We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Greyhound Industry Bill, 1955—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 173–348 of 348. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Greyhound Industry Bill 1955
Lapsed

No. 14 of 1955 ›

I was suggesting that, even at this late stage, in the middle of this most important Bill, the Minister—he is in absentia, but it can be conveyed to him by his deputy, the Minister for Social Welfare—should let this go, as they used to say in the old days, to a round-table conference, remembering that we, on this side of the House, support his view that the Bill should be politically non-acrimonious. As his Excellency, Seán T. O'Kelly, once said: “Does it not cause one furiously to think?” Does it not cause one furiously to think if the Greyhound Industry Bill is turned into a political issue?

To get back to the terms of my amendment, I think no fair-minded Deputy could quarrel with the very reasonable wording of the amendment. My friend, Deputy Finlay, has defeated by his logic the Minister's arguments that the amendment is unconstitutional. I am still holding out in the hope that we will have a free vote on this issue. Indeed, I hope that there will be a free vote on every section, so that if Deputy P.J. Burke and Deputy Briscoe disagree with me, or I disagree with them, we will be at liberty to go into different division lobbies. I have asked the Minister for a free vote on several occasions. Like St. Paul's Epistle to the Ephesians, there has been no reply.

Repetition is odious and I have no intention of going over the old ground, recapitulating "old, unhappy, far-off things and battles long ago." The arguments have been advanced in a far abler manner than I could ever hope to achieve by both Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Briscoe. Let us get down to business in relation to this Bill for the good of the industry. My very good friend, Deputy Carew from Limerick, is in the House. He will agree with me when I say that the present standing committee of the Irish Coursing Club is composed of both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. Mr. Jim Frost——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

——is one of the ablest men one could choose. If he were chosen, even if he were a supporter of the present Government, he would certainly get my support 100 per cent. As a matter of fact, he was a signatory to the report.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy O'Malley please refer to the amendment?

Comment on this

Certainly. I beg the Chair's pardon if I have deviated. I would ask Deputies who haphazardly trot in and out of this House without studying amendments in detail to read the amendments and consider their implications. Deputy Giles is up there in the back bench; he is a man who does a lot of "slagging" about democracy and the rights of the small man. I tell Deputy Giles now that this is a democratic Bill and we on this side of the House, even at this late stage, in the middle of the Bill, are prepared to go to a round table conference, argue the pros and cons and come back here then.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have been very patient with the Deputy, but I must now ask him to resume his seat. He has not once related his remarks to his own amendment.

Comment on this

To conclude——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has concluded.

Comment on this

I had intended to speak on this amendment much earlier in the debate and to put forward some of the arguments advanced by Deputy MacEntee, not for the same reason, but to point out that this amendment, or alternatively, some other amendment on similar lines, might be brought in by the Minister on the Report Stage to ensure that if, at any time, it was necessary for the board to require or get moneys from the Irish Coursing Club the board would have the power to do so. I like the amendment: the very first sentence reads: "The board may require the club." It is not mandatory. It merely gives power to the board to get money from the Irish Coursing Club. I intended to go through the report, as Deputy MacEntee has done, in support of my submission that the assets are there, most of them are easily realisable and should be devoted to the purposes for which, I believe, they were intended.

Like Deputy O'Malley, I have been completely revolted by the turn this discussion has taken. Like him, I feel a Bill like this should be completely above Party politics and I say to both sides of this House that the exhibitions we have seen to-night and all during the debate have been appalling. For that reason, I would ask the Minister to consider at this late stage setting up a Committee of the House to go into the Bill. Otherwise, this state of affairs will get worse because each successive stage gets dirtier and dirtier and no progress is being made. It is quite obvious the Minister has no intention of changing the Bill as it stands or accepting amendments that are put down.

Comment on this

To what would the Deputy attribute the fact that discussion on the Bill is getting dirtier and dirtier? I know the Deputy will be fair.

Comment on this

Who is responsible?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll on the amendment. We are not discussing the Bill as a whole; we are discussing amendment No. 16.

Comment on this

There were many amendments put down, some of which have been withdrawn because of assurances given by the Minister but, in my opinion, some very important amendments to this Bill are being defeated, important amendments which should be tied up in that Bill so that no succeeding Government or even this one, can ever be placed in a position of being powerless to rectify abuses that may still occur when the new industry is organised. I do not think anyone in this House could accuse me of having any malicious reasons for putting this viewpoint. I am as anxious as the Minister is that a good job be done and I do not doubt the Minister's sincerity for one moment. However, if he is as sincere as he would have us believe, if he is going to ensure that the small dog man, the trainer and all the other sections which he says are going to be catered for, will be catered for, he will, even at this late stage, in connection with this amendment and all other amendments, stop this discussion and set up a Committee of the House to deal with the Bill.

Comment on this

I wish to support this amendment which has been so ably discussed by my colleagues. Like the other speakers, I am very sorry that a certain amount of animosity has developed in relation to this measure. I want to pay this compliment to my colleague, Deputy MacEntee. I brought along a deputation from the Irish Coursing Club to him and to other members of my Party and had I known at that particular period that there was a very scurrilous leading article written——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not refer to any such article. The Deputy will refer to the amendment.

Comment on this

We are all anxious that the greyhound industry should be improved and that any money that can be spared to improve it should go back into the industry. We are anxious to see that the ordinary small man will have an opportunity of participating in the industry and that he will have some encouragement at least by getting some payment for the work he is going to put into breeding greyhounds. In this way the legislation now before the House will have a similar effect in improving the greyhound industry as the Racing Bill had in 1945 in another sphere. As I have said before we must divest ourselves of outside affiliations and approach the questions we discuss here in an objective way. All the money possible will have to go back into the industry for its development. I would not say that all the money of the Irish Coursing Club should be taken away, but if the Irish Coursing Club are able to make considerable profits and if their assets are extensive, they should be in the position to help the industry and to help the board so that the board in turn will be able to help them.

I want to see the interests of all sections catered for. As regards the man who starts to breed greyhounds and the man who races them, the stakes should be considerably increased to make it worth his while to do the work involved. If we do not approach the question from the national point of view and be fair to every section we cannot hope to achieve anything worth while. The industry has a long way to go to attain what we believe it should attain. While the Irish Coursing Club during their day have made great strides, we hope greater strides will be made as a result of this Bill and that any money that can be spared to improve the industry will be put into it.

Comment on this

I did not mean to intervene in this discussion but as a countryman I could not but intervene having heard some of the remarks from the far side of the House. Having listened for five minutes to what was said on this matter, my line is that those who live by commerce should be bound by commerce and those who do not, should not. Therefore, the farmer's son or the country dweller who has a dog and does not keep it in the hope that the dog will win a prize of £1,000 or win a race at Shelbourne Park——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest this has no connection with the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

I submit it has every connection. I say that commercialisation as portrayed by the racing of the dog after the artificial hare, and so on, has a very definite relationship to the amendment and that the statements I have made are relevant to the proposal which this amendment enshrines, namely, the levy of a contribution on the Irish Coursing Club. May I continue?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may, if he relates his remarks to the amendment, which deals with the contribution of the Irish Coursing Club to the board.

Comment on this

I believe that the type of young man, or perhaps old man, who lives very often in the poorer districts of the country like Limerick, the constituency of Deputy O'Malley, keeps his dog to go to the local coursing meeting and should not, as a result of this levy which will be imposed on the Irish Coursing Club by the passing of this amendment, have to pay an extra entrance charge. It is notable that, with the exception of Deputy Burke, the men who have thought otherwise on the far side of the House are men who are more likely to be involved in the commercial activities of the dog track than in the coursing of greyhounds in the field. I think this is relevant on the amendment. I know a farmer in County Louth who kept a greyhound and the value of that greyhound was never more than £25.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What has this to do with the contribution of the Irish Coursing Club to the board?

Comment on this

I believe it has a great deal to do with it. If we are considering a levy on the Irish Coursing Club, is not the amount a dog is worth a relevant consideration? Does the amount of commerce that is carried on in the activities of the Irish Coursing Club have its effect? As I see it, this definitely tends towards a commercialisation of an open-field sport. A contribution from the Irish Coursing Club will tend to make coursing more expensive for the ordinary individual in this country and for that reason I would find myself definitely against it.

Comment on this

As an old courser myself, I do not agree with the last Deputy's contribution. If we are to take that to its logical conclusion, we would be in this position that we would not want any Bill at all here and we would not want any Irish Coursing Club or anything else. We would just rear dogs and bring them out to chase a hare. I would go down to County Louth, bring out a few dogs and chase hares in the fields—we would not want any Irish Coursing Club.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The trouble with this debate is that there are too many hares. Would the Deputy please address himself to the amendment.

Comment on this

I just want to say again that I cannot see where any local coursing club would be responsible for raising entry fees if what we have in this amendment did take place. I must totally disagree with Deputy Donegan on this point. The only thing we are anxious to do in this amendment is to ensure that all the money we can get shall go back into the industry. That is all we are asking, and, in asking that, we are helping the Irish Coursing Club because they are going to benefit by the industry being improved. They are going to benefit because what they are going to lose on the swings, they are going to gain on the roundabouts. I hold it is reasonable to ask any body which is the parent body of the industry, such as the Irish Coursing Club, to help the board in any way they can. I am not going to say any more about it.

Comment on this

A number of very strong arguments were made in favour of this amendment to-night, and, in spite of the cheap jibe of Deputy O'Malley about people flitting in and out, I think I heard as much of the arguments on the Bill as anybody else. The arguments made in favour of the amendment would be much stronger if the people on the opposite benches could explain one thing—I believe it might almost convince me if they could explain it—how it is, if those terrible abuses, which are contained in the report, are to be taken as a fact, that, although the report was submitted on the 18th January, 1952, nothing was done about it until now? I think that is the strongest argument against the amendment put down in the name of Deputy O'Malley.

Comment on this

As we go along in this discussion, we get muddled and we lose the hare.

Comment on this

We become unsighted.

Comment on this

I take it that this document should have at least one paragraph in it that the Minister might honour—one recommendation—and the one recommendation which I ask him now to honour is the one which suggests this amendment. If the Deputy will turn to paragraph 146 of this report, he will see that Deputy Barry in company with his six other colleagues actually suggested—not what we suggest, that, if and when necessary, they should be asked to make a grant—that there should be an annual levy.

Comment on this

On the 18th of January, 1952.

Comment on this

All I know is that they signed the report.

Comment on this

It probably leaked out.

Comment on this

A lot of things leaked out, like the secret hearings. I do not know if it was printed after it was submitted to the Minister and I do not think Deputy Tully knows.

Comment on this

It was not in 1956.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What bearing has this on the amendment?

Comment on this

It has no bearing, except this, that, if there is any merit in proceeding with this type of legislation, it should never be too late to do it. I think Deputy Tully will approve of that.

Comment on this

I would draw Deputy Barry's specific attention to paragraph 146:—

"That all fees in connection with coursing and breeding, as defined by the Irish Coursing Club and approved by the control board, be paid to the Irish Coursing Club—any member of the Irish Coursing Club or of the Executive Committee to have the right of appeal to the control board in regard to the ultilisation or distribution of the revenues of the club."

That is something which has not happened up to the present, but which we think may be regularised. If this board ever comes into being, it will prevent additional or surplus revenue being utilised in the manner in which it was utilised in the past, extraneous altogether to coursing, and ensure that it will be brought back in the manner which Deputy Burke suggests and as the report suggests. They might be able to give better prizes or reduce fees.

"The control board to be entitled to demand out of the Irish Coursing Club funds recoupment of any expenditure incurred by it in respect of coursing or breeding, or, alternatively, the payment of an annual levy to meet possible expenditure arising out of action necessarily taken by the board to deal with abuses in connection with breeding or coursing."

We agree with this recommendation, as we agree with most of the others. This amendment is only a compromise as between not adopting the recommendation or adopting it. It is a compromise; it does not go that far. I do not know whether his colleague has informed the Minister of the suggestion made by Deputy O'Malley. He is, as he says himself, a young member of this House, and he is rather horrified that the debate on this Bill has developed into what we might call a personal slanging political match across the House, not started by this side and not continued by this side. It was all very well for the Minister to attack Deputy MacEntee when he came in here this evening; but the Minister should not forget that, earlier on in the discussion of this amendment, he construed my efforts as meaning something entirely different from what I had in mind, and I think he knows that. Deputy O'Malley's suggestion is: this Bill is becoming very controversial now, and if the Minister persists in hammering through by a Coalition majority a Bill of this nature by rejecting this amendment, he is going to have ultimately a Bill which will not be satisfactory and which, as we said at the outset, will some day have to be amended, if and when there is a change as between that side and this side of the House.

Comment on this

If you take as long to amend it as you took to introduce the legislation, it will never be amended.

Comment on this

If the only justification for the non-acceptance of any amendment suggested from this side for the purpose of improving the situation is to be the original sin of not having introduced it earlier, why bring in the Bill at all? Why not let the Minister make a regulation and say: "I take over the whole greyhound industry and I will make regulations as from tomorrow." It might be better that way, because we could raise it occasionally in the House.

I do not know whether the Minister has heard what the suggestion was. Deputy O'Malley's suggestion was that we should agree to send this Bill to a committee of all Parties of the House and remove it from this open arena and the type of acrimony that we are having, that the committee should seek the advice of every person possible and, if necessary, receive representatives from the various interests and hear them on the matter. Perhaps they may not agree with some of our suggestions which we believe are good; perhaps they will not agree with the Bill as drafted, which the Minister may believe is good. Will the Minister not do that? Will he put the Bill——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should confine his remarks to the amendment. There is nothing in the amendment about sending the Bill to a Special Committee.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not accept the amendment and thereby adopt the general principles of recommendations made to him by the advisory committee? Several pages of the report have been read to-night and probably many more will be read and, by the time the discussion on this amendment concludes, possibly the whole report will be on the records.

I am convinced that there is justification for the amendment in the information disclosed to the House in the report. The report shows the creation and the build-up of funds and their utilisation. I am afraid the Deputy from Louth who spoke was not quite clear as to what the amendment is about. The amendment is to do exactly what he wants, from the point of view of removing from the poorer greyhound owners as much tax as possible in the form of fees. He must not forget, when he refers to the amendment as setting up a commercial side to the greyhound industry, that that is really the purpose of the Bill. The whole idea is, ultimately, to build up a large-scale export of very valuable dogs, which will add to the national economy. This amendment is essential to accomplish that end.

The club already has substantial capital and is assured of very substantial income. The number of greyhound breeders, owners and of those who race dogs will increase as a result of the increase in the income from fees of this club.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has been said before.

Comment on this

I did not say it, as far as I know, on this amendment.

Comment on this

Not less than eight times.

Comment on this

I have said it? In that form?

Comment on this

I would not dare to say the Deputy has said it in that form.

Comment on this

I was beginning to doubt my own capabilities.

Comment on this

The Deputy is too old a dog for the hard road to fall into that pit.

Comment on this

It is rather appropriate to refer to one another as old dogs on this amendment.

Comment on this

They called me a cock robin.

Comment on this

Who did?

Comment on this

Your friends.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 16.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee has read out the part of the report dealing with the funds of the Irish Coursing Club. I am referring to their future position. It is very necessary to enable the board, if the occasion should arise, if they are short of money or if they think this body has too much money, in the words of the report, "to levy on them".

Comment on this

That is the tenth time you said that.

Comment on this

Eight and one are nine, according to me.

Comment on this

The Minister is hearing double.

Comment on this

The Deputy now avows that he said the same thing nine times.

Comment on this

No; I did not avow anything.

Comment on this

The Deputy was accepting the Minister's word—a foolish thing to do.

Comment on this

I am beginning to doubt my sanity. The Minister is suggesting that I said things I did not say at all. If he is right, I must be fit for examination in another place. It could also be the other way around. Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll indicated—not for the reasons adduced here in support of the amendment—that she felt the Minister should accept the amendment. I take it Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll is speaking as an individual member of the Labour Party. I am not suggesting that she is speaking for the Labour Party. Deputy James Tully, I think, is inclined to say that, had the Bill been introduced earlier, he would have agreed with this amendment.

Comment on this

I would not have been here.

Comment on this

No, but if it had been introduced earlier, he would have been in agreement with this type of amendment. Deputy Barry argues against it now, although he is a signatory to the document which urges its adoption. Where is the consistency? Where does consistency begin and where does it end?

When the Minister says, unjustly and unfairly, that this amendment has been given birth in the minds of some of us over here—we are all in accord, so when he accuses one, he accuses all— because of our hatred of some person or persons, does he not realise that there are numbers of greyhound owners, greyhound breeders and persons who run greyhounds on racetracks who are also in our minds, from the point of view of protection?

I said last night that there should be equal taxation for all. For what reason and on what basis is this fourth corner of the four corners that make up the interests concerned in this Bill excluded from taxation, while the other three corners are forced to pay all? Will the Minister answer that? What is the reason? They are the people who are getting the majority of representation in the running of the affairs of the board, although they are people who, according to the report, were not considered competent to run the affairs of the Irish Coursing Club. We are here with our eyes wide open being dragooned into handing over majority control of the board to representatives of the Irish Coursing Club. Yet this report said; "If you set up a board, not one of these gentlemen should be on it."

Now we have the Irish Coursing Club still with all its assets, all its income, and with all the potentialities for future increases in revenue and they are not to be asked to make any contribution whatsoever. They are to be excluded, and on top of that, the other interests are to provide all the money by levy and otherwise. What argument has the Minister against paragraph 146, page 60, of his own report? Is he taking the line that under no circumstances will he attempt to justify his opposition to this amendment? I want to tell him that it is not necessary to accuse people of having particular reasons for saying something or doing something but it does seem strange to me that there is no valid argument from beginning to end in the whole course of this Bill for refusing this amendment. It is one of the most vital matters in connection with it. While there may be some argument against the exact wording of this amendment, the sense of it appealed to Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll. Why does the Minister not agree if he wants to end the discussion to say: "All right, I will do this—I will enter an amendment for Report Stage, if not like this, something similar, to meet to some extent the objections to the section without this amendment?" Will the Minister accept that? Or does he think that the suggestion from Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll comes by reason of some undisclosed hatred for somebody?

Do not forget there are more concerned in the greyhound industry than just the gentlemen of the Irish Coursing Club. There are the members of the Irish Coursing Club in the ordinary clubs, and the Bill tends to secure an increase in owners, an increase in the number of clubs all over the country and increased operations and activities. Yet we are not going to make any defence for those people against charges which will be heavier if this Bill goes through without this amendment. Will the Minister just sit there and take all this mental punishment—I assume he regards listening to us rehashing and discussing this as mental punishment? Will he not say: "There seems to be a reasonable amount of persuasion and I will do one of the things suggested either by Deputy O'Malley or by Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll?" Or are we to be faced with the prospect of seeing people forced into the Division Lobby to vote against something they themselves favour? Will the Minister at this stage agree to any of these suggestions?

Deputy Donegan talked a lot about the position if this amendment were to be accepted and said it would commercialise—I think that is the word he used—the greyhound business, but is not the whole thing for the purpose of commerce?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has already said that. He has already commented on Deputy Donegan's speech.

Comment on this

Not on that portion. He said he was concerned only with the man who had a dog at his heels, who went out for a day's hunting, and he said he was not concerned with any other aspect of it. But surely the whole Bill, if he reads it through— takes a much more comprehensive view of it than that. In introducing the Bill, the Minister indicated its main purpose. The country had suffered considerably by lack of control, by falsification of dogs in shipments abroad——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is certainly getting away from the amendment now.

Comment on this

I am trying to argue as best I can that this amendment is necessary for the simple reason that the board will have to deal with the abolition of all the malpractices which are mentioned in this report. In doing that, it will have to appoint officials, and make certain charges. Up to the present, without this amendment the only income available came from three sources. I say there is a valuable fourth source which would make the board more independent and possibly enable it to enter into much greater activities much more speedily than if the source of income from the Irish Coursing Club is denied to them. That is why I am pressing this amendment.

Does the Minister not yet see that there is any sense in this at all or must we take it that when he gets up—if he gets up—it will only be on a basis of personal abuse, instead of relating his remarks to the discussion on the amendment? I think when we come to read the debate, while some of us have wandered accidentally—with all respect to the Chair—others have made no attempt to keep to the amendment. I ask the Minister to accept this amendment as it is drafted. Failing that, is he prepared, not having accepted the other two suggestions, to say that he will give it further consideration and that the amendment can be reintroduced on the Report Stage?

We are being put in an impossible position by the Minister, if he will not say on an amendment of this nature that he is prepared to think it over so that we can discuss it again on report. If he did that, we could get along to the next series of amendments, some of which do not appear to be very controversial. This, however, is one of the most important and most essential amendments to the whole Bill.

Comment on this

I am sorry, but there are one or two things which, perhaps, have still to be said on this. It is obvious from the speeches which have been made by Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll and Deputy Tully that the arguments here are carrying some measure of conviction. It is unfortunate that we have not been able to convince them completely. I think Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll is convinced that this amendment has merits and she has, in fact, I think, appealed to the Minister—I think he was absent when she was making her speech—to say he will accept it in principle and will bring in an amendment on Report Stage to give effect to it.

Deputy Tully seemed to be in the position that he had a great deal of sympathy with the amendment. I do not see how any unbiassed person, if he pondered over the passages from the report which it was my duty to put to the House, could feel otherwise. There is no justification in ordinary reason for rejecting it. Indeed, the only reason why Deputy Tully could not see his way to speak in a more forthright manner in support of the amendment was that the Bill had not been introduced sooner. After all, we have been out of office for quite a long while.

Comment on this

Not since 1952.

Comment on this

We have been out of office since June, 1954.

Comment on this

For two whole years you did nothing about it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

Surely the purpose of discussion on the Committee Stage is to try and persuade those who differ from one as to the merits of a proposal that the merits do lie with it.

Comment on this

We heard what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully said that he would be prepared to consider this amendment if the Bill had been introduced earlier.

Comment on this

Could Deputy MacEntee get a few of his own members to come in and listen?

Comment on this

The Deputy can bring them in. I am too modest to bring them in. The Deputy can bring them in if he wants to. After all, we believe in the division of labour in this Party. It makes for more economic progress.

Comment on this

I did not know it.

Comment on this

When another proposal is before the House the responsible people will be here to deal with it. As I was saying, it seems to me to be a very flimsy reason for not acting in accordance with one's convictions. I gather from what Deputy Tully said that he had a great deal of sympathy with the amendment and that if it were not for the fact that the Bill had been introduced belatedly he would have voted for it.

Comment on this

Are you going to vote for it? We are all sunk if you do.

Comment on this

In passing, let me remind the Deputy that there is a flour and bread report brought in in 1948 which has not been acted upon.

Comment on this

There is also a Milk Costings Report that we are awaiting.

Comment on this

I would not talk so much about that.

Comment on this

It does not affect me, but there are 20,000 farmers very anxious for it anyway. Has anything leaked out that the Deputy is able to warn me about what is in it?

Comment on this

A most extraordinary argument was advanced by Deputy Donegan who seemed to warn some members on this side of the House out of the arena. He said we had no right to discuss greyhounds at all.

Comment on this

Not much, anyway.

Comment on this

I did not, Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy gave me the impression that because I happened to live in the city I did not know one end of a greyhound from another. Let me tell the Deputy that, unfortunately for my personal fortunes, my family were much too closely associated with greyhounds before the Deputy was born and learned a little bit about them. But whether I was born in the city or in the country, I am entitled, as a member of this House and as representing the people of my constituency, in which there is, by the way, a greyhound racing track, to participate in this Bill and discharge my obligations as a Deputy and give to the House the benefit of any experience or knowledge of the facts I may have in relation to the Bill.

It seemed to me rather unfortunate that Deputy Donegan devoted only very little time to the consideration of the measure. He said that one of the reasons he objected to the amendment was that he did not want to see greyhound coursing commercialised. I may not be using the Deputy's exact words but he did give me the impression that the reason he was not prepared to vote for this amendment was because it would lead to the commercialisation of greyhound coursing.

Comment on this

It would place a levy on the sport.

Comment on this

Of course, that is not the argument the Deputy used. The words he did use were commercialisation of coursing. What, in fact, has been the justification for this amendment?

Comment on this

The House need not worry. I have not the slightest intention of stopping the Deputy.

Comment on this

Is somebody talking in his sleep?

Comment on this
Patrick W. Palmer Acting-Chairman (Mr. Palmer) Fine Gael

I believe the Deputy may be talking in his sleep. It would be better were he to come to the point.

Comment on this

The Chair ought to have courtesy at least. Deputy Dillon was babbling like a brook or a baby and how could I keep my train of thought?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The "Minister", please.

Comment on this

The Minister was babbling like a brook or a baby and it makes it exceedingly difficult for any person to participate in a discussion when this sort of thing goes on all the time. I was addressing myself to the arguments used by Deputy Donegan and I think I am entitled to treat these arguments with some seriousness. He has already said that he objected to the commercialisation of coursing. What is the basis for this amendment except this report? It has been pointed out that the moneys derived from greyhound racing, breeding and coursing, and the general operation of the activities of the club have been used to build up a printing business, to spend £14,000 on buildings, £18,000 on plant, £11,000 on procuring liquid assets and £11,500 on Clounanna. This is the commercialisation of coursing which our amendment is designed to prevent. We want to see these moneys, when they flow into the coffers of the club, used for the purpose of developing the sport and the greyhound breeding industry in the same way as the horsebreeding industry.

The Minister, in the few perfunctory remarks he made on this amendment, referred to paragraph 146 of the report of the advisory committee. I assume I will be in order if I remind the House of what paragraph 146 of that report does, in fact, say. It discusses fees and goes on:—

"The control board to be entitled to demand out of Irish Coursing Club funds recoupment of any expenditure incurred by it in respect of coursing or breeding, or, alternatively, the payment of an annual levy to meet possible expenditure arising out of action necessarily taken by the board to deal with abuses in connection with breeding or coursing."

Then the paragraph goes on to say, and I think it is of relevance here:—

"Equally, however, we foresee that circumstances may arise in which the board might at its discretion decide to make a grant towards the funds of the Irish Coursing Club. Fees paid by applicants seeking licences to be remitted direct to the control board. All fees arising in connection with greyhound racing, e.g. licensing fees, proceeds of levies, etc., would come under the control of the board."

There are two points there.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Was the Deputy quoting?

Comment on this

It is the seventh time he has quoted that paragraph to-night.

Comment on this

It would be unparliamentary of me to say that is a lie. I will just say this is the first time I have referred to paragraph 146 and the record of the proceedings of the House will bear that out. The Minister has said that I have quoted it seven or eight times. That was said in order to put me off my stride, but it will not succeed.

The report says that the control board should be entitled to demand recoupment from Irish Coursing Club funds, and let me say that our attitude towards this Bill is based on the recommendations of that advisory committee. The purpose of this amendment is to provide that the report of the committee, in relation to this matter of allowing the control board to demand out of Irish Coursing Club funds recoupment of any expenditure incurred by the board in respect of coursing or breeding, or, alternatively, the payment of an annual levy to meet possible expenditure arising out of action necessarily taken by the board to deal with abuses in connection with breeding or coursing, will be implemented.

I am sorry, but I am tired and am subject to a certain degree of irritation because of the Minister's remarks. My purpose at the moment is to point out that the advisory committee recommended that the board would be empowered to look for a levy from the club and that such a levy would be such an amount as the board would consider reasonable, taking everything into consideration. That is all we are asking here in this amendment. All the amendment seeks is that the Minister might accept the two recommendations contained in paragraph 146 of the report, that, foreseeing that circumstances might arise in which the board might, at its discretion, decide to make a grant towards the funds of the Irish Coursing Club, power would be given to the board to do that. These are reasonable proposals.

Being quite frank about it and being accused of having some personal motive in this, I will say that I am concerned by the fact that the Minister has turned down the recommendations of the advisory committee in toto, because, after all, one of the things the committee did foresee was that the board might have to make some demand when exceptional expenditure might arise out of action taken by them to deal with abuses in connection with breeding or coursing. It would almost appear that the Minister was reluctant to allow the board full facilities for discharging that responsibility. I do not think there is anything more I can add on this amendment, except to suggest once more that it carries a certain degree of conviction. It also seems to have secured a certain amount of agreement from the other side of the House.

Despite anything that may have occurred earlier in the evening I would press the Minister—of course, any pressure from me is unlikely to be effective—to give consideration to this proposal. I would suggest that, if he is not prepared to accept this amendment, he should introduce an alternative proposal on Report Stage, under which circumstances we would withdraw this amendment and allow the debate on the section to proceed. If he is not prepared to go so far, perhaps he might consider between now and the resumption of the debate the suggestions which have been made by Deputy O'Malley that the Bill might be treated as non-controversial and referred to a Special Committee, where these things could be thrashed out around a table and where there could not be the suggestion that Deputies trying to discharge their public responsibilities are actuated by unseemly and unworthy personal motives.

I myself would be very anxious to serve on such a committee, together with other members of the House, and I think I could say the same for Deputies Briscoe, Walsh, O'Malley and the other Deputies who have spoken on this amendment. We certainly did not want the position to arise where the things that have been said in this debate in the House would be blazoned publicly abroad. We like to discuss these things in committee around a table and to come to a reasonable agreement about the controversial parts of the Bill. I hope something I have said may induce the Minister to change his attitude and to approach the Bill in the spirit in which we had intended it would be approached.

Comment on this

May I appeal to the Minister to reconsider this amendment and, in reconsidering it, say to the House, in view of the consistent arguments he has heard in its favour: "I have decided to meet the wishes of the Dáil in this matter." The Minister was very gracious to me in the case of two other amendments, and I say to him now that, in view of all the arguments to which he has listened, and in view of his greater enlightenment, he should decide to accept the spirit of the amendment. We are here only to do one job——

Comment on this

Obstruction.

Comment on this

We are trying to be as fair and reasonable as we can. We are trying to consider this matter completely on its merits. If he argued completely on the merits of this amendment, not alone would the Minister make his position clear but he would clarify a lot of the ambiguous statements that have been made in this House and outside it. In clarifying a lot of the ambiguous statements that have been made from time to time about responsibilities and about the responsible body we are speaking of in this debate, not alone would the Minister contribute something to the industry but he would vindicate the Irish Coursing Club. The one thing that could be done would be to say that if the Irish Coursing Club are in the position of making considerable profits what better way is there of improving the industry with these profits, or what better use could any other board make of both the Irish Coursing Club profits and the board's profits, than that they should go back into the industry. That is all we are asking for. It is a reasonable request. I do not see anything wrong with it.

I may be misquoted. I have no axe to grind on this measure. Looking on the merits of the amendment as it stands, judging it from every aspect, we are merely trying to improve the industry. We have a long way to go. I should like to see the greyhound industry built up so that it will be worth something to the nation and to the individual. We have not many wealthy philanthropists in this country who will just run greyhounds for the sake of the sport. We all did a bit of that in our young days but, if you are rearing greyhounds, you expect some return. Very few people keep a racehorse without expecting something from feeding and rearing and training it. The same thing applies to the greyhound.

We now have a wonderful opportunity of doing something worth while to improve the industry for the benefit of the individual and of the nation. The only way in which that can be done is by putting money back into the industry. The Minister has often said to me in this House on debates on agriculture that certain profits should be put back into the land to try to increase its fertility. The same can be said here about the greyhound industry. We could speak for days and days on this matter but I appeal to the Minister——

Comment on this

A day, did the Deputy say?

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to consider this question again. I appeal to him to end this discussion on the amendment and to say: "I am going to consider this amendment on the Report Stage. I shall try to meet the wishes of the people of the country."

Comment on this

The Deputy is on the wrong side of the House.

Comment on this

The day will come when I shall be on the right side again. Deputy Tully is trying to draw me away from this very important amendment.

Comment on this

I am trying to bring the Deputy back to it.

Comment on this

It is well to have a light heart.

Comment on this

May I again appeal to the Minister to consider this amendment on the Report Stage? Can the Minister not say to the House that he will do that?

Comment on this

May I say to the Deputy that I still believe in parliamentary democracy—and I have had no bigger strain on my belief before.

Comment on this

Even when you were a Blueshirt?

Comment on this
Patrick W. Palmer Acting-Chairman (Mr. Palmer) Fine Gael

Deputy Burke is in possession.

Comment on this

Being another believer in parliamentary democracy, I appeal to the Minister's good sense of judgment to consider this very fair amendment. For the life of me, I cannot see where this amendment will injure or take any honours or power from the Irish Coursing Club. If I thought for a moment it would injure a body with which I have been associated for a long time I would not appeal here to the Minister to put this matter right. However, I am fully convinced that it is in the national interest to do so, otherwise we should never have put down this amendment. We have gone into all these things completely devoid of any personal bitterness towards any section or individual, good, bad or indifferent. We had to consider everybody concerned with the greyhound industry. I have argued here for other aspects of the industry and will continue to do so according as the debate proceeds. If we fail to recognise the individual rights and the individual responsibilities of each section of the greyhound industry then we are not doing our job properly. I am as deeply concerned about the man who has——

Comment on this

One greyhound as ten.

Comment on this

——one greyhound as I am about the man who has 45. I am not forgetting the man who owns a track, or any other owner, the betting man or anybody else concerned with the industry. If we do not approach the matter from that aspect there is no use in our standing up here and trying to improve this Bill. I said to the Minister when I was speaking on this Bill before that I was displeased that this evidence should have been given in private——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

I am only trying to relate my argument——

Comment on this

To half-past ten.

Comment on this

"Until" is the word.

Comment on this

The Deputy has ten minutes to go yet.

Comment on this

If I were not interrupted so frequently, I might have finished sooner.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Another 40 seconds are now gone.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We thought some of the Deputies were not sufficiently briefed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Burke has nothing further to say——

Comment on this

I have, but it is very difficult for me to continue because of the continual rude interruptions. This is a very serious amendment.

Comment on this

What is it about?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Has Deputy O'Higgins not got a copy of the amendment?

Comment on this

I am not sure which one the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

Section 26, amendment No. 16.

Comment on this

What does that say?

Comment on this

I will tell you now in a minute.

Comment on this

It is at the top of the page.

Comment on this

The amendment reads:—

"(5) The board may require the club to contribute towards the general expenses of the board to assist it in fulfilling its functions under this Act such proportion of the net revenue of the club as in the opinion of the board is reasonable."

Comment on this

What does net revenue mean?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! There must be no cross-examination.

Comment on this

I am not in court at the moment. I am merely in the Dáil, but I suppose the Deputy has to have his innings. I say again, in all seriousness, that I cannot understand why the Minister cannot change his mind. We have tried to enlighten him and help him in any way we can.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said that on at least five occasions.

Comment on this

We will help him in every way possible. The people interested first tried to put this greyhound industry on its feet in 1916—that was the Irish Coursing Club—and they went a long way towards doing that. We have now the first opportunity offered of trying to improve the work they did, and the only way to try to improve anything in my estimation is by co-operation. We have passed an Act here to help many an industry and many an individual, from Social Welfare Acts to other Acts. We have tried to help the farmers, the industrialists and various others. I do not see why we cannot approach this problem as the Dáil should approach it, namely, by trying to put more money back into the industry. I do not see why we should not try to eliminate the suspicions that have been cast from time to time on the Irish Coursing Club. I hope the Minister will say to the House: "I will consider this amendment and I will introduce an amendment on the Report Stage to meet——"

Comment on this

He is back again on the old theme.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said that on many occasions. I do not think he should say it again.

Comment on this

I am grateful for the Chair's indulgence. I am so anxious about the greyhound industry, may I claim the Chair's indulgence for a few moments more——

Comment on this

Six minutes!

Comment on this

——to make an appeal——

Comment on this

To the Minister to reconsider it.

Comment on this

——to the House: if there is anything contentious in this Bill, could we not consider it away from the atmosphere of the House? Could we not have a select committee of the House to consider the whole Bill again?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That cannot be argued on this amendment.

Comment on this

May I say that I am trying to get over the contentious points that have been raised in this Bill, according to the Minister? The only way I can see of getting over them is by supporting the other Deputies who have suggested from time to time here to-night that we should have a select committee of the House to go into the Bill, a committee at which we would be free from interruptions and free to express our own personal opinions, in an effort to find out what is the best we can do and at which we could ask ourselves whether what we are doing is in the best interests of the industry. Are we fair to the Irish Coursing Club? Are we fair to the Irish greyhound breeders? Are we fair to the racetrack owners? Are we fair to the bookies? I have listened to the debate since it started. I must say it is very hard on any Minister listening to a discussion like this in committee. If we were sitting in a select committee around a table, I am sure we would eliminate many of the misunderstandings that have arisen here.

There is another aspect of this matter. It was alleged on one or other side of the House to-night that we are making a Party issue out of this. There are as many people on this side of the House associated with the Irish Coursing Club and its governing body as there are on the other side. The Irish Coursing Club is not by any means the bailiwick of any political Party, one way or the other, and those who try to make it so should not do so. Our only concern here is to be fair to everybody, and the only way I can see that will ensure our being fair to everybody is if the Minister, if he cannot consider the amendment proposed or accept the amendment, will at least accept my suggestion to have a select committee of the House. We have had select committees on various other Bills from time to time.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss the question of select committees on this amendment. There is nothing in the amendment dealing with select committees.

Comment on this

No, but I claim the Chair's indulgence again.

Comment on this

It is plenary by this time.

Comment on this

I am merely trying to relate my remarks to this amendment and help the Minister in every way I can. In trying to help the Minister to do the best for the industry, I am merely making all the suggestions I can so that he may bring in a Bill in relation to which future Ministers for Agriculture and future Deputies, when we have passed on, will be able to say that the present Minister for Agriculture, Deputy James Dillon, introduced a very fine Bill when he was in office. I think that the Minister should——

Comment on this

Reconsider the matter all over again.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Burke's piece. The Minister should not say it.

Comment on this

The Minister will not consider the amendment, but at least he can——

Comment on this

Reconsider the matter all over again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I have heard that said 42 times to-night and, for variety sake, I am trying to introduce a new note.

Comment on this

You could modify it. Could you not do that?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister could modify it.

Comment on this

I am not satisfied yet, because I feel that the Minister—

Comment on this

Might reconsider it all over again.

Comment on this

——will change his mind.

Comment on this

Surely, it is time to say it once again.

Comment on this

There is no necessity. This is a very serious——

Comment on this

Deputy Burke has convinced the Minister now.

Comment on this

This is a very serious position for the industry.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy: what does he wish the Minister to do? Is it to reconsider it all over again?

Comment on this

That is the fourth time the Minister has said that. That is repetition.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to accept the amendment or accept the other suggestion to have a committee of the House.

Comment on this