We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 388–567 of 567. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I thought we would get that phrase. Where is the "overnight" phrase?

Comment on this

In ten minutes.

Comment on this

Where is the ten minutes?

Comment on this

I remember the Deputy standing up here in about the third seat from the right and saying that he could reduce it by £1,000,000 per minute.

Comment on this

If what? If we were elected before the July of that year. Is that not right?

Comment on this

Now we are getting all the contingencies.

Comment on this

Is that not right? Get your quotation right.

Comment on this

We will get it all right.

Comment on this

That is, before the mess was made of things.

Comment on this

I am only stating what I remember.

Comment on this

You are apparently only remembering what suits you and that is a bad tactic. It is a disreputable attempt to misquote.

Comment on this

I am quoting the words of the Attorney-General under the present Taoiseach and I have already quoted the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

You have not quoted me yet.

Comment on this

I will quote now the Minister for Education, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party. At column 47 of the same volume having mentioned various figures, £1,800,000, £1,000,000, £2,000,000 and so on, he said:—

"... under the heading of what Deputy Costello described as buoyancy, he was over-budgeting to the extent of £3,000,000. These sums add up to £10,300,000."

Surely if the Fine Gael members were so glib in pointing out how over-taxation was carried on to that extent in 1952 and how it was continued in 1953 and 1954, they should have made some effort to give some relief and indicate how they could now utilise the over-taxation and over-estimation of revenue which they were so glibly describing in those years.

Comment on this

£4,500,000 is not a bad start.

Comment on this

It was rather interesting, too, to hear the Tánaiste referring to the 82 new industrial proposals that had taken shape in the few months the Government were in office. I should like to know is he personally, or as a member of the Government, taking pride in that fact, and is he trying to impress the public and members of the Dáil that because there are 240 industrial proposals before his Department at present, it is an indication of wide expansion in industrial employment? I am sure Deputy McGilligan knows well —he was Minister for Industry and Commerce at one time—that very many industrial proposals are put before the Department of Industry and Commerce which never come to anything and never have a hope of coming to anything.

With regard to social services, by all means the Government and the Minister for Finance can take pride and pleasure in the fact that he was in a position to give certain reliefs under different headings to recipients of social welfare benefits in this Budget. I believe that, having regard to the increase in the cost of living in the past few months, no matter what Government was in power, it would have to face up to an increase in old age pensions, widows' pensions and possibly further and other increases not taken into account at all by the Minister in his Budget. The pity is that he did not go that little bit further and make it a round 25/- a week for old age pensioners.

Comment on this

You said they were too well off.

Comment on this

I never said any such thing.

Comment on this

Your Government did.

Comment on this

My Government never said that.

Comment on this

You did say they were too well off, and you cut their subsidies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

Having regard again to what the Labour Party promised in relation to means tests, I think they could have gone a little further and reduced the means test, so that more people could qualify even for the minimum old age pension and so subvent these little pittances they get by way of superannuation and otherwise in order to eke out a decent living for themselves. I believe that if that was done, in addition to the 2/6 increase, it would not have cost so much extra that a little paring or pruning in expenditure would not easily have met it.

Comment on this

It is a very late thought on your part. You went the other way—they were too well off.

Comment on this

I should like to remind Deputy McGilligan of the history of his own Party with regard to social services and the declaration not very long ago of his leader, Deputy Costello, as he then was, who said that the existence of social services was a sign of illness in the body politic. He went on to say how much he disapproved of the existence of social services.

Comment on this

I think you are quoting wrongly.

Comment on this

I am quoting from memory.

Comment on this

You are giving it to the wrong person.

Comment on this

But I am quoting and directly and accurately when I say that Deputy Costello then said that the existence of social services was a sign of illness in the body politic.

Comment on this

No—he said that the necessity for them was a sign of illness.

Comment on this

A big difference.

Comment on this

It is a tremendous difference.

Comment on this

It is a big difference.

Comment on this

Having regard to the apathy which Fine Gael always showed to these social services and having regard to their record generally, without saying anything about their reduction of 1/- in the old age pension, Deputy McGilligan should be very slow to criticise the Fianna Fáil approach to the social service code generally.

Comment on this

Listen—you said they were too well off in 1952. That is why you slashed the subsidies.

Comment on this

The subsidies were not slashed because they were too well off.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister said.

Comment on this

They were compensated in 1952.

Comment on this

On the contrary, when the subsidies were taken off, or, rather, reduced, Deputy MacEntee said he realised the impact which that would have on the recipients of old age pensions and he gave them an increase of 1/6, which he admitted at the time was not as much as he would like to give them.

Comment on this

And we are giving what now?

Comment on this

We gave 2/6 prior to the 1/6—4/-.

Comment on this

I might also mention——

Comment on this

They were too well off.

Comment on this

I might also mention——

Comment on this

That was why 1/-was taken off the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

——that Deputy Norton, when Minister for Social Welfare in a former inter-Party Government in which I take it Deputy McGilligan had far more power and influence than he has in this Government, was committed to have on the Order Paper of this House for almost three years a social welfare code that he was deliberately obstructed in implementing and when it came to the old age pensions——

Comment on this

Who told you?

Comment on this

——we from this side of the House told the Government that if they were not able to agree amongst themselves as to whether or not there should be a comprehensive social welfare scheme at least if they permitted Deputy Norton to bring in one short Bill to increase the old age pensions there would be no opposition from this side of the House and that the increase would be implemented in as quick a time as it would take to print the Bill and present it to the House.

Comment on this

What year was that?

Comment on this

1951.

Comment on this

And in 1952 you said the people were too well off.

Comment on this

Let me finish.

Comment on this

I wish the Deputy to remember that.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton was not only prevented from bringing in the comprehensive social welfare scheme but he was also obviously obstructed in bringing in that short measure which he was invited by the Opposition to bring in. On the change of Government in 1951, that Bill was introduced and within two months old age pensioners had their increase.

Comment on this

In 1952 the subsidies were cut because the people were too well off.

Comment on this

That was not said. On the contrary, the Minister immediately gave an increase, small though it was——

Comment on this

Did not the Minister say that as the increases had gone beyond the increases in the cost of living there was no reason for subsidies?

Comment on this

I will take the Attorney-General's own interpretation. Is not the Attorney-General suggesting that the Minister for Finance of the day said that because the old age pensioners were too well off he was withdrawing the subsidies——

Comment on this

He said they were too well off and was giving them back 1/6.

Comment on this

We had to pay your debts.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There has been continual interruption of Deputy Lynch. Deputy Lynch must be allowed to make his speech without interruption. He is entitled to that and so is every other Deputy.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General cannot take it.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy wanted an argument.

Comment on this

I was making a statement. Since Deputy McGilligan came into the House at 3.30 p.m. he has been trying to engage every speaker— there were only two—from this side of the House in argument in order to put them off their line in regard to a watery Budget.

Comment on this

I thought it was to bring the Deputy down to facts.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste saw fit to bring in last evening's Evening Press and quote from it naturally to suit his own case. I do not blame him for that if there is something in it to suit his own case. It was a statement supposed to have been made by Mr. Average Married. When asked what he would like to see in the Budget he said—and I think it showed a reasonable degree of intelligent anticipation —he would like to see the £85 allowance free for each child increased to £100. Deputy Norton, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, contented himself with what Mr. Average Married said, but he did not go down the column and mention what Mrs. Average Married said. It was to Mrs. Average that Deputy McGilligan and the Minister for Industry and Commerce appealed most in the last general election. It was from Mrs. Average they got the most support to enable them to form this new Government.

Mrs. Average was of course, presented at her doorstep in every city and town in the country with the wellknown Fine Gael leaflets comparing prices in 1951 with the prices in 1954. Naturally, these prices showed a big difference because of the reduction in the subsidies, but Mrs. Average was led to believe, not only by that leaflet but by the statements whispered on the threshold by the Fine Gael and Labour canvassers, that prices would be put back to what they were in 1951. Mrs. Average, reading the Budget to-day, will not have the same grádh or welcome for the Fine Gael or Labour canvassers when they next come.

Comment on this

We will get Mr. Average.

Comment on this

The Evening Press reporter was very much lauded when the Tánaiste was quoting to suit himself. This is what Mrs. Average said: “As a housewife, my interest is in the cost-of-living figures. I want to see prices reduced.”

Comment on this

That is a good idea.

Comment on this

She goes on: "My husband would probably like cheaper beer but I think our high cost of living demands priority attention."

Comment on this

She had her finger on tea and butter.

Comment on this

That was the priority attention she demanded and expected to get and few people would blame her. Why should she be blamed in view of the statements made by the canvassers and by some people from whom one would expect a sense of responsibility?

Deputy Dunne was here when Deputy Lemass referred to his statement in Navan. He has since left the House. He is reported in the Meath Chronicle of the 15th May as saying:—

"Before Labour would participate in a Government with any Party or group of Parties, they would insist that the prices of bread, butter, tea, sugar, cigarettes, tobacco and the worker's pint must be reduced and reduced immediately."

Comment on this

Butter and tea are mentioned.

Comment on this

Tea has not been reduced. There is no reduction.

Comment on this

These are statements that Mrs. Average Housewife might well have pinned her faith in. She might well expect some measure of relief and some degree of reduction in this present Budget. The Tánaiste himself, of course, wrote a very polite letter to the traders of his district. This letter, dated the 3rd May, 1954, emanated from Election Headquarters, Railway Hotel, Kildare. It reads as follows:—

"A Chara, as you are an elector in the County Kildare constituency I take the liberty of enclosing herewith a copy of my election address and would kindly invite your attention, in particular, to the portion of the programme set out under the heading: ‘Reduction in Prices.'

In view of the serious effect of increased taxation on cigarettes, beer and spirits, which, no doubt, has had an injurious effect on your trade, I trust that you will find it possible to give me your No. 1 vote in the forthcoming election and kindly ask your relatives and friends to do likewise, so that, with the aid of the Labour Party, I may advocate in the new Dáil a reduction of the taxes which so adversely affect your business and the consumers generally. Mise le meas, W. Norton, T.D."

I am sure the Tánaiste will probably send them a copy of the speech he made to-day in which he gave no hope whatever to the traders of Kildare or the publicans and the tobacconists that he was going to reduce the price of tobacco and beer in order to bring back the prosperity in business we were supposed to have before the Budget of 1952. That will be poor recompense not only to the traders of Kildare but to the housewives throughout the country who were quite justified to expect that the drastic reductions that Deputy Dunne so glibly promised would be backed up. Deputy Dunne said that unless there was an immediate reduction, he and the Labour Party would not take part in the Government.

With regard to tea, contrary to what the Tánaiste thinks, we do not find a debate on tea or the commodity itself as unpalatable as he suggests. The Government made a decision to require Tea Importers, Limited, to carry an overdraft until next August or September, which will amount to about £1,250,000, because Sir John Kotewala, and possibly some other personages from tea producing countries, believed the cost of tea would come down in the intervening months. The Minister stated that the Government's decision seemed to be well justified, having regard to newspaper comments and reports from tea plantations and the world demand for tea. The Minister seemed to take all the credit to himself and his Government for that decision.

On the other hand, the Labour Party, either in Party conclave or here in the House, tell us that it was as a result of pressure from the Labour members in the Government that the Government was forced to take that decision in relation to tea. We do not know whom to believe. The Minister gave the impression that it was a unanimous Government decision whereas the Labour Party hold that it was as a result of pressure brought to bear by them on the Government. Beyond referring to Press statements and some other reports the Minister was not prepared to comment any further; he was not prepared to give any indication as to whether the Government is of the opinion that, in fact, the price of tea will have fallen by the time the authorised overdraft of Tea Importers, Limited, falls due. We can only wait in the meantime to see whether or not the Government decision, as forced upon them by the Labour Party, will have been a correct one.

One of the most disappointed sections of the community as a result of the Budget will be the Licensed Vintners' Association. That body poured thousands of pounds into the election campaign last year. They even went so far as to nominate one of their own members to contest the issue in Deputy McGilligan's own constituency and, no doubt, I take it gave a liberal subvention to his candidature.

Comment on this

The Deputy is speaking about a man who is not here. I cannot speak for him, because I do not know; but they gave me nothing.

Comment on this

I am talking about a man who went forward as a candidate for Fine Gael. I do not know him.

Comment on this

Why speak then about his getting a subvention?

Comment on this

I have said nothing derogatory of the man and I have no intention of referring to him further.

Comment on this

I am glad of that.

Comment on this

He represented certain political and commercial organisations in that election and the feeling of dismay and disappointment that the members of those organisations must feel after their two interviews with the Minister for Finance must be immeasurable. The penal taxation imposed by Fianna Fáil has not been relieved by the Fine Gael Minister for Finance. However disappointing the position may be to the licensed vintners themselves, it must be even more disappointing to the average man who was led to believe, again largely by the Fine Gael propaganda and by statements made not only by canvassers but by leading members of the Government Parties, that the price of his pint would be reduced. It was assumad that if the price was not reduced to 1/-, it would at least go back to 1/2. But the Minister for Finance has not seen fit to relieve the poor man of that imposition and to give him his pint at the round 1/-. For these people the pint is now a necessity and not a luxury, but they will have to wait, on the word of the Minister for Finance, until next year perhaps when the Government may be able to do better.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think they are looking forward to a Fianna Fáil Government coming back to get the pint reduced? Not likely.

Comment on this

There is no doubt in the world about it—none whatever.

Comment on this

Who put the price of the pint up in 1952?

Comment on this

During the applause following the Minister's speech yesterday, the Minister for Industry and Commerce shouted across the floor of the House: "Do you want an election?". I believe he would be a very disappointed man at the results of such an election if it came at any time in the near future. If there was an election during the next few months the disappointment felt by the people, not so much at the failure of the Government to implement promises but rather because of their being so easily duped by spokesmen of the Government, would reflect itself very effectively in the election returns. Mrs. Average Married was far more important in the last election. When she reads the Minister's speech or the Tánaiste's apology for the Sweet Fanny Adam Budget, she will not be so very impressed.

Comment on this

If we get the average man in the average Fianna Fáil household it will be all right.

Comment on this

The relief of £15 for each child is of some help in connection with the family man's net yearly income. There are many people who have no families who expected some increase in the personal allowance. Having regard to the fact that more people are being caught up in the income-tax code every year as the result of increased wages surely the Minister could have given some extra relief this year. He referred to the relief, and this was applauded by his supporters, in the tax on tractors bringing milk to creameries. I once made a reference here to the waste of time in taking milk to and from creameries. I was supplied with some figures, though I cannot vouch for their accuracy.

I think, however, they are reasonably accurate and support what the Minister said in that respect. On the 22nd July, 1948, Volume 112 of the Official Report, I said at column 1230:

"In the country we have about 250 main creameries, and about 750 branch creameries, making approximately 1,000 milk receiving depots in all. I do not know whether I am exaggerating, but I think I am being rather conservative in that estimate. I think I would be conservative also in saying that about 50 producers supply milk to each depot every day. That would be approximately 50,000 milk suppliers. Each of these suppliers approximately takes two hours per day to deliver his consignment of milk, totalling about 100,000 man hours per day."

I consider that a great waste in the agricultural potential and the Minister's effort is a step in the right direction.

Comment on this

Who raised the tax on these? You people did.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I believe the number of people affected will be very small, so small that the reduction will have no impact whatever on our agricultural economy.

Comment on this

Why then did you raise the tax?

Comment on this

I doubt if there are more than 20 or 30 people in all who can afford to buy tractors to bring milk to the creamery for themselves and their neighbours. I am sure that even at 30 I am exaggerating the number. I think it is about time that something more substantial and more realistic should be done about this waste of time in the sending of milk to creameries. I do not think that I or anybody else can easily disrupt the Irish way of life. I believe the farmers like taking their milk to the creamery; they like sitting up on the old cart, having a chat with their neighbours as they drive along, buying the daily paper in the shop adjacent to the creamery and reading it on the way home. Nevertheless there may be days in the year when every farmer, no matter how much he enjoys that particular piece of diversion will envy other neighbours whom he can see and who can devote all their time to their fields.

I believe even if C.I.E. were asked to come in, collect the milk and deliver it to the creamery by lorry, covering a certain area it might be an improvement or ultimately if the farmers themselves could bring their co-operation to the extent of getting a lorry either through the creamery or among themselves it would prove a considerable advantage and a great saving of their time and would also make a considerable contribution to the economy of the country.

I do not think there are any other things to which I would like to refer on this Budget. I do not want to go over the ground that Deputy Lemass has covered and I do not want to follow many of the red herrings the Tánaiste has drawn across our path, but I think the net result is that this Budget, which was described by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture as the Budget everybody was looking for, will be known as the Budget that everybody will gladly and readily forget except perhaps the Parties that framed it.

Comment on this

You people would like to forget it.

Comment on this

"This is a bad Budget"—that seems to be the general conclusion of my Cork colleague, Deputy Lynch, in company with his leaders, Deputy Lemass and Deputy MacEntee. If it is a bad Budget, I suppose the only way we can try to form some decision is to make some comparison, not with all the statements of members made either inside or outside this House but with what is actually being done and what has been done.

I noticed that the present Minister for Finance in introducing this Budget said it was a good year. He did not go out of his way to say what Deputy MacEntee, as Minister for Finance, said in introducing his Budget in April, 1954, that the year which had just passed was one of the best years in the history of this country. In this case, in the Budget before us in what has been termed a good year, I notice according to the Minister's statement that unemployment has been relieved to the extent of between 5,000 and 6,000. We can come to that further on, but in Deputy MacEntee's case, in one of the best years in the history of this country the fact remains that in April, 1954, unemployment was higher by no less than 19,000 than the figure of April, 1951.

Furthermore, in this Budget we are now discussing, we are aware of the provision being made in the case of the old age pensioners, the widows and orphans and the blind—an increase of 2/6. Members of Fianna Fáil stated that even this 2/6 is somewhat niggardly but last year in their very good year, they apparently forgot that these old, unfortunate people were in need of an increase. They gave them nothing in the great year they had, and left them, in the case of the old age pensioners, with a maximum of 21/6.

As has been mentioned, there was the question of a reduction in the price of butter but it is also well to draw attention to the fact that the present Government did at least honour its pledge which was something Fianna Fáil forgot to do, which Deputy Walsh as Minister forgot, the pledge to honour the arbitration award. There was many an auxiliary postman down the country, in South Cork and elsewhere, who had reason to be happy a few months back when he got a few pounds, and that, of course, did not come out of the air. It came from the provisions that were made not simply by the implementation of Deputy MacEntee's Budget, but during the operation of the old system here by the present Government during the last nine months.

I cannot understand portion of the speeches in regard to butter. They say it is a subsidy, but Deputy MacEntee came along in his own innocent way last night and pointed out that subsidies mean nothing, that if it is a case of a reduction in price through subsidy the people must pay for it anyway and might as well pay a higher price. If that is so, why then are they abusing us for not giving more subsidies? If they would hold to either line of argument—well and good—but they cannot have it both ways.

I am not going to dwell on other matters affecting the past, but mention was made last year of the wonderful concession given by Fianna Fáil, a farthing in the one-pound loaf of bread or a halfpenny in the two-pound loaf. It is true this was a reduction but we know that the old age pensioners, the unfortunate widows and the blind persons will have much more reason to be happy now when they hear of an increase of 2/6 than they had when they heard from the lips of Deputy MacEntee that they were about to get the two-pound loaf a halfpenny cheaper.

One of the outstanding achievements in the Budget of last year was a reduction of duty on special marriage licences. I do not know whether there were many special marriages but apparently Deputy Walshe's Party considered it was a wonderful achievement in one of the best years in the history of our country. There is no need to remind anyone in this House, nor indeed people outside this House, about the background of the policy not just of last year, but of the introduction of that policy. I believe when we are considering or discussing an important measure such as this Budget we would simply be wasting our own time and the time of the people who are paying us if we continue speaking about the past.

As we heard yesterday evening, Deputy MacEntee seemed to realise that it is a great thing to live in the glories of the past, but I believe it is far more important to face the problems of the present and the future. It is with that view in mind that we would like to relate ourselves to this Budget. After all, a Budget policy is something that will, perhaps in a general way, affect the lives of people from an economic point of view for 12 months. But there is something far more important, something that has been completely avoided by the Fianna Fáil speakers so far. I fail to understand why they were not prepared to talk of the weaknesses or the strong points of this particular matter that is being discussed as a so-called responsible Party. I presume that in the next issue of An Gléas, their famous underground paper, they will have more false articles than they have at the present time. Surely that will not deceive the people. Surely the new organisation that is, apparently, not yet streamlined by Deputy Lemass will have to crack up unless, alone, they are going to come forth now and say they have a policy worth putting forward for examination.

I believe that, in any discussion on budgetary policy, there is one item we cannot lose sight of. There is one item in respect of which this Government as a whole are entitled to take credit. There is one item in respect of which Fianna Fáil, as a Government Party-as a Republican Party, as they always claimed to be—seemed to be most timid about and afraid of handling. I refer to the problem of bank interest. Why did they gloss over it in any discussion here? Deputy Lemass tried to go out of his way to say that he will give credit if he thinks it is due. Why is it that they failed to comment on the fact that, a few months ago—for the first time in the history of this State—an Irish Government were able to say to the banks: "You are not going to do as you have been doing all along and that is to follow in line with the British banks and increase your interest"? Apparently that does not affect Fianna Fáil. Apparently they have reached the stage of imbecility when they are even afraid to say "Boo" when it affects the interests of those people.

When speaking of taxation I presume Deputies on all sides of the House are interested in keeping it down. If we examine all the estimates in relation to a Budget we will find that it is one of the weakest points owing to the enormous amount of money that has to be provided under the system in operation here. If we relate our remarks not alone to central Government, but to local government as well, it is really a case of the few gaining so much at the expense of the many. Fianna Fáil are afraid to tackle that problem. Even in the new streamlined organisation that they are trying to bring into existence, they will not tackle it.

Comment on this

Is this a criticism of the Fianna Fáil Party or is it a speech on the Budget?

Comment on this

Irrespective of how much it may hurt Deputy Briscoe, we expect the policy of this Government will not be just to try to do something for one year. We want reliefs as we go along, but we want a policy that will give our people the benefits to which we believe they are entitled. We have heard a lot of talk about capital expenditure and we have heard a lot from Deputy MacEntee about the National Development Fund. I am relating my remarks directly to budgetary policy when I say that when we speak of national development we have to admit that the whole thing is a huge joke so far as this underdeveloped country is concerned. We supported Fianna Fáil when they introduced the National Development Fund Act, but we said at the time that it was a mere miserable sop and we say now that the amount provided will not be of any use if it will be devoted in the way Fianna Fáil intended it, that is, as a stop-gap measure to meet a crisis in the terrible unemployment position which existed at that particular period.

Comment on this

What about the present unemployment position?

Comment on this

We believe that capital expenditure is of such importance that it will affect the history of our country. We believe it will affect the livelihood of many generations to come if we are prepared to play our part in a genuine way.

We have heard a lot of talk from some Deputies about private enterprise and public enterprise. The two can exist one with the other: we realise that. In relating my remarks to some of the points mentioned by the Minister, it might be interesting for some Deputies, who love to interrupt, to examine their political conscience at times and to study the political conscience of many of those connected with them. Then, perhaps, we might know where we stand and, what is more important, we might know where they stand.

In his Budget statement, the Minister used words which are of vital importance to those of us in the Labour Party. Speaking on the subject of capital expenditure and dealing with the amount of money being provided in the Budget, the Minister said:—

"Such optimism is, perhaps, natural but it needs to be moderated by realism if estimates are not to promise achievements beyond what experience shows to be practicable."

I hope that when the financial provisions of this Budget are put into practice we shall not have a repetition of what we have had in each of the last three years, that is, sums of money being provided for certain purposes but not spent. Surely that is not good housekeeping from a national point of view any more than it would not be good housekeeping from the point of view of a family? Surely it is not good that, where the money is provided and all the arrangements are made to do a job, a person should say: "I cannot do the job because I have not various things ready." There should be no excuse for that type of behaviour. We believe that one of the difficulties has always been the provision of the necessary finance. Surely we have enough experts attached to every Department and surely we have enough co-operation between the various State Departments to enable us to ensure that, where moneys are provided for particular purposes—and, in particular, for capital expenditure— there will be no undue delay in putting the various schemes, which are so necessary, into operation.

We realise, in connection with capital expenditure, the importance of ensuring that the money is well spent. We realise the importance of ensuring that the projects for which moneys are provided will, in themselves, give a proper return. It is important to ensure that they are not introduced for political purposes or by a Government at a particular time when it may suit them owing to pending elections.

In relation to the statement of the Minister and to the general outlook for the coming year—and also in relation to what has happened in the past—we can see that no budgetary policy for one 12 months will be of any advantage to us if we proceed with the niggardly policy of day-to-day administration from March to the end of the following April. The Minister stated yesterday in his Budget speech that the Government had under consideration the overall question of capital development. That is one of the fundamental points in relation to our co-operation in a Government and we naturally stand for full speed ahead in that respect.

Deputy MacEntee also mentioned national development. He said it was one of the outstanding achievements in all the years. If we are to review the amount of money provided during the 1930 and 1940 periods we realise that if a little more progress had been made by the people who were then in their prime in political life, instead of crowing now about what other Governments cannot do, we would not be saddled to-day with many of the problems which can be directly related to the accursed evils of unemployment and emigration.

Industry is vital to us but Fianna Fáil must remember and must take responsibility for the fact that many of the industries established in this country, while they have done their utmost to make them succeed and were supported by Labour in their policy, are still continuing to adopt a system which warrants the closest examination by the Minister in relation to the overall picture. Whoever that may affect or whoever may not like it, that is a matter for themselves.

In connection with this Budget, as in the case of all other budgets, the question of exports and imports has been emphasised. When some of us took a particular line last year in connection with exports, our words were suitably twisted and used against us by our political opponents. We realise that, whether we like it or not, in particular where the British markets are concerned for meat and other exports, when we are dealing in an international market we are not in a position to call the tune, even though Deputy Lemass went out of his way to-day to try to say that Deputy Walsh in particular and he himself, when in England last year, did wonderful work.

Prices are suiting us on the British market at the present time but we cannot afford to close our eyes to the home market simply because we are getting advantages on the foreign market at any particular time. The only way to build up the home market is to build up a true policy of industrialisation in both the cities and rural areas. That will automatically mean more employment, more money available and higher consumption of foodstuffs. It is far more important for us to keep a close eye on the possibility of building up the home market while at the same time maintaining our position on tlie foreign market, but not to have all our eggs in one basket, than to continue in the way we are at the present time.

This is the first occasion since 1945 that any Minister in a Budget speech could point to the fact that there was not a decline in the number of people working on the land. Different views may be expressed on that subject. My opinion is that we had reached rock-bottom, that we had reached the stage when the farming community could not continue without the number at present employed in agriculture. If we could say that there will not be a further reduction in the number of persons employed on the land, that would be of advantage to rural Ireland and, directly or indirectly, to the cities and towns.

Our approach to this subject is not or will not be the Fianna Fáil approach —"anything you can do I can do better". We are more interested in trying to put into operation a policy which will benefit the people as a whole irrespective of what Party is in power or of what political affiliations they may have. From the viewpoint of agriculture, if we can build up our home markets and continue the present policy of exporting it will undoubtedly give our people in rural Ireland, the farming community, the farm workers and business people greater hopes for the future than they have had in the past.

In connection with capital expenditure. I noticed the Minister drew attention to the fact that there was a certain saving which was the result of over-estimation of building progress. That should not have to be the case. We are not blaming this Government. It is impossible to blame a Government that has been only nine months in office for the non-building of houses for which plans should have been prepared a couple of years ago.

We know from our experience in local authorities throughout the country that the building programme has been eased from 1951 to 1954 and into 1955. We do not want the policy of the last three years continued as regards house building. It is essential that those people who are in need of houses should get houses at the earliest possible date. While we express our understanding of the explanation of over-estimation in connection with building we do hope that that will not be the case next time and we do hope that with greater co-operation between the various authorities all the money provided under this subhead will be expended for the benefit of the people, even if it meant that we could not balance the Budget without holding back money.

Comment on this

What do you do when there is a six weeks' cessation of labour?

Comment on this

I will come to Deputy Briscoe in a minute and he may not escape too well.

Comment on this

What do you do under those circumstances?

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe looks up to—I was going to say to heaven, but I will say the sky—with horror when we mention certain aspects of our connection with this Government whether it is on a local authority or the central authority. Will Deputy Briscoe contradict me when I say that a large part of the finances that have to be provided for budgetary policy for the coming year will come under a system of finance that we should not have to admit we accept at the present time? Will Deputy Briscoe admit that his Party and he himself, a prominent member of the Dublin Corporation, were so timid in their approach that they were afraid to tackle the problem even as the present inter-Party Government tackled it? Apparently, they would prefer that the people would pay higher rates and greater house rents than say "we must have lower rates".

Comment on this

You are talking nonsense.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe does not like a bit of this line of thought and I cannot blame him because he has been so many years keeping in touch with——

Comment on this

He does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

We believe a national policy should be based on a general housing programme for the country and on an expansion of general services, giving capital and lasting value to this State. We believe in a policy which will not allow anybody, whether Irish or foreign, to be in a position to hold up the State to ransom. I can understand why Deputy Briscoe and his friends do not like that policy.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy saying? Is he accusing me of being interested in the lending of money to certain people for these purposes?

Comment on this

The Deputy has often opposed this policy of ours.

Comment on this

The Deputy is so ignorant of what is happening that he does not know what he is talking about. Let him ask his colleague who is sitting behind him.

Comment on this

In his usual bullying manner Deputy Briscoe thinks that the policy of this Government should be that in which he has been interested so long. He has had the opportunity here of using his powers and influence with his own Party to try and do the things that we are now doing, but he did not do them. He has always adopted a silly attitude and he is now in the carefree position of not being worried with the responsibilities of supporting a Government Party as he was during the three years during which the inter-Party Government were in power previously. Because of that he can now say that the measures introduced in this Budget are distasteful to him. Evidently it is his policy, as it was that of Deputy Lemass, to allow the highest rate of interest ever on a loan floated by the State for capital expenditure. Evidently the Fianna Fáil Party agree with that policy. If they do then let them put it into their stream-lined plans for the future but let them know that we do not agree with it.

I know that there are people outside who are inclined to condemn us. I know they are trying to say that anything we do in this regard is going to affect the whole structural foundation of the State. But I should like to point out that we are more concerned with the overall position of the people than with any one section. We have made it quite clear that joint stock banks may carry on for ordinary business but that there must be a central bank, subject to control by the Government, so that the poor people of the country will not be overburdened by the huge amount of debt that would accrue year after year if we want to give the people the advantages of housing and of the other things to which they are entitled.

There is one other thing which I should like to mention. Deputy Lemass mentioned our attitude to prices as displayed by the Budget, and I presume his lieutenant here in the House, Deputy Briscoe, will continue on the same line. I should like to make it quite clear that we are prepared to take them up on that. We in the Labour Party have never evaded our responsibilities and we never shall. First of all Deputy Briscoe and his friends accuse us of doing wrong when we introduced subsidies. Then they come along and say we should have reduced prices. I agree, and while I am not going to discuss a matter which may be sub judice at the moment, I should like to say that through certain inquiries that are going on at the present time we shall learn, as there is very good reason to believe at the moment, that the cartels and rings so close to the hearts of Fianna Fáil will not have the control over the price markets as regards various commodities that they had in the past. It could happen, please God, that when we have had the reports of these inquiries before us in the House some of the gentry involved in these cartels and rings, supporters of Fianna Fáil, will regret the day that an inter-Party Government, supported by Labour, took over control of the country.

We say here quite openly that where we are concerned in the Labour Party this 2/6 increase in old age; blind and widows' pensions is not the final instalment. We owe too much to these old people in the end of their lives. We realise our responsibilities in regard to the unfortunate widow with children and to the terrible plight of the blind. Our policy in this regard has been prompted by a true sense of Christian justice. We want to see that these people are protected and, as pointed out already, this is but one instalment of the help we want to give them, and for giving them that help we do not make any apology to anybody.

I should like to repeat that when the reports of this inquiry which is going on at the moment are issued not alone will we be expecting the inter-Party Government but our own colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce—the man we had the honour of putting in that position in the Government—to see that what has been happening in the past will not continue—that price rings will not continue to hold the unfortunate people of this country up to ransom through a system which up to the 1930's had not been heard of. I cannot help it if Deputy Briscoe is surprised. We know that such people were heavily subsidised in the past by their friends in Fianna Fáil. There is one more matter I should like to raise before I conclude. For the benefit of Deputy Carter and of Deputy Briscoe I should like to recall a statement made by their leader at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis on Wednesday, October 13th, 1954, as taken from the Irish Independent.

Comment on this

We had it already from your leader.

Comment on this

It is well you would hear it again. When speaking of possible increases for old age pensioners-the people Deputy Lemass was crying his eyes out for this evening——

Comment on this

Read it.

Comment on this

He said that taxation was now running at a very high level and that any increase for social services would be dangerous.

Comment on this

Go on a bit further. Do not take it out of its context. Read the whole lot.

Comment on this

What I have read is a complete paragraph. And when they stood up to-day they went out of their way, as Deputy MacEntee did last night, to clamour for more for the old age pensioners. Their leader sits down calmly and does not say a word. Perhaps he may later.

Comment on this

He will.

Comment on this

He may say as he did on the 13th October that it would be dangerous to increase the pensions. May I suggest that the time for political playacting is over?

Comment on this

It is only beginning, if you ask us.

Comment on this

As far as you are concerned maybe, but the playacting in which you engaged in this House was destructive to the country. The people have already judged that and have realised your failure. In 1954 Deputy MacEntee said he would have a small surplus at the end of the year. While we have not a small surplus, if we adopted Deputy MacEntee's policy we would have. If we saved the money by not taking 5d. a lb. off butter, if we had broken our bond to the civil servants of this State and to a particular auxiliary postman I know who has to travel the country, we could have a surplus to-day. We would have no worry then because it seems from the view expressed by the Fianna Fáil speakers and by the policy which they have had in operation for three years that their only interest is in balancing the Budget. But we of the Labour Party in our association with this Government make it clear that our first commitment is to the plain people of this country. Our first responsibility is to see that those who are in need must be provided for, that the balancing of a Budget, important as it may be in itself, is only of secondary importance where these people are concerned.

We do not concur in the views on national investment expressed by some people in the Opposition nor can we agree to a certain extent with the Minister himself when he spoke of the importance of national investment. We all realise that, but when, in regard to the necessity for people who were in a position to do so to engage in national investment, he drew their attention to the importance of love of country, our answer is that from what we can see, love of pocket is what affects those who are investing and not love of country.

There may have been a certain love of country among people 30 years ago, but that time is gone and they are not prepared to invest in this country unless the returns are suitable to themselves. That is why we say that the prosperity of this State cannot be tied up with the policy which relates to people or groups who are only prepared to put in for what they can get out of it. This State is too precious for that; the people in it are far more precious than that. I am sorry if what we say does not suit Deputy Briscoe but I am not worried over that. I give Deputy Briscoe credit for the fact that he was a prominent man one time when some of us were only children. At that time the view expressed was that there was no room for certain ascendancy classes. In relation to the present conditions, financial and other, it is quite obvious that a new ascendancy has arisen, a new get-rich-quick section in the community.

The Minister was right in appealing for improvement as regards industry and as regards production as a whole, but there is very little going to be given by some of those people who attend hunt balls or champagne balls with Fianna Fáil. We have no time for them and our co-operation with this Government is on condition that the plain people, the people who are affected by the ordinary budgetary conditions which may be created, will get a fair deal. We are longing for a true policy of capital expenditure to be introduced for those people in whom we are interested, and we will have nothing to do, as we never had, with those whom Deputy Briscoe and his Party may consider to be their friends.

Comment on this

In considering this Budget of 1955, a Deputy has to consider his responsibility to the people who sent him into this House, whether he is here as a representative of a constituency only or is in addition an elected representative of a local authority, a person who is a director or has an interest in industry and also an interest, as we must all have, in our home. I think this Budget of 1955 will stand out as a turning point in the history of this country.

Let me go back just a few years. Many quotations have been given here to-day dealing with the past 20 or 30 years since the foundation of the State. From the time this State was established, we will give credit to every Government for any advancement in the life and industry of the nation. However, I feel that we who are elected to come here and serve the interests of the people will have some day, if not in our lifetime at least in history, to answer to our children who may inquire when they read those glorious passages in Irish history from 1916 to 1921.

We are all well aware of the sacrifices made by men who struck a blow for Ireland and as a result gave us native government in 1921. We will be asked then: "How did you use that freedom for which so many fought and died, for which so many suffered, and for which so many as a result of that struggle, are still suffering in this life?" We will have to answer that question, if not, as I say, in our own lifetime, then in the history of this country. As that great and glorious leader of the fight for freedom, General Michael Collins, said: "We will use our freedom for a greater freedom," and that greater freedom is the industrial and agricultural advancement of our people.

I will go back to 1948 when the Party to which I have the honour to belong and which I am so proud to represent in this Parliament, came into office. In 1948 when an inter-Party Government came into power, many queer stories were circulated about Labour and about other Parties joining with Fine Gael and Fine Gael with them. I am proud that I am here in this Parliament as a member of an inter-Party Government associated with the farmers, the workers, with Clann na Poblachta and the others that are supporting this Government.

Let us bring our minds back to what was done in a very short time. In 1948 when an inter-Party Government took over the reins of Government, scarcely had four months passed when the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, and the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Morrissey, went acrass and met their opposite numbers in the British Government. They went over there to get better terms for the Irish farmer, to get better prices for his cattle, prices which would be related to those paid on the English market. At that time there were fluctuations in cattle prices and complaints were made by farmers and by those associated with the cattle trade, about the unfair methods adopted against the cattle industry here by certain interests associated with that trade on the other side.

Deputy Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, as a result of that meeting with his opposite number in the British Government, brought back a signed agreement under which our farmers could obtain for cattle on the English market prices almost equal to and closely related to the English price. That, in itself, was a big achievement that brought contentment and that brought some ray of hope to farmers who were purchasing cattle in the early part of the season and who, because of the previous arrangements, did not know what price they could sell them for at the end of the season in October or November. Under this new agreement the farmer knew that the price he would obtain would be that on the English market. The English market was the only market and never has this Party denied that, although Fianna Fáil told us at one time that the British market was "gone and gone for ever", that the cattle trade of this country built up over 100 years would "thank God" be ended in 100 days or 100 weeks. They made a quotation of that kind at that time and that was their view.

Relate that to the position here to-day. Where would this country be to-day were it not for the cattle trade and the prices the Irish farmer is obtaining for cattle and beef on the English market? Deputy James Dillon, to his credit, brought back that agreement and on it is being built the cattle trade ever since and on that agreement the Irish farmer is, thank God, in the prosperous position he is in to-day.

We had also Deputy Morrissey as Minister for Industry and Commerce who, in that agreement with his opposite number in the British Parliament, obtained from them the right—and the right, mark you—for Irish manufacturers to sell their goods in the British market. That right was being withheld from them since the establishment of this State. As a result of that agreement, many Irish factories to-day have prospered and are still prospering. Without that market their trade and their employment would be in a very sorry position.

When we were in power from 1948 to 1951—the records are there to prove it—for every montrh the inter-Party Government were in power 1,000 additional people went into insurable employment. That is there for anyone who wishes to trace the records of the employed people and it is there to the record of the inter-Party Government. Now, at the end of three years of that Government we had brought this country into a very happy position. As a result of the capital investment policy of the inter-Party Government, the land in this country that was neglected and that Fianna Fáil never seemed to think very much about, was reclaimed. Much money was spent on reclamation, on drainage, on fertilising, so that the farmers would get a greater return from their land. That capital money was put into the land in the interest of the farmers, so that they would get greater production.

That brings me to a point I am well aware of as one interested in industry. If you want to keep your products at a reasonable price, you must have reasonable production. It is on the greater production that you can give the better price. But for the policy of the inter-Party Government and of Deputy Dan Morrissey as Minister for Industry and Commerce, many of the boot factories in this country in 1948-49 would have had to close their doors, as they would not be able to manufacture boots and shoes in competition with the English market. The same applies to agriculture. It is the aim of this Party to put more money into the land, to give the farmers better chances of getting greater production and, as a result of that greater production, greater prosperity.

On all sides of the House we are agreed that we have to stand or fall by the prosperity of our farmers. It is indeed a grand position to be in in this State to-day, coming up to Dublin and going out to our agricultural show here year after year, to see farmers coming in greater numbers, taking a greater interest in the industry to which they belong and on which we also are dependent. That position has been helped by the inter-Party Government and especially. I think all will agree, by Deputy James Dillon, whose father and grandfather fought such a gallant fight for the farmers in years gone by. It is indeed a source of pride to us that we had him there, to win for the farmers a greater freedom than the freedom they enjoyed and that was the freedom to bring their produce into the British market and obtain for it prices closely related to the prices obtained by the English farmers, whose farmers' union in England has a large influence on British Government policy. I think Deputy James Dillon deserves the credit of the nation for what he has done in their interests.

We go from that period to 1952. It is a period that I well remember, as it was in the 1952 by-election in Limerick that I became a member of this House. Reference has been made to election posters that were sent out for that particular election in Limerick, Waterford and Mayo. I remember the election leaflets and I stand by every one of them. The election leaflet put out, asking the people of Limerick to support the inter-Party Government and to support me, by the members of my Party contained facts. It showed on the one hand the prices in 1951 when the inter-Party Government went out of power and also the prices after the Budget of 1952. That is a statement of fact. I am retaining that poster for future elections, as it is to me something on record of something that is true. There you have, side by side, the prices which obtained when we left office and the prices then after 14 or 15 months of Fianna Fáil coming back into office again.

That is being challenged here by people on the opposite benches, who are asking us what we are going to do about prices. I am glad to say this of the 1955 Budget, that I am glad indeed to be a member of this House and that I am going to take it back, please God, to-morrow evening to the people of Limerick. I am not going back to the ballroom proprietors of Limerick who subscribed so generously to Fianna Fáil in their 1952 and 1951 elections, but I am going back to Limerick to the people who are benefiting under this Budget. I am going back to the old age pensioners, the blind pensioners, and the widows and orphans, because in the 1952 elections they had no money to subscribe to Party funds, but on the other hand, they had votes which they readily gave to me to do something in this Parliament, in their interests.

I am glad and proud to be a member of the Fine Gael Party under the leadership of General Mulcahy, under the leadership of Deputy Costello and Deputy Norton. I am glad to be a member of that Party, and as a result of that election, I am going back to Limerick to put it on record that we are bringing back to the pensioners, on the 29th July, increased old age pensions, and increased widows' and orphans' pensions. I am really glad that the Government took that action, because there is no doubt that the aged people are the weakest section of our community. It is only right and fair that, when a Government is considering giving some benefit to sections of the people, they should, in the first instance, consider the people most in need of it. I am very proud to be able to go back now and say that something has been done for that section.

I will refer to another leaflet which went around during my election campaign in 1952. I issued a leaflet showing, truthfully, the prices obtaining when Fianna Fáil left office, when the inter-Party Government left office, and when the Fianna Fáil Party were 18 months in office. What followed on the morning after the declaration of the poll in Limerick? About 60 workers in the C.I.E. depot, whose notices were withheld a week previous to the election, received those notices. That was what Fianna Fáil did for the workers in that depot at Limerick. They withheld the notices, and obtained their votes. I say that was dishonest. The electors of Limerick sent me here to serve their interests. That I have done, to the best of my ability, all these years.

The taxes imposed at that time were imposed on many commodities, many of which were luxuries, but surely one cannot say that the old age pensioners living on £1 a week, could be living in luxury. It could not be said, as it was by the Fianna Fáil Government at that time, that the people were living beyond their means.

That is a question which had to be answered, and it has been answered by this Government, who realise that, as a result of the increased taxes put on those commodities, consideration had to be given to that section of the community, in the first instance. Fianna Fáil gave the old age pensioners an increase of 1/6 in 1952, to meet the increased price of bread, butter, tea and sugar, and those other small commodities which the old age pensioner was able to obtain. We felt that it was our duty to help this section of the community. I know that the people who sent me here are grateful to the Government.

There have been quotations given here to-day about what this one said, and that one said, where they said it, and all the rest of it. I am not going to indulge in this type of argument, but I can tell what was said to some of the canvassers representing me outside the polling booths in Limerick: "If you vote for Fine Gael, the old age pensions will be taken off you." Outside some of the post offices, there were Fianna Fáil agents threatening the people: "If you vote for Fine Gael, you will have your old age pensions reduced." That happened outside the polling booths in Limerick. I could quote other instances.

I am not going to indulge in crossfire with members of the Party opposite; they could as well hit back at me. Certainly, as Deputy Briscoe said here recently, I agree we could have some good-humoured comments across the floor of the House, and not indulge in personalities, and getting a bit hot under the collar. I hope that anything I have said will not be taken by any member of the Opposition as anything personal. It is far from that. I said that I am here as a representative of the people of the city and part of the county of Limerick, to serve their interests. I am trying to do that in more ways than perhaps talking in this House.

At that election in Limerick, farmers were being threatened that there was great danger if there was a change of Government, that there would be an upset in cattle prices, and that they would only obtain 1/- a gallon for milk. There were agents outside the creameries, as well as outside the post offices. Creamery men, with their asses and carts, bringing the milk to the creamery, were told: "You had better give your votes to Fianna Fáil, because James Dillon will only give you 1/- a gallon for your milk". Now James Dillon and his father and grandfather have in their time fought for the farmers of this country, and we must not forget the part played by the Dillons in the years gone by.

Somebody was quoted yesterday in the Evening Press as describing what was in the Budget, and what was not.

Comment on this

Mr. Average Married Man.

Comment on this

There is another comment in to-day's Evening Press by a man named Seán O'Donoghue (30), married, with four children, of 20, St. Pappin's Green, Ballymun, who says:—

"I'm glad to see the old age pensioners, the blind and widows are getting the money—I'd like to see them getting a good deal more.

"I think the Government did very well considering how little money they had at their disposal. The increase of £85 to £100 in the income-tax allowance for each child is also good for people with large families-but it doesn't benefit me, as I am not paying income-tax."

It is a pity that he has not £1,000 a year and six children instead of four, and then he would be able to assess what he would receive under this Budget. As a result of that, I am going back to Limerick, and I will be meeting men who have been paying income-tax, who have four children, and who have come to me, in my capacity as a member of the Limerick City Council, looking for grants from the local authority which they have got. As a result of getting loans they have built their own houses. We all know the strain that will be put on them for a number of years paying back the principal and interest. I will be proud to meet some of those men and to tell them that their allowance on the four children of £85 a year has now been increased to £100 a year and that provided they are paying at the rate of 7/6 in the £, there will be a saving of £24 10s.

That is no mean benefit for the people I represent here and the people whom I know personally in Limerick. It is something in which I think we can all take pride. In addition, as a result of Government policy this year in floating a loan which was oversubscribed at 4¼ per cent., interest rates in the case of the man I refer to, if he had to build a house now, are reduced by ½ per cent.

Comment on this

The loan was floated at 4½ per cent. and not 4¼ per cent.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon—4½ per cent. I thank the Deputy for the correction, because I should like to be on record correctly. As a result of the policy of this Government in obtaining money from the public at a lower rate of interest, we can say that we have done something better than the last Government for these enterprising young men who, during their married lives, have often to live in flats and in conditions which are not at all in keeping with their positions. I take pride in having been able to play some part in that matter.

This Budget will go down in history as the Budget which marked the turning point, as far as taxation is concerned. As a member of a local authority, I was unable to support a recommendation that the rates in my city should remain at the same level as last year, due to the fact that the many calls on local authorities could not be met without having to impose some hardships. There is no hardship being imposed as a result of this Budget, but there are reliefs for many sections of the people. In this Budget, in which no new taxation is imposed, there is a sum of £2,000,000 given to butter consumers to enable them to buy butter at a reasonable price. We all saw in the national papers some few weeks ago advertisements by the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association advising people to buy butter and to eat and use butter in larger quantities, and rightly so, because we have butter here, the food value of which is greater than that of any substitute which is being bought at present.

If people are buying substitutes for butter to-day, they are not buying them because they want to leave butter behind them. What they really want to do is to balance their purses and this Government has enabled them to get butter at a lower price. The price was reduced by 5d. a lb., which is a concession and that concession is working in the direction which the creamery milk suppliers of the country wish—in the direction of the purchase of butter instead of margarine and other substitutes which they are buying at present at lower prices. If we can even further reduce the price to the consumers, I feel that we will be doing something for that industry.

Furthermore, health services will cost more in the coming year, due to the coming into operation of many sections of the Health Act. These have to be provided for and they have been provided for without any increase in taxation. We, on this side, claim that in this Budget we have given benefits to the people to the extent of £4,250,000. That is no mean achievement but that achievement will be followed by an implementation of the other points of policy which we put before the people when we were returned to office. What is done in this Budget is the first instalment of what we will do in each Budget in the next four years, at the conclusion of which we shall go to the country and render an account of our stewardship. We will then put before the people the record of what we have done during our period of office. We will compare prices and so on, and whether we are to be judged by the electorate in four years' time or by history, we will be prepared to await that judgment, in the sure know ledge that it will be a judgment of gratitude by the people of the country.

Comment on this

May I express my great personal regret that Deputy Desmond, having sent over to me a few of his paper darts, did not think it worth his while to await my returning the darts to him? I will not leave him out of the debate, however, and I hope that in due course he will read my replies to some of his remarks and suggestions.

May I say to Deputy Carew that I think he will be disappointed? He announced three or four times that he is going back to his constituency to-morrow and he has indicated to us the great jubilation which he says awaits him on his return. There will be no bands to meet him as a result of this Budget.

Comment on this

I do not hire them.

Comment on this

And there will be no jubilation.

Comment on this

I leave it to the ballroom proprietors.

Comment on this

Whatever the reason, there will not be that jubilation he speaks of.

Comment on this

You never know.

Comment on this

I have great respect and personal regard for Deputy Carew, but I should like to say this, that, when he talks about people being honest and dishonest in political matters, he at least should keep on the straight line. He made the statement here that the Fianna Fáil Government withheld the notices of the C.I.E. workers until after the declaration of the poll at his by-election and he knows full well that neither his Government nor ours are responsible for the dismissals which have taken place since Deputy Morrissey as Minister gave C.I.E. their complete freedom. I could say to him that the dismissals from C.I.E. which have taken place since this Government came into office are the result of the operations of this Government, but I do not say so, and I hope that Deputy Carew will withdraw that mean imputation against Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I do not indulge in mean imputations.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not accept the fact that the C.I.E. directorate hire and fire their personnel without any direction from this House?

Comment on this

I do accept that, and I withdraw.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Carew would want to remain on record as having made a statement and not having withdrawn it when given the opportunity. I am satisfied with what the Deputy says.

I am very amused in approaching the consideration of this Budget. I do not start off by saying that this is a bad Budget. I do not think that Fianna Fáil could afford to say that it is a bad Budget, because it is almost consistent with the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1954, so that if I were to say it was a bad Budget, I should have to say also that the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1954 was a bad Budget. But the members of the inter-Party Coalition—whatever the make-up is—should say it is a bad Budget because they abused Fianna Fáil in no uncertain terms on the 1954 Budget and I propose to refer to what some of the leading spokesmen of these groups said about it.

What is the difference in the main? In the 1954 Budget, the total of benefits or reliefs granted amounted to £1,793,000. We have heard great shouts about the wonderful reliefs and benefits which the Coalition have made available in this Budget, but nobody has thought fit to add up the figures for the various reliefs. The total of their benefits and reliefs comes to £1,020,000, £770,000 less than granted in the 1954 Fianna Fáil Budget. I am putting that on record.

Where have they got some of that sum of £1,020,000? They are going to get £450,000 by the removal of the subsidy for confectionery. When I referred to the biscuit earlier in the debate by way of interjection, Deputy Norton, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, threw back the gibe that I dealt only in luxury articles. Might I tell the House that in the City of Dublin—and Deputy Larkin knows this well—there is not a child who does not occasionally have a currant bun? That is the confectionery from which the subsidy is being removed and that is the luxury to which I am referring.

Comment on this

Not if it is home cooked.

Comment on this

If it is home cooked, it is.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know that in the City of Dublin—I can only talk of Dublin with any personal direct knowledge—there is a considerable trade done by our bakeries in supplying buns and various kinds of cheap confectionery which are taken by the working classes in the City of Dublin?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy interested in the reduction of the cost of living?

Comment on this

Of course I am but I am proving now that instead of reducing the cost of living by taking away this £450,000 as a subsidy the cost of living is being increased in regard to certain articles. Does the Deputy not agree that if the subsidy is removed from confectionery——

Comment on this

From luxuries.

Comment on this

Apparently only the rich are entitled to a currant bun.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Why are you taking away the subsidy? The Coalition cannot have it both ways. They cannot say they are reducing the cost of living when, in fact, they are increasing it. Neither can they escape by saying that confectionery is exclusively eaten by the luxury classes and not by the working classes.

Comment on this

We do not say it.

Comment on this

You have just said it.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read the interjections when the Official Report is available.

Comment on this

I will deal with this matter afterwards.

Comment on this

It was pointed out by Deputy Lemass and other speakers on this side of the House that £450,000 is being saved through the removal of the subsidy on confectionery. I do not know what proportion of that was applied to exports. Deputy Lemass pointed out that the matter is deserving of further consideration for fear that in addition to the bad effects from the point of view of the people who eat confectionery at home there might be disemployment as a result of losing the trade so recently built up.

Are we to take it that the child of a working man is never to get a biscuit? I saw in this morning's Press where one of our leading biscuit manufacturers pointed out that the increase in the price of biscuits would be at least 2d. per lb. The Government accused us when we were in opposition of deliberately taking away from certain people a certain commodity. Would I be fair in saying that my interpretation of this act is that the Government thinks it is not right for the poorer sections to eat commodities fit only for those who are in the luxury classes? That is what they said to us when we removed the subsidies. When we removed the subsidies it was alleged we were saying that people were spending too much money and that they were getting too much. That is coming home to roost now. The public will interpret this act as meaning that the present Coalition Government concludes they are eating too much confectionery and that it must be stopped. That is why the subsidy is being removed.

The Minister referred in his Budget speech to the consideration given to the brewers. The amount involved is £20,000. It was not pointed out that the Fianna Fáil Government first considered that particular matter in the last Budget and that the remission they gave to the same brewers for the same purpose came to £350,000 in the financial year 1954. This £20,000 is, if you like, the result of a slight correction between the granting of £350,000 and £370,000. It is, of course, another of the remissions.

Deputy Desmond had one of the most difficult jobs to do here this evening. Deputy Desmond, who was recently elected to the chairmanship of the Labour Party, in his discussion on the Budget made certain wide swipes at what he wanted and what was expected in the future. But he did not deal with this Budget on the level it should be brought to or on the level the Labour members brought their Budget speech to on the last occasion the Budget was introduced. With regard to the 5d. off the butter. I spoke about that when the Bill was brought in to bring about the reduction of 5d. I said then what Deputy Lemass said to-day and I have no reason to change my opinion nor have I heard anything that would make me change my attitude.

Butter is not one of the essentially large items of consumption of the working classes. It is certainly not used by them to the same extent as they use bread. On a former occasion here I said that if the Government were really anxious to introduce reliefs for the benefit of the masses they should take off bread the equivalent of what they have taken off butter. I was gibed at on that occasion with the fact that Fianna Fáil had taken ½d. off. That was the answer. Every member of the working classes would prefer to have an additional 2d. taken off the loaf than to have 5d. taken off the pound of butter. On that occasion, too, I gave the average number of loaves used per household and the amount of butter consumed as distinct from margarine.

Perhaps there is another little secret behind all this. I hesitate to assert this as a fact and so I put it as a question: In the £2,000,000 which the Government claims is the subsidy for butter, is there any part of that used to subsidise butter which is exported? Is it not a fact that while there is a subsidy of 5d. on butter consumed at home there is a subsidy of 10d. per lb. on butter which is exported? Is it the idea to hide that and pretend that the £2,000,000 is a subsidy for the benefit of our own people at home? There were 3,000 tons of butter exported in the year under review; at 10d. per lb. subsidy the total sum amounts to £280,000 and that £280,000 comes out of the £2,000,000 and is used to subsidise butter for export.

Comment on this

Was the Deputy listening to Deputy Walsh speaking on the Estimate for Agriculture? He said that the subsidy should be put on chocolate.

Comment on this

I will not be sidetracked. I am pointing out what I believe to be the actual situation. On the one hand you have the Government saying they are subsidising butter to the extent of £2,000,000 per annum and implying that that subsidy is exclusively for the benefit of consumers of butter at home. Is it not a fact that 3,000 tons of butter were exported last year and that every lb. of that butter carried a subsidy of 10d. per lb? Would it not have been better to increase the subsidy on the butter consumed at home, thereby making it a little bit cheaper still so that our own people could eat more of it rather than pay 10d. per lb. by way of subsidy on the butter we export?

Perhaps Deputy Desmond would make a note of that. Deputy Desmond wants a substantial sum of money spent on what he calls national development, but he does not want it spent in the miserable manner in which Fianna Fáil spent it. It was Fianna Fáil which introduced the National Development Fund in an effort to make some contribution towards providing employment for persons seasonally unemployed or chronically unemployed and, in particular, in an effort to have not only money but schemes available should a crisis develop and large-scale unemployment ensue because of international conditions. Deputy Desmond does not like that. He does not, however, point out that, while he wants large-scale activity in connection with national development, in fact, the amount of money provided in the Estimate this year is less than what was provided in the 1954 Budget. He also says that where money is provided for a specific purpose he does not want any part of that sum to remain unexpended.

I interjected at that point and I asked him: What does one do in circumstances such as we had recently in the Dublin Corporation? We estimated certain expenditure to cover our housing programme and we found ourselves faced with a trade dispute; building came to an end. In such circumstances how can one continue to spend the money estimated or continue giving employment? The target aimed at could not be reached. In such a situation there will naturally be a certain amount of money unexpended.

Deputy Desmond indulges in theories. We have to deal with practicalities. Unpredictable obstacles arise and one has to find ways and means of dealing with those obstacles.

Deputy Desmond talked about the rate of interest and he became rather personal as far as I was concerned—as if I personally had something to do with the banks or as if I were personally lending money and demanding this tribute by way of high interest rates. I make a present of that to Deputy Desmond because his case in support of this Budget was so bad he had no alternative but to try to be personal at someone else's expense. Deputy Desmond has a lot to learn. We are living fortunately in a State which has a Constitution and so long as that Constitution is there the right to hold private property is there. If Deputy Desmond wants to do what he implied he would like to do he will have to wait until there is a majority of Deputy Desmonds here and the Constitution is amended.

In the meantime the supply of money can only be directed into Government or local authority operations on the basis of what is offered in exchange for it. The Minister quite rightly hopes there will be thrift and greater savings will be made; he hopes that these savings will become available for capital expenditure. I agree with the Minister in that but the Minister would be the first to admit that, unless you give the man who saves an inducement to make him lend his savings to the State, you will not get his money. Deputy Desmond is either living too much in the future or he does not understand the situation.

When he talks about the Dublin Corporation paying a high rate of interest and implies that is my fault personally, I want to throw that back in his teeth. Next month, or the month after, he will see what happens. It is the policy of the Dublin Corporation to house its people as rapidly as possible. There is no dispute about the rate of speed in relation to housing. Every year £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 is required for our housing programme in Dublin. We apply to the Minister for Finance and we tell him our money is running out and that we will not be able to continue unless we get more money. The Minister replies telling us that we must apply to the bank for an overdraft and he will sanction our borrowing until he has had an opportunity of ironing out the problems attaching to a loan. We go to the bank. We are told what the rate of interest is and we apply for sanction.

Now, if the Government thinks that Deputy Briscoe as chairman of the finance committee, together with the city manager, is paying too much by way of interest the Minister can refuse to sanction. He knows that unless we agree to the normal regular rate of interest for such loans the bank will not give us the money. We are then told by the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government to consult our stockbrokers and the banks as to when we should issue our bonds for public subscription, the price at which we should issue them, and the rate of interest we should offer. Because there is a danger that we will not get the issue fully subscribed, since pressure has been put on the Dublin Corporation to build not less than a certain number of houses, we go to the Minister, tell him the terms and conditions of the loan and he underwrites it, and the Minister subsequently makes up any shortage that may appear in the loan, pays the money out to us and takes up the rest of the scrip.

It is up to the Minister and not up to me to agree the issue price and the rate of interest and if he thinks we should not pay more than 2 per cent. we do not care a hang. We will issue at 2 per cent. because he underwrites it. If he does not want to take up the whole lot—the whole £5,000,000—when it is issued he says: "You had better pay a little bit more. The current market rate will be such that you will get no subscriptions unless you issue at 4¾ or 5 per cent." It is not our responsibility; it is the responsibility of the Minister. If on his advice we issue a loan, and if because of his advice, it is not subscribed to any extent, or not at all, he has to find the money. He knows that our requirements between our housing and small Dwellings Acquisition Act loans are in the neighbourhood of £6,000,000 or £6,500,000 per year.

We are spending all that money in housing our people and getting houses built, but Deputy Desmond comes along and says that Deputy Briscoe is paying too much money for his housing requirements because he does not understand the situation. He is a member of a local authority and if he means what he says, all I can say is that he does not know the first lesson in municipal or local authority finance. The Minister can either give us the money, if he has it in the Exchequer, on loan and can fix the rate of interest which he thinks from time to time is the correct rate. He takes the responsibility of paying into the kitty whatever is short.

Comment on this

Deputy Desmond seems to have got under your skin.

Comment on this

He did get under my skin. I hope when the Deputy speaks he will speak to the Budget and not to an individual.

Comment on this

Oh yes. That is my form.

Comment on this

I am not saying it is not Deputy Kyne's form, but he might not have been here at the beginning. I will say this for Deputy Kyne—I do not think he would have subscribed to the approach Deputy Desmond made in his references here to me.

Deputy Desmond talked of the increases in social services and one would imagine that when Fianna Fáil took office in 1932 they had taken over a vast amount of social services bringing benefits to our people and that they left them at that until this benevolent Government came in. Deputy Desmond should look up the records of this House and find out how many of the social services were in fact introduced by Fianna Fáil and did not exist in the community before the advent of Fianna Fáil. He might learn a lesson or two.

There was talk about the increase given to the widows who were not qualified under the contributory scheme. It was Fianna Fáil who brought those widows in.

Comment on this

Who compelled Fianna Fáil to bring them in? It was the late Deputy T.J. Murphy who was the first to advocate it.

Comment on this

If Deputy McAuliffe could compel this Government to do something good I would be the first to congratulate him or if he compelled us when we were in Government, either by persuasion or by vote to do something good I would still give him credit, but at least credit should also be given to the people who were compelled—if you like—to do it and did it, but the way Deputy Desmond spoke one would imagine the inter-Party Government was the inventor of all these social services.

He talked about housing. Does he ever go back and find out who introduced the 1932 Housing Act, the difference between it and its predecessors among the Housing Acts. It is all very well to try to say that 2/6 extra for the old age pensioners now is the correction of a situation which should not have been allowed to exist under the Fianna Fáil administration but I can throw my mind back to the time when, in order to balance the Budget, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government took 1/- off the old age pensioners who were then getting only 10/- a week. Other members of the House remember that occasion. I have dealt at length with housing and I hope I have done so to the satisfaction of Deputy Desmond when he comes to read the verbatim report, as regards the position in which we are in Dublin Corporation with regard to the raising of money.

I want to emphasise that we are not responsible for the rate of interest that is paid. It is the responsibility of the Minister for Finance who will have an opportunity in the next few months of telling us whether (a) he will provide the money out of the Local Loans Fund or out of any other fund he likes and (b) whether he thinks it is advisable for us to seek this money from the public. He will have to approve the issue and the rate of interest when we have had advice from our broker and when the Minister has had advice from his officials and whatever rate he tells us to offer, we will issue the loan at that rate. But of course he will take the responsibility. If he sets too low a rate and the issue is not taken up, he pays the balance of the money because he underwrites it. I am sure the Minister is not going to enter into any juggling performance with that sort of matter and will try to keep the rate equitable from the point of view of what the borrower is going to pay and also from the point of view of what those subscribing the money should get.

I said earlier and I want to repeat now with the permission of the Chair——

Comment on this

I thought repetition was out of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to put this to the Minister because he was not in here when I began. I approach this Budget on the basis that it is a good Budget. I am not finding fault with the Budget; I think it is a good Budget. It is not very unlike its predecessor, the Budget introduced by the Minister's predecessor. The Minister's speech was if you like, factual, and I want to say that except for a few small items, as far as I can judge, it was straight and above board with no great concealments except that there may be errors of omission.

To listen to the Minister for Industry and Commerce talking here to-day, one would imagine that all the items of capital expenditure were his own brain children. It was interesting to notice the way he drew out the capital expenditure amounts. Every one of the items he referred to had been having capital expenditure for years and years and in most cases the capital amounts on this occasion total to £5,000,000 less than the envisaged capital expenditures in the last Budget. Possibly it may be wise not to budget too much. The Minister may be advised that they cannot be spent. Would the Minister agree with that?

Comment on this

They never were, in any year.

Comment on this

I am not finding fault with the Budget, as such. I will come later to the consideration of what the approach would be if it were the same Budget and if the Minister were sitting on this side of the House. The Minister for Industry and Commerce talked about the capital expenditure on the railways. They are raising their own capital expenditure.

Comment on this

I was sitting next to him and he never mentioned them.

Comment on this

He did. He mentioned the E.S.B. They, also, are going to raise their own capital expenditure.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will read my speech he will find that there is in it exactly the figure the Minister for Industry and Commerce mentioned, that is, £4,000,000 to the E.S.B.

Comment on this

But they are going to raise their own capital. It is not provided for here.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

We are not giving the E.S.B. any more capital for rural electrification. In fact, they are going to pay us back the sums already given.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at the capital Budget for 1955-56 he will see £4,000,000 for the E.S.B. in it, which the Minister for Industry and Commerce mentioned.

Comment on this

Voted here?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it in Table II? Anyhow, I cannot see it here. Perhaps the Minister would show me where the reference to the railway company is?

Comment on this

Look at page 18.

Comment on this

That is the Budget speech. I am talking of the Financial Statement for 1955. Is it in that?

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy where it is in a minute. He can take it that it is there.

Comment on this

The railway company recently issued a prospectus and sought a loan under Government guarantee. The Minister for Finance guaranteed it. I think it was issued at 4½ per cent. and £96 10s. issue price. It was not oversubscribed. It was not fully subscribed. The Minister who underwrote it had to make up the rest. The Minister will be guided by that in his next issue. There will be the market situation, the law of supply and demand.

Comment on this

It is on Table II of page 4 of the tables in connection with the Financial Statement. "Below the Line" issues.

Comment on this

I have that here. They are not specified here.

Comment on this

16.94.

Comment on this

They are not specified here. We now know that from now on —unless there has been a change in the idea—the E.S.B. will seek its own money from the public the same as the railway company have done. I do not know whether it will do it with or without a guarantee from the Minister but we are reaching the stage now where, for capital expenditures, money has to be raised publicly. There is no use in trying now to fix a rate of interest of some 2 per cent. that you believe you can get all this money at. There is no use in Deputy Desmond's attacking the patriotism of the people who have the money, on the grounds that they are patriotic only if they give their money for nothing or for a very nominal rate of interest. And that they are most unpatriotic if they do not. So long as we live within the framework of the Constitution which we have, money also has its rights, even if it is under control. There has been a lot of talk about tea.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this