We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 159–317 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I did not hear him at first. I am very glad to see him restored to health and to notice that he has not lost any of his capacity for interruption. At column 681 of Volume 150 of the Official Report, the Minister for Finance, in his Budget statement, said:—

"The fall in imports in 1954 is explained mainly by increased home production which lessened our dependence on certain foreign products. There were decreases in wheat, maize and sugar. Wheat imports fell because stocks were drawn down and because home supplies were greater. Increased domestic production of feeding stuffs accounted for our smaller purchases of maize."

That is a factual statement, but certainly it is not in accordance with——

Comment on this

Facts?

Comment on this

It is the Minister for Finance who said this. I am not referring to the 1953 Budget.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It left you over there.

Comment on this

The statement I have just quoted is a complete vindication of the Fianna Fáil policy.

Comment on this

Of the policy of "Thank God the British market is gone".

Comment on this

While speaking in this manner about the fall in imports in 1954, and while giving the reasons why there was such a fall, the Minister refers specifically to wheat, maize and sugar, but what the position will be as a result of the present Government's policy on wheat if the present Minister, I should say the present Government, is there to bring in another Budget in 1956——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I would not worry too much about that.

Comment on this

Or about 1957 or 1958.

Comment on this

Ní mar síltear bitear. The Minister then went on to say, at column 682:—

"There was some falling off in local authority housing, but this was largely counterbalanced by a rise in private building. The indications are that physical capital formation was about the same as in 1953."

May I be permitted to quote from the Limerick Chronicle of the 15th March of this year? We shall see from it if there was any falling off in local authority building which was counterbalanced by private building. Here is the extract from the Limerick Chronicle, which is a paper not altogether in love with Fianna Fáil at times. It says:—

"Because of the falling off of various building schemes in Limerick there has been an alarming exodus of skilled tradesmen from Limerick. During the first week of this month 11 carpenters left the city bringing the total since December last to 51. Time and again we have had warning of a slump in the numbers employed in the building trades, and so serious has the situation become now that a special committee has been set up by the Mayor with representatives of the various trade union branches involved, to try and seek a solution. Many of those unemployed have left for England, where they are assured of continuous employment but they are a loss to the city and the country and, undoubtedly, would not contemplate leaving if they had any assurance of consistent employment here. Then it naturally follows that if there is no work for skilled tradesmen the unskilled labourer is equally affected."

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What did you do with the interest rates under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts?

Comment on this

I shall come to that in a few moments. Before the Minister makes his departure in the manner of the skilled workers of Limerick I should like to make one point in connection with income-tax. I should like to give particular consideration to this point. The allowance for children has been increased from £85 to £100 for each child. Under Section 21 of the Finance Act of 1920——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

1920?

Comment on this

Under the Finance Act of 1920, sub-section (21), paragraph 3, there was no deduction of allowances granted in respect of any child who was entitled in his own right to an income exceeding £40. The income-tax allowance for a child has been increased from £36 to £100 but no increase has been made in the income which a child can have in his own right without affecting the reliefs granted to the parents. I should like to give a specific case. Various Ministers for Finance have advocated investments in National Loans and some parents have put hundreds of pounds into these loans on behalf of their children. I know of a specific case where a child had £20 a year coming in and the father invested in the National Loan on its behalf a sum which brought the income over £40. As a result, he cannot claim the allowance for the child. Something should be done about that. He has carried out the wishes of the Minister for Finance and the various Ministers before him, but he is losing money on the transaction.

I will give another specific case. A widower has one child with an income in his own right of £49 per annum. As the income is in excess of £40 the father cannot get the child allowance against his income-tax. Assuming he is paying at the rate of 7/6, such allowance would reduce his income-tax payable for 1955-56 by £37 10s. If the child had not an income in excess of £40 the parent would be entitled to a housekeeper's allowance, which is £100, and that would reduce his income-tax liability by a further £37 10s.

I am informed that Section 19 of the 1920 Finance Act states as regards a housekeeper allowance that "child" means "a child in respect of whom a deduction is allowed under this part of the Act." The taxpayer in question is affected both ways. Because the income of the child is over £40 he loses the child allowance and, according to the Act, he will also lose the housekeeper's allowance. I would ask the Minister to consider that point.

There was a concession given in the Budget. Any concessions are welcome. The hope was expressed by the Minister that the dairying counties would welcome the decrease in the tax on tractors from £31 10s. to £8. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, Deputy O'Sullivan, can tell the Minister that, while it might be an inducement, not one out of 400 going to a creamery uses a tractor.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is not the case in my area.

Comment on this

I am speaking for East Limerick. Deputy Carew can say the same. Possibly the idea of the Minister was to encourage mechanisation. On the other hand, are we exporting horses and buying imported oil and is this in fact such an attraction? I understand that the Minister specifically stated that this applied to tractors used for the carriage of milk solely. I was approached by farmers as, I am sure, all Deputies are approached by farmers from time to time, who asked me could they bring home anything from the creamery or the local store or take anything to the creamery or into the village or town other than milk or would one of these vigilant young Gardaí have them up under the appropriate section of the Road Traffic Act?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean his own goods or goods of somebody else that he is carrying for reward?

Comment on this

Is he entitled to carry his own goods and to sell them?

Comment on this

I just wanted to get it clear.

Comment on this

I do not know what the implications would be or what the financial cost would be, but every Party is agreed that agriculture is the backbone of the economy and it would be a great incentive and inducement to further mechanisation of agriculture if it were possible to do away with the road tax or to reduce the road tax for tractors everywhere. It would be a good thing to consider the point. The cost involved might be a fantastic figure. I have no idea. The position is not satisfactory.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Remember, it was your 1952 Budget that belted all this tax on to the farmer, that copper-fastened them.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the dairy farmer. If the Deputy has a longer memory than I have, he will remember and he will know exactly where the dairy farmer would be to-day if the policy of the present Minister for Agriculture had been followed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Do you remember the half-crown for the calf?

Comment on this

That was long before my time.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Collins should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The Minister dealt in his Budget statement with overestimation. As I have remarked, his speech was simple; it was easy to read but often when these things are very easy to read one could gloss over certain facts. At column 700 of the Financial Statement the Minister said:—

"In 1953-54 overestimation was £3.6 million and last year... £3.5 million. In the light of the close scrutiny I have mentioned, I do not think I can safely put it higher than £3,000,000 this year."

The Minister had previously stated:—

"The tendency, when framing Estimates of this kind, is to set the target of achievement as high as possible. Such optimism is, perhaps, natural but it needs to be moderated by realism if Estimates are not to promise achievements beyond what experience shows to be practicable. In making forecasts for the current year I have acted on this principle and, I hope, brought the Estimates into closer accord with the probable outcome."

Comment on this

Of course, the Minister was talking of two different sorts of Estimates. You know that? One was in relation to the capital Budget, the other was in relation to the current Budget.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that all these Estimates have been gone through with a fine comb, what does the Minister mean by saying: "By comparison with the actual figures"? If I am talking about two different things, I will drop the matter. He said:—

"By comparison with the actual figures for last year, the estimate of revenue shows an increase of £3.9 million, although last year's reliefs are costing £600,000 more this year."

He said at a later stage:—

"Unhappily, unlike my predecessor, who, last year, could draw on C.I.E. for ‘£1,000,000 or so', I can invoke no similar fairy godmother to solve my problem."

Have not three fairy godmothers appeared on the horizon in increased revenue or has not the buoyancy of the expected revenue increased by some £3,000,000? If that is not a fairy god-mother——

Comment on this

I never heard that fairy godmothers arrive as a result of hard work. That buoyancy of revenue arises as a result of the hard work of this Government.

Comment on this

I am no financial wizard. I have no intricate knowledge of these things. How the Minister can make that statement, I cannot see. The point I want to get from the Minister is, if all these Estimates have been gone through with a fine comb, how does he reconcile the fact that even then he has made a provision of £3,000,000 for overestimation. I cannot quite understand that.

We heard a great deal of talk about interest rates and external assets from the various platforms during the last election—all these high-sounding phrases such as "the repatriation of external assets"—but the Minister has made only very slight reference to this matter. The Taoiseach is reported in the Irish Times on 26th April, 1954, as saying at Letterkenny:—

"The repatriation of external assets could safely proceed to a very much further point than had been reached up to the present."

I do not know what the Minister has to say on that point, but I suggest that there is a complete divergence of views between the Attorney-General, Deputy McGilligan, and the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Finance stated in his Budget speech that it was not by an increase in wages that the cost-of-living problem would be solved. He said, at column 683 of the Official Debates of 4th May, 1954:—

"The cost of living may be affected by the rise in prices of imported materials. We can meet this effectively only by exporting more, which means, in the first place, producing more and doing so more efficiently.... No real or lasting protection is given, in these circumstances, by increases in money incomes alone."

On the other hand, Deputy McGilligan is reported in the Irish Press of 27th April last year as saying:—

"The right policy was to increase wages and salaries and let the people spend the money for themselves on whatever they wished to spend it."

There has definitely been a conflict of views there. Now, the Minister for Agriculture and, indeed, the Tánaiste, Deputy Norton, made great capital on the subject of investment when speaking to what might be classified as the less politically acute section of the community. They had this cant that we have £60,000,000 invested in England that we lent to the British Government at 2 per cent. We know it off by heart. We were reminded of our last loan of 4½ per cent. and the loan before that where Deputy MacEntee paid 5 per cent. and the question was asked: Why do we not bring back these assets from Britain? That is what the Tánaiste and the Minister for Agriculture said.

Comment on this

And the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

I have no quotation from the Minister for Defence, but I am surprised that the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement did not put an end to these misleading statements which are causing utter confusion and, indeed, they got quite a lot of votes for the Coalition. The Minister for Agriculture said in Sligo, as quoted in the Sligo Independent of the 15th May, 1954:—

"It seemed to me quite ridiculous that they should charge their own people at home 6½ per cent. on loans to build houses for themselves when they were lending over £60,000,000 to Britain to build houses at 2 per cent."

Where is the £60,000,000 gone since this time last year at 2 per cent.? It has been suggested by the Minister for Agriculture, the Tánaiste and evidently the Minister for Defence in various parts of the country that we are so tied up with Britain and the sterling bloc that we cannot turn around and do anything about it. The Minister could have made reference to that.

Comment on this

The Minister would not be so foolish as to refer to 2 per cent. interest in Britain at present when the bank rate is 4½ per cent.

Comment on this

It is, in fact, an admission of the foolish statements made by the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

Not at all. At that time the bank rate in England was very different.

Comment on this

The bank rate was not so low as to justify a statement that £60,000,000 of this country's money was invested at 2 per cent. There was not that much of a change.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know what the bank rate was?

Comment on this

The bank rate was not as low as that. As I said, I am not very conversant with those things.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan was.

Comment on this

The Minister made a reference to the bank rate and it was suggested by Deputy O'Higgins here earlier to-day that it was due to the influence of the Coalition Government that the bank rate was as it was. The Minister was very careful in explaining that. He used the words that the Minister "made representations" to the banks, which is a very different thing from what Deputy O'Higgins suggested and what no doubt will be suggested at a future date to the electorate of this country—that it was as a result of the action of the Government that the bank rate is as it is.

Comment on this

Surely it is a good thing that it is as it is.

Comment on this

It is, thank God. At column 684 of the Official Debates of the 4th May, 1955, the Minister said that, due to the reduction in the rate of interest, the E.S.B. have effected a reduction in the rate of borrowing, and due to excessive rain the E.S.B. has saved coal and made a profit and as a result the board was able to defer some of its financial demands on the Exchequer. At column 688 he said:—

"The provision for advances to the E.S.B. has been reduced to £4,000,000 in view of the power to borrow from sources other than the Exchequer which the board possesses under recent legislation."

If the E.S.B. has saved so much money and if the rate of interest is going to be more attractive, the Minister has not indicated whether the consumer is to obtain any relief in the E.S.B. charges. A quotation was read out wherein the Minister for Defence is alleged to have promised that in future rates would not increase.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The statement was made but no quotation was read.

Comment on this

Then I will read it. The Minister for Defence was reported in the Sligo Champion of 20th March, 1954, as saying:—

"Fine Gael, if returned to office, would take steps to see to it that the Central Fund would take responsibility for all future expenditure and the existing expenditure at present being met by the local authorities."

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is a different statement from the one the Deputy was whistling about a moment ago.

Comment on this

What is different about it?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Read it again and it might sink in.

Comment on this

It suggests there would be no more increases in rates throughout the country and, if such increases were necessary, the Central Fund would provide them.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

But that is not what the quotation said. Read it again.

Comment on this

I do not want to tie the Minister for Defence to that because he has already said he never said it—I think in answer to a question here. Anyone who is a member of a local authority must be appalled at the amount of money which has to be paid by way of interest for moneys borrowed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Go back to 1952 and the Deputy will find that the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, had a fine skelp at the rates of interest that local authorities have to pay.

Comment on this

I was not in the House in 1952.

Comment on this

Maybe if the Deputy had been here he would have been able to influence him.

Comment on this

If I had been here I would have brought this injustice to the notice of the appropriate Minister. All I am doing now is taking the first opportunity that offers. It is intimated to a local authority that the Minister will allocate a certain grant. In due course they get a letter in January or February notifying them of that fact. They accordingly make provision and certain works are put in hands. They approach the bank to raise a loan. A resolution is proposed by Alderman So-and-So and seconded by Councillor Such-and-Such. That is that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That seems to me to be administration.

Comment on this

It is very bad administration.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be. I am not suggesting it is either good or bad, but I do suggest it is administration and it is, therefore, not relevant. We are dealing with the imposition of taxation or the collection of taxation.

Comment on this

With respect, I suggest that the Minister in his Budget specifically referred to the alleviation of distress and to taxation which bears heavily on the shoulders of the taxpayer. I suggest that some part of the National Development Fund should be earmarked so that local authorities would immediately get the funds they require to implement various schemes. In that way there would not be this appalling imposition of rates and the banks drawing interest for doing nothing.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It still seems to me to be administration, whether it is good or bad.

Comment on this

It would be very interesting to know how the National Development Fund could be so administered as not to require any interest.

Comment on this

Surely there could be some fund. I merely put that forward for the consideration of the Minister. Deputy Kyne, speaking about the increase in the old age and widows' and orphans' pensions, said that half a loaf is better than no bread. Everyone welcomes the increase.

Comment on this

Except Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I said everyone welcomes the increase.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Deputy Carter said it was a mangy sum.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The Minister suggested that any alleviations should be given to that section of the community which suffered most. I think he should have included in that category those in receipt of the disability allowance of £1 per week under the Health Act. I would ask the Minister to consider that.

There is another point in connection with allowances for rents. The old age pensioners, the blind and the widows, particularly those living alone, should receive some allowance for rent. There are three housing schemes in Limerick; in one case a widow living alone is paying a rent of 3/6; in another case, it is 8/6 and in the third case it is 11/-. I am sure a similar position obtains in other local authority housing schemes. The only answer I could get from the Limerick Corporation was that that was the amount decided by the local authority and nothing could be done about it. If the Minister would make some Order so that there would be a uniform rent of, say, 2/6, it would be some alleviation. Even 2/6 would be too much. These widows are getting only 24/- per week. Why not have a flat rate for rents? That could have been done under the present Budget for the entire country.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

How could the Budget deal with differential rents under local authorities?

Comment on this

I said a flat rate. I am bringing the matter to the attention of the Minister. It is only by asking questions that one gets information.

Comment on this

Fair enough, but I think it would be more appropriate for the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

These are minimum rents in three different schemes in Limerick. The Minister gave a concession to the small brewers. He said:—

"Nevertheless, I feel it incumbent on me to make a contribution towards preserving the small breweries and the employment they give locally."

There is one firm here in Dublin which certainly could not be classified as a small brewery. I am sorry that places like Drogheda and Kilkenny could not benefit more because they, in fact, coincide with what the Minister had in mind, and would have benefited more, because this concession is only a drop in the ocean to very large firms. People in the public gallery nearly died of heart failure when the Minister gave no concessions in regard to whiskey.

Comment on this

Who nearly died?

Comment on this

Mr. Reddin and Mr. Hedigan. They were appalled because they would have bet any money that concessions would be given. Indeed, from the speeches of the Taoiseach in the past, they had every ground for believing that such concessions would be given to them by the Government and the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Go back to Deputy MacEntee's speech in Rathmines Town Hall.

Comment on this

I have that here, too. On 7th May, 1954, as quoted in the Irish Independent, the Taoiseach is reported as saying:—

"I may not be a mathematician but I am able to add up and I now challenge the Taoiseach to deny that the meaning of the fresh figures he has disclosed is that in each of the two years 1952 and 1953 the Government got an average of £50,000 a year less duty from the higher rate than we got when whiskey was 5½d. a glass cheaper in 1951 and 1952," said Mr. J.A. Costello at Wexford and Enniscorthy last night.

"In 1953 and 1954 the Government," said Mr. Costello, "only recovered £500,000 of the £600,000 they lost in 1952 and 1953. What good did that extra tax do? The Government got less revenue; the prices went up savagely to the consumer; the consumption dropped over these two years by 80,000,000 half-ones; the incomes of the publicans and distillers dropped and accordingly the income-tax they pay, fell; people in public-houses and distilleries lost their jobs and it has been calculated that the farmers got £150,000 to £200,000 less for their barley."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the extract from?

Comment on this

That is from the Irish Independent of 7th May, 1954. It was only natural that the licensed grocers and vintners should have been convinced that some concessions were forthcoming. It is not for me to say what the outcome of this is, but the Government certainly got a lot of votes —particularly for Fine Gael—on the last occasion, especially here in Dublin. I do not know what will happen the next time.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You need not worry. Is fada uainn an lá sin.

Comment on this

A lot of play has been made of the butter subsidy, bringing down the price of butter by 5d. per lb. That, of course, is due to the Labour Party solely and everyone knows that on the Sunday before the Government was formed, the Opposition, particularly the Minister for Agriculture, complained very bitterly in the Catholic Commercial Club about the condition on which the Labour Party would take part in the Government. Now Fine Gael speakers are suggesting that it had their full blessing.

Comment on this

It had our blessing.

Comment on this

They granted the concession under duress. As a matter of fact, a reduction of 5d. per lb. was given but, on the 8th May, 1954, before the election, the Minister for Social Welfare went so far as to suggest that the price be brought back to 2/10. According to the Wexford People of that date, he said:

"Would they prefer butter at 4/2 per lb. under Fianna Fáil to butter at 2/10 a lb. under the inter-Party Government?"

Comment on this

A lot of Fianna Fáil supporters are eating that cheap butter now.

Comment on this

Is there still a lot of Fianna Fáil supporters?

Comment on this

I am sorry that something more has not been done for the disabled persons and I hope that the Minister will see his way to do something for them because they got nothing. After all, the half-crown is barely bringing the old age pensioners, the blind and the widows up to their previous level—compensating them in accordance with the increase in the cost of living. The cost of living has increased two points and nothing has been given to this category. I only hope that something better can be done for them in the near future.

I cannot understand why, if a pension is given to an old person, a blind person or a widow, these people cannot come into the same category as regards the cost of living as workers who can claim, as is their due, for an increase in wages before the Labour Court if the cost of living goes up. Why should it not be so? Is there any reason? The cost of living could go up an appreciable amount and yet by the time any Government got around to dealing with them they might suffer very grievously.

There is another matter I want to deal with. Deputy Collins, of course, must be disappointed that the means test was not done away with as promised by him.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Very disappointed— but it will come. I talk for myself when I get the change and I do not think I promised it. I think I said I believed in its abolition.

Comment on this

There were some interesting reactions to the Budget in various sections of the Press. I am reading now from one or two extracts from papers which have not been noted for their friendly attitude to the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

You have a paper of your own.

Comment on this

I do not quote from the Irish Press; the Deputy might suggest it was a bit biassed. I quote now from the Limerick Chronicle of 2nd April, 1955, before the Budget:—

"The estimate shows that the former Minister for Finance——"

——that is, Deputy MacEntee——

"——when compiling last year's Budget, was not very far out in his assumptions both for revenue and expenditure. The new Government promised all kinds of reductions in this service and that but it is now quite apparent that it was unable to control the upward trend and that we will have the dismal position that, in one way or another, the Minister for Finance will have to devise means of getting in another £2,000,000. It would seem that, at this stage of modern progress, it is very dangerous for any Party to promise reductions in expenditure."

The Limerick Weekly Echo of the 2nd May had a leading article——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy relate those extracts to the motion before the House?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley has done nothing but read cuttings from papers since he started.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely we will not have read in this House opinions expressed in every newspaper in the country? That would be just as relevant as opinions expressed in Limerick papers, important and all as they may be.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

This is all necessary for reproduction in the local Limerick paper.

Comment on this

The only chance I have of having my speech printed in the local Limerick paper is when the speech is short. I have not much chance to-day.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is honest, anyway.

Comment on this

I have here a most interesting statement—and I respectfully submit that it is most relevant to the issue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the opinion of every paper in the country is just as relevant as the opinion expressed in the paper from which the Deputy is reading?

Comment on this

I propose to quote from a report of a speech made by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton. The speech was made by him at the Labour Party Conference in the Municipal Technical Institute, Limerick, on the 30th April last — a few days prior to the Budget. He is reported as saying:—

"The sneers of political quacks, well versed in the art of misrepresentation, will not prevent us from going ahead with our programme aimed at reducing prices."

The report continues:

"The Minister, in a trenchant attack on the Fianna Fáil Party, claimed——"

——and this is where the interesting lines occur——

"——that only for the participation of the Irish Labour Party in the inter-Party Government there would have been considerable increases in the cost of essential foodstuffs".

Is that not a lovely thing to say about Fine Gael?

Comment on this

That is if Fianna Fáil had been in power. There would then have been increases.

Comment on this

I cannot hear the Deputy. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is now suggesting that only for the participation of the Irish Labour Party in the inter-Party Government there would have been considerable increases in the cost of essential foodstuffs. That is very interesting. I must keep that cutting. The observation of the man in the street, Mr. Average Man, has been quoted here from every side of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how the opinions expressed in papers throughout the country are relevant to this debate unless they express the opinion of some member of this House or unless they are an extract from a statement by some Deputy or Minister.

Comment on this

What I have just read out was a report of a speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in Limerick about a fortnight ago.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That could be carried on indefinitely. I cannot see how that has any relevance whatsoever to the motion which is before the House.

Comment on this

With respect, nearly every speaker on the Government Benches referred to this Mr. Average Man.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Derrig and Deputy O'Malley want to give quotations from the Limerick papers here then opinions contained in whatever number of papers there are in the country are equally entitled to be quoted.

Comment on this

That being so, I will leave these quotations aside. The only other matter I wish to refer to is a speech made here by my colleague from Limerick, Deputy Carew. I want to refer to some of the statements contained in that speech. I may say, first of all, that I hope this speech which was made by Deputy Carew will be reported in full in the Limerick papers. Certainly, I will send a copy of this Official Dáil Report to the local papers.

Comment on this

Are your own speeches not reported too?

Comment on this

I always submit my own for consideration.

Comment on this

Do the papers consider them?

Comment on this

Usually. At column 916 of the Official Report of the 5th May, 1955, Deputy Carew is reported as saying:—

"I will refer to another leaflet which went around during my election campaign in 1952. I issued a leaflet showing, truthfully, the prices obtaining when Fianna Fáil left office, when the inter-Party Government left office, and when the Fianna Fáil Party were 18 months in office. What followed on the morning after the declaration of the poll in Limerick? About 60 workers in the C.I.E. depot, whose notices were withheld a week previous to the election, received those notices. That was what Fianna Fáil did for the workers in that depot at Limerick. They withheld the notices, and obtained their votes. I say that was dishonest. The electors of Limerick sent me here to serve their interests. That I have done, to the best of my ability, all these years."

"these years"—he was referring to 1952: this is 1955. Then, when he had completed his speech he withdrew it. Is that no so? Did he not withdraw it as being incorrect?

Comment on this

Is it in the Official Report?

Comment on this

At column 921, Deputy Briscoe said:—

"I hope Deputy Carew will withdraw that mean imputation against Fianna Fáil——"

——that is the imputation about the sacking of the workers the day after the poll was declared.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe is my Guardian Angel. They were sacked.

Comment on this

They were let go shortly afterwards. Has the Deputy not withdrawn the allegation unreservedly?

Comment on this

I have withdrawn that Fianna Fáil did it but I have not withdrawn that the workers were let go——

Comment on this

So long as the Deputy withdraws the allegation that Fianna Fáil did it, that is acceptable.

Comment on this

——and would not have been let go under an inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

That is most interesting. They would not have been allowed to go under an inter-Party Government. Is the Deputy not aware that, as recently as five months ago, the proposal for a steam locomotive repair factory for Limerick was quashed by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce? Is that not true?

Comment on this

It was——

Comment on this

You admit it?

Comment on this

——not by the Tánaiste, but by the Board of C.I.E.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow matters of this kind to be dragged into this debate. I cannot allow the problem of any group of workers in any particular job or office to be discussed. Deputies may refer to unemployment in general and to the effect on employment of taxation, but they may not drag in particular jobs and particular types of employment.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Chair, I want to deal with the action of the present Government and of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton, in not allowing the steam locomotive depot to be established in Limerick City. Deputy Carew interjected to say that it was not the Government who had stopped it but the Board of C.I.E.

Comment on this

Surely that has more relevance in the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce than to this debate?

Comment on this

The Deputy was asked to attend at an interview with the C.I.E. Board, but he failed to turn up.

Comment on this

As this allegation has been made against me, I wish to be given an opportunity to reply.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow this discussion to proceed between the Limerick Deputies; I cannot allow discussions on administration of particular jobs. The Deputy may refer in general to the effect of the taxation in the Budget on employment or of the alleged effect of taxation on employment, but he may not discuss the administration of a particular industry or of a particular firm.

Comment on this

May I be given an opportunity of replying to the allegation made against me by Deputy Carew?

Comment on this

During my speech on this Budget I did not refer to Deputy O'Malley, yet he comes in here now and makes this attack on me.

Comment on this

I am not making a personal attack on the Deputy.

Comment on this

What else are you doing? I am not a hotel porter.

Comment on this

I am not making any personal attack on Deputy Carew but I should like to clear up one point. It was suggested by Deputy Carew that I failed to turn up as a member of a deputation to interview the Chairman of the C.I.E. Board to which I had been invited. That is correct, but my reason for not turning up was that the Board of C.I.E. had definitely decided to establish in Limerick the maintenance repair depot for locomotives and, in answer to a question here in the House, the Minister for Industry and Commerce informed me that, due to representations which had been made to him, he in turn had made representations to the Board of C.I.E. My attitude was that it was not to the Chairman of C.I.E. the deputation should have gone in order to avoid the loss of this industry but to the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That closes the incident.

Comment on this

There was just one other point to which I want to refer. Deputies referred several times during the debate to the subsidies and I should like to draw attention to a statement made by the Tánaiste on the food subsidies when it was proposed in 1947 to put extra taxation on beer and cigarettes.

Comment on this

The Deputy was a small boy then.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste said at that time—I want to bring out his attitude at that time:—

"I think these are sham reductions. I do not think they make any perceptible contribution to relieving the plight of the ordinary working people to-day and they make a less perceptible contribution in the circumstances in which they are offered. I took the trouble of trying to calculate hastily what the reductions in the prices of tea, bread and sugar mean to a family of six people. That family will, under this emergency Budget, save 1/7½ in the week. If they consume 4 lb. of bread per head per week, they will save bread per head per week, they will save 1/6, and if they consume three quarters of a pound of sugar each per week they will save 9d. At the end of the week this family of six will have saved 3/10½. That is the extent of the saving which this Budget will confer upon them. One would think from these proposals that our people live on bread, tea and sugar and it would seem that this represents the Government's ambition from the point of view of the average person's diet."

Comment on this

He would prefer beer.

Comment on this

These quotations have been taken from the Official Report, Volume 108, columns 435, 436 and 437.

Comment on this

What date?

Comment on this

About October, 1947.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Reference to the volume will give you that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy has given a fair volume of quotations.

Comment on this

I could give a good many more which I respectfully consider are relevant to the debate, but I bow to the ruling of the Ceann Comhairle and conclude.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the attitude of Fianna Fáil here in the House saying that this Budget is a bad Budget and that it is an unpopular Budget. I have been around the country quite a lot and I have also been around this city quite a lot since the Budget was introduced. Naturally there is a big difference between Dublin and the rural areas; there is the difference in out look. At the same time the many people I have come in contact with have told me they were quite satisfied that this Budget was a good one. They appreciated, it seems, the many difficulties with which this Government was confronted on assuming office. They appreciated that the Minister for Finance is a man of ability and that, in the short time at his disposal — during the short period of his term of office—and having regard to the fact that he is a new Minister for Finance, he has done a good job in such a short time.

The people fully appreciate that the task of the Minister for Finance—any Minister for Finance—is a difficult one. It is a task that requires a good educational standard in many spheres, and the fact that the Minister has so distinguished himself on this occasion and has so gained the confidence of the people is a good omen for the present Government.

The Debate on the Budget has been varied and has ranged over a wide number of topics. One of the matters that were dealt with at length in this House both by the Government and the Opposition was the election promises. It is true that practically all Parties, during an election, engage in making certain promises, and perhaps sometimes the promises are drawn out a little bit too far and are, perhaps, a bit lavish. I do say very seriously that any promising that was done by those on this side of the House certainly would not compare with what Fianna Fáil promised for the past 20 years. They are noted as the Party that excel from the point of view of promises. Having promised, they failed bitterly.

Deputy O'Malley expressed disappointment that the Government is an inter-Party Government, composed of various groups—Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and so on. I do not see anything wrong in a group of Irishmen coming together, in the first instance having gone before the people and having made it clear to the people that, if elected, they would be prepared to form an inter-Party Government, that they would be prepared to continue where the inter-Party Government left off in 1951.

The bulk of the promises, so far as this side of the House is concerned, can be summed up in this way: I was not out in my constituency a lot during the last election campaign but I can truthfully say that the election promises in North Mayo were confined to saying that if we were elected as an inter-Party Government we would take up where we left off in 1951. It is worthy of note that we got a mandate from the people, that we got authority from the people to represent them here and I am confident that we will continue for our full term.

That being so, I think it is very wrong for a Party like Fianna Fáil, who were in office over a long period, to try to divide the groups here. Unfortunately, Irish history is a history of Irishmen divided. That was the case in the old Irish Parliament. That is the case now. If Fianna Fáil cannot set themselves to any better task than that, I suggest they should forget it and realise that there is no hope in the world that they will divide forces on this side of the House. We are happily united on this side of the House. Fine Gael have representation in the Government in the Taoiseach and other Ministers. The same applies to Labour, Clann na Talmhan and every other group within the inter-Party Government. They are all doing everything humanly possible for the betterment of the general body of people. I tell Fianna Fáil very emphatically that they are wasting their time if they think they will divide our forces.

A number of comments were made by Fianna Fáil Deputies that are worthy of note. They want to try to convince the people that what the present Government has achieved in this Budget is not what they promised, that it is in fact no achievement. From what I have heard in the past week, Fianna Fáil have certainly not succeeded in convincing the people along those lines. They cannot deny that the present Government has stabilised the cost of living by increasing the subsidies on butter and tea and keeping tea at its present level. Do Fianna Fáil Deputies appreciate that were it not for the action of the Government in coming to the rescue in the matter of tea prices the price of tea to the consumer would be 10/- or 11/- a lb.? Could the citizens of this State afford 10/- or 11/- a lb. for tea? This country is one of the biggest consumers of tea in the world. That being so, could the present Government allow a situation to arise where tea would cost the ordinary people 10/- or 11/- a lb. without any increases in wages to compensate for that increase in the price of tea, in many instances, without any hope of the Government being able to give increases in wages?

We have not in this House control over private industries or private business concerns throughout the country. We could not compel a shopkeeper or an industrialist in the City of Dublin to increase wages the moment the price of tea increased. He could argue that it would be merely a temporary matter and that he could not afford to increase wages. We could bring no compulsion to bear on that person to grant increases in wages. How would the people afford to buy tea at 10/- or 11/- a lb.? It seems that the action of the Government was justified. There are rumours to the effect that there will be reductions in the price of tea on the world market.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It is actually happening.

Comment on this

It is actually happening. I think that justifies the action of the present Government in stabilising tea to cover what was, I sincerely hope, a temporary increase in the price of tea on the world market.

It was very difficult indeed to drag out of the Fianna Fáil people in this House what their attitude would be with regard to that particular commodity. The Tánaiste, a few days ago, tried to drag it out of Deputy de Valera. Although he put the question repeatedly: "What would you have done?" to the ex-Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, he could not extract an answer. He went on with the usual wriggling and just passed it off.

Comment on this

Like you passed off the wheat.

Comment on this

I want to tell Deputy Derrig that, so far as I am concerned, I am lock, stock and barrel with the present Minister for Agriculture in his attitude towards wheat. I want to tell the Deputy, further, that I am a member of a Farmer's Party in this House and I am with the present Minister for Agriculture. I hope he will put that statement of mine on all the newspapers in the country, because the people in North Mayo whom I represent have wheat growers among them. They are an intelligent people. Traditionally, they have had to go to England to earn their livelihood and to come back but they are the type of people whose forefathers, as Deputy Derrig knows, were evicted in the days of Davitt and the Land League Movement by landlords and landlordism. Their fathers and grandfathers had a trying time. They are an intelligent people. They can tell when they have a good Government. They know well that a certain group of chancers came to this country and tried to cash in on the wheat prices that were being paid by Fianna Fáil. Having regard to the fact that the ordinary taxpayer had to subsidise that price, was not it good policy on the part of the Government to reduce the price of wheat?

Deputies like Deputy Harris can say in this House that £35 and £40 an acre was being paid for conacre. Was not that proof positive to Deputy Derrig or anybody else that the price being paid for wheat in this country was fantastic and that it was time for somebody to call a halt? Whether Deputy Derrig likes it or not, had not his own Government realised and awakened to the fact that there was too much wheat being produced in this country? Had they not made a decision in regard to it, and did not the present Minister for Agriculture quote that decision in the House which is available to Deputy Derrig or any member of his Party? If Deputy Derrig wants to discuss wheat here in Dáil Éireann, down in North Mayo or in any other part of Ireland, I am quite prepared to take him on.

However, we cannot set up special circumstances where we legislate for only one section of the community. When we do try to legislate, and legislate in the best possible way, surely it is not suggested we should legislate in respect of the price for wheat? That is completely out of bounds and would knock the whole of our economy out of balance as has been proved by the figures available through the General Statistics Office and through the Department of Agriculture.

There is also the question of the 5d. a lb. on butter. This has been mentioned so often that I hate to refer to it once more, but why is it that Fianna Fáil want to tell the people that a reduction of 5d. per lb. for butter, which is costing a colossal sum in subsidy, was no benefit to the average citizen? We all know butter is a staple food in any household and being the important commodity it is, I think it was a very necessary step that the Government took in coming to the rescue of those poor people by subsidising butter to bring it within their reach. So far as I am concerned butter is still not low enough in price, but there is a limit to what any Government can do in a short time.

If Fianna Fáil were in office to-day, according to their own declared policy, butter would still be that 5d. a lb. more than it is. When Fianna Fáil were in office had we not the spectacle of thousands of people on what we could describe as hunger marches to the gates of Leinster House? These things have ceased since we became the Government. Has anybody seen a hunger march on this Dáil since we took over office? I certainly have not seen or heard of it. I know of no unrest at the present time among the ordinary workers. It is natural that workers would like to get increases. Everybody would like to get an increase in his salary or in his allowance. However, there is a feeling abroad among all sections of our people that each and every section of the community has representation in this present Government, that the ordinary labouring man has representation here through the Labour group and through the other groups.

The same applies to our own Party as well as other Parties. Each Party within the Government is pulling its weight in the right direction. We have got rid of the undesirables from this side of the House. It was no easy job to convince the people that an inter-Party Government was going to be a success because the last inter-Party Government had quite a lot of difficulty. There were a few undesirables who came into the last inter-Party Government. They caused a lot of trouble and some people felt that it might happen on this occasion as well. Thank God we have got rid of those people now and things are working smoothly.

That is exactly what is worrying those people on the far side of the House, that there is no trouble brewing, that things are working so smoothly and that the present Minister has succeeded in achieving what he has achieved, having regard to the fact that it is his first year in office. If he had been in office for ten years— and I have no doubt he will be there in ten years' time—what he has done in the present year would have been quite an achievement. He has achieved it in ten months. One of the daily papers said that the Minister came into the House in a rather nervous condition on Budget day. I was watching him rather closely and he was no more excited or nervous than he is this evening. The Party opposite would like to give the people the impression that something is terribly wrong and that there is only one group of people that can run this country and that is Fianna Fáil. With God's help we will live to give the lie to that sort of thing.

When you consider that it was possible for the present Minister for Finance to subsidise butter and tea, to pay the award to the civil servants to which the previous Government had committed themselves and all the other things that were done during that time, I think they represent important achievements. The man with an ordinary salary is able to get tax reliefs in regard to income-tax.

Then, again, you have the blind person. Fianna Fáil would like to convince the blind people and others that they have gained nothing at all as a result of the present Government's administration but they will not succeed in doing that either. The blind are one section of the community that have my sympathy at all times and, I feel sure, the sympathy of every citizen. If the Minister is prepared to give special concessions to anybody it is to that section I would like to see him give them. We all talk generously in this House about what we would like to give and no doubt the Minister is just as anxious to give concessions if it could be done, but we have to live within our budget.

We must have regard to the fact that we took over this country in a terrible condition. For years and years the Party who were the Government showed a total disregard for agriculture, which is our main industry, and did everything possible to sabotage it by giving precious little by way of assistance to our farming community, by way of arterial drainage, which is one of the greatest needs in the country and by way of the land reclamation scheme by which the present Minister for Agriculture got the land out of the deplorable condition it was in.

Who is so unreasonable as to suggest that agriculture is not our principal industry, and why was it the Fianna Fáil Party in their time did not introduce a lime scheme, a most necessary scheme so far as the farming community is concerned? We all know that if there are cattle grazing on land continuously, or crops continuously taken out of that land, the lime content of the soil goes down. What steps did the Fianna Fáil Government take to replace that lime content in the land of Ireland? They took no steps. It is true there were half a dozen lime kilns here and there. Did Fianna Fáil expect that half-dozen to supply the entire needs of the country?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that would be more relevant on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

I will pass from that but do they suggest that in that aspect of our economy alone they made any attempt to supply the lime deficiency in our soil?

I want now to refer to the interest rates under the loans granted through the medium of the Small Dwellings Act. We all know the shock the people got because of the desperate effort made by the Fianna Fáil Government to have the loan they floated fully subscribed, at a time when there was very little hope that they would get the money. But they got the money by increasing the interest rates beyond all bounds. What was the result? In my constituency immediately many people were affected. They had committed themselves to building projects under the Small Dwellings Act and they found themselves faced with increased interest charges.

Their plight was a terrible one. They were paying £1 5s. per week but, as a result of the increased rates of interest, they had to pay an additional 5/- or 7/6 for which they had not budgeted when they started building operations. They had gone to the limit of their resources to provide housing accommodation for themselves. I remember the phone ringing in my house as if we were in some desperate emergency. Indeed, it was an emergency. There is no doubt about that. These people will have to meet these extra charges for many years to come as a result of the misguided policy of the Fianna Fáil Government.

There are a thousand and one instances I could quote here in condemnation of what the Fianna Fáil Government did. I like to give any Government credit where credit is due. I give Fianna Fáil credit for some of the good things they did, but the good they did was outweighed by the bad— by the harm and the damage that they can never hope to repair.

The Minister has expressed his thanks to the people for subscribing to his loan. He also thanked the former Taoiseach for his co-operation in encouraging the people to subscribe. People who have money to subscribe to such a worthy undertaking should subscribe. The Minister deserves our congratulation and our support for his magnificent handling of a difficult situation. He controlled the price of tea. He reduced the price of butter. He gave increases to the old age pensioners, to the widows and the orphans. He succeeded in having his loan fully subscribed. That is a very creditable achievement for a Minister for Finance in his first year of office. Having moved around the country, I can say authoritatively that the people outside are very happy with the first ten months of inter-Party Government because they have been marked by such wonderful achievements.

Comment on this
John O'Donovan Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. O'Donovan) Fine Gael

The debate on this Budget has followed three different lines. First of all, there were the political points which were raised; secondly, there were the points of comparison between the 1952 Budget and this Budget; thirdly, and I regret to have to say there was very little of this particular type of debate, there was an attempt to estimate the present position of the country in relation to this Budget.

I propose to say a few words, first of all, about the political points raised. That situation was really summed up when, during the course of his speech, the Tánaiste suggested that it was inadvisable for anybody to argue with the Leader of the Opposition; he said the Leader of the Opposition would win in the end. And, at column 872 of Volume 150 of the Official Report, Deputy de Valera replied: "Because you were always wrong." We all of us engage in arguments and discussions but I think very few of us think that the other person is always wrong. That is my first political comment.

Deputy Lemass came back, as he has done on a number of occasions during the year, to the question of the promises that were made during the election campaign. For example, at column 844 of Volume 150 of the Official Report he was asked during the course of his speech:—

"Why then did the farmers vote against you last year?"

and he replied:—

"Because they were misled by the pledges and promises of the people opposite."

Now during the course of that election campaign last year I took a busman's holiday one Friday night and I went down to listen to Deputy Lemass speaking at the corner of York Street. Strange as it may seem, I thought from the manner of his speech and even the nature of it that he realised the election was lost so far as Fianna Fáil was concerned.

I have here a report of that speech appearing in the Irish Press of Saturday, May 15th. It is a jungle of various points suggesting that the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party did not understand one another, that the people did not understand them and that Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach, was making statements which he, Deputy Lemass, could not understand at all. Now, as Deputy M. J. O'Higgins pointed out to-day, Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach, really made only one promise to the people: he promised in so far as he could achieve it that the people would get good Government. That involved, above all, an attempt to lighten the burdens on the people. Since he came in here ten months ago Deputy Lemass has been singing a different kind of tune but that particular night at York Street, at any rate, he reminded me very much of a man trying to get out from inside a barbed wire entanglement with nothing to help him but his bare hands.

During the course of Deputy Lemass's speech the other day, when he said that there was a danger, unless certain things were done, of killing the export trade in confectionery, I made a reference to the fact that the export trade in Jacob's biscuits was lost during a period when Deputy Lemass could have saved it. He is reported as replying to me: "The Parliamentary Secretary is talking through his hat as usual". My recollection of what he said is very different from that. It was not nearly as polite as that. However, if it has been toned down by Deputy Lemass——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the Parliamentary Secretary ought to make a reference of that kind to the Official Reports.

Comment on this

I have a distinct recollection of what he said. Does the Chair wish me to repeat what Deputy Lemass said?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No, but Official Reports are never toned down by anybody. The Official Reports are verbatim reports of what was said in the House and it is a reflection on the reporting of the debates to suggest otherwise.

Comment on this

It was not intended as a reflection on the reporting, and the Ceann Comhairle will appreciate that. I think it is understood that if any Deputy makes a comment which he thinks is too strong he can tone down the wording while leaving the sense remain the same. I think that is understood. But the question, at any rate, is whether I was talking through my hat—we will take the phrase of the Official Report. This evening I examined the trade and shipping statistics, as they used to be—of course, they are now called trade statistics. I found our exports of biscuits were worth £503,000 in 1929; £231,000 in 1939 and that last year they were worth £137,500. The particular period I was thinking of was the period immediately after the war and I find that there is a complete blank for the year 1947. The word "biscuits" in relation to exports does not even occur in the index.

Now, how did that happen? It happened in quite a simple way. It was at the time when we had 100 per cent. flour here. The Department of Supplies which was controlled by Deputy Lemass would not supply this company for export with flour which would enable them to sell their biscuits abroad. In extreme circumstances that is quite understandable—perhaps in the years 1942 or 1943—but when it went on after the war, it was in my opinion quite improper, and every effort should have been made to get that export trade going again, but to make matters worse, in that particular year, 1947, we imported biscuits to the tune of £50,000 because there was white flour available for the manufacture of biscuits in England and we imported the bulk of them from Britain—I am wrong there: we got £12,000 worth from Britain and £30,000 worth from Canada.

Deputy Lemass knew quite well from a phrase that was in the Budget that there was no danger whatever of a collapse in the export trade in confectionery. The Government had no intention of allowing the export trade in confectionery to collapse. During the course of his speech, also, Deputy Lemass asked a fair-enough question. He asked what had the Government done here since it came into office to enable private enterprise to prosper? I take it we are all aware on every side of the House that the State end of enterprise and economy in this country has been very well attended to in the last ten years and what we would all be concerned with on both sides of the House is that there would be some developments which would help private enterprise.

The present Government did one thing—and I think this is what they did primarily to answer. Deputy Lemass's question—they restored confidence. There was a complete restoration of confidence once it was realised in the early autumn of last year that the Government had settled down in harmony and there were none of the difficulties which the Opposition had been sedulously suggesting would occur when members of the Labour Party and members of a strong Fine Gael Party got together. That position has continued and that is primarily what the Government did. They restored confidence amongst business people, confidence which had been previously shaken by the Budget of 1952.

Coming up to the present Budget, I read what Deputy Lemass was forecasting about it and what I noticed was that when he was some little distance away from it, one day he said it was going to be most difficult for the Minister for Finance and the next that it was going to be most easy for him but when it came to the final analysis Deputy Lemass came down to it by saying that he did not see why the Minister would not be able to do something for everybody. Of course, Deputy Lemass realised that it was not going to be easy for the Minister to foot his bill but, of course, it was right tactics, I think, from his point of view to suggest that the Minister could do something for everybody. Once the receipts and estimates of expenditure were published and once it was shown that there would be approximately £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 additional revenue without any increase in taxation, it was evident to Deputy Lemass that there was a position in which the Minister would be able to give something to everybody. These are the political points I wish to make.

The second matter to which I wish to refer is the comparison between the 1952 Budget and the present Budget. There is this real, fundamental difference between the 1952 Budget and the present Budget: the present Budget is an attempt gently to push matters on to a better plane in this country. The 1952 Budget was radical surgical operation. The difference of opinion was really on whether that operation was necessary or not. It is suggested by the Opposition that the greatest tribute that could be paid to the 1952 Budget which, as we all know, was discussed backwards and forwards throughout this country for two years subsequently at various by-elections, and on various occasions in this House during the lengthy debates—it is suggested by the Opposition Party that the best tribute that was paid to that Budget was the fact that the Minister for Finance has carried on the tradition inaugurated by it. In fact, of course, the Minister has not done any such thing. The Minister has moved, in so far as he could, within the limits which were set out for him by the position he found when he came into office.

I think that the Minister has shown considerable courage. Suppose there should be a serious falling-off in trade or anything like that, would anybody say our yields of taxation would go up by £3,000,000 or £4,000,000? I think that is unlikely for reasons I will give later, but still the Minister for Finance is the man responsible and it is on his shoulders that responsibility rests in introducing his first Budget. I also say that we have not got the 1952 Budget with us still because when those increased taxes were made in 1952 wages were much lower than they are to-day and the only concession made to people like old age pensioners, the widows and orphans, and people of that sort, was the concession that they would get exactly the mathematical equivalent in compensation of what they had lost in the food subsidies. To my mind, when you get a situation where there has been an increase in wages since that Budget—a basic increase of 12/6, and varying upwards from that—the Budget is not the same as it was when it was introduced.

The primary criticism of the 1952 Budget was that it was designed to remedy a situation which no longer existed and that it was altogether the kind of operation that should have been carried out only if conditions were really serious in this country. I take it that anybody who looks at the matter in a fair way will agree that conditions were not nearly so serious as the Minister represented them to be at that time. Personally, I was perturbed about it for one serious reason. I paid a great deal of attention to the Budget of 1952. I hope the present Minister will not mind my saying that I read Deputy MacEntee's Budget a lot oftener than I read his Budget, and that I have a great deal more time to it. What perturbed me in particular was the fact that I read in every line of that Budget a huge increase in unemployment.

The Government of the day said: "We did not deliberately create unemployment." That was what the former Taoiseach, Deputy Eamon de Valera, said. It all depends on what meaning you attach to that phrase. I would say that, if the Government of the day deliberately created unemployment, if they realised that what they were going to do would create unemployment, you might condemn them for it and say it was wrong and very harsh. If, in fact, however, the Government of the day introduced that Budget and did not know it would create large-scale unemployment then I would say they were quite unfit to be the Government. The extent of that unemployment in Dublin City was never realised because if they became unemployed they moved off to Britain after a week or a fortnight. I noticed the change and another thing I noticed was that the Dublin people did not turn against the Government of the day at that time. I think they were very fair about it. It was not until late in the autumn of 1952—when they realised that what was being said by the then Opposition was true—that the Dublin people began to turn against the Fianna Fáil Party who were the Government of the day. I think they were perfectly fair-minded about it. I notice Deputy Corry is smiling. Perhaps Deputy Corry is remote from the City of Dublin and thinks that what I am saying is not correct. That was the situation as I read it at the time.

Comment on this

The loss of the £1,000,000 was not troubling them?

Comment on this

Which £1,000,000? The loss of the £24,000,000?

Comment on this

The £1,000,000 for the civil servants.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to the £24,000,000 out of the kitty? There is one other suggestion in relation to the Budget of 1952 and that is that when the Fianna Fáil Government came back into office in 1951— and this is a suggestion made by many fair-minded people outside—they were unlucky that they ran into a bad period when the cost of everything was very high and, generally speaking, no Government could have done any better than they did. I cannot help feeling that the particular views that were held by the then Government in 1951-52 were strongly reinforced by Deputy MacEntee's visit to Mr. Butler, which was referred to here earlier this evening. I am very much afraid that Britain is running into a somewhat similar balance of payments difficulty at the present time as she was in at the fag end of the year 1951 when the dollar reserves began to go down. The present Government have indicated, up to the present at any rate, one degree of independence: they did not raise the bank rate when it was raised in Britain a few months ago. That was one degree of independence from that point of view.

There is one other matter to which I should like to refer with regard to the 1952 Budget. Yesterday, Deputy Aiken suggested many times that the excess profits tax in Britain was removed by the Labour Government in Britain. I am only speaking from recollection on this matter but my recollection is quite distinct about it. These taxes vary. As far as I remember, a large part—I think the whole of it—was removed by the present Conservative Government. What Deputy Aiken was putting forward was: Why did the Labour Party here not insist on the restoration of the excess profits tax when they got into office? The fact of the matter is that it is a long time now since the excess profits tax was removed here and, in any event, in my opinion when you take corporation profits tax and add it to income-tax the taxation of companies is quite high enough here: I agree with Deputy MacEntee about that.

In the earlier part of his speech this afternoon—I did not hear the latter part of it—Deputy O'Malley said that there was an element here in Dublin which was convinced that a change of Government would mean a reduction in the cost of living. There is this much to be said about that. If it has not meant a reduction in the cost of living it certainly has prevented it from going as high at it would be to-day if the Party opposite had remained in office. They were on a good wicket there.

Comment on this

That is a right good one. I will be thinking of that for the next month.

Comment on this

I will repeat it so as to make quite certain that the Deputy understands what I am saying. They were quite right in saying that it was a better bet to back Fine Gael and Labour than to back Fianna Fáil, because to-day they would be paying a higher price for butter—and God only knows what they would be paying for tea. On the subject of tea, it might be no harm to say one or two words. The Fianna Fáil Party had a major campaign ready about tea but the whole thing turned turtle on them. What did the Government do, on the other hand? To give them credit, I think that, in the past, the Party opposite would have fought that campaign about tea but they have grown more wary with the years.

What was done, in fact? Everybody in this House knows that the Government started considering the price of tea last October and November—and the longer they considered it the worse the position seemed to get. When it was at its very worst, the Government had sufficient courage to say: "This is so bad it cannot last." The Minister for Industry and Commerce, on behalf of the Government, announced: "We are taking no decision on this until September."

Yesterday, Deputy Carter spoke in this debate. He is one of the people who originally talked about tea on tick. He mended his hand a bit yesterday, but he said the position was still in a bit of jumble and that we did not know where we were going. I think everybody will agree that the auguries are very favourable at the present time. However, if the Party opposite were in Government to-day, it is to be presumed that the price of tea would be the same as in Britain.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this