We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 169–320 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Did the Deputy say that Deputy Fagan was not long in the House?

Comment on this

He has just come in. According to the figures produced by the Statistics Office, the January estimate indicates a decrease in the number of cattle.

Comment on this

Tell us about 1945 and 1946.

Comment on this

After 11 short months, we see the cash crop, the only cash crop the farmers could say they have a guarantee for, wiped away, and we see the price of feeding stuffs wiping our pig production out of the home and foreign markets, and at present prices for maize, barley, pollard and bran the pig will be as scarce as a Red Indian on the shores of Manhattan in a few years' time. We will not have them. Who is going to keep pigs? Our price in 1954 was 252/- a cwt., with maize, barley at £27 a ton. To-day pig prices are 214/- a cwt., with maize, barley, if the barley were available, £30 a ton.

Comment on this

That is the sixth time you have said that.

Comment on this

It is worth repeating.

Comment on this

And the Minister does not like it.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh's contribution was not so good. He lost £250,000 on 36,000 tons of barley.

Comment on this

Would you like to get the figures?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would you come out into the open with them?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

You will? So will I. That is an issue and I will challenge you on it—as at 31st May, 1954. You produce your figures and I will produce mine outside this House.

Comment on this

What Deputy Donegan objects to is the farmer getting 48/-for barley.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a greater interest in the farmers of Louth than Deputy Aiken.

Comment on this

The Deputy is objecting because they got 48/- for their barley.

Comment on this

Some of the Deputies in this House seem to be labouring under a misconception as regards our commitments to the wheat agreement. Speaking last year—I think it was on the wheat prices motion—the Minister said on that occasion——

Comment on this

What is the reference, please?

Comment on this

I am quoting from Volume 147, column 1516. In reply to Deputy Moher, the Minister said:—

"You will be very welcome. Fianna Fáil fixed 82/6 a barrel for wheat bushelling 63 lb. and over. What is the result of that? Do not let us forget that at the same time that Fianna Fáil fixed that price for Irish wheat they signed the International Wheat Agreement which binds this Government now throughout this year and next year to accept delivery of 270,000 tons of wheat whenever anyone wants to tender that quantity of wheat to us at the minimum price of one dollar 55 f.o.b. Port Arthur for No. 1 Manitoba wheat. That liability attaches to me now. Between now and the 31st July any person in the International Wheat Agreement who desires can compel this country to accept this wheat and pay for it by virtue of the International Wheat Agreement."

The Minister was not correct in that statement. The Minister spoke of No. 1 Manitoba. He was not compelled to buy No. I Manitoba wheat at any time. Neither has he purchased No. 1 in the last 12 months.

Comment on this

I never said that I was obliged to purchase No. 1 Manitoba. Read it again. Read it slowly, and you will grasp it clearly.

Comment on this

It has become a feature of the front bench for the Ministers to deny their own statements.

Comment on this

Read it slowly, and you will grasp it clearly.

Comment on this

I will read it for the Minister again. There is no ambiguity about it at all:—

"You will be very welcome. Fianna Fáil fixed 82/6..."

Comment on this

You should start lower down.

Comment on this

Very well. I will read the whole sentence, or paragraph, if the Minister wishes:—

"Do not let us forget that at the same time that Fianna Fáil fixed that price for Irish wheat they signed the International Wheat Agreement which binds this Government now throughout this year and next year to accept delivery of 270,000 tons of wheat..."

Comment on this

Whoa there!

Comment on this

"... at the minimum price of one dollar 55 f.o.b. Port Arthur for No. 1 Manitoba wheat."

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Let me proceed:—

"That liability attaches to me now. Between now and the 31st July any person in the International Wheat Agreement who desires can compel this country to accept this wheat... "

Comment on this

No, no. Read back. Do not be silly.

Comment on this

No. 1 Manitoba.

Comment on this

Do not be silly.

Comment on this

The Minister said No. 1 Manitoba. The Minister did not buy No. 1 Manitoba; he bought cheaper wheat than that.

Comment on this

It does not say that.

Comment on this

He bought cheaper wheat than that.

Comment on this

That makes the burden worse.

Comment on this

The Minister could not afford to give the Irish farmer the same price as he paid for Australian wheat that was equally as good, and used, possibly, for the same purpose as the Australian wheat. Wheat was delivered to the mills last year which was rejected as being non-millable. In some of the things I have looked through somebody questioned that wheat which contained 30 per cent. moisture was unmillable. It was no such thing. But it was these unfortunate farmers who had to take it home and sell it at prices from 35/-a barrel to £2. I know where a farmer was offered £100 for 100 barrels, and yet the Government had to go to Australia to buy wheat from the Australians which could have been provided by the Irish farmer. Was that good policy?

The Minister, I understand, issued licences for the export of wheat last year at less than £2 per barrel. It went across the Border, and we are going to the furthest ends of the earth to bring in animal feeding stuffs from £27 to over £30 per ton. Is it any wonder our farmers have become disheartened? Is it any wonder that their incentive to produce is gone? Is it any wonder that we are going to run into a slump, that we are going to run into a period where production in agriculture is going to go down? We had built it up. The efforts of three years have now been brought to naught. It may be of interest to some of the people in the House, and to the people of the country, to know what the exact position was as far as agriculture was concerned on the 2nd June, 1954, as compared with the 1st June, 1951. Our cattle numbers in 1954 were 20,351 higher in June, 1953, than in June, 1951.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Sheep were up by 214,000

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Pigs were up by 223,000 and poultry by 274,000. That was the period when Fianna Fáil were in office. We have been accused, possibly, by some people of stagnation in agriculture. That is the record. Let us hope that when the Coalition Government is finished by the people, and when the clamouring from outside will be sufficiently strong to put them off the benches, they will be able to come back to this House and repeat what I am going to repeat: as far as Fianna Fáil were concerned that they could do it in keeping with the progress made under their own Administration. Our wheat area was 72,000 acres higher in 1953 than in 1951, barley by 21,000 acres, sugar beet by 5,429 acres, the total tillage being up by over 35,000 acres. Our agricultural exports were £20,000,000 higher in June, 1953, than in June, 1951, an increase of 34 per cent. Yesterday, we heard the Minister talking about the increase since 1948 but I have shown the increase from 1951 to 1953.

The number of instructors in agriculture increased by 45 per cent. Land reclamation was accelerated during that period. In 1951-54, we created a record, one which will not be surpassed or equalled this year. We had 100,000 acres of land under the land reclamation scheme. That will not be done this year. The sum of £122,000 was transferred to another section of the Department. More than seven times as much lime was applied to the land last year than in 1951. More money was provided for farm buildings and for running water to the homes of farmers. We spent £100,000 in 12 months as compared with the £4,500 spent during the last year of the Coalition Administration. We gave better credit facilities to the farmer. We initiated schemes in the Department because, as I said last night, we wanted to make credit available to our people. That has been taken away from them again. That was the record of the Fianna Fáil Government while they were in office.

We have now started on the downward trend in agriculture. It is all right for the Minister to talk about being priced out of the markets, but there is a remedy for these things. It should be within the scope of the Government to find these remedies. They are there. They were there in 1951, 1952, 1953 and 1954. They are still there if only the Government would look for them.

When speaking yesterday the Minister said he was going to have much destructive criticism from this side of the House. Let us then for a few moments give him something that is constructive. Agriculture needs many things at the present time and it will take more than five years to carry the work out. It will take the lifetime of any Government and even a longer period to do these things. I hope that when the Minister relinquishes office some progress can be shown for the term he spent as Minister for Agriculture. I have here——

Comment on this

Deputy Allen asks you to take your time. Do not be afraid.

Comment on this

Afraid of what?

Comment on this

I am in no hurry—no hurry in the world.

Comment on this

Afraid of what?

Comment on this

I was only wondering.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is not suggesting that Deputy Walsh is afraid of the Minister?

Comment on this

I would be long sorry to think he was.

Comment on this

I would be, too.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to introduce a note of geniality into the proceedings. He would choke if he tried to do that too often.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Walsh should be allowed to continue his speech.

Comment on this

I was waiting for the conversation to finish.

Comment on this

We had to cover up your embarrassment.

Comment on this

Thanks. I am not a bit embarrassed. I do not get embarrassed as easily as all that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had a neck like the Minister's he would not be embarrassed.

Comment on this

Some time before I left office, I was preparing schemes to benefit agriculture under the National Development Fund. It is well worth while recording the schemes we had in mind at that time and which we consider would be of immense value to agriculture. I admit they would cost a considerable sum of money but each one of the schemes is well worth following up.

We wanted advisory and demonstration work carried out. We wanted more buildings and equipment for Department schools and private agricultural schools. There is no necessity for me to dwell on the necessity for these things. If we are going to educate the youth of our country we must make preparations in our schools for the pupils. Consequently, it is necessary that greater provision be made in regard to the Department's schools and the private agricultural schools. Then there was the live-stock progeny testing station. We had already made provision in that case. I think it was approved. As a matter of fact, approval had been given on the 2nd June to some of the schemes I am going to mention but for some reason or another—I do not know why—they were rejected.

The progeny testing station for cattle has been placed in abeyance notwithstanding its importance to the country at the present time. There were grants for university research, control stations for poultry and eggs, establishment of a fish farm, credit at reduced rates of interest mainly for fertilisers. The schemes included also expansion of veterinary services, reclamation of marginal land and improvement of hill grazing, improved services under the farm buildings scheme and farm water supplies, disposal of sewage at creameries, heating of the Gaeltacht glasshouses, grants for factories for fancy cheeses, provision of facilities for growing onions, grants and loans to machinery contractors for lime and manure distributors, storage facilities for seed and ware potatoes, poultry development in Connemara and the provision of facilities for the production of foundation stocks of seed.

We had these schemes. There is plenty of work for the Minister for Agriculture. If he wants to increase agricultural production in the country it is by these methods it will be done. These are fundamental to increased production. It is up to the Minister to use the men in his Department, who are the finest body of men in any Department in this State, to put the flesh on the bones that are there. If these schemes are gone ahead with and utilised in the proper way they will yield good dividends.

Many of them are of the utmost importance and urgency at the present time. I would advise the Minister to get cracking on some of these schemes and not allow himself to be bulldozed by his colleagues on the ministerial benches.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember the Gresham Hotel conference? Was there not great bulldozing there?

Comment on this

There is no bulldozing as far as we are concerned. When a Fianna Fáil Government comes into this House there is unanimity on ministerial benches. There is no bulldozing. We believe in the well-being of the nation. We are of one mind on it and we know that it is only by having unanimity of outlook among Ministers that the country can succeed. It was because of that that we succeeded from 1951 to 1954 in repairing the damage that was created from 1948 to 1951. It was only in that way it was done. I regret to say that the same pattern is being followed in agriculture now as was followed then. I hope some speaker on the opposite benches has the courage—he will not be a farmer—to repudiate the statements I have made regarding agriculture at the present time. If any farmer does repudiate the statement, he is no credit to the agricultural community.

Comment on this

Before tendering my own contribution to this debate I would like to deal with a few remarks of the ex-Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Walsh. In the course of an interjection by me which, I suppose, like all interjections, was disorderly, I stated that Deputy Walsh, when he guaranteed a price of 48/- a barrel for feeding barley, succeeded in losing somewhere between £220,000 and £225,000 on a quantity of barley approximating to 36,000 tons and which, when examined, was found to have cost the Minister many more pounds per ton than the price which he paid for it because of excess moisture content. At that stage Deputy Aiken intervened to say: "I suppose Deputy Donegan objected to the farmers of County Louth getting 48/-a barrel for their feeding barley."

I am proud to say that, this year, as my contribution to the Minister's effort in introducing a contract system, I have succeeded in getting one firm at least to sign contracts for a figure exactly 1/6 less—46/6 of a minimum for 8,000 barrels of feeding barley in County Louth, and I am also quite proud to say that I think I have done more for the farmers of Louth in the very short time I have been here than Deputy Aiken has done during his whole period of office.

Comment on this

Do not praise yourself too soon.

Comment on this

I go so far as to say that the only occasion on which I heard Deputy Aiken discuss agriculture I heard him mention wheat in hand stacks in County Louth. I have been looking at it for 25 years, and I never saw it in a hand stack and neither did anybody else.

Comment on this

You must never be out on the land.

Comment on this

Not in hand stacks. In approaching this Estimate it is wise to consider the amount of money that is being voted—nearly £5,000,000. If we consider the number of males employed on the land we find that, if we dispensed with the Minister and the whole Department, and had a skeleton staff to distribute this money through the offices of the Department of Social Welfare, who would know these people who are employed on the land, all we could afford by direct subsidy would be about £10 per head. We have heard many suggestions from the opposite benches with regard to direct subsidy. All that the direct subsidy can give the farming population of this country is £10 per head per year. That is all it can provide.

If we are to stimulate and encourage agricultural production, one means by which we can do it is by the stimulation of reproduction, by the introduction of ground limestone to the land which, for an expenditure of £1, will give the farmer £3, by the introduction of all the other schemes which the present Minister for Agriculture initiated and which the Opposition now decry or, if they do not decry it, they try to jump on the bandwagon and take credit for it. There is one other way, that is by the education of men's minds. There we have the parish plan.

Before I discuss either the parish plan or ground limestone I would like to discuss corn, because in County Louth we have an economy in which the production of corn is uppermost. We have this year a decline in the wheat acreage of approximately 70,000 acres and we have an increase in the barley and oats acreage, which leaves us with a greater tillage acreage than we have had before.

I want to praise the Minister for Agriculture and to point out that there are six, or seven or eight counties in Ireland which, in my view, definitely subscribe to his view that the only policy for agriculture in this country is one more cow, one more sow and one more acre under the plough, but that these counties subscribe to it in a different way from that which is generally understood. The counties to which I refer are those which invariably produce more corn and more grain than they could use—Louth, Wexford, Carlow, parts of Tipperary, parts of Cork and you know the rest.

We now have a decrease in the acreage under wheat. I am pleased to observe from the figures supplied by the Department of Agriculture for deliveries to and mill intake in respect of the 1953 harvest—which I presume is the only one we should take, last year's season being so wet—that 7.34 barrels per statute acre were delivered to the mills. If we have to-day 400,000 acres of wheat—the Estimate of the Department of Agriculture is that we have from 370,000 to 400,000— we will have 354,000 tons of wheat to mill next harvest from Irish farms. If the figure is 370,000 we will still have more wheat next harvest than Fianna Fáil wanted when they issued their instructions through their various Ministries on January 17th of last year. Their figure was 300,000 tons and we have still got more. In addition, we have more oats and more barley and it is inevitable that a great quantity of barley and oats must be marketed.

The Minister has introduced the contract system. The contract system, if it can be implemented in full in the years to come, is the ideal answer for the internal usage of our grain. Over the last ten years we have imported maize and milo-maize to the value of approximately £5,000,000 per year. There is not the slightest reason why that £5,000,000 cannot be put into the pockets of the Irish farmers who increase tillage and subscribe to the policy of one more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough.

The greatest contribution towards the advancement of this idea of internal usage was made by the present Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, when he introduced, in 1951, his Grain Storage Loans Bill. As a result, we have to-day, for an expenditure, including the amount in this year's Estimate, of £1,100,000, grain storage for 100,000 tons more than we had at the end of the war. Many thousands of tons of that grain storage can be put to the very excellent use of storing barley which can supplant our imports of maize.

Our barley trade can be improved but there is only one way in which the Minister can do it. He has subscribed towards it very fully by the introduction of the contract system. At the moment the system does not embrace all our barley, but we hope that will be possible in the years to come. A contract system in malt and barley is possible because one firm buys three-quarters of our entire output. Many firms buy maize. What is wrong with a firm in Monaghan about which I can speak using up to 20 tons of maize per day, which is approximately 6,000 tons per year, making an arrangement, if overdrafts could be guaranteed, with a firm in Ardee which can store 60,000 barrels of grain, to supply 6,000 tons of feeding barley during the year? The difficulties in the way of such an arrangement are that the overdraft must inevitably be guaranteed.

Otherwise we hand over to men who are at the top of their business and these men will be left with the monopoly and with the right to say what we want. If the Minister can guarantee the overdraft and suggest a means as to how such an arrangement can be implemented, there is no reason why that maize should come from Dublin port but from Louth, having been produced in Monaghan which at the moment uses much more than it produces. I know that there are difficulties, but no man can tell what the price of maize will be in the months to come. This 60,000 tons of maize is but one little economy; there could be hundreds of these economies, certainly tens of them. There would be a certain gamble because of the uncertainty as to whether maize in the world market would drop or rise in the following month. That is a problem which must be met either by arrangement with the trade or by the trade taking up a contract system. If the Minister induces the trade to take up a contract system he will have made a contribution to agriculture which will live long after him.

The Minister is to introduce a Bill in the very near future called the Seed Production Bill. I think it is long overdue and, while speaking on the Estimate for Agriculture, I think it is not out of order to suggest that when introducing the Bill he should refer to the delay and say that he will get for the farmer the extra profit which is his due. All over the world a system has been introduced in places where the geographical position of areas means that they are suitable for the production of seed—where, in a peninsula, pollination cannot take place. The same applies to where mountain ranges occur. I can think of one such area which would suit the production of corn seeds—the Coolea Peninsula— where we have 470 farmers with average holdings of ten statute acres. These farmers do not use the combine harvesters because their fields are too small. They have not got economic holdings. They are excellent men who farm in the traditional manner and produce grain of high quality which they market for seed. From this area could come all the seed that this country needs. From it could come pedigree seed of a very high quality.

Speaking very seriously, I believe that this Seed Production Bill may mean one of the biggest things in agriculture we have had so far. The present Minister is the first Minister for Agriculture who did make the farmers realise by his publicity campaign the value of the use of fertilisers and of ground limestone. Before he became Minister there was no ground limestone and a week ago the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Flanagan, was able to make a statement that 810,000 tons of ground limestone were used last year. That is a very happy position. It is a still happier position to realise that we have 49 plants this year capable of producing 1,500,000 tons of ground limestone and that our output per acre should improve proportionately. We are not a rich nation. We have to spend here at the moment £10 per male employed on the land per year. Can you get any male employee who is satisfied with a potential increase in his income of £10? The only way we can better that is by the use of ground limestone, by the eradication of bovine tuberculosis and by participation in all the other such schemes introduced by the Minister. A nitrogen factory is to be built. This factory should not be centralised in Dublin but should be established in some central position within easy reach of the grain growing counties.

We have an awful lot to do yet. I notice in the Irish Farmers' Journal of January 14th, 1955, an article stating that the Dutch Government has built a pilot plant to make potash from seawater. That may seem far-flung to attempt but it gives us an idea of the potential that is there and suggests that we must follow up these potentials in all parts of the world. But the first and last law the Minister for Agriculture must follow is that we have not got the money to give a direct subsidy for every person engaged in agriculture. And when we do subsidise such products as ground limestone and fertilisers we must ensure that when we spend a pound we may get £3 back. Our wealth is in the land and in the land alone.

With regard to pigs and pig progeny testing, on Wednesday, 20th April, 1955, I addressed a question to the Minister for Agriculture asking him to state the comparative consumption of meals per lb. of live weight gain of the Large White and Landrace breed of pigs. I could not get a list of the type of pigs generally used in this country but I am concerned that the type used should compare favourably with any pig in any part of the world, and I want the Minister to say that we are on our way to getting it as quickly as possible. I have been very interested in this matter and in the Irish Farmers' Journal of Saturday, 19th February, 1955, there is a report of a letter addressed by Professor Helmar Clausen, director of pig progeny testing in Denmark, to a British farming paper. Dr. Clausen stated that there are only two pedigree Large White herds left in Denmark and said that the Large White pig in Britain could be brought up to the level of the Danish Landrace by seven years' progeny testing. We are now to have a progeny testing station and we hope that the results from it and the stock which will eventually emerge from it will improve two things—our rate of conversion and the consumption per lb. of meal.

Doctor Clausen is recognised as the expert on the continent on pig progeny testing and we shall see what he had to say, as reported in the paper mentioned. Under the heading of Landrace conversion Doctor Clausen states:

"There are only two pedigree Large White herds left in Denmark. Although the Large White has had the same progeny testing facilities as the Landrace for the past 50 years, the carcase quality from the pedigree Large White herds has been lower than the carcase quality of all commercial pigs in Denmark for the past ten years."

Doctor Clausen emphasises that there is very little relationship between show ring judging and commercial qualities in pigs. Examination of live pigs has, however, some part to play in such matters as determining the number of teats on an animal, determining the soundness of the visual parts of the reproductory organs and in getting an idea of the constitution of the pig. He goes on to say that in Copenhagen Zoo they found a wild pig and in seven years they succeeded in bringing that pig up to standard by crossing him with a Landrace to the point where the pig had the same conversion rate as the Landrace which had been bred over 50 years before.

His opinion is that the Large White will not give the same quick results. In an issue of the Irish Farmers' Journal of Saturday November 21st, 1953, there is a table of consumption of food per lb. of live-weight gain in pigs in Denmark through the years. In 1909-1910 a lb. of pig meat was produced for every 3.77 lb. of meals consumed; in 1919-1921 that figure was down to 3.59; in 1929-1930 it was down to 3.39; in 1939-40 it was down to 3.22; and in 1951-1952 it was down to 3.05. Approximately four years ago—I cannot say the exact year, but it was either 1950 or 1951—I heard Professor Senior read a paper to the Statistical Society in which he stated that in the Albert College the rate of conversion was 1 lb. of pig meat to every 3.8 lb. of meal fed. Now the comparison there with 1951-1952 is 3.05. That may seem small, but it really means that to get the same amount of pig meat the Irish farmer has to feed one ton of meal for every 16¼ cwt. that the Danish farmer has to feed.

I understand that pig production has reached a stage where, if one goes in for pig production, one does not think of 20 or 40 pigs but one thinks in terms of 100, 200 or 1,000 pigs and one computes one's profit at the rate of £1 or 10/- per pig. If the Danish and the Dutch farmer are in the happy position that they have only got to feed 16 cwt. of meal for every ton we feed, is it not true they can cut our price on the British market?

It is true that the very serious veterinary objections which the Minister mentioned in his reply to my question are there. The British Ministry excluded the Landrace. As I said, I hold no brief for the Landrace. The British excluded the Landrace for a period because one pig in a particular shipment was found to be suffering from rhinitis. After a period they allowed them in and there has been no trouble since. I think with very, very careful supervision foundation stocks from any part of the world could be brought in here.

A very natural sequence of events followed on the prohibition of the Landrace from England. There was no prohibition in the Channel Islands and astute farmers in the Channel Islands built up herds of Landrace waiting for the time when the restriction on their import to Britain would cease and they could cash in. If it is the case that veterinary objections preclude us from taking in any pig from any part of the world, be it Large White, Landrace or anything else, which could be tested here and might possibly prove to be of better value than the pig we have, could we not bring a foundation stock to some island off the coast in order to carry out testing; that stock could be kept there in quarantine for any period of time, years if necessary? I make that suggestion to the Minister. I think possibly the Department of Agriculture, particularly the veterinary section of it, is a little bit stultified. Possibly the veterinary officers of the Department like to play safe; but if the farmers are going to be forced out of pig production, they cannot afford to play safe. I think extreme measures are possibly necessary and the Minister should turn the problem over in his mind and examine it very, very carefully.

Yesterday the Minister referred to a letter of Deputy de Valera's on the parish plan in which Deputy de Valera said that he had nothing against the parish plan. Why, then, did he not implement that plan from 1951 to 1954? Why was it jettisoned? The cheapest commodity in the world to-day is knowledge and education. The cheapest commodity that can be bought is knowledge. If we have to acquire knowledge in the hard field of experience we dissipate our lives and finances in doing so. If we can get it by contact with those who are experts, then we are fortunate indeed.

The unit in this country will always be the parish. If for every three parishes there is one expert available to the farming community, surely we will have made a step forward. I could not care less whether these experts are attached to the Department of Agriculture or to the county committees. Whatever they are attached to, their knowledge will be passed on without bias. Anybody who tries to come between the parish plan and the Irish farmer will be crushed inevitably. I believe the plan will be successful. I appeal to everyone not to detract in any way from what is at the present moment only a blueprint. Mistakes will be made. It will be the duty of the Deputies here to tell the Minister of those mistakes in order to have them rectified. We cannot tell the Minister in advance what mistakes will be made since he has more knowledge at his disposal than we have.

I said at the outset that the only way in which we can stimulate agriculture is by subsidy and encouragement in connection with those things which reproduce themselves. I note in the Estimates a figure of £2,900,000 for land reclamation. There never would have been land reclamation, notwithstanding Marshall Aid, had Deputy James Dillon not been Minister for Agriculture in the years 1948-1951 because there is not the slightest shadow of a doubt that, had the Fianna Fáil Government been in office, Deputy Lemass would have collared all that for industry and commerce. Fortunately Marshall Aid was injected into agriculture and, as a result, we are more prosperous to-day than we would otherwise have been.

Any sane, thinking man knows that what I say is true. The lime subsidy this year will cost £600,000. According to the Parliamentary Secretary's figure, it will probably cost more. I hope it will cost twice as much. No one is responsible for that lime subsidy but Deputy James Dillon, Minister for Agriculture. As far back as the 1930's the Fianna Fáil Party had the advantage of experiments in the use of ground limestone. For 17 years they sat, stagnant, in their benches and refused to give the Irish farmers anything except the price of a calf skin.

The present Minister has been maligned in the last hour by the Opposition. He has been described as the Minister for Grass. An attempt was made by his predecessor to show that we are more interested in the production of cattle through grass rather than from corn. Why then did the present Opposition when they were in Government not put through this House the Grain Storage (Loans) Act, which was passed by the inter-Party Government in 1951, and which gave the Irish farmer an opportunity of marketing his grain. You did not do it because you had no interest in anything but votes and subsidies. Since that Grain Storage Loans Act was introduced, a figure of £1,100,000 has been injected into it and that means that there is 100,000 tons more storage for Irish grain than there was at the end of the war and at the end of 17 years of your administration. If that is the Minister for Grass I would like to hear the reason why he is Minister for Grass. If he wants 100,000 tons more of Irish grain, then surely he is Minister for Corn and Minister for the Irish farmer.

I should like to congratulate the Minister on his very opportune and— shall we say?—certainly delayed beginning of the eradication of bovine tuberculosis scheme. We are behind in this matter. The countries of Canada, America, Holland and of England are far ahead. This is a country which is producing quality beef. We must, therefore, work for the English market and if we do not we must go to the wall. The bovine tuberculosis scheme will certainly prove again that the Minister for Agriculture is the only man who can put Ireland on its feet.

With regard to cattle, I heard the previous Minister for Agriculture state that Britain needed from 200,000 to 250,000 tons of beef per year. The figure Mr. W.A. Smith, a famous agriculturist, gives is 275,000 tons of beef as the requirement of the British market. Irish-bred beef is getting a premium for quality and Irish beef must, therefore, rely on quality. We are getting a quality price for a quality product, and if we are, we must put it up. Therefore, the prudent choice of the Minister for Agriculture, as mentioned in his statement yesterday, that we must all place our confidence in the Shorthorn cow is indeed most certainly a wise one. I, like the Minister, have a couple of Friesians and I, like the Minister, would like Deputy Moher to come along and buy the bull calves.

If we are to export quality beef— and here again I may get derisive howls from the Fianna Fáil Benches— I would like to ask the Minister for Agriculture to impress on the Minister for Lands that the fattening lands of County Meath are one of the most valuable assets that we have. Every factory in this country has a finishing shop. It would be as silly for a boot factory to close its finishing shop and sell all its production as seconds as it would be for us to divide or dissipate or in any other way touch the fattening lands of Meath and Kildare. They must be there to fatten cattle that cannot be fattened on the land. I can tell of a farmer in County Louth who has one field of 11 acres and it is worth more to that farmer than half his farm —and he has a very extensive farm— because every beast that passes through his hands goes through that field at some time. In that field the grass grows for a month longer in the autumn and comes a month earlier in the spring. That is an asset, and there are many of those assets. I would appeal to the Minister to make representations in any way he likes to the Minister for Lands to make sure that these are not touched.

With the end of the bulk-buying period, the British housewife, as I said, has her choice. I believe, in the trade, that if it were possible for the prices to be available to be announced in November for the following year instead of March it would give the farmer—who is really buying ahead when he buys his stores—a very great guarantee of profit. Our production of beef is something I cannot compare with the production in England and Scotland, but I would imagine we are quite a sizable producer for the British market and perhaps it would be possible for the Minister to make representations also to the British Minister of Food that the prices should be announced months earlier if that is possible.

I am proud to stand behind the Minister for Agriculture, and that is because I know why he places his faith in the land of Ireland—because his family has suffered for the land of Ireland. I know that not two miles from where I live the present Minister for Agriculture's father was arrested and apprehended for telling the farmers that they were paying too high a rent and that they could not leave their land in the autumn better than they found it in the spring if they continued to do so. The best way out was not to pay their rents and see what would happen.

The late John Dillon received six months in Dundalk jail for that speech and I am proud to say in my parish there were 20 men to walk 20 miles behind the jail cart to the town of Dundalk and 20 men to meet him outside the jail when he came out after six months. I know then why the Minister for Agriculture places all his faith in the land, because it is only from the land of this country we get reproduction and multiplication of our assets and finances. I would like to ask him to redouble his efforts for the land of Ireland and if he does, then, surely he will redouble his efforts for all the people of this country.

Comment on this

I want to preface my remarks by saying that unlike Deputy Donegan, I do not want to be a cheer-boy of the Minister for Agriculture or any ex-Minister and any views which I put to the House are views which I have studied and am convinced are correct. I want to say at the outset and I want to remind every farmer Deputy on the opposite benches that, fundamentally, everything we have got here in the form of live stock has been imported from Great Britain and we have adopted the extraordinary notion that the best stud farm in the world is across the Channel. That is to my mind a dominating fallacy in everything that has been put forward not alone from the benches opposite but from some of my colleagues on the benches here. There is no unanimity. We should once and for all remove from our minds the fallacy that the best stud farm is the one in Great Britain. It has been proven to us within the past ten or 15 years that is not the case, but we still refuse to accept the evidence which has been so plentifully offered to us.

We have a habit here of importing an alien and wrapping the green flag round it, putting it into a shrine and then going down on our knees and worshipping it as the best in the world. That is the mistake I think that is being made. We in this country if we did not suffer from that inherent inferiority complex would or should examine everything objectively and see where we should go to find what by facts and figures is. or has been proven to be, the best in anything in the form of live stock that we would import to improve our foundation stock in this country.

Before I go into anything in detail I would like generally to refer to the statements made by the Minister in his opening speech. In regard to the particular note on which he opened, he did not give me the impression that 42 inches of rainfall was an advantage to us. He seemed to think that those people who had half that rainfall were in an advantageous position. I hope that I did not interpret his statement incorrectly but if I am correct he seemed to imply that there was a definite disadvantage in our having here an average rainfall of 42 inches. The very opposite, of course, is the case.

Comment on this

Did he not say that other countries would be glad to have the same?

Comment on this

I may have interpreted him incorrectly. However, I can discuss the matter from the angle that we agree that 42 inches of rainfall on an average is a decided advantage. Thinking in terms of grass we must think also in terms of grass as a commodity when measured against the uses made of it and the advantages that our competitors have in the same field. I maintain that with that 42 inches of rainfall we have an advantage over the New Zealander. The New Zealander may have a milder winter and he may be able to reduce labour costs by avoiding the housing of cattle in winter. But let us not forget that in a country where such enormous strides have been made in the production of grass, and that in a scientific way, the New Zealander is exposed to one serious impediment that would not naturally affect us.

The New Zealander is subjected to recurrent droughts, a calamity in many instances because you can well realise that treating grass as they do, as a crop, and not as a gift from God or an accident of nature as we do, to them grass is a highly scientific crop and a comparatively expensive one. In a drought they are apt to lose very considerably in having their swards turned into a brown turf. That is one of the technical advantages which we would have, had we given down through the years the attention to grass that the New Zealanders have given. Then again we have the technical advantage that their main market is something like 14,000 miles away while ours is within 50 or 60 miles. These are advantages which we could use from the competitive angle and if we adopted the same technique as they have in the matter of grass production we could outbid them at any time.

Then you have people who say the natural fertility of the soil in New Zealand is greater than the general fertility of the soil of Ireland. That in itself is an absolute fallacy and anybody who has read Dr. Holmes's report on conditions in New Zealand will readily realise that we have here again a decided advantage over the New Zealander. In his report here in 1948 he summarised the matter in one sentence when he said: "The best land in the country is growing physically as little as it is possible for it to do under an Irish sky." I believe in that one sentence he summarised the position here. He summarised basically and fundamentally the snag from which we suffer, the big impediment which has kept us out of the competitive world in so many fields.

Before I leave making the comparison between this country and New Zealand let me quote what he said in his book on New Zealand soils.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

I am quoting an extract from a report in 1948 on New Zealand soils by Dr. Holmes. It is an excerpt which I used at column 998, Volume 146, of the Official Debates of 1st July, 1954:—

"The soils for the most part are poor, light sands or gravels or stiff clay, deficient in lime and phosphate. Their fertile seeming surface is due to hard toil and scientific treatment by which the farmers have sought to improve them."

Therefore, we can see that not all the advantages are on the side of the New Zealander. We can see we have climatic and physical advantages and proximity to the main market which are major factors from the competitive angle as between ourselves and the New Zealanders but we suffer from having failed to develop their techniques in the production of grass and in the testing of soil developed a good many years ago.

We have not yet scratched the surface. Actually in this State facilities for the development of the technique of grass production are very limited. Somebody from the opposite side may say to me: "Did you ever hear of Johnstown Castle?" Of course, I did, but that is only scratching the surface of the problem. It is a very wide problem, one which requires regional examination and what might be suitable at Johnstown may not be suitable generally in the country. The problem requires a very exhaustive study which has not been made so far, with the result that we are in this disadvantageous position in the matter of competing with any grass product on the English market.

Besides the enormous exports of dairy products, the New Zealanders have developed the technique of allowing sheep as followers on their cattle and cow grazing lands and it might surprise Deputies opposite to know that last year they exported to Great Britain some 12,000,000 sheep carcases in addition to the enormous amount of dairy products exported from that country.

Our Department of Agriculture might examine the potentialities for the increased export of mutton to Great Britain. Our seasons are opposite to those of New Zealand—their summer season, in which they might export the bulk of their mutton, is opposite to ours, so we might come in to fill a substantial gap which remains in the imports of mutton from New Zealand to the British market.

On their sheep farms they carry something like eight ewes and their lambs to the acre. In an experiment recently in three mixed farms, the following interesting figures were produced. The three mixed farms in that recent experiment produced as follows per acre per year. No. 1, a mixed farm, produced 142 lb. of lamb and 110 lb. of beef, giving a total meat output per acre of 259 lb. On the second farm, they produced 215 lb. of lamb and 44 lb. of beef, giving a total output of 259 lb. of meat per acre. On the third farm, which was exclusively a sheep farm, they produced 254 lb. of mutton. One of the striking features of that table is the resemblance between the gross output in each of the three tests—you have 259 lb. each on the farms where beef and mutton were carried as mixed live stock, and where sheep were carried exclusively you have 254 lb., just a variation of 5 lb. In addition to that, on the first two farms there were 43 lb. and 61 lb. of wool, respectively, and 80 lb. on the farm that was exclusively a sheep farm.

Comment on this

Is it not a bad country to make a comparison with?

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this

We have so different a climate and every other condition is different.

Comment on this

We have the advantage in climate. When I started off I prefaced my remarks, before making comparisons, by giving to the House the advantages which we have over the New Zealander. I will summarise them again. First of all, there are the repeated droughts which have, in a number of seasons, created devastation amongst their scientifically produced grasses. We are not subject to that. Another disadvantage is the distance they are from their main market —14,000 miles. We have this market here on our doorstep. All the advantages are on our side, if we were to adopt methods as scientific and as progressive as they have. Again, the inherent fertility of Irish soil is far superior to that of New Zealand. Most of the New Zealand wool and mutton is produced on the farms on the foothills. We have done nothing whatever to develop our marginal land from a scientific angle to produce mutton and wool.

Comment on this

They have much milder winters. They have not to house their stock at all in New Zealand.

Comment on this

I mentioned that point. That is one of their advantages. All they do in the winter is strap a rope on each of their animals and allow them to roam around. That is the only disadvantage we have, if we were to develop a technique that would put us on a competitive comparison with them.

The Minister when speaking yesterday gave what I consider a rather belated warning on the position that we face in regard to the competitive market in England. We need not have waited until yesterday to realise that ultimately we would have to face competition and that the easy going of the post-war period was bound to end. It ended long ago in the matter of dairy products. Every Deputy is aware that there was a time when we could sell all the cheese we could produce here, when we could sell all the milk powder we could produce; but for quite a long time we are out, out because we failed to compete, when normal conditions began to return and normal channels of supply were resumed in England. We were there merely to supply a pro tem need and when normal conditions returned we had to gather up our impedimenta and clear out. I have said here before that if you fail to compete in one dairy product you fail to compete in every one, you are out for all the others.

Comment on this

Were the New Zealand farmers subjected to the tyranny of Irish landlordism, which was the worst in the world?

Comment on this

I would love to sit down outside this House and have an historical review with Deputy Madden, but I am afraid the Ceann Comhairle would not permit me to develop that particular thesis now. We are out for cheese and for powdered milk and we are threatened in the chocolate crumb market. The British at the moment are producing something like 400,000,000 gallons of milk surplus to their normal liquid requirements. Within the past year and a half they have erected five large chocolate crumb factories. They have purchased on the island of Anglesey a particular creamery with an annual intake of 6,000,000 gallons. They are compelled to sell any milk in excess of their liquid requirements at 1/8 a gallon and you can be certain they will produce from that milk the product which is the most profitable—and that product we know to be chocolate crumb. They will not produce butter, because generally—there may be times when it is not—butter is one of the most depressed products into which you can manufacture milk.

There was an appeal by the Minister to farmers to reduce the cost of production. That was the appeal, but there is a question which we all can answer. I believe the Irish farmer is as ingenious and as hard-working as any farmer in the world, but he is entitled to ask one thing: "Give us the competitive tools and we will do it." He is entitled to ask that. That is the only way he can do it. If he has not got a conversion unit comparable with out competitors, then do not blame him if he is not able to compete.

In my speech on this Estimate last year I was subjected to what one might call an inquisition by the Minister for Agriculture. I am glad to say that, in his reply, he was gracious enough to pay me a tribute, for if I had expounded a certain thesis I was prepared to defend it. So far as agriculture is concerned, I have not the slightest intention of being a cheer boy to any particular individual in this House. When I come here I propose to say what I believe to be true.

I think that if we had from all sides of the House the same approach we might, together, do something that would fundamentally change the structure of Irish agriculture. We might do something that would return us to that competitive place in the dairying world which we held many years ago and from which we are now hurled. I would never be the one to come here and preach defeatism and say that there is no road back. I will have the honour to disagree with some of the statements made by the Minister for Agriculture before I sit down—not because I am speaking from this side of the House but because I believe that some of the statements he made are a fallacy and a heresy.

When we speak of grass one of the points one must put to oneself is, of course, that if we produce more grass we must have something to eat it. If we adopt the grass technique it should be co-ordinated with the development of and the increase in our live stock. There would be no use in our introducing an improved grass technique without, at the same time, increasing the number of animals we could set out on it.

The Minister and other Deputies have spoken about extending the beef industry, about going in and taking that red meat deficit which is there for the taking in Great Britain. Do we not know that we cannot have an extended beef industry without, at the same time, having an extended dairying industry? Does the one thing not hinge on the other? If we have, roughly, 1,250,000 cows, and if we can produce the maximum number of calves from this 1,250,000 cows do we not know that is the limit and that we cannot have an increased beef industry without an extended dairying industry? If we follow the general pattern which is being set in this country of the grazier in the flatlands and the midlands waiting for the calf as the by-product of the dairying industry then we cannot have an extended beef industry with-cut having an extended dairying industry. The one thing hinges on the other and if you argue anything else then you are arguing in terms that are contradictory.

I do not know whether the Minister repeated it in this House but recently he made a speech in which he suggested that it would be wise for us to suckle some of our calves to dairy cows. With that, again, I thoroughly disagree. Remember, if the small farmer in the South took the Minister's advice and decided to suckle some of his calves under his dairy cows it would automatically reduce the number of calves going into the grazing areas. Do Deputies not see what would happen? There is no use in our talking about introducing a better grass technique if, for instance, the farmers in my area of east Cork decided to put four or five cows on their holdings to be suckled by calves. It would automatically reduce the number of calves going out of the dairying areas and that would be reflected in the number of stores available to the grazing areas.

If the Minister said: "If you want to increase the number of live stock, if you want to increase our gross output in beef, then my advice to the people on the grazing lands is to suckle the pure beef calf under the pure beef cow," they would not do it. A farmer in the North Dublin area once said to me: "You could not do that on my land. My land is too good. I would not waste my land doing a thing like that. Anyway, I cannot. Young cattle under a year old do not thrive there." A question which posed itself to me immediately in regard to that particular farmer's statement was whether, despite all his praise of his land, the land was suffering from mineral deficiency. We know that animals under a certain age will not survive on lands that are deficient in minerals.

We also know that animals beyond a certain age will thrive on lands where there are certain mineral deficiencies. I submit that the Minister's suggestion was prompted by the statement I made from these benches last year that any Minister for Agriculture would regard an excess of dairy products as something radioactive in his Department. The Minister did not want any fissionable material in his Department. I submit he made the suggestion in the hope that a certain amount of milk would be consumed in the dairying areas in producing that type of calf.

There is another reason why I should nail such a suggestion on the spot. You cannot have a beef economy based on small farmers. You can only have a mixed farming and dairying economy on the small farm and the reasonably comparative figures between the income per acre from milk and beef—these are approximations which could be worked out much more closely, but it will be found that I am not far wrong—are that milk will give roughly £33 per acre and beef, even at to-day's high prices, an average of something like £18 per acre. That is why the small man cannot survive as a beef rancher. You cannot survive as a beef rancher unless you have the broad acres.

Yesterday the only intervention I made was when the Minister was enunciating some of his live-stock theories. He did ask me whether I do this and whether I do that, and I made a promise then that, when I came to speak, I would deal with the interjection I made in a detailed and exhaustive way and in a far more satisfactory way than I could deal with it by way of interjection or interruption during the Minister's speech. I want to say that the Minister is one of the greatest live-stock heretics in the country, and he is a wilful heretic, in that he enunciates a belief without producing any concrete evidence to prove it. If I were to get up on this side, I could "blah" back in the very same way and we would still get nowhere. I do not know who would be impressed in the end, but the Minister's rhetorical ability might come out on top. Stripped of his rhetorical gymnastics, however, the only way I can endeavour to compete with him——

Comment on this

I thought there would be a sting in the tail of that.

Comment on this

——is by producing factual evidence. I heard the Minister in University College, Dublin a year ago last December, getting away with what I deemed to be red murder. To the person who thinks in terms not of rhetoric but of mathematics, it was red murder, and 500 or 600 students at the back cheered him to the echo. He made one glowing statement after another about dairy Shorthorns and about the brown boots, navy blue suits and fedora hats of the farmers' sons. He was cheered to the echo.

Comment on this

Nach raibh an ceart agam?

Comment on this

He sent them roving through the country, not in Prefects but in A.40's and Somersets and he left the hall amidst the applause of the audience. I hand it to the Minister, not so much as a person who came in to argue factually, but as a performer, and I said, when speaking about it the following day, that if James Dillon was never Minister for Agriculture, he could find a place any day on the stage.

Stripped of all the rhetoric and all the rhetorical gymnastics, his speech yesterday might be summarised as saying to poor old Cait Ni Houlihan: "Keep on the black." That is the substance of what he said. Gone are the days of that second flood. We will drown them in eggs, he said; we will smother them with bacon; and we will choke them with butter.

Comment on this

I do not recollect ever saying any such thing.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

I often heard you say I said it.

Comment on this

The worst of it is that the thing has recoiled like a boomerang on us and to-day the farmers are in the unfortunate position that they find themselves plastered with eggs, scalded in bacon fat and floating in butter fat. That is the position we find ourselves in to-day. The Minister was entitled to his little political frolic, but one of the things with which I disagree is that, on such an important Estimate — the foremost Minister in this country, no matter what place convention gives him in the Cabinet, is the Minister for Agriculture, because he is the Minister who directs the country's basic industry and the Minister on whose success or failure the whole economic structure of the country survives or crumbles—the Minister should come in here and use the occasion of the making of his statement on such an important matter as the Estimate for his Department as a political score-off on his opponents. It is bad form. For that reason, I do not want to do or say anything which I have already condemned, but I do want to say that, in making his comparison, the Minister cited the worst weather year in a half century. He quoted the year 1948, but he forgot one thing, that Irish agriculture had gone through a telling time——

Comment on this

Sixteen years of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

——between 1939 and 1945. He forgot to mention that the farmers had dissipated the only real wealth they owned, the accumulated fertility of their soil.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They dissipated that fertility in feeding the non-agricultural sections of our community. Everyone will agree that, in the main, they unselfishly and magnanimously dissipated that reserve to provide food for the non-agricultural sections and to make us the best-fed people in Europe. If, in 1948, we did not have the production figures which we could have this year or last year, the main and fundamental reason was that we had dissipated the accumulated reserves in our soil for the common good.

When the Minister referred to breeds I was confused by his statement and I will possibly clear my rather impregnable cranium when I have an opportunity of reading his speech in the Official Report. But one of the things that we need never be afraid of, no matter what our foundation stock is, is the Hereford or Aberdeen Angus, because these are two breeds that continually colour mark, and you cannot mongrelise those two breeds. We have to accept the idea that our farmers are mature and intelligent, and we cannot make statements implying that the use of the Aberdeen Angus and Hereford bulls would ruin our foundation stock. Any farmer has the means available to him of preserving the foundation stock, no matter what that stock is, because if there are Friesians in some of our artificial insemination stations, there are always Shorthorn bulls there.

I do not claim that I am an authority, but I do claim that I have normal powers of observation. My association with farmers and farming is such as to make me believe that the farmers are intelligent enough not to be treated by people who look down their noses and speak about them as if they were subnormal or imbeciles. Any dairy farmer in this country will do one thing if he is wise, he will produce his own replacements, because it is the only guarantee he has against his stock being completely wiped out by the scourge of abortion. You show me any farmer who has made a habit of going to the fairs and purchasing his replacements. One of the things you can be certain of is that he will do it until he has been taught his lesson, and he will be scourged off the face of the earth by that awful disease, contagious abortion.

Let us assume that our dairy farmers are intelligent enough to produce, no matter what their foundation stock is, their own replacements. The facilities are available now at the artificial insemination stations. There is no use in trying to confuse the issue, and talking about mongrelising a breed by the use of Aberdeen Angus and Hereford bulls, because we have the advantage that they are breeds that colour mark.

Let me issue one warning to the Minister: the greatest crime ever committed against the foundation stock of this country, and which is still being perpetuated, was the introduction of the Scotch beef bull. That wretched animal ruined our dairy herds because that was one breed which did not colour mark. We had unscrupulous individuals in this country who brought these Scotch beef bulls into the dairying areas, mated them with Shorthorns and went to the fairs and sold their progeny in-calf to honest-to-god dairymen. That is a breed of cattle that the Minister should outlaw. That is one breed which has done most damage to the foundation stock, to the Irish dairy Shorthorn. I say these things from my own experience.

When Deputy Smith was Minister for Agriculture, I wrote a letter to him pointing out the danger and the devastation created by this Scotch beef bull in the dairying areas.

Comment on this

I am sure you got a very civil reply.

Comment on this

I did. I can at least claim that I was partly responsible for the withdrawal of the Scotch beef bulls from the dairying areas, but one of the first actions of the present Minister for Agriculture, when he went into office, was to sign a document on the dotted line for the return of the Scotch beef bull. He now talks about mongrelising breeds. Let us be clear on that, let us agree on that, let us not listen to the vested interests. If we have an interest in preserving the dairy Shorthorn stock, let us get rid of the Scotch beef bull.

When I spoke on the Minister's Estimate last year I spoke at considerable length. I produced a considerable amount of data, and made available, and placed on the record, the comparative yields and the comparative features of certain breeds of cattle. I am not going to be tempted to repeat the same thing in my contribution this year. I emphasise that I made available to the record and to this House a wealth of data discrediting in the main, the shorthorn cow as a dairy animal. To-night, in this House, I am going to produce conclusive evidence, apart from the very loose statements and blah which will discredit the dairy shorthorn even as a beef animal. When I have done that, we will have got rid of this phantom, once and for all. I have discredited it in last year's report. I would like anyone who should examine what I am going to say now, to examine it against the background of what I said last year, otherwise I might be tempted to repeat what I said last year, and subject the House to what might be an endurance test. I have not the slightest intention of doing that. I thoroughly disagree with all this howling and shouting and clamour about the dual purpose Shorthorn. The Minister there is a heretic amongst heathens, and a proselytiser amongst believers.

I give my views without reference to anybody, but I must, in speaking in this debate, address myself to the opening speech of the Minister. I propose to give my views, and to produce facts and figures to substantiate them. I will not try to get away with it, because I am not such a good performer as to get away with oratorical blah. Where I fail in my rhetorical set up I have to fall back, to supplement it, by my knowledge of mathematics.

Comment on this

You are doing nicely.

Comment on this

When I was speaking last year, I set out to prove that we had not or could not get in England a Shorthorn blood that we could ever hope would put us in the position of producing a competitive dairy cow. I can only repeat a table which I gave on that particular occasion. It was a report of the progeny tested by the British Milk Marketing Board. The number of pedigree bulls surveyed in the case of the Friesian breed was 3,281; bulls whose daughters averaged over 350 lb. of butter fat, 621, or 19 per cent. ; bulls whose daughters averaged over 400 lb. of butter fat, 141, or 4.9 per cent. Dairy Shorthorns: numbers of bulls surveyed, 2,140; number of bulls whose daughters averaged over 350 lb. of butter fat, 23, or 1 per cent.: number of daughters with average of 400 lb. butter fat, 2, or .01 per cent. Jersey: 962 bulls producing 159 daughters with an average of over 350 lb. butter fat, or 16.5 per cent. ; and with daughters over 400 lb. of butter fat, 65 or 6.7 per cent.

These figures would seem to prove that even in England, the fount of our supply of dairy Shorthorn bulls, there is not available a bull which would put us on a competitive basis or give us a cow that would be competitive from the dairy angle. Last year, I argued and produced data to show the superiority of the Dutch Friesian. I specifically and intentionally mentioned the words "Dutch Friesian" because we know that the British Friesian was developed without any reference to contour. We know that they thought only in terms of producing the maximum amount of milk. We know that they ended up with an animal that carried a very high maintenance which was a loose, badly shaped, ramshackle cow.

We know that to improve that breed they started some years ago by importing into Great Britain a number of Dutch Friesian bulls with certain genetical features that might in the main be used to repair the defects that are general in the Friesian breed in England.

Yesterday, the Minister spoke about the Friesians in England and used a phrase which I cannot recollect. I do not know the phrase but if the Minister gives it to me I will repeat it. I do not know what the Minister called them. In any event it was not very complimentary. Deputy Donegan, being the cheer boy of the Minister, said he had a few more Friesian bullocks which he staggered and straddled around the place. All those statements are loose statements. The Minister referred me to the cattle people. Why should I go to the vested interests to look for confirmation or denial of anything when you have facts produced without prejudice to any breed, facts which are produced and correlated on the performance and merit of the respective breeds tried out.

In my contribution to this debate last year I produced ample evidence to prove the superiority of the Friesian as a milker. I will now produce some evidence to prove the superiority of the Friesian as a store animal. The Minister is aware and any person who has made a study of the subject or who has gone after the facts will be aware that there are two outstanding surveys. There is nothing in this country that the Irish Department of Agriculture can produce by way of substantiation or refutation of any statement which is being made by any particular individual in regard to the beef qualities of any particular breed. Nothing has been done.

Yet we have responsible people going about the country—I am sure there are people who have done so on this side of the House as well—heretics amongst the heathens and proselytisers amongst the believers. That is the position.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh can put that in his pipe and smoke it.

Comment on this

So can the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh did not expect it but I expected it.

Comment on this

Deputy Walsh is entitled to his view but there seems to be on that side of the House a kind of inferiority complex about the infallibility of certain people on this side of the House. Immediately you pin-point a defect on that side of the House they say: "There is such a fellow on the other side." I am not concerned one way or another with that. I am concerned with producing facts and I welcome the opportunity of coming to this House to place on record some of the facts in refutation and repudiation of the blah we have been listening to.

I know there are people in my own Party whose outlook is purely parochial. It is no use for me to try to get the man in Kildare, Meath or Westmeath to accept my view but there are none so blind as those who will not see. There is no cure for invincible blindness. Those people will refuse to accepts facts and figures. They will accept the blah of the Minister for Agriculture. If he goes into any of those places and puts up another one of his performances it will be accepted in the main but where has it got us? As a performer, the Minister will be given the laurels but where has it got us? It has got us nowhere.

The Minister came in yesterday and quoted facts and figures. He quoted one figure after another. Plus, plus, plus. That is what we got. Remember that there is an O.E.E.C. report published recently. The accepted figure for the physical volume of our increase is something around 8 per cent. There is an O.E.E.C. report published recently which puts the average increase, even amongst the devastated countries in Europe, at 30 per cent. So I ask, have we any reason, have we any right, to be complacent? We have not. There is no use in any of us putting up stage shows or counter-shows. We will have to face the facts and we will have to do something fundamental to alter it.

Comment on this

What would you have us do?

Comment on this

Will the Minister allow me to proceed? By the time I have finished I hope I will have completed the picture to his satisfaction. I would remind the Minister that I am only a freshman in this House.

Comment on this

Go away out of that. You are a seasoned old practitioner.

Comment on this

I suffer from all the disabilities and disadvantages of not having taken the pulse of this House. I suffer from all the disadvantages of a new Deputy speaking in this House. Yet I have, and when I first came in here I did have, to face an inquisition by the Minister.

Comment on this

And sailed through it with your colours flying and your drums beating.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that he had invited in here Dr. John Hammond. I am terribly sorry that 25 years ago, poor and all as we were, we did not buy him in here. If we had we would be in a very different position from what we are to-day. When he does come, he will produce facts and figures and he will not accept blah. You will get facts and figures. I had the most extraordinary privilege of listening to Dr. Hammond on one particular occasion when he was invited by the dairy Shorthorn breeders. I do not know who invited him but, whoever did, committed a shocking faux pas, because for two hours he produced one chart after another, one set of figures after another, at the Dairy Shorthorn Breeders' Congress, and everything he produced was most devastating as far as the dairy Shorthorn was concerned.

On the same day I had two contrary experiences. I will never forget it. I listened to an economist talking on costings as a price-fixing medium and, having spoken for two hours and having subjected us all to the most shocking endurance test, he concluded by saying that if costings are to be used as a price-fixing medium then the price must be fixed at the lowest price on the costings index; otherwise you will put 50 per cent. of the people concerned in producing the particular commodity out of business. When he said that I turned to a newspaper reporter who was sitting beside me and said to him: "Will you head that ‘Premium on Inefficiency'?"

Dr. Hammond, as far back as 1946, made a statement which has echoed and re-echoed. I think I quoted it in this House last year. He said: "A cow, to be dual purpose to-day"— remember, that was in 1946—"must produce 1,000 gallons and at the same time a reasonably good steer." I doubt if he has altered his views since. I do not anticipate what his report to the Minister will be but I would like to know what the Minister's reaction will be when he will say to him, "A cow, to be a dual purpose to-day, must produce 1,000 gallons of milk and at the same time a reasonably good steer."

One of the things we do know is that there is not Shorthorn blood available which will give us that 1,000 gallons and at the same time a good steer. That is one of the things we know.

Comment on this

What was a dropped calf worth in 1946?

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to cavil we will have to go somewhere else. I want to proceed and to complete my speech before 10.30.

Comment on this

What hurry is on you?

Comment on this

I have set myself the formidable task of arguing the superiority of the Friesian bullock over the dual purpose Shorthorn.

Comment on this

Formidable is the word.

Comment on this

Wait now one minute. I am not going to use, by way of reply, some statement that I cannot substantiate. There are available, we know, two surveys which long ago discredited the dairy Shorthorn as a superior store. I spoke on this subject last year. I am not concerned about the milk yield any more because on that occasion I produced facts and figures to substantiate my arguments. The figures are available for anybody who wants to make a serious study of tests carried out over an extended period on various breeds of cattle. One of those tests has been going on for six years and is now almost completed and when the Minister meets Dr. Hammond let him ask him about the Brookes and Vincent survey which has been conducted on quite a number of cattle of different breeds under the supervision of somebody who is above question and above approach, namely, Dr. Hammond himself. Those figures are devastating as far as the dairy Shorthorn is concerned.

I would bring the survey into the House and I would attempt to analyse it if it were not for the difficulty of handling figures in a debate. One would need a blackboard and to produce charts and classifications. For that reason I avoided using the Brookes and Vincent Survey. The tests are carried out on varying planes of nutrition, a factor which would make it too complicated to use it for the purpose for which I would love to use it. There is also available something that is slightly easier to handle, that is, the results of a survey made on an experimental farm at Malton in Yorkshire.

That survey will stultify the Minister and will explode his cock-sureness about the dual-purpose Shorthorn as a milk animal and, in the main, as a beef animal. And that is all I am concerned with when speaking on this Estimate because I do not want to repeat or reiterate arguments I put forward in regard to comparative yields of different breeds of cattle from the dairying angle. Let me give the reference. The experiments were conducted in the experimental station in Malton in Yorkshire and a summary of the report is available to anybody who would go to the trouble of looking it up in the Survey of the British Association of Animal Production, 1954. You will get the survey in that. In the main, here are the comparative figures and I shall try, for the purpose of the record, to give them under different headings.

First of all, there is the breed or cross of cow. Then, No. 1 on the survey is the calf. No. 2 is the cost of feeding. No. 3, the cost of finishing on grass. No. 4 is the average income produced, and No. 5 gives the profit. I think myself that for the purpose of this debate this is a very comprehensive survey. In the case of the dairy Shorthorn calf we have first of all the price at £6 7s. 6d.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

£6 7s. 6d. I am quoting from the survey.

Comment on this

When was it made?

Comment on this

The Minister has not been listening.

Comment on this

What year was it made?

Comment on this

I shall have to go back again.

Comment on this

Roughly speaking.

Comment on this

The survey was published in the Survey of the British Society of Animal Production of 1954 so that you can assume that this survey goes on year after year.

Comment on this

So that these figures would probably relate to 1953 or early 1954?

Comment on this

Probably, or even before then. For the purpose of the survey, 12 of each of the breeds or crosses which I shall name were picked at random and were costed. I shall quote only the figures given and these, in the main, are relative. It does not matter what the cost is for the purpose of the survey, provided the costs of the calves are relative. Will the Minister agree there?

Comment on this

I should prefer to listen with attention to what the Deputy has to say.

Comment on this

For the purpose of the survey, if the price of the different breeds or crosses are relative it will not fundamentally alter the findings of the survey. The cost of the dairy Shorthorn calf was £6 7s. 6d. The cost of its feeding was £63 16s. 4d. The cost of finishing on grass was £2 15s. 4d. The average income produced was £76 15s. 10½d., and the profit was £4 0s. 11½d. That is item No 1.

The next taken was the Friesian. The cost of the calf was £4 10s. 10d, so you see the relative cost remains the same. The cost of feeding was the same at £63 16s. 4d. The cost of finishing on grass was also the same at £2 15s. 4d. The average income produced was £89 10s. 0½d. The profit was £18 7s. 6½d. Does that shake the Minister? In the case of the pure Hereford the cost of the calf was £6 13s. 10d. The cost of feeding was the same but there was a slight variation in the cost of finishing on grass which in this case was £2 13s. 10d The average income produced was £86 13s. 11½d. and the profit was £13 9s. 11½d.

In the case of the Hereford Shorthorn cross, and this is coming very near home, the cost of the calf was £6 8s. 8d. Feeding cost £63 16s. 4d. the same as in the other cases, finishing on grass was £2 15s. 4d., the average income produced was £88 6s. 8d. and the profit was reckoned at £15 6s. 4d. The Hereford Friesian cross calf cost £5 7s. 4d. The feeding cost £63 16s. 4d., the cost of finishing on grass was £2 13s. 8d., the average income produced was £88 6s. 4d. and the profit was £16 9s. 0d.

Twelve animals in each breed were taken and the conclusive result was that the Friesian brought a profit of £14 6s. 7d. more than the dairy Shorthorn. Make it up. Now here is a further table which should be of interest.

Comment on this

Might I interrupt the Deputy to ask if his thesis is that the Friesian is the ideal dual-purpose cow?

Comment on this

The Dutch Friesian. I argued last year that the Dutch Friesian cow was a superior animal to the Shorthorn as a milk animal. Now I am pursuing the other prong of the fork in quality and I am pursuing it by way of figures and saying that the Friesian—and this is not the Dutch Friesian—is a superior animal as a dual-purpose animal——

Comment on this

And it is no longer maintained that it is impossible to find milk and beef in the one hide.

Comment on this

That has been a bone of contention for years.

Comment on this

And the Deputy now abandons that thesis.

Comment on this

And a number of people much more competent than you or I and better informed on genetics have been in violent collision on the question of whether a cow should be a pure dairy animal or——

Comment on this

The Deputy is now proceeding to prove that the Friesian is a dual-purpose cow.

Comment on this

I am not. Dr. Hammond in 1946, put forward a theory about the dual-purpose animal. The dairy cow, I would argue, is the 1,600 or 1,800 gallon cow, and I would be very slow to say that that rim-racker would produce good stores. If you study even the first-class dairy Shorthorn, one of the things you suspect immediately and one of the things of which you are afraid is whether or not that animal will produce a good store. Here you have not alone my word for it, but you have the facts and figures produced by an impartial examining body.

There is one factor into which the survey is only examining at the moment, and that is grading. Grading is an important factor but, remember, we have the figures of profit, and those are much more conclusive than any new statements made as against one breed or another. I have here a table showing average weights and ages at maturity.

Comment on this

The Deputy will, I hope, excuse me if I interrupt. What is the Deputy trying to prove? I want to understand his argument. Is he arguing in favour of the Friesian? Is his argument that, by and large, the Friesian is the nearest approach there is to a dual-purpose cow?

Comment on this

The Friesian is one breed, and I will produce evidence to prove this, which is superior to the dairy Shorthorn as a dual-purpose cow, as distinct from a purely dairy animal.

Comment on this

It is possible, then, to get a dual-purpose cow, and the Friesian is the best?

Comment on this

Yes, and the figures I am producing are good enough, I think, to clinch the argument. Next year, if the Minister and I are still above the ground, I will not have the slightest hesitation in coming in here and producing all the available data I can get to show the merits of the Red Dane as a dual-purpose cow. One of the things I have noticed when examining the available statistics is that the Red Dane has a lower food consumption than the Friesian; that is a factor which will have to be considered in arguing the respective merits of any of the big breeds as dual purpose animals.

I will give the table now. The average age and weights at time of maturity were: dairy Shorthorn, 2 years 235 days, 10½ cwt.; Friesian, 2 years 317 days, 12½ cwt.; Hereford— that is pure Hereford—2 years 273 days, 11¼ cwt. One will notice that in the actual maturing time there is only a variation of weeks. Observe the variation in weight. The Hereford Shorthorn, at 2 years 280 days, weighs 11½ cwt.; the Hereford Friesian cross, 2 years 273 days, 11¾ cwt. I would not be so rash in the light of statistics of that kind, resulting from an experiment carried out over a considerable period, and with 12 animals out of each category at a time, as to shout too loudly about breeds. If one wants to boost the dual-purpose Shorthorn, why is a set of figures not produced to confirm or repudiate the statistics I have given? Surely we are as competent to carry out a test here as the people across the water.

Comment on this

What do those figures prove?

Comment on this

Must I go into that again? I think the Minister is indulging in harassing tactics.

Comment on this

I am honestly asking the Deputy to give me his judgment, in a single phrase. What do those figures prove?

Comment on this

I did not anticipate the question, but I have compiled some data. I listened to the Minister here last evening. One of the disadvantages of coming into the debate too soon after the Minister has spoken is that one does not have time to analyse the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

What thesis do these statistics prove?

Comment on this

This is merely an extension of the speech I made last year on the Minister's Estimate. On that occasion I dealt exclusively with the comparative merits of different breeds from the purely dairying angle. To complete the other prong in connection with duality, I come in now to substantiate my thesis and I argue that the Friesian, particularly the Dutch Friesian, is a superior milk animal as compared with the dairy Shorthorn.

I want to explode the fallacy in relation to the superiority of the Shorthorn and to put forward facts and figures which show that the Friesian store is superior to the dual purpose Shorthorn store.

Comment on this

Therefore, the Friesian is the best dual-purpose cow.

Comment on this

I accept that; she is the best dual-purpose cow.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

Those are the facts.

Comment on this

The Friesian is a superior dual-purpose cow?

Comment on this

Yes. I challenge the Minister in his reply to produce evidence on behalf of the Shorthorn. Let him try to get it in this country; he will not get it, because it is not there. The Minister cannot wave a wand and find the evidence. There is no data available. There is a figure down in the Albert College of something over 700 gallons for 63 cows. One of the features of the Albert College is that the culling rate has been very high. It has never been known for a Shorthorn heifer to be sold out of the place because the culling rate is so high. The butter fat is something like 3.6 per cent. If one goes back on the figures one will find that the average yields are on the decline. I never consider places like the Albert College for comparison purposes because from a commercial angle they are absolutely useless. I quoted Goldsmith on a previous occasion here; he said:

"The robes which wrapped their limbs in silken sloth,

Have robbed the neighbouring fields of half their growth."

That paints the picture so far as places like the Albert College, and some other places in the country, are concerned. I do not believe you can get the same efficiency in a State-controlled institution that you get in a unit run for a different purpose and on different lines, and the figures obtainable from such places are, therefore, quite useless. I got a hold of this survey and I was not satisfied, for I knew that in coming to this House I would probably be under fire from every experienced parliamentarian.

I went to the trouble, not alone of examining the survey but of working out all possible deductions from the survey. I went as far as to analyse the live weight gain per day in that survey and here are the figures, which are irrefutable. First is the Friesian on top with a live weight gain per day of 1.34 lb. Now talk of rim-rackers or whatever you choose to call them with a live weight gain of 1.34 lb. a day! No. 2—you had a Hereford Friesian cross second on the list at 1.3 lb. per day. No. 3—you had a Hereford-Shorthorn cross—and that should be of particular interest to us—third on the list at 1.27 lb. live weight gain per day. These are all average weights obtained from each of the crosses of the breeds picked at random; they were randomised for the purposes of the survey and the average figure for 12 of each of the classes or breeds or crosses surveyed was taken.

You had as No. 3 the Hereford-Shorthorn cross at 1.27 lb. per day, and No. 4, a pure Hereford, at 1.25 lb. per day. Last on the list—No. 5—you have the dairy Shorthorn at 1.1 lb. per day. These figures are not mine; they are figures of the survey and are absolutely irrefutable, and in two or three years' time we will have from that very same station not alone this data, but we will have also the gradings of the animals, because that, at the moment, is a further addition to this survey.

I have produced this survey as an answer to all the loose talk and blah which we have been hearing down through the years. In this country we make statements and we have not a fact or a figure to support these statements which are repeated and parroted everywhere. I think Grange is in operation as an A.I. centre for five years—and I am not at all happy about our A.I. centres. Grange has been in operation for a considerable length of time and, by now, if the business was organised as it should be organised, we should have available a considerable amount of data on bulls, but we have not a figure from them. We are no better than we were with the Shorthorn bulls which were licensed at beauty contests at the cross-roads. As far as I can see, the amount of data available is so small that the most we can say of A.I. stations is that we have changed the tactics and have been using them for the purpose of mechanised mating. That is what has been going on. We have so little data available from them.

We are aware that something has been done down at Grange by way of trying to prove some bulls and——

Comment on this

Why did you not prove them at Mitchelstown?

Comment on this

I am as much concerned about Mitchelstown as anyone, because I was one of the pioneers in bringing an A.I. station to Mitchelstown and when the first one was opened, remember A.I. had not the benediction of the Irish Department of Agriculture at the time, and when the Minister for Agriculture came into office in 1948, it did not have his benediction.

Comment on this

Was not Ballyclough the first one?

Comment on this

Ballyclough was not opened by the Department of Agriculture at all. The spade work of A.I. was done in this country by the Irish Agricultural Society. I do not want to misquote facts, but the Minister will admit that he was not in favour of A.I. when he came into office.

Comment on this

What progeny-testing had you done in Mitchelstown?

Comment on this

I shall come to that, too, and I can produce here figures from my own herd, which show that they have done something in Mitchelstown that they have not done at Grange.

When the Minister came into office in 1948 remember A.I. had not the benediction of the Irish Department of Agriculture. They would not touch the thing. It was dynamite and when the station was opened at Ballyclough there was a hush-hush about it and such talk about the business that was going on behind the high walls that the farmers passing by blessed themselves with their left hands. That was the kind of prejudice we had to face.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell me what is the significance of blessing yourself with your left hand?

Comment on this

I remember on one occasion speaking to an audience of farmers on what I had learned by studying A.I. in countries where it had been long since developed, and when the meeting was over a school-teacher came over to me and said: "Look here, we want no bolshevism in this country". He also said: "I shall have you reported to the Professor of Moral Theology at Maynooth". I went home with the fear that I was going to be put on the pyre and burned at the stake.

When the Minister came into office in 1948, he was not then a believer in A.I. and only became a convert when he went to America and saw A.I. demonstrated everywhere he went. It was only then he started things moving in Merrion Street. Then what happened? I shall tell the whole story. One thing happened that I had always hoped for—that the big societies in this country would do something to help the small societies. That was something I had always hoped for. At Mitchelstown we did develop our A.I. station and I am glad, despite all the abuse that was hurled at me at the time, that I was one of the people who was associated with the station at the outset.

Comment on this