We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Purchase of Rejected Wheat—Motion.

Contributions 157–313 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

——that we had to issue an appeal — because we have no power over them — to rate collectors.

Comment on this

Between yourself and Deputy Moher, your voices will carry great weight.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would have patience. I do not wish to do anything that would be unfair and I am not trying to do anything that is unfair. I am suggesting to the Minister that he has a machine in Grain Importers, Limited, who are, I understand, a non-profit-making concern, which he can use to purchase from all farmers, who have it on hands, their unmillable wheat. I see no reason why it is not done.

Comment on this

It is being done.

Comment on this

I do suggest to the Minister quite frankly that his price is ridiculous. It is after all the price of what is a superior article to either bran or pollard or maize meal. A very distinguished professor, Professor Sheehy, has stated that it is worth £27 a ton. That was the price he put on it in the Farmers' Journal last month. I suggest that the Minister would buy it at £27 a ton, and I suggest also that he will find himself, with God's help, in the same position as his predecessor, Dr. Ryan, when he bought the oats, and when he gave out instructions with regard to wheat. Let us get into this problem quite frankly. The Minister will not get unmillable wheat by offering 47/6 a barrel for it. I wonder what Professor Sheehy would have to say to the gentleman who puts up that argument or who tells him, as the Minister has said, that if he holds the wheat for a while he might get 50/-a barrel. If that is the remedy the Minister has to offer I would suggest that he would change it and consult the officials of his Department on that particular matter and announce that Grain Importers, Limited, are prepared to purchase all unmillable wheat at such a price. I suggest that Professor Sheehy hit about the right price.

Comment on this

Which was?

Comment on this

£27 a ton. Surely it is as good as maize, or maybe a lot better.

Comment on this

You are getting more than £27 a ton.

Comment on this

If you are selling wheat with 33 per cent. moisture content for 47/6 you are getting better than £27 a ton.

Comment on this

I am talking about dried wheat. I am talking about dry unmillable wheat that is at present in the farmers' hands.

Comment on this

47/6 for wet wheat.

Comment on this

The Deputy is right.

Comment on this

What is the price for dried wheat?

Comment on this

Did you not agree with me that the man who has dried unmillable wheat which is perfectly safe, has, in his holding, the best feeding stuff he could have if he could use it. Surely some of it could be sold to a neighbour if he is not satisfied with the price of the mill.

Comment on this

The Minister has suggested that if he held it in his loft for a few months he would get 50/- for it.

Comment on this

That he would get anything he could for it.

Comment on this

When I asked recently if there could be a market found for this wheat, the Minister said the farmer would do far better by keeping it in his loft and getting 50/- for it.

Comment on this

No. No. He can get up to 50/- for any unmillable wheat now, according to quality. If he has it of such a fine quality as the Deputy described I am amazed that it has not been deemed to be millable but if it has not been deemed millable is it not the best feeding stuff he could have if he can use it himself?

Comment on this

Therefore, the Minister will lose nothing if he does what is suggested in this motion. Let us get rid of the camouflage and get down to what the people want. I have explained the position here as a farmer and as one coming from a very heavy grain district. I am asking the Minister—I suggest he should hold the consultation, in which he is now engaged, afterwards——

Comment on this

I am only saying that the Deputy is as cute as a Christian.

Comment on this

Let us have the Minister's straight reply as to whether he is going to do it or not. The suggestion I am putting up is a reasonable one. It was a proposal that was adopted previously with great success by the Minister's predecessor. I remember a period here when oats could not be sold. It was unsaleable, and was left in the farmers' hands. We appealed to the then Minister, Dr. Ryan, and he issued instructions immediately to Grain Importers, Limited, to purchase the oats at a certain price. The oats was purchased and the State financed the purchase and there was not 1/- lost. I remember in later years when the Minister was over there. He had told the people of the country to grow oats, and no market could be found for that oats. The following harvest, we had to wait until nearly Christmas until the Minister was sent to America and the acting-Minister came along and bought the oats and did what we asked him to do. We do not want that to happen in this case. The farmers, as I said, want the money to pay their accounts. They have lost enough — the difference between £27 a ton and the price which in the ordinary course they would get. Thank God the farmers in my area always grew oats and wheat that fetched top price and bushelled top, and they have lost enough this season. I am asking the Minister to come to the rescue; I am asking him now to do his job.

If the Minister is so anxious to rescue the farmers, as he pretends, he can rescue them by paying them a fair price for the wheat that is unmillable. Is it not better to pay them than to pay the foreigner for muck? In the ordinary course the supply of bran and pollard produced here is only sufficient for a couple of months and, when it is exhausted, we have to import. This year when the time came for importing the price of the ration jumped £5 per ton. I do not know what the price was that was paid for foreign bran and foreign pollard brought in here, but surely dried wheat is superior to either and is worth a better price than either.

Despite all the Minister's manoeuvres I do not believe he is turning a deaf ear to the case I am making. I believe he will do what I have asked him. I have faith in the Minister; I think he will do what I have asked him. I think it is the natural and reasonable thing to ask the Minister to do. I do not think I am asking him to do anything unreasonable. I am sorry the Minister has not announced the price for next year's wheat. He promised he would do so in October, and we are anxious to get it. I come from a grain growing area in which a large quantity of wheat is being left on our hands. Some of us were lucky and got rid of the lot. Others were not lucky and they are being left with wheat on their hands, through no fault of their own but merely because of adverse harvesting conditions. What is the position? Will the Minister sit quietly by whilst unmillable dried wheat is bought at 47/6 per barrel?

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Do not confuse the issue. The farmers are entitled to bring their unmillable wheat to the mill and they will there get 47/6 per barrel for it. Do not spread the word throughout the country that any miller has the right to turn a farmer away if his unmillable wheat has not been dried before he brings it to the mill. The wheat will be taken from the farmer if it is unmillable and, if it is in any reasonable condition at all, he will get 47/6 a barrel. That does not apply only to dry wheat.

Comment on this

I do not give a hang for the Minister's 47/6. The farmers I am dealing with are the farmers who have paid through the nose at the rate of 3/6 a barrel to get their wheat dried.

Comment on this

Let us not confuse the issue. All farmers bringing unmillable wheat to the mill can now have it taken off their hands at a minimum of 47/6 a barrel. Let me repeat—unmillable, not dried millable wheat.

Comment on this

I have asked the Minister to fix a price for unmillable dried wheat. There are farmers who, helped by the Minister, have rushed all over the country and got the wheat dried. The wheat is now dried wheat. They will not sell that wheat at 47/6 a barrel. They will not put it in the loft, as the Minister has suggested, and keep it for a couple of months and then sell it at 50/- a barrel. They will not do the one or the other. I suggest that that wheat is far better for animal feeding than any bran, pollard or maize. Even if the Minister comes down to the jokers with the foreign barley, native wheat is still far better as a feeding stuff for animals.

The problem that the farmers have to face is the fact that they want an immediate market. Neither the merchant nor the rate collector will wait. I am asking the Minister to provide that market. I think it is his duty to provide it. I go further and I say that, even if it was never his duty, I believe he will provide it. For pity's sake, forget the fellow with the 800 acres. Forget him for the sake of the decent farmers who have answered the request of the Government to produce more. After all, it was a request from the Government that they should produce more. They have produced the wheat. Unfortunately, through no fault of the Government but merely because of forces over which we have no control, we had here a harvest this year unparalleled in the history of this country. The farmers have lost enough. Do not rob them. I hold they are being robbed when the Minister suggests that if they hold that dried wheat for a couple of months they will get 50/-a barrel for it.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry knows that you did not say it.

Comment on this

It is never any harm when a mistake — I use the word advisedly — is repeated sufficiently often to correct it. I did not say what the Deputy thinks I said.

Comment on this

The question I asked the Minister was what he intended to do with the dried unmillable wheat on the farmers' hands.

Comment on this

That is about the tenth time the Deputy has said that.

Comment on this

The genius back there may know how to add two and two and make five out of it. Let him stick to that.

Comment on this

The Deputy might change his tune. On a point of order. Is the Deputy entitled to repeat the same statement over and over again?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not in order.

Comment on this

Is a Deputy entitled, when a Minister states that he wants to correct something, to find out exactly what the Minister did say? That is all I am anxious to find out.

Comment on this

After the Minister has corrected it ten times for the Deputy; the Deputy is not a bit slow in the up-take at all.

Comment on this

If Deputy Morrissey had been listening to my friend there at the back when he was speaking he would know what we are talking about; when we came down to business, I repeated the statement to the Minister and the Minister admitted it was true. Now he realises the hole he has got into and he is trying to dig himself out. I do not grudge him trying to dig himself out if, in digging himself out, he will answer the question I put: namely, what is a fair price for dried unmillable wheat? That is a fair question. Will the Minister answer that? When I asked that question before, the Minister said the farmer need not sell that wheat for 47/6; if he keeps it a couple of months he will get 50/- for it.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I will go with the Minister to the Official Report and see what he has down before the Minister corrects it, if the Minister accepts my invitation. Will the Minister even now state, if he did not say that, what is a fair price for dried wheat which is unmillable?

Comment on this

That is a fair question.

Comment on this

That is a perfectly fair question. I spoke here to-day and I have no intention of speaking again.

Comment on this

You did not answer that question though.

Comment on this

It will be answered all right.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry is in possession.

Comment on this

I have given the Minister a price named by Professor Sheehy, a person who is an authority. I do not know if he is still an official of the Department but he says £27 a ton. If the Minister will give instructions to Grain Importers Limited to purchase the dried wheat that is unmillable and left on the farmers' hands, at £27 a ton, and if he will stand up here and give that guarantee, then the purpose of this motion will have been served. We want that. We want the Minister to do that and to do it now. I do not want my friends over there to be put in the awkward position that they were put in before of having to ship the Minister to America while somebody else was doing the job. I do not want that to happen again.

Comment on this
A Deputy

I am sure you do not.

Comment on this

I do not. I am very fond of the Minister. He may not know it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might get fonder of the motion and deal with it.

Comment on this

I would suggest, a Cheann Comhairle, that what I have said has been strictly to the motion, that I have kept far more strictly to the motion than the Minister has. I did not deal with what has happened here, there or elsewhere. I am dealing with the position in which we find ourselves. The motion before the House asks the Government to make an arrangement with Grain Importers to purchase at a fair price all wheat rejected as unmillable. I would suggest, a Cheann Comhairle, that I am keeping strictly to the motion. I am not going into what happened at the mills. What happened at the mills has passed and, please God, it will never happen again, because next year we will have a man in every mill who will see the load weighed, who will see the wheat bushelled and who will take the moisture content, the same as we have in the Sugar Company, and there, thank God, things are working out amicably. We will have the same thing in the mills next year and there will be an end to this condition of affairs.

The problem that we are faced with is a serious problem for the agricultural community. It is a serious problem for the men who have had their harvest, as I said, thrown on their hands. Surely it should not be beyond the resources of a Government and a Department to find a cure for this problem. That is not asking too much. That is my appeal here. I promise the gentlemen who speak for the farmers or who were so anxious about the farmers last night that if they evaded trotting around last night they will trot around to-night.

Comment on this

It was you who evaded.

Comment on this

You would dodge anything. It is customary in this House when a motion of that type is put down for a Minister to state what he will do. We hear a lot about what the Minister did. We give him credit for doing a fair lot and we give his Department credit for working hard and working overtime on that job. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

That is not what your colleagues said, Deputy.

Comment on this

There is a motion on the Order Paper. The Minister has not stated if he is prepared to carry out the terms of the motion or not. We have been accustomed in this Dáil, when a motion is discussed, to hear the Minister concerned saying whether he will accept the motion or not. Will the Minister say that he is prepared to have unmillable wheat purchased? I do not know for how long he was speaking before I came into the House but he was speaking for a long time after I arrived and he rambled around every subject under the sun, every kind of wheat under the sun but did not answer the particular question that we wanted an answer to. I am prepared to give way to the Minister, even now, if he will state that he is prepared to have the unmillable wheat purchased and a price fixed for it. I am not concerned with wet wheat.

Comment on this

That is what the country are concerned with down our way.

Comment on this

If this is a serious matter, Deputy Corry ought to stop play-acting. He has been play-acting for three-quarters of an hour.

Comment on this

It is not play-acting.

Comment on this

It is absolute play-acting.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very fond of talking of play-acting when he finds he has not a reply to an argument.

Comment on this

I will reply to you when you sit down.

Comment on this

I often heard you replying — half an hour of abuse and nonsense.

Comment on this

Wind and fury.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry on the motion.

Comment on this

We have had three-quarters of an hour of repetition.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not prepared to allow the question of whether the Minister will fix a price for unmillable wheat repeated. I have heard it four or five times from Deputy Corry since I came into the House. I rule that that is repetition and the Deputy will have to pass from it and deal with some other aspect of the motion, if there is another aspect.

Comment on this

I shall not go back on it but I wish to call the attention of the House to the fact that the Minister has not answered it. I am quite satisfied to leave it at that. There are reasons why we should have an early decision on this matter, very definite reasons. I wish that the Minister, before he leaves the House, would give us that answer. Apparently he will not. He can dodge around the corridor for another bit. I hope he will not go to America this time.

I do not wish to delay the House, I have put the case as clearly as I can in the time at my disposal, and I only hope that we will have some definite decision on it.

Comment on this

Every Deputy who has spoken in this debate — I was going to say on this motion — I hope Deputy Corry will not do the usual thing and run away.

Comment on this

I would not waste time listening to you.

Comment on this

The Deputy can give it out but never take it. The Deputy ought to wait.

Comment on this

Wait for what? I am prepared to wait and listen to any farmer.

Comment on this

I know more about wheat and have handled more of it than many of the Deputies in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry is speaking outside the barrier. He ought to know sufficient of the Rules of the House to know that that is not allowed and should not be done.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

He can afford to play act because he told us he was fortunate enough himself to get the top price for his wheat. The motion is:—

"That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the Government should, in the exceptional circumstances of this year, make an arrangement with Grain Importers (Éire) Limited to purchase at a fair price, all wheat rejected as unmillable."

Deputy Corry did not tell us what he thought a fair price would be for it. Other members of the Opposition wanted to know what we thought was a fair price. They did not tell us what they thought was a fair price. Deputy Corry quoted a professor who said that a fair price for unmillable wheat would be £27 per ton. That is a difference of roughly 15/- a barrel between the minimum price which has been arranged with the millers and what Deputy Corry's professor said would be a fair price. Deputy Corry did not tell us — I hope some of those who are yet to speak on this motion will tell us — from where or from whom is the additional 15/- per barrel to come. Who is to pay it?

Of course, it would be much more than 15/- per barrel if it were bought by Grain Importers, Limited. Anybody who knows anything about the organisation in this country for the purchase, delivery, the storing and the drying of wheat, even in a normal year, would laugh at this motion. Earlier one of my colleagues said that as far as Grain Importers were concerned all they had was an office. What machinery would Grain Importers use to implement this motion if the House were foolish enough to pass it? Would they not have to get the agents and the buyers the millers employed throughout the country? Would they not have to utilise the storage and the drying facilities that are available? Would they not have to use the whole of that machinery? This year, when time is a vital factor, the only suggestion we can get from the people on the opposite side is that in regard to the great delaying factor and that this additional cost should be planked on.

The motion is absurd and unreal. There is not a Deputy here but knows that. Deputies will themselves admit that this whole debate was unreal. The fact of the matter is that the Deputies have been completely bewildered by the fact that the Minister made an infinitely better arrangement for the farmers than either we on this side of the House or Deputies on the opposite side thought it was possible to make. Let me repeat what has been said and what everybody knows. This has been the worst year in living memory. There was not a Deputy in this House or a farmer outside it who lived in or came from a representative grain-growing county but thought that we were going to have the most disastrous year from the harvest point of view that probably ever struck this country. In a year when we were having bumper crops and an unprecedented acreage of wheat in particular there was not a Deputy who, if he was not saying it, actually felt that 25 per cent. of the crops would be completely lost and that it would be unfit either for human or for animal feeding.

Will any Deputy who knows anything about grain growing or about the trouble of trying to save grain in a year like this try and be realistic about it? I come from a grain-growing constituency and I know something about the handling, drying and testing of grain. I spent years at it. In the light of what we have had every fair-minded farmer will agree that to get an arrangement made that all dried or undried millable wheat will be taken from the farmers at no less than 47/6 per barrel was an achievement. It was something which every single Deputy in this House would have said a fortnight ago would be impossible. There is not a farmer in this country growing grain but knows it is an achievement.

There is not a Deputy in this House, particularly those on the opposite side who had ministerial responsibility themselves, who believes for one moment that Grain Importers could put up from the farmer's point of view a better deal or a fairer price than the millers have already secured.

When you talk about moisture content that denotes not merely the water but also dirt and chaff and everything else, and for a farmer to-day, going through what he has gone through, to be guaranteed that, irrespective of the moisture content of his grain, whether it is 25 or 35 per cent., he will get a minimum of 47/6 per barrel is a good bargain. I am perfectly satisfied that every Deputy on the opposite side is as conscious of that as I am. Every Deputy believes it is a good bargain. Every Deputy knows that what has now been arranged will get the farmers out of this disastrous harvest in an infinitely much better way.

Deputy Moher, who is too intelligent to believe what he was saying, sort of sneered at 50/- per barrel as just a salvage price. What are we trying to deal with this year but to endeavour to save everything possible? It is more than a salvage price. A salvage price is a price for a part of something that has been saved from either the disaster of water or fire, but the price is not for part of the crop. It is for the whole of the crop.

The Minister gave figures for the grain which has already been delivered to the mills. Between 1,750,000 and 2,000,000 barrels have already been delivered. Is there a Deputy who was not pleasantly surprised to be informed that out of those 1,750,000 to 2,000,000 barrels more grain delivered this year less than 3 per cent. of it was rejected as unmillable? I think we ought to be ashamed of ourselves to be talking the way we have been talking this afternoon. We ought to be ashamed to be posturing — and there was a certain amount of posturing — at being displeased with the situation. I think we ought to thank Almighty God that the farmers are not going to be broken financially this year as it was feared that many of them would be.

I know, of course, that the farmers would like to see — so would all of us like to see—every barrel of the crop millable and every barrel of that crop bushelling the highest. That does not happen even in normal years. This motion is impracticable. It could not be put into operation unless, I would say — and I am putting it very mildly — we were to take Deputy Corry's price of £27 a ton for unmillable wheat and add on the additional cost per barrel which would be incurred by using Grain Importers as a fifth wheel to the coach. The difference to be found is somewhere between 20/- and 22/6 a barrel over the price that has been arranged with the millers for unmillable wheat. I want some Fianna Fáil Deputy to tell me where the difference between 47/6 and 65/- a barrel for unmillable wheat is to come from. Who will pay it? Is it the consumer of bread or the purchaser of animal feeding stuffs or is it to be another £1 a barrel from the Exchequer by way of additional subsidy? As far as I know, these are the only three sources from which they can be got. Will the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches tell us which of the three sources they suggest it could be got from or where it could be got from? Let us be realistic about this. My constituents have suffered as much as grain growers in any other constituency. I know them as constituents and I know them intimately as grain growers. I am confident that they will be perfectly satisfied the Minister and his Department have left nothing undone this year to lessen the blow which the terrible weather has inflicted on them.

As I have already said, I think that any fair-minded man who looks at this impartially and without any desire to play politics with so serious a matter must come to the conclusion that a very good job has been done—far better than anybody believed could have been done a fortnight ago.

Comment on this

The job was done by the farmers.

Comment on this

I do not care by whom it was done so long as it was well done.

Comment on this

It was done by the farmers.

Comment on this

Apparently, the Deputy's friends did not know that a drying yard was 25 miles away from them. The Deputy had to wire to the Department.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

He had to wire to the Department. There were telegrams too.

Comment on this

What telegrams are you talking about?

Comment on this

Innocents abroad!

Comment on this

Will Deputy Allen tell the House or tell me how Grain Importers are going to give a better service or a better price to the farmers who have unmillable wheat on their hands than has been arranged with the millers? What machinery has Grain Importers to pay? How are they going to buy it?

Comment on this

The motion asked that it be done at a reasonable price. That was all we said. That is all that is in the motion. Did you read the motion?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me how it is to be done?

Comment on this

The Minister says he is doing it now.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Crotty Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Crotty) Fine Gael

It is done.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me what machinery is at the disposal of Grain Importers to purchase, to take delivery of, to store, to dry, to weigh or to bushel wheat? Will the Deputy answer that question? Will the Deputy answer a second question — and in my opinion the whole motion hangs upon these two questions. Will the Deputy tell us who is to pay the difference between 47/6 per barrel for unmillable wheat and the 62/6 per barrel suggested by his colleague, Deputy Corry. I see that Deputy Carter wants to answer me. I shall be glad to give way to hear the Deputy's answer.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that Deputy Morrissey continue with his speech.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Carter wanted to give me the answer to my questions.

Comment on this

I have made one speech already.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is the mover of this motion and he has the honour and privilege of replying to this debate. I challenge him, when he is replying, to answer the following questions. Will he tell us what machinery Grain Importers, Limited, have at their disposal to enable them to purchase and handle the unmillable wheat in this country? If they have not the machinery at the moment — and they have not, and the Deputy knows that better than I do and so does Deputy Harris know that they have no machinery other than a few typewriters and fountain pens — where are they going to get the machinery? From whom are they going to get the machinery? When are they going to get the machinery, and how much longer will they have to delay the taking from the farmers of the undried unmillable wheat? I might say that there is more undried unmillable wheat in the country at the moment than there is dried unmillable wheat. Deputies know that too. Will some Fianna Fáil Deputy also answer this question? Who is going to pay the difference between 47/6 and 62/6, as suggested by Deputy Corry? You cannot answer these questions. You could not. It is impossible for you to answer them because the whole motion is impossible. It is cod —and I venture to suggest that it is not worthy of a Party that was so long privileged to govern this country to put down a motion like this dealing with such a very serious situation — a situation which is still serious but no longer disastrous.

Comment on this

I have listened to a number of speeches on this motion. I am one of the signatories to the motion. All the motion asks for is that the farmers will get a fair price for unmillable wheat. Anyone who lives in the country and who is familiar with the conditions that have existed there since the beginning of the harvest knows that the position is pretty bad. Since the harvest started, the weather has been continuously bad. We cannot blame the Government for that. The cutting of the corn is hardly completed yet. A large amount of wheat has been cut with the combine. I know wheat growers who were in a desperate plight with their wheat. When they took it to the mill at first the millers refused to accept it. I know one man who put up an electric drier in order to try and put his wheat into condition. This man is a young enterprising man who took a considerable acreage of conacre, ploughed it, put in his crop, treated it well and bought a combine. Of course, the year was not a suitable one for the combine. All he could do was to snatch every hour he could to cut and dry it. This was in the beginning of the season and I understand that, at that time, the miller refused to take it. He said he would not take combine wheat at all. Although I agree that this was not a suitable year for the combine, nevertheless, if it had not been for the combine I think a lot of the wheat could not be dealt with. The man provided himself with an electric drier. He dried the wheat and I understand that he was then told by the miller that he would not accept wheat that was dried by the owner because it was a skilled operation which required experience and knowledge and the wheat might not be suitable for milling.

I was very interested in what Deputy Corry stated here. I am sure a number of farmers were in that position, that where they could not get their wheat into the mill they got it dried in order to preserve it and keep it from rotting. I believe that dried wheat, if it is considered unmillable by the miller, is really a first-class animal feeding stuff, and I think that the price of 50/- a barrel offered by the Minister for wheat of that quality is very low. Perhaps some farmers who have wheat in a very wet condition and of very low quality, so that they could hardly put any value on it at all, would consider themselves lucky to get 50/- a barrel for it.

However, there must be a large amount of really good quality unmillable wheat in the country. I understand, from reading the Young Farmers' paper, that wheat has been rejected where sprouted grains have been found in the sample. In many cases where wheat was cut — not with a combine — and stacked, the sheaves grew on the heads of the stacks or stooks. In the threshing of that wheat, where a great portion of it is very good, it would be impossible in many cases to keep the growing grains from mixing with the corn. In that instance, if the miller rejected that and considered it unmillable, I would consider 50/- to be a very low price for it. Fifty shillings is all right for unmillable wheat of the very worst quality, but there is plenty of wheat in the country that could be considered unmillable and probably will be rejected as unmillable this year by the millers but which I am convinced would be of equal value to maize as animal feeding.

I understand that the price of maize coming into the country is about £28 a ton. That is much higher than the price the Minister offers for unmillable wheat of good quality. The farmer is in a very weak and vulnerable position. There is a lot of corn still to be threshed; the season is not yet finished and a lot of that corn may be rejected as unmillable, unfit for flour. We are not asking anything unreasonable in our motion. I understand the import price of pollard at the present time is £27 a ton. The Minister said that this wheat is to be used in compound mixtures. If that unmillable wheat were not there to put into the compound mixtures this year and we had to buy foreign grain to substitute for it, the Minister would not get it for the £19 a ton he offers the farmers for their wheat. The farmers are entitled to the import price of pollard or maize for unmillable wheat of good quality.

Deputy Morrissey asked here who was going to make up the difference. After all, if the consumers of animal feeding stuffs want to buy it, they should not ask the wheat growers to produce animal food for them at a cheaper rate than it could be imported. All this motion asks is fair play for the farming community. Despite what the Minister says about the difficulties of putting an arbitrator into the mills, I think something should be done about it to look after the farmers. All farmers know very well the difficulties to be faced. The same thing happened at the time of gluts in the sale of store cattle. It happened with barley and oats in the past and there was not very much sympathy for the farmers when they were weak and disorganised. We put down this motion because we want to speak for the farmers who are disorganised and in desperate difficulties due to the weather. They should receive more consideration from the Government in this matter. There was no lead given to them during the whole year and I think it is almost too late now to be making any suggestion to remedy the situation. In my own county it is only a few days ago that the military were released to give assistance. I have heard of their being out in fields of corn where the stooks have grown trying to pull them asunder. If they were there three weeks or a month ago——

Comment on this

They would be grown, too.

Comment on this

They would not. I know as much about corn as Deputy Hughes.

Comment on this

About one that is on your toe.

Comment on this

What kind of a joke is that?

Comment on this

It is a very cheap one. We can expect nothing else where it came from.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Harris without interruption.

Comment on this

The farmers did not get the lead they expected, particularly in view of the statements made by the Minister for Agriculture about the growing of wheat. We heard Deputy Hughes speaking to-night about the big speculators and the big growers. I would not like to see any wheat lost, and some consideration should be given to the younger men who had not so much experience but were enterprising, paid big prices to land owners for their land to grow wheat and paid up to £30 an acre for it in my own county. These people should be helped out. If we do not sympathise with people who want to get rich quick, we should not ask the whole farming community to suffer on account of them. Something should have been done and nothing was done. The price offered by the Minister for good quality wheat that is not fit for the making of flour is not sufficient. They should get at least its value. It is very easy to calculate its value. Professor Murphy told Deputy Corry that good quality unmillable wheat, dried, was worth £27 a ton. Deputy Corry pressed the Minister to buy dried unmillable wheat. Why not give the farmers a reasonable price for it dried and give them a chance of drying it where they can do so?

This motion was not put down for political purposes but to draw attention to the condition of affairs in the country. There are people suffering silently. The farmers are not grumblers — in the past we heard they were grumblers — but they are depressed and disheartened at present and they have no encouragement from the Minister or the Government.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

I regret very much indeed to hear Deputy Harris say that nothing was done by the Government in relation to the problems the agricultural community have had to meet over the past two months. I could draw many examples of things that were done in response to messages from the country, to assist people in overcoming the serious difficulties that arose as a result of the extremely bad weather. According to all reports, we had a record bad harvest; in living memory it has not been recalled that the people have undergone more privations in trying to save the harvest than they have undergone this year.

I would just mention one compliment, in tribute to a former Fianna Fáil Deputy from my own constituency who is now chairman of the committee of agriculture in the County Cork. He complimented the present Minister on his action in regard to the regulations on moisture content in wheat this year. I am sure Deputy Harris has read the comments of Councillor Meaney on that occasion. It was a very fair tribute from an opponent of the present Minister, but it was one which he felt was demanded by the action of the Minister in meeting the situation at that time. We must be reasonable about it. The grain growers are deeply appreciative of the action of the Minister so promptly taken at that time in giving them that assistance. Therefore, it is very dishonest and unfair to state that nothing was done. In fact, Deputy Corry—despite his claim to have a particular affection for the present Minister, in opening his remarks— would have made an epic contribution to this House if he had sat down five minutes after he got up, for at that point he indicated clearly and rightly that the Minister had responded to information which he had submitted, where prompt action was taken and good results came about from the supply of the information. That was indicative that if other Deputies who have come in and tried to avail of this motion for political purposes had been as active as Deputy Corry was on that occasion, perhaps their efforts would have been more fruitful than they have been here this afternoon.

The Government were sufficiently conscious of the importance of saving the wheat to provide a forum to the members on all sides to present their contributions at some length this afternoon. We awaited with some interest the suggestions that were to emanate from this motion before us. Quite reasonable questions have been posed from this side as to what the movers consider to be a fair price. First of all, we had some suggestions that the machinery to be employed should be different, that Grain Importers should be utilised to handle the unmillable wheat. However, since it was pointed out that their machinery was more or less limited to the extent of their office furniture, we have had no comeback so far. In their reply, I am sure some one of the movers of the motion — perhaps Deputy Allen — will indicate how he considers that organisation could handle the unmillable wheat. It has been pointed out that there is a parallel comparison in what happened to barley on a previous occasion and the impact that it had on the consumers. After all, who are the consumers in this instance but the smaller farmers who have not land capable of growing wheat? I represent a constituency which is practically evenly divided between land that is good, capable of carrying a certain amount of live stock with a very short winterage, and these farmers also grow a considerable amount of grain as a cash crop. On the other hand, one half of my constituency, containing two-thirds of the farmers of the whole constituency, would be called on, if this motion were given effect to, to provide the additional £1 or 22/6 per barrel that the Opposition claims should be paid for this unmillable wheat.

Deputy Morrissey suggested there were three means by which the money could be found, and it was implied that there was a parallel in the history in relation to feeding barley. If so, the movers of this motion feel that the burden is to be carried by the people who buy the feeding stuff, to convert it into meat, to feed it to poultry, to produce eggs and bring them to the market. These unfortunates, remember, have also difficulties to meet, arising from the extraordinarily bad harvest this year. We must not forget that these people are facing a very severe winter, as a result of the impact of the bad weather on the fodder for live stock that they must carry over for the winter. If it is intended to give effect to this motion, will it overcome all the burdens that they will have to carry? Surely it is accepted that the Minister, in the result that has come from his recent arrangements, has found what must now be regarded as an extraordinarily low proportion of wheat which is regarded as unmillable, when you compare it with the estimates of some weeks past? Surely it must be conceded that, in relation to that small proportion of the entire wheat crop, the Minister has gone a long way in resolving the difficulies which the farmers had to meet in this season?

Comment on this

I do not propose to speak at any great length on this motion but would like to say, that, as is typical of the Fianna Fáil Party here, on many occasions when events which gravely concern the well-being of the farming community are being discussed, you find that politics are dragged in. The Fianna Fáil Party seem to avail of any opportunity to adopt these tactics. It is indeed regrettable that that should be the case. They are prepared to stoop even to the tactics we have had to-night; they are prepared to avail of the deplorable conditions of the farmers in recent times in order to try to reflect on the present Minister for Agriculture and on the manner in which he has discharged his duties.

I would like to say at the outset that I fully appreciate the difficulties with which the present Minister was confronted when this emergency arose. We were waiting from day to day in the hope that the weather would improve and no improvement came. Suddenly we discovered that the harvest in the fields was being destroyed. Any fair-minded person must agree that, having regard to the serious conditions that prevailed, the Minister went about the whole thing in a business like way. I think it is up to me to say, on behalf of the farming community — I represent a rural constituency — that though the people were downhearted and despondent on account of the weather they are not without appreciation of the Minister's efforts to do everything humanly possible for them. Even Deputy Corry, though he is very often critical of the present Minister, had to admit that. I was surprised that he did. Other Deputies on his side of the House did not agree with that viewpoint. There were conflicting statements from gentlemen on the far side.

I think I have already stated that the farmers do appreciate that the Minister has done everything humanly possible under such conditions and, furthermore, I feel that the farming community have the greatest confidence in the present Minister in this or any other matter that may arise as far as they are concerned. Deputies from other constituencies, I could not help noticing, referred to holdings of 500 or 700 acres. We have no such holdings in my constituency. People who are fortunate to have such big holdings of land have now evidently turned to letting it in conacre. That, I submit, is a very bad policy and a bad practice for the nation as a whole. I think it is something that should be very strongly condemned. I am aware you have people at present coming across the water from England or flying over in planes buying land for conacre.

I think it was Deputy Harris who said they were paying up to £30 an acre. I do not suggest that the people who bought the land in Deputy Harris's area were foreigners—that may not apply in his district but it does apply in some parts of the country. These gentlemen come along from foreign countries and are actually buying up the land of Ireland or taking it in conacre and sowing wheat in it and I seriously suggest that the Minister should take some steps to see that that is discontinued. We all know and appreciate that where land is taken in conacre, the people who do so have one purpose only and that is to knock everything they possibly can out of it and when they have robbed and plundered it they leave it. That means that the national income here is suffering seriously as a result. I would ask Deputies to appreciate that the one thing we have got in this country is the land of Ireland. I am sure the present Minister appreciates that as much as anybody and to think that we have foreigners coming in here robbing our lands of the very important minerals that are there, lining their pockets——

Comment on this

Are we still on the motion?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am trying to direct attention to the motion.

Comment on this

In a debate of this kind it might be suggested that what I am saying is irrelevant but I think at the same time it is a matter that has a big bearing on the whole question of this motion. My area is not a big wheat-growing area, as the land there is not really suitable for wheat. We are bigger producers of oats and other crops than we are of wheat but I am aware of instances where wheat has been turned away from mills in certain parts of the country. It was actually delivered by lorries and rejected by the mills because it was not up to the standard required. Then the lorry was driven away to another mill 25 or 30 miles away and the wheat was accepted there. That would seem to suggest to me that there is something shady about the type of mill owner who would do business in that way and I can well understand that a farmer who has quite a lot of trouble and expense and time spent tilling, reaping, and looking after his crop who is treated in that way when he offers his crop for sale, will feel very disappointed and it is unlikely that in the following year he will go in for tillage particularly of wheat.

The cases to which I refer concern wheat transactions and I think the Minister when an emergency like this arises should consult with the secretaries of the various county committees of agriculture in the counties concerned and enlist their support and cooperation. I know that he has adopted that practice in the past and in matters of this kind I would suggest to him that he would enlist the support of the various county committees of agriculture to help him over these difficulties. I feel strongly on this having regard to the abuses which I know have occurred in recent times and I feel that the Minister should take some steps to have a representative of the farmers at these mills — if not in a permanent capacity — at least to have an inspector or representative of the Department of Agriculture to look after, say, three mills, so that a farmer who delivers his wheat to the mill and has it rejected can telephone the Department representative and ask him to come along and inspect the stuff and see if the mill owner is giving a fair deal. I think it is only due to the farmer that something like that should be brought into being. Deputies from different sides of this House have said that these things are happening in their constituencies and if that is true — and it is true in my constituency — there is something that needs remedying at once.

On the question of the prices paid for inferior quality wheat I am sure the Minister with his own Department officials has gone very thoroughly into the whole question. He and his officials have worked hard and late to do everything humanly possible in such an emergency as we unfortunately experienced and I am sure in the matter of fixing prices he has had due regard to all the factors involved. I believe that he has had the matter of price fixation under consideration and that he will strike a fair balance taking into account that inferior wheat must in the main be fed to animals.

I would ask the Minister to consider seriously the few points I have made on behalf of the farming community. I have gone around among them in recent times and met scores and scores of people who have suffered very severely as a result of the weather and I can truthfully say the farmers are not without deep appreciation of what the Minister has done on their behalf in most difficult circumstances.

Comment on this
John O'Donovan Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. O'Donovan) Fine Gael

Earlier this evening Deputy Corry asked what price was the Minister prepared to pay or recommend as the proper value for dried unmillable wheat, and he suggested that it was a matter of life and death to the farmers of this country. Personally, I believe that the quantity of dried unmillable wheat available for sale is very small —"none"— I hear one of my farmer colleagues say. In answer to Deputy Corry's query, I can give him a little piece of information: this morning, there was an offer of £25 a ton at a Dublin mill for dried unmillable wheat. It all depends on what percentage of moisture is still left in it, and it is one of the questions to which there can be any number of answers. If Professor Sheehy has said that it was worth £27 a ton, it may well be that my price of £25 a ton is just as good for a certain quality of wheat as his price of £27 a ton is for another quality.

Earlier this evening, we had a lot of rodomontade and "cod" talked on the opposite side, and it looked at one stage as if the motion was not going to get going at all. Deputy Allen said that the Minister has sat back showing his contempt for the growing of wheat in this country, and my colleague Deputy O'Sullivan has dealt with that, and it is not necessary for me to repeat what he said. Deputy Moher made an attack on the Department of Agriculture and wanted such action as will save the farmers from beggary and ruin. If these words have any relation to reality, I think we should not be here in this House but should all be out helping with the harvest. Deputy Carter suggested that one-third of the wheat crop is going to be a dead loss this year and the Minister has answered that. I had made a note and "not one-tenth as much" is what I had put down. The Minister duly confirmed that by saying it was about 3 per cent. What is that 3 per cent. worth, taking it at present prices which the Minister has arranged with the millers? It is worth about £250,000 in a crop which is worth something around £15,000,000 or £16,000,000.

I thought at one stage that the Opposition Party would not go ahead with the motion. The Minister had seen the millers on the morning of the day on which they put it down, and I thought that surely they would not go ahead with it. It looked to-day very much as if they realised that they should not have gone ahead with it, but it seems to me that, when they decide on a course of action, be it right or wrong, they bullheadedly proceed in a stupid fashion, if I may so with respect, to put it into effect. This House would have been much better employed this evening in dealing with the legislation it has been discussing recently.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion and I think there is no question about it. The operation has been put into effect by the Minister already. The job has been done and there is, to the best of my knowledge, no serious problem left. Deputy Moher and Deputy Corry, both from East Cork, suggested that there was a major problem, but I have been told by people who live in East Cork that the harvest on the whole has been saved there for some weeks. That is a question of fact also.

Listening to Deputy Allen, one would think, from the way he behaves, that the Minister was the greatest enemy the farmers ever had. When the Deputy from Kildare, Deputy Harris, was concluding, there were almost tears in his voice when he spoke of his concern for the farmers. Would the Deputies cast their minds back a few years to the period when the land of this country was handed over to the inter-Party Government, which was in office from 1948 to 1951. Who handed it over to them in that condition? I am not going to dilate on that subject, but I think it is a very shabby business that this serious problem should have been made the subject of a motion like this.

Comment on this

I consider this motion, first of all, to be useless and I regard it as a mean manoeuvre on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party to take advantage of the unfortunate situation in which the farmers find themselves. If we examine the terms of this motion we will see that the only effective part of it is that they suggest the purchase and management of the unmillable wheat should be put into the hands of Grain Importers, Limited, who, as previously stated, have no organisation at their hand except a few typewriters and office furniture. They would have to refer the purchase of this unmillable wheat to the organisation of buyers and agents and millers, who are in charge of this problem at present. I heard Deputy Corry suggesting that a price ought to be made for dried, unmillable wheat. I would like to point out that unmillable wheat at 33? per cent. moisture content—and there is quite a lot of wheat at that figure and a great deal of it at more than 33? per cent — is worse value to the compounder than maize at £27 a ton because the maize has approximately 11 per cent. moisture. But still we have that kind of case being bandied about by Deputy Corry without giving figures or any constructive approach.

This motion appears to be just an excuse for a debate on the rather unfortunate situation in which the farmers find themselves. It is a week late. This matter has been dealt with in a very satisfactory way by the Minister already. Supposing this scheme was not adopted, what would be the position of the wheat growers who would find so much of their wheat unmillable and unsaleable? We have a situation now where there is a scheme whereby they will be able to get cash for unmillable wheat that is capable of being used as a feeding-stuff.

The problem that we are facing at the present time and which we are discussing has deeper roots. We must remember that the growers were, if you like, bribed or stampeded into the growing of a very large acreage of wheat and no attempt was made by the previous Government to ensure that the wheat would be properly handled when it was harvested. There were no handling facilities, particularly in this difficult harvest, but last year, when there was a fairly large acreage of wheat and a good yield, there were considerable difficulties in the handling of the large quantity which was offered, owing to the system of combining wheat instead of the old system of stacking and threshing. In spite of that, the wheat grower was encouraged to put in a very large acreage this year, but in spite of the problems that arose last year, when there was a favourable season for the harvest, no attempt was made by the previous Government to handle the larger acreage on this occasion. Added to those difficulties was the bad weather and the farmers had a double problem to deal with.

Now we have the Fianna Fáil Party shedding crocodile tears. They will not even accept a scheme which has been made to compensate the growers of that large quantity of wheat who did not get these facilities. We can imagine, if there was a good season, the manner in which that wheat would have been handled and the long queues of loaded lorries that would have been waiting, not alone one night but several nights continuously, for their turn to have the wheat handled. There is the situation which would have faced the farmers, if it was a favourable season. On this occasion, we did not get a favourable season. There was a slower delivery of the wheat to the mills, but still they had not got the machinery to handle it. We have the Fianna Fáil Party crying about the farmers, but omitting to refer to the fact that they left the farmers completely without any kind of equipment to deal with the very large crop which they implored them to plant this year.

The attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to wheat growing appears to have been one designed to adjust the trade balance, but let us remember that the economics of wheat are these, that 20 years ago, when there was only one ton of wheat grown here for every 15 tons of wheat imported, there were four times as many men working on the land as there are at present.

Similarly we have the situation where growers of wheat are not satisfied with the manner in which the millers have dealt with the corn taken in. The millers apparently did not give the results of the test for approximately two weeks after the wheat had been delivered and then there arose a dispute as to whether it contained 24 per cent. or 30 per cent. moisture. There is no way of proving it because apparently there is no referee or third party to decide the condition of the wheat on delivery. The discretion appears to be with the millers at the present time as to whether they will accept wheat as being millable or rejected as unmillable. It is unsatisfactory but I presume it is impossible at this stage to find a solution for that problem. At the moment it is at the discretion of the millers to decide whether wheat is millable or unmillable. I presume it has been already suggested in the course of the debate that arrangements be made in future to ensure that wheat delivered to the mills be dealt with in a proper manner. Producers are in difficulty in regard to the result of bushelling until such time as they are in a position to dispute the figures given them by the miller.

I think the Minister has done a very good job in devising this scheme when we realise that, if it had not been devised, there would be a large quantity of wheat unsaleable. Wheat is saleable now but the difficulty that presents itself is whether the millers will accept it as millable wheat or unmillable wheat. I heard Deputy Corry make a case in regard to unmillable dried wheat. Most of it is unmillable, although saved in the normal way, and offered to the millers in that condition, because the drying facilities are not there which would enable a large quantity of it to be dried, even though it is unmillable before being offered to the millers.

Comment on this

I do not believe this motion will do any harm at all, but it is a childish motion. It is unfortunate that it should be brought forward, but these are the usual tactics of Fianna Fáil—cashing in on the nation's distress. Certainly the motion has shown Fianna Fáil in a very poor light indeed, because they have made no case for it at all. It has shown also that the nation has a strong, able Minister, a Minister capable of handling the task in the national crisis that we have gone through. It has shown him to be the right man in the right place. There are no queues outside the mills waiting for prices to be arranged. Everything that could humanly be done is being done. I am certainly satisfied that our farmers have undergone untold hardship. They have the sympathy of the entire nation, of the people in town and city, and they deserve that sympathy. I am proud of the fact that the farmers stood up to their job. They accepted the crisis with true Christian resignation. They were always prepared to accept God's holy will. Anything that is bad could be worse. We have had a wheat crisis, but is it not far more easily endured than the human holocausts which have occurred in other parts of the world and in which, not hundreds but thousands, of people have been hurled into eternity. Here we have had nothing worse than a bad harvest. That is only a small sacrifice in comparison with the human holocausts that other countries have had to endure. Perhaps this crisis will be a blessing in disguise if it shows that single-line farming will always throw a nation off its balance. Indiscriminate wheat growing is a dangerous experiment. That has been proved, not to-day or yesterday but over many years. There would be no national crisis if we had a fixed national economy. Balanced farming will stand up to any crisis, big or small.

The county from which I come, royal Meath, has suffered severely. Many large farmers have been severely tried, some of them broken for ever more. Many more have had their hands very badly burned. We have every sympathy for all these farmers, the unbalanced farmers, whether they sowed large areas or small areas of wheat. A farmer of that type is no gambler or chancer; he is the type of man the nation needs. We had, however, many speculators growing wheat in the last few years. I come from one county where speculators have run rife. I am sorry for them, but I have not much sympathy with them. They are nothing more than a crowd of racketeers who blew into this country from all parts of Britain and other countries in Europe. Some of them even came from Dublin and tried to cash in on a handy way of making easy money. It was not the hand of man that struck them down, but the hand of the Almighty Himself. We have very little sympathy with that type of man. I, unfortunately, am in the position that I see the fertile land of Meath being utterly destroyed by this type of speculator who comes in and tries to get rich overnight.

I want to see a balanced farming economy. I want to see the fertile land preserved and conserved in my county where we have some of the richest land in Europe. It is unfortunate to see it being turned into nothing more than a dust bowl such as you find in the American prairies.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is getting away from the motion.

Comment on this

We do not want that type of farming. We want our farmers to have a balance, to provide a proper solution for the problems of our nation's economy. If this thing were allowed to go on——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does this arise on the motion?

Comment on this

I know the motion is concerned with wheat undoubtedly but I am touching on wheat. However, I bow to your ruling. I say that the Minister and the Department deserve the nation's thanks for their action in the crisis we have gone through. They have done everything that was humanly possible. They have allayed many fears. They have alleviated much of the distress by their promptness of action and by the manner in which they dealt with the millers. I am not a strong supporter of the millers but I say they have done a good job in this national crisis. Had it not been that we had a strong and able Minister, the countryside would be strewn with wheat rotting in the stacks and in the sacks and a national disaster would be upon us. Have we a national disaster to-day? No; we accept the will of the Almighty and we are proud of the fact that we have a strong Minister and an able Government to deal with an unprecedented situation. They tackled it in a bold and big way and, thanks to them, many of the farmers have been saved from utter distress. I am satisfied that in the future, as in the present situation, the Minister will stand up to his task and he will overcome the difficulties in the way of bringing into this country a balanced economy. The Minister is a strong man who knows his job and who will do his job. Thanks be to God, we had a man of that type to deal with the present crisis. What would have happened if we had the late Minister in office, or Deputy Dr. Ryan? Would we not have floundered over the job?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That certainly does not arise. The Deputy will keep to the motion.

Comment on this

It is in now.

Comment on this

I did not hear the Minister objecting to that.

Comment on this

I think it is fair hitting. I think it is fair enough to say that if my predecessors were there they would be floundering, and it is very true. That is not offensive, I think.

Comment on this

The farmers should be organised in their own defence. Only one man is trying to do that, and that is Father Hayes.

Comment on this

Is that relevant?

Comment on this

Let us blow away all the ill-feeling and get down to work in peace on behalf of the nation. The Irish farmer has done his job. He has got all the help the nation can give him. In turn, he has the thanks of the nation for what he has done. According to the daily papers it was prophesied that we would have queues three and four miles long outside every mill, with the men on the lorries sleeping on sacks in the roadway waiting their turn. Thanks to the Minister, there was none of that. The situation was settled overnight because he had strength in his hand and the orders he gave were carried out. The farmers are not fools. They know what they are up against. They are grateful to the Minister and an Irish Government for helping them.

Comment on this

I would like to join in this debate as one who has been growing wheat for upwards of 30 years and who knows all the ins and outs of it. The first year I tilled the ground was the best year. It is the same everywhere. The soil deteriorates, and despite artificial manures, rotation and everything else, the continued growing of wheat will eventually turn the soil into desert. That is what will happen if we go on too long.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might keep to the motion.

Comment on this

I want to compliment the Minister on what I consider is a wonderful achievement. At one time I thought 50 per cent. of the wheat would never see the mills. To-day it has almost all been taken. This is the worst harvest year in living memory. I grew wheat in 1946 and I took a cut of 10/- a barrel on one cargo and a cut of 6/- on another, and there was no weeping or wailing or shedding of tears: poor Pat had to take his beating. To-day we have a different situation and, even though it is the worst year in living memory, we have a good sound man at the helm, a man who utilised his brains and stood by the farmers of Tipperary and elsewhere.

Comment on this

Short and sweet.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister is delighted I gave way to Deputy Crowe because of all the bouquets presented to him. It has been suggested that this motion was introduced for political purposes. My word is as good as that of any Deputy on the benches opposite and I can assure the House that this motion was considered over a month ago by the Fianna Fáil Party and it was decided then not to put it down lest it might be represented, as it was represented here to-day, that we were taking advantage of the misfortunes suffered by the farmers owing to bad weather in order to make political capital. The motion was deferred for a month. If it has done nothing else it has achieved an authoritative statement that something is being done. But nothing was being done until the motion was put down last Thursday and it is a strange coincidence that in a Dublin newspaper circulating all over the country a statement was made the following day. How that coincidence came about I leave it to people to judge for themselves.

Comment on this

Was it not a strange coincidence that the motion went in the evening I made the statement?

Comment on this

I do not know whether it was in the evening or in the morning.

Comment on this

It was not in before the arrangement was made.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Beegan concluding on the motion.

Comment on this

There was an article in a Dublin paper; that did not come as a supplied statement. It was not stated that it was a supplied statement. I believe that, the problem being of such major importance, there should have been an announcement on the radio that night. There was no statement from the Government Information Bureau that such arrangements had been made. We had nothing authoritative until this evening. The unfortunate part about this evening is that the arrangement does not go far enough. It has been suggested we should accept it. I shall try to explain why it is not possible for us to accept it and why we should not accept it without putting it to a division.

I would be more than pleased if this whole question of agriculture could be taken out of the whirlpool of politics. I hope the day will dawn when the agriculturists will formulate their own policy and leave it to the Government of the day to amend that policy or indicate where it is either inadvisable or impracticable. That is not the position. For a number of years agriculture has been played about with.

Comment on this

Is this relevant?

Comment on this

It was played about with particularly by the Fine Gael Party. Those who represent the farmers have been absent from the House to-day with the exception of Deputy O'Hara who uttered a few words in condemnation of the motion while, at the same time, admitting there was something wrong with this question of wheat purchases.

Comment on this

Is this relevant?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must come to the motion.

Comment on this

We decided this was a very serious problem for the farmers, added to the many other problems with which they are confronted. It has been stated by the Minister and many others that this was the worst harvest in living memory. What steps were taken by the Minister to meet that situation? That is one of the greatest grievances I have against the Minister: although it was the worst harvest in living memory not a word of encouragement was given to the farmers who found themselves faced with a dilemma.

Comment on this

What was done in 1946?

Comment on this

We know what was done in 1946 and if the same steps had been taken this year it is doubtful if there would have been any need to put down this motion. We needed the weather but, above all, we needed a pool of labour so that the farmers could utilise their ordinary reapers and binders. That is why many of them waited to use a combine and almost lost their crops because they got no hint from anywhere or no suggestion as to what would be done. Even though suggestions were made by various vocational organisations of farmers, there was no hint given that the Army or anybody else would be available until last week, when it was too late.

Comment on this

I have cut 16 acres of corn with a scythe and have put my hand deep in my pocket to pay the men and took 10/- a barrel in one case.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Crowe cannot behave himself I will ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is Deputy Beegan being relevant to the motion?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is very difficult to answer that question because there are so many interruptions. I am trying to deal with the interruptions and then I will deal with Deputy Beegan if he is out of order.

Comment on this

I simply want to direct the attention of the Chair to irrelevance.

Comment on this

It is my right and privilege, if statements are made in this House, to answer them. If they were related to this motion, then I should have the same right to reply.

Comment on this

Without interruptions.

Comment on this

The farmers require sympathy and encouragement because everybody knows that, apart even from the wheat, farmers' incomes have deteriorated very considerably as compared with the same period last year and that their incomes from live stock or any other form of farm produce have decreased from 12½ per cent. to 17½ per cent. The fact that wheat was rendered unmillable and unfit for human consumption by the elements, of course, and also by lack of cooperation and assistance from the fount where it should be expected, made their hardships and difficulties doubly difficult.

Now it comes to this question of the purchase of unmillable wheat and how this motion was worded and we have been asked how does Fianna Fáil believe that Grain Importers, Limited, could handle the unmillable wheat of this country. That question was posed by the Minister, by Deputy Morrissey and several others. How did Grain Importers, Limited, in a similar situation of a difficult kind last year, handle the barley question? Had not they machinery to do that?

Comment on this

The mill.

Comment on this

Have they not got machinery to import from the ends of the earth for cereals to be used by the various mills in this country? We were also asked the question: if the suggestion of Deputy Corry and others as regards price were conceded, who would pay for it — how would it be paid for? Would not that money circulate within the country? Is it a crime to pay to the Irish farmers the equivalent of what has been paid to the foreign producers of maize and pollard and the rest of it?

When it comes to the question of values, I understand that pollard is an offal of wheat and it is being sold at £27 a ton. The whole grain must be better than its offal and in my opinion, must be of higher feeding value. To the layman, without bringing in an expert or professor, the whole grain certainly has a much higher feeding value than its offal, pollard. There is nothing wrong in what was suggested by Deputy Corry and others on this side of the House that the farmers should be given at least that price for their unmillable wheat. But, when it comes to the question of fixing the price at any level for unmillable wheat or getting the millers to take it, perhaps, the easing or solution of one problem may create another. That is the big danger in this whole question and one that, in my opinion, the Minister should take serious cognisance of. The question is how the millers will deal with the problem.

We know very well that there are thousands of tons of what would be regarded as unmillable wheat that is very close to the border-line. Without supervision or a check of some kind there is a danger that people who have millable wheat of good quality could lose and that the price of their first-class quality millable wheat that is suitable for human consumption could be cut and that the millers in that way would try to even up matters. That problem is difficult enough to solve. In the present year I believe the only way in which you could solve it is a rough and ready way, not by sending an inspector to every mill and keeping him there all the time but by having surprise visits and surprise tests and taking from farmers samples of rejected wheat and of wheat for which they expected to get the millable wheat price.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that surprise visits are going on every day all over the country to every mill.

Comment on this

There are no checks on the wheat that is being rejected.

Comment on this

Surprise visits are going on all the time.

Comment on this

I would like checks on the rejected wheat and that samples would be taken.

Comment on this

And accepted in other mills.

Comment on this

Are you sure it is not the other way around?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This conversation must cease.

Comment on this

I am not saying that millers are not conscientious people. I am sure there are many conscientious people amongst the millers as well as in every other section of the community. Perhaps there are certain of them who would try to take advantage of a situation like that.

Comment on this

There are.

Comment on this

It is often easy to ascertain the doubtful ones from the reputable ones and attention should be paid to such people. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Mr. O'Donovan, said this evening that it would be much better for this House to discuss some useful type of legislation than to deal with a motion of this kind. No Opposition in this House have ever facilitated a Government to the same extent as the present Opposition have facilitated the present Government. What Bills have been introduced that are of any special significance or importance that should be given priority over a motion of this kind? Are they not all clarification or codification of existing laws? None of them deals with any important subject. That is my answer to Deputy O'Donovan on that point.

Another question is dried unmillable wheat versus undried unmillable wheat. That also is worthy of consideration. It is too bad that the careful, thrifty farmer who went to the trouble of drying his unmillable wheat in an effort to preserve some of it should be placed in the same category and offered the same terms as the careless man or the man who, perhaps, was not careless but who lost hope in the situation and left the wheat there untidy and uncared for, and who is now going to produce wheat much inferior both in moisture content and in general condition. He will get the same benefit in the scheme the Minister has outlined to us as the person who took the trouble and went to the expense of having his unmillable wheat dried and brought to a safe condition. I am sure something can be done. There is no justification whatsoever for paying only 47/6 and at the same time giving the same benefit to the neighbour who has either through discouragement or carelessness failed to tend his wheat at all or take the steps his neighbour has taken.

There were many points raised on this whole question of the motion we have put down. It was suggested that the handling of the wheat in this particular type of season was something akin to a miracle. There was nothing very miraculous about it. I want to emphasise that again because I believe that it would be only a very simple problem if the proper steps had been taken at the proper time. Thoughts have been expressed here about the wheat rancher and all the rest of it and the get-rich-quick fellow. Perhaps, we have certain people of that mentality in the country who believe, when something comes along in which they see an opportunity, they can get rich quick. Perhaps we have land owners in this country in the same position.

My opinion is that there should be no ranchers in this country. If there are ranchers who are not utilising their land properly, who are going into land and who are letting it to other gentlemen, whether they be natives or foreigners, there is an institution in this State to deal with them. It is, perhaps, an institution which does not carry on its work in a very speedy fashion. Nevertheless, that is the type of person in my opinion to whom they should direct their attention instead of directing it towards some person who is an uneconomic holder and take his holding from him in order to relieve the other uneconomic holder. If that happened we would not have so many ranchers of any type, whether beef ranchers or otherwise.

I think the way this motion has been treated from the Government Benches shows callous indifference to the whole situation. That is the position. That callous indifference was represented here this evening, particularly by the Clann na Talmhan Party. There was never more than one of them in his seat, and only one came in to make any contribution to this motion. We are insistent in putting this motion. I hope that the farmers on every side of this House — if they are interested in the farmers as they pretend they are — will vote to give the farmers a fair price in the situation in which they now find themselves. I hope they will vote to the farmers of this country a price equal to that which they are prepared to give the farmers in outside countries in respect of imports of animal feeding stuffs which, I hold, are not of nearly so great a feeding value as the unmillable wheat we have been discussing here.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 56
·
Níl 69
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?