Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–140 of 481. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
In the explanatory leaflet which the Minister circulated, he gives under No. 5, on the revenue side, a list of certain tax rebates and reliefs. Perhaps, it is good to know that, even on a matter as heavy and as serious as a Budget, the Minister has not parted with his sense of humour because I see he proposes to give a rebate of £200,000 to hard-pressed tobacco. I doubt if the same tobacco were ever as hard pressed as it is under this present Budget. Even if the hard-pressed variety is getting a certain relief as a result of this rebate, it still is a more costly luxury to the old age pensioners, and to that poor section of our people who have no other little luxury than the pipe of tobacco, than it has ever been in their experience.
There is one matter to which the Minister, the House, and the country generally, should give a good deal of attention at present and that is the effect of present policy on industrial employment. Industrial employment does show, from the figures, certain fluctuations, but the fluctuations since this Government came in have been more violent than at any other time since the end of the war. The National Development Fund was established to provide employment for the non-insurable classes referred to as the assistance classes. The figures of employment amongst those classes bear eloquent testimony to the good effect which the expenditure out of the National Development Fund has had in achieving that purpose.
However, we do not seem to have the same happy position to report in respect of industrial employment. From the figures supplied from the Statistics Office, it is evident that there was steady improvement during the year 1954. I notice that, in the month of February, 1954, the number of unemployed registered in that category was 30,000 odd. By the end of May, about the time the change of Government took place, that figure had dropped to 25,000. That was a very respectable drop of about 16 per cent. and after the change of Government that trend continued, even if it did seem to slow up a bit. There was a further drop of 1,500 by the end of the year.
However, between December, 1954, and February, 1955, there was a very marked increase to over 33,000. That, of course, may be characteristic of that season of the year, and the registrants would be more numerous in that category at that time of the year, but I do not think we ever had such a catastrophic increase as we had between December, 1954, and the end of February, 1955. There was a very satisfactory decline from the end of February for the remainder of the year until the month of December. Again, however, there was a further very heavy jump between the end of 1955 and the end of February, 1956, and the number on the register at the end of February this year was 2,000 higher than at the end of February, 1955. There has been a drop again at the end of this month to 30,800.
The comparison of these figures for the past two or three years indicates that there is, this year, a steady decrease of those in the insurable classes who are registered as employed. There is a decrease of between 2,000 and 3,000. The Government will have to put itself in the position of seeing whether or not its financial policy is having a very adverse effect on the class of employment which is most useful, and which tends to stop emigration more than any other class of employment, that is the employment given by industrial firms.
The question of inflation has been mentioned by the Minister in his Budget statement, and, while inflation is a problem the world over, it seems to be somewhat worse here than it ought to be. Comparisons have been made in a statement issued this year by the Association of Chambers of Commerce of Ireland. I think every Deputy has received a copy of that statement which indicates that our position, in the matter of the cost of living, is the third worst of a number of countries which are mentioned— Ireland, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Holland, Italy, Switzerland, West Germany, the United Kingdom and the United States of America. It will be noted that a number of these countries were in the war and that our position amongst the neutral countries, from the figures given in this statement, is the highest.
It is stated in a footnote to the statement that the inflationary pressure on this country is almost as serious as that on Great Britain where an autumn Budget was introduced last year in an effort to correct the position. It states also that France has also experienced severe inflationary pressure, but that, in France, they have succeeded in holding the price index in check since 1952. Ireland compares very unfavourably with many of the other countries mentioned in the table given. These figures are given on page 5 of the statement which was submitted to the Minister for Finance on 17th February, 1956, by the Associated Chambers of Commerce of Ireland.
When we were the Government, we were subjected to a great deal of criticism, largely by the Labour Party, on the question of standstill Orders. Whatever the hardships caused by these Orders, their purpose was laudable and still remains laudable. That purpose was the prevention of this very evil of inflation. It is a bit ironic that the people who were most critical of the Fianna Fáil Government are now engaged in an effort to bring about a standstill situation.
Comment on this
The Trade Union Congress and the Congress of Irish Unions have, for the past six months, been trying to bring about an agreement with the Federated Union of Employers to bring about a standstill condition as regards both wages and prices. I cannot see the difference between what they want to bring about by negotiation and what was brought about by official action. It is quite true that, in the case of such official action, the effect on wages is never quite equal to the inflationary pressure on prices, but, nevertheless, the cut-throat race between them is checked, and it was checked here.
Now, these two large and very respectable bodies of Irish workers, the Trade Union Congress and the Congress of Irish Unions, realise the value of the action taken by the Fianna Fáil Government during the war to secure, as far as official action could secure it, the value of the wages which the workers were receiving. The action of these congresses is to be commended and personally I hope their efforts with the Federated Union of Employers will bear good fruit. The Minister for Industry and Commerce brought in his hire-purchase Order quite recently for the purpose of achieving the same result.
The question I would like to ask the Minister for Finance in regard to this question of inflation is one that a number of people have put to me. I must admit that I did not find myself in a position to give a satisfactory reply to my inquirers. Recently there was a loan of £20,000,000 floated and only £8,000,000 of that money was provided by the public. There must be one or two reasons for the failure. Either the people did not have the money or they did not approve of the Government's financial policy or believe that it was competent to spend £20,000,000 if they got it. I will leave out of the argument for the moment the doubt as to the popular belief in the competence of the Government and assume that the people did not have the money and that that was the reason why they did not subscribe to the loan. The Minister, according to his Budget statement, if my recollection is correct, obtained under this loan a sum of £8,000,000 which was underwritten by the banks.
The question I have been asked in this regard is that if the people did not have the £12,000,000 by which the loan fell short of its target, did the banks use their power to create £12,000,000 of credit and has a sum of £12,000,000 been created by the banks and been let loose in circulation to intensify this problem of inflation? That is what my inquirers indicated to me has taken place—if in fact the people did not have the money—and that, therefore, this inflationary action on the part of the Government in creating this money, which the people did not have, will worsen the position still further for the public in relation to prices. We know that this is a very complex and mixed up question.
Comment on this
It is not an easy question and not even Deputy Anthony Barry, who tried to correct Deputy MacEntee here the other day, is capable of giving a satisfactory answer to it. However, I want Deputy Barry to accept from me that we stand wholeheartedly behind the statement of the Leader of this Party when he said it was regrettable that the loan did fail and that the objects which were mentioned as the beneficiaries of the money, when it would have been obtained, were objects of which this Party has always approved and I think most of them were initiated by this Party. Therefore, I do not want to appear to take any Party advantage from the fact that the loan failed. It is most regrettable that such a position should have arisen, but, seeing that it did arise, I am putting this question. It is not political and it is not Party; it is, if you like, financially technical and I am really seeking information on a query that was put to me: if this falling short of £12,000,000 has been due to the fact that people did not have the £12,000,000, has the creation of the £12,000,000 accentuated inflation by £12,000,000? If Deputy Barry can give a satisfactory answer to that I will be most grateful to him.
Comment on this
I want the Parliamentary Secretary to accept it from me that I had this problem put to me by ordinary people.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance answered it here in the House. He explained how the money came.
Comment on this
The Minister has told us where he got the money. I have been asked the question as to its inflationary effect, assuming that the people did not subscribe the money because they did not have it and that, therefore, the money was created by the banks' power of creating credit. The Parliamentary Secretary smiles at my inquiry. I am genuinely innocent of knowledge in the matter. I admit that quite frankly. The Parliamentary Secretary is adopting an air of superior knowledge on the question.
Comment on this
Perhaps he would give me the answer. Deputy Barry quite sensibly has remained silent on it.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to put me off by smiling irrelevancies he will not succeed.
Comment on this
I want to find out what was the effect of the creation by the banks of that money which was not in the people's possession and giving it to the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
It was clearly inflationary and the Parliamentary Secretary knows it.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would say on this general question of the banks' practice, do they create credit?
Comment on this
We cannot proceed by way of question and answer. To answer would give rise to more questions and still more questions.
Comment on this
That is exactly what has been happening. I am following the bad example of the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
I was asking a question of which I hope the Minister for Finance will take notice and make some reference to it in his general reply.
Comment on this
In any event I think we have demonstrated, in spite of the hard things that have been said about Fianna Fáil's financial policy, that the people had more money to provide for these public purposes when Fianna Fáil was in office. The records show that for the last year of the first period of the Coalition Government, instead of there being any saving, the people spent half a million pounds of what they had already saved, and in the first year that produced that terrible Budget of 1952, the people saved £30,000,000.
Comment on this
We shall not allow the Coalition Government to forget the 1952 Budget. We shall not allow the Labour Party to forget the 1952 Budget.
Comment on this
The Labour Party lambasted Fianna Fáil because they raised the price of cigarettes from 1/8 to 2/4. There have been two increases in the price of the packet of cigarettes since this Government came in, a commercial increase of 1d. and the new increase of 5d.
Comment on this
There was a commercial increase of 1d. on 20 cigarettes and there has been this increase of 5d., a total increase of 6d., since this Government came in. Before the last election, the public were told that the 1952 Budget would be revoked, that the taxes it imposed were quite unnecessary, that we were taking £10,000,000 over-taxation from the public, that we were budgeting for a surplus for the following year in order to have a very favourable Budget and to face a general election on the basis of that very favourable Budget. The out-turn for the year proved that that statement was wrong. The Coalition Government, far from doing what they told the people they would do, retained all these taxes and have now added to them. That is why I say we shall not allow the 1952 Budget to be forgotten, because the comparison to be made now in the price of cigarettes is 1/8 before the 1952 Budget and 2/10 now, an increase of 1/2, of which the Labour Party approves and which it intends to retain.
Comment on this
It was this Party that introduced subsidies. The Labour Party scouted them, derided them and said they were a Fianna Fáil stunt and that they would be no party to them.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary can make his own statement later, without interrupting Deputy Bartley.
Comment on this
The prices which resulted from the 1952 Budget remain and these new increases are being superimposed upon them. In spite of that 1952 Budget, it was established before the General Election of 1954, and testimony is now borne to the fact in the publications of the Statistics Office, that stability in prices and wages had been reached. In addition, the cost-of-living index figure indicated that the trend was downwards. Within three months of the change of Government, that favourable position was thrown into the melting pot and prices started to rise again.
For 12 months, the organised workers tolerated that position, but then they indicated quite clearly to employers that, if the cost of living was not reduced, they would have to seek compensation for it in equivalent rises in wages, and so the competition between prices and wages set in, still further depreciating the value of money for everybody. It is little consolation to the social welfare classes to be given a small increase by the Minister for Social Welfare to bring the value of their small incomes up to what they were before this cut-throat competition set in.
We believe that the people have got wise to the deception that was practised upon them and are now satisfied that Fianna Fáil spoke the truth. To tell the people to eat, drink and be merry because to-morrow will be a happier and easier day than to-day was the cruellest of deceptions practised by Parties who had already experience of Government and who should have known the difference.
Take the statement, which has been referred to so much by speakers on this side of the House, made by an ex-Minister for Finance before the last election. Two days before the election, when nobody had time to reply to it effectively, Deputy McGilligan, broadcasting from Radio Eireann, said that there was little doubt that savings in the cost of Government amounting to several million pounds a year could be secured without much effort; that a distinct change of policy was required, however, and a new outlook on the part of Ministers was demanded, if the reduction of £20,000,000 and upwards, desirable in everybody's interest, was to be achieved.
It is very easy to point out that he did not say that he would reduce the cost of Government by £20,000,000, but a statement by an ex-Minister for Finance, broadcast over the State radio, that a new outlook on the part of Ministers was demanded if a reduction of £20,000,000 and upwards was to be achieved cannot mean anything other than that this ex-Minister for Finance had a plan and a method of reducing the cost of Government by £20,000,000. Who should be better able to tell the public whether that was so or not than a man who had been a Minister for Finance and a Minister for Industry and Commerce over a long period? It is these deceptions which the people now resent.
I was interested to hear one Minister say the other day that he would be prepared to meet the public in his constituency on the basis of this Budget and would feel assured of the same support as he received on the last occasion, or increased support. My comment on that is that there were two vacancies in Dáil Eireann, which occurred recently, and many vacancies in Dáil Éireann were allowed to remain unfilled for a much longer period than the two vacancies in question, NorthEast Dublin and Leix-Offaly. Nevertheless, the Government Parties saw to it that these two by-elections took place before the Budget was introduced. I think that is a sufficiently effective comment on the statement of the Minister for Social Welfare that he believed the people in his constituency would support this Budget.
Only a few days elapsed between polling and the revealing of these new taxes. In my opinion, it would have been a very decent, democratic gesture on the part of the Government to allow this question to be decided by the people, or at least to have allowed. the people in these two constituencies to express an opinion on these proposals. There is not an adjective that was used by any of the Opposition Parties on the 1952 Budget which cannot now be applied with more effect to the taxes of 6d. a gallon on petrol and 5d. a packet on cigarettes. It is not an isolated 6d. It is 6d. down on previous taxes on petrol and it is another 5d. down on taxes already imposed on cigarettes in the 1952 and other Budgets.
I am sticking to one particular item because a great many Parties claimed that cigarettes and stout were as much an essential in the poor man's family budget as was the food on his table. This additional tax the Minister has now put on cigarettes must be looked upon as a superstructure, together with previous taxes, down on the people. The Government Parties cannot simply get away with it by saying: "Fianna Fáil is responsible for the others; we have put on this 5d. only and we are giving the old age pensioners and other social welfare recipients increased allowances."
It is not good enough and if the Government felt any way complacent about it, if they felt really as the Minister for Social Welfare said he felt in relation to his constituency, I am quite certain they would have let the people of Leix-Offaly and of NorthEast Dublin express an opinion. The fact that they did not is very eloquent of the Government's realisation of the temper of public opinion in relation to this Budget. It is very eloquent of the resentment against this extra burden placed upon the public. It is evidence of the fact that the Government know, in spite of this creation of money, that the inflation which has accompanied it has rendered the position of the average householder much more difficult than it has been ever since the end of the war.
Comment on this
I think there probably is a tendency, or a temptation, when discussing something like the Budget, to follow up what may be labyrinths or side alleys of the issues at stake. Even at the risk of repeating a considerable amount of what has been said, it seems worth while now to look at the Budget as a composite thing, with two purposes. Presumably, it will be accepted on every side that the Budget has twin purposes. Firstly, we must look at it as the balance between the State's income and its expenditure for the year and look on that balance as being necessary in the light of the requirements of the financial or fiscal policy of the State for the same year.
I think we will get a lopsided view of the validity or the weakness, the strength or the value or the fault of a Budget, if we look at it solely as an attempt to make ends meet. While that must be the predominant purpose, we should never lose sight, in criticising or praising, of the way in which these ends are brought to meet. Looking at the first aspect of the present Budget—the way in which it is proposed to balance the expenditure and the revenue of the State—I think we must look for criticism of or opposition to the Budget in either of two ways. Criticism may be that the expenditure is unnecessarily high or misplaced, or that, while it is agreed that we have to find money, the money is being found in the wrong way. Looking at the first point, since the introduction of the Budget, we have had from the opposite benches nothing but a number of general vague complaints about the cost of Government being too high and the cost of the services being too high. There have been complaints that the Government is spending too much money.
It seems to me that, if we are to get anywhere on a discussion of this kind, criticism must take some much more concrete form. If anyone were willing to come forward and point out particular services, particular capital schemes, particular capital expenditure on which he thought there was unnecessary expenditure or which he thought could be postponed, we would get somewhere. In the absence of that sort of concrete suggestion or alternative proposal, I think it is advisable again to look at the expenditure which this Budget is framed to provide for. Firstly, the capital expenditure, as the Minister mentioned in his opening statement, is £27,000,000 odd. It comes under the headings of housing, sanitary services, hospitals, agriculture and other matters, the amounts of which apart from shipping and transport, are rather small.
On which of these should we now cut down? Out of a total expenditure of over £100,000,000, we are spending something short of £8,000,000 on housing this year. Does anybody believe that is an excessive amount? I for one do not. I do not believe it is excessive even having regard to the difficulties of revenue and to our balance of payments position. I do not know whether anybody else in this House, particularly among the Opposition, is prepared to come forward and say that is too much. I believe it is a necessary amount. Looking on the other items of capital expenditure, it is necessary, as the Minister has said, constantly to review and constantly to supervise capital expenditure. However, I find it difficult to see in any of these items of health, hospitals, transport, schools and other State buildings, or roads or sanitary services, or agricultural development, any figures which could be significantly reduced, without affecting the real progress of the country.
If there were, we might find in these capital services some way of reaching a saving, some way of shortening the gap between revenue and expenditure, but I believe the Minister has made out his case for this type of capital expenditure for £27,000,000. If those were not projects meeting with general approval, meeting with the general requirements of the public, there would be some Deputy opposite found to point to one or other of the projects which he regarded as unnecessary. We must safely assume that the Government is not spending too much on the capital side and that criticism might then arise on the Supplies and Services and not on the capital side of the expenditure.
Looking at the non-capital side of the Budget, there are some matters which have been mentioned already and which I think can usefully be brought to mind again. The general complaint has been made—and I think this really comes on the non-capital side—in a very vague way by the Deputies opposite, certainly by Deputy MacEntee and certainly by Deputy Lemass, that the cost of Government is too high and that this Government has done and is doing nothing to reduce that cost. That complaint was made as if it was this inter-Party Government which was responsible for the machinery, and for the extent and size of the machinery of the Government, which they took over in 1944. That accusation is so lightly and so easily made that it seems to me worth while to inquire into the size of the Government and the size of the personnel of the Government over the years at various times.
These are figures, now, which are not meant as a defence or as an accusation, but as figures which are relevant to a discussion of this issue. As accurately as the figures are supplied in various parliamentary answers, we find that, in 1932, there were 20,254 civil servants employed by the State. These figures do not, of course, include the Army or anything like that. In 1939, after seven years' administration by the Fianna Fáil Party, that figure had risen to 26,700 odd. By 1947, that figure had risen to 31,500 odd; by 1953, it had risen to 37,600 odd. After the two years of inter-Party Government, that figure is at present 33,600 odd. So there has been a reduction in the number of civil servants in the last two years. There has been an increase in their cost of £2,500,000 and the increase in this year's Budget is the additional cost of increased wages to the civil servants and other Government servants.
I think these increased wages are justifiable. I think they are presented as a necessary claim on the expenditure; they have been arrived at in a time-honoured way, the method of independent arbitration—not as a result of the efforts of any pressure group, not as a result of any generous gift, but, as I say, as a result of the time-honoured method of fairly assessing the matters in dispute. I think it is a moral, as well as a real, charge on the expenditure of this country. That figure of expenditure has undoubtedly increased by £2,500,000 and it is for that reason I think it is too lightly said that this Government has failed to reduce the cost of Government. When it is too lightly said that we are maintaining a top-heavy and useless form of administration—not entirely useless, of course, but too big, too complicated and too expensive—it is relevant to consider that graph of the figures of the size of our Civil Service, and then we find that the only downward trend in these years is the substantial one seen in the last two years, a reduction from 37,000 to 33,000 at a time of ever-expanding Government work and activity.
What is the answer to the cost of the administration problem? The Minister has said that the Government had active measures under consideration in the form of inter-departmental committees, or groups, for cutting down Government expenditure on actual administration and for introducing more efficient and less expensive methods of administering the ordinary services of the Government. That is the obvious and the right approach. Deputy MacEntee thinks otherwise. Deputy MacEntee speaking in this debate, at column 186 of Volume 157 of the Official Report, said as follows:—
"That is not the way to deal with the situation."
—He is referring to the Minister's proposals—
"The Minister is going to meet the heads of Departments. When I first came in as Minister for Finance in 1932, we had the same sort of parlous budgetary and financial problem to deal with and I told the heads of the Departments fairly frankly that either they or we were for it and that if it came to a showdown it was not going to be we. We were going to have the Budget balanced. We had the unpleasant task of imposing taxes in 1953 but we were also going to secure economies. The proper way to do the job is to go to the heads of the Departments and say that if they are not able to cut administrative costs substantially within the next 12 or 18 months, then they are not the men for the job."
I do not think that is the way to cut administrative costs and to increase the efficiency of the Civil Service. I do not think you can go to the head of any Department and threaten him that, if something is not done within the next 12 or 18 months, he is not the man for the job. I do not think that policy is going to achieve anything or is likely to be in any way as effective as the Minister's own method.
Deputy MacEntee, later on in his speech, suggested that that was the way it would be dealt with in any industry. I do not think that is the case, and I think in any modern industry, we would find some such approach to this problem as the Minister is making, and that these results, particularly results which mean a reduction of staff and an increase in efficiency of methods, would come better from cooperation with the staff and not from dictation from above. Although the method proposed by the Minister has been criticised, the single alternative presented so far is grossly unsound and most unlikely to have any good results.
If the Deputies opposite think the cost of Government is too high, surely we should have something more concrete from them, something more definite and more helpful, than the suggestion from Deputy MacEntee that we should go to the heads of the Departments in the Civil Service and tell them that, if they cannot cut down the costs of administration within 12 or 18 months, then they are not the men for the job. Surely, if we are considering the question of the cost of Government, the actual number of people employed by the Government is a highly material fact, and if we find in the last two years a reduction of some 4,000 in the number of civil servants, surely the Government is going in the right direction, and not only going in the right direction, but——
Comment on this
Would the Deputy help me by telling me where he got these figures? I am most interested in them.
Comment on this
I very much regret I cannot. They are replies to a number of parliamentary questions, but I have not got the references for them.
Comment on this
The Government has been hiding its light under a bushel very much, so.
Comment on this
With regard to the other increases, apart from the number of staff, I think the increases in pay to the staff have been arrived at in the correct way. The other significant increases are an increase of £1,250,000 for health services; an increase, as the Minister mentioned, of some £340,000 for relief of rates on agricultural land and a sum of £135,000 for the universities. I do not want to pretend that anyone suggests these are unwise— because they do not; it is only fair to say there is no suggestion that these are unwise, or unnecessary, or misapplied; and, if we come down to the real bones of this matter, I think we must come to the conclusion that supplies and services and capital expenditure are high, but that we cannot find in them any significant items or any significant tendencies, which could be got rid of, or which are unnecessary.
We must face up to the fact that our problem is not a problem of too high costs, although that is part of the problem; it is not a problem of spending too much money or of spending money unwisely. It is largely a problem of ensuring that we have an increase in real national income to meet the expediture that we must bear. If, as seems clear, the capital provisions, and the non-capital provisions are not really in dispute, what is in dispute? It must be that we have gone to look for the money to meet this expenditure in the wrong place, from the wrong people and in the wrong way. I think that is worth considering. The position clearly is that, if we are right in saying that these services and capital projects were necessary and wise, we had to find the additional money by revenue. What way have we found it? We have found it by imposing additional taxes on tobacco, petrol, matches, minerals, betting and dances. That is, shortly, how this money has been found. In addition to that, there is the increase, the not very large special increase, in postal charges so that the Post Office should pay for itself. But, generally speaking, the money has been found to meet the increase in expenditure in the way I have indicated.
What is the first thing that strikes one about all that classification? I fully appreciate, as a person who for a considerable period has smoked himself, that tobacco is, undoubtedly, say, the first of the luxuries. It cannot be said to be a luxury, but smoking certainly is a habit and a very simple habit to which a tremendous number of people are addicted. Even allowing for that fact, the position clearly is that the whole list of taxes, with the exception of one matter which I will mention later, gives to the individual the voluntary end of taxation. A man may or may not pay additional taxation under this Budget, depending on whether he feels entitled or prepared to go without. That sounds a harsh doctrine but I think it is appreciated and is being appreciated by the people of this country that no additional taxation has been forced on any person as a result of this Budget.
Comment on this
I am talking about this Budget. I think it is of some importance to try and deal with it now.
Comment on this
That is where this taxation is of importance and I think, like so many things, it is of importance because it is something which the ordinary person outside this House with no political axe to grind does appreciate. I do say, in so far as the taxes on petrol are concerned, there are circumstances under which they become an inevitable additional expense on people in their ordinary business—and it is only right to say that a large part of the additional part of tax on petrol will fall on pleasure driving—but, outside of that, these are taxes which can be met by any person who wants to meet them by voluntarily changing their spending and avoiding them in that way.
What is the consideration uppermost in the mind of the ordinary man when he considers this selected group of extra taxes? I think it is—it is something which is becoming more and more patent in the last four or five days since this Budget was introduced —that the people realise and that they should realise that these taxes have been imposed in such a method that, with the maximum fairness, the additional money has been obtained in the way and from the people who might be expected to be able to afford it best. I think that is the sharp difference which this Budget presents to the minds of the people of this country when they compare it with the Budget of 1952; and one of the most remarkable things is the precision and speed with which people have realised that a similar problem has been met in such a very different way in this Budget.
The next matters which I think should be considered in the Budget are the concessions which it was found possible to give in it. These concessions are not large. When a Government is giving out tremendous sums of money and is in a position to give large concessions, I think you will probably find, that, in a general way, it covers everybody. When a Government is in a position to make a limited number of concessions I, for one, think that it is important to look with some care at the sort of concessions it makes. That gives us a very good idea of the mind of the Government and the ideas of the Government.
In regard to the two major concessions which arise under this Budget— the social insurance relief and the local authority and other old, pre-1950, pensioners—I think that hardly anyone would deny that they are selected as two sections of this community who had by far the highest claim to any concession the Government found it possible to give. I do not think anybody in this House could have been ignorant of or could have been entirely unmoved by the situation of these pensioners in the lower pension group, in particular, from my own personal experience, local authority pensioners— men who had served various local authorities, various boards of health and various boards of guardians over a very considerable period; men who were accustomed to a certain amount of independence and to tremendous security in their jobs, and who find themselves having retired, and now being exceptionally old and unfit in most cases for further employment, with quite inadequate pensions. I think the selection of these two groups or classes for the concessions that were available is something not only welcome in itself, for its intrinsic value, but welcome as a clear indication of the approach of this Government to the various sections of the population and their various claims.
There are some other matters in what I might call the secondary purpose of the Budget—as a financial weapon used by the Government to influence the financial and fiscal policies of the country. I think it is quite clear that Deputies must agree that the provisions of the Budget, both with regard to the taxes which have been imposed and with regard to the concessions which have been made, are none of them likely in any way to hinder or to obstruct any production or any progress of production, either agricultural or industrial. I think great care has been taken in the Budget to avoid that, and at the same time quite clearly, in the two main taxes which have been introduced, there is a powerful influence created on the balance of payments figures. If you look at the figures for the import of tobacco and petrol alone, you will find that any restriction on the consumption of either of those two articles would have a very definite, a very direct and very significant effect on our balance of payments. I think that in choosing those articles I have listed, in particular tobacco and petrol, the Minister has married with considerable success his obligation to increase revenue and his obligation to keep his eye on the main financial problem in this country. I think their selection fulfils that twin purpose extremely well and it is one of the things on which the Minister is to be congratulated. It is certainly a matter for praise in relation to the actual Budget itself.
With regard to what might be described as the fiscal provisions of the Budget, there are certain things which have not received as much prominence as others—that is, I suppose, only to be expected—and certain things which have not received possibly as much consideration in the course of this debate. Comment was made and criticism advanced that the provision for wear and tear of plant and machinery in industry, and so forth, was not adequate and would not make a tremendous lot of difference to many people. I suggest that this provision was not introduced by the Minister as something in the nature of a major concession, but it is very significant as being the first step in the right direction towards reform and improvement of industrial taxation. Thinking people concerned with industry who take the long view and do not expect to reach the summit of their successes this year, or even next year, are greatly cheered by that movement in the right direction on the part of this Government. It is of some importance to emphasise that.
There are other reliefs with regard to certain securities, both in respect of income-tax and estate duty, which are welcomed by the people and which will give an added incentive to saving and to investing in Irish industry and Irish enterprise. It is not suggested that they are very large from a revenue point of view, but they represent yet one other step in the right direction. They are certainly strongly indicative of the views of the Government and they are of a character designed to encourage people to produce more and invest more in production within this country.
For those reasons, I suggest that, even at this stage in the debate, it is quite clear that, in so far as Deputies opposite are concerned—and it has been made clear over the week-end in so far as people outside this House are concerned—there is no substantial criticism available or being put forward of the way in which this Government is spending the money it has to raise. Indeed, there is considerable appreciation, having regard to that necessary expenditure, of the way in which the Government has decided to raise this additional revenue. People are relieved, pleased and appreciative that, when we were asked to face a problem so similar mathematically to the problem of 1952——
Comment on this
——we took this course rather than the course adopted on a former occasion. Thirdly, I believe that there is appreciation of the other provisions in the Budget and the alterations in the tax code by those people who have gone into this Budget in detail because the steps portrayed therein are indicative of the Government's policy of moving in the right direction with regard to tax reform. Though the measures with relation to tax reform are in themselves individually insignificant and though none of them is very large, they are nevertheless a good thing.
I am quite satisfied, and I do not think the Deputies opposite are at variance with us on this, that people are particularly struck by the concessions which have been given and by the way in which they have been given and of the choice of people to whom they have been given. This is a fair Budget, fair as between all sections of our people. In the financial circumstances in which it has been framed, it is a proper Budget and a just Budget.
Comment on this
The net result of the proposals in this Budget appears to me to be that there are some £9,500,000 additional imposts being placed on the community, not counting the £500,000 which is being taken from the Road Fund, which is existing taxation and admitted by the Minister in his Budget statement to be unnecessary for the purpose for which it was levied. It is now being taken over and used for capital development purposes. We have, therefore, £9,500,000 additional imposts. Of this we have £3,000,000, the yield of the special import levies, plus another £500,000 of current taxation being taken over to finance capital enterprises. To me, that represents a fair summary of the present budgetary proposals—not bad, mark you, for a Government that said it would reduce expenditure, for a Government whose former Minister for Finance suggested that for anybody who knew where to look there were sums of money hanging about in savings of expenditure to the extent of £10,000,000 or £20,000,000.
Now the first question one naturally asks is: Why were these £20,000,000 or £10,000,000 not brought in to relieve the situation, instead of putting on yet another £10,000,000 in unnecessary, as it would be held to be in these circumstances, taxation?
Suppose the position were reversed and that this was a Fianna Fáil Budget. Suppose it was we who were occupying those Government Benches and that we had on this side of the House the four Parties which at present constitute the Coalition: Fine Gael, that great Party inspired with the desire to reduce expenditure; the Labour Party which would reduce taxation on such things as tobacco as representing taxation on necessities; Clann na Poblachta with the fabulous millions in our external assets available for capital development; and Clann na Talmhan—goodness knows, what they stand for—the so-styled Farmers' Party. Suppose these Parties were sitting on these benches and we introduced a Budget such as the Budget that has been introduced by the present Coalition, what an onslaught——
Comment on this
——there would be upon that Budget by the Parties now comprising the Coalition. If our Minister meekly pointed out that he needed a sum of £5,000,000 in order to balance his Budget, there would have been an immediate outcry. It would have been said that the figures were unreal, and implied that there was a conspiracy between the revenue officials, the officials of the Department of Finance and the officials of the various other Departments who help to compile these Estimates, the Minister for Finance and the Government—all together —to deceive both the Dáil and the country. It would be alleged that there was hidden away in these Estimates £10,000,000 of unnecessary taxation. It would be alleged that we were out on a campaign of austerity, that our Budget proposals were cruel, unjust, unconscionable—indefensible. It would have been alleged that such taxation was unnecessary; and, if we gave proof to the contrary, the proof would have been ignored and the charge would have been repeated that there was £10,000,000 unnecessary taxation. Even if that £10,000,000 subsequently turned out to be a deficit of £2,000,000, the allegation would have been persisted in; it would have been repeated and used all around the country and made an excuse for the pretence that we were embarking on an austerity campaign.
We have reached a serious position in the country's economic affairs. There is no doubt whatever about that. We have increasing governmental expenditure. I have always sympathised, both when in Government and out of Government, with the Minister for Finance. Budget day is the day of reckoning for all Departments. It is very popular with heads of Departments and with Ministers who have pet projects of one kind or another—and when I say "pet projects" I mean projects in which they are particularly interested for the public good we must suppose—to forget this. Side by side with their proposals, there should be a taking into account of the resources to meet them. The fact is that there is a competition between Parties, both in this House and out of this House, as to who will promise most. Rarely have we people who will tell the community that these benefits have to be paid for and—if we omit, for the moment, our external assets due to past savings—that there is no source from which these moneys can be got except from taxation and out of the people's pockets and that the result of a great deal of governmental action in these matters is simply a redistribution of whatever wealth or incomes already exist. I always have sympathy with the Minister for Finance who has got to face the music, over a week or so, for all that has been done throughout the year. It should be his duty and the duty of his colleagues to keep that day of reckoning in mind and not suddenly to have to face a deficit of £5,000,000 or £10,000,000, or whatever the number of millions may be, and to have to impose all the vexatious taxation necessary to meet the deficits.
If it were we who had to face this deficit, we would not have speeches from this side of the House such as some of those which have, in fact, been made from this side of the House. We hear people talk about unity. There is or there should be unity in this House amongst all Parties working for the service of the people who sent them here to represent them. It is no pleasure to us to see promises that were made, and that fooled the people, exposed. It is no pleasure to us to realise that this exposure is made possibly only at the expense of the resources of the country as a whole. The best way to get unity in this House is to have a decent Opposition that will do its duty in supporting the Government, where the public interest demands it should be supported, and in ruthlessly exposing the Government when the Government is failing in its duties towards the public either by deceiving the public in getting into office or, still worse, by failing in its duty to the public by not doing its work properly when it is in office.
In this Budget, there is this £9,500,000, leaving out the £500,000 which would make it a round £10,000,000—it seems to be cropping up in multiples of ten, apparently. Roughly £10,000,000 of taxation is being imposed because current expenditure has outrun current revenue— taking as expenditure what the Minister and the Government propose to spend this year and taking as revenue that which is supposed to come from taxation as it existed before these proposals are put into effect.
There is a deficit and it has to be met. It can be met only by reducing expenditure or by increasing revenue, or both. We had to do it when we were faced with a problem of twice the gap that exists at present and an adverse balance of payments of nearly twice the magnitude, too. Our problem was twice as difficult. We had to meet it by a reduction of expenditure and by certain increased taxation. The deficit must be met; we have to face that fact. Let us hear no more of this pretence that there are tens of millions of pounds knocking about for a Minister to put his hands on. You can cut some administrative expenses; I have no doubt about it.
I should be glad if it were true that, in two years, the Government have been able to reduce the number of civil servants by 4,000. I had not heard that figure before. It was mentioned by the last Deputy who spoke. I doubt if it is true. I should like to know where he got that figure. If it is a fact, it is the first instance I have seen that there is any reality in the Government's promise to reduce expenditure. I will admit, particularly if it ran through all the grades, a reduction of 4,000 civil servants in two years would be a substantial diminution, but, as I say, I should like to know where these figures which the Deputy used came from.
It is well for the country to realise that it is extremely difficult to reduce expenditure. After all, if it were easy to do so, every Government would do it. It is difficult and it is because it is difficult that it requires determination if it is ever to be done. We took up the position that State expenditure had reached such a level that we should have to resist any further increase in expenditure. Anybody who has examined a Budget or who has had anything to do with Budgets knows that from year to year there are what you might call automatic increases in expenditure. The most that could be hoped for in more or less inflationary times—in times of rising prices— is that the income in pounds would offset it but that is only temporary because increases in remuneration quickly catch up with income again. There is the matter of the increase in the service of the national debt, for example. There are year-to-year increases in expenditure, unless they are offset by some definite and deliberate saving economy. So far as I know, the Government has done nothing in that regard, but if the figure of 4,000 fewer civil servants is true I will admit it is something and even something considerable, but it has not exhibited itself in financial figures because the amount of expenditure for the coming year is far in excess of that for previous years.
Expenditure has gone up. If expenditure goes up, then, unless the yield from taxation goes up to an equivalent degree, new taxes have to be imposed. The Minister has to balance his Budget; we admit that. However, if it were we who said that the Budget had to be balanced we would be attacked as people nothing better than menial bookkeepers. When we took the national accounts as representing the national position and said that it was essential in our conditions that they should be balanced, we were told we were nothing better than menial bookkeepers and that we should have a higher concept of what a Budget could do.
The present Government has had an opportunity of showing these higher concepts and how these young geniuses they had at their backs would put them on the right road. They should indeed be called genii and they would want to have Aladdin lamps. The ordinary idea of genius is not enough. They would want to have their Aladdin lamps with them. These genii with their Aladdin lamps have not done much to help or show the present Government how to get out of their difficulties. They have not shown them how to balance the Budget except by the time-honoured methods of increasing taxation when the Government cannot diminish expenditure.
There was a gap in this case of some £7,000,000. The Minister reduced it in the usual way until he brought it down finally to £5.3 million. If we brought in such a Budget we would in debate here very quickly get away from high finance. It would be brought down to the individual home, to the housewife and the worker who, at a time when prices were rising, had difficulty in making ends meet. It was a catch cry when we were talking about ends meeting as far as the nation was concerned but when it came down to the household and when the housewife had to try and make ends meet it was quite a different matter. If, in addition to the present pressure on the housewife through increased prices, you had the further taxation envisaged here we would have heard about it at every cross-roads.
There was no use making the case that was made here to-day that cigarettes and tobacco were relative luxuries. In our 1947 Budget, when we introduced subsidies—we did it at a time of rising prices—in order to get the money to introduce subsidies and to lower, as we did at that time, the cost-of-living index figure by, I think, about 13 points, we had to impose taxation. When we tried to subsidise bread, tea and sugar by very substantial amounts and tried to get the money by putting taxation on the pint and on tobacco, we had the Labour Party going around the country, reinforcing Fine Gael, as they are now, and telling the people that we regarded the poor man's pipe and pint as luxuries and that that was our attitude. When we had, in 1952, the very unpleasant task of imposing taxation, we were told that we were pursuing a policy of austerity.
The Minister talks about consumption outstripping production and no savings. When we said that—we said it at a time when it was as true as it is apparently now except that it was true to a greater extent then—we were told that we grudged the people their high standard of living; that we thought they were eating too well, drinking too well and enjoying themselves too well and that our policy was a hair-shirt policy, a policy of stupid austerity. We were told that we were pursuing that policy of austerity at the dictate of the Central Bank and in imitation of, or under compulsion from, the Chancellor of the British Exchequer.
If those who are bringing in this Budget to-day were at this side of the House we would be told that in the attempt to slow down hire purchase and the other measures taken we were following slavishly step by step, Mr. MacMillan or Mr. Butler or whoever might be the Chancellor of the British Exchequer. Everybody knows that it is true that this would be said. Will the present Government say now that they grudge the people the standard of living they have, that they want them to eat less, drink less and have less enjoyment? They will not say it from that side of the House. They said in the past that such taxes would diminish purchasing power, and that they were deliberately designed to limit or lessen the purchasing power that is at the disposal of the individual citizen.
The reason they now give is that consumption is clearly at the present time so high in relation to production that there are no savings. The position is like that which would result from consuming the whole crop yielded leaving nothing for next year's seed. The savings of the community are like the seed, the seed that is reserved from the previous year's crop in order to provide the crop of the following year.
If we are to have economic development in this country we must have current savings but a campaign of demoralisation was started by the Opposition Parties throughout the country and they and we are reaping the benefit to-day. The chickens have come home to roost to the Government but, unfortunately, they are coming home to roost to the people of the country and the community as a whole as well. For the first time in the history of the country, we have reached a situation in which we are not able to meet our capital demands. That which we think necessary for further development we are not able to get out of current savings. We are not able to get it except at grievous loss in regard to our external holdings.
Nothing was so sickening as to listen in this House a few years ago to people who were talking as if there was no limit to the resources of the country and telling the people that they could, if they had the will to do it, raise their standard of living and did not need to save, that the savings of the past would suffice in order to finance the development required here. Many of those who spoke that way either did not believe it themselves or were extremely ignorant. Whichever it is, the country will have to pay for it, I am afraid. Unless we pull together now we will not pull the country out of the mess.
As far as the capital position this year is concerned, there is the fact that at a time when there is an inflationary tendency and when prices are rising, we have had to go to the banks to make up the deficit. The Government got only £8,000,000 odd from the people towards the £20,000,000 loan.
Everybody knows that the big difference between borrowing from the people and using the banks for borrowing is that if you borrow from the people, you are not creating any disturbance in the relation between money and goods in the community. You are not increasing the quantity of money available to purchase whatever quantity of goods there may be. Generally speaking, other things being equal, if you borrow from the banks, you bring new money into the community over and above what already is in existence there. You will have more money than you had before to purchase the same amount of goods available. It seems to me that that ought to be fundamentally clear to everybody. When you are forced to go to the banks, you are creating new money, no matter where the banks get it. Fresh money is put into circulation. If the banks do create credit in order to meet the Government's demands, the banks have to keep their cash ratio in order and have to keep a greater quantity of liquid assets immediately available. That means that they will have a greater proportion of their assets in a less remunerative form.
We have several disturbing features in the present situation, but the most disturbing of all is the one concerning our capital expenditure. I have always been afraid of this. I have spoken about it in the past. We are now reaching the stage when £40,000,000 is the annual demand for capital purposes. This year, the Minister has cut it down somewhat; he has cut it down, I think, to £37,000,000. That is the sum required for public capital within the State and up to this year we have been in the neighbourhood of about £40,000,000 for capital purposes. The savings of the community would have to be very substantial indeed to meet that sum regularly from year to year without vastly increased products. If the savings of the community are to be substantial there are two ways of dealing with the matter—either cut down consumption or increase production.
The greatest fault I find with the measures which the Minister is taking to meet the situation is that there is no consistency about them. He ought to go all out to increase production, and, if he wants to do that, the first thing to attend to is to see that every inducement is given to increase agricultural production. He has not done that—quite the contrary. There is about £12,000,000 of produce brought in from outside every year that could be produced here at home. You have either to increase production or reduce consumption and the Minister has apparently gone out largely on the side of reduced consumption. By his taxation, by his special levies and by the money which he is transferring from current revenue to the capital account, he is diminishing consumption and making some contribution towards meeting his capital requirements, which indirectly reduces the demands on our external assets.
One of the most extraordinary features of the situation, and one of which I would like to get a detailed explanation, is why, when, up to the present, the deficiency in the balance of payments used to be met by increased external indebtedness, that no longer happens now. The reduction in the banks' external assets shows that. We are reducing our external assets and the external assets of the banks and from that there is a whole chain of consequences. The fact that production has not kept up with the greater monetary demand means that there is an overflow of the demand and that we are bringing in consumption goods from outside. The bringing in of these goods from outside means that we are reducing our external assets. When we reduce their external assets, the banks are no longer in a position to deal properly with our external trade or freely make home advances.
Our imports are now over the £200,000,000 mark and you must have a considerable sum available in liquid foreign assets to handle that. The contribution by the banks to the Government loans means a further reduction of the money at their disposal. The Minister and his colleagues know, as everybody who has read the Budget statement knows, quite well that there is here now, as I have said, a serious economic situation which requires to be handled. We believe that that serious situation was largely brought about by mishandling but that is not going to help the country. When the Minister appeals now to the private individual to help, how different from what they said in 1952. It was suggested then by these master magicians, by the genii to whom I have referred, that it was our ignorance was at fault.
We ought all to produce as much as possible and to save the results of that additional production, so that it can be invested in further production. That means that we have to be industrious and, if we want to make further development, we have to be thrifty. Industry and thrift have been placed at a discount for a long period in the speeches made by certain politicians in this country. It is essential that somebody should say these things now. We want industry and the desire to work and to produce efficiently. We want thrift. If we act thriftily, we will have savings and we will be able to finance our capital enterprises by these savings. The whole progress of this community depends upon efficient production and thrift—in saving, as much as we possibly can, so as to employ it in further development.
I do not know what more I can add. I can only say that I, and everybody interested in the welfare of this country, would hate to think that our people should be left in a fool's paradise, that they should be left in the position that, when the savings of the past are gone, they will be like a man who was left a legacy and who became a spendthrift, and then found that, when his legacy was gone, he was out on the road. It is true that we have not reached the last of our savings or the last of our resources but there must be a combined effort to face realities. The first reality is that our resources are limited and that the Government's spending of those resources at the present time is at a higher rate than can be afforded with present production. The Government by taking the amount it is taking even for its capital purposes is depriving private enterprise of the capital it requires.
If I were asked from the opposite side: "What would you give up?" I would say that I would hate to give up any of the enterprises engaged in at the present time but if I had to give up anything it would certainly not be on the productive side. We have social services. It is a hard thing sometimes to decide what you will surrender in order to keep within the country's means. The main thing, however, is to stop further expenditure until production has reached a stage at which we can afford it, to stop increased public expenditure until whatever productive enterprises are on hands get the amount they require in order to produce the things that will enable us to maintain our standard of living. If we do not act accordingly, as the Minister has pointed out, we will face a period in which our standard of living will be reduced. We would like to know what those who have spoken about higher social and other services will then have to say.
As regards the Budget, we could say it is imposing hardships on our people which they can with difficulty bear. But I for one would say it is better that we have these hardships now than that we should have to suffer much more severe hardships later. One of the things that human beings are capable of by reason of their intellect and their will is that they can forgo a present good for a greater good to come and that they can embrace a present evil in order to avoid a still greater evil in the future. As a community we must behave in that way. If it is necessary that we should face the present evil to avoid greater evils then let us make up our minds to face it. I believe the people of our country, like those of any other country, if properly led and if they feel they are honestly led, are prepared to follow that leadership. But the people who are trying to lead them now are people who are eating their own words. There is no statement made from the opposite benches to-day for which one could not get a parallel contradictory statement made two or three years ago. Were they honest then or are they honest now? That is one question that will come to anyone who is asked to follow their advice. Have we still "Philip drunk" or have we "Philip sober"?
The people of our country will, as I have said, if they are properly led and if they feel they are spoken to honestly, accept advice given to them. I could, for instance, demonstrate the consequences from the point of view of unemployment that will flow from the reduction of capital expenditure, and the unemployment that will flow from having less purchasing power available in the community. I know there is a danger of these things and that we must do our best to avoid them. But let us not at any rate be misled into thinking that evils and dangers such as the country must face at present can be met without proper effort. The one thing that is wrong is that there has been no consistency in the efforts that have been made. We have not had, as there should be, an effort to increase production, particularly where agriculture is concerned. Is it not a shameful thing that last year we should have a diminution of our agricultural production? We have had a 2 per cent. increase in industrial production but we have had a corresponding set-back in agriculture. The whole national income in real terms is precisely as it was, but on the national production there are increasing demands.
The same want of consistency is true of the Government in its attitude in regard to prices. They are acting as the dog chasing its tail. There has been no effort to get stability at any stage because it is the hard thing to do politically and they will not face that. Our national income has not gone up. Agricultural production has gone down. The obvious thing to aim at is to increase agricultural production and to increase production in industry, and that would enable us to overcome our difficulties in the safest manner. We have had an investigation into taxation on industry and after a number of years a report has been presented. One would think that that report would be studied and that if there was anything in it worth while it would be acted upon immediately. Surely there are experts enough to be able to come quickly to a conclusion as to whether there are in relation to this report possibilities in regard to changing the incidence of taxation so as to encourage production, and that if there are that measures would be taken now when it is so vitally necessary instead of postponing action on the report and putting it on the shelf.
There is no indication from the Government's side of a systematic effort to secure an increase in production. As far as we are concerned, we are voting against this Budget because of the fact that the Government has not tackled this problem consistently and because of the fact that the people who are bringing in this Budget are people who a few years ago said Budgets like this were not necessary and are now eating their words. As a public protest against the dishonesty now exposed, we propose to vote against this Budget. In relation to many of the statements that have been made by the Government, I do hope we have exploded some of the myths that were created and that it has been proved that what was done by us worked out in the long run in the country's interests. I hope we have exploded, for instance, the myth about the fabulous sums being available in the way of past savings to meet all requirements. As far as I can see the total amount of our external reserves at the present time can hardly be much above and is likely to be below the £100,000,000 mark. There was the year when we had to bring in this distasteful Budget and we had to face a deficit of roughly £61.6 million. Now there is one of £35.5 million. Naturally one asks the question: are the steps which the Government are taking sufficient to bring that down to what would be considered a manageable sum and many people who are interested in national finance are not satisfied that even £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 would be such because of the various consequences in the long run.
If there was a deficit of £35,000,000 last year and if the total reserve that is now available is probably less than £100,000,000 net, how long can we stand such deficits? Is there any real prospect that in the coming year there will be a deficit which will be less than £35,000,000? The first three months do not hold out very substantial hope. I do not think that they show any such hopeful indication. As well as I remember, there is about £28,000,000 of an excess in the three months. Four times £28,000,000 would be £112,000,000. That would be £112,000,000 on our mercantile trade, as compared with £94,000,000. I think it was £21,000,000, for the corresponding three months of last year. If we take four times the £21,000,000, it is short the year's £94,000,000. So, if we take the three months as in any way indicating what will happen in the year, we will not have a smaller deficit, but, apparently, will have a greater deficit. I hope it will not be so. The Minister has suggested that there seems to be a change since he imposed the levies, that the import excess has come down in the month of March, although it went up very dangerously in January and February. It is not yet clear, however, that the debit balance in our total external payments which, of course, is immediately affected by the balance in our merchandise trade will be reduced this year to a level less than it was last year. It went up by, I think, £29,000,000 or £30,000,000 last year, over what it had been before.
We have a very big leeway to make good and we will not make good by half measures. My own feeling is that we will have a very dangerous further deficit in our balance of payments next year and that our net reserves would not enable us to face two more such deficits as that one. The result then would be that we would be back as a debtor country and, if we do get back into that position, then, almost of necessity, our standard of living will fall because people will not lend to us on credit the things that we are able to buy because of the savings we have at the present time.
I conclude by saying that I regard the national economic situation as a serious situation, that serious measures have to be taken to deal with it and that we have no confidence that the present Government, constituted as they are and with the record of their past statements, are the people to deal with it.
Comment on this
A good deal of the criticism of the Budget that has been levelled by the Party in the opposite benches appears to be because of indignation at the attitude of the Labour Party now as compared with their attitude in 1952. I expect a good deal of irritation can be caused by the fact that the Labour Party are intelligent enough to take the line of action that they have taken during the past two years but it ill-behoves speakers on the opposite benches, especially the last speaker, to remind people of broken promises. People who live in glass-houses should not throw stones. We in the Labour movement have vivid recollection of promises made in a certain 18-point programme that undertook that, come what would, there would be no removal of the food subsidies.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will give me an opportunity I will find it in the newspapers in the Library and have it placed anywhere he would like to consult it.
Comment on this
The Labour Party are not trying to make any alibis in regard to cigarettes or the use of cigarettes by workers. We said then, and we say now, that cigarettes are out of the luxury class and have become practically an urgent necessity to most of the people of this country. That is so. But, when a Minister is endeavouring to balance a Budget, he does not succeed in raising revenue by putting a tax on top-hats or bedroom slippers.
The sale of those commodities is so negligible as to bring in very little revenue. The Minister must select something that is in popular demand, used by practically every one of the people and all the time. Could anyone in the Fianna Fáil benches suggest one article that the Minister was free to tax that would less injure the working man and his family than the tax on cigarettes and bring in the desired revenue?
We were conscious and proud of our small part in the statement by the Minister at the beginning of his Budget speech:—
"Let it be clear now as from this moment that there is no intention of interfering with the food subsidies."
To those of us who profess to be Labour representatives, and to those of us who are sincerely and honestly interested in the life of the working man and his family, it was heartening to hear a Minister give that assurance. We accept that assurance as applying, not only to this year, but to every other year of the lifetime of this Government until such time as world events permit the natural reductions in the cost of living and the natural withdrawal of food subsidies.
There is no attempt by the Labour Party to run away from their promises or from their attitude. Does Deputy de Valera, as Deputy O'Leary suggested, forget the jump in the price of a pound of butter following the 1952 Budget? Does he suggest that there is any comparison between the injury or the sufferings inflicted by this Budget and by the 1952 Budget? Is there any comparison in the effect on the worker's family? Under the 1952 Budget, the price of butter jumped from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb. and butter is an essential commodity for the health of the worker and of his wife and children.
Even I, who am an advocate of cigarette smoking, unlike Deputy de Valera, would not have the hardihood or the foolishness to suggest that cigarettes are good from a health point of view. Possibly, they placate nerves. Possibly, they are something we are entitled to enjoy. I do not think that anyone, even the most ardent smoker, would suggest that the national interest is being jeopardised by an additional tax on cigarettes. Look at the revenue that comes from the extra tax.
I was surprised to hear Deputy Bartley, speaking on the unemployment figures in relation to a certain section, drawing attention to the fact that, in 1954, when the inter-Party Government was in office, there was a remarkable increase in unemployment. He also suggested that at another period when Fianna Fáil were in office, there was a remarkable decrease. Surely Deputy Bartley, with his experience in the Dáil, must know that there is such a thing as an employment period and an unemployment period. Surely he does not believe that because there is a change of Government, these figures could alter so radically at any time. His suggestions were typical of the effort being made to build up a case for the benefit of the unwise and the unlearned that this Government are, by manipulation, increasing or decreasing employment.
Deputy Bartley also suggested that the trade unions are now crying out for inflation. At no time did any trade union, no matter to what congress it belonged, look for inflation. He also said that we cried out against the standstill Orders during the Emergency. The only standstill Order against which we cried out was that on wages. We were quite happy that there should be standstills on price increases. We have no wish that prices should be increased at any time. It is understandable that we would be satisfied that wages should remain stationary, but I would to remain stationary, but I would remind Deputy Bartley and others to study the principle advocated by the magazine Irish Industry which has taken great pains always to point out that, if we got increased wages, the natural consequence must be increased prices. I would like to point out now that we have never sought increased wages before price increases. When we seek wage increases before the Labour Court, we have to prove, per the index figures, that prices have gone up and that we were four, five or six points behind, and that we had been so far behind for anything from six to 12 months. We have to prove that we are looking for compensation for such price increases.
It is nonsense to say that if wages go up, prices must go up also, because the very minute wages go up to compensate for an earlier increase in price, prices follow suit. It is time the Government saw that these increases in wages, sought to compensate for previous increases in prices, were not passed on. I will leave it to the Government to carry out that job.
When I stood up, I did not intend to make a long speech on the Budget. I was moved to make a longer speech than I intended by some of the speakers I had listened to while waiting to get in. Now that all the noise and excitement of Budget day has passed, we have been given the opportunity to examine what effect the Budget has had on the people. In my own quiet way, I took advantage of my spare time to go around my constituency and find out what the people thought. It is no use saying that people like to pay more for their cigarettes. They do not. On Monday morning, the first morning, I think, that cigarettes were increased in price, there was a great deal of criticism of the people responsible for the new increase. That is a natural thing. Nobody likes to pay more, particularly if his wages remain stationary.
However, it is recognised in most homes that this is a working man's Budget. Although the housewife who smokes has some criticisms to make, she still says: "Thanks be to God, there is no increase in the price of foodstuffs." I challenge anyone on any side of the House to say that is not true. Thanks be to God, the increases are not on foodstuffs. Thanks be to God, the prices of essential things are not increased.
It was impossible for the Minister to balance his Budget without extra taxation, but he picked the things that affected the public interest least and that will probably bring in a substantial revenue. I should like to congratulate the Minister on leaving the food subsidies stationary. I expressed the hope earlier that the promise of this year is also the promise for the years to come. In the Labour Party, we believe still that the price of essential foodstuffs must be kept within the means of the ordinary people of the country, even if it is necessary to give food subsidies to keep that position in existence. We accept the principle of imposing taxation on some of the things that we enjoy as luxuries.
Deputy Bartley referred to the increased social welfare benefits as trivial. Can any members of the Fianna Fáil Party recall when there was a 25 per cent. increase on social welfare benefits given by any other Government? I do not think that 25 per cent. is a trivial matter. I do not for a moment suggest it is more than was necessary, or that it is as much as was necessary, but I accept the 25 per cent. increase on these benefits as a very substantial benefit to the people concerned. I accept it as a contribution, as a help to the people who are sick or unemployed. It is a reasonable help towards meeting the mounting cost of living and I dislike its being described as something of no importance.
To us in the Labour Party it is important. It is something that we in the Labour Party take credit in sharing with the Government, and as long as we are in this Government, we shall endeavour to help the unfortunate people who are unemployed or ill. Were the Minister for Social Welfare in the House, I would say to him that we still cannot sit back complacently, having achieved this. This is not the end of the road. We have been in office now for almost half our period. In a few months, the beginning of the other half will have begun. The Minister for Social Welfare and the Cabinet would want to see to it that a comprehensive social welfare scheme of a contributory kind will be embarked upon to give decent incomes to old, unemployed and ill people. A sum of 30/- a week may suffice for the time being, but that is not quite enough.
When Deputy de Valera was speaking, I was interested in what he stopped short of saying. Although I would not like to put words into his mouth, my interpretation of what he was about to say when he stopped is that, when the nation is in distress, when imports are in excess of exports, there should be economies and that one of the economies we should look for should be in social welfare benefits. His suggestion was that they were too high. It is quite true he stopped just short of saying that, but that is what he implied. I believe that that is where Deputy de Valera's Government made a mistake. I think that too much emphasis was placed by him on our external assets. I believe there is no point in having external assets unless they are to be of some use and unless you can call on them when you need them. I believe that this country in the past two years has been going through a time which was made for the use of external assets and that we did well to draw on them. We did well to finance our economy and keep our standard of living as high as we did keep it.
I should like to congratulate the Minister on his Budget and in particular on the continuation of the food subsidies, on the improvements in sick and unemployment benefit, and on giving to a very deserving section of the community, the retired local government officials and retired Government servants of pre-1950 vintage, a token increase in their pensions. We are quite satisfied it is not all they are entitled to, but at least it indicates the goodwill of the Government and of the Minister, when even though he is hard pressed to balance his Budget and finds it necessary to impose taxation, he still spares a few thousand pounds for these people.
I hope that the Minister for Finance will indicate, both to the Minister for Local Government and to the Minister for Health, his wish that they would advise local authorities that similar increases should be granted in the retirement pensions of local authority officials to whom they pay pensions. The Minister might like to know that, at least in my constituency, we have already applied repeatedly for permission to do that but I understand it will have to be given both by the Minister for Health and the Minister for Local Government so as to cover the different sections of people who have retired from local government service.
I think I have pretty well said all I have to say. I welcome—although a motorist myself—the tax on petrol because of the fact that, like cigarettes, petrol is a good source of revenue. On last Tuesday or Tuesday week I remember driving to Dublin to attend the Dáil when I had the misfortune or the good luck—whichever way you look at it—to see the road from Naas to Dublin one solid mass of cars on the left-hand side, all obviously bound for Punchestown. I remember saying to myself that it was a pity that I was not Minister for Finance and I would make a good job of these people. Apparently there is such a thing as thought-transference because the Minister did a good job on petrol and betting, but I am sorry he did not do a little better with the racegoers. I am sure there was not one of them without £10 or £15 to gamble in their pockets.
However, I have little grievance against the Minister and, in fact, the only grievance I have is a strange one. It is that when he put a tax on dancing he did not help a little bit by taking a little more from the cinemas and imposing a slightly increased tax. The dance tax was imposed by Deputy MacEntee and I understand one of the reasons why he discontinued it later on was the difficulty of collection. I think it is pretty true that 80 per cent. of the dance tax will, under the present arrangement, have to be spent in collecting it and that would be unfortunate, but I suppose there is no way out unless the Minister for Finance adopts a suggestion made to me by somebody who is not a member of my Party. That suggestion is that the dance tax could be imposed on the valuation of the dance hall and that each year, when the dance hall was being licensed, the licensee would pay the tax and charge proportionately more to the people to whom he or she rented the dance hall. In that way all, or practically all, of the revenue-would come in straight to the Department. I do not know whether there is wisdom or value in that suggestion, but I am happy about one thing, and that is that we, as Labour Deputies, take responsibility equally with other Deputies for what has been done in this Budget. Equally, as Labour Deputies, we take credit for the fact that the working sections of the people were the principal beneficiaries of the statement made by the Minister on last Tuesday.
Comment on this
Although Deputy Finlay has already spoken in this debate I am allowing him to intervene briefly in order to correct some statistics he gave in the course of his speech.
Comment on this
The position is that I got two sets of figures which were—at least one was—correct, but they were not comparable. I quoted the figure out of a reply to a parliamentary question in regard to the number of civil servants in 1953. That was the correct figure for permanent and temporary civil servants, totalling 37,600 odd in that year. I got a figure for 1955 which, in error, I took, from a reply given in March, 1955, as being the 1955 figure. It was, in fact, a 1954 figure and applied not to the same group but to established and unestablished civil servants and totalled only 33,000. I might inadvertently mislead the House in the two sets of figures which I gave, and I wish to explain that.
Comment on this
It is rather noticeable that no reference was made by the Minister for Finance to this question of the cost of the Civil Service and of the administration. He referred to the increases, but this year, and so far as I recollect, last year, he did not give what was customary in Budget statements, a general statement of the entire cost of the central administration.
Of course, the point of Deputy Finlay's speech was that the number of civil servants has increased. It has undoubtedly increased by many thousands over the years. I have not the latest figures, but I suppose we will have them next week. In any case, the total remuneration of all civil servants in the pre-war period was about £5,000,000 and last year, I think in the reply to which Deputy Finlay has referred, the cost was given as about £15,000,000. Deputy Kyne should really have protested against this House adjourning on the day of the Punchestown meeting and, perhaps, if the Deputy objects so very strongly to people going to Punchestown in cars he will organise brakes or cabs for the next meeting——
Comment on this
——so that Deputies will be able to travel in proper style and, instead of supporting the motor industry, support the horse, which is in danger of disappearing.
Comment on this
The Deputy forgets that Punchestown takes place on only two days a year but cars are in use, even by Deputies, on a great many days of the year. They are in use by hackney drivers, for example, and lorry owners. The Minister for Finance has refused to meet a deputation of the hackney drivers. Does Deputy Kyne suggest that hackney drivers or lorry owners and lorry drivers are in the same position as the people going to Punchestown, in the long lines of cars? He also foresaw what Deputy de Valera was going to say and was able to read his thoughts for us; but he need not depend on what Deputy de Valera was going to say. He can read what the Minister for Social Welfare said at Strasbourg, as reported in the Press, in connection with the question of how far countries should go in providing social services. The Minister for Social Welfare represented the Government there, as well as, I presume, the Labour Party and the Labour movement in this country. Perhaps Deputy Kyne has not seen the statement?
Comment on this
It did not seem to get the same publicity as it might have got, had it been made by a Fianna Fáil Minister in Strasbourg. There was a proposal there that there should be a charter for the working people— the "toiling masses", as the Tánaiste used to call them, who were being treated so brutally and savagely by his predecessors in the Government. What did the Minister for Social Welfare say about this workers' charter. He said:—
"The charter would, among other things, oblige Governments to guarantee to their peoples the right to earn a living with a minimum of two weeks' annual holiday with pay."
—I think we had that in this country long before Deputy Corish became Minister—
"adequate food, clothing, housing and free medical care."
And the Minister for Social Welfare said, in opposing the proposition that the Council of Europe ought to accept this charter:—
"The social charter might become just a flourish of rhetoric because it was too ambitious."
Deputy Kyne and his colleagues can take that and interpret it and explain it and say exactly what it means when they go down to their local branches.
Comment on this
That is the effective and important part of what he said. Last year, when the Minister had the opportunity of relieving the plight of the taxpayer, he failed to avail himself of it. It is quite true that he indicated that there was in existence such a person as "John Citizen, taxpayer". The way in which the Minister for Finance in last year's Budget called our attention to the existence of that individual was by allowing him a reduction in his income-tax, through an increase in allowances. The amount came to £100,000. John Citizen had done very well by the Minister for Finance last year; he had served him up with very relishing dishes to the advantage of the National Exchequer which benefited to the extent of nearly £25,000,000 —£24.8 million—and, out of that huge revenue from income-tax, the Minister saw fit to bestow upon the citizen taxpayer the wretched solatium of £100,000.
I am sure, if the Minister enjoyed a meal in any restaurant in Strasbourg, Paris or in Dublin, he would not have offered a waiter such a wretchedly small proportion of the cost of the meal. We have the 10 per cent. service charge, but that 10 per cent. service charge was very far from the Minister's mind when he gave the tip of £100,000 out of £25,000,000 to the income-tax payer last year. He has done better this year. The pourboire amounts to £106,000, although it is estimated that the revenue from income-tax will come to £25.2 million. In the past two years, it has increased by £700,000. We can be quite sure of the £100,000 reduction last year and of £106,000 this year, because we know very precisely what these estimated allowances are going to cost; but we know that the estimated revenue often exceeds, and indeed invariably exceeds, the estimate which is presented to this House, so it may be that the taxpayer will actually contribute more than £25,250,000 to the Exchequer.
The figure which would correspond to that in 1938-39 was, I think, £5.8 million. However, that is not the end of the story. Slimming is very fashionable and I suppose the Minister for Finance has been reading the fashionable periodicals and has decided to give John Citizen a really good course in slimming and reduce his condition. The taxpayer must get his weight right down in earnest on this occasion; he is really getting out of hand, becoming a nuisance to the Minister for Finance and the Government, and he will have to be taught that his good health depends upon abstinence, moderation, doing without the things he would like to have and he is accustomed to having, but which the Government, knowing better, are quite sure are the worst possible things for his good health. His financial avoirdupois, as they might put it, is being reduced very substantially again this year because there is additional expenditure to be met.
Leaving out motor vehicle duties, the Minister has informed us that estimated expenditure is over £8,000,000 higher as compared with last year's actual expenditure; and to meet this, after certain allowances have been deducted, extra taxation is to bring in about £5.3 million, making net revenue from taxation almost £94,500,000. That is equivalent to 21 per cent. of the total national income last year, leaving aside altogether the estimated revenue of £3,000,000 from the import levies and the £5,750,000 from motor vehicle duties, not to speak of the £18,000,000 for rates and £5,250,000 for contributions to State insurance by employees and employers respectively.
The taxpayer, therefore, may take in his belt a couple of inches. But it is not merely that his financial girth is likely to be decreased or slimmed down to the appropriate proportions, but, in fact, it looks as if the position is that, so long as there is any flesh left on his bones, even when the bones themselves become visible, the Government and the Minister for Finance will not desist from collecting more and more from him.
The Minister has told us that the full impact of the increases in remuneration will only be felt this year; it is only during the present year that employers will have to foot the complete bill in respect of increases in wages and salaries granted last year. We do not know yet what else may be in store for these employers or for the State. We do know, however, that in the past the estimates of State expenditure in regard to labour always had to show a considerable margin for increased expenditure, which, in my experience and in the experience, I dare say, of the present Ministers, always went beyond the estimate as drawn up at the beginning of the year, because of increases in wages in the ensuing period, increases that could not be foreseen and could only be guessed at.
Now the price of coal is to go up. Freight charges to Britain are to go up. Transport charges are likely to go up here. Raw materials and the cost of imports generally, as well as coal, are likely to increase. The Minister has told us that there is likely to be no change in the situation, so far as the terms of trade are concerned. The trend of prices in the international market indicates that those who have to import raw materials or primary commodities will very likely be faced with increased costs in doing so. It is in these conditions, then, that the taxpayer, and particularly the taxpayer who is also a producer, will have to pay more for his postage, for his petrol and for his cigarettes. These are the incentives which the Government proposes for the producer, at a time when increasing costs are pressing upon him with greater severity. The well-managed business may be able to bear these imports. It may be able to pass the burden on in due course to the consumer. But what of the smaller business, the average business, the family business? Will it be in a position to pass on the imposts to the consumer? What will be the position of that business now under the credit squeeze which, we are told, is in operation? What of the additional labour and the other costs that business has to bear at the present time, finding it difficult and, in fact, impossible in many cases to make ends meet? The owner of the small business, the small employer, the individual producer working for himself gets no recognition whatsoever from the Government and no gesture in the way of reduced taxation.
When the Minister spoke last year of the changed conditions and the possibility that this year might not be even as good, he should have foreseen that circumstances were tending to move against us, from the economic point of view. He saw certain unfavourable factors appearing on the horizon and he should then, I think, have taken his courage in his hands and given a reduction in income-tax, since that would have been the greatest incentive he could offer to production and investment. Charity begins at home. The Government announced with a great flourish of trumpets the reliefs in taxation available to foreign industry, but their callous and cold-blooded indifference to the plight of the individual taxpayer, and particularly to the plight of the producer, is in violent contrast to their interest in, encouragement of and invitation to foreign entrepreneurs in our midst.
It has often been said that the eyes of the fool are on the ends of the earth. While Ministers have been inviting foreigners into this country to develop it, to take out of it, as they have done in other hitherto undeveloped countries, at the price of a royalty to the people or the Government of the community in question, the mineral resources, the natural wealth of the country—and they are permitted to do that without paying any taxation, left entirely free from contributing to our Exchequer—and while, on the other hand, for two successive years, the Minister can refuse to acknowledge the existence of the ordinary Irish taxpaying citizen, treat him with absolute contempt and indifference, surely, all that should give people food for thought.
Comment on this
There is no magic formula now for balancing the Budget. The present Government had a wonderful formula at one time. They would increase production to such an extent that, upon the proceeds of the increased yield from taxation at the current rate, they would not alone be able to finance the existing services but they would be able to bring in new services at the same time. They could accomplish all that, because they would eliminate extravagance.
At column 1411, Volume 150 of the Official Report the Taoiseach said, speaking on the Budget last year:—
"We will eliminate extravagance. So far as possible we will cut public expenditure and by a suitable production policy, and not just mere talk about production, we will bring about a situation whereby the national income will be increased and the real wealth of the country will be increased."
That was the Taoiseach last year. I am afraid events have rather falsified his declaration and anticipations. The Minister has made up his mind that he must show a surplus this year. It would really be unkind to refer to what the Minister said in 1952 when his predecessor, now on this side of the House, announced the measures which he found it necessary to take to balance the Budget and try to effect a surplus in that year.
At column 271, Volume 150, the present Minister for Finance advanced a most interesting theory. Unnecessary taxation, he said, was being imposed for the purpose of enabling the Government to remain in power for a further 12 months, and at the end of that time they would remove that taxation, show that they had a surplus, and hope that the public memory was short. I hope that no such extraordinary ideas have occurred to the Minister for Finance in preparing his present taxation and Budget proposals.
Comment on this
He has pointed to the much increased costs of the Government's services, particularly of a nonproductive and recurring character, constituting a permanent liability on the taxpayer. The pay increase amounted to £2,500,000 without any countervailing economies whatever. They all mount up, and one wonders whether the democratic system itself can survive, or will be in a position to survive, these constantly increasing burdens which political exigencies, rather than any economic or moral consideration, are forcing it to bear. Many well-informed, well-disposed persons believe that a crash can scarcely be avoided in the long run, there are so many reapers and such a lamentable shortage of sowers. We ask the Minister for Finance where is the money going to come from, or at what point the Government will come to decide that a halt must be called and that they will make an announcement that there will be no further increases in the cost of the central administration? When, where and how are the Government likely to come to a decision on that? How soon are we likely to get a declaration from the Minister for Finance and the Government in that matter?
Nobody will grudge the increases to pensioners, but it is no harm looking at the superannuation, as only one side of the Government's accounts, a side that is not often referred to. The reason I mention it is because when we had difficulties about the superannuation for teachers and it was found that the teachers' pension fund was entirely inadequate to meet the increases that had been granted and the question arose how the deficit was to be met, of course the whole burden had to be transferred from the fund to the yearly Estimates, the Supply Services. It was pointed out in this House at the time that the existence of such funds as the teachers' pension fund or any other funds which were set aside specifically as a hypothecation against the ever-increasing charges, now very much greater than could be imagined at that time, served a very valuable purpose, and that it was not alone unwise but perhaps had an element of danger for the State, and particularly for the Minister for Finance who has to find the money, that the whole dead weight of the superannuation should fall directly upon the Supply Services.
This year, in any event, it is no harm to glance at the various headings. We have Civil Service, £955,000; Posts and Telegraphs, £450,000; Garda, £515,000; Teachers, £643,000; Army Pensions Vote, £1,630,000, and the Old Age Pensions Vote, which is in a somewhat different category, £10,310,000. If we regard the last item for the moment as being part of the superannuation bill, so to speak, we get a grand total of £14,500,000.
I may be asked what is the remedy to meet this mounting cost of superannuation. There is no remedy in so far as cutting shorter the lives of superannuitants is concerned. They continue to live longer and longer, God bless them, and I hope that in the time to come their health and years will continue. But at any rate, one might be permitted to suggest that one way to keep the bill both for administration and superannuation in check and in balance would be to reduce the permitted increases in the establishment. The Minister has not stated that he is going to do that. He is going to set up a committee of secretaries to go into the question of reorganisation and economies resulting therefrom. If there are no increases, and we reach a position of stability, we may ultimately, with goodwill, reach a position where the staffs on the administration side might be more comparable to the numbers employed on similar work in private concerns.
The Minister has emphasised the danger of increasing costs threatening the maintenance of our existing exports and hampering the development of new exports. He informed us that the imperative need for stability in our present difficulties and economic circumstances is becoming more widely accepted. If this fundamental need, which he so rightly stressed, is becoming clearly understood by those who are most intimately concerned that is, indeed, welcome news. But, if the need is not more widely accepted, why not let the Dáil and the country into the secret?
Why has the Taoiseach not been able to give us some information as to the result of the discussions between the Ministers and the representatives of the trade unions? Is it that it was not possible to issue even an agreed statement, which, really, as everyone knows, amounts to very little but at least gives the public information that certain topics were discussed? I am sure it was not the state of their health, or the very fine weather we have been having which is not so very helpful to the farmers, that these gentlemen discussed. They must surely have discussed problems arising out of the Budget and, in particular, the problem of increasing costs and the necessity for keeping down consumption and increasing savings and investment, emphasised throughout his statement by the Minister for Finance. Perhaps, the position is that the unions did not accept the Government's expressed view regarding the need for stability. If that is so the Minister's statement that it is being more widely accepted is rather wide of the mark. Perhaps the representatives of the trade unions detect a certain inconsistency—and not for the first time— between the Government's professed aims and the steps they are taking, to carry these into effect.
The terms of trade are not moving in our favour the Minister said. Every rise in world prices increases our trade deficit. The paramount necessity for greatly increased savings and investment is clearly causing the Minister and the Government concern. But they are not able to give the country any information and the leaders of the unions have not seen fit to give the country any information as to what their attitude in this matter is, although, as has been already mentioned this afternoon, negotiations have been officially on foot between the employers and the unions for some time past.
The Minister says the co-operation of the citizens is necessary. Undoubtedly it is necessary that the citizens should understand the position but when he talks about costs and the dangers of pricing ourselves out of the markets, to which we have access at the present time, is it not very necessary and of the highest importance that the co-operation of the unions should be sought and obtained? Is there any reason why these matters should be kept secret? Are they not matters of public importance? If we have strikes, if we have industrial troubles, we hear all about it very quickly in a very unpleasant way at times. In this case, the Taoiseach apparently has nothing to report. Is it then that there is no co-operation forthcoming on that side?
The Taoiseach was full of confidence last year. He was brimming over with fine sentiments and good intentions. Our first job, he said, was to restore confidence to the people, to restore confidence in the economic conditions existing here, and, having restored confidence, the other things would come in time, with good government and a good policy.
Comment on this
Column 1400, Volume 150. From the gloomy picture that the Minister for Finance has painted, it does not look as if the Taoiseach was in close contact with existing conditions, or with the trends of events, when he told us that they had restored confidence in the economic conditions of this country last year, or if they had it was certainly very short-lived, as the circumstances referred to by the Minister regarding the raising of money for our State capital programmes have indicated. These pious expressions of belief, these platitudes to which we are so accustomed are not likely to solve any of our problems. The country needs leadership. It needs not only realistic appraisal of the difficulties but realistic remedies applied to them. Of what use is the diagnosis of our economic ills or of what purpose are the prescriptions if the remedies are inadequate, or if the remedies that are necessary are not applied?
I think we can agree with the Minister that there is a psychological problem—this problem I referred to a few moments ago—of getting the co-operation, the interest and the goodwill of the parties that determine the levels of costs in this country, for example, and that by their actions now will determine what our position will be in two or three years' time, when it may, if the proper steps are not now taken, become much more difficult even than is the case at present. I believe it is here the Government has failed and I fear must fail.
As Deputy de Valera said, they demoralised a great number of common-sense working people in this country a few years ago when they spoke of a scare crisis, a scare situation that the Government had then created. When the Government, as the authority responsible in this country for the time being, says there is a serious situation it ought to be accepted and it is accepted on this side of the House. As Deputy de Valera has pointed out it was not accepted a few years ago.
The result is that the Government has failed to give the country any sense of urgency in regard to this matter. There is nothing they have done that has sought to bring home to the people in a vivid and impressive manner that the situation is serious. The only way obviously the people can be got to believe it is serious is by seeing the Government bestir itself and taking the necessary action. If the people are to believe that the situation is grave and if their support is to be enlisted in a convincing way surely it is for the Government, when asking them to carry out its wishes, and to co-operate in the important matter of economising and saving, to give the good example itself at the top.
Precepts will certainly be more effective if they are followed up by example—by being put into practice. A recent publication of the Dutch Government, circulated to Deputies, stated that the total investment outlay in Holland this year represents the equivalent of one fourth of the total domestic expenditure of that country. Our savings in 1955 amounted to less than 6 per cent. of our national income. Personal savings amounted to only 4 per cent. or to two-thirds of all our savings. There are other agencies as well as the hire purchase organisations competing with the Government and attracting personal expenditure to an increasing degree.
The Minister has not given us the items regarding personal consumption in this State so that the public would be in a position to judge what amounts of money are being spent and in what directions. It is a considerable time since the Director of the Statistics Branch called attention to the necessity for getting information regarding the amount of our investments. I suggest that in his concluding statement the Minister should try to give the country more information, particularly as regards the first item I have mentioned. We have been living as a community upon past savings and drawing upon these at a greater rate. Instead of replenishing our resources, we are steadily consuming or reducing them. This cannot continue for long.
It is quite evident that the boom conditions in the United States and elsewhere will have the effect of raising our import prices still further. To finance our trade, therefore, we require greater reserves. There is a danger line below which we cannot afford to go, because, if we do, we will suffer, and it may be years before the position can be recovered. The position may arise then that, in the circumstances in which this country has been unfortunately placed for the past few years, and perhaps will be for the future, national policy in these important matters can be determined, not by a majority, in effect, of the elected representatives, but by a minority. It may take only a few years, if we were to allow the position to occur, and we have got very near it, for us to become a debtor country.
We surely must not allow the situation to arise, 40 years after 1916, in which this country will not only not be able to pay its way either on its current or its capital accounts, but in which we would be reduced to the position of the beggar, going to barter our independence and certainly our economic future to try to raise loans and almost certainly failing to raise them in foreign markets.
Comment on this
It is not a poor ghost story. The present Minister for Agriculture was able to tell us very eloquently about it a few years ago. We know what happened to New Zealand when she had to go begging to the London stock market. The Minister for Agriculture was able to tell us what happened to Newfoundland. Does the Parliamentary Secretary consider that our economic position is so strong that we can afford to neglect these things, having regard to the situation that the Minister for Finance has told us has developed since last summer? That is just a few short months ago and the situation has developed after all the promises and the delightful anticipations of the Taoiseach and of other members of the Government Party 12 months previously. Surely the Parliamentary Secretary knows these situations can develop very rapidly and that our economy, as is admitted in the Budget statement, is more prone to injury by sudden changes in the world outside than it ever was before.
It is surely a commonplace that the more we depart from the natural economy to which we were accustomed in this country, to enter into the new modern economy, the more exposed we will be. We can do nothing to improve our export prices, but we can at least concentrate on reducing costs and on improving the quality, as well as increasing the output. The Government has failed lamentably to give a lead in these matters.
I want to say, in conclusion, it has been well said by a very distinguished man that the continued progress in technical efficiency is the dominating factor in the growth of real national income. First things should certainly come first, and surely the training of our skilled workers, through an expansion of technical education and an improvement of our apprenticeship system, is entitled to high priority on the State programme of capital development. The British Government recently issued a White Paper on technical education which shows that since the war they have increased their number of graduates or highly skilled technological workers. I understand that the Government have had their attention called to this matter by the representatives of science, by the universities and the technological institutions in this country. I think they would be well advised, as a first step, to do their share to try to keep abreast of present day developments by setting up a national advisory body to make recommendations on technological training appropriate to present-day conditions.
Comment on this
The whole trend of the Budget debate seems to have centred on the balance of payments. Before I direct a few words to that aspect of the matter, I should like to say that, no matter what political points are made here, no matter how one wants to shirk the issue, the fact remains that we have just had a year of rising costs and that this Government has had to honour its obligations to its servants, whether they be the ordinary postman, the Civic Guard or the higher civil servant. The Government have met these obligations and have had their difficulties in meeting them, just as the small employer or the large employer, the farmer and the shopkeeper have had their difficulties in meeting what has been to them a year of increased costs and increased labour remuneration.
It is easy to decry increased wages and it is just as easy to do the other thing and claim credit for it. This situation has developed largely as a result of economic trends all over the world and there was not a thing anybody could do about it. The Minister has to balance his Budget, just as the ordinary businessman has to balance his budget. The extra load that had to be placed on the community was inevitable, and the Minister must be congratulated on having succeeded, by such hard work and drive, in cutting that load to the minimum.
I am quite sure there are some decent men who have to use a car every day in their lives, who also smoke cigirettes and who will be hard hit by this Budget. It is reasonable that, in a year of rising costs, there would be some people hard hit. I think that, taking all things in their proper perspective, there has, in fact, been a storm but we have weathered it very well. Great thanks are due to the Minister for Finance for the great job he has done in helping us to weather that storm.
With regard to the balance of payments, it is easy to say what were the difficulties in years gone by and to say that the balance of payments problem in 1952 caused the 1952 Budget, which was a great blow to the country and the ordinary individual. I do not propose to say that. If we have got a balance of payments problem we have got to do our best to end it. The Minister, by imposing a levy on 58 articles of import, and by restricting hire purchase which, in my opinion, should have been restricted years ago, has sought to grapple with the balance of payments problem at its root. It is the simplest thing in the world to cure that problem with a sledge hammer. All you have to do is to decrease the purchasing power of the people because the things they purchase will contain, in a great measure, articles from abroad. If you reduced their purchasing power, you would be taking a great step towards dealing with the balance of payments.
I might say that there was a balance of payments problem in 1952 and that the gentlemen at the other side of the House dealt with it in no uncertain manner. I shall not say that. The two situations are entirely different. I am saying that in 1952 a serious mistake was made but then the situation was different. We have now a balance of payments problem and the necessity exists to deal with it. I think the Minister has dealt with it in a gentle, kind and humane way. I suppose that in 1952 we had an even greater problem but we should not forget that, since 1948, 42,000 houses were built in this country. This means, that if you take an average family of five people, practically one in ten is now housed in a new building. When you consider that, and the colossal expenditure that resulted from it, when you consider the land reclamation scheme and all the capital expenditure there has been for the past couple of years is it unreasonable that we should have a balance of payments problem?
We, on both sides of the House, have approached that problem in two different ways and I think our way is the better. I think the country as a whole realises that it is the better way and that there is not, in the country, any resentment to the present Budget.
As usual, the Fianna Fáil Party seems to be divided into two diametrically opposed sections on this matter. You have those who have stood up and declared that this is a terribly hard Budget. Then Deputy de Valera himself said here: "It is better that we should have these hardships now lest there be greater hardships later on". Following on that he said: "We will not make any good by half measures". Is Deputy de Valera following on the same line of thought as did Deputy MacEntee when he spoke on the import levies not more than a few weeks ago and described what he called the Sweetman squeeze as being too soft, too gentle and quite like the kiss of a maiden? Then he said that this squeeze, this kiss of a maiden, would be the kiss of death to the Irish hound. Does that mean that Fianna Fáil would still deal with the balance of payments problem as they did in 1952? Does it mean, as Deputy de Valera said, that we cannot make good by half measures?
I believe that our Minister for Finance has approached the matter reasonably, that he does realise that it is quite hard for people to live in this country, that he realises that things are difficult for many of us and that for those reasons he approached the problem in a proper manner. No matter how anybody at the far side of the House may seek to influence public opinion and to cause a scared feeling in the country, the fact remains that the people realise that this Government is prepared to approach its problems in a humane manner and to put the burden where it can best be carried. That fact is appreciated by the people and will be appreciated by them no matter what is being done to undermine the work of the Government.
Deputy de Valera's line seemed to be that the Government was seeking to cure its problems by effecting a reduction in consumption, as distinct from, and opposed to, an increase in production. Nothing could be further from the truth. Deputy Derrig said that the eyes of a fool were on the ends of the earth and, without saying it, he implied that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should not have tried to bring in foreign industrialists. He criticised the agreement with regard to the Avoca mines and said it was not right that these people should be exempt from income-tax, as it is generally known. That is complete dishonesty.
Everybody knows that, in the case of the Avoca mines, all that is being allowed is that if these people work the mines, sink the shafts and produce a first class mine in Avoca, the capital expenditure involved, in sinking the shafts and working underground before the production stage is reached, may be charged up against the profits for a few years only. In every other country in the world, the position is that it is not allowable to charge up the work on shafts and the making of the new mine faces. How are you going to attract these people if you do not allow them to charge up initial expenditure against profits for a year or so? It is dishonest to suggest that something is being given to foreign industrialists that should not be given to them.
To get back to the question of whether or not the Government is approaching the problem of our balance of payments from the point of view of increase in production or reduction in consumption, it is obvious that every effort has been made in the industrial sphere to increase production. Our Minister has gone abroad and has made every effort to attract all the foreign industrialists he could to our shores. At the same time he told our friends and neighbours, the British, that if they gave him a list of industrialists as long as his arm who wished to come to this country, every one of them would be facilitated to the greatest extent possible. It is irrefutable that all the steps possible have been taken by this Government towards increasing production in industry and also agriculture.
Deputy de Valera made great play about the fact that we are importing £12,000,000 worth of all sorts of grains. What he was trying to convey was that this Government was not encouraging the growing of wheat and the growing of grains. We must be flexible enough in our minds to realise that up to two years ago nobody conceived a situation where enough wheat, for instance, could be grown in this country to meet our needs. The first people to wake up to that situation were the Fianna Fáil Government and in January, 1954, they set about deciding how much wheat they would have in the harvest and how much we would eat and they discovered what was quite correct, that they had too much wheat. Having reached that situation, we must now approach the consideration of grains not on the basis of wheat alone but on the basis of wheat, oats and barley and if you like to include the root crops like beet also.
I do not think we shall ever come to the stage when we can profitably export grain from this country because of the fact that we have certain extra costs in drying which the exporting countries largely do not have to meet. We have succeeded in growing as much of one type of grain as we can eat and we must now approach the whole thing from a different line. We must create a market for our oats and barley up to the level of tillage that we feel we can carry in a proper rotation. No Government has done more to create that market than the present Government. We depend largely on our market for cattle, pigs, poultry and our animals all round. We must increase the number of cattle. What Government has tried to do more than the present Government has done? Which was the first Government to make a cattle agreement with Britain? Who finalised that agreement not so long ago which gave us the opportunity of selling our cattle at a fair price to Britain for the next three years?
If the members of the Opposition would join us in this glorious effort to try to give the farmers of Ireland that feeling of stability and to convince them that if they will rear their calves and sell them as late in life as possible off their farms, depending on their type of husbandry, and that there is a profit assured for them, we could make wonderful progress. I think this Government is the Government which, through its Minister for Agriculture and all its Ministers, have sought to create a feeling of stability and that the gentlemen on the far side of the House are the people who have sought to create a feeling of instability.
It is absolutely necessary that we increase our level of live stock, of pigs and poultry, for the reason that we have now reached the situation where we have grown as much wheat as we can eat and we must now if we wish to increase our grain acreage, make a market for coarse grain which, admittedly, does exist at the moment for the imported article. But if we wish to do that, we must increase our livestock and this Government is the Government that has always tried to lead the people to believe that by their arrangements it was possible to get profit from livestock, from pigs and from poultry. For the last 12 months, the gentlemen on the far side of the House have sought at every possible opportunity to make the people believe that there was not a profit any longer.
Finally, I would like to congratulate the Minister on the fact that so many things which have been so heavily taxed before have escaped when the need was very great for balancing our Budget this year and balancing it completely without borrowing. He said himself in the first few lines of his speech:—
"Borrowing in the present situation would be indefensible."
I am glad that he has imposed no further taxation on beer, wine and spirits. It is now accepted all over the world, that the working man, the businessman or any other man is entitled to a measure of beer and of tobacco without exceeding certain limits. In my opinion the temptation must have been very great on the Minister to place some extra taxation on beer or on spirits. I congratulate him on the fact that he saw the situation in the proper light and placed the taxation so as to gear the Budget to cure as far as possible the balance of payments problem and to aid the levies which were imposed and the hire-purchase restrictions in this regard.
There has been a great deal of criticism from the far side of the House about the fact that the Minister imposed a very small tax on mineral waters. I suppose in the first instance tax on alcohol and alcoholic refreshments was imposed because they were not respectable. That might seem contradictory but when a Minister looks around for new and fresh taxation, he likes to think there are forces in the country which will stand behind him when he makes the unpopular choice. Years ago when taxation was first imposed on alcohol probably the reason was that it was not respectable. But I think the situation has now developed where the excessive drinking or anything else like that that was supposed to have been a feature of our Irish life has largely disappeared. Therefore, I do not see any reason to criticise the Minister, when he is imposing necessary taxes, for putting a small tax on mineral waters.
Taking 1936 as base 100, one finds that, by 1952, the consumption of mineral waters had increased to 326. That represents an extraordinarily large consumption and nobody need tell me that that was accounted for by increased consumption of minerals by children. Most of it, 90 per cent. at least, was made up of mineral waters served to non-drinkers in public houses and restaurants. If money has to be got, the people who consume mineral waters are getting off very lightly and the Minister was kind and gentle to them.
I would recommend that, in future Budgets, if there must be additional taxation, the Minister should approach the whole question of drinks taken in restaurants and bars, from the point of view that the taxation on mineral waters is extraordinarily low and the taxation on alcoholic drinks extraordinarily high. A bottle of ginger ale contains water, imported essence and a little sugar. There is very little labour content in its production. In the case of a bottle of beer or a bottle of stout manufactured in this country, the labour content is very high, from the moment the barley of which it is made is reaped until it is malted and brewed, and the barley helps the Irish farmer.
France and many other countries had to tax mineral waters to solve difficulties with regard to the production of wine. In order that the economic structure of the drink trade should remain sound it may be necessary in the future to tax mineral waters, even for the purpose of removing some of the tax on alcoholic drinks. There is no real reason why a home product, which is not harmful, if not taken in excess, should be taxed to the hilt, when an imported product, which has not nearly the same labour content, even if processed in this country, is left untaxed. The Minister's approach to this problem was the right approach and, as a publican, I laud and thank him for it.
Comment on this
There were two roads open to the Minister when he started to prepare this Budget and I was wondering which road he would take. I wondered whether it would be "A dearly beloved brethren" Budget, which would mean that we would all go to the chapel gates and start off for a general election or a "You can all go somewhere else" Budget. It was the "go somewhere else" one that we got.
I have endeavoured to see if we must be always begging, to see must we, year after year, borrow more to keep this little bit of an island afloat. I suggest to the Minister for Finance that the time of the Parliamentary Secretary, the financial adviser to the Government, would be much better spent, if he were appointed to examine each Department in turn, with a view to getting rid of the surplus stock that is in them. I have put down a parliamentary question about the number of civil servants employed, but the answer will not be given until to-morrow. Some time ago, I got the figures for the number of civil servants employed in the height of the emergency, when everything was rationed, when there were 2,000 men and women in Ballsbridge working on coupons and ration books. To my amazement, I discovered that four years after all that was over, there was an increase of some 4,700 civil servants. What are they doing? Can anyone tell me?
The same unfortunate situation has developed in local authorities since the management system was introduced. Where there used to be one clerk in any special department, he has become a staff officer and he has about 25 clerks dodging around him, all on nonproductive work. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that, if he gets the job I have suggested, I will give him a hand in it for nothing. It would be worth it. Let us cut down our overheads.
I thought something like that was intended from the statements issued prior to the election:—
"We will eliminate extravagance. We will cut public expenditure and by a suitable production policy—not just talk about production—we will bring about a situation whereby the national income will be increased and the real wealth of the country will be increased."
When you ask people to save to-day, what is the first thing they will say?—"For whom shall I save? Is it so that I can lend it to the Government to have a spree?"
I would not mind if civil servants had not got a lesson before. I sought information as to how many increases civil servants had got under an alleged cost-of-living bonus system. Unfortunately, that question, also, will not be answered until to-morrow, but I would suggest to Deputies that it would be well worth their while to take the replies to those questions when they are given by the Minister to-morrow and to examine them and see what is happening.
This country cannot afford to be in the position indicated in the reply given to me this evening by the Minister for Finance, namely, that, in 1956, before you find anything at all to run this country, you must find a dead load of taxation of £13,000,000 odd a year to pay the interest on what has been borrowed to finance the public debt. It is a very interesting figure and the figures for previous years are still more interesting.
Comment on this
I have great pleasure in explaining it here in the presence of the financial genius of the Government. I put down a question here on 23rd April, 1952, to the then Minister for Finance. I asked the Minister if he would state the total amount paid and payable in interest and sinking fund in 1947-48 and in 1952-53. 1947-48 was the year the boys came in; 1952-53 was the year they left.
Comment on this
I got the answer, and here it is. In 1947-48, the borrowing for interest was £3,095,714 and for sinking funds, etc., £1,128,620, a total of £4,224,334. In 1952-53, the sum for interest was £7,354,700 and for sinking fund, £2,725,700. The total in that year was £10,080,400. That represented over £6,000,000 of a jump, of a dead load debt on this country that had to be found every year by whatever Government was in power. That has now jumped to over £13,000,000— £3,000,000 a year more. I was anxious to know who did the job. I asked the Minister the total amount of State borrowings in each of the years 1947-48 to 1951-52 inclusive and in the years 1932-33 to 1947-48 inclusive.
Comment on this
I am giving what I got. I was anxious to know how much was borrowed by Cumann na nGaedheal, as they were then.
Comment on this
With all respect to the Deputy, I have a copy of the reply given on 6th July, 1954. It is in the form of a tabulated statement and it gives the figure for 1923-24.
Comment on this
Not here. I will read the whole lot of it. It is given in Volume 131, column 167 of the Official Report.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well able to help himself. All the help the Parliamentary Secretary needs is a sucking bottle and he might put a little drop of that gripe water in it to help him out.
Comment on this
During the years 1923-24 to 1931-32 inclusive, the amount borrowed totalled £29,326,800. From 1932-33 to 1947-48 inclusive, the amount borrowed was £51,316,400. The figures for the period 1932-33 to 1947-48 include the following loans for special purposes: £10,000,000 3¾ per cent. Financial Agreement Loan. This loan was issued in May, 1938, to provide the funds required for the settlement of the dispute which arose out of the Secret Financial Agreement of 1923; £7,000,000 4 per cent. Exchequer Bonds. This issue was made in December, 1939, for the purpose of meeting the abnormal expenditure on national defence necessitated by the outbreak of war in Europe in September, 1939; and £7,920,000 3¼ per cent. National Security Loan issued in November, 1941, to provide further funds for national defence. These abnormal items, the Minister said in his reply to my question, totalled £24,920,000.
Comment on this
The purposes for which the loans were raised hardly influences the provisions of the Budget.
Comment on this
Right. Now, we come to the later date and I should like to call the particular attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to the fact that out of a total of £51,000,000, £24,000,000 had to be raised for a very definite purpose. In 1947-48, we borrowed £5,400,500; in 1948-49, we borrowed £8,951,500; in 1949-50, the figure was £20,539,000; in 1950-51, £21,686,000; and in 1951-52, £38,938,900. That is a pretty hefty sum for a spree. It is a pretty good sum for the running of a country for three years.
Comment on this
Particularly the last year the Deputy read out. It was nearly double the amount for the other years.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is suggesting that Deputy McGilligan was Minister for Finance in 1951-52. That is a most outrageous untruth.
Comment on this
If a man is in politics, he has got to take political representations and criticisms.
Comment on this
I am giving the facts. If we had to borrow £38,000,000, it was borrowed to clean up the mess that was made in Deputy McGilligan's time.
Comment on this
The figures I got to-day may be pretty low, because the people would not give the money to you.