We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).

Contributions 141–305 of 481. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I am just looking for the figures which are as follows:—1952-53, £31,952,000; 1953-54, £32,929,000; 1954-55, £29,600,000; and 1955-56, £23,408,000. The last figure is only £23,000,000 because you could not get any more, unless you got it from the Jews.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must address the Chair.

Comment on this

They borrowed from everyone else, and the fact is that the interest and sinking fund have increased from £2,420,000 interest and £1,620,000 sinking fund, totalling roughly £4,000,000, in 1947-48, to £8,808,631 for interest and £4,386,459 for sinking fund, a total of £13,000,000 a year of deadweight on the people of this nation that must be found by whatever Government comes in to clean up the new mess. They will have to find that money each year.

I remember being down in County Waterford at a by-election and I had to explain this matter to the people, and I had to explain that both Parties agreed that this money had to be borrowed, but that there was a difference of opinion as to how it was to be paid back. We believed it would have to be raised—as the Minister apparently has decided to try to raise it this year —by taxation, and the boys over there believed that they should borrow again to pay the interest on what they had borrowed already——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not refer to Deputies in such a manner.

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite, Sir, if that will do. That was the difference, and this nation now finds itself faced, not alone with that debt, but with a borrowing every year of £20,000,000 or £30,000,000 to keep this bit of an island afloat. And for what? Who is it being borrowed for and who is getting it? I had hoped that, when speaking here to-day, I would have the figures of the cost of the Civil Service in 1948 and the cost to-day. They should be very enlightening. Deputies will have them to-morrow at 3 o'clock and I hope they will enjoy them. They can have a look at them. That is the most alarming position as far as I can see it. Now, we have another line-up on the other side of this. We have a line-up of the gentlemen who say the farmers are getting off soft; that they are paying nothing; that they do not even pay income-tax. That is the general opinion, mark you, among a large number of ill-informed individuals in this country.

Whatever statement was made here and whatever statement was made by any individual Minister or Deputy about taxation lying lightly on the land, it was the gentlemen opposite who were the people who worked on it and worked on it very well. They started off the job by taxing the farmer who tills his land. He is the first fellow they made for and they said: "For every barrel of wheat you will produce on that land, you will pay us a tax of 12/6". And they did that. They collected from the farmers in that manner last year over £1,700,000, in taxation on wheat. That was collected, or paid for, just the very same as if it was an order left with the miller that, on every barrel of wheat that came in, 12/6 must be collected. Every barrel of wheat brought into a mill last year was taxed to the extent of 12/6. We produce a ton of wheat to the acre. and, on our 350,000 acres under wheat. we paid £1,700,000 in taxation.

The Minister for Agriculture is very fond of telling us to feed calves and I heard Deputy Donegan a while ago speaking very fluently on that, but Deputy Donegan forgot to tell this House that that Minister for Agriculture taxed feeding barley to the extent of £4 a ton, and he collected from the farmers who grew it last year £1,200,000. He collected it in a more contemptible way still when he used that cheap barley for the purpose of taxing the pig feeders whom he taxed to the extent of £617,000.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This argument would have been more relevant to the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

I am dealing with statements made by Deputy Donegan on this matter. Those are the facts. How can Deputies opposite expect to have more production, or to get rid of the adverse trade balance, when that is the manner in which this Government deals with the man who endeavours to produce more, the man who tills his land? When Deputy Donegan says that 360,000 acres just grew all the wheat that was required here, what was done with the 129,000 extra acres of wheat grown the year before? Was any of it exported? Where did it go?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

The weather took care of that.

Comment on this

Does the Government consider it a wise policy, if they can buy foreign wheat as they say, for £26 a ton, to pile up an adverse trade balance by bringing it in? Where, in the name of heavens, did they get the economic policy of importing foreign pollard and foreign bran at £27 per ton as it is to-day? Every jump in the foreign bran and pollard coming into this country is welcomed by the people over there, because every pound it goes up means that they are getting an extra pound on the bran and pollard produced in this country—an extra pound tax on the pig feeder, whom they expect to go on producing more pigs and to whom they have appealed to increase their production of pigs. How is he to increase production? Is it any wonder that 20 per cent. of the sows have disappeared out of this country in the past 12 months? Was that the increased production? Is there any wonder that we had 155,000 pigs disappearing?

Where is the use in talking about increased production, if you are going to tax the man who produces? On those three items alone, the Irish farmer was taxed last year to the extent of some £3,000,000 odd. That taxation was deliberately put on his back by the Government; and then we had gentlemen saying that the farmer pays no income-tax. Something around £617,000 on the fellow producing pigs was a fairly good income-tax, and this was collected in order to reduce the flour subsidy, and £1,700,000 of a tax on the man who dares to grow wheat in this country was a pretty hefty tax, too.

If Deputies think this is not having an effect in other directions, I will tell them that I happened to meet last week one of the directors of Messrs. Gouldings. He was complaining that his sales had gone down by some thousand of tons, and I told him that I would tell him exactly how much they had dropped. I said:—

"You are producing about three-quarters of the artificial fertilisers used by the farmers of this country and you have dropped about 30,000 tons."

He told me:—

"You are not very far out; we have dropped nearly that much. How did you find it out?"

There are 80,000 odd acres of land gone out of tillage in this country and that is where the artificial manure was going. That is going to have a reaction and a pretty serious reaction on labour——

Comment on this

They were charging too much for it; that is what was wrong with Gouldings.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had been decent enough to come with me the day I went up to try to stop them from getting any more, we might have got somewhere. There is no use growling about it in here, unless you act outside. I had to go up before the Prices Tribunal and give evidence on that matter.

Comment on this

That is where the Deputy made a political speech.

Comment on this

Do you consider it a political speech to point out the manner in which the backward section, as they used to call the agricultural community, had advanced——

Comment on this

I heard all about the line the Deputy took there.

Comment on this

The Deputy heard about it, but the Deputy did not come.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I am just stating what has happened and what is happening in this country. It is going to mean a dearth of employment and a drop in employment in this country. If those people drop 30,000 tons of fertiliser, it will mean less employment, less transport and it is going to hit all around. The same thing happened as regards beet. We have dropped 18,000 acres of beet in 12 months.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing agriculture.

Comment on this

I am discussing the drop in production which has brought about the adverse balance which has caused this Budget.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say the beet acreage was down this year?

Comment on this

It was down 18,000 acres last year.

Comment on this

The Deputy is avoiding any reference to the present year?

Comment on this

The year that is gone. That is all you have to depend on for your sugar. I could also tell the Parliamentary Secretary that this is the same state of affairs as put us into the position that we had to import 75,000 tons of foreign sugar the last time Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture and import it at 12/- per cwt. more than the best Irish sugar produced in our factories here. Those rosy pictures that are drawn about how cheaply you can get imports here are not correct.

Those 18,000 odd acres of beet mean that over 200,000 tons of sugar are gone, in the first instance; over 200,000 tons of freightage are lost to C.I.E and to the carriers in this country, and from six weeks' to two months' employment with the sugar company is lost to the workers of this country.

Comment on this

That is your fault more than anybody else's. It was you negotiated the price.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

It was you who presented "Jamesy" to the country again as Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not refer to the Minister in that fashion.

Comment on this

A Minister for Agriculture was put in to look after the interests of agriculture in this country who had publicly stated that beet had gone up the spout after peat and wheat, and God speed the day. That is the Minister for Agriculture you gave us.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy make an effort to come back to the Financial Resolution? The Deputy is dealing with agricultural matters that should have been raised on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Every single Deputy, Minister and Government that came in here has laid it down as a principle that, unless we have increased production on the land, the case is hopeless. I am dealing with the decreased production on the land——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going into details that should have been raised on the Estimate.

Comment on this

If I am interrupted, I have to explain to the children.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not require much encouragement.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, those are the facts and they cannot be denied. The Government is in the position to-day that they are refusing to honour the agreement they made with the beet growers.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss the agreement with the beet growers on the Financial Resolution. It is not relevant.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the reduction in production and I think I am entitled to do so on this Budget.

Comment on this

And the Deputy is being discourteous to the Chair as well.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary not a model of courtesy?

Comment on this

We find that the cost of production has gone up all around and there is nothing to meet it. Any other industry in this country can do the same as Gouldings did—go before the tribunal, prove their costs and get their increase.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the Financial Resolution. The Chair is judge of what is relevant. Unless the Deputy comes back to the Financial Resolution, I will ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

If the Chair decides that the principal industry in this country cannot be discussed on this Financial Resolution, very well.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not in the detail certainly into which the Deputy has gone. The Chair has been very lenient with the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am dealing with each item as I find it in relation to generally reduced production here and in relation to the cutting down of the income of the agricultural community. The total reduction in the income of the agricultural community this year as compared with last year is over £10,000,000. Yet, it is the agricultural community which is asked to produce more in order to get rid of our adverse trade balance. Is it any wonder that the Government and the Parties constituting it got the kick they did down in Leix-Offaly? It is no wonder at all when one considers the condition of affairs; and one has that condition of affairs running right through every branch of our agricultural and industrial life.

What has become of the sheet mills in Haulbowline? Away back in 1936, the late David Frame told the buyer of Rushbrooke Dockyard that he need not import his sheets at all, that he would make them for him in Haulbowline. The sheet mill is up there now. Why are the sheets not produced? We are still importing the sheets and converting them into corrugated iron.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter should be discussed on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce. It is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

That industry would, in my opinion, have relieved unemployment to a considerable extent. What will be the position in relation to our roads? The Government has stepped in and raided the Road Fund to balance this Budget.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not allow us to have a full-dress debate on roads on this Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

It is stated in the Budget statement that a certain amount of money was taken out of the Road Fund to balance the Budget. I am dealing with the gap that will be created as a result of that—the gap in employment, the gap in road maintenance and repair, the financial gap which will have to be closed by the ratepayers. Is there any end to the ingenuity with which this Budget was framed? Some years ago, I brought in a Private Bill to endeavour to open the pubs for an hour on Sunday. Deputies were inundated with letters from the Pioneer Association.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does that arise on the Financial Resolution?

Comment on this

Because this Budget has taxed the pioneer. When people put a penny on the child's bottle of lemonade what can one expect? Evidently the Minister decided that the beer drinkers could bear no more and that there were too many "dry" men in the Government. Beer could not be taxed any more; but there was no reason, according to Deputy Donegan a moment ago, why the pioneer should not be taxed, so the Government put a penny on the bottle of lemonade.

I remember the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture getting up here in high dudgeon and waxing very eloquent about the poor man's smoke. Deputies on the benches opposite nearly went crazy at the idea of a tax on the poor man's bit of tobacco. I remember even Deputy O'Leary grew vocal on that occasion and had a lot to say about the poor man's smoke. We did not hear a word about the poor man's smoke last week here when the "fags" went up.

Comment on this

It is better than putting it on the butter, anyway.

Comment on this

I do not know about that either, mark you.

Comment on this

I would rather have butter on my bread anyhow.

Comment on this

The ordinary workers in this country might not know what butter is now, and if the Government is there for another year or so there will be plenty of butter for export, because they cannot afford it.

Comment on this

Better give them the butter now.

Comment on this

That is what is happening. They are going on margarine. I did not ever think I would see the time when an inter-Party "mixum-gatherum" Government and all as they are, would come along, after all the statements they made, and come in here——

Comment on this

Taking off £6,000,000.

Comment on this

——and put a tax on the cigarettes and tobacco again. Did anyone ever dream that they would see it? The poor old age pensioner——

Comment on this

The old age pension is up.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Leary must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The poor old age pensioner of Deputy O'Leary's constituency——

Comment on this

You were ruining them.

Comment on this

——when he will fill the old pipe now, will be saying: "God be with the days when Deputy O'Leary told me to vote for him the last time and he could reduce the price of tobacco."

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee destroyed him.

Comment on this

There you are, and Deputy O'Leary walked around there last week and voted for that increase for the poor man.

Comment on this

And you voted against the social benefits last week.

Comment on this

How in the name of Heaven, did Deputy O'Leary ever manage to go back into Wexford——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry must get back to the Budget.

Comment on this

They are sensible people there, not like in Youghal. I will talk to them.

Comment on this

Is there any justification for it? If my speech would induce Deputy O'Leary to speak in this House I would be delighted. His speech would be well worth hearing. However, that is only one of the items. They are going to put the 20 Aftons up from 2/5 to 2/10, but we have that kind of thing all round. We have the petrol tax, and when Deputies over there say that that is not going to have any effect on production in this country I do not know what they mean. How much extra will it cost the farmer to get his manures out to the land at increased freightage charges? How much extra will it cost to get his crops taken into the factories with increased freightage charges? The general manager of the Sugar Company told me the other day that his increased costs have already gone up in 12 months by over £400,000. That was the excuse they gave us when I went down last week looking for an increase of 2/8 a ton on beet caused by the 6/- increase to agricultural labourers. He said: "Yes, I have applied to the Government for an increase in the price of sugar to meet that." I will be very much amused watching if the Government will give it, because that price is based on costings, and it would be very interesting to know what will be the attitude of the Government on it.

These are the things that are piling up step by step and crippling our main producers and stopping production. I think it is a very wrong thing to pick out the ordinary lorry owner and haulage contractor in this country and to say: "You will pay a tax but the State subsidised C.I.E. will pay no tax. We are exempting their fuel from tax." I suppose it was the least the Government could do after borrowing a couple of millions off them the other day. It was the least they could do to show their appreciation, by going along and giving them this exemption. How is the ordinary haulier of goods going to earn his livelihood in competition with C.I.E. when there is 6d. extra on his petrol and there is nothing on C.I.E.'s fuel oil?

Comment on this

If he has fuel oil, how much extra will it be?

Comment on this

There is a hauliers' association in the Deputy's constituency. I do not know if they have met him or not, but I would love to be listening to him when they meet him. Deputy Hughes can tell them about the reduction they were going to get at the last general election.

Comment on this

I shall stand by anything I ever said.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear the Deputy saying that he can stand by the statement he made at the last general election that the price of wheat was guaranteed for five years.

Comment on this

I did not make that statement.

Comment on this

I have not it here at the moment, but I will find it if necessary.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not relevant.

Comment on this

Those are the facts. The general body of lorry owners, down in my country anyway, and I am sure all over the country, from what I know of them from my negotiations in regard to freightage on beet, are only working men owning a lorry and living in a little house, endeavouring to make a livelihood out of the hire of the lorry.

Comment on this

And voting Labour, many of them.

Comment on this

They will continue to do so.

Comment on this

It is bad enough for C.I.E. to come along and charge them 7½ per cent. commission to bring their beet to the railway——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That cannot be debated at this stage.

Comment on this

I am giving that as one instance—that that was bad enough without this Government putting 6d. a gallon on their petrol to drive them out of business. I have seen many devices used in this House by legislation and otherwise in the past number of years to drive those people out of business.

Comment on this

By the Transport Act.

Comment on this

We see the result now. We had not yet seen 6d. a gallon on petrol worked as a tax on one and no tax on the other. A tax on one branch and no tax on the other—that is what has been done in this Budget. We are then told that we will have to relieve the farmers. How far has the farmer been relieved? The farmer uses a gallon of petrol once in a while for priming and warming up the old tractor before starting it off. That is all the petrol he uses. The bulk of the farmer's petrol is being used in his ordinary work in haulage, for which there is no relief. Is the Minister now prepared to consider an increase in the price of milk, due to the fact that 6d. has been put on the petrol to haul the farmers' milk to the creamery?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter which would have been appropriate to the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture has gone before this. These are the results, I might say, of this increase in taxation on petrol—and they are only a few of the results that will come from it. Where are all the promises that were made in the leaflets? Last year, when a Budget was introduced here, we were told:—

"We had not time. Give us a chance. We are only at the start of this business now. We took a little off the butter this year. We will take more off it next year."

Lo and behold, they come in here, the following year, having decided that it looked too cold outside to go to the country and that a lock-in at Dublin City and at Leix-Offaly was enough—"You cannot go out, lads"—and the Minister for Finance could not trim his sails sufficiently to get a Budget that would even relieve the blast for the moment, with the result that they had to bring in this.

I do not compliment the Minister for Finance on his Budget. This Budget has proved one thing. It has proved that, perhaps, the Minister himself, or some members of the Government, have come to their senses and no longer believe they can borrow and never pay back. Apparently they now realise that you cannot at election time say to the people: "Look at the price of tea." I do not see any reduction in the price of tea in the Budget. You know, it has gone up 2/- a lb. since our time. I am sorry Deputy A. Barry is not here: he would explain it.

I come now to the price of sugar. That is something for which we shall have a Supplementary Budget tomorrow or later. A sum of £450,000 extra expense on the Sugar Company has to be found and the extra cost for producing beet has to be found to pay me, no matter where it is to be found —be certain of that. We have just as much right to it as the civil servants.

Comment on this

The farm workers have.

Comment on this

We shall see to it that this agreement is honoured, that is, that the price of beet will be paid for on the price of production, plus a profit.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with the Financial Resolution. The Deputy should try to come to the resolution now.

Comment on this

It has everything to do with one fact, namely, that no allowance has been made in this Budget for those costs I am speaking of and that that will definitely mean a Supplementary Budget.

Comment on this

Is that what you are hoping for?

Comment on this

I should like some Deputy over there to get up and explain to me where they are going to find close on £600,000 that will have to be found for this purpose. Unless they tax sugar, where else will they get it? You will not always have the pig feeders, you know.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would ask Deputy Corry to make an effort to come back to the Financial Resolution. He is discussing agriculture.

Comment on this

I am discussing, on this, the fact that no provision has been made in this Budget——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has already said that at least three times.

Comment on this

Very well; I do not want to repeat it. These are the facts. Why, in the name of heavens, did they put a penny on the gallon of paraffin oil?

Comment on this

The dance halls, is it?

Comment on this

And poteen. You know what that is? Why was the paraffin oil taxed? The majority of the people using paraffin oil at the present time are living in areas in this country which, unfortunately, could not be reached by rural electrification. They are the people who are using the paraffin oil to-day.

Comment on this

For cooking and lighting.

Comment on this

They are the people who are still depending on the lamp.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee does not know anything about it.

Comment on this

I know that most of them are farm labourers. Apparently Deputy Tully forgets that.

Comment on this

The farm labourers are paying Deputy James Tully well.

Comment on this

You would not know anything about that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Why was that tax imposed? Was it, perhaps, a case of scraping the bottom of the pot as far as these people are concerned by endeavouring in every quarter to find money? Above all, what is the money for? When people go down the country and urge, and when the Government make declarations advising, the people to save, surely, in the first instance, the people are entitled to ask the Government to economise and to show a lead to the country. What steps have the Government taken in that direction? Can they show any? All we know about them is that they are still recruiting civil servants and still providing increases for them. We are also entitled to know under what system this is worked. Is one section of the community picked out and, if the cost of living goes up so many points, as they term it, so that an ordinary wage-earner gets some £30 a year to meet the increase, where is the team or where are the geniuses in the Department of Finance who make out that other individuals are entitled to £130 and £150 to meet that £30 increase? Is there one section of the community picked out who can look forward hopefully every morning when they awake to an increase in the cost of living and who can say: "If the cost of living goes up by a pound, we will get an extra fiver to meet it"?

I suggest to the Minister for Finance that he would want to overhaul that machinery. I can very easily understand a civil servant with £1,800 or £2,000 a year being able to say: "The cost of living has gone up four points; that is £30 a year. If I succeed in getting this now through arbitration award, I will get £150 to pay the £30." That is being done. Is that the kind of agreement you want us to honour?

Comment on this

The Deputy did not honour the award.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that the unfortunate worker who elected him is going to stand for that? Nobody in this country is going to stand for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Leader did not honour it.

Comment on this

Is one section of the community going to be picked out here in order to honour an agreement, an agreement made by whom? By one civil servant scratching another! It is about time that the ordinary Deputy who comes in here representing rural constituencies spoke out.

Comment on this

And spoke the truth.

Comment on this

And did not misrepresent the facts.

Comment on this

It is high time that he spoke out. If the Deputy will go down to the local authority he is dealing with and make inquiries there, he will find that there is £30 for the fellow with £330; £70 for the fellow with £1,000 and £150 for the fellow with £2,000——

Comment on this

You brought in the managerial system.

Comment on this

It is the job of the Deputy now to get after that condition of affairs and see that it is remedied and that some balance is struck in this country—that we are not going to have one section of the community behind barbed wire entanglements, protected in air-raid shelters from every wind that blows, while the rest of the unfortunate people must pay the piper. It is time it ended. The people of this country cannot afford a Government run as this Government is being run. That is what is wrong. They tell the people: "Save, and according as you save more, we will borrow it and we will pay the civil servants with it." Everywhere we look we are told "Produce more," and then we are told: "You will get the self-same price as the farmer in England and the North according as you produce——"

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should get back to the Resolution.

Comment on this

The whole cry in the country is that the only hope we have of correcting the situation is by getting rid of our adverse balance of payments, and that the only way we can do that is by producing more at home. Ninety per cent. of what we produce at home for export is agricultural produce. The people who use that cry and say we must increase production come along, on the other hand, and increase our costs. How can they expect that we are going to get rid of our adverse trade balance? If you come along to an industrialist and say: "You are producing buckets; I will take all the buckets you produce at a guaranteed price of 1/- per bucket, knowing it costs you 2/6 to produce them." Is there any business man over there who would say that? That is what is being done as far as the main producer in this country is concerned. That is what has driven him out of production, and driven him out in such a way that we are now faced with a position in this country where we must import something which was being produced here at home some years ago. Something like £5,000,000 is now going out for wheat which was produced by the farmers of this country in previous years.

You are going to have the same state of affairs in regard to everything else. Then we wonder why we have an adverse trade balance. We have the idiot down the country who says: "Why does the farmer not produce more? Are you not getting a guaranteed price?" That is the kind of stuff we get and then we are told we are on a par as far as price is concerned with the people across the water, ignoring the fact that the farmer here is paying £5,000,000 a year in rates not being paid by his brother across the water. You are not going to have increased production on the land here, and anybody who pretends we are is only like a person with his head in the clouds. No man who is taxed for production will produce. No man is idiot enough to subscribe to Government loans in future when he knows how the money is being spent.

It is just as well now to get down to it. The Government is going out preaching savings to the ordinary unfortunate man in the country who has enough to do to support his wife and children and who does not know where he is going to get his next week's money. The place for the Government to start saving is here in Dublin. Get out to those Departments and have a bit of a clean up. Do not add 25 where five will do. Can any Minister or Deputy over there justify for me or tell me what they are doing when there are at present over 8,000 more civil servants in Dublin than there were during the emergency when everything was rationed? What are they doing?

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that figure?

Comment on this

Let us get down to it and find that out.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quoting a figure of 8,000 civil servants.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will go down to the Library he will get the answer, giving the number of civil servants employed at the end of the emergency and the number in 1952. If the Deputy has any doubt about my figures, he has a very simple way of finding out whether I am right or wrong—he can put down a question to the Minister for Finance asking him the number of civil servants employed in 1948, when that Government took over first, the number the last time we left office and the number to-day. He can get those figures for himself, and he will know whether I am right or wrong in my figures. I know what I am talking about here. I know that this country cannot afford the luxury of keeping them all.

Comment on this

There must be work for them.

Comment on this

We will send them down to do a bit of tillage for Deputy Fagan. The fact is that we have a condition of affairs in this country where, in order to carry on Government here, we have to borrow an average of £29,000,000 every year and of that £13,000,000 is going to repay the principal and interest on what has already been borrowed. That is the position here to-day. Until we get rid of what might be called the overburden that is thrown on the workers of this country, whether they be industrial workers, farm workers or farmers, you are going to see Budget after Budget brought in, each introducing fresh taxation, each building up, so that the Minister for Finance has to sit down after the introduction of one Budget and start off figuring out for the following 12 months how he is to get increased money out of the people in the next.

It is all going into the one rapacious maw and there is only one way of ending it, short of a revolution. I am an old fellow now and one would not think that I would believe anything I was told, but I had an idea that the former Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, was going to do a bit of paring down. I was foolish enough to believe that. I do not know why, but it reminds me of a little story I was told recently. Two lions escaped out of the Dublin Zoo and got out into the Dublin mountains. They met after a week. One fellow was fine and fat and the other fellow's belly was tied to his backbone with the hunger. The hungry one said to his fat friend that he was afraid that he would have to go back and the other fellow said not to do anything of the kind, that he picked out a fine fat fellow every morning for his meals. They went away again and met after another week and the fat fellow asked his friend how he got on. He said he was doing all right, but he was afraid he had made a mistake that morning. He said: "I picked up a nice fat lassie this morning, but I think she was the one that used to make their tea for them and I am afraid she will be missed." Unless there is a cleaning up as far as these things are concerned, there will be no increased production.

Comment on this

There would be no room for them in Cork, if they all went back there.

Comment on this

It is time that there was some weeding out, as far as this condition of affairs is concerned. You will have to start, not down the country, but here in Dublin, and the local authorities will have to start also.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may discuss the local authorities on the appropriate Estimate motion.

Comment on this

Unless there is a definite change, particularly in the attitude of the Government towards the agricultural community, unless these contemptible methods of getting income-tax from the agricultural community are stopped, you are going to have Budget after Budget brought in here every year imposing increases on the people who have to pay. You cannot tax any industry out of existence and that is what is being attempted now.

Comment on this

I have been listening to Deputy Corry for quite a long time here to-night. As a rule, I enjoy listening to him, because he usually makes a fairly sensible speech. Perhaps it is because he has not recovered from his long sleep on the way up on the afternoon train from Cork that he made so many blunders this evening. One example of his blunders is the reference to the demand from the beet growers for an increase of 2/8 per ton.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair informed the Deputy that he was not in order.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling, Sir, but if the price of sugar, which is relevant, is going to go up as a result of the fact that people in Deputy Corry's constituency take a whole year to look after two tons of beet, I do not think we need to worry too much.

This is not a wonderful Budget, but, in my opinion, it is a sensible Budget. I have been speaking to people all over the country, to the farm labourers in whom the Deputies opposite are so interested this evening, and their opinion is that it is not the kind of Budget that Fianna Fáil would have brought in. Fianna Fáil would have slashed the subsidies on foodstuffs and would have seen to it that the working amn would be made to pay more than his share, as he always had to do under Fianna Fáil. There is no use in Deputy after Deputy offering destructive criticism here. We have not heard much constructive criticism from them. We know quite well that the men and women who smoke cigarettes are grumbling and saying that the increased price is something they do not want to pay. They will pay and, if they do not, they will go without smoking, because they cannot get cigarettes, if they do not pay it.

The same thing applies to petrol. The increased cost of petrol will be a bit hard on the people generally. It will be a bit hard on Deputies as well as on everybody else, but the suggestion that was made, not by Deputy Corry alone, but by a number of other Fianna Fáil Deputies, that the increased price of petrol would be a staggering load on farmers and lorry owners——

Comment on this

And workers.

Comment on this

I presume the Deputy understands that a lorry owner and a farmer are workers. It is ridiculous to suggest, as they did, that a number of lorry owners and farmers will go out of business, because of the increased taxation on petrol. No matter how small the mileage per gallon obtained from those lorries and tractors we hear so much about, the extra impost of 6d. per gallon will not break the people who are paying it. They may be dissatisfied at having to pay it, but most of them will collect it back from somebody else.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! From whom?

Comment on this

That is for you to make up your mind about. I was very glad to hear the suggestion made, and afterwards confirmed by the Minister for Social Welfare, that there will be increases in certain types of benefits. This is something which is long overdue. While I do not agree that it is the most that can be done, I am satisfied it is an honest effort to help people who are not in a position to help themselves. I am also satisfied that the effort to help pensioners is long overdue. I should like the Minister, when replying to the debate, to say if it is intended to give a direction to local authorities as to how pensioners of those local authorities will be affected under the new arrangements.

There have been so many angles put on this Budget by the people opposite that it is hard at times to know which side of the fence they intend to come down on. One thing I noticed was that Deputy Corry's line seemed to be at variance with that of a number of other speakers. I hope I will not become as confused as Deputy Carter was the other night when he referred to a statement I made about something which was under discussion here. It is hard to know what exactly Fianna Fáil found wrong with the Budget, or what they would have done if they were in the same place as the Minister for Finance the other day. I feel that the reliefs given by the Minister, by making available money for social services, will be appreciated very much by working-class people. I feel sure that they, in their wisdom, will realise and, as very many of them have pointed out to me, appreciate the fact, that if they have a few extra shillings when they are unemployed or ill, they can use it to better advantage, particularly when the price of food has not been increased as Fianna Fáil would have increased it.

In conclusion, there is one question I should like to ask. I have been in this House less than two years. During that time, as far as I am aware, there has not been such a tremendous increase in the number of civil servants as some people are suggesting. Is it not a fact that during the time Fianna Fáil were in power prior to 1948 and when they came back into office after the 1951 election, practically the same number of civil servants were then employed by the State Departments? Is it not also a fact that no attempt whatever was made to reduce the numbers during either of the two periods during which they were in office? Again, is it not a fact that a reduction of the number of civil servants is only called for by Fianna Fáil when they are in opposition?

Comment on this

I thought when I heard the Minister for Finance making statements on a few occasions in recent times on his changed attitude on the whole financial question and on the position in general, that I would not hear any more of the misrepresentations that are still being attempted by other members of the Coalition Government. One misrepresentation came this evening from Deputy Donegan. He proceeded to compliment Deputy de Valera when he said that the position could not be rectified by half measures.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

In order to qualify that he went on to say what measures would have been taken if we had Deputy MacEntee in the place of the Minister for Finance—"Deputy MacEntee who recently described the Sweetman squeeze as too gentle." If my memory serves me rightly, he said, or at least implied, that other measures and greater taxation would be piled on the people in order to remedy the situation. The Coalition have allowed this position to develop. It developed from 1948 to 1951. It was rectified from 1951 to 1954, and now, from 1954 to 1956, it has developed again and it is largely of their own making. It is because of all that and it is because of this misrepresentation, deception and dishonesty with the people that I stand up to express my disapproval of this Budget, not because steps have been taken to rectify a particular position.

This Budget was aptly described by Deputy Lemass as one that was a shock and disappointment to the many thousands of supporters of the Coalition Government who voted for them at the 1954 election. If there is a silver lining to it, it is the fact that it is not merely a shock and a disappointment but a disillusionment of the many thousands of the credulous people who fell for the propaganda of the various Parties forming the Coalition in regard to the 1952 Budget and the promises that they solemnly made between 1952 and the General Election of 1954. Perhaps this Budget is a blessing in disguise, if it serves the purpose of enlightening the people, so that they will listen to the various Parties at election time in future and judge them on a policy that is practicable, and not on lavish promises that cannot be fulfilled to any degree, such as were made during the period from 1952 to 1954.

It was not in 1952 that this started; it started away back in 1947. After the emergency, the position here was pretty difficult. It was obvious that many people would expect that the hardships they had to endure during the period of shortage would be very quickly eased. Production did not increase; supplies did not come to hand; and there was general uneasiness amongst large sections of the community. That was played upon by a new Party that entered Irish political life at that time. That new Party told the people that all they had to do was to remove Fianna Fáil from office, accept them, and they would have very good times, that the cost of living would be reduced, that wages would be increased and that, if necessary, subsidies would be increased.

When Fianna Fáil introduced subsidies, the people most opposed to them were the Labour Party. Their idea was that wages should be increased and that they would be able to get value for increased wages. No matter what increase was given in wages, owing to the fact that supplies were short, people could not procure their requirements to the extent that would be made possible by increased production. It was not possible at that time to dispense with rationing. The theory that was advanced and the dictum of the Clann na Poblachta Party of that time, in their effort to play up to the unthinking people, was that it was quite possible to get more out of life than you put into it.

It would not be so bad if that were confined to the Clann na Poblachta Party, but when the seasoned and experienced politicians of Fine Gael accepted that theory and went all out to advance it and to deceive the people at that time by telling them that that was possible, it was no wonder that we had the state of affairs that we found in 1951 and that the Coalition Government now find at the present time.

The Coalition now want us, whom they traduced, maligned, and misrepresented, to approve of their shameless somersault on taxation, the cost of living, external assets, the balance of trade and the many other facets of Government. They expect that we should silently acquiesce in their deception and political expediency. If they imagine that they succeeded in smothering or doping our memories of that period, they are making a very great mistake. If they had acted as they, as responsible people, should have acted, in 1948 and in 1951, and had attacked us on general policy, whether agricultural, industrial, economic or otherwise, and had shown to the people how they could improve the position, we would not feel so much inclined to show them up as we are prepared to show them up and shall continue to show them up, not merely here, but at every crossroads and church gate in the country.

When the 1952 Budget was introduced to meet the serious situation which they had allowed to develop from 1948 to 1951, we were described as highwaymen of the very worst order. Dick Turpin was an angel compared with the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee. The people were told that Turpin invariably robbed the rich to help the poor, but that the idea behind Deputy MacEntee's Budget at that time was to make the rich richer and the poor poorer——

Comment on this

And so he did.

Comment on this

——that he was following the pattern of the British Chancellor of the Exchequer and was acting at the behest of the Central Bank. What pattern is the Coalition following now? What banking report are they following? The deception that was practised on the people was revolting. The sooner we have honesty in the public life of this country, the better for democracy. As a result of what has happened from 1947 to the present time, democracy is on trial in this country.

We were told that the taxation imposed by Fianna Fáil was unjust and unnecessary. Will they deny that they said that? Perhaps they will deny it as many of them denied that they made any promises. I shall not state here what I am not prepared to prove from the records of this House. Speaking on Resolution No. 11—General—on 3rd April, 1952, Volume 138, column 1268 of the Official Report, the present Taoiseach—and he was no youngster in politics; he was no impetuous young man who was anxious to get into political life; he had been in political life and understood the difficulties and ramifications of Government—made this statement:—

"The Budget which the Minister for Finance introduced yesterday is a cruel Budget. It is also a Budget which contains wholly unnecessary taxation. Therefore, it is an unjust Budget."

If it was an unjust Budget, if it contained unnecessary taxation, why has not it been altered since? Why has not the taxation been reduced or modified to some appreciable extent?

At column 1269, he said:—

"The country has not yet even recovered from the impact of the first shock of these Budget proposals. It will, therefore, receive a new and a startling shock when it is demonstrated that the proposals contained in the Minister's Budget statement yesterday contained proposals for the unnecessary collection of from £9,000,000 to £10,000,000 concealed taxation."

That was a statement coming from a man who, I feel sure, had a good understanding of finance and of the economic position. There he went out to tell the people that Fianna Fáil found pleasure in placing tax burdens on them at a time when they were in this House with a very slender majority. They said they were doing it so that they would be enabled to bring in a Budget a year hence with reduced taxation and that they would consequently get back with an increased majority when they went to the country.

At column 1269 of the same volume the same man had something else to say. I do not believe at all in quoting any of the other people who trot after somebody like that and who are "yes" men. I like to deal with people of authority and responsibility. This is what the present Taoiseach had to say:—

"Not merely, therefore, will the people of this country have to face the burden of the colossal taxation that was indicated yesterday by the Minister in his Budget speech, but they will have the added horror of knowing that those proposals are extracting from the pockets of the taxpayers from £9,000,000 to £10,000,000 taxation which is wholly unnecessary to balance the Budget this year."

At column 1288 he is reported as saying:—

"The Minister and his colleagues would not even raid the Road Fund, which was the traditional method for any Minister for Finance in the past to get money in ease of the hard pressed taxpayer."

The Road Fund is being raided now and when Deputy Smith, the then Minister for Local Government, brought in proposals here to increase the tax on mechanically propelled vehicles there was a storm of protest from the Opposition. Deputy Smith's object was to increase the Road Fund in order to improve the roads so that they might be able to take the increase in traffic. He proposed not merely to improve the main roads but also the country roads. The Opposition then said that the Road Fund might be utilised for purposes other than those for which it was set up. It could be used to balance a Budget. A large slice of it has been taken over now to balance a Budget and it will create a considerable amount of unemployment.

I cannot understand Deputy McQuillan voting for these proposals here the other evening in view of the fact that he introduced a Bill to enable the local authorities throughout the country to take over the cul-de-sac roads and the minor roads in order to improve them. It might not have been possible to make money available from the Road Fund under existing law but the statutes could have been amended so that money from the Road Fund could be made available for roads of that kind.

We had all this ballyhoo in 1952 from the Parties making up the present Government. We have a different story now. When the present Taoiseach was speaking on that debate at a later stage, on May 13th, 1952, he said, as reported at column 1442, Volume 131:—

"If by any stroke of misfortune or ill-fortune I was translated to clear up the appalling mess the Minister has created and found myself faced with what he is asking the country to do, I would resign the next minute rather than proceed with any single provision in the present Budget. I would be no party to any provision in this Budget. I think these taxes are cruel and unjust and that they will prove so."

He is a party to it now. Can they show one tax imposed in that Budget that has been remitted? On the contrary, they have supplemented them by increased taxation ever since they took office.

Comment on this

They are putting jam on it.

Comment on this

At column 1443 of Volume 131 the present Taoiseach said:—

"I am anxious to repeat, in spite of the alleged point of order, that I would not be a party in any Administration—either as head of it or as a member of it—to the unjust, cruel and entirely unnecessary provisions of the Budget which he has brought in."

If these taxes were unnecessary in 1952, how is it that they are now so very necessary and how is it it was necessary to maintain them from 1952 to the present time? They have been talking about the butter subsidy—the reduction in the price of butter. I will answer that if I may. In the 1954 Budget, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, reduced the price of the 2-lb. loaf by a halfpenny. It was described as the halfpenny Budget. Let us take a family of five ordinary people. The average amount of butter consumed by each individual in that family in seven days on his slender income would be 1/2 lb. of butter. That would amount to 2½ lb. of butter for the family per week at 4/2 a lb., which amounts to something like 10/5.

Comment on this

What about the 2 oz.?

Comment on this

A great many of them are not eating the 2 oz. yet, even at the reduced price. The reduction in the price of butter to 9/4½ meant 1/0½ a week to that family. Take the 2-lb. loaf of bread. Each member of the same family, if physically fit, and if depending on bread as many people in the cities have to, would consume a 2-lb. loaf in the day. That would mean a saving of 2½d. per day. Multiply that by seven and you get 1/5½, if my calculation is correct. That means that the much despised halfpenny reduction on the price of the loaf was of much greater advantage to that family than was the reduction in the price of butter. Most of these families exist solely on bread because they cannot have potatoes or vegetables.

Of course it was said that the balanced Budget was only a myth, a figment in the imagination of the conservative Fianna Fáil hierarchy. The adverse trade balance was a healthy sign when our external assets were being used to increase imports required for capital development, but the dissipation of our external assets now is a serious misfortune confronting the country. Apparently all the capital development has been carried out and there is no longer, perhaps, any need for hair-curlers or mouth-organs. We were told, of course, that external assets were being built up in England to give cheap money to the British people, to give it to them at 2 or 2½ per cent., while at the same time charging 5 or 5½ per cent. to our own people, and even to our local authorities. Why has that not been changed? If our external assets were dissipated, why was the money not brought home for the purpose of relieving the situation here in Dublin, the housing situation?

We had all this kind of thing— everything then was a requirement and an essential of the people when Fianna Fáil were in office. Many of them, at least, appear to have become luxuries now. Electric washing machines are to be denied, as far as possible, to the farmers' wives and daughters all over the country. It is all right to leave them in the same drudgery as they were in 50 years ago, rubbing their knuckles off against the old board. It is all right for them not to have electric irons and to have to run from the table to the fire with the iron to heat it up. It is all right for these people to be trotting from the fire to the table and back again——

Comment on this

They are sending all the washing to the laundry now.

Comment on this

——and that is the attitude of the inter-Party Government to these people. Cigarettes, tobacco, matches—they are all luxuries now, of course, but they were essentials at one time. We had the Tánaiste, Deputy Norton, coming into the House on 21st April, on the Financial Resolution, 1954, and in Volume 145, at columns 577 and 578 saying:—

"The people are not going to be deceived by a reduction of a halfpenny on the price of bread. They have memories going back..."

This was in 1954—

"...to the 1952 Budget."

At column 581 of the same volume, he said:—

"We come to the Budget and its effects on the cost of living. That is the only thing that really matters to the ordinary people to-day. So far as the masses of the people are concerned to-day they are being crippled by the cost of living which has been driven skywards by the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952. They have been looking forward to substantial relief in this Budget. What have they got? —a halfpenny off the 2-lb. loaf."

What have they got from the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, or from the present Minister for Finance, despite the fact that the wheat producers here have had wheat prices reduced by £5 per ton and that offals for pig feeding have been increased? There is still no halfpenny off the loaf and it will not be exhibited now in North-West Dublin on the top of a stick and there is no talk of all those callous people in the Government.

At column 583, the Tánaiste then said:—

"Before the 1952 Budget you could buy a lb. of sugar for 4d.... Thanks to the 1952 Budget you pay 7d. for it. Before the 1952 Budget you could buy a 2-lb. loaf for 6d.... After the 1952 Budget you had to pay 9d. for the same loaf. You could buy tea at 2/8 a lb. Thanks to Fianna Fáil you have now to pay 5/-."

What have we to pay now for the 5/- Fianna Fáil tea of 1954? We now have to pay 8/6, and, in many instances, 8/10, and yet we are all supposed to congratulate the very efficient and competent Government for the muddle they made of the tea business about a year and a half ago. That has added 2d. a lb. to the increase of over 2/- on the price and yet there has been no reduction made by the present Minister.

But there is something more. I remember on 6th April, 1952, a mass meeting was called in O'Connell Street by the Labour Party, addressed by Deputy Norton, Deputy Dunne and several others, and we had all the fulminations and bellowings that could be heard almost three miles distant about the callousness of the Fianna Fáil Government and what they had done to the people. That talk almost drove the citizens of Dublin to the point of lynching the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, the first time they could lay hands on him.

Comment on this

He was well guarded.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce or Tánaiste can go up O'Connell Street now and make statements. Will he explain now why it is that during his period of office, and with his approval, tea has gone up from the 5/- a lb. that it was in 1954——

Comment on this

Despite the Parliamentary Secretary's—Deputy O'Donovan's —assertions to the contrary.

Comment on this

Will he explain this increase in the price of cigarettes? They were 2/4 then. The tobacco manufacturers went before the Prices Advisory Body and they got an extra penny which brought them to 2/5. They are now 2/10 for a packet of 20, so that, instead of having to pay 5d. more, they have to pay an additional 6d., and we do not hear a word about it now. Neither do we hear any disapproval expressed by the Labour Party. The 2/8 per stone of flour that Fianna Fáil increased to 4/10 when they took it off the ration — there is no decrease on that, and the people are still paying 4/10.

There are several things besides these that were said. Everything then was an essential. Will the Minister explain to the old age pensioners why it is that the 2/6 increase given them last July is going to be almost entirely cancelled because of the price they now have to pay for their four ounces of tobacco? Tobacco has gone up, not by 4d. an ounce on the bar, but it has gone up by 4½d. an ounce since Fianna Fáil's time and four times 4½d. according to my reckoning is 1/6. It would not need an extraordinarily heavy smoker, or an extra healthy man of 74 or 75 or even 78, to smoke four ounces of tobacco in the week, and he has to pay 1/6 more for it out of the increase he got last July, plus the 1d. on the two boxes of matches to light it with, if he does not put himself in danger of falling into the little fire when he stoops down for a coal to light it. In that way, 1/7 of the 2/6 is gone and there is no talk of giving any increase to these people. It is the contributory people who are going to be fed on what they subscribe themselves. They are going to get the increase from themselves.

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not think of it in 1947.

Comment on this

I used common sense in 1947 and I thought of it in 1947 and 1948 and in 1952, and I think of it now. If Fianna Fáil were in office, as Deputy Corry said, this situation would not have developed and there would not be almost £22,000,000 of agricultural produce imported into this country in the past year. If you want to find out where I got that figure, you will find it in the National Farmers' Journal, and that is not a Fianna Fáil production I can assure you. If we had but £15,000,000 of it, the adverse trade balance would be down to £20,000,000 and would not be the £35,500,000 it is in one year or a year and a half.

We have various other statements. We have the Minister for Agriculture coming into this House telling us that the key to prosperity is for the farmers to increase production and become more efficient. He goes out and tells them to reduce their overhead costs and says that one of the primary things for a farmer to do is to reduce his overhead costs. Does he tell them that an increase of an average of 2/- in their rates is infinitesimal, as far as a farmer is concerned? Does he tell them that an increase in fertiliser and maize means nothing, if they only become more efficient? Does he tell them that an increase in the prices of hydrocarbon oil and lubricating oil for their tractors is only what you would put into a child's hand, if you were decent? Does he tell them that an increase of ? in insurance card stamps, bringing them from 2/6 to 3/2, is something they should be delighted to pay?

After all, it is the farmer who will pay it. I have experience of agricultural labourers and they do not bother to stamp a card; and no farmer would be mean enough to deduct it from an honest labourer. Does the Minister tell them that £15 12s. per year for an agricultural labourer is only a token of the restitution they should give to the State and to the community for the easy money they earned on live stock, eggs, poultry, bacon, wheat, barley, oats, beet and potatoes during the years they were racketeering under rotten Fianna Fáil policy? Does he tell them all these things? These are the things they are expected to swallow.

Almost every section of the community is being cushioned to some extent, except the people who are described as the primary producers— the people who are expected to come to the aid of the Government and of the country by producing more, reducing overhead costs, becoming more efficient and all the rest. It is all tommyrot; it is mere bombast to be going out and talking to the farmers in that kind of language, without giving them the proper encouragement to do the work. If they get it, undoubtedly they will come to the rescue. In my opinion, they will increase production and increase it very well. You have very intelligent young men to-day in both Macra na Feirme and the National Farmers' Association, and, I suppose in Muintir na Tíre also. I do not think they want very much for nothing, but they want protection and they want a chance to pull up on the handicap of being for years in the position of not being able to do things such as countries that have had their freedom for centuries have been able to do. They are not asking the impossible.

Will the farmers now be told that the increase in the bank rate from 5¼ per cent. to 5¾ per cent. is going to put more money in their pockets which they can plough back into the land? I am very sure there are a number of honest, hard-working, respectable, decent farmers in this country who are working on bank overdrafts; and to be fair to the commercial banks, they have not been hard on them; they have never been hard, in my opinion, on anybody who they believed was trying to make an honest living and trying to meet his commitments; but for political expediency, when the banks were about to increase the interest on money they were lending from 5 per cent. to 5½ per cent., we were told, and it was boasted of by the Minister for Finance, that he stepped in and prevented them. When it went up to 5¾ per cent., a ¼ per cent., more than it would otherwise be if they had been allowed to put it on at the proper time, that ¼ per cent. is going to make good the deficiency which they had been prevented from meeting.

All this interference with the commercial banks of this country has a very bad effect. When I heard the Minister's statement about the withdrawal of deposits and the amount borrowed, and when I heard that the loan was not subscribed by investors, I felt that it was that type of interference with the banks of this country that was responsible for anything that is wrong. When the Government does not know its mind from one day to another, but is being pushed by certain press gangs, the people are saying to themselves that their money is no longer safe in the Irish banks and they are taking it out of them very quickly, putting it some place where it cannot be collared so readily.

If the policy of the Government is to nationalise the banks, let it be done in the proper way. Let it be done as it would be done in a real totalitarian country. Let the Army be put in in the evening when the banks are closing; let the Dáil be called together and pass the necessary legislation, and keep us here at an all-night sitting to get it with their over-all majority. Take over the banking business of this country altogether. If they did that, the people would have more confidence than they have as a result of the way it has been carried on now. One day, the Government have responsibility; the next day, they have not. The people do not know what is going to happen, and that is one of the several reasons for the big withdrawals of deposits during the past year. There is no use in blinding ourselves to the fact.

Then we have another class: the fellow who tries to evade paying anything to the State, to the bank or to the individual; and he will borrow every penny he can lay hold of in a situation of that kind, if he is allowed to do it. If this Budget was brought in in an atmosphere and in a set of circumstances for which the Government had no responsibility and which was outside their control, I am very sure that the members of the Opposition would be very slow to vote against it. Let them not think that it is because of the imposition of this taxation or the need for it; it is for unmasking the present Government.

All this has followed on the dicta of 1948: "You can have a good time; you can have higher social services; you can do less work and take the money off the other fellow. There are too many of these fellows with big incomes. Why should they be left to them? There are too many people with incomes of over £2,000, £3,000 and even £10,000. These incomes will have to be taken from them. There will have to be an equal distribution."

That was the kind of propaganda that was put before the people: "Live well and be merry to-day and forget about to-morrow; we will see that it will be all right." That sort of propaganda has been the ruination of this country and the sooner that dictum is called in question the better it will be. The sooner people realise the falseness underlying the promises that "the sky is the limit" at election times and give their answer by rejecting the protagonists of such false theories and put somebody with a sense of responsibility in their place, somebody who will not deceive the people, the better it will be for this country.

This Budget has clearly demonstrated the hypocrisy of those who went out deliberately, fully experienced in Government, and misled the people by telling them that the proper thing to do was to put out Fianna Fáil and put the Coalition into control, and there would be a change overnight. According to one of the supporters of the present Government, the Minister for Finance could reduce expenditure by £1,000,000 a minute.

Comment on this

"A million a minute Mulcahy".

Comment on this

Taxation lies lightly on the land.

Comment on this

The present Taoiseach says he made no promises. Number 12 of the 13 points that Fine Gael put before the people was that Government policy on prices and costs would receive in future a new orientation so that an intolerable level of prices does not lead to ultimate economic stagnation. No doubt it has been given the oriental touch, but we cannot see much advantage in it. On the 7th May, 1954, he said at Portlaoise: "We hope to do something for the people, decrease taxation, leave more money in your pockets to do what you like with it." That was no promise, of course. Not at all. That was no promise—"...money in your pockets to do what you like with it." Can they do what they like with the money they have not got in their pockets now? Can they buy what are called luxuries? I sincerely hope that that kind of propaganda will not be heard again in this country. I hope that Deputy Sweetman, Minister for Finance, will go down now to the church gate in South Roscommon where, before the last election, he took out the blue Fine Gael leaflet and compared the prices and gave a solemn promise that they would be brought back to the 1951 level. Will he do that now?

Comment on this

He never did it at all.

Comment on this

What does the Minister say?

Comment on this

He never did it at all.

Comment on this

Did he not? I am very glad to have the Minister's official denial of this because I have met several people down there—

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What the Minister did during an election is scarcely relevant to the provisions of the Budget.

Comment on this

It was a promise made.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy is dealing with promises, that is one thing. The production of a leaflet is quite irrelevant to the provisions of the Budget.

Comment on this

I bow to the ruling of the Chair, but the Minister specified the articles.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not stopping the Deputy on that, but the production of a leaflet is not relevant.

Comment on this

I am not denying I produced a leaflet. I produced it everywhere. What I am denying is what Deputy Beegan is putting in my mouth.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister denies that he said that.

Comment on this