We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–193 of 567. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. Lemass

It may not be generally appreciated by members of the Dáil and the public who are to-day discussing the Budget that when the Government came to prepare it they had before them an Estimate—prepared, I presume, by the Revenue Commissioners—that the revenue from existing taxes in this year would exceed the revenue last year by £3,000,000. That was a very happy position for any Government to be in. They could face the problems of preparing the Budget knowing that, without action on their part—without any alteration or adjustment of any tax rate—they could count upon getting £3,000,000 more tax revenue than in the previous year. I think that is the most significant and perhaps the most important fact in relation to the Budget.

The Budget of 1954, which was introduced by Deputy MacEntee as Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government, would have balanced upon the basis on which he presented it. The tax revenue in 1954 would have been sufficient to cover, with a small surplus, all the Government expenditure arising in that year chargeable against taxation. If the present Government had succeeded in keeping down Government expenditure to the level at which it was last year, they would have £3,000,000 available to distribute in tax reductions. It required no greater effort from them than the restriction of Government expenditure to last year's level to put themselves in the position in which they could give substantial tax reliefs and make a show of redeeming their election promises.

The pledges given on behalf of the Government as to its intentions after it was formed—certainly the pledges given by the representatives of the various Parties comprising the Government during the general election were not limited to keeping expenditure down to the 1954 level. If they had gone to the electorate in the general election and said it would be the aim of a new Coalition Government to prevent expenditure from rising beyond the level to which Fianna Fáil had brought it, do they think they would have received an enthusiastic reception from the public? What kind of support do they think they would have got in respect of a programme limited to that promise? They knew that and so they went before the public with a different type of programme. They said they would reduce expenditure below the 1954 level.

Various spokesmen of the different Coalition Parties gave various estimates as to what reductions were possible. The Taoiseach is on record as saying, as far back as 1952, that in his view a reduction of £10,000,000 on the expenditure of that year was feasible. They sent Deputy McGilligan down to Radio Éireann to broadcast on behalf of the Fine Gael Party—I believe that is what happened even though Deputy McGilligan has denied it since and has said he went on his own responsibility with a speech of which his colleagues knew nothing—to say that a reduction amounting to several million pounds could be achieved without much effort, that the Fine Gael leaders were convinced that a Minister for Finance who was serious in a search for economies could reduce the level of Government expenditure by no less than £20,000,000. One would have thought that a Party that went to the electorate with these pledges on their lips and which got support from the electorate on the basis of these pledges, and found themselves a Government, would have made some effort to redeem them or at least some effort to prevent expenditure from rising beyond the limit that they said was excessive. They did not succeed. If they had succeeded, if they had done no more during their ten months in office than hold the level of Government spending to what it was when they took office, the taxpayers of this country could be enjoying reduced income tax and reduced taxes on beer, spirits and tobacco—reduced tax levies to the extent of £3,000,000.

I do not remember any occasion when I was a member of the Government on which the Minister for Finance was able to come to a Cabinet meeting and say: "I have here an estimate from the Revenue Commissioners that shows that, without alteration in tax rates, we will have £3,000,000 with which to give relief in the coming year." The present Minister for Finance and his colleagues were in that happy position. The main issue that has to be debated here to-day is what happened that £3,000,000.

We know that when the members of the Government were private Deputies, speaking in this House and throughout the country, they considered that the taxes in force upon beer, spirits, tobacco, petrol and the level of income-tax established by the Budget of 1952 were excessive. The present Taoiseach, or Deputy J.A. Costello as he was at the time, who was the spokesman of the Opposition Parties, said in this House, as reported in Volume 131 of the Official Report: "I would resign the next minute rather than proceed with any single provision of the present Budget." That reference was to the taxes on beer, spirits, tobacco, petrol and the rate of income-tax established by the 1952 Budget. The Taoiseach had the opportunity of resigning when his Minister for Finance brought to the Cabinet meeting the proposal to leave those taxes unchanged this year. He has the opportunity of resigning now. Alternatively, he has to explain why he is not doing so, how it is that the first Budget that he and his Minister for Finance are bringing to the Dáil is leaving unchanged these taxes upon beer, spirits, tobacco and petrol and the level of income-tax to which he took such exception in 1952.

The Labour Party fought the election on the same issue. They issued a handbill for universal distribution to voters. They said in that handbill anent these charges established by the Budget of 1952 that "Fianna Fáil deliberately increased these taxes at the behest of the Central Bank". At whose behest are they keeping them unchanged now? Was it the Central Bank that told them that they would have to go into the Division Lobby within a day or two to vote to leave these taxes unchanged, or is it the Fine Gael Whips who will make them do so?

What influence is at work to make Deputies opposite so completely reverse the views they held only a few months ago? A few months ago these taxes were unnecessary, these taxes were a brutal imposition on the public, according to Deputy McGilligan. These taxes were so unjustified that Deputy Costello would resign the next minute rather than propose them to the Dáil. These taxes, according to the Labour Party, were imposed, not because the Government wanted them, not because the situation of the Irish people required them but at the behest of the Central Bank. Why are they being left now unchanged? Somebody has to answer that question before this debate is over or else these Cabinet Ministers in the present Government and the Deputies sitting behind them have to stand up here and say that the words they used last year were worthless, that the pledges they gave were not worth the paper on which they were printed.

The impression which they will leave upon the public, if they do not give a thorough and full explanation of their change of attitude is that these pledges and promises were made solely to get into office by any means and now that they are in office they do not intend to honour any of them.

For myself, I would far rather be sitting over here with my personal honour unsullied than to sit now in the Government Bench with all those unredeemed promises hanging over my head.

Comment on this

The people made you sit over there and they will keep you there too.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

As the Deputy said, that is justification enough for his promises and pledges in his view.

Comment on this

The people were good judges.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Let us start the debate on this Budget by putting upon the record that the level of Government expenditure this year as estimated by the Minister for Finance will once again be an all-time record, that an increase of £4,000,000 in the bill presented to the taxpayers in a period of ten months is no mean achievement for a Government that was going to reduce expenditure by £10,000,000 in ten minutes, according to Deputy Costello, and by £20,000,000 without any effort, according to Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Try to be accurate. I never said anything of the sort.

Comment on this

He said Deputy McGilligan. It is all the same.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

It was not Deputy McGilligan. The present Taoiseach, according to a Press report, at a public meeting in Ballina used those words.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

You were reported in the Press as having said them.

Comment on this

Produce the Press report that said so.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass never went to Ballina to open that biscuit factory.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Is it open yet, and will it ever be open now? Are you going to vote for the tax on biscuits? That is their record as far as taxation is concerned. "Vote Fine Gael and lower taxes"—every dead wall in the country still carries these posters. Is not that right? Every Deputy going home this week-end can look at these dead walls and see these posters on them—Fine Gael and lower taxes. This is the first Fine Gael Budget, and with £3,000,000 more revenue from existing taxes, £3,000,000 given to them without any effort on their part, there is no reduction in taxation except a few fiddling changes and some increases which were not recorded in the Budget statement, but which I will refer to now.

So much for taxes. What about prices? When the Coalition Parties met after the election and issued a statement detailing the programme of the Government they were about to form, they started off that statement by saying that they recognised that the cost of living had been the main issue in the election campaign. Is that not so? The main issue, according to their own statement, in the election campaign was the cost of living and in relation to the cost of living they came in here, after giving pledges to their electorate of a most specific kind. These pledges were, of course, given by all the Coalition Parties and I am assuming that Deputies opposite have not forgotten them, that it is not necessary to remind them of them in detail. Just in case there is some selfprotecting process working to cloud their memories, I will help to restore them to full normal operation.

Deputies who spoke at cross-roads, without newspaper reporters present, could, of course, expand considerably upon the possibility of reducing taxes and reducing prices knowing that their words would be remembered only by the few people listening to them and would never be quoted here. Deputies who made speeches that were reported in the newspapers can, like the Minister for Defence, deny they ever made them when they are quoted against them. But, during the last election campaign we had something we never had before: we had a series of election broadcasts arranged by Radio Éireann. Leaders of the Parties went to Radio Éireann and there on behalf of their Parties announced their Party programmes, announced what they would do if, as a result of their appeals they got support from the electorate. We know that Deputy McGilligan went down to Radio Éireann and on his own behalf or somebody else's behalf or in some backhanded way that Fine Gael did not know about, said there was going to be a Fine Gael Minister for Finance who without any effort would cut expenditure by several million pounds and would eventually bring it down by £20,000,000.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that word "eventually". Your colleague yesterday said "this Budget".

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Deputy Mulcahy, leader of Fine Gael, also went to Radio Éireann and he wrung the hearts of his listeners by detailing to them the hardships occasioned by the rise in the cost of living. He said that the Fianna Fáil Government had to be got rid of and replaced by one which would set vigorously to reducing the cost of living. We are discussing the cost of living now. That is only a preliminary introduction to the pledges that were made. Deputy McGilligan, as usual, was a little more specific.

Comment on this

Most introductions are preliminary, are they not?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Deputy McGilligan spoke at a meeting in Drogheda on 22nd February and said: "We say, as we said in 1947, that prices are too high and we say we can cut them down." There is a multitude of these quotations which I can deliver at length to the House if necessary. I am merely endeavouring at the moment to establish the universality of these pledges. They were not confined to the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party or the Clann na Talmhan Party. Each of these Parties gave a specific pledge to cut down the cost of living.

The Labour Party published an advertisement which appeared in all the national newspapers and presumably was read by everybody who buys a newspaper. "The Labour Party is pledged to reduce the cost of living." Deputy Norton as he was then—the Tánaiste at the moment and leader of the Labour Party—said that if the Labour Party participated in an inter-Party Government it would be a guarantee to the people that the policy of that Government would be always directed towards a reduction in prices. Deputy Davin, another prominent member of the Labour Party and now Parliamentary Secretary, said at a meeting in Mountmellick: "I am prepared to pledge myself to the people of this constituency, if re-elected as I hope to be, to use my voice and my vote"—mark that, "my vote"—"in the Dáil and whatever influence I have in order to force the new Government to give first consideration to the reduction of food taxes and to bring prices of essential commodities back to the figure, or as near as possible to the figure, at which they stood prior to the passage of the brutal Budget of 1952."

May I remind members of the Labour Party of Deputy Dunne's pledge. He has been in the past, and may be in the future, an embarrassment to them. "Before Labour would participate in a Government," said Deputy Dunne one evening at Navan, "with any Party or group of Parties they would insist that the prices of bread, butter, tea, sugar, cigarettes, tobacco and the worker's pint must be reduced and reduced immediately". Deputy Dunne also said that unless they got agreement on that point they would not take part in the formation of any Government. These are the things they all said. Every Deputy opposite owes his seat over there to his going round his constituency saying things like that to the public. This is the testing time. It is in this Budget if at all any effort is to be made to give effect to these pledges. These are the pledges and I can give you more of them if you like but I think it is hardly necessary to do so.

I feel sure there are very few Deputies opposite who would have the hardihood of the Minister for Defence to stand up and say that if these things appeared in the newspapers over their names they nevertheless were not said. It is only the Minister for Defence who would say that; most other Deputies would admit that the reports in the newspapers were correct and that very often they were reports supplied by themselves and published with reasonable accuracy. Since things were said the cost of living, according to the Consumer Price Index, has gone up by two points.

The Minister for Finance in his Budget statement issued a warning that the cost of living is going up further. The clear indications of his statement was that a further rise in prices is to be expected and he seemed to be urging upon the representatives of organised labour that they should exercise restraint, that they should not lend themselves to support claims for higher wages because they might endanger the national economy and place some workers entirely out of employment. That is the prospect now offered by people who a year ago pledged themselves to bring back the price level of essential commodities as near as possible to that obtaining in 1952 and who said that there was no difficulty in doing that—that it was only the opposition of Fianna Fáil that was preventing their being brought down. And what is there in this Budget relating to prices?

Comment on this

£2,000,000.

Comment on this

£4,500,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I intend to make a special reference here to a statement made by Deputy Kyne. He spoke here as chairman of the Labour Party. He is a member of this House for whom I have a great respect. I believe he is an honest man, but a man who knows that he is caught in the maze of Coalition intrigue and who is trying to escape out of the maze if he can find the way.

Comment on this

He is not here or he would blush.

Comment on this

The Deputy put his eye on other people before and where are they now? Where is Dr. Browne and where is Mr. Cogan now? Beware of that evil eye.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I assume that when Deputy Kyne was speaking he was doing so on behalf of the present Tánaiste. If not, that fact should have been made clear.

Comment on this

Do not bury him in the same cemetery as you buried the other people.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I am not going to bury anybody. I have come to praise Deputy Kyne. On the Estimate for Industry and Commerce prior to the change of Government, Deputy Kyne on November 3rd, 1953, as reported in Volume 142, columns 1172 and 1173 of the Official Report said this:—

"I was one who on behalf of my Party, a year ago gave a promise that we would not associate with any Party to form a Government unless we got an assurance that the food subsidies as they then were would be restored in full. Because of certain statements that have been made and because of the passage of time, I think it is desirable to repeat in the name of my Party that our promise still holds good. We will not associate with or be a party to a Government that does not restore the subsidies or the value of the subsidies to the standard that was there in the time of the inter-Party Government."

The significance of that statement and of that pledge given in the House on behalf of the Labour Party by its chairman is that it has not been repudiated until now. Only a few weeks ago in this House on the debate on the Supplies and Services Bill as reported at column 714 of Volume 148, No. 5 of the Official Report, Mr. Kyne reminded us of that promise and he said:—

"I know exactly the promises that were made. I was the instrument of the Party here in relation to certain essential promises. I remember quite well what was said; we would not take part in any Government and neither would we support a Government which would not undertake to bring down the prices of essential commodities to the level of the 1952 Budget. We will not fall down on that promise. That promise was firmly made. We have indicated that should subsidies be required they would be made available."

That was taken, no doubt, by many members of the Labour Party and by many supporters of the Party as a statment of the intention of that Party to ensure that there would be a further reduction, even if only a token reduction, in the cost of living by means of the application of additional subsidies after the Budget. I do not know if Deputies are aware that this Budget provides for a substantial reduction in subsidies. In fact, the total amount provided in this year for food price subsidies of all kinds—bread, flour and butter—only exceeds by comparatively a trivial amount the sum provided last year for food price subsidies. Last year we estimated the cost of flour and bread subsidies to be, roughly, £7,750,000. It proved in effect to be £8,000,000; it took £8,000,000 last year to keep flour and bread prices at their present levels by subsidy. Over and above that there was provided last year approximately £250,000 sterling to stabilise the price of butter. That was not a price subsidy in the full sense of the term but a sum provided to meet the cost of storing butter in the summer so that there would be no increase in the price in the winter time. It was a price subsidy to that extent.

This year the Government has estimated that the cost of flour and bread subsidy will be £1,000,000 less than it was last year, £7,000,000, to be precise. They are proposing to cut it by a further £450,000 by the device to which the Minister for Finance referred yesterday and adding to that the full cost in this year of the butter subsidy we find that the total provision for subsidies of all kinds is much the same, a trifle more but not very much more, than it was last year.

That brings us back to Deputy Kyne's speech of last year. He stated in that speech that he recognised that the full scheme of subsidies which was operating prior to 1952 could not be restored because rationing had been abolished and certain restrictions had been withdrawn and he did not want to see them brought in again. But he said that the Labour Party was insisting upon it that the same amount of money would be voted towards price subsidies by any Government with which they were associated as was voted for them prior to 1952.

Comment on this

I do not remember his saying that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That is what he said.

Comment on this

He talked about price not subsidy.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Perhaps Deputy Kyne will speak for himself.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would argue the point also.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

In my view—and I will admit it is probably a personal view——

Comment on this

And a dishonest view.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

——whatever money the Government can make available for subsidies can be best applied to lowering the price of flour and bread. Bread is about the only essential foodstuff for which it can be said that expenditure on it decreases in relative importance as one goes up the social scale. It is the very poorest of our people who spend the largest part of their incomes on the purchase of bread. The wealthiest spend relatively very little. Therefore, if money is to be provided to relieve hardship by bringing down the price of some essential foodstuffs the benefit of that expenditure for the people of the community who need help most can be best secured by giving it all to bread.

Comment on this

You must have been very powerful as an influence in 1952. Bread was raised.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Will the Deputy stop interrupting?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lemass must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I thought bread was raised in 1952.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I take the Deputy's word for it that he thinks.

Comment on this

I was under the impression——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! The Deputy must be allowed to proceed without interruption. Deputy McGilligan will be able to make his point clear later on.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Was bread not raised in 1952?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I have expressed the view that whatever money can be made available for the relief of the cost of living by the application of subsidies to prices can be best utilised for the benefit of those who need help most by devoting it all to bread for the reasons I have stated. That is not the case as regards butter. In fact, a subsidy for butter benefits the very poorest of our people not at all. It is a benefit that becomes of increasing importance as one goes up the social scale. I am not suggesting that it is desirable to make changes merely for the sake of changes but there is an advantage in making available for the subsidisation of flour and bread the whole sum that the Government can afford to give to food price subsidies and it is the dimensions of the whole sum I am asking the Dáil to consider. It is no higher now than it was last year. It is very substantially lower than the sum which, according to Deputy Kyne, the Labour Party would insist should be made available by any Government with which they were associated.

Let me again remind the House of the statement issued by the Coalition Parties after the election. They recognised, they said, that the cost of living had been the main issue in the election campaign. It is certainly going to be the main issue in this debate. I said in a public speech recently that I considered that there was proceeding within the Government a contest, the outcome of which would be revealed in the Budget statement. There was a contest, I said, between those who attached the main importance to their pledges to reduce taxation and those who attached the main importance to their pledges to increase expenditure, and I said we would get in the Budget statement an indication as to which set of promises was going to have a chance to survive, which group in the Coalition was going to come out on top. I was wrong. The Budget statement reveals nothing except that all the different groups in the Government are in full retreat, because there is nothing either to reduce taxation or reduce prices. The sections of the Coalition Government that carried these pledges to the Cabinet table decided there not to fight on them.

Last year Deputy Seán MacEntee, produced a Budget here which gave fairly considerable relief, not very substantial when one regards the total weight of the tax burden but not inconsiderable in our circumstances.

Comment on this

It was an election Budget of course.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

And there was an addition to the subsidy available for bread and flour which brought down the price of the 2-lb. loaf by ½d., not a very substantial reduction. Deputies on the other side stood up and derided the Budget as the halfpenny Budget. Well, this is the "sweet Fanny Adams" Budget.

Comment on this

That is a halfpenny on 3d.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Was there a single member of the Labour Party, outside the members of the Government, who did not expect that this Budget would make some concession to their election pledges or increase food price subsidies? Let them be honest with the Dáil, honest with their constituents, honest with all those Labour Party members and trade union councils that are meeting throughout the country charging them with having defaulted in their obligations, with having betrayed those who elected them. Let them stand up and say honestly whether they are satisfied with this Budget which makes no provision for the reduction of any prices by an increase of subsidy. They have got to say something. They have got to say whether they are satisfied or not. They cannot just leave it all to the members of the Government who have sold out to Fine Gael. There must be some people in the Labour Party with sufficient independence to assert the Party mind. Does this Budget represent the Labour Party mind?

Comment on this

It has helped the more deserving sections of the community.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

With regard to the increase in the old age pension, I want to express my gratification that it has been made. I think the increase is a niggardly one.

Comment on this

The Deputy has the most brazen nerve of anyone who ever came in here.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The present old age pension of 21/6 a week was fixed by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1952.

Comment on this

Were you at the last Ard Fheis to hear Deputy de Valera?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

What did Deputy de Valera say?

Comment on this

Make it £2 a week like you promised.

Comment on this

Where was the Deputy last night when he should have been here in the House?

Comment on this

I will explain that tonight.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The present old age pension was fixed by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1952 when the cost of living index number was 115. It is now 126. There has been a ten per cent. increase in the cost of living since.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been looking at the telephone directory for his figures.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If the Deputy cannot listen in peace, will he go and twiddle his thumbs outside? This debate will go on for some time and Deputies and Ministers will have time to say what they think.

Comment on this

Why did you not alter the old age pensions, so?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The cost of living has gone up since.

Comment on this

Why did you not help them?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

It has gone up since and will go up more.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have asked the House several times for order to hear Deputy Lemass. Every Deputy will be allowed an opportunity for speaking and I dare say will expect order when he is speaking. Deputy Lemass is entitled to that consideration from the House also.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The point I want to emphasise is that bringing the old age pension to 24/- is only restoring the purchasing power which it had in 1952. Will the Labour Party Deputies accept that?

Comment on this

Who reduced it?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Will there be agreement that by raising it to 24/- the Government has done no more than bring the purchasing power of the old age pension back to what it was in 1952?

Comment on this

Is not that something?

Comment on this

It is more than he did, during the 20 years of Fianna Fáil, for the old age pensioners.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will have to take serious notice of interruptions. I am issuing that warning. Serious notice will be taken of interruptions. Deputy Lemass is entitled to speak without interruptions.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What I want to remind the House is that by bringing the old age pension to 24/- they have merely restored the purchasing power to what it was—and the Minister for Finance has warned us that the cost of living will keep on going up.

Comment on this

Might I ask a question—has it not been restored?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Might I refer you to the Attorney-General, a Cheann Comhairle, he is the worst offender of all? I do not mind poor Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this

I want to ask a question—has it been restored?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy McGilligan knows the Rules of Order very well. The only thing I suggest to him is that he should obey them.

Comment on this

I apologise, Sir.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If prices are expected to rise, as the Minister for Finance has warned us, if the cost of living is going up further, surely one would think that some provision on a more generous scale could have been made for these people? Everybody knows that a rise in the cost of living hits hardest those people who have no margin above their expenditure upon essentials, the people who cannot cut down or alter the pattern of their expenditure because they are already consuming the minimum and any fluctuation in the cost of living prices means hardship for them. That is why the old age pension has been increased on many occasions since the end of the war as the cost of living rose. If it is going to rise further, the pension might have been brought at least to 25/-. The extra cost, less than £500,000 in a full year, might have been secured easily by a partial effort on the part of the Minister for Finance to secure the economies that Deputy McGilligan believes to be possible. Deputy McGilligan said the Minister for Finance could, without any effort, achieve economies worth several millions.

Comment on this

Oh, now, several— not seven.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

You went up to £20,000,000 later, but several——

Comment on this

Is not four and a half several?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

But there have been no economies of £4,500,000.

Comment on this

There have been.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Anyway, I think the Government has done less than justice to these people by making that change as small as it did. I want to direct the attention of the House particularly to the proposals of the Minister to cut the flour subsidy by eliminating from it flour used for the manufacture of biscuits and for confectionery, cakes and so forth. Personally, I cannot comprehend how any workable scheme can be devised which will enable, in circumstances of a free market, in the absence of rationing, flour to be sold at one price for one purpose and at another price for another purpose. If that £450,000 is to be saved, it will only be by imposing upon all flour users an apparatus of control which will be extraordinarily cumbersome and certainly a great public irritation.

Imagine a firm in Dublin or Cork that is making both bread and confectionery—how are the inspectors of the Department of Industry and Commerce going to segregate the subsidised flour to be used for bread from the unsubsidised flour that can be used for confectionery? How will any firm competing with these multiple undertakings in the sale of confectionery be assured that subsidised flour is not being availed of by their competitors for that production? Go to the other end of the scale. Recently I had an approach from a lady who was recently widowed and who hoped to supplement her income by making confectionery in her own home. How are you going to prevent her from walking out to the grocery shop and buying a sack of flour to make that confectionery? Are you going to go into her house and tax her on the flour found therein—or make her put a stamp on every piece of confectionery she sells?

Comment on this

More jobs.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

We will wait until we hear this system of control when it is elaborated. May I say I have considerable respect for the ingenuity of the officials of the Department of Industry and Commerce in devising controls of that kind, but I think that any system of that nature should not be brought into operation at all unless the Government can guarantee that of a certainty it will work with equity. If it is going to mean that some group of citizens will be at a commercial advantage or a commercial disadvantage as compared with others; that will be a bad system, no matter how much money is saved.

Comment on this

It might save £450,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Let us see whether it will or not.

Comment on this

If it does?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

There are confectionery firms which embarked with Government approval and encouragement upon an effort to establish export markets for confectionery and while there was some falling off in export business in recent times, the value of our exports of these goods in the last year amounted nevertheless to £700,000. That is a substantial item in our shipping statistics. That trade will be killed unless the Government intends that there is going to be a further division between those who use flour for confectionery purposes, distinguishing those who are doing export trade from those who are not—in which case they will be open to the allegation that while they are subsidising confectionery for the foreigner they are not subsidising it for the home consumer. You cannot make distinctions of that kind.

I am aware of three firms, two in Dublin and one in Cork, which entered into substantial capital investment in the expectation that they could open up markets for Irish confectionery throughout the world and I have seen the products of these firms on sale in Canada and New York. It is certain that if they have to buy their flour at what is the Irish economic price, they are out of that business permanently; because the Irish economic price is higher than the world price and they cannot have their raw materials at the world prices. As it is, they are at a disadvantage in the British market with their competitors, who have the advantage of what is equivalent to a subsidised price for sugar. If they have now to pay a higher price for flour as well as a higher price for sugar than their competitors in the world market, that trade is gone. I appeal to the Government not to allow the Minister for Finance to follow along this line if it is going to mean the disappearance of that trade, which has built up possibilities of permanent growth. The workers employed in it can no doubt find alternative work in England, but if the trade is lost now it will never be recovered.

Comment on this

Like Jacobs' biscuits—which the Deputy killed during the war years.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Parliamentary Secretary is talking through his hat, as usual.

Comment on this

The ex-Minister is talking a bit like an idiot. He killed that trade.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If the Minister for Industry and Commerce makes an effort to inquire in his Department as to the effort which I made to maintain the export trade in biscuits and to secure the retention of the export trade in this country, he would be able to inform the Parliamentary Secretary on a subject on which he is completely ignorant.

Comment on this

Did you not provide them with white flour?

Comment on this

Were they not successful?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Anyway, there was an export trade in biscuits last year of over £100,000. That also is going to die if this proposal is proceeded with. I am not raising this point simply for the purpose of advancing an argument against the Minister for Finance's Budget. I am asking the Government to reconsider its decision before this new scheme is put in operation. Let them consider what the consequences of it will be and at least take precautions to ensure that these undesirable results will not occur.

Comment on this

You are talking through your hat about this. That will not happen; of course, you know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister says it will not happen. I will tell him all about it afterwards.

Comment on this

You cannot instil gloom into the nation, as much as you try.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister for Finance said yesterday, I will quote what he said——

Comment on this

Do not lose any sleep over this; it will be all right.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I am offering to explain it to you.

Comment on this

There is a good Government in. Do not bother your neck about it. I assure you, you need not worry about it. Your energy is worthy of a better cause.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister for Finance said:—

"For several years prior to the abolition of rationing in 1952 the principle operated was that subsidy should, broadly speaking, be reserved for flour used in the baking of bread. Subsidised flour was not made available for industrial uses such as the making of cakes, confectionery and biscuits. On the dismantling of controls, however, a subsidised flour became available without restriction for luxury and less essential commodities. It is now intended to revert in some respects to the earlier situation and to arrange that the subsidy will be reserved as far as practicable, for bread, for flour, for home baking and for essential foods like sausages. A suitable scheme is being prepared by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who will announce the details at an early date. It will effect a saving this year in flour subsidy payments of the order of £450,000."

Subsidised flour is not going to be available for the manufacture of confectionery, for tarts, or slab cake, or biscuits, or any of these things. If that is so, that trade which was built up, and maintained against a number of disadvantages, by reason of the fact that flour of that price was available for it, must end.

Comment on this

Of course it will not end.

Comment on this

But where is the £500,000 going to come from?

Comment on this

You are playing with pennies now.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister for Finance opened his Budget statement yesterday by reviewing the economic conditions which prevailed during 1954. He pointed out that, in 1954, the balance of payments deficit was rectified, that production was expanding, that employment was increasing, that the decrease in agricultural employment had been arrested, and that generally, the condition of the country was considerably better than it had been.

I will admit that 1954 was a good year by comparison with other years. When Deputy MacEntee introduced the Budget for 1954, and attempted to forecast that it would be a good year, every Deputy opposite got up on his hind legs to howl in derision. That is what he said when introducing the 1954 Budget: that these things were happening, and that these experiences were likely to be recorded in that year. Does the Minister for Finance or any Deputy opposite seriously expect the most gullible member of the public to believe that all these improvements which developed in 1954 were due to the fact that half way through the year, in the month of June, there was a change of Government? Do they not realise that they were the culmination of three years hard work by the Fianna Fáil Government? That is what we worked to achieve, and that is what we got.

Comment on this

That is why you were put out; 21 years were long enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Let us get away from this practice of throwing jibes at one another. If the sole concern of Deputies opposite is to snaffle for themselves credit for anything, no matter with what little justification, then of course they may proceed on those lines. If the Minister's speech was intended to convey an understanding of what was happening in 1954, if he does in fact understand that these benefits were as a result of the policy followed by the Fianna Fáil Government and intends to continue that policy then it was a satisfactory announcement.

If he is merely thinking of buying a few votes by taking credit for what Deputy MacEntee did, then it is a contemptible procedure. If Deputies opposite really understand how these things were brought about then there is more hope for believing that the Government will not follow the same disastrous course as the first Coalition. I think that the Minister for Finance did no harm in emphasising that the improvement in the external balance position last year was due almost entirely to the boom in cattle and meat trades in the last quarter of the year. These are our biggest trades, and it is tremendously important for all the people of this country that these trades would be prosperous. I went with Deputy Walsh, the then Minister for Agriculture to London in March of last year, for discussions with the British Government as to the circumstances that would prevail after July when the British derationed meat and decontrolled its sale.

It seemed at one time, that the circumstances that might operate in Britain after decontrol and derationing might be detrimental to our interests as suppliers of cattle and meat to the British market. Fortunately, we were able to get that position clarified when we returned from London. Deputy Walsh and I ventured to advise the farmers that the market demand and the price for cattle were going to be good after decontrol. We were able to advise them that they could plan their activities for the year upon the basis of a good market, and good prices for cattle in the second half of the year. It was Deputy McGilligan who denied that. He stood up here after the Budget statement of last year, the first speaker of the Fine Gael Party and referred to these forecasts which Deputy Walsh and I had ventured to make. Deputy McGilligan scoffed at them and said there was growing uncertainty as to the future of cattle prices. I will say this for Deputy Dillon, that he came in the next day to reprimand Deputy McGilligan, and asked that no member of his Party would attempt to join in that gloomy forecast, that the national interests required that the farmers should be led to believe the accuracy of the forecast which Deputy Walsh and I had given.

Comment on this

You have changed your opinion about the British market.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

However irresponsible the present Minister for Agriculture may be on occasion he is not so completely irresponsible as the present Attorney General. That situation for our cattle trade will continue so long as there is full employment in Britain. There was at one time the prospect that a flood of frozen meat from the southern hemisphere would swamp the British market and lead to a reduction of the demand for fresh meat. It has not proved to be so. On the contrary, the demand for fresh meat is still mounting and our producers of cattle, and those who are engaged in the dead meat business, can plan their activities upon that basis. That situation is not likely to change unless a situation should develop in England which would result in widespread unemployment and a forcing of the British population back upon the inferior but cheaper meat which comes from the southern hemisphere.

Comment on this

And all of which situation is due solely to the 1948 agreement.

Comment on this

No; it has nothing whatever to do with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That has nothing to do with this.

Comment on this

The Deputy said last year that he brought back no agreement.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What has this to do with the 1948 agreement?

Comment on this

It has everything.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If that is the situation which confronts the Irish farmers today and if credit for it is to be given to any one individual, that individual is Deputy Tom Walsh.

Comment on this

Oh, God forgive you!

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

And the farmers of the country know that quite well.

Comment on this

Why then did they vote against you last year?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Because they were misled by the pledges and promises of the people opposite.

Comment on this

That is an insult to their intelligence.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Is that the test of economic policy or the test of truth?

Comment on this

Truth, I would say.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Is it? Were you wrong every time you were beaten?

Comment on this

No, we were not.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Out of 11 elections, you lost nine. Were you wrong? Will you admit that you were wrong?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputies use the third person and not use the second person across the floor of the House and will Deputies allow Deputy Lemass to proceed without interruption?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Let us turn now to the main aspect of this Budget. The Budget is or should be something more than an exercise in accountancy. It is one of the principal instruments available to the Government to direct economic developments in the direction they want them to go. I do not know if there is agreement amongst all the Parties in this House as to what our economic and social aims should be, but there is no doubt in my mind as to what we should strive to achieve. It is to build here an economy that will be capable of providing full employment for all our citizens who are dependent on work for their livelihoods and to keep that economy expanding at a rate which will enable that situation to be maintained, with a rising population and a rising standard of living. We have not achieved that aim yet, though we have made some progress towards it—insufficient progress, in my view—and the test of every measure proposed here by every Government, the test of every Budget statement, is whether it offers a contribution to the realisation of that aim or not.

The main reason why we have not yet been successful in bringing about that expanding economy capable of giving full employment to all our people and checking emigration is that we have not yet brought the annual level of new investment high enough to ensure it. The British Economic Survey published some weeks ago attributes the present strength of the British economy, its full employment and its Budget surpluses, to the maintenance of a high level of new investment in manufacturing industry. That is what we have to achieve if we are to bring about similar circumstances here.

The Minister for Finance in his Budget statement said that full economic development cannot be achieved by investment in the public sector only. Productive investment in the private sector, he added, is indeed a prime necessity, if our resouces in men and material are to be fully and effectively employed. That is a sentiment and a view from which I do not dissent, but try to relate it to the provisions of the Budget and try to establish any possible connection between that view of the Minister for Finance and the actual proposals which he submitted to the House. In what way can it be alleged that these proposals will operate to induce a high level of investment on private account? There is nothing in the Budget and no suggestion of an idea in the mind of the Government or any member of the Government calculated to make for the realisation of that situation. The failure to recognise it, the failure to make any provision in the Budget which could be regarded as a contribution to the realisation of that aim, will itself have a depressing and discouraging effect.

The finicky little adjustments in taxation which occupied the greater part of the Minister's speech indicate that there is no hope of getting this Government to think of something bigger than a mere adjustment of their accounts. If we are to achieve or make any progress towards the achievement of that aim, then every bit of elbow room available to the Minister in the Budget, every bit of elbow room that may become available to him in every future Budget, must be used exclusively for purposes which will make some contribution to that increase in production here, some addition to the national resources which will enable all this apparatus of Government to be maintained.

It is not true that our expenditure is too high. There is no part of that expenditure that we can forego. The level of our social services is not such that we would willingly vote for cutting them down. The expenditure upon various organs of administration represents no more than is needed to give this civilised community the normal apparatus of Government, and, while some economy may be possible by changes in accountancy or staffing methods, we cannot say that there is unnecessary expenditure being undertaken which we can do without. What is true is that the level of taxation is too high in relation to our resources and the solution, a solution which must be found quickly, is to expend these resources, and that is why I object to every and any proposal which involves a diversion of resources to other less essential purposes, however desirable they may be and however politically advantageous they may be, because we cannot at present afford to divert from these productive ends any part of the limited resource we have.

The Minister for Agriculture, in a cliché which has become hackneyed in its use by politicians, said that agriculture is the prop of our economy, the basis of our security and our prosperity, and, in order to strengthen that prop, to add to our security and prosperity, he advocated a more extensive use of mechanical equipment and the acceleration of rural electrification. The audacity of that!

Comment on this

The truth of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Here is the spokesman of the Government which is sabotaging the rural electrification scheme.

Comment on this

That is not true and you know it.

Comment on this

That is a falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The rural electrification scheme was brought to the Dáil on this basis——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

To say to a Deputy that he is telling an untruth and knows it is tantamount to saying that the Deputy is telling a lie.

Comment on this

It is only a falsehood.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy withdraws "and you know it"?

Comment on this

Apparently I gave the Deputy credit for more intelligence than he has. I withdraw my statement that he knows it. It is not true and I should have thought that the Deputy had enough intelligence to know that, but apparently I was wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The rural electrification scheme was a Fianna Fáil scheme which I know all about.

Comment on this

It was about ten years late.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The scheme was based upon a recognition of the fact that if the E.S.B. was to recover in its charges the cost of erecting a rural electrification network, as well as the cost of supplying current, the charges which the individual consumers would have to pay would be so high that few of them would take connection. Consequently, it appeared that there was no prospect of a rural electrification scheme in this country because no matter how economical the E.S.B. worked, no matter how it cut down the cost of erecting the network, it, nevertheless, was obvious that if the E.S.B. was to get back the 12 per cent. upon the capital cost which the financial experts said was necessary they would have to charge for current more than the rural consumers were likely to pay and, consequently, we could not get the 70 per cent. connection on which the economy of the scheme was based.

It was in that situation the Government said: "We will make a rural electrification scheme possible by contributing half of the capital cost of erecting the net work as a free grant from the Exchequer" to take the money out of taxation and to pay it to the E.S.B. to enable them to sell current under the rural electrification scheme at the board's old rule tariff rate, a rate which rural consumers were willing to pay and on the basis of which the rural electrification scheme went ahead. You are withdrawing that subsidy. Is not that so? The subsidy is withdrawn and the initial objection to the whole scheme now becomes alive again. It was the cost of erecting the net work without subsidy which involved a charge on rural consumers that they could not bear.

Comment on this

That is not so, of course.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I admit that some consumers will pay it.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

But in a number of areas the percentage of consumers willing to take supplies will fall below the point at which the E.S.B. will be prepared to give a supply.

Comment on this

That is not so either.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Not merely have they withdrawn the subsidy but they have withdrawn it retrospectively. They have gone to the E.S.B. and said that they must pay back the £5,000,000 already paid as rural electrification scheme subsidy, which means a payment of £250,000 per year. That is a tax that the Minister for Finance forgot to mention in his Budget statement.

Comment on this

There is no tax.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Rural electricity consumers will have to bear the full cost of future development.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say there will be any increase in prices?

Comment on this

There should be a reduction.

Comment on this

Who agreed to the increase?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What increase?

Comment on this

The increase in the charges.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

When?

Comment on this

Did not the Deputy agree? The present charges are those fixed by the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

They were fixed in 1953.

Comment on this

In the Deputy's time.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not run away from it.

Comment on this

The working surplus this year is likely to be in the region of £4,000,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I do not agree. I confess the possibility that the E.S.B. has concealed in its accounts resources of which the public are not aware, but I know that the statutory obligation of the E.S.B. is so to adjust its charges for supply that it will not produce a surplus. If a surplus is produced there is a legal obligation to give that back to the consumer of electricity by reducing the prices.

Comment on this

The Deputy increased the charges.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The price of coal went up and it is going up again next month.

Comment on this

What about the price of the electricity. The Deputy increased that by 25 per cent.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Lemass should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If the Minister for Finance is sincere in his belief that the security and prosperity of the agricultural industry can be fostered by the rural electrification scheme, why not allow that scheme to proceed on the basis on which it was decided?

Comment on this

We will go ahead quicker now.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

There is a famous French philosopher who said that speech was a method of concealing thought. I never realised the full significance of that until listening to Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Why is the Deputy so introspective about that quotation to-day?

Comment on this

His speech conceals the increase in the electricity charges.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Yesterday, Deputy Norton, Minister for Industry and Commerce, asked if we wanted another election. I have given some thought to the reply I should give to the question. I think it is not merely in our Party interests but also in the national interests that it should be allowed to sink into the public mind a little deeper how thoroughly they were deceived by the Coalition Parties in the last election, and how completely the Government have turned their backs on their election pledges and promises. I think it will benefit not merely the Fianna Fáil Party but also the cause of the maintenance of democratic government in this country if the public, get a more thorough demonstration than they have yet got of the character of the trick that was played on them by the Coalition Parties during the recent election and a more thorough demonstration of the incompetence of the present Government to handle the national problem When that lesson has been learned thoroughly, we will have the election and it will not be a matter of asking the Government's permission either.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not want one now.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The public——

Comment on this

Has the Deputy left the matter of electricity?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

——are becoming more fully conscious of the fact that they were tricked by the Coalition spokesmen in the recent election. The more hide-bound members of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party organisation may not yet have allowed the idea to penetrate into their minds but it will get there. That will be the right time for the election but they can suit themselves. For our part we prefer to wait a few months until there is a more complete demonstration of these facts to the public.

Comment on this

I always gave the Deputy credit for being a good judge. Does he want the election now?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister could talk us into it.

Comment on this

It would take a long talk.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Poor and all as the Budget statement was it was made a great deal poorer by the Minister's reference to possible benefits to come. I would have thought that he would have sense enough to realise how false that note would ring. I do not know how long the members of the Fine Gael organisation will follow that carrot or how long it will be until the members of the Labour Party turn up their noses at it. I would ask them to give up this business of dangling a carrot in front of their supporters' noses. They are only saying that in order to continue to hold on for a little longer to the support they got by false pretences in the recent election. It would have been far more decent of the Minister for Finance if he had come and said that that was the best he could do and leave it at that. Let them not hold this dusty and mouldy carrot in front of the noses of their supporters who are already beginning to resent it.

Comment on this
William Norton Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Norton) Labour Party

We have listened to a very brief and brazen effort by the Fianna Fáil Party to conceal their discomfort at the character of this Budget. Deputy Lemass, the chief apologist for the Fianna Fáil Party, who can usually put a face on the most mouldy of cases, was especially concerned by thunder and fury this evening to try and cheer up the drooping spirits of the back bench members.

Comment on this

Look at the Labour faces.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

They are entitled to talk without interruption, of course.

Comment on this

I would like to congratulate Deputy Lemass on one thing —no doubt, privately, Deputy Killilea will also congratulate him—and that is on the decision that the Opposition do not want a general election at present.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Try talking us into it.

Comment on this

If that is the case, give us the opportunity.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned, this will be a peaceful discussion.

Comment on this

So, the Minister wants no interruptions.

Comment on this

I want to appeal to reason and not to emotion of the kind generated by the amount of noisy fury in which Deputy Lemass indulged this afternoon.

Comment on this