motion states that it is the opinion that owing to the exceptional circumstances of this year an agreement should be made with Grain Importers, Limited, to purchase at fair prices all wheat rejected as unmillable. We must consider what benefit would accrue to the Irish farmers. What and who are Grain Importers? Grain Importers are an agency in an office in Dublin. They possess no drying facilities, no storage facilities and no staff except an official staff. They have no machinery with which to dry wet wheat and therefore they must employ somebody to dry it and the persons they must employ are those who own drying machinery and who have storage for the wheat. Those people whether we like it or not, are the people who rejected the wheat in the first instance. If Grain Importers do buy this wet wheat they must employ on commission the millers and dryers to handle it and there is a very strong parallel between the manner in which they would handle it and in which they handled — the Government having instructed them to do so — the position regarding the surplus of feeding barley last year. There was a surplus of feeding barley last year and the Government had guaranteed a price of not less than 48/- a barrel for it.

When the surplus became evident it was necessary for the Government to see the farmer got his 48/- and they employed Grain Importers as an agency to purchase this feeding barley. The barley was purchased on commission and 48/- a barrel was paid and Grain Importers also paid out to various agents, sacking commission, handling commission, drying commission and eventually storage commission. When the losses on that barley were assessed it was discovered that the barrels which had been bought at 48/- must be sold at 64/-. That loss was not borne from Government funds. It was borne — and I challenge any member of the Opposition to deny it — by the Irish farmer because that barley was married financially to the maize which is being imported, and an Order was made whereby any farmer or milling compounder who bought maize must take 50 per cent. of barley with it. The maize which was being imported at £29 a ton at the time was sold to the people at £32 a ton. In other words, every farmer's wife and every farmer who bought pig meal, layers' mash or any compound feeding stuff of which maize was a constituent, paid a levy which balanced the loss of the Government and Grain Importers on the feeding barley. Does the Opposition wish to pay an unnatural price for this wet wheat and recoup the losses from the farmers who wish to buy pig meal and layers' mash, etc.?

I come from a grain growing county and I would not be a party to taking money out of one pocket of the Irish farmer and putting it into another. I believe that each and every aspect of agriculture should be in a position to stand on its own feet after the Government has made its arrangements to deal with it individually. Therefore, I believe, Grain Importers can make no practicable contribution towards wet wheat. The only manner in which Grain Importers could make a contribution would be if the Government afforded them means to recoup their losses by giving money from the Exchequer. I would like to remind the House that the Minister for Agriculture who has just been described as being disinterested in wheat, half way through this season made a change in the moisture content deductions which has brought to the Irish farmer a sum of £150,000, or 1/6 a barrel for 2,000,000 barrels of millable wheat accepted. I would like the members of the Opposition to realise that and to remember that Mr. Dillon's approach to wheat-growing in this country is very different from what they have assessed it to be. Deputy Allen has stated that all that happened was that, in a newspaper, a statement was made that Mr. Dillon had a plan to take care of wet wheat. Certainly he has a plan to take care of wet wheat.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The correct title is "the Minister for Agriculture".

Comment on this

If Deputy Allen had also read the newspapers, he would have discovered that the Minister for Agriculture had expedited that plan and that it has the effect that at any point of intake where the accommodation is available wet wheat can be sold. Deputy Allen put the poser to the Minister: "Was it as valuable as maize meal?" I will not answer that for Deputy Allen, but I tell him that at the price arranged by the Minister with the buyers of wet wheat, the farmer is getting as good a bargain as can be made in the circumstances and that the Minister's pledge to get for the Irish farmer the best price he can get in any part of the world is being implemented.

I am not going to worry the Opposition with figures, but if they will take the moisture content of the wet wheat, if they will strike a fair average, find its price, put down a commission for drying, deduct the loss in weight, they will discover that the difference between maize at £27 per ton and wet wheat, when dried to a moisture content comparable with that of maize, is very little. With regard to whether or not in the circumstances Grain Importers, Limited, would still be the proper persons, leaving out the probable loss that would accrue to the Irish farmer, to handle wet wheat, I know that last year these barleys which were bought at 48/- a barrel and sold at 64/- a barrel and on which the Irish farmer bore every penny of the loss, were railed from as far as 200 miles from the point of intake to the point of milling.

Deputy Dillon's agreement with the millers and driers at the present moment leaves them holding that baby and the Opposition would be well advised to leave them holding it and not to endeavour to introduce Grain Importers Limited into the position. I therefore submit that the Minister has made a great contribution towards wet wheat. The Minister has done his best in all the circumstances and in the worst year that this country has ever experienced, he has produced a most wonderful result for the Irish farmers and his Department is to be congratulated.

I submit that the motion should not receive any hearing from right-thinking Deputies and that Grain Importers (Éire) Limited would make no contribution to the present position with regard to wet wheat.

Comment on this

I am very sorry that I cannot see the position through the same rose-tinted spectacles as Deputy Donegan and I would like to give briefly what I might describe as the background to this matter. I think a very great contributory factor has been the attitude adopted by the cereals section of the Department of Agriculture in trying to prevent or discourage the provision of drying facilities by farmers in this country.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Fine Gael

On a point of order, is it not the inflexible rule of this House that the Minister is responsible for what his Department does? If Deputy Moher has fault to find, let him find it with me.

Comment on this

Of course, it is with you he is finding it.

Comment on this

I can say that the Minister has been badly advised in this particular direction by those people competent to advise him, and it is a strange situation that in this country we have an opinion expressed on this matter which is contrary to the general practice in England. We have a complaint from the British Ministry of the slowness of farmers to provide drying facilities for wheat over there. There is no encouragement whatever given here. Of course, there is a very good reason because there is a handsome profit accruing to a certain section because they are permitted to have a monopoly of storage and drying. That attitude is not peculiar to wheat-drying; it is a general attitude adopted, unfortunately, by the Department of Agriculture under various Ministers. They have here the idea that the brains trust of Irish agriculture should and must be centralised in Merrion Street. They accept the idea that farmers down the country have not the intelligence or the competence to direct and undertake a lot of matters which are directly controlled by officials and to undertake facilities which are taken over and commercialised at a handsome profit to others.

I submit that if the farmers here were given something like 11/6 a barrel for drying wheat and something like 1½d. a barrel for storing it, we would have, in addition to the large plants, a very great number of supplementary plants and a substantial increase in storage accommodation; but, since this important matter is a closed shop to the agricultural community, we are faced with an emergency like this. We have all the chaos and all the confusion associated with centralisation in this matter. If the big growers, certain people in the grain areas, were encouraged to provide drying and storage facilities, we would find that many of the contingent problems which have presented themselves in this emergency would be non-existent.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

As I understand it, the Deputy is discussing agricultural policy rather than the motion.

Comment on this

I am discussing the problem which has led up to the emergency.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has not spoken so far on the motion. He is discussing agricultural policy as far as I can see and not the motion before the House.

Comment on this

I asked a question of the Minister here a couple of weeks ago and the reply I got was what I would describe as a dressed-up negative. The Minister had no answer except to assure the farmers that on receipt of a halfpenny postcard by him he would have their wheat dried within 48 hours. I looked upon that as being absolutely no solution because the Minister well knew that at that particular time every drying-plant in the country was working to full capacity trying to salvage wheat which had not yet been rejected as unmillable. As the mills were working like that, the question arose as to whether it would be fair to divert drying-plants to the treatment of rejected wheat as against wheat in regard to which a possibility existed of its acceptance by the millers. The Minister's assurance of course implied the utilising of drying facilities far removed from the particular farmer concerned, because if the drying facilities locally were being used for the purpose of drying wheat not yet rejected by the miller, they could not be available for the drying of wheat that had been rejected. That posed an unanswerable question first of all as to the distance wheat has to be moved and secondly as to who was to bear the cost. That was the problem as I saw it and I should like to hear from the Minister in his reply some indication as to what extent his offer had been utilised.

One farmer's organ described the Minister's reply and his attitude on that occasion as that of a fiddling Nero and I think that pretty well summed up his reply from the practical angle.

Comment on this

Had they not been talking to the Deputy?

Comment on this

No, they had not.

Comment on this

They said they had.

Comment on this

Everybody in this country has associated the introduction of wheat and the wheat policy with the Fianna Fáil Party. I think what we need more than anything else—and more urgently—is a statement from the Minister as to his attitude. There is a feeling that in his innermost soul he lacks sympathy entirely with this wheat problem and there is an idea generally that——

Comment on this

Can the contents of my innermost soul be relevantly discussed on a motion to get me to get Grain Importers to purchase unmillable wheat?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know

Comment on this

You are on record in the House here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I asked the Deputy to come to the motion. He is discussing agricultural policy. There is a motion in very explicit terms on the Order Paper which says:—

"That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the Government should, in the exeptional circumstances of the year, make an arrangement with Grain Importers (Éire) Limited, to purchase at a fair price all wheat rejected as unmillable."

That is very explicit.

Comment on this

That is the one thing they do not want to discuss.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has not spoken on that since he got on his feet. I am afraid I shall have to ask him to come to the motion.

Comment on this

No, nor he will not.

Comment on this

The situation is, as I say, that it is incumbent on the Minister, in view of the chaos that exists, to take such action as will save the farmers from beggary and ruin. The Minister is well aware of the acuteness of the problem. He is well aware of what is happening. We all know of instances. It is no use saying that the wheat can be utilised this way or that because, first of all, a statement appeared, I think it was on last Friday, in which there was a report of an interview by the millers' representatives with the Minister and in which it was implied that 47/6 a barrel was to be paid for rejected wheat. I want to make one point in connection with rejected wheat. That is that there must be some system of grading and some purchasing authority which will decide what wheat is worth. Wheat with a moisture content of over 30 per cent. might reasonably be worth 47/6 but let us take dried wheat rejected by the millers on the glutin test. That, surely, is worth far more than 47/6 a barrel. I have consulted somebody who would be competent to give some idea of what the price should be and he gave me a figure of between £25 and £27 a ton.

That is why it is all-important that some central agency should be appointed to purchase wheat—rejected wheat—on account of the varying nature of the wheat rejected and on account of the varying prices as animal foodstuffs. It is only through a central agency that you can strike a mean price for rejected wheat. If such a thing is not done, if the farmers are left to be exploited by every gangster and racketeer that can get hold of them we know what is going to happen. We know that in many instances they will not get 47/6 a barrel because wet wheat, undried wheat, is deteriorating, constantly deteriorating, and no Minister of State can say that after two or three weeks that wheat will be worth 47/6 a barrel because the supposed purchaser may say: "I am taking a risk with it; it has deteriorated to such an extent that it is mouldy and may be poisonous."

That is the position that exists and that is the position to which the Minister has got to address himself. Again I want to bring to the Minister's notice the fact that the millers have been allowed to become and continue to be the sole arbiters as to the moisture content and as to the bushelling of wheat and as to general millability. We know of certain mills where lorry loads of wheat have been rejected on the glutin test and have been transferred elsewhere and accepted. I put it to the Minister that suppose some of that wheat which was primarily rejected in one mill and accepted in another was to be sold at 47/6 a barrel would that be equity; would it be fair? Sprouting grain, sodden grain, and wheat rejected on a glutin test are very distinct products and nobody in fairness or equity can strike a mean price. It cannot be done and it cannot be handled except by some central purchasing authority.

One particular instance was brought to my notice where two combines were working in a field of wheat and two lorries drove away from that field on the same day and delivered wheat to two different mills. In one instance the price was 57/- and in the other 74/-. That is some indication of what is going on. That is some indication also of the considerable amount of wheat which has been rejected and is at the moment, and for two weeks past, deteriorating in the hands of the farmers. Deputy Donegan made the point that this could be fed to live stock. The conacre farmers have no live stock. Then there are farmers who have live stock but have no storage facilities.

In connection with millable wheat there is 11/6 for drying and handling and something like 1½d. a barrel for storage. With rejected wheat there is nothing. There is just the bare 47/6, and that is for stuff that is unusable as well as wheat that is dried and rejected. I submit the Minister's approach to this whole problem shows a compete lack of sympathy.

Comment on this

Now does the Deputy really believe that?

Comment on this

I sincerely believe that the Minister's approach was an insult to the farmers. It was making a mockery of the serious problem affecting them, a problem which was bringing chaos and ruin about them, to merely say: "Just send me a halfpenny postcard and I will dry it and you can do what you like with it afterwards." That was very much the Minister's attitude. It did not show any serious thought or consideration of the problem. The Minister may refer to any documents he likes. I am giving him a general impression of the situation that exists from my own experience as a Deputy living in a grain growing area. In my own feeble way I am trying to drive home to the Minister the urgency of the problem. The problem cannot be solved by advising a miller to pay a certain price. The mills are already chock-full of wheat.

Comment on this

There is no storage shortage.

Comment on this

Very early in the season we were informed that the general manager of the Irish Sugar Company was offering drying facilities in the factories in the grain growing areas. An estimate of the drying facilities available there would be something like 2,000 tons per day. Those facilities were offered early in September, so far as I am informed, and were refused. They were offered again prior to the company starting preparations for the beet campaign and were again refused. Had the Minister and his advisers had the foresight then to have accepted those facilities the subsequent problem which manifested itself a few weeks later would have been rendered much less acute. But neither foresight nor forethought was applied to that offer. The offer was refused with disastrous consequences for the people in those areas in which the beet factories are located. Beet is not a perishable crop to the same extent that wheat is. Everybody knows that the progress of the beet campaign was contingent upon clearing the mess in the corn fields. The general manager of the Sugar Company was aware of that when he made his offer. It was a grave mistake to turn down that offer for its acceptance would have afforded some solution to the present problem.

I appeal to the Minister to adopt a more sympathetic approach to this problem confronting grain growers all over the country and to examine the problem with a view to finding some solution which will provide some recoupment for the labour and anxiety suffered by our farmers during this wretched harvest. There should be an end to exploitation. Statements have been made that Irish wheat is the dearest in the world and those have been taken up and hammered by two newspapers, one in Cork and the other here in Dublin. We all know the facts. We know that actually of the main wheat producing countries in Europe we produce the fourth cheapest wheat. I will submit the list: Netherlands, 62s.; Denmark, 65s.; the United Kingdom, 75s.; Ireland, approximately 81s.

Comment on this

Has this anything to do with the purchase of rejected wheat?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The price of wheat has nothing whatever to do with the motion. The motion deals with the purchase by Grain Importers of rejected wheat.

Comment on this

That is the one thing they will not talk about, but they will talk about everything else.

Comment on this

The explanation of the failure of the Minister to do the job he should do is, of course, his antagonism to wheat and his lack of sympathy with the wheat growers. Down through the years he has gone on record for some of the greatest indiscretions and some of the most reckless statements in connection with wheat-growing.

Comment on this

Listening to the debate one would imagine that all the Minister had to do was to get Grain Importers to handle the rejected wheat, and everything would be grand. I am afraid that is not the solution. Indeed, it is far from being the solution. As Deputy Donegan pointed out, Grain Importers is an office and not an organisation. They have no facilities for either handling or drying grain and, if they come into the picture, they will merely provide yet another cog in the wheel.

I think what the Minister has done so far is the best that could be done in a very serious situation. We should realise that and we should not try to play politics with the situation. It is a serious situation for the farmers. There is no doubt about that. Our farmers have passed through one of the most severe harvests ever experienced. Because of that a certain amount of wheat is being rejected. The amount is not very considerable. I have experience of an intensive grain growing area and the amount of wheat rejected in that area is very, very limited.

On the one hand we have the millers and every drying plant in the country loaded to capacity, drying and handling millable wheat. Does the Opposition want that situation changed? Is it the desire of Deputies opposite that the rejected wheat should be handled and that fit for human consumption let go bad? I do not think anyone wants that to happen. The millers will have to continue handling the wheat fit to turn into human food.

The arrangements made last week with the Minister and the millers whereby they agreed to take this rejected wheat are working out satisfactorily. I have known cases in my constituency where this wheat has been taken from the farmers and is being handled by the millers. To put the Grain Importers organisation into it will not help in the least. It will only complicate matters because it will result in a situation similar to that which arose in the handling of feeding barley. They will have to get their expenses and eventually they will get them from the pockets of the farmers. If this present arrangement works— which I believe it will—we will overcome this very serious problem.

Deputy Moher referred to places where farmers have succeeded in getting the grain dried and he asked the Minister if they would still get only 47/6 a barrel for that grain. That will not happen. I saw an offer to-day of £25 a ton for rejected grain which was dried.

All that has been said so far by the Opposition is utter nonsense—that the Minister is so prejudiced against wheat-growing. If that were the case, he would not have modified the moisture clause—a provision which has meant a great deal to wheat growers in this very serious year. If the Opposition were as much concerned with wheat-growing as they claim to be, they would have made an honest effort, before the season commenced, to see that there were proper drying facilities all over the country. No effort was made and we have the reflection of that to-day. If there had been adequate drying facilities to deal with the difficult harvest the grain would have been handled.

There has been a certain "pile-up" with grain. We were lucky to the extent that the bad weather was spread over such a long period. If we had not had such bad weather, and the grain had come in faster, the position would have been worse. There would have been a very serious "pileup" and a lot of that grain would have a high moisture content and would not stand if it were not handled within a short time. I believe that a very serious situation has been handled reasonably well and that the amount of losses in the grain-growing areas is very small indeed; that is, as far as rejected wheat is concerned, it is very small. I was speaking to a purchaser of grain in my constituency this morning and he told me that he had only two cases of rejected grain and he would be handling 40,000 or 50,000 barrels of wheat. What has happened is that in some districts where wheat should never have been grown, and where it is still standing and has not been harvested, the grain is being rejected. There is not a great deal of sympathy for some of the people concerned. They were people who thought they would get rich quick by growing grain and they rushed in and grew hundreds of acres and had no machinery to handle it. When the weather deteriorated their corn was left there. There are some people, and I am one of them, who have not a great deal of sympathy for anyone in that situation. A person who has been growing grain and who has made an honest effort to secure machinery to handle it, even in a season as bad as this, has lost very little.

Deputy Allen, the mover of the motion, said the amount of rejected grain was as high as 30 per cent. That is nonsense. It is nothing like 30 per cent.

I compliment the Minister on his handling of the situation so far. Undoubtedly, it was very difficult because adequate drying facilities were not available. Deputy Moher referred to the fact that farmers were prevented from providing drying facilities themselves. He compared the situation here with that in Great Britain where farmers have their own drying facilities. The two countries are not comparable because in England there is a large number of very big growers who grow thousands of acres and it pays them to erect drying facilities. The average grain grower here is not in a position to provide such plant for himself and has not the storage facilities. I do not think that these facilities will ever be available here. There is a possibility that the smaller type of dryer similar to the dryer supplied by the E.S.B. may prove an attractive proposition for a farmer to dry the grain that he will keep, but it will never happen here that the farmer will dry the wheat he is going to market. I hope we will never again witness a harvest like the recent one. The farmers have been calm, in spite of their experience, and if the situation is dealt with calmly the results may be reasonably good.

Deputy Carter rose.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter is not one of the five aces either.

Comment on this

Neither am I a joker.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Nor a knave.

Comment on this

Nor a knave nor a fool, if you want to add some little trimmings

Comment on this

This is a very well furnished pack.

Comment on this

The Minister's attitude in this House to-day is symbolic of his attitude all down the years. It took some millions of the taxpayers' money to convert him to the idea of growing wheat in this country. Deputy Hughes let the cat out of the bag on the issue of Fine Gael policy when he said that every colleague of mine in the country could be put out of business.

Comment on this

I said?

Comment on this

That is what it amounts to.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

He implied it. It is on record. He can read the report of his speech to-morrow. The Minister, of course, would have us believe that there is no problem. Of course, there is a problem. There was a problem as far back as last August.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Before it was cut at all?

Comment on this

Yes, because the Government have sources of information and knowledge about even the weather which are not available to the layman and the Minister made no attempt——

Comment on this

Old Moore's Almanac.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Carter is entitled to speak without these interruptions.

Comment on this

The Minister made no attempt to organise his Department or the farmers to put them in a position to deal with the sodden wheat. Contrary to whatever the Government or the Minister may assert we on this side of the House assert that roughly one-third or more, perhaps, of the wheat crop will be a dead loss this year through the incompetence of the Minister and the Government to give a lead in this matter. It is not a matter for cheap sneers or gibes in this House. I think the motion should have been put down earlier but it was not until now that the chaos that has existed in the handling of the wheat crop as a whole was revealed. The Minister is not even too sure at the moment what price is being paid even for millable wheat. In my area I have known farmers who have sold millable wheat for as low as 55/- per barrel, not to mention unmillable wheat.

There was no attempt made, as I said at the outset, to organise the various services which could have been utilised to help out in this crisis. What was to prevent the utilisation of the smaller mills throughout the country to deal with unmillable wheat? They might not have been able to handle a large proportion of the unmillable wheat but they would at least save some of it from going to loss.

I can recall to the House that at least in my area you have ten or 12 kilns which could be utilised to dry unmillable wheat and which would preserve it from going rotten. They are now closed. The kiln heads would have been quite suitable for the purpose I mention. The services of millers who are quite capable of milling wheaten meal—the very best of wheaten meal—were not called into operation. No mention of it was made by the Minister, the Department, the millers or by anybody else.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy but that is not in the motion.

Comment on this

We are dealing with unmillable wheat.

Comment on this

We have not that in the motion.

Comment on this

We are dealing with unmillable wheat.

Comment on this

That is not in the motion.

Comment on this

I can add to that motion. The emphasis should be on saving the wheat crop at any cost and not what is in the motion or what is not in it. There are thousands of such kilns standing idle throughout the country. The Government stood callously by all along and gave no lead. The only lead given was that some Parliamentary Secretaries and other spokesmen of the Government went down the country with false propaganda. They dragged in red herrings and raised hares of all descriptions.

Comment on this

Any sick rabbits?

Comment on this

The Deputy will destroy the wheat before he starts.

Comment on this

They do not want to hear the case against them. They should listen to the case and make their charge afterwards.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin knows as well as I do that there are at least ten kilns in our area which could be utilised. He cannot deny that. They are all standing idle.

Comment on this

Why? Would you not think that you, as a Deputy, would go around and get them going?

Comment on this

I play my part. I am not slow about that either.

Comment on this

It is blooming near time you did.

Comment on this

If the Minister and his Department had given a lead even to the vocational organisations early on and got them to work those kilns and keep them going, it would have contributed some solution to the problem.

Comment on this

Are you not a Deputy standing in the middle of ten idle kilns? What did you do to get them working?

Comment on this

I am not the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I feel that Deputy Carter should be allowed to make his statement. Deputies will be given every opportunity to make their statements.

Comment on this

It is all right for Deputies on the opposite benches to stand up with prepared briefs and throw out a whole lot of statistics but that is no good to the small farmers down the country whose wheat is rotten in the barn and the field. We want to see some action. That action has not been forthcoming.

Comment on this

If it is rotten in the fields it is no good in the mills.

Comment on this

If it is rotten in the fields, it is the result of your failure to give a lead in the matter.

Comment on this

The lead should have been given last March.

Comment on this

There is no lead for the coming year and the price has not been announced yet and the sowing month has gone by. Of course, there is a prejudice in Fine Gael all along because the Fianna Fáil Party were the sponsors of the wheat campaign in this country. That whole hangover is there. That should not be. The Minister is on record in this House as giving out that he would not be found dead in a field of wheat.

Comment on this

He would be a fool if he did.

Comment on this

I submit that we are charging the Minister for Agriculture with gross negligence in this matter.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about the hangover of the economic war.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must resume his seat. We cannot have Deputies standing up to talk like that.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You started the wheat by accident when you could do nothing else.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motion deals with the purchase of all wheat rejected as unmillable.

Comment on this

Our motion seeks to put a bottom in the market and not to let the people be exploited. I have heard of producers and growers who have sold wheat for as little as £1 a barrel in order to get rid of it.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give me their names?

Comment on this

I will give you the reference later.

Comment on this

Give me their names.

Comment on this

Not at the moment in the House. I will give you the reference later.

Comment on this

There is a Deputy sitting behind me who had the same experience. I asked him for the names. He will tell you how I dealt with it.

Comment on this

The Deputy will talk when his turn comes.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Carter should be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

I am charging the Minister and the Government with gross negligence and with callous indifference in this matter. It is not a matter of politics. It is a matter of grave national concern. We had a record year of wheat but we had the misfortune to have one of the worst seasons in the century. One would assume that the Minister and his colleagues would have taken a very different line in this matter as far back as last August but even if they had taken the matter in hands last August, you would have a certain amount of confusion but certainly you would not have the confusion that exists or you would not have the losses.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is the Deputy that is confused.

Comment on this

The Minister might be able to give us an idea of what percentage of wheat gained the full guaranteed price. I should like, when he is replying, if he could give us an indication of that. From my own knowledge of the Midlands, I should say that I know of no grower who succeeded in getting anything near the guaranteed price for his wheat this year.

Comment on this

Plenty.

Comment on this

I know of no grower in the Midlands who succeeded in doing so. One would think having regard to the experience the present Minister had—and he had the experience of Deputy Tom Walsh, ex-Minister for Agriculture, who gave a lead in this matter of growing wheat——

Comment on this

Go down and cut some of his wheat for him.

Comment on this

——that he would have given a lead in this matter. I think the least he might do at this stage would be to accept the terms of this motion and give a lead even at this late stage and see what can be done with regard to unmillable wheat.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Fine Gael

Deputy Carter concluded by referring to my predecessor, Deputy Thomas Walsh, whose absence, owing to illness, from to-day's debates we all greatly deplore and whose early restoration to complete good health we all sincerely hope for. I get the impression that this motion has fallen flat. I have great sympathy with the Opposition. I have often had this distressing experience myself. A trap has been prepared, the quarry sighted and, at the eleventh hour, something has gone wrong. Then you have to face the Dáil with this infernal motion on the paper and put the best face on it you can. I do not mind confessing now that, since last Friday, I was curious to know what on earth are they up to, what is the purpose of the motion. Then, when Deputy Allen had opened the indictment, I turned to my colleague, Deputy O. Flanagan, and said: "This motion has dropped dead before it ever got walking."

I think it is a mistake to drag the unfortunate farmers of this country through the mire of political recrimination at a time when they are having an extremely rough time of it. We all know that anyone who has been struggling to save crops for the past three months here has undergone martyrdom and it does not matter very much what crop he was in face of— oats, barley, wheat or potatoes. What I should like to say in the first place is that what constantly dazzles me in the agriculture of this country is the astonishing capacity of our people to meet adversity and to struggle through it and to come out far better than you imagined it was conceivably possible for them to do.

Let me remind the House that any blame that is due must properly fall on my shoulders, as Minister for Agriculture, and any credit, for the same reason, must be attributed, within the procedure of this House, to the Minister for Agriculture for the time being. I want to say, as Minister for Agriculture, that, confronted with the season through which we are passing, I consider that our handling of the wheat crop has been a miracle of success. I ask Deputies opposite, is it or is it not true that it was confidently prophesied a month ago that the streets of Dublin would be blocked with the queues of lorries that would be outside the mills—and not only in Dublin but all over the country? Was that not prophesied? Has there been a single queue uncatered for in any part of Ireland? Is it not true that we were told that 30 to 50 per cent. of the wheat crop would be lost? I challenge contradiction upon this: that, of the 1,700,000 barrels of wheat taken in at the mills to date, less than 3 per cent. has been rejected as unmillable. I regard that as no mean performance.

The text of this motion is as follows:—

"That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the Government should, in the exceptional circumstances of this year, make an arrangement with Grain Importers (Éire) Limited to purchase at a fair price, all wheat rejected as unmillable."

But, at this moment, no farmer need contact Grain Importers. No farmer need enter into any correspondence or negotiation with anybody farther away than the nearest mill to his own farm. If he goes there with his wheat, he has the certainty that, if it is millable by any criteria, it will be purchased from him at the fixed price in accordance with the schedule and, if it proves to be unmillable, it will be taken at a price which Deputy Moher says is so good that he cannot believe the millers will ever pay it.

Comment on this

What price?

Comment on this

47/6 to 50/- a barrel according to the quality of unmillable wheat. Deputy Moher expresses apprehension that farmers will not get 47/6 per barrel for unmillable wheat.

Comment on this

No. I made a distinct difference between a fixed price of 47/6 a barrel for wheat rejected, with over 30 per cent. moisture, and wheat that was dried and rejected solely on the glutin test.

Comment on this

I understood Deputy Moher to say that he was gravely apprehensive that farmers would not get from 47/6 to 50/- a barrel according to the quality of the unmillable wheat. Is that not amazing when you consider what they have been through? Cross your heart and hope to die, did it not take the breath out of you? Listen to one another talking to-day and there are some Deputies in Fianna Fáil who are as eloquent as other Deputies in this House: did you not make a fluthering bad case for your own motion? Why? Because you know perfectly well that there is no substance in it. I ask you this question for an honest answer. Is it better to put at the disposal of every farmer in Ireland every mill in Ireland to buy his wheat at 47/6 to 50/- a barrel in the event of its being unmillable or to ask a farmer with unmillable wheat on his hands to enter into correspondence with Grain Importers to buy it from him? Which is the more convenient arrangement?

I hope Deputy Carter will not leave for a moment. He is on record as saying that he knows a number of his neighbours who had to sell their wheat for 20/- a barrel. I want to ask Deputy Carter, as a responsible public representative in this country, for the names and addresses of the men who sold their wheat for 20/- a barrel—and the names and addresses of those who bought it. It is Deputy Carter's duty to give those names. Deputy Lahiffe, who is now sitting behind Deputy Carter, will remember that on a previous occasion, in the discharge of his public duty, he honestly gave to me the names of seven constituents of his in East Galway who, he said, had difficulty in disposing of their barley. I think he will agree that, within 24 hours, every one of them was visited and received an invitation to place their barley at the disposal of an officer of my Department for prompt sale. I was grateful to Deputy Lahiffe for giving me an opportunity of testing the veracity of the complaints he had received. I think Deputy Lahiffe did what a public representative is bound to do, that is, to say: "I got these complaints. It is my duty to tell the Minister for Agriculture about them and to ask him if he is going to make good his undertaking." I think Deputy Lahiffe will confess that, in so far as it lay within my power, it was done. If he is a conscientious public representative he has a duty to tell me the names of the men who sold their wheat for £1 a barrel and what I want much more is the names of the men who bought it.

Now Deputy Carter has another tale to tell us here. He says within a few miles of his own home there are ten kilns well able to dry wheat, while there are hundreds of farmers with their wheat rotting on their hands and nobody can get the kilns to dry the wheat. Has Deputy Carter given me the names of one of these kiln owners? Has he written me a line to tell me of that dilemma? Has Deputy Carter taken out his own bicycle and ridden to the door of one of these kiln owners to say: "Will you not light up your kiln and dry your neighbour's corn?"

If the members of the Fianna Fáil Party are honestly concerned for farmers struggling with difficulties, for their own neighbours, would you not think that before coming into this House caterwauling on a Thursday afternoon, that where they knew there were ten kilns idle within a few miles of their own house which could relieve their own neighbours' difficulties, they would do one of two things: send me a postcard asking me to get them working or take out their own bicycles and cycle around ten miles and say: "Would you please light your kiln and help the neighbours whose corn is rotting in their lofts?" Deputy Carter has not used postcard, bicycle tyre or shoe leather, and yet he comes in to rebuke me.

Comment on this

How does the Minister know?

Comment on this

That is what he told me himself. When I asked: "What did you do?" His answer was: "I am not Minister for Agriculture. Why should I do anything?" I am very proud of what I have done. I did not deal with one grain grower at a time; I have been struggling to provide for the grain growers of every parish in Ireland. If Deputy Carter wants to charge Deputy Hughes with jettisoning the conacre man let me say this: when I see a gentleman come into this country, take 800 acres of conacre land, tear it all up, plant it with wheat and present a bill to our Government for the consequential product with the intention of skipping out of the country, I do not care what happens to him. I am not going to break my heart about what happens to that fellow. He came in here to make a speculation and to get rich quick at our people's expense. If his speculation has not come off, the devil mend him, as far as I am concerned.

I have spent the last six weeks day in, day out—and I will ask Deputies in this House to remember that when I say "I have spent" I mean the Department of Agriculture has spent, and when I say "I am proud of my achievement" I mean that I am proud of the achievement of the Department of Agriculture—in that sense I have worked 15 or 16 hours a day for the last six weeks to see that wheat was handled and taken off the hands of farmers, not in one parish but in every parish in Ireland, and I dare any Deputy in this House to say we failed. The wheat was taken, the wheat was dried and now we are in a position to say, millable or unmillable, it will be taken and paid for from anyone who tenders it to any mill in Ireland.

I could go into a much wider field if I chose to-day but you have ruled and the Ceann Comhairle has ruled that we are to deal with the motion put before us, that is,

"That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the Government should, in the exceptional circumstances of this year, make an arrangement with Grain Importers (Éire) Limited to purchase at a fair price, all wheat rejected as unmillable."

We have done much more than that and we are proud of the result of our labours. Let us remember—and all Deputies will agree—that we encountered probably the worst harvest weather in living memory. Our prime concern must be for genuine farmers and not for speculators who are in a racket to get what they can out of it. On that basis I await to hear from any Deputy in this House an honest challenge to the performance of my task in helping farmers who grew wheat or any other cereal this year to get their crop disposed of at the best price obtainable in the circumstances.

The case has been made that when the question of millable or unmillable wheat comes to be determined there should be some arbiter other than the miller and the farmer to determine what is millable or unmillable. I want to say quite frankly that in logic there is no answer to that claim and, in evidence of that, I am free to say that I sent for representatives of Macra na Feirme and said, and I think I said it to the representatives of the grain growers' branch of the Beet Growers' Association: "Turn this matter over in your mind and consider this question as to whether you want to undertake the installation of an arbitrator at every point of intake for wheat in this country, but bear in mind what it involves." I reckon that, taking into account wheat agents, licensed millers and licensed wheat dealers, there must be between 300 and 400 points of intake for wheat. If all these are to be furnished with an arbitration officer it means you have to have between 300 and 400 of them. Bear in mind that in a shockingly adverse year of this kind lots of fellows will feel they would have done better if they had a third party there to arbitrate between them but recall that over a very long period wheat was being delivered into the mills in this country and the number of complaints were very few. What will happen if arbitration on these lines is established? The farmer will bring his wheat to the mill and the licensed dealer or miller will estimate its moisture content, and so forth.

There is a difference between the farmer and the miller and they cannot reconcile it. Then the arbitrator comes in. What can he do? He must take a sample, a representative sample to the satisfaction of farmer and miller and then the wheat passes into the mill and the price to be paid for it ultimately to the farmer will be deter mined by a test of the sample. A third of the sample will go to the farmer, a third to the miller and a third to the Department. That last third will have to be tested by experts in the seed-testing department for moisture content and other relevant points. They are scientists and they will be bound by no rule but the rule of objective, literal scientific test. They will apply the letter of the law of moisture content, millability, maltose content and glucose content. They will report on that and on that report the farmer will be paid.

I think farmers would be well advised to consider well whether in the average normal year they would do better under that system or under the system which has obtained heretofore. Think of this. In a normal year a licensed wheat agent or a wheat dealer gets his living by handling the farmers' wheat. He does not want to acquire the reputation in his district of being a stiff, cranky man. On the contrary, he wants his neighbours and the farmers from further afield to say: "If you go and deal with Pat So-and-so he will treat you fair; if the wheat is good he will take it and give you full credit for it." He does not want to get the reputation: "If you go to Pat So-and-so he will always say your wheat is 1 or 2 per cent. damper than any other miller would say."

The licensed wheat dealer or agent wants to handle wheat; the more wheat he handles the better off he is. The interest of the dealer and agent is to give the farmer the best price he can afford to get for it, because if he does not the farmer will go elsewhere. Remember, this year we had cases of farmers being offered a price by a dealer far less than he thought was fair and taking his wheat elsewhere and finding another mill which treated him much more leniently.

If, however, you set some system of arbitration—and in my opinion the claim cannot be resisted if it is pressed upon any Minister for Agriculture—the arbitration will have to be based upon the cold, objective, scientific assessment of the sample submitted. I will leave it to the farmers themselves to determine whether under that system they would do better than under the system which obtains at the present time. Wheat in great quantity has been accepted this year with moisture contents over 28 per cent. and up to 33 per cent. Do not let us forget that when the Beet Growers' Association, Grain Section, was discussing this matter with my predecessor — and bear in mind they had in contemplation a normal year — their view was that they were not interested in what befell wheat which was tendered for sale with more than 28 per cent. moisture content. I think that for a normal year that is a reality.

Now, I am charged with having treated the wheat growers with contempt, with indifference, with harshness; and the facts are that their own representatives are on record as stating that in their judgment wheat with a moisture content in excess of 28 per cent. was not fit to mill and ought not to be bought by any miller. That was the view of their own representative. The Minister for Agriculture, who is supposed to be the enemy of wheat growers, who is supposed to have treated them with indifference, harshness, and callousness, in fact required and secured that the millers would buy a very large percentage of the total volume of wheat tendered with a moisture content of between 28 and 33 per cent. I have told you the percentage of wheat which was rejected as unmillable — less than 3 per cent. I am not going to tell the House what my estimate is of the percentage of the total volume of wheat which was accepted at between 28 and 33 per cent. moisture content, but when the whole crop is in, if anyone wants to check on that we can go into it. I would ask the House to remember that, applying the criterion of the wheat growers' own representative, that should not be regarded as millable wheat at all. I insisted that it should.

I want to tell the House this, and it is as well you should know, as I believe in telling you everything. The point was put to me that if these grades of wheat were taken, unless there was dilution of the bulk by wheat of a lower maltose and higher glutin content, the resulting bread would be inedible and would create a prejudice against the whole policy of wheat growing. I agreed to permit the miller to bring in a certain percentage of wheats whereby to dilute the Irish wheat purchased with a moisture content of between 28 and 33 per cent., so as to ensure that the quality would be reasonably good for the bread users of the country and that the Irish product would not come to have a shocking reputation amongst those who were ultimately required to eat it.

As I understand the job of any Minister for Agriculture, when he is on the hustings he places his policy before the country, he asperses the policy of his antagonists and he abides the judgment of the people when the polls are taken. But once he is Minister for Agriculture, he is Minister for Agriculture for every farmer in the country. My duty was, whatever a farmer's problem, to help him to sell his crop for the best possible price that he could secure. I challenge any wheat farmer in Ireland in public now to prove that there was anything left undone, night or day, since the first sheaf of wheat was cut last September which could have been done to alleviate the distress under which he had to labour as a result of the appalling weather with which we all have had to contend.

I want to repeat that every single small or large farmer who is growing wheat or any other crop on his own land had a right to call on me for all the help that I could give to get him through his difficulties. Every Deputy had not only a right but a duty to call on me to help any farmer whose circumstances they knew of. Some Deputies did call on me and I do not think they called in vain. I think it is true to say that some Deputies on the other side of the House called on me and I do not think they called in vain. I deplore the action of those Deputies who knew distress amongst their neighbours and would not call on me. They knew perfectly well they had no need to call on me personally if they did not wish to do so; they could call on the Department without reference to me at all. But they were equally certain that if they wanted to call on me personally they were as welcome as the flowers in May; their right to do so was most readily conceded and their representations were most welcome, if they were a contribution to put anything right that was wrong.

I want the House to bear this in mind — Solomon himself could not claim that no mistakes were made, that there was no miscarriage of our plans in any part of Ireland. Of course there were; there were cases in which farmers were getting a raw deal; but I like to make the boast that no single such case was made to me without his grievance being redressed within 24 hours of my coming to know of it. Bearing in mind my corporate capacity I want to say I am proud of that performance. I am proud to be able to claim that no single case was reported to me of a farmer getting a raw deal, or being left in the lurch where help was not brought to his door within 24 hours of the information coming to me.

Comment on this

Pride is your deadly sin.

Comment on this

Before you came into the House, Deputy, I qualified that, when I said that when I spoke here I took the blame for what the Department does. Therefore, I am bound to take the praise for what it does, too. I want to issue this invitation to all Deputies on all sides of the House: if you hear of anybody who is getting a raw deal or less than his rights, you know where to come, and I would say to Deputies of this House that you have not only the right but the duty to come and let me know. But I cannot put right what I do not know about and, even when I do know about it, the best I can do is my best to put it right. That will be done, and it is as true in the case of the smallest farmer with his rood of wheat as it is in the case of the largest farmer with his acres of wheat. But I am bound to add this: that when the speculators come rambling into me to ask me what I am going to do to help them to salvage 800 or perhaps 1,000 acres of conacre wheat which they planted in the hope of making a kill — and they are now afraid they will not be able to make a kill — my inclination is to tell them to go to blazes. But I have not done so, because I think that when you are in the public service you ought not to give way to your natural inclinations as frankly and as fully as a private individual may, but I have no sympathy with these people. I have great sympathy with the man struggling with what he believed to be a sound business proposition when he sowed his crop and through no fault of his, he is now in grave jeopardy of sustaining grave loss. The entire resources of my Department are at that individual farmer's disposal to minimise that loss and, if possible, convert it into a profit for him.

I do not understand Deputy Allen. Usually when I hear him speak in this House, although I never — or very rarely—agree with him, I can always follow the trend of his discourse and understand at least what he is asking for even if I do not agree with him. But what does Deputy Allen mean in moving this motion by saying "hundreds of farmers have large quantities of unmillable wheat on their hands and they are not able to sell it?" How are they not able to sell it? Let me quote from the Irish Independent of the 12th instant:—

"Mr. Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, met representatives of the flour millers in Dublin yesterday and asked that a special effort be made to deal with non-millable wheat by taking it from the farmers, drying it and storing it for conversion into animal feeding.

The millers, it is understood, expressed willingness to come to the aid of the farmers as speedily as possible but a large quantity of wheat suitable for milling has not yet reached the mills although much of the grain requiring urgent attention has been dealt with.

The millers are prepared to reserve portion of their drying equipment for the non-millable grain and farmers could help by not rushing to the mills wheat which has not been gravely damaged. The mills would wish to give preference to grain known to be rain-soaked.

A price of from 47/6 to 50/- per barrel will, it is stated, be paid for the grain, which is said to be reasonably good in the circumstances."

What is the matter with the hundreds of farmers that Deputy Allen knows with unmillable wheat on their hands that they will not bring it to the nearest miller——

Comment on this

At 47/6?

Comment on this

From 47/6 to 50/- according to the condition of the grain, but if Deputy Allen is complaining about the poor men who cannot dispose of it at any price, would not Deputy Moher think they would go to the nearest miller——

Comment on this

It is a salvage price.

Comment on this

I know Deputy Moher has his tongue in his cheek when he says that. Indeed, I think the price "took the breath of him". In any case what I am querying is why Deputy Allen says he knows hundreds of farmers with unmillable wheat and they are not able to sell it at any price.

I honestly came in here with every conceivable aspect of the situation examined from stem to stern and I could not foresee what case the Opposition were going to make and I was rather at sea in trying to prepare to answer them, but the truth is they have said nothing. I want to give this House an instance of some cases where I do not believe, to say the least of it, the approach is conditioned by uberima fides. This case comes from County Wexford. It was a telegram which said:

"Mr. Dillon, Department of Agriculture: Have 100 bags of wheat, no drying facilities available—your suggestions, please?"

I am not going to read out the fellow's name or address, but if Mr. X of County Wexford would go 25 yards down his own street there was a man there who would dry all the wheat Mr. X could bring him.

My inspector went down the following day and this fellow's wheat was dried and returned to him. He was living within 50 yards of a dryer that we knew was in a position to dry the wheat. Does he walk 50 yards to inquire if he can get his wheat dried? No, he sends me a wire:—

"Mr. Dillon, Department of Agriculture: Have 100 bags of wheat, no drying facilities available — your suggestions, please?"

Now, I hate to be uncharitable but I wonder who wrote that telegram? I know the man who sent it. Those are the words that are in it and it was from County Wexford and if he challenges the authenticity of it and gives me permission—but only if he gives me permission—I will be glad to give his name and address. Those are the facts. I would like to ask Deputy Allen who wrote that telegram?

Comment on this

I do not know what all the argument is about.

Comment on this

I do not blame you at all.

Comment on this

I want to say this much: I had to phone the Minister for Agriculture one evening fairly late. He very kindly told me he would have the information on the following day and he went to the trouble of phoning me in Cork City and giving me the information. I think that is due to him. I would also like to say, from my experience this year — and we all know what the season was like: I do not think we have ever had a season like it before for the harvest and I hope we never again will — that in so far as the Department of Agriculture could help out, they helped out and they did, in my opinion, a damn good job. I have no hesitation at all in saying that. I am not concerned with the gentleman who gambled and of whom the Minister has been speaking. I am concerned with the very large number of my constituents who have millable wheat and who have got it dried and who now have it on their hands. I remember reading an article — by Professor Sheehy — at the start of this bad season, in which he stated that unmillable wheat for animal feeding was worth £27 a ton. That was the value he put on it.

We had an experience of this description once before — I admit it was not one-tenth as bad as it was this year— but we had a bad experience in this regard. Winter wheat in particular will shoot when growing, and we had that experience some years ago. I remember coming here to the then Minister for Agriculture, Dr. Ryan, with that problem and that was the reason why I phoned the Minister recently, because at that time there were certain regulations and prohibitions on the use of wheat for animal feeding. I consulted some local millers who said: "If we get a licence to convert that wheat into wheat flakes, we can get a market for it and we can pay a fair price for it." The difference in price then between millable and unmillable wheat was £4 per ton. We came up to Dr. Ryan and he said: "Yes, I will give the licence." He gave the licence and the wheat flakes sold like hot cakes; they disappeared off the market in the course of about six weeks. We have a far larger quantity this year of that type of wheat.

We were informed here recently that because we had to bring in foreign pollard and foreign bran the price of the pig ration went up by practically £5 per ton. I saw questions by Deputy Allen on that matter and I saw the replies given, and I am suggesting to the Minister — as I said, I am not concerned with the gentleman who came in and drew 800 acres — that I am concerned with the farmers in my county, the tillage farmers who have been growing wheat, beet, potatoes and root crops, and who now find the bulk of their harvest left on their hands, not through their own fault.

Comment on this

What was the Deputy saying about wheat flakes?

Comment on this

The millers at that time got a licence from the Minister for Agriculture to convert the unmillable wheat into wheat flakes and found a ready market for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that there is a general licence to do that this year, too.

Comment on this

As I said, I phoned the Minister with regard to it and he immediately informed me that there was no prohibition. I like to give credit where credit is due and I was thankful to the Minister for the manner in which he treated the matter. But I am coming down to this point: what should be the price paid for unmillable wheat dried? I am suggesting to the Minister that these people should not be thrown to the wolves with a price of 47/6 per barrel. I am making a straight suggestion to the Minister, and I have told him the class of people with whom I am concerned — the man who is dependent on his harvest to pay his merchant and to pay his rates and who now finds himself with a loft full of grain, or with grain in bags in his haggard, with no market for it, unless he accepts the market offered to him which, to my mind, is not a case of robbing the rich to pay the poor, but of skinning the poor — the men who find themselves in this awkward position and of whose financial circumstances advantage is being taken.

Comment on this

Has it not to be bought if it is sold as feeding stuff to some other farmer?

Comment on this

That is what I want. I want the Minister to see to it that, instead of Grain Importers, Limited, purchasing foreign bran and pollard and bringing it in here, they will use this material which is to hand and which will give better bran and pollard than they will get abroad.

Comment on this

Grain Importers do not buy bran or pollard. That is a free article which any co-operative or anybody else can import, but it is intended that the unmillable wheat will be incorporated in compound feeds and manufactured into wheat flakes, of which the Deputy has spoken, for animal feeding.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state what is the value of dried wheat which is unmillable?

Comment on this

Bearing in mind the fact that the farmer feeders have ultimately to buy and to pay for it, I do not think that 50/- is an unreasonable price for unmillable wheat, provided that a generous and lenient attitude is adopted in determining what wheat is millable and what is not.

Comment on this

We have got to the point now at which millable wheat has gone. We are away from that point.

Comment on this

There is a lot more millable wheat to come in.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the man who found himself having to dry his wheat and whose wheat was unmillable after drying and is now on his hands. I am looking for a market for that man.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is really in the spirit in which I believe him to be, my advice to that fellow is: if his wheat is dried and safe, let him shop around with it for a while. I believe he should certainly get 50/- and he may get more for it.

Comment on this

Did the Minister ever hear of a rate collector?

Comment on this

Nobody is going to "ate" the farmers this year.

Comment on this

We, as farmers, have to face facts and it was only at the last meeting of the Cork County Council——

Comment on this

The Deputy, as a county councillor, will not issue writs.

Comment on this