We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary and Additional Estimates. - Vote 27—Agriculture.

Contributions 169–326 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I have given the Minister some soft soap before I come to refer to the very serious losses caused by the storm in Portaleen where five fishing boats were completely wrecked, making a total loss of about £5,000.

Comment on this

The boats were not as big as that. They were small boats.

Comment on this

They were the usual fishing boats.

Comment on this

I know each of the five boats and I think I can recall the names of each of them.

Comment on this

The serious fact is that these boats were insured only for one-third of their value.

Comment on this

They were insured for one-third?

Comment on this

That is subject to correction. I know the situation in the harbour. The landing facilities there are so bad that an insurance company would not undertake anything like the full risk. These people have suffered very serious losses. They will not be able of their own efforts to replace their boats unless the Minister comes to their assistance. I understand from a reply given by his Parliamentary Secretary that the matter is being considered.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

I am just trying to back up the representations already made with all the force I can because not alone is there a question of present loss. There is also the fact that in the past ten years they lost 30 fishing boats in all, including the five lost last week. The danger now is, and has been for some years, that these people will become discouraged and that the fishing tradition which exists there will be broken, with the result that many of them will have to emigrate. Some of the younger people have done so already. As the Minister is aware, it is very hard to revive the fishing tradition in any area where it lapses.

Comment on this

We shall try to make the replacement of their boats as easy as it is possible for us to make it.

Comment on this

I shall let it go at that. I know the Minister is aware of the situation and I am glad that he has promised to take steps to ease matters for these people. These are the two points I wanted to refer to in regard to our constituency, that is, that there is flooding; there is distress from flooding and losses. I want those cases to be considered in this Estimate.

Comment on this

I also want to express my sympathy with all the people who suffered loss due to flooding and storm. I must admit that I am rather disappointed to find that there is a differential, if you like, against certain people. What I mean is that in the Vote for Agriculture the River Shannon is given as the distressed area and we all know that in the Vote for the Department of Local Government the River Tolka is regarded as having caused the damage but, strangely enough, the Tolka was not mentioned here; it just says Dublin City. There must have been a reason for that. The Tolka flows through Dublin City but it also flows through a couple of villages in County Meath and the inhabitants of those villages have suffered every bit as much as the citizens of Dublin. In one village, Clonee, the water was almost six feet deep and the people lost everything they had, just as they did in Dublin.

There is the question of whether or not the Red Cross Society will be able to deal with the situation. While I have the greatest respect in the world for the Red Cross Society and the great work they did since the storm, it is just too ridiculous to suggest that the Red Cross Society can deal with the problem. In my opinion they cannot.

Take, for instance, a number of areas in County Meath, where people were depending for their winter supply of fuel on turf which they must take from the bogs. The turf was ruined or, if it was not, the laneways into the bogs were ruined. Is it suggested that the Red Cross Society will be able to have the lanes repaired or to have fuel supplied to the people? I do not think that comes within their province at all.

In Mornington, at the end of the River Boyne, there are fishermen whose families have engaged in fishing for generations, and who have made a living out of it. The Boyne overflowed and took the entire mussel bed and destroyed their livelihood. I do not think it can be suggested that the Red Cross Society can supply a remedy for these people.

I do know that in the towns, Navan and Trim in particular, they can possibly make some small recompense to the people who have lost their household property, but so far that has not been tackled in a big way. I was in these towns to-day and I know that the people who were flooded, some of whom lost everything they had, got second-hand clothing, second-hand blankets and mattresses and stuff like that which would not normally be used by these people. I do not think it was right. I would imagine that it was something in the nature of taking advantage of these people to offer them something which they had to accept because they had nothing else. I do not think it is right, if the Government are to be responsible for relieving the people who suffered by reason of the flooding, that they should try to do it through the medium of a second-hand clothes shop. I am not trying to cast a slur on the Red Cross Society. They are doing their best. The organisations dealing with these matters were treating it from a local angle and they did more than their share, but the Government must do something more than say that the Red Cross Society will deal with the rest of the areas.

The River Boyne runs through County Meath. Flooding on the Boyne is not a matter which need recur every year. It can be remedied. The river can be drained but it has not been done so far and I understand from a reply to a parliamentary question that it will be five or six years before it is done.

Deputy Traynor talked about working a miracle and making the water flow up from the river into the canal but, in regard to the River Boyne, it is merely a matter of having the river cleaned and eventually it must be done. The Government, let it be this Government or whatever Government is in power, should face up to this fact.

I would like to know from the responsible Ministers whether or not it is proposed to give some kind of relief or to do something for the people whose fuel is still on the bogs and who cannot get it out. Will there be any attempt made to put the roadways to the bogs in fit condition so that the turf may be taken out? That is a fair question. I would like to know if the people who have lost a great deal of their property, small farmers in County Meath who have lost much of their crops, will receive any compensation. I am sure they will not receive it through the Red Cross Society.

I notice that some Deputies from the West stressed the fact that there is a big flooded area in the West of Ireland. It can be taken from me that there is a big flooded area in County Meath and even yet one quarter of the county, good land and bad land, is under water and will be for a considerable period. I do not know whether or not it is proposed to introduce a special Estimate.

Comment on this

The Deputy spoke of roads into bogs. Would not it be worth asking the county council could they do something ad interim on a small emergency problem of that kind?

Comment on this

They have already been asked and refused.

Comment on this

Well, now, Deputy Davin is sitting there below you, and if you whispered a word in his ear he might chasten them.

Comment on this

I do not know that Deputy Davin, no matter how anxious he may be, would have power to do something that the county council will not do or have no powers to do.

Comment on this

Perhaps he and I may shake our hoary locks at them.

Comment on this

We may be able to give them some advice.

Comment on this

It is a matter for somebody much higher than the local authority. It is a matter which should be dealt with. We will be told eventually that it is the Department of Finance who will provide the money, I suppose. However, I would like to know if that will be done.

This evening a remark was made about bridges being broken down. There is one particular village in Meath, Duleek, where three bridges have been broken down and the village is practically isolated. Will some money be made available for those bridges? These are only three of at least a dozen bridges in County Meath that have collapsed. Will some attempt be made to provide money to have the job carried out speedily? It is no use waiting six or eight months to start work on these bridges. The work should be done now.

Comment on this

I am very glad to see that the Government has taken such immediate action in relation to the floods in Dublin and in the country, and I congratulate them on having moved so quickly. But there are a few matters to which I should like to draw the attention of the House. The Deputies here have read and heard a lot about the floods in the North Strand and in the Fairview areas, and I should like to inform the Deputies that there are 750 houses alone affected by those floods in the Drumcondra area from Glasnevin village right down Millmount Avenue, and Clonturk Park, on to Fairview Strand and down as far as St. Lawrence Road, Clontarf, as well as the East Wall and Anglesea Place areas. The Minister for Local Government said he believed there were about 1,500 dwellings affected by these floods. I suggest that the figure is 4,000 and also that there were about 500 people in business premises affected in my area.

There is a question for which I cannot see any great remedy and that is the unemployment that has occurred in this area as a result of the floods. One man living in the North Strand Road who carries on an undertaking business has lost cars and motor-hearses to the value of approximately £7,000 and the men employed in his business have lost their jobs. What compensation can be given to these people? Several Deputies have stressed the necessity of housing people that were affected by the floods. As a member of the Dublin Corporation, I should like to say that last Thursday morning, when the floods came upon us so suddenly and catastrophically, the Dublin Corporation had 200 houses and 60 flats to cater for nearly 4,000 families affected. A lot of people have been criticising the Dublin Corporation for their efforts to house these people. The problem confronting the officials of the corporation was one that was really very frightening. The area affected by the Tolka flooding was, I agree, a lot smaller than the area affected by the Shannon floods, but the number of people and of houses concerned was far greater. For the information of the Minister for Agriculture, it does seem strange when you realise that more animals lost their lives in Dublin North-East than were lost in the Shannon floods. In Dublin North-East, a considerable lot of dairying is done; people inside the city rent lands in County Dublin in the summer for dairying purposes. One man, Mr. Byrne, at Leinster Avenue, had 18 cows and he lost ten. The Foleys lost 18 of their 27 horses and even this morning on the railway embankment I saw the bodies of these animals floating on the water.

I should like to pay tribute to the St. John Ambulance for the work they did in the North Strand when the floods occurred. I should also like to thank the Fire Brigade men, some of whom worked two days and two nights without a wink of sleep. These things are not generally known by the public. I want to say a special word about the Garda. One of them who had worked all night in his shirt sleeves and trousers collapsed at 8 o'clock in the morning. That man is still in the Mater Hospital. These are the unsung heroes of the floods. The Army also deserve tribute for the manner in which they speedily erected field kitchens to feed the people. These kitchens and their stocks of food were all lost later in the floods. The Great Northern Railway also deserve thanks. They opened their restaurant in Amiens Street Station that night to feed the people and they sent railway engines up the embankment to bring people from the floods to dry land. We should also pay tribute to the officials of the corporation who worked day and night and to the boat owners who lent rowing boats. It may sound strange to a lot of people to hear that I saw row boats being rowed through the North Strand and into Fairview Strand. The people who sent their lorries to evacuate the local residents who were victims of the floods also deserve our thanks as do the residents who worked right through the night carrying people in their night attire on their backs and shoulders.

The people are asking three questions; the first is, what steps will be taken to prevent a recurrence of these floods? To the people affected this is the most important question of all. It is far more important than any Grant-in-Aid, or any relief, or any compensation that may be paid to them. The bed of the river Tolka is the same now as it was when I went to school in St. Patrick's, Drumcondra approximately 30 years ago. But that river and its tributaries are now taking the flood water from the built-up area of Mobhi Road, Glasnevin, and from the corporation schemes in Walshe's Avenue and Donnycarney and other places along the river. All the waters are now coming into the river which has the same bad as it had 30 years ago.

The water falling on the concrete and tar macadam roads in these schemes is denied, if you like, the ability to be absorbed in the virgin soil and it runs directly into the river. The volume of water now entering the river is four or five times greater than it was 30 years ago. Yet the bed of this river is exactly the same. Factories and other premises have been permitted to be built right up against this river so preventing the widening of the river. From Glasnevin village down to within a little over a quarter of a mile where the Tolka enters the sea, to my mind something can be done at once and must be done. The remedy for the North Strand and East Wall areas is a different matter. My personal belief is that these houses have been built over the last 60, 70 or 80 years on ground that was too low. Any local authority or developers building any housing scheme will naturally avail of the nearest possible place to discharge surface water drainage and in this case the nearest possible place is the River Tolka. When the places they are trying to drain are lower than the flood water level of the river, and when you have flood water coming down the river and a big tide coming up the river, it is natural to expect that flooding will be created. On this occasion, we were unfortunate to experience exceptional floods, a spring tide and an east wind. On East Wall Road the water cascaded across the wall of the River Tolka.

The second question that the people are asking is: what help will be given? In putting that question to the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Local Government I realise that at this stage it is difficult for them to say what help will be given but it is not so difficult for them to answer the third question that the people are asking: when will this help be given? These people do not want this help next March or next February. This help must be given immediately. This help must be given if possible before Christmas. These people lost all their family goods, their furniture and their clothes.

I heard a statement from a councillor of the Dublin Corporation, Councillor Phelan, and I thought that he really hit the nail on the head when he said that he was talking to a man at the corner of Northbrook Avenue, a man of 60 years of age who had reared his family; he stood at the end of the street and said: "Is it not a shocking thing to see, after my 60 years of toil and endeavour, my house ruined and to stand here in a borrowed suit of clothes?" That was the position of these people. These are the people we are seeking to help. A lot of those people have not got clothes to wear. They have ill-fitting clothes that have been given to them, I agree, by the Red Cross Society but these are proud people. They want their own clothes and they want the money to get them. You must appreciate that all last week these people were not working. They were endeavouring to clean out their homes, homes which were flooded to the extent of about ten feet.

A lot of Deputies have been in those houses and have seen the extent and the height which this flood water reached. I was in a house in Spencer Street last Saturday evening where a young man and his wife were living. The young man was from Bailieboro', County Cavan but was working in Dublin and I could see nothing but compliment in the manner in which they had cleaned their house, but the lack of furniture was very conspicuous there. It was thrown out in the back garden, destroyed and broken up. How are these people going to get the few essential sticks of furniture they need to make their home reasonably comfortable?

Deputy Dillon stated that people in the Tolka area experienced the floods for 48 hours. I disagree with him there. They still experience the floods. There is foul sewage backed up by reason of the flood water and in 50 per cent. of the houses that have been affected by the flood you can still get a foul smell the moment you walk in the hall door. Because the flood water has abated does not mean that these people are not still experiencing the effects of the flood.

I mentioned that there were approximately 500 traders affected by flooding in the North Dublin area. A man who had a small grocer shop at the corner of Fairview lost, apart from butter and other commodities, 90 tins of biscuits, the Christmas stock. Through the goodness of some firms, they are meeting some of the loss incurred by these people. There is a shoe shop in Fair-view—and we all know the price of shoes pretty well—and the owner lost 850 pairs of shoes. There is a shop at the corner of Hollybrook Road in Clontarf where the trader lost £300 worth of tea.

I agree with the Minister for Agriculture when he expressed the opinion that certain people should not be looking for this aid, they are not the people for whom this Vote was introduced in the Dáil. This Vote was introduced in the Dáil to help those people who are so affected by the floods that they needed some assistance other than their own efforts to enable them to bring themselves back to the conditions or as near as possible to the conditions which existed before these floods occurred. It has been suggested that the collapse of the G.N.R. bridge was responsible for these floods. At 9 o'clock last Wednesday night in Drumcondra there was three feet of water; at midnight in the middle of the street at Fairview Strand there was three feet of water; and at about 11 o'clock last Wednesday night the water was flowing down East Wall and into the North Strand. The bridge collapsed at 2.30 in the morning. A lot of statements have been made concerning these floods, a lot of them incorrect, and a lot of them true. But the true picture could only be seen by a visit to the flooded areas while the floods were there.

I will conclude by putting again to the two Ministers concerned the three questions that the people of my area, at least, want to have answered. I put this to the Minister for Local Government: what steps will be taken to prevent a recurrence of this catastrophe? The people, I think, are not asking too much, and if the Minister can use all his powers to get a survey or a report from the proper engineers and tell the people what can be done, if anything can be done at all, he will be doing something worth while. There are several opinions as to a possible remedy, and there are several opinions as to the cause of these floods.

My second question is: what help will be given? And the third is: when will it be given? I hope that some of this help will be given to these people before Christmas.

Comment on this

Like other speakers I join with the House in extending my sympathy to the people in those areas of the Shannon and the Tolka on the severe hardships they have endured due to extensive and severe flooding. However, measures' now before us indicate that those two areas which, admittedly, have been hit worst, are being, and will be, looked after. Having said that, I will turn to those areas which are not being catered for and for which no actual promise of material help is being held out. A number of items has already been mentioned concerning my own county and cases have been made for other counties throughout the State, where severe hardship and distress have been occasioned by unusually heavy flooding. There are in County Donegal four or five rivers, all of them small, as we regard rivers, but nevertheless causing very grave flooding which was particularly heavy this year. We differ from people in Mayo, where a case has been mentioned in regard to the Moy, in that there is no real hope being held out to us that these rivers because they are relatively small in size and relatively unimportant will be dealt with in the future. In the case of the Finn, the Deel, the Swillyburn, the Leannan there is evidence, as there has been for months past, that grave losses are being suffered not by the large ranchers with 400 or 500 acres of land but by the 20 and 30-acre farmers who have lost in some cases all their potatoes or oats or possibly both. They may have also lost their hay. And the possibility is that as a result of these losses earlier in the season, if the weather is anything but of the mildest type in the early spring their stocks of sheep or pigs or farm animals may also be lost through starvation because they would not have the crops to feed their animals. In addition to the losses they have already sustained there is every likelihood of further severe losses in the future unless aid is brought to them now.

To counteract any idea in the House or outside it that I and my colleagues in our county are now climbing on the band wagon because there seems to be something going for nothing I would like to point out that at our county council meeting some months ago we directed to the Minister for Local Government a resolution unanimously passed by a very mixed council— politically speaking—pointing out the very grave emergency that had arisen in our county as a result of floods as it affected the roads, particularly roads leading to our bogs in which was the fuel we needed and which has not yet been got home. At a meeting on Tuesday that resolution had not been answered. We have again asked that something should be done or a special grant made available to enable us to get out some of the turf that is so badly needed from the bogs. To add to this trouble we now find that, although taking the country as a whole there are sufficient stocks of coal, stockpiled in some cases as in the Phoenix Park, and the quotas from the National Coal Board in England are fairly substantial and seem to be adequate at the moment, in our county, where we have been depending on turf to a very large extent, the turf this year due to the very bad weather is in very poor condition—any of it that was brought home; part of it is still in the bogs as it was not possible to get it out on account of the roads being torn up by floods—we now find we have to fall back on coal much more than we would have done in the normal way, but that coal is not available——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce say that there were adequate stocks of turf and coal in the county and that if there were not——

Comment on this

In the country?

Comment on this

In the county—that there were adequate stocks of turf and coal available for merchants in County Donegal and that if there were not he would take steps to see that they were available.

Comment on this

I agree that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said that and I take it he said it in good faith, but I want to point out to him that whatever stocks he talks about as being available are not available in Donegal. Although he may cover himself by saying that stocks are available to merchants in Donegal they are not available in Donegal. So far as my information goes there are about 300,000 tons of coal in the Phoenix Park and the Dublin merchants are still importing their total quotas from the National Coal Board. The offer we got is that: "We will send some Phoenix Park coal from Dublin on which you will pay a freight of something over £2 a ton," that before it would reach the merchant in Donegal that extra charge would have to be paid, whereas the simple operation of transferring part of the National Coal Board quota from Dublin to Donegal merchants and shipping it direct to Donegal would have the effect of making coal available at recent prices rather than bringing the coal in from England to Dublin and then sending it from Dublin to Donegal at an extra cost of £2 per ton. Our institutions at the moment are looking for over 800 tons of coal——

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, do you not think we are getting a little outside the terms of reference if we are discussing the relative freight rates of coal imported via Sligo and Dublin?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is going outside the ambit of this discussion upon this Supplementary Estimate. I allowed the Deputy to mention the question of coal but I cannot see how he can proceed to develop the subject within the terms of this discussion.

Comment on this

I want to show the relationship, if you will allow me, and how this arose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I feel that sufficient time has been given to the Deputy to develop the argument.

Comment on this

I have been pointing out that our roads into our bogs have been torn up by the flooding and that in fact it is not just the last flood we are talking about because we have already made representations to the Minister for Local Government to try to relieve the situation. Now I am pointing out the way the matter is being dealt with by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in, as I say, all good faith, but at the same time it is not a very suitable way to meet the needs of the people. A resolution has now been sent to the Minister concerned asking him to do something and possibly the information I have given now may help him to do something useful.

In regard to the position of farmers generally in the county another situation has arisen in relation to which a resolution was passed on last Tuesday by the Donegal County Council calling on the Minister for Local Government and the Department concerned to relieve the farmers who have suffered hardship in this particular flooding, not from paying their rates entirely for the year but from the pressure of the rate collectors in trying to collect the rates at the proper time. That resolution has gone forward to the Minister asking for permission to set aside the requirements of the regulations so that no pressure will be brought to bear and no prosecution taken against people who have suffered hardship until 1st February. I hope that this little facility for the relief of our people will be granted.

It has been stated that the Red Cross will deal with any cases of hardship arising outside the Shannon and Tolka areas. While the Red Cross is an admirable body in the areas in which it is functioning fully and extensively the position in Donegal leaves room for comment. It is not thought that that body would be in a position in Donegal to assess the damage done; neither would it be regarded as the proper body to do so. I suggest to the Minister that he put that view before his Government. Some other organisation should be available. If necessary, such an organisation should be set up to deal with the problem of the losses incurred by the farming community outside of the Shannon area.

That brings me to another matter which has been mentioned here this evening and which it has been stated is under consideration by the Minister. I refer to the wrecking of the boats at Glengad. The recent losses have brought to a head the pressure exerted over the years to get something done for these people. Successive Governments have failed to remedy the situation because they are tied up waiting for reports from their engineers. The reports have invariably been that no engineer would stand over a proposal to provide safe anchorage in Glengad.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see how the Deputy can discuss this pier on this Estimate.

Comment on this

During your absence from the House this matter was discussed. If I wander a little outside the terms of reference I apologise, but it is unintentional and it is only for the purpose of trying to get to the Minister——

Comment on this

Let us be fair. Deputy Cunningham managed to get an innings on the Glengad boats. Deputy Blaney wants a short innings now. I have told both Deputies that we will do the best we can to help these chaps to replace their boats.

Comment on this

Having got your crack in——

Comment on this

Now, is not that fair?

Comment on this

I want to tell the Minister to-day that in answer to a question we were informed that the Donegal County engineer was now being awaited upon for a scheme he promised to the Board of Works.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with it.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot argue the pros and cons of Glengad Pier on the Estimate.

Comment on this

The point raised by the Minister on the position of Glengad Pier is entirely irrelevant. It neither helps nor hinders the people there, and what we want is help and not a vague promise that the Minister will do the best he can. These people have suffered loss due to the storm and they are as much entitled to compensation as the people along the Tolka or the Shannon.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not feel that about the 25 boats lost in Glengad during the period of the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

I have been pressing this matter of Glengad Pier before the Minister had anything to do with the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

That is one for the Minister now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We had better leave Glengad, or the pleasant atmosphere of the debate will evaporate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blaney will come to the Estimate now.

Comment on this

Judging by the Minister's facetious remarks in relation to Glengad and other small communities, these reliefs are something to be bandied about and used in larger communities where their propaganda value will be greater in time of election.

Comment on this

I hope the leader of the Deputy's Party admires the elevated tone that is now being taken.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I think it was rather unwise of Deputy Blaney to end his speech on the note he did.

Comment on this

He could not continue.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I think the general feeling would be one of spontaneous sympathy with all who have suffered privations as a result of this flooding.

Comment on this

That sympathy was expressed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I hope the relief of those people will not become under any guise a gambit of political propaganda.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I want to say——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blaney on a point of order.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I am afraid, is misrepresenting——

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Is it in order to misrepresent what has been said?

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Since when did the Minister for Agriculture become Ceann Comhairle of this House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I am well versed in this technique. He wants to get up and say something dirty under the shadow of a point of order, and, if I can stop him, I will do so.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House will please allow Deputy Collins, who is in possession, to make his speech.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We are being slightly unreal in my opinion in our approach to what the Government is trying to do. Great difficulty exists in finding some equitable means of giving relief in a hurry. The Government, while possibly finding itself forced into a situation in which it has to deal specifically with major problems arising from the overflowing of the Tolka and the Shannon, would want also to take cognisance of the fact that once the door is open every part of the country will put up an incessant clamour for attention. I want in an objective way to make some constructive proposals in relation to the speedy administration of relief. It is unfortunate that, distressing as the floods are, they should have occurred right on the very eve of Christmas. I appeal to the Minister, even though he will have this admirable type of committee to deal with the problem, to establish some basis on which a primary initial payment will be made to deserving cases as early as possible. Some method should be designed whereby something in the nature of an instalment might be paid on foot of claims.

There is no doubt that the Government, and the various members of this House, will be faced by insistent representations from people within and outside the areas affected, in the way of demands on the national purse to alleviate their condition. I do feel that if the Government is to act courageously—and it seems to be the unanimous opinion of the House that the Government has acted effectively and courageously in this matter—where real distress is found—and there are thousands of cases of real distress in Dublin and I understand a tremendous number of cases of acute distress in Athlone—an effort should be made to make an initial instalment available practically forthwith of such compensatory grant as the Government proposes. I feel that unless some very effective definition is laid down as to the basis on which a claim can be made, we shall find ourselves immersed in a situation where the compilation and the investigation of claims will delay the ultimate administration of such aid as the Government desires to give.

I think that some real investigation must take place in a preliminary sense before distribution is effected through any particular committee because time, in this particular season, is running against the Government. The clamour for compensation or for alleviation will be even greater to-morrow morning than it was this morning because people will have seen the spontaneous gesture of the Oireachtas in its unanimous support of the Government's effort to alleviate their distress. There is the problem of which I am anxious to get an elucidation in the Minister's reply. Where is the line going to be drawn in relation to distress? Is it to mean compensation for people who are not in a position to get immediately the essentials to rebuild their homes, whether it be bedding, furniture or a Grant-in-Aid to enable them to make their houses habitable again? I should like some little elucidation as to what form the Grant-in-Aid to these people will take. Is it going to be purely a monetary Grant-in-Aid or, as in cases that have been raised by Deputies here where there has been substantial loss of trading stock or a substantial loss of certain types of chattels, is it going to be a replacement of that particular type of goods to enable these people to carry on?

This will be an extremely difficult problem and I intervene in the debate to try to direct the attention of the House to the immensity of the difficulties that are involved and to get it to preserve that unanimity which is leading to helpful inquiry without any wish to introduce an acrimonious atmosphere. These floods have certainly, to my mind, brought into the forefront of consideration of this House the whole problem of drainage throughout the land. Fortunately, my constituency in the main escaped the rigours and hardships of the most recent devastating storm, but the fate of the Tolka to-day and the Shannon yesterday may be the fate of any of our own areas to-morrow because of the extraordinary lack of progress so far as the general plan of the drainage throughout the land is concerned. The Minister may well say to me that the flooding in the Shannon and in the Tolka is unprecedented. That is true, but the effective answer to that is: no matter how unprecedented it may be, were the beds of these rivers substantially deepened? Was the Tolka suitably cleaned and drained to meet the development that has arisen all round it? Unprecedented as the floods were, I suggest that these rivers should have been in a far better position to discharge these flood waters than they were. Therefore, I feel that when we are dealing with distress arising from flooding due to the conditions of these rivers, we should tackle again the general problem of drainage throughout the land.

We have occasionally flooding occurring in very small rivers in our own constituencies. I can think of many occasions where adjacent to the Island River in Skibbereen houses were inundated. There the problem, we know, can be relieved by dredging, deepening and cleaning the river. That brings to the forefront of our deliberations the whole question of our approach to the problem of the drainage of rivers. You get an answer here in this House that a particular river might be reached in 1976 or even in the more distant future. Surely we may say that out of evil cometh good, if these disasters have forced a reorientation of the administrative mind on the necessity of getting down to the problem of deepening our rivers generally so that they will be in a position to carry abnormal quantities of water. I make that suggestion to the Ministers who have to deal with this problem. There could be just thought and valuable reflection on the general problem so that we may adopt the old adage of being prepared by doing something the day of the deluge.

I would say to the Ministers responsible for the administration of the token Estimates that in order to help themselves in their administration, in order to make the situation of members of this House bearable, they will have to find as soon as possible some method of definition and distinction as to the degrees of priority of claims by people who will suggest that they are distressed. I sympathise with the Government in the difficulties they will have in administering these token Estimates. I commend them, as all other speakers have commended them, for taking the courageous line of introducing these token Estimates to enable them to do something to relieve distress but they should know in advance, and I am sure they do, that no matter how they try there will be people who will say that they did not do enough and, no matter what their best may be, it will ultimately be described as inadequate.

The action of the Government, commendable as it is, is no more worthy of comment in this House than the spontaneous voluntary action of the many organisations throughout the State that helped in the crisis, whether they were the Red Cross Society, the St. John Ambulance Brigade, the Knights of Malta, Army personnel, fire brigade, Gardai or any other organisation. It behoves this House to commend them most earnestly for all they have tried to do.

Mixed views have been expressed here with regard to the function the Red Cross Society will perform in relation to other parts of the country. I may be wrong, and I would like to be corrected if I am, but I feel that the Red Cross Society will be used by the Government solely as the agent to relieve immediate distress in the sense of providing bedding, clothing, food and essential commodities for families that may, in fact, be distressed in areas outside the two areas specified in the token Estimates.

I wonder if the Government ever contemplated, as suggested by the last speaker, that the Red Cross Society might be the agency through which certain reliefs might be granted to farmers in relation to losses in crops or stock. I would like, when the Minister is concluding, that he would tell us what the Government regard as priority claims. I would like to know whether it will be possible to effect an instalment payment immediately to people genuinely distressed. I would be grateful if the Minister, or Ministers, could indicate to what extent the Government propose to make a free Grant-in-Aid to people and to what extent they intend to make other benefits such as interest-free loans, etc., available. Unless a clear indication is given at the beginning there may be in connection with the relief so urgently needed and so spontaneously given by the House, inordinate delays through administrative difficulties created by an overflow of claims, and consequent delay in investigation. This is a problem which might be dealt with on the basis: "If it were done when it is done, then it were well it was done quickly".

Comment on this

Like other speakers, I compliment the Government in coming to the aid of people who have lost their property and whose homes have been flooded. I also want to compliment the various voluntary organisations who assisted so much in the emergency. I have been in the flooded areas in the North Strand and in the county. The various voluntary organisations played their part very well. First I want to compliment the Gardaí. The full brunt of the crisis fell on the Gardaí in the North Strand area. There was a great spirit of co-operation amongst the people themselves in trying to help one another. All the organisations and everybody concerned tried to do their best.

Everything that has been said in favour of the people on the North Strand is worthy of emphasis. The people have suffered a great deal. In my own constituency over 200 homes were badly flooded. Only yesterday some of the homes were still flooded and the water had to be pumped out. There is the problem created by the overflowing of the Liffey. In some houses in Lucan there were three or more feet of water. That was the case also along the river valley, in the Strawberry Beds and the Lower Road. In the parish in which I live about 12 families had to be evacuated. In Finglas, Mulhuddart, Clonsilla, there was flooding. In the Mulhuddart area people had to be evacuated before the flooding took place at the North Strand. I do not want to deal with all the areas affected because I do not want to delay the House.

While the Red Cross Society have tried to relieve people who have suffered, their relief was of a temporary nature and we cannot say that it was all that the people desired.

I want also to mention the case of people who have lost their furniture as a result of houses being flooded to the extent of eight and nine feet.

I have here a pile of correspondence as a result of a check-up made in County Dublin through the Red Cross Society during the last week. The Taoiseach stated that he would set up an impartial committee to go into all these matters. A number of shopkeepers have lost their stocks. In the Swords area one woman lost about £60 worth of cigarettes alone. In other areas, in farms in North County Dublin especially, along the Broad Meadow River, people lost fowl and pigs and in one case a few young cattle were lost. All over the county as well as in the city we have been badly hit in a number of areas and I should like the Minister to take the city and county together for the purposes of any relief that may be given. While the officers and men of the Red Cross went from the county areas into the city where they were so badly needed, we are still getting appeals from the county for help and there are still many cases of distress in the Rathcoole area where a number of houses were flooded out. My rough estimate of the effect of the floods in that area is that there were over 200 houses flooded very badly. A number of families have lost their furniture.

In cases of this sort, I would like the Minister to remember the county is very near the city and that he will treat them both on the same basis. I think the Minister should also remember the problem in Howth where many of the fishing fleet were destroyed. Some of the boats were broken as a result of being beaten up against the harbour. There was one man in my parish whom the Minister complimented and he was Mr. Bergin who gave help towards the relief of the flooding in the Shannon area. I am not a bit surprised at the same man and I should like to add my thanks to those of the Minister. In 1947, when the cattle were dying on the Dublin mountains and when we wanted to get fodder and turnips and mangolds to them, Mr. Bergin gave me £100 worth of hay for the cattle. He is well worthy of having his name mentioned in the House for his work in the relief of distress of this kind. I promised that I should not delay the House and the only reason I got up to speak at all was to ask the Minister to consider the County Dublin area as well as the city and to treat the people there on the same basis. Some of them in the county are deserving of as much assistance and relief as they are in the city.

Comment on this

I shall be very brief. It is only natural in this debate that Deputies should refer to their own constituencies because it is with those that they had direct contact with the distress that has been caused by the floods. Therefore, I make no apologies for referring to the Chapelizod area and for bringing the conditions there to the notice of the Minister. The last speaker referred to the flooding in the Liffey Valley and I think it should not be forgotten that when the authority which it is proposed to set up, and the various voluntary authorities which are working already, are dealing with the distress in Dublin, any relief which is given should not be given merely to the North Strand area. There can be no doubt that they have suffered in the North Strand more than in any other place in the whole country I would say, but there is equally no doubt that in the Chapelizod area in a restricted way there has been a number of families who have suffered as much as some of the families in the greater district of the North Strand.

It is true that surveyors have been out in Chapelizod and that an effort is being made to get out bedding, mattresses and blankets to the area. It does, however, seem to me that we should not forget that in Chapelizod there are 50 small houses in which the flood waters rose to a depth of five or six feet and that as a result in one particular case with which I am personally acquainted, one man with his wife and eight children are living in one room, the roof of which he has tried to prop up with timber from the yard. I am bringing these matters to the notice of the Minister because I feel that the problem is a nation-wide one and it is possible that in a restricted area conditions might be overlooked.

It seems that the present problem can be divided into two parts—the immediate vital one of getting bedding and fuel to some cases and of giving food to the people who have suffered in this disaster. It is true that the emergency, like the waters, has receded, but it has not gone in Chapelizod. There they were still facing the effects of the flooding this afternoon. The second aspect is what you would call the long term one of compensation, and we have been told that the basis of compensation is the relief of distress, but I should like to stress that it is not such a very long term aspect at all. Speed is very essential in the relief of this distress which will only be aggravated by delay. Some delay may be necessary and must inevitably follow the setting up of what must be a complicated machinery to deal with the position.

One last matter I should like to refer to, and that is that some speakers have referred in the course of the debate to the necessity for investigating the cause of the flooding. I should like to raise my voice also with those speakers who have already suggested that some investigation should be made. I am not thinking primarily of fixing any legal liability on any person or any body or any company but only referring to the natural anxiety which I know is felt, certainly in the Chapelizod area and also surrounding the Tolka, that though this sort of thing has not happened in the memory of most people living, it could happen again. There have been rumours that it was not completely the work of nature that brought the river to the high point which it reached in the Liffey Valley near Chapelizod. As I say they are only rumours, but it would be well that they should be investigated, particularly from the point of view of giving an assurance that such steps as are possible would be taken to see that weirs are kept clean and that a proper and adequate warning could be given in the event of any similar happening such as we have experienced in the last two weeks. I want to say in conclusion that the experience which I have had—and it was much less than that of the other Deputies who have spoken during the debate—of the work of the voluntary organisations as being a very happy one. I refer not only to the work by the voluntary organisations but by the officials of the corporation.

I think their work demonstrates what our own people are capable of when faced with an emergency. We have had a fine example of civic spirit, put into operation to help the people who have suffered from what amounts to an act of God. It is good to see that this emergency and this great distress have been met in the way that they have been met—on a non-political basis —and it is proper that we in this House should thank the people who have worked so hard and, by our unanimous decision, do everything possible to assist those who have suffered so much.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Everybody here agrees with the tributes paid to the various services and organisations that assisted in relieving and in dealing with the disaster which occurred in various parts of the country. I think there is a lesson to be learned from all this, that is, the value of such organisations as, say, the Red Cross and the Army, quite apart from war emergency conditions with which most people have associated them. These disasters have shown that bodies of this nature, some of them State bodies like the Garda Síochána and the Army, others, voluntary bodies like the Irish Red Cross and the St. John Ambulance Brigade, have a rôle to play in certain extraordinary circumstances, and that they can be of such value in these circumstances to the community as to amply repay any expenditure that has been incurred on them in years when apparently we were getting no return.

Firstly, I would like personally to join with other Deputies in a tribute to those services, whether State or voluntary. Certainly I would like to join in pointing out their usefulness, but most of all I would like to take up a thread I think the last speaker unravelled, namely, the question that this can happen again, and what is the best way of dealing with it. It is perfectly obvious that if you have these organisations at a high pitch they can be most flexibly ready to deal with such a situation. It is, therefore, not at all away from the subject matter of this motion to remark that it would be very good policy for the State in each and every year to pay some attention to the fostering of these voluntary organisations and to the developing of the State organisations even to the extent of spending a little more on them for the purpose of insurance against such contingencies as we have had to face within the recent month.

In regard to the question of the Army, the Army Engineering Corps and other units of the Army can prove themselves extremely useful to the Government which happens to be in office in dealing immediately with such a problem. Because of the nature of their training they can be efficient in dealing with it and that in itself is something to justify the annual expenditure on these bodies over and above what is justified by mere defence against a possible war emergency.

In connection with the point raised by Deputy Costello as to the future would it not be a good thing, in dealing with emergency problems such as the Government is dealing with at the moment to have the Army Corps of Engineers and similar bodies at the disposal of the State—not unco-ordinated, I hasten to add, with, say, the drainage department in the Board of Works and so on—strictly related to this question of the protection of what I might call in this connection dangerous waterways? Would it not be an economic and useful task for Army engineers to have them spend some of their time studying the problems of a tributary of the Shannon that could be the cause of a big emergency intake in the Shannon in times of great rainfall and be a contributing factor to flooding. Would it not be a good idea if these specialists, trained engineers, with certain troops at their disposal, which would be there in any event, devoted some of their time to examining and working on such a problem and giving a useful return on it? Would that not go a long way towards justifying their existence and their establishment?

Let us consider the valley of the Tolka. Ever since I was a little boy in Dublin everybody in Dublin had heard of the Tolka and its floods. It was notorious, particularly in the Drumcondra area, but anyone who cares to look at the record of the past week will find that the Tolka right back as far as Fairyhouse, anyway, is a dangerous river and has frequently proved itself to be dangerous. There is obviously an engineering problem posed in respect of that river. Fortunately, the calamity does not always reach the dimensions it reached this time in the North Strand area but people with a fair knowledge of this river will remark that it was not as dangerous in other regions this time as it had been on previous occasions. There is a river that would repay some engineering study for the purpose of finding a solution for the problem of flooding.

I am making the suggestion here that perhaps the Government would consider the relation between, say, the Engineering Corps of the Army and the Board of Works or whatever other bodies are available. In the Shannon area we have already seen the Army in another role. They have a certain amount of training in combined action in dealing with problems which apparently no other body could deal with, even if it were only sandbagging to save a local area in a town, and so on, work with which armies are fairly well familiar. In the suggestion I am making I do not want to take from the value of the present move on the part of the Government. If we are looking at the long term aspect here is something we can examine, the provision of facilities for them in the future for their development. Giving them a definite task with a definite interest would be a good thing and I need not delay further on that.

In regard to some of the voluntary organisations, let us consider the Irish Red Cross. We know that body had a very useful history during the emergency and I have no doubt that during the emergency, had it been necessary, that body would have been a very useful service in the city at any rate. Since the war there has been a tendency to forget about this except on the part of a few enthusiasts or some people who have a long view of things. Is it not obvious to us now that such a voluntary organisation as that is valuable and should get every encouragement? However, we must be realists and understand that mere encouragement is not enough, that an organisation of that sort, if it is to be effective must have certain equipment, at least certain facilities, and that translated into plain language means funds. The present surprise, for which one must pay them tribute, is that on this occasion they should have been there in such an organised form and so immediately ready in spite of the adverse conditions in the years since the war. In saying that I do not mean in any way to minimise the good work that has been done by the St. John Ambulance Brigade.

All this again is simply directed to this long-term point. Our rivers are our rivers and our climate is our climate, and if we have a heavy rainfall and perhaps storm conditions, that may mean flooding and disaster for some. We provide against other contingencies and we should, therefore, insure and provide against this particular contingency and prevent it as far as we can. The answer is, I think, survey first, positive engineering to minimise anticipated risks, and eliminate them if possible. That can be done economically by using the services that are already there like the Army Engineering Corps in particular and thereafter the insurance of having bodies like the Red Cross Society up to pitch so that they can be relied upon to deal with these contingencies. That is the main reason why I have intervened in this debate.

There is one further point on these voluntary organisations and peculiarly enough those organisations which have a local basis have a very great advantage over any State organisation in the cases of distress such as we have had and that statement has more force where the distress is widespread than where it is localised for the reason that those organisations, especially those that have local branches can get right down to the root of the matter, can get to the individual cases more effectively and more expeditiously than can any large impersonal body under the immediate control of the State. That is why, for instance, a society such as the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, which is well known to all of us, and societies like that, may perhaps, be the most useful agents we can have at the stage we are dealing with now. The immediate emergency stage called for the Army, the Red Cross, the ambulance service and the Fire Brigade—and while talking about that I think a tribute to the Dublin Fire Brigade is very much in order. Now we are at the second stage—the relief of distress that has been caused, and a society like the Society of St. Vincent de Paul as well as the Red Cross and the St. John Ambulance Brigade in Dublin City—I am not presuming to talk for the country because I have not sufficient experience of conditions there, but I would imagine similar remarks would hold—the Catholic social services and bodies of that nature should be availed of, I would submit to the Minister, for these reasons. They can establish personal contact: they can bring relief in the most palatable, efficacious and most charitable way. They can also bring relief in the most economic way.

The Minister will, I think, appreciate what I mean when I put it this way— if one were to set up a statutory fund, for instance, it would become a matter of law and administration: it would be an impersonal matter: you would have claims, not bona fide as well as bona fide: you would have all the complications of administration, as we know, in connection with claims against public funds: the same type of need of investigation: the same unfortunate situation in which very often the least deserving receives help before the most deserving and so on. All that can be eliminated in one stroke if use is made of parish or local organisations like the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, the Catholic Social Service Conference and the Red Cross. These units are severely local but have the advantage of knowing the local area, knowing the facts and knowing who is hardest hit and who is not so hard hit, of knowing the priorities and strains. I would suggest to the Minister that in the administration of any moneys the Government is going to put forward that every means of using such societies in such a way should be explored and considered as far as possible. I want to emphasise that as far as I can.

There is another point. I know it is already agitating certain people who are concerned with local government administration. It is the difficulty that if the Government attempts to administer the aid completely as a State-controlled matter, they are to a certain extent inviting legal actions. It is not easy for a Government to avoid charges —if they give public funds directly to one person as against another—of unfair discrimination on the grounds that all citizens are equal before the law and so on. I need not expand on that, but I think the Minister will appreciate the possible difficulty I see here in this connection. Perhaps the most expeditious, economic and efficacious way of administering funds of this nature is to use such voluntary organisations as I have mentioned in the implementing of the Government's decision and in the distribution of funds. If the funds cannot be given directly to them to dispose of, at least these agencies should be organised as a rapid means of operating the more cumbersome administrative methods that must of necessity attach to State machinery.

This damage and distress is very widespread, but still it can be sectioned up into areas, and obviously it can be more quickly dealt with by taking areas individually, rather than having one fund to deal with the whole lot. These are all matters of administration and there may be difficulties that I do not see in the approach I am suggesting and, if there are, they will have to be considered.

Deputies have talked of their own constituencies but there is one particular area—Glasnevin—that should be mentioned in connection with the damage that has been done by the Tolka. In the Glasnevin area, and in fact along the whole line of the Tolka, people would be vitally interested in the preventive measures I have mentioned. I think it is no harm for us to realise that although the disaster in Dublin City and the widespread destruction along the line of the Shannon have attracted most attention, there are probably widespread throughout the whole country other areas and other patches which must not be forgotten in this. This is not a question merely of disaster along the Shannon and in Dublin. There are other areas of which I have heard also involved. Deputy Killilea has drawn attention to an area in the vicinity of Tuam. We all know that in the vicinity of some of the coastal areas some material damage has been done.

I do not think it would be very fair to press the Minister too far for his intentions because it takes a certain amount of time for the whole picture to evolve, and, as I say, this is the Government's first, shall I say, immediate measure to deal with the situation, and they would have to see what the whole picture is before there can be any finality about their plan to deal with it. There are, as the Taoiseach said, the problems of relieving distress and rehabilitating people affected in their personal lives, houses to be cleaned up and made habitable and repaired, essential things like bedding to be replaced, hospital accommodation to be provided for people who have suffered consequential illness and so on. In the long term there would be other types of claims to be met, for instance, the question for the farmers of the rehabilitation of land seriously damaged in certain areas by floods—although I understand that sometimes flooding brings a silt which is in fact not detrimental but beneficial. There may be the question of providing fertilisers or replacing stock, replacing some forage that has been lost—all these things come into the second stage.

We can understand that this poses a very serious and difficult problem for the Administration which has to face it. There is, too, the question of boats but, since other Deputies have dealt with that, I shall not delay the House any further in the matter.

I have dealt with the first two phases. Possibly there will be a third phase and now is the time to think out the measures for ensuring either that that third phase will not eventuate or that, should it materialise, we will be in a position to take steps to cope with it. I do not know how far the climatic conditions of the present flooding affect the prospects of agriculture in the coming year. I am told that if the rainfall continues in the new year for any appreciable time a serious problem will develop since certain more or less acute food shortages may occur the year after. This is the time to take precautionary measures in that respect. No such measures can be taken unless a proper survey is made. The Government would be wise now to have some kind of survey made to ensure food supplies for both man and beast in the coming year. We know that this year has not been a good year for potatoes. I do not know how far the wet conditions from July onwards have affected the crop but there are rumours that potatoes will probably be very scarce before next year's crop comes in. A question arises as to whether it is likely that next year's crop will be safe because of weather trends. What steps can be taken now in that regard? Frankly, I do not think I should develop that any further. It is no use being gloomy. We should look at the bright side of things.

Comment on this

Ora pro nobis!

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Perhaps the Minister needs it. I do not raise this from the point of view of being merely gloomy. I mention the matter not from a sense of gloom but from a sense of urgency. Now is the time for the Government to deal as expeditiously as possible through these voluntary organisations with the immediate distress and then go on from that to deal with the rehabilitation or compensation of the people affected. Since we are here acting for the people let us spread the burden that has fallen so heavily on the people in the North Strand and the Shannon area over the community as a whole because, otherwise, it is the community who will have to carry the burden anyway and rehabilitate these people. Let us then try to prepare schemes and take action to prevent such a thing happening again, at least on the scale on which it has happened recently. Lastly, I would urge the Minister and his colleagues very earnestly to make a sober survey of the prospects on the lines I have suggested in relation to agriculture generally and food supplies for the coming year. The Government should take action to ensure that we will safely negotiate sowing and harvesting so that weather trends will have no adverse effects. If all these things are done the country will be the better for them. Services like the Army, the Garda Síochana, the Fire Brigade, the Red Cross and the St. John Ambulance Brigade have given good service. The way to recognise that service is to make further use of such organisations so long as the problem exists, to build them up and make them strong to meet such problems if ever they occur again.

Comment on this

Coming from a constituency that is flooded almost yearly I hasten to add my voice to the other voices raised here in sympathy with the people who have been visited with such material damage of such a great magnitude. In my constituency of North Mayo there is flooding from the River Moy and from the lesser rivers in that area every year for many years past. If there is one lesson to be learned it is the lesson that the time has come when the Government of the day, whatever Government it be, should take immediate cognisance of the fact that the drainage of our rivers, big and small, is a major problem and should be given the priority it deserves, the priority which the people living in proximity to these rivers deserve from any Government.

For too long in my short experience in public life has the drainage problem here been made the subject of political fiddle-strings, played to the best advantage as election succeeds election. It is from such dire calamity as that with which we have been recently visited and from the effects of which we are still suffering that we must learn our lesson. Some of our people have learned it the hard way. Some have learned it to a lesser extent than others. When the immediate problem of relieving present distress has been satisfactorily dealt with the Government, with all the forces at its disposal, should get down at once to the task of reviewing our drainage problem.

It is true, as previous speakers have said, that we must admire the civic spirit of our people and their capacity for endurance. If given a proper lead the people in this country, big and small, have the necessary civic spirit and the capacity to endure, to live and to work, in order to bring about a situation wherein such dire calamity as that which visited us recently can at least be relieved, if not stopped. Someone said this can happen again. Of course it can happen if the necessary precautions are not taken and the lesson learned.

Major de Valera has asked that the voluntary organisations be ready. It must be said in tribute to such organisations, to the Army and the Gardaí, that they were ready in this recent emergency. They did commendable work, and are still doing it. He also urged a survey of conditions. That could be tied in with my earlier exhortations. I disagree with the Deputy when he urges the Government to cast upon the shoulders of these voluntary organisations the administrative work necessitated by this calamity, a calamity which springs from drainage, or the administrative functions of drainage itself. The voluntary organisations must survive for the most part on the enthusiasm and energy put into them and on the popularity which they are able to retain. I think it would be grossly unfair to saddle these organisations with work which is primarily the function of this Assembly or the local authority. Voluntary organisations fulfil their own purpose. That has been admirably demonstrated in this recent emergency. The Government has acted with commendable promptitude. Everybody, from the Taoiseach down, has expressed gratitude to those countries and organisations which so readily offered help and assistance. I should like to add, if it has not been already mentioned—and if it has been mentioned I want to add to it the more vehemently—that our thanks are due as well in no small way to our brethren in Northern Ireland who stood by with their ambulances, ready to cross the Border and come to our assistance if required.

Comment on this

In this debate, no doubt we are likely to be influenced by the abnormal condition of things with which we are confronted and which we are trying to redress. The abnormal weather conditions have been such that not only have they resulted in severe hardship to the community but they have brought fear even into the minds of people who are accustomed to such calamities and a feeling that there may yet be something in the form of some disastrous visitation the extent of which they may not be able to determine with reasonable certainty beforehand. Therefore in discussing this problem as it exists to-night, we must bear in mind the fact that any effort we make or any decisions we may reach must be limited, to the extent that we are unable to estimate what the next few months may bring forth. We are dealing with conditions that are not measurable or that cannot be estimated by any mathematical calculations. We are dealing with the unknown and faced with uncertainty in regard to the hardships that future weather conditions may create. We are likely no doubt to be influenced very strongly at the moment by the damage we have seen, by the abnormal flooding and the extent of the lakes that now exist where green fields of crops grew a few months ago and where for centuries back cattle grazed leisurely. In some cases these areas are now turbulent lakes. The extent to which we can alleviate that situation is very limited indeed, even if we were to devote all our resources to it. They are insufficient to deal with the problem of the continuous rain which brings about abnormal flooding, a condition that even terrorises and drives to dismay the deepest thinkers and scientists we have. Such is the position with which we are confronted now.

To form any rational decision under these circumstances is I think to expect too much from us. All that we can do, and all that is proposed to be done is to launch a campaign to assist our more immediately distressed neighbours and to say to those who have suffered most, that we are prepared to share with them, so far as the resources of the State will permit, the losses which they have suffered and to spread the loss evenly on the shoulders best capable of bearing the burden. That is really the most any Government can do at this juncture. It is a grand thing to see the unanimous support accorded to the Government's efforts to come to the aid of these people but the Government in no way are doing more than is due from them. It is true they are doing nothing less than their best but there is no special thanks due to any Government for doing their best in these circumstances. No Government, I do not care what Government was in office, confronted with the same situation would do less.

The immediate problem that confronts us is to ensure a fair administration of the aid which it is proposed to provide. We must not allow ourselves to be stampeded into the notion that because the calamitous condition of the flooding has brought such sorrow and distress to certain people, we must rush out lavishly to compensate them or more than compensate them. I have mentioned that we have not been able to estimate the extent to which damage may yet occur in the stricken areas and we must face the possibility that a period of flooding may yet arise which may require even more stringent measures than, in the exuberance of our sympathy for those who suffered in the recent floods, we are prepared to provide for them now. It must be remembered also that there are people living in backward districts who have suffered severely also but these people have no access to the publicity which is afforded to centres such as the Shannon area is and the basin of the Tolka river. People living along the Shannon and the Tolka are in close proximity to institutions which afford them the widest publicity. There are journalists anxious to fill their newspapers with thrilling stories of the disaster which befell these people and photographers to provide striking pictures of the ensuing hardship. I speak for an area that has no photographers or no journalists to ventilate their grievances. We have in that district the continuous bog and the mountainous stretch that at all times make life hard and existence very strenuous for those who live there.

What is the difference between those people and the victims of the floods in other areas? The people in these backward districts live in an area that has been perhaps in no way subject to intense flooding but they have a condition of continuous rain and small flooding which has destroyed their crops, their turf, their oats and their hay. Surely the measures to provide relief for distress will not be withdrawn from them because they have no pictures in the papers to show intense flooding in these areas? They live under conditions as difficult as any that exist along the Tolka or the Shannon.

I hope that in considering what is reasonable help for those afflicted by the recent flooding, those responsible for distributing aid from the resources of the State will bear in mind that it is not always the big headline that conveys news of the greatest sacrifice and that the small unwritten story is often as poignant as the most graphic description that can be penned by the hand of a journalist. The Government have taken responsibility to meet the situation generously and quickly. The water that has flown under the bridges left the crops rotting on the fields, turf on the bogs or conveyed the crops with it. The situation must be remedied to the extent that it is possible to remedy it and that will be a very moderate extent.

Consider the situation in a frontal way. What can be done now to save the situation? The stock that was taken off the fields this autumn was in a very poor condition. Grazing was poor. The quality of hay is poor. The quantity of feeding oats available is almost negligible in many parts. What is to substitute for these? Cattle in poor condition that are left to wander in the open and that have poor feeding are very vulnerable to all the diseases that afflict animals. I admit that the Government are as anxious to do what is right as any other Government could be but as one coming from the poorer parts of the country it is my opinion and it is the opinion of experienced farmers that the reserve of feeding stuffs is insufficient. We know the value of our cattle and the contribution it represents to the revenue and to our very existence. We should not content ourselves with dealing on this occasion with the damage that has been done to crops but we should try to estimate and to deal with the consequences that may accrue to live stock by reason of the poor harvest.

The Government should make a contribution in the form of a loan, in the form of cheap feeding stuffs. Let us not depend on the meagre quantity of poor quality feeding stuffs available this year. The Government should make available subsidised feeding stuffs to ensure that at least one mash a day will be made available for cattle to every farmer who is prepared to make some effort. Give him interest-free money. Give him feeding stuffs at reduced prices. Remember that the live stock is the salvation and the lifeblood of the nation and that it has kept us in existence and was the means by which we were able to import essential raw material for factories and essential feeding stuffs. The animal that is lost by a small farmer in Leitrim represents the loss of a fortune to him and he has no means of replacing it. The Government should try to preserve that stock for him. That can be done by giving the farmer some assistance at this stage to enable him to feed the animals during the coming three or four months. If the farmer is left without the means of giving that additional ration to his animals he will be impoverished for many years.

With regard to seeds, the quality available after the last harvest for spring sowing either of potatoes or oats is very poor and it would be the duty of a Government to make provision that seeds, wherever procurable, of good quality, should be made available for the coming spring.

There is a great shortage of fuel on many farms throughout the country. Were I capable of describing the conditions that I have witnessed in the past few months in some homes I could draw tears from even the most hardened Ministers. It is a dreadful thing to see a home without a fire. I have seen such homes and they exist not in small numbers. If a farmer has not his own fuel he goes without. He must depend on whatever piece of timber may be found on the farm and saw it up. Very often it is only whitethorn. In view of the widespread loss and the difficulty of procuring a turf supply from the bogs, whether at high elevation or low elevation, this year, the Minister should consider asking the Department of Social Welfare or some other branch of his Department to do something to relieve the distress that impoverishes more than the absence of food very often, that is, the lack of fuel.

I appreciate that every Deputy is well aware of what the situation is and is endeavouring to do his best to alleviate the distress. We appreciate the efforts of those in the front line who have taken the lead. We thank them. We wish them good luck and we hope that conditions next year will leave us in a more favourable position so that we may do without the help that was necessary this year.

Comment on this

I have been listening for five hours to this debate, awaiting an opportunity to remind the House that there is such a place as County Monaghan on the map of Ireland. One would think that there are no hardships anywhere in this country outside Dublin City and the River Shannon. Some of my Donegal colleagues told us about conditions there. As the Minister for Agriculture knows very well, there are flooded areas in County Monaghan, too. Take for example, the Glyde drainage. The Glyde was drained very well right down through County Louth, into County Monaghan in the parish of Killina, but stopped there, jumped about two miles up river, and cleaning commenced again. They cleaned well back the river, but the rains came and all the water from up-stream came down into the portion that was not cleaned, with the result that many acres are flooded in the Carrickmacross area. People there have lost their crops and their crops to them are just as valuable as the crops of the people on the Shannon or the stocks of the shopkeepers on the North Strand. I would like to remind the Minister that there is a duty to compensate these people just as much as there is to compensate the others.

I am not going to add anything to what the other speakers have said during the past five hours. It would be an endeavour to push through an open door. I realise fully that all sections in this House are prepared to do the best they can to relieve the hardships of the recent floods.

Comment on this

And the Deputy knows his and my concern for the flooded farmers in his area.

Comment on this

Yes, I know that the matter was brought to his attention, and I know he sent the Board of Works engineers to that area and that inside 24 hours the flooding had ceased for the time being, thanks to the Minister. In connection with that matter there have been considerable losses in the potato crop and I should like if the Minister could see his way, when distributing the funds for the relief of distress, that the poor people of that particular area who have suffered the loss of their entire crop, should get some compensation. Up in County Monaghan at a place called Tullygloss near Ballytrain, a large area has become flooded. I passed through the district the other day and I found many acres under floods. The Blackwater, north of Monaghan town, about 35 miles from where I live, is, I believe, a swamp for miles and miles. Then there is the Ballybay area, which the Minister knows very well. You would think it is a seaside place at the moment. There are acres and acres under water there. I do not blame the Minister for these conditions; they are due to the River Erne drainage, and until the Erne is drained properly in Northern Ireland, any scheme on this side cannot be a success. I have been some time trying to get something done locally there, but to no avail, and now I hope that these unprecedented floods will direct attention to the position and will speed up the relief of the people there. I live on the borders of County Louth —in fact with one foot in Louth and one in Monaghan—and I was speaking to Mr. Aiken this morning about a flooded area in Rosslough, one mile from where I live. There is an individual there who has suffered from five feet of water. Fortunately for him he lives in a two-storey house and he was able to go upstairs with his family until the floods disappeared, but he cannot get out of his place. This is only seven or eight miles from Dundalk town. I am glad to see that Deputy Coburn is in the House at the moment. I merely mention this case to show that the hardships are widespread and that it is wrong to think that the hardships are confined to either Dublin or the Shannon.

I heard some talk during the debate about co-operation by voluntary organisations and I should like to say that if any one wished to see voluntary organisations working to perfection to come down to the County Monaghan or to go to Donegal or Cavan, three Ulster counties, where we all work on the co-operative system. In emergencies such as this we do not run for the Red Cross or the Army or the St. Vincent de Paul Society or any other of these voluntary organisations. We help one another and when we are in distress we have not to go to the neighbour. He comes to us to save our crops and we go to him to save his. For a perfect example of co-operative spirit you have to go down to rural Ireland and forget the paid and moneyed organisations. I suggest to the Minister that compensation would be paid to those people whom I have mentioned as well as to those along the Shannon and in the North Strand. I suggest that the flooding all over the country be examined and that something be done to help the people affected particularly in the County Monaghan.

Comment on this

I understand that the Dáil will adjourn to-night until after the recess and it was understood that the Local Government Bill would be taken this evening. I am informed now that unless it is taken and the Committee Stage passed it would be impossible to have the Report Stage ready after the recess. I was wondering if it is likely that the debate would finish at 9.30 and that we would take the Local Government Bill then.

Comment on this

What are Deputy Major de Valera's views if he is leading the Opposition at the moment?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

We would like that the Local Government Bill would be ready for the Report Stage after the recess.

Comment on this

If the Opposition Deputies think that the Local Government Bill should be taken then we would be happy to accommodate them. I do not want Deputy de Valera to feel that the Local Government Bill is being pushed out because of this debate. We are very glad, of course, with the advice we have got during this debate. It will help us enormously in our efforts to relieve distress in the flooded areas but I do not want to restrict the Committee Stage of the Local Government Bill.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The only difficulty is that there is a certain amount of discussion on the Committee Stage in which there are two whole schedules to be considered. Even if we took it immediately I do not think we could finish it this evening. So the obvious thing to do is to go ahead with the Estimate.

Comment on this

How many more Dublin Deputies have to speak about the Tolka?

Comment on this

No more, as far as I know.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Has this suggestion by Deputy Briscoe been discussed by the Whips?

Comment on this

Have discussions been proceeding?

Comment on this

It seems to me that it would be quite impossible to finish the Local Government Bill and, therefore, I think that if there is a number of Deputies yet to speak in this debate— a number have given signs of their intention to speak—the debate on the Estimate should be allowed to proceed. It is also obvious of course that the Estimate must go through to-night and that some arrangement would be made whereby the Minister would be given authority to deal with the distress in the flooded areas. I wonder if we could have an indication now as to how long the Minister will take to reply. I wonder if we could have an indication of how long it would take to go through the debate.

Comment on this

Half an hour would be ample for me.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I take it the debate will not finish before ten o'clock and I agree it is quite true the Minister must make his reply and have done with this Estimate to-night. That must be so. This is of course the most important business—much more important than the Local Government Bill which can wait. Deputies from the different areas are entitled to give their views on the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The proper machinery to arrange this matter is through the Whips.

Comment on this

Am I to be given a chance at all to discuss this Estimate.

Comment on this

You have an hour.

Comment on this

I should like to join in the vote of sympathy to the victims of the floods in the various parts of the country. I think however that we largely deserve what we got but I also believe that it was the innocent who suffered most from the floods.

It took such a calamity to shake us out of our national complacency. We squabbled and fought in this House on small matters for 25 years. It is only a few weeks ago since we had here a hot and bitter debate; a short while later we had a flood on the North Strand. It is a pity the flood that reached the North Strand did not reach this House at the time of the wheat debate so that this House would have been the victim instead of the North Strand. We have wasted millions and millions of pounds in trying to build big highways in this country while we have neglected our rivers, the source of all flooding.

This flooding may be new to many people in the North Strand but it is nothing new to the Shannon valley or to the several families in County Meath. There is one widow within two or three miles of Dunboyne who was flooded out not once but four or five times in the last ten years and people had to come to the assistance of herself and her family. She had to suffer silently. No national Government or local government came to her. This flooding has been taking place over a long number of years but very little is done about it or about the flooding in Trim, Navan and Kilcock and flooding in Dunboyne over the last 12 or 15 years. But now that we have a real flood we are all going to do everything.

I must say the Government has acted promptly in this emergency and has got the nation's thanks for doing so. National funds are necessary and the nation is entitled to put its funds at the disposal of the victims. I do not want to see private enterprise squeezed out and every person, rich or poor, should be encouraged to come forward with subscriptions.

There is much distress in County Meath and I know that not one of those people will get a penny out of the national fund because they do not come under the North Strand or Shannon area. They need money badly because they are mostly poverty-stricken people. There are two or three dozen people living in the town of Navan who were flooded out and their furniture and bedding have to be left there rotting. This has happened for the fifth or sixth time and I hope the Government will see that the Red Cross who are disbursing the money in the country areas will have the money in readiness to alleviate sufferers in this area. I realise no Government could put the whole country under national funds because it would take the whole Budget for the year to alleviate all the suffering. It would mean taking the money from the people and giving it back to them again.

I wish to pay tribute to the voluntary organisations throughout this country. Those silent workers have done a great job, the Order of the Knights of Malta, the St. Vincent de Paul Society, the Ambulance Corps, and so on. We never hear about them but they are always there when distress is around. I will give them the nation's thanks. I do not give the nation's thanks to people who are paid. It is their duty to do it, but I am glad we have organisations in this country, whether they are paid or not, which act competently, but I give credit particularly to those silent societies which have done so much.

There are certain problems for the future. There is one poor man living beside me on a 12-acre farm. He has six or seven children and his house was flooded to a depth of three feet of water and the neighbours had to come to their rescue. He has tried to get a county council cottage built but without success; he has tried to get the Land Commission to help him to build a house but there was nothing doing. I am seeing to-night that this man's case is brought before the Minister for Lands immediately so that something will be done.

The Minister is very active and vocal in seeing that the Shannon valley is cleared out, but I want him to pay attention to County Meath so that people who have been flooded out there are provided with houses. I hope when this emergency is over, when the floods are allayed and the victims are reasonably satisfied, that the nation's resources will be concentrated on eliminating flooding for the future. There is too much money being spent on the highways of this country. We all like good roads but we do not want these skating rinks on which the money is being spent. I would ask the Government to concentrate on seeing that the rivers of this country are cleaned up no matter what the cost is.

There is a question of the River Boyne. I want to see red tape cut and the engineers surveying that river not in three or four years but in one year. The Boyne has given endless trouble for a long number of years. It has flooded the two Black-waters. Of course this is the worst flood we ever had and I hope the Government will see that money is raised in the interests of the people for clearing out the debris that is choking these rivers. I have been told that the River Boyne has islands growing on it with large trees as big as was ever grown in the Phoenix Park. That is a disgrace to the nation. There are seven miles between Trim and Navan and those islands should be taken out—we have enough bulldozers to do that now.

I would ask the Minister for Agriculture—I know he is the strongest member in the House—to use his influence with the other Ministers to tackle the problem in these areas. He tackled this problem some six or seven years ago and he has done great work but I am satisfied that he started at the wrong end. He should have started at Drogheda and cleaned the Boyne from there and then dealt with the tributaries. Flooding has occurred in half the County of Kildare and in half of Meath and still nothing is done about it. I hope the Minister for Finance, who comes from Kildare, will see that the town of Kilcock gets its share of the National Fund for this purpose.

These rivers are deliberately neglected for the simple reason that money was being spent on vote catching and I blame Fianna Fáil for that. They spent 20 years of national wealth in sucking people to their camp to get votes. There were inducements such as free milk, free fuel, free everything, when they should have given men a decent wage, given them a spade or shovel, abolished the dole and close down the labour exchange and give the people work and in that way strengthen the Irish economy. Of course, that work would not be seen. They had to go to the houses of the poor and hand them in the money.

That is as far as I am going to go on this. I want to say that the flooding to-day was caused by the tomfoolery of yesterday when we had millions of pounds squandered in this country, and if the money had been spent in the right way it would have meant that the rivers would have been drained so that no matter how big the floods were in the Tolka or in the Shannon they would abate themselves in 48 hours because the water would have a means of getting away. It is not we who are sitting in this House who are paying for the damage caused by the floods but the poor unfortunate people living in basements and the people who had three or four cattle and saw them floating out in the water. What about all the money that is spent on the high roads to bring in the Jews and the Gentiles and the tourists from abroad so that they could enjoy themselves and have a good time here?

Comment on this

This is a rotten contribution to this debate.

Comment on this

I do not give a damn what it is. The Deputy can mind his own business. He is putting in lip service to catch a few votes around the North Strand.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is not even the policy of his Party.

Comment on this

Everybody was all sympathy to-day. They would pour out millions of pounds to help the flood victims. I have no time for that nonsense. I want to see a plan and a programme and a Government facing up to its responsibilities in a right way and at the right time. There would be no need to worry about the victims of the Tolka and the Shannon floods if the £50,000,000 or £100,000,000 that was wasted had been spent in putting proper beds into those rivers. Now, we have hundreds and thousands of victims. Some people in the Dublin and Shannon areas will get a reasonable amount of compensation although they may not be fully compensated, but what about the men in the Midlands who will not get a bob at all? What about the men in County Meath who saw their stooks and stacks floating away? No Red Cross will come to the people in the Midlands. They will have to get their brooms and clean out their own houses.

I would ask the Government and the House to wake up to their responsibilities and ensure that before another flood comes money will be spent in the right way. I know an enormous amount of money will be spent now, and I know that a lot of tricksters and thimbleriggers who are not entitled to it will try to get some of it. Some of them are now going around with new suits on their backs that they got from the Red Cross, and I know that in the Midlands some men who sold their turf a few weeks before the flood said that their turf was lost and had the Red Cross rushing to them with a ton of coal.

I hope the committee that is to be set up will go very carefully into everything and will put on oath people who are trying to "chance their arm." When the committee meets people who have genuinely suffered I hope they will meet them fully and 100 per cent. The tricksters should be put into Mountjoy. The Government will have many headaches before they alleviate all the distress caused by these floods, and the people who are suffering now are not really victims of the floods but are victims of mean and cheap politics in this country in the past.

Comment on this

Other speakers have made no apology for talking about their own areas and I make no apology for talking about County Mayo. I feel sorry for the people of my native county to-night. Thousands of them have been looking for exchanges of land for the past 20 or 30 years, and it is not much consolation to them to know that a Minister for Lands from their own county is now putting the people of 50 square miles of land before the people of Mayo on the priority list. We do not grudge the people of the North Strand or of the Shannon anything that they get from money voted here for relief of their distress, but I cannot help feeling that the farmers of Mayo who suffered very great distress, too, must feel sad to-night to know that the Government can offer the people of 50 square miles an exchange of holding while they as individuals have been looking for an exchange for the past 20 or 30 years.

Comment on this

Am I to understand the Deputy objects to the proposal to offer people in the Shannon area alternative holdings? Come down on one side of the fence or the other?

Comment on this

He does not know what to say.

Comment on this

Is the Minister finished now?

Comment on this

Do you object to it, or do you just want to make mischief?

Comment on this

He is trying to make mischief.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Lands finished?

Comment on this

I am not finished preventing you from making impudent, mischievous remarks.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flanagan should be allowed to make his speech in his own way.

Comment on this

They can keep at it, a Cheann Comhairle. They are not going to stop me from saying what I want to say and from being perfectly clear about what I mean, and I will come down on one side of the fence or the other in two or three sentences.

Comment on this

We will be fascinated to hear you.

Comment on this

I will make my speech in spite of rude interruptions by the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

They are not rude interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These interruptions should be avoided.

Comment on this

The people of my county, of East Mayo, were told this very evening that they can wait until the Moy, the Corrib, the Suck, the Finn, and goodness knows how many other rivers have been drained before they can benefit from the drainage of the Boyle catchment area. These people found their cocks of hay floating about in the past two or three months: they went out and found the turf they had laboured to save and put into ricks buried under seven or eight feet of water. They were told this evening that they were not going to get anything out of the moneys voted by the Oireachtas. I said, and I repeat, that I do not grudge to the people of North Strand or the people of the Shannon basin anything they are getting. We in the Opposition are co-operating with the Government in voting moneys for the relief of distress. What I am saying is that all the people of my county who suffered almost as bad a calamity in the past three or four months will get nothing out of what we are doing to-night, and whatever hope they had of getting an exchange of lands before, they are now 50 square miles further away from it, and a Mayo man was Minister for Lands in the Cabinet which made that decision. Is anything going to be done for the people of Mayo?

Comment on this

There is not a word of truth in what Deputy Flanagan is saying.

Comment on this

Apparently I am not allowed to make a speech at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am endeavouring to get an opportunity for the Deputy——

Comment on this

I know that, a Cheann Comhairle, and I am very grateful, but apparently I am getting under the skin of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Falsehood is always depressing.

Comment on this

I never deal in falsehoods and I am not dealing in them now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flanagan must be allowed to make his speech without these interruptions, so long as he does so within the rules of order and relevance.

Comment on this

Falsehood does not arise.

Comment on this

I will be forbearing. I will not say some of the things that were said to me when I had the temerity to ask a question of certain people in this House. I repeat that the people in my county are losing because of what is being done here to-night. They have been given no assurance that they will ever be other than losing as a result of the action of the Government to-night. We agree with that action in so far as it benefits the people of the North Strand and the Shannon basin. Let none think that we grudge them what they are getting. We are supporting the action of the Government in giving this help. All I am saying is—it is not a falsehood and I defy anyone to say it is a falsehood—that the people around my area will be worse off to-morrow morning than they were this morning. Where will this land come from?

Comment on this

Where do you think?

Comment on this

We have had enough ignorance from you already.

Comment on this

You are a cheeky brat.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

Where will you get the land to give tenants within 50 square miles? Perhaps that is an unfair question. If it is a falsehood I would like to be told how it is a falsehood.

Comment on this

Would you?

Comment on this

I would.

Comment on this

Sit down then and I will tell you.

Comment on this

The small man never gets a chance. I think I have made it clear that Mayo will suffer rather than gain by this. I defy contradiction on that. I suggest to the Government that inasmuch as the Taoiseach has asked voluntary subscribers to continue to send in money for the relief of distress throughout the country and inasmuch as we are now voting moneys for only two defined areas, all the money that comes from outside bodies should be devoted to areas other than the North Strand and the Shannon basin. In that way we would be endeavouring to solve some very urgent problems outside these two areas. I do not think the voluntary contributors would object if that course were adopted by the Government.

Every Deputy who has spoken has said that in his constituency there is at least one case of severe hardship as a result of the recent flooding. Deputy Kenny, Deputy Giles, Deputy McQuillan, Deputy Lindsay and every other Deputy to whom I listened was able to give an example of grave hardship in his constituency. I appreciate that small sums of money will not solve all these problems but in cases of illness or where there is a large number of children in a family I think these voluntary contributions should be devoted to alleviating that position.

Once upon a time an Irishman was too proud to accept money by way of charity. He insisted on making his own way in life. All the world over as a result of social legislation that pride has gradually been broken down. I appeal to the people for whom we are voting this money to-night to remember their proud heritage and co-operate with the Government in the alleviation of distress by refraining from making exaggerated claims after the fashion of the fellow who runs an old car into a ditch and who, when he goes to the insurance company, claims that it was worth about four times its actual value. I suppose there are people who will do that sort of thing. I hope they will not be many because every bogus claim will take double the time to settle that a genuine claim will take. When the Minister comes to reply I hope to hear him deal with the statements I have made.

I overheard the Minister for Lands say that I want to get this speech into the local papers. I am saying what I believe to be the truth and I would like the Minister for Lands to come down to County Mayo and explain to the people there that they are not worse off because of what we are doing to-night.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I would like to say that Deputy S. Flanagan is not consistent with Fianna Fáil policy when he speaks along the lines he did.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order. The Chair would have a very hard job to keep consistency in statements.

Comment on this

I had no intention of entering into this debate until I heard the statements made by the last speaker. The only trouble that we have in my county is that the waters that fall run too quickly to the sea with the exception of an area in North Kerry and a river between North and South Kerry. It is amazing to me that any Deputy should try to use this Vote in order to reap political capital out of such a situation as that caused by the recent flooding. Thanks to Providence, we have not suffered but I can assure the House that we are behind the Government in anything they propose to do to alleviate the distress caused. In fact we take pride in being associated with anything this Government does for the alleviation of distress in the flooded areas. It is ridiculous talking about Mayo and flooding here and there. These things occur and there is no way of avoiding them. All the Government can do, when a situation arises where people suffer from flooding or from any other calamity over which they have no control, is to come to their aid. I think that we should be really proud of the steps taken by the Minister for Agriculture and the various organisations to alleviate the distress that occurred in this instance. To my mind there is no limit to which we ought not to go, either by providing money or help in any other form, to ensure that the people who have suffered distress because of flooding will be fully compensated. There has been no question in this matter of political associations or anything like that. We as a nation, have on occasion come to the aid of people in foreign lands who were suffering similar distress. Why not, therefore, give aid to our own people when necessary? This Government has done that. It has done everything possible.

I should like to state that the people I represent in South Kerry are proud of what has been done. Their approval will be given to anything that can be done no matter what sacrifices it may entail for the people generally, to ensure that the inhabitants of the affected areas will be fully compensated for their losses of live stock or damage to their homes. I am proud of the action of the Minister for Agriculture and of the Minister for Defence in visiting the affected areas to see for themselves the effect of the damage. I am proud also of the help given by the voluntary organisations. We are especially proud of what has been done by our Army. In fact, I think that the whole world is proud of the action taken to assist the suffering people. There should be no question of opposition to the Estimates put forward by the Government. This is a case really of an emergency and in all emergencies the Government of the country concerned—it does not matter what Party is in power—feel it their duty to come to the aid of the stricken people. There should be no question of politics or party affiliations in matters of this kind.

So far as my area is concerned, we do not suffer from flooding at present but we did suffer on some occasions in the past. The Government then came to our aid in connection with the drainage of the Maine and our difficulties were solved. That, I think, should be the attitude always towards suffering communities, that whenever any section suffer in any way the whole country should come to their aid as we are coming to the aid of the people who have suffered from the recent floods in an effort to alleviate their sufferings.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene in this debate but in view of the fact that so many other Deputies have spoken on this matter, I should like to say a few words in regard to it. I appreciate the action of the Government in coming to the assistance of people who are in a bad way at the moment in the Shannon area and in the North Dublin area. Everyone in the Dáil will support wholeheartedly any action the Government may take in that direction. At the same time, it is only natural that we should direct the attention of the Government to our own counties and constituencies.

I agree with Deputy Palmer's references to areas in South Kerry that were affected up to recently where the people suffered to an alarming degree for a few years. The Maine Valley and the Castlemaine, Keelgallylander and Callinafercy districts were mentioned. People in these districts lost capital and almost everything some time ago, and they received no financial assistance. I do not claim that these are matters which should be considered in the same category as the proposals before the House at the moment, but I should like to make a plea to the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture that if the people to whom I refer cannot be assisted financially from moneys voted now, the Government should at least consider the question of an abatement of their valuations. That is a point that I think could be justifiably put up to the Government, that they should arrange that the farmers who have suffered immense losses in recent years from flooding in County Kerry should be given a remission of rates for seven years. The Government could make these arrangements with the Valuation Department or make an Order to that effect. That would be one way of alleviating the hardships caused to the people concerned. I make that suggestion in view of the fact that it may not be possible to give financial assistance to areas not scheduled in the proposals before the House at the moment. I hope that these points will be considered by the Minister for Lands and the Minister for Agriculture, that if they cannot see their way to assist our people under the present proposals at least the question of a revision of valuations might be considered as some compensation for the losses they sustained in recent years.

Comment on this

Like the last speaker, I had not intended intervening in this debate, but considering the amount of time given to it it strikes me as amazing in one sense that Deputies— perhaps they are right in regarding it from a parochial point of view—should stress the importance of doing something other than is covered by the Estimate. Is it not right to say that this has been a tragedy for everyone concerned? Is it not right to say that it is a tragedy that there should be Deputies who, instead of trying to get this through, are discussing problems which are not related to the terrible problem created by the disaster that has come upon so many of our people in recent days? We do not know if the proposals of the Government will be the great success that we want them to be, but they cannot be a success as long as Deputies act in that way.

Deputy Flynn mentioned his own area. It would be very easy, of course, if there was money available, for all of us to ask that the problems that affect us should be dealt with. I can speak of areas in South Cork where there has been flooding consistently every year. I know many traders and hundreds of unfortunate families in Cork City who, in all the years back, in the years when the Leader of the Opposition was in power, suffered from flooding owing to the terrible, high spring tides. Nothing was ever said here about it. They had to meet that problem annually. Perhaps it was a small problem in relation to the present disaster but certainly it represented much more than inconvenience.

There is no necessity to adopt the procedure of drawing red herrings across the trail. We as a united Parliament should do our best to help those who have suffered so much as a result of the very bad weather we have experienced. If the people concerned had been listening to much that has been said in the course of this debate they would consider that that was a bigger disaster than what they had to go through for the last week.

Comment on this

As one who comes from an area that fortunately, thank God, escaped the tragedy of the floods, I want to express my sympathy with the people who have been affected and to say that we are wholeheartedly behind the Government in voting this money for their relief.

I was glad to hear the Taoiseach say to-night that the other areas would be looked after by the Red Cross Society and that the Government would stand behind the society in that. On 1st December Deputy Kennedy, Deputy Carter and I put down a question to the Taoiseach asking that that be done. The question was answered by the Minister for Defence. He gave the impression that money was not needed. I travel through the Shannon area every week and the floods in that area for the last six weeks have been tragic. Do not imagine that I am going to criticise the Government in any way. It would be in very bad taste to give the impression that it was only when the tragedy hit Dublin that an emergency was declared. Therefore, I was delighted to hear the Taoiseach say that the other areas would be looked after and that the Government would back the Red Cross Society in looking after them.

There are tragedies in other parts of Ireland at present. In Sligo town, a fortnight ago, owing to some work done by the corporation, a very big flood of water covered in a field with the result that the water swept through two stone walls and went into a terrace of houses and ruined every bit of furniture in those houses. That might have happened owing to the neglect of the corporation. The people applied to the corporation but I have been informed that they have been turned down by the corporation. The loss of their furniture is as much a tragedy to these people as is the loss of the furniture of those people we heard so much about all evening. They are just as entitled to compensation. I cannot see much difference between being drowned in the Shannon or the Tolka and being drowned in the Moy or the Feorish. Therefore, I was glad to hear the Taoiseach say that the Government were behind the Red Cross Society and would see that these people were looked after.

We in the West, who escaped the worst of the floods, are wholeheartedly behind this Vote and wholeheartedly join in the sympathy that has been extended to these unfortunate people.

Comment on this

I think it was unfortunate to suggest that the steps proposed by the Government to provide residents in the seriously flooded areas between Athlone and Banagher with an opportunity of migrating would result in the congests of the County Mayo being postponed in securing relief of their congestion. Very well now. I have a message for the congests of County Mayo and I think I know them a little better than their champion this evening and I warrant that they know me and mine a great deal better than they know their champion this evening.

No congest in County Mayo will be delayed by one hour or by one acre in the relief of his circumstance by whatever measures this Government considers it appropriate to take for the relief of afflicted people in the Shannon valley. Their new-found champion may bring that message back from me to County Mayo and repeat it at every cross-roads in County Mayo and then proceed to deny it and my neighbours in County Mayo will laugh him to ridicule when he makes his denial.

Apart from that unfortunate intervention, I think our Government has every reason to be beholden to Dáil Éireann for the helpful attitude adopted by every member of this House, from the Leader of the Opposition down, in dealing with this problem. They have not been consistent in adulation and they have said frankly where they thought the measures we have taken heretofore have fallen short of what they thought was requisite. I can only assure Deputies on all sides of the House that the suggestions that they have made are understood by the Government to be made in good faith and will be most closely examined on their merits.

I want to refer briefly to certain of those suggestions so that I may give specific indication of our readiness to examine them and our gratitude for their submission. But, I think I should make this clear as crystal—if we are to be realistic in confronting the problem that lies ahead, we have got to face the fact that the obligation which this Government undertakes on behalf of the nation is to relieve distress. We are not in a position to undertake universal compensation for loss. If that principle be accepted by the Oireachtas there is not a farm in Ireland in respect of which a claim might not legitimately be made during this year for compensation for loss. It is true to say that in a certain sense every farm in Ireland has been in some degree flooded this year. I think it is also true to say that every farmer in Ireland has, as a result of weather conditions, suffered losses this year and I think that aspect of this situation shows the absurdity of any attempt being made by the Oireachtas to approach this problem on the basis of full compensation.

Let us take the case made by Deputy Cunningham of Donegal who pointed out the case of a neighbour of his in the Lagan valley who lost 17 acres of wheat. Now that is a substantial loss. Deputy Cunningham estimated total losses of that man to be approximately £700. Then I asked him what was the size of that man's farm and he said quite frankly that it was 400 acres. If a man has 400 Irish acres of land and is a competent farmer, I say that he has an income of £4,000 a year. Is it seriously said that we should try to give him full monetary compensation— to a man who has £4,000 a year and who has suffered loss amounting to £700 in this particular year? That illustrates the point that if you accept the principle of attempting to give full compensation all our efforts to pay compensation to the real sufferers would be at the bottom of the bog where we would inevitably sink long before we had reached the cases which are genuine cases of distress and in which we have a clear duty to give aid, comfort and assistance to the limit of our resources.

We have not a deliberate choice to make in dealing with the losses which we see. We cannot go on the lines of full compensation for all losses. If we did we would sink into a morass of uselessness and would paralyse our capacity to relieve those who are real sufferers and who are really in distress as a result of flooding. We all know there have been floods in other parts of the country as well as in Dublin and in the Tolka valley. But we have no doubt whatever that the nature of the flooding in the City of Dublin, as described by Deputy Larkin, while it was not a long sustained trial like that involving the people in the Shannon basin, had the added tragedy that it came upon these people in a clamp in the middle of the night before the people could get any of their property together. Many of them had to try as best they could to get away with their lives. While it is true that their emergency was over in 48 hours, their little store of furniture and the decoration of their houses are there left after them in a state of ruin and desolation simply because they had not sufficient time when the rush of the waters came upon them.

On the other hand you have, as Deputies from the country areas know, the peculiar difficulty in the Shannon valley where they have been wrestling with appalling conditions of flooding for months and we believe that they will go on suffering for another two months no matter how we try to tackle the problem. Even if the weather settles now it will be another two months before the waters recede from their lands and, mark you, we have no guarantee at all that the situation will not be further aggravated if we take the average meteorological experience for the past 20 years and forecast the rainfall for December and January. If we do that, we have reason to believe that the Shannon might rise another foot. However, there is the consoling factor that as we get into December and January it would be a meteorological phenomenon if the river rose any further as the time passes. But we must all the time hope that for the next six or eight weeks the average rainfall will be less than is usual. If it is not, we have further grave problems ahead in the Shannon valley.

Fortunately, I think our resources are adequate to meet whatever flooding problems arise in that area. I do not want to introduce any spirit of acrimony into the debate, but did I not understand Deputy Gilbride to say that I fell short of my duty when I said that no grants were wanted, having visited the Shannon area?

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Then I am sorry I misunderstood him. But the flooding was there and did I not understand the Deputy to suggest that I was not aware of that?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Obviously I made a mistake. But the suggestion was made in a certain form that there was no concern here for the distress in the Shannon area until the flooding broke out in Dublin. It will not do any good at all to make suggestions like these. We all know that flooding in the Shannon valley from Athlone to Banagher is an annual event because the river has a winter and a summer bed. In fact if this were not so a great deal of the callow land adjoining the Shannon would be seriously reduced in value. If the limits of the river were restricted too much some of this callow land would become useless, but the moment those floods began to assume dangerous dimensions, I take no credit for the fact that I told this House on the 5th November that I was going down to inspect the area myself on the 12th. And I went down on two occasions and I travelled all through the floods and I fell into them—through no fault of my own. Driving around in the roads, my car broke down and I fell into the floods, and I was doing the best I could.

In any case, having seen the position I advised the Government that the situation could be met properly by interest-free loans to enable anybody who had suffered any losses of fuel, fodder or live stock to renew their stocks and to give them five years for repayment. During an inspection of the Meelick lock gates, I had a discussion with the Minister for Lands and it was decided to provide a system of migration for the people from the flooded lands. I feel that at that time that was the right attitude. And I can say that I was strongly pressed at that time to recommend that there should be free grants. But I did not agree. I told them in the Clonown schoolhouse that I would not recommend grants. I do not believe the situation calls for grants. I believe interest-free loans can meet the problem with which we are confronted at the present time. I am not saying that in Dáil Éireann and telling a different story in Clonown school. I told them that story in Clonown school and we were then surrounded by water. I told the people there: "Is it not the mercy of goodness we did not give free grants to buy fuel and hay and stock it on land that is now flooded?" But a new situation obtains now since I was in Clonown on November 12th. Houses where the water was not within 15 yards of the front door have now a foot of water in them. Houses where the water was seeping under the door and where they could keep it out with a broom have now water in them up to the handle of the door, and the people have been evacuated out of these houses and are in the Kiltoom military barracks or in their neighbours' houses.

I think that is a new situation and that this House realises that that is a new situation. I would be a fool if I were ashamed to come to Dáil Éireann on the 15th December and say: "The recommendations I made on the 12th November are not adequate for the situation that obtains on the 15th December"; and I would be a fool if I came to Dáil Éireann and did not admit that on the 12th November I hoped the floods would go down. I was hoping and praying they would go down. They did not; they went up and it is the fault of nobody in this House or anywhere else that they went up, and we must face the possibility that they may go up further.

I ask Deputies who say nothing was done on the Shannon until there was a flood to remember this: if nothing had been done on the Shannon, could I have it to tell to-day that not a beast had been lost on the Shannon? Could I have it to tell to-day that there is not a single individual who wanted accommodation, but has been found accommodation? Could I have it to tell to-day that not a single beast that required fodder has not been brought fodder or else been brought to where the fodder was. There was an organisation prepared, and I am not denying two or three times we provided what we thought was a margin of safety and on each occasion we discovered that the event exceeded the margin of safety we thought was adequate. But largely I am obliged to confess owing to the resource, calm, courage and skill of Colonel Collins-Powell we extended our organisation to meet each new development as it arose. It was no more than we were paid to do and I am not claiming any credit. As Deputy Giles has said, there is no thanks to those who are paid for doing their work and they would have to come here in sackcloth and ashes if they failed to carry out their job. I am entitled to say, however, we did our job and that we did not wait for the floods of the Tolka to do the job on the Shannon valley and to be ready to do any further job that a new emergency might thrust upon us.

I quite agree—I forget what Deputy mentioned it—that we must be alive to the danger of exceptional outbreaks of fluke, particularly amongst sheep and cattle, in these heavily flooded areas. I do not care to prick any man's bubble but I am bound to tell the Dáil that I sent a veterinary officer to the Shannon flood area the day before yesterday with a direction to make a survey of every four-footed beast in the area and I have arranged that there shall be inaugurated in the provincial Press of the country an intensive advertising campaign to direct the attention of farmers to the danger of the incidence of this disease and to the methods which they can employ now to cure the disease where it is present or to prevent it developing where it has not yet occurred. If any Deputy can suggest to me any further precaution I could take on that front, I would be very grateful for their suggestions but everything I know that I am in a position to do is being or has been done. I entirely agree the incidence of animal disease consequent on floods is a real danger against which precautions must and will be taken.

I want to reassure Deputies on all sides of the House that we are fully conscious of the situation in relation to seed potatoes and seed oats in these areas in the coming season. Steps are already being taken to ensure that supplies of seed oats will be adequate and of first quality. I do not doubt that we shall be able to put our hands on an ample sufficiency of good seed potatoes because, as Deputies are aware in that particular commodity we do a large export trade and it simply means that the Potato Marketing Board will be requisitioned to keep on hands an adequate supply of seed potatoes to provide all possible requirements in any area which we might immediately anticipate would experience a shortage.

Deputy Giles was checked, I think, for appearing, perhaps, to go a step outside the strict bounds of relevancy when he dwelt on what appeared to him to be the excessive solicitude for road building when greater attention to drainage might avert much of the troubles with which we are now contending. I do not think we can properly or constructively talk about floods if we do not consider how best we may take steps to prevent their occurrence. I will agree with Deputy Giles, as I very frequently find myself constrained to do, in this regard. It makes me almost inarticulate with rage when I am driving down to an area in the centre of this country, 50 square miles of which is inundated, and passing along a fine main road as smooth as a billiards ball I find fellows rooting holes in the road four feet deep over a distance of a quarter of a mile because they do not like the little bump that is in it. It costs about £280 an acre to tar-spray a road never mind rooting four feet out of it, and when I pass these road works proceeding and run down into 50 square miles of country under water and proceed to ferry people out of it in boats, to swim the cattle out and to ferry hay out, and when I hear Deputies all over the House saying: "My neighbours are inundated and that if such and such a river were cleared my neighbour would not be under water;" when I hear them say the Boyne residents are under water, the Barrow residents are under water, the Nore residents and the people living on the river bank in Donegal are under water, I ask myself: is there not a great deal in what Deputy Giles says when he says that we should clear the main channels of the river where the really serious flooding arises in this country? If we got the Boyne and the Barrow cleared, the Nore and the Moy cleared, the main channels, you might never have serious flooding. It is true the tributary rivers running into these might not serve as adequate outlets for the necessary drainage of the land appertraining thereto but you would never get this business of vast areas of country being inundated if the water could escape.

Look at the estuary of the Moy. As Deputy O'Hara says, he and I who live nearby are persecuted all our lives long with our own neighbours floundering around in a sea of water year after year, not because the tributaries are held up; the tributaries are running too well but the main channel of the outlet to the sea is choked. If we could get these main channels cleared we would achieve two great purposes: (1) we would avoid a great deal of the persecution which our neighbours have to go through from this kind of flooding and (2) we would create a pool of employment in every catchment area to which we could put our hands in clearing the arterial rivers pouring into these main rivers whenever employment conditions in those particular areas called for special works in order to increase employment for men who would otherwise be unemployed. I do not want to go too far into this.

Comment on this

Could the Minister do something about cleaning the Shannon up?

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is a cantankerous man.

Comment on this

I want to know will the Shannon be cleaned?

Comment on this

He is an old dog for the hard road. There is nobody in this House who knows better the special problem of the Shannon than the selfsame Deputy Allen. He has been out fluthering around the House all this day writing letters to his constituents and attending to his parliamentary business. I have sat in this House and explained to the House the special problem of the Shannon stating quite freely and frankly what happened. Now that Deputy Allen has got rid of his post, sent his constituents away, he traipses in here at ten minutes past ten to ask awkward questions.

I have been labouring on this problem of the Shannon floods since eight o'clock the night before last, all yesterday and all to-day. Now, I love to chop logic with Deputy Allen, when I am fresh and well, but now the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak, and at ten minutes past ten to-night I am damned if I will chop logic with Deputy Allen. We will do the best we can. Let me reiterate. I am authorised so say on behalf of the Government that we are grateful to Deputies on all sides of the House for the suggestions they have made. We undertake to give them our best consideration and we undertake to do our best in the present situation and more than that we cannot undertake to do. Whether we like it or not on the 9th February, the 9th March, the 9th April and the 9th May for the next four and a half years we will have to answer in this House for the performance of our duty in regard to this matter and every other matter that arises.

Comment on this

Great expectations!

Comment on this

I agree, Deputy, "great expectations." The Deputy may truly rejoice that he was born into so happy a day but I warrant that he will not be disappointed and, indeed, if so disinterested a Deputy should experience conversion, we will welcome him when he crosses the floor.

But this we undertake to do—our best to deal with this situation as it develops. We can undertake to do no more. That we should please all is quite unthinkable: that we are handing over to the best of our ability into the hands of detached and objective judges of the circumstances of each case is certain. In Dublin a committee drawn as best we can from sympathetic and objective judges of the situation will be set up and I have outlined to the House the committee that we design to advise us in the matter of the Shannon valley. In the last analysis it is not those committees but we who must answer to this House for the performance of the tasks before us.

We have told the House what we are trying to do, expressed gratitude for the generous co-operation of Dáil Éireann in this matter and we must leave the future in God's hands in the conviction that it could not be in any better hands.

Comment on this

May I ask a question?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy wishes to put a question he may do so.

Comment on this

In connection with the area involved at the Shannon and compensation for those who have been flooded, will the tributaries of the Shannon be included?

Comment on this

Our design at present is to deal with the whole area which has been subject to inundation, that is from Shercock to Clare.

Comment on this

Are the tributaries of the Shannon, the Suck and the others included in that?

Comment on this

Again, Deputy, I am talking off the cuff. If you want me to get out a map——

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

You know what the Shannon area means and when you begin to consider it—well, the answer is, I do not know.

Comment on this

Is it the whole catchment area you are working on?

Comment on this

No, on the Shannon valley.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister that the 200 families, approximately, that I mentioned when speaking to-night who were flooded out in County Dublin would be treated on the same basis as those in the North Strand?

Comment on this

I cannot answer that.

Comment on this