Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–158 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When I moved to report progress last night I was making the point that the publicans of Dublin were disappointed and I was proceeding to quote from the Cork Examiner of May 10th a statement made by the Chairman of the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association in which he said that it is most likely that the price of drink will be increased on the consumer in the near future. He was referring to the Budget statement last week and said that, having consideration for the association's claim, it had created emergency conditions in the trade. He went on then to state that they had looked forward to a lowering of costs in the trade and said that the least he had expected was that the same relief would be accorded them as was accorded in the previous Budget, even though that relief was small in itself.
I would direct the attention of the Chairman of the Licensed Grocers' and Vintners' Association to the first act of the present Government when they brought in the Finance Bill of 1954 and when Deputy Lemass on this side of the House then challenged them with the windy promises they had made around the streets of Dublin regarding the poor man's pint. At that time their speeches swept through the main streets like a low wind in Jamaica.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass set out these series of amendments to the Finance Bill of 1954 which had as their purpose—or which sought, I should say —bringing the Government to heel and at least bringing them to some realisation of the responsibility they had as a Government. The front benchers had gone out and made specific promises to the publicans of Dublin and the country. One amendment Deputy Lemass moved in 1954 was in sub-section (1), lines 15 and 16, to delete 7/6 and to substitute 6/6 in the £ for income-tax. That not alone related to income-tax but it related to beer, spirits and tobacco as well.
What was the reaction of the present Government to that amendment? Their reaction was to troop to the Lobby and endorse every tax we had imposed in the 1952 Budget. Not alone did they endorse them then, but they still have the hardihood and the brassy countenances to say that they were just and necessary taxes and that the publicans of Dublin would get no relief and that the poor man could pay for his pint and that the cigarette smokers would continue to pay the increased price for cigarettes.
I mention these matters in the House in order to bring to the public a realisation of the new high low we have reached in public life, when men of alleged responsibility make specific promises and, when we remind them of them, merely sneer at us and say that we are play-acting.
We said in 1952 that the taxes were necessary. The Government who were then the Opposition complained that they were unnecessary, unjust and cruel taxes. Yesterday, Deputy Dunne, in the course of a long statement, decried the Budget of 1952 but conveniently forgot that he trooped into the Lobby in support of every tax that we levied on the people that year.
In their speeches on this occasion, members of the Government and their supporters were rather hesitant about the Budget. They were apologising for it. Some of them, when they heard the Budget statement, left the House and trooped out, or drooped out, I should say, like men out of a shower. It damped their spirits.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot live on the past; there is no fat in it. There was supposed to be £10,000,000 to £15,000,000 worth of fat in the 1952 Budget. Was not it the job of the present Government to remit that fat and to spread it among the population? When we remind them of that we are told we are play-acting. We would be failing in our duty to our constituents and to the public in general if we did not remind the Government of their pre-election speeches and promises.
I heard an argument to-day across the House about the rates. The Minister for Defence, General MacEoin, in Sligo, not only promised lower rates but promised to supplement the local rates from the Central Fund. He did not intervene at Question Time to-day to say that that was his policy now.
Comment on this
The present Government have failed miserably to live up to their promises. They have failed miserably regarding prices.
Comment on this
They failed miserably to curtail expenditure. They failed to fulfil any promise they made during the election. That is the way the man-in-the-street looks at it. That is the way the man-in-the-street judges a Government.
They talked about controlling the price of this, that and the other. The body that was set up at the expense of the taxpayer to adjudicate on prices has let prices run riot. We knew that would happen before the Prices Advisory Body was founded. We told that to the Government. They were told that by the Evening Herald following the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the supplies and services debate. I need only quote a paragraph or two from it:—
"Permanent legislation for the control of prices was foreshadowed in Mr. Norton's speech in Dáil Eireann on Wednesday last. The subject is one which the Government should approach with extreme caution. Undoubtedly there are many commodities in respect of which the public feels aggrieved because of the prices charged to consumers. But it is by no means certain that direct Government intervention is a remedy. Very often it can result in grave injustice."
It goes on to say:—
"It cannot be asserted that it is wrong for the Government to control prices. But it can be said that such a power should be invoked only in very exceptional circumstances, as in times of national emergency or acute shortages, and even then only if the normal forces of competition and the weight of public opinion have proved ineffective. The public can scarcely have much confidence in the efficacy of State control over prices when the experiences of the war years are recalled."
It goes on:—
"At best——"
Comment on this
The Deputy is making very extensive quotations. He spent close on half an hour last night giving quotations.
Comment on this
I am nearly finished. It says—I am summarising:—
"At best any attempt at State control of prices can be only a partial success. If it were to be logical the system should not begin at the end of the chain by fixing the prices to be charged for commodities; it should start much further back by controlling..."
—all the things that went to build up the price.
The Minister was advised regarding the establishment of the Prices Advisory Body. He waved that aside as an airy fairy suggestion. He said that it emanated only from the mind of Fianna Fáil. Now that he has failed and that the Prices Advisory Body have failed, the least he could do for the public is to take the Prices Advisory Body off the taxpayer's back and relieve the taxpayer of the cost of that body.
Deputy MacBride, whom I could describe, I suppose, as the chief apologist now that his rôle is reduced to mere nuisance value in the House, belaboured Fianna Fáil, as usual, and talked about afforestation and emigration. He talked, as usual, with his tongue in his cheek, as loud and as long as junior who lost his Sunday sixpence down the grating but he did not get much comfort out of the present Budget. Neither did he criticise it, because he is tied to the tail of the Government like an old tin can and can be dragged anywhere the Government want to bring him.
This Budget, which has been described by the supporters of the Government as a good Budget, can be roughly summarised in this way, that the taxpayer gets no relief, the public get no relief, the farmer stands to lose a good deal, the housewife gets no relief. The housewife finds that the money in her purse is getting shorter and shorter. The farmer finds that the axe fell on his neck and that his income is considerably reduced in face of rising rates and of increased wage demands from agricultural workers and increased overheads. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government need not smile.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary need not laugh. There is a demand on the farmers for increased wages this very month. The Parliamentary Secretary purports to be an economist. He should go to the Library and study this matter and it will extend his education a little. The farmer finds himself at a distinct disadvantage, despite the anxiety of the Minister for Agriculture. He used to talk with his hand on his heart about our 12,500,000 acres of agricultural land and how the living of every man, woman and child in this State depended on it. I often heard him in Earlsfort Terrace at the Literary and Historical Debating Society telling his hearers about what could be done and should be done for agriculture. The first thing that the Minister for Agriculture did for agriculture was to hit the farmer on the head with a mallet and say: "You stay in your corner; if you come out again I will give you a further cut."
The great majority of wage-earners get nothing out of the Budget. They find themselves paying the same rate of income-tax, more for their wearing apparel, more for their footwear, the same for their cigarettes, the same for their entrance into a dance hall, despite the talk we used to hear about the dance hall proprietors and the amount of money they used to contribute to Fianna Fáil. I wonder is the boot on the other foot now and would the present Government be buttering up the dance hall proprietors in the hope that they might contribute to their coffers? If they are, I hope they will not turn Turk on them as they did with the publicans of Dublin who contributed £20,000 to their war chest and then found that they got the axe in the neck.
Comment on this
We were informed it was £20,000 and I am inclined to believe it. They used to be rich men one time.
Comment on this
The old age pensioners, the widow and orphan and blind pensioners get a mangy half-crown a week at the pleasure of the Minister for Finance. Deputy Dunne was very thankful for it and Deputy Kyne said that half a loaf was better than no bread. I suggest he is only getting a very burned crust. However, he is also tied to the tail of the Government like an old tin can and he cannot afford to choose otherwise. Beggars cannot be choosers. I think that is a fair summary of the Budget and that it will be the summary of the people in general. We will probably see the reaction to it in the next 12 months.
Comment on this
I propose to be very brief in my contribution to this debate because what I have to say to-day or what I should say has already been said in this House since 1948, whenever I spoke on the Budget introduced. Consequently, on this occasion I propose to confine myself to a few general remarks on the Government policy in so far as we can find a Government policy in the recent Budget.
We all understand that the Budget speech gives an indication of Government policy for the following 12 months and that in the Budget we find a guide to our economic advancement for that period. Let us go back to last May, June and July and what do we find? We find that the Ministers of the present Government made it quite clear that they had no hand, act or part in, or responsibility for, the 1954 Budget and that in so far as the Estimates which came before the House were concerned they themselves could not accept any responsibility for those Estimates; in other words, the Estimates and the Budget were a Fianna Fáil production. I do not think that can be denied by any members of the present Government.
However, when the present Minister for Finance introduced his Budget recently he pointed out in his opening remarks that, despite some setbacks such as a disappointing harvest, widespread flooding, etc., in the year 1954 the economic position was satisfactory. If that is the case, then it must be as a result of the 1954 Budget and the policy which this Government took over. It cannot be denied that it was the policy enunciated in the 1954 Budget which has guided the progress of this country for the last 12 months.
Admittedly, when this Government came into office they immediately and, I think, in a mistaken and hurried fashion, decided to prove to the electorate that they were prepared to carry out some of their promises, at any rate, and with a great flourish of trumpets a reduction was made in the price of butter to the extent of 5d. per lb. All of us will rejoice at any action that will bring foodstuffs, especially butter, bread, and so forth, more within the reach of the poorer groups. Any action in that regard should receive acclaim from the public, but I felt at that time that a reduction of 5d. per lb. in butter was not going to bring butter within the reach of the lower income groups. It was already far beyond their reach and if the Government examined the position carefully they would find that a reduction of at least 1/- per lb. would be necessary to ensure that those of our population who were not on a high salary basis would receive the due benefit.
The real test of the advantage conferred by this reduction of 5d. per lb. lies in the statistics available. By how much did the consumption of butter increase in the last 12 months? To what extent did the consumption of butter increase within the State? It is there we have the real proof of how little benefit was conferred by this reduction of 5d. per lb.
It should also be borne in mind that while we were conferring this alleged benefit on the poorer sections by reducing the price of butter we were conferring that benefit to a greater degree on the large hoteliers and the large users of butter and that it was the large hotels in this country and the incoming tourists as well who really benefited rather than the poorer sections of our own community. The reason I am criticising this is that I believe it was bad Government policy to take that step. I am all for a reduction in the price of foodstuffs, but I think the reduction should be passed on to the most deserving sections of the community.
Last May and June are not so far back that they cannot be referred to again. I do not think anybody here can deny that the one issue involved in the last general election was the cost of living. Deputy Dunne made reference here last night to certain people who were at one time members of this House. Four Independent Deputies here were held up to public odium and described as being responsible, and solely responsible, for the 1952 Budget. There was a continuous harping on these four men by the members of the present Government and by their supporters in the back benches. No opportunity was lost, here or outside, of convincing the public that were it not for the fact that these four Deputies helped to keep Fianna Fáil in office the 1952 Budget would never have been imposed on the country; and, consequently, the high prices which are now being paid by the public for various commodities would likewise never have been imposed. These four men were held responsible for what I described as a very harsh Budget.
Now, in the last general election as a result of the propaganda of the Parties composing the present Government, these four men are no longer in this House. The electorate believed the men who are now in Government. They believed the supporters of the present Government who pointed out to them that these four men should not be returned and the public acted as a jury in the sincere belief that the present Government would remedy the situation created by the 1952 Budget.
What happened? Other Deputies, now mainly members of the Opposition, have dealt at great length with the trail of broken promises. Let us get down to realities. In 1951, Fianna Fáil returned to office. Prior to their return they said there would be no reduction in subsidies and no penalties would be imposed on the public; everything in the garden would be lovely. But, on their return to office, after an examination of public expenditure it was decided to take the severe step of imposing the harsh Budget of 1952 upon the community. The promises they made prior to the 1951 election were not carried out. In 1954 Fianna Fáil went out of office and the inter-Party Government returned. They tell us now that they find things were so bad on their return that they cannot carry out the promises they made prior to the election. Is there not a great similarity between the two groups when it comes down to not even carrying out one's promises?
Comment on this
I am dealing with the promises made by the major groups in this House. We have arrived at the position where both groups make their specific promises and both groups, having examined the financial situation, find they are unable to carry out their promises. If there is not a great similarity there between the two groups, I know very little about public life.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin points out that this Government has only been in office for ten months: should I say this is the 11 more months and ten more days type of thing? I do not dispute that fact at all and I am not one of those who expect an incoming Government to work miracles. I will leave it at that for the moment.
After the last election, having listened to speakers on behalf of the Government Parties in my own constituency, I half believed they would do some of the things they promised to do in the course of that campaign. The serious thing is that most of the public believed that they would carry out their promises and, in view of public opinion, I felt constrained to give an opportunity in so far as it lay within my power to those Parties which promised these things. I felt it was my responsibility to help by my vote in seeing that they got that opportunity.
What do we get? After 11 months they bring in a Fianna Fáil Budget. I have never agreed with what I can only describe as the conservative view of the Fianna Fáil Party on financial matters. Neither can I agree that it is fair for the present inter-Party Government to pursue in great measure a similar policy.
To my mind this Budget is an orthodox conservative Budget, an extremely cautious Budget lacking in inspiration, as has been every Budget introduced here over the last 20 years. In a speech lasting approximately an hour and a quarter the Minister devoted less than one minute to dealing with our two major problems to-day-unemployment and emigration. Some two months ago there was a motion before this House in the names of Deputy Maguire and myself calling on the Government to take immediate steps to deal with the problem of unemployment and emigration. That motion was debated here at length. The Government refused to accept it. A very flimsy excuse for its non-acceptance was put up by one prominent Government spokesman: the Government could not remedy these problems by immediate steps.
Our suggestion was that immediate steps would be taken to initiate a desirable policy which would have the effect of remedying the present situation. Though that motion was not accepted I felt it would at any rate have some influence on the Government. What do we find after two months have elapsed? In the course of the most important speech of the year in this House less than one minute is devoted to the two major ills which beset this country.
I blame the present Government for pretending to be different from Fianna Fáil. The difference exists only in name and there is a desperate battle at the moment to preserve political identities. But it is becoming more difficult with each day that passes to convince the people that there is a fundamental difference in the approach of our major Parties to our problems. The only difference lies in the matter of a few pounds.
Comment on this
The only difference we can see at the present time between the 1954 and the 1955 Budget is the miserable increase of 2/6 per week to old age pensioners and to widows and orphans. I do not intend to elaborate but I would like to be shown, and I would like it to be proved to me that there is a difference in the approach to industrial expansion, between the approach by the inter-Party Government and the Fianna Fáil Government to capital development. I have always held the view that the policy enunciated by Fianna Fáil from 1932 was the right one, to develop our natural resouces, but where I criticised Fianna Fáil all through the years and still criticise them is for the fact that the rate of progress, in my opinion, was painfully slow. Here, we have the present Government falling exactly into line, accepting the same outlook with regard to capital development and with regard to industrial expansion as their predecessors.
I think that the time is fast drawing near when every Deputy in this House must be pinned down to one side or the other, that he must show himself in his true colours as either a progressive or a conservative. If we are going to have our political Parties in this House, we must know what exactly those Parties stand for, whether they represent the progressive outlook or whether they are conservative. If we can establish that then there will be some hope for development in Irish public life.
To conclude, I believe that the 1955 Budget and the year 1955 will be remembered in a significant fashion in future years as far as Irish political development is concerned. It has marked the year in which the difference between all Parties in this House has been brought to a minimum and it is from now on that we may hope for that change which so many people desire should be brought about in Irish politics.
Comment on this
If there is any Deputy who would not like to see Deputies in this House pinned down to one side or the other, I think that it is Deputy McQuillan, because if ever a person acted like Mother Machree's dog and went a little bit of the road with everyone, it is Deputy McQuillan. I think he will probably continue in that career in this Dáil as he did in the last Dáil.
I want to say in relation to some of the other speeches made here to-day that there is something amusing about the air of injured innocence which we find on the benches opposite. We find Fianna Fáil Deputies coming here posing as the poor innocent victims of hostile propaganda during the election; adopting the attitude that they were people with white hands and that gangs of liars and gangsters were put up against them in the election and that they beat down the honest Fianna Fáil patriots.
I want to remind some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies of the particular type of electioneering which took place in the 1951 General Election and which was also carried on by Fianna Fáil Deputies in the 1954 General Election. I want to remind them that their deputy leader issued an appeal for funds to certain people in this city seeking funds for the purpose of bringing to bear on the election "modern electioneering methods". I would like if any of the Deputies opposite would tell me if some of the things I propose to recount now were the "modern electioneering methods" to which Deputy Lemass referred when he appealed for funds and supporters.
Remember in 1951 these poor innocents had spent three years carping against the inter-Party Government and they had spent the last six months before the general election, when due to the Korean war situation prices had begun to rise slightly, tub-thumping and condemning the inter-Party Government because the cost of living had gone up. I am not going to attempt to argue what the implications of the speeches made by Deputies opposite were, but I am going to say that not only by implication but by specific, categorical, unequivocal assurances did Fianna Fáil tell the people what they proposed doing, on the one hand, and what they would refrain from doing on the other hand.
The House may remember during that election campaign of 1951 Fianna Fáil underscored all the propaganda by posters which were placarded all around Dublin City and throughout the country with just four words on them: "you can trust Dev". Let us see what you could trust Dev to do or not to do. You could trust Dev, according to Deputy Lemass, Deputy MacEntee and according to some others, not to reimpose taxes on beer and tobacco which had been imposed in 1947 and which had been removed by the inter-Party Government. You could trust Fianna Fáil not to interfere with food subsidies. You could trust Dev. There was no doubt about it as far as Fianna Fáil was concerned; they were making specific proposals and you could trust them. Let me say this: Deputy Lemass in his constituency, apparently, did not like this adulation of one man. He took out the "you can trust Dev", and in his constituency he made it, "you can trust Fianna Fáil". Apparently, he felt that he was rather near the throne and that the thing to do was to get the people's minds off the one-man Party idea because he was heir-at-law and, therefore, for his constituency, it was: "you can trust Fianna Fáil". Probably Deputy Aiken, as heir-apparent, made it: "you can trust Fianna Fáil" in County Louth also.
What could you trust Fianna Fáil to do? Deputy Lemass assured the electorate in 1951 again that Fianna Fáil could be trusted; that you knew where you stood with Fianna Fáil. Just before that election he spoke in these terms according to the Sunday Press of the 13th May, 1951:—
"A Coalition Minister has said that Fianna Fáil, if elected, would increase the taxes on beer and tobacco. Why should such taxes be necessary? There is no reason why we should impose these taxes."
There was no implication there and there was no doubt about it. Deputy Lemass told the electorate that if he got back to Government he would not reimpose those taxes and "you could trust Dev".
Deputy MacEntee was even more specific about it. This has been quoted here before. I will quote it again very briefly. According to the Irish Times of the 15th May, 1951, speaking in Rathmines Town Hall, Deputy MacEntee
"referred to rumours being spread by a number of persons in the licensed trade who were saying that if Fianna Fáil were returned to Government taxes imposed on drink in the Supplementary Budget of 1947 would be reimposed. There was no truth whatever in that."
Quite definite, quite specific. He pinpointed the issue. He said that persons were saying that if he got back, those taxes would be reimposed. He was standing up in Rathmines Town Hall to give the lie to that. There was no truth in it. We could trust Dev. To emphasise it even more, on the same occasion, he said:—
"The people were being asked to decide whether politics in Ireland were to be a dirty game played by confidence tricksters who were prepared to promise anything to dupe the people into voting for them."
Could anyone doubt the programme that was being put before them? They had Deputy MacEntee's assurances; they had Deputy Derrig's assurances; they had Deputy Lemass's assurances that "you could trust Dev."
Comment on this
I am suggesting to Deputy Derrig that he assured the people that they could trust Dev— is he going back on that?
Comment on this
All these assurances were given that there would be no reimposition of these taxes. Lest anyone should think that this was just an irresponsible speech by Deputy MacEntee, or that Deputy Lemass's effort was just a speech which he did not think would be reported, I should like to point out that they went a lot further than that. They all got together when the election was over —I should be very surprised if Deputy Derrig were not in on it—and they issued solemnly to every newspaper in this country a 17-point programme, carefully planned out. In that 17-point programme they gave very definite and very specific assurances. I say that Deputy Derrig was probably allowed in the door when the 17-point programme was being drafted. I say to Deputy Derrig that in point 15 of that programme he assured the people that if he got back as a member of the Government he would maintain subsidies to control the price of essential foodstuffs.
Let us just deal for a moment with these specific assurances given by the injured innocents opposite, the victims of hostile propaganda. They would not, according to Deputy MacEntee, put back the tax on beer and tobacco which had been imposed in 1947 and which was taken off by the inter-Party Government. They would not, according to Deputy MacEntee, reimpose this taxation. They would not, according to Deputy Derrig and the rest of them, interfere with food subsidies.
Comment on this
We did not say we would not interfere with food subsidies. The Deputy is changing now.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley probably feels that if anyone can claim to be an injured innocent he can, because he was not in on this. He was not called into consultation, the same as Deputy Derrig, when the Fianna Fáil Party were pledging their honour to the people to maintain food subsidies.
Comment on this
Before we come to that, suppose we come to Deputy MacEntee's reasons why he reimposed the taxes on beer and tobacco? Will that suit the Deputy for a start?
Comment on this
I challenged Deputy MacEntee on this in the Seanad. I have here a quotation from a speech he made in the Seanad in June of 1952. The reference is the Official Report of the Seanad Debates of the 19th June, 1952, column 1638. I had put before Deputy MacEntee, who was the Minister for Finance at the time, the reference to his speech in Rathmines which I have just quoted to the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it permissible to go over a discussion here that took place in the other House?
Comment on this
I do not want to be bored by the Deputy's speeches in the Seanad. It is bad enough as it is to have to listen to them here.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I have wakened Deputy Derrig up. He was resting very comfortably a few moments ago.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins had better paraphrase it. It is not usual to read out statements made in the other House.
Comment on this
I think, with all respect, that Deputy MacEntee might feel offended if I attempted to paraphrase it. The excuse tendered by the Deputy was that when he spoke it was not his intention to reimpose those duties; that, quite naturally, as rational men, the Fianna Fáil Party could not have that intention until they saw what the problem was and that, because he happened to say a certain thing in May, 1951, it did not follow that, in different circumstances and if the national interest required it, he should not depart from it—it did not follow that he would be bound by that promise in perpetuity. "In any event," he added, "what does anything I said in 1951 matter in relation to the problems which now confront the State, the Government and the people?" I want to put this to the injured innocents. In effect, Deputy MacEntee's reasoning was: "I can get up on the platform and give a definite and specific promise and assurance to the people that we have no intention of reimposing certain taxes. If I reimpose the taxes at a later stage, how am I to be blamed? Was I not honest in saying it was not the intention to do it?" I do not think that kind of excuse is good enough. I am not talking about implications that can be taken from speeches by Fianna Fáil leaders or——
Comment on this
Apparently I am not allowed to quote in full. I should be only too delighted to do so.
Comment on this
That was the Fianna Fáil campaign in 1951. In 1954, those injured innocents—having gone back on what they had stipulated in 1951—had to think of something else with which to face the people. We hear talk about election speeches made by present Ministers and by supporters of the present Government. We are told about election pamphlets that were issued. Was any more damnable pamphlet issued in the general election campaign than this one which was produced by Deputy MacEntee and his colleague in Dublin South-East, suggesting that if there was any change of Government—if Labour, Fine Gael or any group except Fianna Fáil had anything to do with the Government of this country—every Irish industry would be closed down, men would be thrown out of employment, wages would be cut, and so forth? Is that not the suggestion behind this pamphlet which was issued by Deputy MacEntee and his colleague who was a former Deputy of this House?
Comment on this
This was one of the modern electioneering methods showing Irish industry as an aeroplane being shot down by the members forming the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
Irish Steel would go. Various factories of one sort or another would go. Irish Shipping would go. That was the type of modern electioneering method used by the injured innocents who feel they were wronged because spokesmen supporting the inter-Party Government pointed out to the people—and rightly so—what Fianna Fáil had done during their three years in office and how they had broken categoric assurances which they gave to the people. That is one of the pamphlets produced by the injured innocents. Here is another pamphlet which portrays Deputy MacBride, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce and the present Taoiseach as a group of bank robbers endeavouring to raid the tills. Here is yet another pamphlet. Is it necessary to add that this pamphlet also was produced by Deputy MacEntee and his colleague? The heading of this pamphlet is: "It is your money they are after." That was the type of modern electioneering method used by the Simon Pures opposite me. That was the suggestion made in the Taoiseach's constituency of Dublin South-East—that "It is your money they are after", that that is all they are interested in.
Would Deputy O'Malley like to inspect some of these documents and then we would see if his face would look quite so innocent? I do not suggest that, personally, he would have anything to do with that type of thing but that is what was going on. Let them search their own consciences before they start reproaching other people.
Comment on this
As the Deputy has glossed over the reasons for the imposition of taxation by Fianna Fáil, would he state what was the deficit in the balance of payments when we assumed office after 1951 and what the deficit is this year?
Comment on this
Your leader told us that in Fermoy. The surplus was £24,000,000, so do not contradict the boss.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley is what would be known in other countries as a deviationist and he might not last too long. Deputy de Valera has at least this to his credit: when he became Taoiseach, in answer to a challenge from the present Minister for Agriculture he admitted that Deputy MacEntee found on his desk a bag with about £24,000,000 in it when he went into office.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil had the option of accepting or rejecting what they term commitments. Let us illustrate that for the benefit of Deputy O'Malley. There was the question of the public services arbitration award. The Fianna Fáil Party did not feel they were committed to honour that. They did not honour it. We felt we were committed and we did honour it. I want to put this on record for the benefit of the House because I think it is time that Deputies opposite stopped this play-acting that has been going on.
Comment on this
Did we not honour these increases? It cost us £3,500,000 when we went into office to honour a pledge.
Comment on this
The Deputy must restrain himself. He will get an opportunity of making his own statement and he may then answer the points that are being made.
Comment on this
I think it is time the Deputies opposite stopped their play-acting about what were promises and what were commitments. The present Taoiseach made his position and the position of those supporting him quite clear to the electorate and I feel there is no need for anyone to apologise for the manner in which the issue was placed before the electorate by the present Taoiseach during the last general election. I am not shirking for a moment the responsibility of saying that this Government and every Deputy behind this Government aims at reducing the cost of living, either by bringing down prices or by bringing up people's incomes to narrow the gap between prices and incomes.
The Taoiseach, during the last general election, made his attitude in the matter quite clear. Even Deputy O'Malley would probably remember that the Irish Times issued a questionnaire to Deputy de Valera and to Deputy Costello and one of the questions put to those two Deputies was: “If returned to Government do you propose in the coming year to reduce the cost of living by increasing food subsidies?” Deputy Costello's reply was:—
"An object of our policy is to reduce the cost of living and to relieve the burden of present prices by using all practical means of increasing the real value of people's money. The extent to which, and the rate at which, revisions in subsidies combined with readjustments in taxation are possible cannot be determined in advance by an Opposition. Responsible decisions on these two matters require:—(1) access to all relevant facts concerning the condition of the Exchequer, (2) the ascertainment of the effect on the Exchequer of a fundamental reform of the financial policy. I do not, therefore, propose to repeat the action of our opponents in 1951, when they made specific promises which they subsequently broke. They failed to keep their specific promises to maintain subsidies and not restore certain taxes. I am prepared to make only one promise—to provide good Government to the best of my ability."
Comment on this
I am reading from the Official Report, for the 23rd June, 1954, column 505, Volume 146. It was a quotation from an interview published in the Irish Times but I have not got the date of the issue of the Irish Times in which it appeared. As I say, the position was made quite clear and the Deputies opposite need not think they are gaining any sympathy by the attitude they have adopted during this debate and during previous debates. A number of Deputies have compared this Budget with the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952. Deputy MacEntee stated that it was an as-you-were Budget. The Fianna Fáil newspapers also made use of that phrase to describe the Budget. I want to say straight away that I do not believe this is an as-you-were Budget. I do not believe it is the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952. In considering this Budget you have to consider not only the framework in which the Budget is brought in, but also the background of the last 12 months and what are the Government's hopes for the future.
The first claim I want to make, having regard to the work of the Government during the past 12 months, is that this is an Irish Budget, a Budget brought in to meet the needs of the Irish people as the Government see them and as the country can afford them. It is not a Budget brought in to meet the wishes of Mr. R.A. Butler, the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. That is the first distinction I want to draw between this Budget and the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952. I think Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Lemass—I am not quite certain about Deputy Lemass—met the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. They resent any suggestion that they were summoned over to meet him so I shall not make it. We all recall how they met Mr. Butler and we can all recall how the Fianna Fáil Government then and the Tory Government in England stepped along cheek by jowl. The Tory Government brought in their Budget for the first time in history about two months earlier than the traditional time. When Deputy MacEntee came back here to Dublin he did the same thing. We all remember the slashing of the food subsidies in Britain in 1952. We remember how Deputy MacEntee did the same thing here.
Comment on this
Probably Deputy Derrig remembers this. At any rate, we remember how, when Mr. R. A. Butler went into the British House of Commons to present his Budget to the people there, he went waving a message from Deputy Seán MacEntee in his hand to say: "Ata Boy, we are behind you" and in the Irish Press of the 12th March, 1952, this appears in relation to Mr. Butler's speech:—
"Mr. Butler said he had received a message from the Irish Minister for Finance expressing his Government's understanding of the gravity of the situation and their determination to play their part in the solving of it. He understood the Irish Minister for Finance would make a statement to-day."
That was the once proud, once independent, Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
What about the devaluation of sterling? Perhaps the Deputy will explain why his colleagues accepted Mr. Butler's advice in the British policy of devaluing the £?
Comment on this
Before we become engaged in a discussion on devaluation, let me just, for what it is worth, draw for Deputy Derrig a picture of two Fianna Fáil Ministers, one the Deputy MacEntee of 1932 who made a speech on the link with sterling. This speech made in 1932 is quoted in the Sunday Independent of the 23rd February, 1947, as follows:—
"I think it was the President (Mr. Cosgrave) said that we were anchored to the £ sterling and now the £ is a millstone around the necks of the people and is dragging them down to the bottom of the sea. The financial and economic position of the country would be much better if we had an independent currency instead of being tied to the sinking £."
That was Deputy Seán MacEntee in 1932.
Comment on this
In 1952, Mr. Butler said he had received a message from the Irish Minister for Finance expressing his Government's understanding of the gravity of the situation and their determination to play their part in solving it.
They got together in Downing Street in 1952. We know the result of that. I claim that the first essential difference between Mr. Sweetman's Budget of to-day and Deputy MacEntee's Budget of 1952 is that this is an Irish, Budget and it is not designed to suit the wishes of Mr. R. A. Butler, the British Chancellor of the Exchequer.
There are, of course, other differences. I do not know if the House has ever obtained from Deputy MacEntee or from Deputy Lemass any light as to what happened during their discussion with Mr. Butler. I would like to have some information on that subject even now. In any event, that is what happened in 1952. In 1955, I think I am correct in saying for the first time in history, an Irish Minister for Finance was able so to arrange matters that the Irish bank rate did not follow the British bank rate. That is another factor which must be taken into account when considering the framework and the background of the present Budget.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Childers had the right idea arising out of the 1952 Budget. I mention this merely to show again one of the differences between the 1952 Budget and the 1955 Budget, between the position in 1952 and the position in 1955. After Deputy Derrig, Deputy Burke and Deputy Beegan had passed the 1952 Budget through this House, Deputy Erskine Childers went down to Rath-downey, County Laois, to speak and is reported in the Irish Times of the 21st April, 1952. He must have been a very shook man when he went to Rath-downey because he said that what the country needed was a feeling of confidence in the business of government so that those with savings would lend to an administration in which no crackpot financiers were permitted to delude the people by burning candles at both ends and pointing out what a grand light they would make.
Deputy Childers felt, after the 1952 Budget, that the people needed to have confidence in their Government. I am quite sure Deputy Derrig felt that the people had no confidence in the Government and that the Government had very little confidence in the people because they held on for another two years.
What is the position this year? Deputy MacEntee, during that period, in order to raise his loan had to offer the people an inducement of a 5 per cent. interest rate. In the first loan floated by the present Minister for Finance, the people had such confidence in the present Government that there was no difficulty in persuading them to lend their money to the present Government at a very considerably lower rate of interest than that which Deputy MacEntee required.
Comment on this
That is another difference between the 1952 and the 1955 situations.
Let us consider also that in bringing in this Budget the Government, in implementing their aim to get down the cost of living, before they were many months in office had reduced the price of butter by 5d. per lb. and had accepted responsibility for the subsidy which that entailed, costing something in the region of £2,000,000. It is quite true that if that commitment was not honoured and if the commitment to the civil servants was not honoured, the Government would have £3,000,000 or so to spare. We felt that £2,000,000 was well spent in reducing what is perhaps the most essential food for the people.
I do not know what Fianna Fáil's view on that is to-day, but this much is certain that if Fianna Fáil had been returned to office in the last general election the price of butter would not have come down. Not one of them will deny that. It was not their policy to get down the price of butter, by subsidisation in any event. The Government honoured the arbitration award and the Government held down the cost of tea.
I know Fianna Fáil Deputies are under orders to sneer at what the Government have done in respect of tea. I once more would like to ask them to answer honestly before this debate is over what would they have done. Is not it true that if Fianna Fáil had been re-elected after the last general election they would have allowed the price of tea to go up and to continue going up without any effort to control it?
The Government during the course of the year dealt promptly with the question of the floods which occurred. I have already referred to the bank rate and to the loan. The Government have made it clear what they propose doing during the coming 12 months. They are continuing the butter subsidy. They have made provision for substantial increases to the old age pensioners and others. They have given important income-tax concessions. They have provided for additional health services and, of course, they are continuing the reliefs which were incorporated in the Budget of 1954 and of which Fianna Fáil are so proud.
Some Fianna Fáil speakers, including their last spokesman, Deputy Carter, have been gibing at the increase given to old age pensioners. Deputy Carter spoke about it as "this mangy 2/6 per week". I want to remind Deputies that when Fianna Fáil increased the old age pension by 1/6, in 1952, they did it as nearly as they could on a callous mathematical basis. They worked out that the effect of the removal of food subsidies was going to cost something in the region of 1/6 per head and therefore the very maximum to which the old age pensioner would be entitled was 1/6.
Deputy Burke looks as if he does not believe me. It is hard to believe, but that was the Fianna Fáil attitude in 1952. There was no question of easing the situation for old age pensioners and others. It was a question of giving them what the Government had decided was the bare minimum of what they were entitled to. In fact, it did not measure up to the damage that was done in the Budget at all.
Deputy MacEntee, in his 1952 Budget speech, at column 1139, Volume 130 of the Official Debates of the 7th April, 1952, had this to say:—
"On existing rations and at present prices, food subsidies reduce weekly expenditure per person on rationed foods by approximately 2/-. This 2/- per week has, of course, to be met by general taxation, that is to say, it has first to be collected from the general body of taxpayers before, by devious channels, it finds its way back to them: surely a wasteful and nonsensical procedure. The rise in retail prices consequent on the changes I have mentioned will not, however, amount to 2/-; in fact, on the average, it should work out at some 25 per cent. less, or almost 1/6 per head per week. This, then, is the outside limit of the burden that will be imposed on any individual, and, therefore, of the compensation that need be given in necessitous cases."
Then he goes on:—
"On this basis——"
—on the basis that that was the outside limit and that it was compensation for the damage the Government were doing—
——"the Government have decided to increase the old age pension by 1/6 a week..."
That was the Fianna Fáil attitude to the old age pensioners in 1952 and now they have the nerve to stand up here and talk about an increase of 2/6 given in this Budget as being a mangy increase. I suggest to Fianna Fáil Deputies that this Budget is a good Budget. It is a Budget with which the people are satisfied. Deputy Carter spent his concluding moments in reading out a list he had compiled of people who got no relief under the Budget. The real people who got no relief from this Budget are the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party because they cannot think of any argument to make against it. They have not yet told the House whether they propose voting against the Budget or not.
The Fianna Fáil Party organ anticipated what the people of the country wanted before the Budget was introduced and the Evening Press, having made a survey of what the people wanted, of what would be considered a good Budget, interviewed a person from Deputy MacEntee's constituency, who was described as “Mr. Average Married Man”. He said he would like to see the £85 income-tax allowance for each child increased to £100. In regard to the old age pensioners he said: “These old people deserve more money.” He would consider that a good Budget. The Fianna Fáil Party organ, having made their survey, gave that last opinion as what the average married man would consider a good Budget, and that was before the terms of the Budget were announced.
The day after the Budget was announced the Evening Press made another survey. They did not go back to “Mr. Average Married Man”, needless to say. They knew his views and they were not going to go near him again. They went around Dublin and they got some other views on the Budget. They gave only three, so we can imagine that the views they were getting did not suit. They gave this view, in any event:—
"I am glad to see the old age pensioners, the blind and widows getting the money—I would like to see them getting a good deal more.
"I think the Government did very well considering how little money they had at their disposal. The increase of £85 to £100 in the income-tax allowance for each child is also good for people with large families —but it does not benefit me, as I am not paying income-tax."
Comment on this
That was the result of a second survey carried out by the Fianna Fáil Party organ after the terms of the Budget were announced. Is it any use for Fianna Fáil Deputies to keep arguing? No one expects them to stand up and say this is an excellent Budget. If Deputy O'Malley, Deputy Burke or any other Fianna Fáil Deputy says this is an excellent Budget he will be feeling the back of his neck for a week and wondering what hit him. The fact is they know the people of the country are satisfied with this Budget and if they had any sincerity they would join with me in heartily congratulating the Minister for Finance and the Government on the Budget they have introduced.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot join with Deputy O'Higgins in congratulating the Minister for Finance on this Budget. One of the speakers on the Government side, my colleague from East Limerick, Deputy Carew, has suggested that 1955 will be a memorable year as regards the turning of the tide in regard to taxation. Be that as it may, 1955 will be remembered particularly by the electorate of the country for two things. In the first place, it is the second time they have been duped into electing a Coalition Government. In the second place, there is the point that once they are given an opportunity, they are clearly resolved that for all time this system of Government will be done away with in the country.
It was admitted by all sides that the cost of living was the main issue in the last election and no one has denied that. While quotations have been given here—mostly on this side of the House because it does not suit the Government supporters to give quotations at the present time—there is no shadow of doubt that the reason that we are sitting here in opposition and that the Government are over on that side of the House is due to the fact that there was a certain element, particularly in Dublin, who were convinced that with a change of Government and with the Coalition assuming office, immediately the cost of living would undoubtedly fall and the price of food would also be reduced. That cannot be denied.
The Tánaiste asked Deputy Lemass did he want an election. I am not in the position of either the Tánaiste or Deputy Lemass but I think it would be very interesting if an election were fought to-day. The figures were more or less equal before the last election. If an election were fought in Dublin I have no hesitation in saying that Fianna Fáil would be returned with an overwhelming majority. But we do not hear much talk nowadays about elections or by-elections. We do not see the Lord Mayor of Dublin, Deputy A. Byrne, careering around with a loaf on top of a walking stick. There is very little talk about elections.
This time 12 months Deputy A. Byrne, as reported in the Irish Press of 21st May, 1954, said:—
"I am going to support the inter-Party Government. But I say to them that they must do something for the housewife and for the unemployed. Patchwork relief schemes are not remedying unemployment."
If the housewives of this country get their hands on the Coalition in the next couple of months, when their rage is at its peak, the Coalition will not know what hit them.
Comment on this
We are a Party with national aspirations and we always work in the interests of the country as a whole. We would not use any situation for our own political advancement.
Comment on this
I would want notice of his question. There was no national issue at stake in the last general election. It all boiled down to a question of the cost of living. The people now realise they have been sold out. I notice that there was very little mention of expenditure and the cutting of the alleged wasteful expenditure of Fianna Fáil when Government Deputies intervened in this debate. Neither do I see any drastic cut in expenditure in the current financial year. One thing has been proved quite conclusively and that is that the Fianna Fáil Budget was sound national economy.
Comment on this
I think it is better that people like me, with a limited knowledge of finance and who can express themselves in ordinary everyday language, should speak in this debate. It is much better for people to hear us speaking here because there is no doubt about it the general public do not appreciate long-winded speeches and reference to fiduciary issues and all these other things. God knows what they mean. This Budget is a very simple matter. Deputy M.J. O'Higgins has taunted us with: "You can trust Dev." You can trust Dev; there is no doubt about that. It is a pity the whole country did not trust him on the last occasion.
No speaker on the other side so far has made any reference to the 17 point programme of Fianna Fáil before they returned to office.
Comment on this
When the Deputy was angling for office. It was after the election when the Deputies opposite were angling for office that that 17 point programme was promulgated. They were wooing Dr. Browne, Captain Cowan and Dr. ffrench O'Carroll at the time.
Comment on this
I will deal with this in as effective a way as possible. There seems to be an opinion on the Government side of the House and amongst Government supporters throughout the country that this is a sore point with us.
Comment on this
——of the commitments which had been entered into by the Coalition before they went out of office. Just to refresh his memory, may I quote some of these? The Coalition left a lot of unpaid and unhonoured commitments. There was an increase in pay to the teachers.
Comment on this
I am not Jimmy Henry. The increase in pay to the teachers, the Gardaí, the Army and the civil servants came to £3,500,000. These increases arose out of the findings of an arbitration appointed by the Coalition. The arbitrator was appointed in April, 1950, and he reported in May, 1951. It was understood that the findings would apply as far as practicable to every class of public servant. To meet the award in 1951 would cost about £3,600,000. The Coalition knew these increases were coming, but they provided no money to meet them.
Comment on this
But Fianna Fáil said they would honour the award, whatever it was, prior to the election.
Comment on this
The Minister for Social Welfare misunderstands me. I am not talking about the retrospective payment. I am talking of the failure of the Coalition to make provision for these actual increases totalling £3,500,000. It was they who were mainly responsible for the deficit in the Budget of 1951. Secondly, there was an interest payment of £477,000 in respect of C.I.E. There was an operating loss of £823,000. The total there was £1,300,000. C.I.E. was bought out by the Transport Act passed in 1951 by the Coalition. They knew the undertaking was bankrupt at that time because of their hostile policy adopted in 1948 and 1949. They knew it was bound to lose money heavily in 1951 and they made no provision whatever to cover those losses, losses which, in fact, amounted to £2,250,000 in 1951-1952. Thirdly, there was a small item of £3,000,000 in relation to increases in the cost of social welfare services, including increases in old age pensions and in benefits under the new Social Welfare Act.
Comment on this
The Coalition introduced a Social Welfare Bill in 1951 and, under pressure, they agreed to grant an increase in old age pensions on the Committee Stage. Instead of fulfilling this commitment, which would have cost over £1,000,000, they provided no money whatever for it in their Budget. They decided instead to abandon the Bill altogether. They dissolved the Dáil and then Fianna Fáil had to come along and provide the full amount, which totalled £3,000,000.
Fourthly, there was an increase in grants to health authorities. All this bears on the reason why Fianna Fáil could not implement its 17 point programme. They made certain specific statements and certain specific promises before they returned to office after the first Coalition. I am showing now why they were not able to honour those specific promises because of the commitments and the unhonoured obligations left behind by the Coalition.
Comment on this
The increase in grants to health authorities came to £1,190,000. At the instance of the Coalition, local health authorities granted substantial increases in pay to their employees while the general election of that year was on. The whole cost of those increases had to be met out of State funds. The Coalition made no provision whatever for this and the supplementary sum of £835,000 had to be provided and the actual amount then, in 1952, was £1,160,000. Other items in that service brought the total increase to £1,190,000. Then the fifth item which the Coalition did not make provision for—the increase in interest and sinking funds for public debt, including interest on the Marshall Aid Loan, approximately £1,100,000 per year in 1952, and a half year's interest to be paid that year. That came to £2,080,000. Totalling all those five items up they come to a grand total of £11,070,000—all this huge amount of money, unprovided for by the Coalition, which Fianna Fáil had to make provision for.
The total amount borrowed from the United States under the Marshall Plan was 128,000,000 dollars, and Deputy O'Higgins made reference to that. No one on any side of the House as far as I can read back opposed that. Where we differed with the Coalition was on the method of spending. Most of it was spent on wheat and coarse grain, tobacco and petrol, paper and motor cars. Although the loan was supposed to be raised for capital development purposes, only a small fragment of it was spent on machinery. The serious part of all this is that this loan which has now to be repaid must be repaid in dollars and the interest on it must be repaid in dollars also.
Comment on this
I am not quoting at all. I am reading extracts from some figures I have here myself—is that all right?
Comment on this
Did Deputy Derrig hear the Minister say that we have a surplus in our dollar payments fund for the first time ever this year?
Comment on this
On the cover of my notebook I have a picture of the Minister for Agriculture looking through the wrong end of a telescope and saying: "I tell you the price of maize will not rise by one farthing in the foreseeable future" and behind that there are two men and one of them is saying to the other: "Who does he think he is codding?"
Comment on this
Now that the Deputy has quoted, perhaps he would give us the source of his quotation.
Comment on this
No source. I will put that away. I will not read that any more if there is objection.
When the Coalition was formed in June—to get back to more relevant matters—they had ample opportunity of taking off immediately the tax on beer, stout and cigarettes. It has been said by very many speakers on the other side of the House: "What can we expect after only about ten months in office?" As a matter of fact the Minister for Finance qualified this further when—I had better give the quotation—speaking on the 15th June as reported at Volume 146, column 95, he said:—
"We inherited a situation which it was too late to change. Two months of the financial year had gone and obviously the year would be far advanced before the Ministers had an opportunity of making a thorough study of the problems facing them in their respective spheres of administration. By then it would be too late for different financial proposals to have a real operative effect in this financial year...."
Yet, when they reassumed office in 1948, on the 18th February of that year, they found no difficulty at all in reducing the taxes on beer, whiskey and cigarettes. However, ten months have elapsed now and in this Budget there is no indication whether these taxes will be remitted even in the lifetime of the Government.
I thought there was one very pertinent remark made by the Tánaiste, Deputy Norton, when the Minister for Finance read his Budget speech. Deputy MacEntee replied briefly and then the Tánaiste intervened and said: "You had that speech prepared." I think that is most revealing, because how could Deputy MacEntee know what was contained in the Budget? Deputy MacEntee was writing on several sheets of foolscap long before Question Time was over or before the Minister rose and commenced to read his Budget statement. The remark is a most interesting one which should be looked into very carefully. Does it show that Deputy MacEntee was convinced that the Minister for Finance had at last been converted to the view that the economy and well-being of the country as a whole was far more important than the pressure and vote-catching tactics of certain other individuals, and possibly Parties, who may have tried to get at him on that occasion? However, as I say, I refer to it only as a matter for the consideration of the House and because it is most interesting, in my opinion.
Comment on this
The interjection of the Tánaiste. I come now to the Budget itself. At the outset, the Minister made the most interesting statement that receipts from abroad virtually balanced external payments. It is a pity the Coalition did not worry about the deficit in the balance of payments when they left office in 1951. It bears back again to one of the reasons why it became necessary for us to reimpose the so-called savage taxes. In 1951, when the Coalition Government left office, the balance of payments showed a deficit of £7,500,000. The deficit under what you might term a 1954 Fianna Fáil Budget was brought down to negotiable proportions—£5,500,000. As the Minister said, the receipts from abroad virtually balanced these external payments. He continued by expressing the hope that our exporters, with the assistance of Córas Tráchtála, would increase their business. Yet no concession has been given.
In my view, that is one of the most unfortunate features of this Budget. I am not dealing now with the increase for the old age pensioners, the blind and the widows and orphans. I welcome these increases, such as they are. I am dealing now with a certain matter of Government policy which affects everybody in this House. It is all right for a Minister to speak at a public dinner or to open a factory and to express the sentiment that it is only by increased productivity that we can improve the standard of living in our country. There is no incentive whatsoever to industrialists in this Budget such as some tax concession. I am not speaking specifically now about the wear and tear allowance. I have in mind some tax concession for those who might be engaged in industry in the export line. I do not see any concession given—and the facilities of Córas Tráchtála are there and the co-operation of Córas Tráchtála is there.
Where is there any remission in tax by the Government to exporters? I say that such a remission could be given. The Minister may say it would be a complicated issue to differentiate between the proportion manufactured by the concerns for home consumption and the proportion manufactured by the same concerns for export. There is the hope that this body which is examining industrial profits, and so forth——
Comment on this
All Governments are agreed that in this country it is necessary to bring down as much as possible the cost of commodities for export in order that we may become competitive in the export market. I am suggesting that, in order to encourage exports, the Minister should give such a concern a reduction in taxation, or some such thing.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want us to sell dearer to our own people and cheaper to people abroad?
Comment on this
No. I have in mind a tax concession such as an income-tax concession for people manufacturing goods for export. I have in mind something that will encourage export. I am not suggesting a dual price.
A short time ago the Minister for Industry and Commerce made the very important statement that foreign capital would be welcome here. As far as I know, that statement could have very far-reaching results because he did not qualify it at any time and explain what exactly he meant. There are people in the country—chiefly industrialists—who looked with interest to the Minister's speech to see if, in fact, any reference was made to this matter —to see whether the Minister had in mind a change in the Control of Manufactures Act. It is all very well to stand up at public functions and in this House and preach the old gospel of increased productivity, without planning accordingly. There are too many of those clichés to the effect that "steps are being taken", "my Department is making an examination of the whole position", "we hope in the near future", and that "such and such a body are reporting to us and we expect to have their report in due course, when it will receive active consideration".
Comment on this
Here is a typical quotation from the Minister's Budget statement:—
"We shall have to export more if we are to keep a reasonable balance in our external payments."
As reported at column 1215 of Volume 138 of the Official Dáil Report, the present Attorney-General—Deputy McGilligan, as he was then—speaking on the 1953 Fianna Fáil Budget, asked: "How are we to achieve stability if no relief is afforded?" Is the Attorney-General suggesting that some relief has been afforded to the industrialists on this occasion? Those were his words after the 1953 Budget. After Deputy MacEntee had expressed himself on the desirability of increased productivity, Deputy McGilligan asked: "How are we to achieve stability if no relief is afforded?" I now ask: how are we to achieve increased productivity if no incentives or reliefs are being given to those people?
I should like to quote a statement made after the 1953 Budget by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Norton, as reported at column 1221 of the Official Report, Volume 138. Here is what he had to say:—
"Does the Minister live in the clouds?"
—he was referring to Deputy MacEntee—
"Does the Minister live in the clouds? Is the Minister a citizen of cuckoo land, or is the Minister's passion for the main road such that he does not know what is happening in the small towns, villages, and rural areas throughout the country?"
The same thing could be said to-day, but the Tánaiste has not yet seen the wisdom of making a statement. Then, further on, the Tánaiste continued, at column 1226 of the Official Report:—
"It is a weary, dreary, uninspiring Budget. It is a Budget which takes no cognisance of the existing needs of the nation, of the need for a bold, forward, courageous policy of economic development and of wise spending in all fields of national endeavour."
Comment on this
The Tánaiste continued:—
"The best thing that could be done with this Budget would be for the Taoiseach to take it to the President and ask for a dissolution of the Dáil."
Later on the Tánaiste said:—
"If the Taoiseach would only take that course, I venture to say that in about three weeks' time he would be a wiser and a more realistic man, as he would then know the feelings of the country; he would clearly and unmistakably, by the vote given in the election, know that this is not the Budget that this nation wants, that they want a Budget which will hold out, as this does not, some relief for the 100,000 unemployed, some relief from the present level of high prices and some stopping of the haemorrhage on our manhood and womanhood by the exodus of our people to Britain."
Comment on this
We got our verdict which was a vote on the cost of living and which was decided mostly here in Dublin. The people here were led to believe that if the Coalition got in, prices of essential commodities would fall. They are disillusioned now. If there was an election in Dublin in the morning, God forbid——
Comment on this
And you would not have the Lord Mayor running up and down Cabra with a loaf on a stick.