We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 232–468 of 468. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954
Enacted

No. 35 of 1954 ›

I have been misquoted. What I said was this. Under the law as it exists to-day and under this particular Bill when it becomes an Act, the local authority may requisition the manager to accept a particular tender. They will never accept the tender themselves but they may requisition and compel him to accept it.

Comment on this

That is right, I am glad to hear that. Section 17 of the Management Act—it is not being altered in this Bill—goes on to define executive functions. Section 17 says very clearly that the manager shall perform all executive functions of the council—all executive functions—and the acceptance of a tender is an executive function.

Comment on this

I am not disputing that.

Comment on this

No resolution of the council can compel a manager in the exercise of his executive function to accept any tender which he does not wish to accept.

Comment on this

Read the Bill.

Comment on this

Is the Minister agreed on that?

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

In other words, that the council have power to compel the manager to accept a tender? Is that the Minister's interpretation?

Comment on this

I did not catch the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

In other words, that the council of a county or an elected body have power to compel a manager, by vote at that council, to accept any particular tender that they think well of?

Comment on this

That is quite right.

Comment on this

They did so recently in one case.

Comment on this

In other words, that they have power to exercise the executive functions of a manager by resolution?

Comment on this

No, but they will direct him to exercise an executive function, by their vote.

Comment on this
Pádraig Mac Gabhann

Níl mórán difríocht.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Pádraig Ó Domhnaill Fine Gael

Tá difir mór ann.

Comment on this

Section 17 of the County Management Act of 1940 sets out as regards executive functions:

"All such matters and things, including the making of contracts and the affixing of the official seal, as are necessary for or incidental to the exercise or performance of the executive functions of the council of a county or of an elective body..."

The manager makes all contracts.

Comment on this

He does.

Comment on this

I want to insist that even under this Bill no elected body or council of a county has power to make contracts.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

It is only the manager of the county who has power to make contracts.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

The Minister earlier to-night argued here that one of the reasons for Section 16 was that the council or elected body had power under Section 4 of this Bill to compel the manager to accept a tender other than the lowest tender.

Comment on this

That is quite right.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We have had this point about six times in this section.

Comment on this

He said it about a dozen times when you were not in the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not need any reinforcement from any quarter. I am dealing with what I have heard myself. I cannot allow this repetition.

Comment on this

I made a new point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not notice any new point. The fact is that the Deputy has made that point, to my knowledge, about half a dozen times.

Comment on this

Section 16 sets out the reserved functions. It says the council of a county shall perform such functions as are in the Second Schedule of the Act. It says they are reserved functions and that they may perform the reserved functions. I want to refer to a further section in this Bill— Section 19. If it ever becomes law, Section 19 provides——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not proceed to read the sections. We are dealing with Section 16.

Comment on this

I am dealing with executive functions and reserved functions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This Section 16 has reference to quite a definite and specific matter, that is, obligations in case of proposal involving illegal payment, deficiency or loss.

Comment on this

I am trying to point out——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must confine himself definitely to that section.

Comment on this

I will. I will make reference to the section. I am trying to point out that the council of a county have certain reserved functions which they have a right to perform and the manager has certain executive functions which he must perform. In this section, the council can illegally perform one of their functions by compelling the manager to make illegal payment—by compelling him to take what may be an illegal tender.

Comment on this

The Deputy has said that about ten times already.

Comment on this

I realise that I am getting under the Minister's skin but I should be glad if he would not interrupt me. This section is reactionary and it should not be in any Bill setting out democratic powers. For the past 12 years the position in local authorities has been that the manager has carried the responsibility for surcharge on his shoulders. We object most strenuously to the Minister's proposal that that responsibility for surcharge be removed from the shoulders of the manager and transferred to the shoulders of members of the local authority.

Comment on this

Earlier in this debate Deputy Briscoe challenged the right of Deputies who are not members of a local authority to speak on this Bill. I am not a member of a local authority but, as a Deputy, I claim the right to speak on this Bill. If one were to follow his line of reasoning no Deputy who is not a showman would have the right to discuss the Gaming Bill. I should like to have clarified whether or not the Opposition want the position to be that if a county council decide to do something against the advice of the county manager—to do something which the county manager knows is an illegal act—and, as a result, there is a loss or the money is spent illegally, the responsibility for that act should not rest on the shoulders of the people who decide to do it?

Comment on this

He makes the payment. He cannot do it illegally.

Comment on this

Perhaps people with a lot more experience than I have may see something in that: I do not. I should be very glad if the Opposition would give me the benefit of their long years of experience and state whether or not that is correct. I have heard talk during this debate as to whether or not authority should be given back to local authorities. I believe it should. However, with Deputy Desmond, I agree that if authority is given, responsibility also must be given.

Comment on this

Before ever the managerial system was introduced, I think it was the practice to have an adviser at all meetings of local authorities—the law adviser or the secretary—who, when matters were being discussed by the elected body, chimed in from time to time and suggested that a decision about to be arrived at was dangerous and looked like being illegal. I agree entirely with Deputy Larkin as to the desirability of making provision for such technical advice. I agree that a local authority should have some technical people at hand who would warn them, in the course of their discussions, that if they decided in a certain way it might prove to be illegal.

I have not heard the Minister on this section but I understand that he spoke on it. While I admit that there should be some provision for preventing illegal action I am anxious to know what this word "deficiency" means. Like every other Deputy I know what "deficiency" means in its ordinary sense but what does it mean in this section? Sub-section (3) of Section 16 reads:—

"Where, in accordance with sub-section (1) of this section, the names of the persons voting for a decision to do or effect any act, matter or thing are recorded in the minutes of the meeting of a local authority, those persons shall be surcharged on any surcharge or charged on any charge that may subsequently be made as a result of the decision as if they had made or authorised the making of the payment or caused the loss or deficiency, and no other person shall be surcharged or charged."

What could they do under Section 4? What decision could they make under Section 4? That is the section in which they are supposed to have got all these powers. It might be a perfectly legitimate expenditure from their point of view but nevertheless it might create a deficiency. Is the word "deficiency" here to be interpreted in the ordinary way?

Comment on this

I may mention to the Deputy that the word "deficiency" has been defined in the statutes governing audits. Also, we have many judicial definitions of the word "deficiency". I take it that the Deputy himself, when he introduced his Bill in 1953, had in mind his own definition of the word "deficiency". I am prepared to accept that.

Comment on this

I do not think that is fair. I am a layman. Whatever may have been in any section of a measure introduced into this House by me while I was a Minister does not matter just now. I am asking for information which I think I am entitled to get.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy the information. It is defined under the—

Comment on this

I know, but the information the Minister is giving me makes me even more suspicious of this term than I was before I got it. I will tell you what this word "deficiency" means now. It means the giving to Local Government auditors of complete power in determining surcharges. If a county council were to decide to take on a road and even if the council felt they were legally entitled to do so, if the auditor came to the conclusion that the work in question was not of sufficient public utility to warrant their decision, he could surcharge the council. This word "deficiency" is intended to give to Local Government auditors a freedom almost to surcharge for anything that is in any way progressive, even if the act itself is covered by some Act of Parliament or another.

I am not objecting as an individual to the illegal payment part of the section, to safeguarding local authorities against making decisions which would result in illegal payments; but whether this word "deficiency" was part of a section introduced by me on a previous occasion or not, I am saying as a layman now that if my attention were drawn to it in this House, even if I were Minister, and if there were pointed out to me the dangers that could result from such words as these, I certainly would have a very serious talk with my officials, with my advisers and the people responsible for the section in order to ensure that the charges made from this side, which are apparently held to be extravagant, were not justified.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy appreciate that these are the words used in the 1925 Act?

Comment on this

I do not care what Act they are used in.

Comment on this

The Deputy administered that Act for years as a Minister.

Comment on this

What does it matter? What is Parliament for? Acts of Parliament are being amended every day of the week in every land. Surely the fact that some section was introduced in the Act of 1925 or that I introduced a section containing these words in a Bill which was never enacted is not a reason for asking the House to accept their inclusion here.

I ask the Minister seriously not to ask for anything so sweeping as is contained in the section. By all means, protect the local authority from doing something which is illegal and from making themselves foolish—I do not say that they would rush into doing these things if they were not protected by some legal provision like this—but, in our anxiety to protect them, let us not go too far and take away from them the very powers we are pretending to give them now.

Comment on this

This section is, to my mind, the most serious section in the Bill, because it is a section purposely prepared and framed as the big stick to be held over members of a council. It is all very well for Deputy Desmond and others to say that we would do certain things. We would, and we would get half a dozen to do them with us, but we know what always happens when the legal adviser tells us that something we are doing is illegal. I have memories of the period before the Management Act when one would be getting something through and there would be a threat of surcharge. The moment there was a threat of surcharge all the boys who had spoken in favour would be talking against it for the next couple of hours to have it knocked out. That is what this section is meant for.

Comment on this

They are not all cowards like that.

Comment on this

That is what the section is meant for. It is meant as the big stick to be used in relation to anything members would look for under Section 4.

Comment on this

It still operates under the 1925 Act in relation to vocational committees.

Comment on this

That is a different situation altogether.

Comment on this

I am already preparing amendments to this that I had not thought of up to the present and I will be bringing them in next November, if the Minister is still here—amendments which I see now are necessary and essential. I cannot see any freedom given under this, and these sections, with the exceptions of Sections 4 and 16, are only padding.

Deputies alluded to the law courts. Fancy a county councillor, in order to straighten out something, having to go out to a court of law. Has he not time enough lost representing the ratepayers inside, without having to go out to a court of law to help the ratepayers again? Most of these sections are framed for the sole purpose of giving work to the lawyers. The section is an objectionable section. It is a section which, in my opinion, has been brought in with a definite object and it should be dropped.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister does not at all appreciate the approach we are trying to make to this section. The Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary see the section through the glasses through which they are looking and do not realise that, if they were sitting on the opposite side and looking the other way, they would see this section in the perspective in which we see it. First of all, the auditor is an unknown individual. He is a Local Government official, one of 100. Any one of these, or even the whole 100, can come down and we could have 100 different definitions on a particular subject.

I said before and I still say that the section means that, notwithstanding the fact that under Section 4 local authority representatives have the legal right to make certain decisions by resolution, under (b) of Section 16, sub-section (1) the very fact of an objection by the manager or any of the officials, some of whom were specified by the Minister in introducing the section, immediately creates the position that if the local authority representatives proceed, notwithstanding the objection, to do what they have decided to do by lawful resolution, they commit an illegal act and are therefore liable to surcharge by the auditor, because the manager, in making his objection, is bound to record the names of councillors who are opposing his point of view.

Deputy Smith put his finger more definitely on that point. That is why the Minister, in introducing the section, or interpreting it as it stands, or as he understood it, or as he has been advised by his expert officials,, points this out in column 299, Volume 150, of the Dáil Debates of 21st April, 1955. He divides (a) and (b) and in (b) there is the phrase: "in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made." Nobody is objecting to an illegal payment being presented, but the Minister goes on and says:

"(b) in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made, or a deficiency or loss is likely to result..."

The word "or" brings in the "deficiency or loss which is likely to result", and now becomes an illegality.

What is a deficiency? The Minister says it is defined in statutes and in court decisions. We all have a layman's view of what a deficiency means. If we strike a rate in accordance with the estimates and if, in the course of the year, we decide on certain expenditure which is not included in the raising of the rate, we shall obviously cause a deficiency as between income and expenditure. Is that going to be called an illegal act? Then every Supplementary Estimate would be illegal, because it is trying to make up a deficiency. The Parliamentary Secretary need not think that we are approaching this from the point of view of obstruction. Some of us have to work these Acts on local authorities, and some of us have become fairly experienced.

Comment on this

Experts.

Comment on this

Fairly experienced.

Comment on this

I said "experts".

Comment on this

I said experience.

Comment on this

But I say expert, in your case.

Comment on this

I do not know whether or not I am an expert. I always try to remember that, no matter how long we may live, no matter what experience we gain, we always have a lot more to learn. What does "loss" mean? "Loss" can be defined by a local government auditor. We buy some gadget with which to experiment —let us say, something for a new form of street lighting or a new form of protective gadget for street crossing, and we put it into use, even on a trial basis. When we discover that it is useless, that the position is worse than before, and we decide to discard it, we have created a loss.

Comment on this

If you get a fool to advise you, it would lead to loss.

Comment on this

It takes a fool to know another fool, and some of us are not fools. Consequently we would not be advised by fools——

Comment on this

You might be foolish.

Comment on this

Progress is achieved by people who indulge in what certain other people regard as foolish and extravagant experiments. If these foolish people prove successful——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps we might, make some progress if we discuss the section.

Comment on this

Many of us on this side of the House who have spoken in this debate have great experience of local affairs. I am trying to bring the Parliamentary Secretary with me step by step. I am trying to be courteous, and I am trying to correct his interjections when they are made, might I say, wrongfully and illegally. I am trying to illustrate with these definitions and these interpretations, because the words of an Act of Parliament, in the hands of a body of Local Government auditors, can bring chaos into the control of local affairs. I have given illustrations of certain things. There is no use in quoting what is in an Act of Parliament of 1925, as being comparable with a similar set of rules or sections, in a different context.

I will give another illustration. A council may, under Section 4, decide to acquire certain water rights from a stream or spring. That stream or spring may suddenly dry up, and the local government auditor can come along and say: "That was a very foolish thing to do. You were warned by your engineer not to do it. Therefore, you have created a loss for which you are responsible." I appeal to the Minister not to regard local representatives as a body of school children who do not take their responsibility seriously. I should like to make a present of this to the Minister. I do not care who the advisers in his Department are. I can pick officials or representatives of local authorities who could teach local government to some of the Minister's officials.

It is all very well for a Department of State to design all the ropes necessary to bring about a complete stranglehold on the operations of a local authority. Local representatives have to deal mainly in operations with human beings. There is, as it is, a sufficiency of red tape that makes it impossible to act quickly sometimes, particularly in emergencies. Now we are going to put into this Bill a section which will provide an example of puppets dancing to the pull of strings from the Custom House.

Comment on this

The strings are false.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that they would be very false strings. When the Minister is talking about illegal payments, nobody objects but then he brings in the question of a deficiency or a loss without defining the limitations to the creation of this deficiency or loss in some form or explaining in the section to what extent the manager is limited in making his objections. We have gone into this in great detail.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I wonder has the Parliamentary Secretary gained any knowledge——

Comment on this

From repetition?

Comment on this

——seeing that he is now saying "hear, hear!" when I say that we have gone into the matter in detail.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

I agree with the previous speakers who said that the Bill, without this section, would not be the Bill that the Custom House wants.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know what the Deputy means by reference to the Custom House. The reference is to the Minister. The Minister and nobody else is responsible to this House for the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his official capacity, has his abode in the Custom House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy would avoid a good deal of ambiguity by referring to the Minister rather than to the office of the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary will have to admit that, without this section, they would have a very emasculated Bill. Without this section, it would not be a Bill at all. We who are representatives of local authorities say——

Comment on this

Of one local authority. Dublin Corporation is not the whole country.

Comment on this

We have representatives here at the moment from Wexford, Cork, Donegal, Waterford and Cavan.

Comment on this

They do not agree with the Deputy, of coarse.

Comment on this

Yes, we are all in full agreement.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan?

Comment on this

As I said before——

Comment on this

The Deputy has said it nine times already.

Comment on this

——I recognise my own limitations. I am not prepared to speak as if I knew anything about local authority operations in a rural area. I am only competent to make some effort to speak on local authority matters concerning the City of Dublin. I can only refer to this particular section from my examination of it and knowledge of it. I am pleading with the Minister and Parliamentary Secretary to imagine themselves opposing this Bill in 1953. Would they not have agreed, if they were speaking on it in 1953, that it meant all the things we now say it means?

Comment on this

And you would have taken the opposite point of view.

Comment on this

I do not understand a Deputy of the standing of Deputy Sheldon making that crack. If Deputy Sheldon goes to the Library and looks up the amendments I introduced in regard to the Committee Stage of this Bill in 1953 he will get up here and bow his apology to me.

Comment on this

I have seen amendments to Bills from that side of the House.

Comment on this

I challenge the Deputy to go into the public office and ask to be handed the list of my amendments to the 1953 Bill and find out whether I have changed.

Comment on this

I would rather see a list of the times the Deputy voted against his Party.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us deal with the section.

Comment on this

I will deal with the section, Sir. I opposed this Bill in the form in which it was presented in 1953 to the same extent that I am opposing this one now. I am not illogical. I am not concerned with a Party approach to it but I am concerned with local government generally. I want to see my colleagues on local authorities, irrespective of the Parties to which they belong, put in a position of being able to administer local affairs without being unreasonably hampered and without their life being almost rendered impossible from the point of view of trying to get things done. I have always said I believed in the managerial system. I believe absolutely in it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That cannot be discussed on this section.

Comment on this

The managerial system I want is the system that serves the local authorities but the managerial system we are creating under Section 16 is a system where the elected representatives of the local authority are subservient to the manager. I am particularly concerned at the moment so far as Dublin is concerned.

Comment on this

No wonder.

Comment on this

I take it that the Parliamentary Secretary portends something he expects and hopes will not happen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not because the Parliamentary Secretary interrupts that the Deputy should travel away from the section.

Comment on this

Is it unreasonable on Committee Stage of a Bill to try and reason with people who oppose your point of view?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

By dealing with the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I am going on to the point I was trying to raise before the Parliamentary Secretary anticipated me. Here you have a manager of whom you have some experience and who is going to be with you for a considerable number of years. You know his attitude and you know he is reasonable. You may sometimes compromise on certain matters because you know you are going to get co-operation and agreement but where you are faced, as we will shortly be, with the appointment of a new permanent manager who is as yet unknown to us and who according to——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how this arises on the section. You cannot proceed to discuss who may be manager on this section.

Comment on this

Surely, Section 16 is related to Section 4? The whole purpose of Section 16 is to nullify Section 4.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not going to enter into that matter. It is not within my province to say whether it is or not or to say what type the manager will be. What is in this section is what is under discussion.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be allowed to name the supermen he is looking for?

Comment on this

That is a very relevant remark?

Comment on this

Would it be in order?

Comment on this

May I read this to you:

"Where a proposal is made at a meeting of a local authority to do or effect any act, matter or thing—"

I shall not read paragraphs (a) and (b).

the manager (or, in his absence, such other officer as may be designated by the manager) shall object and state the grounds of his objection, and, if a decision is taken on the proposal, the names of the members present and voting for and against the decision and abstaining from voting on the decision shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting.

We are going to have—what is this called in other countries?— the commissar system.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This refers to certain functions of a manager but we cannot discuss what type a particular manager is likely to be.

Comment on this

I am off that line. I am taking your ruling on that, Sir. According to this, the manager, whoever he may be, everywhere now, according to the Act of Parliament, keeps a minute book and he says to members of the local authority—unlike you, Sir, here—"I am objecting to this thing that you are going to do and I shall put your name down in the book. I shall serve you with a summons and then, if you proceed to do what I object to you will be all made pay."

Comment on this

He does not say any such thing.

Comment on this

By saying it he may cause it to be so.

Comment on this

He does not surcharge. The auditor does.

Comment on this

He brings it about.

Comment on this

That makes it worse.

Comment on this

Did you not know that?

Comment on this

He is only waking up to what the section contains now.

Comment on this

That makes it worse.

Comment on this

Where is the expert?

Comment on this

Hallsbury.

Comment on this

I must protest. I never described myself as an expert. The Parliamentary Secretary is an expert. It is only a person who has never served on these bodies who can be an expert.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It can scarcely be called a relevant approach.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to spend more money upon O'Connell Bridge.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe, on the section, I hope.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) says:—

"Where, in accordance with sub-section (1) of this section, the names of the persons..."

It does not even give them the credit of calling them councillors. It is as if you were reading about an inquest on somebody who has been done to death by "persons unknown.""Persons"—the contempt in which local authority representatives are held by the framers of this Bill. I must protest. If we were to refer to the members of this House in our legislation as "persons"——

Comment on this

A perfectly reputable term.

Comment on this

Not in the sense in which it is used here.

Comment on this

Halsbury cannot define it for us.

Comment on this

——

"Where, in accordance with sub-section (1) of this section, the names of the persons voting for a decision to do or effect any act, matter or thing are recorded in the minutes of the meeting of a local authority, those persons shall be surcharged..."

It does not say anything about the auditor coming down to examine it. They shall be surcharged and even if an auditor thought it was unfair or unreasonable, the Bill says:—

"Those persons shall be surcharged"—not may—"on any surcharge or charged on any charge that may subsequently be made as a result of the decision as if they had made or authorised the making of the payment or caused the loss or deficiency, and no other person shall be surcharged or charged."

Comment on this

The manager is safe.

Comment on this

Under the present managerial system under which we work, the manager is responsible. If he makes an illegal payment he is surcharged. You could have a case where the manager and the councillors might be jointly surcharged but here you are putting the local authority representatives in that position. I warn Deputy Larkin that if he comes along, if this Bill becomes law——

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy has said this at least six times on the section.

Comment on this

What have I said six times?

Comment on this

It has not sunk in yet.

Comment on this

What have I said six times? There is no need for the Minister to be ruffled, to lose the sense of humour that he usually displays. We are quite serious about this.

Comment on this

You are quite serious?

Comment on this

Quite serious.

Comment on this

I wish I could see you sometime when you are frivolous.

Comment on this

We can be frivolous elsewhere or on other occasions.

Comment on this

You are unfair to yourself.

Comment on this

We are waiting for the Parliamentary Secretary to speak.

Comment on this

You did not give him a chance.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

I am quite serious in my approach to this matter. I have not said six times or once before that I warn Deputy Larkin that if this Bill becomes law with this section as it is he will find himself in great difficulties whenever he comes to a meeting of the local authority and proposes something which may cost a little money which, in the opinion of some people, is not necessary or a waste but which he wants to propose from the human point of view to bring some alleviation of hardship or distress. He will find himself fighting a lone battle and never getting anything done because——

Comment on this

Because I get no support from Fianna Fáil members on the council.

Comment on this

You will get none from anybody under this Bill because they will all have to pay for your good deeds and your good intentions.

Comment on this

They will not like that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us or quote from one of the statutes the definition of the word "deficiency"?

Comment on this

I leave that to Hallsbury.

Comment on this

Or Deputy Smith.

Comment on this

We are asked here to pass a section in the debate on which the question has been raised and doubt has been expressed as to the meaning, in its application to local authorities, of a particular word. We ask the Minister to define it for us and he says "I refer you to Hallsbury".

Comment on this

Or Deputy Smith, better still.

Comment on this

Deputy Smith or Deputy Briscoe—they are the people to define this for the rest of the country.

Comment on this

If the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary will accept my definition——

Comment on this

And write it in.

Comment on this

I will give it and let it be written in.

Comment on this

You were not worried about that until Deputy Smith raised it. You only brought it in a few minutes ago.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Briscoe on Section 16.

Comment on this

I want the Minister to define—I challenge him to define—this word.

Comment on this

Go ahead.

Comment on this

"Go ahead", says the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Define, yes.

Comment on this

Could I ask him to give us the definition?

Comment on this

He does not do crosswords.

Comment on this

I want to know how you define "loss". How is the loss created? Is it over-all or is it limited in any way to any particular set of decisions or transactions? Can we have these words interpreted or defined for us? I have heard many interpretations but I want them defined and if these limitations can ease my serious suspicions about how this thing will operate afterwards it will perhaps make it much easier for us to get together on the matter but, on the present wording of that section, and having regard to the implications I see in it freedom of action in respect of most of the things the local authorities want to have freedom to do, the control of their city manager in cooperating and working with them, is greatly endangered here. I object very much to having a situation where unknown auditors with unknown interpretations of certain things will be the final arbiters and the final judges, imposing on local representatives these punitive measures for action which they may take in the course of their duty with the best intention of doing what is right and proper for the people who elected them.

Comment on this

The discussion on this section this evening has been rather intriguing. On the one hand the section takes away from public representatives powers which should have been left to them and there is a threat in the section that if the public representatives do wrong they are liable to be surcharged for their wrong-doing. Apparently the person who is going to make that decision and issue that edict is the county manager who is implied under the Bill generally as being an officer of the council, subject to their advice and in an executive position after that. In this section he is given the power of determining whether the real representatives of the people, the custodians of the people's purse, are to be penalised if they do something to which he objects. That may be a good thing because if public representatives are warned that they are trespassing on the law and breaking the law, they should gladly accept such advice and restrain themselves from so doing.

The section to my mind is right in so far as it applies in that regard, but what is far more fundamental in my view is that we want to get the right type of person in the country to take an interest in local government and in the administration of local affairs. These men must be men of discretion and honour and integrity and understanding and should not be dictated to from any direction or by any official. It may be in the form of advice.

Comment on this

That is all it is. That is all the manager does—he gives advice. He does not surcharge.

Comment on this

But the threat is there if this Bill is carried through that certain acts of the county councillors may lead to a surcharge. By imposing that threat you may be undermining the responsibility and the authority of the men elected.

Comment on this

It is the same wording as that of the 1925 Act.

Comment on this

The same form of threat was carried on there and do not think for a moment that you are doing a good thing in leaving the public representatives of the country subject to such threats. Local government should be administered by men who use their own consciences, their own experience and their own knowledge without such threats. They should be men capable of using their own understanding without the shadow of such threats. The whole principle of the thing seems to be not only to discourage the right type of public representative but to encourage the individual who does not want these responsibilities.

The principle of a Bill like this should be the encouragement of the individual who is capable of carrying responsibility and of carrying out his duties in a right and proper manner. That should be the aim of any local government Bill. What this Bill does to my mind is to destroy initiative and independence and keep out of public life those who would be capable of managing their own affairs successfully. It not only does that, but it encourages the person of no responsibility to shelter himself behind the protection of the manager. Afterwards the representative may say, if he feels like it, that he wanted to do something irresponsible, but that the manager would not let him. So you have a dual prospect in this Bill aiming at destroying the proper management and protection of the people's affairs. It may be expedient to threaten the local councils with damages if they pursue a certain line, but this threat will make them feel that they are endangering themselves in so far as the Department may suc them and surcharge them.

I say that the responsibility should be put on the councils. I tell the Minister to get on with the job and give local councils men of responsibility and integrity and not give the managers the notion that it is their duty to order and that their orders must be accepted.

Supposing the manager makes a mistake. Is he to be surcharged? Has the Minister taken the same precautions to ensure the public against the manager's mistakes as he has from the point of view of the public representative? If not, why not? The Minister is giving the manager a prime responsibility and a final word. This section is wrong. It may be expedient to bring it in; it may be expedient to devise these schemes, but it is not aimed at getting better local government and I advise the Minister to reconsider the whole thing and to withdraw the section.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to withdraw this section as being objectionable in character and unnecessary in import in relation to the whole Bill. In the first place, this section is linked up with Section 4, which purports to give certain authority to councillors which before this they did not possess. In that section they are tied up by various subsections setting out very carefully the time necessary for notices of motions, the period which will be given for consideration of the resolution, and the particular objects to which it may or may not apply. Now we are told that anything that is not in conformity with sub-section (9) of Section 4 is null and void.

Comment on this

On a point of order. We are dealing with Section 16 now.

Comment on this

I know we are, but, is not the very first sub-section in Section 16 linking it up with Section 4?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may only discuss Section 4 in so far as it relates to Section 16.

Comment on this

And I am discussing Section 4 in so far as it is linked up with this section in its very first sub-section. Section 16 states that anything done against Section 4 is null and void. We have this section in order to provide for penalties, but how can a penalty arise, and if it does arise who is to be charged with the responsibility for having caused it?

In Section 4, sub-section (8) it is stated that if money is provided for a specific thing the manager can, by resolution of the council, be authorised to go ahead with that particular business in so far as the money is provided. If he goes ahead only to that extent, how can there be a deficiency? What is all this talk about deficiencies then? If there is a deficiency is it not the people who did not provide enough money in the first instance who should be surcharged rather than those who voted for the work going ahead on the estimate of the officials?

The resolution can only authorise the manager to go ahead in so far as the money has been provided. Consequently, the resolution of the council so authorising the manager cannot cause any penalty to be imposed on any member of the council. In that case, why have this section at all? The three who put their name to the resolution originally may not attend the council meeting at all, and it is not the people who voted the money but those who voted for the resolution to expend the money who will be surcharged if there is a deficiency. Is not the whole thing confusion from beginning to end?

We are told this cannot apply to the functions of the council generally. Is that not so? We are told it cannot apply to the functions of the manager in so far as it deals with officers or servants. Sub-section (9) states what it cannot include. Under this section we are discussing the council can vote money for certain work. By giving certain notice, signed by three members of the council, a special meeting can be called to authorise that work. Under Section 8 that work can only be proceeded with in so far as the money is provided. If the members of the council vote in favour of the work, then everything should be in order, and there is no necessity at all for the confusion this sub-section tends to introduce or the discredit it would seem to cast on public representatives by implying that they will act irresponsibly and pass resolutions for the illegal expenditure of money.

I cannot understand how anyone could come into Parliament with a sub-section like this. To my mind it has no application. It is, as has been said, the big stick held over public representatives: "You can do certain things, but, if you do them, even though the money is provided and you authorise the manager to go ahead, and anything happens subsequently in the carrying-out of that work and there is a deficiency, those who voted for that particular work are the people who will be surcharged." Did anyone ever see a more senseless section put before Parliament for adoption? I certainly did not.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Briscoe understand now what the meaning of a deficiency is?

Comment on this

I have listened to-night to the back benchers of Fianna Fáil who have now become front benchers debating this Section 16. I am a member of a local authority. I listened to Deputy Allen to-night. Deputy Allen did not turn up at the meeting of the Wexford County Council to meet the Minister.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on the section.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen was not invited to the meeting and was not entitled to be there because he is neither chairman nor vice-chairman.

Comment on this

There were other members there who were not chairmen or vice-chairmen.

Comment on this

Unwelcome guests!

Comment on this

If members of the county council vote for the squandering of the ratepayers' money, then they should be surcharged. If this section had been in operation before this the ratepayers of Dublin would be getting a refund to-day from the Dublin Corporation in respect of the monument on O'Connell Bridge.

Any member elected to a local authority takes on a certain responsibility in relation to the expenditure of rates collected from the ratepayers. It is their responsibility to ensure that those moneys are not squandered and that they are put to proper use. Up to this Fianna Fáil have always backed county management. I voted against the County Management Act. I would like to see it abolished to-morrow and I would support its abolition.

The Labour Party is anxious that local representatives should have more powers. Is not that what the Fianna Fáil Party wants? Why the delaying tactics then? Why take a different line from that adopted by them in 1942? I cannot understand it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is defending the Act now.

Comment on this

I am not defending the County Management Act. If it was wrong in 1942 it is wrong now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing county management. We are discussing Section 16 which deals with illegal payments and deficiencies.

Comment on this

We have a legal adviser in the Wexford County Council to keep us right and tell us if we are going wrong. That is what he is paid for. If local representatives commit an illegal act with the ratepayers' money they should be brought to book. Why should they escape? Ratepayers in many counties condemn their local representatives because the rates are not put to proper use. Now, we in the county councils can strike the rates, but we have no check on the expenditure of the rates. I think it is about time that local representatives faced up to the fact that they should protect the ratepayers and the ratepayers' money.

These are delaying tactics on the part of the Opposition. Are they waiting for their members to arrive? I do not know. All I do know is that they are wasting time.

Comment on this

The one thing which seems to emerge from the discussion here is the fact that the last speaker, and a number of previous speakers on the Government Benches, now try to make it appear that by being against this section we are in fact against any system of protection of the ratepayers' money. That is a completely wrong interpretation of our attitude. It is wrong to say that because we are against this section we are in favour of illegal payments. Did anyone ever hear of anything so ridiculous? We are against the section for various reasons but speakers on the opposite benches pick out only one reason and say that we are against the section because we are in favour of illegal payments and squandering the ratepayers' money.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

Then it is alleged that we must have Section 16 for the protection of the ratepayers' money? Now whom would we expect to be the protector of the ratepayers' money? Who is being put up by the Government and the Labour Party as the ratepayers' protector? None other than the persons who have been vilified over years—the county managers. They are now to be the protectors who will protect the ratepayers from the local representatives elected by the people.

Comment on this

You are thinking wrong now.

Comment on this

Let us have it as we have got it. We cannot have it both ways. We now see that when it suits those in the Government Benches they are for the county managers. For years past, because they thought it was good political propaganda, they were against the county managers. Now the people must be protected from the local authorities by the county managers. In the past the cry was that the people's representatives had to be protected from the county managers. You give us in Section 4 some semblance of power——

Comment on this

You do not understand it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary obviously does not.

Comment on this

You cannot read it.

Comment on this

I know a little more than the Parliamentary Secretary about it.

Comment on this

You do not understand it.

Comment on this

I do and I want to interpret it, because like many another member I have experience for some considerable time on a local authority of trying to interpret certain of these Acts and trying to get through the red tape that is continued and perpetrated on local authorities by people in the Custom House, such as the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister.

Section 16, as has already been pointed out, appears to this side of the House to be objectionable for one particular reason. There are many, but the one particular reason is that the general trend of opinion here is that it takes away from us some of the provisions, some of the advantages or powers that are being given to us under Section 4. Let us have either this power under Section 4 or not have it at all. Why waste the time of the House and the time spent in drafting Section 4 giving certain powers that are later taken from us in Section 16?

Candidly, it is almost beyond comprehension that a Minister, backed up by a Parliamentary Secretary with all their advisers, should for any reason, except some ulterior motive, give us power in one section and go to the trouble of wording another section in such a way as to take it away, and all this is contained in the same Bill. The only reason for this that I can suggest is that, having blown their trumpets so much about what they were going to give us by way of power in the local authorities, they are now faced with the local elections in June and have to mend their hand.

Under Section 4, they have to give us this power, but from the official point of view they do not want to give that power and they take it back in Section 16. They believe that the people will not wake up to this until the election is over. They hope, and it is only a hope, by this means to retain some of the support they gained by using such tactics in the past. That is the only motive that is sensible. It may be a base move, but it makes sense.

Comment on this

Why are you holding up this Bill?

Comment on this

In the name of Heaven, what are we holding up?

Comment on this

Why are you holding it up if what you say is true?

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary say what he is giving in this Bill? The reason we are holding it up is that we are trying to enlighten you people in the terms of your own Bill so that you will know before you pass it into law that you are not giving the people anything like what you promised them and that, in fact, the Bill is a fake. That is what we are holding it up for. The Parliamentary Secretary will agree that that is sufficient justification——

Comment on this

You admit you are holding it up now?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If you want to call it holding up, possibly you can, but we are trying to teach you, to educate you, on what is contained in your own Bill.

Comment on this

It was your Bill, too.

Comment on this

Is that the reason you are supporting it?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Blaney is in possession.

Comment on this

This old story that we should not object to something because we did not object to it in the past— surely that childish argument should be dispensed with. The argument that because you did not do something in the past you should not crib about it now—that is one of the cries we hear so often here. There is no word or question at the same time about what was done in the past 20 years. You will tell us about what we did not do, but you will not tell us about what we did do. It is a handy way of causing a smoke-screen.

Comment on this

The smoke was there that time, too.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy knows——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 16.

Comment on this

These interruptions, I submit are being made from the Government Benches with a view to helping them to get this Bill through the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

You do not want the Bill through?

Comment on this

I do not want it through like this, because it means nothing.

Comment on this

You wanted it for 16 years.

Comment on this

For 19 years—let us be accurate.

Comment on this

What I am trying to do is to save the Government Parties from the embarrassment they will suffer——

Comment on this

Thanks very much.

Comment on this

——when they go down the country in June to tell the people what they are going to give under the County Management Bill, whereas they are really giving nothing.

Comment on this

That is what you think.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to take Section 16 out of this Bill so that when the Bill becomes an Act it will represent something, and will add up to something to justify the words that the Minister used about it here at some other stage when he described it as the emancipation of local authorities. Did you ever hear anything worse in your life? He is a county man of my own and I do not want him to go down the country with this as an emancipating measure. It would be bad enough elsewhere, but it is just too horrible even to contemplate it happening in his own county.

We have heard all the other reasons now, so for shame's sake—if for nothing else—take Section 16 out of it and let this Bill give something when it does become an Act.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 68
·
Níl 40
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 27:—

Before sub-section (3), page 15, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) Notwithstanding sub-section (2) of this section, where a delegation to an officer is made under this section—

(a) the manager may, in any particular case of the performance of the function, inform the officer that he has decided to perform the function himself, and the function shall thereupon be performable in such case by the manager and not by the officer, and

(b) if the officer is satisfied that, in any particular case of the performance of the function, performance would, on account of the importance of the decision involved or on account of any other reasonable consideration, be more appropriately effected by the manager, the officer may refer such case to the manager, and the function shall thereupon be performable in such case by the manager and not by the officer.

This amendment is divided into two parts. The purpose of paragraph (a) is to enable a manager to step in in any particular case and perform a function himself, despite the fact that he has delegated such function to an approved officer. The purpose of paragraph (b) is to enable an officer to whom a function has been delegated to refer back the performance of a function to the manager on a particular occasion. Otherwise, an officer would be bound to perform a delegated function in all cases, even if he differed from the manager as to how the function should be performed.

Comment on this

I am not at all clear on this position. The Minister is dealing with the first amendment only. There is another amendment to the same section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The two amendments are practically the same and they could be discussed together. If decisions are required, they can be voted on separately, if desired.

Comment on this

They can be voted on separately afterwards?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is so.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 28 is similar in form to amendment No. 27. The purpose of the first part of amendment No. 28 is to enable the county manager or the Dublin City Manager to intervene in any particular case and perform a function himself, despite the fact that the performance of such function was delegated to an assistant manager. Hitherto, the manager has had no power to perform any function which he had delegated to an assistant manager. As a corollary to the provision in paragraph (a), the second part of the amendment will enable an assistant manager in any particular instance, if the situation so warrants it, to refer back the performance of a function to the manager, despite the fact that this function has been delegated to him; and the manager will then have to perform the function himself on that particular occasion.

Comment on this

I am afraid I will not be able to deal very adequately now with these amendments. First of all, in the case of Dublin, where we have two permanent assistant managers, does the section with the amendments before us included, envisage the position that the manager would in addition to delegating powers to the assistant managers delegate powers to other officers? That is the first point. Can the manager do that?

Comment on this

Yes, definitely.

Comment on this

Secondly, under this section even as amended, we have an officer, who is an assistant manager, completely in charge of housing, for instance. Does it mean now that, notwithstanding the form of appointment which that officer has from the Minister, the manager now can take over to himself the functions being performed by that assistant manager appointed by the Minister?

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that the assistant manager is not appointed by me: he is appointed by the manager.

Comment on this

The Minister is not quite clear as to what I mean. This section deals with the delegation of powers. Our housing director, who is an assistant manager, had the powers over housing delegated to him by the Minister.

Comment on this

No; by the manager.

Comment on this

The powers were given to him by the manager at the request of the Minister. The late Deputy Murphy, when he was Minister, wanted to get speedy development in housing and felt it was necessary to have a housing director under his own steam, under his own control. I move to report progress.

Comment on this