We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 1–168 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When I was speaking on the Estimate last evening I had no intention of resuming this evening and, consequently, I may not have gone into the detailed examination of the Estimate as closely as I would wish. I dealt only superficially with many of the points raised by the Minister in his introductory speech. There were some points that I did not touch on at all.

In concluding his speech the Minister referred to my action in permitting the Friesian bull to be introduced to the insemination stations. It was as a result of a decision arrived at by the Livestock Consultative Council that a Friesian bull would be admitted to one of the stations on the condition that the semen would only issue to farmers for Friesian cows. I think that was the provision made at the time. If I was to blame on that occasion for permitting a Friesian into the insemination stations, from what I have heard during the past few weeks the Minister is not completely blameless because I understand that permission has now been given or is about to be given to include the Ayrshire and the Jersey in the insemination stations, again, I understand, on the same conditions. If I did damage to the Shorthorn breed, the Minister is following the example that I set. What was good sauce for the goose is still good sauce for the gander, and the Minister is not completely blameless.

The Minister, I am sure, believes that his decision will not damage the Shorthorn breed or the foundation stock of the country. I have and had the same belief that the introduction of the Friesian, provided, of course, that the semen would be used for Friesian cows and Friesian cows only, would not damage the foundation stock. Like the Minister and like our predecessors in the Department of Agriculture, I believe that the Shorthorn cow should be maintained as the foundation stock in this country. I believe that there is no other cow yet on hand or in sight to take her place.

When I referred to the Friesian cow yesterday evening I stated that we have no proof as regards her ability to produce milk under the same conditions as the Shorthorn has been producing milk in this country; we have no proof as regards her production of beef or its quality. I would like to see an experiment carried out to prove to the people who advocate the introduction of the Friesian cow that she is not comparable with our Shorthorn.

We have as good Shorthorns in this country as you will find in any part of the world. There are cows—there are some of them in Glasnevin—producing up to 1,500 gallons of milk. I know we have Friesians in this country that produce possibly about the same. We know that we have a good strain of Shorthorns. We may have a good strain of Friesians. But there should be an experiment carried out in order to prove conclusively that one is outstanding, more suitable to the country, because our economy is based on mixed farming. Mixed farming should be the basis of our agriculture and in the Shorthorn breed we have as good a strain in this country as there is in any other country.

Possibly the same thing applies to our Friesians. I am not too sure about it. It may and we may have people who may claim that that is the case but I, for one, would like to see that experiment carried out whereby we can prove conclusively to the people of the country: "Here is an experiment carried out under the auspices of the Department of Agriculture. We know what this animal can produce in the way of milk, how much it has cost to produce a gallon of milk, the value of her calf at a month old, a week old, a year old, when it came into the store age and when it was finished for beef."

We want to clear our minds on that question because there are people in this country who do not believe yet that we can produce cattle, horses, or anything else as good as can be produced across the water. That mentality is here. We must get rid of it.

I have heard people talk about the Friesian cow. I have heard them talk about the Ayrshire. I have heard them talk about the Landrace pig and many other things. According to them, anything produced here could not be as good as what is produced elsewhere. It is in the Minister's power to do it. As far as our foundation stock is concerned it is in his hands to prove, once and for all, that the dairy Shorthorn should be maintained as the foundation stock of our cattle, and to tell the people, as he has done and as his predecessors in office have done, that, as far as the Department and the Ministers were concerned, they believed that the dairy Shorthorn should be maintained as the foundation stock of our cattle. There is no equivocation about it nor there should not be. It is a question of proving it and of convincing the people in the country that it is so.

I often think over this matter. I have been through the country. I have seen our cows in many counties. I believe that they are not kept as they should be kept, that if they were kept and fed better there would not be any question about their yield of milk. I do know that the people who are engaged in dairying and who have gone to the trouble and expense of bringing in Friesian cattle are in a different category from the general body of farmers, that these people probably feed their cattle better than the general body and that it is for that reason that the claims they put forward have some substance. If the Shorthorn cow was as well fed as many of the Friesians are fed she would milk equally as much as the Friesians. There has been no change, mind, and it is wrong to think that the introduction of the Friesian has in any way damaged the reputation of the Shorthorn.

It has not. But our policy as regards our exports of cattle must be based on a firm foundation. I believe that our exports of cattle should be brought up not by 100,000, 200,000 or 300,000 but by 1,000,000 cattle. We have 9,000,000 of our 12,000,000 acres of land under grass. We are feeding at the present time 4,000,000 cattle on that 9,000,000 acres. We could carry more but it is wrong to think that we can produce another 1,000,000 cattle from grass and grass alone and even if we could it would be bad policy to do so. We are in a bad position even at the present time in that our exports of cattle are confined to eight or nine months of the year because we are exporting our cattle to the British market at a time when that market is flooded with cattle by the English and Scottish producers. There are three or four months of the year during which we could export an equal number of cattle as we do, say, in July.

Comment on this

Walk our crops off the land?

Comment on this

We should have more tillage and it would benefit our export trade. Another 1,000,000 acres of tillage would enable us to export another 1,000,000 cattle each year and it is only on that basis that we can hope to build up our exports.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It is foolish contending that in any year we have a guarantee that we can carry cattle from the month of October to the month of February in as good a condition as they were in October.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

There are some late growing years when you can do it but generally speaking over the last 20 or 30 years there is a period when we are keeping our cattle through the winter and feeding them on beef steak. You need only go through the country and see on a cold wet morning cattle bunched around the hedges. We can see them in the morning after a wet night when a late frost has come on in the morning. We can see the cattle with the water freezing on them. They are losing pounds of beef every night that that happens. We need a proper system of feeding in order to produce more cattle.

Comment on this

The Munster system.

Comment on this

One more cow, one more sow and one more acre under the plough.

Comment on this

That is true and I shall deal with that aspect of the matter. Based on tillage we can build up our cattle exports, our store cattle population and our beef. The principle we should follow here is not to have so many outliers as we have.

Comment on this

Outliers in the winter.

Comment on this

What should be recommended is the wintering of cattle in the yards, that there should be more straw in the yards, more farmyard manure and more hand-fed cattle. That is the policy we should follow.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! One more cow, one more sow and one more acre under the plough.

Comment on this

That is all right. The Minister has used that slogan quite often. I wonder does the Minister know where it originated and when. I could tell him.

Comment on this

The late Mr. Hogan.

Comment on this

Yes. He was told it in Carlow. It was a Carlow man gave it to him in 1926 when he went down there about the first beet factory that was erected. That slogan was given him by a Carlow farmer. That is the policy that is foremost with a Carlow man—one more cow, another sow and another acre under the plough. The late Mr. Hogan was told that and he did not believe that policy.

Comment on this

At least we are agreed on one thing now — that that is the right policy.

Comment on this

It is very well to talk of that policy but we must have an end in view when we say to the farmer: "Have another acre under the plough." What is the ultimate end there for the farmer who is unable to produce those cattle to use up the produce of the extra acre? It is no use telling a farmer in the traditional tillage areas to produce additional corn to feed to the cattle and walk them out if it is not the traditional system of farming there. What would the West Cork people do? How would they grow the amount of corn necessary?

Comment on this

Ground limestone is helping them.

Comment on this

It is one of the richest pig-producing counties in the country. And what would the farmers of Leinster do—in Kildare, portions of Laois, Carlow, Kilkenny, Wexford? In these traditional tillage counties where would they dispose of their crops or where would they keep the stock they would need to finish off the corn they were growing? We must think in these terms. I do know this, and I have often said it, that the price of our barley is dependent on what we get for our beef and bacon and poultry and eggs.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Our policy must be based on that. We must have the basis.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And in trying to find that basis provision must be made by whoever is charged with the responsibility for agriculture to see that the persons who produce that foodstuff is paid a price that will cover their cost of production and leave a margin of profit. He is charged with that responsibility and the only way in which he can ensure that the farmer gets that is by seeing that the produce that is turned out goes into a market where he gets a remunerative price. What does a Minister do in order to ensure that? Let us take pigs for instance. How does he approach it? His approach should be to produce bacon that will qualify for top price—the highest possible price that will ensure a margin of profit for the feeder. That is the Minister's responsibility if he has the responsibility of going out into a foreign market. Here in this country at the present time we produce about 26,000 or 27,000 pigs per week. That is the number going into the factories.

Of these we consume between 18,000 and 19,000 and our export figures represent about one-third of the whole. Surely it should be possible for the Minister to insist on sending out a quality bacon that will get top price in a foreign country. We are not doing that at the moment. The home consumers will not permit us to do it. The home consumer in Holland and Denmark will permit its being done in these countries. Otherwise, the bacon that is now produced in Denmark and Holland would not have the same uniform quality any more than our own bacon has. The bacon going into the British market from Denmark and Holland is top quality. It is uniform. The two sides of bacon are as alike as two peas in a pod. There is no difference between them. There is not the difference of one lb. as between one side of bacon and another. That is not the case here because our consumers are not prepared to make the same sacrifices as the Danish people are prepared to make in order to help the Danish farmers build up an agricultural export market.

Our people are helped in their attitude by our politicians who have gone out of their way to condemn the farmers' attitude in looking for higher prices. Our farmers have not been looking for excessive prices. They are looking for prices which will enable them to produce and have a margin of profit for themselves. We have our politicians shouting from the housetops, particularly in the towns and cities, advising the people that the farmers are millionaires and that they are getting too much for their produce.

If we could restrain ourselves from doing that, we might move along much more smoothly. But our politicians, for their own selfish ends, are using the situation in order to benefit themselves. While that continues we will not make any progress. Our farmers could do equally well as farmers in any country in the world if their costs of production were not so high. The people living in the towns and cities do not seem to appreciate the handicap under which our farmers have to work.

That is the answer to many of the statements that have been made from the Minister's benches. The Minister stated in his opening speech that we were being priced out of the market. I doubt if we are. I believe we can produce bacon if we set about doing it in the right way. I believe we can produce it at a price which will enable us to sell it in the British market at a profit. I know the Danish price has fallen. The quality of our bacon for export may not be as good as the Danish bacon. There may be a preference for Danish bacon in Britain. If there is a preference and if our bacon is not as good, then it is our own fault.

Here I charge the Minister with doing damage by putting maize on the market again. The Minister, in an advertisement issued some time ago, stated that it is now permissible to purchase straight maize. It was not permissible when I was in office, and I had a perfectly good reason for withholding permission. If we are to compete with the Danes we must have quality bacon. Why have the Danes gone over to feeding with barley? The Danish ration is 40 per cent. maize, 40 per cent. barley, 10 per cent. fish meal and 10 per cent. wheat offals. Why can we not adopt the same ration? We have equally as good a strain in our large white. We have just as suitable a pig as the Landrace but we are not taking advantage of it. If straight maize is put on the market, the Minister's statement about being priced out is wrong; we will be driven out because of the inferior quality of our bacon, and for no other reason. That is the sum total of it.

What applies in the case of bacon applies equally in the case of butter. Here again we are up against a problem. We have here a cow which, some will tell us, is capable of producing 450 gallons, or possibly more, as she is fed at the moment. If she were fed a little better we could increase the yield from that cow by at least another 100 gallons. We should be able to get our farmers to realise that. That brings me back now to a scheme—I do not know what has become of it—in relation to demonstration plots and pilot farms. The people have to be educated. Our farmers have the old traditional system of feeding the cow on grass in the summer and on poor hay in the winter. That cow cannot give a high milk yield the following year. She cannot give an economic supply of milk, and something must be done about it. How can we bring that home to our farmers?

Comment on this

The parish plan.

Comment on this

The parish plan will not do these things. One cannot demonstrate unless one has the co-operation of the people in demonstrating.

Comment on this

That is the very point.

Comment on this

The only way you can get that co-operation is by taking over a pilot farm, running it in the same way as the farmer would run his, but with better technical advice.

Comment on this

If one can get five farmers in each parish to run their farms under the direction of the technical adviser, would that not be an even better way?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That is what we are doing.

Comment on this

That can be done, but that needs money.

Comment on this

We have got the money.

Comment on this

That is all very fine, but will it be done any better than under the other system where the local committee controls it?

Comment on this

Let the local committee do it too.

Comment on this

But the local committee will not be in control under the parish plan.

Comment on this

I can only answer for my own plan.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's plan, but it will be directed from the Department of Agriculture. If that plan was under the committee of agriculture and controlled by that committee, then I could see some sense in going out looking for demonstration plots and getting pilot farms and advertising the fact that there was a pilot farm in operation in such and such a district, and bringing the farmers there to see what is being done so that in that way one might educate them.

Comment on this

I hope to have five pilot farms.

Comment on this

The Minister, in my opinion, is tinkering with this serious problem.

Comment on this

Sure, I am doing the best I can.

Comment on this

The best the Minister can do is not enough. It has become urgently necessary to make a move now. If we lose the market it will be gone for good. It is urgently necessary to put some plan into operation and there is a plan which could be put into operation. We have to educate the farmers who hitherto have produced their pigs with potatoes and maize. Now, because of the high cost of fuel, and for other reasons, the potatoes are gone. The farmers will not use them. Why not substitute fodder beet? Professor Calder gave a lecture here at Ballsbridge in 1952. He said then that barley is the cornerstone of pig rations in most bacon-producing areas and before long that will perforce of circumstances become the position in Ireland also. If we are to retain our export we must have barley included in our pig ration.

Comment on this

We have 100,000 acres more barley this year than last year.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear the Minister say so. I believe there is room for a couple of hundred thousand acres more. When I was sitting on that side of the House I asked the farmers on every possible occasion to produce more barley and to import less maize. That was the cornerstone of all my policy. We should produce these commodities at home and use our own land for their production. Not merely is that good economic policy so far as the farmer is concerned but it will produce a product of which we need not be ashamed. Furthermore, even when there were fluctuations in the price of foreign feeding stuffs last year, we were able to send our pigs into the British market all last year, pay a reasonably good price to the farmer who produced the barley that fed them and a profitable price to the farmer who reared the pig.

The Minister or the Government has changed that. This is a case of robbing Peter to pay Paul. The Minister for Finance was not satisfied or the Minister for Industry and Commerce was not satisfied that the bread subsidy should be so high and in seeking a victim they selected the farmers. The farmers have lost over £2,000,000 on the price of wheat. That will, in some way, reduce the bread subsidy but the Minister for Industry and Commerce went further than that when he permitted the millers to increase the price of pollard by £5 per ton in order that he could again reduce the bread subsidy.

Comment on this

Sure, it has gone down again, now.

Comment on this

It has not gone down to anything like what it was. I think the price at the present time—I am not too sure, possibly I have the prices here—the price of pollard is £24 10s. per ton. When we left office it was £20. That £4 10s. per ton will give some help to the Minister for Finance, but the increase of £4 10s. is going to take away the profits that the farmer is making out of his pigs. Is it any wonder that we are again travelling on the road that we travelled from 1949 to 1951 and that we are going downhill? The people who are sitting over on the opposite side of the House may laugh and scoff at this but let me give them the figures because they are very illuminating. It would be well that more stock would be taken of these figures by the people who sit behind the Minister and cheer him when he makes a speech on agriculture in this House. The January estimates of this year—the latest figures we have available—reveal that sows for breeding in January, 1955, numbered 85,000, but in January, 1954, 12 months ago, there were 100,000, a reduction of 15 per cent.

Comment on this

What would we feed them on?

Comment on this

Maybe the 95,000 tons of wheat that neither the Minister for Industry and Commerce nor the Minister for Agriculture know anything about. Probably they could be fed on that. Any questions Deputy O'Leary likes to put to me I will try to answer——

Comment on this

Sure, our bacon factory was closed in Enniscorthy at one time until Deputy Dillon came along to open it.

Comment on this

That fall of 15 per cent. in the number of sows from January, 1954, until January, 1955—are we to congratulate ourselves on that performance? Is that an indication that we are on the upward trend, that stagnation has not hit agriculture, that worse than stagnation has not hit it at the present time and that we are not going downhill? Speaking here yesterday I pointed out to the people in this House that it took us two years to recover from 1950-1951. That is quite true.

Comment on this

You will take a long time to recover now.

Comment on this

Deputies may laugh at these statements of mine which, perhaps, get under their skin, but it is well worth while searing them with a red-hot iron if we are able to put them back on the right road so that agriculture could be put back to the good condition in which it was. The Minister for Lands is laughing at the idea but agriculture in this country as we know it is the basic industry.

Comment on this

Why did you not do more about it, then?

Comment on this

The record of Fianna Fáil as regards agriculture is well known.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I will quote these figures again because it is well worth while putting them on record. These things cannot be said often enough. If we are to follow the policy that was pursued in this country from 1948 to 1951, then somebody will have to clear up the mess that Fianna Fáil had to clear up in 1951.

Comment on this

You will not be asked to clear it up.

Comment on this

I have given you the figures prepared under the Coalition Government in a Government office and, I am sure, approved by that Government. These are the figures that have been issued to the people, the latest figures available. In the case of other pigs—three months old and upwards—we had in 1955, 351,100; and in the previous year we had 354,000. That shows that the older pigs are there and that we are starting on the downward trend and that it is time it was arrested because the next figure is very illuminating. It is this: in 1955, we had 370,500 pigs of under three months, but last year in the month of January we had 432,900, a drop of 14.4 per cent. Does that indicate the upward trend that we have been told about? Does that indicate that we are going to hold our place in the foreign markets?

The Minister for Lands will be very pleased, I am sure, when he sees the exports dropping because last year, when I made a speech similar to the one that was made by the Minister exalting ourselves on the increase in our exports, Deputy Blowick, as he then was, came along and said: "Is it any wonder that exports have gone up when you have been starving the people at home? That is the reason for it."

Comment on this

Precisely that: that is what you did. That is why the people threw you out and left you over there where you cannot do any more damage.

Comment on this

Does it not show the depths to which some people can descend when a statement like that comes from a responsible individual such as the Minister for Lands?

Comment on this

That is the way you increased your exports.

Comment on this

He made that statement even though I was able to tell him that we never consumed as much butter in the country as we were consuming at that time and that there was never before as much bacon or as much bread consumed in this country.

Comment on this

Was that why you decided to raise it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Walsh is entitled to speak and should be allowed to speak. If other Deputies wish to contribute to the debate they can do so later.

Comment on this

That is true, but is Deputy Walsh entitled to make the same point more than three times?

Comment on this

I have not done so.

Comment on this

I am only asking is the Deputy entitled to make the same point three times?

Comment on this

The Minister for Lands said we were starving the people. It is well worth repeating, coming from a responsible person like him.

Comment on this

I am sitting with respectful attention into your third hour. I am starving for my tea but I will remain until you are finished.

Comment on this

I would hate to think I was the cause of any inconvenience to the Minister. I will not stand between him and his tea.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister will get his tea earlier if he does not interrupt the Deputy.

Comment on this

I heard the Minister yesterday evening introduce certain figures. He talked about stagnation. I do not believe there should be any stagnation in agriculture but the indications are bad. The only thing we can rely on, I am sure, are the figures that are published over a period of six months. We have the January figures, estimated figures admittedly, and we have the June figures. The January figures reveal a situation that is not very encouraging, to say the least of it. Let me take cattle. There is a boom in cattle at the present time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be put out of the Fianna Fáil Party if he is not careful.

Comment on this

The Minister for Lands should not open his mouth when we are talking about exports. He thought we had not enough at home, that we were starving.

Comment on this

I was warning the Deputy that he would be put out of the Fianna Fáil Party for the statement he has just made.

Comment on this

We were starving the people.

Comment on this

Thank God the British market is gone. That was your cry.

Comment on this

The Ballybricken pig buyers.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not be fit to clean their boots.

Comment on this

I knew I would draw that remark from Deputy Lynch. The Ballybricken pig buyers. Let me refer for a couple of minutes to the cattle situation. The milch cow, of course, cannot be too easily got rid of in 12 months; the heifers are coming in and it takes a little while as it took, say, in 1951 to restore them. It also takes a short while for the numbers to decline, with the result that we have in January, 1955, 1,179,300, an increase of 15,000 over last year, 1.3 per cent. increase. Heifers in-calf in 1955 are 125,300 but in 1954 we had 145,100. That shows a decrease of 13.7 per cent. in in-calf heifers. The figure for bulls is 16,800; last year it was 17,900. Now we are coming to the very significant one: young cattle, 2,661,600 in 1955 and in January, 1954, 2,678,600, a decrease of 6 per cent., that is after 12 months.

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

Of Coalition administration. After 12 months of Coalition administration we have to record that the agricultural commodities on which the Coalition Minister has set his feet are declining, a sad commentary on the administration. The Minister has set his feet on our exports of live stock to the British market but here we must record that the number he has for export has declined——

Comment on this

The Deputy must realise it takes nine months——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Walsh is in possession.

Comment on this

The number of live stock he has for export has declined in 12 months. We have to record again during that period a complete change as far as the agricultural policy of the country is concerned. I refer to tillage. Gone is that guaranteed market for wheat.

Comment on this

The racketeers.

Comment on this

The ranchers.

Comment on this

Who are the people who are racketeers in the growing of wheat? I do not happen to know. I was not available at the time that discussion was on but I would like to find the person that was able to come forward and talk about racketeers in wheat-growing. I would like to find them and I would like to know what percentage of the people of the country who grew wheat, not merely in 1954, but in any of the years before that, could be described as racketeers. There are people in this country who grew 1,000 acres of wheat during the war period. Would that be information for the members of this House? It was done voluntarily.

Comment on this

Was the Minister aware that during the last year when he was Minister for Agriculture one man who had no stake in the country drew £18,000 in subsidy for the wheat he grew here and brought that out of the country?

Comment on this

Where did this man get the subsidy? He produced an article, sold it in the market at a price that was available for everybody else. I want to know where that subsidy came from?

Comment on this

From the small farmer and the working man of this country.

Comment on this

This man sold a commodity for a price that was available to every person in this country, even though he was a black man. If the Minister's statement is correct, he came in here, tilled his land and I suppose he paid a price for it to somebody. The Minister for Lands has already advertised, I am sure, something in the neighbourhood of 500 acres of conacre this year.

Comment on this

Not to the ranchers.

Comment on this

He has sold it to people who grew 40 and 50 acres of wheat last year.

Comment on this

He has not.

Comment on this

Name one of them.

Comment on this

If he goes down to the Annally estate in Kilkenny he will find out who is purchasing it.

Comment on this

I will look that up.

Comment on this

The Minister will find many farmers who grew that quantity of wheat last year in that area—they were farmers, not racketeers.

Comment on this

They were not farmers, anyhow.

Comment on this

This thing about racketeers does not carry any weight with me.

Comment on this

You backed them up manfully.

Comment on this

We have people who grew that acreage of wheat in the past. However, that is getting away from the point. The Government, by its action in reducing the price of wheat by 12/6 a barrel, has taken the heart out of the individual farmer. The request to the industrious, energetic young farmer, as seen by the attitude of the Government, is: "Produce a surplus" and then the Government's remedy for the surplus is to reduce his price. The incentive to produce more is gone, no matter what may be said from the platforms or in the House. The incentive is gone, the inducement is gone. If it goes in one crop, it will go in others.

We have the sons and second sons of farmers, anxious to work, who set out to get machinery and took conacre to make a livelihood out of it. We know very well we will have to continue conacre. We know of the widow with a family, unable to manage the farm; we know of the unfortunate old people who may be unable to manage it themselves—the alternative these people have is to let it in conacre. We know that system must be maintained. These young farmers invested their capital in machinery—or they borrowed money and invested it—and after one or two years, what happened? The profit they were making was taken from them—12/6 per barrel or £2,000,000, taken out of the pockets of the wheat producers. The incentive is being taken away. If the incentive goes in tillage, it will disappear also in other phases of agriculture.

The Minister has been shouting about increased production, that unless we have increased production industrialisation cannot succeed and may come to a stop. Is this helping to build up the enthusiasm our farmers should have at present and that I must say we had established before Fianna Fáil went out of office? It was taken away with a wave of the hand in one effort. I could criticise the Minister, for instance, because last July he succumbed to the demands that were made to reduce the price of butter.

Comment on this

Do you disagree with that action?

Comment on this

I do and if I were over there I would disagree with it, because I had in the stores here in Dublin, at the time the outcry took place, the finest butter in the world, offered to the people of the City of Dublin at 3/10 a lb. and they refused to buy it.

It was equally as good as any that could be produced in the world. What was the reason? It was unspreadable. Do they forget that our own May and June production is put into cold storage and when handed out to the people of Dublin after four or five months it is as unspreadable as New Zealand butter?

If I were forced in the past at any time to reduce the price of butter, I certainly would not operate it as a consumer subsidy or handle it as such. The Minister is handling this subsidy as a consumer subsidy and there is nothing to prevent a Minister in the future who is supporting the consumers, saying that he has given this subsidy in order to enable the farmer to get this price for his milk. That would be the attitude taken up by some Minister who would be opposed to this subsidy, to wipe it out—say the Minister for Finance—if he did not want to give it any longer. The Minister for Agriculture would be hard pressed to establish the fact that it was a consumer subsidy, that it was not a producer subsidy.

In the end, if at any time that subsidy has to go, the consuming public, because of the greater number of votes they have, will succeed in establishing that as a producer subsidy —which it is not. For that reason, I certainly would not handle it as Minister for Agriculture. If the administration was to be carried out by the Department of Agriculture, there was a way in which it could be done. It could be done through the Stabilisation Fund. They could recoup themselves through that. It certainly would not appear in my Estimates if I were Minister for Agriculture. I blame the Minister for accepting it.

On the subsidisation of milk, I referred yesterday to the costings. There is no one at present—I do not mind who it is—but could tell us how much it costs to produce a gallon of milk. Let us have these costings produced and let the people in the towns and cities see for themselves what it is costing farmers to produce that milk. The farmers are entitled to a livelihood as well as anyone else.

Comment on this

Is not that the fourth time you said that?

Comment on this

I mentioned costings for the first time this evening—the Costings Committee.

Comment on this

That is the fourth time.

Comment on this

It was inadvertently I referred to the costings, so, but let them be produced and then the people will know where they stand. I am not going to refer to it again. The Minister made a mistake in putting a subsidy on butter and not on chocolate crumb.

Comment on this

You said that three times.

Comment on this

That is the first time I mentioned it this evening. I think the Minister made a mistake in doing that.

Comment on this

That is the fourth time.

Comment on this

It did not get proper examination and that is the reason for it. The figures were available there for anybody. It was a new industry we were building up. We could have waited with our butter and built up this industry. We exported about £9,000,000 worth in 1953. We could have maintained that. The figures reveal that this year it is down considerably. It is down because of the delivery charges.

Comment on this

Britain does not want it.

Comment on this

That is not the reason. It is easy to get into the British market with chocolate crumb. It is a free market and there is no difficulty. What prohibited us from going in was the £3 5s. per ton duty and the delivery charge of £4.

Comment on this

And the impact of sugar costs.

Comment on this

The sugar costs were cheaper than Britain, 10/- a cwt. cheaper. Milk for chocolate crumb gives a higher price to the creamery.

Comment on this

That is the fourth time.

Comment on this

I am saying it again. It is well worth repeating. It gives a higher price and that is the line that the Minister should have followed, the line that will bring the most money in to the farmers. It is his duty to examine these questions. That is what he is there for and that is why he is being paid a high salary.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy say? Paying me what?

Comment on this

I think more than what the Minister is worth.

Comment on this

This House thought otherwise last June.

Comment on this

I have dealt with these matters. I should like to know what the future policy in relation to agriculture will be. There is no use in saying to us: "We must concentrate on the export of beef to the exclusion of everything else." Our policy has not been that. We did everything we possibly could to build up a beef export market. However, we need to base it on tillage. I believe that if it is based on tillage we shall provide more work for our people, more money for our farmers, more stock for export and an increase not merely in our exports but in agricultural production generally.

The only way in which we can carry more cattle in this country is by producing better grasses. Provision has been made in the Department for that. A new section was set up to deal exclusively with seeds. We want better grasses. We can get better grasses by using more of the plough, more lime, more fertilisers. That is the line we should be following. Here is where we are up against the snag; there is a snag some place. We want more cattle because there is a market for our beef and for our stores. Britain needs about 200,000 to 250,000 tons of meat. We supply about 20 per cent. of her fresh meat trade. If the prices we are getting now are good, we can attribute that to our proximity to Britain because we, and no other people, can get into her fresh meat market. The British have a surplus of chilled and frozen meat at the present time, but the housewife and the consumer in Britain prefer fresh meat. Because of our proximity to Britain, our cattle, sent in by a Scotch or English farmer, are entitled to go into the fresh meat market. We shall always have that advantage.

What provision are we going to make in the country to get in with our 200,000 tons of meat? I said there was a snag. There is. We cannot have cattle without cows. If we increase our stock of cows from the 1,250,000 that we have, what will we do with the milk? I have heard wiseacres talk about putting a calf on a cow and say that it is good farming economy.

Comment on this

Or four or five.

Comment on this

If we were able to get them. Unfortunately, a cow will have only one calf at a time. If it is the economical way of doing things, every farmer in the country will be putting his calf on his cow and there will be no calves left for Deputy Hughes or myself. They will not be coming from County Limerick or West Cork. What can we do? Even with a bad cow, milking 450 gallons at the 1/6 a gallon that the well-managed creamery can pay at the present time, it would be rather expensive to have that amount of milk going to one calf instead of to four. That is the snag we have to face. We have to examine the question of getting into the milk and butter markets of Britain, whether it be through chocolate crumb or through butter. We must ask ourselves whether we are going to follow that policy or whether we will produce our requirements of milk here and introduce beef cattle as well. That is the alternative, if we want to build up our cattle population. However, we must know the road we are going to travel.

We have been preaching the gospel of more and more production from the land. If farmers who have taken our advice to use as much lime and as much fertiliser as they can, continue to do so, the position in a few years' time will be that we shall not have sufficient live stock to eat the grass. Therefore, we must improve and continue to increase our live-stock population. That is a matter that the Government, and the Minister for Agriculture in particular, must consider. They must know what line we are going to follow.

It is very easy to say that we must increase our cattle population but increasing our cattle population also means increasing our cow population or our heifer population. If we are going to have a proper economy, then it is a matter of working out a plan that will be economical and profitable to the people of the country. With regard to the day when we can capture that market for 200,000 tons of meat that is there at our doorstep, now is the time to act if we want it, because other countries are looking for it. A question that must be considered is how long will the British continue to pay high prices for fresh beef. Maybe, in time, they will acquire a taste for chilled beef. If that day ever arrives, then we are sunk.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! "Sunk" is the word.

Comment on this

Now is the time for the Minister for Agriculture to set about preparing a plan, to formulate a policy and to educate the people of this country to follow the line he has in mind so that we will be able to increase production. As regards other features of agriculture, we must be concerned about our tillage acreage. When speaking last night, I mentioned that the Minister is going to subsidise feeding barley next year.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it not true that, under the rules of order, if a Deputy mentioned a matter last night he ought not mention it again to-day?

Comment on this

The Minister always mentions everything ten times.

Comment on this

The Minister need not be afraid of it.

Comment on this

Do the rules of order not prescribe——

Comment on this

The Minister never kept the rules of order.

Comment on this

I am asking the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

You cannot repeat a good thing often enough.

Comment on this

There are rules of order.

Comment on this

But you cannot repeat a good thing often enough.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Repetition is not allowed in the House, and neither are interruptions.

Comment on this

I do not think it is an interruption to direct your attention, Sir, to the fact that the Deputy is now declaring his intention of repeating what he said last night.

Comment on this

No. I mentioned it last night. I might elaborate on it tonight.

Comment on this

There are no hard feelings—I just mentioned it.

Comment on this

None in the world. That would not ruffle my hair at all. If the Minister is not satisfied, I will change the theme of the argument until he settles down. There are a lot of things I can talk about.

Comment on this

You are telling me.

Comment on this

I could talk, for instance, about the Minister's statement yesterday about exports, the exports he made so much noise about; and— what was worse than making noise— his attributing of this great expansion in agriculture to the Coalition Government. I could talk a lot about that. It might be of interest to the Minister to know that, in 1951, we had no exports of pork. Not a pound of pork did we export in that year, after three years of the Coalition, and even with the much talked of pig agreement of May, 1951.

Comment on this

That is the fifth time you have said that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not aware that the Deputy has said that before.

Comment on this

Is it not grossly disorderly to repeat interruptions?

Comment on this

Do not the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and Deputies know that that is the fifth time Deputy Walsh has said that?

Comment on this

And he will repeat it a sixth time.

Comment on this

It is the tenth time the Minister has said it.

Comment on this

Every time the Minister stands up and challenges my statement, I will repeat it when he sits down. If he will sit down and give me an opportunity of elaborating on my statement, there will be no repetition. Otherwise, I will repeat it every time.

Comment on this

Whether it is in order or not?

Comment on this

It is perfectly in order, if there are no interruptions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Walsh should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I have already mentioned——

Comment on this

Well, now—I appeal to Caesar.

Comment on this

——that we exported no pork in 1951. There will be no repetition. Even though we had three years of the Coalition Government from 1948 to 1951, not a pound of pork was exported, but in 1952 we started, and, after 12 months, we exported 335,500 cwt. In 1948, the first year in which the Coalition assumed office, the Minister exported six cwt. of bacon.

Comment on this

In 1947, you had it under the counter.

Comment on this

Three pigs. In 1953, we exported 115,412 cwt.

Comment on this

You have said a mouthful.

Comment on this

There was a big difference in the trend of things.

Comment on this

A mighty difference.

Comment on this

The trend was upwards. While Fianna Fáil were in office, there was an upward trend in agricultural production and in agricultural prices, but we have now come back to the policy which the 1948 Coalition followed and which gave us a reduction of 500,000 acres of land under the plough in three years. It is amazing that there should be such a collapse in three years that even our cattle population was beginning to do down. I have quoted the figures already. They were on the downward trend in 1951. Pigs had almost disappeared and now, unfortunately for the country, we are to have a repetition of the policy of 1948 to 1951. Where is this going to end for our cities, our towns and our villages? What is to become of our industry, if we are going to impoverish the farming community?

Comment on this

Go back to 1945 and 1946, and talk sense.

Comment on this

Deputy Fagan interjects a remark about 1945 and 1946.

Comment on this

The figures you have given are not good, in my opinion. I do not believe them.

Comment on this

The Deputy talks about figures. I present him with figures issued by his own Government. Does he not approve of them? Does he not accept them as being the truth?

Comment on this

I do, but what about 1945 and 1946?

Comment on this

The figures are there for the Deputy, if he wishes to go into them. They indicate a downward trend at the moment. It might be information for the Deputy—he has not been in the House very long—to learn that we have less cattle in 1955 than we had in 1954.

Comment on this