Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).
Contributions 194–387 of 567. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Deputy Lemass says Fianna Fáil do not desire a general election at the present moment; they are going to wait until some special set of circumstances arises which will prevent them losing as many seats as they would lose if a general election were held to-morrow.
Comment on this
Why not give us an opportunity of trying the issue? Why will the Minister not seize on his opportunity?
Comment on this
We do not believe in going for midnight rides to the Park as the former Taoiseach did. I have no desire to emulate his methods in that respect. Neither do I want to cause any mental distress to Deputy Killilea by seeing him precipitated into a general election which he is praying will not take place for another five years.
This budget will be the subject of discussion for the next couple of weeks. I have no doubt that, no matter what kind of Budget we introduced, Deputy Lemass would have made the same kind of case. In fact, without knowing what was in the Budget at all, Deputy MacEntee, who must of course reassert his right to be the chief filibusterer of the Fianna Fáil Party, blustered in here yesterday evening with a speech which he had written before he heard the Budget at all; he got up here and delivered himself of views which purported to be his views on the Budget, although he had written he speech the day before. That is all right for Deputy Killilea. That is all right for anybody who is well-seasoned in irresponsibility. But one expects something better from a former Minister for Finance; one does not expect that he would write out his speech the day before, bring it in the next day and insist on making it, even though it bore no relation to the realities of the Budget.
Somebody ought to tell Deputy MacEntee to grow up politically. I know it is a pretty tough assignment to give to anybody but, if it is not done, Deputy MacEntee will leave public life, having been the Peter Pan of the Fianna Fáil Party all his life; and my personal regard, as distinct from my political distaste, for Deputy MacEntee compels me to make that appeal now to some of his colleagues on the Fianna Fáil benches.
In any case we can bring someone who is not on this side or that side of the House into this discussion, and see what he thinks of the Budget. Nobody will accuse me if I quote the Evening Press on this Budget. Last evening's issue of the Evening Press carried an article which is headed: “This is what they hope for in the Budget.” The Evening Press sent out some representatives to gather up a few folk and find out how they thought this Budget should be drawn. One reporter descended upon No. 71 Wellington Road in Deputy MacEntee's constituency and he there interviewed a person who is described by the Evening Press as “Mr. Average Married”. Mr. Average Married was asked:—
"What do you think this Budget should do?"
Here is what Deputy MacEntee's constituent says, representing his views of what this Budget should be; remember, this was before the Budget was introduced. Mr. Average Married said:—
"I would like the £85 allowance free for each child to be increased to £100. The round figure will be much better... and would save some married men like myself from paying income tax at all. And another important aspect is old age pensions. These old people deserve more money. Finally, I think revenue should come from more indirect taxation such as purchase tax on luxury goods."
Now I did not write this article or interview this individual; I do not know him at all. He was selected by the Evening Press; I suppose they know their men all right. This statement by this man could almost be a Budget leakage because he prophesied the Budget absolutely to a nicety. This Mr. Average Married that the Evening Press interviewed some time in the early hours of yesterday said, representing the view of the average married man, that the Budget might make increased provision for children's allowances for income-tax purposes and that old age pensions should be increased. The Evening Press thought that man's views were so sane, so sound and so representative of public opinion that they dignified him with the title of “Average Married Man”.
I think that man's view represents the view of the ordinary people of the country on this Budget. I think he represents the views of Deputy MacEntee's constituents, more so than Deputy MacEntee does. As the days and weeks go on, Deputy MacEntee will find that this constituent of his has been closer to the public pulse than Deputy MacEntee was in that demonstration of mock indignation to which he treated the House last evening. In any case Mr. Average Married got something more than he asked for; not only are we increasing old age pensions, but we are increasing blind pensions as well, and 28,000 widows and an unknown number of orphans will also benefit by this Budget. That is something that even Deputy MacEntee's constituents did not ask for.
I think Mr. Average Married Man's approach to this Budget is a more realistic one than Deputy MacEntee's yesterday evening or the simulated indignation of Deputy Lemass to-day. Some statements have been made by Deputy Lemass with which I would like to deal at the outset. Deputy Lemass referred to the export of cakes and the export of biscuits. I want to put on record in the most categorical manner that, so far as the export of cakes and biscuits is concerned, steps will be taken to ensure that the manufacturers of these commodities will get flour at the present price in order to maintain their position in the export market in the same way as certain manufacturers got sugar at a special price to enable them to maintain their position in that market. Anybody who is making cakes or biscuits for export can take my assurance now, publicly given, that their position will in no way be worsened and that they will continue to get flour and sugar at their present prices so far as this Budget is concerned in order to enable them to have access to those markets which are at present open to them. I hope that ghost has been laid once and for all.
Comment on this
That is quite satisfactory. Only the people living at home will pay more. That is quite satisfactory.
Comment on this
That cry will not carry the Opposition much further because during the period in which Deputy Lemass was in office he gave sugar to the cake and biscuit exporters cheaper than he gave it to the people at home. That cock will not fight in this discussion.
Comment on this
At one time I made them pay more for it. We put a levy on sugar for export to subsidise the home market.
Comment on this
In any case, Deputy Lemass can see clearly now that he cannot make much out of that point. I warned the Deputy to keep off those points because he would find himself running into a hornet's nest. The Deputy is now quite satisfied everything is all right.
Comment on this
At the Deputy's special request I will deal with that later. Let me come now to rural electrification. Deputy Lemass made an effort to work up a good deal of indignation here this evening in relation to rural electrification. Deputy Lemass is far too cute politically to believe what he says himself in this House. It was just another of the Deputy's well - recognised attempts at chancing his arm. Everybody knows that perfectly well. There will be no increase in electricity charges as a result of making the E.S.B. bear the full cost of rural electrification.
Comment on this
We will come to that in a moment. I counsel patience. Neither will there be any reduction in the rate of progress in carrying out rural electrification schemes. In fact, during the present year, and in future years, the rate of installation in the rural areas will be accelerated. I am making these two positive statements now. They are there to be quoted at any time, not only for to-day's debate. I will show in the course of time what I am saying here is not only correct in so far as to-day's discussions are concerned, but will represent our future policy.
Deputy Lemass asks who is going to pay. The position is that the E.S.B. has a surplus sufficient to enable it to pay the entire cost of rural electrification, and as they have that surplus, surely they ought to be asked to finance the whole scheme instead of keeping the surplus and getting the taxpayers, through the Exchequer, to put up money to finance rural electrification which does not need to be financed because the E.S.B. has got a surplus at present. That is the plain fact of the matter, and time will justify what I am saying.
Comment on this
There will never again be an increase in electricity charges, then?
Comment on this
Oh, no—that is another case of chancing your arm. In this debate the Government and all Parties in the Government have been chided with not having fully implemented our programme in a matter of 11 months. I think the very fact that Deputy Lemass expects us to do that is a tribute to his appreciation of what he thinks this Government can do, but may I put this to Deputy Lemass and to his leader Deputy de Valera? We had a Fianna Fáil policy in 1932 and this is 1955. That is 23 years ago. Nobody can accuse me of being petulant or fussy after 23 years if— and that was to be the official policy of the Fianna Fáil Party—I ask Fianna Fáil to-day have they achieved their policy of 1932?
Comment on this
Look at the first part of the Fianna Fáil policy?
Comment on this
I remember Deputy Lemass making a speech in which he promised that he was going to provide such a volume of work in the country that he was afraid there would not be enough people here to do all the work that would be available.
Comment on this
I will bet you five to one you do not find it—50 to one if you want decent odds.
Comment on this
All right. You are "on" at that now, and what you said is on the record. At that time it was declared that not only would there be an abundance of work but that there would not be sufficient people here to do it. Then we had the famous postscript from the Deputy that it would probably be necessary to comb the cities of America to bring back the exiles——
Comment on this
You might quote me for the next quotation, too. Somebody said to Deputy Aiken at Dundalk: "Deputy Aiken, do you know there are so many people unemployed?". Deputy Aiken, with that majectic grimace of his, replied: "What about it? Is it not good to have so many people unemployed at the moment to do all the work that Fianna Fáil will make available for them?". What is the quotation on that?
Comment on this
I have written these quotations into the Dáil Report many and many a time. Then, of course, we had Deputy de Valera who declared in 1931 and 1932 that unemployment was easier to solve in this country than in any other country in the world.
Comment on this
Is there a short price or a long one for that? Deputy de Valera said there was no reason why unemployment should exist, that we had an opportunity for solving it. All these statements were made—is there no betting on these?
Comment on this
All these statements were made by the Party opposite. Is it not a bit thick—I will put it no further than that—that the Party which made those promises in 1932 and had 23 years to fulfil them should come back here 23 years later—and one would assume 23 years wiser—and ask us why we have not fulfilled our entire programme in 11 months?
Comment on this
Not your entire programme: just the cost of living.
Comment on this
Deputy Killilea would be advised not to play with millions and to keep to pennies at the outset. This is the Party which now, having simply deserted its own programme, having failed to fulfil the reckless promises they made, expects us in the short period of 11 months to complete our programme——
Comment on this
No, a start in that direction—that is all we ask.
Comment on this
We never promised to do it in 11 months. We put down a 12-point programme and as long as this Government lasts it will strive day in and day out to achieve that programme and before I conclude, I think I shall be able to prove it—not to prejudiced minds like that of Deputy Lemass nor do I propose to penetrate the iron wall of Deputy Killilea's mind. I hope to be able to convince the people that in the past 11 months we have kept on the road of reality and are endeavouring to do the things which we promised the people we would do for them.
Deputy Lemass talked as if he had discovered some nigger of wage restraint in the speech of the Minister for Finance. Deputy Lemass is good on wage restraints. So is his leader. Let us have a quotation from both of them. In the Dáil Debates of the 16th October, 1947, after six years of wage freezing, during which the workers' wages were nailed almost to the ground while prices were allowed to rise and when they were struggling to get back a portion of their 1939 standard of living, Deputy Lemass delivered himself in these terms in this House, reported at column 558 of the 16th October, 1947. He said:—
"I want, however, to make it clear that the Government regard it as an essential safeguard to the interests of the general community at the present time that some check upon the upward movement of wages should operate."
In October, 1947, when the workers had endured under the Fianna Fáil Government six years of the most ruthless wage-freezing that has been known in any democratic country——
Comment on this
They expressed their agreement in the newspapers.
Comment on this
Were it not for the fierce indignation of the workers and the people generally and the general election in 1948, the Fianna Fáil Government would have come back to office to implement in 1948 the same wage-freezing policy that they initiated in 1941. Thank God the people saved the country and saved the lives of the workers from a repetition of the gross injustices which they had endured under the Fianna Fáil wage-freezing policy of the emergency years. In case this was just a stray thought by Deputy Lemass——
Comment on this
When are we going to get back to the Budget? Are you satisfied with the Budget?
Comment on this
Nobody likes to be haunted by ghosts and Deputy Lemass does not like to meet the ghost of his wage-freezing speech made in 1947. Lest Deputy Lemass thought he had a monopoly of that idea in 1947, I want to give pride of place to his leader, Deputy de Valera. He deserves mention, too. On the 15th October, 1947, as reported at column 389 of the Official Report, Deputy de Valera said:—
"The Government regards this temporary limitation of wage increases as vitally necessary in present circumstances, and if the trade unions cannot undertake such an agreement as I have outlined... then the Government will produce proposals for legislation to the same effect."
Deputy Lemass said the unions agreed. Deputy de Valera is rather doubtful. He said, in effect: "If you do not agree, lads, I will introduce the legislation and I will pin your ears to the legislation." Yet, Deputy Lemass, as if he were born only yesterday, comes to the House to-day to express an artificial horror that there should be even a reference to a wage restraint in the Minister's speech—although, in fact, there is no reference there at all.
Comment on this
There is a reference to a rising cost of living.
Comment on this
On the subject of a rising cost of living, I think I have a quotation here either from Deputy Lemass or Deputy de Valera.
Comment on this
Let us into the secret. Is the Minister satisfied with the Budget?
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass gave us an interesting dissertation to-day on bread. He spoke of the extent to which bread is consumed by all classes of families. He mentioned how important it is that the lower paid workers should get bread cheaply and how little bread figures in the domestic economy of families with a large income. He went on to profess a sympathy for making bread cheap so far as lower paid workers are concerned. As I listened to Deputy Lemass talking here to-day I began to wonder where he was the day the 1952 Budget was presented to the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I said the Government should concentrate whatever they can give on bread.
Comment on this
Having declared that bread is an important item of diet, Deputy Lemass endeavoured to shed tears here to-day for those who have to pay the present price for bread. They are paying the present price for bread because the Deputy discovered what he said to-day three years too late. If he had expressed these views to the Government in 1952 he might have prevented the savage slashing of the subsidy on flour. Deputy Lemass was a consenting party to pushing the 2-lb. loaf up from 6d. to 9d.—and then, three years afterwards, he tells us that bread is an important article in the diet of the ordinary people and that we should give it to them at as cheap a rate as possible.
This is a case where practice is better than precept. Would it not have been more consistent and more understandable if, in 1952, the Deputy had convinced his colleagues that they should keep their hands off bread and that they should not increase the price of bread from 6d. to 9d.—which, of course, they did. If bread prices have been high from 1952 to 1955 it is because Deputy Lemass's Government slashed the food subsidies. I think I have now answered most of the points which were raised by Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
I am satisfied with the Budget. I wish the Deputy were as happy about it as I am. This Budget has to be understood not merely by the figures which it contains but by the atmosphere in which it is introduced and by the portents which surround it. So far as last year is concerned it has been a year both of hope and promise in regard to our economic circumstances. We have got away from the gloomy years of 1953 and the early part of 1954. They are now an evil memory—and, please God, they will remain an evil memory so long as Deputy de Valera retains his seat over there on the Opposition Benches. What are the facts of last year's——
Comment on this
What are the facts of 1953 that the Minister has been speaking about? What are the facts which justify the Minister's saying it was a year of gloom?
Comment on this
Good gracious, of course it was. I do not remember anything worse in the last ten years. I take it that some member of the Fianna Fáil Party will point out, before the debate finishes, the blessings of 1953 under Fianna Fáil—blessings which ripened and diffused themselves to such an extent that, in 1954, the Party responsible for the blessings were fired out of office. The people did not see the blessings with the same clarity as the members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
They listened to the falsehoods uttered by people now sitting on the Government Benches.
Comment on this
I congratulate Deputy de Valera on the nimbleness of mind which he displays when in Government and in Opposition. When he is sitting on the Government side of the House he is sitting here fortified by the will of the people: when he is sitting on the Opposition Benches he is sitting there because the people were misled.
Comment on this
The Budget is the best proof that they were deceived.
Comment on this
I should like to associate with that comment of mine a famous remark by Deputy de Valera. He once said that the people have no right to do wrong but if they want to do it at elections——
Comment on this
They supported him strongly afterwards.
Comment on this
To vote against the Fianna Fáil Party is not established either ethically or morally to be wrong. That is not a reserved sin yet—much as Deputy de Valera might like to make it one. Last year shows that the real improvement came after the Fianna Fáil Government left office. The most notable achievement in that respect was in the last quarter of 1954. In the first nine months our balance of trade was £5,000,000 worse than 1953, but in the last quarter there was an improvement of £8.7 million—and the year ended almost £4,000,000 better than the year 1953. Our balance of payments deficit last year was better than in any year since 1946 and it would have been better than 1946 were it not for the fact that there was an artificial balance that year due to the scarcity of supplies. Therefore, taking last year with any year from 1946, our balance of payments position was better. Is that not an indication that we can look forward in 1955 at least to a continuance of last year's situation if not, indeed, to an improvement?
Look at the employment situation. We are running now with an unemployment figure which is 7,000 lower than it was this time last year. I think that would probably be better were it not for the dislocation caused by the recent building strike. However, we are running 7,000 lower than this time last year. Our employment figure— that is, the number of people employed in the manufacturing industries—has exceeded 150,000 for the first time since 1922. So that we have not only a new high record in employment, but we have a new low record in unemployment and these are two features which have came about since June of last year.
Comment on this
What did you do about that? What precise thing did you do?
Comment on this
Not a fear of it. You will get it yourself sooner.
Comment on this
Let us take another encouraging feature of last year. There was a complaint by Fianna Fáil when we were last in office that a good deal of our imports represented consumer goods. This news will be heartening to them. Last year our purchases of agricultural machinery increased from £1.8 million to £2.5 million, an indication that better effort was being made to extract from the soil the wealth which the soil can give us and, in the same period, tractor imports increased from 4,360 to 5,377. While all that was taking place, for the first time for many years we were able to hold employment for agricultural workers on the land.
Comment on this
What date were these figures for agricultural employment taken?
Comment on this
The figures are taken on one day in the year. What day was it? Was it the 1st June?
Comment on this
It is prepared by civil servants whose accuracy and reputation, I take it, the Deputy does not desire to comment on adversely.
Comment on this
The writing on the wall put people into jobs? What was on the wall was "Vote Fine Gael and Lower Taxes."
Comment on this
If you look at this Budget, in particular at the capital expenditure provided for in the Budget, you can see that this Government is approaching its capital development programme with both courage and vision, and those interested in capital development can feel gratified that this Government is making so much money available for the capital development programme this year.
What is that programme so far as this year is concerned? Over £9,000,000 will be spent on housing; £1,250,000 on sanitary services; £4,000,000 for electrical development; £4,600,000 for agricultural development; almost £3,000,000 for hospitals; over £2,000,000 for schools and other buildings; £1,250,000 for turf development; £1,500,000 for telephone development; over £3,000,000 for transport development; nearly £1,000,000 for afforestation; £150,000 for fisheries; Ceimici Teoranta, £120,000; £250,000 for Irish Steel Holdings; £2,500,000 for National Development Fund.
These represent the main features of a capital development Budget which has been planned with reality. These sums are available. It will be our effort to make sure that these moneys are taken up in the worthwhile schemes of capital development which this Government will endeavour to push through in the current year.
Comment on this
If there is any doubt about the credit-worthiness of this Government or its standing in the country, it can be tested against the National Loan which we floated last October. On that occasion the loan which we issued was fully subscribed. It was subscribed at a rate of interest lower than the rate for the Fianna Fáil loans of 1952 and 1953. In other words, we were able to get from the people all the money that we needed in that loan and to get it at a lower rate of interest than the rate at which Fianna Fáil could borrow in 1952 and 1953. As a result, we were able to make loans available for housing and other development schemes at a lower rate of interest than the rate at which such loans were available under the Fianna Fáil policy. Remember also that the loan we issued then, as evidence of the continued soundness and stability of this Government, is being quoted at a premium on the Stock Exchange.
I think any thinking person who is not politically blinded will realise that all these evidences which I offer here have all the characteristics of the activities of a good Government, broadly based, sound in its concept and at the same time enjoying the confidence of the people. These results could never be possible of achievement if the Government did not command the confidence of the people. All these indications confirm that the Government enjoys to-day, not less, but more confidence than it enjoyed when it was swept into office in May of last year.
We have had a lot of talk from Fianna Fáil about social welfare services. So far as I am personally concerned—I think in this matter I can speak not only for my own Party but for the Government—I regard an improvement in our social services as one of the best ways of bringing social justice into the lives and into the homes of the simple people of no power and no wealth up and down the country. I regard a high standard of social services as essential to maintain a Christian standard of living in the homes of people who, unfortunately, are from time to time stricken by the wintry economic blasts that blow across their path. What is the record of the inter-Party Government in respect of social services?
Comment on this
We raised old age pensions when we were last in office to 17/6 per week. They were 12/6, the last 2/6 raising them from 10/- to 12/6 only being paid on the certificate of a home assistance officer, under Fianna Fáil. When Fianna Fáil were in office in 1947-48, you could get an old age pension of 10/-, which the British gave away back in 1916.
Comment on this
You could get a supplementary allowance of 2/6 if you got a certificate from a home assistance officer after he had carried out a microscopic inquisition of your needs. That was the Fianna Fáil policy of helping the old age pensioners during the emergency. We came into office in 1948. We abolished that means test for the supplementary 2/6 and we raised old age pensions to 17/6 per week without a means test so far as the home assistance officer was concerned. When we went out of office in 1951 we left here a Social Welfare Bill which had passed its Second Reading in this House and which provided for the raising of old age pensions to £1 per week. That was the position when we left it in 1951. Nineteen hundred and fifty-two came and Fianna Fáil slashed the subsidies in that year. As a result of the slashing of the subsidies they increased the price of tea, bread, butter, sugar, flour, tobacco, cigarettes and beer.
Comment on this
If I am not right Deputy de Valera will have an opportunity of dealing with it and of dealing with a quotation from his own lips with which I shall present him in a few minutes. All these prices were increased for the old age pensioners by the action of Fianna Fáil in slashing the subsidies in 1952. Then the pharaoh hearts of Fianna Fáil softened and they said: "We must do something for the old age pensioners." They said: "Look here, brother, you will pay more for your tea, your bread, your butter, your sugar, your flour, your tobacco, your cigarettes and for your glass of beer, but what matter. We will give you 1/6 per week, per seven days, to compensate you." That was the magnanimity of the Fianna Fáil gift to the old age pensioners in 1952, and that 1/6 per week was offered as compensation for the rapid increases in these prices, many of these commodities being stable articles in the diet of the old age pensioners concerned.
We said during the election campaign, and we repeated it after the election, that if elected to office and when in office we would seek to improve social welfare benefits, not merely because we had made that promise during the election but because we regarded it as a measure of social justice to lift the standard of living of these unfortunate people in our community. The first step has been taken in this Budget but it is only the first step as the Minister for Finance has said. What is happening under this Budget? 162,000 old age pensioners will get increases; 6,000 blind pensioners will get increases; 28,000 widows, now trying to live on non-contributory pensions, will also get increases. Even in our small community upwards of 200,000 persons will get benefits through this Government. Deputy Lemass said he is glad they have got it. Of course every Christian is glad. Am I offensive if I ask Deputy Lemass why this zealous sympathy now and not before now?
Comment on this
There was also a Budget in 1953 and why could it not have been done then or in the early part of 1954? The fact of the matter is that it had to wait for the inter-Party Government now, as it had to wait for them from 1948 to 1951, to lift the level of the social welfare benefits, especially in so far as these poor people are concerned. People may say they would like to have seen us giving more. So would we like to have been able to give more, particularly in this field of social welfare. As the Minister for Finance said in his Budget speech this marks the first instalment, but only the first instalment of our plans. We have other proposals in the field of social welfare. As inevitably as these benefits came to-day others will come during the period of office of this Government and so will the many other things promised be done so long as this Government is in office.
We will endeavour to apply our hearts and our determination to the implementation of our promises and to keeping faith with the people whom we represent, and so long as we keep faith with them, and we shall be prevented only by physical forces outside our control, we can go back to the people and say to them in this big field that we made an honest effort to keep faith with them. This needy class will know when they read the papers to-day that £1,000,000 more is being spent on social services than by Fianna Fáil in the Budgets which it presented last year or in 1953 and I do not think it is exaggerating to say that if Fianna Fáil were in office this year not another penny would have been given to the old age pensioners or to the blind persons.
Comment on this
The Minister can say that and I can say the opposite. There was £3,000,000 there to give to them.
Comment on this
Let me present this quotation to Deputy Lemass, and to Deputy de Valera particularly, and I hope Deputy de Valera will deal with it when speaking on the Budget. At the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis last October, according to the daily papers——
Comment on this
I want to know accurately what it is the Minister is quoting.
Comment on this
Look at all the papers. I shall not accuse Deputy de Valera at all of running away from any promises he made or from anything he may have said. In fact, I am going to congratulate him on the candour he displayed.
Comment on this
I want to know from what paper the Minister is about to quote.
Comment on this
It is from the Irish Independent of the 13th October, 1954. It quotes Deputy de Valera, speaking at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, as saying that in regard to social services Fianna Fáil had kept to the middle of the road. It quotes him as saying: “The means must be there to meet increases in social services, otherwise the whole nation would be crippled. Taxation was now running at a very high level and any increase in social services would be dangerous.”
Comment on this
That you must have means to meet your obligations.
Comment on this
There must be means there to meet increases in social services, otherwise the nation would be crippled. He said taxation was now running at a very high level and that the nation would be crippled by any increases.
Comment on this
Do not take things out of their context. We have done more for social services than some of you people ever thought of.
Comment on this
The whole social service code of the country was introduced by us.
Comment on this
Here is a candid declaration by Deputy de Valera. I agree that it is much better to come down in that flat-footed way than to attempt to do what the boys in the back benches do when they go down the country and tell the simple fellows at the cross-roads that they were not in favour of something. At least Deputy de Valera put the Party on the one foot by saying that taxation was already too high and that there could not be any further increases in social services. That means of course that if Deputy de Valera were sitting on these benches this year there would have been no increases——
Comment on this
If there were means available the old age pensioners would have got increases.
Comment on this
You are not increasing taxation, are you, except in the case of electricity?
Comment on this
Do not try to argue this with Deputy de Valera because he will win out in the end. He will stick to what he said. Long membership of this House has taught me not to engage in these discussions with Deputy de Valera because he always wins in the end.
Comment on this
Because you were always wrong. That is the reason you do not engage in them.
Comment on this
That is the inevitable result. You cannot play with him in discussion because he must be allowed to chalk up the score every time. You must lose every time. It was obvious to the thinking members of the Fianna Fáil Party, to the public who read outside that that statement by Deputy de Valera in October last was a bleak and despairing statement which offered no hope whatever to upwards of 200,000 persons who will benefit under this Budget. We have saved the people from the bleakness which was then offered to them by the Fianna Fáil Party. Instead we have given them hope and this Budget has given them solid achievement. The rest of our policy on social welfare will be implemented in due course, certainly sooner than it would have been implemented if there were a Fianna Fáil Party in office.
Deputy Lemass talked about the cost of living but before I come to the cost of living I want to quote from the Sunday Press of the 9th May, 1954. This is the paper which, I think, shares with its week-day brother the title that says “Truth in the News”. There is a cartoon here and it is headed: “Back to 1951”. There is a rather corrugated old gentleman in this cartoon with a young lad labelled “Sean Citizen” and the injunction at the bottom says: “Do not cut a rod to beat yourself”. The old gentleman is supposed to be the schoolmaster and he is telling the young pupil not to cut a rod to beat himself. The people, through this advertisement, are warned not to go back to 1951 and they are told by this cartoon that if they do it means that their wages will be cut by 12/6 per week. Has that happened? Of course not. That was untruth No. 1. They are told that if they do, old age pensions will be cut by 4/-. That has not happened. That is untruth No. 2. They are told that children's allowances will be cut by 4/-. That has not happened and that is untruth No. 3. They are told that sickness payments would be cut by 27/6 a week. There is the cartoon which is available for inspection, but it is the most disreputable and untruthful cartoon that ever appeared in an Irish newspaper, and it appeared, too, in a newspaper that says its policy is “Truth in the News”. If there is as much truth in the news as there is in the cartoon, God help the people who buy the Irish Press.
I understand that Deputy de Valera is still the governing director of this newspaper. If he is, let him find out who wrote and who produced this filthy cartoon and who gave the authority for publishing a heap of lies, which Deputy de Valera must have known, if he saw the cartoon, were lies, which every member of his Party must have known were lies. It is a lie to-day and can be seen there. There is no better way of proving it than by what we have done during the past ten months. There is no better way of clinching the argument than letting the people read this Budget which is going to bring relief to upwards of 200,000 people who would never have got anything from the authors of this malicious and untruthful cartoon.
Deputy Lemass spoke about prices. Here again I think the Deputy deserves some congratulation for the glib way in which he is able to put on such a brazen stand in respect of prices. I can understand the ordinary housewife having a critical view about prices. I can understand the person who never votes having a critical view about prices. I can understand members of our own Party here having a critical view about prices and wanting this, that and the other thing done. I have a lot of sympathy with them and I can understand them in respect of what they are anxious to do, but the one thing I cannot understand is Fianna Fáil criticising prices, Fianna Fáil who have been the architects of the present high level of prices.
Let us look at the facts. In mid-May, 1951, when we left office, the cost-of-living index figure was 109. When Fianna Fáil left office in 1954, the cost-of-living index figure was 124, an increase of 15 points in three short years brought about, of course, by the slashing of the food subsidies.
Comment on this
You lose again. Deputy de Valera is right. Mid-May, 1951, index figure 109; May, 1954, index figure 124. I would not attempt to put my knowledge of mathematics beside Deputy de Valera's, but still I can make a subtraction here and the subtraction here says that the index figure is up by 15 points in three years.
Comment on this
But you added something. You said it was due to the slashing by Fianna Fáil of the subsidies.
Comment on this
Yes, and to say how much of the 15 points was caused by the subsidies.
Comment on this
Eight from the same causes as yours went up from November to May.
Comment on this
In any case, I want to ask Deputy de Valera when he speaks on this Budget to tell us once and for all what the Fianna Fáil Party would have done in respect of tea prices. On the Supplies and Services Bill, on my own Estimates and in other discussions in this House I have tried to corkscrew from the Fianna Fáil front bench what they would have done in the face of the substantial rise in tea prices. When there was silence on the front bench I asked that permission should be given to somebody on the back benches to speak for the Party, that we should have some glimmer of an indication as to what Fianna Fáil would have done in respect of tea. I could not get any explanation. I cannot get it now and it is because I cannot get it now that I want to assert this, that if Fianna Fáil had been in office in August and September of last year or were in office to-day they would have allowed tea prices to rise and that the people would be paying 3/-per lb. more for their tea than they are paying to-day thanks to the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
You see the skill of the old political veteran. I am asking him what is his policy to-day——
Comment on this
I want to know where you stand to-day in regard to tea prices. I asked what you would have done and the answer is what I am to do in the future. I suggest we ought to decide the present and let us move on to the future.
Comment on this
I think there is a rumble coming. We are going to get an explanation. What does Deputy Carter think? What would the Fianna Fáil Party have done?
Comment on this
At the same time the Minister is pretending he is conferring an honour on the people.
Comment on this
He said we are putting it on the long finger. His view is that the subsidy should not be on at all, that the people should pay 3/- more. That is their view, but thanks to us they are not paying 3/- more. We have held tea prices steady.
Comment on this
We did that because we did not want an impact on the people's standard of living by allowing tea prices to rise so substantially.
Comment on this
By telling Tea Importers to carry the price on an overdraft, as your Government told Fuel Importers to carry fuel on an overdraft amounting to many millions of pounds for more than ten years.
Comment on this
These interruptions must cease. The Tánaiste is in possession and should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
Let us move off tea, if it is such an unpalatable beverage for the Fianna Fáil Party. Is it appreciated that if Fianna Fáil were in office the people would be paying 3/- a lb. more for tea than they are to-day? Will you deny that fact ?
Comment on this
I will move on to butter. Maybe that is a better wicket for you. We reduced the price by 5d. a lb. as an earnest of our intention to reduce the cost of living. We brought butter down to 3/9 after Fianna Fáil had forced it up to 4/2. I ask Deputy de Valera this: if the Fianna Fáil Party had been returned last year, would they have reduced the price of butter? It could only be done by subsidising it. Fianna Fáil, having abolished the subsidy on butter in 1952, is anyone so soft-headed as to believe that they they would have restored any portion of it in 1954? Of course they would not. I assert here again that if Fianna Fáil were in office to-day the people would be paying 5d. per lb. more for butter.
Take these two items alone. Thanks to the Fianna Fáil Party sitting over there ornamenting those benches, the people now are getting tea at 3/- a lb. less and they are buying butter at 5d. a lb. less. Apart from those two isolated instances, there is a general feeling of buoyancy, a general feeling of progress and of hope, a feeling of solid achievements on every side—all clear evidence of the consequences of the Fianna Fáil Party having taken their departure from office.
Comment on this
Let me cost this Budget in another way. These improvements which have been given in the Budget cost money. The money has got to be found. We have found the money to do it and found it without imposing any additional taxes that would in any way impact on the national economy. For example, the butter subsidy this year is costing £2,000,000 and everyone who misguidedly voted for Fianna Fáil in the last election can sit down now feeling satisfied that, thanks to the inter-Party Government, the Fianna Fáil supporters can put butter on their bread, now that Fianna Fáil are not in office.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe, as usual, is in the luxury trade. No bread and butter for the Deputy.
Comment on this
The butter subsidy this year is costing £2,000,000 which this Government is gladly providing so that the people may have cheaper butter. Then there are additional health services this year over and above last year, which will cost £750,000 more.
Comment on this
We have increased the services and provided improved benefits for upwards of 200,000 people. We are providing nearly £1,000,000 more for social services this year than was provided by the Fianna Fáil Government. We are providing tax free allowances under the income-tax allowances for children, which will bring relief this year to 27,000 families at a cost of £100,000 this year—more next year. The additional cost, borne in our Budget this year, to provide for the reliefs granted last year amounts to an additional £600,000. In this Budget the reliefs and improvements will cost us £4,350,000 this year. When you remember, too, that we are not getting this year £1,000,000 from C.I.E., as Fianna Fáil had at its service last year, that we had to provide also for a deficit of £500,000 in Deputy MacEntee's incorrect over-estimation in last year and that we had to provide for a net increase of £1,000,000 in the Central Fund, I think we can reasonably claim that, especially in the short time we are in office, we have done a very good job with the resources at our disposal.
Let us sum up. You cannot take the policy of a team from just one portion of the football field, you cannot take the conduct of a Government by what it has done in one particular Department: you have to sit back and take, not a microscopic look at the performance of the Government but a telescopic look at it. I want now to take a brief telescopic look at our achievements in 11 short months. Butter has been brought down by 5d. a lb. The price of tea has been held to such an extent that our people are getting cheaper tea than people in any other white country in the world to-day. Our employment is up to an all-time high record; our unemployment figures are down by 7,000 compared with this time last year. Our industrial production is up to a higher level than ever before. Our agricultural production is up. The Dáil is now passing a Bill to give back powers to the representatives of the local people through the medium of the County Management Act.
Comment on this
There is before the House a Workmen's Compensation Bill to give injured workmen better compensation than ever before. That Bill is doing for injured workers this year what Fianna Fáil refused to do for them when we in opposition introduced a similar Bill a few years ago.
Comment on this
Employment on the land is being steadied, notwithstanding the substantial mechanisation of agricultural production. The bank rate, for the first time, is an Irish bank rate and not a British bank rate.
Comment on this
This Government, because of its stability, because the people know its policy, because the people know it can be trusted, is able to borrow money at a lower rate of interest than that at which the Fianna Fáil Government was able to borrow it in 1952 and 1953. We have increased industrial development. In the last nine months, 82 new industrial enterprises or extensions to existing enterprises have been commenced. There are, before the Department of Industry and Commerce, about 240 approaches for the establishment of industrial enterprises, many of which will fructify into new industries, or extensions to existing industries in the years to come. We have, before the Dáil, an Industrial Relations Bill which, for the first time, will give road workers and associated workers entrance to the Labour Court for the adjudication of their difficulties, something which has always been denied them by the Fianna Fáil Government. On top of that, we have this, the first instalment of improved social services.
That is a creditable record for a new Government 11 months in office. By sound and courageous government, responsive to the people's will, and anxious to serve their needs, I hope that the Minister for Finance and myself will be able to do better next year, and still better in the long number of years on which we will occupy these benches. Somebody once said that we could do the impossible in a short time, but miracles take a little longer. That is what we have done in the last 11 months.
Comment on this
I did not envy An Tánaiste his job, as the parliamentary leader of the Labour Party, and as titular head of those who voted Labour throughout the country, trying to defend what has been pretty adequately described by Deputy Lemass as "a Sweet Fanny Adam Budget". Deputy Norton and members of his Party may be able to specify certain little reliefs in this Budget, some measure of social service benefit increases, but the public will not forget how he and his Party so fluently and lavishly promised substantial decreases in the cost of living. Deputy Norton said in his own constituency, using his own words, that even if he had to resort again to subsidisation he would do so. That has been done, to the extent of the 5d. a pound for butter. That was very early in the life of the present Government, but beyond that and beyond the token of holding tea prices not one effort has been made by this Government to hold, much less reduce, the cost of living.
It is little wonder that Deputy Norton should have resorted to the degree of levity he did and to a certain amount of personal jibing at the Leader of the Opposition in order to get over his case, jibing which, of course, got the applause of those sitting behind him, half-hearted laughter, just as the Minister for Finance yesterday got watery applause and cheers from the cheer boys behind him for the puny reliefs he gave in the present Budget. The only relief, I think, felt in this House yesterday was definitely amongst the Labour Party members when the Minister for Finance sat down at about 20 minutes past five, to relieve them of their embarrassment at not hearing fulfilled what they had promised to their supporters. The same goes for many of the Fine Gael Party members. It is little wonder, having regard to the promises that were made in this House, on the authority of no less a person than the Taoiseach, and even the present Attorney General, that taxation could be so substantially reduced as was promised.
In case there is still some doubt as to the figures given—and I heard even the Taoiseach and the Attorney-General challenging some of Deputy Lemass's figures and some of the statements purported to be made by the Taoiseach—I would again remind them that during the course of the debate on the brutal Budget—so described by Deputy McGilligan—of 1952, the first thing he said was that he would repeal every one of the items of taxation as imposed in that Budget if he was sitting on the side of the House on which he now is. He said that in column 1439, Volume 131 of the Official Debates. Lower down he said, in column 1442:—
"I would resign the next minute, rather than proceed with any single provision in the present Budget."
He proceeded with every provision of it, as it was implemented in 1954; he possibly had little choice in the matter, as the Budget was already in operation when he took office. But he has had practically a full year to examine whether his promise to resign was well founded and if he realised that the brutal Budget was unnecessary, then every item of the taxations imposed was unnecessary and he has had ample opportunity to implement the promise that he would resign rather than proceed with any of the provisions of that Budget. I am sure he has no intention whatever of resigning.
It is a pity that Deputy Dunne has left the House, because he was not here when Deputy Lemass was reminding him of some of the statements he made as to what the Labour Party said on the cost of living.
I come now to another important personage in the Government, who was not mentioned by Deputy Lemass, that is, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. I take it that by virtue of his title and of the position he holds in his own Party, he is a man of some degree of importance, who has some influence with the Government. He said in the same volume, column 639:—
"The question was that if there was a change of Government would the same taxes be left on or what would be done."
He congratulated Deputy McQuillan, who was the Deputy who raised that question. In the next column he said:—
"With a change of Government and with the help of men like Deputy McGilligan again, taxation to the extent of that £10,000,000 could be reduced. That is the answer to the question that was asked."
That is a question which the people of the country will be asking members of the Government Parties during the next few weeks: What has become of that £10,000,000 and, in fact, what has become of Deputy McGilligan's £20,000,000? The Minister in column 264, endorsing Deputy Costello's appraisal of that Budget, said:—
"......the Leader of the Opposition made it perfectly clear that, in his view, unnecessary taxation was being taken out of the pockets of the people by this Budget for the purpose of creating an artificial surplus which next year, if the Fianna Fáil Party remained on that side of the House they could take off and go to the country believing that the public memory is short..."
Deputy Sweetman is in that very happy position of Minister for Finance enjoying over-taxation that would bring in such increases in revenue as to enable him to give reliefs that would make him and his Government very popular throughout the country, but he has seen that the taxation then imposed, that brutal taxation, was necessary at least to the extent that he has endorsed it, that he has seen fit not to relieve the taxpayers in all the separate catagories, to which reference has been made—the smokers and the pint drinkers. He has not been able to relieve them of a single penny.
I will refer later to some of the promises made with regard to these taxes, but it was rather paradoxical of the Tánaiste to claim that, as a result of their coming into power in 1954, things immediately took a turn for the better, that, as a result of it, unemployment figures were reduced and industrial employment reached an all-time high and that there was a feeling of confidence and buoyancy throughout the country which made 1954 a very good year for the country. If, as a result of the change of Government, these effects could have been so soon felt throughout the country, why is it that this Budget is such a trifling imitation of what his Government promised could be done if they had the chance and could be done overnight if they had the chance?