Supplementary and Additional Estimates. - Vote 27—Agriculture.
Contributions 1–168 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a supplementary sum not exceeding £10 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st March, 1955, for the salaries and expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture including certain services administered by that office, and for payment of certain subsidies and sundry Grants-in-Aid.
The purpose is to enable me to make grants towards expenditure incurred by an organisation to be established to alleviate distress caused by abnormal flooding of the Shannon area. A payment out of the grant will be made subject to conditions to be laid down by me with the consent of the Minister for Finance. Before proceeding any further I consider it my duty to say that I visited the flooded areas on two occasions and I have been deeply impressed by the manner in which the farmers in these areas are standing up to their difficulties. Really when you do visit people in distress such as the people in the Shannon area have been labouring under since last October you would not be in the least surprised to find them querulous and very short and I am glad to be able to boast that no such spirit prevails in that particular part of the country.
When it was my privilege to meet them during my visits some of them had actually been displaced from their homes and were the guests of our Army in the camp at Carnagh, near Kiltoon. When I sought to talk to them of their distress their primary concern was to sing the praises of the Army and all the Army had done and were still doing for them. We cannot blind our eyes to the real suffering through which they have gone and are going and I know that the House will be sympathetic with those people who have been suffering from flooding since last October. They have managed to struggle along with wonderful resource and admirable perseverance through all the reverses which they have faced and with which some of them still have to contend.
I recall the bad weather throughout the year, the great difficulty of harvesting, the difficulty in cutting and drying turf, and it is no small testimonial to the ability of our farmers that they have been able so successfully thus far to meet the damage caused by the abnormal flooding in the Shannon Basin this year. I had been keeping careful observation on the effects of the rainy weather throughout the country and was impressed by the relative freedom from losses of any magnitude up to the end of November. It has been a record year as far as flooding on the Shannon is concerned. I think it is true to say that the floods in the Shannon area have reached record proportions, even going back to the 1800s. In November the flood gauge at Athlone stood at 16 feet 9 inches. That was the highest recording since 1925 when it stood at 17 feet 1 inch and that was before the Shannon scheme came into operation. The estimate which I have caused to be made of the damage sustained by farmers up to the end of November has, of course, been completely nullified by the disastrous rains of this month and particularly by the two inch downpour which occurred on the 8th December. Since the 8th December the Shannon floods have gone slightly above the 1925 level.
So far as our information goes up to the present about 50 square miles in the area of which Athlone is the centre have been affected by flooding. It is estimated that, so far, about 1,880 farms have been affected to some degree by flooding. These farms lie in an area stretching from Swanlinbar in Cavan to County Clare. It is further testimony of the ability and common sense of the farmers affected that virtually no live-stock losses have occurred.
We have evacuated some 150 head of cattle and have installed them on high ground in the possession of the Army or the Land Commission or neighbouring farmers. There is, of course, a great number of cattle still on flooded lands but these are being tended under improvised arrangements and fed with fodder very largely by their owners. In many cases floors of stables and out-buildings which had become flooded have been raised by planks and other material supplied by the Army authorities. Many isolated farms still have their own fodder and boats have been provided to enable other farmers to get from place to place and to bring fodder to their live stock. The tenacity with which these people cling to their holdings is most impressive and praiseworthy.
It has been found necessary to evacuate about 50 families and these are accommodated in quarters provided by the Army or by neighbours.
Good neighbours in many cases also have made land available to which marooned cattle are being moved. C.I.E. are making available supplies of old sleepers which will assist the people in lifting their live stock above the water level. It is necessary to lift the live stock to the higher ground which is still available for those who wish to avail of it. The Army is ready to remove all cattle to unflooded land. We are taking fodder by boat and in some cases where we had evacuated the farms we are taking the menfolk back by boat when the necessity arises, to attend their stock.
I think the House would wish to know that under the various headings of relief a great lot of the responsibility fell on Colonel Collins-Powell and I cannot pay too high a tribute to the success achieved through his work in helping the people. Under his direction we now have five or six travelling units moving over the flood area in Army lorries equipped to pass through any flood that exists on the roads. All these units are accompanied by a technical officer of my Department qualified to give the appropriate advice and counsel and in addition to this we have now sent a veterinary officer to the area who will complete a survey of all the live stock in the flooded holdings with a view to providing curative and preventive treatment for any cattle which have passed through and are still passing through the ordeal of the floods. The most important thing we have to think about at the moment is fodder for animals because fortunately we have been able to make adequate provision for a great many of the people affected. We must not go a step beyond and force people to leave their holdings against their will when it is perfectly clear that they have prudence and a right to decide for themselves what is best to do.
Therefore, the only immediate outstanding problem which is causing us some little anxiety is the provision of fodder for live stock and to meet that I have sent an initial supply from the agricultural school at Athenry. Of course, that is not going to provide for a very long period. Still out of evil there often comes good because I think I am now in a position to report something to the House which restores one's faith in human nature. In many cases crude advantage might be taken of the fact that people were in dire need and proportionate attempts would be made to keep famine prices for fodder which it was known was urgently required to relieve the great difficulties with which we have to contend. Far from that happening I should like to express publicly the thanks of the Government—and I feel sure I speak for the Oireachtas—to one farmer in North County Dublin, Mr. Bergin of Ballyboughal who without any request from anybody loaded his lorry with hay, drove it down to Custume Barracks, dumped the hay there and said: "Use that now for the relief of those people who are short of fodder", turned his lorry and drove back to Dublin. If we had a few more people of that kind in this country— and I do not doubt we have—we need have no fear of people being able to meet emergencies of this kind out of our own resources.
Might I suggest to Macra na Feirme and to other agricultural organisations such as that, that if they would care to make an effective gesture of solidarity amongst farmers in this country that no more edifying opportunity could present itself than that the branches of agricultural organisations should ask their members to make some token contribution of fodder for the relief of farmers in distress in the Athlone area, and if they will assemble and deliver it to Custume Barracks it will be used to assist those who badly need assistance? If they are not able to provide transport to bring it to Custume Barracks themselves, if they will gather it at any point, we will gladly arrange transport to go and collect it.
I need hardly tell the House that if voluntary effort makes no contribution, an event which I do not care to contemplate, then the Government has charged me to see that fodder will be provided from some other source. But I think it would be something of which we would all feel proud if in that one particular, the farmers of this country would make a gesture of solidarity by placing at our disposal such fodder as may be required to get these poor people over the next couple of months while difficulty continues.
It is not possible in the present state of the floods to estimate with any degree of accuracy the amount of actual distress that these floods are going to leave after them and so I cannot tell the House what measure of assistance will effectively relieve the distress. But I do propose that I should appoint a committee comprising Colonel Seán Collins-Powell as chairman, the chief agricultural officers or the secretaries of the county committees of agriculture, as the case may be, of the adjoining counties, the county managers of the adjoining counties and an inspector of my Department to certify sums proper to be paid out of issues from the Grant-in-Aid.
At present I think the counties most affected are Longford, Westmeath, Offaly, Galway and Roscommon. The chief agricultural officers of these counties have their fingers on the situation in every part of their counties and they would be, in my opinion, of the utmost value in alleviating immediate distress. The county managers of these counties would also be of inestimable value in the disposal of home assistance and such other forms of relief as may be found possible and would be of great value as members of the committee. I am aware that other counties have been affected by the flooding in the Shannon area, and I think that if any question of assistance for the victims in these counties arises it should be disposed of by the central committee in Athlone which I propose to set up, and that that committee should have liberty to call to their deliberations on any occasion on which they find it necessary to do so the chief agricultural officer and the county manager of another county, but for the present I think it most desirable to keep the committee as small as possible.
The immediate work, as I have said, of this committee will be to relieve as far as possible the distress which exists in the district and to ameliorate the condition of live stock in the area. No more can be attempted at present. When the floods recede it will be possible to carry out a systematic survey of the flooded lands and to estimate the extent of the damage which has been incurred. When that can be done, and I hope it may be possible to undertake it soon, different considerations will prevail, and I hope to have the advice of the committee which I propose to set up in dealing with that problem also. There will also remain the offer which I made and the arrangements which were put in train some months ago to grant loans, free of interest, to farmers in this area to enable them to restock their land and to make good losses of fodder and fuel.
Here I think it is my duty to refer to one rather regrettable feature of these events. We have been—and I am sure Deputies would wish us to be—earnestly concerned to carry the people through these distresses with the minimum of upset to them. Naturally there is much solicitude on the part of people in that area lest their live stock should be lost or irretrievable damage be done. I am able to report to the House that, so far as we know, no live stock has been lost and yet in the middle of our most difficult period an Irish newspaper publishes a report that one of its correspondents has seen the carcases of cattle floating down the Shannon. I need hardly tell you that the publication of such a report in the area causes the utmost possible concern and confusion and it took us two or three days to restore confidence and persuade the people that nothing of the kind happened, that nobody had the slightest intention of allowing such a thing to happen, and that for long before any such catastrophe could conceivably mature, abundant resources were mobilised in the area to go out and take the cattle out. In fact we kept every holding under review; in some cases we went in with boats and swam the cattle out. If that had proved impossible, we were prepared to go in with boats or lorries to take them out. It does add greatly to the difficulty of maintaining the people's morale and getting the job effectively done if irresponsible people publish wild and false rumours in the newspapers because it sets up at once a very natural apprehension and people who have so far been full of confidence that everything is under control begin to get worried and you might easily get thrown upon you suddenly an unnecessary burden which would break down the organisation which was working quite smoothly if the people were only left alone.
A further consideration which you must take into account is what permanent improvement can be effected in the Shannon area. I am bound to tell the House now, as I told the people whenever I went to visit them in the area, that it is my opinion and it is not without authoritative backing, that it would take an altogether disproportionate sum to attempt to embank the Shannon for the purpose of retaining that river in its summer bed. The plain truth is the Shannon is a river which has a summer and winter bed. If you wanted to keep the Shannon, summer and winter in its summer bed, the only way to do it is to erect long embankments over a large part of the river, and it has to be borne in mind that when those embankments have been erected at immense cost, that that is only the beginning of the story. They must be maintained year in, year out, flood or no flood, and you have always got to bear in mind that as the British people discovered on the east coast of England, as the Dutch discovered in their experience erecting sea dykes that no matter what margin of safety is left on the embankment, something utterly unforeseen may turn up in some particular year; then one breach in the embankment and you are back in a much worse position than you were before the embankments were built at all.
If you build long embankments in an area like that, embankments which are effective to restrain a river in spate and you get a breach through which the river passes out into the country it becomes phenomenally difficult to drain the water back into the river off the flooded country because you have only got a narrow gap through which to let the water flow back again. If the water flows out in spate it may flow into hollow areas or areas where there are hills and hollows in the flooded country from which there is no natural drainage back, because it has been closed off by the high embankments. Therefore I am not going to hold out to these people, even in this hour of extreme distress, the prospect that this or any Government can be reasonably expected to retain this river within its summer bed year in year out. Nevertheless we will look at it again though it has been looked at many times before.
It is true that there are certain sand bars in the river—and here is a queer kind of thing that can happen. When I was in Athlone many people came to me obviously in good faith and said: "Minister, if they would only open the Meelick weir it would relieve the flooding. Why will they not open it?" I must confess that as I was going through land on which there was a foot of water, the thought that a weir being closed affecting these floods filled me with amazement. And some people said to me: "If you did open these sluice gates it would make no difference." I said: "For heaven's sake, do not ask me to go into the house of a person who has a foot of water on the floor and argue about hydrostatics. If there are sluice gates closed and they can be opened let us have them opened even if it does no good. At any rate it can do no harm." Then I came steaming back to town feeling that some misguided individual was insisting on keeping the sluice gates at Meelick closed while there was a foot of water in the flooded country. I was then told, on the 8th December, that the Meelick sluice gates were opened early last October and were never shut since, and so it proved to be. But I have great sympathy with the people because I began to get hot under the collar myself and I could understand how these people were becoming exasperated at the thought that these sluice gates were closed and holding back the floods. Actually they had been opened long before the floods had arisen at all.
I am told by the engineers—and God knows the engineers of the Board of Work and the E.S.B. are just as anxious as anybody else to avert the kind of floods we have in Athlone at the present time—that the Meelick sluice gates have no conceivable connection with the type of floods we are dealing with now. You can control the flooding in the Shannon when the Shannon is flowing at its normal depth. You can raise it or lower it by a couple of feet by manipulation of these sluice gates but when you are talking of the kind of floods we have now the sluice gates have no effect. But whether they have or not, they have been opened since the month of October and have never been closed and they will not be closed until every trace of flood has disappeared from the whole area.
The last thing I have to say is this: that my colleague, the Minister for Lands, is already in a position to make this offer to all farmers in these flooded areas—if they want to migrate out of these flooded areas they will get an exchange of holding in an area where no floods take place. I do not think anything fairer than that can be done, but I want to remind this House that neither this nor any other Government will go to the people who have had their home in this area for generations and say: "We are sick of your worries and troubles; you will have to come out of this." Certainly I would not be party to that, but I do think we ought to put within reach of farmers who have experienced distress this year and for many years past in the callow lands of the Shannon the opportunity, if they are tired of that kind of life, to move out. I think you will find that a great many will reply that they do not want to go. That may be difficult for Deputies in this House to understand.
I do not think it will be difficult for some of the other Deputies to understand. In the country we get very attached to our homes and if we have to suffer inconveniences at times in order to stay in our own homes we work out ways of getting over them. Even if we have to ask a neighbour to take us in and put us up for a night or two in an exceptional year we know that the neighbours will understand and we will find ways of returning thanks in our own time. I quite agree it is right and prudent that we control all our resources and say to these people: "If you want to go, an alternative place will be found for you and the Land Commission will take over your holding and will give you as good a holding elsewhere."
Comment on this
There is a golden rule when you are faced with a problem large enough to tax the capacity of the teeth to bite on it that it is better to bite on that problem and then move on to the larger one when you have mastered the problem which you are first grappling with. I am now dealing with the Shannon valley and I am not extending to Deputies on behalf of the Minister for Lands a general invitation to the farmers of this country to institute a general exodus all over Ireland because great as are the resources and powerful as is the energy of the present Minister for Lands I do not think he could stimulate the Land Commission into facilitating that operation all at one time. I think the Minister for Lands, on the direction of this Government, rightly resolved that for the moment we will concentrate our resources of the Land Commission on the floods in the Shannon valley and say to the people whose homesteads have been subjected to abnormal floods in this crisis: "We are now offering you alternative holdings to which you are free to go. If you elect to go we will make good our offer and if you choose to stay there is no hard feeling".
Doubtless I have failed to deal with some aspects of this problem in the Shannon valley on which Deputies will want further information. My colleague, the Minister for Local Government, knows a great deal more about the problem involved in the case of the Tolka but I feel bound to say this on behalf of my friends in the country—we have been grappling with floods now from October down to to-day and we have every prospect of living with them for another two months until they are gone and it is a source of consolation to us that the people in the Tolka area experienced the floods for only 48 hours. We only wish that our experience had been as abbreviated as theirs has been. We know that we have the sympathy and condolence of the residents of the City of Dublin and on behalf of those who are suffering in the Shannon valley I offer sympathy and condolence to those who also suffered from floods in the North Strand. I am happy in conclusion to think that the resources of our own country and our own people are equal to this emergency and equal to relieving whatever distress has been caused by it. I ask Dáil Eireann with every confidence to give this Government such authority as it may require financially to deal with these distresses and effectively to alleviate them.
Comment on this
I want to ask a question. It may appear to be a silly question, but nevertheless I shall ask it. In the event of farmers from the flooded areas of the Shannon Valley accepting transfers, what does the Government propose to do with the land? Is it proposed to let other farmers into these houses, as has been the practice in the ordinary transfers from congested districts where the lands are not subject to flooding?
Comment on this
Truth to tell, I would be very interested to hear what the Deputy has to suggest. I am sure the Minister for Lands will eagerly wish to have advice from all experienced Deputies in rural Ireland. I do not know if the Deputy suggests this should be declared a black spot in which no human creature should ever live again. I do not take such a dramatic view about it at all. I think if anybody wants to go and take callow land to live on, and take the rough with the smooth, I would not say: "No. Sorry, it is not good for you."
Comment on this
I have a mind as open as a barn door on this, and the Deputy's opinion is just as good as mine. I would be glad to have an opinion on it.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that it is the agreement of the House that there will not be another discussion raised on the second motion after we have discussed the first?
Comment on this
I do not see why the Minister should not make his case without moving the motion formally.
Comment on this
We have decided that we will discuss the two flooded areas on the one motion and the second Estimate will be moved and disposed of on the one discussion. The Minister for Local Government, therefore, can make his case on this Estimate and move his motion subsequently.
Comment on this
At a later stage I shall be moving a token Estimate for the provision of funds for the relief of distress in the Tolka area. At the outset I would like to thank the various organisations— the Dublin Corporation, the Red Cross, the Army, the Fire Brigade, the other voluntary organisations and, in particular, the ordinary citizens—for what they did to relieve distress in the North Strand area and the Tolka basin generally. I hope that I shall be pardoned if I have omitted to mention some of them.
Unlike the area with which my colleague, the Minister for Agriculture has to deal, this disaster came upon the people of the North Strand overnight. Down in the country the floods rose gradually but, as a result of the collapse of a railway bridge over the Tolka, portions of Dublin City became flooded overnight. The people had very little opportunity of preparing against it. They had no opportunity of seeking relief, and it is a tribute to the organisations to which I have referred that they were able to come to the assistance of those people in such a very short time. Fortunately the emergency that occurred in that area lasted very, very shortly, and at the moment that particular emergency—I use the word "emergency" for want of a better word—has ceased. I think it is only right that we should pay tribute to our fellow-citizens whose lands and homes have been flooded down through the years, be they either in the Finn Valley of Donegal, the Barrow Valley or in some part of Galway or Mayo, who have never yet sought aid in the distress which Providence has inflicted on them; with those, too, we have sympathy.
We have reason to think that the recent flooding which has occurred is not just the ordinary flooding that occurs from year to year and it is because of that that we are moving these Estimates here. The House will appreciate that we do not want to see any of our people impoverished as a result of circumstances over which they have no control and anything we can do to relieve the distress in which they now find themselves we are only too anxious to do. As I am not moving the actual Estimates I am curtailed——
Comment on this
There is no curtailment on the Minister in relation to the two Estimates before the House. He may discuss both, or one, just as he pleases. There is no curtailment.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but at the same time the House will appreciate that it is difficult for me to go into detail on the particular motion with which I am dealing. I know the House is anxious that we should do all we possibly can for these people. On behalf of the Government, I must say that the first thing we did was to cut red tape and rescind ordinary regulations in order to comes to the relief of these distressed people and I would now ask the House to do the same by having as little discussion as possible on these Estimates.
Comment on this
Lest the Minister should misunderstand, we want all the details he can give.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that there were details which he could go into now.
Comment on this
The Deputy misunderstood me. I was merely referring to moving the motion. I wish I had the details. I would be only too glad to give them to the House.
Comment on this
I do not know whether or not there is a misunderstanding. We expect to get from the Minister everything that he can say in the same way as if he were actually moving the motion.
Comment on this
For the information of the Deputy and the House, I should say that approximately 1,500 houses accommodating 2,000 families have been affected by the flood waters. The extent of the individual losses varies in degree. The damage to roads and other public services has not yet been estimated. We have already expressed our profound sympathy with the people who have found themselves in such distress. Further than that, I am not in a position to give details to the House. If I were I would gladly and readily make them available. I ask the House, however, to assist us by giving us this token Vote immediately. When details become available at a later date I shall in turn make them available to the House.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether he is setting up a committee somewhat similar to the committee that the Minister for Agriculture is setting up?
Comment on this
We join with the Ministers and the Government in expressing our very deep sympathy with those who have suffered loss or hardship as a result of the recent flooding. We sympathise also with the Government in having to face a problem of this sort. The difficulty for the Government is, of course, that they are anxious not to create precedents which might possibly be abused and they are also anxious to ensure that any relief given is equitably distributed. Now, the entire problem is one of proper administration. We understand, of course, that the Government cannot at this moment form any just estimate of the total sum of money that will be required. Therefore, we understand why they should use this device of a token Vote. When one has to deal with disasters of this sort there are two things obviously to be done. The first is that some organisation or organisations should be set up to deal with the immediate rescue work and to provide the necessary food, clothing and shelter for those who are displaced and have to leave their homes. Then there is the second problem of how to give compensation for the more permanent losses that are sustained on such occasions. My own view, when I saw this disaster occurring, was that the Red Cross should be equipped immediately to deal with the first problem, that is the urgent problem of rescue work, getting first aid from many State services such as the Army, etc., and that the necessary funds should be made available or voted in this House by the Government.
The second problem of how to deal with the permanent losses is much more difficult. What form of organisation can be set up that will give relief equitably? The Minister has indicated that a committee will be set up but what directions will he give it? He has not indicated the directives that are to be given to that committee. They will have to act on directives. I do not think that anybody will find fault with the constitution of the committee but we have been given no idea—I do not know whether the Minister himself or Ministers collectively have any idea— as to the type of directive he will give. Is he going to leave the matter completely at the discretion of the committee to say: "We shall compensate in full those who have suffered," or is he going to give directives of a less extensive kind?
The trouble of estimation is very great in these cases. Consequently it is a matter really of directives and of a proper administrative body after that. I am putting myself in the position in which I would be if I were a member of the Government and I do not think it is possible to do very much more at the moment than the Government has done in setting up an organisation to deal with the matter. I am surprised that the Minister for Local Government has not some idea as to how he proposes to administer the funds that will be available for relief. I daresay the idea would be to make provision for the replacement of such furniture as had been destroyed and for other losses of that kind, but how far will you go in the way of considering consequential losses? It would be helpful if we knew the form of organisation intended by the Minister for Local Government. It appears he has not made up his own mind on that. The matter with which we are most concerned is the equitable distribution of compensation so that the losses and the needs of the people will be promptly taken into account and so that, as between one citizen and another who has suffered loss, there will be no discrimination.
Besides the two areas of the Shannon and the Tolka we have all over the country problems for the individual. A number of individuals are collected together in areas like the Shannon and the Tolka and the total loss makes an impression on everybody but individuals in other parts of the country have suffered as much perhaps as individuals in the case of the Shannon and the Tolka and the Government may be sure that there will be pressure to try to have these cases taken into account also. Whether the Government proposes to do that I do not know. It is all right for the Minister for Agriculture to say: "Let us deal with the immediate problem and deal with it properly." I think we all agree with that but still, as regards the funds to relieve those who have suffered very severe losses due to the altogether exceptional weather and the exceptional flooding in other cases, the same problem arises in many isolated districts.
You might say: "We shall deal only with the widespread destruction that occurred in a certain area." I am afraid you will not be able to stand on that. When the Government comes in with community aid to assist individuals who are in groups in the Shannon area or the Tolka area, they will find that they cannot resist the pressure that will be brought to bear on them to deal with individual cases in other parts of the country. One of my colleagues, I see, stood up to raise a matter of that sort and the Minister for Agriculture replied that it was a wise thing if you have a problem to start tackling it and to try to do that well. In this case, the Government, I am afraid, will have to widen the scope of this relief and consider a number of other cases throughout the country. We, of course, are supporting the Government in providing this fund. We sympathise with them in having to deal with such a problem and we sympathise also with all the victims.
Comment on this
I rise to congratulate the Government in coming to the assistance of people who have met with great losses in the recent heavy flooding. My sympathy, and I suppose the sympathy of the whole House, goes out to all these people who had to leave their homes as well as to people whose live stock has suffered enormously.
I am amazed that the Minister for Agriculture has confined his investigations to the Shannon area. I live in an area where 17 families have had to evacuate their houses. That has not happened to-day or yesterday. In some cases it happened early in October. As far back as the 17th November I asked the Minister for Lands what he was prepared to do to assist those whose homes were flooded and if he would direct the Land Commission to carry out a survey. I cannot understand why only the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Local Government have come into this problem. I know the Shannon area well, and the people there have my whole-hearted sympathy but the problem that exists along the Shannon is not one of to-day or yesterday. It is a very old problem. It could be described as a hardy annual. The people there have been driven from their homes year after year.
The same applies along the Suck. Within a stone's throw of my home there are roughly about 2,000 acres of land that at the present moment resembles a huge lake. I have travelled over that area a few times since the flooding started. Because the Government had promised to bring in the Estimates I took the precaution of making a tour of the whole area during the last couple of days. The papers may give their estimates but I can stand over this one, that 17 families are out of their homes; they are on the high road. One family still reside in a two storey house where there is two feet of water underneath. In one thatched cottage only about a foot of the top of the chimney can be seen. In another house the walls are burst to pieces.
I ask the Minister for Agriculture does he think that the Red Cross are the proper people to deal with these families? These are some of the best small farmers in Ireland. Yesterday I visited a farmyard where there were seven stacks of corn in the haggard which had been brought in the perfect condition. Each stack was thatched, as is the custom in the West of Ireland, down to the eave. There were four cocks of hay, each containing about five ton, with the water to the eave. There was a huge pit of potatoes and there were turnips, mangolds and cereal crops in that haggard. The pit of potatoes was completely submerged. In one house the water was more than one foot higher than the lower limit of the thatch. These people are not looking for sympathy. They are looking to see in what way a home can be provided for them.
There is another problem. The stock owned by these people has been housed for the last two months. The stock had to be let out. Their lands are flooded. The stock is now wandering around the road. Does the Minister think that the Red Cross will be able to deal with this problem?
During the course of his opening statement I asked him if the question of migration applied only to the Shannon area. We heard his reply— deal with the big problems first. This is as big a problem as any in the Shannon area, but because Ministers had not thought it worth their while to see it for themselves, because even the Parliamentary Secretary who lives in the area has not come down to see it for himself, it does not appear a big problem.
Comment on this
I am trying to drive home to the Minister's deaf ear the problem that exists in my area, which is a very serious problem, a problem to which he is giving a deaf ear.
Comment on this
The people of Mossforth turned out a week ago. We have been looking for relief schemes for this area for a long time by way of drainage schemes. That is not a matter that I will discuss now. The people had to turn out with picks and shovels a week ago and cut a trench to relieve an area of some 500 acres of over one foot of water.
Comment on this
The question should be taken up by the Office of Public Works to see what can be done by way of drainage there. I want the Minister to ask the Office of Public Works to investigate the area immediately. In other areas the people had to tear up a gullet across the road and widen it. I would be anxious that the Minister for Lands should introduce here tomorrow morning another token Estimate to deal with this very urgent problem. I want to go as far as I can in forcing the hands of the Land Commission to deal with the whole question, not merely of the Shannon but of every flooded area immediately. I can bring them to a number of houses to-morrow morning which when the flood disappears will be flattened out. There is no place for the families concerned to go. Their friends have been good enough to take them in for the moment.
Comment on this
But even the Minister might not be prepared to take on a little job like that for all time. Immediate relief must be given to these people. Every help should be given to the people along the Shannon but I also want to insist that the Minister should face the problem of the Belclare and Caherlistrane drainage immediately and that the Land Commission be asked to see what can be done there.
I am not exaggerating when I say that the problem there is equally as bad as it is in any part of the Shannon. In some cases one can see only the chimney of a house, which gives a good idea of what the position is like.
The problem is very serious and should be faced up to immediately. I suggest that engineers from the Office of Public Works and the Land Commission should go there without undue delay and carry out a thorough investigation and see what relief can be afforded immediately and to house the people as early as possible.
Comment on this
In common with every other Deputy I realise there is a problem facing us in this country from the point of view of flooding from time to time, but this token Estimate is on the basis of the very serious problem in two areas. I am concerned mainly with the area with which I am familiar, the area of the Tolka Valley and the results of the unprecedented flooding there. Deputies familiar with the position in the Shannon area are more than capable of outlining the difficulties there. I would submit to the House that there is a great deal of difference between the Shannon and the Tolka on this particular occasion. I think that never before, in history or in the memory of living man, has a flood taken place in the Tolka area as occurred on this occasion and Deputies will be aware that the Minister has told them that 1,500 houses were affected by this flooding. In an area not much more than one mile long, by less than half or maybe a quarter of a mile wide, approximately 2,000 families have been affected to a greater or lesser extent. In addition to that it was estimated that some 400 families had to be evacuated from their homes within a period of hours.
This was no flooding. It was a river rising gradually and watchers could see the extent of this expansion growing, growing. This was a flood from which men, women and children were called upon at a moment's notice to get out of their beds and in many cases be taken out of the windows of their homes without getting an opportunity of putting any proper clothes on them. Deputies in this House and particularly Deputies from the area affected cannot speak too highly of the rescue work and of the assistance given by members of the voluntary organisations such as the Red Cross, the St. John Ambulance Brigade, the Knights of Malta and from our own municipal undertakings like the Fire Brigade and, of course, the organisations of the State the Garda—and the Army—on that Wednesday night and early Thursday morning. Nobody in this House or outside it can realise fully the efforts made by the neighbours of those people affected and it is no exaggeration to say that in many cases the efforts of the rescuers saved a definite loss of life. It is regretted that one poor old lady lost her life but it is due to the efforts of the rescuers working on that first night that many more lives were saved.
The problem, as I understand it, which is now before the House, is that the Minister is seeking powers—a token Estimate—for the purpose of relieving distress. I am sure it will get the support of every Deputy, but we would be all anxious to know what that term "relieving distress" means. To get some idea of what the term may mean we would first of all have to have a picture of what has happened in the individual homes. As I already stated with only an hour's notice in many cases people had to evacuate. Families, large and small, had to be taken out at short notice. Many of those families, particularly in this area of the North Strand, Ballybough Road and Richmond Road, resided in accommodations which are semi-basement and when they were evacuated the flood water took possession and in many cases the result was that every personal possession—clothing, the footwear, the bedding, the blankets, the furniture—all the personal belongings were ruined beyond any hope of actual replacement.
Most of the families in these areas were people who have to rely on their ordinary weekly wage or fortnightly income or monthly salary. Not very many of them are very well endowed with the world's goods and when they have seen the furniture, accumulated by hard work and prudence and savings over the year, and in some cases obtained through the system now so familiar to all of us; ruined completely within a matter of hours, you can get some picture of the position. The emergency is not over yet. It is correct to state that it has been found possible to hand over the relief of the urgent cases from the Red Cross and from the St. John Ambulance Brigade to the Dublin Board of Assistance, but to-day there are still something between 80 and 100 people in the central model schools being cared for by the Red Cross, and even at this present moment I think we have a number of people who cannot yet return to their homes, being compelled to stay with friends and relatives in other parts of the city.
The cause of the flooding is not a matter on which I can give any views, but the Minister in his opening remarks referred to the fact that the collapse of the railway bridge over the Tolka resulted in the flooding of a considerable portion of the Tolka Valley. Whether the authority who control that bridge can be made to accept some responsibility for the result of this collapse I do not know. What I am mostly concerned with is that even at the present moment there are hundreds of families in dire need of assistance. There are hundreds of families who have lost everything and who, up to the present moment, have been supplied with only the most urgent necessities—one or two garments, some bedclothes and bedding. Consequently I, personally, would like to get a clear indication from the Minister, in replying to the discussion, as to what are the actual proposals, not the total sum of money that may be made available— that is too much to expect—not even the amounts that have been made available individually, but I would like to be informed by the Minister whether it is the Government's intention, in dealing with this Grant-in-Aid, to ensure that the people affected by the unprecedented flooding shall be afforded such assistance as will replace the losses suffered by them.
There is also the problem of providing housing accommodation. Deputies may have seen announced from time to time in the Press that up to 200 dwellings can be made available if required by the local authority, Dublin Corporation. But aside from the accommodation of people whose houses are condemned as being unfit to live in, there is the problem of the damage caused to the structure of the houses affected. Many hundreds of those houses were flooded to the extent of five or six feet of water, and it is estimated that the structural damage caused by the storm and flood may not show up at once. I do not want to delay the House on this particular matter because I think the urgency of the matter is to have the Vote moved by the Minister adopted and so enable the Government to deal with this problem.
In connection with the distribution of any money made available from central funds in the Dublin area, I would submit that the appropriate body would be the local government of the city. I want to inform the House that while all voluntary bodies cooperated, the direction and control of the organisation dealing with the problems arising immediately from the flood was taken over by our city manager and his technical advisers on the flood because of the fact that possibly, unlike other areas, we were faced with the immediate question of delivering fuel, of making arrangements for the pumping out and the clearing of houses and also for the examination by the health inspectors under the corporation's control.
There is another section of the population in these areas which has been very seriously affected. There are large numbers of trades people, shopkeepers and some others relying for their livelihood on the distribution of vegetables and other goods from door to door. Many of those shopkeepers suffered enormous losses. Goods specially taken in for the Christmas period just vanished as the flood waters entered their premises. People relying on motor transport to deliver goods in the area found their cars under water with no possibility of getting them to work again. It is true, I understand, that in many cases manufacturers and wholesalers are coming to the assistance of some of the traders concerned by replacing stocks free of charge. I think in all such cases we in this House, as well as those traders concerned, must express our admiration of the public-spirited action of those people.
To conclude, the picture I want the House and the Minister to see is a picture of urgency at this time. Like my colleagues in this House representing Dublin Corporation in the area, I have gone down narrow basement stairs to find chaos, tables overturned, bedding soaked, wardrobes warped and twisted and the personal possessions that people acquired over years just ruined beyond redemption. I am sure this House will support the Minister in voting this Grant-in-Aid and in addition I hope this House will endorse the appeal that this Grant-in-Aid should not be made on any basis of small percentage losses. A large proportion of those concerned have not suffered losses that can be replaced in a question of weeks or months; they suffered the loss of practically everything they had and this House, this Government and the Minister would receive the gratitude of those people, not for expressions of sympathy or sorrow for them but gratitude if we come to their rescue in a material way by providing that they be relieved and assisted in their troubles.
Comment on this
I propose to intervene for a very short space of time now and I do so very largely for the purpose of supplementing the remarks that were made by the Minister for Local Government and endeavouring to give the House perhaps a little more detail than he felt himself entitled to give the House in his opening statement. I would like at the outset to express my appreciation and the appreciation of my colleagues for the manner in which Deputy de Valera, Leader of the Opposition, has received these Estimates and—I think I am entitled to say—the sympathy which he has shown towards the problems with which we are faced in dealing with the difficulties created by the Dublin situation and the Shannon situation in considering what amount of money should be asked for from the taxpayers out of the people's resources and on what principles those moneys should be allocated to those who have suffered as a result of the unprecedented storms and rainfall of the last few weeks and months. It seems to me at all events almost incredible that it is only a week ago since the Tolka overflowed its banks causing disaster along its banks and in the Glasnevin area which brought such havoc to the residents of the City of Dublin.
I would ask the House to remember that we were faced with the problem of dealing immediately with a very widespread distress caused in the City of Dublin area at the same time as we were dealing, as we had been dealing for some time past, with the problems along the Shannon and elsewhere. We took the decision at the earliest possible moment we could, that it was our duty to come to the Dáil and ask the Dáil to grant us public money to enable the situation to be dealt with, at least in some sort of way, so as to alleviate distress caused both in the Shannon and Dublin City areas. We had to come here to the Dáil to-day, in a sense unprepared with details or principles or even guidance for the House, because the Dáil is getting up to-day for the recess, and I am sure Deputies will realise that it was not possible for us, in the space of time that we had available to us, to get sufficient details either in Dublin City or in the Shannon area to enable us to assess, not merely the size of the problem but the manner in which the settlement of the problem should be approached, and the principles to be applied to its solution. So far as Shannon is concerned, the Minister for Agriculture has dealt with that and will, I am sure, deal with any further questions, or give any further information that Deputies may require, in his closing speech. Deputies should be aware of this that, as to what machinery we propose to set up to allocate whatever money is given or what principles will be applied to its allocation, I want to admit frankly that, as far as Dublin is concerned I have not, nor have my colleagues—despite the fact that we have had intensive consultation with all the parties concerned —been able to lay down the principles on which those public moneys should be disbursed. But so far as a guiding principle can be laid down it is laid down in the title or particulars given in this Estimate. The money that will be granted by the Dáil following these Estimates will be granted for the purpose of alleviating distress. That is the only guiding principle we can give at the moment. I cannot say for what kind of damage, what kind of compensation or what kind of grant will be given to relieve that distress nor can I say what Deputy Larkin asked me to give—detailed particulars of the percentage of losses.
Comment on this
Well, so far as Dublin is concerned, I do not think there is any question of a loan at all. That is the way my mind is running at the moment—cash grants. There may be some question of loans in the Shannon area as was indicated by the Minister for Agriculture some weeks ago when he was speaking on the problem as it existed then. Circumstances may have changed since and may require a different plan for the Shannon area at the moment. So far as my mind and the minds of my colleagues are concerned—having gone into the matter in the last few days—the way we are going at the moment—and I would ask Deputies if we have to change later that they will not hold it against us hereafter if we have to alter our plans—our intention is to form a committee somewhat analogous to the committee for the Shannon area, presided over by Mr. Justice Lavery, who has agreed to preside over it, and to be assisted by the city manager and one of his principal officials who has a knowledge of the area. I do not want to mention the official's name because the matter has not yet been mentioned to himself. There will be some other people, not picked or selected because of their representative capacity but selected because of their knowledge of charitable work and because, in particular, of their knowledge of the people who live down in the North Strand and generally of people in the City of Dublin. The people I have in mind are from St. Vincent de Paul Society, the Catholic Social Welfare Conference or the Legion of Mary, not representative of those bodies but persons selected from them. Without actually coming down to personnel they will be people who will know the people of Dublin and, without prejudice to Deputy Traynor's constituency, who will not allow anyone to put it across them.
I am afraid there will be efforts in that direction, and while we want to have a committee able to deal with exaggerated or false claims we also want a committee which will deal sympathetically with the problems that are there, people who will deal first with the poorer sections of the community in general and deal generously with them, and will then deal with the other sections. We are working out this in consultation with the city manager and his officials with whom we have been having consultations, but up to the moment they are not able to give us details of the claims or types of claims or of the persons affected or the type of persons affected such as would have enabled us to chart a course or fix principles on which we could act. It will take them some days to do it. They have had experienced assessors going through each of the houses, and up to yesterday they had done hundreds of houses, and I have seen some of the reports. I have also seen some of the reports from the Red Cross organisation. But it is quite hopeless at the present time for us to try to see the extent of the problem or the nature of it, the different types of people involved and the principles on which we will have to act in accordance with justice and equity.
I cannot give any further direction than that. I hope it will assist Deputies, particularly those interested in the City of Dublin area. I hope it will give them some indication that we are approaching this problem sympathetically and endeavouring to know the extent and the nature of it and, at the same time, realising that there is a limit to the resources of the taxpayer and that we just cannot hand out money indiscriminately or perhaps even to the full extent which might be desired. I shall be glad to answer to the best of my ability and knowledge any questions that Deputies may wish to ask on that subject but I really have not got any more information than I have disclosed. The Minister for Local Government, Deputy O'Donnell, probably did not wish perhaps to disclose even that information that I have disclosed up to the moment, because it is rather indeterminate and in a state of flux. I felt, however, having regard to the manner in which Deputy de Valera and other Deputies approached the matter that I should give an indication of the way we are approaching the problem, stating at the same time that we had not yet finally determined the exact way in which we would set up this committee or what directives we would give it.
The main principle is the alleviation of distress. If there is any person, as I understand Deputy Larkin says there is, in urgent and immediate need I think the resources even at the moment are sufficient to enable us to deal with such a case. If Deputy Larkin will give us particulars of such cases requiring urgent attention we will endeavour to have them dealt with. We have been informed by the City Manager and his assistant that so far as the North Strand area is concerned—and I think that goes for the Tolka Valley generally—the emergency finished either some time yesterday or the day before. The real seriousness of the situation has ceased. Most of the people have now returned to their homes, though they are facing on their return pretty stiff problems.
As I understand the Leader of the Opposition, the Dáil is now prepared to vote public moneys for the relief of distress both in Dublin and along the Shannon. I have no doubt, as Deputy de Valera said, that we will be pressed all over the country; we have tried to deal with that through the medium of the Red Cross. We have given specific instructions to the Red Cross to deal with any cases of distress immediately in any part of the country and we will stand behind that organisation in any expenditure it may have to meet or which it may properly or necessarily incur for the alleviation of distress in any part of the country. We do not at the moment know the extent to which public money will be required, but the amount will be considerable no matter what way we work.
I would like to say now that the fact that public moneys are being voted and that the resources of the taxpayer are being availed of and called upon to meet the distress occasioned by these excessive storms and rains should not dry up the wells of private benevolence and I appeal to all those who have not yet subscribed to either the Lord Mayor's Fund or the Red Cross, or the other charitable organisations dealing with these problems in Dublin, along the Shannon or elsewhere to subscribe generously, adequately and quickly.
My colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, paid a well deserved tribute to-day to a farmer from County Dublin, Mr. Bergin, for his spontaneous and generous gesture towards the relief of the farmers in the Shannon area. Deputy Larkin referred to some public spirited wholesalers who are contributing, at their own expense, to the relief of traders who have suffered loss. I suggest that that kind of voluntary public-spirited effort should be the headline on which our citizens throughout the length and breadth of the country should act, and act quickly. The fact that the taxpayer is coming to the rescue should not be regarded as an excuse for individuals who have the means to do so refraining from contributing to the Lord Mayor's Fund, to the Red Cross or other charitable organisations.
We have had many offers of help from countries abroad with accredited representatives here. We have had sincere expressions of sympathy from them on behalf of the nations they represent here. On behalf of this House and on behalf of our people generally I would like to express our gratitude to the countries which are accredited here for their ready response with sympathy and offers of practical help towards the alleviation of the distress caused. We are dealing with this problem out of our own resources; nevertheless, we are grateful to them for their offers and we appreicate the sympathy and generosity they have displayed towards the Irish people.
It would not be proper not to pay a special tribute and mark especially our appreciation of what was done or offered to be done had we wished to avail of it by our own people in the United States of America. Generous offers came from Irish organisations throughout the length and breadth of the United States. It is a great source of comfort to us to know that that solid unbreakable link exists between the Irish people here at home and our fellow countrymen in the United States of America.
I have spoken almost entirely on the Estimate relating to Dublin City. That does not mean that, while our sympathies go out to the City of Dublin, we are not fully alive to the necessities of those who have suffered such loss and privation in the valley of the Shannon and elsewhere throughout the country. I think Deputy Larkin is right: the people like the sympathy, but they also want a little bit of cash. I have given the sympathy. I hope the House will give them the cash.
Comment on this
As one of the Deputies representing the district affected, namely, North East Dublin, I would like to express on my own behalf and on behalf of my colleague, Deputy Harry Colley, who is unfortunately indisposed, our deep sympathy with those who have suffered so grievously in this disaster. We have to consider here this evening the ways and means of alleviating the suffering which this disaster has inflicted upon the unfortunate people and the Taoiseach has outlined the means by which it is proposed to deal with the particular problem.
Now I have lived in the North Strand area practically all my life. I know it exceedingly well. I know the type of avenue that has been inundated. I know the type of house that has been flooded and made uninhabitable. Personally, I believe we will have to go much further than merely providing relief. We shall have to endeavour to provide the ways and means of preventing continuous repetitions of this type of flooding. In my boyhood days I well remember the cottages up around Drumcondra Bridge being flooded very often to a depth of two and three feet, the homes rendered uninhabitable and the families having to evacuate. That went on from year to year. An attempt to provide some relief was brought about some years ago by what I shall describe as an abbreviated form of diversion of the River Tolka. That brought relief to some extent but it did not provide anything in the nature of permanent relief. I had the honour to be a member of the Dublin Corporation during the years 1933-36 and on one occasion when this periodic flooding had taken place, I and some of my colleagues were discussing the ways and means of preventing a repetition of such flooding. I made a suggestion, merely as a layman since I have no technical experience, that the course of the Tolka should be diverted up around about Finglas. It could possibly be diverted into the canal. I see the Minister for Agriculture looking at me with a certain amount of doubt.
Comment on this
On one famous occasion when I had the temerity to intervene in a debate on agriculture, the Minister described me as the agricultural expert from Ballybough.
Comment on this
I would expect a citizen of Ballybough to know all about the Tolka and I would listen with respect to his opinions.
Comment on this
I do not know what value can be placed on the proposition. Engineers, I have no doubt, would drill holes in it but I discussed it afterwards with people of some experience and I was assured that the canal could take the overflow, in view of the fact that in the canal there is a very severe fall and that there are also sluice gates which could be opened at any time when the flow became very heavy. I had a dual purpose in making the suggestion. Apart from the fact that flooding in the various districts, which are annually inundated, could be averted, we would be able to reclaim the large amount of land which is at present unreclaimed and quite possibly a number of houses could be erected on the site of the filled-in course of the Tolka. I am putting forward that suggestion again for what it is worth. If it could be put into operation it would certainly obviate flooding and avert the possibility of a disaster of the type which we have recently experienced.
I must say that I was very pleased to hear the Taoiseach say that the intention is to deal with the effects of this calamity, not only here in the City of Dublin but also in the Shannon area, out of our own resources. I think that in doing that the Government has done what is right and I should like to congratulate them on that fact. I should like also to compliment both the Taoiseach and the Minister for Local Government on their announcement of the fact that they would suspend all regulations which would in any way impede immediate action in respect to relief in the serious situation brought about overnight in the crowded city area. I think that that was facing up to a serious situation in the proper way. I feel it my duty as a member of the Opposition to pay that tribute to them for that action. I should like to say also, so far as the views of individuals in the city are concerned, that they have the same sympathy with the people in the Shannon areas as they have for the people in the North Strand areas. They realise fully the terrific inconvenience which this type of disaster entails for the families concerned. I, of course, do not know what relief can be afforded in the way of prevention of the continued annual flooding in the case of the Shannon but I have no doubt that the Government is completely aware of the situation there and that they are taking the necessary steps to deal with it.
Once again, I should like to express my own sympathy with the people and my congratulations to the various bodies—it is not necessary for me to name them—and the individuals whom I saw working in water up to their hips on the occasion of the flooding in the North Strand this day week. This day week marked the highest point of the disaster. I felt, looking on at these people as they worked there to help this stricken community, that it is disasters of this kind which bring out all that is best in the individual, as certainly happened in this particular case.
Comment on this
I wish to join with other Deputies who have expressed sympathy—their real sympathy, I know —with all the people who have suffered hardship as the result of the recent floods, irrespective of whether these people are from the City of Dublin or any other part of Ireland. I know that this question of flooding and the problems associated with it present great difficulties to any Government, and the remarks I have to make here will be made in a friendly fashion towards the Government in so far as the efforts they are now making will meet the problem. I would say this, though— quoting the words of the Minister for Agriculture a few moments ago: "out of evil cometh good"—that were it not for the fact that the unfortunate citizens of Dublin suffered flooding due to the Tolka changing its course, the citizens along the Shannon or of any other area of Ireland would not get the benefit that we understand they will get as a result of the measures now before the House. Three weeks ago the Minister for Agriculture toured my own constituency, accompanied by many of his advisers and supporters. He met representatives of the people in the Shannon area, from the area between Athlone and Meelick. I am sure he will correct me now, if I am wrong, that he put the case very fairly and squarely to those people and told them that he could see his way only to provide interest-free loans.
Comment on this
I shall not dispute the actual date but he will agree with me that he suggested at the meeting that he could not wave any magic wand.
Comment on this
I am speaking as a Deputy who comes from that area. I have raised this matter in this House on many occasions since 1948. The only difference at the present time is that the floods have come earlier this year but the hardship is the same each year.
Comment on this
Nonsense. The floods are far higher at the present time than at any time since 1885.
Comment on this
The fact that the floods are higher does not mean that there has been more damage done. The damage is done each year.
Comment on this
Cattle had been taken out each year; families had been removed from the Clonown area each year into Athlone and elsewhere.
Comment on this
The position is worse now than it has been since 1885. If the Deputy does not know that, he ought to know it. It is a shame for him to say it is not so.
Comment on this
When the disaster that we all deplore took place in the Tolka, and when the Dublin Deputies realised for the first time that you use water for more than making tea and that water could cause immense damage to homes and could take away a farmer's crop, his sole means of livelihood, and when they found their own area affected, the hand of friendship was then held out to the people in the Shannon area. It was a help to the Minister for Agriculture in his effort. I know he is genuine in connection with relieving the situation along the Shannon.
The centre of all this flooding is Athlone, and in the last two or three weeks we have had sightseers gawking over the bridge in Athlone watching to see will the river rise another inch. There seems to be a morbid fascination for the papers and for prominent people in all walks of life to visit Athlone and to be associated with the unfortunate people in the locality in their sufferings. From Athlone up to Lanesboro', on to Carrick-on-Shannon and up to Boyle there are families who are in just as bad a position as they are in the Clonown area.
Comment on this
Every inch of that has been surveyed, as the Deputy knows damn well. From Cavan down to Clare every bit of it has been surveyed, and the Deputy knows that damn well.
Comment on this
I propose to read a letter I received in connection with an area that is in the northern end of Roscommon.
Comment on this
The letter is as follows:—
"Allow me to bring to your notice the situation I am in owing to the Shannon flood."
The Minister will check on this.
"I am surrounded by water for the past two months that is almost five feet deep. I have lost my turnips and potatoes, all my grass and ten acres of beet. I have three weeks' supply of hay left, I wrote to Mr. Dillon two weeks ago but got no reply. I also wrote to the Land Commission."
I would not be surprised at not getting an answer from the Land Commission, but I certainly imagine that the Minister for Agriculture would reply at any rate.
"I also wrote to the Land Commission to get me a portion of land on high ground. They also failed to reply. I am a married man with four young children. Am I to be left in this condition? The only way I can get out is by boat. Will you be able to do something for me?"
That is what I face in my constituency.
Comment on this
The Deputy, of course, will let me have the name of the writer so that I can trace his letter?
Comment on this
I will give the Minister the letter. I would prefer not to put the name on the records of the House.
Comment on this
Of course not. Give me his name and I can trace his letter. I am amazed if he has written to me and his letter has remained unanswered for a fortnight. I am gravely at fault if that has happened, but I do not believe it has.
Comment on this
No, but his letter may never have reached me. I state openly that if his letter remained unanswered for a fortnight I am gravely at fault.
Comment on this
The area from which this letter has come is the northern end of Roscommon. I challenge contradiction when I say that of all the counties in Ireland Roscommon is the worst hit. We have the Suck flanking the county on the western side, the Shannon on the eastern flank and on the northern end the Lung river and the Feorish. The whole county should be treated as a disaster area.
Comment on this
I am living on the Lung river and devil a disaster there is. It runs through my land.
Comment on this
There is a deputation of 14 men from Ballaghaderreen from Muintir na Tíre, who are in the gallery at the moment. They are from the Minister's own area.
Comment on this
I am living on the Lung. It flows through my land and since we removed the rock at Tinnecarra the situation there is not half as bad as it used to be, as Deputy Boland knows.
Comment on this
I am talking about the Lung now. It went into Lough Key in the meantime. That held it out for a while.
Comment on this
I do not want to pursue that except to inform the Minister that there is a very representative deputation here from West Mayo and County Roscommon who are now meeting the Minister for Local Government to put their very serious grievance before him.
Comment on this
We have at present a large drainage unit on the Lung briskly excavating it from Lough Gara up to the cut bridge.
Comment on this
I do not care who gets the credit so long as they take the moolach out of the Lung river.
Comment on this
I want to suggest that there are very practical steps that the Government can take with regard to flooding in general in rural areas. It is a good sound suggestion of the Minister to make these interest-free loans available and it is appreciated by the people in rural Ireland. The second suggestion, and I think it is one that will appeal to the Minister, is that the problem the farmers must face next spring is the question of seed, which is of grave importance to farmers in Roscommon and other areas. I am afraid that if this matter gets into the hands of some of the speculators in the country the farmers will be charged very dearly for next spring's seed.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy any particular seed in mind? Is he thinking of seed oats, seed wheat or grass seeds?
Comment on this
Seed oats especially. I suggest matters like that cannot be dealt with by the Red Cross or by the sub-committee which he is considering setting up in Athlone. The Department of Agriculture can judge that best.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that licences are now freely available to bring in seed oats from anywhere.
Comment on this
I want to deal separately with the Shannon problem. The House has faced up to this problem in a frank manner. It is very difficult to see what can be done to remedy the winter flooding in the Shannon area every year. That flooding will be there for all time and the Minister gave the reasons why that will be so. The embanking of the Shannon has been mentioned on numerous occasions and again the question of the money involved will arise and the question as to whether it would be an economic proposition, having regard to the large expenditure involved, must be taken into consideration. There are of course alternatives and one of these is the question of the removal of families from the flooded areas. I do not think anybody in this House would suggest—and the Minister for Agriculture looked at me two or three times as if I had—that people should be forcibly removed from the flooded areas. I think that would be a crime in the first place, but the general impression in rural areas and probably in the city is that these people in Clonown and elsewhere have already been offered alternative holdings in areas not subject to flooding but that they did not go to these new homes. A number of people have been approached by the Land Commission authorities and asked if they were willing to be removed to Westmeath, Meath, or Kildare. Some said "No, I will not go because my father's father was here before me." He apparently did not want to leave his holding and immediately the whole area was blackened because one individual decided not to go, and the Land Commission have used that excuse for years to delay taking people away from the flooded areas.
Three years ago a list of names was submitted by me to the Department of Lands of individuals in the flooded area along the Shannon who were most anxious to leave, and I was informed at a later stage by officers of the Land Commission that these people were not going. I let it go for a certain time but later I went back to meet the people concerned and as a result of questioning them I discovered that of 15 only two had been approached and both of those individuals said they were willing to leave. It was not a private affair at all. I was talking to these individuals outside the church grounds in a crowd and I said in front of all these people: "Say straight out here if you were asked by the Land Commission. If you were say yes and, if not, say no."
Comment on this
The Deputy is now discussing the administration of the Land Commission and I do not think that can be allowed.
Comment on this
I am not. I am endeavouring to point out how essential it is to remove these people if they are anxious to go. Up to the moment the Land Commission have not taken the necessary steps in this situation and I hope from now on the Minister will throw his weight behind this problem and arrive at a situation where he will ensure that all farmers who want to go will be removed. Unlike Deputy Traynor I do not profess to possess any technical knowledge or to be able to give any great advice on engineering problems but I have been informed by men who know the Shannon that when the power station was erected in Ardnacrusha the main thing taken into consideration was power. I have been told that the question of the land above Ardnacrusha in the rest of the Shannon area where people might be subject to flooding did not greatly interest the people concerned—those who were responsible for setting up the dam at Ardnacrusha. We all know the tremendous advance that has been made in the supply of electricity since then. We now have a number of power stations throughout the country and the number is increasing each year so that as far as the Ardnacrusha end is concerned we are not as dependant on power from Ardnacrusha as we were years ago.
The Minister, and others here are, I am sure, familiar with the stretch of water between O'Briensbridge and Limerick and above Limerick where the Ardnacrusha business is situated. Where the water is held up to drive the turbines there is a 100 foot drop into the tailrace below and the House could picture that at Ardnacrusha a number of sluices might be erected beside the turbines so that when there was danger of flooding the sluices could release the water backed up at the turbines. This would mean that the flooding would be reduced very quickly for a considerable distance upriver. The main thing in drainage is to get the water away quickly and I feel sure that if the E.S.B. are properly tackled in this problem the cost of doing the work that I have suggested would not be anything like what it would cost to build an embankment along the Shannon. And my suggestion would do a lot more good. I am offering the suggestion because I was told that a number of American engineers looking at the turbines at Ardnacrusha said that more consideration should have been given to the land upstream.
There will be a number of other speakers here so I do not want to delay the House further. I will say this to the Minister for Agriculture: he is going to leave every Deputy in rural Ireland in a very awkward spot from now on and he should appreciate the difficulties with which most rural Deputies will be faced. We are all very sympathetic with the people along the Shannon and I particularly should be very sympathetic because I got more votes in that locality probably than did the Minister or possibly the Party on the opposite side. But I say there are other areas which deserve very careful consideration. There is quite a considerable amount of danger, too, to people living along other rivers and those people are going to say to me now and to other Deputies: "How is it that compensation will be paid to people in the City of Dublin and to the people along the Shannon and that although we have lost crops and so forth we will get nothing?" That is a problem I can see created and that is why I should like the Minister to take this as an all-over picture rather than in two separate Votes, one for Dublin and the other dealing with the Shannon.
The question of flooding should be treated on a national basis. I feel also that the Red Cross must be complimented for the help they have given up to the present and for the help they are giving, but I feel that this is a task of far greater magnitude than can be handled by the Red Cross in rural Ireland. Voluntary organisation workers can help more easily in Dublin and other such cities than in rural areas. The Minister himself is from rural Ireland and should realise that it is very difficult for the Red Cross to do effective work in a place like Cloheen or other such places.
Comment on this
May I ask a question? Is it not true in the circumstances that practically every field in the whole of Ireland has been flooded this year? What we are trying to deal with now is the problem of the land that has been abnormally flooded. We could make a case that every farmer's land was flooded. We are trying to deal here with the abnormal inundation. It would, of course, be very nice if we could help everybody.
Comment on this
You are opening a door which might, if people put their feet inside, become burst. What I am mostly interested in are interest-free loans and credit for fertilisers and seeds; I am more interested in these than the question of handing out money like this. Still I wish the Minister luck.
Comment on this
I have listened to this debate and it is gratifying to know that some assistance is being given. Everybody who spoke in this debate has expressed sympathy for the flood victims either in the Shannon area or in the Tolka valley. I join with the people who have spoken and extend my own individual sympathy.
The Government, in fact both sides of the House, deserve to be congratulated. We find there is a spirit of co-operation, which is a very satisfactory state of affairs. There is a lot of credit due to the voluntary bodies, the Red Cross, the Army, the Gardaí and others who have co-operated in this emergency. To the people who have supplied goods and materials or helped in any way, this House and the people of Ireland are indebted, not to mention the gratitude which is due to people abroad who have offered assistance.
As other Deputies have said, out of this perhaps some good will come. It has helped, even if it is an expensive way to do it, to focus the attention of this House on the importance of drainage in this country. It is the first time we had an emergency of this kind in the City of Dublin, and at any rate it will have the effect of focusing the attention of the city people on the plight of people in rural areas when an emergency such as this arises.
I would like to agree with the principle adopted by the Government with regard to handling this situation. The Minister for Agriculture has pointed out, and rightly so, that the most urgent problems were dealt with first. Where lives were in danger it was only right and proper that such cases should be dealt with as an emergency. At the same time, that does not rid the Government of responsibility in dealing with problems in other areas. Deputy Killilea, speaking here to-night on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, pointed out cases where 17 families were affected. I can say that in my area there are hundreds of families affected. I have scores and scores of letters from constituents. I have gone out and seen the flood damage myself. There are many farmers in the Moy valley who have lost everything. Across from the Sligo border through Killasser, to Toomore, down by Foxford and on towards Ballina, everything is lost, hay, oats and potatoes.
We must keep in mind so far as these small landholders are concerned that when they lose an area or two of tillage they have lost everything because the majority of those people have only an acre or two of tillage altogether. In some of those other areas, even the Shannon area, the majority of landholders are much bigger and if they lose a few acres— although I agree that some of them have lost everything this time—they may not be as hard hit as people in areas such as I represent.
I know of people who would be glad to help their neighbours if they had anything to help them with but unfortunately they have not. It is a case where everybody lost less or more. Some people's stocks of hay or oats are substantially lower than they were in other years and they are not in a position to help their neighbours. Although we in the Moy valley have not been as vocal as people in other parts of the country, although we have not got as much newspaper publicity about our difficulties, we have suffered very seriously. I have already spoken briefly on this question in recent times when I got an opportunity but as the matter has not been debated as it is being debated to-night I had not an opportunity of speaking at length on it.
Our people are not grumblers. They have been traditionally accustomed to suffering hardships and difficulties and there are few Deputies in this House who can appreciate that fact more than Deputy Dillon, our present Minister for Agriculture, because he himself and generations of his family who came before him—go ndeanfaidh Dia trocaire ar a n-anamcha—have played a great part in trying to help those people, the small tenant farmers of Ireland. I seriously suggest that the people of Mayo will be disappointed in the present Minister for Agriculture if he in his time does not try to play his part in helping the people that generations of his family have helped in years gone by. They look forward to the present Minister for Agriculture, being a western himself—we can claim he comes from County Mayo—considering their case sympathetically.
Comment on this
Very much so. Where do I stand with the Minister on that? Are you going to give me a good helping hand?
Comment on this
There is no soft soap about that. We know the Moy. We do not expect Deputy Cunningham to know much about it.
Comment on this
We know the Moy all right. Although we sympathise with the people in the Shannon area and the Tolka valley and agree that the principle adopted by the present Government was a good one in regard to emergency cases, I am here to speak on behalf of my own constituents, and realising that for generations our people have suffered not alone from flood damage but as a result of the fact that their holdings are small and uneconomic, we feel we have a particular case, a particular problem to which we are entitled to draw attention.
Deputy McQuillan has spoken about the question of seed for next year. I am sure that as a result of all this flood damage a considerable amount of seed, or what we had in mind would be fit for seed, will now be unsuitable. I know the Minister has been a busy man for months past but I would urge him to do everything humanly possible to have seed-testing stations established even if only makeshift stations to test seed for farmers and see if it would be suitable for putting into the ground next year.
Comment on this
Perhaps I would be allowed to intervene. The seed-testing station is available, and if the Deputy could get farmers to send in the seeds for testing now——
Comment on this
Well, Sir, for the relief of agriculture we can discuss all aspects of farming. The question of seed can become a very important one in the spring.
Comment on this
Having regard to the fact that all this has arisen as a result of flooding, I think I am entitled to mention it in passing. People would be well advised to avail of veterinary services at the present time because there is always the danger that animals grazing on flooded lands will get fluke or other disease. If the Minister would consider making free veterinary services available to people whose lands have been flooded I think it would be a very important step, because all this is linked up with our national economy and it is, as the former Taoiseach pointed out, a very serious problem for the Government. It is a problem which is not easy to get over, but, with goodwill and co-operation, I feel confident that, with God's help, we will get over it. We have seen a grand spirit among our people in recent times and I sincerely hope, in the difficult time that lies ahead, that we will see more of that spirit, particularly in this House.
The Minister for Agriculture referred to an incident where a farmer in the eastern counties, somewhere in the neighbourhood of Dublin, kindly came to the rescue of his neighbours perhaps 100 miles away. That was a very fine gesture, and I think it was only right and proper that the tribute paid by the Minister for Agriculture to that gentleman should have been paid, because it is a spirit which has prevailed here in Ireland for generations, and a spirit that helped to keep our country going in dark and difficult days. I would like to see, as far as possible, that spirit encouraged. I would also like to think that people would not turn this whole scheme into a racket, that people would not send forward claims to the Government claiming for damage that has not occurred, and I would say it would be necessary for the Government to be vigilant in matters of this kind, because there are always the few who will avail of any opportunity to cash in on something of this kind. I fully appreciate in that respect, too, the Government has quite a difficult job.
I would like to wind up by saying again that we in Mayo expect the same treatment to be meted out to us as to the people in the Shannon valley. Although our holdings are not as big as those other holdings they are in their way very important. It is worthy of note that in recent times it is from the congested areas such as those I represent myself that the thousands of people are fleeing from the land. All that has happened in recent times as regards flooding will not encourage them to stay. It is up to the Government now to show their sincerity with these small landowners.
I would say to our own Minister for Lands, Deputy Blowick, that if he were to extend the offer of holdings of land to some of the congested district tenants along the Moy valley, I would say many of those people would be prepared to avail of the offer. There are many congested villages along the Moy valley and I would ask him to extend that offer to the people of the constituency of North Mayo—or of South Mayo, if they are affected by the flooding of the Moy. We do not hope to see those lands free of water for three or four months, so that although the people pay rates and rent and taxes many of them have no place to graze their cattle.
Having mentioned these matters, I again appeal to the Minister for Agriculture to pull his weight with the Government—and he can be very forceful when he wants to. I am confident, with his expert knowledge of conditions in rural Ireland and with his ability and forcefulness, if he does pull his weight, we can look forward to the day when something will be done to alleviate the distress and suffering of these smallholders.
Comment on this
I would like to add my voice in commending the work that is being done by the Army and other organisations, and in commending the Government for the way in which they have grappled with this problem. In speaking of the flooding of the Shannon valley, I would like to make it perfectly clear that in my view any statement to the effect that the flooding this year bears any relation to the flooding in any other year is ridiculous. The flooding of the Shannon valley is of a completely unique and unprecedented character. There has always been some flooding in the Shannon valley and there has been a number of different types of floods. There has been flooding which came at the wrong time and removed the hay, and which if it came later would have no ill-effect but might in fact leave a silt of good character in the ground. There has been flooding which flooded a number of buildings about three times in the last 15 years and a considerable amount was done by reconstruction grants, by raising roads, and levelling by the Land Commission, to help the people whose houses were flooded, when the flood was at a much lower level than it is to-day. But as the Minister has said, the flooding at present is unprecedented. I should like also to congratulate Colonel Collins-Powell and the Army in Athlone on the work they are doing. They are doing a very splendid job.
I want to ask the Minister one or two questions in regard to the steps he intends to take in the form of rehabilitation. The Minister has said that the Land Commission would offer alternative holdings to those persons who have been badly flooded, but the view has been expressed to me in the area that as an alternative to that there are people who perhaps are prepared to see another flood at another period entering their homes, but who, having seen this flood come and destroy their crops, might like a small holding in an adjacent area to add to their existing holding in which they could grow some of their more essential crops in perfect safety and at least diminish the losses they would sustain in the event of the rainy periods growing in number. Some might prefer also to build a new house on the smaller holding rather than remain along the Shannon. The proof that that idea has some value lies in the fact that a number of smallholders along the Shannon have already taken steps of that kind. As the Minister knows, some of them have small holdings away from the flooded area and some habitually take land away from the flooded area. I have a feeling that the people of the Shannon area, many of whom have a natural, traditional, family devotion to the Shannon area, and who have shown, as the Minister said, quiet dignity and great fortitude in the face of disaster, might prefer not to leave their traditional abode along the Shannon, but would like to have some sort of additional resources.
Comment on this
May I interrupt the Deputy to say that that position will certainly be examined, but perhaps the Deputy will realise with me that it is not quite possible to make a categorical offer of that kind to all of them? You can say to all of them: "We will give you alternative holdings," but there may not be enough plots to carry out the device the Department has in mind for all those who would wish to avail of it.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister is considering that favourably. There is another problem which is arising now for consideration, namely, the effect of the water on the roads leading to the flooded areas. A good deal of money will eventually be saved if the Minister for Local Government will consider giving some additional grants to the affected county councils for the repair of those roads used for ordinary traffic upon which there are patches of water; these roads will be in a very serious condition if they are not repaired in the immediate future and there ought to be some sort of arrangement made whereby county councils will know that in the case of roads that have been flooded they will be able to get an extra grant from the Road Fund for their repair.
Comment on this
I would also like to ask the Minister whether he has included in his special claim the tributary areas to the Shannon. Are the five families, for example, who had, I think, to vacate their homes on the River Inny, close to the Shannon, included and what exact geographical area does the special assistance cover? The Minister has already been asked about assistance in other areas, but there will be a sort of border line position along the Shannon, particularly where some of the tributaries flow into the Shannon, where the Shannon has backed up into them, where the people have had fairly severe losses of crops and where some people have actually had to vacate their homes. The Minister will be provided with a difficult problem in deciding whether the backing of the Shannon into those tributaries brings such areas within the sphere of his operations and I would like to know from him whether he has made any decision in regard to that matter up to now.
In so far as the long-term project, which has so often to be considered for the prevention of flooding along the Shannon is concerned, I agree with the Minister that the solution seems to be a very, very difficult one indeed. There have been various suggestions in times past. I believe there were some Swiss engineers on the Shannon at one time who proposed the creation of a vast reservoir into which the water would flow. That, of course, would in turn create additional problems in the displacement of people from their holdings. I think the Minister should consider this whole question not only in the light of the very extreme flooding that has taken place this year but also in the light of the more moderate flooding that takes place very, very frequently and which has a bearing on the general problem. The Arterial Drainage Commission, as the Minister knows, regarded the deepening of the channel between Athlone and Meelick as being prohibitively expensive. That was at a time when earth moving techniques were very much less advanced than they are today. I do not think the Minister should say he can do nothing because he cannot face the prospect of preventing this very extreme flooding this year if, at the same time, some steps could be taken which in nine cases out of ten might effect some improvement.
I would also like to express my very great support of the Minister in his effort to promote not only State aid but local effort as well. Everyone in the Athlone area is making a tremendous contribution to the people who have been deprived of their crops. The voluntary committees are working well. It would be a tragic thing indeed if we were ever to see the day where the State would have to provide 100 per cent. of all the aid required in circumstances such as those we are discussing now. I am very glad that an appeal is being made for the co-operative effort to be a joint one, between the State authorities, the local authorities and the voluntary associations.
As I have said, one of the principal difficulties will be the rehabilitation of these flooded holdings in the spring season. From what I hear there are a great many families who are sufficiently conservative not even to want to borrow money if they can possibly avoid it. They will make every effort to avoid borrowing money. There are others in circumstances in which they will be compelled to accept aid in the form of loans such as those which are being offered by the Minister. I do not know whether the Minister would consider in certain cases offering loans to smallholders in the form of kind rather than cash. Would he, for example, consider providing seed oats and the other seed requirements in a scheme analogous to that which is now being operated in the congested areas? Would he consider that a better way of giving relief rather than asking the people to borrow money through the aegis of the Department of Agriculture and the Agricultural Credit Corporation? Possibly he may find that the two systems will be an advantage.
Comment on this
I welcome the Estimate before the House. My first-hand experience of the position in the City of Dublin is confined to a smaller area of flooding than the area affected on the north side. It is an area, however, which in its own way was just as seriously affected. The flooding to which I refer occurred in Kilmainham as a result of the overflowing of the Camac. Out of that experience, which is somewhat smaller as compared with the general experience over the City of Dublin, I have only one suggestion to make and that is that, in addition to any aid in the way of kind or cash for the relief of the distress of the persons affected, there should be an immediate wiping out of any restriction or delay in the provision of houses for people who, as a result of this flooding, are either living or have been discovered to be living in houses unfit for human habitation. In the area to which I refer there are houses, not a great number, which manifestly, as a result of this flooding, received "the last straw that breaks the camel's back." Whatever doubts may have been entertained as to whether these houses were or were not habitable hitherto, once the waters had receded, or even before that time, all such doubts disappeared. The people who have suffered know as well as any architect, engineer or expert that these houses are no longer fit for habitation. To these people alternative accommodation provided now will be worth three times such accommodation provided three weeks hence.
I appeal to the Minister for Local Government to take all the steps available to him to ensure that all the people affected will get alternative accommodation and that no system of priority, no formality, no fear of legal consequences will prevent the corporation from making houses available to house these people now rather than to-morrow.
Comment on this
I would like to bring some northern water to bear upon this problem. It is satisfactory to know that in a situation such as this our Government can take steps to deal with it effectively in a short time. That is something that gives to all a feeling of security and confidence. It is certainly comforting to be aware of that. We hope the efforts being made will be successful. There is one point on which I and many Deputies outside the two areas under discussion are not clear about; what will happen to the persons or families in the areas where, to use the Minister's words, exceptional inundation has taken place?
There are areas in our county where such has happened, where there have been losses due to exceptional flooding. Exceptional flooding in parts of Donegal, as I am sure in other parts of the country, has caused dire distress. I understand this token Estimate is being provided for the relief of cases of dire distress. To take one example, about which I have written to the Minister, giving him a list of names of persons who were affected, we have the case of a breach of the Foyle embankment somewhere below Lifford. A large area was flooded and crops were destroyed.
Comment on this
No. Fortunately, the particular place under water had no houses on it. Still, there was a heavy loss of crops.
Comment on this
If it is the Board of Works, there are the Four Courts there below in which actions could be initiated.
Comment on this
The Department of Agriculture is waiting for a report of a survey which was carried out on the Rivers Deel and Swillyburn. The Office of Public Works say that this job can be included only if the Department of Agriculture make money available for it first. I want the Minister to include that. First of all, I should like to impress upon him that the flooding, which is exceptional this year, is causing unusual inundation in the Deel and Swillyburn areas. I would impress upon him that steps must be taken to remedy that. Those affected are as severely hit as many in the Shannon area and their losses are fairly severe. I know one individual, not in the Swillyburn or Deel areas, but in another area along Lough Swilly, whose losses between wheat and barley amount to about £700. A field of 16 or 17 acres of wheat is still uncut and still under flood.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy seriously suggesting that a man with 400 acres of as good a land as there is in Ireland and who meets with flooding on 17 acres of it, should come to the Legislature for a Grant-in-Aid, a man with 400 acres?
Comment on this
I suggest that a man who has lost crops to the tune of £700 is a person who has suffered distress, a distressed person.
Comment on this
Could he not have insured it? We are dealing with a man who has 400 acres of land. Sure, he could buy and sell me.
Comment on this
I am not going to base my case on one individual. I am telling the Minister that there are people in Donegal whose lands have been subject to flooding and who are, as a result, suffering distress and I am making the case that these people should be assisted in a way similar to those assisted for a like reason along the Shannon and in Dublin. It is a fair case.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not get cross with me when I put it to him: does he honestly think that a 400-acre farmer should seek public relief?
Comment on this
I rather gather that the Deputy is somewhat relieved at the intervention of the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle is endeavouring to put the debate on a regular basis and it cannot be conducted on a regular basis by referring to individual cases.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy would it not be useful to try to segregate the circumstances of the truly distressed person from those of the relatively well-to-do farmer who has suffered a casual loss with which we all sympathise, but who falls into a different category from the person who is caused genuine distress consequent on the virtual inundation of his home?
Comment on this
If the direction of the Ceann Comhairle is of any value, we can get nowhere by discussing matters on that basis. Keep to the general trend of the Estimate, that is, the general principle of flooding.
Comment on this
Will the Minister look at the list I sent him of those who suffered losses? I can assure him they are not all 400-acre farmers. That list will show whether they are deserving cases or not. If they are, will the Minister have the matter attended to? As I understand it, the Government intends leaving this to the Red Cross. We have in Lifford, which is near the Swillyburn and the Foyle, a branch of the Red Cross but I doubt if they are capable of dealing with losses of wheat crops.