Greyhound Industry Bill, 1955—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–172 of 348. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1955 ›
When I was last speaking on this amendment in the name of Deputy O'Malley, which proposes to give the board authority to require the Irish Coursing Club to contribute such sum as is, in the opinion of the board, reasonable towards the expenses of the board, I was dealing with the ability of the club to comply with the proposal contained in the amendment. I pointed out that over a number of years——
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I take objection to the fact that we are beginning all over again? Deputy MacEntee himself said when he was last speaking on this amendment he "pointed out"—and now he proposes to recapitulate all that he said before. Surely, there must be some end to repetition in this discussion.
Comment on this
No. I am not looking for any escape; I am looking for an end of a studied policy of obstruction.
Comment on this
That is quite untrue, and the Minister knows it. We gave him whole sections of this Bill, the most important sections, without any debate whatever merely because we knew, of course, that the Minister and the Government could not keep a House and we did not want to reduce the proceedings of the Dáil to a farce by calling for a House, as, indeed, we might do now, because, after all, it is the Minister who is responsible for the Bill and if the Minister does not do the Opposition the justice of admitting that we are trying to discuss this Bill and what is involved in it in a reasonable way, we will show him some obstruction. We could at the present moment, by reason of the failure of the Minister's Whips to keep a House, just call an end to the whole proceedings for the time being. I merely want to point out there is no obstruction.
Comment on this
Now, Sir, I do not think there are 20 persons present.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present.
Comment on this
The members of my Party proceed on the principle that there is no use preaching to the converted, but I have now a lot of very fertile soil on the other side of the House.
Comment on this
The soil is not too fertile on the Deputy's side of the House, but he is all right now—Deputy Corry is coming in to listen.
Comment on this
I want to put on record, first of all, a protest against the unmannerly suggestion of the Minister for Agriculture. I was speaking on this amendment on the 23rd February when the debate adjourned. I moved the Adjournment and I think it is quite in order for me now briefly to recapitulate the introductory arguments I was then making. That, Sir, was as far as I had gone when the Minister had the audacity to suggest that either myself or my colleagues were enduring the labour and tedium of this debate merely to obstruct the business of the House. That is not our objective at all.
We know that this is a most important Bill. The Committee, which the Minister himself set up, has pointed out that the greyhound industry can be productive of many millions a year, something which the Minister for Finance will not sneeze at, having regard to the precarious state of our balance of payments account. This Bill, as we know, proposes to give very wide powers to the greyhound industry board, but it also proposes to give very considerable powers to the body which has been condemned by the Committee which the Minister himself set up.
I do not propose to go into that aspect of the matter on this amendment, but I want to assure the Minister that it has not been lost sight of and that it will become, I hope, the general knowledge of all the members of this House and all those outside it as to why it is we are opposed in principle to agreeing to every proposal which the Minister has embodied in this Bill. We think, as a correspondent who has written to me from Great Britain thinks, that this Bill is merely an attempt to put a new label on an old body and that what, in fact, is being done in the Bill is to perpetuate the body which was subject to such severe criticism on the part of the Minister's own Committee.
When I was speaking last, I was on the point that it was quite reasonable to expect the club to contribute towards the finances of the Greyhound Advisory Body having regard to the functions of the board and having regard also to the privileges and the legal authority which this Bill seeks to confer upon the club in respect of a great many important matters in relation to which the club has been, in my opinion at any rate, flagrantly lax and, indeed, guilty of a grave dereliction of duty.
I was pointing out on that occasion, and I have not any later figures than those which are available in this official document that according to Table VI on page 49 of the Report of the Advisory Committee, the gross income enjoyed by the club for the year ending 30th June, 1948, amounted to £24,420. The gross expenditure for that 12 months amounted to £16,548 and there was a surplus, before deduction of income-tax, of £7,872. For the following year, the halcyon year of the Coalition, the total income of the club amounted to £20,600 and the gross income——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy MacEntee read out these exact figures on the last occasion on which he spoke. He has given us the date himself, 23rd February. He read out these figures and we have them in the Official Report. What is the point of repeating now exactly what he said then? I do not mind Deputy MacEntee making the same point all over again, but reading out the exact figures he read out previously——
Comment on this
The Deputy had better grow up. Does he want me to believe that he has carried in his mind what I submitted on the 23rd February?
Comment on this
As far as the Chair can recall, those figures were given by Deputy MacEntee on the 23rd February and are recorded in the Official Report.
Comment on this
I am giving no opinion on that. I have been asked to rule in relation to the figures which the Deputy read out.
Comment on this
One could say, for instance, basing argument on the Parliamentary Secretary's submission, that it would not be in order to remind the House that sometime, I think, in last May the Deputy said that the most effective thing the Minister for Finance could do would be to reduce income-tax by sixpence in the pound.
Comment on this
And the Chair has replied to the Parliamentary Secretary's point of order by stating that these figures were already given on the 23rd February.
Comment on this
Surely on resuming a debate which had been adjourned, we are entitled to recapitulate in order to put the arguments in the proper perspective? Of course, if Deputies keep on interrupting me. I will be able to find, I hope, a sufficient vocabulary to continue, but if they want this debate to proceed in an orderly way, they had better stop interrupting.
Comment on this
I am not interrupting. I am raising a point of order on the principle that the Deputy is continuing the speech he was making when the House was last considering this matter and that he gave us all those figures.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy quote the column? I am challenging the accuracy of the Deputy's memory.
Comment on this
I challenge the accuracy of the Deputy's memory.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy MacEntee doubted the reliability of the Parliamentary Secretary's memory in submitting that he had quoted all those figures in extenso to you before. I would refer you to column 950, Vol. 154, No. 6, of the Official Debates of 23rd February in which Deputy MacEntee is reported as saying:—
"...I am quoting from Table VI on page 49 of the Report—for the year ended 30th June, 1948, the gross income of the club was returned as £24,420. Its gross expenditure in that year was £16,548 and it had a surplus, before deduction of income-tax, of no less than £7,872. I grant you, for some reason or other, the picture changed in 1949 because, for the year ending 30th June in that year, the gross income amounted to only £20,000. It had fallen by £4,420, but the gross expenditure had jumped to £20,879 and there was a deficit in that year of £279."
I interrupted, and the report continued as follows:—
"Mr. Dillon: After having paid income-tax of——?
Mr. MacEntee: Yes. Of course, another reason may have been—we had better advert to it before half-past ten——
Mr. Dillon: Would the Deputy mind saying what income-tax was paid in that year?
Mr. MacEntee: £4,294. They paid income-tax to that extent in that year but they paid it to the Coalition Government."
Now the variant is "in the halycon years of the Coalition Government".
"Perhaps that is one of the blessings which befell——
Mr. Dillon: I suppose at this hour of the night any nonsense or insanity will do."
Comment on this
If I challenge the accuracy of the Parliamentary Secretary's memory, I submit that it is not open to the Minister for Agriculture to intervene and interrupt the debate in the disorderly way in which he is doing now.
Comment on this
I have already stated that the figures now being quoted were quoted here by Deputy MacEntee on the 23rd February and I cannot see the point of quoting the figures again. Consequently, if Deputy MacEntee was out of order in quoting them, the Minister is equally out of order.
Comment on this
In making a point of order to you, I have the right to direct your attention to the relevant paragraphs in the Volume, the contents of which were contributed by Deputy MacEntee, and to inquire, if he has said all this, will he be stopped from saying it again?
Comment on this
May I point out that when I spoke in the House on the 23rd February, there were four people sitting in the front benches? I think Deputy Barry may have been one of them; the Parliamentary Secretary was a fleeting visitor; Deputy Finlay was there and, I think also, Deputy Hughes. But I certainly did not see Deputy Belton, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Morrissey or Deputy Dockrell.
Comment on this
Surely I am entitled to refresh the memory of the Deputies who heard me and to give this information to those who did not hear me. Otherwise, Deputies will not know the issues that have been discussed when this amendment is put.
Comment on this
Standing Orders do not allow repetition and the fact that certain Deputies were absent does not justify the Deputy in repeating his submissions. I would ask Deputy MacEntee to deal with amendment No. 16, which is before the House.
Comment on this
I submit to you the figures which I am again putting to the House are vital to the whole of this issue. The merits of this amendment will naturally be determined by the extent to which the Irish Coursing Club would be in a position to meet any levy which the board considers it reasonable to impose upon it.
Comment on this
That does not bring the figures into order. The Chair has ruled they are out of order.
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled I am out of order in being unduly repetitive. I would point out to you that if I have repeated myself once this evening, it was due to the fact that I have been subjected to a continuous barrage of interruptions since I tried to address myself to this particular matter. However, I will proceed. I pointed out by reading Table 6 and I am not going to repeat the figures except to comment upon them in this way...Deputy Morrissey laughs. There is an animal, I believe, which you can hear in the depths of the night out in the desert and which is called the laughing hyena.
Comment on this
In all your 30 years you never learned order. I did not think I would hear that dulcet laughter in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I was dealing, when I was speaking on the 23rd February, with the question of the income enjoyed by the club and the expenditure which that income had to defray. I was endeavouring to refresh the minds of the Deputies about that this evening when I was interrupted, but I would like to proceed from that. I am not going to touch upon this question of income and expenditure, but I am going to touch upon the earning assets of the club. According to the report, on the 30th June, 1950, the assets, including debtors, cash on hands, investment in Government loans amounted to £8,558, and then they had an asset in Powerstown Park, Limited, that was returned as being worth £1— a very substantial writing down of an asset. I am not accepting that figure and, for the purpose of this amendment and the debate, I am going to use the figure which the committee itself placed on that asset. You will note that this club, which Deputy Finlay— perhaps I will be allowed to quote Deputy Finlay's speech, because it was Deputy Finlay who really put this matter in order. Deputy Finlay said:—
"I must confess that I cannot possibly see the point of this amendment. The only thing that would give any point to it at all is if it were an attempt to tax the greyhound racetrack run by the Irish Coursing Club when no other greyhound track can be taxed."
Deputy Finlay went on to say afterwards that he did not think the club could bear any contribution towards the expenses of the board. Deputy Finlay's speech, which was all directed to that particular point, will be found reported in columns 940, 941 and 942— three columns altogether—and not once was he interrupted.
Comment on this
I do not intend to start criticising Deputy Finlay's speech, except to say that it was directed to the argument that the club could not possibly make any contribution towards the expenses of the board. If I might be permitted, I am going to resume my own argument on the amendment.
Comment on this
I am trying to restrain myself; I really am trying to restrain myself. I would hate to air my feelings by saying what I am thinking about you.
Comment on this
To show how the club puts on an appearance of poverty towards those interested in greyhound racing and coursing, who might have thought that they had some stake in the assets of the club, I was referring to the fact that Powerstown Park appears in the balance sheet at £1. That is not what the committee had to say about the value of this particular asset, Powerstown Park, because I know, Sir—I just cannot put my finger on the exact figure——
Comment on this
I am not going to guess. I am going to protect myself against any suggestion that I am misquoting or misrepresenting the position of this very wealthy organisation. I want to get the exact figure for Powerstown Park, which was returned at £1 in the balance sheet.
Comment on this
I have it now and I am going to quote the reference— paragraph 113. This is what the Minister's Committee had to say about Powerstown Park:—
"Powerstown Park, Limited, is a private company with a paid up capital of £10,000. The company was formed in 1932 by the Irish Coursing Club, mainly to establish a permanent national coursing ground, and to that end, to purchase the property known as Powerstown Park Racecourse."
This is the £1 asset.
"Previous to the formation of the company, the Irish Coursing Club had held coursing meetings on this property and had paid a rent therefor."
It might not be strictly relevant, but I suppose those who authorised the investment of £10,000 in Powerstown Park were under the impression that, when they had purchased Powerstown Park, the Irish Coursing Club would be able to run its coursing meetings free of charge at Powerstown Park. That expectation, however, was not fulfilled.
"The company carries on the business of horse racing and other activities relating thereto. The shareholders of the company, who are nominees of the Irish Coursing Club, executed in April, 1932, a Deed of Trust, under which they acknowledged that they held their shares in trust for the Irish Coursing Club and were prepared to act in all respects under the direction of the club, as expressed or contained in resolutions from time to time passed by the standing committee. The senior joint secretary of the Irish Coursing Club acts as salaried manager of Powerstown Park, Limited, and in consideration of payment of an agreed annual sum, is entitled, while acting in this capacity, to reside in Powerstown House and to use the lands of Powerstown Demesne, comprising about 130 acres, except at such times as portion of them is required for coursing or racing."
Now, Sir, I pointed out that the paid up capital of Powerstown Park Limited amounted to £10,000. I have also pointed out that this valuable property stands in the balance sheet of the Coursing Club at £1.
I go on to give what the Committee further gleaned about Powerstown Park:
"We have received no estimate of the value of the properties owned by this company, but we learned that a sum of £12,000 approximately was spent over a period of years on improvements to the race course, in other words on grounds in the same property as those referred to later in paragraph 121, in which the expenditure by the Irish Coursing Club itself, of upwards of £2,000 towards the improvement of portion of these grounds for coursing purposes, is mentioned. As in the case of the Greyhound and Sporting Press Limited, and although Powerstown Park Limited appears to be a prosperous undertaking, no contribution whatever appears to have been made by it to the funds of the Irish Coursing Club. Indeed the Irish Coursing Club actually pays £100 per annum for the right to hold coursing meetings on its own lands at Powerstown Park. Profits made by Powerstown Park Limited have been utilised to increase the company's assets."
This £22,000 company stands in the balance sheet of the Irish Coursing Club at £1.
The Report goes on to say:
"The formation of these two companies, both of which engage in commercial activities, and the investment by the Irish Coursing Club in such commercial enterprises of funds arising directly from the greyhound industry, appear to have been outside the terms of the constitution of the club."
Sir, some of the passages which I have read to the House would be relevant, not only to this debate, but to another debate on this section but I am merely pointing out now in relation to the amendment before the House, which is to ask that the board be empowered to require the club to pay such sum towards the expenses of the board as the board may deem reasonable, that the club is a wealthy organisation and out of the profits of Powerstown Park Limited alone could make a very substantial contribution towards the expenses of the greyhound industry board and towards the development of the greyhound industry in this country. That is what is involved in this amendment and, having regard to the facts which I have put before the House, one would think that it is a perfectly reasonable thing to ask that the club should be required to make this contribution. What is indeed inexplicable, what the Minister cannot explain away, is why he should reject an amendment which is so perfectly reasonable as this one is.
It is rather difficult to keep track of all the tables but I should like to consider another asset in this balance sheet. There is the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited. I understand that that publication has been referred to earlier in this House and that some comments on it have been sent to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. So, perhaps, I am estopped from commenting in the way in which I think it would be perfectly justifiable to comment upon some of the articles which have recently appeared in that publication.
Comment on this
I was dealing with the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited. It, too, is returned as being worth £1. Let us see what the committee had to say about the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited:—
"Apart from printing The Coursing and Racing Calendar—recently renamed The Sporting Press——”
I am sorry. I wish to refer, first of all, to paragraph 109 of the report, in which the committee states:—
"In 1924 the Irish Coursing Club decided to promote, jointly with the secretary of the club, a publication to be known as The Coursing Calendar which was to become the official organ of the Irish Coursing Club. By 1928, this paper was firmly established. The club then decided by resolution—”
Mark you—
"The club then decided by resolution to take complete responsibility for the paper and for this purpose incorporated a company known as the Greyhound and Sporting Press Limited, of which the share capital of £5,000 was subscribed from the funds of the Irish Coursing Club."
£5,000 written down to £1 in the balance sheet of the club.
"On the formation of the new company, the secretary of the club, in consideration of certain financial arrangements made with him, agreed to assign to it all his interest in The Coursing Calendar. Although the resolution setting up the company directed that the property and assets thereof would be held by trustees of the Irish Coursing Club and by the directors of the company, no trust deed in these terms was executed.”
I hope the House realises why it is necessary that there should be some sort of supervision and control over the assets and finances of the Irish Coursing Club, when it hears this:—
"Although the resolution setting up the company directed that the property and assets thereof would be held by trustees of the Irish Coursing Club and by the directors of the company, no trust deed in these terms was executed."
That is, not executed, at least, prior to the date of the report.
Comment on this
Paragraph 109, page 44. The paragraph goes on to say:—
"We feel satisfied that the directors and shareholders of the company do in fact hold the property and assets in trust for the club, but it would seem desirable that the position should be regularised by the reorganised Irish Coursing Club."
That is the body which will come into existence when this Bill becomes law.
I go on and I shall have to repeat a couple of sentences because I inadvertently began my comment upon this aspect of the club's balance sheet by commencing with paragraph 110 on page 45 of the Report, which says:—
"Apart from printing The Coursing and Racing Calendar—recently renamed The Sporting Press—the company prints the Stud Book on behalf of the Irish Coursing Club and prints ‘membership’ and other cards for coursing clubs. The company undertakes printing work for a number of horse racing companies and other sporting organisations, and—presumably in order to employ its staff and machinery full time— engages also in a considerable amount of other commercial printing and paper trading, outside the greyhound industry.”
I hope it will be remembered that one of the things which the House is proposing to do here is to establish on a legal basis this trading and printing organisation which competes with other printers and similar companies who have not behind them the funds and resources in support of the greyhound fraternity in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy had better stop about the Irish Press because I have something here in the Sporting Press which I do not want to open prematurely. Perhaps if I am provoked too far, I may have something to say about the Sporting Press and I may have to ask whether the greyhound owners of this country are going to allow the Irish Coursing Club and the Sporting Press to be run as an adjunct to Fine Gael and to carry on a vendetta for the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
We also know that the Minister met the bookmakers and handed to them a statement of which the preamble had been drafted by him, a preamble which was an attack on the Irish Press and an attack which was repeated in the last issue of the Sporting Press.
Comment on this
I agree, Sir, but if Deputy Thaddeus Lynch and the Minister for Agriculture keep on interrupting me I cannot be blamed if sometimes I course the hare which they raise.
Comment on this
I was coming back to the point that, according to this report, the company undertakes printing work for a number of horse racing companies and other sporting organisations and, presumably, in order to employ its staff and machinery fulltime, engages also in a considerable amount of other commercial printing and paper making outside the greyhound industry.
"The Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited, appears to have been remarkably successful from the outset and the value of its assets including buildings and equipment is estimated by the Irish Coursing Club to be at present at least £60,000."
And the people who estimate the value of the Greyhound and Sporting Press at “at least £60,000” write it down in the balance sheet at a value of £1.
"This estimate includes buildings which were erected in recent years at a cost of approximately £14,000 and includes also plant and equipment said to have cost £18,000. This heavy expenditure on the construction of new buildings and installation of equipment was stated by the Irish Coursing Club to have become imperative when the printing company was informed by the military authorities during the emergency period that it would have to vacate certain buildings held on lease by it in Clonmel and utilised in connection with the publication of the Racing and Coursing Calendar and also by the Irish Coursing Club in other directions. We have ascertained that the proposal of the Department of Defence to resume possession of the buildings has not up to the present been proceeded with——”
I do not want to start discussing the question whether the reason given by the Irish Coursing Club for embarking on this expenditure of something like £14,000 was justified or not—that will arise later—but I just want to draw the attention of the House to the fact in passing that up to the date on which this report was being prepared, in fact up to the date on which it was signed, the Department of Defence has not resumed possession of the buildings.
"The buildings in question continued to be held by the Irish Coursing Club and in any event it was not until some years subsequent to the date of the proposal referred to above that the new buildings were erected at a cost of £14,000 and equipment costing £18,000 installed therein. On the whole——"
Deputy Anthony Barry and his colleagues said:—
"——we have some doubts as to whether in the circumstances mentioned the company was justified in expending on the erection of new buildings and more particularly on the installation of new and elaborate printing machinery large sums which properly speaking belonged to the Irish Coursing Club and to the greyhound industry."
May I repeat that?
"On the whole we have some doubts as to whether in the circumstances mentioned the company was justified in expending on the erection of new buildings and more particularly on the installation of new and elaborate printing machinery large sums which properly speaking belonged to the Irish Coursing Club and to the greyhound industry."
There the committee itself has given the justification for this amendment. We had a property amassed to the value of £60,000 and the valuers were the Standing Committee of the Irish Coursing Club. Where did that £60,000 come from? It came out of the greyhound industry and the purpose of this amendment is to ensure that is not going to happen in future, that this money which, according to the report, came out of the pockets of the greyhound owners, breeders and trainers of this country——
Comment on this
——will go back to the greyhound board and will be used for its proper purpose, that is for the development of the greyhound industry in this country. Deputy Barry has interrupted state and said that is not right, that wrong.
Comment on this
I did not sign Deputy Barry's name to the report. I did not participate in drafting it, but I am reading a statement to which Deputy Barry himself put his name, and certainly, so far as I am concerned, I cannot understand why having a couple of years ago or so said——
Comment on this
If Deputy Barry wants me to waste the time of the House looking up a triviality like that, I can, of course, do it.
Comment on this
The Minister need not be envious. The green-eyed monster that sits over there should bridle itself sometimes.
Comment on this
I am trying to make a mental calculation. I gather that it is four years and, I think, seven weeks——
Comment on this
——since Mr. Anthony Barry, now Deputy Barry, whom I am glad to see sitting in the House as an esteemed colleague of mine, even though he is in opposition, put his name to a report which contains the statement I have already recited to the House and which I do not want to repeat, having regard to the criticisms which previous repetitions evoked.
Having mentioned that these huge sums belonged to the greyhound industry, the report went on to say:—
"We have no information as to whether the Greyhound and Sporting Press Limited, decided on this expenditure or whether sanction of the standing committee for the expenditure was sought. The company appears to hold liquid assets to the value of £13,000 approximately."
Comment on this
No. That makes up the £60,000, but let us get back to the balance sheet again, this exceedingly conservative balance sheet. One can deceive and mislead by understating as well as by exaggerating.
Comment on this
I was commenting on the fact that the committee reported that the company appears to hold liquid assets to the value of £13,000—negotiable securities, as one might say, written down, with the buildings and printing plant, as being worth £1 in the coursing club's balance sheet. The committee then went on to say this:—
"Although these assets include Government securities, earning only from 3¾ per cent. to 4 per cent., no effort has been made to redeem 6 per cent. debentures to the value of £4,000, held personally by the senior joint secretary of the Irish Coursing Club who is also the manager of the Coursing and Racing Calendar. Here it might be noted that income and corporation profits tax to the amount of £24,800 was paid by the company since 1933.”
I hope the Minister has succeeded in getting the relevant passage in the report—I thought he was interested— because I should like him to turn now to paragraph 111, which says:—
"Despite these liquid assets and the fact that the assets and property of the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited, must be regarded as being held in trust for the Irish Coursing Club, it appears that this concern has never contributed any portion of its substantial profits to the Irish Coursing Club."
Mr. O'Donovan rose.
Comment on this
I will make my point of order. I submit, on a point of order, that what Deputy MacEntee has been reading for the past half an hour is the capital assets of this club. The amendment refers to the net revenue of the club and the Deputy should only make reference to the net revenue of the club from year to year.
Comment on this
The amendment refers to the net revenue of the club.
We have listened to the discussion about the £60,000 written down to £1 and we are now listening to talk about capital assets of various other kinds. I suggest Deputy MacEntee is not in order.
Comment on this
What I am going to address myself to is that, in fact, the coursing club has never disclosed its true net revenue, or at least the income and earnings which properly belong to it.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee is going a little wide of the amendment. He should keep closer to it.
Comment on this
The Minister, in discussing this amendment, seemed to make it appear that the club had no means of making a contribution. Deputy MacEntee is pointing out that, having built up this huge capital reserve which is now revenue producing, they never in the past contributed from that to the coursing industry. Therefore, this amendment is necessary and the argument is imperative.
Comment on this
What I am proceeding to show is that if those who control the coursing club made a full disclosure of their accounts to their members, the net revenue of this club would be even substantially higher than that returned under Table 6, because here is what the committee itself has to say:—
"Despite these liquid assets and the fact that the assets and property of the Greyhound and Sporting Press Ltd., must be regarded as being held in trust by the Irish Coursing Club it appears that this concern has never contributed any portion of its substantial profits to the Irish Coursing Club."
In fact, those who got hold of the plant and buildings were not rendering to the Irish Coursing Club any divided upon the Irish Coursing Club investment. The paragraph goes on to say:—
"...this concern has never contributed any portion of its substantial profits to the Irish Coursing Club. Its profits have either been ploughed back through the construction of buildings, installation of plant etc., or invested elsewhere. It was admitted on behalf of the company that its property and revenues belong to the Irish Coursing Club, but it was argued that surplus revenue was retained merely in order that it might later be readily available to the Irish Coursing Club should the latter's financial position decline or——"
and this is the point I am coming to—
"—should the industry as a whole need help."
What we are proposing in this amendment is that these huge revenues of the Irish Coursing Club which have never been disclosed in a way in which those who would read the balance sheet of an organisation like the Irish Coursing Club would understand and appreciate, should now make some contribution towards the expenses of the Greyhound Industry Board. That is what we are contending for in this amendment and I can see no justification whatever for the Minister or any person concerned honestly to ensure that all this confusion as between the property and assets of the Irish Coursing Club and those who control, manage and operate it should be cleared up, refusing to accept it.
I am sorry to have to impose on the House and, indeed, upon myself the physical fatigue of reading through the report, but I think it is essential it be on the records of this House and that the arguments for this amendment which were made so solemnly, so convincingly and effectively by Deputy Barry and his colleagues should be available to direct and guide us in the decision which we will ultimately have to take on this amendment.
Comment on this
The paragraph goes on to say:—
"We have already expressed doubt in regard to the action of the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited, in expending a sum of approximately £32,000 in the erection of buildings and installation of plant, in other words utilising in this manner reserves which must have previously accumulated."
Deputy Barry's comment on that was:—
"We cannot therefore accept as sufficient the explanation as to why the company did not contribute to the funds of the Irish Coursing Club as a whole during a period when coursing might have received greater financial assistance by way of reducing fees and increasing prize money at coursing meetings and the employing of additional supervisory staff."
Those who read the transcript of the evidence given by certain witnesses before the Advisory Committee will learn that one of the most general complaints—and indeed it is referred to here in the Report of the Advisory Committee—was that the Irish Coursing Club did not employ a sufficient supervisory staff of the quality and character which was essential if the sport of greyhound racing was to be kept clear of abuse. The Report goes on to say in paragraph 112:—
"We understand that the company prints the Stud Book at a profit to itself, charging considerable sums to the Irish Coursing Club for the service. The income derived by the Irish Coursing Club from the sale of the Stud Book of affiliated coursing clubs, etc., covered only a fraction of the cost of printing, so that the book in consequence is published at a consistent and serious loss to the club. We see no valid reason why, in view of the sound financial position of the Greyhound and Sporting Press, Limited, and the fact that it was set up with funds provided by the Irish Coursing Club, it could not at least have undertaken the printing of the Stud Book free of charge, or at a nominal charge, to the parent body. We are indeed of opinion that every affiliated coursing club would be reasonably entitled to a copy of the Stud Book, free of charge."
Comment on this
The paragraph goes on:
"We also feel that the company could readily have made other concessions to coursing clubs generally."
Another asset of the Irish Coursing Club which stands in the balance sheet at £1 is Clounanna. In paragraph 116 the Irish Cup meeting is described as the outstanding event in coursing activities in Ireland and is held at Clounanna. The paragraph goes on:—
"At this centre, the Irish Coursing Club expended approximately £11,500 in equipping the grounds, thereby providing good stands and other much-needed public amenities on what are generally regarded as the outstanding coursing grounds in this country. The Irish Coursing Club organised this meeting for a number of years, but in recent times responsibility for the function has devolved on the County Limerick Coursing Club, but on condition that the Irish Coursing Club may at any time resume responsibility. In recent years the meeting, as organised by the County Limerick Coursing Club, has been very successful. Profits acoruing to the County Limerick Club from the holding of the meeting may be disposed of only with the approval of the Irish Coursing Club. Although the Irish Coursing Club incurred the necessary expenditure on buildings, stands, etc., and continues to be responsible for their upkeep, the land on which they are erected is merely held on an expiring lease."
As I have said, this asset is written down as £1 on the balance sheet although £11,500 was expended there by the Irish Coursing Club. I think when all the facts which I have put before the House are taken into consideration it will be agreed that, as I have said before and as I am saying again in order to make my point clear, it is only reasonable that this wealthy organisation, the Irish Coursing Club, should be obliged to contribute towards the expenses of the board such a sum as the board themselves may, after full consideration of the position, deem to be reasonable. The only reason why the principle of that amendment might be rejected by the Minister is that he did not think the board which he proposed to set up would act in a reasonable way. I do not think there would be any justification for such an attitude.
The Minister himself has in fact compelled the majority of the House to accept his proposal that out of the six members other than the chairman whom he is to appoint, four must be members of what I think will be called the standing committee of the club. Here we have the position that the board will have upon it a majority of persons who are members of the standing committee of the club. Is it to be assumed that these four people will act in an unreasonable way towards the club? I think it is not conceivable that such a situation would arise and I simply cannot understand why the Minister should be adamant in regard to this amendment—why he should have indicated that he was not prepared to discuss it. I do not know why the Minister has become so unyielding in this matter. It is possible perhaps that when he drafted this Bill he had not read or studied the report of the advisory committee and that when he looked at our amendment he was not accordingly familiar with the facts which moved us to put it down.
I am now putting it to him that in his responsible position he should accept the amendment and give those who are interested in the greyhound industry the assurance that the profits, the moneys derived by the club from greyhound racing, coursing and breeding—because they will derive a revenue from that indirectly—will inure to the use and benefit of those who maintain the whole organisation.
Comment on this
I just want to say this. I think it is necessary for the record. I believe that Deputy MacEntee in what he says this evening is actuated by personal hatred and malice against individuals whom he conceives to have done him political injury in his own constituency. I believe this is the sole explanation of the disedifying diatribe to which we have been listening, and I believe——
Comment on this
——that it was actuated by the desire to injure individuals who, he believed, contributed to his political discredit.
Comment on this
I am telling the House what actuated Deputy MacEntee in the diatribe to which we have listened. Now I want to bring the House to the only relevant paragraph in this report which he has taken care not to quote. When all the matters referred to in this report had been excogitated by those who drafted it they came to paragraph 154, page 63, where they proceeded to make their recommendations. They said in the course of that paragraph:—
"As regards the source from which the funds to finance the board might be provided... a few witnesses believed, however, that a levy on the funds of the Irish Coursing Club would yield sufficient revenue for the purpose. As regards this proposal we are satisfied that the reconstituted Irish Coursing Club should apply its funds solely in connection with breeding and coursing, and we do not envisage the board——"
Comment on this
The Minister's sanctimonious tone will not disguise the fact that the Minister has disregarded every other recommendation of this report.
Comment on this
"——obtaining revenue from the club, except possibly in the circumstances already referred to in paragraph 146."
If you turn to paragraph 146 you will find this:—
"That all fees in connection with coursing and breeding as defined by the Irish Coursing Club and approved by the control board, be paid to the Irish Coursing Club—any member of the Irish Coursing Club or of the executive committee to have the right of appeal to the control board in regard to the utilisation or distribution of the revenues of the club. The control board to be entitled to demand out of Irish Coursing Club funds recoupment of any expenditure incurred by it in respect of coursing or breeding, or, alternatively, the payment of an annual levy to meet possible expenditure arising out of action necessarily taken by the board to deal with abuses in connection with breeding or coursing. Equally, however, we foresee that circumstances may arise in which the board might at its discretion decide to make a grant towards the funds of the Irish Coursing Club. Fees paid by applicants seeking licences to be remitted direct to the control board. All fees arising in connection with greyhound racing, e.g., licensing fees, proceeds of levies, etc., would come under the control of the board."
I am not going to intervene in this debate further, because I have made it clear what my views are, and they are not to be changed by the nauseating performance begotten of Deputy MacEntee's resentment of his personal political discredit. It is right that the House should know the source of his vindictive spleen throughout the discussion on this whole measure in the House, and know that he has no concern with the welfare of this industry, and that he has spent his time pouring filth, vituperation, misrepresentation and scandal——
Comment on this
——and reflections on the living and the dead. It is important that the people should know that it is not with the merits that he is concerned. The desire is to prosecute a personal vendetta. But neither his threats nor his vituperation are calculated to make the slightest impression upon my mind or on the mind of any other member of this House who understands their source.
Comment on this
When the Minister comes to read the report of this debate I hope that he will be able to put his finger upon one single argument in refutation of the case I have made for this amendment. It is an old saying: "When you have no case, blackguard your opponent", and we know, of course, what an adept the Minister is when it comes to indulging in personalities. It ill becomes the Minister to asperse my character in that way. Whatever any person in my constituency has ever done against me politically, I have never been guilty of a vendetta. There is no trace of Abyssinian blood in my veins, nor have I associated in any way with those who might in Irish history have flogged the unfortunate Croppies of '98.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but, Sir, the Minister proposes to continue on this line of personal attack and personal abuse. I have not said anything except to address myself to the fact that the governing body of the Irish Coursing Club in its administration of the funds has been severely criticised and condemned by the committee which the Minister set up. I have said, and I have repeated it time and again, that the moneys which ought to have been used for the development of the greyhound industry in this country have been utilised for other purposes. I am not going to endeavour to defend in any way, or refute or rebut, anything the Minister says. There are people associated with the Irish Coursing Club who have been friends of mine —great friends of mine politically, people with whom I have been associated during the Black and Tan times. I do not think they have ever found me wrong. I have never found them wrong. But there is, undoubtedly, a situation here which in the public interest should be cleaned up. I am endeavouring to ensure that it will be cleaned up.
The Minister's only rejoinder to the arguments I have advanced has been to try to heap contumely and abuse upon me. Very well, I can take all the ordure he throws, and I can wipe it off my face and my hands will be clean, which is, perhaps, more than can be said about some of the Minister's associates.
Comment on this
I think that what we have been listening to from Deputy MacEntee can only be described as a stupendous performance. It was a display of spurious indignation. I am going to demonstrate now why it is spurious, and that he has no interest whatever in the greyhound industry or what it is or what it is going to be in the future. The hair-raising disclosures and abuses to which he has already referred several times since this Bill was brought in——
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony Barry and his colleagues compiled that report and handed it to the Government, of which Deputy MacEntee was Minister, four and a half years ago, and for two and a half years Deputy MacEntee, with power to put an end to this "appalling state of affairs", did nothing whatever about it. In his comment all along, he has done nothing except to indulge in mudslinging of a type which I find revolting. I do not want to go any further on that line, because I think that all of us who have an interest in this thing know exactly what has happened, and know that Deputy MacEntee is trying to settle some private grievance of his own and using this occasion for that purpose.
I am tired of all this. I did not intend to speak again. I do not want to go into the details. The main fact about these Irish Coursing Club assets is that they are there. They were created by a body of men who came together as sportsmen to create their own sport and, on the way, they created this magnificent asset which is now being handed over to the entirely new industry that is going to be controlled by this new board plus the Irish Coursing Club.
I interrupted Deputy MacEntee during the course of his speech and, as I did not want to intervene for any length of time at that point, I now want to make clear what I meant. The main assets were developed, not from funds obtained from Irish breeders, not from funds obtained from Irish coursing events. Actually, they were obtained from English importers of Irish dogs who sent subscriptions to this country to effect the transfer of the dogs to the English stud. I happen to know that.
Comment on this
It was extremely wrong and improper of Deputy MacEntee to quote from the transcript of evidence given before that commission. It was so reported, and said here, that the people were asked to believe that these bits of evidence he read out were accepted by the commission as being the truth. The contrary was the fact.
Comment on this
It is all very well to try to deal with the matter in the rather offhand way in which Deputy Barry has dealt with it. He has repeated the slander, the vile slander, of the Minister for Agriculture. I have no spleen against any person in this matter. I want to say that—but not to defend myself against any accusation that the Minister for Agriculture might make. The Minister for Agriculture has made accusations before in this House and, when he was asked to justify them before those who could cross-examine him, he ran away. Deputy Barry is not in that position but Deputy Barry has taken the Minister's word. I have no quarrel or enmity with any person associated with the Irish Coursing Club. I just want to say that for the record—not to endeavour to carry conviction to the mind of the Minister for Agriculture but in the hope that, at any rate, an honest man like Deputy Barry will give me that credit. If I had a vendetta against anybody I certainly would show it in another way. I am arguing this case on its merits.
Comment on this
That is something the Minister did not endeavour to do and it is something that Deputy Barry has not done. After all, it is quite true that the assets are there. Nobody says that the assests have been embezzled in any way. They are there all right and the moneys are there. But how is it that they have been used to establish a printing and a publishing business and to buy a racehorse?
Comment on this
That is precisely the point at issue—for whom? We say they ought to have been utilised for the use and benefit of the greyhound industry—but not one penny of the earnings of these assets, not one penny of the income derived from these assets, has found its way back into the greyhound industry. That is what the report says and it does not say anything else but that.
Comment on this
I merely quoted what was printed in the report. The Deputy wants to suggest that there is an element of insincerity about this——
Comment on this
I was not Minister for Industry and Commerce. We had to clear up the financial mess which we inherited. That took a great deal of doing and, when we were doing it, we were attacked by the Minister and the others who told us——
Comment on this
I am answering one point. Surely I am entitled to do that? The suggestion is made that we delayed deliberately and refrained deliberately from giving effect to the recommendations in the report, Surely I am entitled to controvert that statement and to point out how it was that we could not do it because there were other things waiting for us? Everybody knows that the only reason why this Bill has been introduced now is because the Government have no other business. They cannot make up their mind about anything.
Comment on this
Except to the extent that Deputy Barry has raised the issue of why we did not bring in a Bill to establish this greyhound board during that period. If Deputy Barry knew anything about Government Departments he would know that the Bill was probably what might be described as in process of gestation during that period.
Comment on this
Yes, they are here in this report. I should not be surprised if the Bill were already well advanced when the Minister took over. The only thing about it is that the Bill would probably have followed more closely the lines of the recommendations of the Advisory Committee and the Minister has departed from that report in a most extraordinary way. However, there are other Deputies in the House who, no doubt, would like to address themselves to this amendment and I shall give them an opportunity to do so.
Comment on this
As the mover of the amendment, I must say that I am completely disgusted at the attitude of the Minister. It now appears, I am sorry to say, that the Greyhound Industry Bill of 1955 is turning into a political issue of Fine Gael versus Fianna Fáil —and, mark you, not by our choosing. I have no intention of going over all the ground that has been covered or of repeating myself, even though repetition is a very good thing——
Comment on this
Do not forget the wise thrush. Deputy Barry is still as cocky as a cock robin—the man who signed the Advisory Committee Report, "Dear Paddy", and so on.
Comment on this
I will. I will forget the question of repeating myself and of going over the ground which has been so ably covered by my colleagues, although repetition is a good thing. Deputy Finlay will remember what the poet said:—
"That's the wise thrush; he sings each song twice over,
Lest you should think he never could recapture
The first fine careless rapture!"
Ní mar a shíltear bítear. When Deputy MacEntee sits down, there is very little that the prosecution or the defence can add. As a matter of fact, it is a wise man who would rise and say: "My lord, the defence rests." As the mover of the section——
Comment on this
I beg your pardon— the amendment. As the mover of the amendment, I have to say that we have not yet found out whether the Minister has agreed to allow a free vote of the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe informs me that the Minister has refused a free vote of the House. Unfortunately, I was not here for that.
Comment on this
Even at this late hour, I trust that the Minister will allow a free vote, in view of the views of the different Parties on both sides of the House and now that one of the signatories of the Advisory Committee report is departing from the House and we are to be deprived of his wisdom. If there is not a free vote of the House, then there is no question but that this Greyhound Industry Bill is being definitely turned into a political issue.
Let us go back again, like the wise thrush, and repeat: I said before that anyone can get up here, and "slag" and criticise, but it is a good man who will say what should be done. The Minister quoted me. He quoted me wrongly, of course, but I do not mind that since he quoted me to the best of his ability, and I do not disagree with his paraphrase. Now, the Minister's intention was that this Bill should be politically non-acrimonious.
Comment on this
That does not arise on the Deputy's amendment. The Deputy should address himself now to the amendment.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. I had a semi-colon after my last sentence. I was about to say that, that being so, the Bill being politically non-acrimonious, and we being in the middle of the Bill, the Minister should now say: "I withdraw it and I now suggest that we ought to have an all-Party committee on this Bill." There is too much "slagging" going on and the position now is that this has definitely turned into a Fianna Fáil versus Fine Gael Bill.
Comment on this
I beg the Chair's pardon. I have only been speaking for three minutes, so I could not have said it.