Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance—(Resumed).
Contributions 1–115 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When the House adjourned last week, I was attempting to state as clearly as possible that the difficulty which we now face is due in no small measure to the political climate of this country, encouraged by the members of the present Government ever since 1948. They started a habit of mind among our people—or, should I say, among 50 per cent. of our people—which has never yet been arrested, a habit of mind of believing that everything could come relatively easily, so long as money was played around with and so long as the Government appeared to be making things easy for the people by taking action which, at the time, seemed very generous and helpful, but which, if examined carefully, would be seen to be of a temporary character.
I have been trying to look back through the records of the Dáil to see whether at any time a Minister of real importance understood the position of this country since 1948 and warned the people. I speak of a Minister of the Coalition Parties. I discovered a statement by Deputy McGilligan, which he made at the time of the 1951 Budget, and which remains the solitary and sole statement by a Coalition Minister, made at any time between 1948 and the present day, in which there was an element of realism about our trading position, about the care we should exercise in making promises to people that they could vote themselves better living standards. Deputy McGilligan, at column 1884, Volume 125, in the course of the Budget statement, said:—
"Making all allowance for the exceptional conditions now obtaining it is to be feared that we are not producing and earning enough to pay our way. The implication is obvious. We cannot have both consumption and capital development on the present scale unless we save more and produce more. Additional saving would ease the congestion that now exists and causes consumer demand to seek an outlet in imports. It would relieve the pressure on the balance of payments and help confine external disinvestment—or surplus imports —to what is needed for home development."
Since the time Deputy McGilligan made that speech, which was a very definite abbreviation of the Central Bank report, everyone on the Coalition side vilified the Central Bank and went as far as they could to deny the truth—the solitary truth—uttered by Deputy McGilligan in 1951, when exactly the same circumstances were occurring as are occurring now, and when everybody realised that the position would have to be extremely carefully watched from that time onwards, if we were to make quite sure that our trading position was secure and that our ability to buy imports, without borrowing from the British banks and without going on our knees to foreign trading interests, was to be safeguarded.
Two volumes later in the Dáil Report, Deputy McGilligan reverses his opinion—I do not know whether at the instigation of the Labour members of the Coalition or for what reason. In column 1717, Volume 127 of the Official Report, Deputy McGilligan said:—
"If people who have reserves want to spend them, why should they not do so? Have we not got at least to that degree of liberty in this country where a man, if he has a few hundred pounds and wants to buy a wireless set with it or improve his house by putting in a wash-basin or by putting in new carpets or furniture, is at liberty to do it? What is the merit in preventing him from doing it? We are getting completely authoritarian if we say that even the owner of savings who has reduced his consumption at an earlier period in order to get those savings cannot put those savings to some purpose which he considers advantageous if not profitable to himself."
I could go on repeating statement after statement made by the members of the Coalition Government repudiating what Deputy McGilligan said on that solitary occasion and clearly indicating that they were not prepared to tell the country the true position.
I have tried to summarise the things that the people have been taught since 1948 by Coalition members—the things that roughly one-half of the people of the country believed judging by election results. I am glad to say it was not the whole country, or we would be in a far graver position than we are in now. I should like to catalogue this collection of economic nonsense which has been our lot ever since then.
The first is that living costs are largely the responsibility of the Government; the second is that subsidies involve no taxation and come from the moon, and that no one need ever question the amount required for subsidies, or what the effects may be if the amount required in taxation for subsidies is excessive; the third is that, when costs go up, salaries and wages automatically go up. It does not matter how far they go up; that so long as they keep going up the country is well off and all will be well; the fourth is that, when you promise to bring the cost of living down with a bang and cannot do it, if you get wages raised, you have fulfilled your promise and your political conscience is at rest; and the fifth is that, if you have huge sums invested, there is no danger of their liquidation: that you do not need to worry about them: that the reserves are so large that you can completely disregard them.
We can use them to build up a stockpile out of your foreign investments and if you do not replace the foreign investments, it does not matter. Secondly, we can use them for the importation of raw materials to be used for current industrial production. If we import the raw materials in large amounts and do not replace the foreign investments, it does not matter and the nation is no worse off. Thirdly, we can import them for consumer goods. We can buy refrigerators. It does not matter. It is all putting money into circulation, helping the people and increasing the flow of trade. The consequences mean nothing.
I am not going to weary the House by quoting from statements made ever since 1951 in which members of Fine Gael and the Labour Party never could make up their mind quite how much of the appalling nonsense talked by Deputy MacBride on the subject of national credit and foreign investments they were prepared to believe. They dillied and dallied, some going a certain distance, others going the full distance.
Deputy Declan Costello is a young Deputy and one would like to regard him as likely to reach ministerial status some day. I have been reading his speeches, but he could not resist, with all his knowledge of economics, the statement that he believed in selling out our foreign investments for consumer goods. He thought, on the whole, it was a good thing and that, in some mysterious way, it would raise the permanent level of prosperity. If the result was that we could spend less money on fertilisers and agricultural machinery and less money on increased production, once these savings had gone, somehow or other everything would be all right, somewhere or other some cat would come out of the bag and once more we would see the country well off—a mysterious economic doctrine which has no following in any intelligent or well-known country in Northern Europe.
The members of the present Government will find none of their views since 1948 genuinely believed in either by socialist administrations or conservative administrations in Northern Europe. They will find that the only real philosophic originator of all this doctrine is Deputy MacBride and the Clann na Poblachta Party. He started the whole thing and the Coalition Government has been following him ever since.
The seventh doctrine that has been taught the people is the fact that, if you have some £400,000,000 invested abroad, you need never even speak about our liabilities abroad. The fact that we have anything up to £250,000,000 of liabilities abroad need never be mentioned. It is not convenient. It is much more convenient to give the people the idea that these foreign investments can be liquidated the moment anybody feels slightly uneasy, to relieve the situation. The people have been taught never to think of the liability. It does not exist. It is a shadow liability and no one need worry about it.
We often tried to stress it. It is a curious thing that in all the debates I have read during the past two years —I have been going through a lot of them—no serious Minister of the Coalition Government who really studied foreign finance has ever deliberately and actually contradicted the statements made by Deputy de Valera that the actual total public and private net balance of foreign investment is something between £100,000,000 and £125,000,000, involving less than one year's imports. Some of the lesser fry indulged in a lot of fantastic economic nonsense about what could be done, but I noticed that some of the more serious Ministers have not actually contested that statement, and whether they felt they could not go as far as denying it or conveniently forgot it, I do not know, but at all events the statement remains uncontradicted, even by the Minister for Finance in his speech dealing with the Vote on Account after Deputy de Valera had expressly stated that in the North Kerry by-election in an important speech which he made. As I have already stated, the balance is not as large as has been taught to the people by the Coalition Government. We can only count on the "get-atable" foreign investments of the commercial banks. We cannot touch the private assets which are of no use to anyone for immediate trading purposes.
The next statement made—No. 8 in this category of nonsense—is that bank advances are rising; that it does not matter how much they rise because it is always good for the country. It can only mean prosperity. It may not mean that some people are borrowing that much money and leaving too little money available which might assist in increasing production. The country's economic progress since 1948 has been judged glibly by the Coalition Government, among other things, simply on the basis of by how much the bank advances rose, without ever questioning whether it might not be that certain people were borrowing money at other people's expense.
The next doctrine, No. 9, was that so long as the amount of money in circulation goes on rising it must mean that the country is well off. If plenty of money is circulating, if the Central Bank announces that another £5,000,000 is in circulation, that automatically means prosperity, that automatically means we are paying our way, that automatically means that the country's financial position is sound.
The tenth doctrine is that it does not matter if exports fall or if there is a recession in trade or that money spent on every kind of venture that is not productive can continue to be spent. It does not matter if exports fall and it does not matter about our having to pay for all the materials which we must import for capital purposes. You can go ahead and, when you require money, you can ask the country to lend it to you. It is always good to go ahead with the programme: nothing can stop it.
The eleventh doctrine is that an increase in industrial production, however good it may be at giving employment, must automatically be a proof that the country is doing well. It does not matter if some of the production increase involves such heavy imports of materials that the actual nett good done by it, while excellent from the long-term point of view, is barely helping the country at a time when imports have become so important and so much a factor in our economy that you cannot just boast that our production has gone up and that, therefore, trading is all right. You can say that industrial production is excellent from a long-term point of view. New skills are brought into the country. Employment is provided in rural districts. They are a sign of good times in the future but one cannot say that an increase in production of that kind automatically helps us in relation to our capacity to pay our way. It may, later on, but not in the immediate sense.
Lastly, and perhaps the most important point, in the twelfth, we have heard the fraudulently dishonest doctrine that agricultural production has increased so much since the war that everything is all right—so long as Deputy Dillon remains Minister for Agriculture. I do not think I need repeat here all the figures that have been given many times about agricultural production or the fact that it remains, under our Government and under the Coalition Government, a most frighteningly serious problem. From the point of view of agricultural production, 1947 was the worst weather year in our history. When Deputy Dillon boasts of an increase in agricultural production he selects 1947 for the purpose of comparison. Why, for example, would he not take 1945, after the end of five years of war, or 1939 or 1926 or 1911? If he did, he would find that the increase in production has been very small indeed. He chooses to take 1947 when production had gone down in the previous two years by 12 per cent., as everybody knows, because of the appalling two years of weather that were the main feature of our agricultural life at that time.
When Deputy Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture, chooses to say that agricultural production has gone up by 24 per cent. since 1947, it is arrant nonsense to quote this as proof of how well the country is going and of how perfectly the Coalition Government policy has succeeded. Even Deputy Dillon's statement about the number of young cattle in the country is wholly fraudulent. On the figures, you will find about half a dozen occasions from 1926 onwards when there were 1,000,000 cattle under one year in this country. The figures for the last full year are in respect of 1955. In that year there were 1,044,000 in the country. That represents a very welcome increase but it is fractional. It is nothing to justify Deputy Dillon's saying that he has very nearly solved the agricultural problem. The people in the country have come to believe that. So long as the price of cattle went on going up, they felt that everything was all right.
Other Coalition Deputies have been comparing the costs of cattle in 1939 and now as if that were automatically bringing in some enormous gift of prosperity to the country, without counting any of the other items that make up the total balance—items such as increased wages and salaries and increased import costs. They speak as if we would never have to face any balance of payments difficulty. It is all a fraud and a delusion.
The Minister for Finance made a very gentle academic statement—very quiet and mild—about the balance of payments. I do not know whether he imagines that the ordinary man in the street understands these facts or whether it is possible to talk about the balance of payments in just one speech on the Vote on Account, after having defrauded the people for years about all these matters. Why does he not indulge in exactly the same sort of publicity as he did during the 1954 Election? The people who have received these millions of leaflets about 1951 and 1954 prices deserve to be treated by the Minister for Finance with another 1,000,000 leaflets in which the Minister should, in plain and simple language, print the dangers and difficulties we face and in which he should answer some of the questions he has not yet answered in his speech on the Vote on Account.
It is always easier to take the offensive by making easy promises than it is to defend a difficult policy. That was the position in which we were always placed by the Coalition. Offence— making easy promises—is much easier than defence—explaining the complicated pattern of a nation's economy. How much easier it is for Deputy Sean MacEoin, the Minister for Defence, to go down to Longford and talk about the £500,000,000 we have invested abroad than it is for me to go there and, off a platform, to people standing waiting after Mass, to explain to them the character of our economy—the huge imports from countries other than England to whom we sell practically nothing, the complicated pattern of our investments in Great Britain, our liabilities, the annual burden imposed upon our balance of payments, all the items that go to make the whole Budget.
Does the Minister for Finance imagine that, having had his colleagues talk this nonsense throughout the country for the past three years, he can now explain to the worker, to the machinist, to the small farmer who has much too much to do to study economics, that he is unsaying everything he said? We need another 1,000,000 leaflets with all these explanations.
I would repeat again what Deputy Lemass said here the other day. I ask the Minister for Finance to explain to the people in his closing speech the following matters, to give the answers to the following questions in language which every single person can understand. The first question is: why have imports increased so largely in 1955? What is the reason? Why have imports gone up, over and above any question of stock-taking or any other temporary thing? Why have they gone up, even allowing for any increase in the price of the commodity? What is the reason? I dare the Minister for Finance to be honest enough to tell the people specifically, in language they can understand, why imports have gone up. If he tells them, then we should at least have arrived at the position that everybody in Ireland will believe what is the truth. If we are forced ourselves to go around the country giving these answers, there will still be the difficulty that the whole people will not accept the position as it is. So, we challenge the Minister to give a clear and succinct answer to that question: why have imports increased? The Minister, I know, will be very embarrassed when he gives the answer if he gives it honestly, explains it in detail and makes perfectly clear to the people what the import of the answer is.
The second question we should like to ask the Minister is this: why is it that it is not easy to secure credit for industrial or productive ventures at the present time and that the rate of interest has gone up? Why is it that, in spite of all that the Minister for Finance said about rates of interest, in spite of all that the Minister for Agriculture said when he talked of banana republics, and although there is a desperate urgency to increase production, the Minister is unable to take any special steps to maintain an exclusively lower rate of interest for productive purposes even although he himself says that the demand for increased production is tremendous? What is holding him back? Will he explain to the people and give them a succinct answer to why it is impossible for him to discriminate between rates of interest for one purpose and another purpose? Will he justify his decision? Will he justify his failure to do the one thing that he could have done to live up to some of the frantic nonsense that has been talked in these last three years by saying: "Well, we have got to expand production; the emergency levies are only part of the answer. I will now make available £X million of capital to anyone who wants it at 3½ or 3 per cent. — some interest far lower than that available at the present time." I should like to ask the Minister that question.
I think the Minister should explain also to the people in very clear language what he considers to be the current balance of trade position, to go a little more into detail about it. It will not do any harm. The whole country has been very much shaken by these emergency levies. Everybody has started thinking about it. Now that we know that all the nonsense that was talked before is accepted as such, let the Minister for Finance turn over a new leaf and tell us how he regards our external reserves, what he considers to be the total amount of available liquid assets in Great Britain with which we have to carry on our day-to-day trade and finance our purchases from areas to whom we sell relatively nothing in return. Let the Minister for Finance take the people of the country into his confidence. Let him at last give what he considers to be the figure. He will quickly remove the £400,000,000 by itself — that large comfortable, fat sum will not emerge from the Minister's lips any further so long as this Government is alive — but he might perhaps go more into detail and explain to the man in the street just exactly what the position is.
Let him explain to the man in the street the answer to another question: Why it is that every time the Government spend money imports increase and that every time the Government borrows money imports increase and, no matter what they borrow it for, even if they borrowed it to spread on the land limestone made in this country, there would be some increase of imports, not enough to be worried about but there would be some. Let the Minister explain to the people in simple language how is it if a Government borrows money and spends it wholly in this country that, nevertheless, inevitably, imports will increase as a result of their spending.
We have heard nothing of that kind from Coalition Ministers up to now. We want to have them explain these difficult facts. It is much easier for the Coalition members to promise to reduce the cost of living from the 1954 to the 1951 level than it is to explain to the people why it is that every £ of Government money spent must result in some import and when there comes a point when you do not export enough to pay for the imports that we are then in severe economic trouble. We should like the Minister to answer that question too.
In conclusion, I should like to say a few words about the relation of the 1952 Budget to the present Vote on Account. A few Coalition speakers have dared to suggest that the 1952 Budget in some way has an effect on the present economic situation and even on the Vote on Account. We want to make it perfectly clear that the present emergency levies and any other measures that are taken by the Government are in addition to the 1952 Budget. When the Government came in, if they thought the 1952 Budget was wrong, they should have reversed it. There was nothing to stop them. We never heard any comment from any Coalition Minister——
Comment on this
— as to what they would like to reduce in the way of Government expenditure in order to overcome the difficulties of the 1952 Budget. They have not even told us the expenditure they would like to reduce but which they cannot for political reasons. That would be fair enough. If the members of the Coalition Government think that that Budget was wrong, well then, they can be frank and say that when a Government does certain things, engages in certain expenditure, it is impossible politically to reduce it later. Of course, we all know the reason. We know that two-thirds of the voted expenditure consists of social services, of education, of pensions, of superannuation and like items, the reversal of which or the reduction of which would be politically impossible to the present Government.
Indeed, in the course of their policy statements they have indicated that they will increase these services. The educational services are going up. Some of the pensions services have gone up. The Minister for Social Welfare has promised to increase the social welfare benefits. The health expenditure is going up, deliberately decided and approved by the present Government. All those items cover 60 per cent. of the Budget and if they felt that the expenditure was wrong they should tell the public; they should adjust the expenditure. The fact that they have not done so indicates that they know that our Budget of 1952 was inevitable under the circumstances. They have not been able to reduce any element of it by a penny piece. In the case of the remaining services not connected with social welfare, housing, health and allied services, they have not been able to find any extravagance, they have not been able to prove that some of that expenditure was unnecessary and so it is time that we heard a little less about the 1952 Budget. It is time that the ghost of the 1952 Budget was laid by the Coalition Government because, the longer they stay in office the more they justify it by each Budget since 1952. Where there is not any reversal of that expenditure, the more proof there is that the 1952 Budget was sound and right and entirely justified.
I do hope, once again, that the Minister for Finance will take the country into his confidence and will answer the questions as put down by myself and as put down by Deputy Lemass so that the country can proceed to reshape its policy, to reconsider all the fundamental problems of production and export that are involved, so that it will be possible for every single person in this community to think out honestly, unclouded by political nonsense and claptrap, what his part may be in the shaping of the nation.
We have reached a very serious position. I know the present Minister for Finance is utterly unable to promise during this year any marked recovery in that position. He knows very well that, however successful we are in our cattle exports, whatever may be any slight rebound in cattle prices to our advantage, the trade position of this country for the coming year will not be such that he can promise an easy time. He knows that these emergency levies indicate a serious trend which we can overcome with intelligence but he knows that it means that everyone in the country will have to be prepared to think and to reconsider economic policy and the position of this country from its foundation. We can only do that if at least we have all the facts admitted by all the Parties in this House. We have got the present Government to admit that we did not tax unnecessarily; to admit that we did not indulge in flagrant extravagance.
Comment on this
We have got them to admit that the cost of living could not be brought down; to admit that the balance of payments problem was a serious one for the country which could at any time rear its head and require very special and rather drastic action. We have got them to admit all those facts and if we could get the Minister for Finance to answer the questions that I have posed and that Deputy Lemass has posed about the character of the crisis we would be going very far towards being able to have debates in this House conducted in an atmosphere of reality in which we of Fianna Fáil would not always be trying to drive away shadows.
If all the time spent in this House in talking about the cost of living had been spent in talking about savings or about production, or about where to get money for more fertilisers; if all the time taken in this House talking about the cost of living had been taken to talk about the reorganisation of the pig industry; if the Ministers of the present Government had acted as deputy-lieutenants for the Department of Agriculture and had gone around for themselves to see what was wrong with the pig industry we would be a very much happier people to-day. If the hundreds of millions of our savings lost in 1951 and 1955 had been spent on fertilisers we would not be worrying to-day about the cost of bread or the price of the pint or the price of the poor man's tobacco.
Comment on this
There are many temptations to follow Deputy Childers when, in 1956, he now attempts what I think the House can feel is a very halfhearted effort to explain the 1952 Budget. The views of the country on the 1952 Budget were adequately demonstrated in 1954. I think while Deputy Childers may say that he alone is right in his ascertainment of the need for and the correctness of that Budget, the collective judgment of the people has been given on that issue and it has been a rather harrowing experience for Deputy Childers to witness the consequences of that judgment. But I am not going to be tempted into following Deputy Childers along that course. In so far as he says the situation now demands a cold and realistic approach to the whole problem, I am all in favour of accepting that view of the situation as it is now presented to us.
The situation to-day demands hard thinking and cool thinking and both sides of the House will be the better of attempting to appraise the situation as critically as they can, because there are economic factors surrounding the whole position which will not be eliminated merely by endeavouring to discuss this Vote on Account or the balance of payments problem on a political basis. The fact remains that we have a balance of payments problem to-day.
A balance of payments problem in itself is not serious if we have the balance of payments problem for only one year or two years, if we can see the extent of it and the duration of it. The problem always is to ascertain whether a balance of payments deficit is explained by certain abnormal and nonrecurring considerations or whether it is an indication of a trend which if not arrested will, in the aggregate, present the country concerned with a problem the solution of which may involve a rather painful process of self-regulation by the people of that country.
It is desirable, therefore, I think, to examine the situation as we find it to-day. There has been, over the past 12 months, a fall in our exports. Nobody can deny that; the facts are there and they speak for themselves. The fall has been mainly in the agricultural sector of our economy where there has been a substantial drop under certain headings in that field of exports. I share the view of the Minister for Agriculture, as expressed in this House last week, that this nation is going to go through a painful process unless we can manage not only to avoid the drop in agricultural exports but unless also we can step up the volume of our agricultural exports and unless the whole nation can get from the land and from agriculture some return for the very substantial sum of money which has been spent in a whole variety of directions in the agricultural sector of our economy.
We have had, as I said, a fall in our exports mainly in the agricultural sector; we have had an increase in imports, but some of these imports are easy to understand and are easily explained in so far, for example, as they involve the importation of increased quantities of tea, increased quantities of wool or in so far as they involve imports of machinery and railway vehicles, and they are not unhealthy imports. In some cases, they may represent stocking up from a position where stocks were allowed to run down, but when you get a combination of a fall in exports and an increase in imports, the whole thing spilling out into the financial arena in the form of a deficit of £29,000,000 in the balance of payments, then the nation must take stock and see what is to be done with a situation which discloses unhealthy features of that kind.
If this deficit of £29,000,000 were just a deficit which could be confined to one year or to a slightly extended period, the problem would not really be so difficult as if the deficit were likely to continue into the second year and its consequences likely to flow over into an even longer period. It is because the Government realises the necessity for dealing with this problem now while it is within manageable proportions that it has come to this House indicating the measures it proposes to take in order to deal with the problem as we see it to-day.
Deputy Lemass, when speaking here, said nobody would criticise the Government for the measures it has taken; in fact, he complained that the measures were not sufficient to deal with the problem as he saw it indicating, therefore, that he thought the Government should go further. But other speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches complained that these measures were penal measures which would inflict great hardships on the people. If we were to follow the advice tendered by Deputy Lemass when speaking then we would give the people more of the hardships about which the other speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches complained.
I think the proposals which we have brought to the House are proposals which will enable us to deal with the situation as we now see it. I think these proposals and other remedies will bring this problem within easily manageable proportions. In that respect we are in duty bound to the nation to take such other steps as may be necessary in order to right these infirmities in our balance of payments or general economic position. I think the nation ought to be told through a debate of this kind that we have an imports and exports position which, while basically healthy, has within it certain deficiencies. Our total imports in 1955 amounted to £204,000,000. Our total exports were valued at £110,000,000, so that there was a substantial gap in our physical balance of payments. That has always been the position.
That has been a characteristic of our imports and exports position over the past 30 years. We have been able to bring these into equilibrium by counting as an export such invisible items as emigrants' remittances, dividends on foreign investments — a substantial income estimated variously as being in the vicinity of £35,000,000 added to our export side. Thus we have been able to get over the past 30 years a balance in our balance of payments by bringing all these factors together and producing what was regarded as a fairly sound balance of payments position. It would of course have been much better for the nation, and it must ever be the object of the nation, to create a much better position in our balance of payments. Income from dividends, emigrants' remittances and income from tourism are all good but we must endeavour all the time to reduce the gap between the volume of our physical imports and our physical exports.
That can be done satisfactorily only in one way and that is by stepping up the volume of our exports both under the agricultural head and under the industrial head. As far as industrial exports are concerned, we have to remember that we must sell these products in markets which are highly industrialised, where there is a long tradition of industrial craftsmanship and where goods of high quality are made, but I do not think the results on the industrial front are disappointing. In fact in many respects they can be said to have, within a short time, developed encouraging features the further exploitation of which would lead to still more satisfactory industrial development.
If you take 1936 with a base index figure of 100, you find that in March, 1947, the volume of our industrial production was 104. In March, 1954, it was 177 and in March, 1955, it was 182. If you like to narrow the margin and look at the position since this Government came into office last, you will find that the figure in March, 1954, was 177. In December, 1954, it was 194. To-day the figure is at an all time high record, namely 201. When you remember, therefore, that it has moved from the 100 base of 1936 to 104 in March, 1947, and that it is now 201, the highest level of industrial production in those industries producing transportable goods, I think it can be claimed that in the industrial front there has been a progressive increase which has now reached a stage in which it is higher than ever before. There has been no fall back as far as industrial production is concerned. In fact there has been an acceleration of it during the past 18 or 20 months.
Similarly, if you look at the number of persons employed in transportable goods industries, you find that the number employed in March, 1954, taking them in round thousands, was 139,000. In December, 1954, it was 146,000 and in the last quarter of 1955 it had jumped to 153,000. These are substantial figures for an economy such as ours. These figures indicate continuous progress in the industrial field but it may well be that we have reached a situation in which one must be constantly restless about figures indicating increases in the volume of production because the demand to step up production is so urgent and the demand to export goods so imperative that we must, both in industry and agriculture, not merely intensify our production but by every means in our power endeavour to increase our exports.
The fact is, however, that we have to-day a deficit in our balance of payments. What are we to do about it? Fianna Fáil would say we were failing in our duty to do the things a Government should do in the set of circumstances which present themselves to us to-day. When we do something we are accused, as Deputy Aiken accused us here, of imposing hardships on the people by taking a course of action which makes it more difficult to import luxury or non-essential goods. Many of these goods can be said to be luxury goods in the highest concept of that term because many of them are commodities which the world went without up to as recently as 20 years ago, so that they cannot be deemed to be necessary in civilised life to-day. It is questionable indeed whether some of them have contributed to making life better, happier or more stable to-day than it was before these commodities came on the market.
We can take either of two courses. We can let things rest, let us watch with the statistician's mind the balance of payments position, let us work out these figures to our heart's content, draw whatever conclusions we like to draw according to our political views or the side of the House on which we sit, or we can do what intelligence demands we should do, namely, take steps to deal with the situation, a continued deterioration of which would pose for us much bigger and more difficult problems for solution, perhaps in circumstances where the solution would not be so easily found. If we fail to act in the situation now presenting itself to the country then we will be responsible for running down valuable external assets and the danger is that they will be run down for the purpose of importing consumer goods.
I do not mind running down external assets if they run down for the purpose of importing goods for productive or reproductive purposes. If we repatriate our assets in order to provide means of employment here, methods of creating new wealth or methods of finding new sources of wealth then that is all to the good. It is better that our assets should be invested in wealth-creating activities at home, but it is dangerous for us to allow these assets to dwindle merely for the purpose of using them to import non-essential or luxury goods; and it is because the Government does not want to see these assets dissipated on the importation of luxury or non-essential goods that we have taken the step of imposing this special levy on goods, the importation of which we are not anxious to encourage at present.
The plain economic fact is that, no matter what our political view may be, the simple issue confronting us to-day is that, whatever we import must be paid for. Now imports can be paid for in only two ways: by expanding our exports to pay for what we must import in order to sustain and expand the standard of life here, or by running down our external assets profitably invested abroad. If we have not sufficient exports under the category of either visible or invisible, then we can only pay for an excess in our imports by drawing on the credit balances we have abroad. To permit a policy to continue in which we would utilise profitably invested foreign assets on the importation of luxury goods not necessary to sustain life here or the importation of non-essential commodities made in any part of the world would, in my view, be an unwise and imprudent course for any Government to adopt or permit to operate in our economic circumstances, irrespective of what its political complexion might be.
If a stage is reached in which we so run down our investments abroad for the purpose of buying luxury and non-essential goods, then, as certainly as we are in this House to-day, if that policy is permitted to continue and steps are not taken to arrest that policy, we shall arrive at a stage at which, like every spendthrift, we will find there is no balance in the bank and no residue of foreign investments to pay for these luxury imports. If there ever is any danger of that situation being reached, we must quite clearly cut down on the importation of these luxury and non-essential goods, and, if we fail to do that at this stage, we may later on have to cut down on the importation of essential goods, with grievous consequences, for any such cutting down on the importation of such goods must mean a lowering of the standard of living of our people.
If we cannot finance our imports by exports and if we reach a situation in which we have not sufficient external assets on which to draw in order to pay for such imports, then clearly the only course left for us is to borrow; but, if we borrow in such circumstances, we borrow with our hands in financial handcuffs and with no bargaining power whatsoever. We put ourselves in a position in which terms can be dictated to us as to the rate of interest and conditions of repayment, with, all the time, the danger that there might be political tags on moneys borrowed in circumstances which give us no real bargaining power.
Both aspects of these possible courses, either financially or politically, would be dangerous for the country as a whole and I do not think anybody here would desire to see either the good name or the economic or political security of the country put into pawn, no matter what flag might hang over the pawnshop. I think national self-respect forbids us — indeed, forbids all Parties here — to contemplate with equanimity a situation developing in which we would permit our external assets to run down on the importation of luxury or non-essential goods, forcing us to borrow money on terms in the determination of which we would have little voice.
If a situation of that kind were reached, it would represent a frustration of all the ideals for which countless thousands of our people fought, in the belief that, having achieved national independence, they would enjoy and weave for themselves a pattern of economic and fiscal independence as well. I think it must be apparent to everybody who has given even perfunctory thought to this problem that the issue before us is clear. The choice is as obvious as it is possible to make it: we must pay for what we import. That means we must only import those commodities for which we can pay. We have decided, therefore, to cut down on luxuries and on non-essential articles. In that way, we believe it will be possible, with other measures which are in train or in contemplation, to reach a situation in which we will be able to pay by visible and invisible exports for those commodities which we must import. If we cannot pay for these, namely, the commodities which are not affected by the levies announced by the Minister for Finance, then the whole situation will have to be looked at again to see if it is necessary to go further.
I think all Parties will agree that the maintenance of our financial position is the primary consideration in this whole matter; in other words, the nation must realise that, if we cannot pay, then we must not buy. There ought to be no easy appeal to pawnshop economics in order to get away from that proven hard fact, a fact which cannot be blinked if we are properly to appraise the present position. The Government has, therefore, decided to impose special levies on what are described as needless imports in present circumstances. These special levies will continue until such time as we can afford to pay for non-essential goods by methods which will not undermine the economic structure of the nation or affect its financial solvency.
If one looks at the list of commodities affected, I think one will find it difficult to say that the non-importation of them would harm life in this country and the imposition of the levy in a number of instances should stimulate production in Ireland of similar commodities, commodities which are made here to-day but which Irish industrialists were probably finding it hard to sell against perhaps better advertised and better known foreign brands. So that, far from affecting the volume of employment of a worthwhile character here, I think the imposition of these levies in a number of directions will stimulate industrial production here and give our Irish firms an opportunity of getting a bigger grip on the Irish market where their supremacy is being challenged, probably by the supply here of better advertised or better known foreign commodities. It is true, of course, that many people will have to do without the embroideries of life represented by the importation of non-essential or luxury goods, but I do not think we ought to allow that type of individual or even collective vanity to deter us from doing what it is necessary to do in the national interest.
The plain fact of the matter is — as I said before in some debate in this House — that we here live on a rock off the coast of Western Europe. We have not got those immense natural resources which make other countries great in spite of themselves; we have not got the immense quantities of material which can be fabricated and for which there is a world demand. Our natural resources are limited. Probably our best and biggest and most enduring asset is the land of the country — and our proximity to a market which is capable of being used for the immense benefit of Irish agriculture.
So far as raw materials are concerned, our position does not stand comparison with many other countries which have immense resources and diversified resources in these particular fields. We have got limited resources and what we have got to do is to husband these carefully and trade these as carefully as we can in order to buy the essentials of life and the commodities which will give us our present standard of living and, if possible, a higher standard in time to come. The more care we exercise in husbanding our resources, the better life we can provide for our people and certainly the longer they will enjoy it, the more careful we are in the management of our economic and our financial resources.
It is because the Government believe that that course of action is desirable that they have taken the steps to impose these special levies. They are intended to be levies and not an addition to our present standards of protection for Irish industry. These levies will last as long as it is necessary to cut back on luxury and non-essential articles. When the time comes that we can resume payment for these articles in a way that does not endanger our economic or financial position, these levies can go; but until that time has been reached, I think we can momentarily forget our political differences and approach this matter from the economic angle.
Most Deputies will agree that what has been done represents an intelligent approach to a solution of a problem which, if not dealt with, will affect not a Government Party and not an Opposition Party alone, but will affect — and to their serious detriment — every section of the people of this country. Too many efforts have been made down through the centuries on behalf of the people to permit us at this stage to take a course of action which could undo in a few years much of the valuable work that has been done in nation-building for the past 34 years.
We have felt it necessary, too, in the field of hire-purchase to take steps to limit the spending of money in the purchase of articles on the principle of hire-purchase. I personally have no complaint whatever against the idea of purchasing capital goods by means of a deposit and regular instalments, subject to two conditions: (1) that the person does not commit himself to pay to a greater extent than his or her financial resources would enable him to do; and (2) that the person is not so avaricious to get the particular article that, with only a small deposit in his or her hand, he or she will pay an outrageously high price for an article which is shoddy, in which he does not get really good value and where the main temptation to purchase is either its glittering appearance or that other and still bigger danger which is expressed in the phrase "to be as good as the Joneses".
Hire-purchase, however, has in fact taken on a complexion in the past few years that demands that some attempt should be made to cut back, particularly in present circumstances. Hire-purchase, as I have said, is something to which I do not object in principle. Prudent people are enabled to secure goods through the medium of hire-purchase which they could not otherwise purchase. While I think it is legitimate that a person should pay his milk bill and his grocery bill every week, if he is going to keep solvent, it is not necessary that he should buy capital goods every week or stint himself every week in the purchase of capital goods in one instalment, if the domestic life will go on just as pleasantly and as securely by paying for these goods over a period; but I think it will be admitted — I think this is the experience of most of us—that the imprudent purchasing of goods, which is facilitated by hire-purchase methods, is something which is not only nationally bad, but socially undesirable and highly undesirable from a domestic point of view.
Deputies will understand this — a woman with just 10/- in her pocket goes into a firm which has an article priced at £50, but is willing to give it to the woman for the payment of a deposit of 10/-. That woman has just no bargaining power. Whether it is worth £50 or £30, she does not know. All she knows is that there is an article there that she wants. She is most anxious to get it. She contemplates to herself: "What will the neighbours think when they see what I have bought?" Whether it is worth £30 or £50 does not matter — she wants to get it home — and in any case she is not capable of appraising its value. But the £30 or £50 has to be paid back — paid back through a painful process — and one can easily see the domestic and social consequences flowing from the unrestricted development of tendencies of that kind.
But where such a development takes the form of the imprudent purchase of imported goods, it has nothing whatever to commend it. It is bad when the person imprudently buys at exorbitant prices a home-produced article, or commits himself above his ability to pay. What can be said in defence of an arrangement where this imprudent spending — this inability to evaluate goods which are purchased — relates to goods not made in this country? Clearly, there is a case for stepping in at that stage and saying: "Whatever about normal times, in present circumstances, that type of purchasing on the hire-purchase principle should be restricted as much as it is desirable to do so."
This Government has taken steps to ensure that hire-purchase will be brought under control, not by the complete elimination of it but by the regulation of it on a basis which I think will ensure that there must be more prudent buying in future and, in addition to compliance with the regulations for ensuring prudent buying, there will have to be prudent selling as well. The Order which I have made under the Supplies and Services Act, on the subject of hire-purchase, ensures that unless the person selling the goods complies with the provisions in regard to the deposit and the period of repayment, it will not be possible to enforce that contract — which must be in writing — against the person who hires the goods. That is an injection of reality into this whole proceeding which was long overdue and which I hope will remain long after the emergency with which we are now dealing has passed.
One of the problems which has confronted not merely the last Government but this Government, and which I think will be a problem for Governments for some time to come, is the necessity for financing schemes of capital development. If we are to indulge in capital expenditure, even on the basis undertaken in recent years, that can be done only so long as we can find the necessary money to finance this capital expenditure. But if we are going to find the necessary money, then clearly it can be got in the main from our own people only. It is evident, therefore, if we recognise the continual need for capital expenditure, that that must be matched on the other side with continual propaganda to induce people to save and lend to the community, so that the community, in turn, can undertake this capital development work and in that way improve the whole national stake. If, however, we are going to have a situation in which savings drop off, in which money which ought to be saved and prudently invested is spent on the importation of luxury and non-essential goods, then we will not have the necessary savings to finance capital expenditure and if we do not have the necessary capital expenditure we will cut back on highly desirable national undertakings with a consequent substantial fall in the volume of employment.
It is because savings are not now sufficient and, in fact, have not been sufficient for many years, that it is necessary for us, if we are to continue with our policy of capital development, to take stock to ascertain what measures are now necessary to deal with the problem of financing capital expenditure, on the one hand, and to deal with the problem presented by a deficit in the balance of payments, on the other hand. I think it is right and that it is wise and proper that we should say to the people — if possible in this field let us say it with one political voice — that it is nationally and socially desirable that they should save now and that they can do that best by avoiding needless expenditure. If they do that, then we can get all the money we need for the purpose of our capital expenditure projects. We can pay our way as well; we can preserve our financial independence and not be compelled to pay, as we were forced to do, exorbitant rates of interest for any money that it might be necessary to borrow. The Government's efforts, therefore, to encourage savings by the establishment of a National Savings Committee, by making available a new issue of savings certificates, are praiseworthy efforts from the point of view of conserving the national resources or directing those resources into channels which are capable, in turn, of satisfying our most urgent needs and undertaking our most valuable projects.
While these measures have been necessary and represent what it is desirable to do in the position in which we find ourselves, the solution of the problem does not he alone in taking these measures. These measures will arrest tendencies; they may, in fact, remedy a situation temporarily, but these measures represent no permanent solution of the problem which is posed before us to-day. If our people are to enjoy the standard of living which is available to them to-day, if they are to improve that standard of living, it can only be done by a substantial increase in production in the agricultural and industrial sectors of our economy. That increase in agricultural and industrial production must be directed, to a very large extent, with a view to exporting a greater volume of agricultural produce and industrial goods so as to ensure that we can pay for the commodities which we must import if we are to maintain our present standard of living.
We to-day are fated to live in a constantly changing world and in this field of imports and exports various countries have had to adopt various devices. Many countries refuse to make currency available for the import even of necessary articles while they completely refuse to make currency available for the import of luxury and non-essential articles. In other cases, countries have been driven to stimulate industrial exports by such devices as subsidies, by means of extended State guaranteed credits, by means of adjustments in profit margins. All these devices have been found necessary by various countries to deal with the problem of exports and imports as these particular countries saw that problem from their own viewpoint. I think we must be flexible, as flexible as it is prudent to be, in dealing with the problem of agricultural exports and industrial development. I do not think it is a virtue to say to-day that one has the same outlook on agricultural production or industrial production as one had 20 years ago.
Comment on this
Yes, three years ago or even three months ago. We live in a world in which, because of the constant changes over which we have no control whatever, it is desirable to be as flexible as one can be mentally in our approach to these problems and not to rule out ideas merely because they are a break with tradition or merely because they are new. We must not resist ideas and resist a new approach merely because the idea is new or the approach is new. We must mould our approach to the problems as we see them on the basis of what is best for our people. If we have been following practices which have given us dismal results in the past, there is no reason why a claim to steadfastness on our approach to these problems should rule out the consideration of a newer and a more intelligent approach to the difficulties confronting us.
In this situation I think that our immutability of view might be just synonymous with the approach of a period of industrial or agricultural decadence. I think, if we are going to increase exports, whether they be agricultural exports or industrial exports, we must be prepared to endeavour to stimulate that line of policy by the adoption of new methods, which are unknown to us to-day or unpractised by us to-day, and that we ought to be prepared to go the length of, possibly, even advantageous methods of taxation, if it is necessary to do that to stimulate industrial or agricultural exports.
There is one thing that we cannot do — we cannot continue to be satisfied with the present volume of exports under any heading. If we are nationally wise, we will refuse to be complacent with the present situation. We should endeavour to try to remedy it by any method which will give good results, by special consideration, by special reliefs, by anything which will stimulate our exports. The one thing that clearly comes out of all this is that we cannot survive unless there is going to be a substantial increase in the volume of our exports. If Deputies opposite think that they can make political capital out of that, they are welcome to go ahead and do it. I think that, even if they went out to make political capital of it against this Government, they would make it only for a short time and only with certain people. Whether Fianna Fáil or the present Government is in office the problem remains that, unless we can stimulate, and substantially stimulate, our exports, the present standard of living is in danger of falling. Not only is it in danger of falling but, if it does fall, the prospect of reviving it and expanding it may be a particularly difficult and painful process for us all.
In all this matter, there is one other way in which we could make a contribution to the solution of some of our difficulties, and the method available for making that contribution is easy of use and near at hand. In this country we produce — and this is to the credit of Irish manufacturers and Irish craftsmen—a large variety of Irish-made goods. At the same time, similar goods come in from outside, carrying with them a tariff. There are still too many people in this country who buy the imported commodity because they still hang on to the notion that, if it is made outside Ireland, it must necessarily, in their warped view, be better that the Irish-made commodity. Thirty-four years after the attainment of national independence is too long a period to see that type of mentality continue to blossom in this country.
I do not think we offend against good taste — and we certainly do not offend against good economics — if we say to all our people in every sphere of life that there is a national obligation on them to buy Irish products in preference to the products of any and every other country. Every Irish article made here creates new wealth for the nation. Every article processed here provides employment for our people. Every Irish article bought in preference to a non-Irish article helps to cut back in our imports and helps in that way to make a substantial contribution to the rectification of the deficit in our balance of payments. We do not need now to sell Irish goods on the basis of any emotional appeal. We do not need to tell people: "It is not the best, but it is Irish, and buy it." These appeals have not to be made to-day as a means of recommending Irish goods to potential purchasers in Ireland. The quality of our goods, article for article and price for price, is, generally speaking, as good as anything they can get elsewhere. If those who purchase goods from outside would realise that, by buying the Irish article in greater volume than they do, or by not buying the imported article in preference to the Irish article, they could so expand production in the home factories as to conjure up the possibility of even being able to buy the Irish article at a esser price than would be the case where the Irish firm did not supply the entire requirements of the home market.
In any case, those who would buy Irish articles would have the satisfaction of knowing that, by doing so, they were giving employment in Ireland, perhaps to their own sons and daughters, perhaps to their own brothers and sisters. They would be making the employment for their sons and daughters or brothers and sisters in Irish industries more secure by expanding the demand for the products of these factories. They would be recognising that the purchase of Irish goods means more work in Ireland and that it could make a substantial contribution towards redressing our adverse balance of payments. Nobody now is asked to die for Ireland, but if they would even now go as far as—and it is not very far along the road of sacrifice—buying for Ireland, they would make a contribution which would be the counterpart of the struggle of many of those who died for Ireland, believing that they would create an economy in which buying for Ireland would give our people the standard of life that they contemplated.
A summary of the position might be put this way. Savings are vital in order to finance capital expenditure. No matter what are our political views, there ought to be a basic acceptance by all Parties of the necessity for savings in order to finance capital expenditure, to ensure that the capital expenditure programme is not arrested, and to ensure that it will continue not merely to enrich the national estate, develop the nation's resources, but provide valuable employment, which it would provide and which it does provide, for thousands of Irish workers. It should be further agreed that import restrictions in present circumstances on luxury goods and on non-essential goods are imperative in order to redress the adverse balance of payments, that greater production is necessary in order to maintain living standards, that exports must be encouraged and stimulated even by artificial methods, new though they be, and by incentives which are calculated to get the results which we have not been able to get so far. In the long run this country's standards of living will be determined, not by what we hope will happen, but by the measures we take to ensure that these things will happen. Merely wishing that disaster will not occur and that frustration will not crowd our path is not calculated to inoculate us against such difficulties and evils.
If we want to ensure that positive things are done, we have got to go out and do them, even though it may be that for the time being we have temporarily to dislocate our normal pattern of imports or activities in one field or another. The aim, and the constant aim, must be to ensure that whatever is done is done with the object of creating a healthy and enduring economic situation which is in the best interests of our people.
We do not pretend that there is any easy road out of the balance of payments position, but I do not think the road is one outside our competence to travel. I do not think it will require from our people sacrifices, if they are only steadfast in their approach to the problem. I believe that our people, once the dangers are alerted and once the remedies are shown to them, will rise to the occasion and that they will not be found wanting, as they have never been found wanting, in any crisis which threatened the nation. Personally, I do not mind if the Opposition make Party political propaganda out of the situation, but the country, in a situation such as we are dealing with now, will expect responsible leadership from the Opposition, as from the Government, and responsible leadership in the field of Opposition could pay the Opposition good dividends politically in a situation of this kind.
I think there are certain basic difficulties here which are the common problem of both the Government and the Opposition. I think the solution of them will come all the quicker, if there is a general acceptance of the need to take these special measures. I believe the measures which we have taken and the other measures which we contemplate, will, with the enthusiastic support of the people, give us the results that are so necessary economically.
I believe that a detailed examination of the February figures, and even the January trade figures, will show an improvement in certain directions, away from the tendencies emphasised in the trade returns of 1955. I hope the trade returns for the subsequent months will show a substantial improvement in the light of the measures now taken. I believe that the Government has the goodwill of the people in its efforts to apply remedies to the present situation. I would appeal for the widest measure of support from the people for the measures which the Government are now taking in the people's interest in order to safeguard their welfare. I believe we can ride this storm and not only ride the storm but create a situation in many fields of endeavour where we can bring a greater measure of stability into our economic life and a greater measure of development and expansion into our agricultural and industrial activities.
Comment on this
I must say that I am astounded by the speech of the Tánaiste. I remember sitting on the benches over there and listening to him speaking from the benches here in 1951, and at that time he did not talk about responsible leadership from the Opposition, although he was the leader of the second largest Party in it. He expressed a view quite the contrary to what he said to-day. While the position is difficult—we all admit it—for the Government and some action must be taken, it was twice as difficult at that time.
There was twice as big an adverse trade balance and it was not all the making of the Government of that day. It had come about through the action or inaction of the Government of which the Tánaiste was then a member. At that time, we were not told anything about savings; we were not told anything about the treachery of buying unnecessary consumer goods. Everything the Government preached at that time was exactly the same as the Tánaiste has put up now, but at that time it was all wrong. I do not know whether the Tánaiste was really expressing the views he had at the time, but certainly they were not the views he expressed to-day. If that means a genuine conversion, we will all be glad and the country will be immeasurably richer because the way the Opposition of that day treated the position in 1952 and the way they fooled the people cost this country a great deal of money. As Deputy Childers pointed out, in the years 1951 and 1955 alone, it cost this country practically £100,000,000 of wasted assets.
In so far as the measures the Government are taking are measures calculated to deal with the dangerous situation that exists, we certainly approve of them, but, to my mind, they have all the earmarks of every measure of the Coalition. They are a compromise and are not going to be sufficient to deal with this situation. The Tánaiste practically admitted twice in his speech that they did not expect them to deal with the situation and that further measures would be taken.
This situation is due to a large extent to the delay on the part of the Government in dealing with it. The Minister for Finance in his statement opening this debate pointed to the progressive increase in the adverse balance of payments over the whole of last year. Yet, no step was taken. On the contrary, in October last, when the motion of no confidence was put down from this side of the House, we were told that everything in the garden was lovely and, in a Government sponsored amendment to that motion, we were told that it was quite all right to increase wages to meet the rise in the cost of living.
The Taoiseach does not say that to-day; neither does the Minister for Finance. In fact, the Taoiseach at Cork in January spoke about the need to recognise the futility of seeking to offset rising prices by a rise in money wages, unaccompanied by a rise in output. He did not say that in October. We had Deputy Kyne waxing very eloquent to the effect that everything was all right so long as we got a rise in wages to meet a rise in the cost of living.
On page 12 of his statement, the Minister told us that, in the light of the experience of the past year or so, the direct connection between higher wages and still higher prices has been clearly revealed as well as the disturbing effects on the balance of payments of increased expenditure, not matched by increased production. It is my earnest hope that, at least until we have surmounted our present difficulties, there will be stability in money incomes.
Comment on this
He is quoting from the statement of the Minister for Finance when he opened this debate.
Comment on this
For the sake of the country, the action now being taken by the Government is all to the good —and, personally, I am delighted about it—but the Government are singing a tune to-day altogether different from that which they sang in October. Consider, however, what it has cost this country. When in 1951 and 1952 the Fianna Fáil Government tried to take measures to deal with a situation that was twice as difficult they were abused in this House and misuse was made of that situation throughout the country. The people were misled. I would remind the House that our people are only in their infancy, so far as the control of their own affairs is concerned. If we want to educate and rear up a proper democracy in this country then I suggest it was a crime of the first order to go out and mislead them as they were misled in that period. It is easy enough, now that the Government have reached this position themselves, to call for basic agreement. There is no question but of basic agreement. They were always our views. They are still our views. However, when we tried to deal with a similar situation we know how it was met.
We heard Deputy S. Collins speak here the other evening about how our economy worsened under Fanna Fáil from 1951. Deputy S. Collins is quite out of date in following his leader; that was the tune they were singing in 1951 but it is not the tune that either the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance is singing to-day. In Cork, the Taoiseach pointed out that we had reasonable savings in 1952-53—when the people on the opposite benches were going around and deploring the state of the country as a result of the awful Budget of 1952. The Taoiseach pointed out that there were reasonable savings then. There were none last year. It is very nearly time that the people on the Government Benches wakened up and took some action of the kind they now propose to take. It is an outstanding fact, taken over the two Coalition periods, that there was a progressive increase in our adverse trade balance. In 1948, there was an adverse trade balance of £10,000,000. That is reasonable enough; nobody will say anything about that. In 1949, the adverse trade balance was £20,000,000. In 1950, it was £30,000,000 and in 1951 it was £62,000,000. If one likes to read over the Budget statements of the then Minister for Finance, it will be seen that he referred to these adverse trade balances but never took any steps to deal with them.
In this same statement by the present Minister for Finance, introducing this Vote on Account, we are told that in 1954 the adverse trade balance was £5,500,000—and, in the first full year of Coalition Government, it jumped to £35,000,000. Definitely, for the sake of the country, it is high time the people on the Government Benches examined their consciences about what they have been doing in that way, and went a bit further. It is high time they brought us back to the state in which the country was handed over to them on both occasions when Fianna Fáil were leaving office—a state in which the Budget was balanced and in which, within reasonable measurements, the balance of trade and the financial position were correct.
I took a note of something the Tánaiste said while he was speaking. He spoke of "the danger that the deficit would be increased for the purpose of importing consumer goods." The Tánaiste did not always think that way. Let me quote now from Volume 127, column 609, from a speech made by him, as Deputy Norton, on 8th November, 1951. He has been talking about the theories which he expounded himself—theories similar to those put forward from the Government Benches of that day. On that occasion, in 1951, Deputy Norton said:—
"If anybody believes in these theories on economics, he is welcome to them, but I think they are the economics of the mentally deficient."
The Tánaiste is now joining the ranks of the mentally deficient!
Comment on this
Deputy Norton continued, in 1951:
"So long as we want consumer goods or capital goods, we should use our sleeping money, which is being lent to Britain at practically no rate of interest so far, to buy goods, consumer and capital, for the use and benefit of our own people."
To-day he referred to the fact that our money is profitably invested abroad. He had no inhibitions about using any of our external assets for consumer goods then. I recollect quite distinctly that, in the course of that 1951 speech, he made the point that we should get them back because the £ was worth only 10/- and if we left our external assets there much longer the £ might be worth only 5/- and that it would be far better to get them back and spend them. No wonder, I say, I was astounded when I listened to his speech to-day.
The Tánaiste also spoke to us about savings. It is interesting to hear what the Minister for Finance in the last Coalition Government had to say on the question of savings—a matter which has been impressed on us to-day but one which would not be listened to when Fianna Fáil tried to impress it on our people. In Volume 127, column 1717, of the Official Debates, Deputy McGilligan, Minister for Finance in the last Coalition Government, on the question of savings, said:—
"If people who have reserves want to spend them, why should they not do so? Have we not got at least to that degree of liberty in this country where a man, if he has a few hundred pounds and wants to buy a wireless set with it or improve his house by putting in a wash-basin or by putting in new carpets or furniture, is at liberty to do it? What is the merit in preventing him from doing it?"
Do not forget that this same gentleman was referred to as the financial wizard. I wonder what the Government think to-day about that: "What is the merit in preventing him from doing it?" He went on to say:
"We are getting completely authoritarian if we say that even the owner of savings who has reduced his consumption at an earlier period in order to get those savings cannot put those savings to some purpose which he considers advantageous if not profitable to himself."
These are some of the views on savings expressed by the wizard of finance that we used to hear about. They are quite contrary to what we are hearing now from the Government or the present Minister for Finance or what we heard on the wireless last night from the chairman of the Savings Committee that was set up. It shows the lengths to which people on the opposite benches went to try to vilify and impede the Government of that day. Would Deputy McGilligan repeat that speech to-day? If so, I should like to see the reaction of the Government to it.
There is no question about it, in the last few months we on these benches have been completely vindicated—first in regard to the tea muddle, when the Government would not face up to the consequences of the increased price of tea and subsidised tea by loan for nine or ten months. Now the people are paying 2½d. on every lb. of tea they buy to pay for the loss incurred in not facing up to facts at the start. They have to pay, not only the increased price, but 2½d. additional to cover the loss incurred. I do not know for how long they will have to pay that but, presumably, it will be for some years.
Then we had the general rise in prices. We hear nothing now about the poor man's pint being increased and the tragedy that that is. We do not hear anything about the price of tobacco. We do not hear anything about even the ha'penny Budget or the ha'penny that was taken off then, which is more than this Government have been able to do, although they have all the taxation imposed by that so-called infamous Budget of 1952 and the increased taxation that has been imposed since that time. In addition to the £10,000,000 extra taxation then imposed, they had £8,000,000 increased taxation in this year's Budget and they want every penny of it. According to them it was all absolutely unnecessary then and, in spite of that, they were not able to take even a ha'penny off the price of the loaf.
We have been vindicated in that. We have been vindicated in the general rise of prices. Prices could not be kept down by Government action. I was boohed and hissed at the count after the election for telling them that it was not possible for them to do what they had promised. Events are proving that now. All the miracle workers that we had going around at that time claimed to be able to do things that it was not possible to do before but now, when they have the job of doing it, it is a different question and we over here are told we should not say anything about it.
There is to be a different standard of conduct for us when we are in opposition than there was for the people opposite when they were in opposition. We must not do or say any of the things that they did and said. We must not make political capital out of it. It is not a question of making political capital. It is a question of facts and a question of proving that we knew what we were talking about and that the people opposite did not, or else they deliberately fooled the people.
In addition to our vindication in all these matters, there is the complete change in financial outlook of the Government of the day. Thank God, for the country's sake, that that has come and let us hope that their financial mentality will be developed fully in the very near future, for the sake of the country.
Deputies on the opposite benches may say what they like but this is a Supplementary Budget. This will impose taxation. It may be necessary. I am not denying that but I do say that the Government themselves are responsible for a large share of it in allowing the situation to develop so long. It is taxation. It will take away a large slice of the £15,000,000 to £20,000,000 total increases in salaries and wages that the Taoiseach mentioned will have to be faced this year. There is no use in blinking it. I wonder how it was that, when that had to be done, we did not get some of the reductions that Deputy McGilligan promised, when he was speaking as the official spokesman for Fine Gael on the radio just before the election, and when he told us that there were £10,000,000 or up to £20,000,000 there for any Minister for Finance who knew how to go about it that could be saved in taxation. How is it that some of those millions were not used to avoid taking from the workers a large slice of the increases that they have just obtained?
There is another point to which I want to refer. The Tánaiste referred to the growing numbers employed in industry. I want to refer to one point in the last weekly list of unemployed that I have received. I had it here with me but it has disappeared. Perhaps we will get another one—this one shows the same thing and it illustrates the point I want to make. In 1954 the live register on 10th March was 76,278. In 1956 the figure was 70,610, that is, the total figure is down by roughly 5,600. Now when we come to the men on the stamps—mostly city workers, people on wages, excluding females— we find that on 10th March, 1954, the number was 29,797 and, in 1956, the number was 34,488. So that the number of men on stamps, put it that way —the ordinary working men of the towns and the cities—has grown by as much as the total unemployment has fallen.
I think that is a very serious state of affairs. It is all right to talk about unemployment going down, until you examine the details. When you find that it is all men, probably men with families, absolutely dependent on wages, who are suffering, and increasing in numbers, it is a different position altogether. That is a very serious aspect of the present situation as regards unemployment. It has been going on for some months now and continuing to grow, and I do not see anything being done about it.
I do not think I need say much more. I had rather a lot to say, but it will probably be said by others. I am glad that the Government has been converted to the view that a difficult position exists in this country. It has taken them 15 months—12 months from the time they knew it—to wake up to it and I am glad they have now done so. I hope that their education in that respect will progress and that they will deal effectively with the position as they see it developing and that some time they will have the courage to stand up and say mea culpa, mea culpa and admit the damage they did to this country by what they said in 1951 and 1952.
Comment on this
This debate has ranged over considerable territory and I should like, for a few minutes at the start at any rate, to get back to the record of the two Governments in the matter of expenditure. We all know that certain newspapers in this city are continually crying for reductions in expenditure. I believe, personally, that political Parties, in their attitude to Government expenditure, do not change greatly through time. When the Fianna Fáil Party first became the Government of this country, the country was being run for a sum of £22,000,000 and at that time these very same newspapers were complaining that it was costing altogether too much. In fact, never was a campaign on expenditure carried out to the extent to which it was carried out during the years 1930 to 1931.
What happened? Within 12 months, the Fianna Fáil Party had put up expenditure 50 per cent. to £33,000,000 a year, and, before the war, they had pushed it up to £38,000,000 a year. There was no increase whatsoever during that period of six years in either the nominal income or the real income of the country. In fact, at one period—in the middle of it—there was a considerable reduction. The Fianna Fáil Party came back into office in 1951 and I should like to compare the expenditure then, as audited, and as it appears in the volume we have been supplied with, the Estimates for the coming year. Why do I take 1950-51? I take it for the simple reason that it was the last complete year in which Deputy McGilligan was in charge of the finances of this country. The expenditure as audited was £75,000,000 in that year. What had it become when Deputy MacEntee left office? In his last year of office, the audited expenditure for 1953-54—only three years later, remember—was just under £105,000,000, an increase of £30,000,000 a year.
Had any Government ever done that in this country previously? They have certainly not done it since. What is the position since? Let us take the first complete year of office which is to end shortly. The Estimates, including supplementaries—and of course the expenditure will not amount to that at all—total £110,900,000, nearly £111,000,000. It will probably be a couple of million pounds short of that. In a period of two years since this Government took over the expenditure of the State has gone up by a sum of about £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 a year. The Supply Services expenditure, as it appears in this volume, has gone up £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 a year. That does not tell the complete story because there is the Central Fund expenditure also but it gives the picture as no other figure could give it. I want to come back later on to that and I should like the House to bear in mind, when I do come back to it, certain figures about real costs, costs of imports and so on, and to compare that achievement—and it is a real achievement, this rise in expenditure of £4,000,000 in two years—with what? With £30,000,000 in three years.
Comment on this
Surely, it is going up, and the value of money is going down, in case the Deputy does not know it—would that be right?
Comment on this
It did not go down as fast as to go down £30,000,000 on £75,000,000 in the period of three years. It did not lose three-sevenths of its value in the years 1950 to 1953.
Comment on this
The first devaluation was in 1949 and I have read out the expenditure in the following year, which was £75,000,000. If Fianna Fáil were to go back into office again, what could the people expect? I am very glad to say they will not go back into office, but, supposing they did, the people could expect State expenditure to mount at an alarming rate. The people have had that experience already and they do not want it to happen again. What happened actually in this country during the period 1949 to 1953? What I intend dealing with now apertains to both adverse balance of trade and to expenditure. I have here a copy of the British Statistical Abstract and a digest of the statistics shows that, taking materials for the manufacturing industry with the exception of food and coal, the following is the summary of the index of prices; 1949 being taken as the base at 100: In 1950, it was 138.6; in 1951, 193; in 1952, 162; in 1953, 145.8; in 1954, 143.5; and in 1955, 152.4. During the years in which the Party opposite were in office, the prices of these materials went down, down, down.
Comment on this
——is that if you imported the same quantum of goods for manufacturing purposes, you got them at a much cheaper price.
Comment on this
Leave out the "ifs" and leave out the "whats". At the moment we are dealing with the present.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I shall endeavour to answer the interesting point made by the Deputy. In the year 1955, the price index of manufacturing goods was 152.4. I have frequently heard it said on behalf of Fianna Fáil that they came into office in 1951 at a very difficult period. I deny that absolutely. The worst was over when the Party opposite came into office in 1951. The highest price for raw materials was reached in March and April of 1951. Of course, Deputy Lemass subsequently explained that he found on the desk in the Department of Industry and Commerce a large number of price orders. He did, and they were kept, and rightly so, because of what happened subsequently. He signed every one of those and never subsequently did he sign an order reducing those prices. What was the extent of the reduction in the price of raw materials? It was from 193 down to 143, a reduction of about 25 per cent. in the prices of those imported materials which formed roughly half of the total cost in manufacturing industry.
Comment on this
I quite agree with the Minister for Defence. That was the situation when Deputy MacEntee projected himself on the scene. What did he find? He found this, according to the Leader of the Opposition who was back to it again in Kerry, that there were too many lawyers in this Government and that Fianna Fáil were faced with a deficit of £15,000,000 which had to be dealt with as a result of the last Budget of our making. I pointed out in the Budget debate last year that when the present Minister for Finance started to prepare last year's Budget, he found a deficit of £7,000,000 or £8,000,000. What did he do? Did he start out like a bull in a china shop to put on taxation and take off the benefits of food subsidies which the people had got? He did not. He did not put any additional taxation on. A few moments ago Deputy Colley pointed out that we had taken off no taxation. Perhaps we did not, but we did the equivalent; we did not put up taxation, although the people's incomes had increased.
Comment on this
It is not required for the purpose of carrying on the ordinary current State services and, if the Deputy looks at the Exchequer returns, he will see that.
Comment on this
I shall say a few words about the capital Budget later. In connection with Deputy Colley's reference to the adverse trade balance, I should like to ask Deputies opposite a question. What did the present Government do in the past two years to worsen the adverse trade balance?
Comment on this
I can answer that one quite easily. The imports of wheat went up at the beginning of last year, because of the unfavourable weather in 1954. Because of that, a considerable amount of foreign wheat had to be added.
Comment on this
Was the Parliamentary Secretary not against the growing of wheat until five minutes ago?
Comment on this
If you examine the position, you will find that the imports of wheat went up at the beginning of the year.
Comment on this
Order! The Parliamentary Secretary must be allowed to continue his statement without these interruptions.
Comment on this
I would not mind making a bet with the Deputy that wheat imports and maize imports will go down in the coming year. As far as I can see, the steps taken by the Government have had favourable reactions and there is an increased area under the plough this spring.
Comment on this
There is not the slightest doubt that anybody could solve the balance of payments problem in the way Deputy MacEntee did in 1952.
Comment on this
And the people on that side of the House are complaining because we did not dive in when this thing happened last summer. The present Government wanted to have a look at the problem, and they were quite right. If anybody else adopted the kind of measures that Deputy MacEntee adopted in 1952, would "foolhardy" be too harsh a term to describe them?
Comment on this
I might, perhaps, add a further word of personal explanation. It has been suggested that I held that there was no balance of payments problem. I did not.
Comment on this
Over a period of years I have analysed the deficits which have been thrown up in the statistics and I gave what appeared to me to be cogent reasons as to why I thought these deficits were misleading. I have never held there is not a balance of payments problem. There is one at the moment, but it may well be that, when all the figures are known, the extent of it may not be as great as we think it is at the moment.
Comment on this
The Deputy will understand that in bridging a gap, to one extent or another, there is a balance of payments problem to which this Government has to attend. I think the Government has attended to that in a way which will create least difficulty for our people here.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce says it is a storm and not a problem.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is in possession. He might be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Colley made a comment to-day. He said there was a complete turn-over in the financial outlook of this side of the House. What would we have had to face if the Party opposite happened to be on this side of the House now? We would have had two things we have not got at the moment—complete abolition of the remainder of the food subsidies and the bank rate would at the moment be 7½ per cent. Deputy Briscoe may laugh, but that is the truth.
Comment on this
Would these two propositions have been much good? Would the abolition of the remainder of the food subsidies help the poorer sections and would a 7½ per cent. bank rate help the other people?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley made a fair enough point in relation to myself and I promised to reply to it. He said I had been strongly in favour of money for private enterprise and that I was anxious to help on private enterprise. He said that I had said that many times. Perhaps, as often happens, nothing ever comes out in exactly the way one hopes it will. Quite frankly, I had hoped we might have had a big number of flotations of private companies here. That has not happened. Deputy MacEntee's famous 5 per cent. loan in 1952 killed the possibility of that for a very long time.
Comment on this
We have done this much in the last 12 months—the amount of money made available by the commercial banks went up and the amount of advances went up from October, 1954, to October, 1955, by £24,000,000.
Comment on this
First of all, to farmers and agriculturists, from £14,900,000 to £16,400,000; to cooperative trading concerns, societies and creameries—listen to this one— from £1,800,000 to £3,000,000; to mining and manufacturing—the bulk of these figures would, of course, be to manufacturers—from just under £16,000,000 to £22,200,000. Mark you, that is not bad to private enterprise, my particular little pet, though I would have allocated the money in a different way. To continue: to finance bodies, including stockbrokers and so forth, from £3,500,000 to just over £4,000,000; to wholesale merchants, from £17,800,000 to £21,500,000; to retailers, from £18,000,000 to £19,000,000; to shipping and transport companies and so on, from £684,000 to £4,000,000; to builders and contractors, from £4,200,000 to £4,800,000; to other businesses of all sorts, from £10,000,000 to £12,000,000—an increase of £2,000,000; to public bodies, from £8,000,000 to £12,000,000—remember, they are the public authorities, and that included the Dublin Corporation; to personal and professional overdrafts, from £18,000,000 to £21,000,000; schools, charities, churches and so on, from £6,700,000 to £8,000,000; to the Government—and here we come to a reduction—from £17,500,000 down to £13,000,000. Does not that add the last piece of enamel to the picture I have been painting?
Comment on this
From what is the Parliamentary Secretary quoting?
Comment on this
I am quoting from the Quarterly Statistical Bulletin of the Central Bank of Ireland, January, 1956. The total increases were about £28,000,000 and, if one knocks off the £4,000,000 by which the Government reduced its borrowings, the net increase is £24,000,000.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary seriously saying that the Government reduced its borrowing?
Comment on this
I am quoting from Table 6. This was not after the loan. This was on 18th October last. I did not compile these figures.
Comment on this
From what table is the Parliamentary Secretary quoting?
Comment on this
It is on page 8 of the journal to which I referred. On the question as to what the Government did, we all know what the Government has attempted to do. The Government has attempted to solve the present problem in a way that will create least difficulty for the community as a whole. Now, I do not like making moral judgments, particularly on things economic, because very often one may be proved wrong, but at least the measures which the Government have taken are reasonable measures both in relation to hire-purchase and in relation to the importation of non-essentials; and, judging by the comments of the Deputies on the opposite side of the House, they do not feel the Government is far off the mark in the measures they have adopted and the manner in which they propose to implement them.
Deputy O'Malley raised a question as to whether this levy had been put on felt hats. He had some interest in raising that matter. Actually felt hats are included in Item 21 of the list.
He also referred to criticism by the former Deputy Dr. Browne on the manner in which Deputy McGilligan prepared his last Budget. At the time, I read this criticism by Dr. Browne. The quotation by Deputy O'Malley is given in column 519 from a speech made on 28th May, 1951, in which Deputy Dr. Browne suggested he was asked to alter his Estimates. If Deputies on the far side of the House believe that, they will believe anything. Time and again, when I was an official in the Department of Finance, without any personal instructions from the Minister, I wrote to other Departments saying: "Dear So-and-so: I do not think you will spend as much money as that next year"—it might have been a new service or something of that kind—"and, if you will reduce your Estimate, we will raise no objection to your having a Supplementary Estimate at the end of the year." When Deputy Dr. Browne was approached in relation to the new health scheme to do that, he flew right up in the air and said: "You are asking me to fake my Estimates; you are asking me to behave dishonourably to help out Deputy McGilligan." It was not only when Deputy McGilligan was Minister—there are hundreds of precedents every year for that procedure in the Department of Finance. There is a stock formula for it.
Comment on this
Does the stock formula include an indication that you will get a supplementary later?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. I have signed stock letters of that kind myself time and again. I can give the Deputy references to numbers of them. It is a regular feature, particularly in relation to new services, because it is a matter of opinion, when you are starting a big new service, what it will cost. The other Departments want to get as much money as they can for the service—they do not want to be caught short of money—and naturally the Department of Finance want to keep down the Estimates volume as much as possible, and, to get agreement on a figure, the Department of Finance very often say: "We will give you the money at the end of the year, if you find that you want it."
Comment on this
Does that not usually involve cutting down the projects in the original Estimate?
Comment on this
No. What it means is that a new scheme which is of a large size may take a considerable time to get into operation and there may be differences of opinion on the probable cost. The Department concerned may naturally feel that they will be able to push the new service ahead rapidly——
Comment on this
So they estimate only for part of the scheme then?
Comment on this
No. They make an estimate of how much money they will require and decide on the parts of the country where it can be put into operation, and so there will be a difference of opinion on it, but, between them, the Departments get the best estimate they can. There is not the slightest doubt that was the meaning of what happened in the instance mentioned by Deputy Dr. Browne.
Comment on this
For instance, in the case of the Defence Estimates, if there was some purchase item in them, which was not allowed, it would be completely written off in the Estimate?
Comment on this
No; that is not the way. The particular scheme to which this relates is a good one to take—a vast new scheme. There can be a difference of opinion as to how much can be put into operation. For instance, the Land Project took years to get going properly, but this is a complete misconception——
Comment on this
The only difference is that everyone was in favour of the Land Project, and all were not in favour of the health scheme.
Comment on this
You were not an elected representative then and knew nothing about it, except as a small boy official. Let the Parliamentary Secretary not use his official capacity here.
Comment on this
I did not see Deputy McQuillan in the House until this moment, but certainly if Deputy McQuillan's contribution to this debate was as bad as that contribution, I would have a few words to say on it.