Committee on Finance. - City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–231 of 468. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1954 ›
Did the Minister get any information on that section in the past week that would induce him to do what we suggested, namely, to withdraw that section from the Bill? It was pointed out here to him, when we were discussing this Bill before, that the whole section is unnecessary. It is a section put in to withdraw or render useless the powers he was giving under Section 4. I wonder if the Minister has thought that out since?
Comment on this
Possibly it is right that, in view of the amount of discussion we had on the section, I should explain it in detail to the House and I propose to do so.
Section 61 of the Local Government Act, 1925, placed a responsibility on the chief executive officer of every local authority to advise the members before they voted on any resolution to do any act in consequence of which an illegal payment would be made or a loss or deficiency in the funds of the local authority was likely to arise. The names of the members who voted for the resolution, were recorded in the minutes. The purpose of this section was to protect the members of the local authority by requiring the chief executive officer to give warning whenever the council were considering some proposal which, if adopted, might result in a surcharge or charge. If the warning were not given the council as a body might subsequently be surcharged or charged. When, notwithstanding a warning given under the section, the council adopt the proposal the names of the members voting for the proposal are recorded in the minutes and these members and no other member are liable, in the event of a surcharge.
Under the law dealing with audits the auditor is required to surcharge a person making or authorising any payment which he deems to be illegal. He must also charge any member or officer with the amount of any loss or deficiency which he deems to have been caused by that person's negligence or misconduct. Where an objection is made under Section 61 of the Local Government Act, 1925, or under Section 16 of this Bill it does not necessarily follow that the auditor will make a surcharge or charge. The auditor may, notwithstanding the objection made, consider that the payment that arises was not illegal or that no loss was suffered by the local authority. Even where a surcharge or charge has been made it does not follow that the person surcharged or charged must meet the amount involved. He has the right to appeal either to the courts or to the Minister to test the validity and the equity of the auditor's decision and to have the amount involved remitted.
In Section 61 of the Local Government Act, 1925, the term "responsible officer" is defined as meaning the secretary, clerk, resident medical superintendent, or other chief executive officer of such local authority. This definition was all right in the pre-management period. It must now be brought into line with the management code under which the manager is the chief executive officer of the local authority. This is done in subsection (1) which places responsibility for objecting on the manager or in his absence such other officer as may be designated by him.
During the discussion on this section there was a good deal of confusion with Section 4 which provides that the members of the local authority may require a manager to do any particular act, matter or thing which can lawfully be done and for which the money is or has been provided. It has been argued that Section 16 nullifies Section 4. I think it was Deputy Blaney who suggested that on the last evening here. This argument is not correct. A requisition under Section 4 docs not apply to acts which are unlawful. It applies only to lawful acts.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy was not listening. A requisition to do an unlawful act does not, however, necessarily involve an illegal payment. For instance, the council could requisition a manager to close a road to traffic without complying with the necessary statutory formalities. The manager need not comply because to do so would be unlawful. No payment is, however, involved and no surcharge or charge could arise. On the other hand, an act which is lawful could give rise to a surcharge or charge. For example, a manager could be directed to accept a tender other than the lowest submitted. I quoted that example the last night. It is perfectly lawful to accept a tender other than the lowest and the manager would have to comply with the requisition under Section 4. The auditor might, however, consider that the acceptance of a tender other than the lowest involved the local authority in a loss or deficiency, and he might feel he should make a charge.
There was also some confusion arising out of the use of the word "deficiency." The words "deficiency or loss" come from the statutes dealing with audits and their meaning has been judicially defined time and time again. A deficiency in the funds of a local authority arises where a sum of money has not been brought into account—for example where a sum due to the local authority by a person is remitted without sufficient reason. It would seem that some Deputies confused this word "deficiency" as used in Section 16 with insufficiency of funds to provide for the carrying out of a work which was the subject of a requisition under Section 4. Under Section 11 the manager cannot exceed the amount provided in the estimates for a particular purpose unless the local authority authorises the proposed excess expenditure. The provision of funds is a matter solely for the elected members and has no relevancy whatsoever to Section 16.
Reference was also made to the practice of local authorities of inserting in an advertisement inviting tenders a clause to the effect that the local authority will not be bound to accept the lowest or any tender. While an invitation to tender and the submission of a tender does not constitute a contract nevertheless in order to avoid controversy and to prevent litigation, public bodies usually consider it desirable to make it clear to contractors that they are not bound to accept any tender; that they may decide to carry out the work otherwise than by contract or that they may accept any tender other than the lowest when they consider it desirable to do so, for example, because they are not satisfied as to the competency of a particular tenderer.
It is necessary to stress that the question of warning does not arise where a local authority are proposing lawful expenditure outside the provision made in the estimates, e.g., the repairing of a road the repair of which was not included in the road works scheme. Once a work requisitioned by the members is a work that can lawfully be carried out and the council provide the money (by authorising the expenditure) the manager must carry out the work. If, however, he considered that there was a cheaper way of doing the work he should warn the members and Section 16 would then operate. I think I have made the matter very clear. Under Section 4 the council may requisition——
Comment on this
Exactly. This section does not apply except where the words "deficiency or loss" might occur. As I have pointed out it could occur in the acceptance of a tender.
Comment on this
The terms, and provisions of this Bill apply to local authorities where a county manager operates the local authority functions. Is that not so?
Comment on this
To-night the Minister laid great stress on the fact that a local authority might take a tender other than the lowest tender. Where, in law—where there is a manager—have a local authority power to take any tender—even under this Bill, when it becomes law?
Comment on this
It does not empower the local authority to accept tenders for anything. I want the Minister to be specific on that point.
Comment on this
——in the reserved functions of the council. There is no reserved function and there is nothing in Section 4 that empowers a local authority to accept tenders.
Comment on this
In this Bill there is some provision about receiving tenders and making rules in connection with the receipt of tenders but there is no provision in law, and the Minister well knows it. There is no use in trying to bluff the House.
Comment on this
There is no use in trying to bluff anyone that a local authority will have power, when this Bill becomes law, to accept tenders of any kind. They will not.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is so stupid that he does not want to get the proper interpretation of the Bill, I cannot help it.
Comment on this
The stupidity of the Minister or of myself does not arise on this Bill. Last Thursday the Minister mads the lamest explanation it was possible to make about the provisions of this section and what it applied to. "Deficiency in funds." How does deficiency in funds arise? Deficiency in funds may arise under any particular heading of a local authority. Money may run out or what was provided may already have been allocated to a particular service. The county manager, the secretary of the council, the county engineer, the chief medical officer, and so forth, could get up and tell the council that such and such would create a deficiency in funds. Personally, I do not see any advantage, so far as the law stands at the moment, in Section 4. The Minister put it in the Bill and he is claiming for it that, under Section 4, the council are getting certain powers.
Comment on this
However Deputy Brennan, or the Minister, or myself, or any other Deputy may interpret something here that does not make it law. Judges and justices and auditors interpret the law. The Minister and every member of a local authority knows well that the auditors are past masters at interpreting every line of the law. When they want to catch out members of a council or a manager or any official they can do so, without a doubt. The auditors the Minister sends down to the local authority are the best versed set of officials in this country in every line of the law.
In my view Section 16 of this Bill is a most reactionary section and I should be surprised if the House would accept such a section. The Minister said at the beginning that he would leave the question of whether or not the section should stand to a free vote. I have no doubt but that he will do so. Section 16 begins:—
"Where a proposal is made at a meeting of a local authority to do or to effect any act, matter or thing——
(a) which constitutes a reserved function or is mentioned in a resolution under Section 4 of this Act, and"
(b) in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made out of the funds of the local authority, or a deficiency or loss is likely to result in or to such funds,"
They have, maybe, these reserved functions "in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made." It is a reserved function. The council have a right, in law, to make that a reserved function. I am sure all the reserved functions are legal and, as they are legal functions, the council have a right to perform them; we assume that. "... Where a proposal, which con stitutes a reserved function, is made in consequence of which a deficiency or loss is likely to result in or to such funds..."
The members of local authorities are adults. The number of illegalities they have committed in the past 25 years is, I am sure the records of the Department of Local Government will show the Minister, taking them by and large, one and all, very low. They have consistently worked within the law, whatever the law may have been. They have committed very few illegalities in their time. If a local authority have any functions whatsoever, and the reserved functions set out in the Management Act that the local authorities have a right to perform—if they have a right to perform, in law they do not become illegal because a local authority set out to perform them. I do not mean to be disrespectful when I say that if any tinpot officer of a local authority objects to performing any of these functions—if the county engineer, the medical officer, the accountant, the manager or secretary, and so forth, stands up and says: "It will create a deficiency in funds. You cannot perform that function"—I think no self-respecting member of the local authority would ever seek reelection. Members of local authorities have proved to be just as responsible as members of Dáil Éireann, in performing their functions.
Comment on this
They were abolished before his time. In the case of the City of Dublin, the local body was abolished before we came in here.
Comment on this
It has often been a source of wonder to me down through the years why all the legislation governing local authorities was necessary. In my time, more of the time of the House has been spent in passing legislation——
Comment on this
——in connection with local government than any other Department of State. I believe we have grown up sufficiently now that it could all be abolished and a set of standing orders devised under which local authorities could act.
Comment on this
I do not think so, but we find here a Minister who claims to be a super democrat, who is giving to the local authorities more powers than they had for the past dozen years— he proposes to give them more powers under Section 4—and who then says in Section 16: "Gentlemen, be careful. If you do anything under Section 4 that any officer does not like you to do, you may be surcharged and may have to pay." There is no power in law, I want to contend, for a local authority to make any payment under the County Management Act. Section 21 of the County Management Act, 1940 sets out:—
The county manager for a county may, by order signed by him and countersigned by the nominated officer or, where there is more than one such officer, the appropriate nominated officer for such county, authorises the making of any payment out of the funds of the council of such county in respect of any expense or on account of any liability incurred by such council or by such county manager for such council in the exercise or performance by such council or such county manager (as the case may be) of any of the powers, functions or duties of such council which are exercisable or performable by them or him (as the case may be) under this Act.
Comment on this
No officer of any council, where there is a county manager, can make any payment. No council can force a manager to make any payment which he considers illegal. They have nothing whatever to do with any payment. They cannot accept a tender and cannot compel a manager to take any tender. They may consider tenders and give their views to the manager on them and may do as the standing orders set out. Under the 1948 Act, they were entitled to do the same thing, to consider tenders, but we know the standard rules which came down from Local Government which enabled these councils to receive tenders, to look at them and to hand them over to the county manager.
Comment on this
Section 29 of that Act, the reactionary Act which gave no powers to local authorities at all and under which the Labour Party believed —I suppose, honestly, as they did not know better—no powers were given at all, that very reactionary Act which took all the powers from local authorities, states:—
Any council of a county or any elective body, at a meeting especially summoned for the purpose under this Section, may by resolution proposed and passed in accordance with this section, require any particular act, matter or thing specifically mentioned in such resolution and which such council or the county manager for such county or such elective body or the manager for such elective body (as the case may be) can lawfully do, to be done in exercise or performance of the executive functions of such council or body.
The very same power is in Section 4 of this Bill. There was a more involved procedure in regard to the number of members of the council necessary to pass it, the number of days' notice to be given and so on, but the very same powers are in Section 4 of this Bill. There was, however, no Section 16 in the 1940 Act and the manager at the moment carries all the responsibility in the matter, if he makes a wrong payment. An effort is being made in this Bill to unload that responsibility on to the local authority. That is the difference between the 1940 Act and this Bill which is supposed to be far more democratic and enlightened than the 1940 Act for which Fianna Fáil were responsible.
Comment on this
On a point of information, the Parliamentary Secretary has referred us to Section 29 as a safeguard. Is that not being repealed in this Bill?
Comment on this
——because he is an old soldier at this type of thing. I believe this is a reactionary section and I am surprised the Minister brought it in. I suggest that he should withdraw it and redraft it for a later stage. I definitely believe that this side of the House would not accept it, having operated local authorities for the past 12 years under the County Management Act.
Comment on this
Do you know that Deputy Smith incorporated the same section in his Bill and you did not vote against it?
Comment on this
He always dealt with you in the right way. You were always the yes or no man behind him.
Comment on this
He had to run the gauntlet here, and, if we had found anything like this in the Bill, we would not have been slow to draw it to his notice.
Comment on this
Whatever legislation was brought in by a Minister in the past does not concern the House to-day. This is a date late in April, 1955, and we are making, or trying to make, laws for the future.
Comment on this
There was nothing in the 1940 County Management Act putting the onus on local authorities or allowing auditors to surcharge members of local authorities. There was nothing so reactionary in it, but there is a proposal in this Bill by the Minister to saddle the responsibility on local authorities and to make them liable to surcharge. I think that is a reactionary suggestion and one which the Minister should reconsider. I ask him at this stage if he is prepared to withdraw the section and redraft it for Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister has put up one argument on this by which he hopes to carry it out, namely, that county councils might compel a manager to accept a tender which might cause a loss in the funds. I would put something else to the Minister in relation to this section. The Minister's contention is that, if this section is passed, the members themselves can be surcharged. We spent a long time here a few weeks ago thrashing out the appointment of rate collectors. We have a scheme in Cork under which we pass on vacant rate collectors' areas to the office for collection and we save about 3d. in the £ thereby, but if we should decide at any time, still exercising our rights and functions, after this section is passed, to take one of these areas out of the office again and appoint a rate collector for it, the Minister can come down on us under the section, if his contention is correct.
Comment on this
We will see how you vote for this. If it would cost about 3d. in the £ to collect the rates by rate collectors, we might decide for one reason or another that we would do it by this method. We would be within our rights in doing it. Under the section the manager can say: "Well, that is going to create a deficiency in the funds. It is going to cost more to collect the rates than it does at present. It would not be the lowest tender for collecting the rates, and, therefore, I am getting a list of those who vote for or against the motion, for the purpose of surcharge". But if there is any substance in the Minister's argument in regard to tenders, it is equally good in regard to this. Therefore, I see no justification for this section. I think it is taking away whatever power we are supposed to have under Section 4.
Comment on this
I must confess that when we were discussing this previously I had a certain amount of suspicion about the section, but having listened to Deputy Corry, I am not too sure that the section is not perfectly right. Deputy Corry suggested a hypothetical case which might happen in Cork, and he said that under this section the members of the Cork County Council might be surcharged. On the hypothetical case he suggested, I think they should, if, regardless of the fact that rates in Cork could be collected more cheaply through the office of the county council, some members decide to appoint rate collectors. They must be doing it for some reason other than economy, and I think it is perfectly right they should be surcharged.
Comment on this
I am very pleased to hear the views expressed by Deputy Sheldon because I hold exactly the same views. I would be more than amazed if, after the result of the local elections, when Deputy Corry found his Party in a majority, he would come in here and say: "No, we will have rate collectors this time. It would only be right".
I should like to refer to the question of illegal payments. I have noticed, and other members of a local body have noticed, that when an engineer recommended a certain sum to be paid for a house offered to the council, members proposed, in spite of his recommendation, that more should be given to the owner of that house. We know that there have been occasions when, unfortunately, the manager, in accepting the recommendations of the members, bought a white elephant. Deputy Corry knows that. If there is a provision in this section to prevent such a thing happening, then I say it is correct.
Deputy Allen spent a lot of time in pointing out various things which could arise. I believe that it would be only rarely where such a situation as I have referred to would arise. Deputy Corry knows, and other members of a county council know, that recently there was a question of a surcharge recommended by an auditor. I presume, notwithstanding the inclusion of this section, that members, if they were so named as having voted on a particular issue, would equally have the right of appealing against the recommendation of the local government auditor, either to the Minister or to the courts, if necessary. Surely, as members of local authorities, if we are prepared to take a certain stand, if we recommend a certain payment, we should be prepared to face up to it. Surely no one here, who is a member of a local authority, is going to suggest that members would make recommendations for payment if it were not just. That is my opinion of the section.
Comment on this
I am giving examples from everyday life. Take the example of where under present circumstances a local authority has been saddled with paying more money for houses than they were worth. The engineer pointed it out but, unfortunately, because the manager accepted the views of the members, the result was that the purchase turned out to be a white elephant.
Comment on this
The Deputy should realise that I am dealing with this Bill from the point of view of a member of a local authority. I am not interested in what was in the 1940 Bill.
Comment on this
I am concerned with what is going to happen local authorities; otherwise I am not interested. I am not concerned with Donegal, but I want to make sure that everything will be above board in Cork. Whether it is a matter of purchasing houses by a local authority, or any other thing, the question of illegal payments might arise only once in 20 or 30 years. If it should happen, say, once in 20 years, is it not right that we should have that safeguard? After all, we want as large a power as possible in local authorities, and with that power must go responsibility. It ill becomes any of us in this House to say that the powers must be ours, but not the responsibilities. If we want to adopt that attitude, then I believe we are drifting a little away from the true sense of democracy in local government. Even if a situation of which I have spoken arose only in 20, 30 or 40 years, it is only fair and just that the responsibility is placed on the members to see that what is right and what is just will be done, and nothing else.
Comment on this
When we were dealing with the section on the last occasion, a point which I felt should be made, and which I thought was not made too clearly, was that no matter what act was performed by the elected representatives of the council, as I understand it at the moment, such an act must be countersigned by the manager. In the last analysis, the manager must give his signature to the performance of any particular act, no matter what is involved—expenditure, or the administration of the local authority. If that is true—and I believe it to be true—why the necessity for this section at all? Despite all the talk just now as to why we should have it, candidly, I did not hear anything that made me believe we should have it any more than I heard the other night. Since the manager is there, he must countersign every item or an officer appointed by him must do so before it is really performed. Where is the necessity for this section at all?
Why not let such a matter as is referred to under Section 16 come to the manager who in the exercise of his own powers and functions would be in a position to say he could not go ahead with this function because it was illegal? The council can compel the manager to do a lawful act but I fail to see where they are empowered to compel the manager to do an unlawful act. In that event the next thing is that we would have the council saying this must be done and the manager saying he would not do it. The logical thing is to send the matter to the Department of Local Government for a decision as to whether or not it should be done. I fail to see what danger there is in wiping out Section 16 altogether.
We have the manager between the council and before the council at all times. No matter what they decide to do the manager must give it his O.K. before it is done. Is not that the proper safeguard? If the manager is, in fact, the manager of the council or of the local authority he should have the last say in the matter. At the moment he has that. Having the last say, he ought to exercise it and let the matter go to the Minister for his decision in the last analysis. I cannot understand people, particularly people from the Labour and other benches, talking about Section 16 and the necessity for it.
Comment on this
I see a much more serious aspect in regard to Section 16. A proposal—it may be a very necessary one—may be made by a member or members of a local authority. It may be an issue on which the council are equally divided. At some crucial stage during the discussion on this proposal an officer of the local authority, the manager or his designated officer for the purpose of that meeting may object and say: "Look, if you vote for this proposal it will be an illegal spending of the council's moneys and you will be likely to be surcharged". If that should happen I feel that in any local authority you will not get the majority of the members, even though they might think otherwise, to vote for that proposal in view of that objection.
As I see the matter now, the manager is being given directly or indirectly a veto on every matter that could possibly be put before the council by any member of the council, thereby taking away from the local authority any power they ever had. We will not be able to do anything in the future by reason of the fact that we may have a manager saying it is illegal. A simple remedy is to let the proposal go through and if the manager refuses to sign the order giving effect to the proposal the council should direct that it be sent to the Minister who ought to decide as to whether or not it is illegal. Having got that decision——
Comment on this
We have quite a few, as possibly the Minister knows, but that is not the point. It is not always easy for a local authority to get legal advice in the midst of a discussion on a particular item which might be of importance. We do not have a legal adviser sitting with us in the council. The cost is enough already to have one sitting outside the council. That is not the point. Why should we make provision for giving them more money and prevent us spending money on something we ought to do in the county? Surely it would be better to spend money in the county than give it to legal advisers? You have competent people in the Department of Local Government to advise the Minister. I am not too sure that the Minister or the Bill gives us anything.
Comment on this
That is not the point. It is a question of finding out why all that the Minister promised is not being given.
Comment on this
That is not the question. We are trying to find out why we are not getting all that the Minister promised.
Comment on this
Ask the Minister about that. There is a long story to it. Section 16, as I see it, takes from us any benefits, if there are any benefits in the Bill, that were conferred on us. Any extra authority that may have been given to us under this Bill is completely nullified by Section 16. Section 16, I contend, is absolutely unnecessary because of the circumstances I have quoted. I would ask the Minister again seriously to consider this matter because I do not think that Section 16 is really worth rowing about from his point of view because it is unnecessary.
Comment on this
I am afraid that I cannot follow Deputy Blaney's argument. He says that the council has no power to do anything unless the manager okays it. That is not my reading of Section 4. I do not see anything about the manager having to agree. There was talk about bringing in legal advisers. On the question of illegality, surely it is provided in the Bill that disputes would go to the Minister? Apart from that, surely the question of whether or not an act which a local authority wants to do is or is not illegal is not as abstruse as Deputy Blaney is trying to make out?
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. Does Section 16, sub-section (1) (a) not refer to any act that may have been performed under Section 4 and, if so, does not it nullify and cannot it nullify any act performed under Section 4?
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe is looking at the bare words. Never mind the bare words for the moment. Can anyone who is on a local authority visualise the position that a manager wantonly—because that is the suggestion—obstructs a council by telling them that what they are proposing to do will be illegal and that they may be surcharged? Wantonly is the point because, if it is right, he is right to do so. It is only if it is wrong that there is going to be any trouble.
Comment on this
Exactly. I ask any member to visualise the position where a county manager or a city manager sets out to obstruct his local authority by wantonly telling them an untruth. What is going to happen him?
Comment on this
Never mind about the Department. What is going to happen him? What is the next move for the local authority?—to move for his suspension. What county manager or city manager will behave in that way? I admit there is a good debating point in Section 16, but in plain fact what will happen in ordinary life? There is not tuppence worth in it. Deputy Blaney knows it and so does Deputy Briscoe. It is a good debating point but everyone knows perfectly well that county managers and city managers are not going to be so foolish as wantonly to tell the council that something will be illegal which can be demonstrated not to be illegal. They never will keep their jobs on that basis and that is the best safeguard.
Comment on this
I do not wish to prolong the debate. I think it can all be boiled down to one particular point in relation to what Deputy Sheldon has mentioned, and I hoped that he would say it. Should a manager, whether he is a city manager or the county manager, say it is illegal under this particular Section, 16, surely the very fact that Section 4 states that members have the right to requisition that a particular thing be done, taking for instance, the local authority to which I belong, means that the first thing Deputy Corry and the other members of the local authority would do would be to use our right under Section 4 to ask him to prove it. We are entitled to do that under Section 4. We are entitled to ask him to do a particular thing. Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Blaney may wish to make a laugh of it. I am giving credit to Deputy Corry, knowing him as I do on the local authority. If we were convinced that a certain line proposed by us was legal and if the manager should say to us that it was illegal, then Section 4 would give us the right to demand of him to show that it was illegal. The onus must be put on the manager to prove that he is right in directing us that the act was illegal. If it is illegal we have no right to do it, and should not do it. If it is not illegal we have the right to do it. Why worry and talk as some Deputies are talking here to-night?
Comment on this
From the debate on the Committee Stage of this Bill one would imagine that county managers are all saints and elected representatives of the people are all sinners.
Comment on this
I cannot understand that people who for so many years have been condemning the powers given to the managers under the County Management Act should be so loud in upholding that Act here to-day in supporting a clause which, as Deputy Blaney has said, nullifies anything that is being given in the Bill to elected representatives. The phrase "if they do something that is illegal" has been used. It is not merely that. If my interpretation of Section 16 is correct, if the elected representatives do anything which will cause a deficiency in funds, the manager may, by simply objecting to their doing it, have them surcharged afterwards. I would like to be contradicted if that is wrong.
I can visualise a position where members of a local authority, seeing that a certain road needed attention, requested the county manager to have £1,000 spent on that road to put it into repair. The county manager or the county engineer or any official designated can point out that that will cause a deficiency in funds and the members who supported the motion may be surcharged. If I am wrong, I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to contradict me. In other words, it is giving the elected representatives something with one hand and taking it from them with the other.
Section 16 completely nullifies anything given under Section 4. Not merely does it do that but it gives to the county manager the big stick to hold over the elected representatives and the power to say: "If you dare command me to do anything, I have a means by which you will pay dearly for doing it." It is entirely contrary to what the people on the other side of the House have preached since the County Management Act came into force. It is showing no confidence whatever in the elected representatives and absolute confidence in the manager. That is my interpretation of Section 16 which is held to be as necessary as Deputy Desmond has pointed out. It does not entrust the doing of anything under this Bill to the men who will be elected by the people without having a section to save them from themselves.
The people who have been calling out for years for more power for the elected representatives now tell us that they must be saved, they must be brought under the manager's big stick in case they would spend money that he could not veto or have the last word in agreeing to it.
The Minister may tell us that he is giving us what we asked for. For that matter, we did not ask for anything. We were administering the County Management Act for all it was worth.
Comment on this
I have fought several local elections and I have never listened to a representative of the other side of this House who did not start off his election speech by saying: "Unfortunately we have not the powers to represent you as we would like to. Those powers were taken from us by a Fianna Fáil Government under what they call the Managerial Act."
Comment on this
Now they are loud in the House in condemning anything that would give back the slightest power to those representatives. A Deputy like Deputy Sheldon, who represents a minority, who should be calling out for every little bit of extra authority, is now concurring with the Minister. I am shocked and surprised that he is concurring with the Minister in bringing in a section which deprives him of any authority whatever under the Bill.
Comment on this
If any Deputy on the other side of the House can prove that Section 16 does not nullify the powers which elected representatives may have under Section 4 I will be prepared to support it but I fail to see in any way whatever the necessity for Section 16 if the Minister has a shred of confidence in the elected representatives of the people.
Comment on this
I think that some of the Deputies who have spoken on this section have not read it and have tried to take part in the debate on it purely on debating points. I say emphatically, that this is the most vital section of the whole Bill. A great deal of it is eyewash. A great deal of it is window-dressing, but you have in Section 16 here a control superimposed by the authority of the Custom House, on the manager and the local authority. Now, you have the control of the manager over the elected representatives. Deputy Desmond says that Section 4 is the safeguard we are concerned about and that if the manager wishes to do something under Section 16 to which the local representatives object, Section 4 safeguards them. The position, Sir, is quite the reverse, and I would ask Deputy Desmond to read it again. Section 16 takes away from the local representatives all that is purported to be given them under Section 4. I say that with all the emphasis I can possibly give it.
Section 4 is a pious expression once you associate it with Section 16. Does Deputy Desmond or does Deputy Sheldon, who has entered into this debate with a certain sense of humour, not realise the seriousness of it? Section 16 starts off in sub-section (1) as follows:—
Where a proposal is made at a meeting of a local authority to do or effect any act, matter or thing:—
(a) which constitutes a reserved function or is mentioned in a resolution under Section 4 of this Act, and
(b) in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made out of the funds of the local authority, or a deficiency or loss is likely to result in or to such funds,
the manager (or, in his absence, such other officer as may be designated by the manager) shall object and state the grounds of his objection,
Now, under Section 4, it is quite lawful and legal for the representatives to decide to do something or anything. If it is, as Deputy Brennan says, their opinion that a certain road is in an unfit condition and should be repaired at a cost of say £1,000 and if they are prepared to strike the particular portion of the rate involved to do that job, that particular lawful decision becomes unlawful and illegal if and when, under Section 16, the engineer or manager says it is not necessary and holds it is not necessary.
Deputy Sheldon waves his head and says "no". We had both Deputy Sheldon and Deputy Desmond grasping on to the illustration given by Deputy Corry as one of the effective reasons which they are taking to vote for the section. I agree Deputy Corry was not so far wrong. Supposing a local authority decides that they are going to employ a certain number of additional members of the staff for a particular purpose, whether it is new or whether it is a continuation of some other operation, and the manager does not want to do it, it immediately becomes an illegal decision.
Comment on this
That is not what "deficiency" means. The Deputy should have listened to the Minister. It is explained in the older Act.
Comment on this
What makes anything illegal? Perhaps Deputy Sheldon would listen to this. Under Section 4, if Deputy Sheldon and I should by any far distant chance be members of the same authority and agree to have something done——
Comment on this
Perhaps not, but perhaps Deputy Sheldon might come to us and give us the benefit of his vast experience. Under Section 4, if the local elected representatives decided to do something which involved expenditure or an increased expenditure, what happens? The manager, or, in his absence, such other officer as may be designated by the manager, shall object and state the grounds of his objection, and if a decision is taken on his proposal, and so on. This does not limit the manager to making objections to anything. This is an over-all control. I say again that you have at the present moment a control over a local authority. Now you are going further to extend a control so that you will have more firm control by the manager over the council and the councillors. What is meant by "if the manager objects"? Objects to what? He can object to anything.
Comment on this
As Deputy Brennan rightly says, if the local representatives want to white-wash or paint or improve a road, whatever the cost may be, and the manager objects on the grounds that he does not think it is necessary, and if the local representatives, in spite of the objection of the manager, persist in pursuing their decision, they become liable to surcharge. Does Deputy Sheldon say that is not so?
Comment on this
Of course it is not so. No court in Ireland would be such a fool as to give such a decision.
Comment on this
So Deputy Sheldon is going to accept that position because if and when it is attempted to make the surcharge effective the local representatives may resort to the court of law to cover themselves against this unreasonable attitude of the manager.
Comment on this
I say that Section 16 is the beginning and the end of this Bill. If this section goes through you have completely finished with any suggestion of democratic control on the part of local representatives because— and I repeat this—everything that you are supposed to get under Section 4 is repealed if the manager so acts under Section 16. During the discussion, and particularly as regards one of the statements made by the Minister, I became confused. The Minister talked about the position where a lawful decision under Section 4 becomes illegal in certain circumstances under Section 16 and he then talked about the surcharge. Listen to the sense of the language, Sir: "A surcharge for an illegal payment for an unlawful act." We are now legislating to the extent that what appears to be lawful under Section 4 becomes definitely unlawful when Section 16 comes into play. You have provided the money under Section 4 for the then lawful act and this becomes an illegal payment for an unlawful act under Section 16 if the manager objects.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister will agree that that surcharge could become enforceable in law because I have yet to hear that you can recover in law anything spent for an unlawful purpose. I think that is one of the codes we have in our law.
Comment on this
Now, Deputy Desmond talked about white elephants in connection with properties bought at excessive prices. He said that the only safeguard against such transactions is the county manager. First of all, before any such purchase can be made, payment has to be made by the county manager and, unless the payment for such a purchase is out of the rates, the purchase is subject to sanction by the Department of Local Government. Therefore, the white elephant purchases to which Deputy Desmond has alluded would suggest to me that, instead of Section 16 as it stands, we should put in a new Section 16 which would stipulate that the local authority should do its business itself because, apparently, the safeguard of sanction from Local Government has not prevented the purchase of white elephants.
Comment on this
Then the manager was a party to it. There are very few purchases of property out of the rates and any purchase made in the manner suggested by Deputy Desmond would leave the councillors open to the severest reprimand and criticism from the ratepayers.
Comment on this
Now, we have had all kinds of expressions of opinion on this section, and I hope the Minister will admit the seriousness of the section and what it really means. The Minister says that it is what we say here that counts in the interpretation of an Act of Parliament. It does not. Deputy Allen quite rightly says it is not what we say here that counts; it is the interpretation by the courts of the cold language in the Act of Parliament that decides matters. We have had cases in the past where the Official Report was produced in court indicating the Minister's intention and judges have invariably pointed out that they are not there to adjudicate on intentions; they are there to interpret what is in the Act. I agree with Deputy Allen that it is what is in the Act that decides ultimately. The auditor does the same. The auditor will interpret the Act and not the intention.
The Minister must not assume for one moment that the people who participate actively in local government are all fools. I ask the Minister to realise that this is a complete reversal of his own expressed opinions in connection with local government. It is in complete opposition to what the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Davin, has said over a number of years.
Comment on this
The only interpretation of "rubberneck" that I know is to describe the fellow who is always on the look-out and poking under seats to see if anything has been dropped or anything left lying about to read. I believe the phrase was first coined in the United States. Apparently the Minister has a different interpretation for rubberneck. If he said we were a bit stiffnecked——
Comment on this
——over here, I might agree with him. Labour have always stated that they stand for the fullest control of local government by the elected representatives of the people. I hold that Section 16, as it stands, completely nullifies the control that we all believed was intended—the control we want over our own local affairs. One would assume from this section that all, or nearly all, the mistakes made in local government administration are made by the local elected representatives. In recent months I have discovered that more mistakes are made by managers and by the Local Government Department——
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary will in due course have a good opportunity of examining the matter to which he is now referring in the greatest detail and I think he will be one of the first to admit that what I am now saying is correct. It is not solely the elected representatives who make mistakes and on whom the brake must be applied. I have learned in the last few months that mistakes are made by managers, and the mistakes made by managers have been confirmed by the Department of Local Government.
In my opinion, the greater the freedom and the greater the right of elected representatives, subject, of course, as I have always said, to an administrative head and subject to an overall examination and control by the Department of Local Government, if you like, the better local government we will have. Section 16, as it stands, will create a disastrous situation and I appeal to Deputy D. Larkin, who is a very active member of our local authority in the City of Dublin—I am sorry Deputy A. Byrne has left the House; I would venture to say that he agrees with the point of view expressed on this side of the House and has gone outside to examine his conscience——
Comment on this
Leave them alone. They have been two and a quarter hours on this section now and they have not even put down one amendment to it.
Comment on this
After a great deal of study, I got my secretary to type a memorandum for me on this and, nearly all through, it starts with the words: "It will be necessary to have this section fully clarified." Until the Minister declared himself with regard to Section 16, nobody could really believe that it was intended to mean what he now says it means, and what we now know it means, and therefore one cannot amend or seek to minimise something that is bad. The only thing one can do is to destroy it and we are unanimous on this side of the House in our objection to this section. We will oppose it.
Comment on this
The Minister may be impatient and may possibly be hurt when members on this side of the House vehemently oppose a certain line of action. I can sympathise with him in that. I may not agree with him, but I can sympathise with him. What I cannot understand is that the patience of the House should be tried by a constant——
Comment on this
——repetition of interjections by Deputies who refuse to say what they mean by those interjections.
Comment on this
It would be a good thing if the Wexford Deputy got up on behalf of Labour and gave us his opinion of this section, thereby letting the people know how little he knows about it——
Comment on this
——when he makes these interjections. Some Deputies, in their lukewarm support of this section, have tried to make a case for it. Everyone who has tried has only succeeded in damning it further. Deputy Sheldon says that his lifeline is the courts of justice. Deputy Desmond's lifeline is that if it did happen 20 or 30 years ago that was a mistake made by a particular local authority and that that single mistake justifies Section 16 —did anybody hear the like of that before?
Comment on this
It is this puritanical outlook which sickens me. We in this House under all Governments from time to time passed a variety of measures and on a number of occasions the legislation passed here has been found to be faulty and Ministers have had to come in here to amend a mistake in what was drafted or as a result of finding out from practical experience or the implementation of a particular Bill or Act that a mistake had been made. Nobody suggests that because the House of Parliament under the direction of a particular Minister of State with his host of officials and draftsmen behind him—because under those circumstances faulty legislation or mistaken legislation was passed—this House should be abolished and a dictator put in. That is what you are doing under Section 16. You are dismissing the county manager and creating a dictator. That is what you are doing. Deputy Davin grunts and says nothing.
Comment on this
I am saying what I know is going to happen. Deputy Davin occasionally participated in local government legislation debates but the Parliamentary Secretary always prefaced his interjections by saying: "I speak as a member of the House who has never had any experience whatever of being a member of a local authority." Therefore, I say the Parliamentary Secretary does not know what I have been talking about——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is there any penalty for repetition even by one Deputy apart from the fact that he is repeating what other fellows said?
Comment on this
I make a present of this to the Parliamentary Secretary— the Parliamentary Secretary has never served for one hour on a local authority——
Comment on this
——and therefore the work of a local authority is quite alien to the Parliamentary Secretary. Consequently he does not know what I or anybody else is talking about when we are talking about local government management. I would challenge the Parliamentary Secretary who is Parliamentary Secretary to the present Minister for Local Government, to get up and give us his dissertation on Section 16. Let him tell us what it means.
Comment on this
I would believe the Deputy as I would believe a child who might not know what he was saying. I feel that there are a great number of members of this House who have served for a great number of years on local authorities and served many hours of every week trying to unravel their rights under local government legislation, trying to find out what they can do and what they cannot do, and finding themselves hamstrung. The Minister said before in justification of this Bill that this section was included in the Bill introduced by his predecessor in this House, but I do not know whether he has read the debates on the Second Reading of the Bill as it was then introduced. If he has, he would have found that our Minister for Local Government, the present Deputy Smith, was quite willing to listen to criticism, and at least he had personal practical experience and knowledge of the work not only as a member but as chairman of a local authority.
Comment on this
I am trying to refrain from making certain answers to certain interruptions, but it is very difficult sometimes to control oneself. The Minister for Local Government has, on many occasions during the passage of the Local Authorities Bill and on previous sections and on the Second Stage of this Bill, claimed to have expert knowledge of local government, having acted as legal adviser to a local authority for many years. The Minister has said that. Now I appeal to the Minister, and I think he will agree that whatever Party a member of a local authority belongs to, particularly in the case of the local authority to which I belong, the elected representatives have always tried to do their best in the interests of the people they represent, and they are not just lunatics, knaves or fools, and that the manager is not the little green-eyed god to whom local authority representatives must bow down. Surely the combined wisdom of the majority of a local authority in coming to a decision should be sufficient to offset the opinion of a single individual. Surely that particular idea will be subscribed to. Further, if the local authority unanimously decides something, is it not to be assumed that a body of sensible men—as they should be—in unanimously deciding something should be more than a match for the manager who has to have the safeguard of paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 16?
I would like to hear Deputy Larkin on this, not—if you like—from a Party point of view. I would like to hear from him on this from his own experience in the City of Dublin. Does he not agree that the reserved functions —and we have very few reserved functions—should be left in our control without having them reduced to a farce or to nothing, which is the position that Section 16 would bring about. I would ask the Minister, having heard the various opinions on this particular section and having heard, as I said before, the very lukewarm expressions in favour of it, to take courage and admit that Section 16 is not necessary and will be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I have listened with some care and attention to the speeches of Deputies Blaney, Brennan and Briscoe on this Section 16. I find great difficulty in accepting that they have a common or an agreed approach on this matter. Listening for some time to Deputy Briscoe, one gathers that it would be almost impossible for a local authority to make a decision that might result in an illegal act being performed. On the other hand, Deputy Blaney told us that there was ample provision against local authorities committing an illegal act which would result in a deficiency or loss to the funds of the local authority by the fact that, in his opinion, a decision could be made by the Department of Local Government. So here we have an immediate contradiction between——
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. Deputy Larkin, I am afraid, misunderstands what I really said and I think, possibly, that is what Deputy Larkin set out to do.
Comment on this
Deputy Larkin is in possession. The Deputy cannot give a resume of his speech at this stage.
Comment on this
Deputy Larkin has been speaking for one minute and it is very difficult for the Deputy to stand up to contradict anything.
Comment on this
I think the very few remarks I have made in the matter have proved very clearly that there is some confusion between the Deputies representing Fianna Fáil in this House. On the section itself, it appears to me on reading Section 16 (b), that the section is there for the purpose of giving to the manager power to advise very definitely the local authorities that a decision they may be about to come to may be an illegal decision and may result, if carried into effect either in an illegal payment being carried out or in a deficiency or loss in local funds arising from an illegal decision. I am not a lawyer, a solicitor, or anything of that kind but that to me appears to be the interpretation of the sub-section.
Deputy Blaney is not worrying evidently whether the local authority should be advised or not that any proposal they are considering is a legal or an illegal proposal, because he made it quite clear that, in his view, the procedure should be that the resolution be adopted by the council; subsequently the report would go from the manager to the Department of Local Government and the Department of Local Government could refuse to sanction the proposal because such proposal might be illegal.
Deputy Briscoe said, to my surprise —I think I am correct in quoting him —that he believed the manager should be an administrator under the control of the councillors. I am somewhat surprised to hear this statement from Deputy Briscoe because of the fact that when the Minister visited our local authority in connection with this Act the only member of the local authority who indicated that it was their due that the manager should be an executive officer only was myself. None of Deputy Briscoe's colleagues— I do not think he was there at the time—had any quarrel with the present system as such.
Comment on this
They made it quite clear that they were satisfied that the manager should carry out and should possess the general functions he held up to that time.
Comment on this
You should have told the Minister that when he visited the local council. You did not tell him, nor did any of your colleagues, when he visited the corporation.
Comment on this
In my view, it is proper that local authorities should be advised, whether by a manager or anybody else, if a course they propose pursuing may lead them into committing an illegal act. My interpretation of this section is that this section places upon the manager the clear duty of advising the local representatives if the course they are taking would entail an illegal payment. Consequently, I see no particular objection to the section. I would feel somewhat easier in my mind if the Minister would consider making the position plainer by adding two or three words to Section 16 (b).
Comment on this
I am not suggesting any particular words. I think the Minister may feel at this stage that it would be advisable to make a clear position even clearer and so at least assist Deputies Briscoe, Blaney and Brennan to avoid any further confusion among themselves in this matter. I cannot see the difficulties visualised by Deputy Briscoe. I cannot accept that the adoption of this section would, in effect, mean taking all authority away from the local representatives because the section, as I read it, clearly and only refers to the question of an illegal payment.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe suggests, possibly, that there is no such thing as an illegal payment.
Comment on this
The section refers to the general actions of the local authority. Deputy Briscoe suggests there could be no action taken by a local authority that was illegal. Deputy Blaney suggests that there is protection, by every action about which there was any doubt whatsoever being referred to the Department of Local Government and that Department would decide on the legality or otherwise of any particular action. I suggest that before the Deputies opposite conclude their observations they might spend about five minutes in the lobby and arrive at some common understanding as to what they wish the Minister to do.
Comment on this
We would have been glad if the Minister had given us some more justification for the inclusion of this section. The County Management Act has been in operation now for 12 years and the Minister did not give one single instance that came to his notice or the notice of the Department in that period of 12 years which would justify taking from the shoulders of county managers what they have carried for 12 years and putting it on the shoulders of members of local authorities. The Minister was not able to give us a number of instances, nor was he able to give examples of important and serious matters where wrong decisions were made by local authorities that forced the manager into doing illegal things. He did not make a case for taking the burden off the shoulders of the managers, as he is doing in this section, and putting it on individual members of local authorities. That is in effect what he is doing.
If you take Section 16 out of this Bill it is a Bill of tatters—a tattered old coat and breeches, that is what it amounts to, the old coat is before Section 16 and the breeches after it, and they are tattered. Section 16 is definitely anti-local authority and antimembers of local authority. I say that in all seriousness. It is antimembers of local authority and anti-local authority. For 12 important years in the life of this nation the local authorities have operated a new Act, a new service, the County Management Act. In not one single instance has the Minister quoted any irregularity that took place.
We know for a fact, as I said on Thursday evening, that managers have been fighting for the last 12 years to get that onus taken off their shoulders and put on the shoulders of the local authority. The managers' association desired that, we know that quite well. The Labour Party should understand this better and should know quite well what they are voting for in this Bill. They should know that for the first time, in 12 years under the Management Act, the Minister proposes to put on the shoulders of individual members of local authorities an onus and responsibility, as far as surcharge is concerned, that they had not on them before. The Minister had the cheek to get up here to-night, and state that under Section 4 when it becomes law the local authority has power to accept tenders.